The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutBertault - 95 Navy St ICA out Uniq,, Mariella Ostroski,Chairperson Town Hall Annex Anne Surchin,Vice Chair 54375 Route 25 Joseph McCarthy PO Box 1179 Fabiola Santana Southold,NY 11971 Allan Wexler Telephone: (631)765-1802 Tracey Dwyer, Administrative Assistant _-"qERVATAC)�" scwudpi ldh sou l-ioldtasmin .gov Town of Southold Historic Preservation Commission April 15,2021 RESOLUTION #04.15.21.3 Certificate of Appropriateness RE: 95 Navy Street,Orient,NY SCTM# 1000-26.-1-12.2 Owner: Vincent Bertault RESOLUTION: WHEREAS, 95 Navy Street, Orient,NY is on the Town of Southold Registry of Historic Landmarks, and building lies within the designated Orient Historic District according to the National Register of Historic Places and the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO). WHEREAS, as set forth in Section 170-8 of the Town Code( Landmarks Preservation Code) of the Town of Southold, all proposals for material change/alteration must be reviewed and granted a Certificate of Appropriateness by the Southold Town Historic Preservation Commission prior to the issuance of a Building Permit, and, WHEREAS, the applicants representative Gary R. O'Connor submitted an amended proposal to the prior application that received a public hearing on October 22, 2020 and was denied a certificate of appropriateness as per Resolution#10.22.20.2, and, WHEREAS, the Historic Preservation Commission considered the design changes and on April 15, 2021 held a vote to approve the proposed modifications as applied for, and, WHEREAS, the Historic Preservation Commission resolved to withdraw the appeal and approve the accepted amended proposed drawings as alterations and additions to the existing single-family dwelling as applied for under the recommendation of the Southold Town Legal Department, and, WHEREAS, the proposed location of the project will require zoning board of appeals approval before it receives a building permit from the Building Department, and, NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED,that the Southold Town Historic Preservation Commission determines that the proposed work detailed in the above referenced application meets the criteria for approval under Section 170-8 (A)of the Southold Town Code and, BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED,that the Commission approves the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness. MOVER: Commissioner McCarthy SECONDER: Commissioner Santana AYES: Ostroski, Surchin,McCarthy and Santana ABSTAINED: Commissioner Wexler RESULT: Motion Approved Please note that any deviation from the approved plans referenced above may require further review from the commission. LAW OFFICES WICKHAM,BRESSLER& GEASA, P.C. 13015 MAIN ROAD, P.O.BOX 1424 WILLIAM WICKHAM(06-02) MATTITUCK,LONG ISLAND ERIC J.BRESSLER NEW YORK 11952 ABIGAIL A.WICKHAM JANET GEASA 631-298-8353 TELEFAX NO.631-298-8565 ebressler@wbglawyers.com March 12, 2021 Via Electronic Mail John Burke, Esq. Assistant Town Attorney Southold Town Attorney's Office 54375 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold,New York 11971 Re: Property of Vincent Bertault at 95 Navy Street, Orient,NY ZBA Appeal No. 7467 and Appeal No. 7468SE Dear Mr. Burke: We write without prejudice in furtherance of our conversations on March 10, 2021 and this afternoon concerning resolution of this matter. We enclose amended drawings A-5—A-7 prepared by Gary O'Connor, AIA which reflect proposed changes to the design which meet the requests of the Historic Preservation Commission. Specifically, (a)the cupola is removed, (b) the height of the sunroom is lowered such that it falls below the height of the existing house, (c) clerestory windows are scaled down to match kitchen dormer transom windows, and(d)kitchen dormer is modified in accordance with suggestion of Commissioner Surchin to match the scale of the opposite of kitchen dormer and to pierce the exterior wall of the house. We believe that this addresses all of the outstanding issues and our client is prepared to resolve the manner on this basis. Kindly advise. Very truly yours, Eric J. er EJB/cs cc— Vincent Bertault GARY R.O'CONNOR nsMDV ECI.As ®CORBEUSME£ tori..CMW. P :5283%IJ61S ��"4-��wr. SPECIFICATION OUTLINE 4'W'abt bd?�WIYuy xAY'�r" � ••.. ---------------------- - F! w A � ✓ttx��W� �,�k LEORR IES.M'EaYNEPo Nn Y. r. • r rT �fMd'FUJ YI � rM"iY,e1 k 1IBart�� ' � �iJat+lC �":�a- aa Es.aEn[REn Na r. sueoms PruiRUEAxswean_caueTSD CUNM WOOD SPArER SD&ASCN E1NSRtlf:.SDL uNNraN vu wssrre�x aeae. Y� .v I�.Vau.!1�'i✓ILr;,try � ,., 4,'(ury °'-. 1' P" 'li al. �.:. ewESLVS sa: s�ox smm.nR xaruansero€.. 4 wraaru ,.,.. lY Il a Ir z `'a �rr�rr" I4 A-MfV L,tt E a ..... pp �� a',ifi . ®„m Ai V�y f s„ r WT&G kKYn,� C- Z O U __... 3 4VE'S-f ELEVATION w e d.•.%W w O H O Z en m..xa a�,ro¢.ck5uiaarr z r i~a" LL- ----------------- ---------- --- p� Po f • inr,�r' ,dly� � •' � v, �� m r.�� a � lFfl i ��§# a�1 �'�, w ��rmmme. am -� I Ji y u �•�p �ka�YG,.YL r �A°S v�eocmi 9� d 1N Xd ,AaHYLL WST&CCP b1•A}' • ..w.. • 'rt ,,, ,�w.,,a.,,,.,�, „, �„ ,`. ,,,,o, Asrwx� Aacek a ttnn Eike� r Wv ryG ', rraku cw �W n � ra r RMR FlEb'AI S x •t�1T, nmuie5 mi Gra paY A_7 h SC7U14dELEWATION GARY R.O'CONNOR ARCHIIECT,AIA ¢auA.w cw , eeear¢usraet:r ar rrw cmwu.'. ° YAgYPY4AUE 30444 � CAN�wB£95 P9S.A&7% '�,•yew---�+ _SPECIFICATION OUTLINE rqr gr.,uz�r rrr ..inw,c rr ,.... -..............._ ._.— --__—rrn orwre,.z; COM tram O Y�d511. Pl1kNG^I4IlDT AgN'#fWl'iAM, �I� �£�wwwr�wara��r.wn, MOW%1XV WirnII ar erri,r:Cn.a „�l Y«, �/ D 4 ✓,p £AF J,c'f A„>b �,� y ¢•! ,L�' 1 " scularWX4A xarmn.wl xwns: rmsr noae urar �dIL:� � �U i Wait& � wx fx P1Ar "'ll ry� tlt��. �¢ rr_gao was_e venoMI Y:':'�.,'V f�. �,+..a,�4,i,x" „• •---.--- ,•et+u�nnca uwm:zr-e«••• Z o x wam q sfinezr r a�_ O w H Z O U 1 EAST ELEVATION u •a•.e. O H O Z ------------ ---------------- te�raaww x:a,. -"�x«'m"�'•a"�.�,"�."p?w" �w� �,� ,Ts��"�"��nm "`. I Tm a rmv esoxoou MIDGE rri.r •. F n I 4 y nM xxa a• I Pk _ _---E Owe I gooG � ��9f 1 r„ / •„ r.,,:,/•„ �/, i, I na. MIY'PveE0. rcAwtvpiy°I4 uLTIX5WY :5 EITEl4 ELZTKM ma 1:L— ureawee 2 NORTH ELEVATION James Grathwohl,Chairperson �� v�� Town Hall Annex James Garretson,Vice Chair o PO Box 1179 Donald Feiler c 54375 Route 25 Anne Surchin �� Southold,NY 11971 Gary Parker `tl�l .bQ� Fax(631)765-9502 Robert Harper Telephone: (631)765-1802 Edward Webb www.southoldtownny.gov Damon Rallis,Administrative Assistant July 14, 2014 To: William Gesell 11 Harrison Avenue Red Bank, NJ 07701 RE: SCTM# 1000-26-1-12.2.—95 Navy Street, Orient—Proposed relocation of existing historic barn/garage Mr. Gesell: In response to your letter dated July 9, 2014,there has been no written correspondence or oral conversations between the LPC or its representatives and Mr. Bertault or his representatives since the June 17, 2014 public hearing. Please be advised that the public hearing was closed on June 17, 2014 and the LPC is not taking any more comments on the application from either side. In the future, please be aware that any requests for documentation must be made through the Town Clerk's office through a Freedom of Information request. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at (631) 765-1802 Respectfully Yours, amon eter Ra ' Administ ssistant On behalf of James Grathwohl, Chairman, Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission July 9, 2014 Mr. James Grathwohl, Chair and Members of the Town of Southold Historic Preservation Commission Town Hall Annex Building 54375 Route 25 Southold,NY 11971 Re: Commission review of proposed barn relocation on the Bertault property located at 95 Navy Street, Orient,NY 11957 Dear Chair and Board Members: Since I have not heard that a decision has been made I can only assume that there is still ongoing discussion on this case. As the spokesperson for the 54 individuals who signed the petition presented to you at your June 17, 2014 meeting we request the following information in the interest of keeping your decision process open and fair to all. 1. A copy of any written correspondence or summary of any oral conversations with Mr. Bertault, or his representative(s), by any member of the Historic Preservation Commission or their 'representatives since June 17,2014. 2. A copy of any written correspondence or summary of any oral conversations from Mr. Bertault, or his representative(s)regarding above. Once the requested information is received, I request that the Commission provide adequate time so that this information can be shared with all 54 individuals who signed petition and allow us the opportunity to provide information,regarding 1 & 2 above, so that the Commission has input from all interested parties to use in the decision process of preserving the Orient Historic District. Please send any correspondence to: William Gesell 11 Harrison Ave, Red Bank, NJ 07701 732-616-9005 Sincerely, William'Gesell " ` O��OF SOl Telephone (631)765-1802 O Town Hall,53095 Route 25 Fax (631)765-9502 P.O.Box 1179 cia y� Southold,New York 11971-0959 G • �Q co UNTI, SOUTHOLD TOWN LANDMARK PRESERVATION COMMISSION RESOLUTION #6.17.14.1 June 18,2014 Certificate of Appropriateness RE: 95 Navy Street, Orient, SCTM#1000-26-1-12.2 Owner: Vincent Bertault RESOLUTION: WHEREAS, 95 Navy Street, Orient,NY is on the Town of Southold,New York State and National Registers of Historic Places, and WHEREAS, as set forth in Section 56-7 (b)of the Town Law(Landmarks Preservation Code) of the Town of Southold, all proposals for material change/alteration must be reviewed and granted a Certificate of Appropriateness by the Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission prior to the issuance of a Building Permit, and WHEREAS, an application was submitted to relocate an existing accessory barn and an accessory shed on February 28, 2014 and WHEREAS Commissioners met with the applicant to review the proposed project on April 15, 2014, and WHEREAS, a public hearing for the purpose of considering approval of the proposal was held on June 17, 2014,and WHEREAS, the proposed relocation of the historic barn and shed, according to the plans submitted, will result in the structures being restored and preserved as is,and WHEREAS, the proposed relocation of the barn and shed will afford the applicant the ability to maximize the use of his property while preserving the character of the structures, and 1u � tf WHEREAS, the relationship between the existing barn structure and the main dwelling was significantly altered when the property was previously subdivided with Southold Town Planning Board approval, and WHEREAS, there are longstanding precedents for relocating such historic structures throughout the Hamlet of Orient and the Town of Southold, and WHEREAS, the new front yard location of the barn structure(facing Willow Street)is in keeping with other properties in the surrounding area, and WHEREAS, the proposed relocation of the barn structure was approved by the Southold Town Zoning Board of Appeals (#6729)on April 17, 2014, and WHEREAS, the applicant has agreed to make a good faith effort to preserve the property's existing trees and shrubs (particularly the holly trees)during the relocation process, and WHEREAS, a letter was submitted to the Landmarks Preservation Commission on July 30, 2014,by Michael Johnson, of Johnson Tree Co., Orient, outlining how to protect the willow tree adjacent to the proposed location of the barn structure. The letter will be part of the applicant's final building permit application and, it appears that the project requires no further review, NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED,that the Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission determines that the proposal as outlined in plans dated October 18, 2013, and amended on January 21, 2014, on May 28, 2014, and last amended on June 11, 2014, by Gary R. O'Conner, architect, meet the criteria for approval under Section 170-8 (A)of the Southold Town Code. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED,that the Commission approves the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness. MOVER: James Grathwohl, Chairman SECONDER: James Garretson, Commissioner AYES: Surchin, Parker,Feiler, Garretson, Grathwohl NAYES:Harper ABSTAINED: Webb RESULT: APPROVED Please note that any deviation from the approved plans referenced above may require further review from the commission. Si4F. i Ja ohl, Chairman,Landmarks Preservation Commission Date: TBD o��g0EF0(,l-`O James Grathwohl,Chairperson �� G Town Hall Annex Donald Feiler Q 54375 Route 25 James GarretsonPO Box 1179 W Anne Surchin ;55 • Southold,NY 11971 Gary Parker 4,1 �•a0`' Fax(631)765-9502 Robert Harper Telephone: (631)765-1802 Damon Rallis,Administrative Assistant southoldtown.northfork.net Town of Southold Landmark Preservation Commission Minutes 3:00 p.m.,May 20,2014 Southold Town Hall Annex Conference Room Attendees: James Grathwohl, Donald Feiler, James Garretson,Anne Surchin, Gary Parker, and Robert Harper Guests: Mark Terry,Principal Planner, Southold Town Planning Department; I. Call to Order: 3:00 PM H. Approval of Minutes • The minutes of the April 15, 2014 minutes were approved unanimously. M. Chairman's Remarks • The chairman discussed progress made at Village House, in Orient, and urged fellow commissioners to attend an open house event there on Saturday,May 31. • He announced that an administrative permit had been issued for work at the Charnews property, 52180 Route 25, Southold(SCTM# 1000.-63.-6-8). • Chairman Grathwohl announced that he would begin preparing quarterly reports to the town board. • He asked that Administrative Assistant Damon Rallis invite Richard Wines, of the Riverhead Town Landmarks Commission, to come to the next regularly scheduled meeting to discuss the proposed historic corridor project. IV. Meeting with Mark Terry,Principal Planner, Southold Town Planning Department (re:Draft Historic Church Memorandum) • Mark Terry presented options for preserving historic church buildings in Southold Town and recommended the"floating zone"option as outlined in the draft memo. • After further discussion, commissioners agreed that this was the best route and agreed to attend a follow-up meeting on the issue with the Southold Town Board on June 3, 2014. • Damon Rallis agreed to meet with Mark Terry before that date to do additional code research on the language used in the memo (re: fagade easements). • The commission voted to hold a"special meeting"on June 3, 2014 at 8:30 a.m. to discuss the matter further, before meeting with the town board. (Resolution#5.20.14.1) V. Interview/discuss candidates for open commission seat left vacant by the resiLmation of Doug Constant • The commission voted to enter into executive session to discuss the commission's recommendation, based on two applicants interested in the position. • Commissioners interviewed both candidates, Patricia Butler and Edward Webb. • Commissioners discussed the candidates and their resumes. • The commission voted to exit executive session and reopened the public meeting. • The commission voted and passed a resolution to recommend Edward Webb, of Orient, to the Southold Town Board for appointment to the open position on the Southold Town Landmarks Commission. (Resolution#5.20.14.2) VI. Set Public Hearings • Commissioners voted to set a public hearing for Tuesday,June 17, at 3:30 p.m. regarding Bertault(Gary O'Conner, architect): Proposed relocation of existing historic barn/garage at 95 Navy Street, Orient. Suffolk County Tax Map#1000-26-1-12.2. (Resolution#5.20.14.3) • Commissioners voted to set a public hearing for Tuesday, July 15, at 3:30 p.m. regarding Asch(Nancy Steelman, Architect):Proposed additions and alterations to an existing single family dwelling at 290 Skippers Lane,Orient. Suffolk County Tax Map# 1000-25-1-1. (Resolution#5.20.14.4) VII. Old Business • Chairman James Grathwohl outlined a plan to restore the Ben Franklin Mile markers with commitments from Zack Studenroth and Scott Russell. Chairman Grathwohl said he would invite Mr. Studenroth to a future meeting to discuss the proposal. VIII. New Business • Chairman James Grathwohl discussed Southold Town's planned 375t'Anniversary Celebration. • Commissioner Anne Surchin distributed copies of a draft law being proposed in Southampton Town regarding incentives for landmarking carriage houses within the Town of Southampton. She asked commissioner to review the proposal for discussion at a future meeting. o�0$tIFFQ(,�-�O James Grathwohl,Chairperson �,� Gy Town Hall Annex Donald Feiler54375 Route 25 0 James Garretson y , PO Box 1179 Anne Surchin y �► Southold,NY 11971 Gary Parker 'f1p1 �.a0Fax(631)765-9502 Robert Harper Telephone: (631)765-1802 Damon Rallis,Administrative Assistant southoldtown.northfork.net Town of Southold Landmark Preservation Commission RESOLUTION #5.20.14.1 May 20,2014 Set Special Meeting to discuss the Southold Town Planning Department's "Draft Historic Church Memorandum" RESOLUTION: Set special meeting regarding draft historic church memo WHEREAS, The Southold Town Board has directed the Southold Planning Board and the Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission to come up with a solution to save threatened historic church buildings within the3own of Southold, and WHEREAS, The Southold Landmarks Commission met with Principal Planner Mark Terry regarding a draft memo on the subject,and WHEREAS, The Southold Town Landmarks Commission has been invited to discuss the issue with the Southold Town Board during its regular work session on June 3,2014, and WHEREAS The Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission would like to discuss the matter further, in advance of the meeting NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED,that the Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission hereby calls for a special meeting to be held in the Southold Town Hall Annex second floor conference room on June 3,2014 at 8:30 am RESULT: ADOPTED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: James Grathwohl, Chairperson SECONDER: Robert Harper, Commissioner AYES: Feiler, Garretson, Surchin,Parker ,,;�oaxjf F0(,�c0 James Grathwohl,Chairperson �� Gy Town Hall Annex Donald Feilero 54375 Route 25 James Garretson coo ,?7 PO Box 1179 Anne Surchin -y • Southold,NY 11971 Gary Parker 1- Fax(631)765-9502 Robert Harper Telephone: (631)765-1802 Damon Rallis,Administrative Assistant southoldtown.northfork.net Town of Southold Landmark Preservation Commission RESOLUTION#5.20.14.2 May 20,2014 Fill Open seat on the Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission RESOLUTION: Recommendation to appoint Edward Webb to the position of Commissioner on the Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission WHEREAS, The Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission accepted the resignation of Commissioner Doug Constant effective March 18,2014, and WHEREAS, The Southold Town Clerk advertised the open position and called for resumes from interested parties to fill the vacancy, and WHEREAS, The Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission received two resumes for the open position and interviewed both candidates, and WHEREAS The Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission members believed that candidate Edward Webb, of Orient,was best suited for the position. NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED,that the Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission hereby recommends that the Southold Town Board appoint Edward Webb to the position of Landmark's Preservation Commissioner to fill the vacancy left by the resignation of Doug Constant. RESULT: ADOPTED MOVER: James Garretson, Commissioner SECONDER: Robert Harper, Commissioner AYES: Surchin,Parker NAYS: Feiler, Grathwohl y0g�rt F0(,f-�O James Grathwohl, Chairperson ,`�� ?"_ Town Hall Annex Donald Feiler54375 Route 25 0 James Garretson ,� PO Box 1179 Anne Surchin Oy ♦ Southold,NY 11971 Gary Parker 'fIp! �.a0Fax(631)765-9502 Robert Harper 1 Telephone: (631)765-1802 Damon Rallis,Administrative Assistants southoldtown.northfork.net Town of Southold Landmark Preservation Commission RESOLUTION#5.20.14.3 May 20,2014 I' Set Public Hearing RESOLUTION: Set Public Hearing for the proposed relocation of an existing historic barn/garage at 95 Navy Street, Orient. (SCTM# 1000-26-1-12.2) WHEREAS, The Southold Town Board has met in a pre-submission conference with the architect and owner of the property at 95 Navy Street in Orient regarding the proposed relocation of an existing historic barn/garage, and i WHEREAS, The applicant is prepared to present the project at a public hearing as required by the Southold Town Code. NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED,that the Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission sets a public hearing regarding the Bertault application(Gary O'Connor,Architect): Proposed relocation of existing historic barn/garage at 95 Navy Street, Orient. Suffolk County Tax Map# 1000-26-1-12.2, at 3:30 p.m. on Tuesday,June 17,2014 in the Southold Town Hall annex second floor conference room. RESULT: ADOPTED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: James Garretson, Commissioner SECONDER: Robert Harper, Commissioner AYES: Surchin, Parker,Feiler, Grathwohl I 1 i I I I James Grathwohl,Chairperson �� y Town Hall Annex Donald Feiler o 54375 Route 25 James Garretson `n„ PO Box 1179 Anne Surchiny • Southold,NY 11971 Gary Parker ,- �' Fax(631)765-9502 Robert Harper Telephone: (631)765-1802 Damon Rallis,Administrative Assistant southoldtown.northfork.net Town of Southold Landmark Preservation Commission RESOLUTION#5.20.14.4 May 20,2014 Set Public Hearing RESOLUTION: Set Public Hearing for proposed additions and alterations to an existing single family dwelling at 290 Skippers Lane, Orient. (SCTM# 1000-25-1-1) WHEREAS, The Southold Town Board has met in a pre-submission conference with the architectlapplicant for a proposed project at 290 Skippers Lane in Orient, regarding additions and alterations to an existing single family dwelling, and WHEREAS, The applicant is prepared to present the project at a public hearing as required by the Southold Town Code. NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED,that the Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission sets a public hearing regarding the Asche application(Nancy Steelman,Architect): Proposed additions and alterations to an existing single family dwelling at 290 Skippers Lane, Orient. Suffolk County Tax Map#1000-25-1-1, at 3:30 p.m. on Tuesday,July 15,2014 in the Southold Town Hall annex second floor conference room. RESULT: ADOPTED [UNANIMOUS] MOVER: James Grathwohl, Chairman SECONDER: Robert Harper, Commissioner AYES: Surchin,Parker,Feiler, Garretson BOARD MEMBERSSO Southold Town Hall Leslie Kanes Weisman,Chairperson �� UfiyO 53095 Main Road•P.O.Box 1179 Southold,NY 11971-0959 Eric Dantes Office Location: Gerard P.Goehringer G Q Town Annex/First Floor,Capital One Bank George Horning ,�c►O �0 54375 Main Road(at Youngs Avenue) Kenneth Schneider l''C�� `t.` Southold,NY 11971 http://southoldtown.northfork.net ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD ,R r Tel.(631)765-1809 Fax(631)765-9064 APR 22 2014 ...,1 FINDINGS,DELIBERATIONS AND DETERMINATION nF«r MEETING OF APRIL 17,2014 ^ D ZBA FILE: 6729 NAME OF APPLICANT:Vincent Bertault PROPERTY LOCATION: 95 Navy Street(adj.to Willow Street)Orient,NY. CTM#1000-26-1-12.2 SEQRA DETERMINATION: The Zoning Board of Appeals has visited the property under consideration in this application and determines that this review falls under the Type H category of the State's List of Actions, without further steps under SEQRA. LWRP DETERMINATION: The relief, permit, or interpretation requested in this application is listed under the Minor Actions exempt list and is not subject to review under Chapter 268. PROPERTY FACTS/DESCRIPTION: The applicant's property is a 19,905 sq. ft. in the R-40 Zone. The northerly lot line measures 65.93 feet along Willow St., plus 54.53 feet along an adjacent residential parcel. The easterly lot line measures 154.15 feet along a residential parcel. The southerly lot line measures 103.57 feet along Navy St., and the westerly lot line measures 207.70 feet along another parcel. The property is improved with a single family dwelling, and two accessory structures (a barn and a shed), as shown with the existing, and the proposed, new accessory structure locations, on the survey drawn by Peconic Surveyors, P.C. dated Dec. 12. 2012, and the site plan A.1 drawn by Gary R. O'Connor, dated Oct. 18, 2013. BASIS OF APPLICATION: Request for Variance from Article III Section 280-15 and the Building Inspector's October 15,2013,Renewed January 24,2014 Notice of Disapproval based on an application for building permit for relocation of existing accessory barn and shed, at; 1) accessory barn and shed proposed in a location other than the code required rear yard. RELIEF REQUESTED: The applicant requests variances to move two accessory structures from existing nonconforming front yard locations, to a new nonconforming front yard location. The code requires all accessory structures, except in the case of waterfront parcels,be located in the rear yard. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: The applicant's property is a through lot with frontage on two streets, and therefore has two front yards and no rear yard. The subject barn is estimated to have been built at some time in the 1920's, and the shed was also built at some time prior to the enactment of the Town Zoning Code. The applicant wishes to preserve and restore both accessory structures and to relocate them to eliminate the current need to drive cars over the existing septic system and to create more open space for gardening and recreation in the center of his property. The file contains two letters of objection submitted by an agent of adjacent neighbors stating some concerns regarding the applicant's proposed project. The neighbor's agent submitted written information on the history of the subject property. The applicant's proposed project is subject to the review and approval by the Town Page 2 of 3 April 17,2014 ZBA#6729—Bertault ,-_SCTM#1000-26-1-12.2 Landmark Preservation Committee. The applicant submitted a letter dated March 13, 2014 proposing to relocate the barn with a 25 foot front yard setback from Willow Street instead of the 20 feet setback as originally proposed. FINDINGS OF FACT/REASONS FOR BOARD ACTION: The Zoning Board of Appeals held a public hearing on this'application on March 6,2014, at which time written and oral evidence were presented. Based upon all testimony, documentation,personal inspection of the property and surrounding neighborhood, and other evidence,the Zoning Board finds the following facts to be true and relevant and makes the following findings: 1. Town Law 4267-b(3)(b)(1). Grant of the variances to relocate two accessory structures,an existing,historic barn and shed from pre-existing, non-conforming front yard areas into new, non-conforming front yard locations will not produce an undesirable change in the character of the neighborhood or a detriment to nearby properties. The applicant's property is located in an historic district that includes numerous buildings, including both principal dwellings and accessory structures, with non-conforming setbacks; all situated in locations that pre-date zoning. Many accessory structures are located in front yard areas. The average building front yard setback on Willow St. is estimated to be approximately +4 feet. The average front yard setback on Navy St. is estimated to be approximately+17 feet. The applicant proposes to re-locate the barn with a front yard setback from Willow Street of 25 feet and the shed with a front yard setback of 39.6 feet, and a 15 foot side yard setback on this irregularly shaped lot. The subject structures have valid pre-existing CO's, and the applicant's project must have the approval of the Town Landmark Preservation Committee. 2. Town Law 4267-b(3)(b)(2). The benefit sought by the applicant cannot be achieved by some method, feasible for the applicant to pursue, other than an area variance. The applicant's property is located between two streets, creating two front yards and the parcel has no conforming rear yard area. Therefore, the re-location of the two pre- existing accessory buildings to any other on-site location requires the granting of variances. 3. Town Law 4267-b(3)(b)(3). The variances granted herein are mathematically substantial, representing 100% relief from the code for the accessory structures proposed front yard locations, instead of code required rear yards locations. However, this is mitigated by the fact that these two structures already exist in non-conforming front yards because this property has two front yards and no rear yard location in which to move the structures, and also because of the pre-existing non-conforming status of these two structures each with a valid CO. 4. Town Law §267-b(3)(b)(4) No evidence has been submitted to suggest that a variance in this residential community will have an adverse impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood. The applicant must comply with Chapter 236 of the Town's Storm Water Management Code. 5. Town Law §267-b(3)(b)(Q. The difficulty has been self-created. The applicant purchased the parcel in 2005, after the Zoning Code was in effect, and it is presumed that the applicant had actual or constructive knowledge of the limitations on the use of the parcel under the Zoning Code in effect prior to or at the time of purchase. 6. Town Law 4267-b. Grant of the variances is the minimum action necessary and adequate to enable the applicant to enjoy the benefit of moving two pre-existing, non-conforming accessory structures to new non- conforming locations, while preserving and protecting the character of the neighborhood and the health, safety and welfare of the community. RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD: In considering all of the above factors and applying the balancing test under New York Town Law 267-B, motion was offered by Member Horning, seconded by Member Goehringer, and duly carried,to GRANT,the variance for the shed as applied for and shown on the survey drawn by Peconic Surveyors, P.C. dated Dec. 12. 2012, and the site plan A.1 drawn by Gary R. O'Connor, dated Oct. 18, 2013, and r� 9ppfcl 14"-e-4 LAO 4? &S+Oa4C- NOV N VVI CT' �w kAk 2 0515, �� wrr.U� S� Page 3 of 3 April 17,2014 ZBA#6729—Bertault SCTM#1000-26-1-12 2 DENY,the variance request for the barn as applied and, GRANT ALTERNATIVE RELIEF, for a 25 foot setback from Willow Street for the accessory barn relocation, as proposed by the applicant in a letter dated March 13,2014, subject to the following condition; CONDITION: 1. The granting of the variances are contingent upon the applicant securing the approval by the Town Landmark Preservation Committee for the proposed project, if the application is denied by the Landmark Preservation Committee then this decision shall become null and void. That the above conditions be written into the Building Inspector's Certificate of Occupancy, when issued. Before applying for a building permit, the applicant or agent must submit to the Board of Appeals for approval and filing, two sets of the final site plan or survey conforming to the alternative relief granted herein. The ZBA will forward one set of approved, stamped drawings to the Building Department. Failure to follow.this procedure may result in the delay or denial of a building permit, and may require a new application and public hearing before the Zoning Board of Appeals. Any deviation from the survey, site plan and/or architectural drawings cited in this decision will result in delays and/or a possible denial by the Building Department of a building permit, and may require a new application and public hearing before the Zoning Board of Appeals. Any deviation from the variances) granted herein as shown on the architectural drawings, site plan and/or survey cited above, such as alterations, extensions, or demolitions, are not authorized under this application when involving nonconformities under the zoning code. This action does not authorize or condone any current or future use, setback or other feature of the subject property that may violate the Zoning Code, other than such uses, setbacks and other features as are expressly addressed in this action. The Board reserves the right to substitute a similar design that is de minimis in nature for an alteration that does not increase the degree of nonconformity. Vote of the Board- Ayes: Members Weisman (Chairperson), Schneider, Horning, Goehringer, Dantes. This Resolution was duly adopted(5-0). Leslie Kanes Weisman, Chairperson Approved for filing /al /2014 a r `_t 1--2 tG 1�1 A-PW 194CII JT(U�1 -p V4 civ /-66/YIPN5 C S A-7� -Tof A4 rel VA., 61)&Q G fcu�� GU' s t u-,, Ulm (� l C�u�S yl S+V cco- oycl � � gX� L� TOWN OF SOUTHOLD HISTORIC PRESERVATION APPLICATION Meetings are on the third Tuesday of the month at 3:00 pm in Town Hall, 53095 Main Road, Southold, NY. All applications must have a representative at the hearing in order to be re- viewed. Questions? Call Historic Preservation Commission (631)' 765-1800. Date: Property Address: y Owners Name- MF'- ame:MF'• illocipw temAuy* Sections of local laws authorizing review by the Historic Preservation Commis- sion of proposed work on designated town landmark properties are in Chapter 56 of the Southold Town Code. Categories of Proposed Work ❑ Repair ❑ Storm Windows & Doors G!r 1ACGZ55*t JbtjqL1 p1& AQg*L ❑ Alteration ❑ Additions & other ❑ Painting new construction ❑ Roofing ❑ Signs Please attach a detailed description of the proposed work to the application. At the earliest stage of planning of the proposed work, the applicant should contact the Chairman or Secretary of the Commission in order to establish a dialogue of the proposed work. understand and agree that no work on this request shall commence until written appro al has been give y the Building Inspector if a Building Permit is required. Own@ 's Signature: ,r ti Note: Applicants should review Commission Standards before planning work to insure that the application conforms to these requirements. 1. APPLICANT Name: 121 tol)WR z AIA I , I Address: 'O Z • UNION s-r VILAikeeswouz NJ 0&6--1.P0 Telephone/email/fax: , �t7.-Ire-66. LOCONVOK.! gew MP1&W—,tqzrj. NWT 2. PROPERTY Owner's Name: FAX. VwagW Address: -+T NA Vy s'C'. o>zl n►y 1195 Telephone/e-mail/fax: 17- G63- 41& * IVe-CRTAubl'e xAA=P. ceAA Tax Map Number: IO00 - 2 6 Date Acquired by Current Owner: Status: Local Landmark ( ) In Local'Landmark District ( ) On National Historic Register or in NHR Dist. () Use: Current: .SiNGrGE fi�/wtLy Ii�u� . Proposed: G �u 3. PROPOSED WORK Scope of Work: L44010NMOD Dwnaw�� o� 4�TIIVCs �/�IW Reason for Work: f anM &494-rL/UV--,v fit! FXVA _tom tikvote kwgIG�R.A � - 'RA��rG t1�7.oS S Arch itect/Engineer: �/ IX Contractor: , Construction Schedule: 7 FOR LPC USE ONLY I have reviewed the enclosed application and determined the following action to be taken: Exempt Administrative Permit Required Public Hearing Required` igned Date •r Q�gg�FFO��.CO James Grathwohl,Chairperson ,4� Cy Town Hall Annex Donald Feiler a 54375 Route 25 Co James Garretson,Vice Chair PO Box 1179 Anne Surchin d •F Southold,NY 11971 Gary Parker '�I,p� .bd�` Fax(631)765-9502 Robert Harper Telephone:(631)765-1802 Edward Webb www.southoldtownny.gov Damon Rallis,Administrative Assistant Town of Southold Landmark Preservation Commission Agenda 3:00 p.m.,June 17,2014 Town Hall Annex Executive Board Room I. Call to Order: 3:00 p.m. U. Approval of Minutes: May 20,2014(Attached to hardcopy agenda) III. Chairman's Comments IV. 3:30 PM Public Hearing-Bertault(Gary O'Connor,Architect): Proposed relocation of existing historic barn/garage at 95 Navy Street, Orient. Suffolk County Tax Map# 1000-26- 1-12.2. V. Old Business • Ben Franklin mile marker restoration plan. (Chairman Grathwohl) • Southold Town's 375 I anniversary celebration. (Chairman Grathwohl) • Joint corridor project with the Riverhead LPC. (Damon.Rallis,Administrative Assistant). VI. New Business • East End Lighthouses(Ted Webb) • New Suffolk Waterfront Fund Project. (Chairman Grathwohl) • Any new business commissioners wish to discuss. Next Meeting: Tuesday, July 15, 2014 at 3 p.m. in the Town Hall Annex June 17, 2014 Mr. James Grathwohl, Chair and Members of the Town of Southold Historic Preservation Commission Southold,NY 11971 Re: Commission review of proposed barn relocation on the Bertault property located at 95 Navy Street, Orient,NY 11957 Dear Chair and Board Members: As individuals interested in the preservation of the Historic Orient Village,we the undersigned are opposed to the relocation of the barn on the property of Vincent Bertault located at 95 Navy Street, Orient,NY for the following reasons: 1. The historical and cultural foundations of Orient should be preserved as a living part of our community. 2. The relationship of the barn to the principle residence has existed since the late 1800's. Relocation of the barn would destroy this historic relationship, and its unique character and design, which is not duplicated anywhere else in the Historic Village of Orient. 3. The preservation of this irreplaceable heritage,in its current location, is in the public interest so that its vital legacy of cultural, educational, aesthetic and inspirational benefits will be maintained and enriched for future generations. 4. Relocating the barn will require extensive relocation and removal of historic landscaping. 5. The appearance of the original neighborhood will be damaged by the relocation of the barn, one of its integral elements. 6. Relocation of the barn does not comply with the intent of The National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 which states that"The historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. The removal of historic materials or alteration of features and spaces that characterize a property shall be avoided." We respectively request that the Commission deny Mr. Bertault's application to relocate the barn and not grant a Certificate of Appropriateness. Sincerely, See Attached list of signees Office Location: S Mailing Address: Town Annex/First Floor,Capital One Bank 53095 Main Road 54375 Main Road(at Youngs Avenue) P.O.Box 1179 Southold,NY 11971 • Southold,NY 11971-0959 �yCOUi�T`1,� � http://southoldtown:northfork.net BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Tel. (631) 765-1809 Fax(631)765-9064 March 13, 2014 Landmark's Preservation Commission 25325 Main Road Cutchogue,New York 11935 Dear Mr. Grathwohl: We have received an application(ZBA# 6738) from Nancy Steelman for ASCH,Anthony, for construction of a screened porch addition. (tax map#1000-25-1-1) The proposed construction is not permitted without review and approval by the Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission,because the property is listed either on the Southold Town,New York State and/or the National Registers of Historic Places. Enclosed is a copy of the application. Your comments are requested. Very truly yours, Leslie K. Weisman ZBA Chairperson By: Encls. FORM NO. 3 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD � C> BUILDING DEPARTMENT SOUTHOLD, N.Y. NOTICE OF DISAPPROVAL DATE: March 4 2014 TO: Samuels and Steelman Architect (Asch) 25235 Main Road Cutchogue,NY 11935 Please take notice that your application dated February 18, 2014 For permit to construct a screened porch addition at Location of property: 290 Skipper's Lane, Orient,NY County Tax Map No. 1000- Section 25 Block 1 Lots 1 Is returned herewith and disapproved on the following grounds: The proposed construction, on this non-conforming 13,416 square foot lot with two front yards in the Residential R-40 District is not permitted pursuant to Article=II Section 280-124,which states that on lots measuring less than 20,000 square feet in total size the minimum front yard setback is 35 feet and the maximum allowable lot coverage is 20%. Followingtheconstruction,the dwelling will have a front yard setback of 14.8 feet from Skipper's Land 11 8 feet from Oysterponds Lane, and a total lot coverage of 20.6%. Furthermore the proposed construction is not permitted, pursuant to Section 170-8 of the Southold Town Code without Landmark Preservation Commission approval. ------------------ Authorized Signature Cc: File, ZBA, Landmark Note to Applicant: Any change or deviation to the above referenced application may require further review by the Southold Town Building Department. Fee:$ Filed By: Assignment No. APPLICATION TO THE SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS AREA VARIANCE House No. 290 Street Skippers Lane Hamlet Orient SCTM 1000 Section 25 Block 01 Lot(s) 1 Lot Size .3 0 8AC Zone R-40 I(WE)APPEAL THE WRITTEN DETERMINATION OF THE BUILDING INSPECTOR DATED 3/4/2014 BASED ON SURVEY/SITE PLAN DATED 2/13/2014 Applicants)/Owner(s): Anthony Asch Mailing Address: 5 Mt. Horeb Rd. Warren, NJ 07059 Telephone: 908-2 95-23 0 Xax: Email: tony.asch@grnail.com NOTE:In addition to the above,please complete below if application is signed by applicant's attorney,agent, architect,builder,contract vendee,etc.and name of person who agent represents: Name of Representative: Nancy Steelman for(:4 Owner( )Other: Address: 25235 Main Rd. Cutchogue, NY 11935 Telephone631-734-6405 Fax: Emafl: nancy@samuelsandsteelman.com Please check to specify who you wish correspondence to be mailed to,from the above names: ( )Applicant/Owner(s), (4 Authorized Representative, ( )Other Name/Address below: WHEREBY THE BUILDING INSPECTOR REVIEWED SURVEY/SITE PLAN DATED 2/13/2014 and DENIED AN APPLICATION DATED 2/14/2 014FOR: (x)Building Permit ( )Certificate of Occupancy ( )Pre-Certificate of Occupancy ( ) Change of Use ( )Permit for As-Built Construction ( )Other: Provision of the Zoning Ordinance Appealed. (Indicate Article,'Section,Subsection of Zoning Ordinance by numbers.Do not quote the code.) Article: XXI I I Section: 2 8 0 Subsection: 12 4 Type of Appeal. An Appeal is made for: ()9 A Variance to the Zoning Code or Zoning Map. ( )A Variance due to lack of access required by New York Town Law-Section 280-A. ( )Interpretation of the Town Code,Article Section ( )Reversal or Other A prior appeal( )has, Whas not been made at any time with respect to this property, UNDER Appeal No(s). Year(s). .(Please be sure to research before completing this question or call our office for assistance) Name of Owner: ZBA File# REASONS FOR APPEAL (Please be specific, additional sheets may be used with preparer's signature notarized): 1.An undesirable change will not be produced in the CHARACTER of the neighbor or a detriment to nearby properties if granted,because: See Attached 2.The benefit sought by the applicant CANNOT be achieved by some method feasible for the applicant to pursue,other than an area variance,because: See Attached 3.The amount of relief requested is not substantial because: See Attached 4.The variance will NOT have an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood or district because: See Attached 5.Has the alleged difficulty been self created? {-eq Yes,or{}No Why: Are there any Covenants or Restrictions concerning this land? {*No {}Yes(please furnish a copy) This is the MINIMUM that is necessary and adequate,and at the same time preserve and protect the character of the neighborhood and the health,safety and welfare of the community. S' a of t or Authorized Agent Agent must sub#t written Authorization from Owner) Sworn to bef a me this 4ay. Of jha 20 d' Nolgry Public PATRICIA RICHARDS NOTIRY PUBUO,STATE OF NEW YORK NO.01 R16042467 CMUFIED IN SUFFOLK COUNTY COMMISSION EXPIRES MAY 30,20 Asch Residence REASONS FOR APPEAL 1. An undesirable change will not be produced in the CHARACTER of the neighbor or a detriment to nearby properties if granted, because the proposed addition is characteristic of other residential properties in the neighborhood in scale, design and setbacks to the street. 2. The benefit sought by the applicant CANNOT be achieved by some method feasible for the applicant to pursue, othgr than the area variance, because property is on a corner lot and the most of house is located within the 35' front yard setback.A variance would be required for any proposed addition. 3. The amount of relief requested is not substantial because the proposed porch addition will be constructed to match the existing porch details and dimensions so that it will respect both the existing house and the historic neighborhood. 4. The variance will NOT have an adverse effector impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood or district because the proposed construction will retain all water on site via new drywells and comply with all best management practices for storm water run off during construction. 5. The alleged difficulty has NOT been self created because it is the result of a pre- existing situation where the existing house was located within the setback prior to zoning. Prepared b� Date It APPLICANT'S PROJECT DESCRIPTION APPLICANT: Anthony Asch DATE PREPARED: March 4, 2014 1.For Demolition of Existing Building Areas Please describe areas being removed: Existing deck H.New Construction Areas(New Dwelling or New Additions/Extensions): Dimensions of first floor extension: 10 'w x 3 6 ' 6 It L Dimensions of new second floor: NA Dimensions of floor above second level: NA Height(from finished ground to top of ridge): Is basement or lowest floor area being constructed?If yes,please provide height(above ground)measured from natural existing grade to first floor: no III.Proposed Construction Description(Alterations or Structural Changes) (Attach extra sheet if necessary).Please describe building areas: Number of Floors and General Characteristics BEFORE Alterations: Two story residence with Screen porch, one story wing and wood deck Number of Floors and Changes WITH Alterations: Two story residence with screen porch and screen porch extension, one story wing and new outdoor shower. IV. Calculations of building areas and lot coverage(from surveyor): Existing square footage of buildings on your property: 2543 S.F. Proposed increase of building coverage: 2 2 7 S.F. Square footage of your lot: 13,416 S.F. Percentage of coverage of your lot by building area: 20-6% V.Purpose of New Construction: New porch addition VI.Please describe the land contours(flat,slope%,heavily wooded,marsh area,etc.)on your land and how it relates to the difficulty in meeting the code requirement(s): Land contours are flat - does not relate to difficulty meeting code requirement Please submit 8 sets of photos,labeled to show different angles of yard areas after staking corners for new construction,and photos of building area to be altered with yard view. 4/2012 QUESTIONNAIRE FOR FILING WITH YOUR ZBA APPLICATION A. Is the subject premises listed on the real estate market for sale? Yes X No B. Are there any proposals to change or alter land contours? X No Yes please explain on attached sheet. C. 1.)Are there areas that contain sand or wetland grasses? no 2.)Are those areas shown on the survey submitted with this application? NA 3.)Is the property bulk headed between the wetlands area and the upland building area? no 4.)If your property contains wetlands or pond areas,have you contacted the Office of the Town trustees for its determination of jurisdiction? NA Please confirm status of your inquiry or application with the Trustees: and if issued,please attach copies of permit with conditions and approved survey. D. Is there a depression or sloping elevation near the area of proposed construction at or below five feet above mean sea level? No E. Are there any patios,concrete barriers,bulkheads or fences that exist that are not shown on the survey that you are submitting? no Please show area of the structures on a diagram if any exist or state none on the above line. F. Do you have any construction,taking place at this time concerning your premises? no If yes,please submit a copy of your building permit and survey as approved by the Building Department and please describe: G. Please attach all pre-certificates of occupancy and certificates of occupancy for the subject premises. If any"are lacking;please apply to the Building Department to either obtain them -.onto obtain an amended Notice of Disapproval. H. Do you or any co-owner also own other land adjoining or close to this parcel? no If yes,please label the proximity of your lands on your survey. I. Please list present use or operations conducted at this parcel single family residence and the proposed use same with porch Pxt'Ang i on (ex:existing single family,propose&same with garage,pool or other) �l thorized 066we_a d Date kv �. a?t '►. � + ` J J its`r� � n All s ara tr': Z all •� . � � � * a r�TW'�4i �J•,° � $�iA`'r� }i+w3+:•y x#• T`.v -s+ n- f3 r•t'iS� .•s„�'s• X� 'R rc .ted � ttc , a -� ^aaa nt9j 'if sy � &yta� r° .y� 7't1ru d X, etde 3 •try' � " •s��:"c�'+c °^art Pb.?;a+y' "#a°"t�s3'axe.f'•�t.�,.� -3._ .�;�R,]tl5h'?- ''+�.'•e�. .X`�.; �,h<s':c"�r''°#..w�';+�iL+�r"IA:}, `!'�."��'�� " "�!�"i'�"•.�" sa'�'a.ro4"7....Y.t'��M.s+�»x"~'v i`'. `t;. OF k aft L�, � Yy i rsife 1 tot ro AK . • ''� aa'm ur „�, is v_`�1 .. faro SY)�+ `�F:,.�,¢� . x ? _ IF --.. WWP 'r`'"s rp -y.}s_s-4'rc1rd�sS.„'.�x� •r",�:.�`' a'.+,..k �''4 y`'�r.Wf"`'.".rn ° 3.a„/"�. y� �.s_;.i��A'�'+�'i.'E-��.+f. .rJc'r�...� �`��' T �X3P�.a�'-lt•�'�"''�'F. ,'�7,y" .e:.a�,,,j��rh �. �4 i :�� - 2 : "..{'Tl".4'�.� �bw• k�x`1.v« ! aS� �i•} �,•4r "}'P�[ <-. �*�a�r`Ss .�,,., F. !+ �' .r•d•a ria• *.,., <,1 w. .: v -. .l� i � v� v •,y, .. '. .. ..: aR _ .,.yy J 1,Ky .'u+<•- .->� r E • •• • Gary K O'Connor PROP05ED DU I LDI NG RELOCATION ARCHITECT LLC 5t IO2 Norh jam Sclree[ Iambertvl0e,N108530 1111'0e0554 for the Pt,Dne 609 397 3635 BERTAULT RE5IDENCE PROJECT DATA 95 NAVY STREET, ORIENT, NY I 1957 TA,N"ID 100026 IL DIN12 LOT,2(LOT E11b PERS T054BOIV151DN h1AP FILED IN SUFFU,A..O CL[P<B PRI APRIL I:2005+5 R!f h0 112a5 PODRE55 95 NAVY5IPU,T ABBREVIATIONS ARCHITECTURAL LEGEND 6 OR,11 NYI1517 IALL AREA= 19,905 SQ FT cL EL 51T FLOODr ,10 RFo1oFN Au06 DENONt A PNISTING tVALLTO ROMAN 47 SRIT,.1.YLOC TE 1NHl UNE fROMIF YI N,3OC'300GY8 AC6 G' P„ZARD ZOVE P NL Memba I n H.F un'WALL GT-EL ET FROM FIFBI Na 36103CCC6JN5r-009 AB Pncnor BOIL fanrcnnct KNrrgggg 1+1<4sin�abet CFedl Pve)(°rl __________ 45 5� 4 t N N MMeO:M1an,e(+) mFaM U15TING LVPll TO REMOVED L.w da[OVAL TO UE5CR"ION OF L5E Gt15TING tKIM1OPAL L'UILGING 15P A[ 0.�iltetC°rcxL �BO FIOind b' N B Nediirine bm, WILLOW /j ] NSBLE?eP+A'I. � p. L, �'aQ,p�>a^/�, inE 0WONk 5iLlLVE LY1511^G n CE5_`CR`15510KY A v� < m S,an ItM% u wvl Z —_-_— DATUM NNE � / / �L,Jy- p r$a romn M>. WINNE E`J AND 1 5TCi f Vvf`_FEU R N2mn,�n; /II fibeig�a,f"�`-r Ni My 5 PROPERTY NIf / X65 93' U T X EL 5 2 RfyOCATE IW NOUY MIP M°em fry MSFT.',<tNeiJ Met,l NIL IMM�w Mane Rp55�,�„pl M1r Re o'er --- CENTERUNE N852334'E� - E1 B'S gh TO BCR[D inCACCES`TPY BnfJl Af0b 51,01.1`1 Ah'D E FE ycre+t N N sb ouf d er 8 �— % `- 6' TO BCULAKENIONFDOJ U.OvR 1PIE.AS BI10fM FCR �jy�/MMV"ooErrn f n V'�fl.'llead LVozJ N tWI ED Ln O.spenw { � DIMEN50"OFPL[OF 41'AVEflAGE 0-S• A 'L42 �b9 VfnICULVF ENTRY fRG.1 VnLLU151PC w3 NG u N 'm`il ' ON W'LLOW STREET I 4 G- Amt1 "" NLt >n RELOCAE/f0.tY {,1 ZONING COMPUTATIONS A- MAnI 5tt Inr lestm8 NL't. M k Ci W9RK ppINT DAIUN 18•W1LD/ PI M,tcm Is n ''d i"d 9 6 PO Ni/CON�RDL POINT l p NII P eo ^L eF 0)hn CHERRY,>'1 Ul REOURiO tX15TIIG PKOPOSE� nFF PMboacae>f,noxE Fl°or '• I A l} K mW61WD •wNLLAN ,TC Cmvelco of hJ Ffzao +�uc ry n FiV D DOORSYMBOL EE TOR u n —201Ij nl B a (vy fat W.L N NOAs I9.1 5�VT�9 )I6'ORY O Yr V 11LOT Lot REDJARCAR:NEAiS 400W If 199Dc>f IV-1Z >a F+epLic 511D Sau N-Ln 1NxpOJ/5tt1BOL •-- ' %r 02W I INN LOTN10Tn 150 10.57 2-1Z AREA N AAREA I'RE`°"w 44 x Cul[ac[ SNR S.n-Pbn flet //na KEYROTC5YNBOL z ! nslr .,111 N89'S6'00"E 5-J 53' MONO2N 'cG !ocAm� F f��!NM ° P p�col lm9l /i(N)FRARIa FE15'N 042E AIG i ILn pR.fre Door 0 p p(A Z r (N)IM -`F, EL 4 9 STOGLADE FE FRNCPAL BUILD NG NIININL'M YARDMf REOVIR>,11Di 5 rru�ki EIEVARO1 REfOU'U", v o d�0.0 ]•bIN[( i5 vCH 107 ,, EL 6 6 J1Ua,,, BIflCM Zr0U1RED EnS1 'P. CSED rck^B G Er� ' �a a' O r^ � FE O/L 20•TREE fPANi Yr�PD 50 11 LO Lni.Gr CC °npf1IySdRF,�NNrs pay j}ry ,eUc4 5k Sin�s}S�ccl /\ N o 1 ,Fl IX.'I'D MIN 15 15E FC in.'.GE tlC Il.'�%102OF '` OPLI fUpie.J' > "1-1^ LETNL ELEVATION REFERENCE O 11 = i0rA151DE YAFOS 35 5491 IGinVCL C COW`f Mal Cc�rn.7Or P uM1ea IneL'IA a«o^d `/ I PEAR I'D c0 15767 IOC—CE T IA nuE Metal { SECTION REFERENCE �` `P 1WERE L MPN rtlG0 35 fTl2 5 3tt 23 33[22_`T NO c•\C' CC tt 5 ccww 5� ''��ii�� 18•EVERGREEWI3 N j AVJ V CRA9El. FIO !'a�hn¢,sn RT roGe� p Ks e1 nV4cD Ji�ti ew 1� Sr/ �'c O 65051 15'6:,f NOCmti.G! V rave ph�G Pa^Ar� L'=_e 126 200 125 - e� ,• I'� IAPN CUVtIWC[ 2Wo 1112w WO Ci'n1141 E SFT 'et��`erlcNgA1 Aped S+cet 1or< '7'i DELNL REfFRIKCE �• 8� �� / Lot 2 I 1 i%4� B•IREE SHED Pr.CS`A2Y&a'LCwG M111'dLM YAaDI'at Ft(aU„21'[NIS c y�a P ','9 ' 2f II oll �4 `50• REWIR[0 P%15PIG FRQP05ED n noxa b BA�r PP•rtliwn i ow$1�a Groove PNDTO RLfRENLe / 12-TREE 1 R ea^t A Pi leo)4 1(e�nN 1 > l v111 SIDE YARD 2D d3 92 15 >O e fSa nn N°vd Lot �i I L_ a+rG< n R If•.der fmwt l t • T E%ISTING TREE ro ee 107, 4•/6•I I.w REie YAD zD N y DI RtNOVED OR REIOCATFD I.'N'NEICNi 22 Try 75/ISBT115'SV 55-1 .I—,cn Nro -o°:rN`ar4 P a ^q�,o 1- EN e•iREE E%4PN0 I TREES r I MAY ATEA (CD SF ICl3 S> 10 inAJLE R M1 ROYwv OfW epp ABP2^�ibnc.t fd) aFSn / III RGflEEN/ LIASTY wl I ID5 I 20-0'-- Ypf�1R. RNncan PL P ds perYLmeai 1 FflAME Ln t—� ifK E[ucllF'ro^t n T nc�nt la a LN» c G P` s'ott art€a�omn 1 SMf emn MG Ne.')il kG Praug 1ian (JQ i BARN m N� SHEET INDEX (FLR EL6I'J I _k (" M Fla-Nc Lmavte V o ^B Ra2ta fin, [eel n V' cN 1'/arer �d vox u L _ eN'Ei OE5CR1FT10VM POND U YD ubc Y.rd I �rr 2CCEDAR- �I TITLE SILET'Px,nPlne U �_� =� 5 IAlZONxG COMPUTUATIJ545TE P41N I'IS Mtcn ppPJ nsned C BddnCodejp4 1 CDNC.WALLtV ,c[rMate PPPP nfN— h mr�Md [Axrn cOxCxE�E eL.1 � �Im'�m � I LOCAi10'IrFmOTOw ck W 59u>'e F L^.I 12 151PwnLs per•Igwre y y N Lt04' D'FRONT YARD SET BA fj I 13 PLANS r[EVAi1C15 FpT} O LN 4•iREE Ly�n°x Pi BIR PierligIpeR V RlraOmM xOupl wood ll„L RDON m 0 9 Fig Fabr N w G v'D' 6= R K 0 V V ralF;ran I rn sTY U aPL K H IIIb) V VG NSE aia M P� DT aar,y El. v wyFfe r 9 /RReus nrrNm,A, 'K. a [,,,mak BLOotIxC fLE - [ •y ♦ 36 N •13•IREE I claz<xv� E 2 R13�Ia R W , r'v 19•SPRUCEr_] jq 4 2 5TO E p �...�EPIIC NAW SWEET et L RAG Rem[ Rpa.CM WJ H,''d __r�t� FRAM O ON SETBA I a-e x1v1 Si,(fl ,g I' ii ��pp Pwb�^e"r 6ix yaC W nClosct u r r� i/ V 65•) 1 J AVERAGE BLD �0 M ry HT bfer f°od r Y 66 (F iiR ELS /L RE 151DN Jma fF5 P` mk LP Repo ortsStanrcte / ww� 'y 28.8, COVERED 1oiY P Rc°P6Mm 1. W"�nxi» 6 -COV 22'1REE 19;TREE -EL e'ay.�ia.eurvalrt / V[,c 1�'irc'Y:p ERIC rrBF R D 3 B ii''bw"a"<r ® ® 23 1 m - �.cy ba•,c, Vn�ad p�F w'^um v/ W I C� `l/�. 12 piLKET FE 1 , EL 59 1 AM m! y�yg L Re'C 1014 1 1 N'' �55ttt n€k f2�il;rl Paw G ` R P.�.nn$agn w�."5iop4ng Ix xxlcR L varl x C� �` ELafi j' W •35 71 au<ow:`'c`x "L 'w� IP .arcr IAZt, D K<Ov�a iw iFV}'•`waN - S82.49'40"W 586.18'20 CL EL R.n3te M5 M-se xcL I�,.W1,, Llae— M rl,mBdL 'Rc�V xP"<,'v'^fonl Y ® 1 7 86 (Y j�T 5 4 N PROF05ED 9UILDINC RELOCATION R d Mceturc Bamcr RFG Ilcc g YD Yare eArT wsln. L CL EL STREET(J y BERTAULTFt50fNCt ® a NA VY 4 SND E CRf, l11957 SITE PLVI INCORPORATES TES DATA PLrw0o0 FRO115L'RVEYEREP3 P BY TIRE SLEET FPOI DATA a 51%PLAN 1PE 230 TC SURVEYORS f C ,a SOVINFAVEIER STREET197R -/ DATED DID NY 11971 GATED DECEMBER 12,2012 N = A—I 517E PLAN 5CNLF N16-I a L __I Gary R. O'Connor ARCHITECT LLC 102 Nath Umon 5treet NY LIC W-0554 I,ambert0le,NJ 08530 a .\, ,� .f Phone 6,093973635 4 BARN/CARRIAGE HSE.#3 BARN/CARRIAGE HSE.#4 STR[[r,ONI[M,NY H VIEW OF PROPOSED BARN LOCATION FROM WILLOW 5TRFET s. „. VIEW OF PROPOSED BARN LOCATION BARN/CARRIAGE HSE.#2777- ViNC[M srRE[T.oRiCM,NYS • .. FROM VINCENT 5TREET p5TPNCt FROM BARN TO ME mur.12'-0" 1 .. BARN/CARRIAGE H5E #I ' FRONT VIEW OF BERTAULT BARN VO ATO NY MTANU FROM dv*H To PROROPEPIY uxe e _ LOCATION / PHOTO MAP INDICATING NEIGIIBORNOOD CHARACTERISTICS AND PRECEDENCE OF BARN � CARRIAGE r10U5E5 A-2 Gary R O'Connor RfPR RGOf IT-I I'x -- G�-------- ARCHITECT,LLC ON 102 North UNDO,5t,,,t tamoertvdle,NJ O5530 nr uC O.055- PI-1 C09 397 3635 i0P PUTE 12'0=" IEI NEATER ------ IEI RESTROOM � m SECOND FIOORB 0i PERNOU9 APRON 51m,,NR OR EQUAL TO GRP55PAVE2 BY INVISIBLE STRUCTURES INC GRODND FLO UP �I[IEVNIT NSB OR 0 0" STUCCO FINISH w/ EARTH TONE COLOR EAST ELEVATION _ FROM ROOF 18 9" L___ « SECOND fL00RB-0, GROUNDILOOR00 STUCCO FIN15H W/ WEST ELEVATION$A,I, PD WTnTONE COLOR 1 , ------, � I , I I BARN FLOOR PLAN I SCNE 114'=I'{T I I I I I (E)DET CHED SH�D I - I fROxT ROOF IB 9'- I I REAR ROOF,T IIS--- LJ u WEST ELEVATION -- ioP PUTS I2'Off° -- - ------ ® I I SCAIf I14-I'10' RE411O0LL _ I I SECONDFLOCR FLOOR PLAN / SCALE I/9'-I-0' PROPOSED DIIILDINC RELOCATION B:RT,.I RLS ,T 55 PAVYSn I Dt.N L`bEN1M1T 11551 GROUND FLOOR O'O_--__ RLEVAi10N BO1 R PIANS,EIEVAi10V5 GXvPERVIOUS APRON 51MNpR OR EQUAL TO - PlAVE2 Bf INV15181E STR MUM INC rt •"T'R NORTH ELEVATION SOUTH ELEVATION SONE N4•=ro' SOUTH ELEVATION ScuE Ila.=,.-0. SCAIE 1/4'=10' I 1 I A-J „- � _ �� , � s!e"3i � .�._. 3 r 7 Y s-� � —�-- ,. ^-> � ��, � _ --..-. �... ---�..,_ .....�_� .,..�� _� '� '- nw* Z.l any ..f a.-� ��. rti - �+�`' h.. - �. _. �. ,- kr� � ^. �'i ,r ,., - ,. +'"�`�. w. . � ,� - ,, .. baa •.�� - - e . >. -�� -,. „� _, . ... mt+cx;. .� -- . ... � � . ,. � _ „�, r ��, �.,�, >, .- .. ;. ,. . _ , _. -. �. N - .. . tl y ., v :✓ .> ... _ � Ti . .. .. ,. r ..A i v� s .. .. �� '- :: ".: . .. .. n _u �+ Y .. -. �. -. - _ '��..K _ y ..- �. .. ... � � - _ q.- Y+ � Y . r .� r .�. S r ��'' �. n ” ..� '� � � � �.. _ � � - - � `. u n.. '� , .f. '.. Z ti:. `� l t _ .. .. t- ;.w 1 5' ��. _ . ?' ~''xy � 'y? .'gyp"4' � _# t- .. . - ,- �. .a 3 _ty 5x June 17,2014 Mr. James Grathwohl, Chair and Members of the Town of Southold Historic Preservation Commission Southold,NY 11971 Re: Commission review of proposed barn relocation on the Bertault property located at 95 Navy Street, Orient,NY 11957 Dear Chair and Board Members: As individuals interested in the preservation of the Historic Orient Village, we the undersigned are opposed to the relocation of the barn on the property of Vincent Bertault located at 95 Navy Street, Orient,NY for the following reasons: 1. The historical and cultural foundations of Orient should be preserved as a living part of our community. 2. The relationship of the barn to the principle residence has existed since the late 1800's. Relocation of the barn would destroy this historic relationship, and its unique character and design, which is not duplicated anywhere else in the Historic Village of Orient. 3. The preservation of this irreplaceable heritage, in its current location, is in the public interest so that its vital legacy of cultural, educational, aesthetic and inspirational benefits will be maintained and enriched for future generations. 4. Relocating the barn will require extensive relocation and removal of historic landscaping. 5. The appearance of the original neighborhood will be damaged by the relocation of the barn, one of its integral elements. 6. Relocation of the barn does not comply with the intent of The National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 which states that"The historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. The removal of historic materials or alteration of features and spaces that characterize a property shall be avoided." We respectively request that the Commission deny Mr. Bertault's application to relocate the barn and not grant a Certificate of Appropriateness. Sincerely, See Attached list of signees We the undersigned OPPOSE the relocation of the barn on the Vincent Bertault property located at 95 Navy Street, Orient, NY and request that the Town of Southold Historic Preservation Commission NOT GRANT a Certificate of Appropriateness. Name Address r Signature OL LAS —ESELL_ 20 Qk3�k.57%— DZcFA3f � — e 0,7q,3�Wj tiq'-C> G7 0 OPP 0 '07-,80-:5,cc,41 jW 1,7e 0 >ell/1/7-1- F - It , I o sseN 10 p n 1700 V ` C. 2 t", TQ EL -� ny, , ,' �i► Cj 5 S Gil C) Refer- I 1 255" MavY S*F es-; Axk- 4//�X o� Z af On o:5-64 56� CV - CA&yir* Malkuvs x+5 !-i-ar6or-R& 6ruv► M 'Mim"./I �A� I We the undersigned OPPOSE the relocation of the barn on the Vincent Bertault property located at 95 Navy Street, Orient, NY and request that the Town of Southold Historic Preservation Commission NOT GRANT a Certificate of Appropriateness. Name Address Signature a I,JI I to w s F 119 _ palt� G-)�4 S fiEc �j P 'Ayc" ej-0 Old gan --D 4-('r-a, �3 0 IRV LPi 30D bGfW WEN AY 2y40 V1Lc,W� Vi'lacte- TL af 14, d'r// L/o (,t4-&,C- Mit- 4 7 Yrr-1911 JQ —z b, R i i We the undersigned OPPOSE the relocation of the barn on the Vincent Bertault property located at 95 Navy Street, Orient, NY and request that the Town of Southold Historic Preservation Commission NOT GRANT a Certificate of Appropriateness. Name Address Signature 75 A)1074 ST ,03C•6!'VI P X-160 Vi lion 1. 0 urs eA) 001 GC i sf L.._2D N/l L L-A neh I— "AV y .9 .OGS 1 A We the undersigned OPPOSE the relocation of the barn on the Vincent Bertault property located at 95 Navy Street;Orient, NY and request that the Town of Southold Historic Preservation Commission NOT GRANT a Certificate of Appropriateness. Name Address Signature dw- ��1�- FORM NO. 3 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD BUILDING DEPARTMENT SOUTHOLD,N.Y. NOTICE OF DISAPPROVAL DATE: October 15, 2013 RENEWED: January 24, 2014 AMENDED: February 21, 2014 TO: Gary O'Connor, Architect(Bertault) 102 N. Union Street Lambertville,NJ, 08530 Please take notice that your application dated October 24, 2013 For permit for relocation of an existing barn and an existing shed at Location of property: 95 Navy Street, Orient, NY County Tax Map No. 1000 - Section 26 Block 1 Lot 12.2 Is returned herewith and disapproved on the following grounds: The proposed relocation of two pre-existing accessory buildings on this non-conforming 19,905 square foot lot with two front yards is not permitted pursuant to Article III, Section 280-15, which states, "In the Agricultural-Conservation District and Low-Density Residential R-80,R-120,R-200 and R-400 Districts, accessory buildings and structures or other accessory uses shall be located in the required rear ay rd." The proposed accessory structures, although currently located in the front yard, will be moved to another front yard location. In addition, the proposed construction is not permitted pursuant to Section 170-8 of the Southold Town Code. The proposed construction is subject to Landmark Preservation Commission approval. This Notice of Disapproval was amended to reflect the need for Southold Town Landmark Commission approval. dignature Cc:File, ZBA FORM NO. 3 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD BUILDING DEPARTMENT SOUTHOLD,N.Y. NOTICE OF DISAPPROVAL DATE: October 15, 2013 RENEWED:January 24, 2014 TO: Gary O'Connor, Architect(Bertault) 102 N. Union Street Lambertville,NJ, 08530 Please take notice that your application dated October 24, 2013 For permit for relocation of an existing barn and an existing shed at Location of property: 95 Naw Street, Orient,NY County Tax Map No. 1000 -Section 26 Block 1 Lot 12.2 Is returned herewith and disapproved on the following grounds: The proposed relocation of two pre-existing accessory buildings on this non-conforming 19,905 square foot lot with two front yards is not permitted pursuant to Article III Section 280-15 which states "In the Agricultural-Conservation District and Low-Density Residential R-80 R-120 R-200 and R-400 Districts, accessory buildings and structures or other accessory uses shall be located in the required rear ard." The proposed accessory structures, although currently located in the front yard will be moved to another front yard location. oriz d Signa: Cc: igna re— Cc:File, ZBA April 15, 2014 Chair and Members of the Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission Southold, NY 11971 Re: Commission review of proposed building relocation for the Bertault Residence, 95 Navy Street, Orient, NY 11957 Dear Chair and Board Members: Please accept these written comments into the record in the above referenced matter. I am William Gesell and I own the property, on 20 Vincent St, which adjoins the north east corner of the Bertault property. The common property line is 104.45 feet. My sister- in- law Sonia Gesell owns the property to the east of the Bertault property and has a common property line of 154.15 feet. My sister in law planned to be here today but unfortunately could not attend due to the death of her mother. Sonia is in agreement with comments made below. Orient has a rich history with many lovely and unique historic structures. Recognizing the importance of maintaining Orients unique and historical character for future generations, the Board of Directors of the Oysterponds Historical Society, in 1973, set out to inventory the historic structures in the Village of Orient and to have the district registered with the Department of_-Interior under the National Historic Prevention Act of 1966. This work was completed May 21, 1973 when the Orient Historical District was established and placedon the National Register of Historical Places. A booklet entitled "Historic Orient Village" published by the Oysterponds Historical Society provides a list of historic structures in the district. The introduction to this booklet states that "For the purposes of the official Historic District an old building was defined as any structure-including monuments, a i cemetery, a wharf and even a tree-in existence before 1900 and now standing within the boundaries of the District." The structures located on the property owned by Mr. Bertault, my sister-in-law and me are all listed as being part of the Orient Historical District. Mr. Bertault proposes to relocate (defined as "removal" by code) a 10'x18' shed located immediately behind the main residence on Navy Street and a"barn" which is currently visible from Navy Street. It should be noted that the "barn" appears to be two structures that were joined together in the early 1900s. The first section is 22.6'x 25.8' and faces Navy Street. This section appears to be a carriage house which was more than likely build before 1900 as part of the original property development. A 12.5'x 23' extension was added to the back side of the carriage house likely in the early 1900s Sonia and I have no objection to the relocation of the "shed" but do object to the relocation of the "barn" for the following reasons. 1. The fagade, symmetry and character of the Bertault property, as viewed from Navy Street, will be changed from the unique architectural and historic perspective which has existed for over 100 years. 2. Keeping the "barn" in its current location is important to preserve the history and character of Orient Village. 3. The "barn" (carriage house) in its relationship to the historic primary residence on Navy Street, is of such historic interest that its relocation would be to the detriment of the community. 4. Relocating "barn" will require removal of the historic Willow Tree for which Willow Street is named. Note, as referenced above, that even trees are considered a structure and part of Orient Historic District. 5. Other existing trees and shrubs will be removed or relocated. The relocation of the two Holly Trees which have been in place since early 1900s is "risky because you lose the majority of the feeder roots", per Sandy Feather of the Penn State Extension. 6. Placing the "barn" on the proposed location on Willow Street will be out of size and scale and adversely impact adjoining properties. For example my front property line will now face the side of a 48.4' "barn" rather than the existing park like view. 7. Property values on Vincent and Willow Streets will likely be adversely impacted. As a final point the relocation of the "barn" is unnecessary in order for Mr. Bertault to achieve the objectives he mentioned to Zoning Board of Appeals in March 2014. The "barn" in its existing location can be used as a garage and storage area for boat equipment using access to Navy Street. A pervious driveway and/or sanitary covers over the existing septic-system make this access possible. Also existing drainage can be improved to prevent water damage to "barn" and foundation. It is respectively requested that the Commission deny Mr. Bertault's request to relocate the "barn" and not grant a Certificate of Appropriateness. Sincerely, William Gesell 20,Vincent St. Orient, NY 11957 OL 1.4 ., - •,i� � •�� .♦ •_ '•t � � • � „off f• a�M'• s �.•1 10 t4r •• y,� .1►aTee .. t. ♦. ;mel e.. �, fir'" ; y •. � � C .r• � �;,fi'{ r f � {}l-�y' WX Mill " AREA= 19,905 SQ.FT. N SURVEY OF PROPERTY AT ORIENT TOWN OF SOUTHOLD SUFFOLK COUNTY, N. Y. 1000-26-01-12.2 SCALE. .1'= 30' DECEMBER 12, 2012 APRIL 25, 2013 (LOCATED WALL) CL.EL. 4.7' C4.5L. , ' . TREET WILL0 W 4.5' S ti N8578830"E 65.93 5LOCUST FE.1.6's.�k EI-5.2 - _ ' ' EL-4.2 1.6'W. I 3 44" TREE o+oNi N/O/F JOANN T. & cR R H ern.' _WILLIAM H. GESELL ' N 18" HOLLY I 16" HOLL FE.O.2'W. 1 I N89156'00"E 54.53' MON.o.2'N VEL-4.9' STOCKADE FE. 0.4'E. 7 IN 10"TR L.6.6' OFE.O/L. 20"TREE 15"WHITE O O BIRCH Lot ! 416 L. 10'TR 41 N 50" BEACH TREE C)0 nSHED512. B'TREE 18 EVERGREEN Z 12"TREE 5.0' Lot as 033.,9' 8"TRE " '*T 10.7 #' 11'EVERGREEN - 1t/2gTY, 4/6' , FRAME t� _ -- TREES - BARN b (FLR.EL.6,1) D Q M.M.POND 22.6' v 36 a 24" CEDAR -� m 5. 10.4 it r • N, �Nc.wALL � r Ni 1;nQ�' ml o - N 10.4' WELL W 4'TREE Z I U11L,ROOM I VI' O Q,10.1 i5. ' WALL w 1 STY. 13'TREE I 0.7'W cn HSE' 0 V 114 VP 19"SPRUCE 14.4 2 STORY 4 FRAME I 0 HOUS66.5') SEP¶C O (F.FLR•EL FE.O/L tA 28.6' COVERED �+ �� -126.23 16.6 m PORCH 20TREE 19"TREE PIcKET FES EL.5.9' •� 1.1' • ' Ao EL '49'40 .4.6 "W S86'18'20"W 85.71 S82 17.86 c5.4' C4 8• ST RET• 5.4 NAVY - - Bldg Dept copy'from ZBA _ Final reviewed documents ZBA-File# Date: MONUMENT ELEVATIONS ARE REFERENCED TO N.A.V D. O�NEW), Lot, (2)'s refer to "SUBDIVISION MAP FOR JOHN H.-WOODHOUSE & JERILYN B. WOODHOUSE" FILED IN THE SUFFOLK COUNTY CLERK'S OFFICE 0� � , '� ON APRIL 19, 2005 AS FILE No.11245 0- NOTE: NOTE: PROPERTY LOCATED"ENTIRELY IN AE6 ZONE , �•-,- � FROM FIRM. No. 36163CO068H 9/25/2009. N. Y.S LIC. N0. 49618 ANY ALTERATION i A4DI77ON TO THIS SURVEY IS A VIOLA77ON e , /V0 406i�° lC SURVEYORS P.C. OF SECTION 72090F 7HE NEW-YORK STATE 'EDUCA77ON LAW. `� t1 765-5020 FAX 631 765-1797 EXCEPT AS PER SEC71ON 7209-SUBDIVISION 2. ALL CER77FICA77ONS ANJ HEREON ARE VALID FOR THIS MAP AND COPIES THEREOF ONLY IF P.O. BOX 909 SAID MAP OR COPIES BEAR 7HE IMPRESSED SEAL OF THE SURVEYOR 1230 TRAVELER STREET 12-279 WHOSE SIGNATURE APPEARS HEREON. SOUTHOLD, N.Y. 11971 Gary R. O'Connor PROPOSED BUILDING RELOCATION 102CNol North Union Street ¢�(p�y zD� ' Lambertville NJ 08530 \ lV - ; • . f for the Phone: 609.397.363 BERTAULT RESIDENCE PROJECT DATA TAX MAP ID, 100b26-01�12,2 LOT# 2(LOT#REFERS TO 95 NAVY STREET, ORIENT, NY 11957 SUBDIVISION O`N$UFF°LK°°.°`ERK'$°FE°E APRIL 19,2005 AS FILE NO. 11245. ADDRESS, 95 NAVY STREET ORIENT,NY 11957 ZONING DISTRICT, R40,RESIDENTIAL LOW DENSI7YAA ABBREVIATIONS ARCHITECTURAL LEGEND 6 PROPERTY ENTIRELY IN AREA=/) _ 19 905 SQ ri T CL.EL. FROMFIR LOCATEDENTIRELY IN 200 FLOOD HAZARD ZONE 1�1 ).�t rIl 'c� 1 � FROM FIRM.No.3fi103C0068H 9/25/2009. EXISTING WALL TO REMAIN 4.7 DESCRIPTION OF USE, EXISTING PRINCIPAL BUILDING IS AT WO FA.B. A.ah., F M.C. Member RF.H. Roof Hatch -°'g"+'�'�`'""`"'"w" `="'-� NEWWALL CL EL. -�y�0 � ORIGINAL WITHG ACCESSORY 1.5 FR 4.5 T III)uL' n, B A N AN TORY FR EXISTING ACCESSORY LS STORY FRAME MEC Medicine Cabinet RFL Retied(ea)(iris)(or) �� J� BARN AND I STORY FRAME SHED. t F. Fahrenheit MED. Mechanic(al) R.H. Right Henri ---- ------ EXISTING WALL TO REMOVED 0 SIMILAR OR EQUAL TO AC Acoustic F.B.O. Furnished 6y MED. Medium RM. Room ---------- 7 GRASSPAVE2 BY INVISIBLE PROPOSED, THE ACCESSORY BARN AND SHED IS PROPOSED TO A.C. Asphaltic Concrete Others MET. Membrane R.O. Rough Opening rj A/C Air Condittioning PERK Firebrick MET. Metal R/W Right of Way — —— DATUM LINE STRUCTURES, INC. BE REPOSITIONED ON THE PROPERTY AS SHOWN FOR VEHICULAR AD. Area Dram F.D. FloorDin MFR. Manufacturer R.W.L. Rain Water Leader ENTRY FROM IMLLOW STREET. ADJ. Adjustable FDN. Foundation MH. Manhole R&R Remove&Replace — AGGR. Aggregate F.E. Fire Extinguisher MIN. Minimum PROPERTY LINE EL rj,2 AL. Aluminum FGL Fiberglass MIR. Mirror S N85 '-2B O E 65 9T 5"LOC ST X _ RELOCATE 18" HOLLY ALT, Alternate F.H. Fire Hose MISC. Mian,laneous - - CENTER LINE - AMP. Ampere F.H,M.S. Flat Head Metal MLD. Moulding SA R, Supply Air Register �(� I 0 0� FE'W— & ANOD. Anodized S. MOV. Movable B.C. Solid Cate x p0 1.6 W' APR Apron F.H.W.S. Flat Head Wood MRB Marble S.C.D. Seat Cover Dispenser SSA" DIMENSION TO FACE OF BLDG. SE BA ¢,'Q' , Z to APPROX. Approximate Screw MT. Mount(ed) SCHED. Schedule STRUCTURE ¢.1' AVERAGE ��xEL. {} "TREEI O Nms " ARCH. Architect FIN. Finish(ed) MTL Material SCR Screen ON WILLOW STREET i 0 A 1 O ASPH. Asphalt FIX. Fixed MUL, Mullion S.D. Storm Drain RELOCATE 16" HOLLY >0 in Cv ZONING COMPUTATIONS AS.T.M. Am.Soc.for Testing FL. Haor MWK Millwork SECT. Bectian WORK POINT FLASH. Flashing SH. Shelf(Shchas) POINT/CONTROL POINT m� 22'-I a G AUTO. Automatic FLUOR, Fluorescent SHO, Shore(d)(ing) 16 'WILD REQUIRED EXISTING PROPOSED AF.F. Above Finished Haar F.O.C. Face of Concrete SHT. Sheet SHTH. Sheathing DOORSYMBOL AT.C. Above top of F.O.M. Face of Masonry N SKL Skylight ' I , 1e.�I �_\ CHERRY x CV LOT REQUIREMEN'15, Concrete F.O.S. Face of Stud SL Sliding �BatLY tp• �I U) MIN.LOT AREA 40,000.S.F. 19,905.S.F. NO CHANGE B F.O.W. Face of Wall N North SL Similar _ I Bis I I MIN.LOT WIDTH 150' 103.57' NO CHANGE BD. Board FPL Fireplace (N) New S.N.D. Sanitary Napkin (� WINDOW SYMBOL t BET. Between FPRF. Fireproof NAT, Natural Dispenser N —' FE.. .2'W. k BIT. Bituminous F.S. Full Stu N.I.C. Not to Contract S.N.R. Sanitary Napkin RELOCATED n I Q n r PRINCIPAL BUILDING MINIMUM YARD/HT.REQUIREMENTS, B.L. Building Line FT, Foot NOM. Nominal Receptacle l5 KEYNOTE SYMBOL V! 1 1/2 STY. I ' V v✓ vJ O U ' 5�' 5,J ' MON.0.2'N FTG. Footing N.T.S. Not to Scale REQUIRED EXISTING PROPOSED BLDG. Block Shrl Sealant E.1.5'N. 0.4'E. BLK Block FUR. Forcing S.P. Soundproof(ing) z � FRAME BARN k EL.4. 9' STOCKADE FE. rxoNTYAAD so' 1.1 NO CHANGE BLKG. Blocking FUT. Future SPC. Spacer Z SIDE YARD MIN. 15' 16.6' NO CHANGE B.M. Bench Mark FR.DR. Fire Door O SP.D, Soap Dispenser 3 N F.FLR 7' IN 15"WHITE TOTALSIDEYARDS 35' 54.91' NO CHANGE SPEC. Specification ELEVATION REFERENCE 10"TR I L.6.6 BM. Beam pea A-5 -� BOT. Bottom O/ Over SPIKE. Speaker U' EL.=7.o' BIRCH REAR YARD 50' 157.fiT NO CHANGE BRO. Bearing OA Overall SPL Special m 10 FE.O/L. I20"TREE MAX HEIGHT 35 Fr,/13 STORIES 23.33'/2 STY NO CHANGE BRK. Brick G OB. Obscure SQ. Square BRZ. Bronze O.C. On Center S.S. Stainless Steel 1,J { MIN.LIVABLE FLOOR AREA 850 SF 1516 SF NO CHANGE B.S. Both Sid. GA Gauge O.D. Outside Diameter S.SK SeMae Sink DETAIL ELEVATION REFERENCE y U) MAX COVERAGE 20% 11.12% NO CHANGE B.F.F. BELOW FIN.FLR. GAL Gallon O.F.C.I. Owner Furnished/ ST. Street i V -p 11 I -{� B.T.C. BELOW FIN FL G.B. Grab Bar Contractor Installed STA Station C ACCESSORY BUILDING MINIMUM YARD/HT.REQUIREMENTS, CONCRETE G.C. General Contractor OFF. Office STD. Standard C C G.I. Galvanized Iron OH. Overhead STL Steel 1 m I 2a-0' 10"TRE I -P REQUIRED EXISTING PROPOSED BTR. Storage SECTION REFERENCE 9-BZ I2'-(o —� GKT. Gasket O.H.M.S. Oval Head Metal Screws GL Gloss O.H.W.S. Oval Heed Wood Screw STRUG'F.Structural S6 15� Lot O2 18"EVERGREEN fff'''```�� MIN.SIDE YARD 20' 33.92' N C CAB. Cabinet GIL Grade O.J. Open Web Joist SUS. Suspended Z / I - MIN.REAR YARD 20' NA N9.CHANGE C.B. Catch Basin $YM. Symmetrical, _ Il L MAX HEIGHT 22' 18,75'/1.5 STY 19.75'/1.5 STY CEM. Cement GRT. Grout OP. Opaque SYN. Synthetic CER Ceramic GVL Gravel OPNG. Opening SYS. System I CU.FT. Cubic Feet GYP. Gypsum OPP. Opposite S. South DETAIL REFERENCE 50" A T EE I 12.Jr I 8"TREE h' A` 660 SF 1073 SF NO CHANGE C,FL Counter Flashing GSM Gavanized Sheet 5.6 I SHED C.I. Casa Iron Metal CLG. Ceiling P T N CLKG. Caulking \ N A H PAR. Parallel T. Tread 2 a oo SHEET INDEX CL Closes T&G Tongue&Groove 12°TREE ,,,.�.' CLR Clear PART. Partition T.S. Towel Bar 1 PHOTOREFRENCE I I D 5.0 CNTR Counter N.B. Hose Bibb PAV. Pav(ed)(Ing)(ement) T C. To f at H.C. Hollow Care P.C.C. Precast Concrete p Lot I _ C.O. Clean Out TEL Telephone f' HD. Head P.C.F. Pounds per Cubic I Co 4"/6" COL Column HD. Header Faoe TEM. Tempmed / 11 EXISTING TREE TO BE 1\+-vr.) 0 CONC. Concrete THERMOThermoemt 10.7 SHEET DESCRIPTION CONT. Continoue HOW. Hardware PERT. Perimeter THK. Thick(..e) REMOVED OR RELOCATED EXSITING TREES CONT. Contamuson HDWD. Hardwood PERM. Permanent THRESH.Thmshold 6"TREE AI TONING CO PROJECT DATA, SITE CONTR. Contract H.M. Hollow Metal PRLFAB. Pmfabrirate(d) TOL. Toleranm 11"EVERGREEN II 11/2 FRAME 0 2°'_°" HOR Horizontal P.L.F. Pounds per Lineal I O-5 ZONING COMPUTATIONS,SITE PLAN CPR Copper HR. Hour Foot T.P. Top of Pavement a C.P. Covered Pomh T.P.D. Toilet Paper Dispenser I BARN O?I A-2 LOCATION/PHOTO MAP CSM Carpet HET. Height atin P.O. Plate Gloss T . Toilet Partition =0101 O CTIL Center a HTG, Heating PKG. Packing TR. Transom CTR Center HVAC HeatingNeneilation PL Plate T.SL Top of Slab T (FLR.EL.6. 1 '� � I AS PLANS&ELEVATIONS CSK Countersunk Air Conditioning PLAM. Plastic Laminate TST. Top of Steel 22 6' CV. Cove PEA . Plaster T.V. Television POROUS;CONC, POROUS FILL/GRAVEL ,M.POND L CW. Cold Water PLY, Plywood T.W. Top of Wall G1 CU.YD. Cubic Yard I PT. Point TYR Typical _ _ / 24" CEDAR AI FINAL MAP D I.D. Inside Diameter P.P. Ponderosa Pine U / / _ IN. Inch PR. Pair rj ( I}� 104 L rn I REVIEWED BY �1a D,A Double Acting INS. Insulation PREFIN. Po finehed U.B.C. Uniform Building Code 'LLL ' �I Co NC.WAI- DBL Double [NT. Interior PROJ. Project UND. Under In fTrl ;'t (;i'I\jc4i DEL. Demolish INT. Intermediate P.S.C. Prestressed Concrete UND. Unfinished EARTH CONCRETE BLOCK W E. WI z SEE DELI ION 0 - DEPT. Department INV. Invert P.S.F. Pounds per Square UR Utinal IIICn p �l 72 p-1 DATED � ., � b DET. Derail Foot J N 2 8 2014 D.E. Douglas Fir, P.S.I. Pounda per Square v t�� PJ 10_4' 50' FRONT YARD SET BA Drinking Fountain J Inch — Y l— 4'T E DIAG. Diagonal PT. Paint(ed) V, Valt - - DIM. Dimension J, Joist P.T,D. Paper Towel Dispenser VAC. Vacuum �I w 13. ro WELL 00M I, :;;Lli.!, lil- DISP, Disposal JAN, Janitor P.T.D./R Paper Towel Dispenser/ VAR. Varnish RIGIDIINSUL. ROUGH WOOD � o UTIL.R 13 D.L Dead Load JT. Joint Receptacle V.B. Vapor Barrier 10.1 DN. Down P.T.R. Paper Towel Receptacle VERT Vertical 03 STY. 5.2 I {� DP. Dampproofmg P.V.C. PolpVinyl Chloride VEST. Vestibule — - N T , DPR Damper K V.G. Vertical Grain , DR Door Q VIN. Vinyl H'SE. DS. Dowrupoor K. Kip(LOGO lb.) VNR Veneer �� J DW. Dumbwaiter Q.T. Quarry Tile V.T. Vinyl Tile KIT. Kitchen BLOCKING ELEVATIONSTONE t 13"TREE DWG. Drawing KO. Knockout Y' ��1 6'7 N KP. Kinkplate W 14.4' \ SEPTIC E Draw. A W. West /� �ji 19"SPRUCE ZFRAME -I'- O ON NAVY STREET 01121114 D5 INCLUDE PHOTOLOCATITIO L R Riser, Air W/ With ` , 410 1 E. East R.AG. RemmAiCGrdl W.B. Wood Base / 8 1j,3 AVERAGE BLDG. SETBACK N0. DATE eY DESCRIPTION EXIST,(E) Existing R.B. Rubber Base 6.5) FE.O/L. PfV151ON5 EA Each LG. Length W.C. Water Closes EL.= RB.T. Rubber Tile GLASS STONE � 16.6 (F.FLR. ED LAB. Labomro WD. Wood E.B. Expansion Bolt n' R.C.P. Reinforced Conrete WDW. Window 28.6 COVE LAM, Laminate pi PORCH 19"TREE E.LF,S. Ext.Ins.Fin.System IAV. Lavatory pe W.G. Wire Gl.s �,� v P 22"TREE IT I5 THE RE5PON51BIUTY OF THE CONTRACTOR E.J. Expansion Joint LH. Left Hand R.D. Roof Drain W,H. Water Heater 3 ELEC. Electtc(al) R.D.F, Recessed Drinking WHA Wheel Bumper r� ■ TO VERIFY ALL FIELD CONDITIONS AND LKR. Locker Fountain .I 2 f COMPARE THEM MTH THE CONSTRUCTION ELEV. Elevation .I. Wrought /,' FE 1 - S`yJ1{ EL. 5'9 DOCUMENTS BEFORE COMMENCING ACTIVITIES, L.L.L Live Load RDWD. Redwood !� PICKET EMER Emergency LT, Light W.M. Wire ut F ERRORS,OMMI5510N50R ANY OTHER ENAM. Enamel LVIL Louver REINF. Reffrence, (ing) W/O Without FIN WOOD BRICK ELEVATION 1.1 QJ. I INCONSISTENCIES DISCOVERED SHALL ENC. Enclosure REF. Reference W.P. Water Proofing 6' r�Y-1 " 14/ U ENGR Engineer LBL Label REM Refrigerator W.S. Water Stop VV VV E.P. Electrical Panel REG. Register WSCT, Wainscot )� EL. n �� -fig �- IMMEDIATELY BE REPORTED TO THE ARCHITECT. EQ. Equal M REM. Remove WT. Weight �- � tRq-J O EQUIP. Equipment REQ'D. Requited W.T.W. Wallto Wall tr= Q CL�EL' I'RO]ECTNAME EST, Estimom MAS. Masonry RES, Resilient W.W.M. Welded WiteM.h �a 8 r EXC. Exravare MAX Maximum RET Return Y ,� r� � �� 5.4' PROPOSED BUILDING RELOCATION EXR Exposed M.B. Machine Bolt REV. Revise(ion) BATT BNSUL /� CL.EL. for Cite EXT, Exterior MBAR Moisture Barrier A.F.G. Roofing YD Yard 7 BERTAULT RESIDENCE EX R Extruded �l NAVY V Y 4.8' ORIENT, NY 11957 �JI STREET NOTE: 51TE PLAN INCORPORATE5 DATA DRAW NETTLE PLYW700D FROM SURVEY PREPARED BY: TITLE SHEET,SITE PLAN,ZONING DATA PECONIC 5URVEYOR5, P.C. 1230 TRAVELER STREET DATE 10/IB/13 DRAWING NO. 50UTHOLD, N.Y. 1 1971 1241 DATED DECEMBER 12, 2012 JOB NO, SCALE, AS SHOWN A. 1 DRAWN DS I BY, RELEASEDTO 5 FpI T C L I L/lN SCALE: / 6" ° '_0n REVIEWED PERMIT DATE BY: G.R.O'C I J Gary K. O'Connor ARCHITECT, LLC. 102 North Union Street Lambertville, NJ 05530 � �'� NYLIC`. 02055 R. Phone: 609.397.3635 °" ; 4, F. F� KF� k5, t L t { IJ y t 3 J. eJ t� v BARN / CARRIAGE I15E. #3 BARN / CARRIAGE H5E. #4 FLEI"OHER STREET, ORIENT, NY� FLETCHER5TREET C7RIENT, NY VIEW Of PROP05 D BARN LOCATION DtSTANOE FROfih EARN Tt7 THE STREET 1 21-01 fP\OM WILLOW 5TREET ijijil IS I iii IN y 1 „ re I t+r � ,t st s. ...tr 1 .• k'r f i VIEW Of PP\OPO5ED BARN 0CATION BARN,1 CARRIAGE H5f. #2 ERC I I VINCENT STREET - VINCENT STREET, ORIENT, NY DI5TANCE FROM BARN TO THE STREET 12`-O' JAN F ZDtk r 7 01l34114 pg INCLUDE J'HOT{7 LbCATlON3 BY DES£RIPT(ON IT I5 ThI!RE5FON5INUT OF ME CONTRACTOR %.- 't,;r.. s t TOvrRFYALL FIEG3CoNvmoN5AND e COMPARE THEM WfENThE£ON5MCRON UCJCIJMENS36EFORE C6MMENC7N6 A£FiVITIES, C r Tn t7t`f EKRC)R5 OMMLS310NS OR ANYOTHM INCON513TENGE5 DOCOVERED.`MNJ- A "y iii t +'t'Ylt�ri ` F IMMEDIAMYBE REPORTEDTO THE AXhffECT, PROJECT NAME tsar �' PKOPO5ffD BUILDING RELOCATION 1 Es BERTAULToRE5(DENCE 95 NAVY STREET ORIENT,' NY 1 1957_ DRAWING TITLE NEIOHDORHOOD PRECEDENCE PHOT05 BARN 1 CARRIAGE H5E. # I FRONT VIEW CAE BERTAULT BARN DATE I01Ier13 DRAWING NO WILLOW STREET, ORIENT, NY 015TANCE FROM BARN TO PROPERTY LINE I .8' �r DRAWN SCALE: '.AS SHOWN ! A. '.. DRAWN DS by: REL "ED'.TO ` L ' ATI i Phut SAP INDICATING � I I C H HA A TEP.1 T1 AND PRECEDENCE F BARN CARRIAGE HOME REVIEWED CONSTRUCTION eY. : cRO£ Gary K, O'Connor RED AqC �5 y R' N _ ARCHITECT, LLC. REAR ROOF I T-I I" ± < o'co 4. DN. FU 02 North Union Street O Lambertville, NJ 08530 Phone: G09.397.3G35 < = , TOP PLATE 2'-0 8' (E) HEATER - - - - - - - - --- (E) RESTROOM SECOND FLOOR 8'-0 8" I 1 GROUND FLOOR 0'-0" - - 1 UP0 - - - - - - - - - - EAST ELEVATION SCALE: 11411 = I'-G" _ r FRONT ROOF 18'-5' ± — L - - - - I L TOP PLATE 12'-0 8" if I 5ECOND FLOOR 8'-0 8" I I 1 I L L. L GROUND FLOOR 0'-0" — WEST ELEVATION SCALE: 1/4" 1 1-01, _ PERVIOUS APRON 51MILAR OR EQUAL TO GRA55PAVE2 BY INV151DLE 5TRUCTURE5, INC -- 1 I \ I I EXISTI NG BARN FLOOR PLAN JAN 2 8 2014 SCALE: 1/4" = I'-0" (E) DETACHED SHED I I i I I FRONT ROOF 18'-9" + REAR ROOF 1 T_1 1 II I II I LJ I 01/21114 OS INCLUDE PHOTO LOCATIONS 11 WEST ELEVATION NO, DATE 5Y DE5CRIPTION TOP PLATE 2'-0 B" SCALE: 114" = I'-0" REVISIONS - - L- - - J IT 15 THE RE5PON5113UTY OF THE CONTRACTOR BUILDING HT, 12-7' To VERIFY ALL rIELDCONDITON5AND SECOND FLOOR 8'-0�" — — - COMPARE THEM WTH THE CON5TRUCTION DOCUMENT5 DEFORE COMMENCING ACTIVITIE5, 8 - ERROR5,OMMISSIONS OR ANY OTHER L FIRST FLOOR PLAN MME"ATELY01E REPORTED TO THEA°RCHITECT. SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" \ PROJECT NAME PROPOSED BUILDING RELOCATION y for BERTAULT PE51DENCE 95 NAVY STREET ORIENT, NY 1 1957 DRAWING TITLE GROUND FLOOR 01_0 PLANS 4 ELEVATION5 1 fill DATE IQ18113 DRAWING NO. SOUTH ELEVATION I 241 A . 3 JOB NO. SCALE: AS SHOWN NORTH ELEVATION _ SOUTH ELEVATION 5CALE: u4" = 1'-0" 5CALE: 1/4" = '-o° BY: °5 BY: RELEASED TO SCALE: 1/4 - G U I--I REVIEWED CONSTRUCTION gY: GROG