HomeMy WebLinkAboutTRA-04/05/2018 fd'N� i yi„r
Michael J. Domino, PresidentTown Hall Annex
54375 Route 25
John M. Bredemeyer III,Vice-President
P.O. Box 1179
Glenn Goldsmith 6 Southold,New York 11971
a
A. Nicholas Krupski Telephone (631) 765-1892
Greg Williams � �� � �;''�
Fax(631) 765-6641
BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
SPECIAL PUBLIC HEARING AGENDA
Kiln—hW � ,, _ k
Thursday, April 5, 2018
5:OOPM
CALL MEETING TO ORDER
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
NEXT FIELD INSPECTION: Wednesday, April 11, 2018 at 8:00 AM
NEXT TRUSTEE MEETING: Wednesday, April 18, 2018 at 5:30 PM at the Main Meeting
Hall
WORK SESSIONS: Monday, April 16, 2018 at 4:30 PM at the Town Hall Annex 2nd floor
Board Room, and on Wednesday, April 18, 2018 at 5:00 PM at the Main
Meeting Hall
MINUTES: Approve Minutes of March 23, 2018.
I. PUBLIC NOTICES: Public Notices are posted on the Town Clerk's Bulletin Board for
review.
II. STATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY REVIEWS:
RESOLVED that the Board of Trustees of the Town of Southold hereby finds that the
following applications more fully described in Section V Public Hearings Section of the
Trustee agenda dated Thursday, April 5, 2018, are classified as Type II Actions pursuant
to SEQRA Rules and Regulations, and are not subject to further review under SEQRA:
John & Jessica Lupovici — SCTM# 1000-99-4-18
Peter Negri & Elizabeth Kaye Negri — SCTM# 1000-119-1-6.1
Bim E. Strasberg & Alexandra M. Lewis — SCTM# 1000-135-1-1
Oliver Frankel —SCTM# 1000-13-2-8.21
860 Bayview Drive, LLC — SCTM# 1000-37-5-10.1
Joanna Dixon Reisman — SCTM# 1000-54-5-1
Edward & Diane Daley — SCTM# 1000-81-3-23
Nassau Point Causeway Association —SCTM# 1000-104-8-8.1
Lucinda Barnes— SCTM# 1000-40-1-21
2
Ryan Stork— SCTM# 1000-123-8-1
David Krupnick— SCTM# 1000-115-12-13
Cartwright Family Trust— SCTM# 1000-114-10-20.9
Orient Acres, LLC, c/o Eva Mallis, LLC Member— SCTM# 1000-14-2-25
RESOLVED that the Board of Trustees of the Town of Southold hereby finds that the
following applications more fully described in Section V Public Hearings Section of the
Trustee agenda dated Thursday, April 5, 2018, are classified as Unlisted Actions
pursuant to SEQRA Rules and Regulations. A Long Environmental Assessment Form
and a field inspection have been completed by the Trustees for the following applications
and it is hereby determined that they will not have a significant effect on the
environment:
John & Jessica Lupovici — SCTM# 1000-99-4-18
Martha E. Torrance & Lucie T. Turrentine —SCTM# 1000-10-9-5.1
John & Evelyn Braun — SCTM# 1000-115-12-9
John & Claudia Oxee —SCTM# 1000-113-9-5
RESOLVED that the Board of Trustees of the Town of Southold hereby finds that the
following applications more fully described in Section V Public Hearings Section of the
Trustee agenda dated Thursday, April 5, 2018, are classified as Unlisted Actions
pursuant to SEQRA Rules and Regulations. A Long Environmental Assessment Form
and a field inspection have been completed by the Trustees for the following applications
and it is hereby determined that they will have a significant effect on the environment:
Charles & Brenda Grimes — SCTM# 1000-86-2-12.6
John & Kori Estrada —SCTM# 1000-123-4-7
Donna Blanchard — SCTM# 1000-56-5-21
Karen & Carey Flaherty— SCTM# 1000-56-5-39
III. ENVIRONMENTAL DECLARATION OF SIGNIFICANCE PURSUANT TO NEW YORK
STATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY REVIEW ACT NYCCR PART 6117:
DESCRIPTION OF ACTION: Patricia C. Moore, Esq. on behalf of JOHN & JESSICA
LUPOVICI requests a Wetland Permit to cut back 135 linear feet of dilapidated bulkhead
to t6" above grade and plant area with alterna flora 18" o.c. to restore area of intertidal
marsh (approximately 2,400sq.ft.); reconstruct 51' and 41' (92 linear feet) of existing
functional bulkhead in-place and 2' higher than existing using c-lock vinyl sheathing, and
construct a new 18' vinyl return on west side using thru-flo safety cap; install 140 linear
feet of rock revetment landward of scarp and Spring High Water (SHW); backfill
disturbed areas as needed with ±75 cubic yards of material from stone excavation;
existing remains of 5'x128 linear foot long catwalk to be removed; off east side of new
bulkhead, construct a new 4'x24' fixed catwalk; a 3'x18' seasonal ramp; and a 6'x20'
seasonal floating dock secured by (2) new 8" diameter piles. Located: 1625 Naugles
Drive, Mattituck. SCTM# 1000-99-4-18
S.E.Q.R.A. NEGATIVE DECLARATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL SIGNIFICANCE.-
WHEREAS,
IGNIFICANCE:WHEREAS, on March 19, 2018 the Southold Town Board of Trustees found the
application of JOHN & JESSICA LUPOVICI is to be classified as an Unlisted Action
Negative Decision pursuant to SEQRA Rules and Regulations. A Long Environmental
Assessment Form and a field inspection have been completed by the Board of Trustees
and it is hereby determined that it will not have a significant effect on the environment,
and;
3
WHEREAS, the Southold Town Board of Trustees are familiar with this project having
visited the site on March 14, 2018, and having considered plans for this project dated
February 9, 2018, and a K.M. Woychuk survey dated June 6, 2016, revised January 30,
2018, showing the proposed dock and water depths provided by Sea Level Mapping
(September 28, 2017), and;
WHEREAS, in reviewing project plans dated February 9, 2018 and water depths dated
September 28, 2017, it has been determined by the Board of Trustees that all potentially
significant environmental concerns have been addressed as noted herein:
• Navigation: The proposed dock meets standards and does not extend beyond
1/3 across the water body. Depths for the dock terminus are within Town
Trustees, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation and United
States Army Corps. of Engineers guidelines and there is no recognized
Federal/New York State/Town navigation channel in the immediate vicinity of the
proposed structure.
• Scope: The proposed dock is comparable to docks on neighboring properties in
an area where docks historically are used for commercial and recreational
purposes.
• Toxicity: The proposed dock decking shall be constructed entirely of non-toxic
materials.
• Scope in relation to the riparian rights of shellfishers: The plan allows a standard
ramp to float design that will not impede access for small vessels at low tide, and
those seeking shellfish and crustacea on foot in season.
• Scope in relation to the rights of small human powered water craft to navigate the
waters adjacent to the proposed structures: At low tide a kayak might be able to
paddle around this proposed structure as it projects only 33 feet into the
waterbody.
• Scope in relation to view sheds: The seaward end of the proposed dock lies
landward of all existing docks that frame the view shed. As such the perspective
will not be discernibly different from the existing view.
• Environmental upkeep: The dock design projects a lifespan of 30 years, and with
limited pile replacement minimizes bottom disturbance.
THEREFORE, according to the foregoing, the Southold Town Board of Trustees
Approve and Authorize the preparation of a Notice of Negative Declaration pursuant to
SEQRA for the aforementioned project.
DESCRIPTION OF ACTION: J.M.O. Environmental Consulting on behalf of MARTHA E.
TORRANCE & LUCIE T. TURRENTINE requests a Wetland Permit and a Coastal
Erosion Permit to construct a 4'x50' fixed dock; a 4'x20' ramp with railings; and an 8'x16'
floating dock. Located: 468 Sterling Street, Fishers Island. SCTM# 1000-10-9-5.1
S.E,Q.R.A. NEGATIVE DECLARATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL SIGNIFICANCE:
WHEREAS, on March 19, 2018 the Southold Town Board of Trustees found that the
application of MARTHA E. TORRANCE & LUCIE T. TURRENTINE is to be classified as
an Unlisted Action Negative Decision pursuant to SEQRA Rules and Regulations. A
Long Environmental Assessment Form has been completed by the Trustees and it is
hereby determined that it will not have a significant effect on the environment.
4
WHEREAS, the Southold Town Board of Trustees having considered plans for this
proposed dock at their March 19, 2018 work session, and;
WHEREAS, in reviewing the project plans dated November 20, 2017 and water depths
by CME Associates Engineering, it has been determined by the Board of Trustees that
all potentially significant environmental concerns have been addressed as noted herein:
• Navigation: The proposed dock meets standards and does not extend beyond
1/3 across the water body. Depths for the dock terminus are within Town
Trustees, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation and United
States Army Corps. of Engineers guidelines, and there is no recognized
Federal/New York State/Town channel in the immediate vicinity of the proposed
structure.
• Scope: The proposed dock is comparable to docks on neighboring properties in
an area where docks are historically used for commercial and recreational
purposes.
• Toxicity: The proposed dock decking shall be constructed entirely of non-toxic
materials.
• Scope in relation to the riparian rights of shellfishers: The plan allows a standard
piling design that will not impede access for small vessels at low tide, and those
seeking shellfish and crustaceans on foot in season.
• Scope in relation to the rights of small human powered water craft to navigate the
waters adjacent to the proposed structures: At low tide a kayak might be able to
paddle beneath this proposed dock.
• Environmental upkeep: The dock design projects a lifespan of 30 years, and with
limited pile replacement minimizes bottom disturbance.
THEREFORE, according to the foregoing, the Southold Town Board of Trustees
Approve and Authorize the preparation of a Notice of Negative Declaration pursuant to
SEQRA for the aforementioned project.
DESCRIPTION OF ACTION: Jeffrey Patanjo on behalf of JOHN & EVELYN BRAUN
requests a Wetland Permit to remove existing fixed dock, ramp and float; construct in
same location a new proposed 4'x45' fixed dock using thru-flow decking and supported
with 8" diameter cca piles; a 3'x16' aluminum ramp; and a 6'x20' floating dock using un-
treated timber decking secured by two (2) 10" diameter cca piles. Located: 680 Deep
Hole Drive, Mattituck. SCTM# 1000-115-12-9
S.E.Q.R.A. NEGATIVE DECLARATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL SIGNIFICANCE:
WHEREAS, the Southold Trustees are familiar with this project having visited the site on
March 14, 2018 and having considered plans for this proposed dock at their March 19,
2018 work session, and;
WHEREAS, in reviewing the project plans dated January 31, 2018, it has been
determined by the Southold Town Board of Trustees that all potentially significant
environmental concerns have been addressed as noted herein:
• Navigation: The proposed dock meets standards and does not extend beyond
1/3 across the water body. Depths for the dock terminus are within Town
Trustees, NYSDEC and USACE guidelines and there is no recognized
5
Federal/New York State/Town navigation channel in the immediate vicinity of the
proposed structure.
• Scope: The proposed dock is not longer than docks on neighboring properties.
• Toxicity: To protect the waters of Peconic Bay the dock's decking shall be
constructed entirely of non-toxic materials.
• Scope in relation to the riparian rights of shellfishers: The plan provides for a
standard piling design that will permit access beneath the decking for small
vessels at low tide and those seeking shellfish and crustacea on foot in season.
Accordingly, it does not materially diminish riparian access to harvest beneficial
marine organisms.
• Scope in relation to the rights of small human powered water craft to navigate the
waters adjacent to the proposed dock: A human powered vessel traveling would
not be inconvenienced by the proposed dock. At low tide a kayak might be able
to paddle beneath most docks in this area.
• Environmental upkeep: The dock design projects a usual lifespan of 30 years
with limited pile replacement so as to minimize disturbance of the bottom.
THEREFORE, on account of the foregoing, the Southold Town Board of Trustees
Approve and Authorize the preparation of a Notice of Negative Declaration pursuant to
SEQRA for the aforementioned project.
DESCRIPTION OF ACTION: JOHN & CLAUDIA OXEE requests a Transfer of Wetland
Permit#1933, as issued on February 27, 1985, and Wetland Permit#296, as issued on
June 26, 1986 from Martin & Florence Gellman to John & Claudia Oxee; and for an
Administrative Amendment to extend the fixed catwalk an additional 5' wide by 16' long
on the landward side in order to access the catwalk from the embankment stairs.
Located: 1475 Meday Avenue, Mattituck. SCTM# 1000-113-9-5
S E Q R.A. NEGATIVE DECLARATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL SIGNIFICANCE.
WHEREAS, the Southold Trustees are familiar with this project having visited the site on
January 9, 2018 and having considered plans for this proposed dock at their March 19,
2018 work session, and;
WHEREAS, in reviewing the project plans dated February 2, 2018, it has been
determined by the Southold Town Board of Trustees that all potentially significant
environmental concerns have been addressed as noted herein:
• Navigation: The proposed dock meets standards and does not extend beyond
1/3 across the water body. Depths for the dock terminus are within Town
Trustees, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, and
United States Army Corps. of Engineers guidelines, and there is no recognized
Federal/New York State/Town navigation channel in the immediate vicinity of the
proposed structure.
• Scope: The proposed dock is comparable to docks on neighboring properties in
an area where docks are historically used for commercial and recreational
purposes.
• Toxicity: The proposed dock decking shall be constructed entirely of non-toxic
materials.
6
Scope in relation to the riparian rights of shellfishers: The plan allows a standard
piling design that will not impede access for small vessels at low tide, and those
seeking shellfish and crustaceans on foot in season.
• Scope in relation to the rights of small human powered water craft to navigate
waters adjacent to the proposed structures: At low tide a kayak might be able to
paddle beneath this proposed dock.
Scope in relation to view sheds: The seaward end of the proposed dock lies
landward of all existing docks that frame the view shed.
• Environmental upkeep: The dock design projects a lifespan of 30 years, and with
limited pile replacement minimizes bottom disturbance.
THEREFORE, according to the foregoing, the Southold Town Board of Trustees
Approve and Authorize the preparation of a Notice of Negative Declaration pursuant to
SEQRA for the aforementioned project.
DESCRIPTION OF ACTION: J.M.O. Environmental Consulting on behalf of CHARLES
& BRENDA GRIMES requests a Wetland Permit to construct a 15'x24' bluestone patio
on sand; stepping stone paths; 4'x6' steps; a 4'x158' fixed dock utilizing "Thru-Flow"
decking; a 3'x12' ramp; and a 6'x20' float secured by two (2) piles. Located: 4145 Wells
Road, Peconic. SCTM# 1000-86-2-12.6
S.E.Q.R.A. POSITIVE DECLARATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL SIGNIFICANCE:
WHEREAS, on March 19, 2018 the Southold Town Board of Trustees found that the
application of CHARLES & BRENDA GRIMES is to be classified as an Unlisted Action
Positive Decision pursuant to SEQRA Rules and Regulations. A Long Environmental
Assessment Form and a field inspection have been completed by the Board of Trustees
and it is hereby determined that the proposed dock will have a significant effect on the
environment.
WHEREAS, the Southold Town Board of Trustees are familiar with this project having
visited the site on March 14, 2018 and having considered plans dated May 26, 2016
from J.M.O. Environmental Consulting with water depths by Robert H. Fox dated May
26, 2016, and a survey dated May 9, 2017, at their March 19, 2018 work session, and;
WHEREAS, in reviewing the project plans dated May 26, 2016, from J.M.O.
Environmental Consulting with water depths by Robert H. Fox dated May 26, 2016, and
a survey dated May 9, 2017 it has been determined by the Board of Trustees that
potentially significant environmental concerns have been noted herein:
• Scope: Whereas, Chapter 275-11(2)(C)[c] sets forth that in determining the
permitted length of a proposed residential dock, the Board of Trustees shall seek
to maintain lengths consistent with other docks (i.e. the pier line) in the waterway.
The proposed 185 foot total dock assembly greatly exceeds permitted docks in
the area (see attached study).
• Toxicity: To protect the headwaters of Richmond Creek where poor water
exchange and circulation are considered a possibility, the dock shall be
constructed entirely of non-toxic materials.
• Scope in relation to riparian rights of shellfishers: The plan provides for a
standard piling design along the 158 foot catwalk length that will impede access
for vessels at low tide and those seeking shellfish and crustacea on foot in
7
season. Accordingly, it will diminish riparian access to harvest beneficial marine
organisms.
• Scope in relation to the rights of human powered water craft: The 185 foot
proposed dock is an unnecessary infringement of the rights of human powered
craft to traverse the north side of Richmond Creek.
• Environmental upkeep: The Board of Trustees requirement of non-toxic materials
on dock projects within Richmond Creek will translate into a shorter than 30 year
lifespan for the pilings. Accordingly, piling replacement will have a negative
impact on the benthos community beneath and around the structure.
THEREFORE, on account of the foregoing, the Southold Town Board of Trustees
Approve and Authorize the preparation of a Notice of Positive Declaration pursuant to
SEQRA for the aforementioned project.
DESCRIPTION OF ACTION: Michael Kimack on behalf of JOHN & KORI ESTRADA
request a Transfer of Wetland Permit#4096 from David B. Tuthill to John and Kori
Estrada as issued on December 10, 1992, and Amended on June 1, 1993; and for an
Amendment to Wetland Permit#4096 to construct a 4'x8' fixed dock extension using
Thru-Flow decking and two (2) 8" diameter dock pilings onto the seaward end of existing
fixed dock for a new total length of 58'; reconfigure existing floating dock to an "L" shape
configuration; relocate the existing two sets of floating dock securing two-batter pilings;
and install one 8"-10" tie-off piling approximately 15' to the west from the new floating
dock location. Located: 2350 Deep Hole Drive, Mattituck. SCTM# 1000-123-4-7
S E.Q.R.A. POSITIVE DECLARATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL SIGNIFICANCE:
WHEREAS, on March 19, 2018 the Southold Town Board of Trustees found that the
application of JOHN & KORI ESTRADA is to be classified as an Unlisted Action Positive
Decision pursuant to SEQRA Rules and Regulations. A Long Environmental
Assessment Form and a field inspection have been completed by the Board of Trustees
and it is hereby determined that the proposed dock will have a significant effect on the
environment.
WHEREAS, the Southold Town Board of Trustees are familiar with this project having
visited the site on March 14, 2018 and having considered plans for this proposed dock at
their March 19, 2018 work session, and;
WHEREAS, in reviewing the project plans dated October 5, 1992, revised March 19,
2018, and the Nathan T. Corwin survey dated January 17, 2008, it has been determined
by the Board of Trustees that potentially significant environmental concerns have been
noted herein:
• Navigation: The proposed dock does not meet the standards as set forth in
Chapter 275-11 C(2)(a) "docks shall be designed, constructed, and located so as
to reduce a dock's potential adverse impacts to navigation, public safety, and
waterway congestion." The proposed dock and configuration including the beam
of a docked vessel potentially creates navigation issues for the neighboring
docks and the public. In addition Chapter 275-11 C(2)(b)[2] "within creeks and
narrow waterways, no dock length shall exceed 1/3 the total width of the
waterbody. Determination of the length of the dock must include the dimensions
8
of the vessel." The proposed dock and survey do not show a vessel nor the
distance across the waterway as required.
• Scope: The dock as it is presently configured is comparable to docks on
neighboring properties.
• Scope in relation to riparian rights of shellfishers: The plan provides for a
standard piling design that will permit access beneath the decking for small
vessels at low tide and those seeking shellfish and crustacea on foot during
season.
• Environmental upkeep: The dock design projects a usual lifespan of 30 years
with limited pile replacement so as to minimize disturbance of the bottom.
THEREFORE, on account of the foregoing, the Southold Town Board of Trustees
Approve and Authorize the preparation of a Notice of Positive Declaration pursuant to
SEQRA for the aforementioned project.
DESCRIPTION OF ACTION: En-Consultants on behalf of DONNA BLANCHARD
request a Wetland Permit to remove existing 15 sq.ft. fixed platform, 3'x10' ramp, and
6'x12' floating dock; and install new 3'x14' ramp off existing bulkhead, and 5'x14' floating
dock secured by two (2) 8" diameter pilings; dock to be equipped with water and
electricity. Located: 50 Budds Pond Road, Southold. SCTM# 1000-56-5-21
S.E.Q.R.A. POSITIVE DECLARATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL SIGNIFICANCE;
WHEREAS, on March 19, 2018 the Southold Town Board of Trustees found that the
application of DONNA BLANCHARD is to be classified as an Unlisted Action Positive
Decision pursuant to SEQRA Rules and Regulations. A Long Environmental
Assessment Form and a field inspection have been completed by the Board of Trustees
and it is hereby determined that it will have an impact on the environment.
WHEREAS, the Southold Town Board of Trustees are familiar with this project having
visited the site on March 14, 2018 and having considered plans for the proposed dock at
their March 19, 2018 work session, and;
WHEREAS, in reviewing the project plans dated February 12, 2018 and revised plans on
February 16, 2018, and survey with water depths dated January 23, 2002, it has been
determined by the Board of Trustees that potentially significant environmental concerns
have been noted herein:
• Navigation: The proposed dock does not meet standards and does not meet
standards as set forth in Chapter 275-11(d)[1] "whether the dock will impair
navigation or be located in areas of high vessel congestion," [2] "whether the
dock will unduly interfere with the public use of waterways for swimming, boating,
shellfishing, waterskiing, and other water-dependent activities,"[4] "whether the
dock will significantly impair the use or value of waterfront property adjacent to or
near the dock."
THEREFORE, according to the foregoing, the Southold Town Board of Trustees
Approve and Authorize the preparation of a Notice of Positive Declaration pursuant to
SEQRA for the aforementioned project.
9
DESCRIPTION OF ACTION: Jeffrey Patanjo on behalf of KAREN & CAREY
FLAHERTY requests a Wetland Permit to remove existing fixed dock and steps to
beach, and replace with a proposed 4'x68' fixed dock supported with 10" diameter cca
piles; install a seasonal 30"x16' aluminum ramp; install a 6'x20' seasonal floating dock
with un-treated timber decking situated in an "I" configuration and supported by two (2)
10" diameter cca piles. Located: 1077 Bay Home Road, Southold. SCTM# 1000-56-5-
39
S.E.Q.R.A. POSITIVE DECLARATION SOF ENVIRONMENTAL SIGNIFICANCE:
WHEREAS, on March 19, 2018 the Southold Town Board of Trustees found that the
application of KAREN & CAREY FLAHERTY is to be classified as an Unlisted Action
Positive Decision pursuant to SEQRA Rules and Regulations. A Long Environmental
Assessment Form and a field inspection have been completed by the Board of Trustees
and it is hereby determined that it will have a significant effect on the environment.
WHEREAS, the Southold Town Board of Trustees are familiar with this project having
visited the site on March 14, 2018 and having considered plans for this proposed dock at
their March 19, 2018 work session, and;
WHEREAS, having considered the plans dated January 1, 2018 with water depths and a
K.M. Woychuk survey dated September 5, 2016, it has been determined by the Board of
Trustees that potentially significant environmental concerns have been addressed and
noted herein:
• Navigation: The proposed dock does not meet the standards as set forth in
Chapter 275-11(d)[2] "whether the dock will interfere with the public use of
waterways for swimming, boating, shellfishing, water skiing, and other water
dependent activities."
• Coastal erosion: Chapter 96 of the Town Code — Boats, Docks, and Wharves
regulates new construction or placement of dock structures in order to locate
them a safe distance from active erosion of the impacts of coastal storms. The
proposed dock is located in an area with a 10,000 foot plus fetch, a very active
high energy environment. The Board of Trustees recognize the entire physical
aspect of the proposed dock lies in a high energy, high wave, high erosion zone
due to a greater than 180 degree exposure to an open fetch greater than one
mile.
• Scope: The proposed dock is in an area where there are no permitted
neighboring docks used for commercial and recreational purposes, as per
Chapter 275-11 C[10][c][i] and Chapter 275-11 C(2)(a)[c].
• Scope in relation to riparian rights of shellfishers: The plan of a 68 foot long
catwalk, 16 foot long hinged ramp, and 6 foot by 20 foot floating dock has no
provision to allow the public use of the foreshore. Chapter 111 of Town Code
defines nearshore as 1,000 feet from mean low water or to a low-water depth of
15 feet, whichever is greater and determines minimization of dock structures is
paramount to preserving public use and access of the area. Chapter 275-11 C-F
is generally not accepting of development in undeveloped coastal landscapes nor
areas historically absent of dock structures.
• Habitat degradation: The Southold Town Local Waterfront Revitalization Program
states construction of docks in Peconic Bay impacts vegetation through direct
construction impacts, chronic shading, habitat degradation, loss and disruption,
and leaching of harmful contaminants.
10
• Scope in relation to Town Goals and Policies: The Southold Town Board of
Trustees acknowledge Town goals and policies support long-term protection with
consideration of economic and cultural associations, and further reflects existing
laws and authority regarding environmental protection including but not limited to
the Peconic Estuary Program Comprehensive Management Plan and Local
Waterfront Revitalization Program used to find the appropriate balance between
development and conservation.
THEREFORE, on account of the foregoing, the Southold Town Board of Trustees
approve and authorize the preparation of a Notice of Positive Declaration pursuant to
SEQRA for the aforementioned project.
IV. PUBLIC HEARINGS:
THIS IS A PUBLIC HEARING IN THE MATTER OF THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS
FOR PERMITS UNDER THE WETLANDS ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF
SOUTHOLD. I HAVE AN AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION FROM THE SUFFOLK
TIMES. PERTINENT CORRESPONDENCE MAY BE READ PRIOR TO ASKING FOR
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC.
PLEASE KEEP YOUR COMMENTS ORGANIZED AND BRIEF.
FIVE (5) MINUTES OR LESS IF POSSIBLE
AMENDMENTS:
1. En-Consultants on behalf of MATTITUCK PROPERTY FAMILY TRUST request an
Amendment to Wetland Permit#8996 to construct a ±20 linear foot landward extension
onto the recently constructed low-profile vinyl groin. Located: 520 Park Avenue
Extension, Mattituck. SCTM# 1000-123-2-28.4
POSTPONED
2. Michael Kimack on behalf of JOHN AND KORI ESTRADA request a Transfer of
Wetland Permit#4096 from David B. Tuthill to John and Kori Estrada as issued on
December 10, 1992, and Amended on June 1, 1993; and for an Amendment to Wetland
Permit#4096 to construct a 4'x8' fixed dock extension using Thru-Flow decking and two
(2) 8" diameter dock pilings onto the seaward end of existing fixed dock for a new total
length of 58'; reconfigure existing floating dock to an "L" shape configuration; relocate
the existing two sets of floating dock securing two-batter pilings; and install one 8"-10"
tie-off piling approximately 15' to the west from the new floating dock location. Located:
2350 Deep Hole Drive, Mattituck. SCTM# 1000-123-4-7
POSTPONED
11
WETLAND & COASTAL EROSION PERMITS:
1. Michael Kimack on behalf of SOUTHOLD SUNSETS, LLC requests a Coastal Erosion
Permit to demolish existing one-story dwelling, decks and foundation; construct on a
piling system to elevate the finished floor to 16ft. elevation a proposed 957.77sgf.ft. one-
story, single-family dwelling with a combined 262.75sq.ft. of seaward side porch area
with 7.6' wide stairs to ground, and side deck area with 4' wide stairs to ground.
Located: 4200 Kenny's Road, Southold. SCTM# 1000-54-4-3
2. LUCINDA BARNES requests a Wetland Permit to remove invasive/non-native
vegetation and vines within an approximate 9,OOOsq.ft. area landward of the top of bluff,
and re-vegetate area by planting native vegetation consisting of low and high bush
blueberries, beach grass, bayberry, and beach plum; and to maintain the existing access
path to the beach. Located: 63875 County Road 48, Greenport. SCTM# 1000-40-1-21
REVISED PROJECT DESCRIPTION AS OF FEBRUARY 14, 2018:
Michael Kimack on behalf of LUCINDA BARNES requests a Wetland Permit and a
Coastal Erosion Permit to remove invasive/non-native vegetation and vines within an
approximate 9,OOOsq.ft. area landward of the top of bluff, and re-vegetate area by
planting native vegetation consisting of low and high bush blueberries, beach grass,
bayberry, and beach plum; and to maintain the existing approximately 4' wide by 140'
long access path to the beach that consists of three (3) landings, each approximately
20sq.ft. with four (4) stair sections consisting of 36 natural locust log treads set in the
path's grade, and two (2) steps in the approximate area of the slope's toe; and the
downhill side of the pathway consists of imbedded locust logs functioning as retaining
members to stabilize soil. Located: 63875 County Road 48, Greenport. SCTM# 1000-
40-1-21
3. J.M.O. Environmental Consulting on behalf of MARTHA E. TORRANCE & LUCIE T.
TURRENTINE requests a Wetland Permit and a Coastal Erosion Permit to construct a
4'x50' fixed dock; a 4'x20' ramp with railings; and an 8'x16' floating dock. Located: 468
Sterling Street, Fishers Island. SCTM# 1000-10-9-5.1
4. DKR Shores, Inc. on behalf of MARIJO C. ADIMEY & VERONICA M. LUGRIS requests
a Wetland Permit and a Coastal Erosion Permit to remove and replace in-place 84' of
existing vinyl bulkhead with new steel sheet piling bulkhead; install two (2) 20' long
returns; backfill disturbed area with 45 cubic yards of clean fill from an upland source; re-
vegetate disturbed areas with Cape American beach grass and native species of shrubs;
temporarily remove and replace in-place existing bluff stairs with two (2) 12'x16' decks;
reconstruct existing 4'x5' cantilevered platform and aluminum beach access stairs; and
12
install French drains at top of bluff to reduce rain runoff on the bluff face. Located:
21515 Soundview Avenue, Southold. SCTM# 1000-135-1-5
POSTPONED
5. SCOTT KAUFMAN requests a Wetland Permit and a Coastal Erosion Permit to remove
existing damaged stairway and terrace retaining walls; construct along eroding toe of
bluff approximately 210 linear feet of stone revetment, including angled westerly return,
all consisting of approximately 3 to 5 ton stone placed over 50 to 100 pound core stone
and filter cloth; restore bluff face using terrace retaining walls, approximately 600 cubic
yards of sand re-nourishment (including approximately 350 cubic yards to cover
proposed revetment), and native plantings; construct a ±3' wide berm with ±50 cubic
yards of sand/loam within 15' wide vegetated non-turf buffer to be established adjacent
to bluff crest to control storm-water runoff; and construct a new 4'x±50' elevated bluff
stairway with landings and handrails consisting of 4' wide x ±3' long entry steps at top of
bluff down to a 4'x8' upper platform with bench to 4' x ±8' steps to a 4'x8' middle landing
with bench to 4' x ±10' steps to a 4'x4' middle landing to 4' x ±8'steps to a 4'x6.7' lower
landing to 4' x ±14' stairs to beach. Located: 2050 Dignans Road, Cutchogue. SCTM#
1000-83-2-7.3
POSTPONED
WETLAND PERMITS:
1. Michael Kimack on behalf of 860 BAYVIEW DRIVE, LLC requests a Wetland Permit for
the existing 1 & '/2 story dwelling with attached garage (2,314.7sq.ft. footprint); construct
a 190.8sq.ft. addition to existing dwelling; construct a 254.4sq.ft. pavilion attached to
addition; construct a 900sq.ft. swimming pool; construct a 1,766sq.ft. pool patio and
outdoor kitchen area; install approximately 55' of French drain connected to three (3)
8'x13' drywells; construct approximately 88' of retaining wall surrounding the pool, pool
patio, and new addition which is to be of varying height with 5' being the highest.
Located: 860 Bayview Drive, East Marion. SCTM# 1000-37-5-10.1
2. Michael Kimack on behalf of CARTWRIGHT FAMILY TRUST requests a Wetland
Permit to raise the existing 958.9sq.ft. dwelling with attached 190sq.ft. seaward side
screened-in porch to have a first floor elevation of 11.52' above grade by installing 22
18"x18" concrete reinforced piers with microlam (ML) girders, deck joists, floor joists;
new floor under landward entry area; insulate and install exterior grade sheathing under
floor; reconnect all plumbing for water supply and drainage to existing septic; construct
two (2) new staircases with 24sq.ft. landings and two (2) support concrete piers on each.
Located: 55 Second Street, New Suffolk. SCTM# 1000-117-10-20.9
13
3. J.M.O. Environmental Consulting on behalf of CHARLES & BRENDA GRIMES requests
a Wetland Permit to construct a 15'x24' bluestone patio on sand; stepping stone paths;
4'x6' steps; a 4'x158' fixed dock utilizing "Thru-Flow" decking; a 3'x12' ramp; and a
6'x20' float secured by two (2) piles. Located: 4145 Wells Road, Peconic. SCTM#
1000-86-2-12.6
4. Charles R. Cuddy, Esq. on behalf of EDWARD AND DIANE DALEY requests a Wetland
Permit to construct additions and alterations to the existing dwelling consisting of
squaring off seaward side of dwelling and constructing second-story additions to create
a 2 '/2 story, 76.8'x40.8' footprint dwelling; construct an 8'x75.5' seaward side porch;
construct a 8'x52.10' landward side porch; construct a 13.7'x18.1' breezeway leading to
a proposed 26'x30' attached garage on landward side of dwelling; reconfigure existing
driveway approximately 15'-20' to the south to accommodate new garage; construct a
40'x24' swimming pool with 9'x9' hot tub; install a 60'x63' pool patio with 20sq.ft. patio
connecting pool patio and garage; and install a 6' wide concrete walkway from pool patio
to dwelling. Located: 1350 Paradise Point Road, Southold. SCTM# 1000-81-3-23
5. Alfonso Martinez-Fonts, Jr. on behalf of the NASSAU POINT CAUSEWAY
ASSOCIATION requests a Wetland Permit for sand replenishment on the association
beach by adding 250 cubic yards of sand to be graded out to 6" deep in an
approximately 300' long by 45' wide area beginning at the parking lot and ending 20'
landward of the average high water mark. Located: 75 Nassau Point Road, Cutchogue.
SCTM# 1000-104-8-8.1
6. DAVID KRUPNICK requests a Wetland Permit to construct an attached 852sq.ft. two-
story garage onto the landward side of existing dwelling. Located: 880 Deep Hole Drive,
Mattituck. SCTM# 1000-115-12-13
7, En-Consultants on behalf of PETER NEGRI & ELIZABETH KAYE NEGRI request a
Wetland Permit to demolish and remove existing 16'x21' attached greenhouse and
construct in its place a 16'x7' first-story attached pool cabana addition and 4'x5.5'
outdoor shower; construct a 20'x40' in-ground swimming pool (partially in place of
greenhouse and 87sq.ft. of existing on-grade patio to be removed); construct an
884sq.ft. raised masonry pool patio around swimming pool (partially in place of
greenhouse and 166sq.ft. of existing on-grade patio to be removed) with 1'x5' step to
grade and 2'x4.5' steps to on-grade patio; construct 124sq.ft. expansion of on-grade
masonry patio (partially in place of existing gravel patio); construct a 7'x10.5' attached
exterior storage shed adjacent to dwelling; remove existing concrete pad and construct
14
7'x20' trellis over existing AC units; install pool enclosure fencing; remove approximately
35 cubic yards of soil material from behind existing boulder retaining wall and realign
wall to allow for pool installation by removing 58 linear feet of existing boulder wall and
installing 91 linear feet of boulder wall; and establish a 10' wide, approximately
2,100sq.ft. non-turf buffer along top of bluff. Located: 9775 Nassau Point Road,
Cutchogue. SCTM# 1000-119-1-6.1
8. Jeffrey Patanjo on behalf of JOHN & EVELYN BRAUN requests a Wetland Permit to
remove existing fixed dock, ramp and float; construct in same location a new proposed
4'x45' fixed dock using thru-flow decking and supported with 8" diameter cca piles; a
3'x16' aluminum ramp; and a 6'x20' floating dock using un-treated timber decking
secured by two (2) 10" diameter cca piles. Located: 680 Deep Hole Drive, Mattituck.
SCTM# 1000-115-12-9
9. Jeffrey Patanjo on behalf of KAREN & CAREY FLAHERTY requests a Wetland Permit
to remove existing fixed dock and steps to beach, and replace with a proposed 4'x68'
fixed dock supported with 10" diameter cca piles; install a seasonal 30"x16' aluminum
ramp; install a 6'x20' seasonal floating dock with un-treated timber decking situated in an
"I" configuration and supported by two (2) 10" diameter cca piles. Located: 1077 Bay
Home Road, Southold. SCTM# 1000-56-5-39
10. En-Consultants on behalf of RYAN STORK requests a Wetland Permit to remove and
replace in-place approximately 168 linear feet of storm-damaged concrete seawall and
68' westerly concrete return with vinyl bulkhead and return; construct new±7' easterly
vinyl return; remove and replace 3'x6' metal stairs to beach; remove and replace in-
kind/in-place approximately 51 linear feet of storm-damaged timber retaining wall (±77'
timber retaining wall to remain); backfill new bulkhead and re-nourish storm-eroded
embankment with approximately 240 cubic yards of clean sand fill to be trucked in from
an approved upland source; revegetate re-nourished and disturbed areas of
embankment with native vegetation; remove existing storm-damaged concrete stairs and
construct a timber stairway consisting of an upper 3'x6' steps, a 3.5'x4.5' landing,
4.5'x11' steps, a 4.5'x6.5' landing, and 3'x11' lower steps to grade; remove 566 square
feet of storm-damaged deck behind bulkhead; construct a 3'x39' on-grade wood
walkway with open-grate decking from proposed steps to existing gazebo; and repair
storm damage to existing gazebo (e.g., replace damaged exterior siding and interior
sheet rock and flooring, as needed). Located: 1140 Park Avenue, Mattituck. SCTM#
1000-123-8-1
POSTPONED
11. En-Consultants on behalf of OLIVER FRANKEL requests a Wetland Permit to construct
a 3'x±142' elevated timber bluff stairway with railings inclusive of a 6'x8' top entry
15
landing, four (4) 4'x4' landings, and two (2) 4'x6' landings with benches; and to
restore/revegetate areas adjacent to stairway disturbed during construction using native
vegetation. Located: 975 Hillcrest Drive North, Orient. SCTM# 1000-13-2-8.21
POSTPONED
12. En-Consultants on behalf of DONNA BLANCHARD request a Wetland Permit to remove
existing 15 sq.ft. fixed platform, 3'x10' ramp, and 6'x12' floating dock; and install new
3'x14' ramp off existing bulkhead, and 5'x14' floating dock secured by two (2) 8"
diameter pilings; dock to be equipped with water and electricity. Located: 50 Budds
Pond Road, Southold. SCTM# 1000-56-5-21
POSTPONED
13. En-Consultants on behalf of JOANNA DIXON REISMAN requests a Wetland Permit to
construct onto existing one-story, single family dwelling, a 20'x24' partially roofed over
raised deck addition and install a 8'x8' hot tub with stepping stones at the base of
existing deck stairs; and install a 6'x3' drywell for hot tub and deck roof runoff. Located:
2360 North Sea Drive, Southold. SCTM# 1000-54-5-1
POSTPONED
14. Patricia C. Moore, Esq. on behalf of JOHN & JESSICA LUPOVICI requests a Wetland
Permit for the existing structures on the property that include three (3) existing cottages
consisting of an existing 24'2"x20'2" southerly one-story cottage with attached 10'x20'
wood deck that is to be removed; install a new roof, new siding, and to replace existing
windows with new enlarged windows and French doors; an existing 22'3"x32'6" one and
one-half story northerly cottage with 8'x22'3" attached enclosed storage area; install a
new roof, and perform repairs and maintenance to cottage; a 10'x40'6,' concrete patio
with 3'x36 linear foot long walkways against northerly cottage leading to an existing
8'4"x32' one-story 2nd northerly cottage with 10'x20' concrete patio, install a new roof,
and perform repairs and maintenance to the cottage; existing stone wall located seaward
of existing 8'4"x32' cottage; existing dirt/stone driveway; existing 9'2"x9'3" pump house;
and to clear vegetation/trees within an approximate 19,000sq.ft. building envelope area.
Located: 1625 Naugles Drive, Mattituck. SCTM# 1000-99-4-18
POSTPONED
15. Patricia C. Moore, Esq. on behalf of JOHN &JESSICA LUPOVICI requests a Wetland
Permit to cut back 135 linear feet of dilapidated bulkhead to t6" above grade and plant
area with alterna flora 18" o.c. to restore area of intertidal marsh (approximately
2,400sq.ft.); reconstruct 51' and 41' (92 linear feet) of existing functional bulkhead in-
place and 2' higher than existing using c-lock vinyl sheathing, and construct a new 18'
vinyl return on west side using thru-flo safety cap; install 140 linear feet of rock
revetment landward of scarp and Spring High Water (SHW); backfill disturbed areas as
needed with ±75 cubic yards of material from stone excavation; existing remains of
5'x128 linear foot long catwalk to be removed; off east side of new bulkhead, construct a
new 4'x24' fixed catwalk; a 3'x18' seasonal ramp; and a 6'x20' seasonal floating dock
secured by (2) new 8" diameter piles. Located: 1625 Naugles Drive, Mattituck. SCTM#
1000-99-4-18
POSTPONED
16
16. Patricia C. Moore, Esq. on behalf of ORIENT ACRES, LLC, c/o EVA MALLIS, LLC
MEMBER requests a Wetland Permit for the existing 3,456sq.ft. two-story dwelling with
a 304sq.ft. front entry patio area, a 146sq.ft. garage roof extension, a 143sq.ft. master
bedroom deck area, and a 198sq.ft. second floor deck; propose to construct a 285sq.ft.
east side addition; construct a 146sq.ft. landward side addition; construct a 148sq.ft.
front covered entry patio area; construct a 146sq.ft. garage front roof extension;
construct a 235sq.ft. screened porch on north side of dwelling; existing 1,248sq.ft.
seaward side deck area to be reduced in size to be an 858sq.ft. deck area (to be
resurfaced) in order to accommodate additions; and construct a 328sq.ft. roof over
seaward side deck area. Located: 32625 Main Road, Orient. SCTM# 1000-14-2-25
POSTPONED
17. Patricia C. Moore, Esq. on behalf of BIM E. STRASBERG & ALEXANDRA M. LEWIS
request a Wetland Permit to construct a set of bluff stairs consisting of a 4'x8' top
landing to 4'x9' steps to a 4'x4' middle landing to 4'x8' stairs to a 4'x6' middle landing to
4'x8' stairs to a 4'x4' lower landing to 4'x8' stairs to beach. Located: 21225 Soundview
Avenue, Southold. SCTM# 1000-135-1-1
POSTPONED
18. AMP Architecture on behalf of WILLIAM GRELLA & GARY OSBORNE request a
Wetland Permit for the as-built 232sq.ft. Belgium block parking area; as-built 121 sq.ft.
Belgium block walkway; as-built 517.3sq.ft. managed lawn areas; as-built 240sq.ft.
gardens; as-built 160.5sq.ft. crushed shell areas; as-built 22.3sq.ft. metal planter box;
as-built 14.3sq.ft. metal waterfall; as-built 15sq.ft. rear concrete stairs; as-built 713sq.ft.
pavers on sand; as-built 95sq.ft. gravel on sand; as-built 11 sq.ft. fire pit on sand; as-built
41 sq.ft. open shower with Belgium block on sand base; as-built two (2) 7.2sq.ft. concrete
table bases; as-built 16sq.ft. front concrete stairs; and for the proposed installation of a
46.4sq.ft. set of second-story wood stairs consisting of a 4'x4.3' upper platform with
4'x7.4' stairs to seaward side patio area; proposed installation of 27sq.ft. of pavers on
sand. Located: 1200 First Street, New Suffolk. SCTM# 1000-117-7-30
POSTPONED
19. Stacey Bishop on behalf of FORDHAM HOUSE LLC, c/o DENIS BOUBOULIS requests
a Wetland Permit to install a t1,167sq.ft. on-grade paver patio along the seaward side of
the dwelling; extend existing westerly 15' long by 10' high by 12" thick concrete and
stone veneer retaining wall an additional 35' seaward for a total length of 50' beginning
at the left rear corner of existing dwelling; at seaward end of westerly retaining wall,
install a 28' long, varying height concrete and stone veneer retaining wall parallel with
the dwelling; along easterly side of property, extend existing 3' high natural stone
retaining wall an additional ±45' seaward; approximately 15' seaward of proposed 28'
long parallel retaining wall, install a t3' high by ±45' long retaining wall situated
approximately 1' landward of established 50' wide non-disturbance buffer; and to install
a generator pad, generator, and buried gas tank for the generator. Located: 5205 The
Long Way, East Marion. SCTM# 1000-21-5-11
POSTPONED