The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About10/17/2017 James Garretson,Chairperson 4 Town Hall Annex Anne Surchin,Vice Chair `��', t 54375 Route 25 Donald Feiler d _ +� PO Box 1179 James Grathwohl ��lp� �,d� Southold,NY 11971 Robert Harper Fax(631)765-9502 Gary Parker Telephone:(631)765-1802 Edward Webb www.southoldtownny.gov Damon Rallis,Application Coordinator Town of Southold Historic Preservation Commission Minutes 3:00 PM, October 17,2017 Town Hall Annex Executive Board Room Attendees: James Grathwohl, Edward Webb,Donald Feiler, James Garretson, Gary Parker, Robert Harper • Call to Order: The meeting was called to order by Chairman Garretson. • Approval of Minutes: The minutes of September 19, 2017 were approved unanimously on a motion by Commissioner Webb and a second by Commissioner Grathwohl. Chairman's Comments • Based on discussions during the 2pm work session,the chairman offered the following resolutions: • Resolution#10.17.17.1 —Passed: Unanimous o Resolution#10.17.17.1 reaffirms that any properties or structures that are listed as "contributing buildings or sites" in a state or national register historic district or national landmark district, after November 16,2004 must apply to this commission,as outlined in Chapter 170-5 A, before they can be designated as"historic"by the Town of Southold. The complete resolution is on file with the Southold Town Building Deparment. • Resolution #10.17.17.2—Passed: Unanimous o Resolution#10.17.17.2 states that the Sycamore tree on the former Methodist Church property at 1325 Village Lane in Orient (SCTM #25.-2-23.2) contributes significantly to the Orient Historic District and the adjacent park, known as Hallelujah Park and, as such, should be protected. The complete resolution is on file with the Southold Town Building Deparment. Old Business • Brochure Update Status o The discussion was tabled in the absence of Commissioner Surchin. • Awards Nomination o Chairman Garretson announced that he was still taking award nominations and urged commissioners to submit nominations, along with a description of the property,to his attention. Once all nominations are made, they will be voted on by the group and forward to the Supervisor's office for formal recognition. New Business • Plum Island Lighthouse Preservation o Commissioners recounted their presentation to the Southold Town Board during a recent work session, in which they expressed the need for the Plum Island Lighthouse and Fort Terry to be protected and preserved. o Commissioners discussed various options including contacting Congressman Zeldin to discuss the matter,because the lighthouse is owned by the Federal Government. o Commissioner Webb said that the condition of the lighthouse constitutes demolition by neglect and that, within 10 years it will be gone. He described the lighthouse as being on"life support." o Commissioners agreed to enlist the help of Scott Russell to get permission for the commission to survey the condition of the lighthouse. Pre-Submission Conferences • Peter Marren,Architect,for the First Universalist Church of Southold,51970 Main Road, Southold (SCTM# 1000-63.-6-6.1). Construction of a new church complex. o Mr. Marren gave a presentation of the various iterations of the new church complex design to date. Although nothing had been finalized,they had general final concept but there had been no agreement on exactly where to place the steeple. Mr. Marren asked to be placed on the November agenda to further discuss the project. • Robert Harper,2600 New Suffolk Avenue(SCTM# 1000-115.-9-3). Proposed alterations to an existing single family dwelling on a landmarked property. o Mr. Harper gave a brief overview of proposed repair work and a window replacement on the back of his home in a mudroom area. Commissioners agreed to schedule a public hearing regarding the project at its November meeting. New Business • 53245 Main Road sign permit application. o Damon Rallis informed commissioners of a sign permit application that would likely be coming in front of the commission in the coming months.Damon wanted to make the group aware because it would be the first time that the commission would have to rule on the appropriateness of a sign. o Commissioners asked that scale of the sign, as related to the building,be shown with the application,as well as photos depicting other signs within Southold's Historic District. o Chairman Garretson suggested that commissioners also look at signs around town. o Damon agreed to set up a pre-submission conference for November. Meeting Adjourned • The meeting was adjourned unanimously on a motion by Commissioner Grathwohl and a second by Commissioner e,,, hie— TC)VUM or -qni ITt4ni n 1-IICT0P1(- PI?FCFRVOTIht,l APPLICATION - --Meetings are on the"third-Tuesday of the month-at 3:0 pimin-Town fall-53098 --- -- ---� Main Road, Southold, NY. All applications must have a representative at the hearing in order to be re- viewed. Questions? Call Historic Preservation Commission (631) 765-1800. C 7 Date: Od la/1/ 7 Property Address- C2?0�06) /.4� 77 Owners Name:/' ¢,f /G `v Sections of local taws authorizing review by the Historic Preservation Commis- sion of proposed work on designated town landmark,properties are in Chapter 66 of the Southold Town Code. Categories of Proposed Work ❑ Repair Storm Windows & Doors Altera ion ❑ Additions & other ❑ Painting new construction ❑ Roofing ❑ Signs Please attach a detailed description of the proposed work to the application. At the earliest stage of planning of the proposed work, the applicant should contact the.Chairman or Secretary of the Commission in order lo establish a dialogue of the proposed work- understand and agree that no work on this request shall commence until written approval has been given by the Building Inspector if a Building Permit is required. Owner's Signat 1 Note,: Applicants should review Commission�I Stai�darus before planning work to insure that the application conforms to these requirements. 1. APPLICANT ----- ame, rav1-1161^y Address�a v� it; /_GtJ v� t� /��✓�, jai fU�'GL Telephone/emaillfax: 2. PROPERTY Owner's Nam Address: Telephone/e-mail/fax: Tax Map Number. Date Acquired by Current Owner. r !� Status: Local Landmark In Local Landmark Oistrict () On National Historic Register or in NHR Dist. () Use: Current: / zale,07& � Proposed: m 3. PROPOSED WORK Scope of Work• Reason for W rk: ex 114 a W117d Architect/Engineer. Contractor: Constructio Schedule- G f ImlyzG /�LrG' Gr tl �c/fii/ FOR HPC USE ONLY I have reviewed the enclosed application and determined the following action to be taken: Exempt: Administrative Permit Required: Public Hearin fired: Signed: Y 1 9/25/2017 Nicotettis PERMITjpg 53245 32'x 63'x 3/4"Kmoccl 9.0m PoLW Slded mth 5'x 54'x 3/4"Komocel Panels NICOLETTE'S h Stalled on(2)4'x4'x s PVC(AM P05t5 54345-2-1/2'GaraTmd IT Book BT FOR THE HOME NICOLETTES-5'Gara w-d Ir Book BT FOR THEHOME-31Q'Gara rmcl Ir Book Br 631-407-5417 e31-I07-5417-3"Gara-n"IT Dook BT HOME PECOR&ACCESSORIES-2-V4"Gara w-d IT Oo&BT HOME DECOR&ACCESSORIES KItCHEN&BATH DESIGNS-2-W'Gara mM IT Dock BT VINEGRAPHIC-22-1/2'x 16-1/4' KITCHEN &BATH DESIGN ALL LETTERING AND GRAM I C5-BLACK BACKGROUND COLOR-WHITE P05TCOLOR-WHITE ALL SIGNS COMBINED-213-1/2"SaFr GRAPETOTOf OFP05TS-C Wedel Sign Company 631-727-4577 705 WEST MAIN STREET, RIVERHEAD, NY 11901 https://mail.google.comimad/u/0/?shva=l#inbox/15ea4bee3b966673?projector-1 1/1 , _ -_ - _ L�. _ _ ').• a,�sr�.Y_:'F, ,ti t.�/r -_ s n /.Y•r^:Ir, p�rLsgsr,$•5.�;+ .�Ji:.. 1.'1JI•L_yt.,•*y''k'�'Y-•#-,al' `4�.,:n„n f••.�p '`i �F't�y._:.•.s'si4.�E`ih . 1'rvt')•,n�;�<�1 •y-1 1'1�r� - - _[��'•r�'F,+-'�`7 {.F ter,• +rl;.,�t t.Y^�-..Lr - Kk OASI oi�;hl I lap Irs --'J3 , v Pll t r! w�l�c ��'.: , -L All h'�y„'r�Y"�'�„ s;='',��fs'�'ra.�vi•� ��.<�: •�._ _ .. "-- ,_ - ,. ':'' :.L:;-__ ;'s��: ,.J`.it�''.�' :;, t✓.! '3 , �-��t4•.rr , ,.'rs-rx JT.•. 'rik,.--��,rs�{%; ,4Y;+">=:1�%;.4 'r; =r ., _ - _ , _ _ _ r� r�.9. ��, '•�sj. iS�,,ss.`,,,'�' 4:: rn: IJ:t,.<N° ^"i -:.` - - - ,. _ _ ''j': ^.{ziN%�•- -;�,i )f` L�;'^'.0*L.r+ir.i^ •-„ F.?. C,pl ��?`".i"" --Y: _ _ _ ,. - _ u`-;” }'�i�_� vri ^iS`':.n 5'�+�z�fi..i�'.j��'` .YS� s -�'�`'•+ - ,_„ .,,.,�,_.., --,may.:..,..., -.. ,., ;y..oyS,y _ ;ctiisy!¢t;.�<::;,t: i� .:�,�,�.y.` �,{� .ty, �^ qlU. , - •, H!M1a' y��!!�'�^,_y"t t��' '.�T' �!,'�, � S'3i.Y^� ��yr, -=OXY+i � - 'vii''',iUL IP�++t'S'��w - ••:�'��:"�'''.'��L>+y�(�1.ti�f�7y J� ��f�''.�:- .i'� y,..+•..y�,�••� ,,,fir ��'•. .T+c:vt y�,�.. '�+ , •- rj%�:;Y'ir�„�s"`h a,F,'.,rti;+'v:'>i'-;,• s3`w.J/� „`..w'`F3�•.f, ....o�'riy,�t�_� $�.r'+ _ .,_ .^,• ;cM,`�t�'siy'1`�'i ,�,-,7fi�+'?'�� i�.J�..�,•�G;'.', �,•�wR .'.w"�T.Jt' � ...,r•x-"."s.-' ��"►�'-'r.��'^r' �,nH +e' zCy:',4'�gi G7'f�+t s,ea x<-.�. - , '�3'�`•a.Y�Y'+�^ .1' � •a..r'G.,,_ �.d' ay„' -a""=' � `�'':i�L.'✓�f t ,`-��.�KS1`y��r,��•;� Y�•a•:�_�;.',+,,C: - - ,• �.t�'�!".�'�.`r�itr��'v+'t•,�57�:'"..�g�•�`X� + '`^nxy.;'.y'zr7'.rf.`,.'a ' ,iv. •--'.,fi'' �•'t•.° r ..... -t ^:"' .i .�r""'� xx� .F- yn_ .��.Oa1L.'�w.r t�� tom''*s• 4l�r ^,,,, w•�..A-s'S!��.+�'I`^t ..,%Q�`;:Y�yt�.:�w.ia:Ks-;:u:�.. ,.: ,r•c�u.�.,�,.rsL.e-...�i+':::�cl