Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout6946 e' � , f��l �� , -�v?�ti� K j�� > �� �,r,.�.,-�- �'��tC �� ��I � � ��L-�' � �,� ���� D�- �'�--� V'2 S�'"T"l�C'�1.tM �"- � ��ti5�-�- ��- c�-�c��- � �d r � r��-� � s 1 z ��,.�- P�-U'r��� t tvt ,N� �t1°�C� � ���,�� LsS'u2cl. ����f �v. Se cfi�� �--8�-- 1 ���� f t� �'!�-'�� U�t�d 'IZ� � �� . , �/",�, BOARD MEMBERS OF$�U�, Southold Town Hall Leslie Kanes Weisman,Chairperson �0�� yQIO 53095 Main Road•P.O.Box 1179 � ` Southold,NY 11971-0959 � - Eric Dantes � � Office Location: Gerard P.Goehringer G � Town Annex/First Floor,Capital One Bank George Horning �'0 � a� 54375 Main Road(at Youngs Avenue) Kenneth Schneider I�CQ����1� Southold,NY 11971 FtE Efl/ED �a � a � � . http://southoldtown.northfork.net �/ � ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS JUL 2 5 2016 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD � a. �l� Tel.(631) 765-1809 •Fax(631)765-9064 u�hold Towt� Cterk FINDINGS,DELIBERATIONS AND DETERA�TATION MEETING OF JULY 21,2016 ZBA FILE 6946 NAME OF APPLICANT: Frank Kelly PROPERTY LOCATION: 1900 Great Peconic Bay Boulevard, Peconic NY SCTM# 1000-145-4-3 SEORA DETERMINATION: The Zoning Board of Appeals has visited the property under consideration in this application and determines that this review falls under the Type II category of the State's List of Actions, without further steps under SEQRA. SUFFOLK COUNTY ADMINISTRATNE CODE: This application was referred as required under the Suffolk County Administrative Code Sections A 14-14 to 23, and the Suffolk County Department of Planning issued its reply dated April 13, 2016, stating that this application is considered a matter for local determination as there appears to be no significant county-wide or inter-community impact. - LWRP DETERMINATION: This application was referred for review under Chapter 268, Waterfront Consistency review of the Town of Southold Town Code and the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP) Policy Standards. The LWRP Coordinator issued his comments dated April 19, 2016 indicating that the actions are INCONSISTENT with the Policy Standards, and therefore are INCONSISTENT with LWRP. In his letter, the coordinator recommended compliance with several Policy Standards (6.3, 9.1 & 9.3) and suggested factors to follow when assessing potential adverse impacts. Based upon the existence of a Pre-CO and the determination in this decision, the Board finds the actions are CONSISTENT with the Policy Standards, and therefore are CONSISTENT with LWRP PROPERTY FACTS/DESCRIPTION: The subject property has 107 feet of frontage along Peconic Bay Boulevard, 104.54 feet along the westerly property line, and is bulk headed along the frontage on Brushes Creek. It contains a gravel parking lot, boat slips and no structures, all as shown on the site plan prepared by En-Consultants, Inc. last revised Apri127,2006 and labeled sheet 1 of 3. BASIS OF APPLICATION: Request under Article XXVI Section 280-146D requesting Reversal of the restriction on the length of watercraft permitted at the marina as listed in the Pre-CO #38052 issued 1/14/2016 property located at: 1900 Peconic Bay Boulevard(adj.to Brushes Creek)Laurel,NY, SCTM#1000-145-4-3. RELIEF REOUESTED: The applicant requests a reversal of the Building Inspectors determination that the maximum allowable length of the watercraft permitted to dock in the subject marina is 20 feet. � ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: Several neighbors submitted letters and photographs to the Board and/or testified at the hearing objecting to the requested reversal, stating that although the subject marina has been in Page 2,July 21,2016 #6946,Kelly SCTM No. 145-4-3 existence for many years, the current owner/applicant's increase in the intensity of use on the subject property since he purchased it in 2014, has been problematic, They further testified that Brushes Creek is a very narrow waterway with extremely low tides and boats larger than 20 feet would damage the bulkhead and/or other boats; and that the owner/applicant's 21 foot boat was too large to safely navigate and dock in the boat basin.. FINDINGS OF FACT/REASONS FOR BOARD ACTION: The Zoning Board of Appeals held public hearings on this application on July 7, 2016. Based upon all testimony, documentation, personal inspection of the properfy and suirounding neighborhood, and other evidence,the Zoning Board finds the following facts to be true and relevant and makes the following findings: 1. Photographic, oral and written evidence was presented to the Board demonstrating that the subject property has been continuously used as a marina since 1951, including correspondence from a former Building Inspector acknowledging the operation of the subject marina in 1951 with 11 boats on the premises, which constituted a non-conforming use that pre-dated the zoning ordinance. 2. Photographic, oral, and written evidence was presented by long term residents of the neighborhood, including those who had actually docked boats in the subject boat basin/marina, that the watercraft docked in the marina have historically been about 15-18 feet in length. The agent for the applicant presented no evidence to refute those claims or to demonstrate that boats 20 feet or longer had ever been docked on the subject property, or could be safely docked there 3. Photographic evidence and testimony demonstrated that watercraft longer than 20 feet will have problems docking in the marina or will impede the adjacent waterway endangering the safety of boaters. 4. Based upon testimony and other evidence submitted, the Board finds that the building inspector had rational reason to limit the length of the permitted watercraft to 20 feet in the Pre-CO that he issued. RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD: In considering all of the above factors and applying the balancing test, motion was offered by Member Dantes, seconded by Member Schneider, and duly carried,to DENY the applicants request to overturn the building inspector's determination of the maximum length of watercraft permitted in the applicanYs marina. Vote of the Board: Ayes: Members Weisman (Chairperson), Schneider, Dantes, Horning, Goehringer. This Resolution was duly adopted(5-0). r � � Leslie Kanes Weisman, Chairperson Approved for filing� /o�a /2016 ��� � � �'��� �� . �,oF so�r /r J � OFFICE LOCATION. �� yO� MAILING ADDRESS: `� \��r Town Hall Annex � � P.O. Box 1179 �/ 54375 State Route 25 � � Southold, NY 11971 (cor. Main Rd. &Youngs Ave.) G Q Telephone: 631 765-1938 �\\Southold, NY 11971 I�' ` °?L\` �Ol�Q ���0 ,� UNTI, LOCAL WATERFRONT REVITALIZATION PROGR.AM /��� TOWN OF SOUTHOLD �C� � �O RECENED MEMORANDUM APR 19 2016 To: Leslie Weisman, Chair 20NING BOARD OF APPEALS Members of the Zoning Board of Appeals From: Mark Terry, Principal Planner LWRP Coordinator Date April 19, 2016 Re: Coastal Consistency Review for FRANK J. and ELIZABETH G. KELLY#6946 SCTM# 1000-145-4-3. A site visit was attempted on April 18, 2016 however the property was inaccessible. FRANK J. and ELIZABETH G. KELLY#6946 -This is a request under Section 280-146D for a Reversal of the restriction on the length of watercraft permitted at the marina as listed in the Pre-CO #38052 issued 1/14/2016, property located at: 1900 Great Peconic Bay Boulevard (adj. to Brushes Creek), Laurel, NY. SCTM# 1000-145-4-3. The proposed action has been reviewed to Chapter 268, Waterfront Consistency Review of the Town of ' Southold Town Code and the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP) Policy Standards. Based upon the information provided on the LWRP Consistency Assessment Form submitted to this department, as well as the records available to me, it is my recommendation that the actions are INCONSISTENT with the Policy Standards and therefore are INCONSISTENT with the LWRP. Policy 6.3 Protect and restore tidal and freshwater wetlands. A. Comply with statutory and regulatory requirements of the Southold Town Board of Trustees laws and regulations for all Andros Patent and other lands under their jurisdiction. A Board of Trustees Wetland Permit was issued in 2005. Policy 9.1 Promote appropriate and adequate physical public access and recreation to coastal resources. C. Protect and maintain existing public access and water-related recreation facilities. 2. Prevent any on-site or adjacenf development project or activity from directly or indirectly rmpairing physical public access and recreation or adversely affecting its quality. The application does not show representative vessels (maximum lenqth) or how thev would be moored in relation to the bulkhead and waterbodv on the plans. Further, the application does not show if the area under the bridqe could be naviqated at some point in the tidal cvcle bv small watercraft (kavaks, canoes, paddleboards etc....). To determine what level impacts to naviqable waters and public access would result small watercraft should be qraphically represented to show if thev could naviaate past vessels qreater than 20' in lenqth in the area. Further, in the event the bridqe is replaced in the future and a different desiqn is constructed to increase the overhead, the marina use with larqer vessels could furher prevent public access. The further encroachment into the existin� channel could further impair naviaation for small watercraft and public access to Brushes Creek and Peconic Bav. In the event laraer vessels are permitted, thev should be moored parallel to the bulkhead and tie off pilinqs located in the channel should be removed to further this policv. Policy 9.3 Preserve the public interest in and use of lands and waters held in public trust by the state and the Town of Southold. A. Limit grants, leases, easements, permits or/esser interest in lands underwater in accordance with an assessment of potential adverse impacts of the proposed use, structure, or facility on public interest in public lands under water. Use the following factors in assessing potential adverse impact: 1. environmental impact, The environmental impact of increasinq the vessel size could be bottom scourinq in areas of low water due to boats that require qreater draft. 2. values for natural resource management, public recreation, and commerce, The natural resource and public recreation values of Brushes Creek and Peconic Bav is high. 3. size, character, and effect of the transfer in relation to neighboring uses, 4. potenfial for inferference with navigation, public uses of waterway, and riparian rights, There is potential for interference with public use of the waterwav. 5. effect of the transfer of interest on the natural resources associated with the lands, 6. water-dependent nature of use, Recreational boatinq is a water dependent use. The applicant currentiv eniovs access to public waters via an existinq dock structure. 7. adverse economic impact on existing commercial enterprises, 8. consistency with the public interest for purposes of navigation and commerce, fishing, bathing, and access to navigab/e waters and the need of the owners of private property to safeguard development. See above. Further encroachment into naviqable waters has the potential to impair public use of the water wav. In the event larqer vessels are permitted, vessels preater than 20' in (total) lenqth should be moored parallel to the bulkhead and tie off pilinqs located in the channel should be removed to further this policv. This proposed variance request does not safequard development. � , �����, �«� �. ��, � � ��� �, u .: ���� �� , r> � . ��.�» �� ����"� "'«,���� �'� �x����,a�w,�.,, � �' t � � '�� � � ,„���.`�'-�.�.���5"�����c "� .:.��� + ��`�."s�� ��.�`��""����w� � .�,�. r � � ,y� �,r�5� �.�# r r� r ���,�"��a kaw , � �.r f � �. t�� � � �ht `��b� �'���.w Ty�.�.�"�.� ,��-?"�arurX4'�F!f� ���i.�,,'"s���w,y, �. �. � : m � ,� �. �, : ,�t*�, '� .� ,�, :�* �9 ���. - �p �� i� � � � �s . :£ �r . � a � . � �..°°"'a' �,q, � � � �.�°'� �' �`k s �"' d � .� ^� '^�'� '� �;�*a„�ua� �� � f�"°�';� � ���r� �;�z� � � �a4 r. � %s .�9� �p�„��.,mA��., .�. �� � '� �--� �,�� � 4 r .�,�-�.1 ��"�F��'�-*�r � b� "k9 � t ; � � �� � sc$F y �'�r�i�*`+a�'7�""'" � � 'p� �'✓"u � ,�'`�"^�"�'�g� ��"�,��r�,�' �*.�+a' �'�"°'p�,���*✓$��z- ,� � �, z � �: .�� � ��� ���, *,.�r "� ;. �`��., � + ,y ,�s . � f �.' ��� � €"s�An'' � G�s �n ,y�� '"f` "� `�c �^� '3 �s� � - `�� � �<- '�.-f����'�� �������`���� � .�� �",�''"w� � ��v' " ��, �✓ � � ,�' � u�. `�� �� +�.,i �� >.c�.���rn�`��„�,�� �"�,''��� *... s.. �rrF h � � � �. '� � �r.�°� n ��.�.� �'s�,.�.'�H'"' ��t ��.h5°` € «r �`�' °�:,p�`� r . �. '" u�a : � ? , . � �,,ar� ;��n. ,�-k* P* .�'-��8 #�"` ��. _ „z '�.� � �`t: d,� + � x° . ��� �"`�.y�C^gn• fi�" ,g+�� n ^�� �ra"� ,� �^��� � �i ���.$ �s;",�� �,.��.�a _ y.'' ..` , �s� ��R�„� .: ��'����.eai•������'�,�� ��� r.r�.t, � F '�1. `�`"� �`�""` �.� <4�'P �' ., � i��°^r,,� .�S" '�a����: � �°*'`�� '� :�an'"'"'x' 4�t �` '�.�;+� � '�`"�' ,""+, �„�� '" .�',����:.��� .; �'}� k ^"� .� �' ���b^"" .; "&�*�x n'.�^ �� � .r•t�'�' � � �'��^r" A,��n ,�`�M'"?�,"�r��q�.''�;a �t� '�k,�r�� � � .� � ��w� �,� �, �`�, "`�� �,a 4 �. ,y r,e'' . ,� ' ' �r'��„ "����,�L '` . -s,. � r `�' .sa, '�'1wa'� }k �'�' � s � � � � �t� �. . � � .��{� t r�� �. � ���,� �'"'��'�y+ �� �'am���^'�� �r� ,� „�� � �.-���w ,� w��g�,'�'�"�� � `� � .3 +�' �^�h � � �� �,��"�e%�"�� �L. "�`"�, �.�'� � ^� . b.,y 1, # rMw z'riL� �� ..„s'� a* .s'r'� ��• ����. 'S # "41 �'+� � ..�,�"%"�te,�,�e` �°'r�*�'�"_������+"�' ,��3�'�?��� :. �z� ...^- �� � s - ,# �,� -�'�` .� da�- L �^�`"�r ,r `Y, r s. a T- 8 � ' � .u�` '�: d ^ �:�^ " ��^ R'., ^�' "� 1 r �y s c.�,� ��� ,�,3r�9 �'k ,.�.� g � ac "���i��,y� x ��'''Y��t'� 5����s'�"��`�' `��'��""� � ���,�� �� , ! ��°�� �rtrm �� Ks;>� .^� � ; ,� . ��.���R � ����� ���"� a� ``���� ��� ` P �� � � �..� �I' � *�� # M k���yh��."� ,��_.> �� � c��� � ��� r ce j�a�.� w �,�- �� ��S-� €,� +�..�°ga't�r �, � #��•°�";'�� >�.G�'�3��,W°�y� �3 �a ..�"�� �. 3.+ ,�5,�;s.. t }. � 7 p p� y .5���,c �a�aa '� '���.; *. .-' °yr,�,:n x d �a�'� �� � '��' �����"�-� ��� � � � � �`�"�����`�� � �'���� �' �" �� -��"�.� ?� x �� �� � �, � r �a � �a y �t 4 A ';a�e°��x`3��` �e`4�€ �,�i �, �r.��r��'a�� i � !u �� ��„„"� ` � ��..,�� ��� � � � �� ?'� ��r�����'��t�;�a�� � �.��' � ,��*�. � c ._ �8� t '��'sf��, � :t w sn '�`�� 1 ,�s"�"e.:.2� `�`—�` �, `�� '�",�r"r,,� m,��p� �,� . 'S�i a` E`k 3 � � awyr�'s��%' ,� ^:¢-�.£ �+ � d� �. �,w �f`sr �, . ��ui'�" �: Pk��"' �' �+�e g 'ik�, � ?s ; �a °� �i. � a��, r , s. a _ �� s e, -� ��� tu i a.,�Ne' 9 '� dr ��M� �r . v!s� '��5�,-� �9 � r > �w'+a r`� h� F # �., .. �"' '`�e'r- � *� 'a`'��a r "' A��'a'�C�.. . � _ � �°�r' � . �� , x '� � -.tabr�2 ���q��i*'��"5"�r� + �` ���� `'`�gs°"* �,i �. `a -%� a �� a a � �� e.e � �,1� '� � x�,�°� � ..���'���� ".� ��q �y'+-�° �� "`�M�� � t�, .�'�' fi ;` .�,�. � ������n" "a� � �h � "*� t' "R �' E�c�w� �� � �„'� � � ��` �� ,� �" "� �� � � � ,� ��„ � ��� �� � ��v.�P��d ���s k� 't;, �"'a� r �L�"� � �` ����� �� s �x. ��„�`r,�„ . � ��� r��. .�� �a�-�r � t� �� ���n, ar � ��� � �� � ��a. �„�',� w, `� �� � +��j.`�` �q � "' at � � �,�� � � r` .y. �`�4 � �+' � W% ���`��'� �� � ����# ��t'�°�����,3�'M�' �`E �,��:;,�rm T ��'t'� fi'` :, � �',. '�.��"r�.�k"'.'�"� n "� � ',s �.'�� � �`����`*-"�r^^;..��'�4- �',����'�.� ��. ....��.t ; ,, �"".'� d ..�f�`� �'f,� ��a� �.'"3�'�* :�"' ��� �a � , .� �ms.�,..:�.�".,gnv�z�T'��-+.�tv �:.�i,:i.*F`� . .. . . �r.c'.:..� �?". .,�'��*.�+..?'°�''.�m,.,.. Figure 1. 2013 Aerial showing subject parcel. m.� +cr }t . :�y�=, .�,g -.'va n zf,,a:. ""1. ,� 3'9 4.�.�-�-e.�.`"$'v.` '�.y,,.'� �� .t_ .�.s .�'3r...,.�'t� . � �'i�� �,� .�. �u� � � 'yn,,.�, t # � e. � 7 Pr � - V n 9�,�+.'*\� �.i.�+F�l°�"�'?+. x'F dv+� "'-. 4� :g 'I: ..! �,�`vp,�bn� f,d ,;�Y" �!4. �i� P^'Q""}h'�"` : �" 1s�'v++- :r �* ;�s` a�� -.- �i rs« ,�r� . €� .�' a �'5:-. `d . �"'. � �s,�`��ra �. � w� _ ti ' i•�+�,�� ' � � �� � � . �, �� a�.r t�.rr�.�+'� � ���� � � � _-: �t�� ��- ,w,> .� t r,�� ' y"�''�" � '"a 'i�' f` r �/ ,'`���.�,� e�, '✓�� ,j`%� »n { *�,`` � � r, ��-v _�L �v '. ��"��� `� =k_ `'` .' �.. '��,�'�`.aa`�:��. ,,� � �,�� '��' ,.� uy� ''�� ,�- '„ � � " i r � . . �, :, i:..� � .� . ..�. .'t w.e„ ��L> ""' a�,,,,��`c5s"�r." ,�''��m"' ,��3�� � ' f'�� ' �g� �w '3 �a& ` �g� �'`�` •g�'r �. t�- .3.z� �.� ; 7�',.{�z. <-».:�£� ... � � .�.. ti "Yi #' �. �' � C #yl1� .r»?3$ � `` �� �---�" '� �" p .,, � � ~ `� t""'� ��1p+t �y„'��4��,'�'_ , cy � r' �, ` r�� �,,,c. ' � '„�'.��` '�"�,.,�"� `'n'���4,� +*s, f � > � ,,,�, �, h.-nK_a "` �a� , ..d�e�. �p�r M+� �t �'h�-, � . u � � . .�'� �` �i � r-i+ e� ��;��c � 1 ,� r '����, �C , �=n,,`" '� � � �'�"_���`� ���„���� "'S;?; �� � x �f €C�+'"' "y����� �,y�.�� ..r 1 �.� � „�.�°���, :� w _,�...,�� �u m= 3�'�' +�`ir,a�"v.&" ���� � �� �" �` �� � �'.,�. y. � '�' �R ^'�w�. i�a' �"�['n�r ' r�'�`" ��+f. ��1�_a�� ���'? �°� `��°�"'� `� '�,���'�^��-! 4., � .�.,y?"' e,k '�� � 'Y�`.7d `�`.:k� §.l��'3 ����y�} "1� 'yt-�� r�"� , �:�'$,�6,'A" .ir w .� �p., .a � '�„�sm�"��� ���.�e"� ?+,� a -� �'�'J��� ��� 1! � y�a r^^^� a�� ,t�. �; �� �^ F i�'� . w.�"��'���' 3�-.��„ ew�r�i�. �K.� �,�`.� . k.f6�� '�'N��� .�,`d�� . � � � �� .tlF ��,�e- � d ,Me �'�y���'' �-y.��,y�'` ��Y+ v a � .!.c.14� . �• �,�q f �'�'A +SA� $ 'j`�Ls �# �."5`-�"����^ .�?.x'"��' 3�A � r'..HF �{ �, ��§3. yY S�_ � .a�3�§ _ ! '��� ✓� Ct4't5'sn , �� �� �: � P j.i k'R.1*'Y+4',F�� � � : aEC� 1 rfi'�.. �y ,� E � � � �. � � ^�����,'�f�,..�� � ���s�" �r a�" � �"�.'�..x � �5�����'�,:� ;r r � �a��, �',��.' `;`^: `� '`r... '� t�p� °�g,j.X <9 9�g �� 1 4 1"} ' .: °"' _ .4. ' y ��:a�`' 'f� '`'j Y � ���. � r Y4�� �� ��'�'��"y ! L � � � �� � 9� ,..,� . * � �� , ', � 5 � ���. w"'�""�`"��§ ��� '� '�.� 5 r��` �a +� -�, � � I r ?S��'a,+��x � p , �,.� �, � .� �,ry"" �iy�,� "" - � . � ; ;'1 Y- �.s@�"���" � K , -� �rr�, , � � �� �r..s�� ..:t` � . ' �;�. �t, � � �,. -+ � !' -r� ,*t�,�. t er,. . K�.' �� ,s � � � �"a .�: �- 8 d '�� i.�ro � a. y ''� "yN� .m.� s a g�v�� � . Y + � .TaY iFb''.jy,�° s+` .��''�` �`�.� a�' y r '� ., �, M�3+��^� l i I tq€�� a s 7. x *p'"�a .4 � Y�t Myr'4: ` � �<a ` u � s� � z .c m a i� a t i5 w ��a' �x"���,� ..:- `�. ��7r� j "` a � � r �, "a" �; � ^�. �° M-� r t:C' °V"'n��� :�m. a . �,. � �3 ,+�n a °,�{+ F � �+9f� �, �<� � a ``rv .: M k r :a�r � � a ,��. �,,,Wc��� },.�.; ��.�,�"�';. �'�� � w m^.� �' '�ur �o-t ,. r*��,.�w�P TM � "` '� � 6�+ ,� ��` s�e:��w ��� k��i?i, � ��"�'jr� ��� ,�, � .,r. �g�f���a �� �: �4 h..� ��$!�'jN"� � r� �`I�.� ��@� • � p 1 : "�3,�4. P 'y �°a""J'°.^ � ^#�v��,ur�!°.C$*a`.s^.IL✓�/ ..�� � Figure 2. 2013 Close up of aerial showing channel obstruction by vessels. ��� «���+��..k ��H�}� �TM,:� � 1 , �'�"��,�������+a�'��'���°""'f�"�°'u°r��� � �.�.m .. .... x �`!,� .� �.�''y."."..° .,� s' t ,`��.5�,�'� �.� 'w6r��`` �'. _ *� � ' w' r .�s,*t�� k � � - � � : � �c- �•,� � � t'�+�. �.��ds'•h c� � `�,� � ��,��..''� S.:�n3 7«..„�'""'r"'.'�j I .:� "� �t "w1��P „�Y '�.,,, �„t;�°�r�.^^�v"�.w . ,.,+g.�� .+.,� �m t�,�R ,y� J r �-'�„ � iCy, � r� I,�', .• ` .•�;�,� � rs�, q rrt a d �" '^�' � ,�°"„�+' "'�F,+��ro"�y r��e.;�� a�xya1'> !y�.^� � �.w�yCy,y' �� � �' ,k" ,. ` �e�crP ��� � �- '�' ,�` .,�. �I a'��a� �,��E$ . � �" _ P� � -8� s � .Ra;y, �t��'+¢�� -^s' �'� .+ :�,.�� � Y��e. . �I n s>: � �r �a. r �it'°�1q''tia,� .. ,�" � � � -`,��� ° �. � .",�nu�� � �n ..�a s. �� t 'k �. . . �H ��"a� "� . a� 4� . 3 �`���5`�* �d^3 ��+� � <�t�, .t �� �"„ ='.0 a Y�'S � , `^-..:¢ t,,,,^r"'Cy, �+s �` a .� <�";;az a�'�,�`�l4��„»..�w^.,y "i���^�:��,. °C� � 'Y. y°t :`• . '� '`�' �+Mw�!p.t� �..� -�' t't ��` �..e ;t, ""� ,+..�� ��'r� � � ��"` s4:�"�„� �°�„ � . �r s�` ����x� �` i; ����'�n��»�Hw,� r�sb�` � �n� ���"� �$��t .� ^",�;: � � ""b's'.;�� �, T .'�3e d � �� � � �� . a+'`�',7' �T 4 ". , '".,�r m�'q .` x �,a �� �`�k;�'�T� �"� h �'"" j a � � s �� ��., '�"•',.� x �' �' g ° ��°B"+ ��sr� �a"�'"�w � m � � ��� �"`�� re �,�' �" `� �� , s^€�d �r �. : :. � s x 'S �, �t `.z ,k .t ,x+ .. r � tr�, '� wa�Y � � ss.+- � � .� ', r� wu � �,r,y,w� :+�. .s -,. ,�°�,,,s "� �'3 ;, �a�, ,� . .�.��: . $�u�,�:> . � .�,y ��'�^� �,-�,'� �k :_ � ;. � a� ..� ` �Y�S� > � t �'�` �^�"'��ti4�t' �� ������� �a 'd ���"��`��`��t+'r'"9� �*,��# � � � v�r'�� ,�� s����� � 4. ��y.'"�+?"� � '«i�e;, r'�"�� x�°��"'"'� � ` '�4`„ s�"*�fi' ''"`'��.f'���L�� as 8� � i ` .W4�# �� ' M #:T'P: E` . . �+ �9 '� a�� .. .^:y�,��a✓ ��`� � it�f,�y�'�-^^".W�*�„ ''�y�# ����'_;�� 4�b�a.:`'+��� �4 �� x�� ��? "»'^ � �, � 4 � r�,�.;�k✓ °-�''� �..- � �� .� '� ,,✓�,"'"� �' ,�„ �� � ^� �' e i Y fa d� y, 'T'�V @ � �,a8'.` . �. � � r„��a�C?�* Jn. � � '"f ��s ,,,..-^� �''�s`"s � �-^ .aF "�' �: ��'u���6 c�a�� �.,� �'W` p' p�*,rs�, �:' � �.,�h^"h��� �� -4 �,#.�� � .�1 ';��y r . �� f�'�'� .c��""�d*�� �� r r'��",� �z P*�; �}.. '"�t � ,.�I�,�� "�• �� � ` : .s.- °; :. .�yt {n ""r-f(� �� � �L w �-.x� 4 ��"`w�� .y�,., � �` � �F � , .' F�"� �,� §,�J�'�,ry�,,, sF �� ^"� ,✓����y � � '��'y�1�k:_ Z,r'� £ . g�y,S ��b`"�` & d �!ss��^c'� d�^��;, 3 N"`��,._ ,�"��§q�,�r�� � t,,: � . ;� r."�+� � . � �` �" ,.�r. �- �4 .� �.�e���""`�' �. ^vr . .^1' !"z i� `. ,.�r�� �R � . �� Y""� .z YEic � '£f �i l.. '..�s.5'' �+�` Y.T, �"` �� m� � ;�€ty� t �' .,��'' � � . � �� ��.� �.� � � ,�,�a� � �� J../ & ` Y �`° i xd b y �� q .�sre,"4 �� A t�a�+��� r w` �`x.r �r, ��. � � �� � a�'"'�� x �� 9 4���i� � � ����" ����t'��M�a�'w ' U� �i�� �'+�`°s �'� A��F �,. '��.��`y� ��. ga�l:��v ��r�, � a. '�, . .1 € '�4 � �,es� r' � �h, � `�m"r�..,..rR'� �r dc:.,, � r�j; r."°„1..�'^�I y ��r� � "'�� � ,�'��0� , k 4 a:i J'r �&. �-.y, � c�.... •��'��ltl. �+n� � '. � ''�+r �,�'' .z �.�'j� g i �'�� ��' �"�°"��" 4� `��� `�����.F 1, s a.�":;� aa "s..nm i 4�� ��ry ,r �n ����w�T��,��;:� 1��`.� ' ,�'wa��''�P"l,y�� �, *',�,"#L. � rywa ,� �,C<�` 'k 4. �t �. �� �%� ' � ` � � ���'�"4'J�''�j'� �..r�Y ^� ^" s -s�e;s ��t ��� ��. ,,.k",'S�k."' ,y=� "'�'„�"�aa � � �`', x ,� '��,, �+.a-4 ��� ,� r�, ^r€�' � m'�tt'��,'' '����.f�A," a� .�� "t�"s�`�.` �,�'SC � 3� � �-�r� � � �'" .� �:�3 � � �s> .r f,� ` � c � . S 7�,��� ,,� � a,� �ie,�."..� . � ,�. � � � � �,, �...,.rs�,a+ ��' + : ^wm� f ��k�5i' � �.'�- n i 1�` ��� , �asM a.�� ��,.� � `� -�, � ,�.� �" '" � � r� r ��5,�"` ° *��r,��� �- � � �. , i�;.� � �,���s� '��'^` .`"`� ., ,.�,�;y^ `� - '� ,.���.�.-.. ,a`� ��'��{�.<_�s.��,�.....e:� �:. `1,�t.�e . �i' ` �..�.iAbJ'����_` �,. Figure 3. 20�� A.�r;l�� o� �u��,j�:c: ��;rc,s . Pursuant to Chapter 268, the Southold Town Zoning Board of Appeals shall consider this recommendation in preparing its written determination regarding the consistency of the proposed action. Cc: William Duffy, Town Attorney Toth, Vicki From: Terry, Mark Sent: Thursday, April 07, 2016 929 AM To: Weisman, Leslie Cc: Toth,Vicki Subject: Frank Kelly Application Leslie, I am beginning to review the Frank Kelly application and have the following concerns. Although the Board of Trustees issued a permit for the action I do not know if the direction in which vessels would be moored was discussed. Vessels that are moored east to west may severely impede navigable waters. This is a matter of preserving the public access and navigability to the upper reaches of Brushes Creek. The application does not show representative vessels or how they would be moored. More importantly,the application does not show if the area under the bridge could be navigated at some point in the tidal cycle. Small watercraft should be graphically represented. Another graphic should show if the watercraft could navigate past the vessels to the bridge (for fishing etc...) at 20' and larger. We would need these to determine at what level impacts to navigable waters and public access would result. Another concern would be that in the event the bridge is replaced in the future and a different design is constructed to increase the overhead the marina use would prevent public access. Lets' discuss. Mark Terry,AICP,APA Principal Planner LWRP Coordinator Town of Southold 54375 State Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York, 11971 (631)765-1938 Mark.Terrv@town.southold.ny.us � `C°�\� �'� `� ��,�� �`�� �OUNTY OF SUFFOLK ����c ' ,,�� ��. (_�\� /�` , �, � � RECEIVECy J � � � �. 'Q����`� APR 18 2016 �\J Steven Bellone zONING gppKa OF� SUFFOL6 COUNTI'EXECUTNE PE�� Department of Economic Development and Planning Joanne Minieri Division of Planning Deputy County Executive and Commissioner and Environment April 13, 2016 Town of Southold Zoning Board of Appeals 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold,NY 11971-0959 Attn: Leslie Weisman Dear Ms. Weisman: Pursuant to the requirements of Sections A 14-14 thru A 14-25 of the Suffolk County Administrative Code, the following application submitted to the Suffolk County Planning Commission is to be a matter for local determination as there appears to be no significant county-wide or inter-community impacts. A decision of local determination should not be construed as either an approval or disapproval. Applicant Municinal File Number Kelly, Frank #6946 Philippou, Harry& Irene #6947 Very iruly yuurs, Sarah Lansdale Director of Planning �� .C� l����?�il-�-��_ � Theodore R. Klein Senior Planner, TRK/cd H.LEE DENNISON BLDG ■ 100 VETERANS MEMORIAL HWY,11th FI ■ P.O.BOX 6100 ■ HAUPPAUGE,NY 11788-0099 ■ (631)853-5191 {� r *--� �, i���-�,�,� � .� ,,�. ,,i�"�. _� —� �v �.�,.�yc, . �: � � f,'�,t � �, r � i . 1� ��6�-.,��' - � r ` ,i s • . * �� � '�t �� � • ��'� . _ � �""�, _ ' • � ,� _ s� � � � � � _ , . , � �. � .,,,,,, . �� _ �,, . • � . .� � �w ��. "r� � � � « Ma� - . � • .. � # 1y� '#T *, � . .. � •'M ; , '+�I�r�' �'� ` � . ��-s� � '�` ,,, ,!� � �• 9, ��1►- � � +. �4� � ,,, � � s � � �'� ��'� ��� •- ' �' � ' �. . ; � �► ''!� ;��►�' � �,,, ,� . "�. . � � � ...��► ' ;. � , �--�—�,.�. r - . � �_ j""��� ' � �` , �� _1 �; _� ' � - �.. � J. � i � � s �- ��� . ._... .._..... ......_., ......_.,— :<,� 3> �,._ � �� � &��� � a � � ;tii ; ��, ' , . �.e_ '. y a� �,� f'y.,� a I�' a���� iJ , . , � ' . �� '+�� � �� �� �y � �' � � '� �, � a � '� - ��` �.��' . '^sfi Y�. � �ai��� ..Q7F'ji �'i,. � "�4n�, Y .�' .. _ �Y1 �v: ..'�� �������� I�3 �a.. -.r.,� , . ` _ ,� ,. � �t. `�� ` , ,�. ' ' t t . �� N� �� � i �i� 3- � � � ��� �� '8x n� 'a� y,�&'� ' e,t�� � � ��� � � �Wy,, � »�{ �A��"�'�� a' ��(� ���: �,q...� Y �. � ��'a � _"aay. +t 4�a� a � k�• y.�t.'�'�. ,�9. S W�.�s� �'A'✓: . " . . .sa�t`� � 4„��Y'`�"*� " "�'�,.d'�g,�F.- .�, 1 �'� �'g,,..'1" "}F � s�.� � �� �� � �'�� � w3 `'� 'k��� ,. � '�'°"� "�t _�. � �} '���� ^� : � "bJSs �'� Y9�dk°�C �g �� q ro A� .. ^t . b kH 4 s3"�'• �. . . "6's " "�. `�•4- �'� � . , y� �� ..� !``�.3�. �- �J �„�`��,, : � ,=ka �S„ ":,.�' a: � >m:.��`�*`-,���+Nm"� �� . . � .A� ''r' � ,,�Lt"�`.��'a`3`;,� "�t"` �'���i. � 9t-.t�'�� '� „ ; » ; l, w ; ,, - . ., , .,Kb., r�P - . .a�.y �x� ' .'7,�,II� . ,. �. . s��. � ',a� vb�.. i� �'R1t b .. �� � � `���"� �� « �'. � �wn �� �- €. ,. �« � .. �s'�r Y' �- « �` � �.t K�'� 4` ,y,< �� � - � D� k�. . �� r� ��e,y S '� -?n � � �'� �� "�� dz wm_ ,• � � g �k � � � .k"'� ' � �.�,r :.'� .� , . � a � � . • ' J? .. -� : ° a 'Nn. ��'�� �L"' �`ka� � �.�'` � _� �,, .. ' � ., '���•. � � .� ' ..�� ,��as;.F.a +t: ��" t @ ".�� - ��'^� � ' �� ;;�, �,�.,, �' �..!k���'� wc �� , �`�� ����a"'° ��� ��� �� � � " :x `� , �"� �� "� . . >. . � � � :e`'> �; " �� �� � �^�'s�°�S �a�`��� ,� �, d� �. � �W� ... �"" f yi.�., �� a� . .... :cdi �. ��`��,�3 � p. ��;� A}"�q"„4 �� ��` =' S�.A r1 .�. .�. � �_ S �P' �� �� d°� ! � t, F �. � a ..,a� ;�£'" .� �p�: �f.', � � � .aA`r:�! �� ^`� � y�,, � x .y� � g� r ` +' grt�r' . _�:,� t {� �`�s, 4�^ � �a ga � .s� �k�.;�! ��� 4�� yP,,�....t . a' ,, � „ � , .,r.,�.,, e ",� ,�a. ° � - �, ; „ . �yy�. � � �� y ���:� s�� , ^„� r�r� a' a � �„ �� � < ° � �� .�� �:���hx � ? £ �gV!]y ..,«. � u, + . '�� � ' "�W�Se� _ ��.-.� ;.. �`� �j�� ,�, � �i"' x � '� d � .� >.�y7�a" �C` °�v.. '.� 4'�a`�' �°�' �. ,�, b ��` '�.� �"�,�� �'�+l `�,�p'� < � ���;� & � ,.. . . � a',� .�e��"�� �"��t}?s�,��'� ��^!"��� . �-r�,:,;,m �' �$ °�� �� ` „ # a,�^#^7�` � ' � � ,, � �� �. � � ,�_ �' ��'� ."a � "� � �� +, , a�. � �� � � ,..� f� z� ' ��`.��� � ^�r� x� ., «2� � e � � � ,rw� � - � �r � � � `�''.�' �������� s 'a'� � �2� � ` � � � c�ti`+'�'" y � �'.nra � � x 4�,; g m . �g,"�v�iP,� g' d� a , '�r �€'.� '�y {, ��`-1�, , C .t Er. � . �> � € �,� ��p� rrz��a ��+ .� 6 �� .� �.. � `� �F� .Y �« �':� L � �. . � � � � �` � s:.+ ��&�� �s,5�`� x s'� *� a � _�a r�.�'��.�'� �� � m�,;�.�� ��{ �b a���n ��a ; �a z � .�, 3� ,. �^ t�. �' r: � � �� � �. � ' :� �� � � :� �� �� � � ,�'�� '�a:` � �.a,4'�e^' �a � �, �� �'� �`. t« s � � k � � Y 5 � �`'ib� �'�3v � a 2, � z _ �y J �f � � � ���a�s�� � �. ,s��� a -�� �.p : `�" �" �n rn,�a�. -z �uy� ✓� "�{,�A-'� �-� e �'aFY� s.. r e�+� e s � c T. � � ���� � � . ..,. ��� � � � � '� ' zF,,,. wv„� .�. - Y �.:..�; t .. ��� � �"�� ;�.: � � t' ��;. � ��j �_g . -,�� "� "`« �s ��d' p � fi, � .s .,� �1 rR.. +� � �� � �. �;,. i�`�^d m�' `�. s'�''� ��'�°�'� � � � w�,� � �� �s � ; � �� �' '��, �s 3 y D ��-�� f �� � �,� ' s��r..r.-. : � ' �s��� � : § 'r �� k.s' ��� �. ��. : ,�� �' c g � � 4 ' . . e .w�. '>Msa...w-...,,. .._ �..::.... ,: ._ ,...: .>,,,,.,-..r�..+�,...,.�_.'ar�........ . . _ . __, . . . . _ aC.... �.x.,_. . . _ , _ ,a.,., � ., ,,. .:... e.s .. .:a.�,�..�:. .....-%�....F.. ,. . m,_ ,t_.,w ,_ . _.. _.. , ,_ Keega.n. � Keeg�an, Ross & Ro� er, LLP � ATTORNEYS AT LAW Thomas J.Keegan Jr. 3i5 Westphalia Avenue Phone»631.298.i2oo Daniel C. Ross Post Office Box i46 Fax»631•29$•4427 Jamie G.Rosner Mattituck, New York ii952 Web»www.keeganlaw.us Thomas J.Keegan(s923-2003) March 14, 2016 :� : �-Sp/ti► �` , RECEIVED ��� � Southold Town Zoning Board of Appeals MAR 14 2016 Attention: Leslie Kanes Weisman, Chair Town Hall Annex Building ZONING BOARD OF APPENS 54375 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold,New York 11971 Re: Appeal of Building Inspector's 20 Foot Boat Restriction in Pre-C.O., dated 1/14/16 Premises: 1900 Great Peconic Bay Blvd., Laurel, New York SCTM: 1000-145-4-3 Appellants: Frank J. Kelly Dear Ms. Weisman: Herewith please find the original and 9 copies of Frank J. Kelly's Application to the Southold Town Zoning Board of Appeals seeking Reversal of the Building Inspector's 20 Foot Boat Restriction set forth in the Pre-C.O., dated 1/14/16. n � ; Very ruly ours, .- , i . Ro r Western Suffotk Office»Patchogue, New York ._� il F APPLICATION and EXHIBITS APPLICATION of FRANK J. KELLY to the SOUTHOLD TOWN ZBA SEEKING REVERSAL of the BUILDING INSPECTOR'S RESTRICTION, SET FORTH IN PRE EXISTING CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY#38052, dated 1/14/16, TO USE OF MARINA BY BOATS THAT ARE TWENTY (20) FEET OR LESS. Re: Premises: 1900 Great Peconic Bay Blvd.,Laurel, New York, SCTM: 1000-145-4-3 Appellant: Frank J. Kelly 1. Application to the Southold Town Zoning Board of Appeals seeking Reversal of the Building Inspector's Restriction in Pre Existing C.O. #38052 dated 1/14/16. 2. Project Description Form. 3. Questionnaire. 4. Town of Southold and NYS DEC Permits: a) Southold Town Board of Trustees Permit No. 6205, dated September 21, 2005; b) Southold Town Board of Trustees Amendment to Permit No. 6205, dated May 17, 2006; c) NYS DEC Permit#1-4738-00542/00003, dated January 20, 2006, and Amendment to the Permit, dated May 5, 2006; e) Southold Town Property Card for the premises; 5. AG Form. �; a.S � 6. Owner's Consent ��E� 7. Transactional Owner and Agent, ���� 8. Short Environmental Assessment Form. MAR 1 � 2Q�6 9. LWRP Consistency Assessment Form. ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 10. Pre Existing Certificate of Occupancy# 38052, dated 1/14/16, that restricts the size of boats that can be docked Marina that is recognized by said Pre C.O. to 20 feet or less. 11. Correspondence by former Southold Town Building Inspector Howard M. Terry to Mr. F.R. Fleschutz and others dated September 10, 1968. Mr. Terry's Obituary dated 12/17/2006 wherein his position as Southold's Building Inspector from 1956 to 1977 is noted. 12. Portions of transcript from oral argument in the case Town of Southold vs. Frank J. Kelly and Elizabeth G. Kellv, Supreme Suffolk, Index 15-5142 (J. Tarantino) wherein Southold Town's attorney at page 32 recognizes the "Historic use of the property was that people kept their boats in the slips for the season and drove their cars to and fro, but the boat remained in the slip." 13. Deed of Frank J. Kelly and Elizabeth G. Kelly, dated June 11, 2014, recorded 06/25/14 at Deed liber D00012778, page 753 in the Suffolk County Clerk's Office. 14. Affidavit by Walter Koch, sworn to 12/03/15, wherein Mr. Koch attests to the existence of between 10 to 15 boats at the marina from 1963 to present. �Fp�,� Town of Southol.. 1/14/2016 � �� � 53095 Main Rd ��� .� �' Southold, New York 11971 �Q � � RECENEO � '* �'� MAR 14 2416 PRE EXISTING ZpNING BOARD�F�� CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY � No: 38052 Date: 1/14/2016 TffiS CERTIFIES that the structure(s)located at: 1900 Great Peconic Bay Blvd, Laurel SCTM#: 473889 SecBlock/Lot: 145.-4-3 Subdivision: Filed Map No. Lot No. conforms substantially to the requirements for a built prior to APRIL 9, 1957 pursuant to wluch CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY NUMBER Z- 38052 dated 1/14/2016 was issued and conforms to all the requriements of the applicable provisions of the law. The occupancy for which this certificate is issued is: 11 slip small watercraft marina(maximum len�th of watercraft 20 feet)and gravel parking lot, without building/structures. The certificate is issued to Kelly, Frank Kelly, Elizabeth (OWNER) of the aforesaid building. SUFFOLK COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH APPROVAL ELECTRICAL CERTIFICATE NO. PLUMBERS CERTIFICATION DATED *PLEASE SEE ATTACHED INSPECTION REPORT. orize Signa ure ��.�� IRECEIVED MAR 14 2016 ZONING Bpq{�D OF qpp�q� EXHIBIT 1 ' i2ECEIV�C7 , F�:s Fi��By: .e►ssi�nent�vo. MAR 14 2016 APPLICATION TO THE SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF APP RD OF APP��sl� �o� �EEkz � CvF Sr�� �r�v �ao- w�Tc�cR� s- Rf�,�2�tt�a� � �y a��b � Bun� rr� 0(_v,�R►�nF t �W r'RF �� Sirruc- C. o, ��'jDsd,�.d � l House No. 9.l Da st��t P�c���� Hamlet � �t R F_.L. SCTM 1000 Section Block Lot s 3 Lot Size o � \ Zone��� `� � c ) I(WE)APP +AL HE WRITTEN DETERMIlVATION OF THE BUII.DING INSPE�TOR DATED t a I BASED ON SURVEY/SITE PLAN DATED � S �, ��C. Owner(a): '� hJ 12 �f�EL1-�`' a- ��'�Z�P CI 1� C. ��u.`� Mailing Address:� v� �iY4�{ �TI�In� ►�v r�_ �V1'�( ��-�Q I"•�, l 173a ���-aa�- aa�� Telephone: Faa: Emall: NOTE:In addition to the above.plea�e complete below if appllcatlon is algned by appHcant's attorney,agent,architect, builder,eontract vendee,etc.and name�of,per�p n who agent,�e presenb• ��F��¢n1 41�F IE C-►9-►'�j {���5 g K�SY�r� Name of Representative: F3,,. � �1'�1���E L C• ��SS for�Owner( )Other: Address:�ls W�S'i'PN►�-IZW 1���• � 0. BaX � �,6 . M�,�r�w Y• �)Ct�a �3�-aa�- �abn ��$�4� a7 Em�: �Ro� C� k-����'�.�-w � �1S Telephone: Faz• Pkass cbeck to speeify who yok wish eomspowdenea to be n�alkd to,jrone t/ie above nan�es: ( )AppHc��n��wCn�(s), �uth��d�,�R7epresentative, ( )Other Name/Address below: W,_,.•, • WHEREBY THE BUILDING INSPECTOR =�`��=0 � �R� 'r�`�'T��C C. �, �j S��i a DATED � �l�oand DETTIED AN APPLIGA'I'ION DATED FOR: ( ) uilding Permit � ��� ( )CerNficate of Occupancy �Pre-CerliBcate of Occupancy l�'LT tF i� o� ( )Change of Use �S'CR�C'Z'�o►N �(�1�►�► �R C�R 1'�fr ( )Permit for As-Built Construction�.R"�'�'=T� F� �a R �C��'� � ( )Other: Provision of the Zoning Ordinance Appealed. (Indicate�c�e,Sectton,Subaection oi Zoning Ordinance by anmben.Do not quote the code.) Article: Section: Subsectlon: Type of Appeal. An Appeal is made for: ( )A Variance to the Zoning Code or Zoning Map. ( )A Variance due to lack of access required by New York Town Law-SecHon 280-A. ( )Interpretation of the Town Code,Article Sectlon �Reversal e� v� ��'�zYLr�T�N �n1 {'��,— e.G, �$n5 a � a o -ooT f�1 S A pr[or appeal as,�#e�e�nse oeen maae at anv Hme with resuect to this nro�ertv.UNDER Appeal No(s). 6 �g Year(s). . (Please be sure to research bejore completing this question or call our o,�''ice for assistance) Name of Owner: ZBA File# �Q -�{'g �yy.�Yt�• 1�f��t� �- ��T2K18Fi H �. 1�F�Y' � � RECENEU REASONS FOR USE VARIANCE: An applicant for a use variance MUST demonstra�AR 14 2016 1„�,'�� �� unnecessary hardship by satisfying ALL of the following four tests: (Please consutt ome before completing,attach additional sheets as needed,and submit related documentation as required) ���C'' g�aRD OF APpEq!$ 1.The applicant cannot realize a reasonable return,for each and every permitted use under the zoning regulations for the particular zone district where the property is located,as demonstrated by substantial and competent financial evidence because: �j- E�� �DOt=u� �urr� ��� i�� . � 2. The alleged hardship relating to the property is unique and does not apply to the majority of parcels in the same zoning district or neighborhood because: ��� �4(�,��=� �u n1 ,��=I a � 3. The requested use variance,if granted,will not alter the essential character of the neighborhood because: ��r �.�o�er��� � c�r��T� . �� 4.The alleged hardship has not been self-created because: �r�, ��D p►��N o u.r� ��G�2�',�o. In addition to the above standards,the Board of Appeals must also find that: 5.The requested relief is the minimum relief necessary to avoid unnecessary hardship,while at the same time preserving and protecting the chazacter of neighborhood and the health,safety and welfaze of the community because: � ��� ��� �-►� ��►m �-�r �r��� . 6. The spirit of the ordinance will be observed,public safety and welfare will be secured,and substantial justice will be done because: ��E ����� �� 1� l ��1►' � V 12ECEIVED �C/(/� ( 1 MAR 14 2Q16 ZONING BpqRp nF qPp�AtS �� �',�-� v�J� Signature of Applic t or Authorized Agent ,t,y� (Agent must submit written Authorization from Owner� Swom to before me this��� Day of (� ,20 �Ot�PL1bi1C� ZBA Appl.6/2012 d1pt��,�L C. ROSS ::�tary PubliC, Stab of N�w YoMt Na. 4907176 Qualified in Suf�olit CouM�l � � ��^�ission Expirbs Au�. 31, �, , , Addendum to Frank J. Kelly's Application to the Southold Town Zoning Board of Appeals Seeking Reversal of the Building Inspector's Restriction set forth in the Pre Existing Certificate of Occupancy#38052, dated 1/14/16, that limits the size of boats that can be docked at the recognized Marina to 20 feet or less. The Applicant appeals from and seeks a reversal of the Building Inspector's Restriction set forth in the Pre Existing Certificate of Occupancy# 38052, dated 1/14/2016, that limits the size of boats that can be docked at the recognized Marina to 20 Feet. The Pre-C.O. # 38052 was issued as a result of a prior application to the this Z.B.A. and the ZBA Chairwoman's request that the Building Department consider Frank Kelly's application for a Pre-C.O. The Building Department considered Fran Kelly's application for a pre-C.O. and issued Pre-C.O. # 38052 which recognized the pre-existing nature of the use as "11 slip small watercraft marina (maximum length of watercraft 20 feet) and gravel parking lot, without building/structures." The applicant submits there is no evidence to support the restriction of the recognized Marina to boats of 20 feet or less. The applicant submits there is no reasonable basis for the Town to impose evidence to support the restriction of the recognized Marina to boats of 20 feet or less. The remainder of Pre-C.O. # 38052 is accepted. As indicated by the correspondence, dated September 10, 1968, by the Town of Southold's former Building Inspector, Howard Terry, who served in that capacity from 1956 until 1977, after an investigation Mr. Terry stated, I have at hand a written copy of Mr. Murray's operation record showing the start of operations in 1951 and names of eleven (11) people who moved boats there in 1956 � J� and 1957,which would establish his rights to a "non-conforming use" of an eleven ��"l boat marina without further approval of the Board of Appeals or Town Trustees.�ECEIVED *** MAR 14 2016 As far as the Zoning Ordinance is concerned it makes no difference who o�oet�BOARd oF APN�A�-s boats tied up there, the property has been used for this purpose since 1951 and the entire frontage on the water has been used for moorings and launching ramps prior to the adoption of the Zoning Ordinance in April 1957. Thus creating a "non- conforming use" which can be maintained ... See Exhibit 1. Also submitted herewith is an affidavit by Walter Koch, sworn to 12/03/15, wherein Mr. Koch attests to the existence of between 10 to 15 boats at the marina from 1963 to present. See, exhibit 2. The Building Inspector's restriction set forth in the Pre-C.O. # 380521imiting the Marina's use to boats of 20 foot or less should be reversed. It should be noted that an effort by Mr. Kelly to resolve this issue short of this application to the ZBA, was attempted by correspondence, dated 2/1/16, Exhibit 3 hereto, by Mr. Kelly's counsel to Stephen Kiely, the Assistant Town Attorney responsible for Code Enforcement matters. Mr. Kiely indicated the Town was not interested in discussing the withdrawal or amendment of the 20 foot restriction. �ECEiv�n MAR 14 2016 � I��P ZONING BOARD OF APPEqL,S EXHIBIT 2 RECETVE[� MAR 14 2016 � APPLICANT'S PROJECT DESCRIPTION `�`� �ONING BOARD OF APPEALS APPLICANT: �� Y�-- IP'C F—LL� DATE PREPARED: (7 1.For Demolition of Existing Building Areas Please describe areas being removed:T�►N ii II.New Construction Areas(New Dwelling or New Additions/Extensions): �(`)IN �' Dimensions of first floor extension: Dimensions of new second floor: Dimensions of floor above second level: Height(from finished ground to top of ridge): Is basement or lowest floor area being constructed?If yes,please provide height(above ground)measured from natural existing grade to first floor: III.Proposed Construction Description(Alterations or Structural Changes) � � �� (Attach extra sheet if necessary).Please describe building areas: Number of Floors and General Characteristics BEFORE Alterations: Number of Floors and Changes WITH Alterations: , IV.Calculations of building areas and lot coverage(from s rveyor� Existing square footage of buildings on your property: � Proposed increase of building coverage: � Square footage of your lot: Percentage of coverage of your lot by building area: V.Purpose of New Construction: �VD N F VI.Please describe the land contours(tlat,slope%,heavily wooded,marsh area,etc.)on your land and how it relates to the difficulty in meeting the code requiremeot(s): ���� 1' Please submit 8 sets of photos,labeled to show different angles of yard areas after staking corners for new construction,and photos of building area to be altered with yard view. 4/2012 �ecerv�c� MAR 14 2016 ��u,�9 ZdNING BOARD OF APGEALS EXHIBIT 3 , +�ECEI�VEC MAR l 4 201G �C�(�f� QUESTIONNAIRE �ONING Bpp�p OF qpp�� l FOR FILING WITH YOUR ZBA APPLICATION A. Is the subject premises listed on the real estate market for sale? Yes �No B. Are there any proposals to change or alter land contours? �No Yes please explain on attached sheet. C. 1.)Are there areas that contain sand or wetland grasses? �`—� 2.)Are those areas shown on the survey submitted with this application? � 3.)Is the propert bulk headed between the wetlands area and the upland buil ing area? `����'DPCRi Y TS guckH rr4D E�J 4.)If your property contains wetlands or pond areas,have y contacted the Office of the Town trustees for its deternunation of jurisdiction? �Please confirm status of your inquiry or application with the Trustees:�R�t S i EC� (,�►q��f�� 'tSsu h'0 Q��M�� S and if issued,please attach copies of permit with conditions and approved survey. D. Is there a depression or sloping elevation near the area of proposed construction at or below five feet above mean sea level? �O PR�P�srD C'c��i I`R uC lSa{N E. Are there any patios,concrete barriers,bulkheads or fences that exist that are not shown on the survey that you are submitting?�_Please show azea of the structures on a diagram if any exist or state none on the above line. F. Do you have any construction taking place at this time concerning your premises? ��� If yes,please submit a copy of your build' $�ermit and survey as approved by the Building Department and please describe: �1''1' . G. Please attach all pre-certificates of occupancy and certificates of occupancy for the subject premises. If any are lacking,please apply to the Building Department to either obtain them or to obtain an Amended Notice of Disapproval. H. Do you or any co-owner also own other land adjoining or close to this parcel?� If yes,please label the proximity of your lands on your survey. I. Please list present use or operations conducted at this parcel �`�� � and the proposed use �.�. �W p . (ex:existing single family,proposed:same with garage,pool or other) V Authorized signa a Da kECE1VED IQ-1, -1, ` MAR � 42016 �UNING BOARD OF APP�ALS � � � � 1 I� I / -�� A w � �..�.� '"""�. y� s"' i y ��_^�'��c4w��`�`...�'''�'h a'{` ""����it�y'. s i,a.v J�'1.,� ,�'Y r..��,„1 �e�.v�v.� . ��w. ��a°�""w',� 'j,sv`� , !''�; �.,..w�` .� � � . .'' J „/„� ,. � ,✓ --� e�'],c�� gp . �� .'�.� � '`�+. „ �. f ^'w . . � `1. �4 k� �.fq Y� .,9 .'>t. . � . x� � - "t 'y�1 �°% :� �'"' 'h"K �.�y�P"���i r � �*�Mi•'��^�' i r w y �^"'�:/ i�t T �1�0. �f ,'�"� JlH� � a✓ z 1j1�'��• �'A j �'"�. � {, t � t9 '� `.. f ;,y, e. ae. ,1 i - S'-.. 9' `� �t�3 �����'�'�f`����'� �'�i..��,y�3��6"���v�,ri'.�,.�""."i����r� .`� �'� :�f��� ��'� � y,� d wt}' �,. � �.�41�. t � ..� �Sf� �.e� -r.�",y`�y ,y, ,.s��, � .,,,.. ,�, ��� s v . �`' � � R y� ��!Illd�.i ..:�'^t� ������ r .k.�1pr} ��.;� �4�a'G��- �n� ;�`� ' � . ��~ � ' � �` �.,.^ �; � y„k� i� �.� � �� ir l 1 a����� .�`,c 1 � •_S�� .l d �•�tt .f , s ,I e-.`�. :ro ��. s`,! �� y �9' ,��b fi°r F ry✓''��,I'�^' .i.t°7"a4`+�t.r ' '4�' .t��9y'r,'.i5' d,•yi',.' .�,ae" *'r'}'!jR���(����y � � . y a(�J.Jf�,wyr�. Yt'��" � . �a�;l� / .e' y �p R � � ���k % _� � c �F '�;�,�r �����.C��'�� � � � � � � � z k� '. ��y9� `,,����� �� '� � � 6 � �E /c. . � � �, N�* ��_�.. f�.��� n r �: � '1� � .w � /y,� �z� �. }f .','y�`� r:?� �: l�.� .,i.>; f � ."..'�j} �,� .'�,,F Zi', c ,cL„! � s�r�A %'A' ��r r .`' �'r� ' 3 � � � • . - r �� �e. ,`�� +' �o �:�.��:� �:..�� o e � � ,� �. � ,...:� �� �� ���� � ��.� '�' � � � ``�" ��`� ���°r :�� � r .��'-�,.,�� y!��:;i'��:;'`� �� * � �:;; r i,;s E • ��"�� ,,���� '�t �� " Q � � �1 .�;�"�� �y � �,.a ;�1,'���j I �� �� ��; 1�d ��; a o � �{s' � € ���,� � _ � a �"�;` � � �A� T � �,. � ��,,{� ����•"` "z a� , t , �R� ,�+ . • � � > � �`_ �� '"�)i ��'��:�v�,`� .� •�. a • � � �t. �'.;d'�i,F� y".�Fp�j�'�° ��•,;.�7 •k /+' .a» ' � ��i � �` ',i y �:';t a,� Y lTV i�f � p # y. b �� �"" R3: �'� , �� �1 \4���w�h� Y r d �+ p .� ' ��y��,1 ; ~� i � ' A .� � � � �. F �,:?:Y�'•-� ��� � � � �• W � �I� E �p..� �`�� �l .Q�• �. ;-i�"+�, ,. � ''.:'s,�'v.�� � ��� 7 . Y i a tl Le �.C:�.�.r��..v..�. �+,'�G�'�'.. w .a r � �� �;>b,e: :�.,��! �i J"rv:��-,r�T.. "�, � • �'� p�!. �a`�:,���� ��' - � 0 6 a • i . a a e• �n n : a " � +^l� y'I:S';vy • � ��a '�i w �'.� '� t � � 1 i� �� .,� � }� 1�, �.��`�.�`�".i�",�5f * 6 1 r s o a . . �� �'��� �,� � �'��� _ 4��1`�a "'�� ' _ _ � - �� -�- '� ��' �31]� >���~ �' ^ ' �• /��}�' �. i'�y�fTA y11 - �'A�.�f�R�,� ��a+'Y'f �:� � �a • � u 'fr. ....� 3, r��f�v �1�.. P SA _!'7:���{�) .4, `�� __ � ! . � ���� 1�iva�y...��< � h Y ` � �, �,^S '�F��� � .i ( yk: d 'a ..h_• 3��a�.� �1 �y�r. '.'�� :.7'r' .1 � ' t�r '�y�:l�fi�i .E,� �Y~���:� �'�R�J� �.,�'� r �3sii� ��.'� , � �� " ��`.`1�Z,Y, �� � r 3:. _:.",... 9� -fi s .�. l i.�� �, �� ,r�,3�.'�Y?� � • c .� � ' x:,i[.�` +'�� � r��� . 8V '�' �„yd q' .cy E /�'� .�� �' � '�", '��.�, �� / '�-�ej73 ��' , ' " ��^I�<< � � � ��Jx+yY�" �±� r . a • c• y 7y Z��-�� ,`�-.:�'�;��. Ei. � a � .Q... ■'+`�• ��f�w'� . �,m � q, e ;���mil� �: t_'y� y + e �Y : �rs�p..3f� :;� .. J� �sorierere� �,�f / y 3,� ��. i ' '����°•� - a�g �. 'A_p__� � � i�..,d..._ .c:_- - ;7 ,d�1 .�;r �'1 � 'i�. �� � . r_A.a�.a�i�' � . ��:�� � �l r'i v�''+.�,y y� �+. �'f�. � Qi � +�� � d.s.,... -� -�w✓' � ��.��5��� � ��1' ' � ��Ly ��'.i' s� �ll��i' s `�� 5�`�-� '"�:1= ''a� �' � . ' � .i �/"� �' aa�.. �;�{� '= �: ±ta e � �..� �. ! /i a 1,�f. �. •��� hC ', � � + `� ��� / � y:�� � Lf;,�%t •dy,�� o � 3'4 L A..� 1..1� r. e•.-� S ���'7 n 7,d 3,!' 4 '�s{ w „t 'q0 �, s '�[� �fk�,. r. � � ✓r j 1 A � �i l � �yS� � iA� 8� � � � '" " �' �� Q ,'d�� ,��� i � `b �.� s. r .�. ���'.A.e'-,:'A 'F a 'ti A�" ,� Y � 5�� � � � �� ��� �` ' '` � � " �'y�� a��" ��f` ; � ..s �O '�'^'aCa ����'� � ,er.. 4; ��.;�.�.�1����f ��.�..-� (�a�,. � .. t ld`.". ,a:.'Ji" s� .iJ✓':Fd'��rA.',�,�'�`'X"r''t��� tA�'��.i�:r�u'�.,.o� ����'..,r' r�`'.�.?! i.✓�7..`.. �� ,a,-ywy�l.i �,x�.;,.,,,, a.._ p 4 s �1 7 C (' 1�`1t z .�� ` ,� . Q. ,;�i�� Fh ;� k. �;t` � � � u � ,�,,��i, �t4�. .��"�ie x�, �ph`'�.�y'N.� ..'.y��e�. .ia�T� ��'�.f�iA� �q � ���a� rZ.�� ..:� „�t���•r,r�o rya' �,� if � �.1"" �Y;' ) e-��w' ���� /�',''�y�FhG 7}• s 4y','a. e i� . ;(-,�)� �t.2 �',�j ���..�� � ..N !i� � . . "'�.,r! f .- 'S I i �� f♦ y�� . i� � 7.7+Y'�7��'t�� '� \r•^�'4" ✓'""'�.}o'�°�� ��M } .�.� i����'�+"s .^i o .' ��1.�r, 9 .u1p'D� �l�� i fi'�:�.` �L� �,,�"�4 4 ��,r,�"; . °� Y �1, ^ �/� a1 , µa e S 3 . b..�,.�, S w .Sl.. N � b . ' � �J� 1 ^� �,�r,t,t�}t,s�,a '�,�„„.�"' .`h"�, ,. �i �r '�.:.�' "�;d a 4"�-�, ���o '.�'''�=t �..,�!" '��>.., `"� �°' a. C.`Y���""rw,.I c� . ��w` . Uf4..�.C,��:' ��i�„4 r� ..'.'� w'�w��.'Q ,'' 4...�'y&'��....�. �..�wftw���� � ��t+°�".,.r`ry. ..s�+'''�y �``�� �•u j. �.��.on-'i'f s'w'-_ .��s._."�"'+u.a�N+'��'o"� �'aw..w.�a+w.., °`�/`^�"`. '\���� 'w,�"`4aw�sr�"9F '``�,�4' �/ ' — �-..... �_._....y�`" '�..�..s'' �o,_.:� �--...`'^,-'' `�.,....r''.-- -�---.' � r • . ` .. . .. .... ...._. � t ., .... . . . . ... ... ... . c ... ' � . . .� .... ---� � , . ; i . r .. , • � , . • , ' , • ' rr. � . ., .r y • , ., � , �� i � � . : fi ����� �� � � �� �'�' _.. • .�, � .... , . , :. . � .. ;��,��.��acwr�.:: - .. � . .� ���• �. �. � �, . � ' ' �or t ; �q.���.��'�p�r��o�'t4'��'� �'�t�� �P� �`T?�� �� '� � ,•.. . . ; '�i�.� ... . ;,• . • . . � .+ , ���� ���►������,�,������+� . ; � �f�' , : . . .. . ... . �..... � ' � ' y � - ��'�1�.���`� ' .. _..... � , � � , , ` , • Y���,_�.,�,,�,: q�,'t�'�J� � �� . x7��p� ... .. 3't�i0` '�'`��f'�`'�'�+ � ��' r� : , ' �r''IKi����; ' ,'��`�p , , , !���1j''�II'�����3F�'��� � , . fr ,. , ` � � �°'yDi�t �d �a7� � "'�',� �� �'''�,'' ar�xtx��ot�s�'�'+� �f��� ���; , . 'Ws;�°�'i� � • :: . • � ss . '�u. � ��?�! alci?E'aoz�°s► ot� �c# ��aa�N �L 'S ' Y� � � �`� �#,��su , ' � - i , �,, � �.�s �r:� .�p�t�os� � �� � �° vu..�t� .. .y, �:�q�a�.,G�b��+�$�+r Sa�r€u�►�a�3�m��'°sd °iq�' t� ��� P�rs `s�ax �` : ��� � , ao� �' � � �c�s p� �d�' �R? �� �'1I�'�'��rr"�`'PQe► ��p a� � . ,; ' .�� �'�r� sr� �ac�t#� .. e w ��'�71�4�'��`��9P� '�'�; .i�� �t't � � `�?�s°�f !. '� �'��. - . . �g p�:q�y t�R $rs�r'�J!! �'.t�3�p� '� �:1��� �iX �` ?�L� � .. .� ~ .. � • � �si; * � � o� e�� a�� � �" �'�°'� ��#' � ; . ,. � �� , � " ���� �� ��!.�� � ,� �,s,q,�g -� - ��,.� . �aa c�; �ar�Txsat�:� �� '°� �� '�'"�'�ir . ,�� :�':i` ����`: �"��; �E � � r ,�y�y�' '� . � ... . . , _ , '��i . � . .� ��p"^ . . .��'�`�'� . '��#� - � � ��iP�t'�t,i�l4 ; ��, . ,. : ,�� ���� �"'����� , .:�?� � ,_ . .... � .�.�- .� ,�� �"��,.���� �'�,� �"" - �...,. • � :��ci�� ������'�` _. . . � .�� . �.: .. . .. ' . ._ < ' , �x�� , �o �m�� . �,�t��a,:� �,�' �����'"�,,`�.�°�..�.�'�,� ,. ' � l�s �3-g�t�' �t �� ,�'e�'� �'� ��-�° t'�'�'' g� �`� :� �� " . '�,, _. . , - ,: - � �°' �' . ��� ��` _. � . :'�� . .: .. • � ��.:�� � :��. . �� �� � � ,: �r ° �� �:, ;�� .��. �a �tQ�a,� Q�t6T- 4� � � �� � -[�asrr-s� "p�'Lg '� � , • . '. �t#�x: �s��: �� � :�� �eg: it�'�s�g '1 �C 1' . Sltflddti�O C121d09 9NINQZ . � • : . ' 9�OZ � I �dW ��+��U�1�.l�u'� �i�,� ; �3AI3J32� • �1�b� - " , ,. � � .. .. . . . . _ . . � , . . ,: . . � . . , , . :� �. .. _... ...�_.. ..«�„�. .....-... -.,,«,:«� ... , � ,. '"K - � . 'tt, . . :�� VIA� ! :�1'�'�34''��4l.tl{p�l'1y/�4,�i'XD�3A'�1 �P�! ' � ' �''., �:. , � ,�:�'�.aerd `�•f.a�e� , � ,` . "�C��urtr_�•1� ` _ , . . _ . � . ��+�tJahw�ul�lta�k�f�tlas,vlar#,.. . - �� - : ta:�'���+t�Essd �� �'� . ,;�. K '�: ., . ;�� ��, �1�r:a�atr�tiop �a►�rn�ed:f6"� .:�,�, :•�,�,?�.':�:,; •ri�� . .:�.. �irAl�atisra�.�''� . ��4's�i�+p��.�'�+�"ra�b�l�ias�d#a.ba�r,�K$ ,.. . .. dAo�i�fl�x�a�d��:��pa��� °. ` _ aECEIVEG ���� �u„�tajoi,�... oF�''A�1#' �; �;` . ��t�;�.�.��,.��._+���� _� � MAR 14 2 ���.�:���:�na:T��'� �` . 016 to las�ig�etf e�'��a;�+:���rd.�Iat �j,��+`� - . . ' c�- . : �° ��'t.ZONING BGARD OF APPEALS ���'r,ok+�1l;�'(��.Pacaiw J�l'�Ja�ard, � ' , ' . ��f;.,�#�'3Q����� , _ � ,..�'� � f,�'..1�'bft��d�Cfl�y��.�p.. ���y�'y�y����) + t � �'�� '� t� .1GF��Ii4F�11 tK�.� j��LF�'n/' Q��� -���� �' ,: . ��'�' . . �� .; ,�. — — � _ ,:' - .���:. � �_ , , � ��r�'�9' .�!���`�'Q , �,� ,i�:: ,...,, �:; .. . . t� . . � �"` �r ,d�t$-1� :� r '�i;:�"'' ,. :� .�s���.�M •��Nti1��♦ Y�r�..; E�I�I:'�t�� ���r,,.;.,." �JI�T'O,,F Ni��C):fl� . : . . ....p� f� . �X.�b'$�7`�C° 'Ll�hi� ,� ', �w' � �'h�. � ��. r�: . .... , . .. ,. � ,.. , ��� ,=., �:�.� �:.� ,� �.. ����si;�Pn '�� `, r;�, � ' �� �� � .� .11t�ft��' A�A1�"tf�'"t� " :;: "' �. �.� � �2' . � _ - ����, :,1 �a'� � �'1'���1NAV•'I'4.�.���, .. �;- � c-�,r��""�` �t. � �.�'�I 5'-�'-it��:�V�VA`l �� . � .;#.1'�`4!�!.Ol�t��,ri�" '{ �� �`�IE,P�'.C'M��) �, ,.�' 4� '�� � ��; ���2.�w� . - . , , �J {-a'3. 4 ,.,. � . �� ,''� .J�'►J4'� ;'; �: �'^LA`� , � ' .v,�, C�'�Y'' �' � � LX:k�l'P1:1E� y.. . .P�P�$����"��'�': � � ��=K�1� �I� '"' . .tC�:iN �ll` . " 'R � � t. � �`,�i����$��,��'���'�. , �'' ��. "��'� 3? � ;�� � . . ��1� ��. �: , ,r. . � �: :�{���y ,�j ��+:��p�� �y�, �' .�` /�{ y�ny.y.{� .'[;F'��1iQ..f.�'`.��`./�I`G?�VII� L✓ `'''.,• � i �, .. �;��iJ� 1;.''X4/�'►5?��. , r.: a: �� �`j'';�`�`. ��. t�t:ss�� ��/:�t� �►°�� Aty �,,:� n .�.....%� ��� ►1"�?:��" �.'7r�. �!� ���'rM4�+lr!��1�1'lf"�II��M'+'+.YK� � �;'.:i 'I� '� 'I�:�I�yL�.I�.���1?J.�CtCA�E=P���: '�,. ,.�'� �� �,,,� . �t� ;5[ ' ���n���' �, Q� ��•�����. .�. . '�+� � • � � , •` ���,,...�..�+►,�� �"� . , o (k7 , � � a � Q?P�r►i�riei�aA;i�t3'�'�q�vrv dt�anao�s frda; � � �:�a�fie1���uid add rrosrs�aioF ^K �?�4tiy!R�d�l���:��1�ACaa`�rr'!w�'ak �' �y{J �� ��� ' !���a#r:l'�t��.d`,�a . . ��:.. � �� ������f'�''�5to+i�idu►b�atx�ng.�+:rat�d.�et�ia l�i�� 1���±F�+l�#�'f` - �. �.� , ..��' . .. „ ;l`.�;��w �,y��.��•�1fJ�'����;�;�i�4� .����i'M���i'f'f���il��R l�I/�/��r.r l V►�.���.�,�/�� `�.�� .y�y ' }/�( �T�' I��V��F.�!T.'.!�''"• ����� ����Y ���..��[i�, Y ���yyy �1{�� , �1'Y�i� �/ �I ��1't ''�/����j 1.`4.z �' 1���Il:'�.��$�8 ;��}�::3 t���+0�;���?�:.�''..r,.�f t����'�. E`��rt��-���'Q �i� �f,: :i��l��,����4#�'�t�� j ._-- �_, ..� ,.. , , t31�r+t�T:�up��,.Px�i�� �������` �w'�rt1�`�l. 31 J��e�ug,�i�e.Preaid�x�t . �+,, 68���e�p:�9 �ie�4ste� 1?.U..B�x Il�'9: �e�.Fnliv.v��da � � ��L�vY°'S�or�'7�!'�.��t9 Fe�r�..Dzck�ta - . . . . Tel�s�vae���1:5 7�5-1:��2 �1'��'�{,.:: .. Fasc f8`8I?366-ft!�1 ��+�a . . . � ��� ��'���������'�� 6tECEIVEG Tt��'Q��.f3SZTHCl�3! �t�m�er��l, z�tJS MAR � 4: 2Q16 , � �ONING BOARD UF APP�AL5 IU�rk F�ib��t'�E. F-L�r�,,r�t��r� �-���+��n��, �r►�. �:����:F��r� ����{, �I;�'�C�ttc�n� t�'r' �1,19Q$ i��; �,Al�f� M:UR��(8��U�A�C�E�kJF� 'I�.I�O f E��Il�C �A"��L'�`I�„ �.AU�E:�. �:�TM#YI4:�-�-� � ����'�}P. M�f�l'1"#�"i'�#: Tf�e iB�rd c�f�`o�nm �`r.����pa�fl�r.'fo#K��fi�g�'��br�d�r�rty��s re�u;F�r tr�et�rr� f��ld�r�a ��., �e,pt�mb;�r��, �lC�v re�a�dfr���he ab�o�e t��t�w 'll�t�#�F�#��.� ��-�c����Xt�r�, 1r�� c�r�f�ha1�c�Ji4M'�MU�'Y 8ir���4�t`$�ll� appi#:��to the�acat�ol�i �'o�a+t� T��t.�e�fo��p�r�t.ur�d�r�M�p�o�trms���ha�r�� c��tt���a�u:t��ld Tc�v�n ��ds, th�1�1�?�nd�rd�nan�� �#��� �a�r�:�rf�o�.�c�f�, a����t��a��� ,�a�►.�a���, zc�o��na; '����� �aE�i �RR��ca�io�'t vu�i�e��r�� tc�ttte� ��t#�I� Tav�r�-�v�a�a�o�. �r�sar� �v���ff:f..ar tf�.eir�r��ii�g�s an�. t�camr�.�de#iv�s, a�d, V�f�-#E�F.�S�, .a.Pr�1���+¢,H�ar'�n��nt�s �+�I�f bp th�Tn�trr Tru���l'��h �sp��t��x� �p�;l�t�f�a� on<��fi��t?�e��'�, ��5; ,s�t�rhJ�h tit�� i��st�i p�.cs�n;s u�r��i��� �� ,t�����:���'�� !����r't!� a�tQ, V�H��E�S, .�h�'�ar� .r�er�b�rs�h��� p�ers:��i1#y t���'��d �n�����mil:i�r � �.t�t� p�em�s i�c{�a�;stinr� a�c�:th�:�surro.unding are;�,�`ndt i�'t}���5.,#������� :I�� �o�s���r�d �II th�fi��#imon�ar�d.di��m�n��s��i :m�t�� cQt��C�t��g this app�iw�t�on.,:and, � �2 {tECEIVED MAR 14 2016 ���(� ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS t�H���, th� ��ru�tu�.�ompli�s w�h �fie:sfi�����ds ��f�tCh tn ��1apt�►'9Z a#tY��. �t��.�ki Tc�w�t �o��e� °1�����t�:,.��f�o�rd �ra�de�er�irt�d �h�t#� ptt��#� pr�pQ�e�d v�til ��t�t t� �:ea��h; �.a4��t�� g�r��ra���lf�€��f�e-pQ�pl���e t+�wn, �J�'T�I`�I�EF�3RE � �T, �E���l�, tl�t�'Et�� �oar�J a€Ttu��e��apprar�e the:�pplic�ati�� �f J�tiA�I��Nf��F�#�;��S ����t��:����:�a��TttoWe�h�:�l�t�� $'� �#:$'�'��''� 1 T',. 9�4�} �td �8` �ti+an���ti.t�bsT b�.l�Che:a���d�a��'tr�,� ��a�b���r�]ter��idvKaFd ��+ct �i;�" h�gh;�r�+�:i5', �-1�8`�'q.�+��.a'., an�! +��' �e�i�n� o#��n�+l bu�kh�r,d�r��Q���td:r��i���s� Ci��i,r�d/���a�� e��it��8'?� �'ti�i�r baat ras�:; r�tr�r�r�3'�E 9' �vva.�d w��c;:�et�����rt�t t�1�c���tn�r�s�s 1�'� �tsf�ri��'� �::�,:.u�o� w�.�li���� ��"�`�'�'�ce�d d�c�€; rert�����t�r��� ��l�+t��n�� °b�.lkh�,�d;�d�arrs�t`u�(�r�s to 2'�r.�t�t'I�n:dt�ar:d a�d �n f�1,�hr��4' �+al�y afiari� t�� t�11�h�:;,,en�d dr�e �pR�r�x.����c�c:a�s�i��p¢i�fr� �re�rr:�#�t�3�':s.e��rd�n� B�f�h�a����t�i��t-m d�p°t�af�`}�L�l, a�pt�c�,�� �y, �#�r�tt'�'�Y�11 be �€�e.�::�r��''� �b,�itt:ar�d �9��y. af��r�,c�r�r�fie:#ruc��i c�s�e t��� e�r�a�i �pl�r�d�urc�;F �+�h �h���ti��dn��urbid�ty se������� Pn��a��cl:�re���a���ri�r�k���irr�,�r� �Il�� ��,�picfi�t.c�n t�Zs pl�� pr:�pa�d k�y��En-Corrsw.lta�°►t�► I��,:la�.�ed �e�rter�h�r 6rt�Qt��: P�r��fi:fQ ron���u�fi and�+cn�.pi�te:p�r����i11��t�e tt�a� .�'F�c3rtt.�h� d��t�t�,p�t�i� i��i�n+�. Fe�rr��a:s�����:pa:id, )f-�pplic�t�le,,a+1d p�erm.�t i�suec� v�ifii�fn �i���c�nths c�fi tfi�� d�te;�f ChI� n�fiea�i'c�rn. fr����i���s �r� r����r��;��t� feQ�f�$�.���assr i:�sp��iqn. (��e �t�ta���+d�schedtil�.�� .���.��.�D t��r�. }��ur�,. . �''. ���.�� � . �4�bert��J�, k�tup��ti,.Jr., Pr�sid�rifi $�t�'�+�Tr�t��s J�.�i��m� � . .�}���..J.,l�t���i,P•i�aideil#� � ` 1'�Y�n�ia13 ' dart��a�Ytr�`�`�'ic�Pr�sit�an� �3fi�5'RGsu�,e�*�i ���� ,�.r�ie�`Qater � �.�'�,�4?F���T� I���:���v�a � s�o��n�r�,�t������x�;�z.a��a g��y A..D�q�ex�oz� • ' Telephn�Y�e��7"76&=18'a� ;�:.. ,: � F'a?c��1��8 � ,�� �� MAR 14 2016 �G��� B��► �F��+t����r�� ZONING BbARD OF AppEALS T(��T�'�UUTH��D ����R� �:��,�r��Q�r� �c�����r r������,�������a��� aF ������� ��.J�€}t!}�� R�t�1� F�:��MN�E�t�Ehtl�� Q�TH:E V�fi�f�#4,TQ �A�.��1 ,r4�'���1Tl�tE�f�'Ffi?.��4:F����1�1��["f��:CT�#V I�V�p�T��`]:�1. ���X#:1i�f���T�. D:�q:� �l.L B��#f��I�:�C� ,���!�1»�1Tf.Qt�:.+�3 ����J�L:� ���C���'ftt?N C� 'TH.� F'�i�fiT. I.f��,CTt�7'��#�tH:��l�..� .,_,_;�, .��'�-�Ccxtas�i'�t�ti�r�, f��y #aal�, Itn�: ' �I°�.d�y o��a�r��ti�� ',�� cc����ru�t�ef +,•�''� Pr�a�:�c� �a�p��t�� �m�l��n�e Pn,sp��ar�.. RECEN�U MAR 14 2016 �c��(� �T�r1e,s�'.K{n�,P2'�Bfflen� ,�'��`��!��' �P�Ai�'�HRD OF APPEl�L�S .r�11:,A�:�a3��r1b',Vice«Pr.e.�i�enb �+� s�uss.Ra�:��� �" � 1�:Q.$�►�.f 1�9 F'eggy A.�ticl�exson. � � . S4u�ixa�d;�I;ew'Yix'�e�.X9��1 t�9B� Il�ave,Be��ea 3oi�Hblzapf�l .: '� �'��!��zi8�`6�1��1i6`�-.1�� � -. .. �. ... 681 �. :!`� �':�x(. . )`T�f 8�3, ��.. : $�!���"��3'�"�T,I�� • Tf��Q�'����`>L� ' �l{.�y 17, 2�1,�� �lr, ��#�ect E, ��rrt��ra �.t�-�a�su�tarrt�� In�.. 'C�Q�t�rth �e�:��� �t�1�#�:1�`Y' �19!�r,'9 f���,l;�.l�� tVI;�U�f�1f �'�Q�1 f��f�'�1� �4'Y B�J�1:L�.���fl, LAzIJ'��. ��T�#9���4r3 ;[�'�T�r. He�rma�ic�; ''�e��Wlr�.g.�n� t�}��r�.b�fihr.e��c�itt�d Ttsuvr� B:oar� o�Tnrstees at tF�eir I�gul�� 11M��i�q h:�tt� an ��dc��s�fa�, ��y �^��',.`�i���: :��.��:1�:EnY �ha�fi�i�.�tt��ld Ta� B�srr-1 �T`rwsb�es A�RR. ��t�i��.�er�c�rr�� . to .P�Ft��t����#c�e��pa.r�d ths.wic(tta,��a;:���t:r.�Er���r��8'fd°I�'ar����I 8�' �rig�ig�i e�rtsl�t� :t'�t�l�€� �er�la��.pt���r�1.b;�+Eii-�t�ri�ul�t�, I�ic�:a�rr�e��1,�71a6. T�r�f�r�fi� s�e��rmin�t%t�tt fr¢m �n�r��h�t'���; ����a t�a���ny ques�i�r��, pl.e��:a��11.our. ofh�r��t��1�'�8�b-7:8��� ��er�J�r, . , � ` � ��►i�'t�s�. it�gg ' l�r�i�de�i�, ��atd rrfi Trt��te�s �F#�'�tl�c � . . . , , � ���nr Y�rk St�te D�pat~Et�t�nt ofi �nviranmental Can�eruafi�on t�.irri�i+�n r����tv�r�x�r���,tal Rermits, Re�ion fJne Builc#tn�4�3-&tlNY,St4ny B�ook, [�tew 1�ork 11790-2356 Phone:{�3�}�t�1�E•036� • �AX: (631)444•096d �� Websita:wwwvt�d�c.stafa.ny.u5 � Den9se hA.Sk�Beita�t Actfng Gommisslanar J�ua�24,2006 P „�l��C VL REC�YV�G J'�es.Murray�Sus�n�egur �,� 2Q16 p�Box��5 MAR Laurel,N'� 11948 �ONING 80ARD OF Ap�'EALS ��: �ertna.fi.#1-473$-OQ542f00�D3 Dea�P�^r►�itt�»e: �eonf�i�rz�zac�vs�itl�the r�qnire�tauts o.�'Gt��te LTnifc�m Prr�cedures�fi�A�tiale 7f#, �L��czrd i6s ir�pteme�tiag re�uiarions�6'��,Pari�i21�we s�e�n�Lo��g y�tt�x�erm�t PI�s�c,�re€uli�read alI�ae�.�mi�conditions az�,d s��c�al�errnit ccandi�ions can,tarned in th�per�i� to��tue.�om�ianee c�uz��ing ttre te�rn a�'t`he p�n�t. If�!a�.�re unable to �ct�p�y w�t�h ar�y �z�lfitz+�ns,pl�ase�anta�t us at#�ie�bove address. �lso enc�os�d is a permit sign vvl�iah is to be conspiGuougiy posted�t the praje�t si�te a�ni� prcr�acted fro�n th�vv���zer. �xr�cerely, �, �f�'U►�� � I,�arr.ry Cowden Environrn�mtal Ar��13+st � �c: �n-�pnsultan�s,�nc. .�l�e � - , RECEIVEI7 p �/,� ' N�W Y(JRKc 5TATE f3EAAR1'MEN"�(3F�i+1VIf�OWI�IENTAL Cit?N��RV�TIC>N �� �{ � ������r r�UMa��z � �����TFv�D�T� 2016 �fiw4� �4 �Q�Qo�. � � Janua 20 2�06 F APP�AL5 FAGILITYI�'E2��R�M NUMB�i�(S) PER�MIT E�€PIF�4TI�3f� DATE(S� . Under th�Enviranmentai Janu�ry�0,209 9 Conserrfa�icn L�w 1"�P"�OF P�RM1'C�1 t�isw ❑Renewal ❑MAd'ifi�ca#ian Es Permlt to Canstttrct G��'ermft to��erate , ... i.Ar�icle�l5,rNe:�:Prot��tlon of"Vr/aters � Arti�ls 9'7,T}fles 7,8��P{3ES � l�rtiete�7,'(�tte S; 6Nfi'CE�R�'��: H�zarciGUs VtTasfe iVjatiageftt�nt ❑ f�ti'�le't5;�iti�'f5:W�te�SupplY � Article 19:Air Pollu[lon Cqntrnt ❑. �lrficte 34:.�astal Etosion CI Artlele 9•5,Tftle 1�;YVBter Transport ❑ Articie 23,T�tie 27:MIneC Land Management Re�cJamaiion C] Arti�le 75�Title T6:Lcfng lsl�nd Wslis D Anlcla 36:Ftoodplain t+�lar�ag�trten�. 1^/i �a O Articte 24:Freshwaier Wetlands /�,.{i A A x I�s�t �jy 7.,��l'/l�'[� LJ fCIIIV���J� 1[1�Q�7: YYlI�1 47Fr�h��..�n� ❑` 11111�8s�r u� +�� 1�1 L'I/J!/�11 I V'�lf\ Rgeiae�tiortal F�ivers t Artida 25:Tldal WeUartds 3$0:Rasllataor�CortErol �:�NYCRFt 6QSt,�!�ter Quali�y Ce.Rifie9- Cl Articie 27,Title 7; 6NY�RR 360: t��. SaNd ti�laSte t�ta�a e�rrent PE�tI�(iT f��a��D 70 T�LEPHfl�IE�1l�MB�6� ..�ar�e�lafurr d��usar�Se ur 'AsDt�E�E�Qf F�RhAfTTEE . P�'�s�345� �4hdT��7 t�ERSQfiJ �C�Ft PEf�MITT�D IFtl.4F�K TELEPHC�N�NUM9�R �n�C��sz�t�rrts 631�2$3•G��Q NAN#�Attit[3 A[�F�:R�'SS.IC��PRC)JE�I"1FACILITY 'M�t'rr� �.Pr,ca".ert 190Q P�cami.c Eta Blvd �£�UhYTY TfJWN WA1"£RC(�UR�� NY`�'f� C��C�?I�A�'E� .Suf��k Sautl�o�d �rushes�reek � 1�; i�'���RCF�7I:QN �3F AU7HC3RiZED ACTI�/fTY: Recor�stru�t 3B 1in�ar ft, o#kz�tlkhead in-Pla�e, r�r�r�s#�t�ct 11��i�ear$t, of bul:kfieac�wifh viny) bulkhe�d up to 2'#andward:anti 1 B``higher in elev�t�ot�, r.8move i�is�ng 1�`x�17'�I�ff�r:m �d rept�ce wi#�r �`x17' pla#fo�m and st�irs, recc��tstruct boat.ramp, rem�ve ar�d�e�l�C�� ex�stir�g wall�nta�r�, r.eplace 8' r.eturn wtth a �' retu�n 18"high�r in e�e�atian, dredgs desig�ated a�.�a to � m�x'rrnur'r�depth of-3' auerage loav water, and �ackkl'ill r��w k�taikhead. Alt u+rt�rk{s ta t�e done in a��!�r�lan�e wfth'#t���#t��ed �lans s#�mped NYSpEC apprnv�d on 1l2Ql2006. ���ceptan�of th'rs permit,t�e perrr�ittee�grees that ihe permit is contingertt upon striCt epmp{i�t't�e wE�t the E�l,,.�11 applt��le r�gul,atlons,xhe Q�n+�ral Conditions speciff�d ar�d any Spectat Cc�r�dl�i�ns in.cluded as part af.�tts r�tit; P;�ftNli`C�#�lV1I�IfSTRAi'QR: AbDR�S� R�gion 1 N�adq�arters 14i1�t^1e: �rr.ara BIJ�t�.B{d . #4fl Ston �rvok �IY 11790-23�H A'4JT�-IQRI��Q S{f�t�ATURE DATE Janu$rsr�4,�Qo6 Pa e '1 �f 5 . . , • ' RECEIVED ���� � MEW YORK a ini E QEPRRTM�NT OF 61�IRQKM�NTAI,CflfVSERVATION Sp�CtA�.�QNDITI4NS � �ONING BOAttD OF APPE �1. Ai�y.debris qr exs.�ess material from canstruction of this pr•c�ject sha(I be comptetely removed frnm 4he adjacent area (upNanii�at�d rerrtoved tfl an appraueil upland area for dispasal. No debris is permit�ed fn tidal wst�ands ar�d or pr�te�ed b�affet ar.e�s: ' 2. 7here shall be no disturbance to v�getated tida!wet(artds or pr�t��ted buffer �reas as a resu#t�f the perm�ted act�rtty. 3� ,All p��i�heraC berm`s,cbfferdams, rocl�re�retments,seaw�IlS,gabions,buJkh�ads e�C. shall be compt�t�d priQr in p(acement oP any fiil�naterial behind such structures, 4. Prior#d��1X canstruc�on or remo.val of bul�heads ar�d other st�oreTine stablli�at(an�Eruc�ures aU bac�till sh�1! �e excavat�d#ar�tlward of the t3ulkt�ead�nd r�t$inec�.sa�s r�ot to+�riter ttxe wafierw�yt tid�lwv��tan+�v.r p�r�f�ct��.b�ar�€�a,. 5� 'T'f�ere shall be no ctisch�rge of r�rr�off t�r other effiuent aver or thrflugfi any bult�head ar shorellrte stat�iliz�tion str.uCture s�r inko any tidal�vetiand or adJ��erat area. �, qll distulrbed areas wher� soil wtil b.e temporarily e�tpa5ed or stockpile.d for longer than one (�) week shall be ctsn�a�ned by a�ntinu�us Iine of s�ked h�y C�al�s/s(tt curtaln (or tittrer�i'�SL?E� app�aved met�o'dj �i�ced'�h th� s�sa�r�rd stcf�b�tween fikie fill an�l wetland or profe�ted 3au�'er gr�a. Tarps are autho�l�ed ta�wppl�m�r►t thes8 apprOved memads�, '�. All iUl sha11 cc7r.rs�st of''clean''sand, grave(,or sflll (r�at asp"haft;flygsh, bxotcc�n���crets ot dert�olition deb�is3. 8.. Dock or t�mber oatwalk shall not��cceed 4 f��f ii�widch and shall.be�min(mum �of 3fz feQ;at�ove.gradp*auer tic#al weflarrdar���('`�s rrreasured from grvwnd�bvt#om of dock shea�hir�g). 9, in�tall�fla�0f additJonal do�ks at marinas,boat basins,or ott►e�eotnmer�ial 1`��IFitles is not aufl�Qri�ed by tliis p�trrii� 1�� .All r��alrr�:t�sixisti�rg structures shali be confined tr�rep�lacement�of existing elemertts with no r.1�an�e tn.design, dirnetlsh�,�r m�terials,.unless sp�ai#icaliy au#hoci�e�d hereir�, 91, l�ir�rm�c��n�t stfu�t�l�s rna�t�e fn5talie�i an doCk/catw�[Islfl�at witi�r�ut first obtaining wrltten a�epartm�nt a�sprov��l f p�rmtt..modification, c�r amendment). 1'2. Pilin�s:m�y not:��}ext�nd�ieyond properfy lin�s, (b)ba p[�c�d so that docl��d k�oat��xtend av�ar prvperty lines, (c}irrterfere wfth navigation, (d)inter�er�with ofher landownecs riparian rigtits. , '13. K���rCteture,S are ta be�Qnst�uot8d on pitings without fuYkh�r aukhorization of the D�p�r#ment. o�c��n�tr tauMe�t PAC�� 2 Af 5 1-�47�&�6��1�Ofl03 � f�EV�t YC3RK&TATE DEP�RTMENT OF ENiFJRC3NMENTRL C�NSL�'tV`Al'!�N ' ������►�.�t��t�i�r�t�Ns MAR 14 2016 ��� ZONING BOARD UF APPEALS 1�, A!I dredged materiaE shalt be dispose�l or�an approved upfar�d sife and be r�tairred so as tb nc�g re-enf��ar��wa#�r t�o�t�+�tidal wettand or prote�t�d buffer area. 15. C�.uring#tie drecfging opsratian,the permtttee and hls contractor shatl prev�nt spilla�e af sediment during�xCavatic�rt ` and haulsge. Dredging stialk be a�camplEsMed u�ifh a clam s�el(or ot#�er ctased"buCket"equi�ment. 1�, Excavate�i ssdiment�shaii.�rapl�aced dire�tfy it�to#he appfiaved dispt�sat site dr eona�yanee�eMi�cf�; PIt3 B�CI�CBS�Ih� (doUb#��ippin�)�ternporary storage of dr�.dge materi�l i�aWthorized. �7. Ttae�se of a dragtine,for etredgin�is s�rictly prcthiblEed. 18. �1Vi�k���t 3�D d��s of�Amptetior���dred�ing ap�ratiar�,a dted��ad depth survey of the dr�s�ged aeea sh�tl b.�submitt�ad to #���egtc�rr 1 BWreau of tVta�lrae Habitat PratectF�n, SUI�Y Bufldir�g 40, �tt�ny Brook, �11' 1179t1-13a�6. At�en�iori; �c�r�1R(i$rrc�: �n����R►�F wuMe�� PA�.E�OF 5 1-47�.-Q��61t�(�f�� . , . . . , o��e�rv�� �L��4� ' F�EW YOF2K s 1 iwl E dEPAR7'MENT�F EM�!iRON1Wl£NTAL GON3�RVATtt7N NOTt�tC�7tQN 4F t�THEf�PtRMtTTEE t�$LfGAI`I��1S t�erz�A: Permlfitee.Accepts Leg�tl Responsibiltty and Agre.es t�D 1nd�mnlftC�tic�n zONING BOARD O�APPEAL The permittee, ex�epting state or federal agencies, e�€pre�siy agrees to inc�e�n,fy and hoid h�rmless the Depe�tman# ��nvirvnmental.�onservatic�n af the State of t�ew York,its represanfatives,empiayee�,�nd ag�nts("Q�G"�for�[I�(aims, suits,aotioris,and damag.es,to th�extent attributabf�e ta trie,permittee'&acts or or't'�lssi�n�in conn�cflonwith,oropecation and mainte�ance af,the facili#y vr facilities aUt�o,ri�ed bq fhe permit wheth�r in�mpt��Ge ar r►t�t Irt complfanca�V�I�;t#h� tei-�s�and�anditions of the perrnit. This fnden�rrific�#ion daes not ext�n�1 to�rty oXafm�,suits�actiatts,or��m��'Ca� e�#en���f�ibutable to DE�'s own ne.gligent r�r intentionat a�ts or omissian�,s�r to at�y�I�aii'r�s,suit�,or act{�ns nei�►ing tt�e L7E�;aitd.arist�tg.under AFficie 78 of ths N�w Yarsk Civil t�r�atice Lews and.Rules ar��y cltl�sn�u�t a'r civil,ri�?its pr�5�isian uncter feder�h ar state faws, tt�m B: F�ermitte+a�'s Cc�ntractvrs to�C�m�riy with Permit Th� per�a�ee is responsibte tvr informing its ir�d�per�d�nt cc�n�r�actctrs� emp)�}re�s, ag�nts and aasigns. of the�r Cesp�ansFbitltyt�complywifh thfs�perm[t, incftrding�tf�pecial con.ditPorrs w#yile acting�s th��ermi�te�`�agent�witf��es�ct tv�th�p.�'mitted acYtiv�ti�.s, an� suc�li persans stiall be subJ�et to ths same ��nctions f�ar violations of the �nv'iror.tmerit�l C�r�S�rvatit�ti Lawas those prc�scribed for.the p�rmittee. Iiem �: A:ermlftee Respnnslble for Ot�taihtng C,ytFiet Requlred Permtts T��pefrntf#�ee is responsible for�bta�ining a�y pt)�er permits,�pprqvals, I�rtds, �asemen�s and rfghts-of�v�ca�that may be req�ired t4�rry at�#the ac#ivlties th�at ar�authorized b.y tftis:permit, i.terrx�; IVc Rl`ght#o Trs�pass or Inte�t�ere wtth R�pa�fan Rtght$ �'his p�rm[f daes n�t c�nvey to t�e p�rmitt�e�tty r�i,gh.t#�t�e&�ass uRtin th�lends qr��#erfere wftfi the riparian�ights o� tit�e�r�in order.to p�rform the permitt+ad worl��or tloes it au#hariz,e the impair.ntet7#of any righfis,tifl.e,�r�rttet'vst it�f'�al�.r per�,�nai pr.operty ktatd or vested In a p.etsorf �c�t a�arty to the permit. CaERiEAAI.Gt)t,IdIT10NS +Ger�ecai CnM:�iti�th 1: Facility(nsp8�ticn b:y fiMe Deparkment • 7h$peCtnl�ted site oP fa�lti�t,inaiucting relevantrecacds,.fs subj�c#to lnspe�tion�t rQason�bie ho�r�and it�t�rvafs b.y ar1 authbr'fx�:d r�pt'�sentative ofi the �e�r�rtmertt of Env#ronm�ntal Cons�etvatlon fthe Depart.ment.)ta determine wha,fher'Ehe {��t'�nitCe�ts coii�►�lyPi�g with ihis permit and th�ECL.Such represenfative mayorderthe.work suspen�fed p�ursu�ntt���L "�1:»Q�.01 �n�SAPA 4Q 1(3�, 'f��pet�rttt�e��haf(ptt�vide a�.erson to accr�mpany#he aepartm�nt`s repres�ntati�e d(�rin�-an ir�spectir�r�t�tMe permiE �r�a�vl��t��t�t��C�d �j�Che Dep,attmer�t. ���ap�af#h�is pe�mi#,i�tcludin�all,ref�r�t�ced maps,.drav,rings and speclsl conditi�ns,must t�e availabla ft�r lnspect�pn by th'e ��p��krnent at all tirrtes at tf�e proJect s+te nr facillty. �at{u�e to produ�ae a copy o�#he petmit upon rae}�est li}+� � ��rkrn�nt r�peasentat(ve�s�vivfat��rn�fi th�s.�ermit. Ger�r�l�crnc�it�vn 2: Re(ativn�hip t�f th�s Perrr�it to Qth��'D��a�tt�rtent C�rciers at�d.1�e.ter.r�rtrt8tions Unless express[y PravEd,ed for b,y�he De�a,rtrrtent� is'suanc�of tt'�i�,permlt does not modtfy, superssde�r res�ind an� p.rcier or deter�ina#'ron�r�v�o�asly issued by t�e Depar#ttmen#oc any of the terrns,ctinditinC��or re:quiremertts cae�tai�t�i�t s�:i�h ordec:Qr des�erminatican. f�eneral:�pi�di��n.3: E4ppl.�cs�ti�r�s for Permit Renewats�rr Modlf�catlons Thi�p�imrttt�e�ust Submlt a sep�r�te written��5pti.�ati,on to ttte Department forrene�►�I., Cno�i�icafl�t�t�r.tr��tsfee.z�f�his permtt, �ual� .�p��ic�#.ion must in�Iude �ny f4rms or sup�.l�rraental fn.formaiivn the Dspartment r�tq�ires..A�ty.re,�Teuva,k� mackEfi�.a.t�qn or tr�nsfer granted hy the Departm�.nt rnust be in writing, Th.�p�rnn3tt��musfi sub"m1t a reri�Wal appticatibn at least: �.): 1,8Q da.y��efor� expirati�n of pe�rt`tits f�r State F�.oflutant C7ischarge Eliminatian S�stem (�RDES�,.H�z�rdc7us Vy��t� IVl�nagerrient Fa�Cilities (HWM��), major Alr�Pollut}fln �ontrQl (}�R'�) and SQIid Vtf�t�te �1�I1�9�tttetlt �aci�iti�s tS1�/M�'�:�nd �r� .�0 zlays�ef�r���pirati�art �#a(I oth�r permit types. Submissid�qf�pp�ieatians f�r p�r�mit r�,r�ewaE or rrrvdificatican are fa be submitted to: NYS��C Re�1�n:�1 PerFnit Admint�trator, Region 1,SUNY Bldg#40, Stvny�roak NY 11"790��3�6 Gener�l C�anditi�a.n 4, f�ermtt Modiflca#ion�,Su�perl.�fc�r���trtd Re�raca#fvrts�y.�I��D�p,ar�ttYre�t Th�'£le�srtm�r�t res�rves the right te,me�dify.susper�d or re�oke this�permit in�ccr�rdan�e with G t�i'�'CR�t Part 82t. 7he ��rau�rd��t��d��ic�tian,.susp:�nsion ar rev��at�on inciude: �) m.�t�C��lly��1se or.i��ccur.�te state�rX��ts.i�t�re.{�ermit.a�plit;ation or supporting.papers; b} �flilre b�y•the permitt�e tc�cc�nti�ifywit�r�ny t+�rms or eo�iditions eif th8:p�rmi#; c� �xcea.ding the scape of th�pr���Ct.as described ir�:�he par.m[t a�plic�t�n; �: n�a+f.y disoc�v�;red maferial inf�rm�fian oC a r�ate.rial ch�nge in�n+�ironmenf�}�nditior�s,relevent technalvg�ar �PlicabEe lavu�r r8gul�tiprt�sinae the issuanee af the ex9stit�g p�rrnit; �e� �o�comp#iance wit�i p.re�riou��y i�s��� perinit co�ditiahs, or.d��s 4f the.�omm�saionsr, arty pr�vi�ior►� �f#h�E �n,v(rorr�r�nt�l.Conserv�t��n l.aw or r..e�ul�flnn�af th.e De�arCmsnt rel�ted ta.the p�rmlt#e�d activity� a�c Pe�l'r t�a�� PAG� 4 �� 5 1-4�38-0:(�54��00003 ,,._ _... � , NE1N YDRK STRT�'i fJ�'PiRtMENi'OF ENVIRONMEN'TAL CQN3EFtYATION A�I34TIO�fAL GENEF�AL CONDITIQNS FOR ARTI�LES 15('fITLE S),24,25, 3a i4Nd 6NYCRF�PA�I�T 80.8 p V MAR 14 2016 � I�� �TiQa�.wer��n�j 1, )f f��Wr�qp�r�tlons by the Sta�e vf New York require an alteration ir� tFre posifion ot the st� ��rb�6�e�Pf�P A� auth,tttized, �r ifi, ir1 ttte op#ri1r�t af tk�e Qepartmen�af En�itor�m�ritel �ttnserva#ian ifi sh�tJ cause ut�reasonab1e tif?SfxLf43t�Eff►t4the frQe�fiavig�ti9[fi�tf s�fd W&t�p3 DI"°fl@Od�nWS Q�8K�d81�gBt�#tQ hE�ffl7,safety�a�'w�kfar�o��f�rep�.opie +�'��t�'i�,�r cau�e 14�s or destru�ti�r►.cr�the natufi�l re�b�Irces 8f�t{�e�tate. Chs ovu�tet rnay be artdered b,�r the D��r�rt►�t�t t�rerrro�e�r�it�r the stru�fur�l work�ob�#r�ic�tor�s,c�t ha�,at'�#s��6ed�h�r�by WlthaUf�pet'�e!o�e. aS�9,aTfd lf,U�ki�)�1'T@ @X�Ji�8i�14t3 QI'PBVxlCB�l�t1 Of thlS p@C'�TI��the structur�,#il��e�avati,an,�r om�r cr,od���n�m ofi the wetercot�rse Mereb.p�ufha�rized st��tE r�o#6��amp�eted;the owner�s,sh��11,+Iditl�ou#expenS�to#he 5tate��nd tit su�h+�cter���r�d in such tim��nd.manner�s the t�epa.rtrrietl�of E�V(ronm�r�ta)Con���uatiori mayre��Iif�u tei�v� ali or.any parfion of the�ricompiet�d struc.ture or fill arad restc�re to its fotrr�er�and�tion the ri�vigabl���d flo�od �rp��it�of the watercce�urse. No claim shall�e made a�ainst the State of New Yo�k san accountaf at�y such r�m�val ar�I�eC��i�xr�: 2, The S,ta'f�qf N�w Ya�k shafi in no cas��s Ii��le�or any dal'��ge or'ir►Ju�y�o the.structute or v+rdrl�he�+air►�ufitabtF�ed r+��ric� r�ay �e ca��ed by mr res4.lf frc3m �uturs Q�er�tionar w�d'ertaken by 4he �#aYe for fh�e aonse,i�af(qri �r Imprav�rla'�rtt-of na�ig�tdtiri,ntfvresther purp�s'es,anctno d�i�'t�vrrig�rt tr�crompens�fir�rt shall ac�erct�#�a�h�ny s�ic'hi �tarn�age. �.. RU ne�ces:sary preca�ations shatl b�taken�o preclude contamina#�pn qf anywe�land or waterw�yby�s�s��ndsd�atids, se�m�nls, fue1�, solver�ts, lubricants: �p�xy�oating�� paint�, concret�, I�e�at� or ar�y �tt�81'envUctn'R1�n#�t�+' i�el.�terinus mater'rats a5scrciated with the�roject. �#, �r�y mater�al dredged in fhe conttuct of the wprk hecein p�rmitEed sfi�tl be remave�l evenly,with�ut leaV��f�s'ge re�'uss.pites, r►dg�s�ecross�or elong thB bed of a waterway ar ffqot�pi�€n,dep��it�wifh�n any re:�u��fory floa�fsv��, o�'d��p I't�9:�tf�&f trtaX.hav�8 terrdency trs cause damage io naatgsbJe cttanrrels.or to the t�arrks o�a�ten�y. � 54. Thr��'ski�((.p��o ufireaso,nable lnterfQl�ence with n�vig�tion by the work herein authorized. 8� I�up�ri t�e e�pi��tian oC re�oeation af this permit, the proj�ct hsreby authorized has not been corripleied, the �p�ltt�nt�ta�N.wi�h�ut e�tp�rt�e t4 tk�e 5tate,and to suek�extent an,d in such time and rr►anner as the[3epartment �f��1Y���m�rrtal�ris�rtiratio�F m�y r�c}uire,fer;nbve all:or�rr�r purtion ofthe.une�omp4.eted ste.uafuce orfiil and`r.esrtbre� �the�te C�o I�s former cvndition, No clatCn SM�II k�e rnade ag�irtst tl�e-S#ata ct#Ne�n►York ort aaCount of arry�uch r,�mt5�r,at orait�ration, 7, �f,g��it9d un�ler�iVYCRR P�art 6QS, tlle N�'��epart�nent of�nvironmerrt�l Conservatinn hereb�+certift�s ffiatff�e subj�t p�iaje�vVilf.t�oYct�rrtr.t�verte ef�EU��rt litr�lt�fiinrts or,�fher'11rnit�tfons ars�andards under 5e�ti+ans 3�Q4,3�3�,.�03, 3C?i�:�nt13�7 c►�the Gle.�n VVater Ack af't 977(PL 9.�-?17}pr�vided th$t ali of the conditions li$ted lasrein�re:met. �, ti4t:f�s��l�c>urs p�1or to�C�rrtr�le►�c��cr�#�t Of the proje�t,th�e permi�ted and contrach�r s#rall s�gn�and rsturn the kop par�f�o�f}�e�Bfti�ed hattf�aatton fot�r�t.c;ert[fylrtg tha�kh��ar�fuil}t avuare c�f iand�urtdeFstsr►d a!t tsrms,�nd conc�t�on�c�f this p�'mi#. �ll�ifhi�30 da�a���pf�t�or�of prc�J���,the bottair►pot�Ei�an nf#he form mus�a�so be s�gn�d.��id re�urr�ed, �lor�g with phbt�qgr�p�r�of the c�orriplet�d work arid,if required,a sur�ey. 9. �It a�t�V�Pe.s �4ftkrariied by thtis perrr�it mu�E�e in strtct c4a�fcumance with tfie apprctved plans submitted by the apPtioarrt�o��ris ager�!�as part�#the perm�f�#���i�a#iz�n. Su¢h apprc�ved pl�n�were pre�ared by En-Cc�nsuitants.Jn�,I�sf r�v_t�ed cm 1�•1�-a5. a�o��tro�r t�u►�e� pAG 6&0 F 6 a-�.��s=u��ss��+Qc�ctn� .,..�...,.. .`........��.�.,r..�... ' ,��; � � ` � ,�) �iu'�rn��`ltal�n};�e�rma-�a`s�u�tireqeras�on � . �' ciriEtd��s�id d4�kz+qc F��Iit�as 511� J��5-V1A � �) �a�rn,AI.�YY �.,�C�'��t�t�' '.�,� �}eVir E�kkttad ghe�thutct to�be u�r�t:all t1m13er :rtcl��'f I�5�� �a ba G��trea�cd � : ta be ratsed tf3": .� ��t• �� �fia t'�ap:r�a�vaYtcu of� /� � , �; k,�..�' w�lk»�a#�Si ba'rat��" ,�'�,. � � ;�� , � �n ; , ,t�,,� , , �3 �ea up.fa':�`�ff x�c!i bulCthead�cr ba dredqed v�a � �' '' '�fi`;� . :���""�`<� ;.�" ,�'� ' � y ' ��� l �f�l�o�t�na�frara wb�ct parcef> . . . t��m��+�.r�f�-3'1V.#N �� ��.������I{���� RECEIVEU sl�l�E�s:►�a�.a�l�f�l.,a��+zma�ux�bask�`in i' � �;�t�������-��i�, � � MAR 14 201� �� I�rdp�i�{Iuca�or�C�`Ot)P�cctr�ic t3ay I3a�iewa�l. � ��e e ��''�,,�������"�"� �'�� Z(7NING BOARD UF APPEALS 8� F'!�amandcd�Q-17-Q5�to sha�dF�ka��fram Q.,''� }aafd krr buikftiead�ard�Ia trt�ss�z�ctkm af �j 4�'� �° f-ar# v°i�!�dC'Ekn3 OFbi111;�reacl belnq rCpi�ed In'pl�ce; ,t�P �£�� �..�. $'R�7i.�1�1 fQ t3�'. �p rro Eh�s�.�a praJ�t+�n r��e ,(.�i ��,' �2.�� . ;� 1M�H�+'�1'�1�( 'k�R? G Q�'�� ��� � �rn * � —e• — +3' z 9' �C�?WpLK fQ C� �X,.f�}AT�A�t' . • �M4'�t7 � ..� �� ra r�r��.a�n � � ` : � . .• , `t-,:�. ��,.I�`�fa7' ��11(�hl5 CJ� � ; `' �� I,fMIT fJ��A�CI t� 17MG��(31:�,.K#�f�p t`CtC�'i�MC»t7 �'. ''•.;. . � p�t7G�I7 ft��►� &��l�p YV1TN 8� V1I�1-���,#.KI�NG� � ';;i,, '• : .� g�l�i f�-'�'/AI.IN � . 4,�'tC�2 t�PJJI�V�l1�p N�l8 MG�� �` l c_+•,r� ;� / � � ! J ' ,�'' � �+ �` •'� � 9'� ��.� I��Y.�4N�tY T4 i���& : � t .f-�.�� ',� �� ��l.I�C�d7 WI�}� 3' -�'1+�/l9.:KW�Y ` . ;� �i�.l,tQ N�i�.f�1�.K,1�?+�k�"NIc��J•, 'I :��.� a ��PII:�t711'.) , �`�'�, �,► � �o, ' . `r t `�"��� c,.� .,,'�2'� `.:. .PI�C�C��� 4� �. . ��wi�r� ' �" r�r������ �,.��,, �. v���n�v�n � �� �' ����a w�.xw,�� �� . ; ��� t-�,a7 • � �"� ��.d1' &1�''���t� *' ' ' � =a� ����:K�����T� � �I�t'i���1N13'N:�'il�i1�L�41.Kk�Ap � 3� �: '� � I �_�.� � l��"t�'�'`�,AhIF�Wf�6?�JC�18"Wt�� Q .•�:�' '� ,r, �X.:It�'X I CJl1CK.1'C�C� �. � �t`.� �•. . , �'' � �,.r� 1�11'�t�dl�ND k�Wf.f�T� , Vt�11��° 19'`��`i1QI�t 0� 'l� , �:�C.�E3'��Tl�t,�11���K�1�1�d �. . . �� f�12�hfi(31�17�hlp�C�<I1J-I'LAG�) s� �• . i� , �-i.e� -.Y kVf11�i 1flNYl.I�:K#�i�9(�il5�f�18"#�pfk�PJ � E-t.r� , �13 . � ' �U ��'fi�i�`�� • M. � a � . ���'�`�AMS �} ,R—. � °�` �Nt:} ,�....._.• t� s :��� ���# a������ � . . � !�'� � Q � . : .. ' � i�4��5�n����ll�����I��� �� ����������T�, -��C. � �.��u� ���������s�►�� i`��� #����N ��� ��� C�Y��. pD�K,.��1.���`�; ����` ��3� ����- Y 1 9- :�����.���It+l�.l�+Y� �,l�����i.� �. �I , 1� 1 �$ ��'�A�(NA�AGII�l�1''�N ��.�C��� �3�-���-$��Q L�:�l,, �..1��C�.f� �0(�N1�, N1� IZ-I�-t�� 5��`l Q'� �rx���Q�,zr i�1�,�1��t�,io�ta.�v� ' � �!1�Y.8.�'E C " , ���:P�t�'�'�RI1� �Nd �. � S��iF , '��AIT _�b ��,�G�b�},� �A't'� . .. �c-na� �pU p�o�os�r� �;��w�n ���������c�r� ����� a� � t� �l�-�Ap � 1��1.KWAY; p�MOVaI,. 0� p(�K, f�Jl� p�Q1'C)�p b{�nCl� Cp l.� `.��-� :�" " ��� C2ECEIVEG 4A�FLKWAY TO I?t?CK'�(J t�t�MCN�CJ r..^'--�'------*-� �IX�IT nOCK�Q(��Ig,&���w�m��wr��w��r MAR Y � 201G w�.����ro r��r�ov�r�,��.�r�.���r�5�� � �, .`,�„ ZONING BGARU UF APPEALS �rn�rn s c;23 r�o�n sra��ro w��w�r �A��a��iu.�a�sn��""�' � a�r x��� s�� ���'— E, _. ��� ��p �2) 6"x b."1NAL�S ��. � ,..�,,� , ,� �.. .: ,� ,�,�Xi2 ._^_.�.. � �„6�� t'��� � , I�ftiYLfJG 1�(?���X, . � �.W- `�� _?Z�� f�f�.YJ�hi� . . $''��f�'IMRt�I p�f;�'QS�p fK'�- �3'l�W E �X,f3U<KF�l��4 C�k�#1viGGV�t7 r� A�tBA�t�G�i�p�p �C�Mt�X.1�P'tf-1<C�'��'I°�:V� {i"��f���y'�.fp�J���}yC�J�J�mfi*l11�.k��ml,l.y,K��n�2g' � '����� ��, �� ,a�#'�£)X,��CY�'�:> Y�y/�''I�,V{V,�"►.YFY\K Vi '/Y�I/�U4��tM'Yf� • �M G� �l�l/afV�����1�+1�,{.�� �ii X�FJ� V�iYi�*Nc.��L�l . 10�� R 20'PIL�� ���o� �� ���pa�n p�r�������o� r��,r�� �-r�►� � ao��r�� �X,W�WAIrK1NA1''(Q f�K�EMCJV�17 r.•�----9'--•, �C,W�4p��II�1'P�f013�K��,�D 22' �---�� �"i7�f.K1NC� CfJr�j ��4,11 X(L�� LM�f� :J AtJtAI� �Jt�/11 ' F'(IYK y 4� f!L.y'aI� C)',_Gl" 2�r �,.f3",�{ll'S ��4.i31:�.,YrI�Al7�C1(3E.k�MOV�E7 14" t'IL�S ''� l��f'f,�5�n Ylf�ti�.�Ai�2'_ , . � LAlVE?VYR�G�A�Jt�f8"i�C�C� �"–�-� . .. . ..... TI�fP1�1�YJS�fhIG�4.I-K}�f�"1 �'�'j ���� ������.���� ��.... ��'�������T���� ��� ���{�'�������'��� ������ ��.��1?. nDGK,V��+L�W�Y����A� 1�19 �t�R'�� ������� �Mp �4�J?,��5 �Il��'� �.1�A�.��L�K ����T�,�i��"�'��I, I��' 1 �9�� �t 1�CI�A�A�11.11'Y QN'�����G�K, :-��h��3�c��6� �.��., ���Q�� ��UP��, �l� I��I���� ���� ����o�c�.���rfo�.�:��o�..�ar��f c�� ` �YSDE� ' ai�'�b A81�R TE,RMB� ���'n aNCl:�4NDiTldM8 ) !' `� ?�#�Ilil17' , � '� �� /�V�d� �tECEIVED DA'fk� MAR � 4� 2p16 ��`�kQN �'N�.! ��OpQ�C� ��I�/��h�h��"C ANp �SI�lPJ�) C��' I�J�KN�'A� Sc WAI.KW�1Y; �I� I��O�O�� ���iI�NG �(7NING BOARD OF APF�E/aL5 5�}V.� tl�� � �Q' Wp1.KWRY1'4t��Ml1b�p.I�PI.P�p,&�WW;�n 5�� --r-� a}� F+— � �----�---,-�- +l�t�' (mm,l--� AF�R D�f3ACKt=ILLI PI�fV� q�� X 6" S.iC;N�� � r-�----15 —�---+ 2� C{�' � ��- 18" C 2) 6"z b"1�VPI.ES ��,� ,��R,��q� fWW�.T,6„ I.AYLOLrt � �P Of`�X, /�V1!+' �'�('�n C3l;�Kf�AD � "--��T...� -�2�� �"�I?�;�MRN ROpOS�Fili�E��'P4YV _-__..1 ..._.—.----- �Q' - -- ,�A�'CJ[�ti�i�t� �-1 II' {�N, "�. �'�7 IvlfVf,C�k�hf f1�`-3'PLW �6���I'(7�f5 f'�fi,�f'4.`�n VI�JYL�An I�J 9"x fb' VlPM.�A1'NING PtA�t��Xl�l�1T�tZ Dl.�. 10" �2�7'PIl.�S ���������f��������� �-�1.l�i� �pL.A��1���1"Q���1�111��r ������1����,�A€��5, I�#�G, t����?, i?�C�. t��.KW�t�, ��C?�f° ���� �����I �� �t?�D I�'�' ��Ji�1�� Mt��AY� �U�.� �� �������I����, N'� � 1�b� �t N4�+����f'�11�1'f'F C11�1 �1�1�N����, l�l�l�l,., ���1.���I�N�'Y,°IJY ��-��� �3 i-2$��b.�:b� ��'��c� �E �o�c�s ���t c��,�t��c�,�Fxro� d.5a��;�,r��0� 10:�� �� �siaaao2�� r�3t���c - s� �hRQ:� �r�w ��rk �t�te flepartm�nt �rf En�ir�anr��r���il �a�servat�c�n ����-��.����c�. ��Qfit�f �RC��►K. ��r ����o-a��s Nfarin�H��a1t��hate+:ticn ��( � � Rtaor�s: C�"1`} 4d4�C���� I�A►X: f63'f J 444-4293 "� �ECErven ��r,��.;�iif��r Catn�a�bssi��tor �i�C�IC�M�i�T�`t� PERN� MAR 14 201G 20NING BOARp pp pppEq� 5i'1t�U��s J�m�M.r�rray���u�an 9�gut` f�e: P�i"r1�it# �-+��88-�OQ�i4Z/00.QQ3 Pu�,t�!�t�J�� Laure�, NY �1948 �ar P�r�l�ittvw�; '��ur�re�.raq+��st tc xnvs�it�r#h�.ab�ve p�t tt�s be��:r+a��e�r►r�d��rsus�t't+���Y���; �r�t�2�. �t h3�r I�i1"t�i�Ti rlut.6xE1 li'fdt 11'�Fs.�tv�758�f1���ia��c�l��i�s i�lilt il�+t�uf�i�1`i�iALI�F�I]��r'�+��e t17+�s���Io'x�wt�"t� �ahti��d ac�i��ae#he exP�i�ig permifi c^uati.di��t►��. T�t�t'efo�ei, ft���er�ii#t���rlt�nd�d to �i�ieri� ���r�i�n��th��c�a�ram�r la�t�d a�����orth�nd of tt��prc�j��t�ite�'�r�the�rmitted 8 t� ?'E�'�1�rit��- 7#�i�f�t��er is an amendme�t to tr�e or��inai p�rmit a�d, as��u�k�, shall be availabte a�t#he jab sif� viri�e�i��st'�ti�c�ria�d vvork is in pr'�gteaa. Aii���.�r.t�t�ars aa���a��3,€i�,�s��e��3�i�� a�v�rri����u�t�1��or��i���l}��rt�nr*. 1f��r it�.�y¢ur,�, -.. �-�v��.-i��'--�-���-�'•�__. �hart�ss 7. Hamirtcn i�apu�F��$3or�al Pecmit 1�drnint�tr�ivr �c B�V►WP 0�%E11.�-�2�t)6 xfl t 29 FA,� 69144�Q�97 N3t�9DEC - BMHP ' Oib�f� . M �. � �. ' . r�t � � I� �'�v,�lu1�r�.ma�a�s er�at+rq ero�an ��'.�'G"f Pl�p�fY =r.adroJ 1�ra art�doek�qs faCdl�es ��'. K� a�=C��funr/�.VY j�;. � �Vfep 2t '���r�r k�ki�a.�ats,ra to t�a�#,�t t�►�r �i�S .��� 4 C� ;t ��?. tal�s CCkir'aated APPR,QY$D;A�.S FE1� �� , .; �""�,'. �t hJ 1`op dav�toP��to be c�sad l8". �ND C.OI�'DITP N' t��r�RMS � �' . .`,;, �_�'�'�`�'+��^�;�;+�k ; '�"s:' nr�v�tl'�t�t�sd�►" PB� . � -,.. ,� � . �'�,,•• �.�; . ' '" �0 l�� t �� Pro�:��:� �F'�w bu►khe�d�o b�drdd� �ECErvEr; da�NdE,dud;elsrx�a4from�rjet�p�ruf> � .. �����'i��/�.� �'i � . MAR � � 2016 6�) �F'�appr�,'�5 r�sa�d.op�l.�XR��J c+� �ad t�br.use�.�au�flll.�nd remar,�bark� �,�Q�'�d' ����,���.��� �� �ONING BOARD UF APpEALS �� P�p�tb�{�S�{.� Is(9Q�l�ecar,l�C���au4B�*ard, �0 ��° (-s.� � *dt' �J1i11�J��1���"1`J �,� • � (Jj FLFL9VV TO� ����� •�.�r � Q' � 1� WCM t�'1�7i.�:N C 1 `NI'�ER,� pe�°� '�°� `�� � �- �.... i �' +3' x 9'�1+17Rp Vk��{-K 1f�J 6E �i�.l+L��� �. ��: YVII?�{+���NI 8`�'O I�' ' •. � � 1c�N1C�1l�t? , , .�. E�'d0 f"�dp,-r 8'APJa.�p , , /'�t-,,o�a GXt�N�N'fQ�:N � . '• '. � LIMK O�A�A�O I�C ��I�� a 6?� �CtIG�s CJ� �� '�''�•," � t�E�G�p ro A�u�E. a . � �IIti�C3��^g1LK�A�'Tt7[��� b � � , r t�f�M CJF-��PLW � .�, 8 f�pl.Pt�#�1+V1'CN$'�' ItU�itti���AC� ���; � E-v��h � � «� u�id�1►.rwaw�a�?t��E�r �,� ��,� = ' ,. � r�.u�� �-�,��.. � �� �X��R'������'�'�i�IrvJYr�'$�. ;� � �"t� I � �� ��.�p v�m �����W/d,l�lh►RY � �� �� .f�'1J.�'�t�(ilt�t11=�W?C�1"H+'.�12)�. �I �•� r ��(�F'ILE�� t �� ��� .� 3a, ' •;, 'r�{1 • `���' t-,.� .' :F,�F. , -.. t�L7�t��'j�#' •r� �X�WP�.K t0 • ' r'1.A1'�C�f 8 UZ3�}'X:' �''� DE I�MCIY�n �' ;` ' �I�1�I�VA�ICWJ��' �� . •�'.,�� {-+.►7 / �r+� �7�.:��':�1�`�4'`t1�5�` � �s �If41�t��:�`�'��i3��ML�P �: ,� �,, t� !�� � � ����Hr��e��!f �c��y� � . � Gv ��� � �'����W vt/1�f'�5:u;t�I�I8��}�GC+�vF. ' C+' '• ,ti x��, j , f+n.(Q'X f . 17G►GX��`6�� ��,. �r:; ,�,5 , fr t-�.ati R�Mt�A�i�Pf,�/+L�{� � WtM�' i?' S�C11U1�1 C� p1.K E3�.�`�ff�N�I�11hA�R�U;K�/�f7 Td . . . ;Bk P�``�1'�?�(?,�lE�'t�'l-�n C���-#�LN�) � �~ ' i� t-�.� .Y iM`!1�WI�191�"IrI��t7'(�'N`.�b l�i HGl�C�'f�) -t�' � t-t.ag : � � •�� � i �ti ; , .J � � . — o � � p� �y o -� Li'����E��ld-G�y�,�►drsta�ce�fram �y � poha��lllc#ie�d=car��a�d,�f.a�v�a-s�tlai oF �, L, �d.�s d��d I�,��I���p�: � ����D5�1�f����1�1��Ip���1��1�.. ' ' ������� �� f'9��1A�:'}'�'l-O6�a w�dsa bao�.rat+p�e��nc1 re�rrt ��ry���//�{�yJ�/� y�y/'��{�./.�r'�������.�+� Y�3V•1��1 V V�li� 1������4.�Y�r.�� �I�-��I��U�i�h�f�,�N�. �1�' �C�.1�5 MI.�'Y& �.l��� , ��3]� l��3�t� ��R�I� ��m�►���i�,an����r���; � _ S�U'�l�MP���, f������8 ���., ��a.�co�a►� � I�3���$3"b3�� `��-�� Q� � It 2U/4�.�F�rl C�f 4�r G!C�. ►�t��r Q�,E�r�� r�:���,�c� � ���������� 1A.c�o F�t e3�4��oz�� �x�n�� - �� �[o�� ��s �B.� . C��t�� . A�FR4V'P�D A�.�ER TE'RM5 �ECEIVED AND CaNDI'�I4�f� �� r�ltHti� rtr�.p���,..,.�r���,/''o.ra� MAR 14 2016 � � � � ��� ZUNING 80/1RD UF qpp�q� S�G�ION�I�U p��'Q5�l� LAN1�1h/A�.,p�I'��M�N'I"C ai'�In ��ii�G) C� I�f:�.��� & UV�I,KWAY; p�MUVA�,. 0� �lC1CK: l�h1C��'�U�'�5�n��n�ING w�.�w�v ta nc�K�`a v�r�Mt�v �f�%�;1" - IO' ,-�--9'-----•�, fl��t70CK�'0�!:k'��G$l�f�.f��C�WMt1�t'V�+/"I.KWf�Y r---IO'—�= W?+I.KWAYtdD��N�1t�f�,��:��,��vs�n 5�� -•� $� �- I�LA?Pf��vl&.4�)P�f'�Ep�fAl�,`+'fD•�!VAl.KWAY �EA QF f�f+�kt'll:Lf'pl�At�IL�-'�' �� ,� X� STI�1+�� � I�i' ,,.t�i'! � tg" �P!' t 2} 6"�x d"1NPl.� � �..,---;,r �� �1�Q�4���'� . : .. .... -- � 2,rb� '�" � R11M/'� r1k�/11t �,�� r���x �.�Ui� lJ k/ r3u6.KNEP1? � " �� ��� �� .�`� __... ..� 8"�E7�PI��1�1 . l�J� �� -'��lV; � �,"G�ILKf�N�TU!�I�MG�D ''� A�At�1 p�nG�l� ��ro�v�►�.i���� i -�i����'`'~�--., Ta���,w o�-��x.w l�N�l�f?CJF P+�18'"ffit�K <;__ d"Al�l'OI�fS PV'f'�0}G��C.�5P'C11.� �k1P�J�t1�1'IN�0(,Ll�f�tV7 g" �16' VINri�R'[�NG ����X��r pN.�.'S �G�1�N �I:I ��Qp(���p �PI.t1C�l��N1'C� �l�.i��p��.N � I�QA�"� �c,wr��g��I��ro �K�Wl'1fJp�4At 1�'1'fI C�1�5L�AL�� 2'" p�GPJN� �« �.�.� .. �,,,�" f��' �r' r- .ti. T-�.. �n�,12" Gl�i�'S � � .I A � � � tY �. ; . ;t' AI, ,� ,, .�� _ E . ; �, 2" x 8" JQISrs ___------r � ;�� ; �f� � � ' �i , lQa ,, � ; 1� � . } � � " � � �' ' ����i���.�+'.�.�� 'r j ' � � �� ' , � '�����-��J � i , i, � i E � '� , . ' . I p�2CJP11��1 VINYI.RLlI.Kh�N7 2' � , ' • , �, I.AAI�WP.�J 0�AtJC►1@'�N(l�-� �. '"��, ""'_'_'fi g ""� 1Ni�i�XXf5511NG I�l-KI�I'� tc�TLI�N ' :�l�D�tUf�+d�X'I�NSKJN }���b������������� • ���Lt��W���i���, �.���.����� ���� �l�.K��, I�QGK.IN�KV�A�, �[��lfi , ��'�� ����� �i����I� �Ah�'' �Q�JAIV1��MI:�Y��I�+I�E%� ����1�1��E��� ��1 Qt�:� A�"1V�I1�1A��l�G1�11Y C�?�f���-C1��K+. �31��3�d�6� ���., gU���:��4u�`, C� 51'��1�2 D�� V�01'05��f f?�C15;9/d/0$, � � �nii���� t�/i��nti �r��� �t3/fl�.i��q��° 1�,3U 1�AX 6314940Y9? 1`+iYBDE� — $3►�IP �I9.D4 r � h � � i � ��� ,�PRflF��i A��:1�TB�MS . ��(,l �.P Al+�}�Q�I.T�Q i�� � p$� �, .. C2ECEIVEG 1?A7'S % MAR Y 4 201� ���IpN�1�.1 p�Qpp�� I�p1��{�N'I'C ANp 1���IN�+? �ONING 80ARD OF APPEALS � ��,1�-�� � �l+��1.�1�f%�Y; �I�1� �'KC'�'���'q���IPJ� � SCNr�:I'� R IC?' WPGKWrA'(1'�7 t�K'�hAf�V�p.R�PE,.PG�d.��l�t�5" . ---�+ �{ �•.— � �—�-- �.I�$`1 m�i)---� . Pt�ACJ�'f�/�GK�1LI-/�15�Pl�JG� ��� ���� y�lW�� -�� ,.r-I�'---�-•�, �" C�!' IS". �Z)8"x�+"1+VN.�S � �X� � �n �t�' tWM��'�G" ....r..d... ��� �� �� �� I.AYIS�G f�� , r� �.�.'_��� ����14G/w'I�IYYV�.,,�, � .r �7���§'�ir��. •.tiJ � ��a.yx i a�Arv r���� � . �f��.\,, �rd t�vc:r�r�n�o���}�.w ��Ui'�q 1�11.C��,nt%1�1 6„ :1,�'I'C�f� 1�L+�QF��11Ntw?IMI�12�1.��7, �g" �16' Vit�l�.�A1}�tJG 1C�" ��C3`PII�3 ��"�.�������� • �������r���� ���������� . ���"�f�i�'��i�Y p�'G�p !��'1�!G� ���,A�-r�' I.�++�Y��'��'I.�M��11`���II�� � F�I�P�. �� �V.�YVV��t�+A�`���' . �i�lkJl���J�lVI���ll.J�A�� ��I�� .A�t`M�'J�rl��1'��•I'�`Pw�.1��GI��K: � ��i<, �l�f'��'1L�'C�L�I��C't', NY ��-��� ` � 5l����3 i�r�,��,�t�r�.���.:�n �i��c� . , 12ECEIVEC p n�� �p�,� MAR Y � 201� �. ZqNING BUARD qF qpp�qVc ST�t� ot� N�vv Yc�RK QEPARTt�I�t�T OF $TATE �4 I STA7E S`f'R��T A�.BA�'�, NY i�23 I yU�C3 I c3.�t�.�ta� E. P,�ra�ti R�.�a�A. D�t+i��.s �KCRNOR $E6RETARY+DF S3'FTIC April 18,20Q5 �.�tfly�..:�I��e �rr-�ians�l�its,.I`nc. 13191'�oz�h�a�t.oad Sauthamptan,NY 1`I�b8 Re; �-2t30�-410.6 U,�.A;r�iy C�r,ps qf Eng�r�ers/��ew�€''t�rk Di�st�ist�'�rmit A�iic�tion-r�m�s Murray&�usan Segut•Remow��r�p�ae� (in place)apgraximai�el� I6U 1#'nf sxist�rtg bulkhead;r�ise.18� highe�r thann�xistrng;r�movs&.r�pi�aee�'m.kind�inpla�cej e�cisting S`��rbaat ramp;r�znr�ve&replaa���d raise 1�3° high�r}dred�e�ppro�itnat.�l.�30Q cubic ya,rds $rusla�s�rs�k,Tav�n of�qut�old, $u�f`oll�C'c>u�ty General.��ncz�rr.euce T3e�t�Ir,.�t,�e; 'I'h�L'�ep�rtmet�t of�ate reeeived}roux Tcdcral Cat�si�t�ncy A.s.sessz�e�t Fornn aa�d,ccmaist��ey aert���at�s�n�s1 s;uppS�i�3g,itt�`c��'tY�Lio��pr this p�q��sal o�Februaty 7,�.�p�. T�ie I��'tm��t af�t�te h�s d�t�r�iir�e�tii�t this g�opQsal tn�ets the Degartmen'�'s g8neral consistezrcy aoncurreat�e criteria.Th�refore, �tu�t�rer rcwiew af the propostd sa�ivity by the�Departx��ent:ttf State,an�i t�ie '27�pac���'s eoncux�rence vvit�,an indivict�al�coansister�cy cer�fica�tion,$re tt+ot ter��tiY�d. �l�en�c�unicating witt�us r,egardin,g tt��'�ttcr,please contact us at{518)4"7�}-600D and refer to aur�le #�-�t�C�3-t►lUfi. � ceraly, ��.� � �.� �vett�.Resier I���uty Burea�t Ckiie#' I7ivisinn of Caresfa}Resources sr� t>c: �Q��v`�orlc D�stn�t-1�Iivl'i��l Vissx�helli I�tlx�'L�E�Regi�on-Jahn Fav�.cia w�vw.00,s.srwn.rt�r.ua • E-M�uL: ir�Po(p�ocs.srx�.�rr.us- �envcuto►art� � ,y��,,,�•;.-, . . � , -` � .� _� -_ � ;3 ��� �� ����,��� �.'�� �� , , _. . _ _ O�R STREET �'� VILLAGE `DIST. SUB. LOT � Y ✓ l�• �t�<������.1.C.�� � / � �/. � :� �' . ' - - - - � QWNER ... � . . N � . ACR. � tf � � __ , �� S W TYPE OF BUILDING 'a . �1 �S a - �w ��� F�l � ri % ;� i✓ RES. �f� SEAS. VL �,� ` FARM COMM_ CB. MISC. Mkt. V�lue ► AND 1MP. TOTA� DATE REMARKS , , �-d�(j � C� U� `.!t �,!��.3 � � � a Q w � � � a � �` � - -. . . 7 // �-� I - � .�'�r�:� _ j` .�► � � m a a � � � t� �'1 �-e� .c,� ,L,�c �'s�a-�� � � rr �� - Liz�78 ��- �. .� . AGE N BUILDING CONDITION PIEW NORMAL BELOW ABOVE FARM Acre Volue Per Value Acre '..�• �b1e 1 ��i nable 2 Ti Ilable 3 Woodtond Swar�bnd FRONTAGE ON WATER Brushlarid FRONTAGE ON ROAD House Plot DEPTH BUL.KHEAD �otol • DOCK �� � � {�ECENEa MAR 14 2016 ZONING BOARp pF ppNEp� EXHIBIT 5 � `� `ti� P�ECEIVEG MAR 1 � 2p1� AGRICULTURAL DATA STATEMENT ZONING BOARU OF qpp�pL� ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD WHEN TO USE THIS FORM: This form must be completed by the applicant for any special use permit, site plan approval,use variance,area variance or subdivision approval on property within an agricultural district OR within S00 feet of a farm operation located in an agricultural districG All applications reqairing an agricultural data statement must be referred to the Sufjolk County Department of Planning in accordance with Section 239m and 239n of the General Municipa!Law. ^ 1. Name of Applicant: � r�.� 2. Address of Applicant: V?r 1.�} V ^ 1 L � 3. Name of Land Owner(if other than Applicant):T-F"-,1A�1'M� 4. Address of Land Owner: �aV r 5. Description of Pro osed Project(Zr v��RS`4L b� (�('LST�R�T�►U DN �'!W-R GWJ/4 �`c� o � r 6. Location of Property: (road and Tax map number) 1 Q Ot� C R(��4r P(�LbW 1� �°Y4� �L�D. . 1 t7OU �I'�-f 5� ' ��,3 7. Is the parcel within 500 feet of a farm operation? { } Yes Q�No 8. Is this parcel actively farmed? { } Yes �No 9. Name and addresses of any owner(s)of 1 n within the agricultural district containing active farm operations. Suffolk County Tax Lot numbers will be provided to you by the Zoning Board Staff,it is your responsibility to obtain the current names and mailing addresses from the Town Assessor's Office (765-1937)or from the Real Property Tax Office located in Riverhead. NAME and ADDRESS 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. (Please use the back of this page if there are additional property owners) � ✓l.J-' �/ Y �-F /� Signature of A p Date t Note: 1.The local Board will solicit comments from the owners of►and identified above in order to consider the effect of the proposed action on their farm operation. Solicitations will be made by supplying a copy of this statement. 2.Comments returned to the local Board wili be taken into consideration as part as the overall review of this application. 3.Copies of the completed Agricultural Data Statement shall be sent by applicant to the property owners identified above. The cost for mailing shall be paid by the Applicant at the time the application is submitted for review. ���� � FtECEIVEG MAR Y 4 201� ZONING BOARD OF qppEq� EXHIBIT 6 � 10��� t2ECEIVEt' MAR � � Zp16 ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Board of Zoning Appeals Application AUTHORIZATION (Where the Applicant is not the Owner) I,��Q-I� � �. � 1=L� 1 residing at U T r I,J ��=- 'rl�-�i� �i(��� (Print property owner's name) (Mailing Address) . . ��j � �E�'C-hY�KE�--�'�� R8 5 S � f�o SN�r/L do hereby authorize (�� '- �AN1��L G �D SS '� (Agent) ���NC- 1�1�P 1 0�t�'-QmX� Q�v���S�-°F to apply for��arta�ee�-s)on my behalf from the Southold Zoning Board of Appeals. c�! (Owne ' Si a e) �(��►�I�- � � 1�t��.�Y (Print Owner's Name) �iECEJVEC r n� / ���l �� ' MAR � 4 �016 ZONING BOARD OF APpEAL� APPLICANT/OWNER TRANSACTIONAL DISCLOSURE FORM The Town of Sout6old's Code of Ethics orohibits conflicts oi interest on the aart of town of'ficers and emulovees.The ouroose of this form is to orovide information which can alert the town of oossible confiicts of interest and allow it to take whatever action is necessarv to avoid same. YOUR NAME :��I�W� �- �i�'�'�-Y (Last nsme,first name,middle iniNal,unless you are applying in the name ot someone else or other entity,such as a company.If so,indicate the ot6er person's or company's name.) TYPE OF APPLICATION:(Check all that apply) Tax grievance Building Permit Variance Trustee Permit Change of Zone Coastal Erosion Approval of Plat n /�. Mooring Other(activity) ��„ � Z r�►1 Planning Do you personally(or through your company,spouse,sibling,parent,or child)have a relationship with any officer or employee of the Town of Southold?"Relationship"includes by blood,marriage,or business interest."Business interest"means a business,including a partnership,in which the town officer or employee has even a partial ownership of(or employment by)a corporation in which the town ofticer or employee owns more than 5%of the shares. YES NO If you answered"YES",complete the balance o this form and date and sign where indicated. Name of person employed by the Town of Southold Title or position of that person Describe the relationship between yourself(the applicant/agentlrepresentative)and the town ofticer or employee. Either check t6e appropriate line A)through D)and/or describe in the space provided. The town omcer or employee or his or her spouse,sibling,parent,or child is(check all that apply): A)t6e owner of greater that 5%of the shares of the corporate stock of the applicant(when the applicant is a corporation) B)the legal or benercial owner of any interest in a non-corporate entity(when the applicant is not a corporation) C)an officer,director,partner,or employee of the applicant;or D)the actual applicant DESCRIPTION OF RELATIONSHIP Submitted th'�day o�,20�Q Signature U ""'" PrintName_�'`w� � �— F�I"'�L� ���� RECEIVE[7 MAR 1 � 2016 20NING BC�ARD OF APPEAIS EXHIBIT 7 RECEIVE� ��'�� � MAR 14 2016 AGENT/REPRESENTATIVE ZONING gONRn uF qpp�AL� TRANSACTIONAL DISCLOSURE FORM The Town of Southoid's Code of Ethics orohibits conflicts of interest on the asrt of town omcers and emalovees.The nuroose of this form is to arovide information which can alert the town of oossible conflicts of interest and allow it to take whatever action is necessarv to avoid same. YOUR NAME : �Y'�-w��� C- �OS� {�ee.�yoy.�� �j�cw. � �-C� (Last name,fust name,middle initial,unless you re applying in the ame f someone else or other entity,such as a company.It so,indicate t6e other person's or company's name.) TYPE OF APPLICATION:(Check all that apply) Tax grievance Building Permit Variance Trustee Permit Change of Zone Coastal Erosion Approval of Plat Mooring Other(activity) � Z�� Planning Do you personally(or through your company,spouse,sibling,parent,or child)have a relationship with any officer or employee of the Town of Southold?"Relationship"includes by blood,marriage,or business interest."Business interest"means a business,including a partnership,in which the town officer or employee has even a partial ownership of(or employment by)a corporation in which the town officer or employee owns more than 5%of the shares. � YES NO If you answered"YES",complete the balance of this form and date and sign where indicated. Name of person employed by the Town of Southold Title or position of that person Describe the relationship between yourself(the applicant/agent/representative)and the town ofticer or employee. Eit6er check the appropriate line A)through D)and/or describe in the space provided. T6e town omcer or employee or his or her spouse,sibling,parent,or child is(check all that apply): A)the owner of greater that 5%of the shares of the corporate stock of the applicant(when the appticant is a wrporation) B)the legal or beneficial owner of any interest in a non-corporate entity(when the applicant is not a corporation) C)an officer,director,partner,or employee of the applicant;or D)the actual applicant DESCRIPTION OF RELATIONSHIP Submitted this��day of ,20 ��D Signature Print Name��w-�r�- �� ���� � (��� � 6tECEIVEG MAR 1 � 2016 ZONING BOARD C�F qpp�q�� EXHIB IT 8 • �ECEJVEC:� 617.20 MAR 1 � 2016���b Appendix B Short Environmental Assessment Form zONING BOARU OF APP�A� InstrucNons for Comnletin� Part 1-Project Information. The appticant or project sponsor is responsible for the completion of Part 1. Responses become part of the application for approval or funding,are subject to public review,and may be subject to further verification. Complete Part 1 based on information currently available. If additional research or invesrigation would be needed to fully respond to any item,please answer as thoroughly as possible based on current information. Complete all items in Part 1. You may also provide any addirional informarion which you believe will be needed by or useful to the lead agency;attach additional pages as necessary to supplement any item. Part 1-Project and Sponsor InformaHon Name of Action or Project: +�V��S��l, O CLKri'�C�W d � S�' 'LL � O T � �or oR �x �a� vn�.,�z,� �ucb pR� �� �• �3$�sa ��1 t��� �b Project Location(describe,and attach a location map): � �t , �� �.�r �v�. L.r�u ,�t�� rv�'. I��►�t s ,�i �3 Brief Description of Proposed Action: ��v f�,r+c. 6� (��S�n.�rvw i� a�s��s ao ��oT c�tz �t�s �� ��(�w� �ss�.r� 4R� - �� �• � "� 8���. �.� �/ti�rb Name of Applicant or Sponsor: Telephone: ��I'FY`��, � ,2�LL E-Mail: Address: 6�Yv��W �4v�. f�—�s� �s��n rv�' 1 ��73� City/PO: State: Zip Code: _�� �St .`�_ l �'7 a 1.Does the proposed acrion only involve the legislative adoption of a plan,local law,ordinance, NO YES administrarive rule,or regulation7 If Yes,attach a narrative description of the intent of the proposed action and the environmental resources that may be affected in the municipality and proceed to Part 2. If no,continue to question 2. 2. Does the proposed action require a permit,approval or funding from any other governmentai Agency? NO YES If Yes,list agency(s)name and pernvt or approval: / 3.a.Total acreage of the site of the proposed action? � acres b.Total acreage to be physically disturbed? b acres c.Totai acreage(pmject site and any contiguous properties)owned or controlled by the applicant or project sponsor7 p l� acres 4. Check all land uses that occur on,adjoining and near the proposed action. ❑Urban ❑Rural(non-agriculture) ❑Industrial ❑Commercial �sidential(su��bu,/r�ban) .r� ❑Forest ❑Agriculture ❑Aquatic ❑Other(specify): ►M- � �►l��fi� 17' ❑Parkland Page 1 of 4 FZECEIVEG 5. Is the proposed action, 20�� NO YES N/A a.A permitted use under the zoning regulations7 � �f Lj ZONING BpqRD UF pPP�'qLr�6 b.Consistent with the adopted comprehensive plan? 6. Is the proposed action consistent with the predominant character of the existing built or natural N YES landscape? 7. Is the site of the proposed action located in, r es it adjoin,a state listed Criti al Environmental Area? NO YES If Yes,identify: L � GL fi�i �� 8. a.Will the proposed acrion result in a substantial increase in traffic above present levels? NO YES b.Are public transportation service(s)available at or near the site of the proposed action? c.Are any pedestrian accommodations or bicycle routes available on or near site of the proposed action? 9.Does the proposed action meet or exceed the state energy code requirements? O YES If the proposed action will exceed requirements,describe design features and technologies:���Ow/� 10. Will the proposed action connect to an existing public/private water supply? NO YES If No,describe method for providing potable water: � 11.Will the proposed acrion connect to existing wastewater utilities? NO YES If No,describe method for providing wastewater treatment: � 12. a.Does the site contain a structure that is listed on either the State or National Register of Historic NO YES Places? b.Is the proposed action located in an archeological sensitive area? 13.a.Does any portion of the site of the proposed action,or lands adjoining the proposed action,contain O YES wetlands or other waterbodies regulated by a federal,state or local agency? b.Would the proposed action physically alter,or encroach into,any existing wetland or waterbody? If Yes,identify the wetland or waterbody and extent of alterations in square feet or acres: 14. Identify the typical habitat types that occur on,or are likely to be found on the project site. Check all that apply: ❑Shoreline �Forest ❑AgriculturaUgrasslands ❑Early mid-successional ❑ Wetland ❑Urban ❑ Suburban 15.Does the site of the proposed acrion contain any species of animal,or associated habitats,listed NO YES by the State or Federal government as threatened or endangered? � 16.Is the project site located in the 100 year flood plain? NO YES l/t.(N 1�Ot�YU 17.Will the proposed action create storm water discharge,either from point or non-point sources? NO YES If Yes, a.Will storm water discharges flow to adjacent properties? ❑NO 0 YES b.Will storm water discharges be directed to established conveyance systems(runoff and storm drains)? If Yes,briefly describe: ❑NO❑YES Page 2 of 4 18.Does the proposed action include construction or other activities that result i dment of NO YES water or other liquids(e.g.retention pond,waste lagoon,dam)? �AR Z 4 2016 � �,t,��p If Yes,explain purpose and size: � � ZONING BOARD UF APPEA�S 19.Has the site of the proposed action or an adjoining property been the location of an active or closed NO YES solid waste management facility? If Yes,describe: � 20.Has the site of the proposed action or an adjoining property been the subject of remediation(ongoing or NO YES completed)for hazardous waste? If Yes,describe: � I AFFIRM THAT THE INFORMATION PROVIDED ABOVE IS TRUE AND ACCURATE O THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE ApplicanUsp sor name: ��'(� 1 1 "� � — �"1= i'�`� Date: / (� � Signature: � Part 2-Impact Assessment. The Lead Agency is responsible for the completion of Part 2. Answer all of the following questions in Part 2 using the information contained in Part 1 and other materials submitted by the project sponsor or otherwise available to the reviewer. When answering the questions the reviewer should be guided by the concept"Have my responses been reasonable considering the scale and context of the proposed action?" No,or Moderate small to large impact impact may may occur occur 1. Will the proposed action create a material conflict with an adopted land use plan or zoning regulations? 2. Will the proposed action result in a change in the use or intensity of use of land? 3. Will the proposed action impair the character or quality of the existing community? 4. Will the proposed action have an impact on the environmental characteristics that caused the establishment of a Critical Environmental Area(CEA)? 5. Will the proposed action result in an adverse change in the existing level of traffic or affect existing infrastructure for mass transit,biking or walkway? 6. Will the proposed action cause an increase in the use of energy and it fails to incorporate reasonably available ener conservation or renewable ener op ortunities? 7. Will the proposed action impact existing: a.public/private water supplies? b.public/private wastewater treatment utilities? 8. Will the proposed action impair the character or quality of important historic,archaeological, architectural or aesthetic resources? 9. Will the pmposed action result in an adverse change to natural resources(e.g.,wetlands, waterbodies,groundwater,air quality,flora and fauna)? Page 3 of 4 . F�.E`:y]VE:L- No,or Moderate MAR � 4 201��0��� small to large impact impact 70NING BOARD OF APPEALS may may occur occur 10. Will the proposed action result in an increase in the potential for erosion,flooding or drainage problems? 11. Will the proposed action create a hazard to environmental resources or human health? Part 3-Determination of significance. The Lead Agency is responsible for the completion of Part 3. For every question in Part 2 that was answered"moderate to large impact may occur",or if there is a need to explain why a particular element of the proposed action may or will not result in a significant adverse environmental impact,please complete Part 3. Part 3 should,in sufficient detail,identify the impact,including any measures or design elements that have been included by the project sponsor to avoid or reduce impacts. Part 3 should also explain how the lead agency determined that the impact may or will not be significant.Each potential impact should be assessed considering its setting,probability of occurring, duration,ineversibility,geographic scope and magnitude. Also consider the potential for short-term,long-term and cumulative impacts. ❑ Check this box if you have determined,based on the information and analysis above,and any supporting documentation, that the proposed action may result in one or more potentially large or significant adverse impacts and an environmental impact statement is required. ❑ Check this box if you have determined,based on the information and analysis above,and any supporting documentation, that the proposed action will not result in any significant adverse environmental impacts. Name of Lead Agency Date Print or Type Name of Responsible Officer in Lead Agency Title of Responsible Officer Signature of Responsible Officer in Lead Agency Signature of Preparer(if different from Responsible Officer) Page 4 of 4 , ����� FtECEIVED MAR 1 � 2016 ZONING BOARp pF qppEA1.5 EXHIBIT 9 Town of Southold I�ECEIVEC �� � � LWRP CONSISTENCY ASSESSMENT FORM MAR 1 � 2Q16 A. INSTRUCTIONS �UNING BpARD()p q�p�€,��� 1. All applicants for permits* including Town of Southold agencies, shall complete this CCAF for proposed actions that are subject to the Town of Southold Waterfront Consistency Review Law. This assessment is intended to supplement other information used by a Town of Southold agency in making a determination of consistency. *Except minor exempt actions including Building Permits and other ministerial permits not located within the Coastal Erosion Hazard Area. 2. Before answering the questions in Section C, the preparer of this form should review the exempt minor action list, policies and explanations of each policy contained in the Town of Southold Local Waterfront Revitalization Program. A proposed action will be evaluated as to its significant beneficial and adverse effects upon the coastal area(which includes all of Southold Town). 3. If any question in Section C on this form is answered "yes", then the proposed action may affect the achievement of the LWRP policy standards and conditions contained in the consistency review law. Thus, the action should be analyzed in more detail and, if necessary, modified prior to making a determination that it is consistent to the m�imum extent practicable with the LWRP policy standards and conditions. If an action cannot be certified as consistent with the LWRP policy standards and conditions, it shall not be undertaken. A copy of the LWRP is available in the following places: online at the Town of Southold's website (southoldtown.northfork.net), the Board of Trustees Office, the Planning Department, a11 local libraries and the Town Clerk's office. B. DESCRIPTION OF SITE AND PROPOSED ACTION SCTM# �� -��- �' �3 The Application has been submitted to(check appropriate response): Town Board � Planning Dept. 0 Building Dept. � Board of Trustees � 1. Category of Town of Southold agency action(check appropriate response): (a) Action undertaken directly by Town agency(e.g.capital � construction,planning activity,agency regulation, land transaction) � (b) Financial assistance(e.g.grant, loan, subsidy) (c) Permit,approval, license,certification: � Nature and extent of action: �� c���r�.sr �6 �Fn� R�����nJ �r� ��� - C. C�_ �}1�4�Y�- Location of action: ���a �`��1 Q I����� 1��� IJL��.,�i ���F-1- � . Site acreage: + �� � � RECEIVED �A J � Present land use: ��� MAR � 2016 Present zoning classification: �— � zONING BOARD OF APPEALS 2. If an application for the proposed action has been filed with the Town of Southold agency, the following information shall be provided: (a) Name of applicant: �1��� 1�- � � ���� (b) Mailingaddress: �� �j�����-� ! l��I�. _ ���Z �5�� r��`f'. L (� 3� (c) Telephone number:Area Code( ) �� � � �-1 � � �� � �J (d) Application number, ifany:��C, (��, � � v d�a Will the action be directly undertaken,require funding,or approval by a state or federal agency? Yes ❑ N� If yes,which state or federal agency? �1 � �t DEVELOPED COAST POLICY Policy 1. Foster a pattern of development in the Town of Southold that enhances community character, preserves open space, makes efficient use of infrastructure,makes beneficial use of a coastal location,and minimizes adverse effects of development. See LWRP Section III-Policies; Page 2 for evaluation criteria. �Yes � No � Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 2. Protect and preserve historic and archaeological resources of the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III-Policies Pages 3 through 6 for evaluation criteria �Yes 0 No ❑ Not Applicable - I�ECEIVEG . MAR 14 2016 b���0 Attach additional sheets if necessary IUNING BOARU UF ppp�AL� Policy 3. Enhance visual quality and protect scenic resources throughout the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III—Policies Pages 6 through 7 for evaluation criteria � Yes 0 No 0 Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary NATURAL COAST POLICIES Policy 4. Minimize loss of life, structures, and natural resources from flooding and erosion. See LWRP Section III—Policies Pages 8 through 16 for evaluation criteria � Yes � No�Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 5. Protect and improve water quality and supply in the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III —Policies Pages 16 through 21 for evaluation criteria � Yes 0 No �1ot Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 6. Protect and restore the quality and function of the Town of Southold ecosystems including Significant Coastal Fish and Wildlife Habitats and wetlands. See LWRP Section III—Policies; Pages 22 through 32 for evaluation criteria. Q Yes � No�Not Applicable � �Q� � RECETVEG Attach additional sheets if necessary F APPEALS Policy 7. Protect and improve air quality in the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III — Policies Pages 32 through 34 for evaluation criteria. � Yes � No� Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 8. Minimize environmental degradation in Town of Southold from solid waste and hazardous substances and wastes. See LWRP Section III—Policies; Pages 34 through 38 for evaluation criteria. 0 Yes ❑ No�Not Applicable PUBLIC COAST POLICIES Policy 9. Provide for public access to, and recreational use of, coastal waters, public lands, and public resources of the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III—Policies; Pages 38 through 46 for evaluation criteria. � Ye� � No�Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary WORKING COAST POLICIES Policy 10. Protect Southold's water-dependent uses and promote siting of new water-dependent uses in suitable locations. See LWRP Section III—Policies; Pages 47 through 56 for evaluation criteria. 0 Yes ❑ No �Not Applicable ���� ' �ECErvEG APPEALS Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 11. Promote sustainable use of living marine resources in Long Island Sound, the Peconic Estuary and Town waters. See LWRP Section III—Policies; Pages 57 through 62 for evaluation criteria. � Yes ❑ No�..Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 12. Protect agricultural lands in the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III —Policies; Pages 62 through 65 for evaluation criteria. 0 Yes ❑ No�Not Applicable y Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 13. Promote appropriate use and development of energy and mineral resources. See LWRP Section III—Policies; Pages 65 through 68 for evaluation criteria. � Yes ❑ No �Not Applicable Created on 5/25/0511:20 AM ' RECENED ���� MAR � � 2Q16 ZONING BOARD UF qppEq� EXHIBIT 10 ��,�* Town of Southol.. 1/14/2016 � �� � 53095 Main Rd � Southold,New York 11971 ��CEIVEG / �� 1 � �'� MAR i 4 201�` �o , # �'� ZONING F3pq�r,�,� �..__ �►�rtq� PRE EXISTING CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY No: 38052 Date: 1/14/2016 TffiS CERTIFIES that the structure(s) located at: 1900 Great Peconic Bay Blvd, Laurel SCTM#: 473889 SecBlock/Lot: 145.-4-3 Subdivision: Filed Map No. Lot No. conforms substantially to the requirements for a built prior to APRIL 9, 1957 pursuant to wluch CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY NiJMBER� 38052 dated 1/14/2016 was issued and conforms to all the requriements of the applicable provisions of the law. The occupancy for which this certificate is issued is: 11 slip small watercraft marina�maximum length of watercraft 20 feet)and avel parkin�lot, without buildinQ/structures. The certificate is issued to Kelly, Frank Kelly, Elizabeth (OWNER) of the aforesaid building. SUFFOLK COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH APPROVAL ELECTRICAL CERTIFICATE NO. PLUMBERS CERTIFICATION DATED *PLEASE SEE ATTACHED INSPECTION REPORT. orize Signa ure �ECEJVFG ���� MAR 1 � 2016 ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS EXHIBIT 11 � � ` ' � . •' � �; � � � ���� � k�c�rv�a �' � , �wAR 1 � z��s � . ZQNrNG���kU UF APP�q� � f��)'�`�IiYl��3� �.t1�, 1��E� ' ���"� ��'.�. �?'�.t��23;��'!4�`�� t�+ltt�. f7'S��(�f''�, ���sii��.� �� ��c�.;. ������,x ���fi �'��k �e�� fli�:: _ � �Ci1 'S�'�''=�'�:I.I]�`. �iS� ;�IOIl f�(,�"�.�.f� h�.� ;�'�31,11' il�t1Q t�.�:3�'t��"33 c�"11 'G�� '�L� G►'�` 't�l� ���� �'� ���na.$tiix'�s !3ri ��x�; ��'���'��i] k�; 1:�• Jt�l�� �u,�'�.y � ���in�a,� '3�rt�,�Y�.�� ��'s��lc,, �s����l., R7���t "'����. 3�r��� ��� ���tc�r �� .Au�t��� ��'�1�� � �r�v� �r:c�ra�.n�c� �1� �4�i Trui���� ;����sr�a a��� ��Y� '���vn �t��,:�c�� x��x��,s .c�r��. ��.�� �'��"� Q�s� ���► �� �:��'� �zz. �'+Q�FI�i�.4�t i1,E3f'x �V�i' $ �•�'i �'iiJ,#�'.r �i].���7 v��$ I�Q{#�''�:31'� �'+f"� '�.tY�,u��°8 t��?A�l.� V�:�•:3 I;�f3;fR�;�.& f�1,��Y't�'��.C,�il�, f;j,���G7 �l'.J:1�7J7 VVk��� r+��VT'*���6,���'Gn� 41�AW •4��`/5A�(.��� 4Llc�r{I 17�.T�.r14� y'Y��� •FK Y16J'�F�i7��k+� Ci� ��'Y��.�' 2"t�.�'S c��" �Li�'"�8�1�.f3��i�.4�1.. �:�it3 ':►'_�.w�r� ?3�a�d �i�xe n�t a�:�. r� ��)��� 7��it �`o.� �a�.'C� �.M S3�t�t���3�t n�c�s�1� �.� '�s� �,. �.r� �ir�e. � �.�.�r� �.t ;z�.ji<�. �. ����.�*�� av.��" �� x��. ������,v' s �ap�r���,oiti ���v,w d �ho�v�.xi� ��a ��art of op�;��a*�c��� .�� 1��5Y ��.��d r��.��� v� ��vw.��� (�2} �o. .�.� �t�id �c��r�d b�rr��a ���t°� �:� �_�3�� ��. �:��7, i�����a �,��Ltild �����,l�l�,��i � � h�.s �^3.�.t:� '�c� a �r�a,�.���n�'c���:� �� " ��' �,ii 91���x��t b°��.t r�r�;r�rt�a y��.���c�u� �`��t��x .��apr��a�. o�' �h� ����. a�' �p��:�a �.� '�wr� ��s�ei��. �����$ ���c��.���� �ki.� peti'�3.��1 � h�:�r.�. tA�,:k����. '�r� ���►. P�+�r���" ar�� h� ��s a��s�u�:s� �� th�:� xxz�a:��t c��' �hc� ba-��,� �:��d ��a.r��c�� at �h� r��in�x �c� o4.rrrY�.�. �ay �r�i�.r'�� �.'q��6�:BI1'�9 f�a�a �5:��*�Yt Or�l�c�rac�d ����,d i�]� 8�.��r��'� ��fi ��1� t��1.� ��tx� t�rit��� 'G32e �_x�t3=s���'t �t�At�Stiv �3� ?�1.�t�1. ���:d�e,r ��.bct�.�3�.f �.�c� 'l�:� 'r��a��i��, �rx�3.. dne or �t�,� ��°�� �:.�.v� �i��.��1� q�a '�k�� 3��gt�. ���1��'. , � � � � ��� � ltECEIVEG � � ��"�. � MAR � � � 2016 ` LCJNIIVC; f�OAk[� UF HNN�A .I�.$ .�`�.�` �� '�r�7�G' �iC��l�,I1�' �.�.'5�;�,����G*f3 �.C� 4��?T1C�.Q�.^�i1�.'`t� �.�'r I;��#�� �2;1� � �i�'��r�n�� �?�� c3t��� �}�Q l�or��� t�.�� up t��xsi�.�, t3�� �>�.n���N��r ��.�� �e�.� � �t��� �'�.� �'�i3.� �a�x��:�� ��.rlt�� :1.�6�. .�.� �� ����?:+� �':rn������ c�� �`�i� ��4'`�i-�� �i;�� ���'3� 1.1��'`fi�. �p-�"' i�4���I2�� l��s� �.E�,a��k�3�Y9.#�tg w'�t�]38' ����'��' "'�r'2 �1?,� t�,����.�'1� t��` �'i�.�,�� �ri$31�I1-� �3,"C���I�"3`l� �21 ��1''�.�: '.����. �}1�$ S."�"`f$�E,+'i'�..�l�y ��. ��z��'��aa��'���.�i�; u��s� ��h.�,��� �� �� �:���:ri�a.ii���� �;� :�c�i�� r�� �.� �.� ��� �1;�i3��,t�.ir�t�t�, ,��t� � � �t�r�r ��► �.c����,� ����c>c�. . �� .�i�+4✓!� la.'d`,�.13"� ��1x�1�.t3.;'�'• �r:!��'�t f�»�8 f�,j��`�''�L'�1.�1� C��t��.t8':'���' �'i'� .�;,� F�I. �i����e :��: t��a�::t:�1 zt+�t ��� u�f��� �� �ae����r��. o:� �;Iz�.� �e��a�.v'�r���i�� t�q ���.'`+� �fi1�:�0' q�?�3��+�.�'il��� ��.'�i�t "��1� t��,� � �:�'1t�, ���. I�t�,��.t�„�k1�t�s ' �k��.l::'� '��'7:t���'r ���. �dW&�`t�. �.'��"1"� . ���"��al�� �"c���tl �3Ut�,t�.1�1� ��;.�����c�� . � `��, . RECEIVED - -- - - -- -- -- - - - - - - 10/27/2a15 How�d M.Terry Obituary MAR � 4 2016 118�"[L$"�o ZONING BOtiRD OF APPEALS Howard M. Terry Ried: 5unday, Decemb�r 17, 2006 Age: 94 Haw�rd M. Terry, a Southold resident, died at San Simeon Nursing home on December 17. He tived in SouthoLd his entire life, except for a few years in the 19ZOs when he lived in Arizona. M�. Terry was born in Southold on October t3, 1912 to Mary (�ee Mvnsellj and Howard H. Terry. He attended Sauthotd � SCIlOQES� including the 0[d Bayview Schoolhouse, and, over the years, had been a farmer, a truck driver, a carpenter and worked on oyster boats. From 145b until 1977, he was a building inspector for the Town of Southold. Mr. Terry was a member of the First Presbyterian Church ln Southotd, the International Order of Oddfeilows, the Buildtng Inspectors Association of Suffdk County, and served on the Civfl Defense Cummission of New York State. For 76 years, he was an active vo[unteer firefighter with the Sa�thold Fire Department. There he served as a commissioner and delegate to the North Fark, Suffolk County and Southern New York Volunteer Fireman's Association. For a period of time, he was a F1re Coord�nator for the Eighth Division. Predeceased by his wives, doris Jor�es and 1Catherine eerry, he is survived by four daughters, Jane Jcerchel of Catverton, Frances Caoper of Mattituck, Edna Terry of Southotd, and Catherine Terry of Mattituck; a sister, Carolme Rass of Prescott Valley, Aruona; and 10 grandchildren. He was predeceased by two daughters, HeLen Pontino and Elizabekh Montgomery, and a brother, Jonathan Terry. • The family re�eived friends at the DeFriest-Gr�ttan �uneral Homes in Southold where firematic services and IOOF services WeCe held. Futteral services were held at the First Presbyterian chur�h fsy Rev. Dr. Peter J. #Celley, interment was at the PresbyLe�iah Cemetery. Those wishing to remember Mr. Terry and his famify in a specia! way tah make a dvhatioh to the Sa�thold Frre Department, San Simeon Nursing Home nr the F1rst P1'esbyt�rian Church. : � C�� �� RECEIVEC MAR 1 � 2�16 �ONING BOARD OF APPEALS � , - i � . EXHIBIT 12 , , ' V t�� 1 � R�cErveo � �l SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK MAR '� � ZO�6 � COUNTY OF SUFFOLK : PART 50 z�NING� �- 2 --------------------------------------X APP kD pF �qLS � TOWN OF SOUTHOLD , 3 Plaintiff, INDEX NO. 4 15-5142 -against- 5 6 FRANK J. KELLY and ELIZABETH G . KELLY , and JOHN and JANE DOE (S) 1-4 . 7 ' Defendants . 8 --------------------------------------x � September 10 , 2015 9 ' Riverhead, New York lb P R O C E E D I N G S 11 12 B E F O R E : HON . ANDREW G. TARANTINO, JR. SUPREME COURT JUSTICE . �� 13 -_� 14 A P P E A R A N C E S : 15 GARRETT W. SWENSON, JR. For the Plaintiff 16 76 Bay Road Brookhaven, New York 11719 17 18 KEEGAN & KEEGAN, ROSS & ROSNER, LLP For the Defendants 19 315 Westphalia Avenue � Mattituck, New York 11952 20 BY : DANIEL C . ROSS , ESQ . 21 22 ' 23 24 25 JILLIAN CASSAR "��` OFFICIAL SUPREME COURT REPORTER � 2 � PROCEEDINGS r /,��� l�I�� � 1 THE COURT CLERK: Remain seated . RECEYVEC . MAR I � 2p16 2 Come to order . �ONINCi k3UARCi OF APP� 3 We ' re on the record on an 4 application under index number 15142 of 5 2015 ; Town of Southold, plaintiff, against 6 Frank and Elizabeth Kelly, et al . 7 Counsel, please place your 8 appearances on the record. 9 MR. SWENSON : For the plaintiff, 10 Town of Southold, Garrett Swenson; 76 Bay 11 Road, Brookhaven, New York 11719 . 12 Good morning, Your Honor . � 13 THE COURT : Good morning, 14 Mr . Swenson . 15 MR . ROSS : For the defendants , Frank 16 and Elizabeth Kelly; Dan Ross Keegan & 17 Keegan, Ross & Rosner, 315 Westphalia 18 Avenue, Mattituck for the defendants . 19 THE COURT : Good morning, Mr . Ross . 20 You can both be seated . 21 Okay. This case matter came to me 22 yesterday . A show cause order was signed 23 by Justice Martin . 24 On August 27th, the town is alleging --�,. 25 that the defendants , Frank and Elizabeth � � 3 ' PROC�EDINGS ' n�� «�� C2ECE7VEC ,,�.,� 1 Kelly, don ' t have proper approval to use fl�AR1 � 2016 2 the subject property in accordance with ZONING BpqRD pF qpPEA S 3 town codes . 4 We did receive today a courtesy copy 5 of the affidavit in opposition by 6 Mr . Ross ' s office . � The Court did go through it . The g temporary order, signed by Justice Martin, g has certain restrictions on it which were 10 affected pending the return date of the 11 motion and the return date was September 12 lOth, which is today . ��' 13 I take it , Mr . Swenson, you ' re 14 asking to continue the TRO? 15 MR . SWENSON : That ' s correct , � 16 Your Honor, for the same reasons which lead 1� Judge Martin to issue it . Nothing ' s 18 Changed, except that the defendant has 19 removed the recreational vehicles from the 20 property . 21 THE COURT : Mr . Ross . 22 MR. ROSS : We oppose the �3 continuation of the TRO and oppose the 24 application of the town with respect to �'"`' This is a premises that ' s 25 this property . � :ETVEC 4 ' PROCEEDINGS MAR � 4 2016 j ��� b �UNING BOARU UF APPEALS ,-., 1 located in an "M1" zone . The premises are 2 benefitted by a permit issued by the 3 Southold Town Board of Trustees , which is 4 the board with jurisdiction over wetlands 5 and 100 feet inland of wetlands . 6 This property is also benefitted by � a DEC permit . It ' s been operated as a g marina for years . Its changed hands in the g recent past , and now the town has 10 determined to stop it ' s operation . 11 I suggest that the balancing of the 12 equities are not in the town ' s favor . I � 13 suggest that the likelihood of success is 14 questionable when you see the permits that 15 have been issued, and I oppose the very 16 broad scope of the stay and request that it 1� be vacated . 18 THE COURT : All right . The Court 19 has some questions . I ' ll posit the 20 questions , and I ' ll seek a response from 21 the person whom I would like to respond in 22 one second. 23 There is a boat ramp located on the 24 premises ; right? '�` 25 MR . ROSS : Yes , Your Honor . � � 32 �'� �, PROCEEDINGS � �p-1� � RECEIVEU �� 1 pertinent , that would be permissible? MAR I 4 2016 ��' 2 MR . SWENSON : He only has LUNING BOARG C)F APPE L$ � � 3 authorization for up to 14 boats . � £ 4 THE COURT : Oh, okay . But still, ; �, '`` 5 14 . If I lived in a neighborhood -- Look . � r 6 I ' ll let both counsel know on the record I � �, 7 looked at Google Earth, to take a look at a � - -- . � 8 picture of the neighborhood -- even on > r 9 Peconic Bay Boulevard, 14 boats coming in 10 the mornin.g and going out in the afternoon 11 everyday for summer, that ' s a lot of 12 traffic on that little road and we alT� now 13 what that roads looks like . � � -''� 14 MR. SWENSON : Historic use of the 15 � property was that people kept their boats 16 in the slips for the season and drove their 1'7 cars to and fro, but the boat rem_ained in lg the slip . lg ',,� THE COURT : Okay. But historic y . � 20 ' s one thing . 21 MR. SWENSON : Right . 22 THE COURT : Today Mr . Kelly can call 23 up 14 of his friends , not that I ' m telling 24 to you do it , I don ' t want anybody to walk 25 out and say the Court told him to do this . � , , � z � � KECE]'VEG 41 � , PROCEEDINGS MAR � � 201���i (,�� � I� � P 1 T h a n k y o u . �UNrNG g�q�U UF APPEA� f � . 2 MR . SWENSON : Thank you, Judge . 3 (Whereupon, the proceedings 4 concluded . 5 * * * 6 C E R T I F I C A T I O N 7 8 I , JILLIAN CASSAR, an Official Court 9 Reporter of the State of New York, County of 10 Suffolk, do hereby certify this transcript to be a 11 true and accurate transcription of my stenographic 12 notes taken on this day; 13 Furthermore, photocopies made of this �-....� 14 transcript by any party cannot be certified by me 15 to be true and accurate . 16 Therefore , only those copies bearing an 17 original signature in blue ink are official 18 certified copies . . 19 20 -- --- — ----- --- -- J IAN CA 21 O ICIAL COURT REPORTER �- 22 �� � 23 � -- — -- ----- DATE 24 � 25 RECETVEG f_�� � �O MAR �. 4 2016 �ONING BOARD OF APPEALS - i � « EXHIBIT 13 '� . �e: �F� • �� � W � i�ECEIVEC MAR � � 2016 I IIIIII'IIII�IIII IIII)IIIII IIIII IIIII IIIII IIIII IIII IIII LONING BOARD�F HPPEALS I IIIIII IIIII IIIII IIII IIII -- -.�_---�---- �:._ �__-�. _��S-�i��?4-�I�-SOi�N`9���'.�E�#--,.-�,.. -- _ -__ -,.. _ __ - _ _ - � RECORDS OFFICE RECORDING PAGE Type of Instruntent: DEED Recorded: 06/25/2014 Number of Pages : 4 At: 03:05 :14 PM Receipt Number : 14-0082868 TRANSFER TAX NU1�ER: 13-29558 LIBER: D00012778 PAGE : 753 District: Section: Block: Lot: 1000 145. 00 04 .00 003 . 000 EXANlINED AND CHARGED AS FOLLOWS Deed Amount: $205,000 .00 Received the Following Fees For Above Instrument Exempt Exempt Page/Filing $20 .00 NO Handling $20 .00 NO COE.;. . , $5.00 NO NYS SRCHG $15.00 NO - --�A-C�TY-= -- $5.-fl0 - NO �A��TAT� _$250,OD NO TP-584 $5 .00 NO Notation $0.00 NO Cert.COpies $0 . 00 NO RPT $60 .00 NO Transfer tax $820 . 00 NO Comm.Pres $2, 600 .00 NO Fees Paid $3,800.00 TRPiNSFER T�iX NiJt�ER: 13-29558 THIS PAGE IS A PART OF THE INSTRUMENT THIS IS NOT A BILL JUDITH A. PASCALE Count3� Clerk, Suffolk County -• ' • � ��� 2� d c. RECEIVED � • . ' ' ° ' �� � � . MAR142016 Num,b,:r of��age:, -• RECORDED <014 Jun 25 n3:C�S:14�NTNG BOpRp UF qpp� ,�1.1pITH R. PR5�_RLE A� This document wiii be public GLERK UF record. Please remove alf SUFFi�LY. CnUNTS� Social Security Numbers � nnaoi2��� P ?53 prior to recording. DT# 1�-2gss� Deed!Mortgage Instrument Deed/Mortgage ir.x Stamp Reco}�ui.��,- F:::n�;Stamps 3 N�rs. �� _ ..,._ - -_..:T.... ..,,.,_„_�.,.�._ _ Page/Filing Fee _ _ � t�;uy.,,.-ce:'•..,• _�--...-- — i ..;:'la:c Handling 20. 00 2. �1ad�tic;�a'.l��x _______ _ TP-584 SLJ 1'otal _ Notation Spec JAssit. --- — or EA-52 17(County) _ Sub Total__• Spec./Add.____ _ EA-5217(State) _ TUT.MTG "fAX _ (�v � �� li�a11'o�vn Dual County_ R.P T.S.A. �•� � Heici;o;.�ppointment Comm.of Ed. 5• � �; � Transfei T�x _ $c2��' , Affidavit _ ���� Mansion Tax _ Certified Copy __ The property r,overed by this mortgage is or will bu in:p.oved by a one or two NYS Surcharge , 15. _00 ran•cu}�dwcl'. nly. =- - Sub Tocal __ �p:,�� ,._..n:,�, ��, -�- _ Other - — �✓}�j) ""' I� 'O •••: ;..� '�tax clause�n Grand'fotal� "':�- � ��e o �,.._t,�tr��ei,�F. —��L -.r,_ �i_ 4 Dist.l000 �,�15�5 loo0 14500 oaoo 003000 � 5 Commun:tty Preservation Fund ReaAPenperty 23 UN 1 IIIIIIII�II�I�IIII�IIIII"I�II""I�IIII� CPF Ta�c Due � o$na (e00� Q' Tax Service R POL A a, g Y / Verificauon / Improved 6 Satisfactions/Discharges/Releases List Property Owners Mailing Address RECORD&RETURN TO: /� Vacant Land �_ DANIEL C. ROSS P.O. Box 146 TD 10 Mattituck, New York 11952 � TD TD � -.,�..:_. - . ._ _-- - • - -_� --- -- - — - _ - �P- -=� -�- - ------�.�---- - --—-. _.,._, _- _ Mail to:Judith A. Pascale, Suffolk County Clerk 7 Title Com an In�i�x��r.at�on 310 Center Drive,.Riverhead, NY 11901 �� www.suffolkcountyny.gov/clerk Title# - p _ S 8 Suffolk Count Recordin & End�rsement Pa e This page forms part of the attached _Bargain and Sale Deed made by: _ (SPECIFY TYPE OF INSTRUMENT) James Murray and_ _^_� The premises herein is situated in Susan Segur SUFFOI;K�;(ilJIv'Tl',?v'�`�V YORK, TO ' In ihe TOWN of Southold Frank J. Kelly and In the VILLAGE Elizabeth G. Kelly Laurel --...------�--- --- --..._.. cr HAMLET of •---------•--- BOXES 6 THRU 8 MUST BE TYPED OR PRINTED IN BLACK P.VK ONLY PRIOR TO RECORDING OR rTi.ING. u-o�a_�woe�t - — i,..,��. ' � - � � -��� �� b�y � • `�CONSULT 1'OUR LAWYER BEFORE SIGNING THIS INSTRUMENT-THI3 INSTRUMENT SHOULD BE USED BY LAWYERS ONLY : aECErvE� THIS INDENTURE,made the //� day of June, 2014 , MAR 14 2p�6 BETWEEN ZONING BOARD UF ppp�p� JAMES MURRAY, reaiding at 1825 Peconic Bay Blvd., Laurel, New York 11948; and SUSAN SEGUR, reaiding at 826 Oyster Pond Lane,�#trgtvn, North Carolina, 28411. W�I�rt�ncJtov. party of the first part,and �(u�bqu� � W;,�+� FRANK J. RELLY and ELIZABETH G. RELLY,�residing at 12 Bayview Avenue, East Islip, New York,. 11730, , party of the second part, WITNESSETH,that the party of the first part,in consideration of - � � dollars paid by the party of the second part,does hereby grant and release unto the party of the second part,the heirs or successors and assigns of the party of the secohd par�forev.er; ALL that certain plot, piece or parcel ofland, with the buildings and improvements thereon erected, situate, lying and being in the Hamlet of Laurel, Town of Southold, County of Suffolk, State of New York. SEE DESCRIPTION of Sechedule A attached hereto and made a part hereof. BEING AND INTENDED TO BE the same premises conveyed to the party of the first pary by deed dated July 11, 2003 and recorded in therOffice of the Clerk of the County of Suffolk ia Liber 12264 of deeds at page 340. �J�ly 3��2003 THE LIFE ESTATES OF James M. Murray aad Emily A. Murray have been extiagnshed by —.- ���A�i�s�tton•of �"ea�h.. I TOGETHER with all right,title and interest, if any,of the party of the fi�st part in and to any streets and roads abutting the above described premises to the center lines thereof;TOGETHER with the appurtenances and all the estate and rights of the party of the first part in and to said premises; TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the premises herein granted unto the party of the second part,the heirs or successors and assigns of the party of the second part forever. �_ __�.�:./�ND-the-party o#-th�€Irst pa+#-cever�ts-that-the-�a�-o#�ie,�-Rar��as,.-net--der�e�-er--sa#ered-anythirs�--�-•--- whereby the said premises have been encumbered in any way whatever,except as aforesaid. AND the party of the first part, in compliance with Section 13 of the Lien Law, covenants that the party of the first part will receive the consideration for this conveyance and will hold the right to receive such consideration as a trust fund to be applied first for the purpose of paying the cost of the improvement and will apply the same first to the payment of the cost of the improvement before using any part of the total of the same for any other purpose.The word"party"shall be construed as if it read"parties"whe� ever the sense of this indenture so requires. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the party of the first part has duly executed this deed the day and year first above —- - !N PftESEN6E-OF: - - --.- - - - ES MURRAY �� � written. SUSAN SEGUR Standard N.Y.B.T.U.Form 8002-Bargain end 5ale Deed,with Covenant against Grantofs Acts-Unitorm Acknowledgment Fn�m 37Qfl • , . . • � � ,,� �j . � l� � � ' Fidelity National Title Insurance Company KECEIVEC� ' TITLE NO.F14-7404-94725-SUFF 1����� �n+-zv7II— SCHEDULE A-1 (Description) ZqNING �3UpkD��APP�ALS Amended ALL that certain plot, piece or parcel of land, situate, lying and being in the Hamlet of Laurel, Town of Southold and State of New York,being more particularly bounded and described as follows: BEGINNING at a concrete monument set on the southerly side of Peconic Bay Boulevard at the northwest corner of the premises herein described adjoining land now or formerly Childs formerly of B. Mesrobian; � ____�..—-- --- - - --- - - . _ - ., ; RUNNING THENCE along said land now or�ormer7y of Childs�rcnerly Mesro�'an;'Sou��i����zt�gr`���'15�iinut�s-East, 140.54 feet to a concrete monument; RUNNING THENCE North 62 degrees 06 minutes East, 9.00 feet to mean high water mark of the channel or Brushes Creek; RUNNING THENCE a tie line course and distance of North 12 degrees 04 minutes 30 seconds West along the mean high water mark of Brushes Creek, 165.08 feet to the southerly side of Peconic Bay Boulevard RUNNING THENCE South 69 degrees 29 minutes West along the southerly side of Peconic Bay Boulevard, 107.00 feet to the monument and point of BEGINNING. -, ! ;a_;, -- . -.- -- - - - - - - -- � - -- - -- - , - -- - THE POLICY TO BE IS,SUED under this commitment will insure the title to such buildings and improvements on the premises which by!aw c-onst�6ule rea!-�rope.rt}'. -— --- - -._� .--- ------ -- Ft�l2'C'01V�EY�N`N'�'1'NC O1V�Y.� 7'ogether with all the rig�t, title at�d interest of the party of the first part, of in and to the land lying in the street in front of antl adjoining said premises. SCHEDULEA-1(Description) y •• „ , .... , � TO BE USED ONL. ....EN THE ACKwbW4E'C�aN1EN`�IS MADE IN NEW YOR.____�TE, �ECETVEG �Q( I/ , � "�l/ �- , MAR ��� 2016 State of New York,County of Suffolk ss: State of New York,County of ZONINGs�OARL�UF APPEALS On the /3 day of June in the year2p14 On the day of in the year before me,the undersigned,personaliy appeared before me,the undersigned,personalty appeared James Murra personally known to me or pr�ved to me on the basis of personaily known to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the indtvidual(s)whose name(s)is satfsfactory evidence to be the indiv(dual(s)whose name(s)is (are)subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledgad to (are)subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in hisTherttheir me that he/she/they executed the same in his/herftheir capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their stgnature(s) on the capacity(les), and that by hislherttheir signature(s) on the instrument,tha individual(s),or the person upon behalf of which instrument,the IndNidual(s),or the person upon behalf of which the individual(s)acted,e d the instrument. the individual(s)acted,executed the instrument. (signature OTARY PUBLIC ual taking acknowledgment) (signature and office of individual taking acknowledgment) Ro b er�F De F�cs� ROBERT DEfRESE � NoUry Pub4e Sbte ol N�w York No.01DE5035117 Ou�Nted In SuMONc Gounly Cqnmluiqi Expins OUober 2s,2011 TO BE USED ONLY WHEN THE ACKNOWLEDGMENT IS MADE OUT3IDE NEW YORK STATE State(or District of Columbia,Territory,or Foreign Country)of ss: On the /I�' day of June in the year Y01q before me,the undersigned,personally appeared personally known�ame o��oved to me on the basis of saUsfactory evidence to be the individual(s)whose name(s) ts(are) subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/thelr cepacity(ies),and that by hisR►erttheir signature(s)on the instrument,the indfvidual(s),or the person upon behalf of which the individual(s)acted, executed the Instrument,and that such indivfdual made such appearance before the undersfgned in the State of North Carolina �� New Hanover County (insert the City or other political subdivision) (and insert the State or CounUy or er ce the nowledgment was taken) „�� „ �"�,. �F�. (signature and o ice � �1 �g�.;s�cw'o�gm . /�/7�,.r�/ /''C �� � ���':�; ��• r/s/�� �^�i� ��'� � :�: �,I�Iliam E•.StaLsid-z - -''.,� � Q ;�4 BARGAIN AND SALE DEED SECTION 1 ys•oo s� ���FA'�`�';��`�,�.''�+,' WITHCOVENANTAGAINSTGRANTOR'SACTS BLOCK oy•DO +/ ��"���r,�,�t�:y��ti;�� TitleNo. F14-74oS�-4�f?aS-SvFF LOT o03•000 ' COUNTY OR TOWN S v f Ptitk James Murray and Susan Segur STREET ADDRESS Frank J. Kelly and Elizabeth G. Kelly Recorded atRequestof COMMONWEALTH LAND TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY RETURN BY MAIL TO• STANDARD FORM OF NEW YORK BOARD OF TITLE UNDERINRITERS DANI EL C. ROS S Distributed by P.O. Box 146 �i,�LandAmerita Mattituck, New York 11946 �Commonwealth Commonwulth Lmd TIW Imunnu Comp�ny RESERVE THIS SPACE FOR USE OF RECORDINO OFFICE - —_.---�...�— -� --- - - - -- - - �� �� 1 � RECEIVEp _ MAR 14 2016 . � ZONING BOARD OF qppEq� 11 « . � EXHIBIT 14 � 4 �w � RECEIVEC ' MAR 14 2Q16 SOUTHOLD TOWN ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS COUNTY OF SUFFOLK ZONING BOARD UF Apptq� -----------------------------------------------------------------------------R APPLICATION and EXHIBITS of FRANK J. KELLY to the SOUTHOLD TOWN ZBA SEEKING REVERSAL of the BUILDING INSPECTOR'S NOTICE OF DISAPPROVAL, dated AUGUST 31,2015 � Appellants: Frank J. Kelly and Elizabeth G.Kelly � Re: Premises: 1900 Great Peconic Bay Blvd., Laurel,New York, i SCTM: 1000-145-4-3 � -------------------------------------------------------------------------------x � STATE OF NEW YORI� )ss.: COUNTY OF SUFFOLK) WALTER KOCH, being duly sworn deposes and says: 1. I reside at Oakwood Road, Laurel, New York and have resided there since 1963. My residence is down the block from the Marina at issue in this matter. 2. I have observed the Marina on an almost daily basis since residing at my present address. I observed during that period that the premises were operated as a Marina. I know the prior owner James Murray and I knew Mr. Murray's father James Murray, Sr.who I understand owned the Marina before Mr. Murray Jr. owned it. 3. I can state that there were numerous boats between 10 to 15 kept at the Marina on a , regular basis. I kept a boat at Mr. Murray's Marina for several years. I am a marine mechanic and own a marine repair shop in Mattituck. I worked on boats that were kept at the Marina at issue here in leased spots at that marina. 4. I can state that the premises were operated as a commercial marina with 11 slips on a regular basis since I resided at my present address. .,-,' Q!% : � WALTER KOCH Sw this�� day of D DA,NI�L C. ROSS Nfotary Publf�� 3tate of New York IY"o:490'1175 QualMied in g�v�k CQunty Eommission Expirbs�At�g. 31, �� �Og�FfOL�co ELIZABETH A.NEVILLE,MMC �y.� �ly Town Hall,53095 Main Road TOWN CLERK � � P.O. Box 1179 eQls = Southold,New York 11971 REGISTRAR OF VITAL STATISTICS p � .� Fax(631)765-6145 MARRIAGE OFFICER y� a0�' Telephone(631)765-1800 RECORDS MANAGEMENT OFFICER �l � �► �vww.southoldtownny.gov FREEDOM OF INFORMATION OFFICER OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD TO: Southold Town Zoning Board of Appeals FROM: Elizabeth A. Neville DATED: March 17, 2016 RE: Zoning Appeal No. 6946 Transmitted herewith is Zoning Appeals No. 6946 for Frank J. & Elizabeth G. Kellv-The Cover Letter from Keegan& Keegan, Ross &Rosner, LLP to the Southold Town Zoning Board of Appeals for an Appeal of Building Inspector's 20 Foot Boat Restriction. Also enclosed is the Applicant's Application and Exhibits Contents Listing, Pre-Existing Certificate of Occupancy No. 38052, Exhibit 1-Application to the Southold Town Board of Appeals, Exhibit 2-Applicant's Project Description, Exhibit 3-Questionnaire, Exhibit 4-Board of Southold Town Trustees Permit No. 6205 Dated 9/21/O5, Survey, A Letter from the Board of Trustees to Robert E. Herrmann of En-Consultants Dated 9/21/O5, Inspection Schedule, A Letter from the Board of Trustees to Robert E. Herrmann of En-Consultants Dated 5/17/06,NYS DEC Letter Dated 1/20/06,NYS DEC Permit No. 1-4738-00542/00003, Survey with Description of Proposed Dredging, Amendment to Permit No. 1-4738-00542/00003 Dated 4/18/O5, A Letter from the Department of State to Roy L. Haje of En-Consultants Dated 4/18/O5, Property Card, Exhibit 5-Agricultural Data Statement, Exhibit 6-Board of Zoning Appeals Application Authorization from Frank J. Kelly for Keegan & Keegan, Ross &Rosner,Applicant/Owner Transactional Disclosure Form, Exhibit 7-AgentlRepresentative Transactional Disclosure Form, Exhibit 8-Short Environmental Assessment Form, Exhibit 9-LWRP Consistency Assessment Form, Exhibit 10-Pre-Existing Certificate of Occupancy No. 38052, Exhibit 11-A Letter from Howard Terry, Southold Town Building Inspector to Mr. F.R. Fleschutz and Others Dated 9/10/68, Obituary of Howard M. Terry, Exhibit 12-Proceeding Town of Southold Against Frank J. Kelly and Elizabeth G. Kelly, Exhibit 13-Recording Page of the Deed, Copy of the Deed, Fidelity National Title Insurance Company Page, Exhibit 14-An Affidavit from Walter Koch. * * * RECEIPT * * * Date: 03/16/16 Receipt#: 201491 Quantity Transactions Reference Subtotal 1 ZBA Application Fees 6946 $300.00 Total Paid: $300.00 Notes: Payment Type Amount Paid By CK#2433 $300.00 Keegan & Keegan, Ross & Rosner, LLP Southold Town Clerk's Office 53095 Main Road, PO Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Name: Kelly, Frank J & Elizabeth 12 Bayview Ave East Islip, NY 11730 Clerk ID: SABRINA Internal ID:6s46 BOARD MEMBERS � �Southold Town Hall �OF SO!/ry Leslie Kanes Weisman,Chairperson ��� O�O 53095 Main Road•P.O.Box 1179 Southold,NY 11971-0959 Eric Dantes �c � Office Location: Gerard P.Goehringer G Q Town Annex/First Floor,Capital One Bank George Horn�ng '�� � i� 54375 Main Road(at Youngs Avenue) Kenneth Schneider I�CQ(f�,�� Southold,NY 11971 http://southo Idtown.northfork.net ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Tel.(631)765-1809•Fax(631)765-9064 LEGAL NOTICE SOUTHOLD TOWN ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS THURSDAY, JULY 7, 2016 PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN, pursuant to Section 267 of the Town Law and Town Code Chapter 280 (Zoning), Town of Southold, the following public hearing will be held by the SOUTHOLD TOWN ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS at the Town Hall, 53095 Main Road, Southold, New York 11971-0959, on THURSDAY, JULY 7, 2016: 1•30 P M - (ADJOURNED FROM APRIL 21, 2016 SPECIAL MEETING)—FRANK J. and ELIZABETH G. KELLY #6946 - This is a request under Section 280-146D for a Reversal of the restriction on the length of watercraft permitted at the marina as listed in the Pre-CO #38052 issued 1/14/2016, property located at: 1900 Great Peconic Bay Boulevard (adj. to Brushes Creek), Laurel, NY. SCTM#1000-145-4-3 The Board of Appeals will hear all persons, or their representatives, desiring to be heard at each hearing, and/or desiring to submit written statements before the conclusion of each hearing. Each hearing will not start earlier than designated above. Files are available for review during regular business hours and prior to the day of the hearing. If you have questions, please contact our office at (631) 765-1809, or by email: kimf@southoldtownnv.�ov Dated: June 6, 2016 ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS LESLIE KANES WEISMAN, CHAIRPERSON By: Kim E. Fuentes 54375 Main Road (Office Location) 53095 Main Road (Mailing/USPS) P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971-0959 Z�G BOARD OF APPEALS � MAILING ADDRESS and PLACE OF HEARINGS: 53095 Main Road, Town Hall Building, P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971-0959 (631) 765-1809 Fax 765-9064 LOCATION OF ZBA OFFICE: Town Hall Annex at North Fork Bank Building, 1st Floor 54375 Main Road and Youngs Avenue, Southold website: htt�//southtown.northfork.net June 6, 2016 Re: Town Code Chapter 55 -Public Notices for Thursday, July 7 , 2016 Hearing Dear Sir or Madam: Please find enclosed a copy of the Legal Notice describing your recent application. The Notice will be published in the next issue of The Suffolk Times. 1) Before June 2ptn: Please send the enclosed Legal Notice, with both a Cover Letter including your telephone number and a copy of your Survey or Site Plan (filed with this application) which shows the new construction area or other request, by CERTIFIED MAIL, RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED, to all owners of property (tax map with property numbers enclosed), vacant or improved, which abuts and any property which is across from any public or private street. Use the current owner name and addresses shown on the assessment rolls maintained by the Southold Town Assessors' Office, or Real Property O�ce at the County Center, Riverhead. If you know of another address for a neighbor, you may want to send the notice to that address as well. If any letter is returned to vou undeliverable, vou are requested to make other attempts to obtain a mailing address or to deliver the letter to the current owner, to the best of your abilitv, and to confirm how arrangements were made in either a written statement, or durinq the hearinq, providinq the returned letter to us as soon as possible; AND not later than June 27th: Please either mail or deliver to our office your Affidavit of Mailinq (form enclosed) with parcel numbers, names and addresses noted, along with the green/white receipts postmarked by the Post Office. When the green signature cards are returned to you later by the Post Office, please mail or deliver them to us before the scheduled hearing. If any envelope is returned "undeliverable", please advise this office as soon as possible. If any signature card is not returned, please advise the Board during the hearing and provide the card (when available). These will be kept in the permanent record as proof of all Notices. 2) Not Later June 29th: Please make arrangements to place the enclosed Poster on a signboard such as cardboard, plywood or other material, posting it at the subject property seven (7) days (or more) prior to hearing. (It is the applicant/agents responsibility to maintain sign until Public Hearing) Securely place the sign on your property facing the street, not more than 10 feet from the front property line bordering the street. If you border more than one street or roadway, an extra sign is supplied for posting on both front yards. Please deliver or mail your Affidavit of Postinq for receipt by our office before July 5, 2016. If you are not able to meet the deadlines stated in this letter, please contact us promptly. Thank you for your cooperation. (PLEASE DISPLAY YOUR HOUSE NUMBER ALWAYS). Very truly yours, Zoning Appeals Board and Staff Encls. � � � T � � � � � � The following application will be heard by the Southold Town Board of Appeals at Town Hall , 53095 Main Road , Southold: NAME : � SCTM # : _ _ _ VARIANCE : - . . REQVEST: DATE : T R . LY 7 2016 1 : 30 PM HV S JV � � If you are interested in this project, you may review the file(s) prior to the hearing during normal business days between 8 AM and 3 PM. ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS-TOWN OF SOUTHOLD 765-1809 04/15/2016 16:32 F�1 �001 ;; ; „ Kee��l & Kee , Ross & R���ier LLP ; . � �� � ' i , •, ��\� ATTOHNEYS AT LAW ' Thomas J.Keegan Jr. 3i5 Westphalia Avenue Phone»63i.z98.2zoo �`,';' . , , ' '�j` �i Daniel C.Ross Post Office Box z46 Fax»6 z.z 8. �=: Jamie G.Rosner 3 9 4427 J Mattit u c k, N e w Y o r k i 1 9 5 2 W e b»w w w.k e e g an law.us f ;;, ,. , � Thomas J.Keegan(igz3-soo3) ;;�, e. `/ (^� l b � ,' �� It1ED t � ,� , RECE � , , April I5, Zoi6 APR 18 2016 , � By Fax: 765-9064 ,.,k, ry�,..,•.., • ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS " '„ � Southold "Town Zoning Board of Appeals ' ; ' Attentian: Leslie Kanes Weisman, Chair : 'I'own Hall Annex Building 54375 Route 25 � "'� � P.O. Box 1179 . � Southold,New York 1 1971 ��;; , . Re: Appeal of Building Inspector's 20 Foot Boat Restriction in Pre-C.O., dated 1/14/16 , Prernises: 1900 Great Peconic Bay Bivd., Laurel, New York �� , � SCTM: 1 Q00-145-4-3 � . ", Appellants: Frank J. Kel ly � ZBA#: 6946 ,, Dear Ms. Weisman: � This is to request an adjournment of the hearing oi� the referenced appeal and the ; , ,' applicant's time to notice the neighbors and post the property ta the next hearing date. We are attempting to resolve the issue that would allow for the withdrawal of the appeal. , ery t 1 , ° ° C. R s , ;„ Western Suffolk Office»Patchogue, New York � � , ��'�,��y � � � ��,��� Keeg�an � Keegan, Ross & Ro��a�r, LLP � � ATTORNEYS AT LAW Thomas J. Keegan Jr. 3i5 Westphalia Avenue Phone»63i.z98.i2oo Daniel C. Ross Post Office Box 146 Fa�c»631•29$•4427 Jamie G. Rosner Mattituck, New York i1952 Web»www.keeganlaw.us Thomas J.Keegan(i9z3-zoo3) April 14, 2016 � / ` � MtECETVED By Hand APR 1 � 2016 Southold Town Zoning Board of Appeals Attention: Leslie Kanes Weisman, Chair, and Board Members ZONING BOl�RD OF C�pPEAL�s Town Hall Annex Building 54375 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Re: Appeal of Building Inspector's 20 foot Boat limit in Pre Existing Certificate of Occupancy # 38052, dated 1/14/16 Premises: 1900 Great Peconic Bay Blvd., Laurel, New York SCTM: 1000-145-4-3 Appellant: Frank J. Kelly ZBA#: Dear Ms. Weisman and ZBA Board Members: At the April 7, 2016 hearing on Mr. Kelly's first ZBA appeal I represented to the Board that I would meet with Building Department personnel in an attempt to resolve Mr. Kelly's second referenced ZBA appeal. While I have full ability to bind Mr. Kelly and resolve the matter the Building Department has put conditions on the meeting that we cannot meet. Because of my representation to you I wanted you to know why the effort is failing. In fact, as you can see from the attached computer generated letter, dated 2/1/2016, the original of which was delivered by me to Mr. Kiely, I had tried to discuss this issue with Town representatives prior to your staff encouraging me to do so. In response to my efforts Mr. Kiely indicated the Building Department was not interested in discussing the matter. That changed on 4/8/16 when a Building Department representative stopped by my office to indicate that the Department's position had changed and a meeting would be entertained, however, the offer was conditioned on Mr. Kelly being present for the meeting. This condition cannot be met. As his legal representative I can bind Mr. Kelly and any understanding reached can be put in writing and Mr. Kelly will sign it and I will notarize his signature so long as the Town also signs the writing. I will present myself at the Town Annex in the afternoon of April 15, 2016 prior to the mailing and posting required for Mr. Kelly's second ZBA application. Western Suffolk O�ce»Patchogue, New York � � ^''-'.�1��i� 10 A���� za�s ZONING BOARD OF AppEq� In connection with Town Violation charges against Mr. Kelly, one of which was operating a Marina without site plan approval, I represented to Judge Price, at the urging of the Town's prosecutor, that Mr. Kelly would file for Site Plan Approval with the Planning Board. At the conference with the Planning staff, which was attended by Building Department personnel, Mr. Kelly's proffered Site Plan Application was refused by the planning staff and there was an insistence that Mr. Kelly file an Application for a Building Permit. The reason given for requiring a Building Permit Application was that a determination had to be made in the first instance by the Building Inspector as to whether site plan approval was required or not. I pointed out that a Town Code violation had been issued so it seemed that a determination had already been made. Nonetheless, the Planning staff would not accept Mr. Kelly's site plan application and the Town code violation is still pending. I indicated at the meeting that Mr. Kelly would not submit a Building Permit Application. Mr. Kelly then discussed the issue directly with Building Department personnel and was under the belief that upon his submitting the application a Pre-C.O. for a Marina would be issued. With that belief in hand Mr. Kelly submitted a Building Permit Application which resulted in the Building Inspector's Notice of Disapproval, dated 8/31/15, which was the basis of Mr. Kelly's first ZBA application. Thereafter, your Board, through Mr. Kiely, encouraged the Building Department to consider Mr. Kelly's application for a pre-C.O.. A field inspection was held. I am advised that at the field inspection a measurement was taken of Mr. Kelly's boat. In fairness, that observation is denied by the Building Department inspector who conducted the inspection. Nonetheless, there are restrictions in the issued Pre C.O. # 38052, dated 1/14/16, that cause Mr. Kelly concern and has resulted his second ZBA application. I will present myself as Mr. Kelly's legal representative for discussion of the issue tomorrow, April 15, 2016, at the Town Annex. , �_ Very tru� yo s „ , � , < �... Daniel C. R cc: Southold Town Attorneys Office Att: Stephen Kiely, Esq. Southold Town Building Department b� K�b iLECENED APR L � 2016 ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS February 1, 2016 By fax: 765-6639 and regular mail. Southold Town Attorneys Office Att: Stephen Kiely, Esq. Town Hall Annex 54375 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Re: Kelly ZBA Application #6898 Premises: 1900 Great Peconic Bay Blvd, Laurel, NY 11948 SCTM no.: 1000-145.000-04.00-003.000 Dear Mr. Kiely: I discussed with my client the withdrawal of the Kelly ZBA Application #6898. Mr. Kelly is concerned with respect to the 20 foot limitation for boats in the Town Building Department's Pre-C.O. No. 38052, dated January 14, 2016. I would appreciate the opportunity to discuss this at your convenience. Very truly yours, Daniel C. Ross ,�F�`''f���"' Town of Southold �„�,��t q��;'�',., 1/14/2016 � � �°��' S3095 Main Rd (,�/ ;a;,,:'� .��... � �b t, �;; Southold,New York 11971 RECEIVED '1 Pfi- ';��'�� ,� ,���"��� APR 1 � 2016 , . ---- - - ------����BOARD OF APP�ALS . PRE EXISTING CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY No: 3R052 Date: 1/l 4/201 C THIS CER'I'IFIES that thc structure(s) locatcd at: 1900(;reat P�,�;onic i3ay f31vd, Laurel SCTM#: 473889 Sedt3lock/I,ot: 145.-4-3 Subdivision: I+iled Map No. I..ot No. conforms substantially tc�the rcyuire�nents for a built prior to APRIL 9, 1957 pursuant to which CF.RTIFICATE OF'OCCUPANCY N11MI3ER 'L- 38052 dated 1/I 4/20 t 6 was issueci and conforms to all the requricments of I.he applicable provisions of thc law. "1'he occupancy for wh�ch this ccrtific;alc is issuf;ci is: 11 sli�small watcrcrafi marina (inaximum_Iength_of watercraft 20_feet)and bravel parki.n�*lot, without buildintJstructurc�. The certificatc is issued to Kclly, Prank Kelly, I;lizabetl� �c��vni�:it) of the aloresaid building. SU��OLK COUNTY DEPAIt'fMN N7' OF 1�EAI�I'II APPROVA[, ELI:CTRICAI.. Ck R7`IF1CA'Tl; NO. PLUMBF.RS CERTIFICAT'ION DATED *PLF.:ASI:SI's}�.A'I'"t'AC:IIED 1NSP1_;C'1'TON REPOR'I'. ; -°' ,r'`���, .... ��,� =--- - �i oriic� Si�nat� f BOARD MEMBERS OF S�u�, 5outhold Town Hall Leslie Kanes Weisman,Chairperson �� yQ 53095 Main Road•P.O.Box 1179 ,`O !p Southold,NY 11971-0959 Eric Dantes #t � Off'ice Location: Gerard P.Goehringer G � Town Annex/First Floor,Capital One Bank George Horning �'� � ,�ai� 54375 Main Road(at Youngs Avenue) Kenneth Schneider l'YCQ�����` Southold,NY 11971 http://southoldtown.northfork.net ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Tel.(631)765-1809•Fax(631)765-9064 LEGAL NOTICE SOUTHOLD TOWN ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS THURSDAY, MAY 5, 2016 PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN, pursuant to Section 267 of the Town Law and Town Code Chapter 280 (Zoning), Town of Southold, the following public hearing will be held by the SOUTHOLD TOWN ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS at the Town Hall, 53095 Main Road, Southold, New York 11971-0959, on THURSDAY, MAY 5, 2016: 11:30 A.M. - FRANK J. and ELIZABETH G. KELLY #6946 - This is a request under Section 280-146D for a Reversal of the restriction on the length of watercraft permitted at the marina as listed in the Pre-CO #38052 issued 1/14/2016, property located at: 1900 Great Peconic Bay Boulevard (adj. to Brushes Creek), Laurel, NY. SCTM#1000-145-4-3 The Board of Appeals will hear all persons, or their representatives, desiring to be heard at each hearing, and/or desiring to submit written statements before the conclusion of each hearing. Each hearing will not start earlier than designated above. Files are available for review during regular business hours and prior to the day of the hearing. If you have questions, please contact our office at (631) 765-1809, or by email: Vicki.Toth(c�Town.Southold.nv.us Dated: April 11, 2016 ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS LESLIE KANES WEISMAN, CHAIRPERSON By: Vicki Toth 54375 Main Road (Office Location) " 53095 Main Road (Mailing/USPS) P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971-0959 � ��l�1��� JUN 2 7 2016 � TOWN OF SOUTHOLD BY:_ ---j�------- ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS � �'"l�,� SOUTHOLD,NEW YORK l,Cn , , , ru��� AFFIDAVIT OF In the Matter of the Application of MAILINGS ��k T �:�.��y �a �t�Z� �. �c-�.i (Name of Applicants) SCTM Parcel# lOQO- /�j5 -'�-3 COUNTY OF SUFFOLK STATE OF NEW YORK �- n u�-�,`�-� I, ���� •��55 residing at 1�5� ��v�T� ��') � New York, being duly sworn, deposes and says that: On the 20� day of �'uh�, , 20�1�, I personally mailed at the Unit�d States Post Office in I�r»a-�}-,'-lu,ck. ,New York, by CERTIFIED MAIL, RETURN R.EC�iPT REQUESTED, a true copy of the attached Legal Notice in Prepaid envelopes addressed to current property owners shown on the current assessment roll verified from the official records on file with the �ssessors, or( ) County Rea1 � Property Office for every property which abuts and is across a public or private street, or vehicular right-of-way of record, surrounding the applicant's property. �-�-�� (Signature) Swo to before me this �JeT `� � . � otary Public) '�`^����L C. ROSS Mptr, -u talic, State of Nsw Yor'k _ ��o. 4907175 O�IINEL C. R(`�� Qi: f�fi� ' �n Sutfolk Coutrty PLI�Ib�}i���� ��oa;a sheet c�a�q�g t�lc�umbers next � to the owner n���lresse����which notices were mailed. Thank you. QwHf�ed in SW�oik County Commission Explr+�s Aug. 31, 20� � � � � �,��� LEGAL NOTICES SENT TO THE FOLLOWING �Vl �(2�I(b . � - � . - • _ 1. Kathleen Knapp .� �• � - � n� 2260 Peconic Bay Blvd. o � • ° • Laurel,New Yark 11948 �.At�tEL.! �IY 1 i�►4a8 1000— 145-4-4 � Pos�y� �'g��� 2. James Munay � Certified Fee ti�.[�t� 1905 Great Peconic Bay Blvd. o P. �q,r,�t P Herre� Retum Recel t Fee � (Endorsement Required) P.�. B�X 3�5 0 RestrictedDeliveryFee �� (Endorsement Requlred) Laurel,New York 11948 � fi�. � Total Postage&Fees $ �.�6�2��2�16 1000—127-8-13 � 3. Jerome Morrissey and Linda Morrissey � sa��ro ' �4-�'+��C�Cvt �h��---------------------------------- -------••----- ---•----------- - - 504 Morris Avenue o srraer,AptNo.��D ��G�/� ��y ��d or PO Box No. Rockville Centre,New York 11570 �` -------------------•----------------••-�---------------- --- -------------------•------ C�ty,State,ZIP+4 / „u/,._, / N �i 9�e L.{L (LI 1000—145-4-2.1 :�� • • ��• 4. Southold Town Attorney's Office � . , Town Hall annex ' � � - • 54375 Route 25 °' '' � � ' a P.O. Box 1179 � FcOGK�IILLE GE1�TRE► �IY !15?0 Southold,New York 11971 m 1000- 145-4-5 � _ P°5��� t�gr� Certified Fee #[�.1�1[I v� � Postmark p Retum Receipt Fee 0 (Endorsement Required) f��.��t� Here � Restricted Delivery Fee � ■ � (Endorsement Required) � ��. ' � ' � � � rota�Postage s,Fees $ llb/2CV2C�16 p �. - . • . : • . - .. - ' . •-• � � Sen To . r,.i . . � . . . . �. � . . . . � nt _02Jt�s�� _ 0 o �,�----�..--- Xt------------------ ---�s�r SOUTI�I.�Q► ?�lY �.1$71 � 't�eet,�Pt No.: - --- � or PO Box No.�Q� rn���s ������ - ---------------------- '�--------------------------- --- • ----------------------------- m �� �Ig�� Ci State, /P+4� � Pos � ab e N i�5 �-o `� CeRified Fee ��.�•���� '�� ��� Postmark � Retum Receipt Fee s������� Here � (Endorsement Required) � � O Restricted Delivery Fee � . , � � � (Endorsement Reqwred) a ���' t�d/2tV2ii1 b m •• • � Total Postage&Fees � m � entTo O�d /O!/�/J 5 Vr � �GQ� � •�AI�Gs.t hY #1'9'4$ . .. - . . ----°�-'------------------------f���---------------------------- m rl Street,APt.No.; p m Pos 7 � �igc2 O or PO Box No. � �� ���I � ��� � -------------------••-----------...__...----•------•-------------.. �- �;ry s�e�e:ZrP+so�t�,old N !t q�! `� Certlfied Fee sa.ac� � Postmark :�� • ��. p Return Receipt Fee ' ' � (Endorsement Required) $(�.[II�I Here � iiestricted Delivery Fee • O (Endorsement Required) ���. 0 Totel Postage 8 Fees $ (�6�7(��2��16 �l.l Sent T '� - �'��---.�'1�(�i�.%Zct�/-- � S`freet,Apt.No, ------------------•---------- � or PO Box No. �Q ��( �� - ----------------�C_:---------------------'--•----.....--------•------ City,Sfate ZlP+4 �� w� , ,n� / /� ���J� :�� ��. • • ��K/ SOUTHOLD TOWN ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS �� COUNTY OF SUFFOLK RECEIVEp -----------------------------------------------------------------------------X �JUL � � 20t� APPLICATION of FRANK J. KELLY to the SOUTHOLD TOWN ZBA SEEKING REVERSAL of the ��ING 80ARD pF qpp�ALS BUILDING INSPECTOR'S Restriction on Boat Length set forth in Pre-C.O. #38052 dated O1/14/2016. Appellants: Frank J. Kelly and Elizabeth G. Kelly Re: Premises: 1900 Great Peconic Bay Blvd., Laurel, New York, SCTM: 1000-145-4-3 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------x AFFIRMATION OF POSTING - #6946 DANIEL C. ROSS, being duly sworn, residing at Woodcliff Drive, Mattituck, NY and being an attorney duly admitted to practice law in the Courts of the State of New York affirms the following under penalties of perjury: I am over the age of eighteen (18) years, not a party to this action, not related by blood or marriage to either of the parties to this action, and I reside at Mattituck,New York. That on June 28,2016,I placed the Town's Official Poster,with the date of the hearing and nature of Frank J. Kelly and Elizabeth G. Kelly's application noted thereon securely upon the fence that is facing Great Peconic Bay Blvd. loca d on the captioned premises located ten (10) feet or closer from the street facing the street a h� I hereby confi at the Poster has remained in place for seven (7) days prior to the date o the s ject he ' 2 � �a� �� DANIEL C. ROSS � � � . . . . . ■ Complete items 1,2,and 3.Also complete A. Signatiire ��n item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired. p,�� ^- 'r ■ Print your name and address on the reverse � � ` `/I�, so that we can return the card to you. g. Received by(Printed Name) C. Da of ivery � � ti Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, ` or on the front if space permits. �p ,' 1. Article Addressed to: D. Is delivery address different irom Rem 1? Y s If YES,enter delivery address below: ❑No � �a`ne5 h'1���zay �d� . �to5 G�- !-�� �Y . /�D l3ok 305 L�vr��! , N y /( �f�� 3. Service Type ,� �CeRified Mafl ❑Express Mail > ❑Regfstered ❑Return Receipt for Merohandise O Insured Mall ❑C.O.D. 4. Restricted pelivery?(Extra Fee) ❑Yes 2. Article Numhar (Trdnsfer 7pyy 200� aooa 6433 0333 PS Form 3 _,February 2004 Domestic Return Receipt 10269S02-M-1540 � _,, � • • • � • . ■ Complete items 1,2,and 3.Also complete a Si�"atu item 41f Restricted DelNery Is desired. X ❑AgeM ■ Print your name and�dress on the reverse ��� so that we can retum the card to you. B. ed by Name) C. D e Delivery ■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, � or on the front if space permfts. D.�Is delivery address irom Rem i T ❑Yes 1. Article Addressed to: If YES,enter delivery address below: ❑No S'ocrl�►Ald 7'vw��-�'��°Ys �ce �� ��o��e z� 5�f 3�5' �� ��X ��N� !� Q7l 3� � u [i C��ed nna�i o�s M�i So u�'h�l d r � ❑Registered ❑Retum Recelpt for Merchandise ❑Insured Mail ❑C.O.D. 4. RestriCted Delfver)/1(Extra Fee) ❑Yes 2. 'a�ii°ie 7011 20�0 aaoo 6433 0340 (Transf PS Form 3811,February 2004 Domestic Return Receipt T_ 102595-o2-M-15ao � � � . • . ■ Complete items 1,2,and 3.Also complete �►. Signatu item 4 if Restricted Dellvery is desired. ��� �Agent ■ Print your name and address on the reverse � ❑q�re�� so that we can return the card to you. g, ecefved by(Printed Name) C. of�livery ■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, G or on the front if space permits. D. Is delivery address differeM from item 17 ❑Yes 1. Article Addressed to: If YES,eMer delivery address below: ❑No ��'�!'e�� �� / zz������� �l�d ����eer� ����� Y ���, �v y ll�`f� 3. ��Z:e��rtifle�d Mall �E��Mail ❑Registered ❑Retum Receipt for Merohandise ❑Insured Meil ❑C.O.D. 4. Restricted Deliveryt(Ext►n Fee) ❑Yes 2. { � 7011 20�0 0�0� 6433 0326 ; PS Fom,3811,Februar�r 2004 Domestic Retum Receipt ��9�_�,�.1yy�; � Keeg�a.n. Keegan, Ross & Ro� er, LLP � ATTORNEYS AT LAW Thomas J. Keegan Jr. 3i5 Westphalia Avenue Phone»63i.298.izoo Daniel C.Ross Post Office Box i46 Fax»631•298•4427 Jamie G. Rosner Mattituck, New York i1952 Web»www.keeganlaw.us Thomas J.Keegan(ig23-zoo3) �� � T RECENEd July 5, 2016 'JUL ! 5 201fi 20NING BOARD OF APPEALS Southold Town Zoning Board of Appeals Attention: Leslie Kanes Weisman, Chair Town Hall Annex Building 54375 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Re: Appeal of Building Inspector's 20 Foot Boat Restriction in Pre-C.O., dated 1/14/16 Premises: 1900 Great Peconic Bay Blvd., Laurel, New York SCTM: 1000-145-4-3 Appellants: Frank J. Kelly Dear Ms. Weisman: Herewith please find my affidavit of Posting and the green RRR cards that were returned with respect to the mailing. One is missing. V y t s, an' . os Western Suffolk O�ce»Patchogue, New York �"��� � , � � �� �� ����i� �, r t�' #12842 `J STATE OF NEW YORK) ) SS: COUNTY OF SUFFOLK) Karen Kine of Mattituck, in said county, being duly sworn, says that she is Principal Clerk of THE SUFFOLK TIMES, a weekly newspaper, published at Mattituck, in the Town of Southold, County of Suffolk and State of New York, and that the Notice of which the annexed is a printed copy, has been regularly published in said Newspaper once each week for 1 week(s), successfully commencing on the 30th day of June, 2016. ___., 4�C.f�'-� �� Principal Clerk �Sworn to before me this day of 2016. CHRISTINA VOlINSKI flIOTARY PUBLIC-SiATE df NEW YORK No. O1V0610S050 Quollfled In Sutfolk County MY Cain+nliclan Fxplres februo�y 28,2020 tor's February 23,1A16 Amended Ivtarch family dwelling,at;l)Iess than tbe code review during regular business hours and LEGAL NOTICE 24, ?A16 Notice of Disapproval based required minimum side yard setback of prior to the day of the hearing. If you SOUTHOLD TOWN ZOMNG on an applicaHon for building permit to 10 feet,located at:205 Knapp Place,(aka have questions,please contact our office BOARD OF APPEAIS demolish existing'dwelling aad construct 326 Knapp Place)Greenport,NY SCI'M at,(631)765-1809,or by email: KimF@ THURSDAY JULY 7,2(116 a new single family dwelling and a new #1000-34-2-18.1 southoldtownny.gov PUBLIC I-IEAR�IGS accessory in-ground swimming pool,at; 11•2n A M -ROBERT e��BE'�'H Dated:June 13,2A16 NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN,pur- 1) proposed accessory in-ground swim- ELLIOTT M6967-Request for Variance ZONING BOARD OFAPPEAL,S su�nt to Section 267 of the Town Law and ming pool in location other than the code from Article XXII Section 280-116A(1) LESLIE KANES WEISMAN, Town Code Chapter 280(Zoning),Town required reaz yard or front yard on wa- and the Building Inspector's March 17, CHAIRPERSON of Southold,the following public hearings terfront property,2) proposed dwelling 2016 Notice of Disapproval based on an BY•Kim Fuentes will be held by the SOUTHOLD TOWN results in e�cisting accessory shed in Loca- application for building permit to con- 54375 Main Road(Office Location) ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS at tion vther than rear yard or front yard on struct an addition to an existing single 530y5 Main Road(Maili�g/USPS) the Town Hall, 53095 Main Road,P.O. water front properties, located at 1795 family dwelling at;1)proposed addition P.O.Box 11'I9 Box 1179, Southold, New York 11971- Central Drive (Summit Drive), Matti- is less than the code required setback Southold,NY 11971-0959 0959,on THURSDAY]tnX 7.2016. tuck,NY 5CI'M#1000-106-1-30.2 of 100 feet from the top of the bluff,2) 7?R42-1T 6/30 9:ti A.M. - RUSSELL H. BATES t��)A M -ROBERT ANz,i�C�IS- proposed addition exceeding 1,150 sq.ft. N69G4-Request for Variances hom Arti- TINE IIEA�LpEL. ii6969 - Request for total building azea as stated in coaditioa cle XXIII Section 28(}-124 and Article III Variances from Article XII Section 280- no.l of the prior ZBA decision No.5555, Section 280-15 and the Building Inspec- 116A(1)and Article XXIII Section 280- da[ed October 7, 2004, tocated at: 275 tor's Apri118,2016 Notice of Disapproval 124,and the Building Inspector's May 11, West Road,(adj.to G�tchogue Harbor) based on an application for building 2016 Notice of Disapproval based on an Cutchogue,NY SCI'M N 1000-110-7-11.1 permit to construct an accessory storage application foY a building peimit to con- ]�00 PM_. lV7'FIONY AND LLSA shed,at;l)more than the code permitted struct a new roof over an`as-built'front SANNINO N6882 — (Reopeaed on maximum lot coverage of 20%,2)acces- porch and new screened enclosures over 5/5/7A16 by unanimous Board resolution) sory storage shed proposed in other than existing rear deck attached to an exisHng Request for Variance under Article III the code required reaz yard,located at:15 single family dwelling,at;l)the proposed Code Sec[ion 280-13A(4)and the Build- Mitl Road,(adj.Mattituck Creek)Ivlatti- deck enclosure,`as builY front porch with ing Inspeccor's June 17,2A15,amended tuck,NY SCTM#1000-106-4-2 proposed roof is less thaa code required June 23,2015 Notice of Disapproval for a 9�'�1 A M (ADJOURNED FROM setback of]00 feet from the top of the building pemtit to construction of a win- MAY 19 2�16 SPECLAL MEEI7NG� bluff,l)less than the code required mini- ery/tasting room, at: 1) winery located 7AMF4 O'HAGEN M6945 - Applicant mum side yard setback of 10 feet,2)less on a parcel less than the code required requests a Special Exception under Ar- than the code required total side yazd set- minimum of at least 10 acres devoted to ticle III Section 280-13B(14).'Itie Appli- back of 25 feet,located at 160 Lakeview vineyard or other agricultural purposes, cant is the owner requesting authoriza- Terrace,E.Marion SCTM#1000-31:9-17 located aL•15975 County Route 48(aka tion to establish an Accessory Bed and 10�45 A M,-NEIL AND LORI KE- Middle Road) and 7495 Alvah's Lane � Breakfast, accessory and incidental to ARNS H696Z - Request for Variances .Cutchogue, NY. SCTM#1000-101-1-14.6 i the residential occupancy in this single- from Article XXIII Section 280-124 and &14.4 family dwelling,with four(4)bedrooms theBuildinglnspector'sApri15,2016No- 1•';0 Phi - (ADJOURNED FROM ; for lodging and serving of breakfast to tice of Disapproval based on an appGca- APRIL 2l 2016 SPECIAL MEET the B&B casual,transient roomers. L.o- tion for building permit for additions and INC;I—FRANK J and ELIZABETH G. cation of Property 1125 Windward Road alterations to an existing single family ICELLY q6946-This is a request under • Orient,NY. SCI'M#]000-14-2-30.1 dwelling,at;l)less than the code required Section 280-146D foc a Reversal of the v�ac a.M, - WICKHAM ROAD. minimum side yard setback of 20 feet, restriction on the length of watenraft LLC q6968-Reyuest for Variance from 2)less than the code reqdired total side permitted at the marina as listed in the Article X,Section 280-45A&C(2)and yard setback of 40 feet,located at:18075 Pre-CO #38052 issued 1/14I2016, prop- the Building Inspector's March 22,2016 Soundview Avenue,(adj.to Long Island erty located at:1900 Great Peconic Bay Notice of Disapproval based on an appli- Sound) Southold, NY SCTM#t000-51- Boulevard(adj.to Brushes Creek),Lau- cation for building permit to maintain an 1-8 rel,NY SCI'M#1000-145-0-3 apartment,l)existing apaztment without 11i)0 A M-GABRIEL AND KATH- 'Ihe Boazd of Appeals will hear all a principal use building,located at:12800 F.RINE ACRI 1i6966-Request for Vari- persons or their representatives, desir- 12oute 25,(NYS Route 25)Mattituck,NY arice from Article XXIII Section 280-124 ing to be heard at each hearing,and/or SCTM#1000-114-11-15 and the Building Inspector's April 27, desiring to submit written statements 10�10 A M.-BILL LIVANOS#6965 2016 Notice of Disapproval based on an before the oonctusion of each hearing. -Request for Variances&om Article III application for building permit for addi- Each hearing will not start earlier than Section 28a15 and the Building Inspec- tions and alterations to an e�sdng single designated above. Fles are available for a •n►r Tarvn a � 7� 1� � � � � The following application will be heard by the Southold Town Board of Appeals at Town Hall , 53095 Main Road, Southold: NAME : � SCTM # : _ _ _ VARIANCE : REVE RSAL O F REST RI CT 1 O N O F P RE-CO #38052 REQVEST: DAT E : T H V RS . MAY 5 2016 11 : 30 AM � � If you are interested in this project, you may review the file(s) prior to the hearing during normal business days between 8 AM and 3 PM. ZON I NG BOARD OF APPEALS-TOWN OF SOUTHOLD 765-1809 ZG�.��+IG BOARD OF APPEALS MAILING ADDRESS and PLACE OF HEARINGS: 53095 Main Road, Town Hall Building, P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971-0959 (631) 765-1809 Fax 765-9064 LOCATION OF ZBA OFFICE: Town Hall Annex at North Fork Bank Building, 1 st Floor 54375 Main Road and Youngs Avenue, Southold website: http://southtown.northfork.net April 11, 2016 Re: Town Code Chapter 55 -Public Notices for Thursday, May 5, 2016 Hearing Dear Sir or Madam: Please find enclosed a copy of the Legal Notice describing your recent application. The Notice witl be published in the next issue of The Suffolk Times. 1) Before April 1 gtn: Please send the enclosed Legal Notice, with both a Cover Letter including your telephone number and a copy of your Survey or Site Plan (filed with this application) which shows the new construction area or other request, by CERTIFIED MAIL, RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED, to all owners of property (tax map with property numbers enclosed), vacant or improved, which abuts and any property which is across from any public or private street. Use the current owner name and addresses shown on the assessment rolls maintained by the Southold Town Assessors' Office, or Real Property Office at the County Center, Riverhead. If you know of another address for a neighbor, you may want to send the notice to that address as well. If anv letter is returned to you undeliverable vou are requested to make other attempts to obtain a mailing address or to deliver the letter to the current owner to the best of vour abilitv, and to confirm how arranqements were made in either a written statement or durinq the hearinq providing the returned letter to us as soon as possible; AND not later than April 25th: Please either mail or deliver to our office your Affidavit of Mailin (form enclosed) with parcel numbers, names and addresses noted, along with the green/white receipts postmarked by the Post Office. When the green signature cards are returned to you later by the Post Office, please mail or deliver them to us before the scheduled hearing. If any envelope is returned "undeliverable", please advise this of�ce as soon as possible. If any signature card is not returned, please advise the Board during the hearing and provide the card (when available). These will be kept in the permanent record as proof of all Notices. 2) Not Later April 27th: Please make arrangements to place the enclosed Poster on a signboard such as cardboard, plywood or other material, posting it at the subject property seven (7) days (or more) prior to hearing. (It is the applicant/agents responsibility to maintain sign until Public Hearing) Securely place the sign on your property facing the street, not more than 10 feet from the front property line bordering the street. If you border more than one street or roadway, an extra sign is supplied for posting on both front yards. Please deliver or mail your Affidavit of Postinq for receipt by our office before May 3, 2016. If you are not able to meet the deadlines stated in this letter, please contact us promptly. Thank -you for you� cooperation. (PLEASE-DISPLAY YOUR HOUSE NUMBER ALWAYS). - Very truly yours, Zoning Appeals Board and Staff Encls. Office Location: �o���F SO(/jyOlo Mailing,Address: Town Annex/First Floor,Capital One Bank 53095 Main Road 54375 Main Road(at Youngs Avenue) � � P.O. Box 1179 Southold,NY 11971 � � � Southold,NY 11971-0959 � � ���OUNTI,Nct� http://so utholdto w n.northfork.net BOARD OF APPEALS � �v�� � f� � L� 1111 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD D �S Tel. (631) 765-1809 Fax(631)765-9064 MAR 1 6 2016 J March 1, 2016 SoutholdTown Planning Board Mark Terry, Principal Planner LWRP Coordinator Planning Board Office Town of Southold Town Hall Annex Southold,NY 11971 Re: ZBA File Ref. No. # 6946 KELLY, Frank Dear Mark: We have received an application seeking for a reversal of the Building Inspector's restriction set forth in the Pre-Existing Certificate of Occupancy that limits the size of boats that can be docked to 20 feet. A copy of the Building Inspector's Notice of Disapproval under Chapter 280 (Zoning Code), and survey map, project description form, are attached for your reference. Your written evaluation with recommendations for this proposal, as required under the Code procedures of LWRP Section 268-SD is requested within 30 days of receipt of this letter. Thank you. Very truly yours, Leslie K. Weisman Chairpe on By: < <� ' r'� � � Office Location: �o��QF SO(�jyOlo Mailing Address: Town Annex/Fust Floor,Capital One Bank 53095 Main Road 54375 Main Road(at Youngs Avenue) � � P.O. Box 1179 Southold,NY 11971 �O • Q Southold, NY 11971-0959 � �y�OUNT`I,�c� h ttp://so utholdtow n.northfork.net BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Tel. (631) 765-1809 Fax(631)765-9064 March 16, 2016 Ms. Sarah Lansdale, Director Suffolk County Department of Planning P.O. Box 6100 Hauppauge, NY 11788-0099 Dear Ms. Lansdale : Please find enclosed the following application with related documents for review pursuant to Article XIV of the Suffolk County Administrative Code: ZBA File # 6946 Owner/Applicant : KELLY, Frank Action Requested: Seeking a reversal of the Building Inspector's restriction set forth in the Pre-Existing Certificate of Occupancy #38052 limiting the size of boats that can be docked to 20 feet. Within 500 feet of: ( ) State or County Road (X) Waterway (Bay, Sound, or Estuary) ( ) Boundary of Existing or Proposed County, State, Federal land. ( ) Boundary of Agricultural District ( ) Boundary of any Village or Town If any other information is needed, please do not hesitate to call us. Thank you. Very truly yours, Leslie K. Weisman ZBA airperson B : t c������ Y Encls. BOARD MEMBERS OF $Q� Southold Town Hall Leslie Kanes Weisman,Chairperson �0�� ryQ�O 53095 Mam Road•P.O.Box 1179 Southold,NY 11971-0959 Eric Dantes #t � Office Location: Gerard P.Goehnnger G Q Town Annex/First Floor,Capital One Bank George Horning �'� � ,�a�� 54375 Main Road(at Youngs Avenue) Kenneth Schneider l'`�'QU����v Southold,NY 11971 http://southoldtown.northfork.net ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Tel.(631) 765-1809 •Fax (631)765-9064 July 22, 2016 Dan Ross Attorney at Law PO Box 146 Mattituck,NY 11952 Re: ZBA File#6898 —Frank J. Kelly SCTM No. 1000-145-4-3 Dear Mr. Ross: Enclosed is a copy of the Zoning Board's July 21, 2016 determination filed today with the Town Clerk regarding your application. Since e , Kim . Fuentes Board Assistant Encl. CC: Building Department �__ _ / -- � . /� � �, /�� `�o�, w N291C81 �� �� y / p , ��F O� �/ 8 g �`a, �y / a J `'� $� // � ' � 9LF � p0 � W +1� � // \\.y+� 0 0,�0�.0 �,� � 6 9 /� a / � '�y�� � � ey: �a s /� `,, ?'�` `' ' �� s�'d '� � 'v^°�Si ��$" ,y, e ,j a'/ �T ,^N^ d� �• '« ,�. . °' ArO� .,6 i+ ��B ' . L `` 8 � •e^` 1 � � �,��A� '" ",' ,.� 9i ' �� � . , �. �� , v /O� cP . � a w /�.' �,5 fO .� ' p� � .�a� ` ,� '�� s?l `�8 � � Q ' ,f � P ` �i ��' �o '9� ,� °� , ( � �c � ���0 , � `�`DJ ` O� `� e, '"" /e� '♦ � �2'� `,y a • a� �p � M1 � �'� �',�� �. i '� � 4 '. r' o �^ oP g . � ��\. , `^�. � g y .�:� �1 � � �, .\A` \ '+. 2 � �� � ��s 4 s� �O 3 11 ^� � �ti�o� m � � � `�' o ` ,- ` � 1� �''�` '� /q 1 ` 10 � '�-"'_ L� � � .� �� � . � � m .� a� + s a �� \ �� '9 `f No 1'�� �g db � q ,p �A yp \\ � `�� wMl� � )) // � �� 'l, 4� � � / ) I W � 1� � �� . 4 ¢• / ,9 /�\/ I �� �+.. � 10 ��Nix) ! � �'� / � � �� � a-- i `�s= �-3 /� y �" P /' � �111,GC l 'l/l.� � a .� /- u , !a�-�-�3 �. � � �� - c� - �. l � 14-s - �- - `f � �c- y� -- � o�`° Q�G N 1B9 SB1 K ��� 1B SOUTHOLD SECTION NO NOTICE ��„� COUNTY OF SUFFOLK OC E *ow�oF NMiD MrIINiENTNCE,ALTERATION,SALEOfl � � Real Property Tax Service Agency v �. ,� �«�E°F 145 oiSiR�eu7iOn 0�nnv POR7iON OF inE ' County Center Riverhead,N Y 11901 ��a SIIFGOLKCOUnTYTAXMAPISPROHIBITE� �1 . � M SCALE IN FEET tMTMOUTWRITTENPERMIS510NOFTME ��� �40 0 �� � A t DISTRICTNO 'IOOO � aEaivrtoaEarv��ucsEmncEncErvcr '1`qf� P �acm PROPERTYMAP CONVERS�ONOATE Aug08 Nt2