HomeMy WebLinkAbout4492�r
APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS
Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman
Serge Doyen
James Dinizio, Jr.
Lydia A. Tortora
BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
Southold lbwn Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax(516)765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1809
FINDINGS, DELIBERATIONS AND DETERMINATION
REGULAR MEETING OF OCTOBER 9, 1997
Appl. #4492 - WALTER KLEIN PARCEL 1000-43-1-8
STREET & LOCALITY: 3235 Manhanset Avenue, Greenport
DATES OF PUBLIC HEARINGS: July 10, 1997; August 14, 1997;
September 25, 1997 (final hearing).
FINDINGS (PROPERTY FACTS):
DESCRIPTION: This property is located in an R-40 Residential Zone
District, being situate along the north side of Manhanset Avenue,
Greenport, and along the west side of a private right-of-way
referred to as "Gull Pond Road." This lot contains a total area of
6,821.29 sq. ft. and is improved with a 1-1/2 story frame, single-
family dwelling with sunroom, the "as built" deck in question, and
"as built" accessory frame garage also in question.
BASIS OF APPEAL: Building Inspector's Action of Disapproval dated
May 28, 1997, which reads as follows: "...under Article III -A,
Section 100-30A.4 Accessory structures are to be located in the
required rear yard and have a maximum height of 18 feet, or 17.5
feet confirmed by applicant ( - also see memo of Ed. Forrester).
Under Article IIIA, Section 100-30A.3 of the Bulk and Parking
Schedule, "as built" structures exceed the maximum allowable lot
coverage of 20% (at) approx. 24.25% or by 292 sq. ft. Deck
addition "as built" at 8.3 feet from setback ROW is in violation of
15 ft. minimum setback established by ZBA Appeals ruling of
June 12, 1975, #2045. Under Article IIIA, Section 100-30A.3
normal required setback from ROW is 35 feet...."
AREA VARIANCE RELIEF REQUESTED BY APPLICANT:
1. "As built" 576 sq. ft. accessory work -shop garage building,
substantially located in a front area facing a private right-of-way
to the east, with an "as built" nonconforming setback at 2.4 feet.
The height of this garage is confirmed by applicant's attorney to
meet the maximum 18 ft. height requirement (average mean height
code definition) .
2. "As built" deck addition to existing dwelling. Applicant
modified plan for consideration by removing 157 square feet of deck
area, located on the north and east of the sun room. The removal
of the deck area, as indicated on the revised survey dated Septem-
ber 17, 1997 prepared by Joseph A. Ingegno, will reduce the
existing lot coverage from approx. 24.24 feet percent to not greater
� s
Page 2, - October 9, 1997
Appl. #4492: 1000-43-1-8 (W. Klein)
Southold Town Board of Appeals
than 21 percent (exclusive of driveway and allowable 30 sq. ft. step
areas). The revised plan will also increase from 8 ft. 3 inches to
11 ft. 3 inches the setback of the remaining 6 ft. by 27 ft. 8 inch
deck to the right-of-way.
REASONS FOR BOARD ACTION, DESCRIBED BELOW:
(1) In considering this application, the board finds that the
revised plans submitted by the applicant and relief requested therein
are the minimum necessary and adequate and at the same time will
preserve and protect the character of the neighborhood, and the
health, safety and welfare of the community.
(2) The granting of the area variance will not produce an
undesirable change in character of neighborhood or a detriment to
nearby properties because the accessory garage has existed for more
than 15 years in its present location with no apparent ill affects on
the existing R.O.W. or surrounding properties. Removal of
approximately 50% of the existing deck area will decrease the degree
of nonconformity in relation to both lot coverage and setback from
the right-of-way.
(3) The benefit sought by the applicant cannot be achieved by some
method, feasible for applicant to pursue, other than an area variance
because the size of the lot is extremely small, 6821 square feet in
area, and there is insufficient land area in the required rear yard
to locate the accessory garage. A cost estimate submitted by Artco
Corp. to remove the garage was in excess of $10,000. Such
expense is unwarranted because the existing location of the garage
is of minimal significance.
(4) The requested area variance is substantial, however, the
applicant's revised plans reduce the degree of existing nonconformity
in lot coverage and deck setback to the right-of-way.
(5) The proposed variance will not have an adverse effect or impact
on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood or
district because the revised plan will be an improvement that will
reduce the degree of nonconformity.
(6) The situation has been self-created because the prior owner(s)
failed to comply with the terms and conditions set forth in the Board
of Appeals ruling #2045 dated June 12, 1975, and subsequent ruling
#2781 dated March 5, 1981.
RESOLUTION/ACTION: On motion by Member Tortora, seconded by
Chairman Goehringer, it was
RESOLVED, to GRANT the application as amended, SUBJECT TO
THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS:
1. The deck area comprised of 157 sq. ft. on the north and east
sides of the sun room shall be removed within 90 days, all in
Page 3 - October 9, 1997
Appl. #4492: 1000-43-1-8 (W. Klein)
Southold Town Board of Appeals
accordance with the revised survey dated September 17, 1997,
prepared by Joseph A. Ingengo, Surveyor. No building permit,
certificate of occupancy or other town entitlement shall be issued
until this condition has been met.
2. The garage shall only be used as a non -habitable accessory
structure. In no event shall it be connected to the principal
single-family residence, nor shall it be occupied or used as a
separate dwelling.
3. The garage shall not be expanded or replaced unless it is moved
to a conforming area.
4. Access to the private right-of-way shall remain open at all times
and there shall be no parking of vehicles within the right-of-way.
5. Grant of this variance supersedes all prior decisions of the
Board of Appeals.
6. These conditions shall be permanently attached to the certificate
of occupancy (C.O.), a copy of which shall be provided to the
Board of Appeals within six months.
AYES: VOTE OF THE BOARD: MEMBERS GOEHRINGER, DINIZIO,
and TORTORA. (Member Dent h s �cglution was
oyen
duly adopted (3-0). a / A
*****s**ssss***s**sss
Actions. all/43-1-8
... aaw awuuw
Approved for filing
I:LCHj✓ti� AND FILED BY
THE SOL L(_:LD TOWN CLERK
DATE /v�i"/s7 110UR/.'1'5-,P „`
Town Clerk, Town of Southold
APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS.,,,
Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman
Serge Doyen
James Dinizio, Jr.
ddkffkkM&ffl@@
Lydia A. Tortora
Maureen C. Ostermann
BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax (516) 765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1809
NOTICE OF HEARINGS
SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS
THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 25, 1997
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN, pursuant to Section 267 of the Town
Law and the Code of the Town of Southold, the following applications
will be held for public hearings by the SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF
APPEALS, at the Southold Town Hall, 53095 Main Road, Southold, New
York 11971, on THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 25, 1997 at the times noted
below (or as soon thereafter as possible):
6:45 p.m. Appl. No. #4506 - Application by Lillian J. Mulligan Estate.
This is a request for a Variance under Article IIIA, Section 100-30A.3,
based upon the August 5, 1997 Notice of Disapproval issued by the
Building Inspector regarding "as built" deck addition, disapproved on
the following grounds: "the deck addition "as built" will exceed
the maximum allowable lot coverage of 20 percent, or 1500 square feet.
The deck addition will increase the lot coverage to 1635 sq. ft. or
approximately 21.75 percent." Location of Property: 210 Third St.,
Laurel, NY; Parcel ID No. 1000-126-7-11. Also known as Lot 472 on
the Map of George I. Tuthill.
6:50 p.m. Appl.=1508.JI7 - Joseph Melly This is a request for a
Waiver under Article II, Sectiou 100-26 based upon the July 24, 1997
Notice of Disapproval by the Building Inspector issued oil the following
grounds: "...a non -conforming lot shall merge with an adjacent
Page - Legal Noti.,.:"
Southold Town Board of Appeals
Regular Meeting of September 25, 1997
conforming or non -conforming lot which has bee held in common
ownership with the first lot at any time after July 1, 1983. Lot
104-02-24 has merged with 104-02-23...." Location of Property:
1375 & 1475 Sterling Road, Cutchogue, NY; Parcel 41000-104-02-24 & 23.
7:00 p.m. Appl. 44501 - E. Nagy. (Continued from first hearing held
8/28/97). Waiver under Article II, Section 100-26 based upon the July 7,
1997 Notice of Disapproval of the Building Inspector stating two reasons:
(1) under Article II, Section 100-24A.(1) land area identified as
1000-27-4-2 and 1000-27-4-3 were created by deed in 1965 and do not
meet the minimum lot requirements (12,500 sf) and (2) under Article
II, Section 100-25A, total land area merger exists for 1000-27-4-1, 2
& 3 having been held in common ownership after July 1, 1983. Location
of Property: Harbor Road, Orient, NY. Applicant proposes 28,445 sq.
ft. of land area and 132.57 lot width as to 1000-27-4-3 & 2, and with a
remaining house lot of 20,000+- sf_ and lot width of 100 feet as to
1000-27-4-1. Zone District: R-40. (Schedule AA as revised .July 22,
1997 shows a size requirement for lots created between April 195; thru
November 1971 at 12,500 sq. ft. and 100 ft. lot width.)
7:10 p.m. Appl. #4492 - W. Klein. (Continued from 8/14/97).
This application is based upon the Building Inspector's ;41ay 28, 1997
Action of Disapproval, for building permits in the "as built" construc-
tion of accessory garage in an area other than the required rear yard
and deck addition with an insufficient front yard setback from private
right-of-way (easterly property line) and excessive lot coverage, at 3235
Page " - Legal Not
Southold Town Board of Appeals
Regular Meeting of September 25, 1997
Manhanset Avenue, Greenport, NY; 1000-43-1-8
Property size: 6821 sq. ft.
Zone: R-40.
7:25 p.m. Appl.
#4509.LT -
Tonyes Realty Corp.
d/b/a Southold
Automotive Corp.
This is an
application requesting
a Variance based
upon the August 13,
1997 Notice
of Disapproval of the
Building Inspector
in which applicant has applied for a permit to construct addition, an
alteration to existing gasoline station, which application was
disapproved for the following reasons: "...under Article XXIV, Section
100-243A, a nonconforming building with a nonconforming use shall not
be enlarged, reconstructed or structurally altered unless the use of the
building is changed to a conforming use. The preexisting building is
located in the Hamlet Business District and is not a permitted use in
this district. The side and rear yard setbacks do not conform to the
required 10 ft. side and 25 ft. rear yard...." Location of Property:
54360 Plain Road, Southold, NY; County Parcel ID 01000-61-4-23.
The Board of Appeals will at said time and place hear any and all
persons or representatives desiring to be heard in the above
applications. The above hearings will not start before the time
designated. Each file is available for review during regular business
hours (8-4 p.m.), and written comments may be submitted before that
hearing is concluded. If you have questions, please do not hesitate to
call 765-1809.
Dated: September 12, 1997. BY ORDER OF THE SOLTHOLD
TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS
GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, Chairman
By Linda Kowalski
x
FORM NO. 3
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
BUILDINGDEPART`ENT
SO THOLD, N -Y.
NOTICE OF DISAPPROVAL
ToPATRICIA-C,-MOORE, •ATTY_ _ _ . - _ . _ . _ bw4 : IArCEl pV
P.O- BOX 483 - 315 WESTPHALIA RD.
---------------- ---••-•---•-
,.c:MATTITUCK N_Y- 11952
_.... s ... .........................
;Uj , a a 17
DATE:
PLEASE TARE NOTICE that your application dated _ MCEMSI;R.S......... 19.94_._
for nermit to ."AS_BUILT"-ACCESSORY-GARAGE_?-DECK ADDITION .................... at
Location of Property __3235•MANHASSET• AVENUE ______________ GREENPORT.•H_Y:--- _
House No. Street Hamlet
County Tax Yap No. 1000 - Section ...43. ..... BLOC% LOT .... $_.......
Subdivision _______________________________ Filed Man No_ ......... Lot No_ .......
is returned 'herewith and disapproved on the following grounds _UNDER ARTICLE -III -A--••--_•-•
SECTION 100-30A.4 ACCESSORY STRUCTURES ARE TO BE LOCATED IN THE REQUIRED REAR YARD
.......................... -- •- ---•--•------•--•-•••-----_____--•-•----••----------••-
AND HAVE A MAXIMUM HEIGHTfOF 18 FEET (SEE MEMO FROM ED. FORRESTER). UNDER ARTICLE IIIA
........................... -..........................................................
_.__•.
SECTION 100-30A.3 OF THE BULK & PARKING SCHEDULE, "AS BUILT" STRUCTURES EXCEED THE
----------------------------------------------------`-•----...------.--.-.--.--
MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE LOT COVERAGE'OF 20% BY APROX. 24.25% OR 292 SQ. FT. DECK ADDITION
.................. -•--•--••••••••-•-.•..••••-........................
"AS BUILT" AT 8.3 FEET FROM SETBACK R.O.W. IS IN VIOLATION OF 15 FT. MINIMUM SETBACK
............................... ........ •---•-•.._...•••..................................
ESTABLISED BY Z.B.A. APPEALS RULING OF JUNE 12, 1975 12045.UNDER ARTICLE IIIA
................ .............................................. _.............................
SECTION 100-30A_3 NORMAL REQUIRED SET BACK FROM R_O.W- IS 35 FT_ ENCLOSED ARE
•-••...-••••••-..........................................................................
BACKRGROUND INFORMATIONAL PAPERS IN THIS MATTER.
............ -........... =•••••••••-•••••--••-•--....•=•••••-••----.._.•-••••••••••.___.__._.
ACTION REQUIRED BY THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS.
._--•..--•...._..•••-••...................•-•-•._..._.._._•.__..__._______.______-_____._._.
UILDING INSPECTOR
JOHN M. BOUFIS
RV ;/80
k Y
9�
a
N
N�
FORM NO. 3
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
BUILDINGDEPART`ENT
SO THOLD, N -Y.
NOTICE OF DISAPPROVAL
ToPATRICIA-C,-MOORE, •ATTY_ _ _ . - _ . _ . _ bw4 : IArCEl pV
P.O- BOX 483 - 315 WESTPHALIA RD.
---------------- ---••-•---•-
,.c:MATTITUCK N_Y- 11952
_.... s ... .........................
;Uj , a a 17
DATE:
PLEASE TARE NOTICE that your application dated _ MCEMSI;R.S......... 19.94_._
for nermit to ."AS_BUILT"-ACCESSORY-GARAGE_?-DECK ADDITION .................... at
Location of Property __3235•MANHASSET• AVENUE ______________ GREENPORT.•H_Y:--- _
House No. Street Hamlet
County Tax Yap No. 1000 - Section ...43. ..... BLOC% LOT .... $_.......
Subdivision _______________________________ Filed Man No_ ......... Lot No_ .......
is returned 'herewith and disapproved on the following grounds _UNDER ARTICLE -III -A--••--_•-•
SECTION 100-30A.4 ACCESSORY STRUCTURES ARE TO BE LOCATED IN THE REQUIRED REAR YARD
.......................... -- •- ---•--•------•--•-•••-----_____--•-•----••----------••-
AND HAVE A MAXIMUM HEIGHTfOF 18 FEET (SEE MEMO FROM ED. FORRESTER). UNDER ARTICLE IIIA
........................... -..........................................................
_.__•.
SECTION 100-30A.3 OF THE BULK & PARKING SCHEDULE, "AS BUILT" STRUCTURES EXCEED THE
----------------------------------------------------`-•----...------.--.-.--.--
MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE LOT COVERAGE'OF 20% BY APROX. 24.25% OR 292 SQ. FT. DECK ADDITION
.................. -•--•--••••••••-•-.•..••••-........................
"AS BUILT" AT 8.3 FEET FROM SETBACK R.O.W. IS IN VIOLATION OF 15 FT. MINIMUM SETBACK
............................... ........ •---•-•.._...•••..................................
ESTABLISED BY Z.B.A. APPEALS RULING OF JUNE 12, 1975 12045.UNDER ARTICLE IIIA
................ .............................................. _.............................
SECTION 100-30A_3 NORMAL REQUIRED SET BACK FROM R_O.W- IS 35 FT_ ENCLOSED ARE
•-••...-••••••-..........................................................................
BACKRGROUND INFORMATIONAL PAPERS IN THIS MATTER.
............ -........... =•••••••••-•••••--••-•--....•=•••••-••----.._.•-••••••••••.___.__._.
ACTION REQUIRED BY THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS.
._--•..--•...._..•••-••...................•-•-•._..._.._._•.__..__._______.______-_____._._.
UILDING INSPECTOR
JOHN M. BOUFIS
RV ;/80
lixruulued f?16..:......, 191
f U"M NO. i
TOWN OF SOUTNOI_D
BUILDING DEPARTMENT
TOWN IIALL
S001 -11O1-13, N.Y. 11971
TE I_.: 76511102
1102
Approved ......JJ... 19 ... Tenant[ NO........... .
Disniii '1.
roved a/c y ...........
J
7 SETS OF Pf..\IIS ..... .. .
SURVEY ...................
CHECK ....................
SEPTIC FARtI ............
It U'l I P Y i .70 . ? �.
CALL- ... rP ..
"AIL TU:
(Building Inspector)
APPLICATION FOIA BUILDINGPEIIMiT
Dale ............::.....19
INS'rI(UC'r1ONS
a. lids applicalimr oursl be arnpielely Hier! In by typewriter or In Ink and submitted to lire Building Inspector, with 3
sets of plans, accurate plot plan to scale. Fee according to schedule.
I). Plot plan showing location of lot and of buidhrgs on premises, relationship to ndjohring premises of public streets
or wrens; Find giving it detailed desmiplion of layout of propetly must be drawn on the diagram which is parr of [Ills nopli-
ca Bon.
c. 'rhe work covered by this application may not be amumeuced before Issuance of Building Permit,
d. Upon approval of this application, lie lhdk Ing inspector will issued a Iluilding Permit to the appltcaoL Such permit
shall be kept on the premises avatidde for Inspecllou Wroughoul the work.
e. No building shall be occupied or used in whole or In part for any purpose whnlever mdU a Cerlificnle of Occupnmcy
shall have been granted by the Building Inspector.
APPLICATION 1S IIGRGBY MADE. to We Ilutldiug Depariureot for We Issuance of a Building Perrnll pursuant to the.
Building Zone Dulivance of the 1'own of Southold, Suffolk County, New York, and other applicable Laws, Ordinances or
Regu6thi s, for We construcllun of buildings, additions or alterations, or for removal or demollllon, as herein described.
'rhe appBcanl agrees to comply whir ell applicable laws, Ordinances, buifriing c I rot ng code flip 1- egula(ions, and to
admil authorized Inspectors on preonises'and In building for necessary Irspec
�.........
(Signature of applicant, or nnune, if a corpornliun).. .
.O.O/'�a' x,/83 his Wts�oh�cCca %' Q
'titling address of applicant)
7- sip 2 -7
Stale whelher applicant is owner, lessee, agent, archilect, engineer, general contractor, elechicinu, plmober or builder.
.......................... ......... . .
Name of owner of plenlises /?.............................................. .
(as on the lax roll or blest deed)
U applicant is it corporation, signelure of duty aulhoriied officer.
...... ............. I...................
(Name and title of corporate officer)
Builder's License No.. I ...................... .
I'lumber's License No . ................. .
Llechictao's LicenseNo. ......................
O1her'rrade's License No.
i. Location of Inud on which proposed work will be dome . .......................... ..............:........
Ivor* 5fdf /tiar>hgl5ef �� Co/7br
.........................................
Il nese Number Slice( Ilaurlet
(!ounly'Fax Mar) No. 1000 Section .. .3.......:.... Block .... ............: Lot ..®8.... .
Subdivision ..................................... Filed h1ap No. .............. Lot ............. .
(Nance)
2. Slate existing use amJ occupancy of premises and Intended use and occupancy of proposed construction:
Amm
a. IxislugS+se gird uccupancy .�.. - "'� "^"�` ......... .
1).till ended use and occupancy ........................................ :............. ...............
3. Nalme of work (check which applicaole): New Building .... , ..... Addition .......... Alteration ......... ,.
Repair ...........:.. Removal .............. Demolition .............. Other Works ....:.. .
t"f)escriplion)
4. Estinuded Cost ...................................... Fee ..........
(lo be paid on fling this applicallon)
5. if dwelling, number of dwelling units ............... Number of dwelling units on each Hoerr ................
Ifgamge, number of cars.......................................................... 1 .............
6. If business, commercial or mixed occupancy, specify nature and extent of enc, type of use .....................
7. Dimendous of existing situctures, If any: Front ............... Rear .............. Depth ...............
fleighl............... Nnmherorstories ........................................................
Mansions of same slruchire, with nUmallons or additions: Front Rear ..... . ........... .
Depth ...................... height ................. , .... Number of Stories ...................... .
8. Dimensions of entire new cooshucllon: Front ................ Rear ............... Depth ...............
Height ............... Number of Stories........................................................
9. Size of lot: Front ....... ....... ..:... ... Rear...................... Depth ......................
M. Dale of PmAinse ............................. Name of Former Owner .............................
11. 'Lone Onto dish let in which premises are Muffled ........... ......................................... .
12. Does proposed conslrucflon viclule any zoning Inw, ordinnnee or reguin(ton: ................................
13. Will lot be regraded ...:........................ Will excess fill be removed from promises: Yes No
K Nnnne of Owner of premises .4 .................. Address ................... Phone No. .............. .
Nome of Architect ........................ . .. Address Phone No. ....... ; .
Name of Cootrnclor ... :...... ........... I . I .. Address ................... Phone No............... .
15. In this property within 300 feet of a tidal wetland? *Yes........ No.........
*If yes, Southold Town Trustees Permit may be required.
PLOT DIAGRAM
Locale clearly null dls(Inclly all buildings, whether existing or proposed, and. Indicate all set -back dimensions front
properly lines. Give street and block number or description according to dead, and show street names and Indicate whether
inledor or cornerlot.
pant
1 C.
S'I'A'l F OF ItIM YOItK, S -S
COONI'Y OF :. '5.v-fFV./X:.... .
L� ..........
(Nnme of Individual signing conlrnef)
1 I
I
FLV411
being duly sworn, deposes mut says Hill[ lie Is Iiia appliennt
a lova name .
Ile is fife .... .:...... .... ....
4........... .....
(Conlraclor, agent, corporate of(icer, etc.)
of said owner or owners, and Is duly authorized to perform or have performed the said work and Igmske and HE this
applienlion; (lift( of sialemesis contained In This nppllcation are one to the best of his knowledge and belief, and Ihn( life
work will be par for filed In life stunner set forth In the applicallon filed therewith.
Sworn to before me this
KINN. .........day of ..1 UOV, �M3� /? ...., 19
Notary Public, 4#-�r4 .� •... �"Comfy
. MARGARET0.gl1TK0v,::..1
Notary Public Sl&!e.:f iC'sr "or!< ...:..... ......... ...................... . .
No. 445257
puatified in $001'A Coen/ (Signnhtre it(nppllcnn l )
Commission E&frs Jugs 3.74_ -
1. d:`...' ..
Town Clerk Southold
TOWII Or SOU11101.1), NEW YORK
APPEAL FROM DECISION OE OUILDIh.IG It•15118CfTOR
TO TI IE ZONING BOARD Or APPEALS, TOWN Or SOU Tl IOLD, N. Y.
APPEAL HO.
DATE ....: �°%.....
1, (We) ..W.alter:..Kledn...................................of .... 3235 ... Manhass:et...A.ve.............................
Name of Appellant Sheet and hlarnber
Greenport, Town of Southold NY
................................................................................................. ........................ IIFREBY APPEAL TO
Municipality Stole
r '
TI IE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS FROM TI IE DECISION 01: II IE OUII-DING INSPECTOR Ohl
APPLICATIOhi FOR PERMIT MO . .................................... DATED ...12/6f 96..,and„.�f.27..l.�.Z......
WIIEIIE13Y THE BUILDING IhISPFCTOR DENIED TO
Patricia C. Moore, Attorney
. .............. ..... ........ --- ............ ........ ......
Ihlorne of AppBcarnl for pennif '
of P.O.Box 483 315,: West
................................. .. Rkla] 7 a:..Rsi..,Mattituck..IIY...L1-952........
Street and Number Municipality Slott;
(x ) PFRMIT To USE "as built” accessory garage & Deck addition
( ) PERMIT POR OCCUPANCY
1. LOCATION Or THE PROPERTY ,-3235 Manhasset Ave,.�...•LIse.R .4Q.::
Street /Naiiiiel District on Zoning Map
District 1000 Section 43 Block Lot 8 Walter Klein
......._........._.._...._..._. _... ............--furrent Owner
Wo -p- No. 'Lot Flo. Prior Owner D'Aquisto
2. PROVISION (5) OF TICE ZONING ORDINANCE APPEALED (fndicule ilia Article Section, Sub-
section and Parograpli of Ilia Zoning Ordinance by number. Do not quola Ilia Ordhronce.)
Article IIIA 'Section 100-30A.3
3. -TYPE Or. APPEAL Appeal is mode herewiti, for (please check appropriate box)
( A VARIANCE fo the Zoning Ordinance or Zonbrq Map
( ) A VARIANCE clue it) lock of access (State of New York Town Low Chap, 62 Cans. Lows
Art. 16 Sec. 200A Subsection 3
( )
A. PREVIOUS APPEAL A previous appeal O+ns) IiT44xii been mode Willi respect to Ibis (lecisiatr
of the Building Inspector or wilir respect to this properly,
Such appeal was ( ) request for a special perrnll
( X) request for a vorionce
and was made in Appeal Ho. 2.0.4.5 (June 12t�r}t�r�5.).. and. Appeal.. No.. 2781 (3�.$,[,$1')
REASON FOR APPEAL
( ) A Variance to Section 200A Subsection 3
( X) A Variance to ilia ZorJng Ordfnorrce
Is requested for ilia reason tial
The existing garage and deck (on grade) was built by the prior owner
who was denied a variance, however the garage and deck remained. The
deck is a minimum encroachment needed for access from the rear door.
The garage was used by a world famous guitar maker and is a cultural
Toren ZBI
(ConRnue an other side)
landmark. The removal of the garage would be not only a financial
hardship to -the present owner', but a destruction of a cultural landmark
for Southold Town.
Reason for Appeal Continued
Zoning Board of Appeals
re: Walter Klein
Pursuant to Town Law section 267b-3 the Southold Town Zoning
Board of Appeals is to analyze and assess the personal benefits
anticipated by the applicant against the potentially deleterious
effects that a grant of the relief requested would have on the
health, safety and welfare of the effected neighborhood or
community. In performing this balancing test, the Zoning Board is
charged with the responsibility to consider the five factors
enumerated in Town Law Section 267b -3(b). The variance should be
granted for the following reasons:
1. No undesirable change will be produced in the character of the
neighborhood or a detriment to nearby properties, if the variance
is granted. The property is very small, triangular shaped and is
burdened by a right of way. The residence was located on the
parcel pursuant to a variance (Appeal No. 2045) which stated that
"the house shall be located no closer than 10 feet to the westerly
side line, and no closer than 15 feet to the easterly side line."
The house complies with the ZEA decisions but the deck is set back
8.3 from the easterly property line and results in a lot coverage
of 24.25% or -292 sq. ft. over the required lot coverage. The
property is not level and the deck extends from the year door
access which is approximately two feet above grade to the front
yard which is at grade. The decking is used as a platform and
walkway, and is in character with the rustic style of the house and
seasonal dwellings.
2. With regard to the Garage, the garage was built pursuant to a
building permit by the prior owner, James D'Aquisto. The survey
did not disclose a right of way, therefore the building permit was
revoked. A subsequent zoning appeal by D'Aquisto (Appeal No. 2781)
was denied on March 5,1981. The garage has remained on the
property in violation to date. The setback of the garage is
burdened by a front yard setback on a very small parcel. The lot
is only 6,821 sq. ft. Pursuant to Section 100-33, if the right of
way were not there the set back required would be only three (3)
feet in a lot which is less than 20,000 sq. ft., therefore only a
.6 foot variance would be required. The garage can not be out
back, to demolish this structure would be unreasonable and a
financial hardship.
The previous owner, D'Aquisto became a world famous guitar maker
who used the garage as his studio. Anything associated with
D'Aquisto is prized. This structure will become a cultural
landmark in the music world, the garage already attracts visitors
to the property. The benefit sought by the applicant can not be
achieved by some method, feasible for the applicant to pursue,
other than an area variance.
3. The area variance is substantial because of the front yard
setback requirement of 35 feet, however, the garage has no impact
on the adjacent property or the right of way. Construction of a
new garage located 35 feet from the right of way would result in a
violation of the westerly sideyard. Moreover, a large utility pole
is located east of the garage, within the legal right of way, which
creates a physical barrier and obstructs the right of way. The
application of the balancing test weighs in favor of the grant of
the variance.
4. The variance will have no adverse effect or impact on the
physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood or
district. This property is well screened with overgrown vegetation.
The properties in this neighborhood are routinely the subject of
variances because of the small lot sizes, the purpose of this
appeal is to maintain this property with the as built structures.
5. The alleged difficulty was not self-created. when the Kleins
became aware of the zoning problem they were prohibited from
seeking a variance prior to the purchase of the house. The
D'Aquisto Estate was selling the property "as is" and the Kleins
were forced to choose to go forward with the sale or risk loss of
their down payment. They chose to go forward and hope that the ZBA
would appreciate their situation.
6. The variance requested is the minimum variance practicable
given the personal benefits anticipated by the applicant.
We respectfully request that the appeal be granted, together with
any further relief that is deemed necessary and reasonable.
signature
State of New York )
)ss
County of Suffolk )
Sworn to this -3 40 day of June, 1997
MARGARETC. RUTKOVVSKI
Notary Public, Slate of New York
No.4982528
Qualified in Suffolk County 4q
Commission Expires June 3.19-2 7
TOWN OF 5 uTHOLD► il-olOPERTY RECORD CARCO
.zf�
OWNER
STREET _ '1 X'"
VILLAGE
.
SUB. LOT
fICR.
FORMER OWNER
N
E /� 7 y-�c,
10r lv
tl
/r d i� //ter
S W rYPE OF BUILDING
0 c1 h ha piQ 7 Ve d F Lh 9f
RES, '�f)
SEAS.
VL FARM COMM. CB. MICS, Mkt. Value
LAND
IMP.
TOTAL DATE REMARKS i� i --
Sr9S,:J ___—__
/1 0.12-
__.___—__._
----
__L �n ' �_— / •�Q %� •✓'Q/— UQQr V �U/hll�oV/ �..z
7-d /7,4
oVr e
JVD)
— --
2666
--
c n
3
�Z%Od
> UZJ Sj�o� �l`tl n snLp �S2 Soo L LLfay4[
r
c
'54?.a
���U.�?
j�U S_ 2- / 1/ s_//L 62 (c� �_/oyiG� 1�'_�1 pian° la��' C �`: r>o
<�`T�saC� L
BUILDING CONDITION
AGE
NEW
NORMAL
.... _..... ........ _ ...... _ .. ._ _._.._ .._ ,._ .___-...... .._._.------------------_----
BELOW ABOVE
I ARM
Acre
Value Per VQlue
Acre
tillable
FRONTAGE ON WATER
Noodland
FRONTAGE ON ROAD,- '
Veadowland
DEPTH 1 1l
-louse Plot
BULKHEAD
C'otal
i
`' `'
DOCK
on
COLOR A'a
0 0 d TRIM
416e
S,
= �13
J-41
Both
Dinette
-------------
Floors 411, tO (I Q U1 K
Interior Finish Wa LR.
I -feat
-DR.
rc
Rooms 1st Floor
Rooms 2nd Floor FIN. 13
Driveway
Foundation
rsh
Basement
)rch-
4' 7� i
�'�
Ext. Wells
reezewoy
Fire Place
Drage)
Type Roof
ZINO
Recreation
B.
Dormer
0 0 d TRIM
416e
S,
= �13
J-41
Both
Dinette
-------------
Floors 411, tO (I Q U1 K
Interior Finish Wa LR.
I -feat
-DR.
rc
Rooms 1st Floor
Rooms 2nd Floor FIN. 13
Driveway
( A ,r' u cf R '57- ) _ a P/7.. / � 6,9- , , . fir_ n. , —0/7")
r
9.cY /LK. vo fig K'j/a.`-�V.�v� r -,-v Alm 13
Xy A
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD PROPERTY RECORD CARD
OWNER
STREET C
.
VILLAGE
DIST, SUB. LOT
V
� Lf, ,��,�,.� '��/.�{�✓": rid/
FORMER O NER
�/({ (, i f r..., /)t•'�'�', G.....
N
(c v._
��lf CF' rh
E
V,
J2SC—
ACR. I
G_�,��-�_�,L.' ��r ,,''�.a�-9:j"
S
W '
��:�G1�=--
TYPE OF BUILDING
RES. o2�b
LAND
SEAS.
IMP.
___r�_.4�UX/ll'V_1ri�_�'�J`41t✓AP'_
VL.
TOTAL
FARM _
DATE
_ _—
COMM. CB. MISC. Mkt. Value
REMARKS 5 % S
� n
—3—o"
AGE
BUILDING CONDITION�-
NEW
NORMAL
BELOW ABOVE
FARM
Acre
Value Per
Acre
Value
Tillable I
-
Tillable 2
Tillable 3
Woodland
Swampland
FRONTAGE ON WATER
`
Brushfand
FRONTAGE ON ROAD
House Plot
DEPTH
BULKHEAD
Total
DOCK
M, Bldg. 4)
Extension
Extension
Extension
Porch
Porch
Breezeway
Garage
Patio
0. B.
Total
COLOR
TRIM
��nclolion C Both Dinf,
Basementtit1
Floors K.
Ext. Walls Interior Finish S:,qk4 7 /C LR.
Fire Place Heat DR.
lu
Type Roof Rooms -'-t Floor SR.
Recreation Room Rooms 2nd Floo FIN.
Dormer
Driveway
V
F
coN� D
. "Ok
N/0/F
MARIAN E. REINFURT
N 84750')50" E
�� Qn
d, QNE
C �" a •• 90
qAo
(A�-tfOg£
- �To OF
[ ° ° •� .
c
Y /
SURVEY OF PROPERTY
SITUATED AT
GREENPORT
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
SUFFOLK COUNTY, NEW YORK
S.C. TAX No. 1000-43-01 —08
1 SCALE 1"=20'
APRIL 9, 1997
SEPTEMBER 17, 1997 SHOW PORTION OF DECK TO BE REMOVED
TOTAL LOT AREA = 6,821.29 sq. ft.
0.157 ac.
LOT COVERAGE DATA
DESCRIPTION
AREA
% LOT COVERAGE
DRIVEWAY
931 sq. ft.
13.64%
DECK
167 sq. ft.
2.45%
HOUSE & SUN ROOM
756 sq. ft.
11.08%
GARAGE
576 sq. ft.
8.44%
CER TIFIED TO:
WALTER KLEIN
UNATHORIZED ALTERATION OR ADDITION
TO THIS SURVEY IS A VIOLATION OF
SEC11ON 7209 OF THE NEW YORK STATE
EDUCATION LAW.
COPIES OF THIS SURVEY MAP NOT BEARING
THE LAND SURVEYOR'S INKED SEAL OR
EMBOSSED SEAL SHALL NOT BE CONSIDERED
TO BE A VALID TRUE COPY.
CERTIFICATIONS INDICATED HEREON SHALL RUN
ONLY TO THE PERSON FOR'WHOM THE SURVEY
IS PREPARED, AND ON HIS BEHALF TO THE
TITLE COMPANY, GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY AND
LENDING INSTITUTION LISTED HEREON, AND
TO THE ASSIGNEES OF THE LENDING INSTI-
TUTION. CERTIFICATIONS ARE NOT TRANSFERABLE.
THE EXISTENCE OF RIGHTS OF WAY
AND/OR EASEMENTS OF RECORD, IF
ANY; NOT SHOWN ARE NOT GUARANTEED.
PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE MINIMUM
STANDARDS FOR TITLE SURVEYS AS ESTABLISHED
BY TLI S. AND APPROVED AND ADOPTED
FORHETHE NEW YORK STATE LAND
N.Y.S. Lic. No. 49668
Joseph A. Ingegno
Land Surveyor
Title Surveys — Subdivisions — Site Plans — Construction Layout
PHONE (516)727-2090 Fax (516)722-5093
OFFICES LOCATED AT MAILING ADDRESS
One Union Square P.O. Box 1931
Aquebogue, New York 11931 Riverhead, New York 11901
— 1 U0_ 1
09/.22/1987 14:25 5164745gF9 PORT JEFF HEALTHCARE PAGE 01
. Port
Jefferson
FAX # ' CP 6- r
DARK HOLLOW ROAD
PORT JEFFERSON, NY 11777
(516) 473-5400
FAX: (516) 473-5402
DATE:_ / /
TO:
ATTN:
FROM: Social or Services _Ve'1a�c?s,l
RE: IGho a4 -7-'1019#1
MESSAGE: _
g12Y (9-7
Documents including this cover sheet..
IF YOU DO NOT RECEIVE ALL OF THIS TRANSMITTAL
PLEASE CALL: (516) 473-5400 EXTENSION 530
OUR FAX PHONE NUMBER IS: (516) 474-5362
CONMgSEAL COMMUNICATION
This transmission is intended only for the individual or entity to which it is addressed, and may contain
information that is privileged, confidential and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If the reader
of this communication is not the intended recipient, or it is intended recipient you are notified that any
dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this
communication in error, please notify the sender immediately by telephone and return the original
communication to us at the above address by the U.S. Postal Service. Thank you.
SW/,FAXCOV
LS/la A DIVISION OF GLEN -HAVEN RESIDENTIAL HEALTH CARE FACT M .
1
r•
it
.i
.. .. , , .. ( •,..`• .. .. : • r :^I - r : - > - in " f: .4r'. -
SURVEY O.F.: PROPER:TY,:::
N/O/F e� SI TU A.''D ' A T
-71
INFURT.°
MARIAN E••xEj , a GREEN.PORT
8
4.5050 E o. TOWN . OF' .SOUTHOLD
N35.80'
SUFFOLK COUNTY, NEW YORK
�'
•'d• S:C.. TAX, No.:..�1000—.43=01=08.
mo � <
A \ o
`�a r SCAL' E 1"= —20'
to
Q) �� z �,�� APTIL 9, 1997
2�. } 8, o
O 14N�°
^ , c" �p TOTAL LOT AREA = 6,821.29 sq. ft.
0.157 ac.
o •
c�� I ?�e / rr1 I' LOT COVERAGE D,4TA ;
O
WOODAIR
�\ y c i p
F
Cpa\
N� p
"PA!
�ONF
4. a° °
.a
e e, 4A
�V'd
d
CERTIFIED T0:
WALTER KLEIN
DESCRIPTION
AREA
% LOT COVERAGE
DRIVEWAY
931 sq. it.
13.64%
DECK
324 sq. ft.
4.75%
HOUSE & SUN ROOM
756 sq. ft.
11.08%
GARAGE
576 sq. ft.
8.44%
UNATHORIZED ALTERATION OR ADDITION
TO THIS SURVEY IS A VIOLATION OF
SECTION 7209 OF THE NEW YORK STATE
EDUCATIONLAW.
COPIES OF THIS SURVEY MAP NOT BEARING
THE LAND SURVEYOR'S INKED SEAL OR •
EMBOSSED SEAL SHALL'NOT BE CONSIDERED
TO BE A VALID TRUE COPY. .
�p UWD
�ti�c'�r,QN A. �
N .
0.4 6 COQ`
•:N.Y.S. - Lic. No. • 49668•
Jose 'h A: In a no j
p ,_ : •g
:Land Surve.yor. :: f
Title Surveys - Subdivisions — Site Plans — .Constivction Layout
PHONE (516)727-2090 Fax •.(516),722-5093
OFFICES LOCATED AT AOLING'•ADDRESS'
One Union Square P.O.' Box -1931.
Aquebogue,' New •York 11931 Riverhead, New York, 11901{.`
PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE MINIMUM
STANDARDS FOR TITLE SURVEYS AS ESTABLISHED
BY THE LIALS. AND APPROVED, .AND ADOPTED,
FOR SUCH USE BY THE NEW YORK STATE LAND
TITLE ASSOCIATION.
CERTIFICATIONS INDICATED HEREON SHALL RUN
ONLY TO THE, PERSON FOR WHOM THE SURVEY
IS PREPARED.. AND ON HIS BEHALF TO THE
TITLE COMPANY,'GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY AND
LENDING INSTITUTION'-- USTED . HEREON, AND
TO THE ASSIGNEES OF THE LENDING INSTI-
TUTION. CERTIFICATIONS ,ARE ' NOT TRANSFERABLE,
THE EXISTENCE OF RIGHTS OF WAY,
AND/OR EASEMENTS OF RECORD. IF
ANY, NOT SHOWN ARE NOT GUARANTEED.
APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS
Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman
Serge Doyen
James Dinizio, Jr.
*X.0 AjjTcLrtorbstermann
Patricia C. Moore, Esq.
P.O. Box 483
Mattituck, NY 11952
�O��SOFFO(�coG
o ?�
CO3 Z
oy�
BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
September 15, 1997
Re: W. Klein - Variance Requests
Dear Mrs. Moore:
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax (516) 765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1809
This will confirm that the public hearing on your variance
application will continue on Thursday, September 25, 1997 at 7:10
P -m -
As soon as may be possible, please forward six copies of the
anticipated amendments which were discussed for the deck alteration,
reduced setback for the deck and reduced lot coverage. y-- }N
Also, please forward a copy of the changes directly to Mr. and Mrs.
Nicholas Durka in the essence of saving time for reviews prior to the
9/25 hearing. Thank you. C \
Very truly yours,
Linda Kowalski, Clerk
Board of Appeals
cc: Mr.. and Mrs. Nicholas Durka (./, -- )
�PPEALS BOARD MEMBERS
Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman
Serge Doyen
James Dinizio.. Jr. _
Lydia A. Tortora
Maureen C. Ostermann
Patricia C. Moore, Esq.
P.O. Box 483
Mattituck, NY 11952
BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
September 4, 1997
Re: Appl. No. 4492 - Walter Klein Variances
Dear Mrs. Moore:
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax (516) 765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1809
As confirmed earlier by telephone, the public hearing on the
above application will continue on September 25, 1997_ The time is
expected to be 7:00 p.m. and will be confirmed with you once the
agenda and legal notice have been finalized.
In the interim, please furnish seven copies of the new sketch
showing the anticipated amendment of the deck area, with the
proposed reduced setbacks. Thank you.
Very truly yours,
Linda Kowalski
Board Secretary
cc: Mr. and Mrs. Nicholas Durka
ZBA Chairman and Members
.......................... ................... .......... ............. ..:........ TRANSMISSION RESULT REPORT ......... ......o...(SEP 15 '97 09 36AM)..................
S( TOLD TOWN HALL 516 765 1823
.................. ......................... ................. ......................................... ...:........................................................................ . ( AUTO ) ......................
DATE START REMOTE TERMINAL TIME RE— MODE TOTAL PERSONAL LABEL FILE
TIME IDENTIFICATION SULTS PAGES NO.
SEP 15 09:31AM 2985664 01'18" OK S 02 002
.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................
E)ECM >)REDUCTION S)STANDARD M)MEMORY C)CONFIDENTIAL #)BATCH
D)DETAIL $)TRANSFER
F)FINE P)POLLING
A UG - 1 2-97 TUE 14 34"
PATRICIA C. -MOORE
BY FAX.
AugUat 12, 1997
Southold Town Zoning Board. -of Appeals
3outhold.Town Hall
Main Roast
Southoldi-HY 11971
Re:. Variance Application of Walter Klein
Dear Linda:
I am in receipt of your metro to ties . Zoning Board regarding
Mrs. Durka's request for an adjournment of the Klein hearing from
August 14, 1997 to the September sc:hodaxle.
Please be advised that Mr. and Mrs. Klein reluctantly consent
to an adjournment of thsir hearing to 5epptezber 25th. The Xl.eins
want the Board to know that this adZ4u3rl±imant poses a great
inconvenience to the Kleins. Mr. and Mrs. Klein work in Arizona.
Mrs. Klein is a flight attendant and uorked all month in order to
enable Mr. and Mrs. Klein to attend the August 14th hearing date.
. We appreciate Mr. Durka's medical condition and wish him .a
spay recovery, but ask the Board to :earls September 11th the final
adjournment.
Please place this matter on . your September 25th-hei�riinq -
calendar. Thank you.
very truly yours,
Patricia C. Moore
F�Zmr
315 wevhali® Roiul .
P.O. lions X48]
52
Mstti4wk. Ncw York 11952
'pct: (s16)291i-29
'AUG 217
FOX: (5 16) 298,W4
BY FAX.
AugUat 12, 1997
Southold Town Zoning Board. -of Appeals
3outhold.Town Hall
Main Roast
Southoldi-HY 11971
Re:. Variance Application of Walter Klein
Dear Linda:
I am in receipt of your metro to ties . Zoning Board regarding
Mrs. Durka's request for an adjournment of the Klein hearing from
August 14, 1997 to the September sc:hodaxle.
Please be advised that Mr. and Mrs. Klein reluctantly consent
to an adjournment of thsir hearing to 5epptezber 25th. The Xl.eins
want the Board to know that this adZ4u3rl±imant poses a great
inconvenience to the Kleins. Mr. and Mrs. Klein work in Arizona.
Mrs. Klein is a flight attendant and uorked all month in order to
enable Mr. and Mrs. Klein to attend the August 14th hearing date.
. We appreciate Mr. Durka's medical condition and wish him .a
spay recovery, but ask the Board to :earls September 11th the final
adjournment.
Please place this matter on . your September 25th-hei�riinq -
calendar. Thank you.
very truly yours,
Patricia C. Moore
F�Zmr
r
1
)4 Ju �`� %�.�X77-�00�
u ,/
cot-
--� � C�,' -/�, /��'�� azo
�- 7,
I r 0 IAD
Port
Jefferson
Cane Fac
August 8, 1997
DARK HOLLOW ROAD
PORT JEFFERSON, NY 11777
(516) 473-5400
FAX: (516) 473-5402
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179 Re: Appeal No.:449591- Variances OX. Klei ,,Property)
Southold, New York 11971
Atten: Linda Kowalski
Dear Ms. Kowalski:
Mr. Nicholas Durka was admitted to Port Jefferson Health.Care Facility on August 1, 1997 for
medically necessary reasons: Discharge is anticipated, in approximately four weeks.
LS/la
Durka.ltr
Sincerely,
Leslie Saren, Director
Social Wclrk- Services
A DIVISION OF GLEN -HAVEN RESIDENTIAL HEALTH CARE FACILITY
APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS
Southold Town Hall'
Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman
��` °yam, 53095 Main Road
`1179
Serge Doyen
; " P.O. Box
James Dinizio, Jr.
COD=
Southold, New. Yotk" 11971
gift "'Womem-1
Fax (5.16) 765-1823.
. Lydia A. Tortora
O! ��� Telephone (516) 765-1809
Maureen C. Ostermanii
BOARD OF APPEALS
' TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
July 29, 1997
"`- Mr. and Mrs. Nicholas Durka - — -
530 Angler Road
Greenport, NY 11944 -
Re: Appeal No. 4492
- Variances (W. Klein Property)
Dear Mr. and Mrs. Durka:
This will confirm that
the hearing on the above application has
been postponed for a continuation on Thursday, August 14, 1997 at
7:00 p.m. at the Town
Hall (Court/Meeting Room), Main Road,
Southold, New York.
:. .
Additional information
was added to the file' by the applicant'
since the original July 10,
1997 „hearing. If you wish to stop by our:
office, the file is available for your review at .a time convenient
" for you (during regular
business hours. Monday through Friday
between 8 and 4 p.m.) .
If you have any questions, please call us.
Very truly yours,
Linda Kowalski
Board Secretary
Enclosure (8/14 agenda)
Port
Jefferson
H
FAX &'S
m
MESSAGE:
RK HOLLOW ROAD
JEFFERSON, NY 11777
(516) 473-5400
\X: (516) 473-5402
DATE:
TIME:
Documents including this cover sheet. \.
IF YOU DO NOT RECEIVE ALL OF THIS TR
et�rn53O
PLEASE CALL: (516) 473-5400 EXTENS
OUR FAX PHONE NUMBER IS:. (516) 474-5362
CONFIDENTIAL COMMUNICATION
THIS TRANSMISSION IS INTENDED ONLY FOR THE INDIVIDUAL OR ENTITY TO WHICH IT IS
ADDRESSED, AND MAY CONTAIN INFORMATION THAT IS PRIVILEGED, CONFIDENTIAL AND
EXEMPT FROM DISCLOSURE UNDER APPLICABLE LAW. IF THE READER OF THIS
COMMUNICATION IS NOT THE INTENDED RECIPIENT, OR IT IS INTENDED RECIPIENT, YOU
ARE NOTIFIED THAT ANY DISSEMINATION, DISTRIBUTION OR COPYING OF THIS
COMMUNICATION IS STRICTLY PROHIBITED. IF YOU HAVE RECEIVED THIS
COMMUNICATION IN ERROR, PLEASE NOTIFY THE SENDER IMMEDIATELY BY TELEPHONE
AND RETURN THE ORIGINAL COMMUNICATION TO US AT THE ABOVE ADDRESS BY THE
U.S. POSTAL SERVICE. THANK YOU.
THIS IS AN AUTOMATIC TRANSMISSION. SHOULD YOU NEED TO REACH THE SENDER
PLEASE CALL (516) 473-5400
SW/FAXCOV
LS/Ia A DIVISION OF GLEN -HAVEN RESIDENTIAL HEALTH CARE FACILITY
08/09/i997 11:54 5164745362
PORT JEFF HEALTHCARE
PAGE 01
PORT- '-fqLLOwRo AD6)4730X(5I6540
1777
fiAX: (S16) 473-5402
DATE:
TIlVIE:
FA.X#_-7& S I�g -2—
TO:
TO:. J
ATTN: ��_ _ 2a Zd 94
RE:, 1�-Jl t L
MESSAGE:
r4o
-S Documents including this cover sheet.
IF YOLJ DO NOT RECETV
PLEASE CALL: (516) 473-5400 EXTENSION 530
OUR FAX PHONE NUMBER IS: (5] 6) 474-5362
CONFIDENTIAL C CAT N
Lle
THIS TRANSMISSION IS INTENDED ONLY FOR THE INDIVIDUAL OR ENTITY TO��CIAH IT IS
ADDRESSED, AND MAY CONTAIN INFORMATION THAT IS PRWU-FGED,
EXEMPT FROM DISCLOSURE UNDER APPLICABLE LAW. IF THE READER OF THIS
COMMUNICATION IS NOT THE INTENDED RECIPIENT, OR IT IS INTENDED RECIPIENT, YOU
ARE NOTIFIED THAT ANY DISSEMINATION, DISTRIBUTION OR COPYING OF THIS
COMMUNICATION IS STRICTLY PROHIBITED- IF YOU HAVE RECEIVED THIS
COMMUNICATION IN BRRO�COPLEASE
NOT HE US T p�7ER TADDRESS BY THE
ELY
AND RETURN THE ORIGINAL
U.S. POSTAL SERVICE. THANK YOU.
THIS IS AN AUTOMATIC TRANSMISSION. SHOULD.YOU NEED TO REACH THE SENDER
PLEASE CALL (516) 473-5400
SWIFAXCOV [i5S1DETiT1AI.1 -'Di CARE FACA f y
W(F A DMSION OF GLFr1 F1P►VEN
08/0811997 11:54 5164745362 PORT JEFF HEALTHCARE PAGE 02
Port
Jefferson
Cam R
August 8, 1997
DARK HOLLOW ROAD
PORT JEFFERSON, NY 11777
(516) 473-5400
FAX; (516) 473-5402
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179 Re: Appeal No. 4492 - Variances (W. Klein Property)
Southold, New York 11971 '
Atten: Linda Kowalski
Dear Ms. Kowalski:
Mr. Nicholas.Durka was admitted to Port Jefferson Health Care Facility on August 1, 1997 for
medically necessary reasons. Discharge is anticipated in approximately four weeks.
Lsna
Durka.Itr
Sincerely,
i
Leslie Saren, Director
Social Work Services
A DMSION OF GLEN -HAVEN RESIDENTIAL HEALTH CARE FACILITY
08/08/1997 11:54 5164745362
,APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS
Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman
Serge Doyen
James Dinizio, Jr.
ffdkAM&a
Lydia l Tortora
Maureen C. Ostermalill
•
PORT JEFF HEALTHCARE
;�gl1FFOL
,�coG
o
BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
PAGE 03
i
Southold Ibwn Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax (516) 765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1809
Enclosure (8/14 agenda)
July 29, 1997
Mr. and Mrs. Nicholas Durka7 " -
530 Angler Road
Greenport,.. NY 11944
Re: Appeal No. 4492
- Variances (W. Klein Property)
Dear Mr. and Mrs. Durka:
This will, confirm that
the hearing on the above application has
been postponed. for a conLi.nuation oii Thursday, AugHst 14, 1997 at
7:00 p.m. at the Town
Hall .(Court/Meeting Room),• Main Road,
Southold, New York.
Additional information
was added to the file by the applicant
since the original July 10,
1997 hearing. If you ' wish to stop by our
office, the file is available for your review at a time convenient
for you (during regular
business hours. Monday through Friday
between 8 and 4 p:m.).
If you have any questions, please call us.
Very t. my yours, - ... _ .... .
Linda Kowalski
Board Secretary
Enclosure (8/14 agenda)
APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS -
Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman
f� Serge Doyen
James Dinizio, Jr.
Lydia A. Tortora
Maureen C. Ostermann
BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
tes for File Re: Walter Klein:
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax (516) 765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1809
About 7/17/97: Mrs. Durka called and indicated she and her
husband are asking for another postponement because her husband
would like to look into this project and be able to participate.
We confirmed that the hearing is scheduled to reconvene on
August 14 (carryover from 7/10/97) . ZBA Office suggested she
send a letter confirming their requests and approximate time needed
for the postponement, and concerns or reasons involved.
8/8/97 - Mrs. Durka asked Health Facility to send fax to ZBA office
- time postponement is requested is approximately four weeks from
today. That meeting would fall into Sept. 11th or the Sept. 25th
meeting.
8/8/97 - Upon receiving fax, ZBA office called Pat Moore asking if
she would consent to a postponement for Mr. Durka. She said, no,
she will not consent.
8/8/97 - ZBA Office called Mrs. Durka at Greenport # - answering
machine. Left message asking Mrs. Durka to call ZBA office. y�i l
S -/Y1 -1°a t/Yl o+�-� rte-% u1/ nk YYZ�. / e. ?I-% �. e� `�� -V— .�6 �J
Hearing remains on calendar for August 14th - pending action by the
Board after receiving additional info, and whether or not to postpone
the hearing, to close the hearing, or take other action.
Await outcome at 8/14 meeting by board resolution.
Cc 10-a �- lA ' 6yCS 6-n S-1881.
)1�4 cf/�F
................................................................................ TRANSMISSION RESULT REPORT ....................(AUG 08 '97 01:53PM)..................
SOUL D TOWN HALL 516 765 1823
................................................................................................................................................................................. ( AUTO) ......................
DATE START REMOTE TERMINAL TIME RE MODE TOTAL PERSONAL LABEL FILE
TIME IDENTIFICATION SULTS PAGES NO.
AUG 08 01:52PM 2985664 00'49" OK S 01 003
..................................................................................................................................................................0.060..................•.......1.........11.11........
E)ECM ))REDUCTION S)STANDARD M).MEMORY. C)CONFIDENTIAL #)BATCH,
D)DETAIL $)TRANSFER
F)FINE P)POLLING
APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS -
Gerard P. Goehringer. Chairman
Serge Doyen
James Dinizio, Jr.
J\Q���
Lydia A. Tortora
/y1. &7e.<'1172,121"l
7/25
r��o gUFFf1(/�G0 -.
� 1
o -
ClJ Z
o��V,
BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
AGENDA
REGULAR MEETING
THURSDAY, AUGUST 14, 1997
6:45 p.m. Call to Order.
I. PUBLIC HEARINGS:
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax (516) 765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1809
6:45 p.m. Appl . No. 4497 - NOREEN TOSCANO. This application is
a request for a Variance, based upon the Building Inspector's
June 20, 1997 Action of Disapproval which states that under Article
XXIV, Section 100-244B, Article IIIA, Section 100-30A.3, the rear
yard setback on a lot in an R-40 Zone with less than 20,000 sq. ft.
shall be 35 feet and the deck construction exceeds allowable lot
coverage. Location of Property: 5225 Peconic Bav Boulevard,
Laurel, NY; 1000-128-1-12.
RESOLUTION: Appl. No. 4356 - MARTIN KOSMYNKA. - Postponed
to September 11, 1997 at request of applicant.
6:50 p.m. Appl. No. 4494 - ANTONIO PIRAINO. This application is
based upon the Building Inspector's June 1997 Action of Disapproval,
for a Variance under Article III, Section 100-32, Bulk Schedule,
permission to place new dwelling with insufficient front yard setback
from right-of-way which passes through center of applicant's
property, and reduced rear yard setback. Location of Property:
3637 Right -of -Way off the west side of Cox Neck Road, Mattituck;
1000-113-3-2.3. Zone: R-80.
7:00 p.m. Appl. No. 4492 - WALTER KLEIN. This application is
based upon the Building Inspector's Mav 28, 1997 Action of
Disapproval, for building permits in the "as built" construction of
accessory garage in an area other than the required rear yard and
deck addition with an insufficient front yard setback from private
right-of-way (easterly property line) and excessive lot coverage, at
3235 Manhanset Avenue, Greenport, NY; 1000-43-1-8. Zone: R-40.
Property size: 6821 sq. f t .
7:10 p.m. Appl. No. 4068 - ELEANOR SIEVERNICH. Upland area is
less than 80,000 sq. ft. per lot; Article XXIII, Section 100-239;
Article III, Section 100-32 in this proposed two -lot subdivision at
3200 Cost Neck Road, Mattituck; 1000-113-8-5. Total acreage: 3.5 --
acres. Zone District: R-80 Residential.
Page 2 of 2 - Agem _ i
August 14, 1997 Regular Meeting
Southold Town Board of Appeals
.
I. PUBLIC HEARINGS, contintted: .
7:25 p.m. Applications 4485-V and 4486 -SE:
_BELL-ATLANTIC/NYNEX by Richard Weyhreter (Owner: A. Rehm) .
Location of Property: 425 Westphalia Avenue, Mattituck, NY;
County Parcel No. 1000-1.11-3-34. Applicant is requesting: (a)
Special Exception under Article XIV, Section 100-141 (100-31B-6) for
placement of a new tower and building for public utility cellular
transmission service, and (b) Variances based upon the Building
Inspector's April 29, 1997 Action of Disapproval, which states that
"... this lot is in an LI Zone District and has a lot area of
approximately 13,400 scl. ft. Presently there is ail existing building
and use. The proposed building and additional use would require a
total lot area of 80,000 sq. ft. in an LI Zone. The proposed
construction is required to be set back a minimum of 70 feet from
the rear yard and 20 feet from all other lot lines. Zoning
Ordinance, Article .XIV, Section 100-142 Bulk Area and Parking
Regulations. Owner: Adrienne M. Rehm.
II. SEQRA: Type II Designations re: minor projects.
III. DELIBERATIONS/DECISIONS deemed appropriate by board. IV.
REMINDERS:
a) Committee Sessions
Planning & Zoning:
Code Committe(--,:
b. Regular ZBA Meeting G:45 p.m., August 28, 1997
IV. RESOLUTIONS/MISCELLANEOUS:
A) RESOLUTION: Additional New Applications Hearings dates:
�� T
I
APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS`—
Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman
Serge Doyen
James Dinizio, Jr.
Lydia A. Tortora
Maureen C. Ostermann
BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
July 29, 1997
Mr. and Mrs . Nicholas Durka
530 Angler Road
Greenport, NY 11944
Re: Appeal No. 4492 - Variances (W. Klein Property
Dear Mr. and Mrs. Durka:
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax (516) 765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1809
This will confirm that the hearing on the above application has
been postponed for a continuation on Thursday, August 14, 1997 at
7:00 p.m.. at the Town Hall (Court/Meeting Room) , Main Road,
Southold, New York.
Additional information was added to the file by the applicant
since the original July 10, 1997 hearing. If you wish to stop by our
office, the file is available for your review at a time convenient
for you (during regular business hours Monday through Friday
between 8 and 4 p.m.).
If you have any questions, please call us.
Very truly yours,
Linda Kowalski
Board Secretary
Enclosure (8/14 agenda)..
APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS
Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman
Serge Doyen
James Dinizio, Jr.
X 4--k -�
Lydia A. Tortora
Maureen C. Ostermann
Patricia C. Moore, Esq.
P.O. Box 483
Mattituck, NY 11952
BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
July 29, 1997
Re: Appeal No. 4492 - Variances (W. Klein Property)
Dear Mrs. Moore:
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax (516) 765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1809
This will confirm that the hearing on the above application has
been postponed for a continuation on Thursday, August 14, 1997 at
7:00 p.m. at the Town Hall (Court/Meeting Room) , Main Road,
Southold, New York.
Very truly yours,
Linda Kowalski
Board Secretary
PROOL)wi 15 IM, - .,.o Order PHONE TOLL FREE 1-B00.225E380 - f - 4 C ,'�
ARTCO DRAINAGE C(
Excavation & Drainage
P.0 BOX 1132 . JOD ESTIMATE
MATTITUCK, NEW
p YORK 11952 .\
(516) 298-9660 PHONE -DATE \
FAX (516) 298-2291 7/8/97
JOB NAME/LOCATION
TO Mr. Walter Klein
C/O Patricia Moore
Westphalia Road
Mattituck. N.Y. 11952
Greenport
0
ESTIMATED $10.000.00 + landfill invoicE
THIS ESTIMATE IS FOR COMPLETING THE JOB AS DESCRIBED JOB COST
ABOVE. IT IS BASED ON OUR EVALUATION AND DOES NOT IN- for concrete
CLUDE MATERIAL PRICE INCREASES OR ADDITIONAL LABOR AND
MATERIALS WHICH MAY BE REQUIRED SHOULD UNFORESEEN
PROBLEMS OR ADVERSE WEATHER CONDITIONS. ARISE AFTER
THE WORK HAS STARTED. ESTIMATED
40 % Pre -Consumer Content • 10 % Post -Consumer Content
PRODUCT215 � Inc, Groton, Mass. 01477. To Order PHONE TOLL FREE I-BOb225-5380 � ,
— �
:
w - - . -_ �� - _.-r� - " I — -1. I -z -tV- �:'7 ' 7� �', ; ��. 5-'- i� ---- .", -' _' ; ;:��-.'!�:�-_,-.-,-__ , -11
. . - - - -7 I , - .-; . __ . . .- , , - _ - " -,.!. - - ,� - --.r j- - �� -� "� �. ,.,. - -:%7: - _* �- _` *
- , . . -, - r� - ', � - '_:'� - !'� -:�.'. - ..; , -, , � " .`.!� , -, -- , 7. '! �- -': � 7' Z - - - '.- -Y�.`�, Z�;'.. r- •T�Ez . .. i .-- -. , .. -_ ..'�--7*,�7"�-�7-
.1 , � ., � - . . . ._ . , . � ... . _; . �
i . •, . .- � � , . -:.: -. .- t P�
. _� : ;�:_ - , _�� I- — ."', ;.,rI',.; - ,
_ . , .� - .. — - ____ , . _ .. - - - .- - - .��
. . . . 4: . . ... . .
'. � , —
. . :...I.f :��..,. .,.,.;.,.
- ��-�,--.--;-.:�--,..�,---,-�;-,,,i.",
��' :�
, , . 4.!,-t-��_ Pa- -
. . .
. - - - - - I -
:. . I- .. , .. . . . � � . . - -
_. t' :1; '" - . - , -, 'r..zW.- ... ,:...;,�,:t;-_'.;_ � . ... �%,-� -.-. .. - 11:-.1
. - I . . I . .M... - , . •_�,�,::S,.:�;._ .. _. -__--,_:".�,,�_;:��.. _ *-.I. � `�'.. .i�z .,�*-:;�,�� *_
. - ... ., � -- . , I �_. - ....:. ..: . I � - - , ?�.' ".- �. I 1. '.�'..7'.i..- �- -ER,T,) _-;I.._I .,. , _�"
. _: _,, . . ,.I. ... -I.- .. ---. I, ': .: �t .e, Zk�. , 'i.--_�. 4, -I-
- .. . - .;.;... . . .-:, - . -, - '- '_ - - � , , �_�- - --�- •- .. -- -�. ..(_, W. - -;j - .-
. . _ . i , � -:�--(: .-.?v.t. .\:.. .;��.:";�..,:--.:% - . ��: .f
....: . . , . I ' -`�` - .,* .. �--�.-.. - 1 � .. _: .A�'.L�, '' ..; ".7. -�?, - , .. . , .. - - -.:,-L; - � -__�;:_II_`-__ ,?-::�, .., -�� � C.
, __ .!7�
- . _I- -,: --_--.--:Az: --- . , :9 -_I; -_ *1 Z�� .. - I .";:.,.�::,�
. . .. .. I—.- 1,��.,-:-_: ,�- �` .. , ,..,..-... ,.;.-.I',:c., -: -.-,r..7z,., .... .. ,.,�"._,. !L,r: . -
, - ""I .� ..
.., .I-;-;":.--. -�._ -r'..e.*�.- �...Z.. --,:�)--.J-' -'.- " , _.-
, �t` . " ?..t.�
. . - .'..... -4 --.1, .,%�,�-�, - ��;� . . �,V,r ;K�. , ,:,--.:- - . '.
. . Q,� - ,_ �_ -4�., Z -! ;-::- ---',; -,� � " . . . - 711 0/� 7
. -
.. . . - , — . .
. . - .: .. , ,�`- I i�, - . J- lc:t� "I'AN, ..
..-- -� .-- - -7 - * Zr,47- . .:.'_'7;,,�*.'._ .: . . ... . _� ., - ; -:I--�Z�
: _.��.. " , ... .. .. . - "
. . . .. . . . . . � . . . . . . - :> ,�, - - r:�� -,-. - � _ . - . . .. . '. !.;
- , :, , ',�. * '.. : - . --.-.... -..� Z. -,%-:�' -:�1,1 (
,
. I .. .
__ .- ,� .
. , .. . . . �? .ii -42 7. -,--,'.*,. ;.-:.. � - . ;,-, - � �,- .-%,:._..,_-.---� -
. .. . , . .
. . , ... .. . . . . . . .... *y ....-_.�:�� .7. .: _
...?.- ... Iz V , - - 1� :_ _.','--- -----
� . . - - - . . . ., " . - -ill` -, ...?, - , " , - , -.-- - .. ",:- - z .. .. .., � - I _,_ - ;: - ',�',* _.
, . . ... - .- _ . _ ........., �T#<&5."'..: . ... -;,.. ;..� .,.. .11 ..
.. : . . �- -, -: � -- �-Z' , -, Z."4-.�.,��-Z,*:: -; ,�Z��, -, ';-.'. Z. , , 'r ".J� : -�.!a
. I . . .- .. ,�L... . .. .
. . . . . - . . . . - . 11 -14' *�:;"w - .'. - ' - - ' .. "' '�,I-M� . ,,;, I .- . .,� 1- -*,: .;-, - _*'%�;'� - -
� . . . - .. _. ., . - -;� - - .Z--- -11 � .- . .. , _-�P;.. .- �' ' _ - ", . - .. . - , , ,
-, - - - . -49 . . . . .
� , '.' -!i . .. . . '.� " - ... . :14--e�p_, . � ,Y19; ; _ ,' ]f .' t �,
. .;,. 7
1 - � " . . . .. I , , - , , - .1;'n -, i�-, - * . .. � . - .,�- ,t --,F-- 'i.-," , - . -, . .*�` ;Z_ - �k - ,," -.;Z��`, .- '- _- -%� <'::!5.,;��r .,. -_,Z'�,,�.
- 'k . . .. . - .
.. .. - . - 1�. . . ,�-;:..- .(..
: . .:.. . - , �. . Q -;r. r �, .. � -._ " .- _. ... . ";�'. ,
� . .. ", � -;'. ,� j-,.:.,, - ,� ..- .. .. . j- I ;- . . -
_� .. . ( -;.,;--�-:7-:-r -4 - , ,r , r ;�- , - ,, -,., .-. - ,-- _,� - , - - -, -, - . z;: - moi' _--S-,,:-,,��L- Q6 �
.. . , - . �.:�',;_ A-.&,.--., ;, ��_4_ �;. - '.I- ��--_'-:�:,_e..'%� �k _.�._. '. / . �-. -1 .
,
_.-.-x- - __ . . . : -,�- 1. .1-C.::__ �SY�.V' , *('7_11 1, i e..? � :x I.' _)� , :; , ".;. ,
. � . . : . � . . .. ' .�4 , - _.-� �z � I I , .,
, , - - - -, . , -, -:� --�W-
` - ...:. �� ' -?�t.j-".4.,"Z:� -A--���:�_7_%. - ,.:� .- .--. _ - � - - I,: , I . - . ..
, , . - ... - - -,7p,f ..-%,.�-,"./ .1 --, -.'�-�;.,:�-, ;.��,�;- -,..--. .
. . . . . . 4� ,'� i _/ � . - _;�' :-,;� T.�� , , -;, .." I _11...- -_ 11 .--,-. - -*.: -,
� ncml .ii� �. . � � ��'
- - I . - ... - . .. -
, - I
- . - - - - :
. - ,.. 7z -
. � :,.-. �•- ".. J., - - ... .�,,'
:P_ , - - --
.. . . . . � . � . , . ,,,��.,S: , ,
-All- / , _",,'ft�;z.!�,,-� -,. ., i , �� - ,
- . ..•- // .. v _ .. . - �' - ... � -- --- � .
. - , . - .- , , � :A�� -:-.*:- " '... 01 -
I-', , . , :,2,-, -:�_. - " , .F., � -.1 , .
. - & �- " . — � -.Z_�A--�:
. . . . I ... -., — -1 -, - - " , - r --- - - - 1:
- `;., , _',�, - . ` M.- " : !,.
. . . 4-1 - 4
.., . . . .;�, .t' `�TI_P_rr , _7;71'
,41_.� - - -, _.__ !_:%. ..� _.k.." - - . ., rX
, , .;.
, . . " , ; / - .,: ;/ _- , 1-� .- ,� t;�ZrA,,, .;I� /�� ;�; _�: ,. "u'. �� ,
I
. — -, .. - - � Z4. - - - - ,� '-,.L - ..-,,-�,.
.Y�j �* � , ,'�, �" I __ AV— � f_ - - ,,�, � _;....'
� - �,�Z:_.� �., ".:,�,_, ..-.-_. ... ::_�_-
(_ . , *� -/ .. —1-
J, f
_ _/
- _/
- �� . /,7. , / , .4 f .y .
` - -� ... r'"; . - . . . - . .v - - ; -- -6 :�. I _� .. . -:.-- !7-,-"";-
. .. 11 � -
Y. . 1, -..j� ,- -IRFv. ;Z"A-* , - . " I _ �. - . --.--,,- . - --,-. , ..�
.0 :'4 �_ . I •- _'�-,: �:- �;,-_ 11:._.M�' .
- - . - , _ - , . -_ - I '. - - . . , -
_e� �' - -1-4, -.71 .:.: . .- -.4. �- , .
.. . - . - I :A , %_1 PTV�' X _7z - , ��i - . -..f --' '*--' - �. Z.
��_11_" ix-73--;�r--_ - . `;:,,-.` !�:'- - -,��'-_-"- - � " -
. --- , ,-I- -, - '-' " - 1 t�z�.�!
I - �:7 --.- - - 1- .,I�
. . :-.'. --t -�,:.- ,
. ,�: �,
I I . ... / .'. -4 _.Yv'!� ,4�
. ... 1 14 _,_`;.-X _�' . Ne, , - -
., e', . .,- I 7. "�W'. %'A' t_ �4'_, " .V '1_7f� : . .�E - -77 It Y3 -, -, .� �.
, :.,. - - I—- ��.el� -�!��:X
. - - , . I � - �,�-I...-_._- , , -.-.-7,.:- .
.. - _.-
- . _ .. , - , . Z'--' "", 4,
. 2- .: - - , fa 17 1 -7 - . .Z - . __ . �� v �-
9 '. -..: " .% .
-1
. �
,
,R.,� �1.., ".."7
� . - , -,:/. - - 0��:Iy, ,'/ -7 pl.i.5 ��-.r -._,;, --,`_*4 �
.. - . 4) 1 . -
r .-" N
. .
.:n � - ;. .. I ��? u . �,. .;:,. .."i, - . f;. - - �'Z -, .
I 4as �.' /; 1,� W -. ,
I -
- , � 01.. , . to . - , , . 11 . 1/1z, : e, -C W. 7,.:; �__. -
-, - - , - ... . .�,. � - I so ".-, . , _. .�� , __ _:11
.-.,.-" . aF�: ,;m. : - -, ". - ., � ", � , . E_ - .. :--'
. , - -
. . . . .. " - .1
t . . V. . . - `V,�-_- . - :." , - -��,� 14
� - I .... �;,�. W - � z - ` "�'
4- -- - o/'// .r 7-;�� ,_- - ` �t .- -- ..:
;F � ��_' �-. p� - - I - - , _. ;-, ,--y
..7-- .
-•
� - '- - _r� - �F il�� % 1�, t,�_r,!,.:� I_- ,'-- -
_.. I . _, --. �q I . , 'A .
- .'!-�
I /. . .
. - - -.*-., � � 1�- .' .-
% --- io " � " --7 .. -I-- - . , ft-, - - ,�,
. ,� .- . - '� , "M '�.-:__,.,� �.-_��.-,' , � .,�' __ . I Iz 11.
. ,wr . . � : � I ." .��-Z `--% � Nt�-_I. 9
S -S -:_,.,-t Im ` - ---- .39 - .. --- � .tl.:.--. rx_�V,! -,�� -, �".,:�l 7 ", _.- ; -I.
-,. - , . .� 6 `1� ". 1. , . -..- -
+ - . . �Vl: . - I . - ]
. . , - . .4 , / I . - -o . . - , , - -
, I A . _. �� L_� -��.,- �L ---;�, 77�:�- ;�.. .'
4 .. ... �
. I . , - --I -.- �-: -t;. " .- '.
, I r. .: ."r_t- 1-)� /'/ . .7., � .1 ..��,r, � - - - -
..
. I � Y , . 4 7. i.,d
` _ .. , - r�?� 71- -.I- ...
,::� t j" - . � . . - . _
-_ -, I - ;�� , , � -N.-' , -z�N-,** J',;-- --- i�� - - I - � . - -,;�. - . I .
, -`--,. - �1- �r ,..--., ,-.,: 4.;;� 1 . . , . ,7� �.i. �..
� 7- /' �N, , r*._v4.. _.:* , , % %
. . 4. - �.-_ , _ � '. - - -; -,7 � ..�..,�7•
.
"---1 - - : - -.::: _'.I'..' - - -
. I . �.,__ _1�
.. . I � ------ , ,.L;J'.� iw, - -, �, lg�--_ ____ .., . -?W. z - .- �,?. ._"�.�:- 7- - - - ,
.�. _ - 7 -O... - 7: _:. _ ✓, , -_..,_-__k ----, ��j...----,:� - .
-;-P,�_- 63� _. /- x � - .bb;�-.11,_ U.-
% P ---. .� � , ;. I ?,'� - ;.��:'.'.��%��
� :;I . 4,1�_. 3.6 � .;A,- c 7. - - . ... ,
, q - ,� �-. ,-v 1 ;,;!A` ." - - , ,;�,Z.-:�-,;; - _�4,� .�`41'7�.� ---I-- ..r.
.. . ? P*-: *� " -.-;�. . "3�5, oc It, .1. - , -� .-
-4. -. 25`%�-;�'�-_'--" - _� -- - ---- _
v
2 A_X;�-- - --- - .-�;!�4* _4:,O�i; - ,,-,..- -, .. �� � - 0_
I .X _ -.- _:��`� zz,-,-. .44z, -?p--,4,- - v,�L"�'-!'t:;4,w�,��7!�Lz.. -- -"1;r..
'�.,�-W --�4
-" ,!�! ,�� _,,��Z:, i;,��„�
. tl�a . 4, , � - _4 ��,- -.r�.,;.,*-�-� 'L - - - .1 -i t -,��-j '31�'! -.:fm_7U-;
V. IV., .,= !.h A,-
� , . _;;R&vc , �; - -
1% .1-11 ,Z-4- �>!J_'-� �i-; ��, , . 4 . �, ,_,�A _
,.tom
�. I , - ,_15-:�* N'. -',,__-.,,;V, �.t4r.. .!..C,;,7Gz-�I_n_ __.. . i
. , ” ; .'.Z'_�7-1.%.� 'i W �L--W, "Iff.Z.-A �W. .. r, 4-t _,, _I'�z:--',_j_ ,�:, . t
.,;; 1. , � -17-1. - � �� W., _ !!. -�.�":-`: - . .,.::-�-;%,.sP7_.-.�_,i., -�-�,
I .. ��. . .rmNr,7 -- .. -� , -
-
� _ .- . P,%�V -_e.-'�.-,
- I.". ... - -�-.1--j�,4!f�.4---W e_ _.
, -, _
.
, - - . ,.., _-,W...:-?; , �'�-_' �'_4717�!FNP1177;;_� _
I: N __ M ..
1 .. . t -," �',_ TI . SADOW� ... . � I Art,:.- --;�. �.W
. 1.11,;� 1�..��,-,P- %4-5i�-_,,�.7;r' V" - -� ""' -, -
..;:.. `�' -Z'V-:, ?.�-!! -� � .. - - - -,' �% '---��;!l . �- '-?�
- ."-.-. - �. - -Z�-.-�%4;7, �I_i.. - _f. .- .!,;-. .,.y�p,i_:. _. � . ,�; - -�--�,, ;� , � ': ? *.', -7:-�
- - . :X.- � � •, . � , - -f7 .- .-: �,
- - I.... �_ . . ._�E;Elil _O-R=-�: -I..;
��,�.7;1- - '- , " _- , - '-!Pa,-. �� 40, t: . .-'_'114�� '� - -�-I , ,� " �_ 41 -
. " � ..7.-
�% _ .- -- - - :��.%,j.._.Z, _.4��_., 7. - - - - , ,- -
, ��, '� 47%, --_�- j ;, , .; � -�_, - -7: � -o _ , , -ll.l�-.---.--,i-...,-� -,-,- -, -1 _.�
I I 1. Z� "�:!-%T-?;:!- -_-�., - " - - ,;
. - - .
,
-_ , - -� O'� t�-,:��--:__. -I.. , '. _ , . _
... - .- .. , .1-11 ,,-:t ;.g.g_- .. !� . � .,--;, -,�._`- _. . .e... --,-.-. __., - '-
m!; ar:?t .1 �� . I � ,:% . . 1. - - -- - -:-. -_ " , . � _ - : :tnt-.
. . - ,*,X ----- -- ,.,A� - -- -, , ,-.-. - - -IF .. � . . . ,�.!.*-,` -
� _. :�7 . ,.to, , . ;,',V� -�-:,'-:' .� ,�. - � . .-
-
. at,
.. � I , �� - A�I . ;. . , :
.. , i�:: S � � 5 - - .. .
. . - '-'- .,-Ir.- . _t -f....�'fi�.-...,�.!�.;:,.,--.., ., , ,1:.,�.--`.'�-�,
•
, -i� .!-k- N _
:. � .k �;�,4 , -4
. . ��:.:;��,�_,Vf, ,_.- .
. -t..-.�'.
, . - . '. "'i,
-,-�,-1;vJ: .
. _ .-; ,.. T
j
- '* ,-
7��- . _. `
. z!
.7 ;! . � lc_�
-•
. , , -�M. d. ,�, ,� . ,�: , _., - � - . _!�T .- - - -- --._-i-",-_-,: .: ;�; __ . .1 ..;� .
rf� *:,.� -- -: --�r- -.- .---
- - - . --. , - . " ; - '_� ., � .. _ - - _; " _1 ,
, . - ,V. _�'. .'4-. _ ,�_-. j,� . � - � , ;�;
. . . . � - - . . _,�. 6; __,�. *-Z"-�Q.Y�. .7, I�.:.`%Z.-, _-... I , - ,,;. "
--- . I "�X,r, -; , -- , . !.
. , I . I - , ,.!;. - - I . :.. � . .?.. . . .
�,!:' __I I. .:, _ - - � �- --.:, 5 - -'.�g".,: -4z,;�7� _�-�-'��:--_ . , �-_ - ,-,�f- .:�. ., .:.F .;..
_-, . - ->
� &..!�
1 .4, , , - . .4. ,_�� �-, *f'-�,?; ,-t_� ,z"_;-` .:, , .!� � -Z�:.r , 1�_J,
,� o Z,�A � � ... _- �
•res
..
,-" _ . z : �_K I . -� �, . ,
, ,
-A.;
_ , 11 - "* :"-' ... . :,;�-%j-_c . jz,--�- .-.. _ . .- -
, _",W..%�.,�'_ '.f - T� - . - .1; - q,
,� 7�1
- - ", � . .; .-
. .�4�.'. - � �. __
:. ��, ..�-. I I .- -�r.
I .R " ..;,. .. ., - - ,
J��_�:I� (I �i.j. - ,17-,�.�- �',�i_ .;�". . - ` -Z ; .4, .,�O"_ _-.�:. �,�c-.
I I E.P-. ,;A..,.T4L!;�, - - -:k� w .
... 4, -V . .. �1 't . -! "I' - 17 * , � � . .
- - .. .., . , - = - A 4! .-.I -4;, -:;;: " "
- - . :' - -� � ..
I-.... . _-T__I - ,
. - "��5c_A-Ct
e � .- ,g�. - .; �� _ :+s:: :,.qs
" � I _... - - .z-, eq- I . - �. , _. ". , __ .-. __ ,�� ..
., �, - . -:�-!��-.4E - , - -:r --t , . __ . )�,�, . —,
.;� N -I,.:. 4:��.�-4, ,�;Yr��,7-� �_-; -�`��-.-: �, _ . � - -.-I.
-,.;r ._m.. - - 41�;i", I.;;r Bj.. 'A .1 i. . ...'r . - '. * - - .. -,..:., r� � - -:�__4�_� _ ",
- , It.7,; J- - -11 ..7_,,� -,�!&� ., , I- . � ._
- Z . - -�-C_ _�:.
.:- - _ , . _._ .i
- - 7 �-,N M -o if r. -q .-A , hy_:�.�-: , � .3�;I 7� - . ��, -,-, .�, - -
.�;J,,:;��
.'�� -, _. ,., -�_,_I-;,;7- - ,-. q: ,.: - �� ..---.-�,,-":----,,---- ,e- - - - - -_,�-._'
- .t ', , �;" �_ __ 11 �,,
_ '. :!�� . � A,- -z-. P�_ - � T-. �. , ,;- .. -- " � ___ ,�� �� ew-f K� - : :. , .; ..
- . - .. -, T�: . �: . . ,�.
- ." . .. . . - - . �. . " � . :- - , . - .
. ; -�� - ,IF :.,---��.-,� � -, . -
7-;;�;. I. .::,� �,. 4. ... ,:.-. , "I'- T_ Si
.". . � .x �, _- � -�
.� I", A _7 - ___ . �, 7 1:. -: - . ---. , ,, �t
� . :K.'I�i. _.- - ;,9 .-,i .. , . .
`��, - - ��"-4,-,_. e . *411:9�7T�,,.- - ,�� - - �' . , :..,-. - .., .-
.. . , i�_-- - _:�' :�-__:"-i:7�,
- �e. .., .r .
- . . . . . ,__ w-,,�-?, , , - .s5. , .., _�` �44�__70 _-, _;T7 - - ,:.-,!�..,--,--,- _1�. ,
- .. I- ztt h , . - .
- .•
. -
, .��.; - , , II .L11 -it, - " - .�:,-`_N _Oz,__.I - - - .� _-, -,� . ,*- i� ":, -
- ".Co.m. - - �
, - - " " , - . ,
--- . *1 69' . wtiF "I , -.`!'".,�� -I`W ,;e �'. �I..:�!,-:':
- , -.4., j _; , -. - ., - ; .- , , - - -�---_"�-_Irt�. - *� --
. _ia .
� - . _ I - P:� . ,, I.- .. -, , �. 191ft-I - .. ;�_,.� T, �7 .; -*�� -.- - _ _'. , , " - .. 1. - !_Z�I�-'
!,.: : ,U��y;t, ;.�z , I x , :7._!,J:�. __.;t� f .- .C..... �. ,'%'.*::_ce`. ,.�z . _Z: .�,:::.�_, I
��1�7.
'i , , . , 1�1. .t-� . - -z", _�_I - - V-11" -- � or�;r�,--!�-`- �- �,;�_ - eA � , `j....�L'.�:%- _��- ;z '.,-; _'_�,t
. : W1, . , . . �� . �:7. - - �,��,., -�6�� -t. - r
--�;'w'; ---- - , , �__,_ ,�,,-&, - -11 .,.-. -
_... I - .I- .-W' . 1�1. , 1. �..:I ;_-, '. -,..-.-- . �.- :,�. -
- .., -, � 1:3 , � - 'f`--Z*�':��-Lt* ;.-:��_11'., .,.•.
- 1;71 i
':«l+
,.:. , , - - 11.1� - . M -, - -- - , �
... . . _rt_ i. : , - I I � - . . . - - 1, I - _:�
, � � .. .k;��. . -<,4 - - .. --,x--- �. � .;
. . _,� _. . , 4�
- - _. . :: . vVI'_ '. 1".. . - .1 _". �,V'z __i��i`o _. � - -..,�-��-.�-.�'C,,�,:.--�-".-��'.."-:,, -:, `z �. ..-. . :-_.y',
_ . � . _. . , ..;-,.%-:k, �e,-L?�."_v -1 �, ". " .- ,�- :�-
-,
� _'n. i.! i . ,��.
- ;-�, ,*� 7�_? V. � , :'. --L . --,7. '. w --- � ,__ .- - , .
. - I , . .,_--,-4. ��J--
; ._. - . - - 'Zil c ,�, ,4 . .
.In4�
-- -- - - �,._JVI' 'I� . '.. - -
, . - . , �t�...F:5'%wZ .% IQWKI !-
.:'I� -a - ..I.
, .=.'I"f �
.._. .E. *4_411 V,16* 7� 4 ,:.... ...•
. 7 .�`� -
_ , - , :_-.:.,tr.. -, - ��:�__ '�"
... - - .,,/.. Z. ',q ��e,'.�,
- - . y :- - �- , L , - I ,. - -
- � - - - �_ _zI .6".; - .�X. -.*;��.- -�-_ -
. � . �� . . .
'. -,' � , Z,,* _;;�J- �4 -�F%,' -ki , ..,,:- -, - .. �-_:_ :,.
� , ,��'ejjii;-- " '.F V� Aav��v - - - �,.
. .! . . � _,�__.._ - , -0 -
" .�� _. �; . - ,it - " - . .LI -1 "I - - , �_;_ , i� q r " ,
, '! " , - -.,.,.. � t�z��* V.*117' " .
_ � I ., %%, �z . - , - _. .;� -
I .4 ,� -- . C, - - . .
�64 •
_.� t - iF�, ;.- "- .V..-.,;) -------- I
-
� , - " . �X ��27!r�_ .- -.2 �� _ .�, ". . -..-.. _...'_
.: - - - -Z. q 11, " ; - _. . P., _�- i:.:j: : - , -. - ,-
*
� .;, . . -A *kl'
---."-.-. zl-," � - - -40k , , .",'�'-��,.'::�' 1, � � - __ ..
,
Z% -_7e":5 .. ,-_��"-!C:,�, - , . ,> - , � � . , ..- � ,r:,�. -;� ,
, . _�,,' -1 . ! I - - ,:�: - � -�, , "4 'k�I,zn..ftct . - •;.____I;I.5 , -
. :f wl� . .- : , r:- � _!.�, 77 --- ;;�W�:�.!.-.�-.- !7..T -11, a
�-i�i�fe;S', .; . �, 1Y F � � i v , _* -
- , . :-�_,� .'. 3 .v 4��z 1_1_.P.�L'!�, ��--., I- ;.a._-,,- ��- ..
,� _,-, .T.V,�,.'I_ � . - -1 - i., �,
. . - 1. , 1. �. , . _-.-7_.- ..
'-'-;; - � ,
.,, - F ,� W� S�Y� .4 �'Xsj -. - .. -1. " .X;:,�Z: i,;:-� - .�2_ - -
o�r---� -: .,�- , , ,�-e�� V --��,;, ,.:R I_'I.t-_ i�,
I I
*
,�!Ii,"5- iW,�Vo-m - - -.� .. , .. �
� � ----- - - �_ ,; --.f,.,
1�_.' I ,� -5 .
- _ -, . I _,;.-�_ - __ - , - -►:--;* V " , - `7--'--- .
.�� . _� ` - - , W'-`_'-' 4 %ily RS4'a 5.��!� -':r-- -,
-
. _ y!:9- tz�,.
z .11 . .- �-Vp. �� _ .* ':
- . -:��t
-.-,-,. �, : . �; I ��-'� �: .. ,;__-,,
, -4- ,�,_�' __1 S ---
-
. -:�It-;., - �� -; � - i�, . '�,.-.v ',,',.'��,,t TZ�:t ._; ,_ ,. - 0-Y I � ., "-t, qn, .;
9 . , � .n. �::. r , - I
.T� I , I _., . . , - - . _' . ...'�, fl * ,A- .. .
m - �'-- - . - __ -. � - , - z .- '. 4 -, ` , - " - _.��. " ,•" . .
, C� .'_� "" �-, _; V ��- __� ..., I -;.4L�7_�� .. _ 7;� , , . .
�;:; j 74 �i; �00—�;c,c . - . -, ��,*- -,-�Z'W_v:�, _� --.J:
ft..�. __j -,- , - -11
,-_:.I%.._%_,N*1 .•t. 'ea 9. - - .. t�
�- ?fl . . , - ,- --- � -7-k- - - ". - - .�, , _;.
Z.:f.'� f: .� 'A 1 � tA6 11;� h_;_ - r - .,..F:.,q- !.';� , , %11"Nj; 11 I I , I .I,,. - -
- � - v., _; i4,, Z' . -,*r �._ _ ,I:�W:;.- -.-�4,*Z,j-.--' �i
, - - .1. ---,.7!i , '. .
, . . - ".�_�. -
, ok;;,�, 7-� �:: __._ , � . -7t� - __ W.�--%_�: _Z . - . -, , -1 - I
.k.5 � .��,�� - -1 . .- - .-k � _
Z; , . .'J'7 , T�'. A ��
� I& _,'. , - .. - _-.1 - ", �-, ��_ , 1-1-.Q... �7..,;,ZA;,7-,�',-,�l-,5!��.',-n�'.�-'?��-7�r�,-� ,4,r.,._<� _ .....,i��-,:--,.,t,�.�,,--�;--;4: �,�.'�
't - . �
,S,�- . I VML� .� =S- �f- ',-!�t7.�� ,.!',. -:�.-,;4:� -�Z'.-.-�;;�.::.'.' -
. V:I___ :7-- ;.kv: ,:,��.,_.,Z, ,--. �! .1�
-F! ,,--,?"- S, , _;� , _i:,; ., I
M - _,.�p __ , - .; .1 ..�,�r �__ _.e:
- I __ - - I - _100 -77,�* 1-�; _j.,n%.i4�r�,,m_ za __ - - _ , - '_ . - .,
.1 _._-511z�;r - "
. _. -I> - .1 . 1 _�_V�I__�_,!�� t &ft.y --I ,I �� . " " ". �' , --"-7.'.z "i'l, . .
__ - . - . �;_.:_ - - ,
_. _ ck-sx. . n.4, �,::�L,?. .--�. _��Z2� � , mw-, -* , , ,, ,� .
'— �� , , - , - �- - .- ��, J - I � , .. .. � .,--+,:." -�, -.
, F -p --it..: X, Z74 �C� . - --_--� ". .F...,� _;:�,,� _��
�� `7�i;_.��.'*514�11 '. - zrli _ . 'i ,�� � --,:-z- v'�-.I�el.�'-t�!�A ---, __ ,-. * .
-, - , . , - - - - -:; _ .
I-X.;.X�!-,r,2;".,�_� -r.. " -.._- .. .- ,)�V,-_"_-,, T'...; '. � . . , .: ..Z�Y.. -, .,--Z:,- •-.-,S, .- - , -, -.--- -
- . .. - _.:� _ � .
. Wo;:� Tbitln:,-. - - �,;. � �, � _
- , � _� -,. � -..,-. � I
4� Z_, � I - - , 4L - .
.�..A�;-A�., �-A, -- -, � W , . ,:" -�- �., . , .
, .-,.. V -Z ,
-1� , �_ - ."! .. � , ...", iiv.11_117ir_-I. Z!�:"V, - .,�-!;Z�)L- .- -
g��': ,,X",� .. .�..., -7 �� 1. - . L. � . ..,
. WN
.. -
-5, - •- - - � -,- .kr tf,�, .%.- ��-k': - , 2� mk
, rv, , ,
. vr',Y, , � _* , " r . , ":,.�;,_ . . . .-�. .'.
- �07,0- - - --- -r- .-I ,:;. - . _IZIk ---- �. %�J,. I I _:�.
-301 !�:__-" 4- !. �2;�',t . ..... - .1 " "'. ,%I�-�,��,,-: -�N'..'-q- _�, .��-
.,-I-
.". � -- I >.- � , -.i.9.J��_ .. - -; .--:j;!_-.-..
77* I 4�t4..,Z_;i�,�',_. , ', ._-,14."
". �..IW7R,, . ,�, -1 il
.
. I
. ;rdt---"-? - _ _ I ;I , .. -
i � ;....
. I � 71, � - .�T 7..Z:�, -, �_-:� Z. -, -
. .._ - _� . .. Z�.z ".:% . . ... - . _ ': - . :,J;�. . .-..qz, :,.17.
1 . .. ... --: I- - I
, ��Zr;.: 1 ,b * - . �_ .., Z. _.. Y - ..:4f, - .
40 r, ^ ;t - . i M2 "`��- -.,.. . _�?Z--�. - �� �
1. � , �:. ... - __ , S,I-�_." .1 -:,-;,,, - ,.'.�.:,... . . - -_ .
- - -- .., . _,,��-. ., I _-, - . 1.41 . , ,- ` .",.. ..'
!� ., , _- _.� , - '. Z. �._IN _f i*. % - .; III -1 �L I- - I , -
I— _- . : ,;: .i� =,-�� -1 �. . . .--, *;...
� , , ,_ .
- .- _A7, .. .. ;;�11. .ti��. ,F-��: _SZ lw-s� . 1. - -- - � -:�- k;� "' , , , -,.,:.,;-
. ��__�_-7�tv __
-�... I . I I _ ,I_ - - ;4c , ::�j;l � -1� �:.V'r,�_
-;S� _11 . . . . . . . . ,;.-;. %: t�_�-,�;:, -..,-
- - 11--Im *-,:�i.-, 1*�_. - - .,.-..":.-.�.;".It;�,,--..'-�f-'--.'�4
Z, I . .
- - -
`;,�*�,-�A-? _,V_I
1� I Sc. .� ��!.- -
, -61'
, -
ei,,,,.;�--7.j";Ajj�:P� -.I'.-- 0.�_-
-
.- "
, �
i . .
- .;V�;_ 4� * - 4 -
7 - ���-. % -1 - .., __.,
I �,7 - 1: �,�,v -.1w, -,•"
z ... I - - - --. , !.7_1.7i"4�51_ , - _1� 140- � . __; - .,- . - - - -
" . - �1. -
'. -_Q-��,a� - - - __ 1.� .... � - - __' - ... I 1--��---:;."IT�-"r-,;.-,:�:.���;�. - *- : ,-_,J .: - - _..9 ..
.. t� 1��, . .--- -,-47 1 �..'._ " - "I't � * ., . -, - ...... . � .
.Jr . !11 _'y ,Lr:�;,ir�__,_ -i �', . g.d
... . , '.�i -�� � -,.-Z:;-"t TF - .. .. ... ,Z�, _.
- -7 1_ --'C� - -C -? -�tl . ..."� "' * � •- f . !,: .
. -:�:�;� fs� - : �11 - , - 1, J�jt� " .. 11-i -, ;;!.-.�._,.,�� - �:`_ *- � , - I
. , - -�!!!!t�,; _4-m , J,. - _:�;.", ; .t.� . - E
-, _ 11--_ ��,,�.%,�.L�!�.;-'��Z�-.��,-..,. 1 .7��- - . ',7.- ...
� ---,- - - , !��`.`:-;.-,',. - - `
- " -, ?" � , - r_I_ - , I I ;;...-".,:. ., - , - - - �-�-- , " o:;;. -. - Z,.,. ... -1
-, � .Tz
...�tk'-71 ,--I!': - . � . , . . .. I �
T_%,�-��,.�Z�tR. I - " . - . ,'PF I _ - . - ". ,
..,�._. z"j, wl."". , - - -�. ,..-- _,,. , -,.;��_,':: , _ , -:". 9 _ - . .'- .-..:� �' ,
r - . . __.:r ,.A,Z�_ ; F . - -.- � '. I - - '... , .. _...., .. . _. .- I ".
; - -,A -t - ,Rk,�_ __ --�,. ::-,-:4'.:�.t'.,", - * . r '., I.. I -1 . . .., __ :�..-
�� � .��4,.4.-� .---- - �.* - � . � -,,�� .. i. 1.
�, , _. -,� �P.;" .1. I" I- I.--:' �__j
.:; .. . � - !roki-, z;r"--_S'- "1.c UA - �_ dow.11. ir�#_. -
""' ,:� ...- .
--1 - %t,N .:--O,Z_-..-.`��.w� ,--i'�,_"�,` __ I 4 - I __.fm:. �
_-
ZIq",.:f!T-`__t-,-�:_.-_- , , , - 5 ��, -�
A,rzp�r-_ -, 7, -_ -w.
;�5 ... . ,� �,- ,
__ -� - -, - I . 11, - '!�. . 1.�q_ .. ., 11 .. .11. .- .. I --- �., �. , - . �17; - ,
-:i•- �f�','�zz:-,-,---i:i�j�z_,-,I.t-c - -4- ..:.-_C._ j. .�, -, , - - , - — - ... . .i - . -: -GA6 -, ,.*�t-;:
. , W e,�� cw
.- , 4 -i - : __ _ - - -1,3 -
*Ic. ` - ,� - . . 4 �,;!�--Ps; -F -R;;� �C . _. 11 I I
__ . r Hi -W -M . igrAXA, _L Jc;� X16--. .
7 .-.-:-�-�,,. - .. ! ?,.- !.�F'-..Vt I.. � -, ,z - -c- _ -
- f.� � . .7 __ I ,,
Vk.� .- -_�r.h-. - - -.--:.; .-.,. -;�6 --..��-- - k . I .t ,7 _�
:,111.1,111 I I",...,. 1. : . , , __ -,;.�-, -, - . j",
I :1 . _7 �. .... . .,
� . . - 4-111111111 __ , .._�,;?'t- .-.:...;--, . , :�. I - , ;;�7 _, - $*,A
. _W�� .- . - , . 471. __"..,
.
i . � .;2 �. . � __ . -1 , ,�:'11 I _� - , .r*--,--- c -A. -..,. _. .
.. . A^ -I - - �4 . � . ,nQ. _. � � - - , . ,W r., . . .. -,::.,. . -. " .,-,.,:
.. - - - -�,,'�-:, -_ " - -, . .. , - -- . . .
i_l� - _'��_--' ,-.- ,-- -57, -, -
111111 -•
� - . ��. - -,.�_. n.-.... _.,: 1,
-'A- ; !� ., - - I . . . 40 _.�z -.11 - -- :-�;�.,�.-., I-Z;� ., - - . ��* � "
11111, .. . � . ,I ., .. '.. -In:;� . ... - -
. _� - I , , �-� - .�. � I . . .4-1. - ,_ 4P.T r- c , .
.�^
.;
: �. I 7_ - . _. . -
: - - Ir - . -, %.; - - -,",- •
- , - : •j - .. T.'"i., - � - - . KZ. V. __ I �___ -, , _. . . .
- i '&� � ;� ,�7. .. V. ,--���� ;. .C.f.., �_� , , �
- `7'�,�.;t-- , N ", ,'��, :,-fl�,, 1,� �- - .. - i.�, ., �. _',j� �, I ,z "
�., _. , . ; . .- .N.4 C#t�;V-��, ... .*_-#'�-,7�� 16u,", . t!,� x _', .
� _* , y
. 4_ 3 .., -�� .,�7 .,%�r 4
.
. . �-�'ri i-,,:�I-!,Pirt -!_.�,. . C��- - _.;-
- , _ _.fr . .
� .7 ;,�.7 -,, �,.; -, �� - :; -7y-.-,-: ------ , .,�, , .,!:�, .- &; - ". .4g - , 7
. . .. -, --..;:. - , _ - - , �
Y. � � -. X ;-- - ,,4--;*,-, .. .--- I -Z;�s'l.,'-�,j,.'.-.,.*...�.���..,----,�.. _ - , . _., .. ,
. . -r ,-,w. _7.�'It 7 . - -.11.1 r..Z�� - .. � .L- ,I-" _��___ )3� -
..
. . . L
- , , - . . i: � - , � . f! .
. .:- - t,. ; ..- . �:Tk IZ-1L, __ !_,.� P_ZN ,
- �?tn �___. _._ . ,-,- ." - _*�,w - - ,'.- - � - " � - ., , ., ... -, . -,--- , ...
. j:.., - , � . -, -1 ,�, -'�1111�11111111"1.ft.6�..--"r..�; --��%-s� 1 4,51i - fz�;�,�. -1 .." .:�- , ��77 ";
- t , - � � ......
.--q;-, � -WI•" 4.�.-Z:i _- � -,4?1; V.31, . -.j, 1477i.; --. , . .. . .
-, _.�_:, iwl-, - - - ., . .... I � - 1�� , I �_, .. -ze ; "
I .--
-:,�, - - - -1-1. 7:1: .. , . .
- - -;k, �-�':t._Pj'�. � . " .�
-:-, . , F_, .. -.. .. Z N - ^�' , _.�_111_1!11111 �r . I.- I , �- ,
Nl,; I - � - - __ , - F,*,7� . "I . , . . �,�. . �
. . , .. - . 'r �� :..-TT--.,�,�
. . .;.--;- -�,
!11 . �z .-
�4! - " - , .; .z. t_ . Z�1,7,,,-�.. I 1111111111- I . - . �
. . � � - � IIIII Z -.,it,��
_..'.. -_ CN, . - . :- _. `�Z!'F , -. - 7�111111,111111111111 . �-;- " -
. �. e!�4v N ip . E, , 5 N. ,
i . . . . . ;.. .�� . - qt- � -r,: �:-;z'::'.
. � .,. . -
. . . . - ..
. ': - .
-, . ;��---. 4 -�!.�4t, -;. . -.1 ,
.-f - : I� - � _
---. _... .. .:.: .. .:..- . .. - . - - �'-- 'A" t4�� * - ".._'�;-:..�,.�,_..-..._.
- . 11- - , ' .:; , ...It. . .. �� _.,� _. " , --I.;, - .
, ...i. ". , , . , X� '. ,.,-" -:;;' - �. Z. , I - ., - - -. _.,��,;:krp�... . I t ., 1- ...
. . -%Ibft.O..,..,-,;t � , . , :.. .. - * ,
.. , ,,- ., _ . , ,;� ------ ;� i - ", "!��' - - -, -',' " �,. -0 �r-,.i ,„,.1111��'ll,7l
1. .;:: .- , i5l>fi(b,et;t�l"...Z-J-Wt�f-,i3�;:*1951r, -4, -. v%.- * -;. -� — .,
. 5 V. '. , % ;I- T __ -_` __� . � -- _n _-;. � . -, ”' , - - .. . � -. ... .,-,.
. . .;, ;..�, , -r- _,�;'.;..�-., , - - � _. ;� .- ".,Z;�, ;t--�-",�'- ,
_ . -z- .. . -- -,
I -1 I - -- �.._-, ..-.� - - - . .,!� ,�,J�4% _- ..! - :,�-
. -, .., ._-;�, . ,.�_ .., -t.;-. --v-77 , .
'- -t ---_-T.-. - . . - -� ..; . - �;, * -;- -�3 _. , -.., -..,;--- - " " . . . . .. .
. , ... �:_,_ --!, ..;�j M.
•_ .-
.;),.,. " -T --C, - - - , --.*,: , -.iZ;K..� . -
.,� .��
. _,�, � - - , ... ... ,_. _'.. __ _.... -e _ . .:;. . ...,
,-_,z � 4. � t. . 4' .. - -_- .r,� *zz-..-_,.".. , -1." �1_11.;W,64_11z- -
. . , --i. -* - . �:..: , -
, , -��'.:.,.-_:-. . . - - , I
� , i . _..... .- - -:,., -. .. .T� .. .,... ,, ,z .- -;---. -
. L * 4 . .,��- )�:�
.
CL.�.e-_A�4 ..%Y4 4;4`�-e L -'-, 4-,:�� 94 --- - - -" "!7 -: - - "" - - - . �
- , , ��.:�, , . . _. . .
.,
. � 'fit' __
, .�;�:,�&-:�:_'�,.', _. - - .. - .Z-_ . . -;I
.----j,.:.-" - . , . - - 1-j--,- ,erf. e'.,-�.. - - ;-.�_! , .-;,ff.x -:.;,�. - - �;, r., - �.. ... 1. -1 _-1 - -X� ---- -un, I �
-1;:,.,: � � �� . - .- -- .. � - � . -t.-- , 4 --' - ,
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
., - � - .. , -, % - ,--�-. <.- � ;�_� t . . �. , . - -Ii-
.
. ..- �_ . . 3 i -ji� -, .--- - -- - � - , - -
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. � ". t�- �,`�'.' . I '. __ �4R; .. .. .
. I . _ I -,:-.:��, _: � - � I *�' "': '- "; :,� . " �-N "�.-- ,-, ',� �_ .�',-7!�.-, !6.:,!- TV
: * " - , I - - - - , ..- ,.� , -j�l - .. --..-. : -,��;�,:.--,� ;,k,: F � .. -9- I'e -:r-,��.,-
,
- - . *' " , -- . - - " - . . .. � * - _ . .. ,__ . . - ;- � _ - ... -
- , 'r - . - - .. , ---5.,: .L..� -,L ". ... !;- - _..�_-; - - .;, , & ---.--; M ... * - -* , -I, �- .";, - �. .;z -, ;, � _.....,_._., *'. �Z, , - .; -,..- ......�. . ..... . -
. - � . - . ... .� . . .
., - .. . , , - - . - .. �. . - - , .. . . , z 't, �
-� - - I .. __ -, - .- - - - .-I I . , ,
_� .,; < " - ;,: .., -- -.-.Z .., �.I�' - -
, . _v -7,
- � -, .�.Z 7- I -� -.I- ...-:,�.-,:;4---';r; -;;.,�,�i�_ -Z,. . - ..
� I A%Ocok�z.., :' - - - , r - - -
. .T, , .4, ,Iz..� __ - . . . . r - . .
.. 1-!M - --,t. , .. ,, �:- , - __ .1'. .., . _.. ... . - - -- - -�
. . .I'. f. I _. t : . - 1.
i . -
, '5-.:� - � 0 � -A. "t.. . " � __ * . " - - t;--. ,� ... 'z,,:' .1 .. - ,
.;� -..-, � . - - J. . . A . �
. .: - ,S-,--"_ z � . �L , .. . .
:,. _..... . -, . -. " - , � - - -, . ,� �v!..I�f,z::;�- .:.-,- VF � 'I-
" .. . .
-, ', -7 .., .� . _.... ._... L 1-� I � �___ m, -z __
�Iz_ '�� ,;, -L '� , - , '. .. - .
'. . , .- .��'.'-. . ., � - �'- I .; . ; , . . . "' `� 'i " :� -. .. . - - ,
. " . .-
. `I�Pz!.-- �-.'.47�-'_�- ,f`- ,,..-�, z ., ; '.. -,:; '.
.:, .
., ;. ,:: � . .
� ;.4� . -,.•
. . 'jW.: -.7 -:._. .-j., ;. �'- . : �. 1.
z . - , �t , , ':_ -�!. - I - - ,�, .-
_ •, _ ..-- .. . 7. . � ., . . .., _ . F", -
1. . . " , � .: -%Fi-. " , , - !��., �%C ,% .., -_.. , . - .., .. . . I , - , " " .... -
y
-, , ,_
,
__-
I I _`
- -
, �
I
, -
,-�--:,
4, . 7:. �: .I... - P. I , . ... _.., ..$,t -n�: , F -'?�;, - r - 'I i _,., . I . . ,__ '. -
� _. .'. � . - - q.�, 1 , , . - , - - . %� , - . - � .-
I A- , rt M- L ]D-,:.. m � - '� . .. .. - � . -:. _ ".. ?. .��. - - -K;. _. . . - . _ .
.. - ;� . .I:.,!-.- _ . - ! . .; _.
t z7e_� _a-t_-IAA&r_I;k&4�S_`: ,--,-- ` ` -�-�---, . ., _ ... �. _. . - I ...... : . . - . ;I .
I ; . - ., ... - . ., j 1. I.-
_ ... ,�. 'e", .� - .'.�_- _-.��- I i:% . . . .. � '6' . � : . __ ,__, ,._,
. ". ...I , -.-r, � - . .._. . _. .
.% I . . " - ,�, ` 7�: :_ _.. , - " I'% .'-! �- _.-�' __ .,.:I- . f ..,
- - I - _ , --� -%, -.--..-. - - - _,;_ _ ... -_-�. _.:�iv . ".: .
-,Z___�, - I .. '..., .. �.e . . ...�.: .. .5,
. -- ..: - . - I I . . . -'kw - z -� -, , :,� . . . . i. .. - . ? , ,
Q�t - ._...� -*.. - .. ;� - _ " - - - L.,:;,.;.Ik �', -, -7-`..-:, -t . -t, . . . I ....,
:.. "
. , , .. - �
-- -;64.� . , , - . 11 - -.1 I -:',
- "_ , - - �-.
. . ". . -Z::, , , - ..., t . - �:�� - in' .. .. .
-�;w, _.. .t . I � " -�,�* � i
..:�, . . . . �
. . I _ �
_ i ,� - - ,--- ,='_,.
. - i _;
i.. � :
, - I . -;. . I - - -A. .; , . . * - -
- - �y . .. . . .1 - . . . , --`� - . , ", ,
.����f;4, . - .... , _�i - � ._WI,V. �,.
.. . . . t .r,.-..:t� _.: , !, I 1, � - , - ... . I:- . I.- . .... --
. - . . I - , * � %, _ _-_ :.. , .. -.-I,
- . - - � -, - , "i, � . - - -, , .,.
- :�,;.,j` - , . . ... - . - - -,-... � -, - .-O.,, ...- .. .:,. -I.. -
.1. .,;.-- m 1. .7 ..- .;.., :!�t' k .'.- . "..; . .. -- . 11:. _,, .. "i .
.- , - * - . , '�' , * - .- - I - ; m.,.,�.-��.. . . ... I - �� .:;,-. ,.. --,. .4- -- " -% :.�, , :_ I % , - ... .. . . _. .1
, -� ..... �; . : , -.1 - -:- .-.:. '. �. . - . . .
-?��.� -77 - - - - -, , .,
- I --:?� . . �
� _ f," .
,
- ... _ __. . - � � -, ..*.. .
. - r,---,. . - - � -,- Ii- -'..-- --- _ : � � _�:: . � ..11. .. � . .. . .;, �. : . . , . _
- -: - -_ " " - - ; , N. 1 .�, ': . * -, -` , - _ , . .. � i.' -71(".`��!- , -
. , _ � . �. L .-' �- .. _- _. . - ..;.. - .: , . . .. , . _.. _ . ... i , .. .r:. � - . . I .
I - ,.�6� . - . � . . .:� :. .. .,. . .. . . . . .- - '! - - - -X. _� �'.. 1, , . �
NI ,..'� . . � . , . �
1, . . . _�, . . . . . , _ 19:. � .. - T .., . � . . .v - . . I . - .
. _.. - . - , i . _.- . . . _ . -_ , . _ _. . .-
�� _.
0. . :_-;-.,",- w.. .,.- ,�,,
7-' , ;z - . , !'L - -, � - -�t -.`�..'� ;,7-.�,-. -V." ,�t: " '�*, - ..�,
:� . . .". - . I., - , t.,�;-.-.,_: . I . -,,I.. ..'r ;'. ,� :*.:�
. . 1, ... - -
. - _ 'I" - �_ - , -�:. .- . _:.� I .:. -;r....-. .,
� - , 1. 1. -:',I-'. - , , -., ..
. - .-: , : a .- �*��'.'-'-'-','-.,--.- - _-.� .-- -r:�-: .'- - 'a, - ,'; ; . . .- ... . .. .,.,:� _,�,. ..�.L"� �'
w , .. - , - ;. . " � - I , . . - ,
*I i��, '. .. k- ,� I .
-r - _. .�;-.,. :_;�� _s_;., - , .. . . � ` ._,-,'t,!-�_s;'*,; .
. - .. �. . .. - -
.., I . -S: - ,;I - - ;-, . . 1. -.4 L.- .
. . . , __ �, " *
: . .- - .: �'.z_1_11,�.. .-' ., .... .. - I . . .
�� . .. - . . - - � �. ..
, - - - 1. . . �
I..
I
APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS
Gerard R Goehringer, Chairman
Serge Doyen
James Dinizio, Jr.
Lydia A. Tortora
BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax (516) 765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1809
FINDINGS, DELIBERATIONS AND DETERMINATION
REGULAR MEETING OF OCTOBER 9, 1997
Appl. #4492 - WALTER KLEIN PARCEL 1000-43-1-8
C
STREET & LOALITY: 3235 Manhanset Avenue, Greenport
DATES OF PUBLIC HEARINGS: July 10, 1997; August 14, 1997;
September 25, 1997 (final hearing) .
FINDINGS (PROPERTY FACTS) :
DESCRIPTION: This property is located in an R-40 Residential Zone
District, being situate along the north side of Manhanset Avenue,
Greenport, and along the west side of a private right-of-way
referred to as "Gull Pond Road." This lot contains a total area of
6,821.29 sq. ft. and is improved with a 1-1/2 story frame, single-
family dwelling with sunroom, the "as built" deck in question, and
"as built" accessory frame garage also in question.
BASIS OF APPEAL: Building Inspector's Action of Disapproval dated
May 28, 1997, which reads as follows: "...under Article III -A,
Section 100-30A.4 Accessory structures are to be located in the
required rear yard and have a maximum height of 18 feet, or 17.5
feet confirmed by applicant ( - also see memo of Ed. Forrester) .
Under Article IIIA, Section 100-30A.3 of the Bulk and Parking
Schedule, "as built" structures exceed the maximum allowable lot
coverage of 200 (at) approx. 24.25% or by 292 sq. ft. Deck
addition "as built" at 8.3 feet from setback ROW is in violation of
15 ft. minimum setback established by ZBA Appeals ruling of
June 12, 1975, #2045.. Under Article IIIA, Section 100-30A.3
normal required setback from ROW is 35 feet...."
AREA VARIANCE RELIEF REQUESTED BY APPLICANT:
1. "As built" 576 sq. ft. accessory work -shop garage building,
substantially located in a front area facing a private right-of-way
to the east, with an "as built" nonconforming setback at 2.4 feet.
The height of this garage is confirmed by applicant's attorney to
meet the maximum 18 ft. height requirement (average mean height
code definition) .
2. "As built" deck addition to existing dwelling. Applicant
modified plan for consideration by removing 157 square feet of deck
area, located on the north and east of the sun room. The removal
of the deck area, as indicated on the revised survey dated Septem-
ber 17, 1997 prepared by Joseph A. Ingegno, will reduce the
existing lot coverage from approx. 24.24 feet percent to not greater
Page 2 - October 9, 1997
Appl. #4492: 1000-43-1-8 (W. Klein)
Southold Town Board of Appeals
than 21 percent (exclusive of driveway and allowable 30 sq. ft. step
areas) . The revised plan will also increase from 8 ft. 3 inches to
11 ft. 3 inches the setback of the remaining 6 ft. by 27 ft. 8 inch
deck to the right-of-way.
REASONS FOR BOARD ACTION, DESCRIBED BELOW:
(1) In considering this application, the board finds that the
revised plans submitted by the applicant and relief requested therein
are the minimum necessary and adequate and at the same time will
preserve and protect the character of the neighborhood, and the
health, safety and welfare of the community:
(2) The granting of the area variance will not produce an
undesirable change in character of neighborhood or a detriment to
nearby properties because the accessory garage has existed for more
than 15 years in its present location with no apparent ill affects on
the existing R.O.W. or surrounding properties. Removal of
approximately 50% of the existing deck area will decrease the degree
of nonconformity in relation to both lot coverage and setback from
the right-of-way.
(3) The benefit sought by the applicant cannot be achieved by some
method, feasible for applicant to pursue, other than an area variance
because the size of the lot is extremely small, 6821 square feet in
area, and there is insufficient land area in the required rear yard
to locate the accessory garage. A cost estimate submitted by Artco
Corp. to remove the garage was in excess of $10,000. Such
expense is unwarranted because the existing location of the garage
is of minimal significance.
(4) The requested area variance is substantial, however, the
applicant's revised plans reduce the degree of existing nonconformity
in lot coverage and deck setback to the right-of-way.
(5) The proposed variance will not have an adverse effect or impact
on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood or
district because the revised plan will be an improvement that will
reduce the degree of nonconformity.
(6) The situation has been self-created because the prior owner(s)
failed to comply with the terms and conditions set forth in the Board
of Appeals ruling #2045 dated June 12, 1975, and subsequent ruling
42781 dated March 5, 1981.
RESOLUTION/ACTION: On motion by Member Tortora, seconded by
Chairman Goehringer, it was
RESOLVED, to GRANT the application as amended, SUBJECT TO
THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS:
1. The deck area comprised of 157 sq. ft. on the north and east
sides of the sun room shall be removed within 90 days, all in
• Page 3 - October 9, 1997
Appl. #4492: 1000-43-1-8 (W. Klein)
Southold Town Board of Appeals
accordance with the revised survey dated September 17, 1997,
prepared by Joseph A. Ingengo, Surveyor. No building permit,
certificate of occupancy or other town entitlement shall be issued
until this condition has been met.
2. The garage shall only be used as a non -habitable accessory
structure. In no event shall it be connected to the principal
single-family residence, nor shall it be occupied or used as a
separate dwelling.
3. The garage shall not be expanded or replaced unless it is moved
to a conforming area.
4. Access to the private right-of-way shall remain open at all times
and there shall be no parking of vehicles within the right-of-way.
5. Grant of this variance supersedes all prior decisions of the
Board of Appeals.
G . These conditions shall be permanently attached to the certificate
of occupancy (C.O.), a copy of which shall be provided to the
Board of Appeals within six months.
AYES: VOTE OF THE BOARD: MEMBERS GOEHRINGER, DINIZIO,
and TORTORA. (Member Doyen a sent.) This lution was
duly adopted (3-0).
GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN
�' Approved for filing
Actions. all/ 43-1-8
APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS
Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman
Serge Doyen
James Dinizio, Jr.
'1}ebert
Lydia A. Tortora
Patricia Moore, Esq.
P.O. Box 483
Mattituck, NY 11952
Re: Variances for
Dear 1V�re:
BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
October 14, 1997
Klein Property
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax (516) 765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1809
Please find enclosed a copy of the board's decision, adopted at
our October 9, 1997 Regular Meeting. A copy has today also been
furnished to the Building Inspector=s Office as an update to their
initial Action of Disapproval and for use in the open building,
permit application file.
Please be sure to amend your application for a building permit
with the Building Department to show the reductions and conditions
written in the ZBA determination.
Very truly yours,
��nr da Kowalski
Enclosure
Copy of Decision to:
Building Department
5-��ua-�6
FOLLOW-UP and UPDATI; FOR YOUR RECORD:
7
TO: All ZBA Members
FROM: ZBA Chairman via ZBA Office
DATE: . 02.5 , 1997 �%.Sd %J•rn,
Attached is an (original) ;;r of(new
information added to the original Town ZBA file)
re: Pending Application of. 71-2r-Ak
Other Comments:
# of: Pages Attached: /
)
Placed in Members' office
mail boxes for update on
7/d5/97 by
�.
--------------------
Board.Trans
FOLLOW-UP and UPDATE FOIL YOUR RECORD:
TO: All ZBA Members
FROM: ZBA Chairman via ZBA Office
DATE: a5 1997 F,' -5t ,9 M,
At Cached is an (original)(new
information added to the original Town ZBA file)
re: Pending Application of l.(>>. &Z:g:e
Other Comments:
( )
4 of. Pages Attached: / }
Placed in Members' office mail boxes for update on
--------------------
Board.Trans
7/,6/97 by �.
NI0/F
PIAN E. REINFURT
N S4509
50" E o
,�
35.80\ T �
Rw Ln0
o
O ' 2.4
ti FR t�0
Q4 AN
O
�• y "`•ac M466
"16.0
�
�?
V ti, FRq ?STOR H `rn r
\p yOUtz
SE o b
c�N Crlv
24.0 1 b0
' � � a
l80.pp,
o / / WOon CURB
4 V / �g1G a / • .• • O
4-4 41001D STONE DRNEWAY
0 't ; / WOOD CURBING I `
►"Y � a
a G p O7 a
•� _ G I rye
• . - : t • ••
a 9 00'K
PA
•.
NA3� a ..
/ c -
SURVEY OF PROPERTY
SI T UA TED AT
GREENPORT
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
SUFFOLK COUNTY, NEW YORK
S.C. TAX No. 1000-43-01-08
SCALE 1"=20'
APRIL 9, 1997
SEPTEMBER 17, 1997 SHOW PORTION OF DECK TC BE REMOVED
TOTAL LOT AREA = 6,821.29 sq. ft.
0.157 ac.
LOT COVERAGE DATA
DESCRIPTION
AREA
% LOT COVERAGE
DRIVEWAY
931 sq. ft.
13.64%
DECK
167 sq. ft.
2.45%
HOUSE & SUN ROOM
756 sq. ft.
11.08%
GARAGE
576 sq. ft.
8.44%
CERTIFIED T0:
WALTER KLEIN
UNATHORIZED ALTERATION OR ADDITION
TO THIS SURVEY IS A VIOLATION OF
SECTION 7209 OF THE NEW YORK STATE
EDUCATION LAW.
COPIES OF THIS SURVEY MAP NOT BEARING
THE LAND SURVEYOR'S INKED SEAL OR
EMBOSSED SEAL SHALL NOT BE CONSIDERED
TO BE A VALID TRUE COPY.
CERTIFICATIONS INDICATED HEREON SHALL RUN
ONLY TO THE PERSON FOR WHOM THE SURVEY
IS PREPARED, AND ON HIS BEHALF TO THE
TITLE COMPANY, GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY AND
LENDING INSTITUTION LISTED HEREON, AND
TO THE ASSIGNEES OF THE LENDING INSTI—
TUTION. CERTIFICATIONS ARE NOT TRANSFERABLE.
THE EXISTENCE OF RIGHTS OF WAY
AND/OR EASEMENTS OF RECORD, IF
ANY; NOT SHOWN ARE NOT GUARANTEED.
PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE MINIMUM
STANDARDS FOR TITLE SURVEYS AS ESTABLISHED
Joseph 'A. ingegno
Land Surveyor
Title Surveys — Subdivisions — Site Plans — Construction Layout
PHONE (516)727-2090 Fax (516)722-5093
OFFICES LOCATED AT MAILING ADDRESS
One Union Square P.O. Box 1931
Aquebogue, New York 11931 Riverhead, New York 11S*
1
Southold Town
Southold Town
Main Road
Southold, NY
Dear Linda:
w
PATRICIA C. MOORE
Attorney at Law
315 Westphalia Road
P.O. Box 483
Mattituck, New York 11952
Tel: (516) 298-562
Fax: (516) 298-5661
81997
July 18, 1997
Zoning Board of Appeals
Hall
11971
Re: Variance Application of Walter Klein
Rutkowski
Secretary
Enclosed please find the following for the above referenced
matter:
1. A copy of the survey which shows the pink highlighted
area as the area of the deck to be cut off.
The smaller area is approx. 6 x 6 = 36 sq.ft.
The larger area is approx. 10 x 14 = 140 sq.ft. (steps included)
The deck area to remain is the wood walkway along the side of the
house which is 27.8 'x 6 '. One step may be required from the deck
to the grade.
2.' A copy of the tax map with. the names of the property
owners who may have a right to use the right-of-way.is enclosed.
Please note that Lot #10 has an adjoining parcel (Lot #4) which
fronts on Angler's La., the parcels may be deemed merged by the
building department; Lot # 20.1 has direct road frontage on
Ang'ler's lane; Lot #19 has a right to this Right-of-way, but the
closest point is Meadow Lane & Angler's Lane. All these properties
would require 280A approval from the ZBA, therefore the board would
have input on the best access for each lot.
3. Also, please note that the right-of-way is completely
impassable beyond Mrs. Reinfurt's property and would require
extensive clearing for future access to any of the above mentioned
parcels..
On July 17, 1997, I hand delivered a copy of the relevant
pages from the book which you requested during the hearing for the
file. If there is any other information you need please do not
hesitate to contact me.
Very truly yours,
atricia Moore
PCM/mr
Encls.
cc: Mr: and Mrs. Klein
"y`~ '{ s;; • N10 REINF URT :
MARIAN: E.
15Cr E,
8,4750
35.80
Oyap , Af'c-
04Rq�F
`'` Q1 J%DY
.01
AD0.— 4V,
Cv
my
BUND 20.3
,.•�' i'. ;tib` • 18� 00• FS / / �• I;' `
►FOOD
�t9
R l4A 1
*00'
W ° STONE DWVEWAY a'
A/474
WOOD CURBING14
9.
z ' q . 0.
q 00•
}y�','yc,�� - 't .!' '�i, < 7✓' � . '. ��, '° ♦i' ',fid ,. (5 :+�•
I Lj
06
*VC)
1.0AW
23.4
IjAw
it LTA (0
MEADOW Li — — — — — ____•\
---
o
22
IT ,A(-1 of
41,
FOR
,=AQ5eE5t a.o43
7.3
MAIC w.1
5ec w0.036 O.Q34
1 4 Io
a.
2.1
oA
It
3T. AGNES CEM.
I.T A I.) e� 3 5
A
It
T Is
6
13 IJ A (91
1444 of 6 4
zq ori
ma
A
INLET
FO"P RCELNa
SGE IEC o.cI3
_.z -ml
LIME
TOWN OF
SOUTHOLD
I
t.GA(c)
16
TOWN
OF
arms
CInt 5 IL&I-Ir-
ioob-.36- -4
_j
Munkel Le 5i le� r'
a &:
Crus
m
")env
)ac) o - 3 j6
FILJULg 1y9�
1..�
23.3
Z—
2
2 5.4
I.IAk
0
F SEE SEC. N0. 132
BA(c)
ISA(cl. • w•
A02
° MEADOW LA. (5o') — -- ------
0
o
/NLET
3
u
_
v 2A
•a
4" a' l O gee_ 12 : A
M A (c)
i p
Q b 9 J
Q•f
/ X
13
S 6e1 R T
W
••
W
ti �o-W : 26A
21
/ FOR PARCEL NO
SEE SEC. NO -04] j:
-02-007 Nsai,coo
_
FOR gE0�.043
BEE TENT
yATCN�LINE -- 0
o
U. 14.. 2
:w°HI� -os
.
I 00D - 436 - a2
L,C*
�,Z���tIP� e s-fier
M v n
• E SEC.110. 043 14A 1..) •7 _.
on MLIM036SEE SEC. N0.036 N St7,01C
NNCEI N0. 0T_OSS S wu/yCEI NATCN INE
AKN Ll�l XF.. SEC. W' T'- 7 T e t
•ai SEE SEC
zd�INE_ 1 / / Mar �a n
S� TOWN OF
1.0A 3.3 a SOUTHOLD
i 8 ({fes O O •a 1.3A(°I / _.�.
Q j f� ° , .� •° • 1 (WIEER1fATER)43
AX
7
4/4 Q e g ,a• TCWN OF 2.6A10
NMq ¢ SOUTHOLD
• "Ser N '- s .� 4 Sone ph i nR.
a '
ISO')
12
Is. leu .•e' a•e + ,..
X19 27 34 1000
y,r•
3 � i
13 ewe 1.3 A (°) `M!
Iee20. n n ',.
8.6 A (e) I
c s xI S _ "s 2e°° .°• } TOFN : G [O -V
r°
1 d g 14 N.re E xz ea ° SOUTHOLD
J 36 E
423 3 30 ® _ _ _
l
J
15 Ind 25.3 q 31 r Y 3. 17
u _ 10 _ 1e°• 36 er.
Z 2S.2 9 32
G F 4z 16
u�♦,p.
3� qc J
O _ 3S 8'- _ — - S �� fit' 9' is 3
39
\ TOWN OF IT IP)
SOUTHOLD 2e dJ/'•
r
xEw rartN I =
STATE , roe °0(60) (10 p
1 ;S 7 21 e
GARDINERS BAY
� E2
�• o °O O _ 3
�.; CL 41 • °1 e
n° a
'•0 7 42 J
(; Z
O O
NEw YORXx 'N K9
- _
STAT[ ��. 43 4
IUNOENw.TER 12 e'// SEE SEC. NO. 132
44
STERLING CPEEK � \��•\ F = ° a F �l
45'° co ° 10
�Ye: 13.1 .••.
R
Me 160.1
E S.°14}61.7
-.-- -WIND(
q
vi
7
i�M
- -- --.- TO P
3
fR o N 7-
pm
CONCPETE FOUMPATION
PDO YVS
TPE ALEIIV GARACE
� IDE
7
BOARD OF APPEALS:TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
-----------------------------------x
In the Matter of the Application
AFFIDAVIT
of
Walter Klein
(Name of Applicants)
------------------------------------x
AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING AND POSTING
COUNTY OF SUFFOLK)
STATE OF NEW YORK)
I,
, residing at.
New York, being duly sworn, depose and say that:
by rtified mail, return receipt requested, a true copy of the
attache - Notice, addressed to each of the following named
persons a the addresses set opposite their respective names, that
the addresses the_
below are those shown on the current assess-
ment rolls of the own of Southold; that said Notices were mailed at
the United States t Office to each of said persons by certified
mail, return receipt req sted:
Name of Surrounding Protty Owner Maili.nM Address
2) On the p?� day of Q U� , 1997, 1 ersonaily posted
the pro erty identified as District 1000, Section ,
Block �, Lot iF . , by placing the Town's official poster
ten (10) feet, or closer, from the property line facing the street
(or facing the right-of-way) , and that I have checked to be sure
the poster has remained in place for seven full days prior to the
date of the public hearing (date of hear' oted t on to be held
-7/`0 l 1997). -
Sworn to before me this (signature)
Or_!f- .svl.1 -
> day of Y , 199I _
MARC C. R�!T,[C�y^yl MAMA RET C. RUTK6=1
Notary r'uL!i , Jc Notary Pub% State of New York
Notar• No. 4982528
Q 1.r Quoin'I I I
Comrvss!on En S &soya( County
Commission S;.pires jVp 3,1, P 9 %
(Please return to the office of the Board of Appeals +nen completed.
Thank you.)
� 7W rr• , ..
rww
a
44
June 13,1997
PATRICIA C. MOORE
Attorney at Law
315 Westphalia Road
P.O. Box 483
Mattituck, New York 11952
Tel: (516) 298-5629
Fax: (516) 298-5664
Southold Town Zoning Board of Appeals
Southold Town Hall
Main Road
Southold, NY 11971
Dear Linda:
Margaret Rutkowski
Secretary
Re: Variance Application of Walter Klein
Thank you for your letter dated June 12,1997 with regard to
the above referenced matter. Enclosed please find a copy of the
current deed which you requested. Mr. Klein purchased the
property from the Estate of James D'Aquisto on November 22,1996.
As the letter which is in your file from Mr. Hart of Pelletreau &
Pelletreau indicates Mr. Klein was prohibited from making this
application until he was the title owner.
I have revised the disclosure to reflect that the applicant,
Mr. Klein is the only person with an interest in this property.
Enclosed please find the notice to adjacent property owner,
'`'dia ram of the structures, and affidavit of mailing.
� (Svn��
My client is preparing a building plan (sketch) of the garage.
The garage is within the 18 feet height requirements in the code,
this was confirmed by Ed Forester in a memo. to Gary Fish dated May
16,1997. Mr. Klein had measured the garage to be 17.5 feet high
from the grade. However, I have asked him to confirm this
information.
Thank you for your assistance in this matter, if there is
anything further.you need please do not hesitate to contact me.
Very truly yours,
atricia C. Moore
P.S. Mr. Klein has re—measured the garage. The height from the foundation to
the top of the wall where the roof starts to slant is 7 ft. 9 in. The height
from the foundation to the peak is 16 ft. 10 in.
-13' 97 (FRI )
f'
1043 CAMINI�''i a GIB9�U DWIE 516--/o7-5902
l JUN 1,37,19971 (
std N.Y.B.T.U. Poon 8005Adminirl lwex Deed-Individm or Cugvnum (single Sheet)
.•-_ P. 002
CONSULT YOUR LAwnR BEFOiM SIGNING T= INSPRUAWNT TM INMUM>I M SDOULD BE USED
By LAwYEAS ONLY
T= MENTURE made the _C22 day of Noven er, ninetear hundred and ninety -aft
BETWEEN PHnLIS WAQUISTO, residing at 41 Lolly Lane, Centereach, Ny 11720,
as Administratrix of the Estate of JAMES VAQUISTO, who died on April 18, 1995,
DIST. pursuant to Letters of Administration dated July 17, 1995,
1000 party of the first part, and
SEC. WALTER ROLAND KLEIN, residing at 5791 North Chieftain Trail, Tucson, AZ 85750
043,00 party of the second part,
BLIiG Wr NESSETH, that whereas fetters of Administration were issued to the party of the first
Part by the Surrogate's Court, Suffolk County, New York, on July 17, 1995, and by virtue
01,00 of the power and authority given in and by said last will and testament, and/or by Article
11 of the Estate, Powers and Trusts Law, and in consideration of ONE 1F uNDRED
LOT THOUSAND AND 00/100 DOLLARS ($100,000.00), paid by the party of the second part,
the party of the first part does hereby grant and release unto the party of the second part, the
008.000 distributees or successors and assigns of the party of the second part .forever,
ALL that certain plot, piece or parcel of land, together with the buildings and improvements
thereon erected, situate, lying and being at Greenport, in the Town of Southold, Suffolk
County, New York, bounded and described as follows:
BEGINNING at a point on the northerly line of Manhanset Avenue 180 feet in an easterly
direction along said Avenue from the point where Marthanset Avenue is intersected by the
easterly line of proposed public highway to be known as Anglers Road;
RUNNING THENCE North 21" 24' 10" East along land of Soygen 100 feet to land now
or formerly of Reinf m;
RUNNING TIlCENCE North 84" 50' 50" East along saaid land of Reinf4rt, 35.80 feet to
a private road known as Gull Pond. Lane (Pell);
RUNNING THENCE along said Oull Pond Lane (Pell) South 50 09' 10" East, 129.68 feet
to the northerly line of Manhanset Avenue;
RUNNING THENCE along the northerly line of Mahanset Avenue North 68" 35' 50"
West 90 feet to the point or place of BEGINNING.
BEING .AND INTENDED to be the same premises described in deed to the decedent,
JAMES D'AQUISTO, dated January 9; 1980, and recorded in the Suffolk County Clerk's
Office on January 22, 1980, in Liber 8766, at Page 599.
SAID PREMISES ARE KNOWN AS: 3235 Manhanset Avenue, Greenport, New York
11944
TOGETHER with all right, title and interest, if any, of the party of the first part in and to
any streets and roads abutting the above described premises to the center lines thereof;
TOGETHER with the appurtenances, and also all the estate which the said decedent had
at the time of decedent's death in said premises, and also the estate therein, which the party
of the first part has or has power to convey or dispose of, whether individually, or by virtue
of said will or otherwise; TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the premises herein granted unto
the party of the second part, the heirs or successors and assigns of the party of the second
part forever.
� � 4
„M'97(FRI) 10:44 CAMINIT, GIBBONS 516-1b6-5902
it LM
P. 003
AND the pony of the first part ,covenants that the party of the first pan has not done or
In suffered anything whereby the said premises have been incuznbered in any way whatever,
Cz except as aforesaid.
00 Subject to the trust fund provisions of section thirteen of the Lien LAW.
The word "Party” shall- be construed as if it read "parties" whenever the sense of this
indenture so requires.
IN WMESS WHEREOF, the party of the first part has duly executed this deed the day
and year first above written.
IN PRESENCE OF:
C
L—
AAd�
ylHJ DAquisto, trX
STATE OF NEW YORK)
)
COUNTY OF SUFFOLK)
On November d-; 1996, before me personally came PMLIS D'AQUISTO, to me
known to be Administratrix of the Estate of James D'Aquisto'and the individual described in
and who executed the foregoing instrument and she acknowledged to. -me that she executed the
same.
ADM]NISTRATOWS DEED
THE ESTATE OF JAMES DAQUISTO
TO
WALTER ROLAND JaXIN
deed
RETURN BY MAEL- TO:
Paul A. Caminiti, 14
Caminiti & Gibbons
P.O. Box 992
Southold, NY 11971
0
C R 0 W IE,
JUL 41 110 w
20
faLe) �e*
�-- (e , e -t I
IA -A
. ..................
............................................................................... TRANSMISSION RESULT REPORT ....................(JUL 10 '97 09:56AM)..................
SOL LD TOWN HALL 516 765 1623
................................................................................................................................................................................ (AUTO) ......................
DATE START. REMOTE TERMINAL_ TIME RE- MODE TOTAL PERSONAL LABEL FILE
TIME IDENTIFICATION SULTS PAGES NO.
JUL 10 09:55RM 2985664 00'43" ,OK S 01 019
...................................................................................................................................................................................................0...0.0.............
E)ECM ?)REDUCTION S)STANDARD M)MEMORY C)CONFIDENTIAL #)BATCH
D)DETAIL $)TRANSFER
F)FINE P)POLLING
�P
The World's Premier
Guitar Store
Southhold Town Zon
Mr. Gerard P. Goehri
Box 1179
Southold, NY 11971
June 21, 1997
Board&
,UM 2 51997 II,
V,
It has been brought to our attention that the workshop of James D'Aquisto will be
discussed at a public hearing Thursday, July 10, 1997 at the Southold Town Hall at 7:15
p.m. This is with regard to a variance to keep the garage/workshop on the property.
James D'Aquisto had achieved an international reputation for building some of the finest
guitars ever produced by any maker in the history of the instrument. His workshop is
practically an international shrine to guitar lovers. It would be a tragedy to have it torn
down.
Sincerely
cc: Pat Moore
315 Westphalia Rd
Mattituck, NY 11951
Specialists in Vintage Guitars,
Mandolins & Banjos
Established 1970
400 Broadway
Nashville, TN 37203 USA
phone 615.256.2033
fax 615.255.2021
email gruhn@gruhn.com
r
DISCLOSURE
i
JUL A;1 11
I, William D. Moore hereby state pursuant to General Municipal Law Section 809 and
Southold Town Code Article 10 the following:
1. An application has been submitted by Patricia C. Moore to the Southold Town
Zoning Board of Appeals for a 280A Variance on behalf of Andrew Lettieri and Joe Gazza.
2. Patricia C. Moore is an attorney duly licensed in the State of New York practicing
as a sole practicioner with her own clients. She is not affiliated with my law practice.
3. Patricia C. Moore is my wife.
4. I am a member of the Southold Town Board.
5. I do not directly or indirectly review, discuss or participate to any extent in the
matter of Andrew Lettieri and Joe Gazza before the Southold Town Zoning Board.
6. Patricia C. Moore is compensated for her legal services, at an hourly rate,
regardless of the outcome of the case, and her fee is not contingent on the results obtained.
Dated: July 16, 1997
Moore
5
JUN 2 3199F
June 20, 1997
dot ik-
629bm�«
FOREST AVENUE.
EN ISLAND, NY 10310-2576
718-981-3226, 981-8585
FAX 718-816-4416
Mr. Gerard P. Goehringer,
Chairman
Southold Town Zoning Board of Appeals
Box` 1179
Southold, NY 11971
Dear Mr. Goehringer:
it :icE `Ji:.c to ::iy &t: E:i:,ti%ii tiio: i lib i. .8ers 'J'L' .icT1Y i&te
James D'Aquisto's house and workshop in Greenport are being faced
with having to remove Mr. D'Aquisto's workshop (a converted garage)
from the property.
I would like to state for the record that forcing the owners to
remove that workshop would be a travesty against all good judgement
and artistic sensibility.
James D'Aquisto is considered by many (including us, and we are experts
in this field) to be the finest archtop (jazz) guitar builder of all
time. He will be (and to many already is) revered at the same
exalted level, in his own art, as are Leonardo DaVinci, Michaelangelo,
Stradivarius, Picasso, Van Gogh, and others in their genres.
Mr. D'Aquisto's total life output was only around 350 instruments,.
His illness prevented him from making more pieces than that.
All of his late work, which is considered his best work, was made
in that workshop, work which presently sells in the range of
sixty thousand to one hundred thousand dollars apiece and prices
rise continually. His influence on modern guitar making is far
reaching. He was willing, in that workshop, to take risks and create
designs whose influence will be felt for centuries.
To force the present owners to destroy that workshop would be to
lose for all eternity 'Lhe site of. a potential futare--useua. to =.e
of America's greatest artists and craftspersops.
We hope that a variance can be granted to allow that workshop to
be preserved.
Sin er y,
Stanley M.
FINE MANDOLINS, GUITARS AND BANJOS
t
S�FFOt
EDWARD FORRESTER
Town Investigator
C= y
O
OFFICE OF THE TOWN ATTORNEY
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
To; Gary Fish, Building Inspector
From; Ed Forrester, Town Investigator
Date; May 16, 1997
Re; Premises at 3235 Manhanset Ave Greenport
SCTM# 1000-43-1-8
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax (516) 765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1889
At 1:30 PM on May 16th I went to the above referenced address at
your request. I met with the owner, Walter Klein, and conducted
an inspection of the structure at the rear of the principle
dwelling. I observed a wood frame structure comprised of one
large room with a loft above. The structure is insulated with
the exception of the double doors. The structure has an
electrical panel with approximately 100 amp service. The is no
permanent heat. I observed two LP tanks on the north side of the
structure that I was told supply fuel to the main dwelling only.
This space is not arranged for, nor do I believe is capable of,
being a habitable space. In addition, the median height of the
structure is below 18 feet.
APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS
Gerard R Goehringer, Chairman
Serge Doyen
James Dinizio, Jr.
am
Lydia A. Tortora
Maureen C. Ostermann
Patricia C. Moore, Esq.
P.O. Box 483
Mattituck, NY 11952
BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax (516) 765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1809
June 12, 1997
3 P— . /Q -%'-
Re: Appl. No. 4492 - Walter Klein Variances
Dear Mrs. Moore:
This will confirm receipt of the above application for
processing. On June 5, 1997, a board resolution was adopted
scheduling the public hearing for 7:15 p.m. on Thursday, July 10,
1997.
In the interim, the following are requested:
(a) copy of the current deed (not on file with the Town);
(b)
disclosure of
other persons or
entity that may have a
financial
interest in
the property or
this application (the
disclosure
questionnaire
is enclosed for your
use and convenience);
(c) notice should now be sent certified mail, return receipt
requested, to all surrounding property owners - including those
across the right-of-way and across Manhanset Avenue. When
sending notice, please include a copy of the survey map, and
confirm the date and place for the public hearing;
(d) rough sketch showing the height (mean height and tallest
height from ground) .
Very truly yours,
Linda Kowalski
Enclosure
,o
BOARD OF APPIALS:TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
-----------------------------------x
,7QWC
I ,,7�
J ___ i997�
In the Matter of the Application
AFFIDAVIT
of
Walter Klein
(Name of Applicants)
------------------------------------x
AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING AND POSTING
COUNTY OF SUFFOLK)
STATE OF NEW YORK)
I, Margaret Rutkowski, residing at. Theresa Drive, Mattituck; T -l'
New York, being duly sworn, depose and say that:
1) On the 13 day of ,Tune 1997, 4M, I personally mailed,
by certified mail, return receipt 'requested, a true copy of the
attached -fNW Notice, addressed to each of the following. named
persons at the addresses set opposite their respective names, that
the addresses listed below are those shown on the current assess-
ment rolls of the Town of Southold; that said Notices were mailed at
the United States Post Office to each of said persons by certified
mail, return receipt requested:
Name of Surrounding; Property Owner Mailing Address
and,
the prone r tified as District 1000, Section ,
Block Lot by placing the Town's official poster
ten (10) feet, or closer, fromperty line facing the street
(or facing the right-of-way), and that '�1� checked to be sure
the poster has remained in place for seven full or to the
Sworn to before me this signature)
1997.
f'l RIC1A Q MOON
NMW Pow Stas of Now *k
otary Public cCounty-No.4�1668
OM MWeion Expires June t e, 19, e
(Please return to the office of the Board of anneals when completed..
Thank you.)
Y
r�
fr
,o
BOARD OF APPIALS:TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
-----------------------------------x
,7QWC
I ,,7�
J ___ i997�
In the Matter of the Application
AFFIDAVIT
of
Walter Klein
(Name of Applicants)
------------------------------------x
AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING AND POSTING
COUNTY OF SUFFOLK)
STATE OF NEW YORK)
I, Margaret Rutkowski, residing at. Theresa Drive, Mattituck; T -l'
New York, being duly sworn, depose and say that:
1) On the 13 day of ,Tune 1997, 4M, I personally mailed,
by certified mail, return receipt 'requested, a true copy of the
attached -fNW Notice, addressed to each of the following. named
persons at the addresses set opposite their respective names, that
the addresses listed below are those shown on the current assess-
ment rolls of the Town of Southold; that said Notices were mailed at
the United States Post Office to each of said persons by certified
mail, return receipt requested:
Name of Surrounding; Property Owner Mailing Address
and,
the prone r tified as District 1000, Section ,
Block Lot by placing the Town's official poster
ten (10) feet, or closer, fromperty line facing the street
(or facing the right-of-way), and that '�1� checked to be sure
the poster has remained in place for seven full or to the
Sworn to before me this signature)
1997.
f'l RIC1A Q MOON
NMW Pow Stas of Now *k
otary Public cCounty-No.4�1668
OM MWeion Expires June t e, 19, e
(Please return to the office of the Board of anneals when completed..
Thank you.)
BOARD OF APPEALS, TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
J7It
JUN I , :7,1997
LA
In tite Matter or tite Petition z!f
NOTICE
Walter Klein
TO
to the Board of Appeals of the Town of Soutliold ADJACENT
TO:
YOU ARE HEREBY GIVEN NOTICE:
PROPERTY OWNER
1. That it is the intention of the undersigned to petition the Board of Appeals of the hown of Southold
to request a (Variance) (NJ6KX-!circle choice)
HEARING SCHEDULED FOR TH RSDA JULY 1 ,_997 at 7:15 t �_
2. That thro erty which is the subject of the Petition is located adjacent to your property and is des-
cribed as follows:�3T39 Manhasset Avenue, Greenport
3. That the property which is the subject of such Petition is located in the following zoning, district:
r-40
-1 llrat h� such Petition, the undersigned will request the following relief: To al low a11sX-r-uc-tures
which are presently in violation of zoning (garage and deck) to rema-in.
asbili 1 t, sari anc esnP�Pcc�3z_ a—gip �r--�e--thae�s to—�r�rL—e�wsy--_—
and lot coverage exceeded by 292 sq.ft.
5. That the provisions of the Southold Town Zoning Code applicable to the relief sought by the under-
signed are Article TTTA Section_100-30A ---
6. That a written Petition requesting the relief specivied -hove will
be filed in the Southold Town Clerk's Office at Main Road Southold, New York and you may then and there
examine tite same during regular office hours. (516) 795-1809.
7. That before the relief sought may be granted, a public hearing must be held on the matter by the
Board of Appeals; that a notice of such (tearing must be published at least five clays prior to the date of such
hearing in the Long Island Traveler-Mattituck watchman, newspapers published in the
Town of Southold and designated for the publication of such notices; that you or your representative have the
right to appear and be heard at such hearing. ,
Dated: a.
Petitioner Patricia C. Moore Esq.
0 w n e r ' Naine s : Walter
Post Office Address
315 Westphalia Rd.
Tel. No. (516 ) 298-5629
[Copy of sketch or plan showing proposal
purposes.]
to be attached for convenience
PROOF OF MAILING OF NOTICE
ATTACH CERTIrTED MAIL RECEIPTS
NAME ADDRESS
43-1-7: Howard & Grace Sorgen 6 Algonquin Drive, Huntington Station NY
11746
43-1-9: Marian Reinfurt 10-28 49th Avenue, Long Island City NY 11101
43-4-12: John & Diana Retos 68 Keeler Drive, Albany NY 12208
.43-4-18: Emmanuel Tzannes 229 Washington Ave., Garden City NY 11530
36-2-18: Nicholas W. & Jacqueline Durka 530 Angler Road, Greenport NY 11944
36-2-23.2: Carol Tuthill and Nicholas W. Durka 530 Angler Road, Greenport NY
43-2-3: Dimitrios Sariyiannis & wf. 171 79th Street, Brooklyn NY 11209
43-2-2.1: Anne Lawrence & others, Trustees, c/o Jayne Kiewra
16 Hillside Ave., Northport NY 11768
.a
f
® ;
cl)
N
M
I V)
CM
O
1
n
tt3 y
CD
cd dJ
Cts
pCl �4 a., o
—�
V
E
rQ
f�1
VEn
V L 0 fA •u ^'
c
aoi
LL
E N
a`�i'n X
M
Z ®V O a1 F1
Napo m ._ . .rl `5
OE
a41i
1
�c C
ro r -•I
4J .�
m .�
>
0
v) 0 .c -
•� m Cn
m
O
O v1 o t~ 'ff •—I O
m
tL d
v
o n m
m 0 a� v
cc
in
o 0
A [n -i pq
D
y
c n
� o E
¢ E
z 0 ao
a
U U)
¢
°A d m
cc: ¢
O o
9661 iudv loos£ wJod Sd !
STATE OF NEW YORK ) ss.:
COUNTY OF SUFFOLK)
Margaret Rutkowski residing at Theresa Drive, Mattituck, NY
being duly sworn, deposes and says that on the 13th day
of i June , 19 97• , deponent mailed a true copy of the Notice set forth on the re-
verse side hereof, directed to each of the above-named persons at the addresses set opposite their respective
names; that the addresses set opposite the names of said persons are the addresses of said persons as shown on
the current assessment roll of the Town of Southold; that said Notices were mailed at the United States Post Of-
fico at Mattituck NY _; that said Notices were mailed to each of said persons by
(certified) mail.
(Ma garet Rutkowski
Sworn to before me this 13th
clay of '-----Ziune , 19 97
Notary Public
PATRICIA C. MCORE
Notary Public, State of New Ydrk
Suffolk County - No. 4869 668
Commission Expires June IS, 29-91911,
f
(This side does not have to be con►pleted on form transmitted to adjoining
property owners.)
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
jjvptjRT,
BRIAN
A ,
E
84!50'50
35-80
Co
IV x
q4
AN
r Ilk*
Z
C
16
ry
.0, A.
n,,
44 FRA f? STS'
1,00.
Vv
y X80 2
CV
00,
Woo CURB
IA
A
*odo ♦STONE DRIVEWAYEWAY
68-
lP4)ZV..
WOOD CURBING
4.
qtr tD
A,
9
A. 0.0 .9.
.0
•�•' � it .. - � .. � 1•.,V/(�� ]' .f!� + t� •
01,
19
r
sg 2 3'�i
tvu' ICE
_ SOUTHOLD TOWN
` BOARD OFAPPEALS
THURSDAY,
SEPrEM BER 25,1997 • -
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN, pur-
suant io Section 267 of. the Town Law
and the Code of the Town -of Southold;
the -following applications will be held
for public hearings by 'the
SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF
APPEALS,at the Southold -Town Hail,
53095 Main Road, Southold, New
York 11971, on THURSDAY, SEP-
TEMBER 25, 1997 at the times -noted -
below (or as - soon thereafter as possi-
ble):
6:45 p.m.. Appl. #4506 —Appli-
=tion by Lillian J. Mulligan Estate•
This is a request for a Variance under -
Article IIIA, Section 100-30A.3, based
upon the August 5, 1997•Notice--of_
Disapproval issued by' the Building
Inspector regarding, "as built" deck -
addition, disapproved on the following
grounds: "the deck addition "as built"
will exceed the maximum allowable lot
coverage of 20 percent, or 1500 square
feet. The. deck addition will -.increase .
the lot coverage. to 1635 sq. ft.. or
approximatley 21.75 percent."
STATE OF NEW YORK)
) SS:
W
TY OF SUFFOLK
rndhaal),
f Mattituck, in
said County, being duly sworn, says that he/she
Is Principal Clerk of THE SUFFOLK TIMES, a
Weekly Newspaper, published at Mattituck, in
the Town of Southold, County of Suffolk and
State of New York, and that the Notice of which
the annexed is a printed copy, has been regular-
ly published in said Newspaper once each week
for weeks successively, commencing on
the JkLday of 194" .
Principal Clerk
Sworn to before me this �t
Location of Property: 210 Third St.,
Laurel, NY; Pari el ID No. 1000-126-7-
sq. ft. of land area and 132.57 lot width -7
,: XXIV,. Section:100-243A, a' noiican=
11. Also known as Lot #72 on the Map
as to 1000-27-4-3 & 2, and with a
remaining house lot of 20,000± sf.•and
--- forting building -with a noneonform-
of George L Tuthill..
6:50 p.m. Appl. #4508.JD
lot width of 100 feet as to 1000 -27 -*1;:,
ing use shall not be enlarged, recon -
stmcted. or structurally altered unless
—
Joseph Melly. This..is.a request for a
. Zone District: R-40. (Schedule AA as:
revised July 22,'1997 shows
; _:. the use of the building is changed to a
-`
Waiver under Article II, section 100-26
based upon the July 24,1997Notice
a site'
`requirement for lots created between
:conforming use: The preexisting bw7d-
ing is located in- the Hamlet Business
of
Disapproval by the Building Inspector.
` April 1957 thru- November 1971 at .,
12,500 sq. ft, and 100 ft, lot width.)
District -and is -not a permitted use. in
this district:
issued on the following grounds...".,;. a
non -conforming lot shall merge with
.. _. 7:10 p.m. Appl, #4492 — W. Klein,.-
(Continued from 8/14/9�.-This.appli-
The side add rear yard set -
backs do not conform to the required
t co fo
.an adjacent conforming or non -con-
forming lot which has been held in
cation is based upon the .Building -
10 ft. side fL rear yard •„d
:-: Loration_:zof .Property: 54360 Main
common ownership with.the first lot at
Inspector's May 28, 1997 Action of
Disapproval, for building in the
Road, Countycel ID
any time aftdr July 1, 1983. -Loi 104-'l
02-24 has merged with 104-02-23
permits
° -:"as built" construction of accessory
: -” #1000=61.4-23: ..
_: .: The Board of -
'res- w� at said
..."
Lo=tion of Property: 1375 &. 1475
garage in an area other- than the '
!_.._required rear yard and deck addition`
time place hear any and all persons
Sterling Road, Cutchogue, NY; Parcel
#1000-104-02-24 & 23: •
with an insnfficient-fiont yard setback:.
'
- in the eve- appli o to�be �
7:00 pm. Appl. #4501— E. Nagy
: • from private right-of-way_ (easterly'
- property line) and excessive `lot cover
=' hearings will' not start' before the time
designated
(Continued from first hearing held
8/28/97). Waiver under -Article II,
-
I. :age,, at 3235 Manhasset Avenue, -
Greenport, NY;1000-43-1-8. Zone: R-
_Each file is available for
,review during -re gular business hours
`
Section 100-26 based upon the July 71
4 40."Propeity size: 6821'sq. ft. ;.
be
1997 Notice -of Disapproval of the
PP
Building Inspector stating two reasons:.
_ ;•
{ 7:25 p.m.. Appl. #4509.LT ..=-
;' submitted before that hearing is con -
chided If you '"have questions,' please
(1) under Article II, . Section 100-
24A(1) land area identified. 1000-,
; . Tonyes Realty Corp. d/b/a Sontltold..
j . Automotive Corp. This is an applica- _
• do not hesitate. to call 765-1809.
" Dated eiitate. to all12; 765-1
as
27-4-2 and 1000-27-4-3 ' were created
i::mtion•requesting:a.-Variance based upon
•," the ,=August 13,'"." 1997. -, Notice
�.'
BY ORDER OF -THE
by deed in;1965-and'do'not meet the
_
ofSOUTHOLD
bisappiovah of.tlie Building Inspector
TOWN
minimum lot: reijuirements (12,500 sf)
and 2 nnderArticle.
() II,; Section 100- :"f;:
' -: in .which `applicant has. applied for. a
�::"
permit construct: addition, an alter
BOARD OF APPEALS
GERARD P. GOEHRIDTGER,
25A,. total land urea merger exists for
:to -
anon to existing
�r n to e g gasoline station, which
Chairman
1000-27-4-1,•2 & 3 having been held in
common o wner'ship'after July -1,1983.
"' `
',,f .4p ,.„.. n _was".O smpproved for the
4 tfolIowiiig: ":::'
By Linda Kowalski
1132-11S18
Location of - ProperfyHarbor Road,
reasons under Article
; : • : •,
Orient, NY. ApplicanE proposes 28,445
..
NOTICE
SOUTHOLD TOWN
BOARD OF APPEALS.
THURSDAY, JULY 10,, 1997
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN,
pursuant to Section 267 of the Town
Law and the Code of the � Town of
Southold, the following applications
will be for public hearings by
the SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD
OF APPEALS, at the Southold
Town Hall, 53095. Main Road,
Southold,-New:...York-:11971, on
THURSDAY, JULY Pi' 1997 at the
times noted below_ (or ns soon there-
-after' possible):
6:50 p.m. Appl. 146': 4494 AN=
TONIO PIRAINO. This.application•
is based. -upon the Building_ Inspec-
tor's , June .1997.'Action;:; of;Disap- - r
proval,-for, a. Variance: under Article
III, Section' 106-32 =Biilk-Schedule,
for permission to place new dwelling I
with.insufficient: front:>yard�setback
from: right -of way; .which;: passes.,, .
-through. center�of, applicant's prop-.
erty, and for.'a reduced'rear-yard set-
back, adon of Property: 3637
Right ray off the west side of
Cox Neck Road, Mattituck; 1000-
113-3-23. Zone: R-80.
6:55 p.m. Appl: No. 4493 —
ANDREW LEPPIERI. This ap-
plication is based upon,the Building
Inspector's June 2, 1997 Action of
Disapproval;- for -a- Variance under
Article III -A, Section 100-30A3. of
the Bulk Schedule, for permission to
place nein dwelling with an insuffi-
cient rear yard setback. Zone: R-40
Zone. Limon of -Property: 1726
Arrowhead Lane (west sideN
7:15: p:m.`�AppL�No 4492 —
STATE OF NE ()RK)
) SS:
OF
? r
1hi of Mattituck, in
said County, being duly sworn, says that he/she
is Principal Clerk of THE SUFFOLK TIMES, a
Weekly Newspaper, published at Mattituck, in
the Town of Southold, County of Suffolk and
State of New York, and that the Notice of which
the annexed is a printed copy, has been regular-
ly published in said Newspaper once each week
for I weeks successively, commencing on
the day of 19(17
' gaiied, rear -yard -and' of-dedc adddiofi
or- shear`watls such
with'an-insutixaeaf�'onr:ysid:se(-
that thebottom of the lowest horizon -
• badcfrom'Pnr80eofa'8Y:(eas
�yti
�9 P?nperty.-line), and:right- exces�ve lot%�.:,
lowest elevated floor is elevated to or.
.coverage at 3235 ManhaasetAveaue,:.
Greenport;. NY;,_`1000-43-r-t3:'Code:_
/ , j° �y
YJ Principal Clerk
:
'Article ':Sectibff
not to impede the flowof water.
Proi bions: IQ -A
- Note: Building Peiinit.No. 22965
100-30A,3and 100-30A:4 ;Zone R='
daied- August -.24,: 1995 authorized=.
40. Property size: 6821:sg8�<==::' -
applicant" ..to renovate and alter. an,
7:25 ..p.m. AppL :No
• existing single-family_ dwelling. as•
NICICEIART
Sworn to lAefore me this
= . -
-p.m:'AppLrNo.-4490-=:
day of 19 �l %
CH
RICHARD and THERESAi
York;1000.442-13: This parcel eon-
ANO. Ibis application is based;:r
��
MARY OIAMA FOSTER
the April 19;.1997 Action of Diaap:,
proval issued by the Building lnspee-_
b) Chapter 46, Section. 46-18A MOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF H YORK
CUIiNP
tor; for -.a Variance . under Article _
new construction add substantial -int- 10. 52-4655242, SUFFOI_Y•
AUGIUST 3' 1 77
xxv Section 100-244CaadSectiaa=
provements shall be elevated on nil-- COS MISSION EXPIRES
100-33 fo_r"penaission to locate:an ...ings,,colunms
or- shear`watls such
accessory garage building in a final `.
that thebottom of the lowest horizon -
yard to less than the required `40 R'
tal structural members supporting the
front yard • setback provided -.by
lowest elevated floor is elevated to or.
Article III; Section 100-33C and Ar=
above the level of the base flood so as I
bele XXIV, Section 100-244B per- "
not to impede the flowof water.
raining to waterfront lots of less_than
- Note: Building Peiinit.No. 22965
40,000. sq. R in :size- Zone: R-40.
daied- August -.24,: 1995 authorized=.
Location -.of. Property:- 600 Beebe.
applicant" ..to renovate and alter. an,
Drive; Cutchogue;-NY; Comity Par-
• existing single-family_ dwelling. as•
cel 1000-97 7-5; also known. as Lot ,
.applied. for:: "location of Property:
829, Moose Cove Subdivision
58365:.0 R:.- 48' Greenport,- New
750 p.m: Applications of' ARTO
York;1000.442-13: This parcel eon-
KBRIMLAN'-for -variance relief, -
. tains aiotal lotama of 2125:sq ft.:.. I
based upon the Apnl 28, 1997 Actiob
- . The Board ofAppeals will, at said
Of Disapproval' of. the Scalding In:. .
":brae and place hear ani -and- all-per-
spector'in•:which applicant was de.- ""sons
or, representatives desiring to be
hied -a burl permit to• continud--
- heard.in:the abdVwapplieadons: The'. 1 -
-ding
conctiou ,for the following"ren=
above hearings: will- not--start_before : j
sons:
the times designated. ; Each: file. is j
a) Article M"- sectibm-IW`-
available for review :during' -regular -
242B(1): a nonconforming building
business • hours,= and'•written • com-
conhaining a conforming -use which-
meats may be -submitted before that
has bees ".damaged- by fire or other---'
hearing is concluded If. you have. _
causes -to the extent of -mom than fifty
questions,. plese ado- not hesitate to
(5046) perrent,of its fair.value shall
call 765-1809. -
not be repaired or rebwlt -unless such
Dated: June 21,-1997:
building is ade substantially to con-
BY ORDER OF THE SOUTHOLD
form to the- height and yard. require-
J , TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS
meats of the -Bulk Schedule (see Sec- .
"' "'GERARD GERARD P. GOEHRINGER,
tion 100-244B -Nonconforming Lotr
Chairmair
—BA _-
'" :' By Linda Kowalski
1044-1TJuM6 - -" -
APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS
Gerard R Goehringer, Chairman
Serge Doyen
James Dinizio, Jr.
Lydia A. Tortora
Maureen C. Ostermann
BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
June 24, 1997
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax(516)765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1809
Re: New Application
Dear
Please find enclosed a copy of the Legal Notice which has been
forwarded by our office to the Suffolk Times for publication in the next
issue. At this time, please send a copy of the notice with the hearing
date, time and place and description of your application by certified
mail -return receipt requested, to all surrounding property owners,
including property owners across any street or right-of-way.
Also
enclosed
is a sign . to be posted
at the subject property at or
within 10
feet of the front property line
(facing the road entrance) for
a period
of seven
(7) days, or longer at
your choice. The sign must
face the
traveled-
road or town street,
or if you are on a private
right-of-way, face.
the traveled portion of
the right-of-way where your
driveway
entrance
is located.
After the above has been done, please sign the enclosed Affidavit
of Posting and Mailing before a notary public and return it to our office
(not later than the hearing time) , and attach the following:
a) postmarked receipts from the post office showing the
date you mailed the notices by certified mail;
b) green signature cards once they have been received (you
may return these later if you do not receive them all by
the hearing date) .
If you have questions, please feel free to call.
Enclosures
Inag..97/1etter. ,.=
Very truly yours,
Linda Kowalski
r°:f
NOTICE OF HEARINGS _
SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS
THURSDAY, JULY 102 1997
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN, pursuant to Section 267 of the Town
Law and the Code of the Town of Southold, the following applications
will be held for public hearings by the SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF
APPEALS, at the Southold Town Hall, 53095 Main Road, Southold, New
York 11971, on THURSDAY, JULY 10, 1997 at the times noted below (or
as soon thereafter as possible) :
6:50 P.M. Appl. No. 4494 - ANTONIO PIRAINO. This application is
based upon the Building Inspector's June 1991 Action of Disapproval, for
a Variance under Article III, Section 100-32, Bulk Schedule, for
permission to place new dvielling with insufficient front yard setback
from right-of-way which passes through center of applicant's property,
and for a reduced rear yard setback. Location of Property- 3637
Right -of -Way off the west side of Cox Neck Road, Mattituck;
1000-113-3-2.3. Zone: R-80.
6:55 P.M. Appl . No. 4493 - ANDREW LETTIERI. This application is
based upon the Building Inspector`s June 2, 1997 Action of Disapproval,
for a Variance under Article III -A, Section 100-30A.3 of the Bulk
Schedule, for permission to place new dwelling with an insufficient rear
;raid setback. Zone: R-10 Z -tie. Location of Prooert� : 1720 A_~ow-
head Lane (west side). Pecouic; 1000-98-?-_?._.
Page 2 - Legal Notie
Southold Town Boarc. .._ Appeals
Regular Meeting of July 10, 1997
7:15
p.m.
Appl.
No. 4492 -
WALTER
KLEIN.
This
application is based
upon
the
Building
Inspector's
May 28,
1997
Action
of Disapproval, for
building permits in the "as built" construction of accessory garage in an
area other than the required rear yard- and of deck addition with an
insufficient front yard setback from private right-of-way (easterly
property lineAat 3235 Manlhanset Avenue, Greenport, NY; 1000-43-1-8.
Code Provisions: Article ilI-A, Section 100-30A.3 and 100-30A.4. _
Zone: R-40. Property size: 13821 sq. ft.
7:25 p.m. Appl. No. 4480 - NICKHART REALTY. (Carryover).
i:40 p.m. Apel. No. 4490 - RICIIARD AND THERESA SIRIANO. This
application is based upon the April 19, 1997 Action of Disapproval issued
by the Building Inspector, for a Variance under Article XXIV, Section
100-2440 and Section 100-33 for permission to locate an accessory garage
building in a front card to less than the required 40 ft. front yard
setback provided U�� Article III, Section 100-33C and Article XXIV ,
Section 100-244B pertaining to waterfront lots of less than 40,000 sq.
ft. in size. Zone: R-40. Location of Property: 600 Beebe Drive,
Cutchogue, NY; County Parcel 1000-97-7-5; also known as Lot T29,
Moose Cove Subdivision , .
7:50 p.m. Applications of ARTO KHRIMIAN for variance relief, based
upon the April 28, 1997 Action of Disapproval of the Building Inspector
in which applicant was denied a building permit to continue construction
for the following reasons:
a; Article == Scc_ion 1_00-24.2.B( 1", : a nollcollfoi'mlllg
containing a confcrming :vinic_ nas been damaged by =ire J! ��n
Page 3 - Leal Notic
Southold Town Boarc_ __ .appeals
Regular 1-Ieeting of July 10, 1997
causes to the extent of more than fifty (50%) percent of its fair value
shall not be repaired or rebuilt unless such building is made substan-
tially to conform to the height and yard requirements of the Bulk
Schedule (see Section 100-244B Nonconforming Lot - Bulk Schedule) .
b) Chapter 46, Section 46-18A: new construction and substantial
improvements shall be elevated on pilings, columns or shear walls such
that the bottom of the lowest horizontal structural members supporting
the lowest elevated floor is elevated to or above the level of the base
flood so as not to impede the flow of water.
Note: Building Permit No. 22965 dated august 24, 1995 authorized
applicant " ... to
renovate and
alter an
existing
single-family dwelling as
applied for...."
Location of
Property:
58365
C.R. 48, Greenport, New
York; 1000-44-2-13. This parcel contains a total lot area of 2125 sq.
ft.
The Board of Appeals will at said
time and place
hear any and all
persons or
representatives desiring
to be heard
in the above
applications.
The above hearings
will not start
before the time
designated.
Each file is available for
review during
regular business
hours, and written comments may be submitted before
that hearing is
concluded. If
you have questions, please
do not hesitate
to call 765-1809.
Dated: June 21, 1997. BY ORDER OF THE SOUTHOLD
TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS
GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, Chairman
By Linda Kowalski
P
�A, ea5c and I)eck\4 45 BU 1"LT- it
NOTICE OF HEARING
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a public hearing will be held by the
SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS at the Town Hall, 53095 Main Road,
Southold, New York, concerning this property.
41WNER(S) OF RECORD:
rb
DATE OF PUBLIC
HEARING:
If you have an interest in this protect, you are invited to view the Town file(s)
which are available for inspection prior to the day of the hearing during normal
business days between the hours of 8 a.m. and
BOARD OF APPEALS •TOWN OF SOUTHOLD (516) 765-1809
LL C -0-7-16M On b
r
NOTICE OF HEARINGS
SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS
THURSDAY, JULY 10, 1997
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN, pursuant to Section 267 of the Town
Law and the Code of the Town of Southold, the following applications
will be held for public hearings by the SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF
APPEALS, at the Southold Town Hall, 53095 Main Road, Southold, New
York 11971, on THURSDAY, JULY 10, 1997 at the times noted below (or
as soon thereafter as possible) :
6:50 p.m. Appl . No. 4494 - ANTONIO PIRAINO. This application is
based upon the Building Inspector's June 1997 Action of Disapproval, for
a Variance under Article III, Section 100-32, Bulk Schedule, for
permission to place new dwelling with insufficient front yard setback
from right-of-way which passes through center of applicant's property,
and for a reduced rear yard setback. Location of Property: 3637
Right -of -Way off the west side of Cox Neck Road, Mattituck;
1000-113-3-2.3. Zone: R-80.
6:55 p.m. Appl. No. 4493 - ANDREW LETTIERI. This application is
based upon the Building Inspector's June 2, 1997 Action of Disapproval,
for a Variance under Article III -A, Section 100-30A.3 of the Bulk
Schedule, for permission to place new dwelling with an insufficient rear
yard setback. Zone: R-40 Zone. Location of Property: 1720 Arrow-
head Lane (west side) , Peconic; 1000-98-2-12.1.
Page 2 - Legal Notice
Southold Town Board of Appeals
Regular Meeting of July 10, 1997
7:15 p.m. Appl. No. 4492 - WALTER KLEIN. This application is based
upon the Building Inspector's May 28, 1997 Action of Disapproval, for
building permits in the "as built" construction of accessory, garage in an
area other than the required rear yard and of deck addition with an
insufficient front yard setback from private right-of-way (easterly
property lineAat 3235 Manhanset Avenue, Greenport, NY; 1000-43-1-8.
Code Provisions: Article III -A, Section 100-30A.3 and 100-30A.4.
Zone: R-40. Property size: 6821 sq. ft.
7:25 p.m. Appl . No. 4480 - NICKHART REALTY. (Carryover).
7:40 p.m. Appl . No. 4490 - RICHARD AND THERESA SIRIANO. This
application is based upon the April 19, 1997 Action of Disapproval issued
by the Building Inspector, for a Variance under Article XXIV, Section
100-244C and Section 100-33 for permission to locate an accessory garage
building in a front yard to less than the required 40 ft. front yard
setback provided by Article III, Section 100-33C and Article XXIV,
Section 100-244B pertaining to waterfront lots of less than 40,000 sq.
ft. in size. Zone: R-40. Location of Property: 600 Beebe Drive,
Cutchogue, NY; County Parcel 1000-97-7-5; also known as Lot ##29,
Moose Cove Subdivision Map. .
7:50 p.m. Applications of ARTO KHRIMIAN for variance relief, based
upon the April 28, 1997 Action of Disapproval of the Building Inspector
in which applicant was denied a building permit to continue construction
for the following reasons:
a) Article XXIV, Section 100-242B (1) : a nonconforming building
containing a conforming use which has been damaged by fire or other
Page 3 - Legal Notic,.
Southold Town Board of Appeals
Regular Meeting of July 10, 1997
causes to the extent of more than fifty (50%) percent of its fair value
shall not be repaired or rebuilt unless such building is made substan-
tially to conform to the height and yard requirements of the Bulk
Schedule (see Section 100-244B Nonconforming Lot - Bulk Schedule) .
b) Chapter 46, Section 46-18A: new construction and substantial
improvements shall be elevated on pilings, columns or shear walls such
that the bottom of the lowest horizontal structural members supporting
the lowest elevated floor is elevated to or above the level of the base
flood so as not to impede the flow of water.
Note: Building Permit No. 22965 dated August 24, 1995 authorized
applicant "...to renovate and alter an existing single-family dwelling as
applied for...." Location of Property: 58365 C.R. 48, Greenport, New
York; 1000-44-2-13. This parcel contains a total lot area of 2125 sq.
ft.
The Board of Appeals will at said time and place hear any and all
persons or representatives desiring to be heard in the above
applications. The above hearings will not start before the time
designated. Each file is available for review during regular business
hours, and written comments may be submitted before that hearing is
concluded. If you have questions, please do not hesitate to call 765-1809.
Dated: June 21, 1997. BY ORDER OF THE SOUTHOLD
TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS
GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, Chairman
By Linda Kowalski
APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS
Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman
Serge Doyen
James Dinizio, Jr.
RA*ZAK
Lydia A. Tortora
Maureen C . Ostermann
BOARD OF APPEALS
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
S,E.Q.R.A.
TYPE II ACTION DECLARATION
Southold Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax (516) 765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1809
July 10, 1997
Appeal No. 4492
Project/Applicants: Walter Klein
County Tax Map No. 1000- 43-1-8
Location of Project: 3235 Manhanset Ave., Greenport, NY
Relief Requested/Jurisdiction Before This Board in this Project:
"As built" garage in area other than required rear yard and deck
addition with insufficient front yard setback and excessive lot
cove,hlgs Notice is issued pursuant to Part 617 of the
implementing regulations pertaining to Article 8 of the N.Y.S.
Environmental Quality Review Act of the Environmental
Conservation Law and Local Law X44-4 of the Town of Southold.
An Environmental Assessment (Short) Form has been
submitted; however, Section 617.13 of 6 NYCRR Part 616, and
Section 8-0113 of the Environmental Conservation Law, this
variance application falls under the Type II classification as
established by law. Further, this Department may not be an
involved agency under SEQRA {Section 617.13(a) as amended
February 14, 1990).
- Although this action is classified as Type II for this
variance application under SEQRA {specifically 617.13, 616.3(j),
and 617.2(jj)), this determination shall have no affect upon any
other agency's interest or SEQRA determination as an involved
agency.
For further information, please contact the Office of the
Board of Appeals, Town Hall, Main Road, Southold, NY 11971 at
(516) 765-1809.
Original posted on Town Clerk Bulletin Board, Town Hall
Copies to applicant or his agent and individual board members.
Copy placed in ZBA project file for record purposes.
JUDITH T. TERRY
TOWN CLERK
REGISTRAR OF VITAL STATISTICS
MARRIAGE OFFICER
RECORDS MANAGEMENT OFFICER
FREEDOM OF INFORMATION OFFICER
g�FFO(�cOG
yam`
o
CA Z
OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
TO: SOUTHOLD TOWN ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
FROM: JUDITH T. TERRY, SOUTHOLD TOWN CLERK
RE: ZONING APPEAL NO. 4492
DATE: JUNE 10, 1997
Town Hall, 53095 Main Road
P.O. BOX 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Fax (516) 765-1823
Telephone (516) 765-1800
Transmitted is an application for a variance submitted by Patricia Moore,
Esq. on behalf of Walter Klein together with Zoning Board of Appeals
Questionnaire; Short Environmental Assessment Form; Notice of
Disapproval from the Building Department; survey; and other relevant
documents.
Judith T. Terry
Southold Town Clerk
PATRICIA C. MOORE
Attorney at Law
315 Westphalia Road
P.O. Box 483
Mattituck, New York 11952
Tel: (516) 298-5629
Fax: (516) 298-5664
Margaret Rutkowski
Secretary
BY HAND
Southold Town Zoning Board of Appeals
Southold Town Hall
Main Road
Southold, NY 11971
Re: Variance Application of Walter Klein
SCTM# 1000-43-1-8
Dear Linda:
Enclosed please find the following for the above referenced
matter:
1. Notice of Disapproval
2. Application
3 Environmental Assessment Form
40 Z.B.A. Questionnaire
5. 1 original and 5 copies of a survey
7. Authorization letter from client
8. Disclosure Statement
9. Filing fee check in the amount of $550.00
10. Copy of letter from D'Aquisto's attorney prohibiting
Mr. Klein from -making an application for a variance.
11. A copy of an article regarding Mr. D'Aquisto.
Please place this matter on your hearing calendar. Thank you.
Very truly yours,
atricia C. Moore
PCM\Mr
Encls.
DISCLOSURE
I, William D. Moore hereby state pursuant to General Municipal Law Section 809 and
Southold Town Code Article 10 the following:
1. An application has been submitted by Patricia C. Moore to the Southold Town
Zoning Board of Appeals on behalf of Walter Klein and Lorraine Klein.
2. Patricia C. Moore is an attorney duly licensed in the State of New York practicing
as a sole practicioner with her own clients. She is not affiliated with my law practice.
3. Patricia C. Moore is my wife.
4. I am a member of the Southold Town Board.
5. I do not directly or indirectly review, discuss or participate to any extent in the
matter of Walter Klein and Lorraine Klein before the Southold Town Zoning Board.
6. Patricia C. Moore is compensated for her legal services, at an hourly rate,
regardless of the outcome of the case, and her fee is not contingent on the results obtained.
Dated: June 2, 1997
3235 Manhasset Avenue
Greenport, NY 11944
February 13, 1997
Patricia C. Moore, Esq.
315 Westphalia Road
P.O. Box 483
Mattituck, NY 11952
Dear Ms. Moore:
I, Walter Klein of 3235 Manhasset Avenue, Greenport, NY 11944, hereby authorize you
to make an application to the Zoning Board of Appeals, Town of Southold on my behalf.
Very truly yours,
GIQ L
Walter Klein
ate �v.?.S_ =.zvirorae»t31 Qeat_=y Review Ac= =acuiras succn_ssien
.�`'-=s �o =, and an envi_oncenc_1 _evzew will 'ue m,�iae L j
'e_ore any alion is Y �.:,s soar_
talcea_
SRORTIVI.^.ONM�N C�.r, aS5'cSSNEIT FOti;q
I.ISTRQC"_ IONS
(al is order !a answer the questicns in t.'lis short Z.18 it is assumed
Project
the preaarer wi 1 7 use car --ear y a��2e �ro�tiea cantiag the
and the L•''cely imaars az tta `-:iac-zoo. It is aoc e^cn +.
addi�_enal s�..dies', research or atter izves'` atioas T b eczad tbaz
g wia uade—_.ken.
(b) I_ MY. questiea has been answered Yes "m project may be sig -
rd '" cant and ccmnletad Zmvi--O=,,,ta.L Assessment rets is aecessar-r.
(c) I2' all questions have been answered No it is L�cely that Project is act sig�+T =icaat. the .:
(d) Lsv4 ---Onmental Assessmeist
I. aiZ ?mjecr result in a lar7e ?aysical mange
tte Project site or ?aysic3'=y•al�w^ mora
!hart Ia airs a= l and?
2- WI-27
there be a major crenge t0 any uairue or
IInBb'Bal. IaIId Lz= as -the sit3i .
3. ',1111 Project alter or have a Lar_
on
as +�r'"g hodv at +azer? ---
-_ wi== project have a _lenrlally Ia.�e imaaet ort
g�uadwater goal -y?
]. i?2?� prOjeir sit��i=C..II`T17 ee-Z'Cr drai.=Z'qa tiGK
ca adjace_zz sltasz
�• 'L' grject a ret- aav ``traatrned or �T aRg�Ye
in '
a
z or s-- as?
7. W, , , orajer Z-su=: ia a major adverse sae a ort
ai : cum t+r?
a.
9.
. I0.
'fez /`to
a
_'es V10
_Tes ✓.yo
r7i'= Project have a major e?=acz on v_sual ctar-
3C`»^ OL t.'Ie C`mmt+R++7 Or Scenic Vi2Ws Or sy+_ �G /
'sncwm a be ;^^arr..aaz to r+•o =.0=, =r? as t/Y/
_.' _ o
Qil eroject adversely imaal .any si- =ts or 3 l_
uta e= hiszoric, Pre-zisza c, or paleoazalagiral
imaar'aace or any site desigaatad as a til=t l �
=wixM �$tal arra by a Iocsl agency? s
Wi,11 Project have a major er_a—as exis=t Zq or
=Mr --Z-2 ra=,zational annortsai;`es? 'fez �Vo
tT. vy'_ project result i= major
7 t�__c problems or
cause a :major e=_ace a enc trZLnsnor-3t=en
. • - sys. oNfS�
`.'es Vo
iz. di== Proje s-qularly cruse objet- actable odors,
anise, glare. 7ib==ica, or_elec--ical
anCe as a result OL tte project's oceraz`Oa? _:r`S
�Vo
pro ect � .
%7 nave any imaact on public heal!.:
ar sazaty?
will P''es Ya
14. roject af,act t':e e:Lis`.zg cammuri-r a.,
di_ectly causing
tion c= more a growl^, r.z pe_ -manes! ponuya_
Pe =cd or pezc=z aver•a one -,rear „o
have a majora azive err= s =ta
corse-wr of � e4 ct do t.•e
=.e C'•. mmUx t `-r or aeiq"Qrtead2
IS. Is gle=e pubL'c cantroversv concerning t,:e
?rajel .
es `to
=e?are=s Sig :at•:re: —'
aear"
asent y
Zy^ 5.. g:— Il �v.�. Data:L��5 %6
1+-16" 03711—:a:t tz 017=
PE1C IEs:. 1 7. VUMflER Appendix C
State e..svirenmental Cuality Review
SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM
Far UNUSTc7- ACTIONS Only
PART I—pR01ECT INFORMATION (To be C'rnoisted by Aapiicaat or Prnjec: sponsor)
I L PROD . NAME
t. APQt�T is?CCANGtNSGarage
We
FPRCjECT-L--'=--TOM Caumm► Suf f olk
Southold
GTION (Street =we= and toad intersdaion>, pratntnent lattdrnar7t3.Or ptaviae maul Manhanset Ave., Greenport NY 1000-43-1-8
�54 Is PROPOSE] Ae•ION: permit for ex i s t i l
r; Nem [ F,�,„r„�„ Q Mddletnridnratterattdn
;_ ns:5ta1flE Paa:t-C- 3AIE='.:^. '
existing garage- cert.of occ needed
variance
AMOUNT aF LANG ar.=_cam:
intttatty 9, 0 0 0 s a. f3ulflt±ratatV g n n n s«ta
d. 'NIL.2RCFG5'c7 AG:C•`4 C ;MFI.y WITH =STING
OA OTHER SING L,uvO USc r�Eo:AIC:CN
CYe= a4a It Na. dm=20&arroflY. Variance for existing_ garage
SECA
{ 3_ WMArT IS PREficIT UNO USF IN '41C: -"IV' OF PR01E+.-? 1= CP3t7ctFCtelrJCCen ' I�Ctier
{ i Aestdanaalnatssmal r Camrnereial %.grsrwtttssre
CesctOe:
30E5 AC:.C.t INVOL'/E . P�MIT AP4RCVAt_ OA r�1JNOtNG. vOW CA UL',MAT_e_.:
-RC. ANY OTHt� GCyQ4NME't-%•L AG'ealC. tF-72:�AL
SATE OR LCCALI?
C Yea t2r-
No It yes lest aQancY131 atsC.aertntrlant7ravals
__ES
ANY ASPSt- OF THE C;:ARtetTL: VAllD PEiMIT OA APPROVAL
l�Yes t�:M It ye=. ist aOxsY name ana permtuatsnra+tal .
house ha -s .�-C of 0
t�. AS A AM OF PgOPCSF7 A�CN WILL �CIS:ING PqMITIAPPRCVAL.aECiAAE MCOIFICG.TIC'
CYes Na
I CZMFY THAT SIE INFCAMATSON PROVIOF.ta ABOVE IS TAUE'O HE 3S' OF MY KNOW' �'GF
Aaati�ntrsoans0r name:
P tricia C. Moore Esq,, Oste
SignaturC
If the action is in the Coas:ai Area. and you are a state agecampleiv trte I
Coastai Assessment Farm before proceeding with osis assessment
OVE=
.(Continued o.n reverse side)
over the factories and train:: ;�;;;
rom his side of Queens, It can j404
t feel all the more anonymous
zpitai of the world.
world away, Mr. Craddock is a big
is said to be the first Westernerttgl
a public art commission from the,.,
Government, having spent two: w
signing "Phoenix and Dragon,", en
:all metal sculpture In ChongQIW.
.na, he was feted at banquets and ;�.
'ed into homes. Officials praised his
o make a piece that rendered tray
ambols in a bold, modern style, Big,
appeared in newspapers. He't 6,4
spot: he was the 6Y�t 3rfn r� .
:._y y•
d black man. . • +.�
very different here," he said;'slttlq
s workbench, where a jumble htjat
iintbrushes sparkled In the MolrihlE
qo one has given mebre this `
ng, yet." ...�..r:..
:huckled. in a week that an wittiy
htlon's dual affirmations of demo;.
triumph and raclal equality, Mr:;'-
ock is unheralded at home but em-,
d by a country that hes been criU•i n
for human rights Problems. Maytn
s natural fate In the marketplace
,e not. "In this coantryryou are de;'
nv race In a way that is just st►iltng,
THE commission came his way u
1994, after he zot to know some
nese artists while preparing an
at the Jamaica Arts Center in Qu
e he was a curator. The Chthese a
•,erelmpressed by his wont and t
toned It to officials in Chong9wg'
searching for new public aft for I
Ly growing city, .
-hey were looking to connect to th'
in terms of commercial 'possibW
" Mr: Craddock said"This wa$a
tending themselves to themet i&'
was invited to Chongglog,'._
trips; to begin what seeiiW-U cit
socializing with dhmera� ind t6wN
ned as an art PsYch9l�+tO
e of those skills to begln'td unders
ides Inherent 1n me umqurwue
of the ptioenhi and the dragon`, commnl
lith a final design where a golden ptioe
'loiters over the tongue of a dragon^
•se jaws rise from a 10foot-bigh stone
'"Society is important, and at the cor
tatisthe family,' he said;"Andattih@
!of that family is man aridwomnn.
enix and dragon."
ne work, which was dedled la Tho
lber, has become so popular
ig nominated for national recognition,
i Yuan You He, the director of Chong;
,'s sculpture commisslo44w-",: 3"'
We were worried about our people's,>.•
;ity to accept abstract art," he saidr:i'
e were impressed with his wW...&' :
-sign the piece with a deep understan
of the meanings of the ChineseAulttttr,
Isymbolism"
..r. ,.. • tC'' !,•,:?: � •tip^.
zzzw-�IIE fact that a black artlsYdesigttt
Lthe piece may have symbolic! me'
ing of its own,but Mr. Yuan insist
.t race was never an issue or a Probler
e very idea puzzled him, "Why should
or matter?" he asked. "It is the art th
:aks to people. People don't look tit+ the
:1st. They look at the art." ,;
:nChina, Mr. Craddock embodied the
_cessful American, the New.Yorkard
nerica's lure and its prosperltyls a!
ghty one, obscuring at timeirthe less%
has gleaned In his dealings with tnhr•1
umsand galleries::x-+
"I got to a real appreclation and sent
tat the rules of the game are," he said
tou begin to understand whd'gets valu
id who doesn't. Slcigt:olor,iathissociel
China rn#y have its Great wait, out nu. j
inks this country also has a wall of its
•n that exists in the hyphen between Afri-
. n,
upward of
ATLANTIC CITY, Jan. 24 — wtm twe
1 �rncene heaters for warmth and nothing to
,%CJ♦ . v
y
csely, five hours, of
which. the accused a
nervously outside the
male, court-martial p
Army officers acquitt.
United. States MWtw
raping a female class
{' Both the cadet, Jan
'22 -year-old senior, at
who accused him of ri
into tears — he out of
;of apparent frustratio
'Cadet Engelbrecht
his parents in tight ht
.here from his hometo
father, Paul Engelbi
and cried out, "It's o'
i; About two dozen c
tiny courtroom — all
.turned out in support
shook each: other
;.broadly: "That.s exa
,,be," oneof them mut,
Zr' Male,and female; bi
The jury also a•
brecht of a lesser ct
;i; indecent act. Both c
:. an Incident last M-
.
' -during which Cadet
,t`�,
,��.yoang woman ansae
at a.•Iake
�s�,Jersev.owned by an
rt�? the. charge should
st 4; court=martial, but t
r =.
itt lY wanted to avoid
fir ;#.:.that the woman's
r' ',,,, ceived fullconslde
• � ;r. The court martu
4
g ; yit.ed tour days Was t
3 :been -charged wit
since women were
soAit S'i`. in 1978. CadetEngi
�� r=► ,•.vilitelmptisonment
wU+la; ti... convict ,
M1';4o.had been
�rPlte verdict ca
yedhea
'r n5that porira
w aw:;x Pfd`, mo ;D.AtLulstos�; _� r.campus.and•ottei
r±a fine ere' cei rt
.3 es itQttisttijW✓1a4. kk;; C • M gdIVlf'. S� ,der B4t,:� ;A:3.unllatter(ng ligh
.-
'tit
fns` Y , ;nn' earlier,.. est
i?„ attention to quest
,_:a >„ • _ :tary scandals in
tnticti'a'� Y .: a0lldt ttneple` 91des-.auryedt - :coexistence of me
1101Yc R;�+4uto, bullder;:a long
"It has lowered
- r by;thtaliand of lt4 ►?cast ; •. public the est(
_ had a coni •.. to in<; can
lt>$aal t 199 dai?,OfzNOOM ,:cutbg;lVlr D�Aquis p Ca
5e°! d� tr!'!1pr11 a fis r411190 , etionY aged ' s: ,; academy; ' Pc
ti C ' prosecutors! said
►Yt,''�':iesr,C,� - A't P
"rv;iiisl SealBniYito g a :ot•pi neck, i:t, Academy oftic
.. }; hwchs �'. r. c perception
-aimme �n lacesy9 9da a:r $ :si}ddenr everyc :, public pence
g ' 'R4s ► !VI Sri kk:! aYied,t'. of ^ a
' ' ?, i; an's aIle atlons
hAt+a `q p tial tarJus�had;tobe; g
L s Maw,Pte4g'r,4='the, gttj.
bouts3s#iiiw7�;:yyF�p�'ty 'with the court -m
wasoneuCthemuslciatte,��.-T,�i- #l.+ ca11o...t:Jahn Monteteone;`:�.,.:. tary's equtvatem
r . 9w a n .�mlre.. opine,. _7
edbttilden.of''aichWp:Butt.i+.`•,:: ; mended that the
ash' Pralseetio444�cde-' 8II°r=re " ed h1ti1 to eotnplete the'f: During the coo
?p Isia'n onG gg... _
pn4; teletme . I ctant • afPresented wtmes
r8 ,Mrc d ,01 x'- r was; _
' .FF.4;.;i' " �,t�!? z+?<' parted the confer
xe.drtLO 0— .1. `"s�:,:'.,:•Cix. ;': .'.:.'.
tYt� ihisto ghitars had'sjntc� .first'.1?+:;:i �, -had been too do
w t a8• 8' 6enttt `
g" with;rai onatre;co.. SuuE=lieAcce rhalleitge doing, and that It
dder'sAeath,=
pant'and the; Unitcg States.Peyltt� ' jMentai: sand off' on ;and fellow :, was abundantly
00,00o for,dejtli9'Jnlidp cite lie said -1 mhd:7ani m -5T usinB'on15' 3
"which ;.r.. oth taatet'fels`• isto'.s - '. testified that aP
table and his,workbear a tttmmt M><1A2N ^' about the sexes
eoldYoi €,t,. . as' , minute
!tai coii>t3lsseursi F c a Y t f' qct.', : `: two- peril
i ids, y' ,� �Tb ORtinae' S►t'rage28:3
Iettdsbl�ollars2- �;�� arm �7•S ,�^'`"t'+�:: ,:x, - —
ar' Conti
aft+i'�#dd"%":J�23�2�".t�3d'•�'a-,. M.i.. •P�. ,'�� a.'ft'.::��r:;r'�.�+C�in fisc"+-., .�'-'ti- u'ri_��' .r,`;'•,r .: F,i�; ti�i,,:;�'.
a
tra+^<?`SL�;{C''`"e^ ''•.=tir';{e.'✓.5°w•,-J ic.n,.'-if`•"'`!+ ',•�i,S'i%'.
X�� tdanttc`C�i
zldren Fiq an
to a ackle.,A:....:._...
r ,Y i i.•:4r:�a:4: ;'• l'vFir,"p�.iw.•,,F•-,..�r:,�•
?! `W'Y..i2; that their paren
`Ng'pt ��y tfisAf>' t�htitYlieywei'tinotr@latedtothe'•',;.'
q:)hey'p4etec� fie r t; . the'hoase three
y- th 'r : c►Ildtlyi'aoddim'9;uftivlthoutidentltying::*'>
d
dark Pa Phernalia'att' themselves;<:he said�]YIr`Greenwood said ""'turned:'
•,ark.••.. ++.� -m+ ar apartment. he said, and the police questioned them, and allowed The building t
top -mainy AIDS patients. 'the length of - - im includ 'a painful kidney'stone attack that for ing 'that they had fir(.d on'theoffirelis.,
"This is a very tragiq case,
stay was 12 to 15 days, and the death
1:. S� Han I" Tb� NM Yack M� �1: sent h rn weeping to a hDspit a emergency,
Yd
1. , was nearly 50 percent. In recent months th6 t• .:!,.room. He switched medications. tragicon all gides," Ms. Stewart said. rk
length of stay has risen to 120 days. i�ore:�,, DericD1X'O_ right; an AibS pa�ini at R!"ivington TiL's'e, wond' ri-abdtit hid ttlktaft'e",'.'.,;Mr.'Bmei�who hastli'rEechildriniifida:,.:.I 'I think the judge veiv wisely rival=':;'
people are feeling healthier and are going,"' recovering.from double pneumonia. Joseph Breen, an actor;sooil will lia th� ti ' said he to be wi: ized that
ex-wife In.Connec cut� d4wasa'case"i6hatse ed..,,
home. And the, death rate 'at Rivington.,"- * leading mad in television soap operas I�clud-11' I nobody's Interest by going forward", A'
Housey,, the-.., natton's,, largest�! rpsidential'� - P. -
What do the XIDS patienti do, now that th6y�l�',tdconsidek He'talks about his hope to"re"c'o.n. ing."Gulding LighQ1,!'As the World TOM 'i
-6ire" facility for AIDS 'patients, has,, ha�6 gotten better Instead of worse?, c e with-lild famfl� and 6"r matters t ""i& At po,
'health "end" `W� he said he v�
fallen 20yercent, which has left the center.ii,,�: '17
making !pqFq,t�a#,!3 am
-patients viT. heart��`A
For somp,
kindle" 41i kind of hope, ad to thd11`i;,'-;Y - "Will !"I �"afidw,jnysel(� Ltq: jQv years tmemp ent bit, t um ers
!4 withabout 20-enioiy the drugi'�a' Lott b
V. po -0 .1
d a M _ of u. Plel,
Meonr.�
b,
1: j, eFpf.,!�e,pT uslon at -bil ly e
id the complexftles?!,t��Qain?.,. How nI jpI1kRm�qon.qjj., only $k9'A a —,bin.* 2
f _ - . 1� .1 . . iti97: t. % [70
hniihtli i. iaiv rhanfi!O.
he 'iv
eve
9yern.
:plafi6.t.'4Mrd; Sfiyd6r; OaK1,13i
instrikinetntthat-pan do:.anythli
dei4v as'r10 ped.whezi he
the
hlstoryh.of
wlhave 'chills,"mr.-SW3�de�said;f".,pqssess4q.of,the w
OUMM.....
00
77
�,Y.0
44
0-
0 1-1
fdr
•
Ap"
A Vh, I MITDUt# 16 IN'
ingame me. r r qn.
le ekcIalmeO.,,�,-%TkAt'.9,ft ex W low., q, . "".7
!yipailed It;, 'clal. "It's jilk sffiokfi Olt I "uW
jj�it4 grt,
of. .rs
t
coli Big time'? al,
U "K, ..p� �n part r,
Ml t
M,
oU cS^_C-egTAIRE
FOR _Li�.G W --,TE YOUR Z.B.A. APP LCAT=Ori
A. Piease disclase the names or the owner{s) and env at=e_
�� �-iduals ( and entitles) haviag a Financial steres t ' the
sun 7 ect- prami.sas and a description. at theiX i.atarests : 1.
( Separate et may be attgched- j
none
3. Ts i=e sue7 ecz pm -ami Ges Li.s=Z4 o32 the rear. es Szem
sale ar bei :g szcwa to ves
{X ria. {Tim
C. Ara `ie--- 2=7 M 1 V - nJa-TZ tri #=ga V i a-7—,-=
{ } Yes { xi INTO
o. Xza there any a-a3s wiLLah ccnmz� weno
2. Are -the wet l =rd argaz shcwu an the map
this appli.czj: ijan? no .
3. :s the praper `v , bu? kaeace_ bet-aea.W the we_ -t j a+.cs are, and
the upland bui _T ng ar=..a? no
4. i- your pr=a -ty cgnta as we e! ? ra or -zcnd arras, have
vCU c^.nt3atd the Od=ica a= the TQa-a .—ZS4._as �Qr
at Zur ::ic-`aa3 n/a
...
Is them a depression or sla•ging elsv� as-. ca ne a- t -e ar_= of.
Pra-CCSeu CCn--=Ud`On 0 -at ar be!. -.W =i -Ta "feet al=`7e Me — Sea,
level? n/a (,..r not ,app-ic-21^le, SLstS
F. Are the— any pat cs, Caneta�= 3,
fr- bzL3"ll-eacs = -era-�
Wa-C.= -_T.IQare aa -t- -zna-7a an t e � saL�e-T ma- "' = t you
s-ai ciai tea. V no acne e�cist, - ase s t_ "acne
G. Da vcu have any canst--action tz?<:L=g glace at t_ -Lis time
ccac`r-g vett- pr_inisas? .. no rl yes, glease saI _^..':2it . a ac -v
az ycur at,l7 diyg pe--.ait and map as apgrzved t r �e au:Ljdrq
Degan ent. L acne, Plea a stwte
FI. Do you or amy cc-cwmer a? sd awn atter land c? csz tc. `t—r;s
pascal? noa T r `
yes, please z"p T wne_ ` or
at deeds.
Pl ease =st crasent use or aperat=crs ccnducca_' ac th_s
gazcai I garage' and residence a� d
grcPQsed use - aaraae and residence
3/37, 1n./�aL:t
r
§ 9743 ST -i3
TOWTIT —Mae Taws of Sortthcid.
T''�iS r: ES The Hoard of T. of the Town or
Snurhaid.- (Added 6-5-84 by L -L. lYa. 6108841
►T�: �ii3S (Amended 8 -25 -To by L X0.2-12-45;
85 by T' Yn 6 -Z0&5�:
(I) U Lands s-.�sily covered or irate-ami=-tly cav-
ered with- or which border = tidal arate_s. ar lands
lying beneath tidai wase*s. which a.= mesa low dde
are cave_ by tidal waters to a madmum depth of
ave (5) ie°_" inci•.:ding but act Limited to banks.
bogs, salt raarzIL swamp& meadows. dam or other
low lying lands sublet : cc tidal ac:iasr»
(2) A.11 banks, bogs. meadows.:I= and tidal marsh
sabject to such tides and upon which zxmvS or may
gratin some or any or the following: salt hay, biack
gr..�. saitwars.. sat lavendan tail =rdg-- m- :sigh
bus$. &-i—iis. neat Zma last
T..-z.-t-� ���arrJm- •
(3) AII I=d izmnediateT :djzcm^.z-m a tid-mi ---;e .ant
de*:ned in Subsec^on A(2) and Iying within savers-
t7-dve (75) ' feet landward of the mases landward
edg✓ of such : tidal a:etf-Tnd
:^snw-ater wetlands- as deained in :I-rticle 21. Ti -
tie 1. § 24-010T- Subdivisions I(a) to t(d) inclusive,
or "41-.- Environment :'i Canser -tion fes•:r of the St=n
of N. 'ztv York: -Id
(2) All land immediatelr adjacent to a "f: cshwater wet-
land-- as defined in Subsection S(I) z-nd lyin^ .vlrh-
in sen enty -tire (73) feet laudwnrd of the mast
•-dfta of a-fresintivater we• r.. d:'
-
9705
JOAN J. HART
447-8025
JOAN .1. ROE, III
447-X020
FREDERIC L. ATWOOD
447-NOIN
BRUCE T. WALLACE
447-X001
BENJAMIN L. HER7.WEIG
447-X003
Paul A. Caminiti, Esq.
Caminiti & Gibbons
P.O. Box 992
Southold, NY 11971
PELLETREAU & PELLETREAU9 L.L.='•
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
20 CHURCH STREET, BOX 110
PATCHOGUE, NEw YORK 11772-3564
(516) 447-8900
FAx: (516) 475-5651
October 21, 1996
Re: D'Aquisto, et al. to Klein
Premises: 3235 Manhanset Avenue, Greenport, NY
Dear Mr. Caminiti:
ROBERT S. PELLETRF.AU
(1801-1043)
RICHARD A. SCHOENFELD
( 1050 - 1080)
ROBERT 11. PELLF.TRF.AU
447.8024
PF.TF.R V. 1,NYDPR
447-!1022
OF COUNSEL
This will confirm our telephone conversation in which I advised you that your client has no
authority to file a proceeding or to take any action with respect to an application for a variance
for premises being purchased from the; Estate of James D'Aquisto.
By copy of this letter to Attorney Moore, I am confirming that fact with her.
If there are any damages sustained as a result of your client's action or communication directly
or through agents with the town board, we will be forced to proceed against him for redress.
V. truly yo sj
JOHN
JJH:s
c: Pat Moore, Esq.
VdagWstoVdeiB\can iBi 10.21
« °dam(l
rOCT 2 31996 � UI
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
OFFICE OF BUILDING INSPECTOR
TOWN HALL
SOUTHOLD, N. Y. 11971
December 10, 1980
Mr. James DtAquisto
14 Willow Park Center
Farmingdale, N.Y. 11755
Dear Mr. DtAquisto:
TEL. 765-1802
Regarding 3235.Manhansett Avenue, Greenport, N.Y.,
Mr. Reg Hudson submitted a current survey of your property
in Greenport. The survey -shows building violates set
back for accessory building. -
You cannot proceed with this structure until you receive
approval from the Zoning Board of Appeals. The structure
is in violation of Art.III, Sec.1-00-32B of the Zoning
Ordinance.
Also, should you wish to use the'R.O.W;.`owned by William
Pell for access to the garage, you will have to receive
approval of access. I would suggest you consult an
attorney.in this matter..
If I can be of assistanceto you regarding your appeal
to the Zoning BoaPd, do not hesitate to call me.
You truly;.
EDWARD F. IdDERMANN
Building & Housing Inspector
EFH/mw
5
Southold Town Beard of Appeals -o- June 12, 1975
7:55 P.M. (E.D.S.T. ) , An(:relo Angona, Appeal No. 2045.
A public hearing was held on this aonlication at 9:55 P.M.,
May 22, 1975 at which time the Board postponed decision until
June 12, 1975 because no clot plans :were submitted with the
application. Applicant has now furnished the Board with
the required plot pians.
The legal notice of hearing for this Appeal No. 2045,
which was heard on May 22, 1975, reads as follows :
9:55 P.M. (E.D.S.T.), upon application_ of Angelo Angona,
57 Holmes Place, Lynbrook, N. Y. for a variance in accordance
with the Zoning Ordinance, Article III, Section 100-30 and
Bulk Schedule and Section 100-34 for permission to construct
dwelling with insufficient setback on private right of way.
Location of property: Manh.anset Avenue & R.O.W., Greenport,
N.Y., bounded on the north by C. Reinfort; east by R.O.W. -
Pell; soutin by Manhanset Avenue; west by E. :Kowalski. Fee
paid $ 15.
THE CHAIRiv1AN : This involves a triangular shaped lot in
single and separate ownership on Manhanset Avenue and private
right of :way, "r'a'n District. The plot plan indicates that the
house will be located as centrally as pOSS1b12 in the center
of the lot. is Mr. Angelo : ngona here?
;Nay?
MR. RONALD ANGONA: He is my -father. I'm representing him.
THE CHAIRMAN: Does he have the right to use this right of
MR. ANGONA: Yes.
THE CHAIRMAN: How many people use that right of way.
MR. ANGONA: One other person, Mr. Reinfort.
THE CHAIRMAN= Do you Dian to use that right of Nay?,
MR. ANGONA: I believe we do but it could be avoided.
mr;E CHAIRP.a?N The location of the house will be 35 feet
to Kl=hanset Avenue and 10 feet to the ;westerly side line and
it locks as if you will get 15 feet to the easterly side line.
You also 1 so nave 40 feet or more of depth in the rear yard.
How large is the house going to be?
'
27' _c 29.
Southold -Town Board of Appeals -7- June 12, 1975
After investigation and inspection the Board finds that
applicant requests permission to construct dwelling with
insufficient setback on private right of way located on
Manhanset Avenue & R.O.W., Greenport, New York. The findings
of the Board are that this -property is in single and separate
ownership and there is no way to enlarge the lot. The Board.
agrees with the reasoning of the applicant.
The Board finds that strict application of the Ordinance
would produce practical difficulties or unnecessary hardship;
the hardship created is unique and would not be shared by all
properties alike in the immediate vicinity of this property
and in the same use district; and the variance will not
change the character of the neighborhood, and will observe
the spirit of the Ordinance.
On motion by Mr. Gillispie, seconded by Mr. Grigonis, it was
RESOLVED,. Angelo Angona, 57 Holmes Place, Lynbrook, N. Y.
be GRANTED permission to construct dwelling with insufficient
setback on private right of way, Manhanset Avenue & R.O.W.,
Greenport, New York, as applied for, subject to the following
conditions;:
'1. The house shall be located no closer than 35 feet
to Manhanset Avenue.
2. The house shall be located no closer than 10 feet to
the westerly side line, and no closer than 15 feet
to the easterly side line.
Vote of the Board: Ayes:- Messrs: Gillispie, Bergen,
Grigonis, Doyen.
* *
THE CHAIRMAN: On May 22, 1975 we postponed decision on
application of Paradise Aqua Farms until -receipt of Department
of Environmental Conservation approval and Suffolk County
Planning Commission approval. It is up to the applicant to
apply for*D:E.C. approval and then we send the application
£o the County for their recommendations.
MR. JOHN L. PLOCK, SR.: I thougizt the Board of appeals
:Mould apply for D.E.C. approval. I'll get in touch with Mr.
Dan Larkin.,
THE CHAIRMAN: I don't believe you will have any difficulty.
Our difficulty is that we have a si.,:ty day limit by State law
to make a decision after a public 1110aring so =„e are in a -eriod
where we are trying to convert to having everything L -t,0rovcc d
TEL. 765-1802
October 23, 1980
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
OFFICE OF BUILDING INSPECTOR
TOWN HALL
SOUTHOLD, N. Y. 11971
Mr. James D'Aquisto
14 Willow Park'Center
Farmingdale, New York 11735
Re: Revocation -r B.P.#106652
3235 Manhansett Avenue
Greenport, N.Y. 11944
Dear Mr. D'Aquisto:
The above permit is being revoked in accordance with
Article XIV, Sec.100-142A/B of Chapt.100, Code of the
Town of Southold, N.Y. for the following reasons:
Site plan submitted shows adjacent Pell
property as vacant land when, in actuality,
it is a private R.O.W. This places garage
in front yard area.which is not permitted
under zoning;
Structure is not being constructed as
applied for in that size has been increased,
plumbing facilities for bathroom and laundry
room have been added and building setback
from property boundaries have been reduced;
Zoning violations exist on the above mentioned premises.
You�rts . t ru
JWA
n
EDWAR F. HINDERMANld
Building & Housing Inspector
EFH/mw
FORM NO. 5
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
BUILDING DEPARTMENT
TOWN CLERK'S OFFICE
SOUTHOLD, N. Y.
0
ORDER TO REMEDY VIOLATION
Date .0-4� ja..6� ....... .............. 191F
TO `...,I,(/l-`?l.0 .........
(owner or authorized afgent of owner)
(address of owner or authorized agent of o0er)
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE there exists a violation of:
Zoning Ordinance
,.��a ..................
Other Applicable Laws, Ordinances -or Regulations ............................................
at premises hereinafter described inf'
/ (state char�er of violation)
%............,+'�
.................................
in violation of ....�✓4: .....��% ..- ` ....... ......... .... .I...................
(State section or paragraph of applicable low, ordinance or regulation)
YOU ARE THEREFORE DIRECTED AND ORDERED to comply with the low and to remedy the
conditions above mentioned forthwith on or before the .........'� �:`�r�=
.........................................................
dayof.......................................................19........ } ,
The premises to which this ORDER TO REMEDY VIOLATION refers are situated at
:....�T�.................County of Suffolk, New York.
Failure to remedy the - conditions aforesaid and to comply/ with the applicable provisions of low
may constitute an offense punishable by fine or imprisonment or both.
4uilding Inspector
03/45/1995 10:11 516, tib SRF PAGE 07'
�' Appeila�ct .has appealed to: -this` Board seeking a variance to permit.,;
the:.con9tr`uctIo'n' of a proposed two-ta,r'garage, 24 -foot by. 26 -foot in-.•; .
the`:frontyard,,;area•wlth .a setback'of'two feet from -the easterly prop-
erty;!llne.and Jour. feet -Jo thenortherly.;property line.'
The premises'in question'is a'parcel'of land located on the
.northerly side of Manhasset Avenue, Greenport (County T x Map District
'1000 Section 43 Block l Lot 18), having an area of 6+9LP2 square feet,
and bounded northerly by Reinfurt;.west by Sorden; south by Manhasset
.-:,.private'
� Avenue: east by Pell. There are presenthy existing on the lot a
private'ope•family one and -one' -half story dwelling; with an attached
deck having a minimum area of 350 sq: ft; and the new structure
'applied for herein... The'dwe111ng is set back 35 -feet from Manhasset
.i ;Avenue.' The subject.premises* fronts. along.,Manhasset Avenue 90 feet
and is an;!average.o,f 144.84. feet ,fin. depth.,•
On'September 25, 1979. appellant's' agent was issued a building
..,Permit to constr6ct.a'24' by'24' two -car garage parallel to the
easterly property line -and, with a setback of approximately eight
feet from the easterly side and approximately three feet from the
westerly side/and three feet from.the northerly pedperty line. '
On!October, 23, 1900 the',Building"Inspector revoked the building
% permit upon finding that'the abutting property on the east side was'
a private•'right-of=way, placing the:structure in the frontyard area
which is;no.t,pern1tt6d under Art. III,' Sec.. 100-32 of the' Code, and
also -upon finding that:the strutturo-had not been constructed in
accordance with the approve.d.building-permit for the following
reasons: (a) the structure had -.been increased in size; (b) the
,property setbacks were reduced; '•'(c) plumbing facilities for
bathroom and laundry room were.added; (d) the location of the
structure was changed.
Upon inspection and investigation, the Board found all of the
above to be true, and that also existing on the premises was a deck;.'
substantial in size,'approlcimately l -i feet - above ground,
apparently was constructed without a building permit, which was not
shown on any of the surveys submitted with either the application
for the building permit or the variance herein, and which does cause
.,,,the. structures to exceed the;.maxmlmum' permitted ,lot coverage of
20%, Art.. III ,.Sec+ 100-31. '-;The Board has also -found that the new
;:.structure does;:not•.appgar to`'meet�the-definition of a two -car garage
as applied. for .•-I'n t1l.at :thel'structure has: (1) one door opening
" approximately'six by six �fee.t :in size, rather ,then two openings;
(2) several wlndow'openings;'-'(3) a skylight'dome; (4) access,,
for connection into the existing septic system for which an open trench
lending from the septic system to�.the' new structure has been dug:, (5)
plumbing, facilities ready for -use. i
The Bo6rd finds and-determinos'that the variance requested in
relation'to the Code r•equirements;is substantial; that if the
variance is granted a,substential'detriment to adjoining property
will be,created; that'a substantial change will be produced in the
tcharactbr of the neighborhood, and that the interests of justice
will be served by denving the Variance requested.
On motion by Mr. Grigonis, o seconded by Mr. Goehringer,
was
RESOLVED, that James D'A uisto, by R.B. Hudson as agent,.,.136
Front Street, Greenport, New or a denied a variance to the
Zoning Ordinance as applied -for in.,Appea o: 2781'.'
Location of Property: 32351 Manhasset Avenue, Greenport, NY.
vote of the Boardv' Ayes: 'Messrs..Grigon�
and Sawicki. Absent was: Mr.,Doyen.
APPROVED
Cbaiitnan Boards I AP041 ,
I:i ICEIVED BIND F T. -M BY
1M SUUiaiGLD' '1'C,+ . '1, '
. `�Ji•r � r rPh
. „IZL-SL-RVED DECISION Appeal No. 2181. Applica n of James
D`Aquasto, by R.B. Elud:,_ as agent, 136 Front Stre Greenport,
AN for a Variance to the Zoning Ordinance, Art. III, Sec. 100-32
for permission to construct accessory building in frontyard at
3235 Manhas�et'A'venue, Greenport, NY; bounded north by Reinfurt;-
west by Sorden; south by Manhasset Avenue; east by Pell; County
Tax Map Item No. 1000-43-1-8.
After investigation and personal inspection, the Board finds
and determines as follows:
Appellant has appealed to this Board seeking a variance to
permit the construction of a proposed two -car garage, 24 -foot by
26 -foot in the frontyard area with a setback oftwo feet from
the easterly property line and four feet to the northerly property
line.
The premises in question is a parcel of land located on the
northerly side of Manhasset Avenue, Greenport (County Tax Map
District 1000 Section 43 Block 1 Lot 18), having an area of
6,922 square feet and bounded northerly by Reinfurt; west by
Sorden; south by Manhasset Avenue; east by Pell. There are pre-
sently existing on the lot a private one -family, one and one-half
story dwelling, with an attached deck having a minimum area o -f
350 sq. ft.; and the new structure applied for herein. The
dwelling is set back 35 feet from Manhasset Avenue. The subject
premises.fronts along Manhasset Avenue 90 feet.and is an average
of 144.84 feet in depth.
On September 25, 1979 appellant's agent was issued .a build-
ing permit to construct a 24' by 24' two -car garage parallel to
the easterly property line and with a setback of approximately
eight feet from the easterly side and approximately three feet
from the westerly side and three feet from the northerly property
line.
On October. 23, 1980 the Building Inspector revoked the build-
ing permit upon finding that the abutting property on the east
side was a private right-of-way, placing the structure in the
frontyard area which is not permitted under Art. III, Sec. 100-32
of the Code, and also upon finding that the structure had not been
constructed in accordance with the approved building permit for the
following reasons: (a) the structure had been increased
ilill size;
(b) the property setbacks were reduced; (c) plumbing
es
.for bathroom and laundryr,00m were added; (d) the location of the
structure was changed.
Upon inspection and investigation, the Board found all of the
above to be true, and that also'existing on the premises was a deck
substantial in size, approximately 12 feet above ground, which ap-
parantly was constructed without a building permit, which was not
shown on any of the surveys submitted with either the application
for a building permit or variance herein, and which does cause the
structures to exceed the maximum permitted lot coverage of 20%,
Art. III, Sec. 100-31. The Board has also found that the new struc-
ture does not appear to meet the definition of a two -car garage as
applied for, in that the structure has: (1) one door opening
approximately six. by six feet in size, rather than two openings;
(2) several window'openings; (3) a skylight dome; (4) access -for
connection into the existing septic system for which an open trench
leading from the septic system to the new structure has been dug;
(5) plumbing facilities ready for use.
The Board finds and determines that the variance requested in
relation to the Code requirements is subst:antial;, that if the variance
is granted a substantial detriment to adjoining properties will be
created; that a substantial change will be -produced in the character
of the neighborhood; and that the interests of justice will be served
by denying the variance requested.
On motion by Mr. Grigonis, seconded by Mr. Goehringer, it was
RESOLVED, that James D'Aquisto, by R.B. Hudson as agent, be
denied a variance to the Zoning Ordinance as applied for in Appeal
No. 2781.
Location of Property: 3235 Manhasset Avenue, Greenport, NY.
Vote of the Board: All Ades. *(Absent was: Mr. Doyen).
RESERVED DECISION; Appeal No. 2777. Application of Robert
New York for a
56
however, they encouraged D'Aquisto and
spread the word about the fine instru-
ments he was creating.
By 1967 the orders for guitars were
steady. D'Aquisto worked steadily for six.
years, in which time the family expanded
to include Michelle and James II, the fifth
and sixth children. During his time in
Huntington, D'Aquisto had taken on a
new partner for the string business. He
relocated to Farmingdale, also on Long
Island, in 1973, to manufacture his own
strings. He was in Farmingdale for four
years before moving to Greenport.
Though Greenport offered the peaceful
atmosphere D'Aquisto desired, the town
was initially reluctant to allow him to build
Part II D'Aquisto
a little shop behind his new home; so he
was forced to drive to Farmingdale to work
on the instruments. Soonthe town of
Greenport assented to D'Aquisto's request
for a shop, and as of this writing (in 1990)
he is creating instruments in that location.
Amidst all of the business and artistic
pressures D'Aquisto was forced to bear in
his early days as a solitary guitar maker,
another more serious and long-lasting
problem appeared: he began experiencing
symptoms of epilepsy. Mrs. D'Aquisto:
His sickness has b en a terrible cloud. As
he gets older it se ms to take him a few
days longer to "ca e back." We didn't
recognize it until h�was in his late 20s, a
A photo session: D'Aquisto and one of his recent creations, 1986. (Photo by the author)
The Man
57
A D'Aquisto New Yorker in the shop for adjustment. (Courtesy Tim Olsen) .
little after John died. He had a very bad
concussion when he was nine, another
one in a car accident when he was about
20, and another accident on the Long
Island Railroad. It bothers me a lot now.
It makes me sad and worrisome.
D'Aquisto is astonishingly optimistic
about his health. D'Aquisto:
I actually think it has helped me a great
deal. After a seizure I need to recover and
I have a lot of time to think, which can be
good or bad. At times I think of the things
that are unjust, such as living under a
standard where many do not recognize
ability, and many with no ability wind up
rich! I always thought it was the people
that couldn't do anything that invented
money. But I also get excited to get back
to work, and I come back with even more
drive and enthusiasm, and usually some
new ideas to try on the guitars. They are
something I can leave behind and a way
that I can help make the world a bit
.better.
M
2. D'Aquisto
Ledger
'
Number
Model
Date
Number Model
Date
1001
New Yorker
5/65
1036
New Yorker Special
1/70
1002
Excel
8/65
1037
New Yorker Deluxe
5/27/70
1003
Excel
9/65
1038
New Yorker Special
7/10/70
z
1004
Custom Excel
10/65
1039
Excel Special
1/70
'
1005
Excel
12/65
1040
New Yorker Deluxe
4/1/70
1006
New Yorker
3/66
1041
New Yorker Deluxe
5/21/70
?" j
1007
Excel
4/66
1042
New Yorker Deluxe
'70
1007A
Excel
4/66
1043
New Yorker Deluxe
12/10/70
1008
New Yorker
4/66
1044
New Yorker Deluxe
1/8/71
1009
New Yorker
8/66
1045
New Yorker Deluxe
4/12/71
1010
New Yorker Special
9/66
1046
New Yorker Special
5/71
t
1011
New Yorker
10/66
1047
Excel, American Wood
7/71
1012
New Yorker Special
11/66
1048
New Yorker Special
8/71
'
1013
New Yorker
11/66
1049
New Yorker Special
8/5/71
s
1014
New Yorker Special
7/66
1050
Oval Hole Special, 17"
1/12/71
' r
1015
New Yorker Special
1/67
1051
New Yorker Special
2/1/72
'
1016
New Yorker Deluxe, New
6/67
1052
Oval Hole Special, 17"
4/3/72
..
Design
1053
Oval Hole Special, 17"
3/2/72
1017
New Yorker Deluxe
6/67
1054
New Yorker Deluxe
4/17/72
1018
New Yorker Deluxe
8/67
1055
New Yorker Deluxe .
5/12/72
1019
Excel
10/67
1056
New Yorker Special
6/14/72
-
1020
Excel Deluxe New Yorker
10/67
1057
Excel
8/28/72
Special
1058
New Yorker Oval Hole,
9/12/72
1021
New Yorker Deluxe
11/67
17"
1022
Excel Deluxe New Yorker
12/67
1059
New Yorker Special
11/4/72
Special
1060
New Yorker Deluxe
10/17/72
1023
New Yorker Deluxe
1/68
1061
Special Oval Hole, 15"
11/9/72
1024
Excel Deluxe New Yorker
2/68
1062
New Yorker Deluxe
1/23/73
- °
Special
1063
New Yorker Special
12/22/72
1025
Excel
4/68
1064
New Yorker Deluxe
2/28/73
—
1026
New Yorker
6/24/68
1065
New Yorker
4/20/73
1027
New Yorker Deluxe
8/12/68
1066
New Yorker Special
5/2/73
=
1028
New Yorker Special
8/12/68
1067
New Yorker 7 -String
5/16/73
1029
Excel
11/29/68
Special
1030
New Yorker Deluxe
1/4/69
1068
Oval Hole
8/15/73
1031
New Yorker Special
2/69
1069
Oval Hole
7/10/73
1032
New Yorker Special
6/23/69
1070
New Yorker Special
10/2/73
1033
New Yorker Special
9/69
1071
Special 12 -String
9/20/73
1034
New Yorker Deluxe
7/9/69
1072
New Yorker Deluxe
11/15/73
f
1035
New Yorker Special
11/17/69
1073
New Yorker Special
12/13/73
94
,z
S
M
D'Aquisto Ledger
95
Number
Model
Date
Number
Model
Date
1074
New Yorker Special
1/11/74
1130
New Yorker Special
9/10/79
1075
New Yorker Deluxe
2/20/74
1131
New Yorker Special
7/25/79
1076
New Yorker Special
3/25/74
1132
New Yorker'Special
10/9/79
1077
New Yorker Deluxe
5/10/74
1133
New Yorker Special Jim
12/20/79
1078
New Yorker Special
6/10/74
Hall Model
1079
New Yorker Special
7/18/74
1134
New Yorker Special
7/24/80
1080
New Yorker Deluxe
10/3/74
1135
New Yorker Deluxe
3/30/80
1081
New Yorker Special
8/13/74
1136
New Yorker Special
2/26/80
1082
New Yorker Special
9/27/74
1137
New Yorker Special
5/15/80
1083
New Yorker Special
11/14/74
1138
New Yorker Special
5/30/80
1084
New Yorker Deluxe
12/26/74
1139
New Yorker Special
6/20/80
1085
Excel
3/6/75
1140
New Yorker Deluxe 7-
6/18/80
1086
New Yorker Deluxe
2/20/75
String
1087
New Yorker Deluxe
4/20/75
1141
Excel
10/20/80
1088
Excel Oval Hole
11/30/75
1142
New Yorker Special
11/9/80
1089
New Yorker Deluxe
4/30/75
1143
New Yorker Special Jim
5/10/81
1090
Special Oval Hole, 16"
5/20/75
Hall
1091
Excel
6/18/75
1144
New Yorker Deluxe
2/6/81
1092
New Yorker Special, 7-
7/25/75
1145
New Yorker Deluxe
10/31/80
String
1146
New Yorker Electric
4/20/81
1093
New Yorker Special, 7-
8/18/75
1147
Excel
1/18/82
String
1148
New Yorker Special
3/20/82
1094
New Yorker Deluxe
9/20/75
1149
Excel
1/5/82
1095
New Yorker Oval Hole,
3/24/76
1150
New Yorker Special
10/24/81
18"
1151
Electric New Yorker
11/17/81
1096
New Yorker Deluxe
1/20/76
Special
1097
New Yorker Special
4/28/76
1152
New Yorker Special
4/20/82
1098
New Yorker Deluxe
2/24/76
1153
New Yorker Special
5/17/82
1099
New Yorker Deluxe
7/11/76
1154
New Yorker Deluxe
8/25/82
1100
New Yorker Deluxe
8/19/76
1155
New Yorker Deluxe
6/18/82
1101
New Yorker Deluxe
9/30/76 ,
1156
New Yorker Special
6/7/82
1102
New Yorker Special
11/22/76
1157
Excel Special, American
12/20/83
1103
New Yorker Special
1/28/77
Wood
1104
New Yorker Special
2/17/77
1158
New Yorker Deluxe
8/23/82
1105
New Yorker Deluxe
12/25/76
1159
Excel
12/13/82
1106
New Yorker Special
4/2/77
1160
Excel
11/9/82
1107
New Yorker Special
6/18/77
1161
New Yorker Special
3/29/83
1108
New Yorker Deluxe
6/3/77
1162
New Yorker Special
7/4/83
1109
Excel Special
7/9/77
1163
New Yorker Special
6/25/83
1110
New Yorker Special
9/3/77
1164
Special 12 -String
12/24/83
1111
12 -String Special
11/3/77
1165
New Yorker Deluxe
4/25/84
1112
New Yorker Special
11/15/77
1166
New Yorker Special
4/30/84
1113
New Yorker Special
1/27/78
1167
7 -String New Yorker
5/4/84
1114
New Yorker Special
12/16/77
Special
1115
New Yorker Deluxe
3/26/78
1168
New Yorker Deluxe
5/7/84
1116
New Yorker Special
3/18/78
1169
New Yorker Special
4/18/84
1117
New Yorker Special Oval
5/17/78
1170
New Yorker Special
8/28/84
Hole
1171
Excel
12/20/84
1118
New Yorker Special
6/1/78
1172
Excel
8/28/84
1119
New Yorker Special
6/20/78
1173
3/4 Size Excel
8/27/84
1120
New Yorker Special
8/10/78
1174
Excel Special
10/84
1121
Excel
8/78
1175
New Yorker Special
12/20/84
1122
New Yorker Special
10/78
1176
Excel
4/21/85
1123
Excel
9/8/78
1177
12 -String Classic Oval
3/20/85
1124
New Yorker Special
11/12/78
Hole, 16"
1125
Excel Oval Hole
11/12/78
1178
New Yorker Deluxe
4/25/85
1126
New Yorker Special, 16"
3/28/79
1179
New Yorker Deluxe
8/15/85
1127
New Yorker Special
3/15/79
1180
New Yorker Special
10/24/85
1128
Excel
4/15/79
1181
New Yorker Special
9/19/85
1129
New Yorker Special
5/15/79
1182
Excel
8/15/85
W.
Number
1183
1184
1185
1186
1187
1188
1189
1190
1191
1192
1193
1194
1195
1196
1197
1198
1199
1200
1201
1202
1203
1204
1205
1206
1207
1207
101
102
103
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
Model
New Yorker Classic, 18",
New
Excel
New Yorker Special
Excel, Non -Cutaway
New Yorker Classic
New Yorker Special
New Yorker Deluxe
New Yorker Special
New Yorker Classic, 17"
New Yorker Special
New Yorker Special
7 -String New Yorker
Deluxe
New Yorker Special
New Yorker Deluxe
Excel
New Yorker Classic
Excel
Excel
New Yorker Deluxe
New Yorker Special
New Yorker Classic
New Yorker Classic Oval
Hole
New Yorker Deluxe
New Yorker Classic
New Yorker Classic Oval
Hole
7 -String New Yorker
Special
[CLASSICAL CUTAWAYS
HOLLOW -BODY ELECTRICS
Date
12/17/85
10/18/86
2/22/86
2/23/86
12/25/86
8/20/86
10/1/86
9/19/86
11/25/86
12/24/86
1/5/87
12/18/86
5/23/87
5/13/87
2/4/88
5/1/87
8/25/87
8/16/87
1/28/88
8/31/87
1/29/88
1/30/88
4/8/88
2/20/83
11/20/86
1/85
11/9/76
2/10/77
5/27/77
5/12/77
7/16/77
8/16/77
10/27/77
11/9/77
3/6/78
5/18/78
4/18/79
11/9/78
12/12/78
10/9/78
7/1/78
1/9/79
5/25/79
6/20/79
7/16/79
8/19/79
Number
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
E101
E102
E103
E104
E105
E106
E107
E108
E109
E110
E111
E112
E113
E114
E115
E116
E117
E118
E119
E120
E121
E122
101
102
Model
Left -Handed
Left -Handed
SOLIDS &.HOLLOW SOLIDS
7 -String
7 -String
Special Curved Back
New Design Double
Cutaway "Americus"
Double Cutaway
New "Sonorous"
Model #1
Double Cutaway
FLAT -TOPS
Special 15" Short Body
Deluxe 16" Full Body
Appendixes
Date
9/16/79
10/16/79
10/30/79
7/26/80
9/10/80
10/20/80
2/15/80
2/15/80
4/15/80
7/2/82
11/20/82
8/30/82
2/12/83
3/2/83
5/17/83
3/12/85
8/20/83
12/20/83
12/20/84
6/12/85
5/15/87
2/3/88
2/3/88
'76
12/27/76
3/12/77
5/1/78
5/10/78
8/3/78
3/30/79
10/30/79
11/19/79
8/27/80
9/6/80
11/9/81
4/20/82
3/28/83
8/28/83
3/12/84
4/25/85
8/21/85
11/9/85
1/86
5/1/87
1/73
10/25/75
21 — 8/29/79 103 Deluxe 16" 6/12/76
11t '
4;
i
i
t,
D'Aquisto Ledger
97
Number — Model
Date , --
,Number.
Model
Date
104 Deluxe 16"
4/18/77
113
Small Cutaway
5/20/81
105 Deluxe 16"
9/10/77
114
Small Cutaway
11/3/81
106 Deluxe 16"
2/10/78
115
Small Cutaway
3/3/83
107 Deluxe 16"
12/20/78
108 Deluxe 16"
6/20/79
[MANDOLINS]
109 Deluxe 16'
12/18/79
110 Deluxe 16"
12/20/80
101
—
—
ill Deluxe 16"
2/20/81
102
—
—
112 16" Special Short Body
4/13/81
103
—
—
The Instrurizents
produce a slightly. different tone color,
something D'Angelico did very little of.
Thus, as D'Aquisto began experimenting
with the bridge, tailpiece, carving, brac-
ing, neck angles, etc., he began to change
his instruments.
A general description of the creation
of a D'Aquisto guitar involves a number of
procedures. The top and back are carved
to their exact shapes (thicker in the center
and thinner towards the edge). The sides
are bent on an electric bending iron and
placed in a mold. Then the neck and tail
blocks and kerfed linings are installed,
along with the side braces. The s -holes (or
an oval hole, or elliptical holes) are jig-
sawed out of the top, which is placed on
59
thesides in the mold (held by two'brads
situafed'at each block). Then the contour
of the blocks and linings is traced onto the
underside of the top, the same procedure
being followed with the back.
D'Aquisto braces the top with an
X -brace, the angle of the scissor being
incumbent on the tone the instrument is to
produce. The gluing edges of the brace are
affixed to the top with Titebond glue. Once
the top and back are glued to the sides and
the binding ledges have been cut, the
binding is glued to the edge. The binding
material is either black -and -white cellulose
plastic or wood, depending on the model.
The neck is fashioned from domestic
maple and the headpiece is veneered with
D'Aquisto bending the sides for a flat -top instrument, 1987. (Photo by the author)
:M_
i
The Instruments
masses, and deleting the inlay from the
bridge, D'Aquisto soon learned what an
important aspect the bridge could play in
altering the tone color of the instrument.
He also elected to shorten the metal
tailpiece to enhance its performance.
D'Aquisto showing the form in which he receives
wood for the matched backs. (Photo by the author)
_ Kj v
A back in the rough. (Photo by the author)
61
These variations occurred between 1967
and 1969. During the period of 1970 to
1973 he incorporated the ebony tailpiece
and ebony pickguard. The fingerboard
widths became steadily wider (though any
width was obtainable, depending on the
The machine D'Aquisto uses to rough -carve the
backs. The second and third (from the left) forms
duplicate what the operator does in the first form.
(Photo by the author)
Note the highly figured back and sides of this
18 -inch D'Aquisto New Yorker Classic made in
1985. (Photo by Glen Delman)
62
Part II D'Aquisto
A neck in the rough. In the background, note wood
for the tops and backs. (Photo by the author)
D'Aquisto readying to work on a neck, 1986.
(Photo by the author)
Necks and bodies of various D'Aquisto -instruments being readied for completion, late 1970s. (Courtesy
Tim Olsen)
r'
•
i
68 — 1� J kcr
D'Aquisto playing one of his creations, 1986. Note
instruments in foreground, in various stages of
completion and repair. (Photo by the author)
A body in the rough for an instrument that will
become a guitar controller for a synthesizer, 1986.
(Photo by the author)
bodies), and "folk guitars" (flat -tops), and
"classical guitars" (nylon string flat -tops),
he would not be known for those, and the
truly "Custom Guitar Maker" " title that
appears on his letterhead. D'Aquisto:
People don't understand that I can make
aiiy kind of guitar. The reason I don't
make a lot of solid bodies is because I
don't get a lot of orders for them.
Part II D'Aquisto
A solid -body in the rough, 1986. (Photo by the
author)
The back of a semisolid -body instrument (mahog-
any body with maple top). (Photo by the author)
Those who do order instruments from
D'Aquisto often need to be educated in
order to fully realize the qualities and
utilize the capabilities of such responsive
musical tools. D'Aquisto:
When I make a guitar I have to talk to the
player to find out what they are like so I
know what that guitar should sound like.
When I hear a player talk, I know what