Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
4845
F,C'&--iv%Z /6,64.e 02, ezo Oren/ '114/6"W/4s6J GW 7°/ A/I. 8714, GG v/i/S c 4.).e)i iia ev' 4(1-7,„9„e .se--776,9c 70E-1,-aw 4nlT b /P-4G'F' i`9.`�,4) -,�02o • APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS ,,1"' SOFFOL4 1r &, COG ` Southold Town Hall 41 Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman ��� y.�: 53095 Main Road James Dinizio, Jr. y Z P.O. Box 1179 Lydia A. Tortora ; p rn �= Southold, New York 11971 Lora S. Collins ` 'j' O`��r' ZBA Fax (631) 765-9064 George Horning �'\O! Jit $..' Telephone (631) 765-1809 . .... BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD FINDINGS, DELIBERATIONS AND DETERMINATION MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 6, 2000 Appl. No. 4845 — ROBERT FRENTZEL STREET & LOCATION: 1900 Old Orchard Lane, East Marion 1000-37-2-9.1 DATE OF PUBLIC HEARING: August 10, 2000 FINDINGS OF FACT PROPERTY FACTS/DESCRIPTION: The applicants' property comprises 22,500 sq. ft. located on the west side of Old Orchard Lane, East Marion with 150 feet of lot depth and 150 ft. of road frontage. It is improved with a single-family dwelling with garage, set back 32.5 feet from Old Orchard Lane, 11.63 feet from the northerly property line (not including a small protrusion that is to be removed) and about 75 feet from the rear property line. BASIS OF APPLICATION: Building Inspector's June 22, 2000 Notice of Disapproval denying a permit to expand the house for the reason that the proposed addition would have a rear setback of 36'4" in violation of the 50-ft. requirement of Code Section 100-244B. AREA VARIANCE RELIEF REQUESTED: Applicant requests a variance to locate proposed construction that will add a second floor to the existing house and a near two-story addition with a rear setback of 36'4" in violation of the 50 ft. requirement of Code Section 100-244B. REASONS FOR BOARD ACTION: On the basis of testimony presented, materials submitted and personal inspection, the Board makes the following findings: (1) The existing house is small and the owners wish to enlarge it for year-round occupancy. They testify that the only practical direction for expansion is westerly into the rear yard, because the southerly and southwesterly yards are planted in mature gardens and have some significant topographical irregularities. Because this lot is over 20,000 sq. ft., Code Section 100-244 requires a rear yard of 50 feet. The current rear yard is about 75 feet; applicant proposes a rear yard of 36'4". Applicant also proposes a northerly side yard that continues the existing nonconforming setback of 11.63 feet for the entire length of the addition. The required side yard setback under Code Section 100-244 is 15 feet. (2) The proposed project will result in a much larger house than now exists, with two stories rather than one and a much larger footprint. The proximity to the northerly and westerly property lines raises a serious possibility that the property will appear crowded and the house will intrude on the neighbors. Because the project is in the planning stage, applicant is in a position to revise the plan to allow for greater setbacks. (3) The Board concludes that with greater setbacks as set forth below, the project will not produce an undesirable change in the character of the neighborhood or detriment to nearby properties. 4 I Page 2—September 6, 2000 ZBA Appl. No. 4845—R. and M. Frentzel Parcel 1000-37-2-9.1 at East Marion (4) There is no evidence that the action set forth below will have an adverse effect or impact on physical or environmental conditions. (5) The action set forth below is the minimum necessary and adequate to enable applicant to enjoy the benefit of a larger home with minimum disruption of established gardens, while preserving and protecting the character of the neighborhood and the health, safety and welfare of the community. RESOLUTION/ACTION: On motion by Chairman Goehringer, seconded by Member Collins, it was RESOLVED, to DENY the variance applied for and ALTERNATIVELY to GRANT a variance authorizing a rear setback of no less than 40 feet from the rear property line, subject to the CONDITION that the northerly wall of the proposed addition shall for its entire length be set back no less than 1eet from the northerly property line. VOTE OF THE BOARD: Ayes: Members Goehringer Chairman), Din' in, Tortora, and Collins. (Member Homing from Fishers Island was absent. is R= olution s dul .e.ed 4-0). i "GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMA RECEIVED AND FIT.Er. BY bOu i.C.LD TOVv1J Citi DATE �IVa1� HOUR '- 'P'il` aidOCI 1414 Town Clerk, Town of Southold • fes' NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS THURSDAY,AUGUST 10, 2000 NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN, pursuant to Section 267 of the Town Law and Chapter 100 (Zoning), Code of the Town of Southold, the following application will be held for public hearing by the SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS at the Town Hall, 53095 Main Road, Southold, New York 11971, on THURSDAY, AUGUST 10, 2000 at the time noted below (or as soon thereafter is possible): 7:15 p.m. AppL No. 4845 - ROBERT FRENTZEL. This is a request for a Variance to Article XXIV, Section 100-244B, based on the Building Department's June 22, 2000 Notice of Disapproval. The Disapproval denied an application for a building permit to construct an addition to a one-family dwelling for the reason that the addition does not meet the required minimum rear yard setback of 50 feet. Location of Property: 1900 Old Orchard Lane, East Marion, NY; Parcel 1000-37-2-9.1. The Board of Appeals will at the above time and place hear all persons or their representative desiring to be heard or to submit written statements (before this hearing is concluded). The hearing will not start earlier than designated. Files are available for review during regular Town Hall business hours (8-4 p.m.). If you have questions, please do not hesitate to call (631) 765-1809. Dated: July 17, 2000. SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS Town Hall 53095 Main Road Southold, NY 11971 " Q / FORM NO. 3 eACD' (° o SO TOWN OF SOUTHOLD r� BUILDING DEPARTMENT rr t5 © 1E U i�! 6 SOUTHOLD,N.Y. {i l !I i\.1' JUN 26i 1 NOTICE OF DISAPPROVAL DATE; June 22, 2000 TO Amy Martin A/C Frentzel PO Box 521 Greenport NY 11944 Please take notice that your application dated May 19, 2000 For permit to addition to a one family dwelling at Location of property 1900 Old Orchard La East Marion County Tax Map No. 1000 - Section 37 Block 2 Lot 9.1 Subdivision Filed Map# Lot# Is returned herewith and disapproved on the following grounds;proposed construction on lot 22,500 sq.ft. not permitted pursuant to Article XXIV Section 100-244B which requires a minimum rear yard setback of 50 (fifty) feet, proposed construction shown as+/- 36 (thirty-six) feet from rear lot line. 1F. Authorized Si e v ((;;�s... -....tea- ......., ii- Ii ref Pi;Y f Luau 6 BOARD OF HEALTH J t FORM NO. 1 3 SETS OF PLANS --' TOWN OF SOUTHOLD SURVEY ot.DG.DEPT SO!, s BUILDING DEPARTMENT CHECK TOWN HALL SEPTIC FORM SOUTHOLD, N.Y. 11971 TEL: 765-1802 NOTIFY: Any MAte--7 A-1 CALL _ .1?-22.7:9.7 .2-7-i. . Engined.. • , 19.... MAIL TO Approved , 19.... Permit No. Disapproved-a/c (Building Inspector) APPLICATION FOR BUILDING PERMIT •Date. j/A. . . .. ., .., 19 INSTRUCTIONS a. This application must be completely filled in by typewriter or in ink and submitted to the Building Inspector c 3 sets of plans, accurate plot plan:to scale. Fee according to schedule. b. Plot plan sharing location of lot and of buildings on premises, relationship to adjoining premises or public streets or areas, and giving a detailed description of layout of property must be drawn on the diagranwhich is part of this application. c. The work covered by this application may not be commenced before issuance of Building Permit. o d. Upon approval of this application, the Building Inspector twill issue a Building Permit to the applicant. Such permit shall be kept on the premises available for inspection throughout the work. e. Nb building shall be occupied or used in whole or in part for any purpose whatever until a Certificate of Occupancy shall have been granted by the Building Inspector. APPLICAITCN IS WHY MALE to the Building Department for the issuance of a Building Permit pursuant to the Building Zone Ordinance of the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York, and other applicable Laws, Ordinances or Regulations, for the construction of buildings, additions or alterations, or for removal or demolition, as herein described. the applicant agrees to canply',with all applicable laws, ordinances, building code, housing code, and regulations, , and to admit authorized inspectors on premises and in buildi,_ ..r nnecei: i tions. i I, , (Signature-applicant, or name, if a corporati / 7 . / ( Wi m' ' (Mailing address of appl t) State whether applicant is owner, lessees., arch.tect,/,e engineer, general contractor, electrician, plumber or lxiilde / ' ,e.7- #7 e'// Q �dI`%rcipir,. ,. Nene of owner of premises /1.+Q 11�'.,y jiL`.,cl. rte.[-r.— (as.on the tax roll or latest deed) If applicant is a cotputatioo, signature of duly authorized officer. (Name and title of corporate officer) Builders License No. Plumbers License No. Electricians License lb. Other Trade's License Nb. 1. Location of land on which proposed work will be done /qoO O/d a ac' 9/gN.ec�sr t,cvoAK House Number - Stieet Hamlet County Tax MapNa. 1000 Section ....Q.-7.1...... Block al Lot ..!i &nbdivision9.9e&&4' Opy Stades Filed Map lb. Lot (Name) 2. State existing use and occupancy of premises and intended use and occupancy of proposed construction: C, a. Existing use and ocwpaocy ...,Si71 ` �4 ./ <1.,6.l ' �-.r- b. Intended use and occupancy Q���!! ? . .��:"""' .../.‘t3-(:,/,--x-e.e.„ a, w (Description) - 4. Estimated Cost 71:6-S-04±.=00 fee J (to be paid on filing this application) 5. If dwelling, nxmber ofdwelling units / . holier of dwelling units on each floor If garage, winker of cars 14- / 6. If business, commercial or mixed occupancy, specify nature and extent of each type of use /� ! n 01--, 7. Dimensions of existing structures, if any: Front...(!%O. l !_ Rear . .G%. : ;1:.. Depth 1T oil ileigtrt-- Umber of Stories / ,// //�� / /Dimensions f same structure with alterations or additions: Front ....../nn uit r Rear ...'E:Q........ Depth ...X.3'c- " lkight ...sd2.c& ' Nutter of Stories -- �" / 8. Dimensions of entire new construction: Front ..� � 14-1. -' Rear ....vlf� Depth Height Naber of Stories `>1--' 9. Size of lot: Front ..JO Rear ..15-0 Depth ..15"0 10. Date of Purchase Name of Former Owner I I. Zone or use district in which premises are situated 12. Does proposed construction violate any zoning law; ordinance or regulation: 13. Will lot be iegiaded Will excess fill be removed from premises: �_YYES Pit 10<g) 14. Nares o r of premises CRO e!?,_. r Address �O X,363 ltlllClo No.C2.' G7 �r O Li71 l ��iPs'?�l�?y No' i� L Name o itect Address _a Name of Contractor Address . 15. Is this piuperty within 300 feet of a tidal wetland? * YES N) *IF YES, S XJi1flD TONT 7ROSW1S PERMIT MAY BE REQUIRED. PLOT DIAGRAM locate clearly and distinctly all,buildings, ,wbether existing or.,pipposed, aid indicate all,set-back dimensions frau piuperty lines. Give street and block iutber or description according to deed, and show street nares and irdicat( whether interior or corrn1er:lot. . • SPATE Of NEiYORK, SS COUNIY OF an" m K` L / ' ` being duly sworn, deposes and says that he is the applicant (Name of individual signing contract) above nvzhed, �. GJlle is the a-rcI I fed— (Contractor, d (Contractor, a corporate officer, etc.)/Y of said owner or owners, and is duly authorized to perform or have perfonied the said work and to peke and file this application; that all statements contained in this application are true to the'best of his knowledge and belief, and that the Work will be performed in the «envier set forth in the application filed therewith. Sworn to before me this ifq- “ day off1 F9 c 2CLC Notary Public _ ".', Ii iZ LINDA J.COOP...-. (Signa. "of Applicant) Notary Public,State of New York No.4222563,Suffolk Ccu ity Term Expires December 31, . s � #e.Ar-c2 • C47/ • TOWN OF SOUTIIOLD. NEW YORK " APPEAL FROM DECISION OF BUILDING INSPECTOR APPEAL Na DATE ...A07449-00 TO THE ZONING BOARD TOAPPEALS, TOWN OF SOUTI TOLD, N. Y. 1. (We)a. . .`W. .. gerS Y,r 'Nome of Appellant Street and Number ,CE717/70te .HEREBY APPEAL TO Municipality foto THE ZONING BOARD OF.APPEALS FROM THE DECISION OF TI•iE 8UILDING INSPECTOR' ON APPLICATION FOR PERMIT NO. DATED ` a/ El V E D WHEREBY THE BUILDING INSPECTOR DENIED TO JUN 2 $ 2000 "lob-cc-74 1✓TZ�IJ __.. .._.»» susattotrl town Clerk Name of Applicant for permit of /100. Old �fPi(Gard Jac. ets7±4o9Rio4/ y Street and Number Municipality State ( ) PERMIT TO USE ( ) PERMIT FOR OCCUPANCY • ( -t pe mrd �5 P f IJP E%� ' 3 0//el f f.? Y-eiiefnn s r C 1. LOCATION , l.THE PROPERTY ... o 0 O,e »#iJ av/Df Street /iiamlei:a/ Use District' on Zoning/ J514 op District 1000 Section . j131ock „Lot ! / f Current Owner ow/ tre/ e Mop No, • Let No. Prior Owner 2. PROVISION (S) OF THE ZONING ORDINANCE APPEALED (Indicate the Article Section, Sub. section and Paragraph`of the Zoning Ordinance by number. Do not quote the Ordinance.) Article XX 11V Section',: I/0O -c?4 /%3 3. TYPE OF APPEAL Appeal is mode herewith for (please check appropriate box) (i0) A VARIANCE to the Zoning Ordinance or Zoning Map ) A VARIANCE due to lack of access (State of New York Town Low Chop. 62 Cons. Lows Art. 16 Sec. 280A Subsection 3 i. ) • • 4. PREVIOUS APPEAL A pteviotis appeal (hos) (has not) been mode with respect to this decision of the Building Inspector or with respect to this property. Such appeal was ( ) request for o'special permit ( ) request for a variance and was mode in Appeal No. Doted REASON FOR APPEAL ( ) A Variance to Section 280A Subsection 3 ( ) A Variance to the Zoning Ordinance ( ) • is requested for the reason that • Fenn 2131 (Continue on other side) REASONS FOR AREA VARIANCE ONLY (to be completed by applicant): Do not use these standards for "use variance" or "special exception. " (Also attach sheets if necessary, with signatures. ) 1. An undesirable change will NOT be produced in the character of the neighborhood or a detriment to nearby properties, if granted, BECAUSE: _.,t/ ��_ rhe t } r ./A•t, /J crlvY w+ J y y o tit ,/2 s)v Gds S num,' Ti 2. The benefit sought the applicant CANNOT be achieved by some method, feasible for the applicant to pursue, other than an area • variance BECAUSE: `lf /r/2°' Gc x�fc o✓ /E Q, _ p /deo Lai a—A. r -�-rV 3 . The amount o' 'relief requested is. not" substantial BECAUSE >t;LY , f 4 . The variance will NOT have an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood or district BECAUSE e.J. J % j aec pe-0_s-coma 5 . Has_the alleged difficulty been self-created? ( ) Yes . ( ) No. 6. This is the minimum that is necessary and adequate, and at the same time preserve and protect the character of the neighborhood and the health, safety and welfare of the community. STATE OF NEW YORK) COUNTY OF SUFFOLK) //t/ _ , � pplica /{�� Agent attach written consent from owner. Sworn to before me this t' ay of ? �.. , oZ® Notary Public HELENE D.HORNE s:t:SSS .....aaa:x: Notary Public,State of New York . : .tlk/form.var/t ;D ft- 3951364 Commission dualifie Suffolk Courst' Commission Etres AAa°q x?. 61 d t J. . t _ '� / - TOWN OF SOUTHOLD PROPERTY RECORD CARD /eoo - 37 -2 - 9.1 Lt5rds Col -n4 6,3 OWNER - 91/ QQ VILLAGE DIST. SUB. LOT%/ o.- . Tr d b +" Pre �' , ")/s4a=av �,. dile-f, ; S.t..Z` . d , 2r 2� i`;/✓�..��s�dt�c.�dt^Q� '. .ems FO MMER.OWNE 1 N E ACR. Kn b erg-tren+zc jd- W F . 7c ,. 530 S W k_ TYPE OF BUILDING tltl //�� / RES.Vej SEAS, VL. FARM COMM. CB. MICS. Mkt. Value LAND IMP. TOTAL • DATE, -- REMARKS Peys`n'. 572. l/iB P iSG'h �d 7—f-f.,7`27 500 ,. ,. ,. /64 J660 /o/Zc/rs Nle ,, /©or SOD 4800 111-516) '2/ii (P92." 1Qfro? -s3 ,rC'h"1"2et 71-a jltctn-1,GI Pk Il AGE BUILDING CONDITION NEW NORMAL BELOW ABOVE FARM Acre Value Per Value Acre Tillable FRONTAGE ON WATER • Woodland FRONTAGE ON ROAD 7.i / cc 7 _ j,..�3. , Meadowland DEPTH 4-6-0 House Plot BULKHEAD Total nrry i.: .. \ py F 1 1 cA 7 I { _ 14 4iB ' i .,.00, ,;:# 1 1 ; C OLOR /Yee TRIM /1,11,0,--- — ifw . ASIP(' �l7 v ■■n■ ■■ 11111111111• Elle 14 :uCl' II"? ° Pd` ;1:1114447 _ ■■■1111111 1111111111111111111111111111111 11111111 l* 4A yy i d Y}+ ) - 1 TlIia3Re :.F.4%.4i1:"..' i C74 ,iir.i. ' f Irr- I p i11 11■ ■ ■ il ind!i!!IdSrmmmmng _ anamminsaimummilis am 11111M1111111111111111111111111111111 iiiiiUhii!tIIIJiiiiIIIIIt sae indwargosertaram.metiEsimummiessamsI U nPia fit! M. Bldg. 1( y/ r7 11■■■imi"'�sul■� ■i..... " Extension 3 X�� 3 J � � N Extension / 1111111111111 9 Fr -J c tG f� ■ ■■� �■ ■ Extension S� � 2. p 3 _ 4, i �� 21 r7(. 0 _ �� / ��foundation G (?� Bath �. 0 Dinette s Porch / Basement FP // Floors (5a6 K. . Porch Ext. Walls ti,'VI .T4 Interior Finish ,4 e LR. // a t. 3reezeway 9y (enj! y, o if dire Place Heat 0 I C r DR. '� 3arage yy 3-4) / q, 6 Tjipe Roof Rooms 1st Floor NMIBR. y 'atio Recreation Room Rooms 2hd Floor FIN. B i.'i i. B. Dormer Driveway { �" otal 3r �_ [j/ / ----.. TOWN OF SOUTHOLD PROPERTY RECORD CAR11 D O7 2- 9./ DIST. SUB. LOT /2 �CoS. STREET VILLAGE l0/�4i'S OWNER ' 7a � . % /cat-, � . 4,, o417 " ncau.5— FORMER OWNER 4 N' E `- S W TYPE OF BUILDING 42, a Vi :ex Adeosea- PY-lU.f, --- FARM COMM. CB. MICS. Mkt. Value RES. SEAS. VL'3/1 1/11 :', / r LAND IMP. TOTAL DATE REMARKS//9/?yJ/w � i- 'o Aa e wei_ 7 /6,.e/ �� ii/G ( .0itrIa\Qi*E0 'ply ' L �h boa ll � �- UI0/> SOo�1 Soo 7 10/30/ 78 i AGE BUILDING CONDITION NEW NORMAL BELOW ABOVE _ FARM Acre Value Per Value Acre FRONTAGE ON WATER Tillable /, -6 n Woodland FRONTAGE ON ROAD 7__{ �__ -7_ %a . fMeadowland DEPTH ii-0 House Plot BULKHEAD . DOCK . I i tw a ..r is Js"W y s +. \ 'r t'C''''.1 :c."'.4. 5 l \�''i` \y 0 ems^«»+\. $4 'ai' '�.'. a »saa.a.{ �„� ....ww,,rw,w.«;n+,e-.�.v,� +.....*w-q.ww_u=.._�...w�,......�,:;�t«. k,_-'»c-.z......•-,....-...w.,.d.rr..M.,-r, -»,w.. ,,,«a.m ,.,.+ru..uro-ww.,, �.wn m r k �a -k F :.0 n;k+ 2, t g'✓'�1 AiL4 ' Ls _ ✓' .... fY+.nswv S+? -• m MA ' o re' ° 10 s� N ll j��Wtr.1`Ryj$�yryY���Nyf/jM�1fy(�X” (M�`ry( � !g �1��1)�q}}} - {p�yyµµ��if{ ..o.,�. d o r..{ G2.+3'< -+' rif,� URV E t 4 f W . tto .w++d-^nt w.� '-'^ wtz.pn ,mow, K...« a },•;-2.4. - .R" , - 1`� , R »• , M�M•. x - `�..... ! � F • {I$$,{ .F 4w l��M t +z.N'. �y Kr v a i . I a,, . _ c �` ire : "F' f p gyp,t p s 5,,,,i0' , y f"°,,,y ^ `.. _ .J( QPY`Ilwi wF' kaf L le) , • • • • c- h t k 'tRy h i t pp y(pty yyy - }ttf y. �'FY M,.' h4 i trk�� rt' 'AIS 4, '44' A': H i 1 i, 16 8 _T r e / tteil 1 { fix' pkr ,�, / kn.y w + ,, tY l „ fi .5047 < r A t�lyi� � ✓• ' -- ' 1 / . a. , 4r , ,. r � r '*t 0 f .04-41 'pTiq r a a tit. .,.. x e .' 'x»` u - 'N " {: fi i!' 1^ ° ? :-;.t tkl,,,,:',4 U' '. ' '7�. «,r°i , E y,,. .a3x I^ s ur et m p eitl t -e ^r ldSQUIatslnrted<cxl%"' , ,. _ -�soel sh¢Ii rva¢ho con �.,,u ��( 44 �e s n ft .varm imo copy. a. a 3 w rn^^ cZif4 Y9 e"rri .'y 4 �'4£4 *Y'L'1tFb ' .1':N SA'S " i ..1« , pp }, e C F!4 y r; `�"` x4 ��' �? i' Y � � oas md,cnteri heroont i � 9 �' �«'�� 7 a4kpr . »v ' r ,""A .»' -,'d, a `t :.'$.', .:i3 p1{ i «`,ffie.,14:,i °....,w,•Sy s: .. . , :i y�ners>n Por whc�i C.c..rv. t `.. 6w+ x t rv�s �..; 'w. u .x# ' . �$` A;r "tk s.�LknAt rRm i! x.�S.w. >~.. t R. ,% P 8r1" i b a . .4 ,1 ' 4a; {.� "- 4 e ? 'i1f r., ,-44g t 4..' ` _ c'Ih 5 .«... ....,....,.. �' .. ^7«a ».t� +..Sx Fb�' M ,r rn xi. � s v �ti,� .•msµ .e,-.......« a. . ...<.- �v . • }a y x • _�,,+ *rM ,- f.',p4.�::_ ,R t j„ �" e ks al". 4y w. , _ ,. aM 1t� m A"u' ': "6. "1w1.+v "«w•, "'3w c9'st,,x.... r Y ... .<i' - R irit i ;!'S 59,¢e litat.�§ t SYtx 4 ,� .... � ..'.. .::':... ,. .;. .S,v.... _.,.., b ta..u.... gid. v......>t_ ,. wxai..., .a ...... --_ rr..,-....�....•:�-.. .,.,-,..s. .,...-r. ,,..,weey..--J+x,a.n..4 .. .L1w :`w'✓rvrv,e•y d..». ....W....ww....-nw. w.5y.,vevww..,w.»w..-A- w.^,ux.. r .y.x,*n.rM+^..*nr»...w.-:w>n.-s.;rnyy.n,« zeR,. �,. -.;e»=•rt 5 '>e�•+ i✓ �vtf^ armW '.r ^•.rY. ^7. r . ,,�- ..a ... zvrv,�_ ..4...... _ - _. 'n -, w � :., �,ry...�4,� x� .3Zw',re.�.ko-,:ri4 0' \ I al 2001 Mr. Gerard GoehringerPO Box 37` � � Board of Appeals East Marion, NY.119 9 Southold Town Hall May 30, 2001 53095 Main Road Southold, NY. 11971 REF: Approval to construct Frentzel home. Dear Sir: It has been many months since your decision concerning the construction of the Frentzel home on Old Orchard Lane, in East Marion. I felt it would be prudent to hold my thoughts until construction had progressed to a stage in which it would be possible to imagine the final out- come. The structure is every bit intrusive, as all of us in the area had suspected; oversized in its environs, it dwarfs the surrounding homes and casts us all in shadows. There has been no other construction previously allowed in Gardiners Bay Estates that even remotely compares to this monstrosity. As a result of the Board of Appeal's dereliction in judgement, you have driven the thin edge of the wedge into our stable and uniform community, opening the area to future atrocities, using relativism as your guide, as well as your excuse. Such an affront to our sensibilities leads us all to wonder whether Frentzel's variance had been approved by unscrupulous means. The real problem here is our lack of direct means to defend ourselves from an intrusion of this kind. We have no choice but to look to a third party who has the power of enforcement behind it. In this instance, the Board of Appeals had failed miserably, and the rest of us will now suffer. Yours sincerely, Florence A. Heess P.S. Enclosed are a few photographs of your handiwork. c.c. James Dinizio, Lydia Tortora, Lora Collins, Ed Forrester, George Horning, Jean Cochran. , 47/)/0 I' 1)D tfiCitIffig t"-1)\-/ &m-k/ q 6 O-14`i Pirlju'ru 5 . 1 , . '� 1 1♦L pR40 y� . x fr ' *�� rte'? ‘.7; '_ \I ��'A'. A 4i;a e i . e. 1r/«H ` ,V41 iii, 'i Atm. __4, ,. ,,, 4\ Vri, T yr • 3. H • • JZIE AYE::.: ' - '^tis x- .. ... vt'' + ►��E�iI.Ax�° ayKt+'� a d,�4 ��� � q� t r �I r it dac 'sly •so 4. ��tzi nYt IIPA..A''•••::`,7.111.44\ 1 p�/,flits f •• • t Mille .l n i.:4').'-.=,'44:♦ 1 `/� ;: n,; ,i`,;•il> ,wr `'y 1._ ' �I`.. . r 9g, �,' r„.„....,-.s. , "444#1. / ;,•', A:,'","', r hr (�I ! ;1 -t , /, 40) ;11a ,r uk, rA! td k y...„ ,4„,.... „, .. ; 094 r r 4. f , , -;, 1 r _. , , r_iii it-r„,.1.,-%, . / ' ._ .."'”,.1..* 'Ar ' * ''''-' i .I., % .. ' '''...''- - ' V''. '*, , , r ,,,.„. . . . . .. . _ . , or! - ,,,,_ =-' . , . - 4----->A6 - r ...._.... ..._ _. , . .. u "" ,_ _ Tum T , ..._ , , ...... r_ .tea 1.„-1,- -•_ c ,e APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS _ ,�i" tFFOL4 0, 6'®G Southold Town Hall Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman r : 53095 Main Road James Dinizio,Jr. t y P.O. Box 1179 Lydia A.Tortora tt� Southold, New York 11971 Lora S. Collins / ZBA Fax(631) 765-9064 George Horning = IAlp *tool Telephone (631) 765-1809 .// I BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD September 12, 2000 Fax Transmission 734-7702 To: Deborah Doty, Esq. Re: App4845 — Frentzel Variance Project Dear M y: Enclosed please find a copy of the Appeals Board's determination granting alternative relief at the September 6, 2000 Meeting, during which you were present with the owners and the architect. As the next step of the permit review process, please be sure to submit amendments to the Building Department (765-1802) to bring the plans and site map into conformity with the ZBA decision. Very truly yours, enAie-1-41--(---- GERARD P. GOEHRINGER CHAIRMAN Enclosure Copy of Decision to: Building Department Fairweather-Brown, Architects (by fax) - TRANSMISSION RESULT REPORT (SEP 12 '00 01:48PM) SOU _D TOWN HALL 516 765 1823 (AUTO) DATE START REMOTE TERMINAL TIME RE- MODE TOTAL PERSONAL LABEL FILE TIME IDENTIFICATION SULTS PAGES NO. SEP 12 01:47PM 6317347702 01'18" OK ES 03 012 JA.0,-„idaee-c-,-A A ., 0ty f/2...7) 0 r-. E)ECM >)REDUCTION S)STANDARD M)MEMORY C)CONFIDENTIAL #)BATCH D)DETAIL $)TRANSFER F)FINE P)POLLING TRANSMISSION RESULT REPORT (SEP 12 '00 01:50PM) SOU _D TOWN HALL 516 765 1823 (AUTO) DATE START REMOTE TERMINAL TIME RE— MODE TOTAL PERSONAL LABEL FILE TIME IDENTIFICATION SULTS PAGES NO. SEP 12 01:49PM 5164770973 01'36" OK ES 03 014 jAriV O1LC. --A '71-6"-etikel-i — 6L'e-13)/ (74° E)ECM >)REDUCTION S)STANDARD MEMORY C)CONFIDENTIAL #)BATCH D)DETAIL $)TRANSFER F)FINE P)POLLING - • ® 0 DRESSING BILCQ DOOR I ' SINK ' REFRIG .�� TABLE I III I . %6'-0'LG 0 I SHOWER . ,,o„ MASTER BATH / - 1 0 DEN DINING RM I • O�IJ"�II DUMB I ® WAITER�` I H r I I RRFAKFAST RM I I /\ /\,..../\ /\ ''11 1 1 CEILING HOT 9'-0" al I --,r � - --T �---- UP DN I I I --- t I I a I I I MASTER BFDROOMJIVING RM CEILING®9'-0" ON IU OPENNTTOO ABOVE 1 CEILING HOT 9'-0" / I fNTRV FOYER CEILING HOT 10'-1 1/2" 1 • i 1___-' I - \ I r 1 ,,----I ■■�1 101 DNII 11111 ON O_■I. Q - - - - - II—. II — - , T I PAVED PATIO II GARAGE I 1 T II 1 I N E W F I R S T FLOOR P L A N SCALE: 1/8'.1'0' i---I I---I I-II I I -I I l I I 0 L A BRTARM 91 _- BATHRM M2 - BEDROOM Hi , I (3)VELUX ROOF WINDOWS / 7/`/ C _ 7/ J \\L _ IOSET , L , I , , l - C I J WAITER I - DN DUMB -1 BEDROOM 92 UP II - I I I CEILING HOT AT 9-6" I '> Z OPEN TO BELOW (OFT /PI ANT ROOM I I - _ aoJ - I BaH - Ii L 3'-0"HIGH LOW WAIL 1 11 h 11 I I I ' ..- I _ [)\�7Y I CLOSET L__�y UN II IBEDROOM 93 I I I--I I-- . I I N E W S E C O N D F L 0 0 R P L A N SCALE 7 1/8'.10 4 4 IRENTZEL RES. N/F HEE55 C5 N/F MUNCY 64 e Fn , cs N58°58'30'5 ' - 150.0 O O In ' DLCO DOORS . 37 50' N - ( I I I _ Y 63 �• / 74 ' 2 STORY � FRAME HOUSE w g" _ a 2nd FLR P NED E.:44) �Ls DECK PATIO s zp O 62 PAVED PATIOA d a LOCUST COURT 2 CAR 73 GARAGE 61 01w 0 to o o oz E :(5 m N 2 z 558°58'30'W 150.0 60 MANNING __ 4-1t.,,,J2BASED ON SURVEY FOR �OOOii .ROBERT FRENTZEL EAST MARION /�- ^ /JTOWN OF SOUTHOLD,N.Y. I. 'j' ilii f ate...4_, ; SUFFOLK COUNTY TAX MAP DESIGNATION • 1000-037-2-9.1 �"t E LOT NO.'S REFER TO MAP OF SECT.2,GARDINERS BAY ESTATES, ______ FILED IN THE SUFF.CO CLERKS OFFICE AS MAP NO 275 TOTAL AREA:22,500 S.F. •MONUMENT .IRON PIPE SITE PLAN SCALE: I"=30' 9/02 aa c FT Ft ti 2 51- ,. - U _ Ply C�h )C >' (V ., i • ', / �- �1 -"e- J • 71 ljfit 41/ 6248 l000 joidit.4-14 ( - Demi c53og5 ,d'Z `d Gtr /19 7/ -- ----- - - -- - ------- -- -- --- -- --- --- - --- -- ---- ------- --- ---- - - - - Bipti 21)1) - - - tita) hg-A- td-11.1 gar__ eijA-7-e-4 JI-V-1/Le Ai® 451/5 api,ce-vLi .11x)-(Amt., 1:14 4e,La„,>7. ut&zdet ,Op_14A.p_J a_44-1 -/tILL2 ILLY, _ a - - 16.41-1:A-) LbtUA-IL6Wr "UL,tff etA-12- .it2.9 /Uri ae( cei,„„t4± luv4:411,4 jj,JU ?if/LA/-11,4) c()1%.3 jWY v 7 J l l A j . • Qui QhL��, _� �►'. P' .X C 41 FAIRWEATBER-BROWN _ ftE 1--.) DESIGN ASSOCIATES,INC. P.O.Box 521 MG 1 7 2tt00 1` 1 413 Main Street ;," Greenport,N.Y. 11944 631-477-9752 (fax)631-477-0973 August 16, 2000 Zoning Board of Appeals 53095 Main Road Southold,New York 11971 Re : Application of Robert Frentzel t� 1900 Old Orchard Lane East Marion,N.Y. 11939 1000-037-2-9.1 Dear Chairman&Board Members, Persuant to your request at the hearing on August 10th, please accept the following information. The measurement from grade to ridge at the rear of the house is approximately 28'6". However as you are aware, this property is lower than the surrounding properties at this point.Measured from the road, the height of that same ridge is only 24'8". Sincerely, �7 Ian A.R.Fairweather ,. www - , ; - •,.I.` :-0 -4 '- % ' "'•''''''k. - • - .- $4, : . '•_,• ', - ....,. - . ,. . .;. *..,, :;" .,,,,•- `'. s ,' jf;,-•1, 4 t' ;iiik--t ' • --, ... - ' , - ,-.;-• -- -.r.• • ‘,0".‘kaa ' t" 11.•'' “*, , x: N - -.c.vt — -. bip. -- - . , ,-.4... ' . .4, ,t, .: 6:.1.;_,1# - . , •• .., 4."•-•,,, 4 ' r... • 1 'e,,; -. egiii,, + 1 ''t 1:- ' .t.. 4", ' `1 - • - 142.- - ,, ,w,..'. s-• - , '' v,-4, ' *, . -- . ' :',,i' a 7 ;i4 - -.' , . . • ' , -:;.- ' ' - . • • , ;,-, i . .,..- . .0- . . •..-.. • -,- ' A... , • - . .---- ' ' ''' - ' --tte''' 41:-. , t. •IP,-z.. . ,. . #4, -- . , . - Z ----3 ,.. _ _ -,. ......,.... .. _ .„ .,.._ ,., , 4 . - ..,--.MN -5 — - —MI 1 no_ _in_ .,.'I . • ' - 1. - a ---= ____..-------- -. --, , , • • -- -,..:.‘"':' ' -- , . L , -..- - i, iiii: , aii 1 i P Ig _..., -- ...._ • is 4 . ,.• _ .. _ .. . ,. is-3;:tii •'6' ' '- ' . =',"' >- , ---•,-r,....., '7**. — - ni LAI& ,,,,,, 7-, tit efre-6d, (vilk zO 7 76 ,�y/ ��Q • r/ ,t4e- --7:A.,z-.-Se_e 727_ Ae- /642,4 4461-44 ,— L 7 61-#6 -Titcx.p<-5,e1 "to /e/v,_ AY-ce_ .� -z. ,sem- M ti X1'3 9 �►' a �De ef' h.-tt/sola Y• ROBERT FRENTZEL, A _'�No. 4845, SCTM #1000-37-2-9.1 / Supplement to Application - August 10, 2000 4or /9/01. The premises is located in Section Two of Gardiners Bay Estates - the map for which was filed in 1927. While there is some new construction, the structures in the area primarily are (1) summer bungalows, or (2) summer bungalows which have been renovated, expanded and/or converted into year-round use. The subject premises consists of 22,500 square feet(0.53 of an acre) located on the west side of Old Orchard Lane in East Marion. It originally was comprised of three of 50x150' lots on the filed map. In March 1974, the applicants purchased the premises as two separate 75x150' lots. The dwelling was and is located on the northern of the:two 75' lots. For a reason unknown to both the owners and the Southold Assessors Office, the two parcels were combined on November 5, 1981. (See Southold Town Property Card.) ' The applicants purchased the property with the intention of retiring to East Marion. They personally landscaped the parcel and installed and tended the lush gardens located on the southern and western part of the property. The focus of the current house (and the proposed addition) is from the north side of the premises toward the south. The applicants wish to expand and renovate the dwelling so that it will be,their retirement home. While converting the existing first floor into a foyer/breakfast room/kitchen, dining room, living room and den, the applicants propose to add an atrium and master bedroom suite off the northwest corner of the house. A second floor inchiding,a study and guest rooms will be added. The garage at the south end of the house will be extended to provide extra space on the second floor for Mr. Frentzel's extensive model train collection. The approximately 5x15' existing extension as well as the chimney projection on the northern side of the current dwelling will be removed making the side yard setback not more than 11.63'. The proposed lot coverage is-15%. Because the proposed rear yard setback is 36'4" rather than the requisite 50', the applicants are seeking a rear yard variance of 13'8". It should be noted that if the applicants were to sell a strip less than 17' wide to the neighbor to the south, the proposed structure with a 36'4" setback would be in total compliance with the Code. 1. An undesirable change will NOT be produced in the character of the neighborhood or a detriment to nearby properties, if granted, BECAUSE: The requested variance is consistent with what currently exists in the neighborhood. As a general rule, the lots in Gardiners Bay Estates are non-conforming under the Town Code. Most of the lots are smaller than 20,000 square feet for which the rear yard setback is 35' (which is less that the proposed 36'4" setback in this case). Nonetheless, many of the neighboring dwellings in Gardiners Bay Estates have insufficient setbacks. For example, the house immediately to the north (Fisher, Lot#7.1) has a side yard setback of only 7'± (possibly 6'±, depending on whether the deck remains in the place reflected on the 1991 survey) rather than the required 10'. The house across the street (McKeon, Lot #12.1) has a rear yard setback of 13',± rather than 35'. Whereas the Code requires a 35' setback, the Thorp house (Lot#4.1) has a rear yard setback of 25'±. The house at the end of block (Lasgar, Lot #33) has a rear yard setback of 151h',± rather than 35' and a front yard setback of 19'± rather than the required 35'. (See copies of surveys'annexed.) Numerous additional examples exist throughout the Gardiners Bay community. • The extension is directed back from the road and located in an area that will serve to preserve the privacy of the neighbors and the applicants. Accordingly, the proposed addition will not produce an undesirable change in the character of the neighborhood or detriment to nearby property. 2. The benefit sought by the applicant CANNOT be achieved by some method, feasible for the applicant to pursue other than an area variance BECAUSE: In light of the layout of the current house and the grounds, the proposed extension parallel to northern line is both logical and aesthetically appropriate. The proposed master bedroom wing to the rear affords the applicants' privacy and preserves the house's focus toward the mature landscaping to the south and west. A two-story box on the property with the master suite on the second floor is not feasible. One of the applicants has arthritic knees as well as a leg problem which dictate against daily and repeated stair- climbing to a second floor master bedroom. Moreover, the owners wish to use the house as a retirement home. . A relocation of the extension so that the dwelling is shaped as a "T" would result in a larger-side yard If the unexplained 1981 combination had not occurred (and a Code merger were avoided);,.the '-•.; lot would be less than 20,000 square feet and the proposed 36'4" rear yard setback would be acceptable under the current Code. which essentially would be and would provide a view of a fence and the windowless side of the northern neighbor's house. Placing the addition at the back of the garage is not architecturally sound. It would require that the owners walk through or along the garage to get to the main living space on the north side of the house. To extend the house to the south is neither feasible nor appropriate. Such a plan would increase the road frontage, require relocation of the garage, and destroy a major portion of the mature landscaping installed and maintained by the owners. Simply put, the proposed "L" shaped dwelling makes sense. 3. The amount of relief requested is not substantial BECAUSE: The requested 13'8" rear yard setback is less than a 28% variance from the required 50' setback. Other existing non-conforming dwellings in the immediate vicinity have substantially larger variances. The McKeon's 22' setback is a 63%'variance from the Code; the Lasgar property has a 56% yard variance and a 46% front yard variance; the Fischer property has a 30% side yard variance; and the Thorp house has a 29% rear yard variance. 4. The variance will not have an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood or district BECAUSE The extension toward the back of the property is designed to minimize the physical and environmental impact on the neighborhood. The addition is directed away from the street and into an area where neighbors will be least disturbed. If the extension were tothe south, there would be a significant adverse impact on the street scape as a result of the increased road frontage of the house. The proposed structure is in keepiniwith the neighborhood. 5. Has the,alleged difficulty been self-created? ( ) Yes. (X) No. 6. This is the minimum that is necessary and adequate, and at the same time preserve and protect the character of the neighborhood and the health, safety and welfare of the community. araPir DEBORAH DOTY, as attorney for k.•licants STATE OF NEW YORK ) ) ss. COUNTY OF SUFFOLK ) Sworn to this 10th day of August, 2000 dL' c 641 e II Not.fy Publ ` JUDY OKEEFE Notary Public,State of New York No.30-4900952 Qualified In Nassau County Commission Expires July 13j 1'"c \ID. \-_., ,,, IE IC MOWE ALS "Cul To the Southold Town Board of Appeals: Regarding the application for a variance by Robert Frentzel 1900 Old Orchard lane,East Marion N.Y. Parcel 1000-37-2-9-1 -- is,,s \ �c.) u\g L.c This is not an easy letter for me to write. Bob and Mella Frentzel are good people and good neighbors. But I can't help but express my reservations regarding their proposed addition. This looming 25 foot high addition,which is bigger than many of the houses in our neighborhood,is being built a scant 11 1/2 feet from my property line along almost my entire back yard. In addition, our houses were originally built very close together,less than 20 feet apart. We are afraid this addition will create a"city"like atmosphere where the only view you have from some of your windows is that of another building, and what that will do to our property value. I don't know if this is possible,but I was hoping that some Solomon like compromise could be reached where the addition would be allowed but attached to the other side of their house, behind their garage. I know they must have spent a lot of time, effort, and money on this project and this arrangement would allow them to build their addition with very little change to their plans. It would also move the structure away from most of the neighbor's property lines thereby limiting the impact it would have on any of us. I would like to make one final proposal. I think part of the reason for putting the structure where it was proposed was to make it into a kind of inhabitable fence, screening their yard from most of their visible neighbors. Therefore, if they would be willing to move the addition to the other side of the house we would be willing to incur the expense of planting screening trees on our property to help create a better view for them from their backyard by blocking the view of our backyard. Thank you for taking my reservations into consideration. Sincerely, ,� wii/ 0 Bernard Fisher , & 1,, ♦ i y Southold Town Hall Zoning Board of Appeals Fax Cover Sheet (631) 765-1809 Office`Tel. • 765-9064 Office Fax TO: ,i(Z!/ZW2(LAV J (31-61n1) FAX: L7 7 - 6 73 DATE: 6 /be d PAGES to FOLLOW: I — Comments: 53095 Main Road 6 P.O. Box 1179 ' 6 So,thold NY 11971-0959 l 5/‘ MEMORANDUM TO: Building Department Attn: Ed Forrester FROM: Jerry Goehringer, ZBA Chairman DATE: August 8, 2000 SUBJECT: Notice of Disapproval -Frentzel (37-2-9.1) A neighbor has contacted the ZBA about a question with regard to the proposed expansion of the nonconforming side yard (less than 15') for the above project, and why it was not addressed in the June 22, 2000 Notice of Disapproval. The application was advertised based on a request for relief under the rear yard; if the Notice of Disapproval is amended for the expansion of a nonconforming side yard, new notices and amendments to the pending appeal would become necessary. Please advise. Thank you. cc: Fairweather-Brown Architects—'Y ° LhOYnh J oTy, e-sJ . /-�/'1, ie SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS 631-765-1809 Fax- 765-9064 facsimile transmittal To: galiiibteamiastev),3 Fax: //7?- e773 From: ZBA Office Date: 67/7/2 Re: Pages: a Taw 0 Update 0 For Review 0 Please Comment 0 Please Reply 0 Please Recycle 6 TRANSMITTAL MEMO TO: ZBA Chairman and Members FROM: ZBA Office Staff DATE: aur, A ,nod SUBJECT: File Update - Hearing Calendar of r/a/o - \yealliff With reference to the above application, please find attached the following new information added to the official ZBA office file: Comments: Number of Pages Attached: C:\WINDOWS\DESKTOP\ZBA FOLDERS\ZBA\ZBA MEMBERS FROM STAFF\TrMemo.doc FRENTZEL RES. NIP HEE5E 75 NIP MUNCY 64 an p N58°58'30"E - I 50.0 • ■ O p 0 O earn DOORS 32.30'H rt, 3 74 ?ro foseta F--y — 2STORY •, " 1P FRAME HOUSE A / 1 .*'''... '‘'& /\— DECK LR. P vED PATIO / cv o � 62 PAVED PATIO X p LOCUST COURT --/ 2 CAR 73 GARAGE 52 °= I 61 72 w m 0 m o o m m N m z / 1 558°5630"W 150 O , 60 MANNING D v tE © E a(�,rl E 1.1\.\BASED ON SURVEY FOR AUG o 2 2000 ROBERT FRENTZEL EAST MARION (I0 �\:,TOWN OF SOUTHOLD,N.Y, . I j SUFFOLK COUNTY TAX MAP DESIGNATION: 1000-037-2-5.I i I i -6 , LOT NO.'S REFER TO MAP OF SECT.2,GARDINERS SAY ESTATES, FILED IN THE SUFF.CO.CLERKS OFFICE A5 MAP NO.275 TOTAL AREA:22.500 S.F. .MONUMENT •IRON PIPE SITE PLAN SCALE: I"=30' C 0. / r, C. 69 v i30 I ,k • 0 0 0 H 0 ?•9 0 68 4) W " ,rs.9s o � o 58 o " <9 o 67 v) Z - J c 0 78 ,3� 0 3l :3v ° S NM66 1n 13- 2 S G +� o, '3 '4. 1 \ o S5 ti -- 1111.111°4,_ . _ ° 47 inR rso. o h 5 h C v // O M r z - '10 /3 Vn �� — � 7 S �s 0 S3 4 -` rz _• o0 S 00_me4 ,// r ° 6 Z vl. F• o 73 T , r ;;i � oCu ,, / Min0 V / O ` r' ,9-r - /OO 0 /i ° 4' 441 A '/ 1S° + N :Altill . \' ,/::, // v / oUd 4Z 4ZF' t 70 0 60 10 4t a �`�" /4 * Q Z--"/ 39 4o r p / 3,s # /3 -44S0 P ., 10 .t Sm �� F //4.4• // A J \ .I/ / / 4 e °l 8d 0 9'L O ° - �- O / 0A ._ ------- I .4.. „4.-..:,.;,....;-.•.•:„. .-,;.•••.:;:,---, .,,,,,4- ,i,-‘,.. ..--4.•::,,',1:,--.,,... .r,- •,..;`, _ ,,,,-- ..., _ , ,1-i.?.!.,._--r:i.,-;',..,:.,-,---?-.1,:,-..,,,-_,-;-*-!..,-„ t....__.--_. :,. ••••--•___-...t-t-.F...--,--_--,•- -- v- i --:--,•:.'';'-4---t•-gc,:•-14,---;-= z---_... •. :-, t.. \:- ..,._•,--------,,,,---.-.,..-,-,=,•,._ t - --• --- -- ;,-- :-:--,_,_-x-,,r-, ,...,---.24.4.•-...:,--:.--•"--4,.-••-•-•,,..;;::-.:t.'-.,;--(••it--, z!--t.,,,,,:fl'-'-*--,t•-•'•`: ,--_,-:• ---A ..--,t-•,--tz-iti -'-'"--.'.%)•‘:•:'",%''. ---•- :,•,,.,,,,-„..,..,,,,_:,...:,,.. .,.r, ,,,,,.,,..„t,,,,,,,,...„3,,.....,,,,,,.w,:,/,,,_,;:....,•,_ ,,.,.,1,•,...: . ,,-. ;...,,,,,- .••,f_-,..,,._:,•-•;;.;_•-;.;-!.-..,i,,.-...:,-. ?•..-:•- --_,..-;-,,_•,,,..,:i:,•'., ,3,1-,..--',„-.1,-':.,•c;--' •=r-,'''',;_; i-i•'-'_::: '",•.:-- .-: ::,-.;"4_'',;•°_.?:•-.;.?-%.---,,- (f-1i;-4szk-f-k`,.,4..-"•‘_:: 7-41 ".. .1--,-t:-:----.!.,":-47-:•A`-,--zs.'3•122.'-.;.;,-;f:,: .,'•t',Z,',-•,- ?.... ?z- ,;,.'''',-,, -=,....,.,''- ':• 1- ..:,'5:,_''...--='.---•,-:::c.:---:,•,-:-.;_'''.---:%•;,,,..:f,.;,.itti„tik%,-,-;,---r!q-':':i2;:.•-,-,e--,`,-zr-,-;'•.,•;:i'-•';„fi;.•7'..,7,1-:`-fY,M,:--::f'.'rrz_'-''',.1Act,-',1-X-'':1-'.5:,_-'',:4:.•t,1,;'1':?t,;',=_.:.,7:::2-.,f.:.,-',,I.:'.E. N:,"•!-;?.,,-.::•z.i-Y-2:f.,'.1;;;', ' ;- -t--'"?.7,-,- ,-;-:2-2i.L:•.'-11,-.- - • --• ,c•-•':-'',,,f '-',.- -,• ....--;•.-.1-L -,- -- --”, .'--- •--7:,-..-2':'`•:;:-"aill;:.,---.. -;'--.--- ',-. ...,'S.L-,-;',',;t,,-'-',,,::-._.....,-1-,-.,•••(4-::::':'-iee-i:: •-'-'0771.0::',-pi".4-fat, ,ri,--`3,-;.7-:.,1/4:;:',-.:,-.1.-.7,J,.: „-?-"C''q;:.--41-''- '..."''' -.,--''''''' '-' ., '.;• - -":-'--4.- -. ... . ',..' .. - • ......"-N;1. --1,- -k.:'''''''..; ',..:'!.'.c..',e,. -'.,,,,..4.A,11.111)7.,z., ,,--.1),--c,,:p.:24 ' .,1.44..„f,, Z-4.:-irr-:•:<,-s:1-)„,,,,:j-...--,N;,,f-*4..,...•:7:_!;.,;:".,:::: , -",":. '747'•,'?',''-••„'-'.. -??•,.-2-.._--_-_7.-:.;I- .:'-,:•,•--°,1-:„.'-'.-; • - -_-----;', .1- -... ,, ''', -',I.; - '• „-'4„.', 'r- ,:.;,-...:-._2 '...-.}; -,-".c.---,.---4,-.--'.;-s.-.' .•'-.1"---,:f "•:,'•;, -.5...-- '',.'-f.:!,..:•'...:,,.. ",--,-„,,,:,..!-, - ''.-1 . •LP„„--:,,,:-,--_-,__,-‘.-, : .-.,_--:-'.,...,,-;:, •••.,.... -..../."%t:•-,7,:,.. : .-. -i-..- - ,---r-,..",, - -,--,..‘;•,.,...---- -,_, ,,t'..4-,.1.:4::::::-.:.._;,......-'-'...q:'.......,..,:-:.S,'-„,t::•: -,-_!,!•-•-'sf-.,•,_-,.;,-,. _, : :`...-,.' --'-t 2"...:;--_.7'7---..'-'`. -;',-::- - • .."-..... ...-- .- -i''2- .-.- -- I.."-,'-'`f.- -- "..'.- 0.-...r-i a"----•_..,--: .-- --;-.1.+:..,'''--,--.' 1 - ''‘'"- T..-'.:*--_ ...aZI,&,_.. .,.......,......,.,......M;:_..: Fr...,91.4......,-..',.'""ICe • ' 4.-"4 -.' -L..'.--<:;--;-:'. ",-.•'.'.?2,--''. ; I 1 --7: -"?-: - '4-...-..- - ': .. --,',-, ' ' --,- - -• - --'---..-•-' ,:- "-' -...- - .---- -.... ek Z '-''1'.--' -',71 ,:-:-...-.. "'-.':=.4:--2' “:'-'-_'------I ti•Zip- :',„,..pt.A., . ,:._ .,.• . ...r , . .,..„ , .e_v ii 1--.--. , „ ....;:.',.."--.."--.- :.:,-,-•••::•`..--'•', ' - . --,.-•s-,-,•_:.,-,--„, '• - . •-:-;-!-- -;- ,. -, „,-.-_-_-- -... -r,...,'. - - ,r---....,.......,-,ifi.z. _-_;;-;--,.7,---......, :.. -;.•.--7.,,:„ , E. 12. _. A:. _ e, . fzy_ ... _ „, ......... ...:- E.,. .,.............. .., ... .. . _ '•-f-- ' ''',"-‘-i'f.,'A.--;.-',•2,': ' ' i;--•• ---,e,''-.A,I,':' . .;.“ ' -.- - - ' ''-'. ' '.' - . "`'.4.-4'-"'' ' T- . -6----6-_-_--t..-„•-_.- - .;:..-_,:-..,- .-. ,- :,..,- --;..,„ . -T.,-..--;-,;;,.„-A,3",...,---,-•• .... _, --,-...:---,-----,.. : --- -,-;--.--,:-,-.• ---.'" -::::-, ,-, -, . ,.__,-..i.„..-_5•14.kerc-7,`-.,-.---.--•innet.s-,--,.- .-..:--,- 7.,_:-?- ,..:.-=;".• .,--'4:,7;-.-,-!.:._,Fr..--.--1-7:::% :.:'..-:-;.-.-• -..,-,•‘--j„;„::, -.,::,•.-:,-- -',-'-.-0`,-;-,'..f.'.....r.,-,,,,i,az.:1-.-•,-..4. _14_,',"-',....:s:-..---,-., -."-e- --?,--,--- ... •-• . -: ' --;..,..:,..F.,‘,4t - ,, ,..ft'1, t•rt--7--v--..1L'' '',K:'__--r•- -•• ‘l':,•'„•-,, •cal ,.: z-. ;,::..:2, _,,tL-:, ,'-,- ''.-."=":--- --'-'f.tilt.altZM'Al2I0H-;-:_- • '—: • ._- ' '. :.:e'':',,,%:-•':,'-,-- '11. .< .. . „ -- -,. , 0 t44...-6:-..Itk_CollftFitre,--f-- `. ' - ',77 7.7-1-.2_ , •-. . . I ,-.;.',-- .•..--,t. .-; ,,_ - -•Tr.,,i.,„,--- oc.:'=-,, ,..4-1,-.14111.:(_, bi.":-CP''.1-cS'c?A',,',:._'..•c_.:' ----" -- ------; ' - ‘ . • ''IA:' •'- --Roil::pgts1.474,,..„, „Ia.?' . - -.2tatiolete -. g -:• ---•-:, '‘`,.---:. „- --,.....--: ,„-, ; •-L---,-r-r-,- -..- !-,f•••----,, -r.'-:-., -'.r, --1.-.J...i ..--:=:: :,--r--- -.: .-t„.-.:,,,- • : r.-- .- .---• . - • --Tr' ----. ,7-.--z---_.. - ,, .. ...-- — - -- — - -„f _ . - . 1 1— . : --,-. - -'• :• .--J.;'.." : :.- :---: __`_ —L":..„. -.- E _.,‘: > - - , - 1-' _-...'". iii- - i-1„,-.. ._• - -- trobis s'urveY is a vmNI 1.1'10ttltaio ' -. - :, _ ,„ ,_ 4„,,-, . .. ,-- --; ..,.. • .. >.;' -:linal..lbonzed-atterpt.lra pro eockjit.:17.111.,;:,- .z: ,:•-,, , :,,....-_, - • _ --_,--• ; .. .—.. ". Sefton 72,09 of ttle EN4 • .. .., ' ".. .. _.--'. ,... f: , . •,c. ,, - -;._ - .., .-- ''''-',- , - . , .%- - Edocation Lay4 __ --.. L •,'..: ', -, ,_ --,,,- -•,. _ - • '' -,•--•.,..' i...:---:-":▪ .4-•'., .';-,••-1 - , •_, . :. . ". . . - ' ''''./iN...1-f--- -:_-* ,:,;, •(;;;- :' ' - • .; . . . - . • . as. > — • •-, _- .." '' ''..m: '' , ,a-----,,-,-,- __ -— • - -- --------,-,' -')----,---'--.:-- • --,.'- ---1 'musE:t A--I t" wAt.14:. ' --; .::---- :,:, •-•:-..i.---„:,..1/4-.:-,, ;...z.-!---,' ; ' :: V,- - ' ': la -: ` ''''''')- ''''- ' -''embossed seal shalt not be osnsideesd ,-; ,. " - ` •tr.-•.A , ----..:-•.-‘,---,-..-,z, .----,- -cr....,,-:•.:-:,3 I. . :-,-.•-', ;- . ••:-• '--:.'...-_, _‘_ , _. ti: • ' -1:- .'* . . -..4 _: • , .--_.., __,..,,,--„, - 1. .- ' -.- — ,•:47 41--• - ,-, . -- „-:, .,, , A •. ,..„ _ _ ..,, _ , _ • " .4;•, _ ,,7.: fit: cr.::..,_ • . :- Guarantees Indiaited hersoil AO tan.'._ -,-. .. _ • .- .: -_i ,,- ,:', -,... ' •)- '.,f-a`:-,.:ty-,,-:,.. 1- _ . -- . - . - - • . .. •, • . .•...._ . ... '• - , - - . . _ • . . - .:..,__ 5.-$8, actrwr.,,,. ,.,.,.,_ .; , _ • - „ r:--.- iscy..0-f._1, --; ..::: _ : , . „- company governmental . h , , ._, , , , ..,,, ,:..,___ ..s. ,_....,.. : , :,,,_ .„. i . ,. . ,..•-•„, ----:..--,: '..,...--," . . . • _ _ .. -4-- *--.'- ' -4 '•'4- :::: . - . . ----, .---• . „-• _ - -,-, -- - , .. -••-. . .:-... . .- ; ,,. _-T. ; •titeot.antic:hienng.355Gi iluistagrnititnetlienoll intsthree:Nbdh:ehonhi:adatrril;fna:ngtne:fi nsta:natiervf1:6 .: :11.4".'- .:''.!'-:.1:v:1.: .-?-1--- :7:: :: -'.-:-'1':'-', 1.-31 at -,-_ .. I: - ---' ' . -'- ' 7--- r- 7 -L.---,to Additional institutions ciru!-" ;,.., t • t . - - ,,.-- - :... - . --: - _ • , - . ,. .....,, - .. • -. --- _ - - . - i ----2.,--- ..,,''''-:--1--'-'.:?,-..!:...i-,--.:--,.-....---1:::":-'"'-t'':;." 1 - _ - 'i . ---' .3,CF-- .. _ - '.' • :- --- - - - -'7.: - -, - . - • .• , - , .- . 4, . ...:.• -. : : .- - .....,•:.; , - • •: r :::• .; -.„ ' 4(/‘[.;:t.. ''--.- . •1-', -•. —'- '.:- •;;.•:..-. --;-, --,..,-- -'.:".---::.„.7.-•-,_I ---:.-'=",•.;' "., '----=-'- '.,-;`:::':-,-:-: ,-. 4,4-.„, -: -:---:-,. '•:'.-,„'.,-',,- .:•--:...--- ''.-,- : "I-"-,. -'--,1',.-.-. ,_-T-. ..7,4.:-. -,---- '''.''.----:-.:--;..-,.- _'--",...•..e:---,.' frt-.f.lo}4mt.... .1- ...s, -,-....? , „ - i : , —, ' - _=. ._. „,.• , . . , A28k7 : -1 4'717:---.3:-.''-:,...--";'-"_':;.-.. - i -'-- -' --_ .•.----,- -..:-..„'--..,-' ' -: ' -- _ - 7-,..-,' !,.•.-_-'. . ,•: '2-, ''"'”- . _,--;:.-''.. .'.'''-.1 3.--.:, '- -:,-,-,.-'-'.. -,„ • --;..r.". - -;-.-- • -,.--..-.:T,',-.'-'__''f;-:i'•--::,---f..''..'..17,pC',-:-.t.--,,,,,,-...--•1 ,-- • - -.,. ... - ;• --,'It' -'----,"-''. -.---,'-•.-- '- •,- - -:- :.-, ••---:• 2,,,-.--' -•-•. - .•- _;- - ;,, ,--..:- ;''- ---. .„ -,1,----.„,='''' ' --r• -- ' --'.--- ,-- t1A, PA,. . Ki_T-EV.Cr ' ?'';'1.g'95-•1>i•Oril/G-A-G- :g•.,;_.,k1 -'" -„(,- -- -•-‘• .K0 .12.E.P_EQ. -MAP:OF- 4-Cr.-17\417•:•-P'"''''-'"'-----------=- ' • ' '----... 01/455,11:41 c;-70_,71. e,-.0VIKIER- --t4P--.--%-';;-:•'- --z.:,;▪•-'-':, '-e-'-- •-..,... ...__•.•:.-. . -- ,#,„iikt?. $-T-i\Tes..!!,Ft.fiE2a lq-rt-Je'suFt- co, CL2PIC. ,,,.. „ - _,._ ...„....-4:.,:-....-. . _. • .• - 1- , . • . '-citjA2ANITEED:To-,Ftpt Lt- Y--::NAIORACTAILE;Iti,151)0V-51.-rc-Eq -,.... .. , --- .•..,._ .....,.- • ---„,..„, --• ---,-•-,---oFFK.4: .14r. MAP-L-z,,,,k,-275.-- •:-..,... ._- ... . .=,.•. ,,.. • , _, . ••• , • ,- ,_ 7.,...;_••..-_-•;-,:_fi4--,t'5uFR:',02-:,Int--F:etew.r.vs-rA,-,i.:rcco,,,57..-.........:_74._‘•-•.. _,-,.. --..---,,-;;•.---- • - --.---- •-. -7 ' 5'4 -''''' ' ''' 4. . ' , ' -'1Z..1 . 1" ''' --F"ftd-1 '''..'e-0-':• .":::.1.?:':'''-1-^i..2=2,1'''!..' . •:;--,,.--',..?s;.3,'%:,:::"., :,^',':•%•-.,,16'.4"",,;",,-.2',. !.‘s-ui^•';',..:-.4'-.... ..‘i;. ',:q..!! --.-.-..-...:t.',-. ',:'',. 'Z'),- Z •' '. :-'"'F'. ,.;.-' ('--: ;--' :i-' '-7-''- ' '' -i•-... ",,,-- '--.."-' -!-.- -- - - .'w:`. .'V00-- .. ,` „.' .7-... - ,, ...' ,---'--Crnii..--3 -- .::•,--,'----:14h .12'.' ..-11 •:"-',,,„l'-' .:3-12Aiiieit. i ---L'•!f-'''7- . '..'T.----'•:';, .-•'-'.7.-1.1 k•-- .:,;;=-:-' - i.-,••%.•.., -, - ',. ."-.--:- ttniee., 4-41-' .* .-- '---".-- ..,:re. =.5.r,jraVEYEI.??....ttit.•NN-•=r-•-4.("ti 4 ,•'.'"'"''''-''''''''''''''''''.-''''-'-.`” -A- .-'''.'''.: '...','" •-.I.;- '-';'; . -_.---'..:-.1.-r '.1:-r.- ...:-`t--:S•' ',A- ..•-•,"'..---.--- ,..,.1.:'•: :k 1,i',-r L:.`'-'''':.:;-:-.:'%'"'..." ''.....'--_,,:;,...'5..;;E::,;:i4-f,;c5i,1",'At..0:I4:::i',•i -•:4 2..L.:AZi_-,-,- n--*' ,--...,..A,OrtrUP.1,.."", L.- ' lattr/ART- ,, . , etE3-1cMerk . . iir;- '-r-2--05)-'.!--•c':"-- -- -'z---' -- -.::-,-,..."',....e.',.... --.-- •-•'' -•--- -.., , -,---.--,-- -- '-' ,e-''4`,-:." . -:>-.. . ...!t= - --"""""". ,-.'.3_,'-`,---.•----...',,./,e..--..........-----1-'_.------,---....ts.)._t ;14-4 .: ' .,...,,,-,,,...,,,,•• •- c....d?4,..,...ff•-'•----,-- ...--"'Kr.a..0.---",',..t4-5-;q7,-"'-'-,,:.z,-.i".7-..-'-...:k'';. -.•-•."..".":-'%-f-',„;-74 71.:3:,-- - .-.',:._A---1•-',••'--...,-,...1,--;',-.,1-..'f'...4?- --,..;;Fr i______— -• , - '4'rt.11.. ^ , ,:lx.,-;•;:•,-....;:;..,',-.4:;`;''''....4,'F''''''',7t•-:.▪ ----;• _,;‘..°:... NT.A=1,..k.......0...‘0-44-:=-:_AZ, 4, , , .-`,-.1:*1-4,4,t,-,,,r:::.„':;-•!.-2-,-;s5.*T..77-"- ..7.•:2;:,1-- .,......;.:f-.,; A .:„.;-; -- ,,,,--,•k ;-",- --v,..5',1........;;L.,, ...f....._..„:.:-.• ... .,_...:.- ••..t..-.:'7.,,,,,,,:::,____ _.,..z.,...._,,.-,,,......-.:m ,_,:,... ,• . Z.I,C---...,,,r.,--,,-.--.:1-,..., .i.-•<-i-,-;- ,I-.,;..,1.'{S.'r-y'•17-=.---'1'=-..i.'j.. ..?-r,`---'=-7-1W-1.7c:/ e. "-t;t•:-.1:-(i.nr--;f:',.-a`,P.14-:14,'.':::';V.1"';itY- r--- :.1^---;.=-1:--";;;-:-(•;''''‘';:'-'1''-'-i•-'.;:7"- fi432-1-1'r4. ^i:C"‘s• -c,-P--c-',26";--,i.,v---",•::-.;,,'..--- ,..--::1.-,•:.:.:,:pbf-1,.':-:.,:,:',74,4;-...t;_zz_.._:,--,4,?:,.:-=-,J,•-,,,-1.-.':.4,,..4-...1,...i:;-..2?-,,..--.`'-',i(-,:'-'-'-1----•--5.z-.',-,..,.•:-,;;:,, ....---,•: .1-.--,,--.::-.-_•.-e.-f-dR.,s.-7, -,--5.,,,,,j-i..--7.3.„.-K.,.,,:-,::0-4„,,,,--,,,;,-,,,,r,-;.-,..-_..•-::,_:.....,t--.: -,-,,,--,-,..;,..:-.•<--z-..,-,..,----.,...,:-.- .-..-•------...-7-7:::4-.----_-.,--r c:•••-:.-,...,,,i•-....,•:.-..:•• -• ::::-.V.,‘11--Vi.,-.1;...4:-=:',4,4-....`,t'<.5.:.;..-,.. z-1.--0-r--z,a,,,,-.4:1:;._-,--;,-v-:::,!:-_,-.--.4,........-.2.---...-..1--?--p..--,:i•-•7_,„;,•,-...,,s,,;Ti!-.4,k•,-- --;,----,A(k-1....,.:-.^,..-7-,c-,,--...--,,,- . .-- . . ,-•-_-•, • '!' .• 71 ,•1 , J : ,,t,4.' ,:,., •• 4 •• •••— •, '-4—'i�•.^!',?•47- t •r C••, _, ` ,,.,' ..•�,+r....' .°f,f'•� -t''+^i):^',ir 'l.aG - �'�T 1'r S •1 r 1 „ . • • ///��. ' .� N , • IA:. .0 ] 7-�..n•..+ -.-�.-r••-+r....4444 , • • • 58 • 4 1. -...L�„•. .-+-.rw. - 2.-.-0,,-.......-„.0, ..,...---_,,,.... :,.... 2,—,7,---7-4--., • •1•" ` • Q ;••,:r.,'' .2•' ''c' "j- '-: _.1 .! OW:FGA.; ' , q e.•{ , , • • •} , d c,,,.•„ ' ,pq -' . „ `-,A. r . ,. P4H', ;I .`5i 4Av�l It ; • • 4444 • -. �'' ,�, r A,.Z'..+..�I -.� 4444-w •-•-_ -...,•..... • A , • „• , ,'.9 • ' ', -5:58°58y 3O\iJ , "I 16.9,5",-.1 • • . „'�'' , ''f' 1 IJ , . , , r ' /,,fir�j ''"' • :NOTES) :`' " , , 1 _ A• ' - ` .�-/�- ,',. ' ��''((. ' _., +••p�ry},.'• 'tZ�„ ,-��'jj. ,l�� ,y� ,. •. �u,.S• •��", ,qi+ •+ 't ,.r... a I - , - , ,�°'{i {V�,.v, c- +�-,.�.,f-.:-:- ../-°�..0 f�, v.;*.-.••.�.y---j-»/-•�+ �{R-...-5,=�I�oz1p'.+r- 4-lrr 1, •'j,, 4.S,I itaplisk . `, Fl,1. 1c P...14.'�?oFv1v..e•.,_rt,,i1"I. ;SS -}T3+IFD, 4i ..t I ' 1• .........,,,•,...-.............4••••••-•-r•-•-•,,,-S «44'44.--;4+r-m, ,+ ',' �r '_ 4'' ' 2 5uFF;q :. -' ATA'ltt ?,", 51'41 .-4 . : *4.'Oa:f- .l' .•; " , - • . '}- .o1,A, „r. "•' J } r. :�...�.-..•r-4,444---.....�.,....1 - 'x,• +,• < ,. ,y5, .d • ,."r' , 'aU*,i • .� ,.S�,' X""6 •_ ,',.z." :'•"-i, E ," +,!,. ' ,;:-�•�--.r• •=----•:.•a..c.2...r -. ...-r'.4•' ^a .i,^�•'r.1.� 'li', •_i, ' , rrl �1. ' - • ° •.' ', ! V ,r ''• • ` i ,.. ' fiCP'''• i4.ia+, "'l•r�rd�a,,,fa44,.., ..;1.�'" ,;+' '}*'•.'.rr"1,-_,..!..1t ";zc.ljy."r'.5,; •}- ..! l • , '' '' ` . •, i ,.,i=. ,ps.,,,'1'p,i. 1."° ', ''''.-,,:4t1;5“!,',„ a -,•'4,‘",3"0'‘',-01- 45, Le , j.' ,_: ! . , _ -'rt, . Ae''''41 - rr. . • i '"� 1.%.••,41,a' .1:12,t.•$i4'''+'Is"',•v -rr •,a an=11.1-qfr±`,ay'". ' ,', ,,•'1',,,;-;.4;;:•:,',,,,,ii}'"• •• •` q . y-l., .I.y -r,-S'd' Xl'PF:yi}.(�'.$ �4SK? 'tt,:,,1•dvr ° ' ,'r,-„;a5 -{,}C,;� '.t;�V=: -r'', ,,...,;,'•` ;f•f • _ ea,;'•„' � X^i'- cJL.J,}ai„,,F;},4y"� ,:4Xyr, i'ti''1lai', ' ,';'°y t'rN r.,'•a,' ;'. _ ,'fy - . ilr4y + , > ?+4h4t>r ;+ yi "+ yy -yt ; , ,1: , 'n,"s = . `il ,i!" :t , - j•'- „ : .Y•' r44;,'. pr:.4�.,(.''; " 4,,.' 7.i,`r•. % r :r1a;; iz`iiwe :..:h,,tCX�-a?yp.'- �: ,` r', 04 r:,„, .1,r.,...;o` .•4rld`t%;. . ;e : l:-a.; - . --"'-y »-p`^-" 4s... „ .:++,r•r:�• -1* - • • • '' '' 7•;1"6Mi,, * '°y',.1� :;az;,k:.:;- 'i, .t_t c; r } .4t' '• ,y , i ' . t' ..' ;. ,...±.....2...., .A; : t - ,. • 1 - •.....w.....ew.......w..••••• .+s••aa•+•w1rorrose. •^^^'^•••••*•aV••....,.>wn.saww.••.r•wwnmw...... • • • N 5'8..Sif ;I3 o a , 1J S. 95 (5:7) . V , 1 \ dt/!'7t(it BN / $ Y4u6 1 0 r.j1 . Q w - .5--- - - --._- - —5— --- - o — - ft ty C NA a•--36.81r4.1 ,�, �— a , • f —'st' i_iits 56► L.,,,,,,r_F--- . 1 ,.. ______ . C? - i55) Q em p :-.5"8-'30."14t, ._.{� --.i. . i 6,5$. 58.3C? W - ./15. 95 • �. . - � . Q 5 . , . „ , i I • a . , .. t • . , „/71,, ,,,ify..4.73-- . 1 , ., . . , , . , • liOpt. . . 8 . ! t . , 2.,0 C.4.1,6 r cauer /3 Y4-eht) ... ,- 5 . . _ . .."-1-44A"ilile—e- -. • --•• --,- -- • ••,-,n, - -:- •-I..- •J—- ••,,• -- --g••-• .•• - Nsoi----•,''s-s---''•:_i•z--;-; -'"AsT.,,:.-' ,., , . • •_ ., .- ....,_.--t,-. ,,c. ,,..s ..,,, ,. ......, ....,„ ...e e,.,. yk.,...,S.:9-, e ee, - T.-• r•Tra.nr.zirri..„.„ 7-..„:„_,_t_,W,77?-_,„: 1&,-. ..i.,-.:T,•,,,fe',,,,f,.•;,-S_ .7e.••- ni. ,!.,..r.,..4-,.,...C..„4,3••••-4,1,-.17•••• ....4, .- "-_-'4,•,,!,-` L•-.,4.,:t-•-•'"le'-,-,-J•, ".--1V--4-.;.:',.---.,P-..-..a.;.;'1St)a-.'"•.1---,,I...•-•.,-.1.;-,',"-''''1.----•••••10‘.^3.•,'"' ---.•,..it,',,,••••••-1,21'-2.7.',. ,'p„,••-,:jt•.:? 1-. ,4i....,,, ,......s..?:.......,..„. ..:-,,j4„,,..z.,...j.,.....A,..e,c..,,,,,,,,, „..7.4.,„...0,1„.„,,,f;-14 ),...4....,..,..,.:51.. ..,..4..„,..,., - .,.. fl„al et--,.,,,.,,V. --mt,.:,•,.,:..'" • --.,- -. -;..p.,,...,;;;e,,-;<-;,..„2..-S.-7-7 -.?-• ,1 f...; ,1.-;•,-',....-i-•-.7-‘41,•--4- ... v••-:• 4.• •-•.`-',,,,.,41c,..1. , ' .4,,,,,r,=.-, „-).,;-::,-'.,-,t E•••_,),--,,-,--.1, ,','&-"..c•-_,-N-e,-;-., f' i`-2-:-,,,',..-,,:,Z,:•,.;-,,..1,-',.;;-,;•:..,',-,.;..-.t1.r-;'.7.:`-.;-4.,:,...•-7. '''....;.`-?..1,.1./...-,-1.--_.",•47...1:;'. ..!......,t, ‘;.-/,‘,.4.,.J'e•-": -,:,:,:44,,f,;(7._-',4A'.,':.:••il,'_'•..-.k:,-:„•.,;',:vT•;7 t',..;:."..,-',..l..f.....c'./'n? • ....a ,...U,,'r z•-,,,,. .....,-. 1,k A,,,,:.#1,,,<;:,,,1-•.;:::, 1.-0,y1- '...7,..-:,:.•!...;.1-_---7..:_`:`._.,S_.: : .,..•I- _:"....2.r,„!:,!.,,,:...r.:,..,..„ .,...i.„,,,, .,,,-,-.,--......_ 1-_,,.......,.::Tx..;..,:.);i:÷,:.,,..4,,,_71c:Aw ..?,_.egyrr.•*fit..A.A}44A7..:%.,,,,,,tc,!..e.,1,7,,,,..,,,r..•••.-f.;".•-•,..;:`...-::!:::,•,;;;';-,..;`,,.?:_,;:,i.:_,C•,,,i-7.'....,/,,' t.e.., s.'t+i,',.,r,:3 i "21;,t'r•---1V171:.7-A-L•f4.4!C::'--:- "''''','':::1":(...1.,:-‘ i.2.V.:f..4..- ' .... ••• l':te,;.-.' .1,-- .-, e,•:z",-,.:•-IV `-9-".4.-t',Z..:',";.- •n•- .7--2',..ikrir!..7 " .„-:"•, !..:"---:',,.,,-.-V....-.4-•••;-„:•••:-. 4,-. .,a,P. -:-•:• ,./4,3,:Vaa a',•.",..-•,•;•c:':'-'•••!41.-,;-,I1.1 -,?,:4",?.. ci.,,tr-t-l' -‘.4-,i rfr'liz`4,!--,z.,'••.'.'.'•_.4-,./ ..-;.: _:_-,',4,-4 _:,_-_..f- -.14,•••-f:,-;, .;.-.3-2.-,.-, ... ,,ki",:i...-:-.,,,',..--!•,.; -...,-.s,•',%.-•-: -'-'.;•'''..7.-." --.-'L'',''''.:-.:'-.1.:-.:;•,••';..-.:-.--‘.::,....-.;.':.-''•1•7.n.:.:'-'fL;'''V--"..ea'i--......-1.2-V'1-4'71--::.;-1: s 2..."-C-:--'-';'..‹.--,-'--7-''..7-''''f z's,'--4";-'4"'•,;,!:.-"..- 's•';'-7i---'i,- :'•1)'-'',-.,1115.' -,:s''.•Fli;-"••"'':- vz,--• --i,:'s-';, •:-....: •" •%•-• ';`'..‘"?--'=-1 . --, ',:.'-'.-;,;.:-..-:i'--- r---s$4:, ,- '"-;-%-.F..1 V.-.%, •--:-•:::1_4•'.:-:;,:-.-1-4-,-;,•-•','-7,-,stjp_•_-.VW.,tkV..„. ,Q,K7.:1'll.o:,4-1. ,•,;,...4:_-_z,-.. !-%_-'--re.::•!.-..t,,,s,,,:;.-.-_-•:__,'I:t-,s.,::t.,: ..,.:::,,, .;.,...'4".e,:ii.,. '1,'.15'-., -tir4,-, '-''• 9',...,-z->4-•'',2:s f'..-,•._-,-1.,-2 ,-..:_Q- s •--: ..o.i..,•-•-;•- ---.-. : s,-..,,s.• -• '-es--, --z•-,..-- :-= .--:.4, -- -.:., •-,-..,,-r-,-,-4/-7.,,-.'-o-.-1,4-.-.-,,::..':-.;,.41214.--,-c.44"•!,..;-,-;.';`.-1.3••:',:e::.-,"..s.,,,,,--4-.'•'2:-....-_,.;:3,_._., ; •• _,,.,,e:--,:.••• _......, ,.'3 .•f.,.- ;.,,;14..,•,-, ;„7?"-..t.‘‘..;'''','.:7",-..._:;if,:.e•• .,_-4.'%- - •-4,- :1'..? 4• .: '-'7.!:.: 4'--; A'-,••••".••.-,A-.4",-1,Lzi-'.$-.',:•-$, -:.:-• '-'•,:."-- '1::,,,'7:Et--,,"`.t.',ct.fri.,-•-•".• -•;-".:'-':'---:•:--1`!,..,-...'s.7.-"J'e,....7.'"S.).1. VY;-'1-.'"s _- ,,A - .-,,,,...:.,-,- .., ..,,_, ,,•,..., -,-.7.• :„- , , .: -"; P'-',- •'.2‘,...-••4• ••••4:••"2 ,0,;•-•.,•2 •_- „ ,1.='•-': . ...0.,,-:“7 --•:atittipLt Pdf.?a...-dole,,,Lri-i ,;_s-. . t'a'.,T-t,..•.....il..• ..e. :- •-,-., .,::::•A,cr.,:i.4,,...:.••,t•-•6 2 „ta,,,,,i1.7.;•,...1 ,..t `... -7''---';•-v1"'r 7;.-'4,7;----:•‘-:".-- "••• s, 4- •a••.--?, '•• -.. s-."•'".".'..r. -,•-S." ‘•-"•••:-f.1.•-•'t `'.7.-f.?fiai•••,•••-•':-.-.•-•'••'--•It• Se.'rkt....jf,,`- ft,5•.-.-rf2tfro".'‘.3..1‘11.73•••••: ---,Sill;••:•••kI. :‘,-...,,a'_•,,,%11.!;,..,r:„t.,:ff,.41;--4,,::•!;,:-...:,'LL,-,:t....s.-:',7":',..-2,...-14:,--;-14-W,a-,a,i-4-7':„Z±:.• ..,,.......ys: j.L.taici ,,,,,;:f., :-.I,I.P.:"...,:gasV,;,,,,,.„ , •'• }c ..5_, . ..„ .E.,..a.:,,-.at_.:::, ',..- •-..:::•-Pal.a,„:: ,, ,,_-" •,_,.-,-.,„."1,.......- ....!......,....;i...,_.-,-,,-,-,..1,',..,.;.,-;-....:,..,•___,.-0;,".;27.:, -.:,,,.- :"?'„,„...,„:.:,,b.!„-,f;,...k:iu,.;.'..-1',.;';',_;"--..ip.;:=-,,••,-,:.......--=..,,-..1,f,s,.:...f,-----•,•-.--,.-4.,!.•-.',-.:A:*1..-t,..----..e:‘,5•1:-...- ..,4:'.?-..'"P'7., .,...z.v.:',..;:72,..),,..I.;J•;_l•1.:4.-4.4--„...,,.._.._;,_,. ,_-_._.;_ ..4; :f-..:.,..4 • ,,,,.5•,-.,,;i'.,_-,'-'4'- i-..,.. 2'..3:•,,,I,_.!...;..._"; ^ '"-.-1._^I:••,,--7..-.:- -Z,r-"1,•.1:-...1 -A--:-..,---,`,,,YAV.:7-:2tr,‘"'-•-.,. : :2-..`••"••• ‘,•:','-C'"1:1.--- "-'- -.'''-;.'%.•.-':".....a.--;!--';:-- _.‘i•'•.‘,:- .-'71;‘,.-4‘.4:6-:.-7,'•: ',71,"...:j ',--,r.1-='•''"•i C.l'.1-'-'-''1"‘''''''• •-•.''-t--- --:-' • '': ‘,4.1',-e--. , .r. :-. 1:-- -4,- '-T', r''.::•,-- ' ."r:1.'l'- . ."-:-11,l'-c' -.g•S"•-':1 - -''' •s.'-:,`••:.'- 1.-1?-."'''-‘., f J,-,.-...-''''',.' '.....,:..:-.f_‘--',4,--,'•:-,'T. r"..,! .z-•,-t•-.,„;:• -.,1'.. "::',-- .„-:•"--.',-. .;""'S,-4,,::'-,;.1.4.--,..1--• .f.::-t'-:'-_, -.5.'-z ••,0•17-4-±--.•-,,'-:'•---" -7, 4.1•.'e, , fe :,.." y ':.. ,...,.,L :: ..". •/,--;". .., --."-• •f.-..;-, •,,,-;-c•1-,..-,f,.,ae- ‘. sr ,-.144;;ApatottA.,:,.z.l.:,.,.,,,..--- f..,•-_,,,,A.,-,,..,:,,,-.....,,.,;_ .....:-., ..,.,- ,_,f,,._ti,.,-..oridditio,i,,,t_,-: .- ,-......._,;:.„?..,i,,...„ „..„. _-,,4.„-:,---x Jr„-.,....:.,.: •,,_ ', -.,..f,.::„.., ..,-',-, : --,t '-"1.-zr- ':.----,- •.7:-• . -,,-',21:4•••:-...f,,'. ---L-, • --: ,-',if• -2-' '; "e , ."-,•,'.>r 7"' -."..." ' i .•''''-';''. -arf.:%.3110,itht•trt_i al ..„.,c1, .. ._ ,,..„,z!z- ,.. ,•,_-, ',•---- -^ . -'''• -,q--. -,, -- - - -IT-' !-- -- '',,-'1,- -.---'-••-•-•-'--- ----‘' ,`...-•-; -.' ---"''-- "-'-1 e -''-'---',----:.; •''-‘--.1•,....'''"'-',.':;-,-••e• ,','Z'-',;A:to this survey is -,-,-:::::: .••••24:Ff.-.--4-',•‘-'-':-,,,,;(:)•.'"x' '.7.;--- ,..,-..----•-_ .r.:_,-..„-,_. -: - - --- • ,• • -- ,..•,. --•• - , - .• • , . - -. , .•.:• .....,--. .•. ..-- ,----:- ...6"... .,.-.;•-• •Th.' .•:sr...-........:- ; _;,:: -r. ,.. --,...:; , ----- -.,, .. ..-...t..-- ..4,-, (....i.... ..f...er..: -...,--.list .ti...!,t_ ,.--- ,.•-:,----'.- -- 120o •the riey Yorg'Stallf;_*•,`r• .,:.Y.--,...;.t..:::-:•-',.--,V"-r I-.z:::',.......1-:',4-Ct.fv.'•,‘"•:--.'•-•-i_;-,•,-•-•-•,7.7.f..i..._a•k .-.c..,...:,;-.-:.•--.:''•,,,,--_-,P'.7_f.... ,;c r,-,..:"ait•,fl'' f-'-'-..-;,•-• - ----..‘ .-,-,''• a,----r WN.'1.-, :O.F.,:,.. C),„ii.t-triw.... •_ .,,.••,. -.•.•,---<`•*--2-..•: s",c "--Sectac'n -i• -.7 ...„1,--.-„.„2-_,-.•••(,;•-;=.-..--. 7--,-_-•-•.-,:,,-i!,---;.-:-.4.-.Fc''.•._ -_-•:', '- •• --•- t -•-•-•_.--,r -.2, ' ''":':"---r, ;-, " - - - - - ., ,... .1.“-,i '' •-••••,. z. .` '-":-.. •--.,-: ,•.-1- <..,••'..,..-4. Education -,•.4-,24:/::,'rzf....zr;‘,,,,,•',4;`; ..,:4,;,-.C.,..--4,---%---4:- -..4, -•:.-,,,„-- ,-' • -,f•-'_•,.•7--LI' ' '••••-: -.,' '-' ..1 4 "." • -• ' -,• 4.'4 '•; .-•• • . `-, ..,.. ., t_ 5,-,.i.,. . •,copies. ,.,,curverf.rm, ...4-,,:;.!- • __••••••-•:,•-, ..-.,.•-,,-,-4,, :.• c.-„•,•o-.'..1-,.-•-, -,--4,.'/ - :•••• ' -4-• --•‘• --:-- ' •- ' -•-- -•z---••- " ' •.--' --•• .,''• , -:--''''-'-',-;-' -)--- ••' •"7---'45' i,-.(---:,:••-•:---7:-AIL--, , lAisct /P'60'es inicedieeiat ce;',-:•:,-,':. -5,-..,.•-...-t' •-: '"„ "..-•_•,.12,i•,•.-••••-• 7 • , l',- .,..-4 ,t1„,.. -t_ •,-.,:._1: ,si: -.."..•-•••. : --.-. . -,„ r. •• ••..:- - - • •- ..•• - c."-.= ,..- •.-t .......•-.',.'.s...' :.•1-•"-• •-4n:-.••='4/•.?•••*1-• then -- i. • • • • • '•'' ' fi.:••' 's 7'4'' '' 's';'7'-'11"1'--qS".'-'"-• ..-:-:....'.. if r••:.' I':• t--,,,‘79'Cre :'%••;:- -''' •::•..' ,‘•••`--• .',;-- •••,-)--'••--' •••.-_-s,"‹.•,..)--,..,;7.:1 --.:".i'•• :.•71. ;7,1-'=',:,•• • ,•.• ±-••••'•' '•'•-•,,,Z.;r n'••••,.••••••' 241'7 embess.; ssai_shatknollr,conen.fersd, ,7 3: ,i„,•••:;;,•=i,..._:,-.. •X,-,„-,...4,,,_•,•41"i„..•.--•.,, ,"•.- ...... -•...-.,...".-111,,e— ••.';", IL,-.,.....".-..:--.,K,-4 - -: •,,-._..,,,, _....,,„4,. !_, ,,.....,•,:", iy-.4.-,-• ,- -4:1i-1'.:- :, ..;...,_••• -1'; ,,.,--1-' -1- ,'... : .1.---:..-1.. •-•‘!„-... ,10 be.if-iidtrue copy.. ...r.;,-Ifi,.,:-.-;.1!.,`i:0,..:..t.:,,L,; , -----',. • ..:: '.: .,- •.--,1 .:•,';-1-••:.--,:•- -,1:;'•",..'.- : :',.':;-71--= ‘..1 finik.litaali;ietilliNil,TEL112‘I'' ' ',...----•''.- ' .4.; .•.7•:- ' :,-:- • 14.t.,:- - •, • •-• -, • Ai_-• 4,• .-.,-••-,.• . • - •-•: .---•---. 7/kit...k - -•••• , _ - . ' -'NJ .'- 4 „.":......-, • ,'1:.•••i'••,.. ..,-::.'••• ...,'-.i:-.C,'•-:••••• ...••: ,•: ', ..eV.the pnesiiii.fciewrici-n1 0'6 okrytn__ ! • • s .,.,-,• •.,.._• .: 7 .. ,-. - ,•. .,... •• • ,._ is epared;and on_hig tislialf to ttn----,7".-•; ••,• •- , ..•'--- , - ,..-•.'.•-•• ' ••'-`: '•:.3,--,i `-••••'---. :-_,.-'-•,-, a- _e•*. stzit,.. 4; ▪ „-- „-•,,_.. -- . 2 A ''. . --''' di? c anY goyenimEintal 2gen:.!aild-, , .... _ 1..--, _, ,,.-.,. • -...'.., ", : .. ,. ' ':-' foir--4"- -' -. *.0...- -.;,.'" 1- -fo-,,_. • - - *N-A4i.-4i. •-,. •-" ' ' - i _ . , ., ,,,* .. t„. ,......., _ ..,..,_ _. :. r.ridifig institeuteisonotith,stel,..die„.h_rideriecriiipr•nasipt.'.....,:::,.c..„. :11'-- :' .17'-‘. ...0 0. - . ' --': ' '11 Cr,' .-. ,'' - ' '•-• . •-' ge „' I.,.,.. • -,_ ,. '•.• -,..4 . ' ,., ,,..,...,-:„ . .,.., -.,...,1,,, s ?. ., , , . , • ci-t.he Assign , _ ., _. _ ...-..,,,,, •.;:,7 ' •, '1 -,•%•;,,-.,..S '• -rt • - ,.._ :. .''' ' -..v.-• " ,. ,- •:'7',. - 9-'')/: '7 - -- • ••••••••• •-•'•-'• i l'-",„,1---; .',';'•! •'-' •., - ' i: •: •'-' -:' - • : ; . .- •-. 0•,'„'•,, : "--, _,,,• ......:- .. • •••• •--, ,• _.: _ ,,., ..,_ ....., `,-,--•- •tutto alcdn;it?ourq.;t:titut:F73..,p;,otar..,traujart:f.eralliie4F:_litii.u::::::: • - •• • • • • t- ,........ , • ' --," •• ---: • • •..-cr • - . • . - - t-I.: '-- ••-•- • -',•-,L.,.• --',. t.-- --- •, "--,,,,--:....-,-,'.-t-, -s•I''''r*F,-(-`1,“A ,-1 -= V.-""'4-- ‘-_, -• , -ttd.: -•••......s.--74"1Ni-ft,- • ,,•-'?,• ----- - -,,, 'i.,',4i,l•-• , -- _ • ' • -• • --, : .: i - ,- •• - . -,•_, __, •, --.• '7'4., _-_,,--t. 4,,,, . . , •• , --,—'• .•' -.-•.-, ---.1-4?-• ":;`-' ,•••• - 1 -,',..- 4f.i•-'-''-t-,'2-',.,.'-',-,:.'' •'-':-..-;--L-V..,'''••,•-:%-,`}i:1-W.--:', ..1,- . ._ !.., ,.- • ...:-, . ",i. '2,.4,....,,..-:- .,..• t rt••• L'' - _I;..-.,„,,,',„•!.._,'..•_ -r•'.-'',.4:,-4,'.'_r-.:!..t',7g:S;‘,,-.;2f.,••t. •I : -••• ,:.'t!'',T. - j`..e,:...°,1 ",';`...-,eF: :'--•'.: ' —-- -,-.,::-1._-_ :;'''' ',.:`?. ' •••''. - - • -,: ' -..--...,.,. iv ,---- el'._ '' -c - •*'"..‘- • --f,'., .. """::a s., --',‘"'- '.-)••"' -'''f'Z-•.'' ''' .• -• "Z..•7';' 1 ,....,..., , :_.„5,. „,,..„. .in „,..t,,. 4 .... :.:,- ., ...km:. _-,,...._............:_.,,,,....- , -...,,,,..,--•...‘,..,-...7,..l'7.-.,.,...,,,,, r........:-... ., ,...-... ......,......„....t : ,... A......,.-,. =.74:1.-.7.:,:,..,...%6.-..,:',...„,.........-,,,,..,..‘;Lt..t.i..%;...1.1,...,,,,:.,..i.ire..,.??._74,.....>t,../.1 , --...;:.•,"!...,,•. 's .'2.'.' : . ''''"'3"“'..- :- ' '-: *' '- 2 .' ..3.,"-- *.'-.7 f•-.',.: ,•• 2.'•'•.,.. ::" ,,•-, ' •-k %;-:,•-• .,$:_4,7,41,,•,.. '. •• ' '.' ':', n" ,:- " •-• ••• :. ni,':.,...-','•.-r1-,,...,-- •• 11'. „.„...,.:-....:••••/,'.,1- M- 'Ir"._....1,tip...--4.71Viii. ..4111,-.*".4.4'1,-.. .,,;,?!..s1/2-...?4.2::=:.,•, - • 1 . ',..„."•':::-A ?- !,' ,', A.1,1. .•-e..-' .--,,i,--1• .1.• ---.:•• •''''_ '. '1- :• ,-..- '. ,.• .:'' ,' - 0, -:. -" -7-'ke`.;, . ' r!' : i..,,...,,,,--,.,-L, -...,, --.,..,,,p._ ,...,•et,24.;^$-...•,11-1-,3''','-'-,..A.7,,a-7. ,-%71"' -.., .. • + ----. • ,"".' ---•-..*- - • , • 4111r#7.1;'•6.41,tt.11ree*::--,C:r4; -41_,:-'4'-'i- ,_•,,,,,,,;,,i',,,4, :.•..ft_A • •-Pt. _-.'--f ,-.) •-,, _ ,-.---,...., .'c.-:,': :'-7-- --. • ,•.•-,,- •;-„ei.-e - •:-:,' .- -., .,1-+ _,•• -•,,, •-r„- s.if-•--.,-.-.•- ,,,n-:..-1,4.-.•, 1.-- • -;•-r. - ---r.,•‘:,, , ,„ 1,-, .44.,y 4-u ,--tc,z-Lf.:•?-?r•/‘;',,-?4.-41,-4-•-t.' . `47. %ilk ..! -.._ -....- ;--`....,•;'1".:L...1.1,%z.. ..:.•=4;•:•,- ••.-;7 1- 4 '..• •-•z:.:,..,.7,,,,f1.,.:.-r,..,:;-...;,,,-,;::;1-,..,..!,,_-•;.,,,..-„t,ti,,,,44„:1-t.,!.). ,. .._, - --. - .- • N - '.5•...- ,-..,"-,4• '-' ' " • •.'",.. 7 .1i: • "•-.'. -,'--••••••.-•., '4.:.---774,-4.T•cr...1',„•1;1"-"!::•04-7,21::.• • - -••••' '-'- 7 ' :::-• - :- • -:,,,,!--1 • - -.,%.•-..•• .- -4"'. ... ' --'-J. .' •r''-";• •- - .-:-..-...--...V---, ',A, P‘•-1, :I.,,...,..,•1,..:,,..--. :-----4 i...,, •',- !'•--- ;•:'- : -:-= ••"--..'-ec-,"--•‘‘-•.--'e,---.,';', -;,-x••••7,r'`,4_,..."3„.•_;:a,;•;:f-,„ic.,,,,,,,i„ - ''. - '4 'r-'•'--•''''' • tii:.4-a, . L...., :••-••i,'1.•'-ai...:• -.",--• .,-,, -: - c +--• ,:_,,s• I •,...%Ca,t/C3f411&-;• 4 1•••• '-'-./..`-- ',P••,-: '"-`:.-'4;.,.-.•• Y..-I'•-•r::;-'''. • :;:14'r- ",---'..-:‘'..,1:1--:-.C. -i.:::ai''';'4'•”''',•-e".71"L''-•-1-".',-fli'l-Ari-V,....k. (-':.a ;•.:. ...‘ -_,t-,. ,, --' • a, •-,.• 1,,,,;:,_- , .:a,,,,a_._.•!,•,, Ca,.. -'[.-,....t"• ,,....--,a •• -•• ,-.t:. - • - " ,fln:•_‘,,'--%•‘-'!. "i..,!.—..-1.-gi,•-.:'•,-,.,e,„ : -i.;:•;•.„•_•,,---•-,-`•=7„:,-,s;-.-,*•---_, ..•:•-" '•-r_''`;--N--,..;•,,,'-',-,-3-Vei•o4 r•-,•,„A„s;-i_2:' .--.-14.,:-,.:--_-"..;,_:7,•,•,,•!;:`.-,14,-,-..),•:_f__-,'s t.': ,."-. ..-;,`-k„ p•-",,•:_:- , •:_,,,..••„- .t,„.:•t-:„ '-z_r'.. -•:.i.:!-,..'t-„t•S',A-f_f.;•=_;_:-:-.7.7' r....-. :-- s4:--Z.""L„ tieK.1-- -1 -ic,l!:,!.',.%-.:,-?:..,,:',‘,,--:41'•"..?-al.....-,':%-' 7'..':;51--;:.-....3.:;•:• •,-'•-•;,Y•-'2•'4'fr.-....:%:%:--LT'in':,.:';t-4.-,-4 •-'1-1.17.n.7,-; 1'1'. - •,.-.."',0,-t.,,-i',;-:.:•.'.!--•••••.. ;'•'•-• • '1W-C -"'•.'7'4 '7 .,..'4..---'•--•‘•-,•.:`'''?,:-''''-:2,,.''-"'"-.,-.• j2,-.`n-t^:••,",'•' .. -.1'..--,f-•••---.-7 - ' •.':::- t 't '''. '.1-• : ...d. . Z''.: ' -4-..2-•-7%-:4.'-?..• ',ill'.-..,.....; ','-•-•‘• 5.;*---I;!,ut‘<"--' !'x:-_:•';'-'rC,-1','.7,'.o`,..-,,t,•:•;.-7,--:•,',3"•-•,!.,f,;-Z-,•.;;=.--,i'-g7:.,,rri;,t1±: ,--:.-"--..-'1- t-;..-:'1':. 'te,---'10 -,- ...._ --•,:-,,'___,q..--., •-.‘„,_, ----•,:,(,•.e...,. •,:.....e,.;,-*Kft,-_,,-;-: ..,-_.._._-_ ....::..,,,A••,- ',-r-.:1;..i 01.5,„ ,.--.-,.-.2,-.. '• ,-;•---,•_,:, : ,•••........---c:-.4,-;;-• ,,•-__•,•;_-;,..s--,--•-k_,..,;‘,-,•!-, „_t4,•-.-f:2,,:,.',;:,..4.-,_• .:23,..-_-_,r,:_tzr,,,re,„.....-;74.,, ,tisr..s.i.?„.., ':.,''!,s'',1'..."4')-""."---1".:::'..; €-.z...:.CC. ,,,.4.0,-;fr.:4- • .-,4."4.,' " ... -;',,_-'-....4'...„..▪1 ../',. .. -_,,i_or- ,v.,,4,-,- ,7.-•.:. ,... ?,-„....,',;• :-;...'cr • -.'. -., • '•:••• •-i,,' -::-..fictiiitti-•?.-;:pfeeri4o•- •troe•xtmg.k-*.f.tia._. -,.1,„„z'catTS:s.}k-'" ......,.... •,,,,,,,t.-. , J,,,,- , ,, •,.! • „,..- ---,-,,.., •...--,--,-,..,,.. 1 y -• ..- • .-L-1;'•-- "." if t- N : 4--- i -.,'-r r.:"--' i"::----:',''-r,,-.:-*:•- c i J t i''',.. -, -,... '-',''.1`::le_". -.^.---`•-• '-',r..';',,-t-.7 _' ,-,st4_ .v:-. :-'4',,,1• ,.5;14,--.i 4? ' ,---..-- ,::-%;.' ,...: 't ,--',': ''.:44--;-•-: ....,---.:, ;;..-::4,-,jf-•:--,:.,.,,r--,--4.•-.-, -•-...:-.;s=.• ,:.,-.-.4,.,„- ik,-,forii(GA:G4A.,zi. de...L•gs.. allakrrf:VAS„-,z_-.:•••:' ..4, .:.e. !,7%.;..‘,:.; :'p,,. g.'?.. '.',...i.jeji :1',';•--, - -"•.-',.- ;•• :'....t.';•.''':.' .,-1-:`-'. ,-‘e'•;•',77:::'• - e=:' .,-. '--..,,':..3?.'-'1 i.•••/••••,-I'-' 'bi-vif.., ,j-:::•'4'7:';4;stlt;_e-7.-`:' C.1,1.---'.z"'''',':6-r?---L.7._kt• .:- a.--...cp-,;04-wcv,w, utifrovwz-/ ft.,'17•,:e••'',‘,...r-,.,:N•,•.r--,!...'n•g:-•M., .:i•.1,''':,••-;,.•2..;*--.• •••."'••f .,i'•', : ' •'-,. :i.- '...'s••5-f-'.',•7-,Z•"ei7'7••••: :-1 ',.4•1'•..ri-.le- I- '''', ty- ,4-..,r r;• .-.Z %iv' C-...;,..-.:-••:', ,-,',e''-,,IS.44•4.,,,..,-Cr.0 I. -....-..e,. „,,,,....,,,, - -,)!..,•- v,,,,„....'p,...,. -,,,'• -.., .!•.:11,,,,,,-.)4,,,,... ......0,.,4 e..:... ..,Ct...„-f..... , , ...... ..s , • ...,..,!/,, • - ,• ' l',.••••-!,•'.'...:.,..• .=•.,•.- •"' ,' •••••'•, •4.'',= I Q.-it: 1'--,;-..'*-,•.e'..-•• ',..,'-'---.---f-,E.,--•7' '''..-11.--t•"•-•3'•‘••• "tr:-":,111:•••-•:.'''•Z-•' .''•-• -r'Ctifir"ttp0-,, ,.-•i-.- -c-,. .i-.,..-.,.i-c: i..--.1'..,-,.,_ ...-.1- - -.,.,,,_:',c:„„ .-,-, :.....--,_ •--:&,. -._ .._;.., 7,,,,-•- ,,,--,. -,7, -.-_-::: ;-,--,,:,.---....-%,"- .rit--: • g_"--....-, ,-,- -,,,-i._-,vottl4i,4•Lik C-.t. .--Ali,...sk•_•,', 4C"-s../P.•,, ,„,, ••••••„.t,,,,--••,....* .-6-•-''-'• q' ;*--- ---:-..'-."•-•',:.1'.'"-'-'''' Ct ‘ ''•-'" •••• '.'",=I :••r• •,:*; ,-' --- '-`' • .- '-' '- • -'••••'-- -.;.:- - z.•, .„..• •-;,,i IV" -?- -......`;',._?-•,,,4'..'i.,''-'';'?..;:,-;_, -' 2,.-:•.---.t- _•:e.'.-,,-;A's,,,z,,'--..-•,-".--',-,,cr?•-:.1-4",-w-'-::‘'-c,• =-Iliz-=':-?-•..s. -pt..-.:.'.4-......*-:,'•-. , o•.--',=.p.t,=;•:= ...- •,,,.. '7.-;-:'-'. •-f-- =.-‘. - e '",''.-"•-•-:•4 '--- ' , ,•-•iF"rt'-• \. ..,-.:-" :f.,-'-' rk,47.'...------ -:.'s_7";:,c,-.::-: •,;.'----.--,:--,,:•;-',...(e..--..;.,',,-,,,-1.-‘,,L.,',:‘•-e-,..-"';,--e.:::-.--,-.`_•:--;'--z---.)--;'..4'4;-0,::•7•"'"''''''s.--v.''''''''11' 1-.:7:t•:.•'4;' • ' '',•%.-';`''44'' 'i:'..i.: '''''': ‘,1.1'''' '';* rit.,1 --:';'-';::,.,‘,--:.a. ''z:•:-.).• :':•:`,:'''' J ',',---J "'V-P-- ''''r• •-,!„:• ',. . V-k-•..-',•;-,,,• ;CE.i.r--,r i•_.-,k .;-,-.,•-•.•:,t-.5-... .7:,..;:.,--tA-...,i,.- --r*,••.•,s,'-,4 .--.,-,-,,-;,ti..-.; "-•.-1,.•,/,' .1..q.:::'•-c-,';,''.1•:';':•,'a'1"-.,",ir-;:-'7.Ar2 "'".;;--..,-':-'1.'"i'i.,; -'t----I', -,-,eri-'-'-,--. "i 0,...• '1'.'.75'1:,,•i+."'.7.g-c' ;"'7-:1-7; ..r-....!''c 5'.L. .--•''t'5-•'.-5 '-, s' ---",-. '.-. ed1.-5-'11F-•--,';'.'5-'':':,-Z_-.P.'‘.1-.--'...'-- ,;',,,"'' ..'':?".•-- ':::',4.:.F--Sic;:t,-;',..- Y'i;',.":--.:t 5''''.11-..1.1?,114.7'7':$7,,'42 kciii.'+'::4.4...7"Y'-:' X'a'.72'-i..' -F.. i '.'''';‘.'-•, ''''.':; .--7.+:j.---".'?"-...-''i. ..."5.i...-.(-17.,''-':',-.?,•-'-....- ,".A... , : .:5-'T.:--:--;• •-.7 5.'---474`." :.5''' '-.--.15;'..i 2:- '•-•:- s-It-: tm- tj"--,,::--...'2,-.F.,- .--'. . e;'," As.,-;'7'.,,-•••=,,.2i_3_.7„.•,"17• ;',„7i4,...:::.;,‘,..;',r.i;,},1^,-"..-7:•;.,•":.V:2`.f",ira.:I.:V.5;'•.1-,.?,:,"'s".11-,!:,-;;.,„ .. •,?;.::...,:-,:?..".7%;"-,3. :••';,..:-.•*,•,••4`"4-'•' Ai, n a'=z,‘-••.rt• •i',..-`- ,;:l'-.,-,...0e:4,-kr,e-,..es,t,if,:isit ,-,,- -,,•,._ •,.• -,:-,. •.._. •0.4._),.-, 2.-L.,_,..,,,,-..,,,_•. ,,,,,,-.,--_......c.,,..:._-_.,•,.,..r„,....„_,..\_.,...-_-,,.-,..„-_,:.,-,y,,,:---r-r., •.,.--7,, •f.,,,.1,,..,-.. -:„-- 1;-:•.-: ) ,,,... .,_,,• ., ,:;-,„,::,,-, ... .-.i2, „- „.--2,., ...s'"'/•,, •1 - ', ••; . ...t- d- .... :--:-- .."•,. ,/,'.1., -, :••-. - • '..-a': '1•,-;,•-•4i.. ,' •-...-I'l...e:-v-'---- -'.;.-.c,,,. .?;--v.':-74‘',.PJ;-0"r--i'rt:i-:- :,`;',"•-''--r•'-'-'' -.1-"',-,.".-.•.;'! "r• - •. ',' -- , 0--'•___-- -,--,--- -4 ''' ''-— ""it' •" -7-c*----71----" --; '•;'-''' dr Z'+' t----•4 ••:- " • ';'=''- ..-2-- " - ':,--- •'','••;,. --':..T• ,-;al, 4:',...- .0 .,a`a. ,,• -,... ) ,--.`•',1',:-•=,&•.; '''''.. . •-•• ,. a„••,--•'••• ' r-•• 4/7..--..r.0 %177,---••..,7, ..?,,7;;;:?,, , -_-•.:,••, • •• ..„. i f 5,9,5."-_ ' --! , r.- im.r-.-I' --, '". „'',..::."0.., : 1 .." ,r,, .,:f-7,?-••.,-:;-,,-.2?-•t-,:"-V.-•,-;-: 77;-.7 7'.rr‘•5,;;•-A,,-;I..., • ;:'-',... -'• c'' --(T--.. e-'' • - ,-' ..4-, '•'• -- -.,-a- . .. i - .- .. .- --• '••••, ."-:;.•'1.".-- ,P.:-..,•• --.1-::•.- 4, , ...;'„;.-. "••••.,_•,..i-.-h-'.-• ...i.1-_,..,,,....9e,ne2.11.4-44,.P7,ri:•„'.5 c 4,i• ''-‘•' :•-' ‘.:4- , $..sistserawyr,,c-.F:-,,.,:;7, ,,-,....‘',,' t -r.,7 - '•, • -A'•a . • .. ' -.,',,- -,•-•!--..-• ".-•".•-•et;i4WeirditeMeaa;i 4Cr•-`14:14•Ift:`-";-.1 mk ,. .._. -- 0. -• , - -:', .7-,........'..4• .-...-- --- . . -. .,„ ,I., -Ae„..": ,,.,'T-,--:--,,•-. C_', .,`:••,...-- ,.., - ,,,•...-t, .:,_ , r- .r:...,.. •-1•;••.; ,L. .,_,, ,,. .- ..„ ',-Ve_s•_, _taiLs-,.. ,.,•,,-.. • .;.:_-',:.-,•,•-••4, •.: •- •. • ,.•_ .:.. • --i• -_ •,. .,,,'- ,• , .- ., ‘••••. t,.••••- • - -- ', • -•• ' 1.•``•-. - - 2' '--7,..... "13•••:: • Ci7 sttiaZtkeN,A19.ktfpf...11114/ '‘..•747.I'fr-:-...7,:,-3 1 . •s-- -‘ r-:-7> -, '-• -. -' ,.. • %-. --• ' - ' - A - . -- --:. • -Wi: 11-9**v1 '''S - ---- .44-ttek' ' -------- — - - ' • - ' -- -- - • -- --ipt., iatyeit.€4-is,rcer.), tiore...k_.•-•,„ ...,_.—-,.-•:,:-,,, .,_ --...... . -..... - T- -' . . -.----•--,'a .. --:'.5.:. - te ,z------- • .:.t. '-3. --'5a7 • .. ,-:_. .:1 `r -- - „.. . . ,.!••••- . .1%.iii-iekuoi • -...,. ‘i.•-•-4- .-•-r•••4 7- - '• •;•••••-• ':'•-7,• n • •: •''- •e'-r• -''.• ` ` 6.•0 I:••• ":•7;"")....-'. , ,'•::" •.,2: - ... ,..-. ,,'.,„'--:7-..,:;,"-' ,,,7 ,. • , ',:.1-• •--,, -„„..,--;-:".1.,.1::::.:-°-•-•:t-,,,,,,3,-•-• -• ' '..„)„,.,•;.••‘:7p/.1.',..!.1",‘:'`'4'•r4;;P:,•-;','L-•:".":".=.4.*'-: ,,x,-.-• .,.. z e... - -_ -,..s. . ,., ' .- •,,-..:- .‘... ,el.„ • ,,.1. , ,/,•,,,, .,, „:. i'-'' c.: - ,f z•-••:•.•'7,;(-, •, -'. . Er-*„.: •'''i'.-.'„?, ,,,4r--' -,': ..,__.• _.,: „::: -1<aidq-;-RI Cif-,•;,,14114-`,..,rj.itykt,.:"L„.S..7-4.7`tetf.:•:?_;"1:.„'-f:-;•;_14:•;r,:: r 4 .,.°•.-. .N.-,------ . • _. 4. ,1,4_ ,^ • -• .--,.. • ''--, ';,('' „•-••, • ; '. -, ' ',..'•-:-V.r:, .'„4.- , '-;- -_,,E _ _"-. J--,,- •"...• - ' '- 1,'..',,-;,-•,-0:4"...:,--,---Vp. I, -,`'-' - •'-' = '--:. •'''x -•/- .-4-':--•••••• -,••• l ••i...'”•..`".:'• ,-. ,..„..• ..1' i...._,' .. ,•'_:...,, -,,"!- - .,-,• ,- , a:4-,:..c.: ,:f..f:';, - _ :,:_-_,i-7--,,•• - 2.- ..,, r.::. .„..r r,44,474446r4::, :,i,:-4;4:,4;'," ‘,.- 14,:k;."1,4....47-,'EW-,,;!•:_f..2_,,1- ,;:• • ': -. "-`' -;•;• •• i '"--,:. ;••• •ri...1;:•,,`jl 4. ,•..- '4 .44,-_, ..--4, _,_•.,,,._ ,.:"!,-;-•-"f•,•-fi•s.". .- ,_, .„-.1 , ,.,.. --1 7 __.T,4 - , . , .. ;4- „..4 „•,1 (44-....-.,,;Lai..4.3.4.!i-t.44yee-4:... i.,,, = 4..•'f..i.i.,.•.. '"..,:-.•,c ,,i•, i',...,..•,, -, •::••.i,: .i.7.-•--••••••••:•.7z.-,-:'" ... --1.:,•• ,1`• •..%•4'... •;• .. '_i -'-'::•-••i:,';-`''r.::•-•. '.-,f.." •i:,'•‘.•-••:1--.t....:-' ..•',n'/ ° •" :,• . .,,:-It.. , •-• ^:3 t,- ' tae , r••1:' ,. • ---, • • 7:-.•%, -"""7 i•-•.>•"•••",.':-'44:. = ••••••2!,-c, '`."..:.•-,' •.-.1.4-..!''n,-,-',.,..'",.....7'.47,,;;•Z 1. ':.•-,-i,:.-•. ,•,' _ _s7.!• =,:::4'1=7,%, -, ."1'''.-‹•-•..; ,. :•_-_,-:-...;Z••••=7 .' ••'="-'.7 'if .••.•.;. ."i* -''••• •,:e.Z...': ,7• n• e' ',.'•,a4,,,,4, ....v,ii-71r-1.-.,,i :•;.::e"4-er.- '-"=`,.;‘;:: e‘4.-.--..4-:---•.'rEZ.:$-.t.g-!•2,._ ,-,'-',"..Z:42.-:,4';'-, --7 ,•''-''t.,: :-..:' "-.---'.-1,5.--^'-`..-:•*--...j.;..` 7,_. ' .. '_':.,-..,•.7.-'"-.;;_4: ,',P.-4•-.•r',L.,'s,.,.•:„pit' '"z..;•tr.,- •'',.:-,,',,..- ,,i-c-:,:•.•' . ,,, ! • _, "'„' i:,', • ,.:•.---.'. ..!g+-„..:- Tift.t,.--41.L.•-„. ______,'t,' 4-..=• -i14...-"-,••.•-,t-m-14-44 ..".,-'4- -- ':;_.v.4.....".-' 1._;'.4._,_T--,o•Ar".•: -,r- ......- ...1. ..,..,..- ---,_.ii.i.....,,•-e-fv,--:',•?:-ti;-;--s--:.'s--,-,,,-':•'.%.••.-...':•:.,--1.•. .--:.--4.--t ..--...,er,-.;-.-_;-t;•-: :--'.%..,-ii:o-•-•,•,:o.,''. •,;.. :f1:••,' 2't-*'re`C't''1-•''''''4..:'-•:v.%''` •-."•-•41 ---- '40".A% '.--:---.7..''71'''1 "--.----,9. .7--..... "a: '.:'7'41,ter Ve:','MOLL', --L.1 -.4119.40.,-W4 C•••4r:?77,i,-,4`.,,i-.4',=:•_,.L.-,*'‘::-.4:--,`_4• -4'7•,--:._?:.-?,0.r;c.,:,r, ._-'f.....-'1 -1'*--'.:, .,`-$..‘,;:.,-; 5-7.5--'-'',-1-- *.'"- ,-A.,", -,vre----.:' ,• - •.•,--_,.:• •-. i-.7: -:-,F•t t--,--,r.,•---' ••••.3•-•-•": -•,1"-i,„•22.,..f.;•-••\‘''.t..s-:i t k.:_g•,_•-••-•1:2! rct 14 , .•••/:.• ,-.„-: .,-,.., '...2" ^ "''-`- •45 •••'.-^"•4 e'‘--.' i 1-, -„ s.,-.71-..7.,1.•••." -.. ,,, •t•f' '_ 'IPA ..4...''2.:.1.2'.2.21,,,,;_ I r.," :'-';'. --v..:- 4:'f •.'" '-* '.....-.-'.1- -e- -7----V,''-..-- '-' ---,'.- : 1-..--' ,,, •• ,e'- --•-=s'• ' --,, '-:'=:.',.-e:-•-•e.r..,•1,-..: ,-,:' ,- -...:•.; ,:?,24:-<••:-;_:'--47.'-"; -g•- :•-..";•,•--A:e ':.-..‘,„ -.:••r- -..... ......,.... a.is•41,- •-' - ..:"-----,,,-...,..'...•-, e..,i-• ,,,.. ':.--c'-',... ' e•_-.: 1.16,...;•,..„!-•";....: --,•,•,%•;v:./...e-ee 1:,..,.;:,..--,•"v-:.A.:„."•.`,„1. 3„.,x,-f t-," 4,-2",`,-t.-ny.., .,-:,1,-,:i4,, •„.• g2ri 4_3-:,-,...,,:.=_,I.i.,. -.:. •-4/2..,.- - ._ ,,,.-4.-4.,1„,„:1-,_,,,..„1 ,,, .,:•-:4„.„...--r. "....:2t,r.„. .V,„...__a„,;,k,,a,........,...- '4. 2..•,•,- .._.„,,,,--.;_„4.„„,„.......„..,:z10,2421 .t.47.1a=....Ti•iii-iil-iiii , ,r--, ......_•F..- (F l r GL1 1: Certified Mail) 1/(* L" 17 V 11 [1:2 July 26, 2000 a a 21700 Southold Town Board of Appeals Town Hall 53095 Main Road ' Southold,NY 11971 Re: Application No. 4845 —Robert Frentzel Dear Sir/Madam: I am writing to support the application of Mr. and Mrs. Robert Frentzel to construct an addition to their one-family dwelling at 1900 Old Orchard Lane in East Marion,NY. As a next door neighbor, any changes to the Frentzel property would have a direct impact on me. While I realize that the proposed plans do not"meet the required minimum rear yard setback of 50 feet,"the overall proposal would enhance the houses on our block and the entire neighborhood.-Therefore,I request that the Board vote in favor of the variance and overturn the Notice of Disapproval at its meeting on Thursday, August 10, 2000. If there are questions or additional clarification is needed, do not hesitate to contact me during business hours at 617 494-2715. Thank you for your consideration in this matter. Sincerely yours, 0. Peter A. Manning 2050 Old Orchard Lane,Box 325 East Marion,NY 11939 • ` _•\ ? + Tl . _ _ ` _ ,. — e it - ; . _ ' im i - - ., - , - . : ` i _ •, _ _, _J . `Y a N/F t1C-ESE s= _ - f r .' h: 1_ = R 1V58°58'3b"E 15Q,© O ` I :- . ;_ `_ 0 r. O IC -DOOR �i _ � - ._ STORY•. z • - "� = fRAIVIE_MOUSE -- . • DECKr�� t Q ... ::" ,' k '. .- i AO _ , , . / - - : ..- i. 2 ;PAVED PATIO*, - . 9•w p Q LOCUST COURT �Jk _ - -' OARAGE-j.: _ • _:_ J- l _ ,. _ - - - ,. j. `i _ _ - `r.. .7• ate. _ s .. - - . - _ Y . L :(.7.__2 - # - " s_.v55&°58'.�V , 150.0 •I b= ,{ ,,iii i, , ''0�OFFO`� 1,II��® 0 ELIZABETH A.NEVILLE �� y� Town Hall, 53095 Main Road TOWN CLERK P.O. Box 1179 REGISTRAR.OF VITAL STATISTICS �, Southold, New York 11971 MARRIAGE OFFICER :®sfe ���� Fax(631) 765-6145 RECORDS MANAGEMENT OFFICER 1* ® / Telephone (631) 765-1800 FREEDOM OF INFORMATION OFFICER " .',,,"i�� OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD • TO: Southold Town Zoning Board of Appeals FROM: Elizabeth A. Neville DATED: June 28, 2000 RE: Zoning Appeal No. 4845 Transmitted herewith is Zoning Appeals No. 4845—Robert Frentzel-Zoning Board of Appeals application for variance. Also included is Building Department Notice of Disapproval, Building permit application, 2 property surveys, Fairweather Brown estimated lot coverage, energy calculations, copies of property cards, and ZBA questionnaire. REASONS FOR AREA VARIANCE ONLY (to be completed by applicant) : Do not use these standards for "use variance" or "special exception. " (Also attach sheets if necessary, with signatures. ) 1. An undesirable change will NOT be produced in the character of the neighborhood or a detriment to nearby properties, if granted, BECAUSE: itei ", .z or), lZge- 2. The benefit sought by the applicant CANNOT be achieved by some method, feasible for the applicant to pursue, other than an area variance BECAUSE: 0(4 3 . The amount o relief requested is not' substantial BECAUSE .iLetiL1/41A4g, 4 . The variance will NOT have an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood or district BECAUSE .tat ,cam y''iJ � - 5 . Has the alleged difficulty been self-created? ( ) Yes . ( ) No. 6 . This is the minimum that is necessary and adequate, and at the same time preserve and protect the character of the neighborhood and the health, safety and welfare of the community. STATE OF NEW YORK) COUNTY OF SUFFOLK) / (Applica - Agent • ' • attach written consent from owner. Sworn to before me this -ay of -u - 1) Notary Public HELENS D.HORNS NotaryPublic,State of Naw York • :xtl /form.var/t(`Th.D Ne-4951364 Commis ongExpi es�olk May??Co 'O FAIRWEATHER-BROWN DESIGN ASSOCIATES,INC. P.O.Box 521 413 Main Street Greenport,N.Y. 11944 631-477-9752 (fax)631-477-0973 Frentzel Lot Coverage Plot size 22,500 sq. ft. Proposed completed structure 3,398.34 sq. ft. Lot coverage 15% 1 Energy Calculations Frentzel X 7, gross SQ' GROUND FLOOR SQUARE FOOTAGE 2851.31 GROUND FLOOR WALLS 2623.5 DOOR(1/2 GLASS) 174.4 WINDOWS 318.8 NET WALL FIRST FLOOR 2130.3 SECOND FLOOR SQUARE FOOTAGE 3517 ' WALLS 3006.05 WINDOWS 534.01 DOORS 0 NET WALLS SECOND FLOOR 2472.04 ROOF 3517 FIRST FLOOR SF U" RATING 6-3 FLOOR R22 2851 0.045 14 6-1 NET WALL R19 2130 0.038 264 6-1 GL 319 0.38 -69 6-1 DOOR 174 0.38 -40 SECOND FLOOR 6-3 FLOOR 666 0.045 4 6-1 NET WALL 2472 0.038 288 6-1 GL 319 0.38 -69 6-1 DOOR 0 0.38 0 6-3 ROOF R22 3517 0.045 18 6-3 SKYLIGHTS 28 0.37 0 TOTAL 410 BASEMENT As per Section 7814 Part 5 Building design by acceptable practice FLOOR R10 NET WALL R 10 IT IS A VIOLATION OF THE LAW FOR ANY PERSON, GL R2 UNLESS ACTING UNDER THE DIRECTION OF A UCENSED ARCHITECT.TO ALTER ANY ITEM ON THIS DRAWING IN ANY WAY.ANY AUTHORIZED ALTERATION MUST BE q °g pgpg� R y NOTED,S . 1 r�^' '!',F? best of my aiot eda 4�91�i 11 f on WISCR .r,'1'",•Ap? E r1 r i .;, �, fA o otT L Rc'Y/ sicna. :��d sment, these plans and Specifications Q��oe -.70 0 't it rorty fa ce with the New pork tate Energy * ,, f3 . , ,,``'��' 1 :1 � . e i- lVtr, 'l NEW-4°� QUESTIONNAIRE FOR FILING WITH YOUR Z.B.A. APPLICATION A. Please disclose the names of the owner(s) and any other individuals (and entities) having a financial interest in the subject premises and a description of their interests: (Separate sheet may be �ched. ) / ? A ; �.2 B. Is the subject premises listed on the real estate market for _ - sale'or being shown to prospective buyers? { } Yes { r/} No. (If Yes, please attach copy of "conditions" of sale. ) C. Are there 3ay proposals to change or alter land contours? { } Yes { "} No D. 1. Are there any areas which contain wetland grasses? it/tr--- 2. Are the wetland areas ,c hown on the map submitted with this application? 3 . Is the property b •eaded betw e the wetlands area and the upland building area? A/ 4. If your property contains wet ands or pond areas, have you contacted the Office of the Town Trustees for its determination of jurisdiction? A/ 4- E. Is there a depression or sloping elevation near the area of proposed construction at or below five feet above mean sea level? A//- (If not applicable, state "N.A.") F. Are there any patios, concrete barriers, bulkheads or fences which exist and are not shown on the survey map that you are submitting? y)®= If none exist, please state "none." G. Do you have any construction taking place at this time concerning your premises? A(a If yes, please submit a copy of your building permit and map as approved by the Building Department. If none, please state. H. Do you or any co-owner also own other land close to this parcel? / 'a If yes, please explain where or submit copies of deeds. I. Please 'st resent use or opera 'o• co.ducted at this parcel s -�iLAL-- + / and proposed use L19 /-e` g7 . fo /61° -Ale thor , Signature and Dat 3/87, 0/901k Town Of Southold - ' . P.O Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 * * * RECEIPT * * * Date: 06/28/00 Receipt#: 1853 Transaction(s): Subtotal 1 Application Fees $400.00 Check#: 1853 Total Paid: $400.00 Name: Frentzel, Robert 1900 Old Orchard Lane East Marion, NY 11939 Clerk ID: LYNDAB Internal ID 13690 Page 30 August 10, 2000 Board of Appeals Hearings CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: Appl. . 844 — DONALD BUS - Anybody here for Buskard which is ext hearing? I ybody - to speak for or against? The neighbo otices were n. • operly se. •ut so therefore we are barred from having the heari o we'll • en to Frentzel. 7:28 P.M. —Appl. No. 4:45 — ROBERT FRENTZEL This is a request for a Variance to Article XXIV, Section 100-244B, based on the • Building Department's June 22, 2000 Notice of Disapproval. The Disapproval denied an application for a Building Permit to construct an addition to a one-family dwelling for the reason that the addition does not meet the required minimum rear • yard setback of 50 feet. Location of Property: 1900 Old Orchard Lane, East Marion, N.Y.; Parcel 1000-37-2-9.1. CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: Anybody here for this hearing? Ms. Doty, how are you? MS. DOTY: I'm fine Mr. Chairman, how are you? I have the Affidavit of Posting was signed for the Board. CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: Thank you. We're ready whenever you are. MS. DOTY: The separate parcel is 22,500 sq. ft. property located in Gardiners • Bay Estates. That area is predominately small non-conforming lots and this is probably the largest in the neighborhood. The applicants are requesting a rear yard variance of 13 feet 8 inches less than 28%. One could theorize that if they sold a 17 foot wide strip on the sound side of their property, we wouldn't be here. We'd have less than 20,000 sq. ft. and rear yard setback of 35 feet with the bluff but that's not the case before you. The applicants wish to convert the existing - essentially summer bungalow into their retirement home and they want to have the living space primarily on the first floor. The architect just mentioned it's convenient for older people to have their living space on the first floor, their master bedroom. The plans show a master bedroom suite to the back of the property along the north line of the property following the existing north line of the house. And the living space will actually focus towards the mature gardens there. The applicants installed it. I don't know if you all went out to the premises but they are lovely. CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: There's also a significant elevation factor. MS. DOTY: Yes, as well as that. They're behind the garage. The addition extends back from the road, which limits the measure impact actually on the neighborhood. We cold theoretically go down the roadside but that would have a dramatic impact on the road coming into the house and would, in fact I think that Page 31 August 10, 2000 Board of Appeals Hearings (coughing) the street there by extending to the south. This is the most feasible way of achieving what the applicants' want, which is living space on the first floor for the retirement home. It is conceivable that a two-story box could be put up there but unfortunately one of the applicants has arthritic knees and have legs and that means that's against going up and down the stairs all the time. By focusing the house to the south and the west, they're actually increasing the privacy for the neighbor that's closest to them, which is the one to the north because the house is actually going to go that way and there's not going to be that much activity to the north. We're also increasing the side yard setback by eliminating two projections into that side yard setback. So the wall will be no more than, the north side of the house will be no more than 11 feet, 11.63 feet from the side yard. This is really no different than what exists in the neighborhood. There are any number of insufficient setbacks pre-existing I grant you because of the pre zoning. But for example across the street, the neighbor it's the McKeon house, it has a 13 foot rear yard setback. Now that's a 63% variance from the Code. Up the street there's a 56% variance, for the rear yard and a 46, I have all of this, I'll give it to you. Next door there's a 30% variance on the side yard because the house next door toward the north, is only 7 feet off the line. Other configuration of the house, just don't make sense. If for example the extension were moved to the back of the garage, which has been suggested, that divides the property in two essentially. Actually increases the activity on the north side of the property and decreases the privacy of the neighbors to the north. Linda was kind enough to fax the property of a letter that the Board received from the neighbor to the north and that person doesn't seem to object to the rear yard setback at all. It's an issue of the extension of the house backwards of which we can do anyway and a second-story could be put on the existing dwelling without a variance. He makes some comment about limited views from windows, etcetera but I have a photograph here which I took before I got the letter of the side of the house which has no windows at all and the house is actually directed a little bit to the north and the west of, that is the - neighbor to the north of and this is not a spite addition or any effort to strain the • property to the north. This is the logical place to put living quarters over property existing dwelling and therefore we requested the Board grant less than- 14 foot variance and do you have any questions? CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: George? MEMBER HORNING: You mentioned single story but the proposal is for a two- ; story addition, is it not? MS. DOTY: That's correct. I have plans here for the Board. They are simplified plans which show you what the proposed addition is. It doesn't have' all the plumbing features in it etcetera. I have photographs for the Board and information on the building property. Page 33 August 10, 2000 Board of Appeals Hearings MEMBER TORTORA: True. I realize that the 11 foot side is not an issue because you're essentially going along the existing footprint of the property. MS. DOTY: We're actually improving. MEMBER TORTORA: (more than one person speaking) because it's going to be a considerable size house and it is going to present a wall that will be 11 feet from their property. So I guess the question I'm asking is you have such a large parcel of property and so many options of other places that it could be where you wouldn't impose on neighbors on either side and you practically wouldn't even be required to get a rear yard variance. Why wasn't it designed like that? MS. DOTY: Because of the existing landscaping that was there. The depression of the land and the fact that the living space on the house, is at the other end of the house. Now Mrs. Tortora, I do have a photograph of the Fisher's house which will hand to the Board but and I took it very innocently on Sunday. This is the existing dwelling and this is the Fisher's house. So you can see there's not a window on that side of the house. MEMBER TORTORA: There isn't. It's still going to be pretty close and you have so much room on the other side where you wouldn't be required any variance. That's my only comment. CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: Could you just state your name for the record? MS. FRENTZEL: I'm Melanina Frentzel and I've lived here 56 years of my life and this is going to be our retirement home and we've worked on these plans. We had a local architect, which we those very carefully so everything would be done exactly right, two years and living in this house, I have another home in Greenport that is now for sale. We thought of the neighbors. We thought of Sean and - Craige barbequing at night and the barbeque grill going in our window. We thought of Mrs. Neece with no privacy because if we sit on our deck, she has absolutely no privacy. Sally has privacy now because we put up a fence because her evergreen trees are too high and there's absolutely— CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: Ma'am, ma'am, you have to address the Board. MS. FRENTZEL: So we put a fence up if we were there for the privacy and when we worked with our architect for two years, we probably will have a pool because we do have the land for it. We are going to have the grandchildren and,children and they also have children and grandchildren and,we were advised that what we were doing was legal and correct and that's how we did the plan. Not that if you find it's not that way, but we do want you to know and our Real Estate Committee kept asking for the plans and I grew up here and I know the most important thing - before anything is to have it approved by you people which I did say to Anne let's Page 35 August 10, 2000 Board of Appeals Hearings perhaps believed that a 35 foot setback was adequate without realizing they were over a line in the code. OK, thank you. MS. DOTY: Yes. It was an innocent mistake and they'd like to built their home. CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: You were going to give us a set of plans? MS. DOTY: I was going to give you a set of plans, a series of photographs, and some surveys from adjoining owners. CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: OK • MS. DOTY: As well as an expansion on the original applications. Does anybody have any questions? CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: Yes, Mr. Horning. MEMBER HORNING: I'm curious because the applicant has mentioned the possibility of putting a pool on. The code calls for a pool being in the rear yard. MS. DOTY: It could go — MEMBER COLLINS: You could put it in the rear yard, here. MEMBER HORNING: That's not quite the rear yard. MEMBER COLLINS: Well, it's rear side. We'll see them again George. MS. DOTY: I've numbered the photographs on the back and then indicated the locations of the photographs being taken. These are surveys of adjoining - properties with setbacks, insufficient setbacks and this is the site plan and these '• • are the plans for the house, first floor, second floor. • CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: Thank you. Any other questions George? MEMBER HORNING: No. CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: OK. We thank you, we'll see what develops. Anybody else like to speak in favor? Yes, Mr. Torkelson. MR. TORKELSON: I've been working with the Frentzels and Fairweather-Brown and I've been over to look at,the property. In fact lap and I have been working together in'the hopes of our doingsomething. The'awareness that we had was that it was a 35 foot setback based on the other houses in the neighborhood. Again, they're going to get penalized because of the size of their property Page 37 August 10, 2000 Board of Appeals Hearings MEMBER TORTORA: Right here. CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: Oh, OK, right directly to— MEMBER COLLINS: Where is here, Lydia? MEMBER TORTORA: On the site plan, the corner. MEMBER COLLINS: Oh, directly behind. So it's catty-corner. CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: Right. Thank you Mrs. Heese. Who else would like to speak? Yes Sir, just state your name for the record. MR. HOGAN: My name is Bob Hogan and I'm a resident in Gardiner Bay Estates. I have heard some reference to a gully which I am not familiar with but it appears that if the gully is prohibiting the design, if the gully is in such a location that it prohibits the addition from going to the south where all of the apparent space is, then why couldn't this gully be filled and I guess this would be a question to the architect because at first blush, looking at this layout, there's at least a half a dozen designs that come to be readily to go in the other direction without in any way of infringing upon any of the neighbors. So it's a question of the gully. As I said I'm not familiar with that but maybe that question could be answered. Why couldn't it be filled and why couldn't this design be proposed in such a way that it doesn't infringe on anybody else's property? Thank you. CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: Who would like to answer that? How are you tonight? MR. FAIRWEATHER: Fine, thank you. Extending the house to the south, we took - a very conscious effort not to increase the house in its width along the street there. Most of the houses in Gardiners Bay Estates are 30, 40, 50 feet wide. We had the right to make this house 100 feet wider if necessary but we really didn't want to change the character of the neighborhood by doing that. It just seemed appropriate to extend the house towards the back which will have the least impact on the neighborhood and also as it's been pointed out, there are topographic situations on the south side of the property but we are also dealing with a pre- existing house which we're just trying to extend on to, and the pre-existing house has L shape already on the north side of the property and we were just extending back on,that side of the property. CHAIRMAN GOEHRINGER: A question I have that goes back to the question of Mrs. Heese over here, and that is from an elevation factor, could you supply us what you think would be above grade since the grade to the rear of the house falls away anyway? • w iit ;++rs _ SON. ` br . ' 11111Nt-..cilit '••••• •. •. b.- Ilit± • 10.......... '...� .;;� ♦ - .. '� ,�,lt,urs 'ru •- 4 r • 11. lir kle&I.4 INI*614.4"' ' . . ...- 'i , .-;44,10, .r tR ..'' riiiiiimpo Id• °‘• ••'..006--1.r-' • • *" ''..b:t;,• ,.., : . . * ` . "gyp ,�,"r ...'1[' ' ^ • ,S;r _'G ~ •1lik Y `� • �.'� . '; •.._sift c _; ;, ''!t ,•t a6, r� +, 71P1'f�'rT .1!' "M.'.c __- • . t +' r "' t• r , '� .. .y•.c +" ^ r } • :t j,r..„+ in :'' Yom,,.,,,, • 1 } N v f > . It • •. k ..' 4..M • i. ir r v fillki;' Y ••i..,,• ,,,, 1 } i Ir.,Ve. v' A R ' 11;1 +1 r f •,, . • . �'4:'4. • - = 3 4 to ... 1 t t.' ,r f -4 � �.a•' �•-{'� � may 'R'�' � F1. t a tet. ` �`;` � � � :�l, • .,. • - ' 46:4014?4 6 r:..:ACx11 .1,, .... . .. ..- . _. 0 - :,# • "-. - bra' ', . tIG!tlNliilit _ .`. 1 sem.. ' ` +- . • ,• +.te it w... I elazz, aria t) , lir .,. { 1 ,i.1 /4..b .)1;' :-z ',14 2 1r.r �" a <,,, fI I iF 4 i ..t . + t � " M Wyd ' • ,, . r� n - .i?cf - i .. . ,, r.7 7 .! t. ...-,, . 7 .•7 = ; --- . -7 • 0.,•-::, 7 : 7,/--;• 1,I I `4, ..., .1 •C•••••,,..1 ......•,• ' ' 'i.''' ;4/041 Ill -- r SII vyr''t 4401 • — �ryr. , H t�. i lit_H ,w 40 • st� + / Iw r Sa % � ' aia» t•, 0 A s . ...i. :_. -.-:..„-,-tv:jr.._,_11.:,,..4, .01„,*(....., -.:._ 4-&-' ipRip,..,:tt,,,, ''''',:t'. lip A., 4:114 4 k 1i � is t '+ r t i'': -� �. _ sli g. 1t t n v , . ',SI:"... `/ UI lull ■ii r — s < ijT Av' y� - 1111111111111111111.1.11111 14 --X41#7,.. ..;. _,/ rt 7#0 • IMO moor - , .;-,• . - # 4f411/4 .... � yy pyt r 4,c•- .. . ,. imillir • 4 111° - '� 444- 0 ,. A Vi -w ... w:. . T. �..� '•' .�'- .e13�a� -.s. Z sa. ..:—a +, '`.,.,.....a .s.dai.v _ __ Y F 'A i-l�y� ar<' :""k, Det " :z : Y �.► �+ e +- .. � 4titt, n ! 10 igg- ^� -:� a _ ,` i "" y 'r r r �' �� -. tii Li•-1 yh . �•� q)L �yr.k � `. ` T _ .fr .. '<_ - mo'�Rh.� '.cay' -'* - ' �'GvyF - 4 }�� ' - .„,-4.,,,,- i : r:.— ma +hv omy x ..,,,t4-''. ,, t /. - is .:l''i ,y y Wit' , w. " : ;,: r! • ras mow, r" l+4/ •*•. v"' .. rpt. r+ " 'k,‘,; - , lc • w . \ { ��. �\ 7,........4 .Fes,.. ` , J 1 • t'11f$ w.Q� v . w „ T.,.. 4 e -4046.1 rwatr- '` y *' y 2 4'- 1 '1,4:. 'IMS •d"",�y .\r?i . - 2y > :::•Vc. M 4'•. .-11 Ij - -<.4e1 alt T` , "• • a / 7,f,""ii, 4, 'f r la'} Y - .,.''4C,. r \ !, . :.'.,/1 ,./ gym. ( J' ,. ..e,t. ,:•-• \� Rt + , 't M. - Iii • ♦t est . - 'I .'-.A--- ,• mia Jo_ --.4.- • • r. 7• 4,4 Ki I� '• • by } �. I .. '7s *el at tiff IV -3.`! ? e,1-f . AUTHORIZATION - - - (where applicant is not the owner) I, eOneer / rt- residing at 7P,&,. B4O/ 363 j /700 a° Ott/Yap L9,gE 595''r llige 0cJ,il. 7, 11931 (mailing address) do hereby authorize Deborah Doty ,Esq to act as my agent to apply for all permits necessary for the proposed work to be performed at /900 O o ®,ea-h Zp LI9I1 Ins/—/#Fi0,)` /y //f39 7e1 • , „,/, / ( Owner' signa 6 The Town of c'outhold ' s Code of Ethics p&ohibits conflicts of Interest on the part of town officers and employees. The purpose of this form is to provide inforlation which can alert the town of possible conflicts of interest and allow , • it to take whatever action is necessary to avoid same. YOUR NAME: FR'6TZ e0.13E/Z j (Last name, first name, middle, initial, unless you are applying in the name of someone else or other entity, such as a ,company. If so, .indicate the other person ' s or company's name. ) NATURE OF APPLICATION: (Check all that apply. ) Tax grievance - Variance 4� Change of zone Approval of plat . Exemption from plat or official map Other ( If "Other , " name the activity . ) Do you personally (or through your company, 'spouse, sibling, parent, or child) have a relationship with any officer or employee of the Town' of Southold? "Relationship" includes by blood, marriage, or business interest. "Business interest" means a business, including a partnership, in which the town officer or employee has even a partial ownership of (or employment by) a corporation in which the town officer or employee owns more than 5% of the shares. YES NO Lee."' If you answered "YES, " complete the balance of this form and date and sign where indicated. Name of person employed by the Town of Southold Title or position of that person Describe the relationship between yourself ( the applicant ) and the town officer or employee. Either check the appropriate line A) through D) and/or describe in the space provided . • The town officer or employee or his Or her spouse, sibling, parent , or child is (check all that apply) : A) the owner of greater than 5%' of the shares of the corporate stock of the applicant (when the applicant is a corporation) ] -B ) the legal or beneficial owner of any interest in a noncorporate entity (when the applicant is not a corporation) ; C ) an officer, director, partner, or employee of the applicant; or D) the actual applicant . DESCRIPTION OF RELATIONSHIP ILJ]l+` '' WAIF & JUt. 2 5 2400 Submitted t4.- 7/1/ Signature .& ;] L1. :_ Print name /0' ' 7 �� �_. . .. N 58°58'30E (5 0.0 O 1T : - - ILCO DOS - • • 3250' •: t._ - * 1.:____ 1..,,,, -,, :'77 - e///./- ..,-.: v ,-... . -.. - -•••:-..•:.1.-4, 3•4' • „ / ' ';' I - . , "s ` �i2AME_NOUSE enc! PwED • _.. /7.•,„,/ DEC ,'K;, _ = o - _ ti.. F PAVED PAT1Q �j/ = g • - - s- �� _ - — • //��, O I.._ LOCUST COURT �'• :: • _ ,2 BAR / �' F •• �• : • - - - _ — ARA - ' . - ter :s• • `72,11 •- Z Tom;` '/ • t i _ _ D- /J/j/tel FOR BOARD AND STAFF USE lit ff — Z c Updated New Information 7/3/0o (iffibi . d.iiiii} - 1-0-1-0-3 ,L,„,,,..„6_, tra„.,),,) .,,,„,, i , _u... . '/ " ' . o-L) 4--A____. ___,— - / q. z I , , , / ki,L-40,„ 4-- X1_,C___e_Lo - Lh.im_ lb -//x-e-4:0&i ill 0)1) 6-G a± ,44.-4" 14/ ftiu '. s) 9//06 __-..e d, Lel 2/ it /u/74), Pwe, X J oCe c 4-- c-�6 nt_c:r 6,,\1 , ;,\OA. , _,, , x4, - ,,,,,:,-..._, , . _ . , ROBERT HOGAN ARTIST/ILLUSTRATOR 30 Hollywood Ave. Lynbrook, New York ,516.593.5197 a ' a tp� , � e //7. 1 East Marion, New York 631.477.9659 //1 ,011///7 / �/ S q61. 6. f' 111� A�`Q 2 - ---,7 - . .� 32 eAtil 49ef ____,, \, s,, pp/ ' ilail � 8" o / �r�/ S ,/ //97/„, `f bee4/ 4„,,d,1# 4 ,0.„,„ ,9,/,,,,k, . d„,,, ,7< --o -A-te 6 ieri-v-eviat-heofed- z)-e- aof- --7-- , , /- a”. . 4 ael, 4-r /e4fref, ./4e6'-- ..f �uv4Z d .ge ' - / & 16-i, dowt,of.,ade,e0, Addity- , , i<,--nedoi - - ir; /'"e7 �-e-0.4 i' 4:401.0.Y �. a ,ire/' �i /iii / J Gni ,--44e. sailer 74e . r, ' i ,,,,„,,,e -76,,,,,,t70„J ..$0 . vari-y5 , / //' ea4-eittreW/0& , /1/.97/1-, :- '- b /,, _Aef,ez 1,-fr - . .---. d.),:e, , ; -. , / �� t� aid 04.ke . . ' rg7e 1 / '. .4"/eflAeee6 411/ 71)ee itrhe4 4 dieViee . fikie .e9e74/ e‘;' ' / /4 i yfr/ // 'or, i . 4_ -,r pfrz------ .'' ' ------ 'ARPiALS BOARD MEMBERS ,•i" FFOL,f-C ��. p Southold Town Hall Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman ;1 Gy1 53095 Main Road ; Q . _ P.O. Box 1179 James Dinizio, Jr. � �n . v- ^7 Southold, New York 11971 Lydia A. Tortora • p ' �� Lora S. Collins `--- v ,0� ZBA Fax (631) 765-9064 George Horning '= �l * �►a,dt Telephone (631) 765-1809 . BOARD OF APPEALS ____,WA_Aer- �?i /lLoW TOWN.OF-SOUTHOLD - „A„.e,e //f))/.,?(.., ' o FINDINGS, DELIBERATIONS AND DETERMINATION E' i ,� �\ MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 6, 2000 ///j ' c!2 f zoos ! / Appl. No. 4845— ROBERTFRENTZEL /3 _ STREET& LOCATION: 1900 Old Orchard Lane, East Marion 1000-37-2-9.1 Ul -DATE OF'PUBLIC HEARING: August-10,-.2000_..__ FINDINGS OF FACT PROPERTY FACTS/DESCRIPTION: The applicants' property comprises 22,500 sq. ft. located on the west side of Old Orchard Lane, East Marion with 150 feet of lot depth and 150 ft. of road frontage. It is improved with a single-family dwelling with garage, set back 32.5 feet from Old Orchard Lane, 11.63 feet from the northerly property line (not including a small protrusion that is to be removed) and about 75 feet from the rear property line. BASIS OF APPLICATION: Building 'Inspector's June 22, 2000 Notice of Disapproval denying a permit to expand the house for the reason that the proposed addition would have a rear setback of 36'4" in violation of the 50-ft. requirement of Code Section 100-244B. AREA VARIANCE RELIEF REQUESTED: Applicant requests a variance to locate proposed ' construction that will add a second floor to the existing house and a near two-story addition with a rear setback of 36'4" in violation of the 50 ft. requirement of Code Section 100-244B. REASONS FOR BOARD ACTION: On the basis of testimony presented, materials submitted and ' personal inspection, the Board makes the following findings: (1) The existing house is small and the owners wish to enlarge it for year-round occupancy. They testify that the only practical direction for expansion is westerly into the rear yard, because the southerly and southwesterly yards are planted in mature gardens and have some significant topographical irregularities. Because this lot is over 20,000 sq. ft., Code Section 100-244 requires a rear yard of 50 feet. The current rear yard is about 75 feet; applicant proposes a rear yard of 36'4". Applicant also proposes a northerly side yard that continues the existing nonconforming setback of 11.63 feet for the entire length of the addition. The required side yard setback under Code Section 100-244 is 15 feet. (2) The proposed project will result in a much larger house than now exists, with two stories rather than one and a much larger footprint. The proximity to the northerly and westerly property lines raises a serious possibility that the property will appear crowded and the house will intrude on the neighbors Because the project is in the planning stage, applicant is in a position to revise the plan to allow r greater setbacks. G / g (3) The Board concludes hai ith greater setbacks as set forth below, the project will not produce an undesirable change in the character of the neighborhood or detnmen to nearby properties. . / eat . 4 r7 •i Page 2— September 6, 20C„ . ./ ZBA Appl. No. 4845—R. and M. Frentzel Parcel 1000-37-2-9.1 at East Marion (4) There is no evidence that the action set forth below will, have an adverse effect or impact on physical,,or environmental conditions. (5)The action set forth below is the minimum necessary and adequate to enable applicant to enjoy the benefit of a larger home with minimum disruption of established gardens, while preserving and protecting the character,of the neighborhood and the health, safety and welfare of the community. RESOLUTION/ACTION: On motion by Chairman Goehringer, seconded by Member Collins, it was RESOLVED, to DENY the variance applied for and ALTERNATIVELY to GRANT a variance authorizing a rear setback of no less than 40 feet from the rear property line, subject to the CONDITION that the northerly wall of the proposed addition shall for its entire length be set back no less than 1 eet from the northerly property line. VOTE OF THE BOARD: Ayes: Members Goehringer Chairman), Din' ' Tortora, and Collins. (Member Homing from Fishers Island was absent. is R= olution s dul •-;,ed 4-0). GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAill • •fir vl.. { Robert Hogan Member of the American Society of Interior Designers 30 Hollywood Ave. Lynbrook, N.Y. 11563 Phone 516 593-5197 BIOGRAPHY Bachelor of Fine Arts 1955, Pratt Institute Design Consultant for Citibank, Design Alternatives, and Wiedersum Associates, Architects. Previously associated with Avis Rent A Car, Construction and Engineering. Consultant to the State of New York, Facilities Management, Pan American Airways and Van Ard Design Corp. Original paintings in the collections of Citibank, The Dime Savings Bank, The Williamsburgh Savings Bank and The Home Savings Bank. Also Spear, Leeds & Kellogg of N.Y. , N.Y. Awards Edward Fields/ASID 1980 Wool Rug Design Competition-First Prize. Edward Fields/ASID 1982 Wool Rug Design Competition-Third Prize and Second Honorable Mention. Edward Fields/ASID 1985 Wool Rug Design Competition-Third Prize. Rockville Centre Guild for the Arts, Grumbacher Award 1985. Rockville Centre Guild for the Arts, Award of Merit 1987. Malverne Artists-Third Prize 1968. Specialty Area - Architectural and interior rendering. . 1 pklkl0s it4 ..r,0f•,„-rkwlii•"...,.,4.,.,.,,91..4.„,r80/ NfAT m4 i I4Af*..—:•.,..4 -i,, ,_- s ,'f'.,'.4.•'r: . . . „. if .: . , ..,.--..„ - . , L • .t,,, .,___,J. _ ,.. . , • ... .. - • - -d.0741-4 - 11 ,, . fr • , F. I 1II I . ,,. .. • I*, //:' . ,t1, II t a- , i., , _ ... . ... ..„ , lip•, e 4 / f, l 124 1 • ' ' F.. ..;• - 44,444\,,, , ,, • . 1 \ , 1,,,,,-,!,,,,-, • ' ''.• •,•,r0"''' ...1, C . - , - 1 •,,„...,,'1- . • 4 ; • - .,,,_ ,•• i, , • „r—m..,A. • .--- • , . • '•., T 1 / roil v; -4141%---, . -,.,, ,. ‘\ --, ' 111,gb- „, % I 1 ,t,t,.. i -„'''' 1V,'4V illft,. fiNZLI iit'.,.•...!.i. t,,.,%A-.1..0k-ikA,i1; •;f • ' 1 — —'— ""t••','', ----4•••"" , . ' irieZ„ e• 0.- ,.. e + J • , IR 4 , el ' 'i , s‘i 13 i r , lip', L t,,t,,,,; ., , ,,,,,i' ,,,,,,,.. _ . , i ' 0 , , '11.1. ' ', /01104, ofir " ,'/I Y/7"�", NVQ ' • i- 1, ,. I i I' Ada ,`• t it '�, f'' s. 1�4!J�� , r, ♦ ./ t it iA !II 1 I JJLL 11116' 4iiii, AIR / / "i,. .p,`1,1'' 'i • , .%F 1 . 4:— , ' 4 -' 'f, e ' • , , 101.0j0... l '.fr ,'C!.'� '''-k- 44.4'...:t.'') 4.r `+" '_` - ' i _ ' } • Ir }( • .,14,,-;,. 4t:',;,..43/4.444 '- -Ii;:,..::- ,� .'r II � 1f t r I1� a ?� 6 �Fri ', :#� .i.,, ,,-.: ""1 itko!;;11silk,b 1 p.,... ,,, - . fitig., \ iii t_414;'I; ii•rd 1 i L'.-- - ... -' Wow � A 'z � fob KV 0r1a � - K/IQG �/ /•t iG•�i ` ,i r'1, ` V . ■41y 1 J r ) - . Y , . / , ;x, kiti ., le,40 ..„.,., tr.. fir!,71. ,...., 1 (,. A,t 1*,- 444 A .i,I‘ • /,'. - ''';' 7. ' / lyilt!‘ i ‘, f$4 1 I 111,0 ...it. , • li. al /I .1. r l 1 I f., fi „ 40 I .111- i 4 Si . /` zi . c„i , � • { 1 , ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD:NEW YORK In the Matter of the Application of AFFIDAVIT • em-i.r ) OF SIGN (Name of Applicant) POSTING Regarding Posting of Sign upon Applicant's Land Identified as 1000- 3 7 - a - 9. COUNTY OF SUFFOLK) STATE OF NEW YORK) • y �^ ;Om mfr d residing at Jf8 �'y°�' qie-e-ner//- , New York, being duly sworn, depose and say that: On the / - day of Av9a , 2000, I personally placed the Town's official Poster, with the date of hearing and nature of my application noted thereon, securely upon my property, located ten (10)feet or closer from the street or right-of-way (driveway entrance) -facing the street or facing each street or right-of-way entrance;*and that I hereby confirm that the Poster has remained in p/.I-_,or seven days prior to the date of the subject hearing date, op h hear)I%%-�fn to be /(Signature) Sworn to before me this .Ibe day ofeb_p_° - , 2000 . Otelfitirkeboliste Onatid to Beds iftrw, (Notary Public) *near the entrance or driveway entrance of my property, as the area most visible to passersby. i i u i__. Li V LS ))i +s/a� ' " , ;:r -•NOME or-, ,.1-0,14- JUL 3 1 200u I'. UBLIC•ifEARING ,4''-4 ;' .-c.SOUTlitILEPTOwNZ'-rw. I STATE OF NEWYORK) I= BOARU`'OF'APPEALS'`'7='' i ,, - -(•- •;::THURSD,AY,µ,.-cpi1 ao NTY )SS: -""-AUGUSTio,.z000',.-'' ---- ___ ,� OF SUFFOLK) in said NOTICE IS HEREBY;GI-VEN;', pursuant,to Section 267 of,the Town county,being duly sworn,says that he/sof he is�Principal - fM1es�w-‘�.c,u,uK1 clerk of THE SUFFOLK TIMES, a weekly newspaper, ate_ Town,of,Southgld,"Lthe .' .__follpwing applications will >ze"held'' ' published at f°r;N.:public hearings by_ the .i Mattituck, in the Town of Southold, souTHOLD Towil,BOAkD..o1.: County of Suffolk and State of New York, and that the • `M PEALS at=the Town'Iiall s3o9s:. Notice of which the annexed is a Main 'Road;•Southold;Newyork'''' been regularly printed copy, has :r(11971,,Qp;THUpAY� AUGUSTS 9 y publi shed in said Newspaper =-10;.000it:ihe ficins noted eelowr(or": each week for P Per once ooirt weeks as soon thcfreafter as possible),- = commencing �� $�CCeSSIVeIy, 6SSip.m App1.•No..4843 --M:,; _ of n9 on the 1 day COGEN-act m.HO ARD:-This'is'' 20 a i4llest,:fojrY a;Varian - , ce.under_ ,,'�, :the zo'niY Section"lo0az44E:of- r� t .CO I The B e^:Ordinance, based"u o s /L/ '20 _!?No gpaztument's Iv�ay, 0 # 4 incipal Clerk � = _of .-•Disapproval:• Applicants are proposing an addition - Sworn to before e this to the exxistipgdwevipg and were'dis-, _ day Of Approved for the reason that the side 20 CO �.Yaz4(_°_e:d for ca es5,not t t e side_;, 'b .required,;mintmu x. of,-,1Sfeel=Coca- ' CHRISTINA T.WEBER ,tion':r. e4,1.9:54 Fleetwogd'•w,-.Rd Notary Pubic,State of New York :Cutehogue�Parce1:1000- 1 ,,. '_. ' No.OIW Suffolk b4 r,. 137=4-3 r, 7:05 p m;APPhNo:4$44-_DON_,; Qualified in Suffolk County AI.p'Bp Commission fres D Ste:T1us'is'a request -'' (44 December 13, ZOO fora,Vaiat}ce to*Article,- y; K_.i 3 h� / , 9�, , _ _ .�,Section. Section -o , the, "I I v W No-(' . • ,Building Department's June 14;2000, rNotice rtof,•:Disapproval.,.:The ,. i-Disapproval,denied a`request forma-' ' 45 uildpig permit-for a proposed addi- ' tion >`removal of ewng pool,.after • for-two- tg deck and.porch,. ; • reasons: (1)_,that,the-son-„, ' , . struction-will the;maxim 't lot coverage,,pf;20%.of the ` •,; ' '' resulting in a lot coverage of 26011 sq. ft:,or"25.5±%, and,-(2)=that_{the, • k ' • ;':•...:..:' .':.,''.::•.;•;,.:%...'l• pool is proposed partly in a side,yard: "*Location•of-Property:12705 Gillette r% - '3,8-3-11K--...-':,aBas tVlarron;NYParcel i000 ;, >, '7:15 s i :^ ,`s-eF, a :�`ROBE-p m. APPI No.;4845'= ., RTW.FRENTZEL. • , • request;for:•,a a" - , Vaziance`,to Article J `' ;, . ...,:, . 11 XXIV.Section;; Buildin 100-244B, <,' the g,Department's June=22` ,• "' i 2000; Notice of'Disapproval:_The-_- % ' ,Disapproval;denied' an__application ' • ,j for adb��g permit to construct an.- ;ai; . n to°a one-family dwelling for • " •1, the reason meet the that the.addition does not ,,-. il :required=minimum"-rear ; • ,• yard setback of feet.-Lo ', ' j Property: 1900 Old Orchard rlanef •' ,, . 5 i. er- r-sg F_:LrT4A��Arcbiitectf t'ROGEIL.m�2 APED rloa.4847- fi. , YOU111G&;ORS;This.is•a _ request for'`a j.ot,yaiver�as provided:� T. funder Article III:a$ection11QO-26;to 1000-128 I ot10000.128r3-12A'from•y • • ' jIVotice r of 2 S'Qd, une`.22,2()DO,a, 'No . .'-Disapproril:was issued stating'that;:-Lot-.12.4 merged with :adjacent_lot,12 5 pursuant to Section A;r ofy;th0,;4;Zoningr Code: ' rtioriof Property"3495:and 3585 Peconic:Eay Boulevard,,`Laurel;+NY` also• -'on:'•the, 1969 "' shown Minor 1., k3py onMa 'for:Ce' •; :, 4.0730 cil�'oimg. :._ 1?,4 . p1 V0= 83T4-* (Continued from;°July;6;2000 ,atm , request"of-=abutting{s:owner) ' HARRY .CASITY; and:),MARIA s,' MISTHOS'..•Request:for swimming L{, pool and hot,t bin !i ed7'if; i _u_ the ' ' r ,:;yard•witla'a location at less` '`fit i• , toprmuhei equaed,100 feet from the 'tj' ofbluff or ba • Island Sound at 1900 H of, eR d, Southold;CTM#1000-50,1=3:•', oad , 7:35 p.m.Appl.N 4846-3:." - , ,�. request ICNOEaRSCCHIL This' anti • •'• • • ;ti;'; Sections 1OQ 33 . to Article III; j; Buil .�,hased. ,oq the Building Department's April 21,2Q00 Notice oaperovof Disapproval. -'The . :!::I:,,,,:',1,:`,.:;,:::::',... ,:,....::::::::,...',.1.,....‘..7, �, for a.buil denied-an.application i• ;;,; ding;permit_to construct' garage for the fire _be.Iocated' ;*naso garage will' • ;3i } 7 'ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS < , TOWN OF SOUTHOLD:NEW YORK -------------------- x In the Matter of the Application of AFFIDAVIT ,r� Tz,e'L, OF (Name of Applicants) MAILINGS CTM Parcel #1000- 6,--3 _,,_ 7, L • COUNTY OF SUFFOLK) STATE OF NEW YORK) I, }-my p,,,-,e r.n/ residing at .i8 9 .e,"),,a6-r f , New York, being duly sworn, depose and say that: On the cO qday of /i, / , , 2000, I personally mailed at the United States Post Office in *,.Ike- , , New York, by CERTIFIED MAIL, RETURN RECEIPT REQUE _ D, a true copy of the attached Legal Notice in prepaid envelopes addressed to current owners shown op-the current assessment roll verified from the official records on file with the ( sessors, or ( ) County Real Property Office �vcya4, , for every property which abuts and is across a public or private street, or vehicular right-of- way of record, surrounding the applica '- property/ . L (Signature) Sworn to before me this 3161-day of 0-k.) �f , 2000. t LIOI L ►� �, LYNDA M.BONN Notary Public) No TARYNo 0180E 02093Now eWYork Cualified In Suffolk Count!, Term Expires March 8,20 ! 'r PLEASE list, on the back of this Affidavit or on a sheet of paper, the lot numbers next to the owner names and addresses for which notices were mailed. Thank you. f r v Adjacent Property owners to: Robert Frentzel 1900 Old Orchard Lane East Marion,N.Y. 11939 1000-037-2-9.1 37-2-7.1 Bernard&Mary Fisher 520 New Suffolk Ave, Mattituck, 11952 -2-12.4 Peter Manning ,/ 2050 Old Orchard Lane ,East Marion 0( -2-2 Henry Ressmeyer a / P.O. Box 283, East Marion 1}( -2-3 Sally Haupt P.O.Box 112, East Marion -24 Florence Neese / P.O. Box 37, East Marion parcels opposite / -3-8 Doris Miller V P.O.Box 305, East Marion -3-9 Robert and Donna Manley )( 198 Aspinwall St, Westbury 11590 -3-12.1 Kimberly&Joyce McKeon 44 Grant Ave North, Valley Stream , 11580 'I)(/ • .4 ,_', NIP HEESE - 75 N/F MUNCY 064 m u - 150.0 N 58°58'30"E • O 0 in 0 0- //r BILCO DOORS _/ 32 50' - J I I I / l 63 �� r �) 2 STORY a FRAME HOUSE f 36 ,4 f' sB w a45 Lu DECK LR P NEDPA710 / = s O 2 PAVED PATIO O a LOCUST COURT 62 > 2CAR 62 73 GARAGE • 61 w 72 0 a b m m N 0 cn z • 1 555°58'30W 150.0 60 MANNING BASED ON SURVEY FOR ROBERT FRENTZEL EAST MARION TOWN OF SOUTHOLD.N Y. SUFFOLK COUNTY TAX MAP DESIGNATION . 1000.037-2-9 I LOT NO.'S REFER TO MAP OF SECT.2,GARDINERS BAY ESTATES, FILED IN THE SUFF.CO.CLERKS OFFICE AS MAP NO.275 TOTAL AREA:22,500 S.F. •MONUMENT •IRON PIPE SITE PLAN SCALE: I°=30 SD OFFICE OF 41111/ ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 53095 Main Road Southold, NY 11971 (631)765-1809 Fax765-1823 (or 765-9064) July 17,2000 Re: Chapter 58—Public Notice Requirements-August 10,2000 Dear Applicant: Please find enclosed a copy of the Legal Notice describing your recent application. The Notice will be published in the next issue of the Suffolk Times. Pursuant to Chapter 58 of the Southold Town Code(copy enclosed),formal notice of your application and hearingdate must now be mailed with a map or property sketch showing the new location of the area being considered. By Friday.July 21st,please send the enclosed Notice CERTIFIED MAIL, RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED,as soon as possible,with a copy of the project map to all owners of land(vacant or improved) surrounding yours,including land across anystreet or right-of-way that borders your property. Use the current addresses listed on the current assessment records in the Town Assessors'Office(765-1937)or the County Real Property Office in Riverhead. If you know of another address for a neighbor,you may want to send the notice to that address as well. By Monday,July 31st, please complete your Affidavit of Mailing(copy enclosed)with parcel numbers noted for each,and return it to us with the white receipts postmarked by the post office. Later,when the green signature cards are returned to you by the Post Office,please mail or deliver them to us. If any signature card is not returned,please advise the Board at the hearing. A sign is also necessary for posting at the property by you not later f/ian Wednesday,8/2/00,and therefore must be picked up by you or your representative some time,between now and August 1st,between the hours of 8 and 4 p.m. The sign must be located on the property no more than 10 feet from the front property line bordering the street. (If you border more than one street or roadway,an extra sign is enclosed for the front yard facing each.) Thesign(s)must remain in place for at least seven (7)days,and if possible,remaining until the day of the hearing. After the signs have been in place for seven(7)days,please submit your Affidavit of Posting to us(copy enclosed)for our permanent file. When convenient,please also return the sign to us. If you do not meet the deadlines stated in this letter,please contact us promptly. It may be nec- essary to cancel your hearing if the required steps are not followed. Thank you for your cooperation. Very truly yours, _ ZBA Office Enclosures ROBERT FRENTZEL 1000 - 37 -2 -9 . 1 VARIANCE FOR ADDITION REAR SETBACK AUG . 10TH - 7 : 15 PM _ DER: COMPLETE THIS SECTION •���tJII*IMA IEWIA rrVe[•lv1a111ri4i' • Complete items 1,2,and 3.Also cotnplete A Received by(Please Print Llearly) Bi sate .f Delivery item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired. ii 17 3.1 U V • Print your name and address on the reverse so that we can return the card to you. C Sign.ture • Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, 1 ` gent or on the front if space permits X_ �'�/ ? r' I=1 Addressee D. Is delivery ad.ress different from i em 1? 0 Yes 1. Article Addressed to: If YES,enter delivery address below. �No yin y-r (. 1-22/kAV ' V /AY 3 Service Type ❑Certified Mail 0 Express Mail //9,3� 1:1 Registered I=1 Return Receipt for Merchandise ` 0 Insured Mail 0 C.O.D 4. Restricted Delivery9(Extra Fee) El Yes 2 Article Number(Copy from service label) 'o'1 3cfn &Ina o to f acr o PS Form 3811;July 1999 I - i ;, Domestic Return Receipt 102595-99-M-1789 UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE First-Class Mail f. 11 al USPSPostage&Fees Paid Permit No G-10 • Sender: Please print your name, address, and ZIP-I-4 in this box • FAIRWEATHER•E+ OWN ' DESIGN ASSOCIATES,INC. 413•Main Street P.O. Box 521 Greenport, N.Y. 11944 631477-9752(fax)631-477-0973 ■ Complete items 1,2,and 3.Also complete A. Received by(Please Pnnt Clearly) :t�Of'+eliv item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired. l.�)fA • Print your name and address on the reverse C. gnature so that we can return the card to you. 4 _ ■ Agent. • Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, 'k/� ` Adressee or on the front if space permits. D Is delivery address different from item 19 0 Yes 1 Article Addressed to: + If YES,enter delivery address below. 0 No -?TA/KWAS.016A1/ig•Sht( 520 Ale ou H i 3. Service Type • 1 I `q 0 Certified Mail 0 Express Mail 0 Registered 0 Return Receipt for Merchandise ❑ Insured Mail 0 C O.D 4 Restricted Delivery (Extra Fee) 0 Yes 2 Article Number(CopyATIservice label) i i i a + i I i i i !! yy i fia I (hi( liiIi ii ffi Iiili i i Hill i itis 1 t (! { PS:Form 381;1„July 1999 i • ;? Domestic Return Receipt 102595-99-M-1789 !!!!! +! +! ! 11 1I;; i !! I II= } UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE First-Class Mail r Postage&Fees Paid Permit No.G-10 • Sender: Please print your name, address, and ZIP+4 in this box • FAIRWEATHER•BROWN DESIGN ASSOCIATES,INC. 413 Main Street P.O. Box 521 dreenport, N.Y. 11944 631-477-9752(fax)631-477-0973 i• .:s �_ ititiiMiiititttittltl:tiiitttthitailtltttilttititttiiilitti - SENDER: COMPLETE THIS SECTION tKcirigi 1*1 7iaciXottLeATECZ/B»IP/4a' ■ Complete items 1,2,and 3.Also complete A Recewied by(Please Print Clearly) &. D e of Delivery item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired. f'.,1-.E,� F1 * mi- 7 Z1/ G ) a Print your name and address on the reverse C Signat r) i so that we can return the card to you. a 41)() ,---c, M ❑Agent • Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, X f, ,. �ti /"/ 0 Addressee or on the front if space permits. D Is delivery address different from item 1? 0 Yes 1 Article/clAddressed to: If YES,enter delivery address below 0 No ?Til (v�61 mitto, ;2y i ' �' 3 Service Type ri , ,r � 0 Certified Mail ❑ Exp'_ �al - C�{0� /(/q 7 0 Registered ❑ Return".='eipt for(der andise iJ ❑ Insured Mail 0 C.O D. 4 Restricted Delivery'?(Extra Fee) 0 Yes 2. Article Number(Copy from service label) . . '[DR coo .0-01a 040 oft Cro :PS Fbrrii;381+1,July 1999 i , i ;i i iDomestic`Return Receipt 102595-99-M-1789 UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE First Class Mail Postage&Fees Paid USPS Permit No. G-10 • Sender: Please print your name, address, and ZIP+4 in this box • FAIRWEATHER•BROWN DESIGN ASSOCIATES,INC. 413 Main Street P.O. Box 521 Greenport, I .Y. 11944 631-477-9752(fax)631-477-0973 14; 0=•1-= Iiiilliiin ,llitliililiilflliiillltilliluilliehlmilllfIII SENDER: COMPLETE THIS SECTION *<K0h02l»WMITI.Y.9xel/LoletelffI.1441%411' • Complete items 1,2,and 3.Also cotnplete 1 A. Received by(Please Pnnt Clearly) Bs Date of Delivery item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired FL o%CA/66 //EE We-) • Print your name and address on the reverse so that we can return the card to you. C. Signature • Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, . X ``/ ❑Agent or on the front if space permits. jG r� �� ❑Addressee D. Is delivery address different from item 17 0 Yes 1. Article Addressed to. If YES delivery address below. 0 No acre e,-/' 7 N 0NRIOyit /043Y37 jlli w elki- /24,14.6"/ ,lY 2.•'rad(Ct Express Mail /l/73� Isere ❑ Return Receipt for Merchandise /% ❑ Insured Mail ❑C O.D 4 Restricted Delivery?(Extra Fee) 0 Yes 2 Article Number(Copy from service label) /oOct 3o i Do - 6tH C& 0Z.1 i R� ;PS Form 3811:.;July 1999 ;i Domestic Return Receipt 102595-99-M-1789 1 iiii ii .il i iiii ,is it i i . it UNITED STATES-POSTAL SERVICE First-Class Mail 1 1 1 11 I ° PostageUSPS &Fees Paid Permit No.G-10 • Sender: Please print your name, address, and ZIP+4 in this box • FAIRWEATTHER°BROWN DESIGN ASSOCIATES,INC. 413 Main Street P.O. Box 521 Greenport, N.Y. 11944 631-477-9752(fax)631-477-0973 Ir,III,ulllrl,,,l„Irl„IIL„rlri,r,i,I,r,Ii„L,I,,,Iill,,,I SENDER: COMPLETE THIS SECTIONtK•M1»►*r4111►1:m:MercOa[.MI.1011rr4:1+ ■ Complete items 1,2,and 3.Also complete A. Received by(Please Print Clearly) B. PPat? Delivery item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired. S }.kAu'e' 'i(./t7°-6 • Print your name and address on the reverse (((( so that we can return the card to you. C. Si ature • Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, X A-14 / ❑Agent J or on the fro' t if space permits. - ('jddressee D. s delivery5ddress different m item 1? 0 Yes 1 Article Addressed,to:• / . < If YES,enter delivery address below. IKNo A,06,Y //2- gke}74frieffn /vy 3. Service Type 0 Certified Mail 0 Express Mail //Q3 0 Registered 0 Return Receipt for Merchandise 0 Insured Mail 0 C.O.D ` 4. Restricted Delivery?(Extra Fee) 0 Yes 2. Article Number(Coy from service label) (Copy from Ma b+ltil 1,(,4 Fofm;3811,Julii1999i 1 II i s iDomestic Return Receipt 102595-99-M-1789 UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE 1 11 11 First-Class Mail Postage&Fees Paid USPS Permit No.G-10 • Sender: Please print your name, address, and ZIP+4 in this box • . FAIRWEATHER•BROWN DESIGN ASSOCIATES,IIYC. 413 Main Street P.O. Box 521 Greenport, N.Y. 11944 • 631-477-9752(fax)631-477-0973 D ': COMPLETE THIS S • 1 •u• s, s. • Complete items 1,2,and 3.Also complete A. Received (P ease rint Clearly) B Date of•5 livery item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired. ,D,q ?/79 0- l-veff%', ■ Print your name and address on the reverse so can return the card to you. X Si tur� • Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, ,�/tel; c%���'' 0 Agent •or on the front if space permits. 0 Addressee D Is delivery address different from item 19 0 Yes 1 Article Addressed to. If YE e r ry address below 0 , N o _ L /4' ' = /b.6K r ��� 3 ervi,-Type t •-, CerU -` ;• �'Express Mail ` //q�J 0 R -� ❑ Return Receipt for Merchandise ndise 0 Insured Mail 0 C.O.D. 4. Restricted Delivery?(Extra Fee) 0 Yes 2. Article Number(Copy from service label) PS Form 3811,July 1999 Domestic Return Receipt 102595-99-M-1789 UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE 11111 1_ First-Class Mail PostageUSPS &Fees Paid Permit No G-10 - • Sender: Please print your name, address, and ZIP+4 in this box • ,FAIRWEATHER•BROWN DESIGN ASSOCIATES,INC. 413 Main Street P.O. Box 521 Greenport, N.Y. 11944 631477-9752(fax)631-477-0973 DER:COMPLETE THIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY ■ Complete items 1,2,and 3.Also complete A :-ceived b (Please Print CI B Da-of D•livery item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired ./ P4 ( i I .2) 60 • Print your name and address on the reverse ignature so that we can return the card to you. • Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, X El Agent •or on the front if space permits. ,El Addressee D Is delivery address different from item ❑Yes 1 Article Addressed �j to If YES,enter delivery address below 1:1 No WfrA 4A7 /9agP6ve-a2"t $ . i//`-o[ ;71/ 3 Service Type ��/���/// ❑Certified Mail El Express Mail //so El Registered ❑ Return Receipt for Merchandise ❑ Insured Mail ❑ C O.D. • 4 Restricted Delivery?(Extra Fee) ❑Yes 2 Article Number(qopy from service label) . . 1 ; i j . i, ) i , 1 J$ li! i)i I . ! )ii( / iiih ! : 1, ; i i t ' ) PS Form 3$11,July 1999 Domestic Return Receipt 102595-99-M-1789 0 0 I _ _ _ UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE'.Y S "r T' First-Class-Mail : F M ., t -� Postage,&*Fees Paid "'---"'''"7-'''-'- r.,� �` =USPS cn 21 �iiL ,y/ _�- -Permit No.G=10 -y: • Sender: Please prinWyour name, address, and ZIP+4 in this box • FAIRWEATHER•BROWN DESIGN ASSOCIATES,INC. 413 Main Street P.O. Box 521 Oreenport, N.Y. 11944 831-477-9752(fax)631-477-0973 Ii:iiliiiilitisiiliiiiliiiihi„Iiiittlilmili iiliiiiiiliiii - ti_I ' : COM-L HIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY • Complete items 1,2,and 3.Also complete A Received by(Please Pnnt Clearly) • 'gel{very item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired. ' tigili • Print your name and address on the reverse so that we can return the card to you. C Signature ill Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, ' • El Agent • or on the front if space permits. ,•'i��.i 0 jI - -d 2140 !II. Addressee r(deliv_, address differ-. ,m item 1? Id Yes 1 Article •ddressed to• If YES, - ter delivery address below ❑ No .4/ ' / 1--9.fe.fir. ;ill 3Service Type �! \., ❑ Certified Mail ❑ Express Mail /1/ }U(�� El Registered 0 Return Receipt for Merchandise ❑ Insured Mail ❑ C O D 4. Restricted Delivery?(Extra Fee) ❑Yes 2. Article.Number(Copy from service label). i, ; ;i ; • . : t;, : i t , i , {, i;l• It , 1 ,{; ii. tii •iitt I .it l • i . . ?II . i PS Form 3811;July 1999 • Domestic Return Receipt 102565-99-M-1789 i , ii :i ;i; t . : , • , . s. _ ll$ UNITED STATES POSTAL f3VIuE`��6 �p.MEZ U PM .z <-- _-......— — &Fee Por - 4- 2n JUL Y it No._ . ''/pp • Sender: Please print-your name, address, andZtF in Rs'box • FAIRWEATHER'BROWN DESIGN ASSOCIATES,INC. 413 Main Sheet P.O. Box 521 Onzenport, N.Y. 11944 631477-9752(fax)631.477.0973 111111111111$1Ii:1„1,IitIIt .HIllmliiI I1111,L1111111111 • N/F HEESE 75 N/F MUNCY 64 N58°58'30"E _ 150.0 O o O BILCO DOORS it 32.50' O 74 63 ••2 STORY / //E7 FRAME HOUSE /),//15)./ a ' w D2nd ECK tu LR. PAVED PATIO az Q O 2 62 PAVED PATIO9 Q LOCUST COURT 2 CAR CD GARAGE a_ 61 72 w o - m 0 m o oL tu o ( m I z 558°58'30"W 150.0 ■ w z 60 MANNING BASED ON SURVEY FOR ROBERT FRENTZEL EAST MARION TOWN OF SOUTHOLD, N.Y. SUFFOLK COUNTY TAX MAP DESIGNATION : 1000-037-2-9. 1 LOT NO.'5 REFER TO MAP OF SECT.2, GARDINERS BAY ESTATES, FILED IN THE SUFF.CO.CLERKS OFFICE AS MAP NO. 275 TOTAL AREA : 22,500 S.F. • MONUMENT • IRON PIPE SITE PLAN SCALE: 1 "-----20' N/F NEESE 75 N/F MUNCY G4 i q N58°58'30"E ; 150.0 • a O O O is 5 BILCO DOORS r--1 f/i1 ?2.90' -- . r , _11///// G31 '/ ,jOx ////// . �� ) moi' I Y 7 4F/ 7 ' /// FRA ORf10USE 72o4e,f,A, Afi1=D//"// oc.-Lu Hz Q 2nd FLR. Pr�VED // DECK PATIO J• , d / i L Es, o z // a0[ �', PAVED PATIO) LOC .• V� - 2- 0 O > 2CAR t,7 GARAGE • X t / 72� tu 0 p -,--s O L1-1 N m fn