HomeMy WebLinkAboutDE CHIARO, NICHOLASMeeting of 8/18/9Lt f~
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees
DISAPPROVAL of the Waiver Request of JEANNE WflATMOIJ(~H 122-3-38 to
add 15~ x 22' covered porch and reconstruct 6~ x 13~ entryway.
The CAC recommends disapproval because the project is within 75~ of the
wetlands and should be required to obtain a permit. The Council would
approve the.application for a per~mlt.
180 North Riley Drive, Mattituck
Vote of Council: Ayes: Bruce Loucka, Stephen Angell, Robert Kelth, Jack
Hagerty and Allan Connell
Nays: Patricla Isaksen
WR-17
Moved by Al an Connel[, seconded by Jack Hagerty, it was
RESOLVI~D to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees
DISAPPROVAL of the Waiver Request of VINCENT MANETTI 80-5-5.1 to
constructa single' evel deck appro×imateiy 880 s.f. (~0j x 28~).
The CAC recommends disapproval because the pro~ect is within 75* of the
wetlands and should be required to obtain a Dermlt.' The Council would
approve the project when it is submitted as a Wetland Application.
West Shore Drive, Southold
Vote of Council: Ayes: All
Motion carried.
DISCUSSION AND RECOMMENDATION FOR REQUESTS OF NON-JURISDICTION
NJ-9
Moved by Bruce Loucka, seconded by Jack Hagerty, it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees
of the request of Non-Jurisdiction of NI~fIOLAS DiCFilARO
59~1-2~'.5 to construct a house.
The Council strongly feels this project needs the full permit process.
Lake Drive, Southold
Vote of Council: Ayes: All
Motion carried.
DISCUSSION AND RECOMMENDATION OF AMENDMENT TO PERMITS
A-7
Moved by Allan Connell, seconded by Patrlcia Isaksen, it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees APPROVAL
of the Amendment to permit of STEPHEN BUCZAK 115-17-17.11 to add a 10'
w~de gazebo.
Willis Creek Drive. Mattituck
Vote of Council: Ayes: All
Motion carried,
A-8
Moved by Allan Connell, seconded by Stephen Angell, it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees
DISAPPROVAL of the request to Amend Permit submitted by VICTOR E.
~7plans. to add two (2) 6j x 32' floating docks as shown on submitted
Page 3
Albert J. Kmpski, President
John Holzapfel, Vice President
William G. Albesrtson
Martin H. Garrell
Peter Wenczel
BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
Town Hall
53095 Main Road
P.O. Box 1179
Southold, New York 11971
Telephone (516) 765~1892
Fax (516) 765-1823
August 10, 1994
Bruce Loucka
Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council
Southold Town Hall
Main Road
Southold, NY 11971
Dear Lo~cka,
Transmitted herewith are the following applications for a
wetland permit:
LEWIS HECKER SCTM %127-6-3
STEPHEN BUCZAK SCTM ~115-17-17.11
CHIARO SCT~%59-1-21.5
SCTM935-5-37
Please prepare a written report of findings and
recommendations with respect to these applications.
Very truly yours,
Albert J. Krupski, Jr.
President, Board of Trustees
AJK/djh
KE[NNEY'S E EACH CIVIC ASSOCIATION
P, o. Box 88!
SOUTHOLD, NY 11
MOndaY, September 12, t994
Mr. Albert J. Krupski, Chairman
Board of Trustees - Southold Town
Main Read
SOuthold, NY 11971
Re: File # 59-1-21.5
Application of Nicholas DeChiaro
Lake Drive, Southold, NY
Dear Mr. Krupski,
The Kenney's Beach Civic Association has been informed that the above
applicant seeks to obtain a building permit for construction in a D.E.C. designated
wetland area, on Lake Drive, Southold. We are opposed to such proposed construction
on wetlands.
The survey presented to your office, dated July 1994, does not present a
complete view of the extent of the wetlands. These waters are seasonal in nature and
recede considerable during the summer, when the survey was performed. During '~,nter
and spring there are surface waters that cover the entire area. We understand that the
D.E.C. has classified the entire ama as a Typo One VVetland.
The survey does not reveal that there are appurtenances to adjacent properties
that could be adversely affected by the proposed septic tanks, The property of Serge
Rozenbeum, directly across Lake Drive, has its fresh water supply, from a well !oeated
on the front portion, or Lake Drive side, of his property. Another adjacent property may
have a similar well. There are else sprinkler systems, supplied by fresh water wells, in
the area of pt"oposed septic tanks.
Lake Dr ve is composed of an impervious readway, the septic tanks are only five
(5) feet from the road, a spillage across the road is a potential factor to be considered.
Additionally, the septic tanks, as shown under the submitted survey, are only
fifteen (15) feet from the wetlands noted in ;July by the surveyor. The Suffotk County
Health Code requires a one hundred (100) foot margin of safety. Actually the septic
tanks would be directly in wetlands for most of the year.
The proposed dwelling is sited so that two walls, North and West, are only ten
(10) feet from wetlands described in the ,July survey. Dudng the winter and spring
months, the d..~!ing would be directly in wefla~.ds.
Such proposed construction ~poses a serious and detrimenta] danger to the
environment and could adversely affect the health and welfare of the residents in the
area.
Building such a proposed home would undoubtedly involve requiring thousands of
yards of fill. for the house, septic tans, and driveway, as noted on the survey. Several
thousand feet of wetland would be filled in. This proposed building site is directly in, and
adjacent to an important designated fresh water wetland area.
If permitted it would destroy irreplaceable wetlands, alter and damage
topography, have an adverse visual impact, change vegetation, existing surface runoff
would be destroyed, and it certainty would damage wildlife habitat.
Addifienally, it would fill surface waters. It would degrade both sur[ace and
grouna waters, and the uses of both such surface and ground waters would be seriously
cempromised.
The site now provides a habitat for a number of species, including various upland
birds, animals and water fowl. It contains important species of wetland vegetation. Jt is
part of a functioning and productive ecosystem, that provides a wild life nesting habitat
and food production supply, it also serve to absorb excess nutrients in surface waters
and is important in the control of ama flooding.
~n sho~, the environmental impact caused would be pe~anent and serious, it
would severely compromise the entire area. Examining the survey submitted by the
applicant, his intentions is to p~ace a dwelling on proFerty that is perhaps 90% wetland in
the summer and the balance of the year is near t00% wetland.
Our position is that utilizing this parcet for a dwelling wiii substantially violate
section 97-28 of Chapter 97 of the Code of the Town of $outhold, as well as the Suffoid
County Health Code. Utilizing suc, h a site for a building should not be permitted.
We therefore ask that your office keep the Kenney's Beach Civic Association and
its residents informed of any further developments concerning this matter.
Sincerely yours,
president
Mr. P, obert Greene, NYS - DEC
iVlr. Dennis [Vloran, P.E., Suffolk County Board of Health
New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
~,sl~~. Jorllng
o118r
RE: LEAD AGENCY COORDINATIONi REQUEST
The purpose of this reoues~ is to determine under ArIicle 8 (State. Environ-
mental Ouaiity Review - SEQR) of the Environmental Conservation Law and 6 NYCRR
Part 617 the following:
Your agency's interest in acting as lead agency;
Your agency's jurisdiction in the action oescribed below; and
Issues of concern which your agency believes should De evaluated.
Enclosed is a copy of ~ne permit application ano a completed Part
Environmental Assessment Form to assist you in responding.
Project Name:
1 of the
DEC Project Number:
SEQR Classification: [ ] Type I [~Unlisted
Contact erson:
DEC Position:
[~DEC has no objection to your agency or another agency assuming lead agency
status for this action, but reserves the right to comment on this action if
a positive determination of significance is made.
[]
DEC has no objection to your agency or another agency assuming lead agency
status for this action, out we have the following concerns regarding this
project (see "comments" below).
[ ] DEC wishes to assume lead agency s:a~us for this action.
[]
The proposed action has been identified by DEC as occurring wholly or
partially within or substantially contiguous to a critical environmental
area (CEA) that was designated by
It is the position of this Department that your agency, if it has a juriS-
diction over the action, should assume the lead agency role based on the
existence of the CEA ano the fact that the anticipated impacts are
primarily of local significance.
Other. (See commen:s below)
Comments (Optional):
Response:
Please respond to this reauest within 30 days of the date of this letter.
If no response is received within 30 days, we will assume that you have no
objection to DEC or another agency assuming the role of lead agency, aha have no
comments to offer regarding the proposed action at this time. If neither your
agency nor any other involved agency, including DEC, has indicated a will-
ingness to serve as lead agency within 30 days of this letter:
[ ] We will petition the Commissioner of DEC to designate a lead agency
for this action.
[ ] We will petition the Commissioner of DEC to designate your agency as
lead, presuming you have jurisdiction.
Please feel free to contact this office for further information or
discussion.
Enclosures
cc: (see distribution
list)
Sincerely,
KF. NN EY'S BEACH CiViC ASSOCIATION
SEP
,,'T~O~,OUTHOLD
Monday, September 'i2, 1994
Mr. Al Krupski, Chairman
Southold Town Board of Trustees
Main Road
Southold, NY. 11971
Re: Application file 59-1-21.5
Dear Mr. KJ'upski,
Enclosed please find a petition signed by 40 home owners in the
immediate area of Lake Ddve and Leeton Drive that oppose development on this
wetland property.
Since this wetland area is fragile, we look to you and your fellow Trustees
to preserve this property.
Sincereiy,
· ent '
KENNEY'S BEACH CIVIC
P. O. BOX No. 881
$OUTHOLD, N. Y, 11971
TOYVN OF SOU'
September 5, 1984
Southold Tov~ Board
Town Hall
Southold L.I. 11972
of Trustees
Re Application file
No.59-1-2!.5
DeChiaro
Please be advise~ that as Property Owners residing in. the Kennys
Beach area, we are opposed to contemplated ~e~elop~ent of property
on wake Drive on wetland lots.
We would appre$iate the To~m Boar~ keeping us advised of any
developments or meetings concerning the application to ouild
on this property.
We si~ our names and addresses underneath to indicate that as
resT~nts in the immediate area of this prope~d constrmction,
we support the a~tion of the Kennys Beach Civic Association,
in opposing the use of this wetland property to build upon.
/ix &
~0
JAY DEMPSEY REAL ESTATE
TOV N OF SO_UTHOLD__
P. O. Box 5 Cutcho§ue, NY 11935-0005 (516) 734-6058
August 5, 1994
Jill Doherty
Southold Town Trustees
Town Hall
Main Rd
Southold, NY 11971
Re:
Dear Jill~
Enclosed is survey of property for my client Nicholas
will be applying for a building permit for Mr. DeChiaro.
Please advise as to if Trustee Permit will be required.
Thanks..
Sincerely,
JD/sp
DeChiaro
Lake Drive, Southold
1000-059-01-21.5
DeChiaro. I
enc:
t