Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCAVALIER, JOSEPHBOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hail, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 TELEPHONE (516) 765-1801 May 13, 1982 Mr. Dennis Santolo Dept. of the Army New York District Corps of Engineers 26 Federal Plaza New York, N. Y. 10278 Re: Public Notice No. 11119-82-060-L2 Dear Mr. Santo!o: The Board of Trustees of the Town of Southold would like to request a thorough investigation into the navigational problems that might occur should the above application of Joseph Cavalier be approved. Of all the waters in the town, this area of Mattituck Creek presents the greatest problem in reference to safety. The Cavalier property and the Petersen property adjoining it to the east form an abrupt turn in the channel that, along with the narrowness of the channel, creates this problem. Fishermen and boaters alike have complained that even now, without additional boats docked in this area, visibility and maneuver- ability around this corner are difficult. We would be more than happy to meet with one of your representatives at the site to discuss this further, so that all concerned would be in- formed. We have previously met with Chuck ~tamilton of the DEC in Stony Brook for just such a purpose and would hope your department would arrange for a meeting in the immediate future. Looking forward to your prompt reply, I remain for the Trustees for the Town of Southold, Sincerely, Paul Stoutenburgh, President Sou~hold Town Trustees BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES Town of Southold twain Road Southold, ~Wew York ] 1971 P/1 Rev~ NOTICE OF ACTION - i~OT A PER'lIT En Consultants, Inc. for Joseph Cavaliere 1. Your application, doted January 22, 1982 ..................................................................... has been reviewed bY this Board, et a meeting of the Trustees he d on .A.~ril 7. 1982 and resulting in the action, os indicated below: ( ............ ) (_..x..x...x...) Application approved. Application denied. Application tabled. 2. Commemsand remarks: Application to construct a dock, ramp, bulkhead and to dredge in Ma ttituck Creek, Mattituck, was tabled until the application of Howard Petersen is filed, so as to deal with the two applications a~ the same time. , A PER~IT FEE 3. J¢ ~,our aapiicatiOn iS aa.oroved above, ,~ ?L~rm~i' ,--F--~, iS now due, and should be made poycb e to ~e order o( the Board of SouthoJd Town Trustees T ' the. Schedule or Rate n, -¢* ¢~h ' .L , . . . ¢.hts fee ~s co~put~ below according to pazd wzthzn 90s~' 6~"~ ~i~t'%~n~e~E~r~-~]~- ~hzs fg~ ~ust be t ee is D~id i~ pecan to th~ 5ecref~ o¢ the 8~rd, ~f the some time. If the ~e is p~id by m~il, the De~i~ will be ~Hed in r~y. Computgtion o¢ Permit Fee: Total Fee for this cppiicadon ................................ Clerk BO/ Telephone 516-765-1938 So 11971 March 23, 1982 To: }{oward Petersen From: Frank Kujawski, Vice President Re: Informational Meeting The Southold Town Board of Trustees will hold an informational meeting on Tuesday, March 30, 1982, at 7:30 PM, at the Town Hall, Main Road, Southotd, New York, in regard to the application of Joseph Cavalier to construct a dock, ramp, bulkhead and to dredge in Mattituck Creek, Mattituck. BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES Town of Southolcl Main Road Southold, New York 11971 To; EnConsultants for Joseph Cavalier I. Your application; doted ............ ..J..a...n..u..a...r.k;.,.2...2.,.....1..9...8,,2. ..................... has been reviewed by this Board, at a meeting of the Trustees held on March 2, 1982 and resulting in the action, as indicated below: Application approved. Application denied. Application tabled. 2. Commentsandremarks: Tabled, as the parties involved were not prese~nt. The Board will discuss this matter with those involved at a special meeting. 3. If your application is approved above, A Permit Fee is now due, and should be made payable to the order of the Soard of 5outhold Town Trustees. This fee is computed below according to the Schedule of Rates as set forth in the nsrruction Sheet IForm l/l). if the Permit Fee is oaid in person to the Secretorv of the Board, The Perm t will be ob?ainable at the same time. If the -fee is paid by mail, the per'it will be mailed in reply. Computation of Permit Fee: Total Fee for this application ............ .¢,%,a~ Board of Southold Town Truste~. New York Ste~a D~q~rtment of Env~ronmen[al Conservstlon ~at~:y. Alfa/rs %~it Building 40 ~ SU~/ StOn. y Brook, ~ 11794 Ro~r~ F. Flack~ 1982 ~. J~ith T. Terry T~n Clerk To~n of 53095 ~ P.O. Box 728 Sou+J~.o!d~ NY 11971 natic~ of Significanca Application for ~tland peri, ts ~ Enco~sul~nt~ for JoSh Ca~Llier to dredge and create a n~orin§facility for cc~arcial ~sels at ~t?cituck Creek~ Southold~ ~Tf Dear Ms. Terry I am %~it/~g in response to your letter of February_,.; t0 ~ 1982 our ~c~c ph~%e conve.~atic~s !~gam6/ng establi~t of lead agaucy and ~te~-minatica of signific~nca in accordan~ with SEQP~ Although this project is c~Dp~sed by staff of our Bu~au of Tidal P~t!ands dk~ to its lJke!y des%ruc~c~ of ~*etl~, ~ r~f~ae~s ~I ~t ~e s~ ~d ~t~ of ~ w~d ~d w~e~rel~ i ha~ been L~ cc~tact ~rith ~r. Pa'di StotI~cbe~g~ P!~sidant of the T~ T~s ~d ~ ~td ~ ~at ~ T~e~s ~ for ~ p~]ect not wi~% ~e ~tl~ b,~ ~l~ ~e c~a~ion of a ~s~ h~d e~ ~viga~ I ~ b~m of ~ ~c~i~ ~ ~ a~ja~t 1~- ~, P~ ~g ~r~, for a ~ p~j~t of ~ he ~ %%th a ~ ~h~ hea~g '~ ~nd o~ Till ~'~ ~ for Ms~ Judi~_b T. Terrf Page 2 you for your continued omoperatic~ wi~h regard to ~se Sincerely Dzvid Fm Ridder .Associate En~rc~menta! A~lyst A~ ~ Sro ~, Southoid To~a %~z~tees Col. W. Smitl% N. Ch~p~ USDOD, ELmH and Witdli~ Se~zice R~ l~ma R. Haje~ ~z~m~oltants Lnc. D. Cole .,% D£P)~RT~£NT OF TH£ AR~Y N~-w YO~C. N.Y. ~.0278 NANOP-E APPLICATION NO .- 8 2)- 0 6 0. 13 April 1982 PUBLIC NOTICE NO. 11119-82-060-L2 TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: This Discrict~has~rece~ved an application for a Department of the Army permit pursuant to Section-10 of ,the River and Harbor Amc of 1899 (30 Stat. 1151; 33 U.S.C. 403; Section 404~of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act ~mendments of 1972 (PL 92-500, 86 Stat. 816~, 33 U.S.C. 1344); __/7 Section 103 of the Marine Protection, Research and Sanctuaries Act of 1972, as amended (PL 92-532~ 86 Stat. 1052, 33 U.S.C. 1413). APPLICANT: Mr. Joseph Cavalier 2022 Central Road Fort Lee, New Jersey 07024 WORK: WATERWAY: LOCATION: Dredging~ Riprap, Mattituck Creek Town of Southold, Walkway, and Ramp Suffolk County, New York A detailed description and plans of the .proposed work are inclosed Co assist in your review of the proposal. The decision whether Co issue a permit will be based on an evaluation of the probable impact Of the proposed activity on the public interest. ThaC decision will reflect the national concern for both protection and utilization of important resources. The benefit which reasonably may be expected to accrue from the proposed work must be balanced against its reasonably foreseeable detriments. Ail factors which may be relevant to the proposed work will be considered; among those afc conservation, eco- nomics, aesthetics, general environmental concerns, historic values, fish and wildlife values, flood damage prevention, land use, navigation, recreation, water supply, water ~ua!ity, energy needs, safety, food pro- duction and, in general, the needs and welfare of the people. NANY FL-129 Aug 78 NANOP-E PUBLIC NOTICE NO. 11119-82-060-L2 A preliminary review of 'the application indicates that an Environmental Impact Statement will not be prepared. A review of the latest publish- ed version of the National Register of Historic Places and of the pre- sence or absence of registered properties or properties listed in the latest published version of the Register as being eligible for inclusion, therein, has been made. Presently unknown archeological, scientific, prehistorical or historical data may be lost or destroyed by work to be accomplished under the required permit. The evaluation of the impact of the activity on the public interest will include application of the guidelines promulgated by the Adminis- trator, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, under authority of Sec- tion 404(b) of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act or of the criteria established under authority of Section 102(a) of the Marine Protection, Research and Sanctuaries Act of 1972, as appropriate. Any person may request, in writing, within the comment period specified is this notice, that a public hearing be held to consider this appli- cation. Requests for public hearings shall state, with particularity, the reasons for holding a public hearing. The following government authorization(s) has(have) been obtained or will be obtained prior to the issuance of a Department of the Army permit: A permit and Water Quality certificate from the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Any criticisms or protests regarding the proposed work should be PREPARED IN WRITING AND MAILED TO REACH THIS OFFICE prior to 14 May 1982 otherwise it will be presumed that there are no ob- jections. It is requested that you communicate the foregoing information con- cerning the proposed work to any persons known by you to be interested and who did not receive a copy of this notice. If you have any questions concerning .this application, you may coqtact Mr. Dennis Santolo of this office,rTelephone No. 212-264- O183. 2 Incls: W. M. SMITH, Jr. 1. Description of Work Colonel, Corps of Engineers 2. Plans District Engineer NANY FL-129-2 Aug 78 L~UAY NANOP-E APPLICATION NO. 82-~60 PUBLIC NOTICE NO. 11119-82-060-L2 DESCRIPTION OF ~DRK The applicant, Mr. Jose,] Cavalier proposes to create a mooring for co~uercial vessels in Mattituck Creek~ Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York. The area, as shown on the attached drawing, would be d/edged by clamshell to a maximum depth of 7 feet below the plane of mean low water. Approximately 3,000 cubic yards of dredged material, which is 50% sand and 50% gravel, would be removed initially. Future dredging operations would be performed as required over the life of the permit, 10 years, if issued. The dredged material would be placed on the adjacent ~upland area, graded and topped witch bluestone to provide an access drive. ~and parking area. The shoreline would be stabilized by placement of stone riprap and planting of Spartina alterniflora in the t~oper half of the intertidal zone. A 4 foot wide timber walkway, supported on pilings, would be installed to provide pedestrian access~ and two 6' x 40' ramps wou]~d be installed to provide vehicular access to the boats. The proposed work would destroy approximately 1500 sg~are feet of S~artina alterniflora and approximately 4600 square feet of S~artina ~atens. The applicant would create approximately 1000 square feet of S~artina alterniflora. The applicant states the proposed work is required to create a commercial mooring facility for 2 to 3 cormmercial work beats. ~ do BOAI~D OF TO~z'N TRUSTEES Town of Southold l%tain Road Southold, New York 11971 NOTICE OF ACTION - NOT A PERMIT To: EnConsultan~zs, Inc. for Joseph Cavalier 1. Your oppIkofion, doted January 22, 1982 ................ ' ............................................. hca been reviewed by this Board, at o meeting of the Trustees held om iVia~ 4. 1982 and resulting [n the action, as bdkated below: xxx ( ............ Application approved. Application denied. APP~Fetion tab[ed. 2. Comments and remarks: Tabled until and Army Corps of Engineers. the Trustees hear from the DEC A PERz~IZT FEE 3. If-y0ur c~p[[qstion iS aur~roved nbove, R~,--a~t,m~_l e~ is now du~ and ~ouid be mode p~b[e to t~,brder of the Boarc of SouthoJd Town ~rustees T - ' the. S~nedul¢ of Rates as set f~h ;~ ,~_ ~ . _. - ~_h~s fee ,s computed below accordina to paz~ wztnzn 90 G~vs 6~"~2~f~r~nee fF rm 1/l . his at the same time. If . u ,n person re me ~ec, eta~ of the Board, The Permit will be ~?ainb%i~~ the fee is paid by moil, the pe~it will be moi[ed in rep}y. Computation o{ Permit Fee: Total Fee for ~his application ........................ t! ........................... $ ............................ -. Pres. Boar -;'<:~ .~.-.~,,,~ Clerk ,. r ............................ * League of Women Voters of Riverhead-Southold, New York R~R. l~ B~x 209A:~ Mat~ituck~ N.Y; May 3, 1982 Mr. Paul Stomte~ourgh~ President Members of the Southold Town Trustees Tov~nHall Somthold~ New York ll9?l Gentlemen: We respectfully reque~-t that no. decision be rendered by the Southold Town Trmstees 'regarding the applications of JQs~eph~a~'alier ~nd HOward Peteraon until the Dept. of Environmental Conservation ~d the Army Corp. of E~gineers ha~e evaluated the impact of the applicants ~ojects. Lydma Tortor~ Chairman Natural Resources Lea~gme of Women Voters Riverhead/Southold EN-CONSUL TANTS, INC. 64 NORTH A~AIN STREET, SOUTHAMPTON, NEW YORK 11968 ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES 516-283- 6360 April 12, 1982 Southold Town Board of Trustees Town Hall Main Road Southold, N.Y. 11971 Re: Joseph Cavalier with Northville Industries, Inc. Dear Sirs: I regret that circimstances beyond my control prevented me from attending your meeting of April 7, 1982 at which you further discussed the above referenced application. Captain John Dudley of Northville and Dr. Thomas Samuels both attended and informed me of the discussion which took place. The Board recommends that more of the point be removed so that vessels moored there will be fnmther south. This poses a problem to Northville due to the type and size of the craft to be moored .there and the configuration of the parcel. As can be seen from the survey with which you have been supplied, the width of the parcel decreases as one progresses southward. Therefore, the more of the point which is removed, the closer to the property line vessels would be moored until the point when they would extend over it which would be an infringment upon the rights of the adjacent owner. As presently proposed~ a 30' x 85' barge would be tied parallel to the main section of the dock. A 20' work boat would be tied to the westerly 25' n-s section of the dock in a n-s direction. Assuming the dock and dredging were to be moved to the south further, it would not be possible to accomodate these vessels in this manner. A significant inconvenience of ~r~asting the smaller ~ork boat to the barge would result where it would have to be moved every time the barge was moved. Southold Town Trustees The amounn of the point to be removed was determined by taking into account the vessels which will use the facility and the impact of the project upon navigation and the environment. It can be shown that vessels to be moored under the proposed conditions will extend ~o further into the waters of Mattituck Creek than the present shoreline and that no impediment to navigation will accrue. Due to these special circzmstances~ we request that you consider our original application un~hanged. I shall shortly apply to you and other regulatory agencies for a dredging and dock project on the Petersen property directly to the east of the Cavalier parcel. While I can understand your desire to review both at the same time, I believe it would be unfair to both parties if approval of one would be contingent upon approval of the other, lhe proposed usage differs as do other conditions. Therefore, each should s~and on its own merits. Please accepn these comments in your further review of the proposal and contact me with a date for any future meetings. CC: Capt. Dudley Sincerely~ Roy L. Haje March 30, 1982 Jose Almodovar, Corps of Army Engineers, has made a preliminary investigation of the Joseph Cavalier property and finds the proposed projecz does not effect navigation; however there is a question of the wetlands. He will submit his report to his of£ice today~ 20~i 94~78t89 A/4 ~l~ev. 6/72 ~ ~ ~ ' ~_~ Town Of Southol~ ~~~- ~ Main Road ~ pro~ect involve the use of WHTkANDS ~s defined in the Southold Town Ordinance _~ in Wetlands? YES~. If it does, your application must be filed through fhe Town Clerk's Office. 2. Applican~s name and address: Eh-Consultants, Inc.~ 64 North Main St 7 Southam ton,NY f.O2 .J.O~¢Pk .~.f.g~.~.igr~ 2022-Central Rd x Fort Lee. New Jersey 0702z 3. Contractor's name and address: .... BP.g...Y~%..afl~g~D~ ................... 4. Explain briefly the purpose of this application: .....(SI~8..A2Tb~J~4]~.D.). .................... 5. After issuance of Permit, I expect to: (mark with an X) (a) Commence work-- AT ONCE ............ ; ASAP ...X.....; UNKNOWN TIME ............ (b) Complete work, in -- I DAY ............ ; I MO....X. ....... ; 1 YR. ............ ; FUTURE ............ 6. Secure the correct Area Map from the Secretary of this Board, and by using an X WITHIN A CIRCLE as a mark, indicate as closely as possible the location of this work. On the reverse side of this map, 9rovide a SCALE DRAWING which will show the Ordinary High Water Mark and the size and shape of the structure or work. Ail dimensions offshore of the O. H. W. M. should also be shown and include any free standing pilings which will remain at completion. 7. Provide the following documents: (a) A Licensed Engineer's Survey of the property involved. (b) A copy of the Contrector's Plans and Specifications. 8. Has any prewous application for this work been denied by any other local government agency? 2xSll~ior NO. If it has been, nome the agency ........................................................................... Dete ~f denial ........................................ 9. If dredging is contemplated, give your estimate of the following. (a) Average depth of water at M. k. W.where dredging, . .................... 0 ft. (b) Maximum depth of dredging below the bottom ................................................... .7 ......... ft. (c) Maximum length of dredged area ......................... . ....... 60 ft. (d) Maximum width of dredged aree ............................ ;.0. O:... (e) Maximum amount of material to be dredged ...................... $.,.0.0.0 .......... c. yds. if filling is expected, give your estimate of the following: (a) Maximum amount of material required,. ................................................................... c. yds. (b) Explain how fill wili be obtained and where it will be placed. ]0. 11. !n requesting approval of this application, I submit that: ! am the person accountable for the performance of the work in accord with the plans and specifications attached hereto; I have read or am familiar with the provisions of any Southald Town OrdJna.~ce pertinent to the work involved; and further, I intend to adhere ~9~qd ab~heZerms and Conditions of the Permit. ' L. S. Accepted by: d ~Deted~ BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES Town Of Southold Southold, New York 11971 Main Road Rev. APPLICATION FOR A BULKHEAD, DIKE, OR JETTY A RaP 1. Does this project involve the use of WETLANDS as defined in the Southold Town Wetlands Ordinance? YES or NO. If it does, you must file through the Town Clerk's Office. 2. Is the proposed work entirely within the boundaries of your own groperty as substantiated by your Deed or Survey? YES or NO. If it is, a Permit is NOT required from this Board, but the Town Building Inspector should be contacted for full details. 3. Applicant's name and address: ................... .A.-~..~.~.. ^ ............................................................... ou. rs, zro ....... 4. Cant ractor's name and add ress: ..jC~-cr2~..~..~-~... ......................... L..~.......~.../.....'~...?.] .?.~..6~ 5. F~ploin briefly the purpose of this application: ....................................... 6. After issua.nce of Permit, I expect to: (mark with an X) (a) Commence work -- AT ONCE ............ ; ASAP ...'..~.......; UNKNOWN TIME ............. (b) Complete work in,- 1 DAY ............ ; 1 MO ..... .~......; 1 YR ............. ; FUTURE ............. 7. Secure the correct Area Mop from the Secretary Of this Board, and by using an X WITHIN A CIRCLE as a mark, indicate as closely as possible the loca.tion of this project. On the reverse side, provide a SCALE DRAWING which will show Ordinary Hig'h Water ~Mark as well as the size and shape of the structure or work to be done. Also include all dimensions for portions which extend offshore from the O. H. W. M. 8. Provide the following documen.ts: (al A Licensed Engineer's Survey of the property involved. (b) A copy of the Contractor's Plan and Specifications. 9. Does this project extend into Town Waters beyond .an imaginary line or boundary formed by existing works of a similar nature along this area's shoreline? ~ NO. If it does, state the approximate distance beyond, ............ ft. i0. Will this construction require lhe Filling of any land offshore of the Ordinary High Water Me:rk or the Dredging of a,ny material from Town Lands under water? YES c;-'NO. If it does, Form A/4 (Application for Dredging/Filling} must be completed and attached as part of this application. Accepted by: In requesting approval of this application, I submit tho,t: the information presented herein is true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief; I am the person accountable for the performance of the work [n accordance with the plans and specifications attached; I have read or am familiar with the provisions of any Southold Town Ordinance pertinent to the work involved; and further, I intend to, adhere to and abide by the Terms and Conditions of the Permit, when 'and if issued to me. .......... ................................. BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES Town Of Southold Main Road Southold, New York 11971 APPLICATION FOR FIXED and 'or FLOATING DOCKS ............................................................ ! ............. L ........... .......... 2. Contractor s name and address: ........ ./...~....'..~......~ ........................................................ After issuance of a Permit, i expect to: (marl< by an X) (a) Commence work AT DNCE ............ ; ASAP ..~.~......,; UNKNOWN ............. (b) Complete work in -- 1 DAY ............. 1 MO....'..~.......; I YR ............. , FUTURE ............. Secure the correct Area Map from the Secretary of this Board, and by using an X WITHIN A CIRCLE indicate as closely as possible the location of this dock. On the reverse side of this map, provide a SCALE DRAWING which will show Ordinary High Water Mark, the shape and size of the dock and any supplemente pilings which ore needed to hold a floating dock or tie-up a boat. Give all dimensions necessary to determine the area of the dock surface which extends offshore from the O. H. W. M Will any portion of this construction extend offshore into Town Waters beyond an imaginary line or boundary formed by other similar structures along the area's shoreline? ~ NO. If it docs extend beyond this so-called dock line indicate by how far, approximately,. ......... ft. Provide the following documents: (a) A Licensed Engineer's Survey of the property involved. (b) A copy of the Contractor's Plans and Specifications. Will this construction require the Filling of any land offshore of the Ordinary High Water Mark or the Dredging of any material I:rom Town Lands under water? YES ,~, ~45. If it docs, Form A/4 (Application for Dredging/Filling) must be completed and attached os pa,rt of this application. n requesting approval of this application, I submit that: the information presented herein is true and correct to the best of mv knowledge and belief; am the person accountable for the performance of the work in occ(~rdance with the plans and specifications attached; I have read or am familiar with the provisions of any Southold Town Ordinance pertinent to the work involved; and further, I intend ~o adhere to and abide by the Terms and Conditions of the Permit, when and if issued to me. f~ccepfed by:. Dated: ! .... , 'bescrlption for Jose~ Cavalier Create a mooring for commercial vessels as follows: 1.Remove 3,000 '~ c.y. of granular material from existing shore and upland to create a mooring area approximately 100 ft. by 60 ft. Proposed dei~th Of dredging wtll be 7 ft. belo~ MLW. 2. Stablize shoreline by use of stone rip-rap and SL~artina alterniflora plantings in upper half of intertidal area to be created. 3. Install 4 ft. wide timber walkway supported on pilings as pedestrian access to boats. Install two 6' by /~0' ramps to provide vehicular access to boats. 5. Spotl to be placed on adjacent upland graded and topped with bluestone to provide access drive and parking area. 6. Install diesel fuel storage tank for use of boats and bring wa~er power and telephone connections to site. A storage trailor is also to be placed on adjacent upland. 5 ~ ipti ph -~ .. . esot on for Jose Cavalier Create a mooring for commercial vessels as follows: 1.Remove 3,000 - c.y. of granular material from existing shore and upland to create a mooring area approximately 100 ft. by 60 ft. Proposed depth of dredging will be 7.ft. below MLW. 2. Stablize shoreline by use of stone rip-rap and SRartina alterniflora plantings in upper half of intertidal area to be created. 3. Install 4 ft. wide timber walkway supported on pilings as pedestrian access to boats. 4. Install two 6' by 40' ramps to provide vehicular access to boats. 5. Spoil to be placed on adjacent upland graded and topped with bluestone to provide access drive and parkiug area. 6. Install diesel fuel storage tank for use of boats and bring water power and telephone connections to site, A storage trailor is also to be placed on adjacent upland.