Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutTR-8367 F Glenn Goldsmith,President �Q soury Town Hall Annex Michael J.Domino,Vice-President h�V� ��� 54375 Route 25 P.O.Box 1179 John M.Bredemeyer III Southold,New York 11971 A.Nicholas Krupski G Q Telephone(631) 76571892_ Greg Williams �� �� Fax(631) 765-6641 �yCouffN BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD September 17, 2020 Henry & Mary Pat Mulholland 2440 Village Lane Orient,-NY 11957 " RE: 2440-VILLAGE LANE, ORIENT SCTM# 1000-26-1-17.1 ,- Dear Mr. and Mrs. Mulholland: The following action was taken by the Southold Town Board of Trustees at their Regular Meeting held on Wednesday;:September"16;"2020, , RESOLVED, that the Southold Town Board of Trustees APPROVE the request for a Transfer of Wetland Permit#8367 from John & Sarah Henry to Henry & Mary Pat Mulholland, as issued on February 19, 2014. Any other activity within 100' of the wetland boundary requires a permit from this office. This is not a determination from any other agency. If you have any questions, please contact our office at (631) 765-1892. Sincerely, Glenn Goldsmith, President Board of Trustees GG/dd Glenn Goldsmith,President QF so Town Town Hall Annex �k —-- -- - - -54375 Route 25 Michael J.Domino,Vice-President ,`O l0 P.O.Box 1179 John M.Bredemeyer III l [ Southold,New York 11971 A.Nicholas Krupski G Q Telephone(631) 765-1892 Greg Williams , �O �� Fax(631) 765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE 1755C Date: September 16, 2020 THIS CERTIFIES that the existing fixed"J" shaped pier that consists of an 8'x152' shore- perpendicular section and 10'x36' and 10'x17' shore parallel sections; as-built repairs consisting of the installation-of new 2"x10"untreated decking and the replacement of inside pilings cans and stringers; and Qoposed-repairs consisting_of the installation of additional 2"x10"untreated decking and replacement of additional 10" inside pilings 6"x6"cAps and outside stringers and 4"x6"tnstde stringers; At 2440 Village Lane,Orient Suffolk County Tax Map#1000-26-1.47.1 Conforms to the application for a Trustees Permit heretofore filed in this office Dated January 24,2014 pursuant to which Trustees Wetland Permit#8367 Dated Februn 19,2014 was issued and conforms to all of the requirements and conditions of the applicable provisions of law. The project for which this certificate is being issued is for the existing fixed"J"shaped bier that.consists of an 8'x152' shore`perpendicular section and 10'x36' and 10'x17' shore-parallel sections; as-built r_pairs consisting of the installation of new 2"x10"untreated decking and the replacement of inside pilings caps and stringers-, and proposed repairs consisting of the installation of additional 2"x10" untreated decking and Leplacement of additional 10"inside pilings 6"x6"caps and outside stringers,and 4"x6"inside stringers. The certificate is issued to Henry&Mary Pat Mulholland owners of the aforesaid property. Authorized Signature John M. Bredemeyer III, President o~gpFFO(,pco Town Hall, 53095 Main Rd. Michael J. Domino, Vice-President Gs P.O. Box 1179 James F. King y Southold, NY 11971 Charles J. Sanders oy Telephone (631) 765-1892 Fax (631) 765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD YOU ARE REQUIRED TO CONTACT THE OFFICE OF THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES 72 HOURS PRIOR TO COMMENCEMENT OF THE WORK, TO MAKE AN APPOINTMENT FOR A PRE-CONSTRUCTION INSPECTION. FAILURE TO DO SO SHALL BE CONSIDERED A VIOLATION AND POSSIBLE REVOCATION OF THE PERMIT. INSPECTION SCHEDULE Pre-construction, hay bale line 1St day of construction % constructed Project complete, compliance inspection BOARD OF SOUTHOLD TOWN TRUSTEES SOUTHOLD, NEW YORK PERMIT NO. 8367 DATE: FEBRUARY 19, 2014 ISSUED TO: JOHN & SARAH HENRY PROPERTY ADDRESS: 2440 VILLAGE LANE, ORIENT SCTM# 26-1-17.1 AUTHORIZATION Pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 275 of the Town Code of the Town of Southold and in accordance with the Resolution of the Board of Trustees adopted at the meeting held on February 19, 2014, and consideration of application fee in the sum of $500.00 paid by En-Consultants and subject to the Terms and Conditions as stated in the Resolution, the Southold Town Board of Trustees authorizes and permits the following: Wetland Permit for the existing fixed "J" shaped pier that consists of an 8'x152' shore-perpendicular section, and 10'x36' and 10'x17' shore-parallel sections; as-built repairs consisting of the installation new 2"x10" untreated decking and the replacement of inside pilings; caps and stringers; and proposed repairs consisting of the installation of additional 2"x10" untreated decking and replacement of additional 10" inside pilings, 6"x6" caps and outside stringers, and 4"x6" inside stringers, and as depicted on the survey prepared by Nathan Taft Corwin III, Land Surveyor, last dated February 4, 2014, and stamped approved on February 19, 2014. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the said Board of Trustees hereby causes its Corporate Seal to be affixed, and these presents to be subscribed by a majority of the said Board as of this date. John M. Bredemeyer III- recused ~~o~g0EF0(,~~0 - y~ol Ar ~a~' TERMS AND CONDITIONS The Pennittee, John & Sarah Henry, residing at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, New York as part of the consideration for the issuance of the Permit does understand and prescribe to the following: 1. That the said Board of Trustees and the Town of Southold are released from any and all damages, or claims for damages, of suits arising directly or indirectly as a result of any operation performed pursuant to this permit, and the said Permittee will, at his or her own expense, defend any and all such suits initiated by third parties, and the said Permittee assumes full liability with respect thereto, to the complete exclusion of the Board of Trustees of the Town of Southold. 2. That this Permit is valid for a period of 24 months, which is considered to be the estimated time required to complete the work involved, but should circumstances warrant, request for an extension may be made to the Board at a later date. 3. That this Permit should be retained indefinitely, or as long as the said Permittee wishes to maintain the structure or project involved, to provide evidence to anyone concerned that authorization was originally obtained. 4. That the work involved will be subject to the inspection and approval of the Board or its agents, and non-compliance with the provisions of the originating application may be cause for revocation of this Permit by resolution of the said Board. 5. That there will be no unreasonable interference with navigation as a result of the work herein authorized. 6. That there shall be no interference with the right of the public to pass and repass along the beach between high and low water marks. 7. That if future operations of the Town of Southold require the removal and/or alterations in the location of the work herein authorized, or if, in the opinion of the Board of Trustees, the work shall cause unreasonable obstruction to free navigation, the said Permittee will be required, upon due notice, to remove or alter this work project herein stated without expenses to the Town of Southold. 8. That the said Board will be notified by the Permittee of the completion of the work authorized. 9. That the Pennittee will obtain all other permits and consents that may be required supplemental to this permit, which may be subject to revoke upon failure to obtain same. 10. This permit does not convey to the permittee any right to trespass upon the lands or interfere with the riparian rights of others in order to perform the permitted work nor does it authorize the impairment of any rights, title, or interest in real or personal property held or vested in a person not a party to the permit. John M. Bredemeyer III, Pent ~OFFOLKC49 .Town Hall Annex Michael J. Domino, Vice-President 54375 Route 25 James F. King at P.O. Box 1179 Charles J. Sanders 10 Southold, NY 11971 Dave Bergen ao~ Telephone (631) 765-1892 1 Fax (631) 765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD February 19, 2014 Mr. Robert E. Herrmann En-Consultants 1319 North Sea Road Southampton, NY 11968 RE: JOHN & SARAH HENRY 2440 VILLAGE LANE, ORIENT SCTM# 26A-17.1 Dear Mr. Herrmann: The Board of Town Trustees took the following action during its regular meeting held on Wednesday, February 19, 2014 regarding the above matter: WHEREAS, En-Consultants on behalf of JOHN & SARAH HENRY applied to the Southold Town Trustees for a permit under the provisions of Chapter 275 of the Southold Town Code, the Wetland Ordinance of the Town of Southold, application dated January 24, 2014, and, WHEREAS, said application was referred to the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council and to the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program Coordinator for their findings and recommendations, and, WHEREAS, the LWRP Coordinator recommended that the proposed application be found Inconsistent with the LWRP, and, WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees has furthered Policy 6.3 of the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program to the greatest extent possible through the imposition of.the . following Best Management Practice requirements: the issuance of permit on structure in its existing configuration; and WHEREAS, a Public Hearing was held by the Town Trustees with respect to said application on February 19, 2014, at which time all interested persons were given an opportunity to be heard, and, 2 • • WHEREAS, the Board members have personally viewed and are familiar with the premises in question and the surrounding area, and, WHEREAS, the Board has considered all the testimony and documentation submitted concerning this application, and, WHEREAS, the structure complies with the standards set forth in Chapter 275 of the Southold Town Code, WHEREAS, the Board has determined that the project as proposed will not affect the health, safety and general welfare of the people of the town, NOW THEREFORE BE IT, RESOLVED, that for the mitigating factors and based upon the Best Management Practice requirement imposed above, the Board of Trustees deems the action to be Consistent with the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program pursuant to Chapter 268-5 of the Southold Town Code, and, RESOLVED, that the Board of Trustees approve the application of JOHN & SARAH HENRY for the existing fixed "J" shaped pier that consists of an 8'x152' shore- perpendicular section, and 10'x36' and 10'x17' shore-parallel sections; as-built repairs consisting of the installation new 2"x10" untreated decking and the replacement of inside pilings, caps and stringers; and proposed repairs consisting of the installation of additional 2"x10" untreated decking and replacement of additional 10" inside pilings, 6"x6" caps and outside stringers, and 4"x6" inside stringers, and as depicted on the survey prepared by Nathan Taft Corwin III, Land Surveyor, last dated February 4, 2014, and stamped approved on February 19, 2014. Permit to construct and complete project will expire two years from the date the permit is signed. Fees must be paid, if applicable, and permit issued within six months of the date of this notification. Inspections are required at a fee of $50.00 per inspection. (See attached schedule.) Fees: $ 50.00 Very truly yours, Michael J. Domino Vice-President, Board of Trustees MJD/amn 0 John M. Bredemeyer III, President ~$pfFO(,t- Town Hall Annex V-- Michael J. Domino, Vice-President @4 CMG- 54375 Route 25, P.O. Box 1179 James F. King (°n = Southold, NY 11971 Charles J. Sanders Telephone (631) 765-1892 y~~! laa Fax (631) 765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD TO: En- Con Spl+arn-Is' -fir Sohn-f- Sarah Uevlw_ Please be advised that your application dated has been reviewed by this Board at the regular meeting of and your application has been approved pending the completion of he following items checked off below. Revised Plans for proposed project Pre-Construction Hay Bale Line Inspection Fee ($50.00) 1st Day of Construction ($50.00) Constructed ($50.00) Final Inspection Fee ($50.00) Dock Fees ($3.00 per sq. ft.) Permit fees are now due. Please make check or money order payable to Town of Southold. The fee is computed below according to the schedule of rates as set forth in Chapter 275 of the Southold Town Code. The following fee must be paid within 90 days or re-application fees will be necessary. You will receive your permit upon completion of the above. COMPUTATION OF PERMIT FEES: TOTAL FEES DUE: $ SO • DO BY: John M. Bredemeyer III, President Board of Trustees 4 E_ 0- R E C~_! " , SURVEY OF PROPERTY SITUATE FFB - 7 2014 ORIENT JONNDNENRY FEB - 7 2014 bl. Lin } a ° 4pV >T " Sullt" m'. I,. rl; TOWN OF SOUTHOLD ' \ 1J1~ Ti's RoarddTll,='.~i~. SUFFOLK COUNTY, NEW YORK S.C. TAX No. 1000-26-01-17.1 N 61 0 fl 00, SCALE 1 "=20' 14 APPROVED BY VED BY FEBRUARY 1, 2012 MAY 10, 2012 ADDED DOCK NOTE ° BOARD OF TRUSTEES 'TRUSTEES MAY 17, 2012 ADDED CZM LINE 5. ' \ e TOWN OF SOUTHOLD SOUTHOLD NOVEMBER 1, 2013 CORRECT SOUTH PROPERTY LINE LOCATION FEBRUARY 4, 2014 ADD ADDITIONAL NOTES s \ Y q DATE. n/ I AREA = 12,024 sq. ft. (TO TIE LINE) 0.276 Inc. VENERAL NOTES: DOCK REPAIR NOTES ARE FROM OWNER AND OTHER CONSULTANTS. a01 a o \ \ ,gy 4A ]q ~ TYPICAL DETAIL OF DOCK REPAIRS, PLAN AND SECTIONAL VIEWS SCALE: 1" = 10' *11FE ,E I rI1N<rE ;I - Tu ~i 1-F I' I FIII, IIbIFEP r1-11 FI_ 1 ° -FII 1111 FII 5\ ` 9 / \ 111 FE- NlII- TaiI(a I I -U~ ST111,[IF T~F• I, _IIISIDETl/IFF ~~r [ 1, Al I- mF,i Fine D mnLd IT nF oI !,-i P \ 104 i. • ~a., ~ + r~i ~-F' - T -"F 'I- F VV DI IT k IF El I E , EXISTING FIXED TIMBER DOCK TO BE PERMITTED PURSUANT TO \ a f~ eb\ 'a Y"/ T I' III-IFI II \ CHAPTER 275 FOR THE PURPOSE OF ESTABLISHING THE ABILITY 1 1, -1 1 11 TIE, I ]I TO UNDERTAKE "ORDINARY AND USUAL MAINTENANCE," I.E.. ACTIONS °y,\ i NOT AFFECTING MORE THAN 75N OF THE STRUCTURE. AND/OR "NORMAL - MAINTENANCE" AS DEFINED BY CHAPTER 777, I. E., "PERIODIC \ \ `"AO \ REPLACEMENT OR REPAIR OF SAME-KIND STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS OR \ I Ago 16 PROTECTIVE COATINGS WHICH DO NOT CHANGE THE SIZE, DESIGN, OR PROPOSED REPAIRS TO EXISTING FIXED TIMBER DOCK AS OF 6/11/13 INCLUDE: FUNCTION OF A FUNCTIONING STRUCTURE" AND WHICH "DOES NOT bb se 1) AS-BUILT REPAIRS FOLLOWING HURRICANE IRENE. INCLUDING INSTALLATION REQUIRE A COASTAL EROSION MANAGEMENT PERMIT" PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 717. \ I~ ~,'a OF NEW 2" x 10" UNTREATED DECKING AND REPLACEMENT OF STORM ' (THE TOTAL COST OF REPAIRS MAY NOT EXCEED 50X OF THE ESTIMATED FULL \ YP~ GZ $y\ DAMAGED INSIDE PILINGS, CAPS, AND STRINGERS (ACTUAL COST = $16,450) 2) PROPOSED REPAIRS DUE TO DAMAGE CAUSED DURING HURRICANE SANDY, REPLACEMENT COST OF THE STRUCTURE AT THE TIME OF REPAIR, AS ANY \ I~ Tp _ •a0 INCLUDING REPLACEMENT OF ADDITIONAL 10" INSIDE PILINGS, 6" x 6" CAPS SUCH REPAIR WOULD CONSTITUTE A "RESTORATION" AND REQUIRE A COASTAL \ 1 \Nyi~,~ ~L _ AND OUTSIDE STRINGERS, AND 4" x 5" INSIDE STRINGERS; AND INSTALLATION EROSION MANAGEMENT PERMIT PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 111). I A a i 'Sa • 5.0~ OF ADDITIONAL 2" x 10" UNTREATED DECKING (ESTIMATED COST = $6,700) CPA -.A tp. 4) TOTAL COST OF AS-BUILT AND PROPOSED STORM DAMAGE REPAIRS = $27,150 3) ESTIMATED FULL REPLACEMENT COST OF DOCK AS OF 4/6/13 = $202,700 I 5) TOTAL COST OF AS-BUILT AND PROPOSED REPAIRS AS PERCENTAGE OF RON, pt~ES I a ` HEOCE ESTIMATED FULL REPLACEMENT COST OF DOCK = 13.4% ~ ~ (11 M51p5 PNO ~ cM+c~iweci . ' REPUOG ~2i1M0Eas SHG ON 83.33' W Ep o cK w caD V 52'()O\ 1N5SP 5fGt 0 fNtS 55 cP. / / / / 5 B SSN,N P\lE , / / /Wa ( 0 B k1 K PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE Wn THE MINIMUM 1 yc<O` wNs` JOBN N5 R'DfiA! BREDEATEYER ro 'k JfiAR R. n STANDARDS FOR TIRE SURVEYS AS ESTARUSHED h.P~N J E EUCH U LIALS. b ~ED TAOPTTED FOR SUCH U ATE D ASS r^ TC 10 / REPLACE (2) INSIDE PILES y ,EE T ~ n . s , s ST / / KING "two sv~`,/ / REPLACE (4) INSIDE PILES N.Y.S. Lic. No. 50467 TO THIS UNAUTHORIZED SURVEY AGOmON TO Nathan Taft Corwin III THIS SURVEY IS IS A A VIOLATION OF SECTION 7209 OF THE NEW YORK SLATE Surveyor EDUCATION W. Land COPIES OF LAW. THIS SURVEY MAP NOT BEARING THE LAND SEALS AL INKED SEAL SSE TO BE ED SEAL SHALL NOT BE CONSIDERED TO BE A VAUa TRUE COPY. CE"nCATDNS INDICATED HEREON SHALL RUN SUCCess.r To: Stanley J. Isaksen, Jr. L.S. ONLY TO THE PERSON FOR WHOM THE SURVEY Joseph A. Ingegno LS. IS PREPARED, AND ON HIS BEHALF TO THE TNLE COMPANY. GMRNMENTAL AGENCY AND Tithe Survey! - Subdivisions - Site Plans - Construction Layout LENDING INSTITUTION USIED HEREON, AND TO THE ASSIGNEES OF THE LENDING IN6II- PHONE (631)727-2090 Fax (631)727-1727 TUIION. CERRRCATHMS ARE NOT 1RANSFERARLE. OFFICES LOCATED AT MAILING ADDRESS THE EXISTENCE OF RIGHT OF WAYS 1586 Main Road P.O. Box 16 AND/OR EASEMENTS OF RECORD, IF James ut, New York 11947 Jomesport, New York 11947 ANY, NOT SHOWN ARE NOT GUARANTEED. Po 0 0 John M. Bredemeyer III, President o~~1FFQj/( pG Town Hall Annex Michael J. Domino, Vice-President s~ 54375 Route 25 James F. King °w = P.O. Box 1179 Charles J. Sanders c Southold, NY 11971 'yl~p a0~ Telephone (631) 765-1892 Fax (631) 765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD February 26, 2014 Mr. Eric R. Bredemeyer PO Box 522710 Marathon Shores, FL 33052 Dear Mr. Bredemeyer. The enclosed Errata Sheet Notice of Error submitted by you during; the Board of Trustees hearing of February 19, 2014 was not accepted and admitted as part of the record of this application. Consequently, these documents are being returned to you. If you have any questions or comments, please contact the Board of Trustees regarding this matter. Sincerely, Michael J. Domino Vice President, Board of Trustees p ECG°' MAR 1 9 2014 March 12, 2014 To Whom It May Concern: Enclosed, please find a check for $50 for a permit approved by the Trustees for repairing our dock at 2440 Village Lane, Orient. If you have any questions, please call me at 212-724-5041 or e-mail me atjohnhenry2360@yahoo.com. -J ~ Sincerely John Henry Nunemaker, Amanda From: Nunemaker, Amanda Sent: Monday, February 10, 2014 10:32 AM To: 'Eric Bredemeyer' Subject: RE: Bredemeyer Family Trust FOIL Fees and Copies Attachments: henry file_20140210083155.pdf; henry file_20140210083724.pdf Mr. Bredemeyer, I have received all fees due and have attached two separate attachments. The first one includes all documents received in the Henry file from December 2, 2013 forward; and the second attachment includes (3) three surveys that have been added to the file since 12/2/13 which have been copied in "pieces" since our Town copier cannot accommodate copies larger than 11"x17". I will go to the Ink Spot either today or tomorrow to obtain full-size copies of the three surveys to give to your brother Jay. Have a nice day! Amanda From: Eric Bredemeyer rmailto:mysauireCcbembaramail.com] Sent: Monday, February 10, 2014 12:18 AM To: John Bredemeyer; Nunemaker, Amanda; Cantrell, Elizabeth Subject: Re: Bredemeyer Family Trust FOIL Fees and Copies On 2/9/2014 2:18 PM, John Bredemeyer wrote: Hi Liz and Amanda, Acting in my individual capacity as co-trustee of the Bredemeyer Family Trust (and not as Town Trustee), I just received a request from my brother, Eric, that I pay FOIL fees pursuant to the Bredemeyer Trust's recent FOIL request, which I shall do when picking up those items. Eric also requested that I pick up all hard copies directly from you (and/or the print-shop as necessary) instcad of moiling aim copies to him. I Ic rcitermed his reyucst flMl you kindl} send him ekxIn nie cupids of the FUII, maleriak as ~\clI. On behalf of the Bredemeyer Family Trust, we wish to thank you for your assistance in this matter. Jay Amanda: Yes, I spoke with my brother "Jay" (John) who will pickup the photocopies Amanda already made and pay the $17.00 for photocopies and the print-shop fee for the 3 surveys. So Jay will fetch the "paper stuff," however, if you would as Amanda and I (Eric) discussed email me scans of the photocopied materials as soon as you can. Thank you. t Nunemaker, Amanda From: Nunemaker, Amanda Sent: Tuesday, February 11, 2014 8:02 AM To: 'Eric Bredemeyer' Subject: RE: Bredemeyer Family Trust FOIL Fees and Copies No problem. I have the full-size copies of the surveys in hand and will give to Jay next time he comes into the office. From: Eric Bredemeyer rmailto:myss wre(alembargmail com] Sent: Monday, February 10, 2014 6:59 PM To: Nunemaker, Amanda Subject: Re: Bredemeyer Family Trust FOIL Fees and Copies On 2/10/2014 10:31 AM, Nunemaker, Amanda wrote: Mr. Brederneyer, I have received all fees due and have attached two separate attachments. The first one includes all documents received in the Henry file from December 2, 2013 forward; and the second attachment includes (3) three surveys that have been added to the file since 12/2/13 which have been copied in "pieces" since our Town copier cannot accommodate copies larger than 11"x17". I will go to the Ink Spot either today or tomorrow to obtain full-size copies of the three surveys to give to your brother Jay. Have a nice day! Amanda From: Eric Bredemeyer rmailto:mysyuire(cbembargmail com] Sent: Monday, February 10, 2014 12:18 AM To: John Bredemeyer; Nunemaker, Amanda; Cantrell, Elizabeth Subject: Re: Bredemeyer Family Trust FOIL Fees and Copies On 2/9/2014 2:18 PM, John Bredemeyer wrote: Hi Liz and Amanda, Acting in my individual capacity as co-trustee of the Bredemeyer Family Trust (and not as Town Trustee), I just received a request from my brother, Eric, that I pay FOIL fees pursuant to the Bredemeyer Trust's recent FOIL request, which I shall do when picking up those items. Eric also requested that I pick up all hard copies directly from you (and/or the print-shop as necessary) imlctid of mailing m I \ cohics to him. I Ic Icitcratcd his ICq(IL5( Ihat vnI ),UldlV" send hiIII clec(ronir collies of the I ()II materials as \4cll. On behalf of the Bredemeyer Family Trust, we wish to thank you for your assistance in this matter. t Jay Amanda: Yes, I spoke with my brother "Jay" (John) who will pickup the photocopies Amanda already made and pay the $17.00 for photocopies and the print-shop fee for the 3 surveys. So Jay will fetch the "paper stuff," however, if you would as Amanda and I (Eric) discussed email me scans of the photocopied materials as soon as you can. Thank you. Respectfully, Eric Eric Bredemeyer 305-609-7488 Amanda: Thank you. R/ Eric Bredemeyer 2 Nunemaker, Amanda From: Eric Bredemeyer <mysquire@embargmail.com> Sent: Monday, February 10, 2014 6:59 PM To: Nunemaker, Amanda Subject: Re: Bredemeyer Family Trust FOIL Fees and Copies On 2/10/2014 10:31 AM, Nunemaker, Amanda wrote: Mr. Bredemeyer, I have received all fees due and have attached two separate attachments. The first one includes all documents received in the Henry file from December 2, 2013 forward; and the second attachment includes (3) three surveys that have been added to the file since 12/2/13 which have been copied in "pieces" since our Town copier cannot accommodate copies larger than 11"x17". I will go to the Ink Spot either today or tomorrow to obtain full-size copies of the three surveys to give to your brother Jay. Have a nice day! Amanda From: Eric Bredemeyer [mailto:mysquireC embaromail.com] Sent: Monday, February 30, 2014 12:18 AM To: John Bredemeyer; Nunemaker, Amanda; Cantrell, Elizabeth Subject: Re: Bredemeyer Family Trust FOIL Fees and Copies On 2/9/2014 2:18 PM, John Bredemeyer wrote: Hi Liz and Amanda, Acting in my individual capacity as co-trustee of the Bredemeyer Family Trust (and not as Town Trustee), I just received a request from my brother, Eric, that I pay FOIL fees pursuant to the Bredemeyer Trust's recent FOIL request, which I shall do when picking up those items. Eric also requested that I pick up all hard copies directly from you (and/or the print-shop as necessary) instead o('rnailiu any cohice to him. I le reiterated his rryoc;I that ~olj kindk Send him electronic conic, of the PUII_ maleriak as well. On behalf of the Bredemeyer Family Trust, we wish to thank you for your assistance in this matter. Jay Amanda: Yes, I spoke with my brother ".lay" (John) who will pickup the photocopies Amanda already made and pay the $17.00 for photocopies and the print-shop fee for the 3 surveys. So .lay will fetch the "paper stuff," however, if you would as Amanda and I 1 (Eric) discussed email me scans of the photocopied materials as soon as you can. Thank you. Respectfully, Eric Eric Bredemeyer 305-609-7488 Amanda: Thank you. R/ Eric Bredemeyer z Nunemaker, Amanda From: Eric Bredemeyer <mysquire@embargmail.com> Sent: Monday, February 10, 2014 12:18 AM To: John Bredemeyer; Nunemaker, Amanda; Cantrell, Elizabeth Subject: Re: Bredemeyer Family Trust FOIL Fees and Copies On 2/9/2014 2:18 PM, John Bredemeyer wrote: Hi Liz and Amanda, Acting in my individual capacity as co-trustee of the Bredemeyer Family Trust (and not as Town Trustee), I just received a request from my brother, Eric, that I pay FOIL fees pursuant to the Bredemeyer Trust's recent FOIL request, which I shall do when picking up those items. Eric also requested that I pick up all hard copies directly from you (and/or the print-shop as necessary) IIUtca,I o nYIIIInL' anc cupid to I J n I I Ir rrilantcd hI,, rcLlucat that %ou kindlti wild him ckkif „rii( enhi~r:01 1l1k IOII 111alcrialsa,t~r1 l. On behalf of the Bredemeyer Family Trust, we wish to thank you for your assistance in this matter. Jay Amanda: Yes, I spoke with my brother ".lay" (John) who will pickup the photocopies Amanda already made and pay the $17.00 for photocopies and the print-shop fee for the 3 surveys. So Jay will fetch the "paper stuff," however, if you would as Amanda and I (Eric) discussed email me scans of the photocopied materials as soon as you can. Thank you. Respectfully, Eric Eric Bredemeyer 305-609-7488 a. Cantrell, Elizabeth From: Cantrell, Elizabeth Sent: Tuesday, February 25, 2014 10:57 AM To: Neville, Elizabeth Subject: RE: FOIL for Village Lane Betty, I will forward you all that you have requested, however, please be advised that everything you will receive from this office has already been submitted to Mr. Bredemeyer in a timely fashion and as requested by each of his FOILS. Sincerely, Elizabeth Cantrell From: Neville, Elizabeth Sent: Tuesday, February 25, 2014 9:43 AM To: Cantrell, Elizabeth Cc: Norklun, Stacey Subject: FW: FOIL for Village Lane Elizabeth, Would you please send me all of the documents and files you have in the Trustee Office on the Eric Bredmeyer FOIL since 12/2/13, 1 will have Stacey scan them and return them immediately. Please call me with any questions. Thank you, Betty Neville Elizabeth A. Neville, MMC Southold Town Clerk PO Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Tel. 631765-1800, Ext. 228 Fax 631 765-6145 Cell 631466-6064 From: Norklun, Stacey _ Sent: Monday, February 24, 2014 8:52 AM To: Neville, Elizabeth Subject: FOIL for Village Lane The attached file is the only file on Laserfiche for this property, it is the file he already has. There is no backside to the permit, I checked the file and have placed a note in Laser stating that the back of the permit page is blank. t 1 Cantrell, Elizabeth From: Eric Bredemeyer <mysquire@embargmail.com> Sent: Monday, February 24, 2014 6:42 PM To: Neville, Elizabeth Cc: Cantrell, Elizabeth; Norklun, Stacey Subject: Re: 2nd Request FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 On 2/23/2014 6:09 PM, Neville, Elizabeth wrote: Eric, I am sorry you are having such problems with your FOIL. I believe you pretty much requested any and everything associated with 2440 Village Lane, Orient, so I don't believe you should have to file another foil request. I will see what I can do for you in the morning. Again, my apologies, Sincerely, Elizabeth A. Neville, MMC Southold Town Clerk PO Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Tel. 631 765-1800, Ext. 228 Fax 631 765-6145 Cell 631 466-6064 From: Eric Bredemeyer fmailto:mysquireCulembargmail.com] Sent: Sunday, February 23, 2014 1:14 PM To. Neville, Elizabeth; Neville, Elizabeth; Cooper, Linda Subject: Fwd: Re: 2nd Request FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 Dear Ms. Neville: I hope all is well with you. I was at Town Hall and the Annex in person this past week. On Tuesday, February 18, 2014, I was at the Town Trustee Office with some file access questions for Ms. Cantrell (Trustees' Clerk) who was very helpful because she indicated that she had just that day received the LWRP Report for the Dock Wetland Application for 2440 Village Lane, Orient, which within it contained a copy of a "grandfathered permit" issued to a Gerald Dorman from 1995 apparently not known during the period of the pending application at 2440 Village Lane. I offered to complete a new FOIL request in order to get a copy of LWRP Report and its attachments and we discussed my still open FOIL request of February 2, 2014 (which I provide again as the "string" and attachments to this email today of February 23, 2014, and of which she had a copy in her files). She determined then that I need not complete another FOIL request and I paid for the copies which she gave. I also discussed with her that the "grandfathered permit" copy provided me was the face side but on it was mentioned additional terms and conditions on the reverse side and had not been provided me. She could not find a copy of the reverse side of the "grandfathered permit" for me. It made sense to me that I did not need another FOIL request 1 since my FOIL of February 2, 2014, still even until today remains open for the Legal Department (including but not limited to Lori Hulse) as stated in my FOIL FORM and Cover Letter, both again are attached to this email today. I still have not received anything from Legal for the updated period since December 2, 2013 and continuing until filled. I left the Trustees Office and returned the next day on February 19th, 2014, only to be asked by Ms. Cantrell to now fill out a new FOIL request for the copies I had been provided the day before. She was quite insistent. I explained that such a new form could confuse matters since there was still remaining responses from my pending FOIL Request of February 2, 2014. She advised that your Office had been the source of the change on the need for the Form since the day before. I advised her that I would speak with you. I left the Trustee Office and went over to Town Hall only to be advised that you were still out of Town at the meeting of the Associations of Towns. Since you had been out of town I figured I would wait until either I saw you or email you as I am doing now. At the Trustee Hearing on the evening of February 19, 2014, I also learned that there is a copy of an application apparently associated with the "grandfathered (dock) permit" of Gerald Dorman from 1995. I have never been provided a copy of this "old" application in any of my FOIL requests to the Town Of Southold. I attach my request of November 10, 2011, as one of my previous requests for your convenience. [ I write this as Co-Trustee of the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust as Brother John "Jay" Brcdemeyer III remains in a recused status.] PURPOSE My purpose(s) in this email in hand of 2/23/2014: (1) To obtain the updates of requested materials from the Legal Department, including but not limited to Attorney Lori Hulse, updates since December 2, 2013 to present per my FOIL Request of 2/2/14. (Please note Ms. Neville's email of 12/13/13 in response to a prior FOIL Request contained Legal Department materials under cover letter of 12/9/13 of Ms. Hulse thereby reflecting that there is no objection to providing such materials.) (2) (a) To obtain copies of the reverse side of the "grandfathered permit" and (b) the associated application of Gerald Dorman and anyone else from 1995. Please see my attached letter and request from November 11, 2011. (3) To express my willingness to complete another FOIL Form for items provided me on 2/18/14, if required, but subject to the clarification that I have not closed out or been provided those materials requested in ITEMS (1) and (2) of this PURPOSE portion immediately Above. Please let me know when I might get these outstanding materials and if I can be of assistance to you and Ms. Cantrell by completing a new (but perhaps superfluous) FOIL Form for the Items provided on 2/18/14. I appreciate your assistance. If you or your Office would please acknowledge this email and let me know same is being processed/worked upon. Also, please also let me know when I might expect to receive scanned and emailed copies of the outstanding materials requested from my 2/2/14 FOIL Request. Of course, please be sure that any materials withheld are fully identified as to their location, description and dates so that I may consider an appeal of the withholding. Please call if any questions. Thank you again. It is truly unfortunate that my Brother's recused situation makes these matters so difficult for you and of course, my parents. Respectfully, 2 Eric Eric R. Bredemeyer, Co-Trustee TELEPHONE: 305-609-7488 On Behalf of the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust P.O. Box 522710 Marathon Shores, FL 33052 Dear Betty: Thank you for your reply of last evening. I look forward to the filling on my outstanding FOIL. Let me know if any additional questions. Thanks. R/ Eric Eric Bredemeyer, Co-Trustee Telephone: 305-609-7488 On Behalf of the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust P.O.Box 522710 Marathon Shores, FL 33052 3 Cantrell, Elizabeth From: Cantrell, Elizabeth Sent: Monday, February 24, 2014 9:32 AM To: Neville, Elizabeth Cc: Hulse, Lori; Norklun, Stacey Subject: RE: Re: 2nd Request FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 Good Morning Betty, I just wanted to share with you a bit of information for you regarding the grandfather permit Mr. Bredemeyer discusses. An application for an existing dock on this property has been ongoing for just shy of two years. All throughout that time until February 18, 2014, the office of the Board of Trustees, the permit expeditor for the property owner, and the property owner themselves were not aware of any permits or grandfather permits for the dock structure on this property. This office received a copy of said permit only a couple of hours before Mr. Bredemeyer stopped in asking to see the file to which I informed him of what was only just found, and the file was brought out and opened up in front of him for his full review of all of its contents. If anyone I mentioned was familiar with this grandfather permit, it would have absolutely been a part of this dock application and would have been submitted to Mr. Bredemeyer under his FOIL requests. Sincerely, Elizabeth Cantrell From: Neville, Elizabeth Sent: Sunday, February 23, 2014 6:10 PM To: 'Eric Bredemeyer' Cc: Cantrell, Elizabeth; Norklun, Stacey Subject: RE: Re: 2nd Request FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 Importance: High Eric, I am sorry you are having such problems with your FOIL. I believe you pretty much requested any and everything associated with 2440 Village Lane, Orient, so I don't believe you should have to file another foil request. I will see what I can do for you in the morning. Again, my apologies, Sincerely, Elizabeth A. Neville, MMC Southold Town Clerk PO Box 1179 Southold.NV 11971 1 el. 631 765-1800. Ext. 228 Pax 631 765-6145 Cell 631 466-6064 From: Eric Bredemeyer [mailto:myNuireC embargmail com] Sent: Sunday, February 23, 2014 1:14 PM 1 To: Neville, Elizabeth; Neville, Elizabeth; Cooper, Linda Subject: Fwd: Re: 2nd Request FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 Dear Ms. Neville: I hope all is well with you. I was at Town Hall and the Annex in person this past week. On Tuesday, February 18, 2014,1 was at the Town Trustee Office with some file access questions for Ms. Cantrell (Trustees' Clerk) who was very helpful because she indicated that she had just that day received the LWRP Report for the Dock Wetland Application for 2440 Village Lane, Orient, which within it contained a copy of a "grandfathered permit" issued to a Gerald Dorman from 1995 apparently not known during the period of the pending application at 2440 Village Lane. I offered to complete a new FOIL request in order to get a copy of LWRP Report and its attachments and we discussed my still open FOIL request of February 2, 2014 (which I provide again as the "string" and attachments to this email today of February 23, 2014, and of which she had a copy in her files). She determined then that I need not complete another FOIL request and I paid for the copies which she gave. I also discussed with her that the "grandfathered permit" copy provided me was the face side but on it was mentioned additional terms and conditions on the reverse side and had not been provided me. She could not find a copy of the reverse side of the "grandfathered permit" for me. It made sense to me that I did not need another FOIL request since my FOIL of February 2, 2014, still even until today remains open for the Legal Department (including but not limited to Lori Hulse) as stated in my FOIL FORM and Cover Letter, both again are attached to this email today. I still have not received anything from Legal for the updated period since December 2, 2013 and continuing until filled. I left the Trustees Office and returned the next day on February 19th, 2014, only to be asked by Ms. Cantrell to now fill out a new FOIL request for the copies I had been provided the day before. She was quite insistent. I explained that such a new form could confuse matters since there was still remaining responses from my pending FOIL Request of February 2, 2014. She advised that your Office had been the source of the change on the need for the Form since the day before. 1 advised her that I would speak with you. I left the Trustee Office and went over to Town Hall only to be advised that you were still out of Town at the meeting of the Associations of Towns. Since you had been out of town I figured I would wait until either I saw you or email you as I am doing now. At the Trustee Hearing on the evening of February 19, 2014, 1 also learned that there is a copy of an application apparently associated with the "grandfathered (dock) permit" of Gerald Dorman from 1995. 1 have never been provided a copy of this "old" application in any of my FOIL requests to the Town Of Southold. I attach my request of November 10, 2011, as one of my previous requests for your convenience. [ I write this as Co-Trustee of the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust as Brother John "Jay" Bredemeyer III remains in a recused status.] PURPOSE My purpose(s) in this email in hand of 2/23/2014: (1) To obtain the updates of requested materials from the Legal Department, including but not limited to Attorney Lori Hulse, updates since December 2, 2013 to present per my FOIL Request of 2/2/14. (Please note Ms. Neville's email of 12/13/13 in response to a prior FOIL Request contained Legal Department materials under cover letter of 12/9/13 of Ms. Hulse thereby reflecting that there is no objection to providing such materials.) (2) (a) To obtain copies of the reverse side of the "grandfathered permit" and (b) the associated application of Gerald Dorman and anyone else from 1995. Please see my attached letter and request from November 11, 2011. (3) To express my willingness to complete another FOIL Form for items provided me on 2/18/14, if required, 2 but subject to the clarification that I have not closed out or been provided those materials requested in ITEMS (1) and (2) of this PURPOSE portion immediately Above. Please let me know when I might get these outstanding materials and if I can be of assistance to you and Ms. Cantrell by completing a new (but perhaps superfluous) FOIL Form for the Items provided on 2/18/14. I appreciate your assistance. If you or your Office would please acknowledge this email and let me know same is being processed/worked upon. Also, please also let me know when I might expect to receive scanned and emailed copies of the outstanding materials requested from my 2/2/14 FOIL Request. Of course, please be sure that any materials withheld are fully identified as to their location, description and dates so that I may consider an appeal of the withholding. Please call if any questions. Thank you again. It is truly unfortunate that my Brother's recused situation makes these matters so difficult for you and of course, my parents. Respectfully, Eric Eric R. Bredemeyer, Co-Trustee TELEPHONE: 305-609-7488 On Behalf of the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust P.O. Box 522710 Marathon Shores, FL 33052 Original Message Subject:Re: 2nd Request Fwd: FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 Date:Wed, 05 Feb 2014 20:41:15 -0500 From:Eric Bredemeyer <mysquire c~,embargmail.com> To:Cooper, Linda <Linda.Cooper(c~,town.southold.ny.us> Linda: You are correct that the attachments are basically contained in my cover email received by Ms. Neville and forwarded to you. Just in case you need them I am sending the attachments here for you as it appears that Ms. Neville's Blackberry did not. Again let me know if any questions arise. And, if you would let me know that you did get the attachments, too. Thanks. R/ Eric Eric Bredemeyer on 2/5/2014 2:51 PM, Cooper, Linda wrote: > Mr. Bredemeyer, > I did receive your request that was forwarded to me by the Town Clerk however it did not contain any attachments. The email itself seemed to contain all the info you were requesting so I have forwarded your request to the Trustees' Office and the Town Attorney's Office. > Linda J. Cooper > Deputy Town Clerk 3 > Town of Southold > 631-765-1800 > To reach the highest peak you must first believe you can. > -----Original Message----- > From: Eric Bredemeyer [mailto_ ysquire@embargmail,._com] > Sent: Wednesday, February 05, 2014 8:22 AM > To: Neville, Elizabeth; Cooper, Linda > Subject: Re: 2nd Request Fwd: FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 > On 2/4/2014 8:35 PM, Neville, Elizabeth wrote: I am sorry I am out of the office. Therefore, I am forwarding your request to my Deputy, Linda Cooper for processing. Betty Neville Sent from my Verizon Wireless B1ackBerry From: Eric Bredemeyer <mysquire@embargmail.com> Date: Tue, 4 Feb 2014 18:50:39 -0500 To: <Eli.zabeth Neville@town.southold.ny.us>; Neville, Elizabeth<E.Neville@town. southold.ny.us> Subject: 2nd Request Fwd: FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 Dear Ms. Neville: I am sending my email FOIL request again also with its enclosures. I understand you have had weather events in the Town, but wanted to be sure you got my request. In my prior dealings with your office you were always fast and courteous in acknowledging by return email receipt of my request. I am not sure if you got it, but want to be sure. Thanks. I hope you fared well with the snow. R/ Eric Bredemeyer (phone 305-609-7488) Original Message Subject: FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 Date: Sun, 02 Feb 2014 20:10:56 -0500 From: Eric Bredemeyer <mysquire@embargmail...com>_<mailto~squire@embargmail.com> » To: Elizabeth Neville@town.southold_ny.us<mailto:Elizabeth.Neville@town.southold.ny.u - S> Ms. Elizabeth A. Neville Town of Southold Freedom of Information Officer REQUEST OF FEBRUARY 2, 2014 RE: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST--Application for Public Access to Records on the PROPERTY AT 2440 Village Lane (f/k/a Bay Ave.), Orient, NY 11957 in Suffolk County the matter of proposed dock permit and its related applications/materials District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1 and its predecessor Lot designations 16 and 17; property is owned by The Henrys Dear Information Officer Neville: 1.Attached please find my completed Form requesting copies of the subject property records. Please consider this request as my request for an update of any records/materials on the subject property received, generated or on file with/by the Town of Southold Board of Trustees, Attorney Hulse and Legal Department since December 2, 2013 and continuing to present (NOTE: not before Dec. 2, 2013). Please call or email 4 if any questions. Thanks. This request is an update and also I have limited the offices within the TOS government. 2. My parents now both in their 90's have relegated much of their affairs to their two sons, John M. Bredemeyer III, and Eric R. Bredemeyer, the undersigned applicant of this request. I am requesting copies of the following again only as to the Southold Board of Trustees, Attorney Hulse and Legal Department a. Since 12/2/13 only: any update application materials, diagrams, surveys and correspondence, emails, memos of phone calls from persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY for a proposed dock permit and it related applications/materials. b. Since 12/2/13 only: Copies of correspondence, memos of any calls, emails, memos of any meetings, discussions by TOS Attorney, any TOS Official(s), any TOS Staffer to/from/with the "applicant" persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. The names and titles of the officials & communicant(s), and the dates of the contacts are requested if the underlying documentation of the communication is not being provided as a result of this request. C. Since 12/2/13: Copies of any and all official determinations by Town of Southold Board of Trustees, Attorney Hulse and Legal Department as to who is the Agent of the Applicant for the subject property and its proposed dock permit and related application(s)/materials. d. Since 12/2/13: Copies of any pleadings with any court or court official and/or to any attorney and/or official correspondence (as addressee and/or copy to) by or on behalf of the TOS and/or any TOS Attorney re-opening and/or seeking new/resumed judicial participation in matters concerning the unpermitted (dock) structure or (alleged/founded) violations in the bay in front of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. 3. On behalf of my parents and The Bredemeyer Family Trust and as the Requester of these records, I am willing to pay for the copies. However, if for any reason the costs of research and copying were to exceed $150.00 please contact me in advance so that I might be able to consider some way of limiting such costs, if possible. Also, if for any reason a record cannot be provided me please identify the record with such specificity that an appropriate appeal can be made. 4. I r respectfully request that any diagram or survey submitted since 12/2/13 that may be provided me be scanned/copied in as easy and "fast" manner in the "fast" copy being provided to me. IN ADDITION AFTER SENDING (BY Email preferred or disk) I should also request in addition a full size copy of such diagram(s) and survey(s) be made and I will make arrangements to retrieve the fuller size copy in person. I shall want the "fast" copy emailed, if possible as an attachment as you have done previously. PLEASE DO NOT WAIT TO SEND THE "FAST" COPIES FOR THE FULL SIZE COPIES OF THE DIAGRAMS/SURVEYS TO BE MADE. Call me if other arrangement for sending need be considered. I agree to pay for the full sized copies of the diagrams and surveys (post-12/2/2013), but do let me know if the aforementioned $150.00 should not be adequate before copying. I am sending this letter as an email with attachment of the scanned TOS FOIL Form and scanned signed copy of the request as a cover letter. I require the records copied/scanned and emailed to me if possible as soon as possible. Your assistance in this matter is very much appreciated. Thank you and all concerned for you help. Respectfully, ERIC R. BREDEMEYER Eric R. Bredemeyer, Trustee of the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust, P.O. Box 522710, Marathon Shores, FL 33052 (tel: 305-609-7488) Encl: (1) Signed TOS FOIL FORM (2) Signed Copy of the letter 5 > Betty: you are the best! Thanks. > Linda: Let me know if you have any questions. > R/ > Eric Bredemeyer 6 Cantrell, Elizabeth From: Eric Bredemeyer <mysquire@embargmail.com> Sent: Monday, February 10, 2014 12:18 AM To: John Bredemeyer; Nunemaker, Amanda; Cantrell, Elizabeth Subject: Re: Bredemeyer Family Trust FOIL Fees and Copies On 2/9/2014 2:18 PM, John Bredemeyer wrote: Hi Liz and Amanda, Acting in my individual capacity as co-trustee of the Bredemeyer Family Trust (and not as Town Trustee), I just received a request from my brother, Eric, that I pay FOIL fees pursuant to the Bredemeyer Trust's recent FOIL request, which I shall do when picking up those items. Eric also requested that I pick up all hard copies directly from you (and/or the print-shop as necessary) in:,Ica~I i~I mailim! inc 0 1111 es I(' I I I I I I I IC rcitrrd.•d his rcyticst Iha1 kIIit llk vend liiIII cIco IolIIc collie, of the FOII m,tlcriul, <r; Xv ell. On behalf of the Bredemeyer Family Trust, we wish to thank you for your assistance in this matter. Jay Amanda: Yes, I spoke with my brother "Jay" (John) who will pickup the photocopies Amanda already made and pay the $17.00 for photocopies and the print-shop fee for the 3 surveys. So Jay will fetch the "paper stuff," however, if you would as Amanda and I (Eric) discussed email me scans of the photocopied materials as soon as you can. Thank you. Respectfully, Eric Eric Bredemeyer 305-609-7488 t Cantrell, Elizabeth From: John Bredemeyer <jbme4u@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, February 09, 2014 2:18 PM To: Nunemaker, Amanda; Cantrell, Elizabeth Cc: Eric Subject: Bredemeyer Family Trust FOIL Fees and Copies Hi Liz and Amanda, Acting in my individual capacity as co-trustee of the Bredemeyer Family Trust (and not as Town Trustee), I just received a request from my brother, Eric, that I pay FOIL fees pursuant to the Bredemeyer Trust's recent FOIL request, which I shall do when picking up those items. Eric also requested that I pick up all hard copies directly from you (and/or the print-shop as necessary) inslcad of niiiIim~ any' Copies to him. I IC IcitC;itcd hiS rcqueat that Nou kindly send him clcoronic copies of the 1 011 nzaiczial, as «cll. On behalf of the Bredemeyer Family Trust, we wish to thank you for your assistance in this matter. Jay t Cantrell, Elizabeth From: Neville, Elizabeth Sent: Thursday, December 05, 2013 1:19 PM To: Cantrell, Elizabeth Subject: Re: Town of Southold Application for Access to Updated and Additional Records 2440 Village Lane, Orient Thank you Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry From: "Cantrell, Elizabeth" <elizabethc@town.southold.ny.us> Date: Thu, 5 Dec 2013 17:59:46 +0000 To: Neville, Elizabeth<E.Neville@town.southold.ny.us> Subject: RE: Town of Southold Application for Access to Updated and Additional Records 2440 Village Lane, Orient Betty, Regarding the FOIL request made by Eric Bredemeyer, received on December 3, 2013; the office of the Board of Trustees has forwarded Mr. Bredemeyer's requested documentation to the Town Attorney's office. Sincerely, Elizabeth Cantrell Clerk Typist Board of Trustees From: Neville, Elizabeth Sent: Monday, December 02, 2013 4:03 PM To: Toth, Vicki; Lanza, Heather; Donald J. Wilcenski; James H. Rich, III; Martin H. Sidor; Pierce Rafferty; William J. Cremers; Flatley, Martin; Blasko, Regina; Cantrell, Elizabeth; Standish, Lauren; Verity, Mike; Bunch, Connie; Weisman, Leslie; Nunemaker, Amanda; Bob Ghosio; Bredemeyer, John; David Bergen; Domino, Michael; King, Jim; Andaloro, Jennifer; Christopher M. Talbot - Forward; Doherty, Jill; Finnegan, Martin; Jim Dinizio; Krauza, Lynne; Standish, Lauren; Louisa Evans; Neville, Elizabeth; Beltz, Phillip; Russell, Scott; Tomaszewski, Michelle; William Ruland Subject: FW: Town of Southold Application for Access to Updated and Additional Records 2440 Village Lane, Orient This FOIL request is being sent to every department referenced on the foil form. Please respond to my office within five (5) business days. Thank you. Elizabeth A. Neville, MMC Southold Town Clerk PO Box 1179 Southold. NY 11971 Tel. 631 765_1800. I :x(. 228 Fax 631 765.6145 Cell 631 466-6064 1 From: Eric Bredemeyer [mailto:mysquireCOembaromail.com] Sent: Monday, December 02, 2013 7:07 AM To: Neville, Elizabeth Cc: Eric Bredemeyer Subject: Town of Southold Application for Access to Updated and Additional Records 2440 Village Lane, Orient REQUEST OF DECEMBER 2, 2013 RE: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST-Application for Public Access to Records on the PROPERTY AT 2440 Village Lane (f/k/a Bay Ave.), Orient, NY 11957 in Suffolk County the matter of proposed dock permit and its related applications/materials District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1 and its predecessor Lot designations 16 and 17 Dear Information Officer Neville: 1.Attached please find my completed Form requesting copies of the subject property records. Please consider this request as my request for an update of any records/materials on the subject property received, generated or on file with/by the Town of Southold(hereinafter TOS) since September 5, 2013 and continuing to present. In addition to the update request, I am requesting copies of records (Item 5 d) seen by me during my F.O.I.L. inspection on September 5, 2013, of TOS Board of Trustees' records/file but which at that time I had not requested copies, but do so now and related materials if they exist (Item 5 g). Paragraph 5 a. through h. below breakout the request(s). Please call or email if any questions. Thanks. 2. On or about September 11, 2013, 1 sent a letter to Robert Hermann, EN -Consultants, with a copy to The Henrys (owners/occupants of the subject property) with copies to TOS Officials, including you (in capacity as Town Clerk), Trustee President King and TOS Asst Attorney Hulse, which were all received by the addressees within or day or two of my posting it. 3. On or about October 28, 2013, 1 sent another letter to the same persons with the exception that Trustee President King was an addressee not merely a "copy to" on my 10/28/13 letter. 4. 1 have received no calls, no correspondence and no communication from the Applicant, anyone on their behalf of the Applicant; and no one from the TOS or anyone on its behalf as a result of either of my letters. I sought a response and the letters speak for themselves. 5. My parents now both in their 90's have relegated much of their affairs to their two sons, John M. Bredemeyer III, and Eric R. Bredemeyer, the undersigned applicant of this request. I am requesting copies of the following: a. Since 9/5/13 only: any update application materials, diagrams, surveys and correspondence, memos of phone calls from persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY for a proposed dock permit and it related applications/materials. b. Since 9/5/13 only: Copies of correspondence, memos of any calls, memos of any meetings, discussions by TOS Attorney, any TOS Official(s), any TOS Staffer to/from the "applicant" persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. The names and titles of the officials & communicant(s), and the dates of the contacts are requested if the underlying documentation of the communication is not being provided as a result of this request. 2 c. Since 9/5/13: Copies of any and all official determinations by Town of Southold as to who is the Agent of the Applicant for the subject property and its proposed dock permit and related application(s)/materials. d. Provide copies of 3 checks that were in the TOS Bd of Trustee file when viewed by me on 9/5/13. (These 3 checks were stale* checks from May 2012). [*The FDIC considers checks older than 6 months as stale.] If for any reason copies of these old checks need to be redacted or otherwise altered stamping the copies as not negotiable or similar marking, please consider this request as allowing for such a markup in order that I may be provided copies but so TOS does not disclose excluded/protected information. If for any reason copies of even redacted checks cannot be provided me, then please provide me such information so that I may properly identify such non-provision of requested records such as a listing of the check number, payer, payee, signatory of the check, amount of money the check is for, any notations for what purpose the check had been intended, the issuing bank and account number. e. Since 9/5/13: Copies of any checks reissued to TOS or in its possession and/or control for the 3 stale checks from May 2012, or correspondence related to the staleness of the checks or suggestions of re-issuance now or in the future by TOS, the Applicant/its Agents and/or any financial institution. f. Since 9/5/13: Copies of any new checks issued by or on behalf of the applicant to TOS. g. Since May 2012: Copies of any and all ledgers, receipt ledgers or books maintained by TOS showing that it received and holds at least 3 checks in its TOS Board of Trustees' file on the subject property, and any other ledgers or books reflecting payments made, checks received, returned or cashed by TOS from or on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY, exclusive of routine tax payments to the TOS since May 2012. Please consider my request as allowing redacting of other entries/items copied not pertinent to my request and protective of legally exempted personal financial information. h. Since May 2012: Copies of any pleadings with any court or court official and/or to any attorney and/or official correspondence (as addressee and/or copy to) by or on behalf of the TOS and/or any TOS Attorney re-opening and/or seeking new/resumed judicial participation in matters concerning the unpermitted (dock) structure or (alleged/founded) violations in the bay in front of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. 6. On behalf of my parents and The Bredemeyer Family Trust and as the Requester of these records, I am willing to pay for the copies. However, if for any reason the costs of research and copying were to exceed $98.00 please contact me in advance so that I might be able to consider some way of limiting such costs, if possible. Also, if for any reason a record cannot be provided me please identify the record with such specificity that an appropriate appeal can be made. Also, please specify the specific appeal authority and suggested/requirements needed for any appeal. If any privilege and/or exemption is asserted in a record/document precluding it from being provided by the Town of Southold to me, please specify (1)who by name and title, if possible, is asserting the privilege/exemption, (2) the nature of the privilege/exemption with specificity as to the specific item withheld (3)what action if any was last taken by anyone on behalf of the Town of Southold that might require the privilege/exemption to be continued and maintained, (4) what was the date of that action in (3), and (5) what acts or passage of time or occurrence would remove the privilege/exemption without the need for an appeal to obtain the record/document concerned should the privilege lapse or reason for the privilege no longer be required. I am sending this letter as an email with attachment of the scanned TOS FOIL Form and scanned signed copy of this letter. I require the records copied/scanned and sent to me here in Florida. Your assistance in this matter is very much appreciated. Having had no response to my aforementioned letters, I am turning to this FOIL. Thank you and all concerned for you help and patience. 3 Respectfully, Eric R.. Bredemeyer Eric R. Bredemeyer, Trustee of the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust, P.O. Box 522710, Marathon Shores, FL 33052 (tel: 305-609-7488) Encl: (1) Signed TOS FOIL FORM (2) Signed Copy of the letter 4 Cantrell, Elizabeth From: Cantrell, Elizabeth Sent: Thursday, December 05, 2013 1:00 PM To: Neville, Elizabeth Subject: RE: Town of Southold Application for Access to Updated and Additional Records 2440 Village Lane, Orient Betty, Regarding the FOIL request made by Eric Bredemeyer, received on December 3, 2013; the office of the Board of Trustees has forwarded Mr. Bredemeyer's requested documentation to the Town Attorney's office. Sincerely, Elizabeth Cantrell Clerk Typist Board of Trustees From: Neville, Elizabeth Sent: Monday, December 02, 2013 4:03 PM To: Toth, Vicki; Lanza, Heather; Donald J. Wilcenski; James H. Rich, III; Martin H. Sidor; Pierce Rafferty; William J. Cremers; Flatley, Martin; Blasko, Regina; Cantrell, Elizabeth; Standish, Lauren; Verity, Mike; Bunch, Connie; Weisman, Leslie; Nunemaker, Amanda; Bob Ghosio; Bredemeyer, John; David Bergen; Domino, Michael; King, Jim; Andaloro, Jennifer; Christopher M. Talbot - Forward; Doherty, Jill; Finnegan, Martin; Jim Dinizio; Krauza, Lynne; Standish, Lauren; Louisa Evans; Neville, Elizabeth; Beltz, Phillip; Russell, Scott; Tomaszewski, Michelle; William Ruland Subject: FW: Town of Southold Application for Access to Updated and Additional Records 2440 Village Lane, Orient This FOIL request is being sent to every department referenced on the foil form. Please respond to my office within five (5) business days. Thank you. Elizabeth A. Neville. MMC Southold Town Clerk PO Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Tel. 631 765-1500, Ext. 228 Fax 631 765-6145 Cell 6J 1 466-6064 From: Eric Bredemeyer [mailto•mvsquireCalemba[amail com] Sent: Monday, December 02, 2013 7:07 AM To: Neville, Elizabeth Cc: Eric Bredemeyer Subject: Town of Southold Application for Access to Updated and Additional Records 2440 Village Lane, Orient 1 REQUEST OF DECEMBER 2, 2013 RE: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST--Application for Public Access to Records on the PROPERTY AT 2440 Village Lane (f/k/a Bay Ave.), Orient, NY 11957 in Suffolk County the matter of proposed dock permit and its related applications/materials District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1 and its predecessor Lot designations 16 and 17 Dear Information Officer Neville: 1.Attached please find my completed Form requesting copies of the subject property records. Please consider this request as my request for an update of any records/materials on the subject property received, generated or on file with/by the Town of Southold(hereinafter TOS) since September 5, 2013 and continuing to present. In addition to the update request, I am requesting copies of records (Item 5 d) seen by me during my F.O.I.L. inspection on September 5, 2013, of TOS Board of Trustees' records/file but which at that time I had not requested copies, but do so now and related materials if they exist (Item 5 g). Paragraph 5 a. through h. below breakout the request(s). Please call or email if any questions. Thanks. 2. On or about September 11, 2013, 1 sent a letter to Robert Hermann, EN -Consultants, with a copy to The Henrys (owners/occupants of the subject property) with copies to TOS Officials, including you (in capacity as Town Clerk), Trustee President King and TOS Asst Attorney Hulse, which were all received by the addressees within or day or two of my posting it. 3. On or about October 28, 2013, 1 sent another letter to the same persons with the exception that Trustee President King was an addressee not merely a "copy to" on my 10/28/13 letter. 4. 1 have received no calls, no correspondence and no communication from the Applicant, anyone on their behalf of the Applicant; and no one from the TOS or anyone on its behalf as a result of either of my letters. I sought a response and the letters speak for themselves. 5. My parents now bath in their 90's have relegated much of their affairs to their two sons, John M. Bredemeyer III, and Eric R. Bredemeyer, the undersigned applicant of this request. 1 am requesting copies of the following: a. Since 9/5/13 only: any update application materials, diagrams, surveys and correspondence, memos of phone calls from persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY for a proposed dock permit and it related applications/materials. b. Since 9/5/13 only: Copies of correspondence, memos of any calls, memos of any meetings, discussions by TOS Attorney, any TOS Official(s), any TOS Staffer to/from the "applicant" persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. The names and titles of the officials & communicant(s), and the dates of the contacts are requested if the underlying documentation of the communication is not being provided as a result of this request. c. Since 9/5/13: Copies of any and all official determinations by Town of Southold as to who is the Agent of the Applicant for the subject property and its proposed dock permit and related application(s)/materials. d. Provide copies of 3 checks that were in the TOS Bd of Trustee file when viewed by me on 9/5/13. (These 3 checks were stale* checks from May 2012). [*The FDIC considers checks older than 6 months as stale.) If for any reason copies of these old checks need to be redacted or otherwise altered stamping the copies as not negotiable or similar marking, please consider this request as allowing for such a markup in order that I may be provided copies but so TOS does not disclose excluded/protected information. If for any reason copies of even redacted checks cannot be provided me, then please provide me such information so that I may properly identify such non-provision of requested records such as a 2 listing of the check number, payer, payee, signatory of the check, amount of money the check is for, any notations for what purpose the check had been intended, the issuing bank and account number. e. Since 9/5/13: Copies of any checks reissued to TOS or in its possession and/or control for the 3 stale checks from May 2012, or correspondence related to the staleness of the checks or suggestions of re-issuance now or in the future by TOS, the Applicant/its Agents and/or any financial institution. f. Since 9/5/13: Copies of any new checks issued by or on behalf of the applicant to TOS. g. Since May 2012: Copies of any and all ledgers, receipt ledgers or books maintained by TOS showing that it received and holds at least 3 checks in its TOS Board of Trustees' file on the subject property, and any other ledgers or books reflecting payments made, checks received, returned or cashed by TOS from or on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY, exclusive of routine tax payments to the TOS since May 2012. Please consider my request as allowing redacting of other entries/items copied not pertinent to my request and protective of legally exempted personal financial information. h. Since May 2012: Copies of any pleadings with any court or court official and/or to any attorney and/or official correspondence (as addressee and/or copy to) by or on behalf of the TOS and/or any TOS Attorney re-opening and/or seeking new/resumed judicial participation in matters concerning the unpermitted (dock) structure or (alleged/founded) violations in the bay in front of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. 6. On behalf of my parents and The Bredemeyer Family Trust and as the Requester of these records, I am willing to pay for the copies. However, if for any reason the costs of research and copying were to exceed $95.00 please contact me in advance so that I might be able to consider some way of limiting such costs, if possible. Also, if for any reason a record cannot be provided me please identify the record with such specificity that an appropriate appeal can be made. Also, please specify the specific appeal authority and suggested/requirements needed for any appeal. If any privilege and/or exemption is asserted in a record/document precluding it from being provided by the Town of Southold to me, please specify (1)who by name and title, if possible, is asserting the privilege/exemption, (2) the nature of the privilege/exemption with specificity as to the specific item withheld (3)what action if any was last taken by anyone on behalf of the Town of Southold that might require the privilege/exemption to be continued and maintained, (4) what was the date of that action in (3), and (5) what acts or passage of time or occurrence would remove the privilege/exemption without the need for an appeal to obtain the record/document concerned should the privilege lapse or reason for the privilege no longer be required. I am sending this letter as an email with attachment of the scanned TOS FOIL Form and scanned signed copy of this letter. I require the records copied/scanned and sent to me here in Florida. Your assistance in this matter is very much appreciated. Having had no response to my aforementioned letters, I am turning to this FOIL. Thank you and all concerned for you help and patience. Respectfully, Eric R,. Bredemeyer 3 Eric R. Bredemeyer, Trustee of the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust, P.O. Box 522710, Marathon Shores, FL 33052 (tel: 305-609-7488) Encl: (1) Signed TOS FOIL FORM (2) Signed Copy of the letter 4 Cantrell, Elizabeth From: Cantrell, Elizabeth Sent: Tuesday, January 21, 2014 9:06 AM To: 'Eric Bredemeyer' Cc: Bredemeyer, John; Hulse, Lori Subject: RE: Wetland Permit for Address at 2660 Village Lane, Orient, NY application by Bredemeyer Family Trust Good Morning Mr. Bredemeyer; I have received your request to table the Bredemeyer application until the February 19, 2014 Board Hearing. We will see you then. Elizabeth Cantrell From: Eric Bredemeyer fmailto:mysquireCcbembargmail.com] Sent: Monday, January 20, 2014 6:57 PM To: Cantrell, Elizabeth Cc: Bredemeyer, John; Hulse, Lori Subject: Re: Wetland Permit for Address at 2660 Village Lane, Orient, NY application by Bredemeyer Family Trust FROM: Eric Bredemeyer, Co-Trustee of Applicant Bredemeyer Family Trust Wetland Application Dear Ms. Cantrell: It is my understanding that the Southold Board of Trustees cannot accommodate my telephonic appearance at their Public Hearing as same would not be be for the "Record." Certainly I want to speak on the Record. In accordance with my previous communication to you this means that the Bredemeyer Family Trust Wetland Permit Application for 2660 Village Lane, Orient, NY, shall be moved to the February 19, 2014, Board of Trustees Public Hearings Agenda. I, on Behalf of the BFT-Applicant, accept moving it to the February 19, 2014, Hearing Agenda of the TOS Board of Trustees. I have therefore adjusted my schedule making it now February 19, 2014. Thank you. If there are any questions please do not hesitate to call me. The courtesy of a reply email from you confirming the change to the February BD of Trustees Agenda would be appreciated. Thanks. Respectfully, Eric Eric Bredemeyer t Co-Trustee Bredemeyer Family Trust-Applicant Telephone: 305-609-7488 2 Cantrell, Elizabeth From: Neville, Elizabeth Sent: Tuesday, February 25, 2014 10:58 AM To: Cantrell, Elizabeth Cc: Norklun, Stacey Subject: RE: FOIL for Village Lane OK, I would like to scan. Thank you. From: Cantrell, Elizabeth Sent: Tuesday, February 25, 2014 10:57 AM To: Neville, Elizabeth Subject: RE: FOIL for Village Lane Betty, I will forward you all that you have requested, however, please be advised that everything you will receive from this office has already been submitted to Mr. Bredemeyer in a timely fashion and as requested by each of his FOILS. Sincerely, Elizabeth Cantrell From: Neville, Elizabeth Sent: Tuesday, February 25, 2014 9:43 AM To: Cantrell, Elizabeth Cc: Norklun, Stacey Subject: FW: FOIL for Village Lane Elizabeth, Would you please send me all of the documents and files you have in the Trustee Office on the Eric Bredmeyer FOIL since 12/2/13, 1 will have Stacey scan them and return them immediately. Please call me with any questions. Thank you, Betty Neville Elizabeth A. Neville. MMC Southold Town Clerk PO Box 1179 Southold. NY 11971 Tel. 631 765-1800. Ext. 228 Fax 631 765-6145 Cell 631 466-6064 From: Norklun, Stacey Sent: Monday, February 24, 2014 8:52 AM To: Neville, Elizabeth Subject: FOIL for Village Lane 1 The attached file is the only file on Laserfiche for this property, it is the file he already has. There is no backside to the permit, I checked the file and have placed a note in Laser stating that the back of the permit page is blank. z Cantrell, Elizabeth From: Robert Herrmann <rerrmann@enconsultants.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 04, 2014 11:43 AM To: Cantrell, Elizabeth Subject: RE: Henry dock Attachments: 32-006.pdf Liz, pursuant to your request, please find attached a PDF of the survey updated to depict more specifically in plan view the areas of the dock needing post-Sandy storm damage repairs as well as a detailed plan view and sectional view to graphically depict the various structural components of the dock that are described in the description of work. We are forwarding 5 hard copies of this map to you today, assuming 3 for you, 1 for CAC, and 1 for LWRP. Please let me know if you need more. Best, Rob From: Cantrell, Elizabeth [mailto:elizabethc(o)town.southold.ny.us] Sent: Wednesday, January 29, 2014 3:24 PM To: 'Robert Herrmann' Subject: RE: Henry dock Rob, I would appreciate it if you could give it a shot on creating a project plan for the dock. I understand that time is needed. If we could get it by sometime next week that would be great. Thank you. Liz From: Robert Herrmann Imailto:rherrmannPenconsultants.com] Sent: Wednesday, January 29, 2014 10:15 AM To: Cantrell, Elizabeth Subject: RE: Henry dock Liz, what you're asking for is difficult to provide, as there are sporadically damaged pieces of decking and lumber located in the understructure of the dock that need to be repaired or replaced, as described in detail on the most recently submitted survey, but no particular section of the dock is being completely removed and replaced. Both the scope and cost of these proposed repairs are also detailed in the cost estimate from Ian Crowley, which was included with the package of supporting materials submitted by Steve Angel. However, I can have a "typical section" added to the survey to provide a graphic depiction of the caps, stringers, etc., as they are described, and I can do my best to show where on the dock as the crow flies these repairs will take place. It may take a few days to add this though, as given the nature of the work, I did not anticipate having to provide this. Rob From: Cantrell, Elizabeth [mailto:elizabethcCaltown.southold.ny.us] Sent: Tuesday, January 28, 2014 11:37 AM To: rherrmannCalenconsultants.com Subject: Henry dock i Hi Rob, I see in the project description you have proposed repairs, however, I do not see a project plan from you, nor is it on the survey (looking for picture of proposed w/details of where repairs to be made). Can you get that to us please. Thanks. C1erkTgput Town of Southold Board of Trustees 631-765-1892 z SURVEY OF PROPERTY SITUATE Iw 61 OHIEN'r c TOWN OF SOUTHOLD e oa°10o t SUFFOLK COUNTY, NEW YORK y+ S.C. TAX No. 1000-26-01-1 7.1 FEBRUARY I. 2012 ADDED NOTE 11 A AREA . "..l. (DD DE IRE) 0 VI ~y ¢ V AY .111, -2, A ~0 c NNOI OWNER o oqP CONSULTANT. AD . w ~ t G nx ..i L no SECTIONAL Dews 5 \ ~ 4$ I Y PI Al I 1 11 A -I P. ,T Ti ~7/ .¢F.. L~ o.~, .a a~I 111~11117,,"`AAAARA 1 1, RARRA , I. ROWER A, IT" 11 LAN"E RARE R.- \T \ 6 ..A 'AAAAA I", A I TA- PINT A AD WIN ..A -IAIN .,-A I . ...K~.. s ,~..,.o,.,,,,.,.,e,u m, a Irv, V -p.wJ I RAD.,II r}°l ML.. .P WAR A~I. LING _IR:C Nathan Taft Corwin III Land Surveyor INIE -)721 RAW RI T -AWN- Cantrell, Elizabeth From: Robert Herrmann <rerrmann@enconsultants.com> Sent: Wednesday, January 29, 2014 10:15 AM To: Cantrell, Elizabeth Subject: RE: Henry dock Liz, what you're asking for is difficult to provide, as there are sporadically damaged pieces of decking and lumber located in the understructure of the dock that need to be repaired or replaced, as described in detail on the most recently submitted survey, but no particular section of the dock is being completely removed and replaced. Both the scope and cost of these proposed repairs are also detailed in the cost estimate from Ian Crowley, which was included with the package of supporting materials submitted by Steve Angel. However, I can have a "typical section" added to the survey to provide a graphic depiction of the caps, stringers, etc., as they are described, and I can do my best to show where on the dock as the crow flies these repairs will take place. It may take a few days to add this though, as given the nature of the work, I did not anticipate having to provide this. Rob From: Cantrell, Elizabeth [mailto:elizabethcCaltown.southold.nv.us] Sent: Tuesday, January 28, 2014 11:37 AM To: rherrmannCalenconsultants.com Subject: Henry dock Hi Rob, I see in the project description you have proposed repairs, however, I do not see a project plan from you, nor is it on the survey (looking for picture of proposed w/details of where repairs to be made). Can you get that to us please. Thanks. Clerk Typist Town of Southold Board of Trustees 631-765-1892 t Cantrell, Elizabeth From: Eric Bredemeyer <mysquire@embargmail.com> Sent: Monday, January 20, 2014 6:57 PM To: Cantrell, Elizabeth Cc: Bredemeyer, John; Hulse, Lori Subject: Re: Wetland Permit for Address at 2660 Village Lane, Orient, NY application by Bredemeyer Family Trust FROM: Eric Bredemeyer, Co-Trustee of Applicant Bredemeyer Family Trust Wetland Application Dear Ms. Cantrell: It is my understanding that the Southold Board of Trustees cannot accommodate my telephonic appearance at their Public Hearing as same would not be be for the "Record." Certainly I want to speak on the Record. In accordance with my previous communication to you this means that the Bredemeyer Family Trust Wetland Permit Application for 2660 Village Lane, Orient, NY, shall be moved to the February 19, 2014, Board of Trustees Public Hearings Agenda. I, on Behalf of the BFT-Applicant, accept moving it to the February 19, 2014, Hearing Agenda of the TOS Board of Trustees. I have therefore adjusted my schedule making it now February 19, 2014. Thank you. If there are any questions please do not hesitate to call me. The courtesy of a reply email from you confirming the change to the February BD of Trustees Agenda would be appreciated. Thanks. Respectfully, Eric Eric Bredemeyer Co-Trustee Bredemeyer Family Trust-Applicant Telephone: 305-609-7488 t Cantrell, Elizabeth From: Eric Bredemeyer <mysquire@embargmail.com> Sent: Thursday, January 16, 2014 7:13 PM To: Bredemeyer, John; Cantrell, Elizabeth Cc: Hulse, Lori Subject: Wetland Permit for Address at 2660 Village Lane, Orient, NY application by Bredemeyer Family Trust Attachments: Eric B. by Phone 4 Trustees.pdf FROM: Eric Bredemeyer, Co-Trustee of Applicant Bredemeyer Family Trust Wetland Application TO:John M. Bredemeyer III President of the Board of Trustees AND Vice Pres., The Board of Trustees Town of Southold AND Ms. Elizabeth Cantrell Clerk of the Board of Trustees - Town of Southold RE: Application for Wetland Permit for Address at 2660 Village Lane, Orient, NY (P. O. Box 416, Orient, NY) 11957, SCTMap 26-1-18; application by The John M. Bredemeyer, Jr., and Jeanne R. Bredemeyer Family Trust ATTACHED TO THIS EMAIL IS A SIGNED AND SCANNED VERSION OF THIS EMAIL IN LETTER FORMAT. MS. CANTRELL IN ADDITION TO THE ELECTRONIC COPIES SENT WOULD YOU PLEASE HARD COPY MY ATTACHED LETTER NOW FOR THE VICE PRESIDENT OF THE BD OF TRUSTEES. THANK YOU. Dear President Bredemeyer, Board of Trustees and Ms. Cantrell: 1 I ask that someone other than President Bredemeyer read this letter in order to avoid any conflict of or appearance of conflict of interest at your January 22, 2014, Public Hearing when the subject wetland application for a shellfish operation is to be open for consideration. Thank you. (Continuing by such other "Reader" in support of the subject application:] I, Eric Bredemeyer, the co-Trustee of the Bredemeyer Family Trust (BFT) and the Applicant, write in support of the subject application. By now you have the application, supporting materials, as well as an Original Official Certified Copy of the Recorded Deed for the Bredemeyer Family Trust (BFT) property at 2660 Village Lane, Orient, NY, and an Original Official Certified Copy of the Recorded Deed of the closest-adjoining neighbor's property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY, and you have completed the Field Survey. I do request approval and that the permit be issued. Since my brother may be limited in what action or presentation he may have concerning this application, I do ask that the matter be opened for hearing and that I respectfully request that were you to have any questions or additional concerns that I am standing hereto speak by telephone to address the hearing. The Bredemeyer Family Trust continues to cooperate and has tried to fully keep the Town, your Board and Panel Attorney advised. On the January 2014 evening of the Board's hearing on my (BFT) wetland application, I shall be standing by at telephone 305-609-7488 to participate. My brother, John M. Bredemeyer III, who is present in person at the hearing, as no doubt your minutes/record reflect has with him a cell phone with a speaker phone option which should handle connection logistics for calling me and placing me before you; or should you otherwise desire contact me at that number by another telephone. Since other members of the public and applicants are not under oath, I hope that a telephone conference-type meeting call will be sufficient. Please call me whenever you believe I may be of assistance in providing answers and information concerning my pending wetland application. If my request to appear telephonically as I propose is denied, or being considered for denial, I respectfully ask that you nevertheless call me for the purpose of discussing such possible denial and status of the situation. Finally, in the absence of a clear telephonic connection; and/or if there exists a prohibition in New York law to my telephonic appearance for this matter (or there is a sustained objection to my brother John III undertaking the limited role of authenticating me/my voice), I would respectfully then request that the subject BFT wetland application be formally moved to the agenda for the scheduled February 2014 Public Hearing of the Board of Trustees. Thanking you in advance for your consideration. 2 Respectfully, ERIC R. BREDEMEYER Eric R. Bredemeyer, Co-Trustee of the 1 & J Bredemeyer Family Trust Applicant for Permit 305-609-7488 Copy to: THIS LETTER HAS BEEN PROVIDED BY E-MAIL TO Ms. Cantrell; Attorney Lori Hulse; and President Bredemeyer. I also respectfully ask that Ms. Cantrell provide a copy to the Vice President of the Trustees, too. I am mailing a hard copy (original and 7 copies enough for distribution to the dais) but wanted to be sure everyone gets it in ample time. Thank you. 3 ERIC RAWSON BREDEMEYER P. O. BOX 522710 MARATHON SHORES, FL 33052 305-609-7488 January 16, 2014 John M. Bredemeyer 111 President of the Board of Trustees Town of Southold -Town Hall Annex 53095 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 AND The Board of Trustees Town of Southold AND Ms. Elizabeth Cantrell Clerk of the Board of Trustees - Town of Southold RE: Application for Wetland Permit for Address at 2660 Village Lane, Orient, NY (P. O. Box 416, Orient, NY) 11957, SCTMap 26-1-18, application by The John M. Bredemeyer, Jr., and Jeanne R. Bredemeyer Family Trust Dear President Bredemeyer, Board of Trustees and Ms. Cantrell: I ask that someone other than President Bredemeyer read this letter in order to avoid any conflict of or appearance of conflict of interest at your January 22, 2014, Public Hearing when the subject wetland application for a shellfish operation is to be open for consideration. Thank you. [Continuing by such other "Reader" in support of the subject application:] I, Eric Bredemeyer, the co-Trustee of the Bredemeyer Family Trust (BFT) and the Applicant, write in support of the subject application. By now you have the application, supporting materials, as well as an Original Official Certified Copy of the Recorded Deed for the Bredemeyer Family Trust (BFT) property at 2660 Village Lane, Orient, NY, and an Original Official Certified Copy of the Recorded Deed of the closest-adjoining neighbor's property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY, and you have completed the Field Survey. I do request approval and that the permit be issued. i Since my brother may be limited in what action or presentation he may have concerning this application, I do ask that the matter be opened for hearing and that I respectfully request that were you to have any questions or additional concerns that I am standing here to speak by telephone to address the hearing. The Bredemeyer Family Trust continues to cooperate and has tried to fully keep the Town, your Board and Panel Attorney advised. On the January 2014 evening of the Board's hearing on my (BFT) wetland application, I shall be standing by at telephone 305-609-7488 to participate. My brother, John M. Bredemeyer III, who is present in person at the hearing, as no doubt your minutes/record reflect has with him a cell phone with a speaker phone option which should handle connection logistics for calling me and placing me before you; or should you otherwise desire contact me at that number by another telephone. Since other members of the public and applicants are not under oath, I hope that a telephone conference-type meeting call will be sufficient. Please call me whenever you believe I maybe of assistance in providing answers and information concerning my pending wetland application. If my request to appear telephonically as I propose is denied, or being considered for denial, I respectfully ask that you nevertheless call me for the purpose of discussing such possible denial and status of the situation. Finally, in the absence of a clear telephonic connection; and/or if there exists a prohibition in New York law to my telephonic appearance for this matter (or there is a sustained objection to my brother John III undertaking the limited role of authenticating me/my voice), I would respectfully then request that the subject BFT wetland application be formally moved to the agenda for the scheduled February 2014 Public Hearing of the Board of Trustees. Thanking you in advance for your consideration. Respectfully, Eric R. Bredemeyer, Co-Trustee of the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust Applicant for Permit 305-609-7488 Copy to: THIS LETTER HAS BEEN PROVIDED BY E-MAIL TO Ms. Cantrell; Attorney Lori Hulse; and President Bredemeyer. I also respectfully ask that Ms. Cantrell provide a copy to the Vice President of the Trustees, too. I am mailing a hard copy (original and 7 copies enough for distribution to the dais) but wanted to be sure everyone gets it in ample time. Thank you. ERB/ms ~CI?IC RREDEM67/rR Fdsn~~L zNIPvT F6R Tos TROS TC6- h~C1} R I NCr ~D w ~Y ti z ° ~ yY V ..o E D F E B 1 9 X014 PRESENTATION OF ERIC BREDEMEYER ON BEHALF OF THE J & J BREDEMEYER FAMILY TRUST (BFT) OWNERS OF 2660 VILLAGE LANE, Southo;a town' NT, Y,RIPARIAN NEIGHBOR, AGAINST PERMIT APPLICATION OF 2440 VILLAGE LANE, ORIENT, NY, FOR AN UNPERMITTED DOCK & UNPERMITTED REPAIRS Intro of Self: 3 presidents Jill Dougherty; Jimmy King and 1B; this matter is over 3 Presidents or Leaderships of the Board. Let me read an Email I was a copy to on: e C Tt My Brother recused himself very early on in this matter; he got an ethics opinion from the Town and continues to recuse himself. On the other hand my parents who live in their home at 2660 Village Lane, both are in their 90's are the victims here. Before my Brother became a Trustee a little over 4 years ago, my parents had already looked to Brother Jay and me to take care of much of their affairs. Recused Town Officials can't act on matters such as this application of course, but I would have expected more from those in the Town not recused. Right now I do not live close enough to be here hands on. But let me bring some background known already to Mr. King and Ms. Hulse, if not others of you not recused. I brought to the attention of Former President King and Attorney Hulse as early as last September concerns that the applicant here tonight was apparently helping themselves to a large swath of my parents' side yard on a survey and then using it in their application. All I asked of Mr. King or Ms. Hulse was assistance in contacting and determining who was acting for the Applicant. Mr. King never called or wrote me. Ms. Hulse did not answer my questions. So I have certified mail I could show you. But get ahead of myself. I just wanted you all to know that my parents are the ones that drink the water and live there before this massive junk pile of a dock. It is my elderly parents civil rights that were disregarded or diminished by the Town not those of the applicant. I ask you to remember this as we proceed with my comments. A -ff' To: Southold Trustee President, Jill Doherty From: Trustee, John Bredemeyer, Trustee specializing in the OrienvEast Marion area Subject: Request for Board review of activities at 2440 Village Lane, Orient & including Trustee Bredemeyer recusa Date: October 10, 2011 While this Trustee has received several requests from area residents inquiring how to proceed in the aftermath of tropical storm, Irene, activities within the coastal and wetlands zone at the subject property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, including but not limited to possible repair and new construction on a residential dock there, have taken place since, Irene, with no known contact with the Trustee Office or the area Trustee, myself. Within the last year, the Town Bay Constable and Code Enforcement Officer intervened on the subject parcel in a separate matter, status undetermined. Consequently, on October 4, 2011, I requested that the Trustee Office place the subject property on the docket for Trustee monthly inspections for October. Since the subject property adjoins 2660 Village lane, the property of the J & J Family Trust (where my nearly 90 year old parents have owned property and/or resided in excess of 46 years) for which I am a Co-Trustee of that Trust (as disclosed in my Town ethics filing), I must recuse myself from all Board of Trustee discussion, review and determination(s) that might follow from this request, reserving a right of impeachment. To not delay the Trustees field inspection in my absence, I have contacted my co-Trustee in the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust, my brother, Eric Bredemeyer, and he has authorized me to communicate to the Board a right of access over the property of the J & J Family Trust property at 2660 Village Lane, Orient to enable the Trustees to perform their duties in the pending survey and review on or about October 12, 2011. Because of the age and infirmity of the Bredemeyer parents and owing to the uniqueness of this situation, Co- Trustee, Eric Bredemeyer requests that an additional official copy of any copy(s)and or notice(s) that would ordinarily be distributed in such a matter, be sent to him at the following address, for which he is willing to reimburse the Town regular postage costs. If this request is not possible, he respectfully requests that he be so notified in writing of the declination. Eric R. Bredemeyer P.O. Box 522710 Marathon Shores, Florida 33052 As this communication contains issues that may be both legal and ethical, Trustee President, Doherty may want to provide copies of this memo to the appropriate Town officials. I am sending an advance copy of this memo via email to those Trustees who get email service. Thank you all for your understanding and assistance in this matter, T~tee o~ J hn Br,e-de-meyeru O CC: Eric Bredemeyer, co-Trustee, P.O. Box 522710, Marathon Shores, Florida 33052 Trustee, James King (b/c no email service) 8 a So let's look at how this matter unfolds: FEB 1 g 014 Let's read the legal Notice 1 got for tonight I quote: SUUII1t/~+) Cr.il U Perform ordinary and usual maintenance activities on no existing fixed, "J" shaped pier, which pre-dates 1955 and consists of an 8'x 152'shore-perpendicular section and 10'x 36' and 10'x 17' shore-parallel sections, including: 1) as-built repairs following Hurricane Irene, including installation of new 2" x 10" untreated decking and replacement of storm damaged inside pilings, caps, and stringers; and 2) proposed repairs of additional storm damage caused by Hurricane Sandy, including installation of additional 2" x 10" untreated decking and replacement of additional 10" inside pilings, 6" x 6" caps and outside stringers, and 4" x 6" inside stringers, all as depicted on the survey prepared by Nathan raft Corwin III Land Surveyor, last dated November 1, 2013. How does this current predicament start?: Tropical Storm Irene (Hurricane Irene hits were in the Virginias and NJ but was a TS when landfall at the end of August 2011 in Brooklyn as it went inland to VT and NH; TS Irene is the proper nomenclature and is important as I rode out 1999's Hurricane Irene onboard a boat in Miami). But the matter here with the Town of Southold goes back earlier that year of 2011 as your Board knows; and as does someone for or on behalf of the Applicant. Earlier in 2011 before TS Irene, the Bay Constable and Code Enforcement Highway Dept. and your Trustees had been addressing a street flooding and drywell overflow into the street with hookups from the main house of The Applicant from a lesser rain event. The Constable and Enforcers know who was acting for the Owners of the basement or pit at 2440 being pumped out. My Thanks go to the Constable and Code Enforcers my parents' water was not sullied. I am under the impression the Town in order to get compliance forbore (forbeared) as to sanctions in order to get compliance on that matter. How did that go for you Attorney Hulse? So nowhere arrives Irene during this forborne period by you Trustees. I guess the drainage matter got lost in the storm or some file cabinet. So now comes T.S. Irene As I already told you my Brother the area Trustee had to recuse himself. Your Town records show that. Within months of the drainage problem a large barrier fence now appeared fence penning off the entire foreshore. No permit just installed. The fence hid what appeared to be major unpermitted 2 G F ~Y -MAL 771 All, Jy i• !lit- b' LI ..Lg~ T.' construction. Thanks to the Constable the Barrier was removed onsite. My folks and anyone else had the foreshore totally blocked by the fence. all While the Town was forbearing on the drainage. Photo of foreshore violation; T6,1 More problematic: unpermitted construction . Written up for a violation of wetland ordinance with fine. JB always and still in a recused status. Your attorney backed off the drainage event but with the Judge the applicant and/or his contractor they arranged to pay the fine and agree to apply for permits to bring the structure into compliance. Here we are then. Let me read you the letter of the Applicant from Robert Hermann of MAY 10 2012. TAB 4 T~? So all of this is done between August 28-29 of 2011 and May 2012... about 9 months. So lets put this into perspective nothing is filed or done by the applicant the summer of 2012; nothing in the fall of 2012; nothing in the winter; spring or summer of 2013 over 2 summers and over a year nothing is done. Remember JB remains in a recused status. The dock is in disrepair; has been or appears abandoned How's this forbearing thing going ? Forbearing your way into compliance going? As many of you know I work in another state's court system and have even been a Clerk on a Federal Appellate Court. Since May 2012 has a Judge been updated? I live far away, but In September 2013 1 ask for a FOIL (Freedom of Info Look) look at the Applicant's file on file with the Trustees. I inspected the Applicant's file and the false survey they had submitted. WOW I I could not believe it The Henrys were taking my parent's land; not down by the water. No they were taking the upland, the side yard. About 20 feet up by my folk's house. The erroneous and incorrect lines on the survey changed the entire dock. Made it look like the applicant owned more than he did on the upland and as if the 15 foot side setoffs-setbacks were compliant. Yeah looks sweet but was and is false. The Applicant's file seemed to have stopped in May 2012. Nothing by the Applicant until the 4th week of December 2013. 1 looked for the Henrys at their house when I was in Orient in September but did not see them. Maybe they were back in Manhattan. So I returned home to Florida in September 2013 and Sent Certified Letters. Since nothing appeared to have been done for over two summers; and 2 storms it was 3~' : F .t +?~i.w+r `j' r; ' Q'~ap~' - u ai r ~ ~ Y ,t ,X,~„ne+rw~+-•~ , ~s ,t`--ut~~l fthl.,. .euir~~ m .gL+d Y~- .:Ei• e,~ti~;, .,y4~4 IR yif,~s~v ,,,t• y~I _ ~R V ~t r.+d .tjf r IMF 1+ to'' t 4 Y p F. +fiirt r r ~ I 1 { ~ 5q. e w w~ a ut; u ow FT x r t° F r CCD E -9 k , r f t t 7 i e +1~~ T T n y r.~ t ~ y.LU •.~..-3'!i rr. n~ '~_'q F ~ Aj ~ ~ r+a?sf..' sxr' - - ' Yom,;. N I ~ lL~ 1~ s 1 1319 North Sea Road Southampton, New York 11968 631-283-6360 631-283-6136 M EN-CONSULTANTS wwwFax:. enconsusulta Itants.com . com ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING D May 10, 2012 Lauren Standish ELF 2014 Board of Trustees Town of Southold , MAY P.O Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 I Re: John and Sarah Henry. 2440 Villa¢e Lane, Orient - Dear Mrs. Standish: I Please find attached an application to permit a preexisting dock for the purpose of making ordinary and routine repairs and maintenance. This application is being made at this time because after Tropical Storm Irene, the Henrys' contractor commenced some simple structural repairs, including the replacement of individual storm damaged inside pilings and girders and damaged and/or aging deck boards. It is my understanding that a violation was issued for the work because although the dock has existed in its current location and configuration on the property since prior to 1955, it is not a permitted structure pursuant to Chapter 275. t i Please note that because the proposed activity involves only "maintenance or repair involving no substantial changes in an existing structure or facility," the work is defined by §268-3 as a "minor action" not requiring waterfront consistency review pursuant to Chapter 268. Therefore, we are not submitting an LWRP Consistency Assessment Form with this application. Res tfully yours I Robert E. Herrmann Coastal Management Specialist Enclosures N 1319 North Sea Road ,r Southampton, New York 11968 631-283-6360 631--6136 coin sulta sulta Fax: 283 EN-CONSULTANTS www.en conn nts.coin . ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING _ May 21, 2012 James King, Chairman Board of Trustees Town of Southold MAY 2 3 1111 2 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Re: John and Sarah Henry, 2440 Village Lane Orient Dear Mr. King: Last week I submitted an application for a Town Wetlands Permit to permit a legally preexisting dock that has existed in its current location and configuration since the 1950s, as evidenced by historic aerial photographs readily available online. As a result of a violation, the application is being made at this time to legalize several repairs that were made after Tropical Storm Irene, including the replacement and/or repair of several inside pilings and girders and damaged and/or aging deck boards. A small gate was also added inside the parameters of the catwalk to prevent trespass on the structure (see site photos submitted with our application). In response to my application, I received an email from Lauren Standish requesting additional application fees and an application for a Coastal Erosion Management Permit. As I understand that an additional $250 is due on the wetlands permit application because the repairs were conducted without the benefit of a permit, I have enclosed herewith an additional check for $250. Also enclosed are three (3) copies of an updated survey identifying the Coastal Erosion Hazard Area Boundary. To my understanding, however, the completed repairs and similar future repairs clearly fall within the category of "maintenance of structures when normal and customary," i.e., an "unregulated activity" defined by §111-6 as not requiring a Coastal Erosion Management Permit, as "normal maintenance" is defined as the "periodic replacement or repair of same-kind structural elements or protective coatings which do not change the size, design or function of a functioning structure." Such work is differentiated from the "replacement, rehabilitation or reconstruction of a structure," which would require a Coastal Erosion Management Permit for a permanent dock having a top surface area greater than 200 square feet. Therefore, it is our position that a Coastal Erosion Management Permit is not required for the repairs that were conducted after Tropical Storm Irene on the functional dock structure. However, should the Board have information about the work I am not aware of and/or would interpret the nature of the work differently, please let me know and I will act accordingly. R pectfully yours, Robert E. Herrmann Coastal Management Specialist cc: John Taggart, Esq. Town of Southold A 2 2 6 7 Suffolk County, NY The PE 11 1 1 the Slate of New York vs. L NA~~1/~ (D/EJfENOANI) FOIST E MIWLE IWTIAL ~ Sind AUCHESS J~ yy. V ~G4 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - /"~p STATE //V, IILE FORREGISTMTIWNUMBEfl //St~ STATE TYPE CF-ENS. GATE IXPWES IX ~~,~p{O,~,D,~ATE aF BIRTH DPEMTgi 'PH OVRIYVE 1 THE CPEIATCR OR RE USTEREDOWNERCF VEWCIE OESCRIBEp BELOW OYES OHO M E NO. OATS EMRREY STATE ?N.Y, ?NJ, ?NY. ?NJ, ? fU1ETYPE ? PASs ? CDMN ? :~EWCU N(E BUICN ? CHEV ? CC KIE FMD ? IXAS ? ? PONRAC TOYOTA Rw ? V s ? BOGY ? z tt E ? f OR RUCK iMM1ER ? BUS ? MCY ? &W. ? ? VW ? VIN NVM THE PERSON DESCRISED AE,W IS CiW1GED AS FCIUU g PLACE OF OCCMRENCE / to PC TIME ~ att~RW1Y HY / B E THEAISCi THE? µ VEWLIf D T, CUW CF }HE PTATE OF HEW YLyy( ETHER RPELIf1') oDS ?C N ?Bl4 ?HAz DFF sPEEdHG VFN WT MPH IN A MPH ZCNE OMEfl OfPE14E /Va ~ry r MISBEABEAHM C] FALIWLPNR PYDTFOR IVBI / THE ABdOVE `NAM_ED DEFFty,~O/'+~ qO ONT1ESTAMSATE.TMEAHD ACE OL T1~ F ~ NMAY (.bnRls~s EPIIBI.ti~AI"ro wsr,.a..Pm la _ PARKING SCHEDULED /A/4~fE S "W CONTACICgRiT? SWT1R%y TpYN IDBTICE CWRT. LspPS THE PERSON DESCflIBEO ABODE IS BDMNONED TD APPEAR AT ROU1E]5.8pJTH0(p. NY 11911 _ GTEO TMRMKENPTgM1 AT AYE11/ I FAIBE tTATEMFNT3IEpBNN1EgPWMOEgA QA4sA WDEMFMN/1 WXSLLVITTOSECIILW 9t0.q fi REI.LNYY LOMRAINANT DALE BADDE R COURT COPY imperative that I find out 2 things: (1)WHO was husbanding the apparently now abandoned Permit Applications; and (2)that they DID NOT OWN LAND that they claimed they did. I wrote Robert Hermann (the putative applicant), The Henrys, Attorney Lori Hulse, Your then President King. I have provided you copies of the Certified Mail receipts today. I am reading you now not my first letter of Sept 11, 2013 but my second of October 28, 2013 st e All my letters went ignored. Governments open; governments close and some are just plain Tk b r unresponsive. I did another FOIL seems that Attorney Hulse and Robert Hermann and no one else had last exchanged some emails between themselves in that May 2012 period and NADA; zippo; zero action since. This brings me to the 4' week of December 2013. No one has called me. No one has written me. My neighbors are asserting they own a large chunk of my parents' side yard. The dock still with gaping holes; a hazard for well over 2 years. As an aside the dock hasn't had a boat at it for years long before Sarah Henry bought the land ; It hasn't had a boat at it for maybe some 7 to 30 years. So let's look at the application The dock: built for wealth owner of the compound manor estate across the street Manor Home; 3 or 4 car drive through garage; separate 2 story home; a separate 2 story servants quarters and other sheds ; fish pond, gardens and orchard. All of this is across the street and not at all part of the applicants property. The dock at the farthest southerly edge of the beach property of the across the street manor was built so the owner could watch his boat in the little protected harbor. And the owners of the Manor House could keep a watch on their youngins. Kids or grandkids; neighbors kids such as me. Here are Sep. some photos I took /printed for you. Also, the dock was more of a community dock. Here is a photo with my Dad's boat that was permanently tied there. I know for the last ten years he has not had a boat ON 10/16/1998 the owners across the street sold the property to Sarah Henry note not John and Sarah Henry. Southold Towp as you Trustees know, requires any permit for a dock to be transferred by the current owner to the next. A dock permit does not run with the land. Makes sense so codes and compliances on state and patent waters can be upgraded on transfers. So if someone has a silver bullet permit, it too, would need to have been issued to the proper owner of the property at the time of application for the permit and then duly transferred from each and every prior proper property owners of the property upon which this unpermitted structure sits. In this matter you have none of these. Some may erroneously believe that Gerald Dorman was the owner of the property in 1995 when a wetland permit was issued in that name. However, he ceased to be the owner of record FIVE years earlier. In 1995 Suffolk County Property Records show the property upon which a then unpermitted structure existed was a vacant lot with ownership by Gerald and Lois Dorman, the same owners of the Manor House across the street. This silver bullet permit is really a blank not a bullet. So no permit ever existed for the owners of record. So at the time Gerald and Lois Dorman sold their unimproved beach lot they had never reconciled the permit even as between themselves. Lois was Gerald's second wife. Therefore the buyers of the beach lot, Mark Jacobson and Steven L. Prenzlauer, ccould have had no permit even if a transfer had been done which it was not. Jacaobson and Prezlauer sell to Sarah Henry 41 Page 1< I F p xa D ERIC RAWSON BREDEMEYER FEB 1 9 P. O. BOX 522710 MARATHON SHORES, FL 33052 a ti Te% 305-609-7488 October 28, 2013 Certified Mail NO-700q /630 000/S 5-,l 37 79 Robert E. Herrmann, CM Specialist EN-Consultants 1319 North Sea Road Southampton, NY 11968 AND i President James King Certified Mail NO.A O V7 1620 OOV I SSII 3v o Town of Southold Board of Trustees 54375 Main Rd. P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 RE: Application for Town Wetlands Permit with TOS Trustees for John and Sarah Henry, 1440 Village Lane, Orient, NY, filed may 17, 1011, by Robert E. Herrmann, Agent-Signatory for EN-Consultants, Dear Mr. Herrmann and President King: I wrote you, Mr. Hermann, with copies to several others of my correspondence dated September 11, 2013, concerning the subject incomplete application including a copy to (but not limited to) President King. My letter was addressed to Mr. Hermann based upon my review of the TOS Trustee file during my F.O.I. L. review in earlier September 2013. Mr. Hermann appeared then to be the person to whom I might be able to address my concerns on behalf of my parents/The Bredemeyer Family Trust. Please refer to my letter as if fully state herein. Since my letter I have received no communication from Mr. Hermann of any kind. I have also had no communication of any kind from The Henrys or anyone else on their behalf. I had hoped to hearfrom someone by October 15, 2013, given what I thought would be more than adequate time as I expressed in my letter. I do not know if the subject application has been withdrawn, modified or whether it has lapsed. Am I to expend additional time in this when there has been no courtesy of even a polite reply? I do realize that during this past month the closure of the Federal government (i.e. the Army Corps of Engineers) may have made it difficult for person(s) to properly research matters of concern in my letter of September 11, 2013. 1 also do not know if Mr. Hermann remains the point of contact for the subject incomplete TOS application or related matters. If, either or both of you (Mr. Hermann or President King) know with whom I may discuss/address and communicate about my concerns about the subject application, please advise. Cp~nGafhs Whit 14%1% $~w ye 6-fl es"46 L Sooty 0- Wwhe tafW:t% OFL ~ 12 )2. Due to the temporary closure of the Army Corps I have extended the October 15, 2013, date for the initiation of formal contact by the Applicant and its authorized representative with me until the first business day after the two-day Thanksgiving break. If the TOS Trustees have a Point of Contact (POC) for the subject application that might be someone other than Mr. Hermann, please advise. A response in the negative by the Trustees (e.g. that no new POC is known) would be appreciated. Has anyone at the Town had any contact with anyone on behalf of the applicant recently? I would like to communicate with them. Given the situation I hope that officials with the Town by this letter will assist not necessarily in having my concerns addressed directly but will promote needed contact with the purported applicant. I desire to hear from somebody on behalf of the applicant or to at least know the Town of Southold remains actively involved with a viable POC, if I am not to be ignored or the application silently abandoned. I look forward to a responsive communication as indicated soon. Thank you. Very truly yours, /S/ ERIC R. BREDEMEYER Copy to: (CertMail)TOS Clerk; CCa1v,30 7001//6p0Qpp/ 5 s-// 3y y y Copy to: Co-Trustee John Bredemeyer III of Bredemeyer Family Trust John & Sarah Henry; and Attorney Lori Hulse COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY ¦ Complete Rams 1, 2, and 3. Also complete X Sgryoy~~ w)[r- Rem 4 If RestrICW Delivery Is desired. ¦ Print your name and address on the reverse 0 Ad so that we can return the card to you. ¦ Attach this card to the back of the mallpiece, B. Ra" ry or on the frospace permits. 1. ArtlUe Addrsa~bik to: D. Is delivery address dllrerera 1? 0 If YES, enter delivery address ~k; a- Nev if- us Tows. .ark S 3 Q3.t5 2 0 tAie 2 . 3. ,yp. -r Certlgsd Met ' 0 Express Man V 13 a `r ( / 9 Regsteed 0 Return Receipt far Mardarx2se SO••t~-.O)C11 1v y I S'7) 0Insured Met Omo.D. 4. RsstdUao D very'1(Bft Feel O Yes . 2. Article Number (rranshrr tern swvke labs 7009 1680 0001 5511 3454 '.1 PS Form 3811, February 2004 DoRreega Return Receipt - ",IMM024A.teeri I SENDER: COMPLETE THIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY ¦ Complete Items 1, 2, and 3. Also complete A. Item 4 If Restricted Delivery Is desired. X 2 Print your name and address on the reverse j so that we can return the card to you. B. Recaw~e (.q{'Madilpr• peps of ¦ Attach this card to the back of the malipieca, r Re" w s~ -GG.GC'.'YY ee'''• ~e or on the front R space permits. + 1. ArtlCle Addressed to: D. lsdetwry address d wawt ae 17 0 Yee ( If YES, enter delivery address 0 No UPS _5W 4T SavTW fl~ d~TVj s*S 5Lf 37~ JM4 ~-1R~~ i 19 3 X CWUflad Met 0 Express Man ` II ~d ply So`l~h o .A Ci , I ? Insured mat E3 c.0 D Receipt for Merchandise 4 1 l 4. Restricted DaWery'1(Odra F«V 0 Yee 2. ArUm 7009 1680 0001 5511 3461 (lrensrensthrer homrn service rrfxy PS Form 3811, February 2004 Domestic Return Receipt t12518-024A 1540, ENDER: COMPLETE THIS SECTION i COMPLETE SECTION • DELIVERY ¦ Complete Rama 1, 2, and 3. Also complete A• item 4 If Restricted Delivery Is desired. A6•rrt ¦ Print your name and address on the reverse 0 Addressee so that we can return the card to you. B~ C. Date of Delkwy Is Attach this card to the back of the mailplece, Fk Received or on the front if space permits. 1. AAICle Addressed to: D. ls delivery address otle a t torn Rem 11 0 Yes ff -:w If YES, enter delivery address below: 0 No Ro(otvfi \ 2erv .a-n ICM7, S'3 X4 § I a }DNA -1v 3-K ~f' I Cenined Mall ? Ezprses Mall 0 Registered 0 Return Receipt for Memhendies, 1 T9 1 e 0 Insured Mail 0 C.O.D. b O 4. Restricted Delivery! (Exec Fee) • 0 Yq 2. ArtIUe Number frransferhomservice fabo 7009 1680 0001 5511 3478 PS Form 3811, February 2004 Domestic Return Receipt 1025e5-0244.1610 SECTION ~ i SENDER: COMPLETE THIS ¦ Complete items 1, 2, and 3. Also complete A. Item 4 If Restricted Delhvry is desired. X i 1:14A O Ap t` ' • Print your name and address on the reverse Addresses so that we can return the card to you. B. R t f O. Date of Delivery. ¦ Attach this card to the back of the mallPiece, or on the front If space permits. , D. Is delivery dMa•d 14 O.Yee 1. Article Addressed to: If YES, ender del lelow: 0 No 1 ~owr\ Clef-Ic sr _rOW . h51 ~ S 3t-0~ 9 S M4 1~'~ a man o owr.ee tiw Wcorwad '~..f~ 3O)C l l 1q oRegisla Q 0 Rstm Realpt for MWO" MtIP" 'V` ~-7 0 Instead Mall 0 C.OA. sOt c~~Ot " l q 1 I 4. RestrictedDeMpl/ oft Fes, 011es 2. Article Number 7009 1680 0001 5511 3447 (me wwhorn service law - -^i Ps Form 3811, February 2004 Domestic Retum Receipt toZ6o94¢iFtelOt~ . . . e s _ A awre 0 Ae ' l der t ¦ Complete 9 1, 2Dd. and deep X ¦ p 70fw!" Prtr your name and address on the reverse B. by (printed Ne 1 Received n^e~ c. Date s t that hI can to return ~ the card back Of You. Ip~e. ¦ Attach fhb card 14 A Yea or on the floral M spew Pwn*"- D. Is dewy addles' > . , NO 1. Article Addressed to: c it YES, enter delivery ~ +G~~e~m4NV1 C. IM•} Der ' ~N - ca 0 pMv,1 <319 p11 & ;dcwwwmd SO U~~0. \ TOr 11~ y 0 Ream Redalpt lion t4«ar•eB q O Irk Mau ? c.aa t / b g 4. Rest!WWI Deuveryf (fie ? Yee 2. ~ Number 7011 157? 0002 1742 2004 Domeadc 102a6e-0TM'164d , Return Receipt PS Form 3811, February 2004 I ~ , i- ~ 4' i {'full ~a tri6 - t YI 1 r S. y ~ I ~_d~1 Y4 ~ . t G Vti'., aa~.ln at v wi.' ~ t , I ' y . t t l ~~FA 1 + . I la ~ ~`fra r,S I t 1 y -P f . T ' V I' ; y y ~r - I J r' 3 yigA~ t``~ , 7 Ci:> at l xn+ riti i 9 1 1 s'R I:, % ~•sl l~ra,4 va ,~'~wtwE ~'r f 5 _ a. i9~ 1g11~~5\'~'4!'\~*k~ en ra~ !y v kC I 6yG { 1+Y t u_ c`t' } rit' ~,~~;,~a~7k': y '~c pl~~ i•~.. ~A.F" "~~~~1~'r:. >-t ` ;7- ~I,ta` ^'°T ;y, ALL, 1F S L..;r, Xrv< ,a Fl\Y4 t 1-y~i '~M i 1. a3. , 1 y JH "''V• ~;i, y9i Y V ```d,vt d.'. 'Cth~s , 4; Y+ ~::°1WV.j\L+ '~ti Y S it I w. w- , .r r4 P ` ' y n 4 t ;ti r t; dlt A• ~f. ~l D y. ; }r t 1 1^ gyp ,1 ' t, e. Z r s. p 1t ~'.~,,,i 1} -a I s t.tix a ~ t 1: ~ ~:,,d y s. s"' • .S r" .p 'h 7 0 t 4 Ell 'L i F 1 •v c 49r:Sat! i~ t r i t :.u r ~8. r sl~x v ~ m R 19: ~ S ~ tyr 1.1'c' c ~~s t a' t s ~7 t ~ I R~SLt v''.. t r W N ~x 4 ATISM t = r r r U r J ~ 1~~ 5 r 5~ y~ ^L J 4 .:t a. - a ,~f(il r ,:Y\,. vq- ';r y, ll'' s I _ lit .rr a'Y~ a.,. ro •f, b _ d 'r} :y~ ~ rY -x:;; # t 'U' IN w_ tR a z „k r L i ..way r_ v. t ..111. ~ , yy i eC a ``p rt\ ..Xi{ m tyyl A ~ BaR~~~ ra 4 ~'T~ o 1 s. ° . ' ~ `y4 ~ , ~rY~ ..7 1.~ + ~1 t Dill / er'~t`'~'S,. . -y ~ 4a"ta t ''y~.+._,..r fi ~;i, i' ~~"T. ~ r ~4f; 1 0'` 'r IG ~ ~„4~.+~~i ~I~;~~ E i{ u16t~~~d~u y:;j~4~°'aS. v - '.`f A. ( ,1_ I'. I tit-, a ,y. I +121i{ ~ i „ 11 t u d tir i+,' j? . 5 s t. ` +:S ~ 1 ! I-'•`!a~ - a;. T; i~lw 5~~?~ -_x~ 1; `~l,k• `s ~ ~ti;~~, i+~>,.~ i y':, 1 y'~ aii1~: v,1 .S 9 ~~,1?4'q~l r j..'" M ` ° 1 erg ~ .y~,MvysJ~,'~y~ t I,~'! t~i~r' 'SC '4'yi. J: .y,~ ~,Ca.' yA y~r R oa r'•~ a:' o Cry (T" c ~'tn +rk -.~J. '~x(y la. a K:-C Q7 r'y a-0 o- yr! 9t, +tti tal9 .,r \ pu a~ P ayrr'G - a~ . _ an t 4 ) C t4 i' (y~T t Y + ryM1 ~S IF 'fit ~t .,W+ 'n t ax e 5 l "saw Noy f+fu4P %"k 1 1 Va AA' t~1( 4 ' ' ~ ~ ~,~p r ~t ~9 .tip i°y-y~ ~ ~'h ~a 5 j '7i i ~ t e -s- tyt~9 101 U 't~-~ ,ka~ ¢ t,.,. ; i'_ 'afi(^~'?.:'.'~.. '.4 Vk. {3V. .,,`t;~p t ''"`~y w4~,~. s, gx ~',4~~(•~' Sic .i.,- .w-. ~R Bw is ~r.~, ~s~Zi':. 4hS f ~ s " r•'t ~fl. .G% ti. 1r X,,.x i ! ,r 9.t?.tAtZ r~ 5 ~ f,~ 1 h l ti s Yom' 4J."ry R - T I'E 1 ;1d~yP~ N - .^~°Y "L .:t H,;P ~ o`~:i7.i'•ir ~..1..~:`~ 1 It . .'k F: - L r i 4 F psi s. 00 8t 'WA it l r h '+rc r7 ~ _ a1 t ntlt: t > i." SIC m t - LL - :g ?`W is IT i s is\~{±}4!Ly't>7~i3F~:!~:ist. T4 /S.~.i -rv{-+ T I III KZ Fy ` :A `l =a r x' II 9^" r.'7 Y i y !•I ^'~fp4 1 a.~F~Yi rfs~ M1, JC`~ ,fix ~ ~ ~ tM1 T d ti yW~' t ri 1~ 3 1 Ott" Ip'i ~ y Y t.: wow L Colo Y 'ail. 7 ~A¢ 4 Syr 1M1Sxa;,~ 1 v a a ,_~J a ly, ; ~M k~op Y` F m , r I L-a -s- ' l _ oal%~ r N f _ ~ i• x f ~ r ~~'llfM rl;< A i ~ f ~ 7f 1., 4 g t h,. 14, 0 L rV!' ~ E7_ w M i, u: s Sa 1 1 Y 47 1 Y I "gyp ~ c~ ~ c ~ r ~ ' H4tM XI ff -77 ry rX@e~ u t" v k ~ a. 1 +wAr Fl i ~ t VA- w`h M1n C` 4; Y,• " t 1 lent ~ w k. tl t ~ ~ AFf t c 1 I - -mss II I I, I' II 'll t I~ <r a`~ I wil ` d ~ r 7„~',: f hl 5~ ~.aos~ y.,.. I I - _ _ ..r.wc`r?'Ai~'. `+1?!~`•~z~~`~ - lot Wlsi+a' R : w, M1~ I w+`"IV4 i .n "*Wu w..loeG . - Y, .yy •.w.+_. "wit.. 4 ~ t _ ~.a~-. zi42 ~y,i ld+~~°H~7+F'~r ~aar*-~Twrr •:sr~R~ ..4r .r~ ,-.,,.V ....;~s~ Vgm -w d , n,. A Y' la ors . „ . ^ s >°Mwnegl!'~ .I`dla+,".. I w» d A u 7 I, » ,iC waw~^t„ SE" 1tq?~ .'a<s"' + Ir< v ~:~G"o"w71~9 _ - e~.. 1 - ter' ~*A"2 ~y ,,,C y r 94e, , f h r. I ' 1 II ~I I if ' NI I it I s~~ ~ II J. t I ~ lj I I I' II lil i~r .1 , ~ I I Ji ! i' III I A. I 1i ,M1 4 7~ lrr~li~ I t}frl I~1 ,~1Y ~ Ij+, t i q r r 1 INS ) ~I Rom" PL,,I+ Nil i. y If `f# r kyy y,~~1''., ~ I(1 {(t~ 5f~y h~F 7~, i y14 ~ Icr'1 ~ 1 y t 1 I' tSn i i 4 ~ u? } r Lt b ~ I, ~ - 1i_~t n~ I } I I ' PIS' (t f. I I e ~ , I:7(~~ r , ~ y T 1 ly6j } [ r 1 f + };I Il n e 5a I _ _ ( I ( ( S! Irrli 1 ~ 5 r d ~ ~~r~ r Y~ ~ I ~ I f! r Ry I :1 M1 t I~ i a y lu ~ Ha b.lt' F ~t 11 4 ~t v," }`fir I n~3t'•: x3tM f l ' l',W~ I'~ 1 tl`i)' 1 7 \l / l ..f ~ ,,~'7 ~I ~ ~ .`•f.~~'l. _.~:Ililwau. ~ - ...T'~ - zov a - c.p- x >il+.++•~"y_~--•.....~ _ A.; ~d" a~V": ru~..".i: t „~^jr r" - .:c- Via!^, k~ rr Wl I y b _ ` r. .l qp it .,x LL i 4 1 17 J •I ~ i Y _ C r r t ~ ~ rl. f' l --,t;k k, y~~ rylfrl~ • i' Ih. r 41 1 {t t~1..~. >N~,. ' ~ ^r 4~ !j ~`I„i ~rl~i jt~l~r~'>if. i i^ _a1 - a ,r I Ldi 5 1 f i~ / 7~ 1 C r 1 a r i,, ~ r o'l' ' 1.' M,1k t 4 h r q ~,I t?' r I1F r ~ 1 ' ri x ~ ~ ~ 4u''r a!. 1 r~? of ~q.. ~ 1 ~ •W J OOT SJaTaw i e a 1 Sj r- 00V ~aaT y 1 ago* i a saw ^lip 0000" a / - mot, r .000 :p ,...y _ {I~~ ~A a ~1iy Jam' _ _ t. - _ _ '00000000~ b& As T : I' x - M, EE ~ l - 4 5 ~ 1 1 1 • r~ ~ d~' ti ti 0 S.• X15 h bF .7 s i ~rs 31 k s r5. ~ r p N %0 V- 0 O (p r > C37 ~z~ ~ .p. ~ , ate; a I z s' - and again no permit and no transfer. Next Sarah deeds to John and Sarah Henry who merge the vacant lot with its unpermitted dock structure to the lot with the primary dwelling for address 2440 Village Lane, described on SCTMap Lot 17.1.. Of course, No permit and no transfer. The discovery of a void document in support of an application, the genesis being violations, with no colorable transfers at all and no association remaining with the Manor House across the Street is a red herring and not a magic bullet. The 1995 Foundationless paper has different dock dimensions. Another 2 FALSITIES. [FYI: The "dock lot" is too small upon which to build its own house ...the dock is no longer and as now owned will never be in front of an owner's dwelling] These processes do not require notice of neighbors, however, as to the Henry's due diligence in concerning buying an unpermitted dock gives me pause. Also, the Henrys have an ownership interest in the house on the harbor immediately to the north of 2440 And, I am sure if there were a next owner (BFP without knowledge) maybe they would do their homework better. Are we looking here at an application for a dock to be permitted or a dock to be repaired.? The letter of May 10, 2012 emphasizes permitting of the dock and as far as I know that letter has never been expunged or invalidated. However, the newest letters that bring us here focus more on the repairs than the dock itself. Do we count the previously sneaky construction in the numerator or the denominator when looking at percentages? Of course in your Code percentages do play a part. The Coastal Zone Erosion Hazard percentage and the already permitted structure repair percentage. I will address your code in a moment. Stay with me In my photo of Nov 11, 2012 you can see the light deck color of the unpermitted repair-construction and the darker by the gaping hole section -shows the stop work line of when the constable came. both in the foreground and the new decking in the distance. The estimates of repair from Mr. Crowley from June of 2013 now added to the Application materials does not advise which repairs he is making; do the Trustees give credit such that the bigger the violator the easier the permit? hope not. But I do see that Crowley Marine agrees that permits are still required whether he repairs or rebuilds the dock. I also do not know if Mr. Crowley in his reconstructing of the dock considers the savings since recent code has a 4 foot width dock and not an 8 foot wide dock. Maybe the number is half. Of course you guys are no a zoning board and appeals on the Coastal Zone determination go to the Town Board. Again, there is no clue as to the numerators and denominators for percentages. As for including, the what might be considered and the undated estimate from A Mr. Christiansen the person who performed the violative work and who the constable wrote up on 11/17/2011...is like asking the fox to regurgitate the chickens from the henhouse when caught and looking through bird entrails for proof like the soothsayers for Julius Caesar. Next, on the last business day of 2013 and the last day of President King's term as President the applicant is finally heard from at least on the public record again. The letter is to President King with copy to John Henry and Attorney Stephen Angel. BUT NOT ME. Let me read paragraph one and then the 2 paragraphs that concern the survey correction. 51 Page EC Read Tab 7 Gee guys the date of the survey showing the property line change was done on November 1, 2013. So remember my letter of Oct 28, 2013... I gave them until after Thanksgiving actually December 2013 but no nobody shared the Corrected Survey. Yes, there is a correction of the South Property line. Yes, the prior survey was False. I had to get this letter of Mr. Hermann from a FOIL request within the last 2 weeks. And, the corrected south property line of the applicant took all this effort by me. the protection of the homes and property of our parents is in the Ten Commandments in that we shall Honor and as for property that predates back as far as I know to the Pharaoh 1100 BC Amenamope. Chapter 6 : 01 Do not move the markers on the borders of fields. 02 Nor shift the position of the measuring-cord. 03 Do not be greedy for a cubit of land. 04 Nor encroach on the boundaries of a widow. Our Town of Southold and NY has changed much since the 1800's but although it may have no longer use the Decalogue as the Code; your Town Code and the protection of Civil Rights of yes even the parents of our elected officials probably are in these codes. Let Me finally thank MR. Hermann and Surveyor Corwin for correcting the south boundary line. Now how does the Town of Southold reflect the False survey submitted and the new Correct line . I have not seen that the applicant has done anything to limit the ramifications of their false survey line. I am really please that they recognized this error. In order to preserve the correction since there needs to be accuracy in the record. May I suggest this Errata Sheet be affixed to any surveyor mention of survey in the Applicant's File prior to December 30, 2013. Of course, you have your own attorney and she should know how to protect the record. As with medical records changes or anything when erroneous and false matter needs to be processed, there has to be proper entry within the proper context. Here is my sample/Suggestion of such a Form maybe Ms. Lori Hulse has lots of experience handling errors. But I have made this one easy for you if you wish to use it. If not used something similar I implore since I have sent many certified letters to the applicant and to President King, your Town Clerk tl and Attorney. I am just so pleased for you final correction if not the lack of courtesy. U` %6 6 I > ~wrr FF D f na-~ D D4 r. D FE8 1 q ; HA/ Boar opuses n ~ IJ IIJ IAllr. 14umM, Jo, mu )mom Rm4 Cluunivi rDL- po» oM m.. l A1ll vY R I5 1011 ~:nWPY1, NV iIYl1 ~J1 Ir J M Y.J SYnY lle.xv END VIWw luve.lllku to av Itrn Mx Kmp Ax Yuu ue ewue, w M. 2.1 xvmMMypxuliM IvW1 YsvW Puwsl m Cy$75 4`11t, Y IOI SaWwW l..w l:uL m Dvlmil a IuYIIY luuuuw{!w\ IYI Iw uu1K w tlu .uUlsi pgs1Y uvm tl IM Ju I4Yk, u wYluwrl4y hlwio vul pluWppbl IW~ nJ1.11e mKS. Tvt gJ1u11M w>. upviVd ~ eMY u(x vxrlmMn wxul m Ml, llwy fnr JuJ laps tlW wlv mtl: n I\v "Mpxnnee0"+vvmrr Jls wVUeJ n.no J.vuR Junny Tupiul $bmx Ima b AutlW 1011. Ally vxniWM 1\c'Mx'ui1 Iw»uw1.1 wu WvuW LY ww Mfv<tlW Wnw Re Jx\ k Null 6. (iuxui V~uirxl NvW Amt, we .wW un Pawl w wMW .o Apliulwn f r. t'uwwl ('elan M.npo4 Wui1 uM Ibl u.r rypllulbn lu . WaMJI I'smil wwW ru lu Puael Ptli1 xA yglblb Y.m M1Ml Ax Y'.u wu Jw .wue. I Nuu I.vriwxh .puxu wish rya. 11w Ilnucq uJ Wn HWU iepNlllg mY p°Illm nut Ju. N. W ...w. ul IM Ip:., dupe 111 Jm Iw IuxYM Wv M. Pntl.l I IYIUBMImn drlivu Ia.xJ, waW1u. rrwnpnn. wlWUm rams wY.wWmJ DMDiD.d.SMM1I Chbpa III ieauW W ruviry• lM -oauMUliln. moGiflullm a m.D.+im a pi d. muxuu...:' wlrr. 'niumliun- v Jel'wJ n IM "Imwtru[liw wiUa. nu4(IOYiaD vf. MI[9n. W [M of'MN qul. xr v.vW >DN N Nx O.IbuuO OJ1 lerlu am w1 N Mem Y IM , of mMtlb.' "Na1W "nf{mutnaMIMxM IunJ,i. Jvfd by Ey CT.ps I M 11 ul }sdaI,.-1xo77 ,d vuM.bw tlrvuO wa.wlu ur paatiw auluy whm Jo oa rlw{.IM vm Jmpi. w -V of IwuilaiPx mucmn.- MJ'MnvW muamumv of. ulWUe Jou Y rtDUb . .oWW uxwiui muu9..un1 \vlnl" purvu4 w CYpa III. 1nplM~ Ib IFWeM mW fuY I LUCIUrt w 6-.. »I.... liwul IN ut M.iwpleY ii I. JuamWo wMha U ===W u . rv4vil". (rquvhl . CuYY rnvim M.L.Ileewm I•e mJ) w Uxx ~wpviotl v C'uYl Wv.i111 M.IUpm.vl P-4 AW m m.\u IIU1 .IU.M1iu~w IMrn1 u' Ib !aw Jea+ibN JA6iM.. W uM a IM xmpbW wl .eJ 6. eu.iJaeJ. Ibwm, Eomun WJIYOVJ llgin m IFv al Nill ~uVlw ul lb. u.l b, a.\ ~w,.. wm M . P ,kPrtx• m'wn n. Iwn~mM S.mh • uDw~a nH1. Jn M.muw wp. Pr IMV ~wnkJ ruy.in YwW M u.whvxJ u wW. 1:. nM ul I Nw aiuNMJ apw u1 m u.u Wv Wb U.. Vmiwniuo .vJ CMWry M... wD 1. 111. mryn Nu »en xvngleud Wa Irvpul ]IVn11my i.e., Ou :uW Wim Pf row 1'. 1 V- Jw\mY .PJ Pcw uwJc D'JwYV rpy W .N11{v.. JI. ai M `PEW NukA Slt J50. ANO aubaed u n m wP y RItliM cPPnaW=e ur 111. s! ]W wm\ Dray.:. w pilkp MJ mmmtl I:vbn Ja1 uW w >.iM11W Ity Ey Ilmriux 4.1tly, hinYUy Jiu w1.1 awl n! Ilu v'wnplvlW uJ iii iadW IePi1. rv S:/el W. v11uw.W ar:MW .n wimue Iva CnPVky Muiue liuv.ui.j fw IM fWllyle.rva wu WDe JIt1 »IwE.~uk 33111: W. Ilmpvb MfuMl m.•wvt.Yq Ilu dc111apm vwWerNnllW Ulmu $1.1 lm- sox arm.tm. ,,,rwyy ns.ooo,,,,m arse, N,.yuy yy rRrk rpn "i s1 by ft rears .Nw.yn. N N 11 a,lve m. "him ft; Ne'IA.Ne.,YgrM nM N.1 the rgwiw.paulJ M ebaaariesell n nrrm.l m.armga" riaayuirbyl. Crwg1 Ym.lm Mwpmrrr Pmmh ".A N if it N JMYn1IrJ XW Xw rft. M E. tlW.r;. he b p'mRUI rmefied ' •pl rquNrg . Many Pnr.ien fAa.bs..m V se tbm t , Ne u ui M b w A .I nube.pMnHFedva aft .-Mils bC Na(W:M1xnCUJ..munby em u . mian rtbn" i ftese rgw. mia0a be 0.an !mm r.ewl'maumi.lnwY Rata. SpeiynlH, mh.w . Rtes. nMarl q Salion 2" telo4ace) awe.,, mNbilblirq a r,wwa fib. cf ..tr.er.e or M1cllly. N rivet ur lle quw site (n place) nap it, • nrcb.a in w Ouiwrl q Me f',.wl Fmmr N.rvX Na ((:I'l IA) N. M.s w,cnres m.y rxr b 'TUIarJ. '"rod fan1r-MlFiri iiarlubpAN wIXU...p miM1•Tyr is bIrmfl.r Ile.,rrtanMy.w nlrMwt Xe . C'.upl6tvb Mryenmt Pmnh, tba ft wM i. defmul a wi nemlx mimv.cNm thalwa 1 wv .4iMUM Feewtb a see pla peprW by N.Jr TA G..Or Ill 1w Snrvya. W M1tM rvr..aNU 1. 7013, Is" M1a bamr ierimW to hdr.N mwyw. "If74t ft W- vessel Restates rte ibtate mmpmela mM..lme, Witt Xb uym.tM Nil r.PNn.rwX ruse aft Oat AM Is -se" rift ses rmird PIuF 1 w aW.. elly rytaai.X Xr tle 13mr1 sewer tv xAl.n4 apllrmim Is emir rrt.u.illN . inX SJtHRt b.maaaq. rpr..ylvaeb.NX. mm.r eMet ra tsm.nm na.n l...lm.y it wee ruFmieW cM1M.be pyrrrMbm,..tMy mu m,r muR Xyn.yvm.ufJrt m`°. ^R° N. y^..uy Ir.. Yb bmt twbd n m,taR r am. b tb uXN of0ro.mbvly pgaty Ime u ie Nta c Bre yrXlpyH n l SWei sees R1,bplrbhaL. 11 M bm I m . essei yby It leellor y XrymNy -seed".... .M1J W Y 1 rRwy • aft ,Nba 11.1013.ishisish "M b RyM M. yu. W~ , Mr. Caron wmlMeJ tl.t ye Xrebe.m,wm M1erH pepvs,ry pp.ud by W. yWem7v, vNN bb. I uyb MIb .wyey Pq»lY lir diJ i_. . r.ryb mr.eCNm lYrswu., LM,ve.lhe 1. he u Is, 0m eem by n nm.atim Mite is u.u1 se ytl se rnweJ gllr of Ibs P.wr> Rae ,.vvmmu. M.. 3rrry. J i urn y. v.N 'ejefte estate umy P^FsefY litaawyentamtaw.m.tbtavwad pnrjetien a(. pppty Ibw 6 dmm .t l ..4m Wb ro Ne MnI:..M rwt u . mvmow v..M p,~jummt of Ilse pysely IW for ptapeb. of Mbeseby'Yip.ir .ipbR Trmelora lM1mym rill bpmllrlw ms IrmRrttamrmsta rlrN bwtatlvy liuaNN. SIwrIJ tbu BeuE Jm..en. Xa h sv rrm.pm ris m p,Wm. awme,X 0r. neM far 1:rwW Ibveiorr .w bs m.J.. d.v rab bps bve 0rtl Xwl MXilbrl NMveWm n r,gN,M aplic.tbn 2RW w Ihltapob rosRSse M1N~~,~rlm. a ~•llmR MM my mW libb mme M1N v.b ra M NpImX ..J mPletrJ R rytlly )nuR N~Nse,ere Cmml Mamvwn SmcNIM IMn Have, Sr4Nn AsM1 S.9 j6 2 F E B 1 ERRATA SHEET N OTICE OF ERRO Saar; f IOT Board of Tri,ste , -s TOWN OF SOUTHOLD BOARD OF TRUSTEES IN RE: PROPERTY AT 2440 Village Lane (f/k/a Bay Ave.), Orient, NY 11957 in Suffolk County the matter of proposed dock permit and its related applications/materials for including but not limited to those submitted for Review under Chapters 96,222 and 275 of the Town Code District for the property at SCTax Map 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1. This errata sheet is hereby affixed to any and all diagrams and drawings done under signature of a licensed surveyor filed or maintained within the Town of Southold files for the subject applications or referencing same for the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY, SCTax Map 1000-26-1-17.1 that are depicted between the dates commencing January 31, 2012, and continuing through October 31, 2013, whether said diagrams and drawings are mere drawings and plans or deemed/determined by competent authority to be surveys or not. Description of error: This diagram and drawing although placed and maintained in the official files of the Town of Southold Board of Trustee (other location, if any ) does not correctly describe the south property line of the Property Situated at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York (SCTax Map 1000-26-1-17.1). I Without otherwise validating and/or verifying the accuracy of the remainder of the diagram and drawing, A CORRECTION OF ERROR has been noted and made on the "survey prepared by Nathan Taft Corwin III, Land Surveyor dated November 1, 2013" with the "CORRECT SOUTH PROPERTY LINE LOCATION" for the south property line of Property Situated at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York (SCTax Map 1000-26-01-17.1). BE OF NOTICE TO NOT RELY UPON THE ERRANT SOUTH PROPERTY LINE WITHOUT REVIEWING THE CORRECT SOUTH PROPERTY LINE FOR SCTM#1000-26-1-17.1 DO NOT REMOVE THIS ERRATA SHEET WITHOUT PROPER AUTHORITY AND OFFICIAL NOTATION. Signed, Title/Position Affixed Date zT Might I comment that the Old False survey made it look as if not only were The Henrys adversely possessing the land but the diagram of the dock looked as if not only them dock but even the required 15 foot setback of the dock was compliant. So the property line is correct now. I breathe somewhat easier knowing that The Henrys did not add my parents' Trusted land onto their slowly amassing shorefront enterprise. I am still also concerned that here is that shed on the southern and beach side of the Henry's main House. It too, is unpermitted. Why don't the Henry's just build the dock to current code with proper 15 foot side setbacks? I do agree with the Applicant's letter of December 30, 2013, that one of the possible methods of determining the seaward projection is the right angle from the shoreline method. I must also state that New York since 1852 in the case of O'Donnel and Kelsey has also recognized the proportional method. I read from the 1989 Case of Freeport Marina. I found Mr.Angel's website a treasure trove. Attorney Hulse you should look at it. Anyway, the O'Donnel Court discussed the proportional method. I quote: Read TAB 9 ?ee T~ I have pictures here of how my neighbors Laura Weil and E1 Camp to the south of 2660 (i.e. property J/ south of Bredemeyer's) have their bulkhead and dock and it along with the applicant's dock as proposed by the applicant taken together limit the access of 2660 Village Lane to the navigability line as the holding in O'Donnel states. I also realize and appreciate that you Town Trustees could be forced to go back and reallocate shorelines. Brother Jay would not be so recused but I have no doubt that only the Attorneys fees will accumulate were we to seek the proportional method rather than the perpendicular. Let me CAREFULLY state that for the pending application of The Henry's ONLY the BFT will agree to the perpendicular method. Without knowing of any re-dos or some other future submission I cannot say so blanketly for either the Henrys or any other neighbor. I do not wish for you Town Trustees to bog down doing your waterfront alignments and realignments so my licensed brethren of New York feed on your woes. Accordingly, I do not disagree with Mr. Hermann's letter of December 30, 2013, but only for this Application as currently filed. I apologize that new York does not have a plenary mediation law like we do in Florida, however, there are limited institutions in New York as Mr. Engel may know with which THE BFT had been willing to participate. 7I ort Bay Marina, Inc. v. Grover, 149 AD 2d 660 - NY: Appellate Div., 2nd Dept. 198... Page 2 of 4 (action No. 2) for essentially the same relief requested in their counterclaims, but added parties and 8 increased the area of dispute. f4 A joint nonjury trial was thereafter held and it was stipulated that the trial would be bifurcated so that ` the declaration of riparian rights would be made prior to and separate from the determination as to damages. The trial itself essentially focused on three issues. The first issue involved the determination of how the riparian rights of the parties should be apportioned within the cove. It was stipulated that the appropriate method of apportionment would be the so-called "proportional" method; however, there was still a question as to how the proportional method should be applied. The proportional method has been recognized in New York since as early as 1852 in O'Donnell v Kelsey (10 N.Y. 412; see also, People ex rel. Cornwall v Woodruff, 30 App Div 43, affd 157 N.Y. 709). In Groner v Foster (94 Va 650,652-653, 27 SE 493, 494), the court, citing O'Donnell v Kelsey ! (supra , formulated the following step-by-step application of the method: "measure the length of the shore and ascertain the portion thereof to which each riparian proprietor is entitled; next measure the length of the line of navigability, and give to each proprietor the same proportion of it that he is entitled to of the shore line; and then draw straight lines from the points of division so marked for each proprietor on the line of navigability to the extremities of his lines on the shore. Each proprietor will be 1P entitled to the portion of the line of navigability thus apportioned to him, and also to the portion of the 662 662 flats, or land under the water, within the lines so drawn from the extremities of his portion of the said line to the extremities of his part of the shore". The plaintiffs were in favor of the application of the method as formulated in Groner v Foster (supra) i but the defendants were not. The defendants proposed a modification of the proportional method which would take into account each party's ratable proportion of the cove's surface area. Under the proposed modification each party's prorated share of the line of navigability would be awarded as in Groner v Foster (supra); however, the surface area in the cove would be awarded in the same proportion as their frontage was to the entire frontage of the cove. To achieve this allocation of the area within the cove, crooked or angular lines (as opposed to straight lines), of necessity, would have to be drawn from the points of division so marked for each party on the line of navigability to the extremities of each party's lines on the shore. The court rejected the modification proposed by the defendants and apportioned the riparian rights of the parties within the cove using the traditional method. On appeal the defendants claim that this was error. We disagree. It is clear that the court's application of the proportional method was equitable and in keeping with the long-standing principle that the right of direct access from a landowner's entire frontage to its share of the line of navigability is paramount (see, Town of Hempstead v Oceanside Yacht Harbor, 38 AD2d 263, affd 32 N.Y.2d 859; see also, Jenks v Miller, 14 App Div 474; Consumers Coal & Ice Co. v Citv of New York, 181 App Div 388). The modification proposed by the defendants, as the court correctly noted, would unfairly encroach upon Seneca's right of direct access to Freeport Creek. The actual ~~size of the waters encompassed by the connecting of the dimensions under the proportional method http:lscholar.google.com/scholar case?case=9027254845788003079&hl=en&as sdt=4000... 2/4/2014 Moving on from the false survey. I like to but I must bring to your attention that the Town Code is your Town Code any Court will figure you guys know it and if you don't use it then how can you expect others to do so. First on your Wetland Code: Section 275-6 (17) Under Applications for wetland permits the Applicant provides and I quote "A statement indicating submission of false information will result in rejection of the application and may subject the applicant to criminal sanctions." We are already here due to a violation but I do not in any way seek additional criminal sanctions. You have your own legal Counsel. What I do see is that the submission of false information will result in the rejection of the application. I know it sounds petty, but the applicant here is only here because of a court requirement; and your code spells it out not me the term is WILL result in rejection. Not may; not could but WILL. No discretion. Next, the applicant since December 30, 2013, now uses surveys in lieu of project plans. Look at the Survey of Nate Corwin updated for now February 4, 2014: The Old Dock Notes from prior versions May 10, 2012, now are omitted just disappear. (ONE REASON I want that South Property Line Errata Sheet affixed). You need a table of contents just to know at which time which survey exists. Cover letters from May 2012, and December 2013 shape shift again with a February 4, 2014 "survey"... This applicant shape shifts so often This survey of February 4, 2014 describes that the Notes are from the Owner and Other Consultants. This survey has shape shifted into the plan. The Owner does not appear by name anywhere on the survey. Has the dock been sold? Who are these other Consultants? Does your Department of Education allow surveys to become catch-alls for whatever unknown persons want to slide in unqualified stuff? There should a project plan with a responsible person planning it. It could have drawings and diagrams but it would not be called a survey. , 81 I Next, the applicant now in his post-December 30, 2013 survey submission do what I call their tribute to William Burroughs and the Dadaists cutup technique of writing. When they don't like the word in your Town Code they use the Code Number and when they like the Word they will use it. Sort of a cut up technique. So I draw your attention to the code your Code does NOT say as the applicants wrongly states : I quote: " Existing fixed timber dock to be permitted pursuant to Chapter 275 for the purpose of establishing the ability to undertake "ordinary and usual maintenance," i.e. actions not affecting more than 75 % of the structure, and/or normal maintenance as defined by Chapter 111, . it goes on to periodic replacement or repair etc. and so on.. The problem is that is not what your code says. the 75 percent figure applies only to do& permitted structures. I read your code Under Section 275-2 Definitions and usage: Under the definition for Ordinary and Usual Maintenance: I quote" Actions on wetlands-permitted, functional structures which do not involve more that 75% of the entire structure." The 75 % number is for permitted past tense That was conveniently omitted in the cut-up method of Town Code presentation of the applicant. They don't have a permit. The percentage is meaningless. What about a functional structure? This dock is not a functioning structure. No boats at it for 8, 9, 10 or more years. It was designed for the house across the street no more grandkids to watch of an owner. No more nice neighbors looking out for kids and boats. We're still nice we just have been barricaded off. For safety and security the dock should be in front of the applicants' dwelling(s); also that unpermitted shed is in the way of watching small kids that might get out on the dock. And there have been no boats to watch for safety concerns for years. If history tells us anything an oversized dock is an attractive nuisance. The applicant is a part-time resident but even when he is here this dock is at the periphery; out of sight out of mind. II OK let's look at the Dictionary to be sure I am spot on. I use Webster's Third International Unabridged Dictionary: 91 Page I MM Quick for a moment what does False mean: Read TAB 10 4t, e. What does Information mean: y~ What does correct mean: What does functional mean: So the dock has not functioned with boats for years. It was not meant to function as dock for the applicant but the Manor Home and large Estate across the street. The Applicant's enterprise is not clear as to his upland lands and if he will use them to turn this dock into marina with not in front of his houses and out buildings. As for the Coastal Zone Erosion permit there is no proper plan and a survey that has hearsay entries. There is no reference to dates and the percentage method suggested seems to reward violators. The bigger the unpermitted repair and the longer time taken to get it before your board will be rewarded acceding to the theory of the applicant. My Brother remains recused; the rights of my parents forgotten; I am ignored. I agree with Mr. Angel yes, some might consider that I am adverse to the application. So what is your Board to do. 1 am glad I am not your attorney. Here you have a dock 1600 square feet that is 8 times the size of what you would permit today. Here is what I have done I have already tabled any and all applications that the Bredemeyer Family Trust has pending with the Town of Southold. The Town has not been straight with me and the applicant appears to parse the word. l 101 N A Inns raise broMn, _ •rrA r ••~a1< pr[r Jd rlnR °I FALL , Jul of MME Eur° eilhef8 r~ 1,11, Snlpa n ; AE0.9ACFEV CAN4rrrEa -tern (Odd<a (aceJ gr.1 the I., am ~ ane aain a[bypOdlwr 411-sow H : ,o aoW or land) in autumn 0nn rum and BI W ) 1.1111.0 \ n ; AUTUMN faW buckMoijisY ggD fall to vi : Io an, also., doing --."hill, EM. actively or I... in... of hen : air spm ,ere (B or yy r brcmo' fight IS : to bolo to "I Veil in as noon as dinner wu - woolly isyr soutern U. S, having Is d Jul tona en ~ /I a eat r to ob)oollh issues er ish WiN It, the undC is C. a~ wess I fall logalher rl: to become identical : become kvelM -used bfollowed ud use A Wo" globular !tulle, a hin rW nor very - ,of s Nech sounds forms pp faW in ~Wi~w`4 ~ -nown lull-~riD n : • trap with • door or • -,Hall that falls table buckwhMt n ; nchy. pun the victim r (POIYYOnum an AmeriCan herbacwIa ins ip a0 alp P W manes. 1. v 411 wehat it a pale Yellow dusly-striped hairy Carer- labs balf do srandrn+7 with seeds rewobnot btsrb DVS s[Yw 3a¢ani~ o other moll Ihat is the larva of either of two common while arniid of the western test 'orbs (Nrphanbia room end H. rrerorl and that live iraag ^ : e low tufted pan (Munroe sgrnrr0y) Ltun es rolog" / i.awes- sariou.. in nests of webbing at the ends of branches or many flow be IF V.S. with stiff kavn err wiry branches Gam WWr is g • Passage, ergmr d11 Whom treat - ape n : a tall herb (Zlamrc4rrb mrohneu4) of IM Par Ia II Wheat n : " compare FEW CATERPILLAR Y anunculacua Of the uxesn U. S. with tarp nut ,all wind rr ; e ka ba,ic w nd laves and while epe,aIOS flower better Rlnmsm ms¢ ebtmW / am= war, Ian wit05 faW ~Wence V n, pECE Card cADLNC{ f ` PTVE n , a Card ug, 1/'yrV " W«+e Il.rmIm ~apnaNm) with (4N leaves, briule ruulmsnand very hbeeet~ \ • ddl.e lumina, pea caving an opponnt a ,o the c"onumfuf one in1u,W of of do- A dale<0mmaaa IwCOmC mmblewttadsd" that bunk rl []obe card tab - fall a.'0 n ; use uNe away el muuriU .oil IoW Cut n ; is cut 1 : to play a false-urd nor line touches the YW~j ori'luMult Lar hen flYdhhing in Which ndth<r fly ~ lots Per a/a:e / / rp~l FEU WdMU-) .0.~ and AM this.-rY \'felUlsarg fat" cedar n :any of several trm resembiinu cedar of the a ~zz~Y WLC¢p /nl+us t .Iris Y7 er - -es r bale[," lalmrlq or L °barlua, fr. faW Celli a Cap. in odor syrt// s, resu Rot hfalsef w /e err IOlstlg(pa w ; w .uan[P - : FAIAFIM. pECFIy[a; if C..` ' • calling she' is hung so ispeone- me dls 4oce below the _ be is M ls \ fa nbo Is [ IoW cplpia4 _ j DPr 11 ad/ -u/-EST [ME refs, au; fr. OF & L' /a aaloml[s n ; is plant °f the genus Boinme e eemlb M a FI AIL]lea j alru; peal Par'. o[ I.,.rr to dn<ive - W c nh bit A : AxaICAN CRIMAaOYT z m borb I. ; uu.rN[ou I no, corresponding to truth or realir 18W ehmC i r : a small dark bu jj n -[e (me itcW Vgnp xcoaaECr ((his assumption that this 4 tsm, he 'he' gih rommonlateded unchhn bw g (NY+Iu+ and r) re- w'IY nwstM1l< in'erprc4bon is d monnnbl _ gin appnruna aM haM4 • the oualhY wan Of pna~ • ~11rtornoble Y untrue : Ln claims are in,. emir ads Destructive ,o cultivated crops nda antltl not Often Seriously ltOltryr (a "C11RALry (the Oz N rv0 m, J wauessarr a g S.L.PeYne) (the ,"'im.ny any O of (,am acirmAcumul a cirtusloud ola eA . I e) (i)Talaxa[k~of e seummr . onimbus cloud -ppl.i.ble Ihicknenoriginuin¢ to his wil anlu'n[sri our .hi' nders n falsehood : not truthful I8W e4hoi statute Cl ; called also rbunderrrorm clrru+ ICtherc fs is cmuln. .1 'tie ~ - m +yn<i- y er. o! her uccunn -Shak.) knowingly (arse Claims .pion the a °rnalidna the maker of aanA (,Deer tW n : any o1 esvnal Penn 'mgr, rings. I'4[tetl to men[ or • e government or an de ~fm uula in ..pared. a persons -H.E.Saliflor IS (1) false , °cY ,hero! Y a ( rt- hlee 4=" n ; is blind, i,ii11ijn re ?\¢ta4) 'oh 1o < seal") dice 0 A ; CAADITA i known function lying (rkh :r , nlalR0 "gtend ive In to dratest: te"e IVs false cO'LUMI n; WILD DINV[e is reypprptwifact ..cb . zwnada -Dols. Donne) (7) inaccurate yPSOw n : any of nvenl coniferous shrubs or treat in burning of the horn aarw a ma fr. nvurr "Cat of Ca ne ;m member or the e nalmgn[so Ohe r f war t : f he to mialntl : oEC[rtwE, D- genus Cbamaec bald) m'h of 1anusu ,haw -Louis Bro.- teal of • cYpren Ypa uhhful or l° FEE) wish foliage fals err or FALSE z°embling (aW pow Twr ye n" p robust Oat p e r.encnue Ye] , n to op "[.lout alle once, or far P s ay n 1 : i.r r 9 a l : ,I^ s, PERFIDIOUS Ao.a p Glands (a s0 dandelion is lse Daci o'er~4~ Aa>? "c'J Car Jn¢ .,her than hat is lover) Com as, of a : any Of u r rioua A mer ican he rbs A aen` D vmY 'T' ¢ned to deceive ;nor purported or a pOfi4e) having flower herds rcsemblini Irbhe" . of a + d Y 'runty, -parent mna<lion (family tl4'In ufshed to 2oeu .be" L '..Dear r'C4L, aH A4, genuine of real. COVN - L tads (paverceaaibo e xotP. sr[nous (^•tiun L( rel.j packau~•-\u~L(ve ban as faW dawn a Joint lD on ,he nai¢rn horizon sometime faW • b nl un d er ~ c ) ( before dawn; often :zoo, ^CAL next va 1l Riroliff"too 6tr"glamor r ngto ( dtttla of of IoW doer. era n: an uuic(Amartira ma 04 . r male or assumed (a ea' of - 1`n[ ,o o hers p -.Data n I : tloc ar Iror yy D ) With the death CUP (A. Wha/lotdr+) but a ~nL often nfusW representation, rnpgtrn era no )I~ Is "DUO,)<riahe-led". gill, _L tanh)(b yon, - lemon Yellow Or hire with no Iron of ce matins for he pis CUA ""endue, wintlo r~ ois Long) b • euNx p oats. false DarNn n s etD?ser f dead Ir a having pro 0 : of a kind releteA to. re- bulbous s4m ban wish the volva separngre n and he very part/.) that is sometimes or M1a•.,) parties similar to another a byy to Olson. poove sum faW wtaach ur,es a ~ rased kaaL n ",re s the un0ualifiM vernacular - paler that !8106 dichotomy n; a branchin which the V l Ym 'era , nsc, pea) a used in plane todivid<dkhommouslyallhe geem led or pans o/ (1) : not Essential or Inaln eras appear (aloe alp an, r5[uhar Car +"noG"'cnwl a !structure that are rem pay 'he powrh being con's I brut, nmel usopprCtzaa pa ) or YDpar brPm r O•J'o Or !loin siding) -orar dichnium) nuW by • kfwb rYl wupul'iY entire W"~+s ° °r •'nrthin e over o mein pillar) ooQ (i) ,fact-IeW maeolaheed Us in she faW Dimpmel A Jrwm. most, tae (g IhI col pre to with I, hen is lopro,ec1 is 1 : a plant Of the JlYranfhra S : • pier ex/ . of the p mn'> e ; ` deck)" in Correct with i', ono disguiu its Mrsi0 fine nxuo genus PhY+wu b ,armed law of • chuck l luiuuq with on. purplish ~eoe of ru arr. lu hrou; to unawaren"a or mimntlwiser) o \ n ; is caricature of human or animal feauru 1~ amens tmslar r u gy (tt^ i 'hat u made of cloth, plaaler, or similar -'list and worn lea "QUO. n : e method of a.Wzzm n ,,.rr) v r a singular formed from the real late-hcsatt • NASK the remlr obutinetl b r< Car .uuherinliv , failin Y"o i L: locking realism, poturaln<ss, false 1 ad~ • disguised by is false face 101.0-poeltlsa by pst;n/ Use nuuus abili,Y 1O a-pproduce m effect of anisuc ri hb lag n : is p ant o 'he lebOn'or \ • •f-0•\ • any1~ nxrmlCUL <Anne (.reed, stained, i rLE .asuaE, ALL-SEE gaol CameNna - an VOLp OF y data or ..,no daa{1( p^i'ah ,R) .1 'coat and they th are or mmn- faW floor n : a flor" so ryu IL x faction or hypeesens - Y 1 Rd ere o IY two pen cracks placed about I if or diynar. cueeoryvhe does not y 'i.,bran 1i~ 1pjbular Y occur .ward the end - ouch. above the sin floor of a farm (rug, ,else Pte {shop 5 Y 8110.. and often ludicrous 'S storeye to facilitate fra circMinolion r of air or vegetable Islas 01 well founded ; a ! not in Y ti la,gO f ~aaC'y . r r[aU rclor the mall band onfac4orwrrm, emises tale. fx gt 11 loves[umromu ntfct... ngel;! unauP[rvr, urvw ( present fun or evems for the, purppm r' -'erg of uurPar. s4[, INCORRECT our time flowers that rexmhle ,,lour. ? foatlove 7Wt+Dtline n ; a fame W'Udo -rut in hesi,uion, starts, and g<nrdias having yellow to ..it iln the m led weral n!" ;'%<'"oale prM 12 C Is e ^oen) (mak a painful fete IIOntA 1: • facade e[nndint beYend and esP. above the aro of Ch ~Ge ) < .nice a c turn in his Our: dimensions of a false u---ty n , faulty pronuneb dg u ~ppe?°ng Cinconsbmn wjrh .11 conamY) (,his Opeat.nce building [o dive it • more imposing Ivalaeel ,in rupee[ t° is 9umtisY W Unts. i ''h Jta,hr'rn"tnsmr,, n^C j(truyen erofaer ortroien~ labstlrult n `a CCf aE2aOPY1iRVlr us"tl for bang or curls a ,he f quarter n • a cleft in ,he u'[wwxu a c[ J • apW once or manner intended to deceive hWDYli pararivr / FAL"F euatrQ ~nnl .~ieumna he Put I (b~' + -ring ,hr auppon of Ielsa Lalene n : srxwLERns s Mu, n 1 a ten. of Men a zplac " fa..r)'y : sxwnr, tt[vas ptY is ~rrhild that k owl 1e oubh ea n UU IBS and" h< W herb ) ELDEP /use \ \ or .eu Y~, see rAITNLLss (Nolhnucordun blvnive of the rsca seeds and rezembltng a VV swne a t or E LL / lrn aufo LME InGen. Imrsrn, fr. OF laid L10 n : a .Co. dior shttt Indies large e b Uoa n the d4crepar,q Y raxux\ °jI" I ME /a/+"rl nbr : ioex 1.1+01. by lame of a bodly (Oernor o 6)rin Ru"` frac nd is ends "d y using in different , revel vas sxq acac ives/N+r, Jnb. h.Nnb. Imo. add. I n goatspyrd n : e -lam of the HeL'rLV ,uLr 1 F Ialea i eom1Y or to summivc Cho it lnY glW 1`Ve ra~,~ -uao. Mair false LOltlel4otl u:a No. American M1<rbs(S°IiA ? A ,THLESS<r . hovin sessile or mE <hromure tlerinU or call.. also aly,n „ 1 bath olaorle'h plop (his wile plated him q ago +aha[rfara) [arse made t too aaeiveeanother to his d u b andin leatil< ram in glomerulH tan the g 1 Jmnr,r w a bat, faits tom 4lse L¦[omwell or : a feel untrue but recklessly made when n Ce, car , re R ) t r'r earl heir Jry[overest- ardOrRon oas false ¦Ylnaa apyent OI the genus D^ormadlu.. W" OF to its truth or lishUc o: ;Yy per,-• klat. Illy e•n n _ _ Bader tI88a re' pHNFOM OAAsy fA,lo 0~+c..rr.Ylnt tout. C FC[R R r I-- 0 e ~C, 1~~. I " " FEB 'I $iJilillluJ iGrvG Board of Trns4 e 00 I of 01 tea I/ 1 I i 1 d to I .I I to, 1 nnante Orr" h« f I 1 r II s t. n JclNPncn he e I.) I x x) 2: IN' L xv 3 In-,tact-ed I~t k u ll II 1 }wulvh urnxrexal - _11 ( ng wish raper II 1 f lfnrminu of (these f 1 1 1 Ir 11 k. 1 scr e Wrlrin a I t 1_ A- ll f d i as "I'd ibla 1 1\ I ahk f being flecmJ v A y l= \aIfl k h a [LL 11/ fl a/l clot L WlAt ) I f) A T nN t r A D I x'' t iy J flI -r ( q /fin t Y A r. (.wide Serlra°Oln et n t 11 N J [ Ili I lit' al DracDcn AC I ll to f. Il. r eral (D t P t (11/"pyre c1 5 D J t I Ic) + I,m , vne at 1 YEe rl 1 Ili a t I a _e J 1 f f uI 11 ¢ e h n Ihnn1 h Id k) T valsr u/ soma FA.O i no of urvlnµnnc~ndinA(excd-n P ° I (A -.1 tl ufM1 If r Siren, 41" I otte Ih1nN r - Interest or 1 h1°g C(O is. -Sacheverell 1lrwel0 : uervu 1 ¢ (1f I J d by of the humncruric llcr Yl l Iharl h!s` 1 J l p J haamas u it e I h h I w 1h ) (T itram a curlnJed by St 1 h its ollo, v r Aalhony Powelp 2 the change c in m v: apeakieon of throu¢hom the Midaf l< A Ne 1 (I, fWe A 8 or roular l l lot Au a - O.C SI.m r cry)J (,he ed a .y in a t 11 is f~rcvwnal nl Nhlsgpr<sense -(hale Franck n order I. pp l r Ne qu loudnen : d no a ris or v Auswsl which,Dfar I < than anY ;Pal O ) Gn [ouch him 18 (quarinnr, fe no slops (^acof humor, irony, constitutional device , was Inc ue 5 re( of his later p someone lot spline,. nl 1 there -Mary Aumin) To`~ topmast .has h h o a nehve speaker Gmf- John Buchan) (to face :md a good 1 chntra ich inwarJower II ugh) 3 a a d f lion in Muthar dywmin in a outward aufM1Orlrv antl a I eke a fgnificant N((een waae<f[o tlim inns aomahN Na nd at hoe Is : a h Ae ( mIh< monomn; in mm..iCd m the force of <wnuowrexcelknc< prof coeiF Ye dE tales Plan 't olnn su^ 99 a1s a forewarnin9 or <ounsehnn pOI InB 4 a h iw n r change 1 /arm That wara as superior with rnuhaw abJiry to rommand deference p he I(h` it d dvtredomr that c e w1^e 1 had (Col go to ma vkodaM `nntsinm n( ase, )anal" number, nose, Imo. mag¢al pr e e by hatl belonged ro Ih< onxinal J Da a! T R.M.L u) (1 ndvird him srro~ Oren " mood, pantos It ; a form, s Ilx, or le- humanuta AIJau9 dd an¢er qaw ,thing p (eniom ithoweacquinmg B°IY °I C~haa gl mvolved'^ suc~1 variation wcovorencenv 6 a: m ang is uque r H *I°Y) CNaO~OI~On insisted o a ruict fenional ualihcabom -R.G.G.Pnce), Norav teen pre, at rvsture from m eve ro convex cacruly b o e ue. ewe a soh r. Ir waaonlybykeepinsupthefiction of about notice or make a wu. formal communication~o Nee on point : the t where inch a change yak. pbc<' role) waOMTS a he P to ma ndmenniniaha prufige AndN bl u- so s tlon•al \-ahan'Poahnal d Dp power over or influence over olhen, ck rtvriArd Ili rw tnevo r when too PP err mien (~n"asy ya lapwar \ w / 1 o(,s relating te, or Mrs. measurable And' ` ct<rized br 1n(Icaion ,1 plwyed i an fix ) ) (norlJy Art tl nd ble, an d manctimer decisive of his acceptance in a club To Aov¢anse;;a, rare m Curren m hed from derlvTton.ed al in 2 a bnguaya charac~ (Mn HawNoirin mhorip've air w a eginning have lingo b this aenae, is l0 'storm or sooty by fy f ou the expression of grammalka~rela,iona b some wrighr, wtItch im -Archibald Manhal Is q (men who A. inuanslamn, of warnigg I modi(i<auon rouAh internoJial m (a i r/nggsanoSf th th the oth<n whLG. FP az cr)a CREOrt applies have ability (0 ak1n- wood Protrnanp, were eyeful ro adrcrB+e or fumonsl affix Ih auwn of ml g great wrighr read" that hat they offered wAs Le`CkrcS Moroi -27 lking. Ike) - d1 tin Yhangeelemenm as in walk, (,"coca a sin from mealg`or lavorabk r< "tips (hai- r LU. S.PpJ mp t f 0 ! IaHnqa tndlee•tlon•el, guued tram geludnadw non waa duunetl neon rand once more he had shown Ais f m`m °JJ [MF I°/ormq fr. L In/oackrmingbr, freeu. Inlsr- r 1a1 •llon•legg \-ahanba ~Y \ l { > y more at ass al oba ; l I^- + 16 \ ad/ • havio 1~ act era. abil co handlea delicate situation to the nedif o(hir Quern- ] form ; ^°o -five \5 'flekliv, - -v s n0 mllecciom men,ityand .lineal, -W.C. Ford) (the film war a mccen uth Ip 1u nEFORMeD 2 oba :packing <ruted form : m \ ad/ 1 ; apable of, relatins tq much of the credit goins n -Current ~)Or : cond aged uiicerned om wimp^m Por% re I N"O1 °rnul age) ing[oin(I«tion. DEFLECr,ND <R: mFLeCT,oNU.( -a n tler 11.inflnana!•i is to an i the talmakal caed cm" ..di,"an' h err 1 ME \(')in kk91, ad/ r °nA4• 'th drivcaine d" t ins ( eed r ceremoniom euler ed ;f n'h\ [L InJlezw past •wh lnlluen _ poocedure unaemcuL rlnllaely to B part. oarrion _ << hyrin Is e to mtla) } E -ed-more at rrvn.ecr] 1 : Tuarvm, ducq \ \ thou. h vb - or eD/e-INO/-9tt character) vt 1 yoto topaaun Affect or alter the a' u frieined,, r n. Rf1am ilichar uarene x(~• ruilc of soy art`s) (•y enip 2 halo ( or turned abora ruptly 1 oral or tlownwced or of b (or intangpible n ) propriate to Onc"98 .1 ina a i [Ae axb ~ an" (lower) li tY t<npdn meow ;sway (pi'ob by Iistenine tgen woo tsav< Qnelbh) (eNialwo ^ar) Ibllit9 \C)in, an+\ n the ) In/furnrrd better lud mast-Sk w° r C^•aaaY) 3 obi: oeRanogo, MAD °e man 1 9ua or stem of being _ g Y Y) [a onom m and political more but ivtrumenu -Shock.) q of a dal rt :shaan a ving N life : uNVSFiowoNen tattoo that dalsion. b y m Ana SSm !M o! European ro s to arymmetrical composition yr arrangement it d ible \(')in, an+\ ad) [ME, fr. L Inprzlbllls fr. iii-in. -R.S.Tmomzn) 2 to nave an e(1at an the caadition or spoon and diapncea balaae in • stage " from u r flezible- ore al FlszleLej 1 no, (capable j develop ant of :determine ar(blly : Mower ^WUa ben[ ; a1alD 2 : lirm in will or purpoat p urav NO, atrone y Inl/umred by she lalmga of the ark r "bo w the ,coinoff Ibr \;i n+\ n [rln- + l rmaNry] 1 : the yyu~GtY or :AeL¢ (a man of u ri ht and w job -Stuart Chax) (outdoor Hv3ing has /o,"cored the deign tomary term (WAY luk of regular prearibed IT ourpose In a temper -Joseph Addi- / (w°(ayside camps. here t}se ) 3 : capable of mange : UNA-raoxaL . of lurni[ure -N.C.Brown) oba; ,rvpuce, INyuu H, loosened tan of dardrhiq Amg (arbitrary and -V rulings of burnucrac °rrhwlc : n axes influeae so see AFFECr it. •si. a Bun -Mabel R. Gillis) ((evnyday aaah i^ It g gag gyiyr Y-Edward In•(In•eaceACfl•1•t9 bil i IgflUansa'ad.'e aomrrlmer iqb\ ^ -a pr nd case -R. A.Hall ceremony b. 1911) 2 an i enlivened nformal an 12 liability m influence 1 yyna : oceedin g (thewWdin was or d•yl s n : mPLEZianrrr in•fla•anCe•ebla •z>bal aomedma:... u spared Inlormafld'I by s"eel 619 Vl....m, an+\ adv ; Rromtr, uauTUwatr, slue- - ble] ; liable to be influenced : «adilY s\ad Ito/ n(Iwott po(ormmnoiia~; rormif ma,liz r In °rmal + - a ect v, wexoawotr Inllaenve luae is : YNnxlMrtr zvse (college cation of the (uiuae mm lea v'flekshan\ lr/ly BNr r of RIFLEm'. mflpence Imo lye \i\in'(IeW,Y\ d/ [hL m en, of toffee,.... g alien cap L 1 lve oe Inawnce Br.uY ai.pliried and In/ormatlxrd-Nation) B p + E -Ivey] rhlrllY Br/t : Affez INSLECrs (Pull v¢ benAb ..owing Me va ' lion of the'!. ngitudinal acres, h2 a is in ear, pou(o msemo r( ern}ormairyal( ddrened fhe al manna : wilh- \in'f4kt\ t -eD/-,rvo/-s (L InJllrrw, Past part. of am moment, other dfat "PI, astructursl mem6 (due droved in iLnneIs aM gap"i^B M e, (r. in- yin- + Jllgrr<to ,"Ike-mare at PaoFl-,DATE to a moving load A. as a function of the position of that load be lint o°t) : uNOrFICULLV (tan train ay (e blow) on :caws (something damaging or pain(ulj hflaenw mgchlne rt : INDUCrroN Nwcxlrve Her low j be ulkd, more r Iw the Cannonball endured ,MP0.e¢ (threaten punishments ou do not Hn•ene•er \-apO\ n -s • o e chat influence a ^--Bertrand Rwadl) ( or cruel end unusual "slap- ia•f[a•en•Cive pe \'In,flUansiv\ d', r hale ; wvw¢NnAL InlormW plaaNng n : ercnilatunl plannaing 'n hich d omi - ~•ed -U. S. Connimdon) defeat is ° •ed with min•flnent \ m,flUant\ wd/ (ME<, (ra , L inJ/vent-, InJluen, am axe end strong visual clime.. arC voided in favor of r (miner are still out, and Indus ) ` ".line) Part, of is Ma to flaw in -more t wvwena7 :flowng In "r circulation Penam opal more .ubtle tlramatk;flap of era paralysb -H .1.Lnki))~ ap : contributing Well m she zone of SatuIration aind for-moat \in (Orman,, d(a)m-\ n -s [L In abfle \ping aal in inefor /omwnr- 1 th \ d :capable of be' therebyy .wlainineg"inrcorgroc"ins thece amt table (I s" /ormana, pea. part. of rnlo.marc to inform - more ra rNFRM //ense) x 1ng inflicted (the 2 rrMic page) .one that informs ;one who give information: as e : w- off] nfluen (beneath the - hevew FOAM.. b : one Wn0 fapphy rylwr8l O( INgal9llr don e- 1 error cadf rc-tor \-[a(rw\ u -a one that i1. 1. ((death shift era Bs arowmne s tomcods the w o onda, roamed rkened Inflaent \ \ ^ -s 1 ; is Iribmary stream : AFrn.u¢Nr; atop ; as b° tl an sn. ata amen d br n invntigamr (finding -Sean O'Caxy) air.. or part o(v stream that contribute weer us the zone be the uneducated-be B.ASh ho among both the edocarad 'on \en'flikahan\ o -a [MF or LL; MF, fr. LL In I/r_ of aatmoston underground 2 as ; an animal or rarclYY a plant tiow by u pf livin )'analysis of gru[ civiUza- "'Vo fr. 1 InJlkms + -i -io - / that ha an important allot on the balance and arabilit of an is tor-mg R `a-Carcgory Batson ion] 1 e the act of aoloekal communit Y pa¢•pe.HS \.fdrma'DOparia, = ) -F (i( t[1e reads will bear one t rlher~ of antiarin and y (rabbis and prairie doge are impatint [L, in the form of a a° paOP-\ ad/ (err ad,) dewxpOon -Ernst Barker) of dams e b n Insome rangelands) b: A determining rector tnthC SOlogg11- D Perl:napoor man:reli"ed o(fw sic association -C. A.000ke) 2 ; romechin BinfhYaed cal balance of a human community (location of home in on eh- end coop in a teal Action beaux (inability to pay (pu_ M call ,hex B tips to job u an w in ciI o rh) nips we granted to file an appealnM-lofmq pan U eon) people via" Los at all... they are ~a -P.A . Ia•Ila•ea•Hal\•igUU;encM1yya1 d/ (ML mllaremlle Of'or-U1141% Omashes s ) ive ll'ba g g E -cal - m 66\ influence + \.infa r \ lien acct," [ME ore at nantru NC¢j 1 : exerting or g ' °rmalow, (r. eNourrnrn, In/ormen or norm + - 10 \ oval): <amin infliction ;actin err en inflic- (as w arza.in in- - lion - mare at mroaMj 18 oba ; an endowing with form Is Raven delighted the ?u<oce : rorENr, EFaEa a an n -Timm Llr. Sup nstincp of thousands y g ) 2 : havili t r or u~ Is oba the act of enimatmg or inspiring C oba : TaAINIra, is (or so Io= G country -Merle Calla pan g outpos° py Opcseuue. ss r¢rauerroN b \in [ a - + )load] vl: m (low in -V rt : to over- Eu strove w 3 Is (xert leadership for Maxis -D.D, of knowled a or inteili tl [ [he communication u taeyytiov :y flowin8 in upon (unexparedlY in a gust .(wind the influence 3 obr ; of the nature of or relating to occult be Bence (the function o(a public If Mary a J Ooy field we are caught up. ^•ed and informed In'Ha'en•iial•19 \ch(a)IZ -I[\ a, ) Cweenclose a Prlc° INt for 2 • aomethinH Devoe) In•na-ea•ga \.igf1U'mza\ -s [[r injlu<nrq epidemic, in- calved or obteined through informing; as a : knowledge coroc m- :cenae \.in+\ n ENE, In/bferce^a°, (r. LL In bfn- fluenza, !r. ML inlluenrla inrluentt; Fr. the fact that ePidemin Or ssrmuetino awe Is knownints o~afrom invatigatian, nadYad in . 1 re formerly attributed to the in(lu<n<a of the Stan -more tips ; tNr¢uroB a¢ g° pertkular event or silua- - t wFLDErvc¢] 1 : an acme highly o andernic view f ron) (saLL Nc N`ws, get I as (lout ~ It.. Me battle \`57,i//y~~ diuax Mat a<un in end<mio, epidemidemicc, or r Inndem¢ form bout figo funs in the nape atmosphere) O ~O is es and pai palmrd, by and sudden owes, (.ey a us. bureau) C ; fun or jgum rudy (a commuvicaion or acne and ly ro plat ever re as vial bra n hed from No. incorporated in a formally progressive inflemmetion•of the mpln- Ipry nd ary ocog9 membrane, And is frequently comlkated by d: A sib nch of he di dg% oeTw g(reliable aoua° °f ) reap in(ation s (ow uueumonia); broadly a human gust n one of t d' pin dialin uelephone numb;I) h 2 X113 4 ij I (Q' H rspiaatory i (anon ( determined pusC j t rpoxly i (mPraxd °pon,the input ofact a communcation sya- um e'"In febrile uzu. vi m alit"," far Ship it (ever of e to or a cakubnurs muhinC 3 : the of informing a8aixt / 8 }I O o9W10,W gp ~o hor9n, Swine inpu<za, infatiow Ia otrachenu of ulm b anon °r prty 4 e : a formal aauaatiov of crime made marked by mpira[or s %n, p y) 'Y Dlwec°tlng ot(i<u on informatiobroughhis tmn- r YptomS, n( ammis of muo us ion as distinguished from a n indktmwt resemM tob 3ema ranest espi and crying tleof Systemic involvement jury mweth his diman isease nfluena gs and sca shat p perhaps other pblig e in which Idental wits hu y a and eral or w lnnn ; a vaccine aeaimt influenza: a/ some pblic of the nte b nsesfed C te dment 9rT of f°rmaldeh de-in p Ja runing.ghe epositiowa°he witess d or relief 11 from chick embryo culture y utivamd influenza virus of crime 6 : the b Monte. by Which 'be form of an objet oI in•fI \'igfl>ka\ n [LL inJluxa, fr. L Mile zw, knowledge u iinPrened upon Ile apprehending mind so as 0 :I inflorac<nm .agummatically illustrated: 1 M Were to flow h - more at ua, fr. L 1 obr Pawy°,.ueNa jog snout the aete of knowing 6 a togkal quantity 1 3 "tube r tom ountl umbel S capI[- 2 : a ,NF,.Ow of li gins to propwitiow and argumen as any a. well t"ma and .S a .Pike, lks 7 l c compound spike, H pankle, 9 cyon,/U linuow flowcoing mma in ; ap. of individuals to loch of air) 3 : e tom comprising the sum of t.e synthetical An in bjat or coaryoub, which thyrse, /1 vmicillatu expected an •~Of holiday visitor) q; the mo h r numbers debvuc6 the term, proposition, or arNment en ensproaaititera as au iorexeru Tentax• of Ariver redlcate, antmedem or ovre lial tak-see An bier Jc v in sin (pm. part. of IOJIO.<xerr to begin to W.Hlop \A-T.1tehan, 'iv,f-\ n LL !n (uzla_ : a no merical quantity that m<amra the uaertainty in the + Iforexor to begin to bloom) + iw -y - L In/loin (pan Part) + _ [ 1 InJluxlo, rr. outcome Of an exariment to be per(ormW wn<v en evens :.oaESCgae¢] 1 a (1) the made o(tlevelopme-n[ and ^s of new blood - o INFWx (<ominual occurs whax probability ova We event is s(aid to communi- :nt of flown on an ezp (2) : A floral axp with its Info \'N ,)f0 1 hn Galsworthy) t< an amount o(~ to a Bow" duster or .om<Bma a mltla Oowa Ia• I \ abbe rE ynJ ^ -s info amount of s (1/) -W,F.Brown b. 1904) (the ter of reproductive Msaw on a men usu. a "tended in-fold \in'rold\ b [erMoldeyn, Irrmation. yn d- zin- + Ideyn, used U defined the aimplnt wsn, to be mea- t(manymosxshaveaeparatsrigh, a Jolden to (old- 1 by tb(logarithm o(thevuneXanvailaba(hole"~.E. 7 f : H : Sh W ;nd unfolding of bloaroma: ¢owmlNO ) 2 : the erd or toward maonex at eoanotherLp(the neuralENFDLD create to to andld (uu In- ID•/obann on k array W<avu) s a xNOwL¢poe ent \1in+\ wall [LL InfIaNrxmr-, She pa., unarm lead margin) ng of she hind eut wale ) ma'HOa'al \;•r,m3shan'1, _S he KI % , a lib, up ebtin [to of ' OnON,ND, FLOWERING T, ( ) \ glvlnH In(OrmatiOp ; ,NFORMINa (rcal rug ( fr. MP eNofiner enJouNoo,~ fr.b [ ) L Informare fr. in ~1Im`^' ~olmetloa girj n 1 : a telephone oy scot oho give in(°r \ vI UEN E flow] 1 : to flow in 2 aea, °I v loanore to loan -more at EnaM t + ,nation from the cannel off[<e awi ograt 2 h a clerk e( as • dy :mFLENC tub, form to : mold or rho j v y oba a : to give me- nformetion dock •r\ n 1 . the cat of intro ter) (2 : something that Aaawrve¢ a Phyaicall b , 10 set m order [nlotmation theory n ; A theory that utilize ateti9tic « a- .Nnux (--of air) (moo( water) of ban It tl<posip) ex[em can N2 a : an give character or enence to (x what nips"" in dealing at of encoding on the edil it its Dora) practice of scien« Knder more Significant (procenu (With the ;R m h I :e \'igflaan(ps somnimn Mf-\ n -s (ME, tr. MF, the objects of common sense -Gail enned p y algu rrans f inion .n of comlmunication u fnria, (r. LinJiuenr-, in1h n; quietly•ying the Outlook of men in politics as elsewhere`W.L. orsbetwxn m(nsandtl alnachmemror betty" od n macBin aedand olna) r. m. rte- + Jlvrre tousflow +a.aPart. of inlluere Miller) b . to be the formative princi k f ) f -y- o!c at •-•actualoaasiow with hierarclic pattePm pN. Waitehad lan in computiMa machine) a : n "sere., fluid Noh' , flaw from the stars (everything that is made fromw thou, and by head rules, and ]nf 1 or : aass pq \ ower(w-;f.bin, amMI, ~ or von fi y+2 ~raim~ 'an theactions of : from e rro2 sars P obrm:en of ba ap w or supposed emmamramenranation du of e - doe Oaca( not WilPide)in ge: to spkit g i( Deering knowledge : ,NSravrnv¢ tue) broc.une) -over 2 ;tan cxerclse of f a of po spiritual or the su mcoal pposed force the char.in rive, ~gsualul of "within thANIMATE,ongs finale some F s, INFVS¢b(thae 8 In.lorroipR•Ng;TOav - In•form• n.HVe•ly \4v18, -li\ our to -Orc :he : ems are ~-ed with sincerity -Richard Ebe h rt CMy erg \-ivnb\ ¢ow,stags wrwz 4 nhoul a :the pparent act, procev, orof mo ) µscwi- ln•lorm.eto•r effect w Power bl of coml. Prmatant (has that hw alway. •--ed hie citing INroaMINC, wsraucrsv[ e0 wiurs sad/ Uolormwlion + -o Y] a .croon tang e -L.A.Fiedkq 3 oba : to form (the mind) in roc at to char- C Y b ok) miJ ; de- at om, <exercise oprimlitcive ommand'hia and often withow dasher- otter alp P 'sed M. intended to convey information bid in ported itent ( menking Nat almost every- 4 obr : cu~DE,ooiR¢erab(:t Id• es AIN, orsnvuNe, I edsrg your uer inlobridrmge)alory ni(i<am and can exert y of some sort -William (d pa htmsr ath doable n a double node in bridge to convey corrupt grain mce I1h or Mani lation of YuY°gCr txt -John Milton) Babt a ; to lebe known give information pa r 'net and to invia is bid from him 'err personal gain p° ,'ruction in (era a doctrine) 6: to communicate know,ledge ,led Ito mtokeourne'a double m ay have had someNin6 to do ao make quainted : Tet4 oviSE. ENLICIr reN (accused informed ad) [fr) . past itgas of cor prey (o! the dote" -harem She ll en'o the a8M ...'o be, cart. o ar)orm] 1 : having information .ergo f corruption a d peddling -Ch uian the a«nsation-U d of the nature and cause of (an citizenry (a w U-in)a f Of man) : basetl on n tor) a :the exertion of force a' a dlstance~(tida himself _S.Conmrunon) (obligation u a cad is to of information aimem of next pos«seiession by the of (tee moon and sun) 6 : the p cr or Houston) (pco reram of wingarding theI se overs[i.1 "tees -Clifford 2 : CDUCATED, INTEL is, C aAT car's tax pp) .usi ngan ef~¢t in in direct or intangible Hg m[ of he orld about our i n W isso) Part E, SWAY. AseENOAN ntro Cr (under the •V of liquors way of Isle -H. H . Davis) Al 1 : to give informvtion : im- ° (transition eke of e~a sadly measure the _ of a li ) Part knowledgge (in theory news -1 hile advertising Sill. In•I r M sea form", - fro-6(.).(r-6(.).(r)\ n habit to [ME r, fr. Wr glen by out Bankrog) 3; \ efou T V,ez i[ pup uP-Gran Prytair (the intoxicar- authority s Ion Hive information or mtelrigence to a civil Jauraa n, to inform -11oc hill Visit to m used as a torpor Life would have teemed .hockin •LtinV w cat. w ° sex atsy [M psymushilnbsl. and the myr L ac Lie J un t I Gcar will upon Tor La. SuppJ s:solar L P.Smi[h) ax AS ig so e m [imes interchangeable li Enaleip said, each arm,:orp to go I to aJvan.r attract a. accord,, uCns i +hlrr % X w11h PRECISE, a[nefallY emphasl[CS he SlflclMy OI 1DC a{rCC- a common cr..ado \ki -d, ko \ - lb -I./ Nu/ s I L rare J re I. .ram 1 m or co format, with sacs. sunJaM, or truth ss hr program he acu i.xs of the college and lugmher. Ir. .,a- + w r.r,lrrr raps, - m re f RASE] ar: tD Ihe. A hundred and shiny lee. street (not le gani°atioas for rural improvement -Amer. Guide Sir weir way by abrasion .a ',,am •--s its banks) - to twenty-nghr to be sea (-DO-OIh _ hundred and Ml. rumble ay Through abrasion Y Si yC«)(mien.asm not .Correlate W; \ ads 1 : (7ORRauTEG 1 teal ; helon u, t coral \ki rat, ko'.\ . -s [Sp, fr. (.'named) VL r role vague, On she contrary they are extra. They are based on fact. the same stra.igraphm horizon I, strata) y' ..dasure fur vehmler, Ir L w . a L. fr. c rear m run - Proved fact -T.B.COnain) PRECasE carries the idw of sharp- cOuelated cal (fr. past part. of r stria) 1 : losely. e cuan ENr7 1 a : o Pen a' r,ct.,u,C for cunforce o Per; of definition or delimitation or xrupulous exactness (f (emetically, or recip .cull, « . rt +p ulntl livestock laxd (human hcuhi<s to ore ru this re mbl c raw the outside of he nose. addressed in straggling. irregular - whole; and this composite human nature seeks to an, livestock D : + y a corral characters. dry unlike Hot.,, uo tl refer hand r.peaawn held 1 a raised ndmoff - u.. it they co IJ be Doyle) (only an ndlevl i -A, C. function-H.O.TeYloq Z: relamdasa universal a«Omy: wror cued) c : x fish cap reseribinls a corral in shape 2 : ms invern star uld set Y Patient. careful, Iabodou; perdu client whether causally conneemd orEnot (nes buildinss is ( enclosure male wish wa{onl as a Place of defense for a t uD she new rcvolwionarY eollmpliom ith a prreix pphYiOla . dale -.A.Alm3ltnOOD 3 y;+ ampmall lli an c dad lot. place these tradilI is and preconmpno..-Have- lacing to or inAi gear the relationship between the aluibs 4orral rob corralled; corralled: corralling; corral, 0, lock Es) rvicL in the ume pe'Lee. here, implies [real, in a mathematical correlation 1 : to enclose in a corral or Lim Jar pen or yard : round up as aomaimes eacesfive, p(ecision or delicacy .11 n discrimination OOFm•la•UOa It,han . "Idle) unJ Jr v' into A urrri l 2 : to."..a. ( a{onl so t to of m or Is ans, or [he mI., of bmrrelamd pare (the small Ir. L arm- + )orlon-, LL, 11 reload \ -s [ML relation .aorl - marionr< - at , roa gaaar/nt flout a corral 3 a ; In as hold ul, µn contro l over, catch, or Drovincialg entry dr of the Wesr as awn by Miu Amtan e 1 : the au or tracts. of curr¢la[int :she condition or fad Xado!' up (somethin, wander... or Elastic) • get pmsenton of their genWi[y almm. m a fault reoryan)aril being correlated (,he e.act of lamDO, emphasis, and din A le desk f° his xcreury) (ma drivers corralling tote lime of revolunen, when aim legal dutinniom are mean- -Parker Tylep; speclf, :he I lotion of phenomena a job ustomers h for a a vines) phe wimmng candidate if the man who n¢le 11To I n Buchan) (the detail of the cornices, the delicate variable amompammenn of each other whether causally can - d ) D : m bring together in one lace fool g M and n1 It spot Lion of carved ornament on the while ected or not (the assumption is Ella[ there I. a YS'.. II tile Passengers in she Garlic) : restrict to a p°aticulaf lace enenor-Ante C Id. Serlar: VIJ pIOxT very clog, m non. between performance and a pecipre D 'be to M...Cr, hats more D Y T Kermit Eby) 1 :.deem pcpunen c the cro d the co ay, in a corner of the lobby) re than mere avoidance of error seta earl h( .dice, armor: eyed mutual relation cats or The the expression .trap dadominatua m trot the nt it our) of f <(bboys quickly corralled is small (on aW, sake" w.s t It to h deotion of FI is or Henry James lane) of different structure c It see spiced or .oraces S•,. amnoal od the fire encampment put nncampment (he main to form probably a protective corral -TB.Eli.D (where wiser from he has lull that rlPhdegree in orPnismf 3 : an interdependence between math<mv[i ,vor -L.DSm ter'- Liam wagons. F RI wagon turning right, the would - second by left het.. of -Correct Permanent In her the nen to mouth I. It U , br<win pp p ) arlag. esp, in statistics 4: determination of synchrony, e circle was formed -W.F .Harns) ,yn see arvcl.F. adult cam kmem of °I rh« : in, the full homotax[., or of relation to the scale of geologic time - u. cor.ra-Rlon \ki rezhaa, ko'-\ s -s I ISV corr.,. (fr. L cC,,oG., per, p permanent teeth xd in the comparison Of geologic formal.... or of far: pas[ part. of earnedoq + don] : the wearing away of rocks rwi-able \-labal\ ads : capable of being corrected faunas or floras belonging to different districts and soil by the abrasive action of material moved along by eonreC•lani \ka'rekmm\ n -s prorren + --1) ; CpRRErnv[ eor•re•la•tiss ra,vahanal, -ahnal\ ads : of or co ;ern: ? wind, waves, flrants, or 111-11111 : one of the several processes corrected pas( o CORRECT correlation . ecip oYa'n¦¦ correlation (me aphysim is be of erosion corroded establshMent n tro"enrd fr. pawl art. of corruG and - duciplin¢ -V,C. ldrich) Ti c I'll slva g \ ud/ [ISV macs- (fr. L commas) ? : tile mean of ill hi{M1-wane Nodular inmrvalx for at last a rArtelatlou Coatilctept n : a number thath.eves to mus4 s vr proJucinUCin¢ O, r len mnJinB8 mall reduce corm Man mnth used in navigation to find the approximate lime of high the degree o(cor«lasion between two matematical vari ba j. " cos•rea \ki rb, -rga\ a f NL. m lose F. Corr this Serra -A(., by eddina it to the time of he moon', upper transit es being the quotient of the arithmetic mean of the tl XD Yor[. atateanun and b.t8niFr 1 cap ; • small shown n the nautical.].easc orresproducts of t emus of correlated y ponding deviation (from their mean) of he velum ,slud Aunt 3 Port. shrubs (family Rutscea is I most of which have Vail A . ]Gather that has been lightly or the variable, in question divided by the product of the earn y' tubular m sile[, yellow, or him flower s _s ;any plant have s Cokivertxdteto move grain defects Dondins landerd deviations of the two vuiablo the genus Correa -called also Lief: re luchrlo d time n • a ship's elapsed time Was her lime Blow- eOmFlat on carve a : CORRE[OGRAN tor-re-al \Oko;rf(a)I, 'kbrg.\ ads [LL a^°e'^ Yacht racing correlation ratio IF : a mbar other than [he Correlation c (if, L.um - + r rear accts nruf loin[ criminal correcting pear parr of rnapev article., that m°uura de, degree of correladon between is add person, prob.lr. rat lawsuit, [hinge eor•reet•Ing•li, de • a correcting, sneer mathematical variables joint aalisat oar aat gEIkL] ivil now having or consilurug COnreC•t,m \Wi Fklli r.aid'kre- Is s ME corrrccon, fr. Ieor.rel•a- t, S, ahl that n y be enforced in full xisn't a \ [ flue \k 'r<laa• iv, -lag. I'e a4a k0'- or av any one of several laim table,, or by any one of uveaas joint MF c moon, Jr. L correction., orreulo, tr. continues (pest [ML rorrNaNvw, fr. L ram- + LL nuardr se relative -more SR.. creditors yy i l astngle debtor pin, of corr/egre to make straight, Earnest) + -lo -ion RELATIVE] 1 : naturally related (as by occurring in conjun car-«-al•1-ty Vat Is the quality or .(a,, or being 1 more al mnaECr] 1 : the action or an inatanm of correct- Lion) : maaasroxotNO (points of view toward the conga eat ing'as a:'he action or a^ instance of,,.dyi,$ oat removing purary world always imply w points or view toward . cor.rect "a'rek[, rap. 'kre-\ vb EO/-Irv,/a [ME .orrrnen error or defect : ANE NPMCHr, RECTIFICATION $:laic ^ of stream dozen crucial issues in pass centuries-Paul Farmer) 2 : he , ck„•;, correct. r rm; eau all. of ....Pere ad make strati t, Pollution by the of sewage) inaccuracies m ing, indicating, ror involving reciprocal Fteds relation :being treatment fr.. covert, LO Iced a[ui hr gu6d, rcou.,ing b ; the the or r an instance calling attention lo, - delam (linked the Continuing War esa democratic our system to :toed- rul) -more eta VxT ( g rtpronn{, or Yyi•i 1 v 1 It a : to to m make e or ss"' hl : remove punishiact n ng fa ohs or or devi eviati tions from Propriety - evelo t the fault. Or C.m« from MENP ee «he - of 1,.. clu bee I. a has hum a,a pmePl in ethe xistence IX conce of to Or all <the ,i Jess about larmfn C.R.Ho some of was wrong and or he Y molecule N. between : eidirector, related exec that is cat u- pe) (his answer was wrong and of Gunther I. can x he should observe any directly implies the exhxna of the other (the rights at once * 2 h . ! d hmxlD (le6uluive coon deal ^ed so symptoms of her saying trace Charles Dickens) C :the dories s between shareholders , nec ton, and executives -G y st R di fficuI Fir-U. S. Coop) ( i act n instance of making that right which as wrong Hurff) 3 of paired word,. or expression ' regularly used b Js b: in mean or Lieu trahzC b~ abuses in the city prison) or or bringing 1 to conformity with a standard (she of eeth<r but t , SC" mnJ<ncies- Ymamof apyywib qua ilia or injustice) (small (zanier ~z Yp¢ally not adlacemto each other (the ^•conlurv p Wsu phcr uxd es leaning p. f what a undesirable [he oad hi- were made by Ehe Conference of [ion ](her... or) (the I demonstratives he former . rl (t p naliom) g ; the action or in instance of counteracting or larger) 4 blot : exhibiting condition - Cor•Tel•a•UVed v little in the other ead)on m the neutralizing wreathing harmfof or undesirable I, of cidity) \Hvlg, -li\ Ed, i° di hellenmin{ rut A . N . Whitehead) hud) C : to alter of visual defects with eyeglasses) e : the action or an srmrralatlva a bring vlo some standard or required condition stance of adjusting or alterm so a to in \ \ ^ Pr : riculd tore; as a • either of two udi ng rf a yz olame for mmpisazure and Pecuure) condition or result g of phoEoW°phi. Imru,) I. aareverul (Mu l) relative words or exrcxion b : a wortl denoting s c°rrclai d")"yaxr,'- ( I ss, f spb oke rar Puon)aft. the u mmg m a of mxra .t~a\ a : to rebuke or m 8aeraled trend in s marker or indust ; es ~ f It lane (as from propriety) Danish r dixiphrm far ume in keg 7 : • Beeline conrel.a•tlv.1•ty, \ka, ell hvadd, (,)ko; \ e -ES : the 9ualit propriety) (the older woman acrd the in prim or in busieeas activity following Protracted or late of being cor .I.tive N errors mkme ben ea) b ;sat p nu g a . influential Eli., is or should be substituted in wrvraho•gram \k 'rela,¢ram\ s [.orrdvlion + -a- kt 1"- Point o [ (or amendment he piece o an is wrong (mark an an examination papeq; -gram] : a co relatio or laul [she student told be t uvenl times peel/ : n indication on a proof of a chan.. ce to m be made by the between twcurve o C a gerarouted lkal to variables exhibit ~i•Y' Ito trad. her rcc u s is a, I proof by y indicating ng the changes to inter D the - called assumed alaoac r.h : E'%1 rrim _r tYorder Lo,) p; teacher -1 aumin umn gape.) 3 Pro, inaccuracy in a an instrument applied way of correcting (m. for ooa es-te or a E rAxa vi : to make correction. t has algebraically of f i its ad e to the rrs`eq :the ecou ame more a et l e k COYkA NorTE] ' s CO/(\YRaA-NTE s [It. nadir. of M vlxIEETny' MEN., gE.e.l......a A.P.M. Less , REFORM, pF- qrl°^l'ly that l must has < .YII Of OYran(- ol "i? verbs measurement to obtain the correct value to ihlue - compare ERROR 3 cnr.ra• \:kdra:lpgnd, kfr-\ to -EP/-ING/-s IMF o tine r maces au nw in cu s Lid ^t~,.iii mnhrintl by attm'nq tPhelth. naccIt, urmrronm, 3 : the mcalment P( offender through a yy.gram involving ML; MF corresponirs. fr. ML rorrespondre, fr. L c I` " I'- r a Perot custody, parole, and probation (diubiliues from which r ponal« - more at RuPoNo] 1 a : to be in conformity o ^•v per/eat in it or atom it so iM1 tit iuccuntF. true. or the field ( - he. offered -Yale Law Jour.) (two prison ee eemem : Sul, AGREE (incomes do no. Rivers - with N c'4 t 1 Y nuuue asainu r[um subsum[nt for it what 1s wards under the Conttrla De ailment -N.Y. Times) eftorla or skill that W 1:. or pp ka par r r a falss aecuuuon) (to often match or compare closely (the nor, I son used s p °pmu to be involved nvoWVedhose I A Hob conscnous^a Lie -JJrev n + 1.111.1 A (at orrery • serious pl. (training in .Inc t«hmg a of casework k'k4va ct, I eq pis mein( spelling errors) One atrnries a and.+ general field of Equation prole, and the ^a -L.1. tlms not w to that of the majority is ° madman -G.B.Shaw i r * ) ~ s by harp) ([he worker who has the interest and tour." to t e n d mbers of the paragraphs with numbers on the map J~, a deviation from A (and. Is b the look a1 his own work obiahvely -C.C.ScOII) - under D to be equsvalent (government bat ee<ss, n their is m 4 R see deviation I,, of to iM1a eundarE rlce r by ,r 1 correction : subject Jnl;ra.el"I blunter, wl zhnul t usable 1.LSavato correction (1 speaking weer fmm m inaenli on urveYi' of pendi[we -G W rvxnhle ,1 pis <mv abblire] III, J be , . a for my the Editors know how h were '1 .11) be p r Iles be the counterpart Ohe Er isl that [Lied r^ "rill --Nor He bllc) ([.have ted Exploited. ..her eor.roe.tlon. e) parih may be said [O ~doulY 10 [hC Pneh rural commdn. (•n himself to recillY so 1 th ILI' e sunJentanJnas -Times Llr. Sapp.) Lion; rzp ; deahngsl ith or chertedlwilh Ne: aCmmgisuallon a( munionHo r ri, lereourx oath [o have rc~mmu^ication, m 1^: pep^IO--Green PeymIL arvmbphysical Poverty It x court) (a institution) with or Providing ion personsf ffrr( Etta arm at and c' od.n. esp, a smmmmt that miu¢ l.[ion) (a romisec. war ( d) counties te with a pe son by exchange tun : RESPOND (O-(Malady preaenu a speaker's imenno^ correction line" • one Of is sea of Parallels of latitude institute es mi¢ ariCntls) .~halc: 1° make a rewr(Ma[ild: `t` rat niece of writing that coolant. doubtful reading (lo emend apart that is used for laying out nominally square seeliona end be connecmd by means of • geometrical vents. iodation or b) d a uans<ription of a ) (to townships in the public land survey means of a functional relation (as of the values x - 2 a Rlancma a c ancient r h u. scroll) One cor•rec•ti-tude \-ta,lud,-la. Iyud\ n -s [blend of Lcorrecr ocuo"s "r ° e of trouble, hazrm, evil ly renderin l 'n and rectitude] co ectnev o y - Ii in the relation Lit I", substituting for it hat i r 6 p r propriety of conduct Y r) ,yes xC AGREE or via, is good, ht, or let ful lcor•ree•tlve \ki rektiv, -tea oho -mv: rapid 'k,C-\ Lodi IMF cor•re•, BL' G.lD. never rmrdIF , it 'no only mexpiated carreuU.fr. MLcorrenivus,fr. Lcarcius+ -Iran ive]:tend MF correspondence, pondamea -E , fr. MLcorrrsondesnru, f Unm^ 'S c`."Llsrr) [Dvr) (one m in uu h e(a dv the confusion -Amer. ing to correct lensed) P• la.uhmen) : having she Gull.) D,dr their dcisaenci,a -LOrola power fa. condition of agreement nt cre, or + of one L ne 1 thiang : with he ato another m o l alance ne atog assa , an u n a or ma nal property condition C...ci M) COaR : s,d. or restoring to a .ndiio of agreement o I [hi Things r recallMU metimes by elimination of it but us.. 1c b mkin ECTiorvAL - cor•roe- .elation of .....aM ,a ocn n ( t gat Hve-ly \-mule,-It\ adz- eor•raC•tive•neav -Nino, -[ev- congruity :resemblance or similarity of detail e mpen«tion [gin to redress the O iom moidin also -u.-\ .as \ T1 Yu elaborates a point-lo-point , between the spirttual nO eau loom Iron .bad militia -E. B, aeorteetive a -s 1 : something that corrects : a corrective wanderings of Vlystts DFbsrnc it Fergualson) and he unythiml Strntiyhgdthe whe balance t in American moliticz of (uses criticism a. v of abuua) (plsenobarbiul is a or point of _ : an instance tidy olds 1 < the tenon. the of Food.nq REMEGY [his speech was a timely or tween the two pla ys)re smo h . rGetnits, association Po f certain Mahalm M egeriJ sat°A, Lithe abase, . be done away with national complacency) R obr : ° change that correct ate _u, _ e<) (she redrecr or certain social in. - em.anuv. o.vsw - _ member of one segregate with each member of a second and wn Yellows rota ,r , u. c,.,..... ....n........... ..ter'.; t....- _ n... 11 l' 'r1 11 II I -I Par u, ties as a it or ppnations w in u tl hat'. nil nant Viallumn t I L-1-\ roll D. I.0 nrrnr I , Arbnl lu.nmr•o far as ! n, ) -sacs 1. p'a of f•dalmNe in lido utl • II L oN IN,; J [11V Ir.r ('3) : 1 kills t ply N1 rnrlt. ppre. ' WI•mf•nale \ t - 1 4V\ b 1u/ '/s [ME I'll- f-ce.4 n•._ ,watt p Nat nls e n° arcn fir ML I I t P t p' t. f / I - ! L t IUma•t041•um \,fYmma m _ r, as d pl I, I J 1 'turn wh° ligh,mnq, s« k h fgM1l g f f al 1 I lightning. (past all. of Arnmra to intake, I l I g the - Cgh, h jcr and h compare ne t Which i i I r my he ee ter r th hydro Y id '"nj stroke of h 11111111 g k t L f IxF t [,Inc. flash JI gram ay] • an airtight to burn - r ore it in.AcK1 vl 1 : to utter or send out with Yled to deal,., fungous m inxu In"' 01 111 Nmwi'g Phalli fn•ouslil aLmu . f1 m olarooda.,\ n s [NI.. (r L : POnuroamM L 1uml. or cc sores a decree) 2: to cause to explode • a Fumigation chamber gurus + - rium - ry) m issue m send forth censures or Involves memac- stumble \'tambol\ b fumbled; fumbled; fumbling \-b(ar) fu•mi.ga•lo•ry \'Iyumaa taree, -meg-, -lot-, -it\ no, [Jan. ingly or suit, nmtivnI R to make a sudden loud noise ho\ fumbles [prob. of Scand n,gn, kin to Sw /mnla to F my) : having the gm]ity of f.migming -Be" PK`.,.. 3 nJ a disease : to come oa suddenly fumble, bungle, hh rw dial. form.] 1 a : .rope far or )mn•1-ly \'IyUm'le\ Odv : in a fumy manner an inten.ely handle something cluandy. rNIPIn.dly. err aMcsaly (ANrrbled 1mn•[ng-1y Parr (JnmiPH (pres. part. of if c) r tumimle n s [ISV /.lain- (fr. L Jnlmu-, Jumrn light- nervously with her necklace before she answered) IS : make fuming manner : ANGRILY (exclaimed , that he it ' in nine) + -ate] : a sale of 1.1 inic acid; asp :...Cone PUL- awkward attempts to do find something (his numb hands accustomed to such UP'"men0 w Bot NINATE with the shoestring) (jumbled in his Vocka for a mm) fuming nitric acid : concentrated nitric acid emitaini ulmimla of mercury : MFRCUay FOLMINATE c: search by trial and error (a generation that ^-s after a bash dissolved nitrogen oxides prepared as either a colorless to Dale ulminating I) tic nre5. part, of /Iulounu7 1 : exploding .,look an life) it BLu.me. (lust when the whole scheme yellow or a red to brown o ro a poisonous liquid and with . Vivid flash : Tun....... 2 • hurling denunciations, hung in balance he jumbled) 2 occlude : to be Impotent in used ei i as rocket a nitrating ell e t ad as a powerful ex,di;ieg menace, or censures (a - bishop) 3 : m ng on suddenly sexual relations 3 . m speak gropingly or indistinctly (1e e (p prop with great s verily cbamctenzed by co rapid and seven Ju bled in answering and made them Suspicious) : MUMBLE fuming sulfuric acid n : OLEUM 2 u x (a Jixase) (shyness made his tongue ) 4 : to feel one's way or move fum•ish \'fyumish\ adj. obr 1 : emitting or having the cbar. ulmlm in8 Hold o .any of several explosive substances con- awkwardly (they fumbled along the dark path) UNmbled about « r of lama : SMOKY 2 • tending to fume • osoLEaic Cluing gold and uutagen R. a powder obtained by the acnon until the admiral indicated where he was to sit-J.A.Mu,IN.'O lu•mi•to•ry \Jyum;t&a\ -ES [alter. (influenced by E -cry) of ammonia on gold oxide) 6 a : to drop or juggle or fad to play rlnanly Fecund bell of earlier J eterre, fr. ME fumetrre, tr MF, Jr. ML join., ulm(mling material t : a detonating substance that appears - compare MUFF D : to lose hold of a football while handling terra, fr. L Junius smoke + lerrae, gen. of leas earth - mo , digim thunderstorms as luminous balls c running with it w 11 to accomplish or bring about by at Tra .curl : A plant of the genus Fortino.; asp : a commoon '.uimting mercury n : MERCURY FULMINATE clumsy or groping manipulation (Jumbled the door open) European herb (F. ollicindu) ulmimting Bitter n 1 : a black crystalline explosive sub- 2 e to feel of or handle gropingly or clumsily (his tea (Umltery lamp, : FUMARIACEAE z i stance obtained by the action of ammonia on silver oxide Jarrrblin, the ro.iedge of is big rip in the carpel -Raymond tumostly it -as [ME lumorile. tr. MF & ML; MF lumnsire 1, 2 : SILVER FULMINATE Chandler) (he ambled the pages looking for the place) ML Jum aimf-, Jumarims, fr. L Jumoaur + -i ter-, -irate 1tyl :uldal•m•llon \,fulma'na.han also ,fat-\ u a IMF, pro- D : w deal with in an awkward or blundering way : BUNGLE 1 obr: the quality or state of having or emiuing Puma 2 ob, nouncement of an ecclesiastical Sentence arc nsure, fr. L (where ade t decisive action is needed he •-x the problem) : a tom, exhaimion Julminatlon-, )ubnirmrio lightnin&, tc Fulminates (past part. of (he jumble~a chance to take, the fart by surpriu) 3: to over tumour o"a lumase Pdj ( ME, Ir. L jumorw, to Jr mPl rmoke fulminate to UNhining) + -iorr - O -ion] 1 : relit m menace in a groping, indistinct, o blundering way (startled into con- + -oats -use] obr ,producing, lull of. oI consisting of lump or c nsure (uncaweit by police 2 mme,hing that it Fusion, he •-•r out a few broken srntencn~ << its to feel in. soma' thundered forth (neclesias,ical -s) 3 : the act or action of f rior if we an unusual word - G.A .MiI er) 4 archaic : to fume pl of HE. exploding bundle cumbrously or confusedly (send them (forth so covered, lu•mu•Im \ ditnyalas\ a -a (NL, tr. L Jumur smoke + NL ttll•r 2tor V -Old-W). -3te-\ n -s (L, hurler of lightning, veiled, ad jumbled up -John Molle) this, next, and last -ul ] : a thin cloud resembling a veil and forming at any lead fr. Julmtnarur (past part, of Julminare tO lightning, strike with wait's devotion all in a ptayer-Thomas Fuller6: to make fumy \YYUme\ adi fumfer; tnmfest 111a11 + -y] ; produun`` lightning) + -r] : n that fulminates (.a.', ay) I. a clumsy or groping antler (the baby turtles or full of fumes (a bottle of household bleach) (a, care ) lul•mina \'fulmOn, 'fat-\ vb -ED/-mG/-s IMF Julenner, fr. L will, their way down to the water's edge-Alan Moorehead) Vum \'tan\ vb fumed; fumed; fuming; funs [ h, all, fulminate] archaic : FolcoNAIE ( wh a paaemg community w in way to maturity -T.H. of ME /annum to fool, make a fool of fr. )armo loop du I n, tul•min•e•ous \(thil'mineas. [lal;-\ dl (L fubnmrns, fr. While Is. 1915) 6 a : MISeLAY A ground ball) b: to lose now dial : up.., TEASE, TRICK. Km - vi fix. Jan , I min-, Iuirnm lightmnm ± -cur - s] - FULMINOUS hold of (a football) while handling or running indulge in banter or play : speak or act in tun : JOKE. From, n [/uiminlr ISV /ulmbr- z/umbla \ e -5 1 : an act or instance of fumbling U lone U nmq about the marriage <passed the time Iunnine till }ubmin•fo acid \C)ful;l ik-,:1.1;1 a of his horseplay) (fr. L /ulmin-, Admen lightning) + -'c] : an unstable acid evolution mat begins with the-,, trials and errors of practical others Ural CNOF?I isomeric with cyanic .,,it and known my in Soluion n -Charles Frankel) (safe o the shortstop'. 2 : a 'fun n -S 1 obr : a practical joke : ra¢R, N-A. 2 : who, (era ether, which it polymerizes rapidly) and in the form of fumbled ball (fell on the quarterback's Provides amusement or enjoyment (a book that IS - to read) h glity explosive suits fum.Dle[ \'tamb(>)b(q\ n -S • one that tumbles (a fellow who is , to have around) • enjoyable activity (the 1111=l•nuus \'fulmamn.'[al.\ ad] [L lul in-, Juimrn + E fumbling adj[fr. Pon. part. of Jumble): marked by groping or game was no•-•>(picnics are great -•)(did Wt know hard sled, -mall ; f relating rot or resembling thunder and lightning clumsiness (a rite, . so pre«cupied with his «<r as to could he so much (sitting on he ground was part of the ful•mi Lurie acid \:Fall ma;n(y) urik-, tall\ a [lidminuric ISV as careless and, in his manner -Brand Blanabard) - rum- catcall :playful often borsteryus anon or speech : socu- Jdmin- (s in Julminic) + uric) : a white crystalline explosive bkng•ly ade tram : RimCULe (made myself a fine figure of -for someone acid NCCH(NO;)CONHa structurally related to mate- lum•bli'tii•ne n -a • the quality of state of being fumbling u.ide -Arthur liable) 3 . the disposition or and I methane and ob tumble in the form of sal. by boiling me,. (was courtly Sell-taught. and his earliest paintings reveal a find or make a cause for amusement • PLAYFULNESS is care- cury fulminate with potassium chloride solution certain R.M.Coates) free man who was always full of (ha -a lo, of I in him) fulne Me of FULLNESS (fume \'fybm\ -S (ME, fr. MF face, fr. L Jum ; akin to (don't say that even in 4 AMUSEMENT, ENIOY.Uzz fill-1110 \'fdl -,o\ n, pi fulmo or fulmos su cap 1 a : A OHG roumen to be fragrant, Gle Ihymor spirit, mind, courage, (play cards for (have at the party) (the baby had a lot people of the state of Pernambuco, Brazil D : a member of Ski dhsma smoke] 1 a: a gaseous em.smn has [rem a burning [ with the bbcles) (robbed him lust for the , of it) lI tech people 2 : the language of the Fulnio People or evaporating substance) that is usu. odorous and sometimes (never got any out of listening to serious music) 6: violent t6.16pp•ite also IWlopp•Ite or lul•opp•ite litub.plt. 'fit-\ noxious : SMOKE (a thin ruing from his pipe and scenting or excited activity or argument • FIREWORKS (a rabbit stam- p -s [Bela Iblic 10th cent. Hung. mineral collector + E the library) : VAPOR (the rain , sprang back on itself and peeled the herd and then the, began) Oust toss in the South .in) : a lead-gray mineral PbsSbsSis consisting of lead, the ground was hidden by a white -Audrey Barker) as a conversation piece and watch the, -James Street antimony, and sulfur : omen (notlced the -s of whiskey when he calked) IS : an Syn FUN, ANT, SPORT, GAME, and PLAY agree in designating fulas PI .1 F., often noxious surpeaian of Particle in air or gas that may be what provides diversion or amusement or is intended to tLLIB Pit of -FUL formed in various ways (ate by condensation of vapors or by arouse laughter. FUN implies amusement or an engagement in ul•some \'tatam also -IS-\ ad] (ME Julsom, fr. Jul, full full + chemical reaction) (the it pollution aspects of smoke and hat in,ereds as an end in itself or applies to what provides -soms -Some - more at FULL (adb)1 1 a : COPIOUS, ABUNDANT ) -.a.. Used In Dl. and Somalian only of suspensions of this amusement or interest, often also Implyingg a propensity is obr : Fu'iUe, AT 2 obr : LUSTFUL, wANxoN 3 a : of- solid particles in distinction from ire e • solid material for laughing or for finding a usu. genial taus for laughter or fensive to sense or appetite : NAUSEATING. SHcIRIUN. rich- deposited byy condensation o[ fumes (the baghouse , in lead amusement had such a rest for everything and thought it all ness o1 the food) b :offensive to moral or aesthetic sensibilityY smelting) 2 a : a noxious vapor formerly suppod to Ties to such JIM E.RdIVaa ) (make living more fun. life more • REPULSIVE, DISGUSTING ptel.diCea) IiOg.agc) c : aI- the Intent from the stomach (as from alcoholic ddrisnks) (a day's complete -Printers' Ink) (a man full of fort) IFS,' ocean in fensive from insincerity or baseness of motive politeness) idleness m let the -s of rum-ppunch get out of his head phrases (as in feu) or applies tO activity or utterance no, to be praise) compliments) (trying not to be, to make ap -David Garnett) b : wzNa jag on an emotion) dual 7m- taken seriously, sometimes carrying an implication of ridicule for his coldness at the governor's party -C S.Forester) pain ones reasoning (Until the ^•s of passion cleared awry) or joining (a man given to making his most significant re 4: counter to the norm of propriety or social usage : display- 3 : a sure of excited satiation or angry - usu. used in [ e marks in jest) (make Jest of very serious problems) SPORT, ,no bad taste (the, chromium glitter of the escalators-Lewis phrase in a Juror (might go away in a w muttering -Thom. often interchangeable with yu. (there is a good deal of ,port in Mumtord) (a prose style) - fal•some•ly ad,- fulsome- Wood tt950). 4 : Something 1 ke a fume in being transient many avious xtiviuo) or stir (play a trick on a friend for mesa n -ES or unsubstantial and noxious or offensive (the .11-pervading the spore .(it) or GAME, although M1ere usu. generic or applying tulth \'f lIrUh\ O -5 [ME finite. Joint, fr. 1.1, fail full + -the, -r of sanctimontomness -Max ASKOR) to activity calling for a certain skill (go at xyart as A it were a -oh -ill] now dial Enq : FULLNESS, REPLETION 'fame vb -ED/-INo/us [ME jumrn, fr. MP Jumer to smoke, ay of life) (the 5 If of Ry Casting) (t Da rpOre of tennis) can [ul•toa wt \'fult'n-\ n, arts cap F [prob. fr. the name Fulton] expose to t'omu. ft. L / re to smoke, tr. fumus] ve 1 a : to auo Imply amusement or provoking of laughter by putting CAT exppoose to fumes a fabric with add variety on develop color so no or something up to entlee or mahctow ridicule WILLOW fulnp au nip, tar O j FELUP effxu) D ; to till or permeate with fume as of instant.) (make apart of a MG, it.. (make a good deal of sport out of inl•Veae \'ful,v"en, JiAA n -S [G lulvm, fr. Llunvus tawny + G C Ohs : PERFUME (sheet fumed with violas -John Manton) someone el u'. muforntne) GAME to an. w rare earlier sense at -one] • an unstable yellow hydrocarbon Ca Ha that is a 2 : to give it I. of u ii in fume (the freight" was fuming FUx tatylies Is rain ridicule (make game of an unfortunate -en methylene daivuive of cyclo u nniciums; oho : any of a series thick black smoke) (an itinerant mutual who fumed ace five[) More commonly today it applies to any activity engaged of is derivatives harmed) 3 a : m cause (a substance) to emit fume (a by hut- in for fun (a game of tennis) (games to keep children amused) ful•gog•eenl \(')ful;ves'nh ;fal;-\ adj [L foams + E -,scent] ins) the slag in a furnace to recover the lead contained) Puy, a generic term far all games or amusements, sustain in : somewhat fulvous In : to produce by fumingg; esp : suauMe Is - usu. used a a all soma an opposition to earnest. carrying no suggestion of a ful•ald \'tulvad 'f 1-\ of [LL lubiduy fr. L/ohm] : FULVOUS past participle (joined litharge) 1 a : to emit fumes (as anything but an intent on divert or be diverted (play time in ful•vom \-vos\ adj [L Advur: perh. akin to Lflavas yellow- in combustion at chemical action) (hydrogen chloride ~•e i ornery) (made his work plat by enjoying it thoroughly) ore at BLUE) : dull brownish yellow : TAWNY (my neighbor's out air) : swoKE. F.E. (a cigarette ^x forgotten in the ash (Pretend to Spank a child i pay) field turned to a stretch of ~ stubble -Lori Petri) (staining tray) (me refinery area -rwith oil) b: to act as i[ generating Stun Bob, [if..] 1 • providing tun, entertainment. or the clearness with its storm water -Victor Canning) t turn. as (1) • to be in a state of excited irritation or anger amusement (a, party) hat) 2 : full of fun : PLEASANT rultrom tree duck n a long-legged long-necked brownish (he (rated and //umed over the delay) (2) : to speak Ina (a night) (have a, time) duck (Dendrocygna bicolor) known from several widely fuming manna (he fumed at his opponent to an arm-waving, Nun n -E [alter. of what] Scot : were epparated pop da,iom in the Americas, India, and eastern amt-calhngbatangue) 2: to rite and pass away in or as if in stn \'fun. -UU\ n, pl run flap] : a la anese it of weight Africa fumes (a cloud of intern ~a from the cennq (that happiness equal to Me momme, .325 grams, or 5.1~ grains Iul.yfe or fill-ins \'ful(y)e\ n -s IME (Sc) Julie dung) Scot had suddenly fumed away) - Emm•Q \-ma(r)\ n -S fu.m .M.la•tion \(.)fyU,nalnbya'lashan\ -s [prob. If. : DIRT, FILTH; speed : street sweepings fume chamber or more Cupboard a, chiefly Brit : a chamber Jmmmbu/ater, after such pans as E perambul ,O,: pmambula- tum \'I..\ o -S : FfNG HUANG with forced draft used for eliminating undesirable fumes ,ion] : ROPEDANCLNO Irlrnadfddle vor of 11...AD racia - comp.,. HOpO 3d (2) 'U•nam•Eu.M.tor W-.lad.a(r)\ t -S [perh. fr. obi. E fmrnm- fu•ma•gil•hn \.fyuma'jinn\ n -E [Jumaginn- (rearrangement of fumed ooh n [lamed fr. Past pact. of -fume] : oak given a bull, v., to walk or dance on a rope (prob. Sr. L Jutambdes. : Furv AMBUUSr some of the letters of the species name NL Aspergillus lutriga- weathered appearance by expo a to fumes of ammoms a., funambulut) + E -ator7 fur, fr. AapergilWs, genus name + jumlgarvr, Specific epithet, fame•IeBB \ fYmmlaa\ aft :free from fumes fII•mm•Dm•la.tudy it:la,tba\ adj [prob. fr. Junambdmor, fr. L. past part. of Jumigare to fumigate) + -In - more at fumexole var of FUMARCLE afar such path a,E aii imr- auditory) 1 : relating to or lo- ASPERGLLLUS, FUMIGATE] • a crystalline orally effective anti- ilm•mel \'[yumat\ n -S [Prob. alter. of ME ]time, fr. MF stablingB mpcedeemng 2: performing as or as if a impedance, biotic ester of an unsaturated acid produced by a sail fungus fames. fr. OF, excrement, fr. feat of fume, /tale, put part. of fu•mm•iIs.llat \-layl\ n -S (prob. fr. L Junambulus funam- (Aspergilluxfamignegs) and used in the treatment of amebtasu ]"race, faster to fertilize with dune, discharge excrement, fr. In lut (fr. Ions rape + -a UNd., - fr. ambulare to walk) + E • V lu•ma•gine \'lyuma,en\ n -S IF, fr. NL Fumagin-, Fumago. ML //mare to fatiltte with dung. [f. L JITLL} dung; prob. -art - MOM at FUNICULUS, AMBLE]: ROPEWALKER, ROPEOA( CEL former genus name. 1r. L Jumur smoke]: a dark,.lured sooty L lumw amokel r haic :the dung of der Ip.aam•Dm•lo \-,lo\ n -FS [It Junambelo, lunambdo, mold found chiefly on greenhouse plants or in southern fail- " alra fu•melto \~')fym;ma\ t -S IF fomef odor, Junambalur] : PUNAMBULIST 140 Under and caused by various tun 8i of the order ErysiGhales fume of wine Or meat, fr. M , fr. Jumer to smoke. expose to fmambmm n, If tunamOLLH [L] obi : FUrvAMauL.r tumar-Or luma,o-comb form (IS V, fr. NL Fumarial: furnark toms] : A concentrated essence of game or fish, herbs, and fm•mnia \tyU'nabGr'ea\ n, cap ENL, tr. L Janis rope + NL acid (IumaramidO Uum ouniolik) spices used i flavoring a sauce -arm] : the type genus of Funarsacese comprising the cord e~ fu•ma.rme \'fymma,ras, -az\ o -S [ISV Jumer- + -are] : a fumewort or fumerool \ n • FuaLrrmar; broadly: any of mosses and being characterized by filamentous sae, a Ilib- crystalline enzyme occurring in many animal and plant tissues several plans closely related to the fore tories (as some mem b s obtusely pyriform capsule, and usu. a double periuOme that accelerates the mterconversom of fumaric acid and L. bers of the genus Corydaits) - often used in combination of 16 teem fr. malic acid by hydration and dehydration (as in the Krebs (the yellow and slender tn•nar•i•e•ee.3e \fyt1P.(a)re'aee e\ N pl, cap [NL, cycle) found adj [L Jumida smoky, fr. junior smoke] obs : SMOKY, Fumaria + -ace.,] : a family of acrocar ous true masses ,u-ma-rate \-,,a,. - rdt\ a -S [ISV Am, + -au] : A soh or VAPOROUS (order Funariales) with annual or biennial erect gg meloVhOres ester of fumaric acid fu•mgg•a•cin \fyu'mig.Sm\ n -s [JPmiga- (fr. NIL fuml.amx, -see FUNAIP, - fm•nal4-l"egm \.;..;ashas\ adi alas) fu•mar.ia \fyU'ma(a)rea\ n [NL, fr. LL, fumitory, fr. L Spatfic epithet of Aspereillus Juougamr) + in (as in acurl fu•nar•i•a•les \-a(,71ez\ n Jill rap [NL. tr. Forlorn + f inus smoke + -aria] 1 cap : a genus of annual herbs p r ycin, sueprofhricia) - more at FUMAGauN] : a crystalline an order of usa acmcarpous mosses having erect gameto- Q Jy Fumariac<ae) with only one Octal spurred are the base antibiotic acid CuH«Oe obtained from a soil fungus (Arper- Ph rn with an anGid Instant of leaves (rat- and s one-seeded globose capsule 2 pt famari.ae an Bull, jurnamut) - called also hebola.¢ and Ifine•tion \'faq(k)shan\ n -s [L Junuion-, juneeia pier o r ` extract or dried leaves of the common fuattory formerly used lu-mi•ganl \RyUm ated. -m ug-\ n -S [fumigate + -ant] : A are, fr. / c tux (past part, of fungi to perform) + - on-, o. akin to Ski bhunkee he enjoys] 1 a : professional as a tonic and alterative gaseous or readily volattlizable chemical (as hydrogen cyanide -ion, pm it fu•mar•i•a•ce•ae \fymmaGa)m'ase"\ n pi nip [14L. fr. or Daradmhlorobenzene) used as a disinfectant or pesticide or official position : oacutanON (big business has elevate Fwnaria, type genus + -ac a 7 : a ]amity of erect or climbing - compare AEROSOL 2 the - of management to the status of the learned professions herbs (order Papaverates) of the northern hemisphere and fu•mi•gale \Iyum;gat, user -j w -ED/-INC/-s LL -$Ption t Business) (a man combining the dust ,•,r of chief southern Africa wdb basal or alternate dissected leaves, irreg. lu rigarux, past part. of Jumigare, fr. fwnus smoke + -igar, and sorcerer -1.G.Frazer) b obs : those engaged in an Occu- lar spurred flowers, and capsular fruit - lu•mar.i•a-eeom (aka to L pHerr to drive) - more at AGENT] 1 : to apply pation (the scribes are not a sect but a , -Ste uel Patch.'> . ashn\ di smoke, vapor. or gas to (tribes that , bodies to dry and 2 • the action for which a person or thing is specially filled. tu•inarde acid \(9tyU;marik-\ a [faHarta ISV 1 oar- + -'e7 preservethem): as aarcharc: to scent with incense or pefume used. or responsible or for which a thing exists : the activity supine tins euramd dicarbo.yLC acrd HOOCCH= (with fragrant thyme the city - -John Dryden) D : to treat appropriate m the nature or position of a person o mine H that is found in lumnpry and many ,her plants (as a house or room) with a gas for the purpose of distn- ROLE, ouTy, woRK (the , that older people can perform in 1l) Drmed from sucemic acid as an intermediate in the I (acting or of destroying pests e : to make an odor taper- dry life today) (It u the-• of stockholders to assume ,he risk) . . rnmmit- 1 U t r: -1 b- i t l 1. t/ n _ 11- IIY Y I( Y 1 1 Y 1 1 1 as ' i n t ' I y) I th n rY f J) change, beneath it, conunw iN m ) I 1 ( i 1 h over I 1 (tl IF 11IL11 11 IUac tl,1 all Of I J(k)tacticians n' IaJ \ S th quality. + J portal - :I'Ut daahn anoN general 1 dl 111 ( I' Of cvC , r r WI . f ly- N es nr I r Near N IJY)' V 1 g w tt A i, radius h t Y value of the I' n xLae ,ceause -on \ t a(k)xh a h , -M1 1 I - chemical f doelicalrpr«eu) mtl r Ih aut 1 r tic 1 1 Upli'aluch cerned had rasp Is a nmque value Of Ih area A) se . a Y wnliW, lonc•tlon•ai-im ti bail. ITT tact s reltN to a Iher 'hat it is d `pendent ,pan o,li z \ n -S 1 : the act or process Of Functionalizine 2 : the ' r life oOrse r a n); sp b : with anals (vs Of v tin lh it (sand height is u r .con - Of s -level hemht quality Or state of being functiormhaed nLn? ( (,Cpi.replace Jernixl arid .Science) 8a:a,eaprraumwbich:anexavariaMcerm tuned.tlon•al-me\'fa.(k)xhan'I,iz,-do liz\vt -eta/+Nn/-s with - gglli ligio l s.Ecble lEsSnnsi)l EGNOA Urvuwa ME preacher who 'h. is evangelical. liable' x emential l an: to cause egemem ipIt. unit lperforming 2 : Io u al `task,work or teabishednnandard, reference rapoint, employing ais of mcl anY a Sal whose meaning Or muh udcmnN°p -.iuonnl ecotcroor values d the variable are specified b : a pr. m 7 t Specialized g EgualuncllOn'.- cm opens eaemcwre Ili c :'hc rule, law, notation, I.cH.mI load s. lunellonal burden functional it Of measurement) (akin the or as theT^-circle M Or havin r I wGunin denaled by such tan ex.rotot 9: 'h.nsecrisuc burdening n [prob. Iran.. of G fu k omi lle Aelators] : the aof a t latinat1OOrfor rnn ~edibY •ihe lowes hecoroot in mponent ofva bchav Or of group ompou d due to the presence of a particular measure of the actual functioning of a nzu. phonemic differ. b : 04 re 6p We of groOnin once as the (u morPAem«tor words] o two languagetu identical crnlOl lest fflossfirazz : ess.L (thI ^-r gneiss of the n nit sh i lag) soin.tgroup nl aoms (as .n orson. o . up). Ultom, of mums ps o double IwnJ)'als P• °r ; de of W50. Unang,me,t can.tag such behavior is compound of imple Inne•Ifon•¢i•ly \ 1 0(pshan'l e. -shoal w were dv 1 : as regards 6 : °I `crust importance : PR INUFAL (lost sight of his our- taining only one kind of -Chem. Abstract) function (Ornamental column. that ere unnacmsty> pose in the pursuit of Secondary aims) : VITAL (such nt is 10 ; the performance or fulfillment of a function : eurvcrwN- 2 : in a functional manna (a , designed auditorium) s birth, marriage. Bad death) 7 ' forming a sustained fact ° (,Its ubblre in the titoom .1moed Sensory or functional MWMern¢n A : Atonal MIUOLIAGN rased n Is m knn t ~eing ass b ackground n.l or Starting lact moor ^-a -H.G.Arm Iftm,) llrgamenti...I unit functional psychology n : G.11WNALnM I h )°ro as in performing a group of related seta and processes • ACnVnv functional representation ' repr[sent.d.. in legslative T Pal) (in the, position the boxer's right arm is leading, his duce1ed all of the department to effect a reduction i of Other Political bodies basal on the Economic and social jmf t guar Ong), e if (the eii Eathe ter nfeels derlyingdo blrn 10 1 in from s .f a community rk of aft As a I. W nctional h orna e D and PRoauNcE can whichoa word or 1°rmuccon es to be useda in a second orrtthird Bwhether r ithwi te)h(obuurn the - imagMet. or - e of his 0 emgwit-Warwick : the common the acts,act OFFICE. o oper operations expected of la npearm luzuA innat or thing by virtue of his of its nature, slrecturc, status. or grammatical fualton ps • on used in a verb lullction) - etapphor)OEEr-ROOT nsi (fatigue nor wmeror mnUProlessordom position. FUNCTION Can apply Very comORhensively to Person earn are CLASa CLEAVAGE or thing (to fulfill one's junction as a uman being) (one of lunellonal Yield as (grab, trans. of F trade.., Javct/oarll could °atingush his ^ gaiety -John Mason Brown) sYn am the Junolon' of a chairman t to a Je over rneetings) (the : FUNCTIONAL LOAD ESSENTIAL 1 ..how of the appendix is unknown) (the main Junction of a funo-tion•a•rlam s,'f.Q(k)mh(Om,,fizvm\ a -s (lunrf.Nary + Efllndamenlal IT -a 1 : SomeNi.9 fundamental; tap : one language is to communicate ideas of l,e8ngr) ancE, often -ism • administratton by functionaries : OFFICIALISM of the minimum comtiluerat without which a thing would not ,JOSE to FV rvrnoN in application to th(°ga, Use. apples to the tluno]ll \'mo(k),oq.ae, -rd~ 1'. fmc-tion•aire or be what it is or on which all further devclopmcnl I. founded - function or work expected of a person by virtue of his trade, lonc•Hon•nalre \}•:na(a)I(a)R -,ne, III, a. PI funcuomrles often used in pl. (reading, writing, spelling. and arithmetic are rime profession. or position in relation to Ming (the a]lice of books to IMCHomdres or lmctltiomairm (Imctimary (than.. of gals of a ho ucat viion) 2 board I t as pch of 0e mine imndnl ar co is Mt 1. creole bookworms, but independent souls -Howard F /°neriarmhn) fr. Junrrlon + ry, fiM. al M. J..Cs> (the a here taken of the work and JJ//Ire of lu cti.nnaire enci it. (influenced bar E /unction) oi'~ Joelorm- Parent tutee re bt/ memo of or Waal train 3 the earmnd cPhilosophy -John Dewey) (tor 11 these the Bonn aJJim of aire. fr. )...Gone function (fr. L /unction., /uric per complex wave) Editor are needed -Times Lit. Sup,.) ((the hangman once) + sire -ary - more at FUN NI :one who xrvm N a that has the lowest frequency end commonly the greatest addressed himself to his °/dire -T.B.Macauln) (performing certain function (characters in a] to a are rather .mp8mde sun sus PRDICDLE the .)lice of Vresident in his absence) (t is not the .Jpg of a limene a.,M, in a preconceived plot -Roger Manvell) (I he llmilamonW bass n 1 : the root note of a musket chord triad to meddle no much) nun, in this connection, applies functionaries who summon To torcan for the clubhouse 2 : the generating tone of a Satire of harmonics 3 : e bass the room harmonics so coast it Expected in aerformbYreor calling(aci Obligation duty or patrons in a government or rty: CIVIL SIXA psiraeburSid tunndaFnanW Managing a lu a Widespread compte....blue. or the in cons et in ono',e s position, releuonshia ua as a can un to vote intelligently) (the duties of a uhool racy includes a number of lunmionarim 1 court clerk of highly meumorphie rocks that is the foundation e forest Oak tl is... toomen members of the Com renuumoryp¢lumka in a Ym repo. aadsof any tae thatuncon- assem Ph old a o1 clI In ashdwit histJones cas aackrgyrN (the due es of : FICML <thguard a trrk) PROVIrvc. may apply to any duly or ff coon falling munist party and Iunctionades, -Sidney H°ok) formality underlies the acdrmrntary °r unmft mOrPhOmd on or one's if as idion, power. ompetence, and s° on (the zfunctio v V \ adl ('luncdon + any (Wll. Suffix) I : Foxe- rocks of the region historian aka for his Densure those human activities which TION.aL lb fundamental education as : preparation of children or adulm flaw from thought -E.J.Tapp) (a question of universal in. tum•Hon•ate \'••.nxt\ d Io carry on a natural without o portunily for traditional formal wheeling (as in terest which lie in Ihe DroN..r o the b'olop How did lit, esp. organic function (haterlerm with the normal action of the undedevePo,ed nos) for effective participation in earn- Man not appeance IS our planet?-W TV out) (such auricle. renderingg it powerless .sto n roperty -F A literacy. ity9. agriculture, ingrusc homemaking, babasic nq cilizrnskiills D) (as of .1 issues are dcemed bnontl the yrovince of a court -Felix Faughq - Inm•HD-Narmor 1un•m•mm•tal•ism %mentaz..a \en -r illundamoml + Frankfurter) functioned 1111 r m] 1 a °/rrn cap : a militantly Conservative movement in flvn (,,)W \d functions I I. ha /nmtload; fanCHOning tunpltonm{ rea fan o 4 oN f FDNrnox mehp to maintain e : Io have a function tsegvn (shiver t(ion 0D•IeY \ fan (k)Shanlb\ add :having vo useful vnc- American 20dr Century l in opposhu v to m°alersl thsmaha cim and ing ^a to aimmin the heal of the n a ) can attributive noun lion We (2: Cann on a unction a or action functiena P1 01 FUNCTION. l Ca3d sing aJ FUNCTION empllaalaing BE absolute ener I nGlf Bbl Scrlyo lire Itiaal Irl- as an adjective) ~OPERATF. WORK (a government ^-a through eaah numrmerous divi- tnmHOU word as n : a a wool exPressin$ primarily ionYpctian' nemmind° second iCOmIn Yol JCSYS Chfla1S l1 as virgin Si m) (war u, when stun ,ing, use eta end horrible rclstiomhip (as as prepaaili.n, goal. verb, PhYa1c0 -Rose Macaulay) (a conductor who Zed also for a time as a conunctive adverb, or relative) - called ale empty word. O~thephsi elan w tthu movementlwa loo IYded as cvad~ u .critic-Harriers Johns°N an sm ACE far- grad: comp.. FULL WORD tunetiormHe vac Of I G.T,moo v f=c.tur VfaO(k)ta(q\ -a (NL. fr. L Junctus (past part- of herc.m to The attitude opposing modernism and to the literalist lune•tlon•al Vt.o(k)shang, - bnol\ add 1 a : of, connected / Bf to perform) + L err- more at FUNCTION] 1 : on..- datrines of fundamrntelsm (a minister noted for his strict with, or being a function (replace the foreman who supervised thing that performs a function or operation 2 : a sign for a 2 : a. movement or attitude Similar in a significant respect all aspect of work with several , foremen) (a manager who nonprop national function; orp : a syncaleg noul lagn used ps literalism or strin nine,... to traditional beliefs) to the has, authority over a specified process through the Several m ,d¢ae operations in symbolic logic - fone•lo•ri•aa American TellgtPUS fundamenmsm (Muslim ^9 in educe- de arlmot) : de edently related (many s mdaritiq some \:faG(k);aoreaj\ dl lion stream the three R'a) l + -ISt] 1. he pasor.! Pomade way of lit, some due to historical Imc•tus o1•H•elo fau(k)lasa'fnhe,E\ add IL, having per- stun-0ft-ist \-'laq n a [r]undamrnm I L.Imnship -Elomb[rh Bacon) b :.L relating to, or baud formed his duty, having served its purpose] : of no further 1 sometimes tap : an adhamt or proponent of Protestant nn to [ion or functioning (Ihe problem now u not a con- Tifton] authority or legal efficacy - used of an officer no fundamentalism 2 : an extreme conservative; es, : one who sritulional one it is a w one to ke Ihe rarmc hUM long.. in office or °I on ia.trumevt) power. or agency that has, attacks any deviation from certain duct rings and educational Established al an Francisco work -C.M.Eichelbergtt) p fulfilled the purpose of fu emotion (once aacawd, their consist. emenlist pS to a m1i on.. Po excerL available to kmp the oJminisvative organization Dower of approval or disapproval is lane. ,picl. -U.S. s oliticel aonhiovmy into COuFd conflict between i good running order -F.R.M.d, Paula) (a presentation Fed. So P.) yFm ante ritrover y into IsbmnRi 3 adieu Ca, : a member of gover°m cm activities that groups related items reprdlew of ttmd \'"d\ n -a IF & L; Fjand bottom, innermost part, bads ( p agency or 11 such : By (1) : off ling functioI S but not.tme, & F j. dm stork or cy el. place of landed property, fr. L of a small dissident Momon Fact continuing TO Practice )arc - mapam ANATOMIC. ORGANIC. PSYCNOOFNIC (2) ' of ].ad. bottom, piece limited plnp,flY -more at pTiOM] y IYBamy cite its outlawry in 1890 or rejected functional re anion (delegatre elated an 1 all a : the lowest or innermost part : BOaoM b : awsn J slundementaH t err [m•da•m= led-111\... rather Ihan geographical bass) :OCNPwrwNAL 3 of hat may afford ^ enough for ridicule -Joseph, Butla) :islik. -tek\ adl (rJundamenmisf IF. jundamemsa/irC )..do- pry equipmml or 2 tuba :Four 3 t: a quantity of mmerial rewurm maintained acute/srie fr. JunAamenmalst + -ic) gg or affecting the adaptation of a pro l y << of, adheres w, or a building) to prevailing Imm and. on. us. (the or 0 iii°ned or available. a source of supply (of.large - of land and of . marked by fundamentalism (comparingg the neoorthadox with Bch resulted the w Oil ce mof the old day coach) considerably remove of labor making emalgreen) in agricul. the ponuon) (a revival premha) (rev aonomic oudook 2 : closing of used to contribute to the development or main. ture -Peter Struve) IT : a supply of intangible resources (mot strongly , in tone) tux \ as -m : the tenance of a larger whole: having a useful function (a style of information, stories, wisdom, goodwill) 4: an appro nation fm•m•men•W• fanala,men•'IaHd<. writing in which every word in <it, wnk and branches were o. of permanent lemma) or . deposit a collection of money quality or Bete of beingg lundamotal a part of the tam house): a : designed or developed r it equivalent used as a resource or Security: a : e tom of Inndamental law as : We organic or basic law of a slate or chiefly from the pain( of view of tau : vranAR1AN amhi- moon or other resources the principal or intact of which Political subdivision with which all departments of govern- house) fabrss) (Use play's dialogue was strictly iS not aria fa a specific objective or activity (a - for mire- merit mdudin¢ the lawmaking hadY moat conform : NNSTrTI1- b: relating directly o aaYday needs and intermix concerned ant of Conde)) (a manarm sma l : a reserve a ummu- Twx QIs Ne statues esxd by the legislature to be cm- ith repFFlvalion in activity : PawrncAL education ulact last.. Sal up by a mlf-inora or Some public body (as the im to the Jwdamrnmi Into of the nary >tOmerfmrS +-tIZ or knowlefm that is concrete antl usabit not abslnct and federal or a slate govam ant) for the assumption of certain lnn•da•naen•ial•1y \:tanda:merit-115 Ihornkal) e : carrying out or consisting of a group of re- risks b : money on depmsit which is held at a specified place i\ adv [ME Iundammtall fr. lundamenml + -II -IYl : in a ).led actvilies: ponfo sit pPacialized service (ro , European and on which checks or drafts can be drawn -usu. End m pl, fundamental manna . in the manner of a Primary more Defense Community and oth ear - arms of Ne Emerging (prefers payment from foreign Concerns in New York ^a) (animal are~dapeas a Ion plant life): in essentialswctom Political structure -New Republk) (whether coo Orion pere : no nr, Covent (the of a bank) d fmda YYf : the on. function (sYSema Nffefrnt) W all forms of mthematim would lead to structural union) 3 ptt forming or able to stock of Use British national debt - called also pablle J=&; arc short cut for Ihe opeTenon of ¢grTOde-uhoal arithmetic mrfofor n its regular function . to is lno lioning dition Fed with the (the holdings of these men in then-'-W.O. -Robert Bending):mfundamental disposition(a - hovret (vision that in - only in bright light) : woRKINO (the ft Is Aydelole) 8)mds pi : available pecuniary resourw or- person) : eASlceuY mrnl'Inb\ as -FE :Ihe 9ue8tY of light ion still -after being droppd) 4 : placing, related alNariln smludi "an and negotiable p.yya W at Co. be con, Im•da•mon•tal•nesa fuations in an industry or business Budg Ne IT tlon of a varied to cash at Why time without lase <w'ill h in ~a Retain stem of being fundamental sation (-organization) aItg ~BydaY) 6 . in organization administering a special tunda tO PRrtide n : ¢E.msfrARY PARTICLE specialist : having aoataliesd admin u manammenq 6: NCrLONALm 6: relating or attempt. tad (the Inmtnational Monetary Fwd... Confirmed with it fmdamenW tisane es : plant tissue other than dermal anc Fu n{ to demonstrate the relalednas of any single aspect of members -BrhNW1a Bk. of the YrJ vascular tissum that comiats typically, of relatively undif collure to the maintenance of an integrated sociocultural atom IT -eD/-nw/e 1 a : to provide and appropriate a Instantiated parenchymatous and supportive cells hole (in our western civilization the penoval life Brad. the - fund or permanent reveal to pay the interest of : make londMMW gone IT : NNDAa W.L 2 lift have (alto apart -P.C.W.Gmkid) saology) or Provision of mesourcm for discharging the interest Imftm is PI of Ftimaa mMlam\ n -s [L. hL. touvdafion - 7 : Navin n° neurolo ical or organic Pathology (a pay- r principal of (a pledge of costoms revenue to ^ government Inn•da•mm- &m Shaw' Of O by maldryagy Which i ld - . . . discarded the notg) emp10ym pemioin) IT • to make provmwa for more at rUNDAMFM] : or logical larom or ruling paintpt' amount of organ pathology whkh is iwovered, even with modes (a mounenl future liability) by Systematic secumula- • GROUND arefol and thorough oammasion. is nitha sufficient nor (m. non of a fund a pmWn pDia.) 2 to place in a fund fm•da•t1Uge•nia \ fan.dI-uB'l~nya. -nb\ N. pi Inndatr( Uonoe enough to account for the gymvCOma -E.A.Streckg) : store UP : ACCONN LATE <4 bactground of it notions of Vanilla \-ng,e\ OL, 1n.. Jundanf- (fr. jundanfa) -genii le tali l pAlMmua n a branch °f symbolic logic that the beautiful-F.1.Malha) 3:toconvert(afloaling or.hod• (igeg. IT. OR -gen& bom) - mote at-Ge.): a vivlparou ,to me quantifiers in order to deal with propositional tune. lime tlebl of a number of differentiation) mo a debtN&i is y- parthenogenetic winglm female aphid yroducd by . fund. tln, to addition to the unanalyzed propositions of proposi- able either at a distant date oats. with en OF non to the debtor viz and giving rise to further wingless forms or o maante Tional Calculate -called also predicate akulm; see xloxEa to redeem after .certain time or at no dmile date and that -tm•m•trl•{en•ic $rnik\ add f n'dd•va se: n 011 1"1 d detarWmpCALCULUS,lLOWER PUNLTIONAL CALCULUS bears a fixed interest 4 : IO invest (money) in the British Im•da•tnX \.foaa dIA6 a. pal lmdaM.ms Sa a am Iune Pa ounder, Ir. r.r. fsez\unda'w [NL. f[. (pest LL, pan fa of u Jndundama,n to to of faunal, L 1r1. a ldtmdr Orel . of anrminanl tiles whose as Constituents author Impublic are Davit tl ontlva of n ; e on. determinant •dal Y funds fand'1'f of []un a + -.13 vuNmc found col -TR ] : a viviparous retain Both row cerivaiive Iy of only one variable riable and fun.".Mant \'fandamant\ q at -s [M [ME, loundelion, site. (in- bottom) +~on-mpreaNBOT TDM. the Public flu ced by L/undamentum f demenq ndnal tr. OF noge.elic Red or rglen. female aphid produced on 11 each column derivatives 4 a I ge Moae enable ,country design imoee n :management of the public debt o(a / den. nr, fr. L/undamenfum, !r. J dare to fond (fr.]Radio primary host plant from rev overwintering tertilizd as* t OuvY Ed to balance it Economy, bottom) + -m mm -mend 1 a ON : the base on which a funded past of FUND nOebhured group n : FUNCTION 9 structure as a building or wall) is enacted b : an underlying funded debt also funded liability as [Junded fr. Pont Para, t rJ dl' FIXED LIABILrrY; specff : BONDED DEBT fbOC"f und illiterate a : a person unable to read and under- ,anal .r(thory :basnnm le (relations bb countries ynd directions (Selective Service soled that all examinees basil on the -a of :basic pp respect and neighborlinessco Foue- lundholder n 1 : one that has money invested in it wtihtnsthan five years of schooling were Junctional illireraes) DATION(archaeolov and history are us e firm of tact British public tundra 2 : one Nat holds stacks, bonds,' 1?ow•tloO.at.'sm Vshon'hizam, -slmxJ giving which mental or behavioral GNESSea are viewed es Oda fosse : etrITOCRIe ba ANUS h3 blot of ANLAC yy which one sit other funds as a mere investment gat eland s; ~d~ Ufa da\ W s [perh. tr. Limbo Jandi ha grass] onxx of the whole oT Baum :instrumental psycho,, uriace that has not been shad by hu an activation m she ld rap in bey of design ps aMaterial )holding has Ilun•da•memtal \Tanda:awm'l\ anti [ME, fr. LL fund - tropical Atrsan gams (DighannW esiifs) cultivated for its se, h ' tlcsign i b dap ad to tau trial, End structure rnmlis, of a foundation, tr. L Jundamenmm + -oli, -al] Net resembles mtljet 3: a rheas which the h ndi,my th Principle dominates 1 : producing, supporting, regulating, of conditioning Some- Iun•dic, Vtomik\ aN[fun. dos + -f.] : of or relating 1° a fund C." of culture which analyzes al interrelatedness and thing (as a d,velo matt or system) : BASIC, UNDEFLYING - fmdie glen. n :one Tubular glands of the fundus of t h secreii°gprosinavdmucas-compereOx Cnl Mnd ence of patterns and 1 sutuv p : a: serv- atom Be ons within a cultural often used with m Pesponvbthty is ~-lo democraty) lex or social System and which emphasam the interaction big ex an original or generating sourm : being Use one from PARIelAL COLL. 1 1% 4 cc \J V% ad V% ~ Nii vail~, I have some suggestions. Maybe you can make them work. maybe not. The dock with no one across the street caring about it is a danger. The dock as proposed does not comply with the Town Codes setback of 15 feet from even the perpendicular proposed by Mr. Hermann in his December 30, 2013 letter. And in addition to the 15 feet there needs to more footage for a boat outboard of the dock. The drawings show there is at best 11 feet of setback. Interesting, code compliant docks are 4 feet wide and this 'proposed one is 8 feet on the plank. If the applicant were to halve his dock to 4 feet he would get the 15 foot side setback and if he were to by proper filing of covenants not to permanently moor a boat (it is the exposed side so that should be a natural) at the outboard ; then that outside southerly side would only be used for safe harbor in storms or loading and discharging of small craft. He might shoe horn it in. But that application is not before you. You could for purposes of safety as boards and planks continue to strip off and present danger: You could grant an emergency repair or do it your selves and send the bill to the Applicant. Not based on the False application but for safety and a very limited safety purpose. However, the emergency repair should permit creating any rights expressly NOT Be a transferable in either a transferor or transferee. That might allow some form of repair but not compound the problem. IT MUST BE CLEAR THAT THE BIGGER THE VIOLATION AND THE LONGER TERM OF FORBEARANCE that endangers cannot be continued and that ignoring the terms of governance should not be rewarded. Any emergency repair should not condone repairs from future events. This applicant has already played you. Any future repairs would again be on an unpermitted structure so they would need to come before you. This applicant has pulled so much fishing line out of the Trustees reel. You also need to protect some innocent future bona fide purchaser without knowledge. The now former applicant in my hypothetical "scenarios" of recommendations could either decide to move the dock, maybe reduce its size and shift its location those 4 feet I suggested; or maybe move it in front of either of his two dwellings or between them if the Town Board could see to it. The Applicant should be on Notice as should be the Town this abandoned structure even if rebuilt is a liability. Safer is better compliant is better. Maybe you can avoid litigation or appeals to Courts and Counsels maybe not. Here we are some 3 changes of leadership in your panel, 2 storms and a big mess. When the non-violative person of the Town comes to you with their application let's go over what happens. I know it gets filed and heard the next month or within 4 months the application gets terminated due to the passage of time. So about 5 months in total. It is much better in this Town to violate your laws and take around 9 or 10 times longer to make the application.... The Town Trustees have a strong hand do not waste it. Set and hold your policies firm. 11~ I On the very same Orient Harbor others have been denied when even their situations were more compelling and historical and all applications both wetland and Coastal Erosion permits required. So what is before you a permit to have a structure or to repair the structure? I repeat. Use your Code. Don't reward the wrongdoer and the delayer. You can get repairs effectuated under you safety police authority but deny the Applicant's false permit and badly conceived application. I thank anyone who finally realized that my elderly parents yard and their civil rights needed protection. Brother Jay good luck in those matters upon which you are not recused. Thank you. 12 u ~c \ ' a • • IIIIIIIII^IIII(Illl SURVEY OF PROPERTY FEB - 7 2014 SITUATE N/ gENgY + : "'A' FEB - 7 2014 ~DgN 6L~b \ S - ORIENT Board of ~Lu,,IIIi -Board of TOWN OF SOUTHOLD SUFFOLK COUNTY, NEW YORK S.C. TAX No. 1000-26-01-17.1 SCALE 1"=20' FEBRUARY 1, 2012 MAY 10, 2012 ADDED DOCK NOTE MAY 17, 2012 ADDED CZM LINE NOVEMBER 1, 2013 CORRECT SOUTH PROPERTY LINE LOCATION FEBRUARY 4, 2014 ADD ADDITIONAL NOTES O a\ ~ROP< "A ~ • d a+ AREA = 12,024 sq. ft. (TO TIE LINE) 0.276 GO. Vy- GENERAL NOTES: DOCK REPAIR NOTES ARE FROM OWNER AND OTHER CONSULTANTS. TYPICAL DETAIL OF DOCK REPAIRS, PLAN AND SECTIONAL VIEWS SCALE: 1" = 10' AID4 w90E L- 11F -'4' DG_ II>PnaA PF .;1 - I11-L /I 1,1111 I,' A11, TIIIPEP. TIMEEP i 11111 1E_C I II 111 111 BI Irr I II ---~,T I- _ m=L> rl' DD-11111 - 'FT EDIT Ti ILL III~J I_ILl r;' ~UT~DE ?UJ TI[AP~ - ICllh rp \ ryfg// \ a~ rl r-n- arll VIS TIFI PL 4r -1 ~I!I'P I IEE-' ;IEC C,~GEP II F- GE^_I -1F111 EP'. ~IID IIII~E •1ETH III, II EXISTING FIXED TIMBER DOCK TO BE PERMITTED PURSUANT TO paH^R'S~\ fC f _I 11P 111 II IEIDE PILE =LI- LLIII CHAPTER 275 FOR THE PURPOSE OF ESTABLISHING THE ABILITY TO UNDERTAKE "ORDINARY AND USUAL MAINTENANCE," I.E., ACTIONS \ ~ Op £ 1501 111; V='S-IF ED I I']I, NOT AFFECTING MORE THAN 75% OF THE STRUCTURE, AND/OR "NORMAL MAINTENANCE" AS DEFINED BY CHAPTER 111, I.E.. "PERIODIC \ I \ p \ REPLACEMENT OR REPAIR OF SAME-KIND STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS OR \ I Ao~, °s " A y \ ° PROTECTIVE COATINGS WHICH DO NOT CHANGE THE SIZE, DESIGN, OR , oy PROPOSED REPAIRS TO EXISTING FIXED TIMBER DOCK AS OF 6/11/13 INCLUDE: FUNCTION OF A FUNCTIONING STRUCTURE" AND WHICH "DOES NOT .4°. 1) AS-BUILT REPAIRS FOLLOWING HURRICANE IRENE, INCLUDING INSTALLATION REQUIRE A COASTAL EROSION MANAGEMENT PERMIT" PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 111. OF NEW 2" x 10" UNTREATED DECKING AND REPLACEMENT OF STORM + (THE TOTAL COST OF REPAIRS MAY NOT EXCEED 50% OF THE ESTIMATED FULL \ Iw \ 6i Cya^ DAMAGED INSIDE PILINGS, CAPS, AND STRINGERS (ACTUAL COST = $18,450) REPLACEMENT COST OF THE STRUCTURE AT THE TIME OF REPAIR. AS ANY \ \ U A •T' 2) PROPOSED REPAIRS DUE TO DAMAGE CAUSED DURING HURRICANE SANDY, SUCH REPAIR WOULD CONSTITUTE A "RESTORATION" AND REQUIRE A COASTAL I NPo f 001 INCLUDING REPLACEMENT OF ADDITIONAL 10" INSIDE PILINGS, 6" x 6" CAPS EROSION MANAGEMENT PERMIT PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 111). lP \ I 0 4 AND OUTSIDE STRINGERS, AND 4" z 6" INSIDE STRINGERS; AND INSTALLATION I \ £ I O Pte, OF ADDITIONAL 2" x 10" UNTREATED DECKING (ESTIMATED COST = $8,700) 4) TOTAL COST OF AS-BUILT AND PROPOSED STORM DAMAGE REPAIRS = $27,150 3) ESTIMATED FULL REPLACEMENT COST OF DOCK AS OF 4/6/13 = $202.700 M1~t 5) TOTAL COST OF AS-BUILT AND PROPOSED REPAIRS AS PERCENTAGE OF 70, ~ ~ cf \lfs d HEpGE RUM...., f'cN•N. + . ESTIMATED FULL REPLACEMENT COST OF DOCK = 13.4X ti aCpV,Of ~l1 GSES NNO ON 3 ca+c~M N ' l4P ~CKN~WBOPLO 5 0~~ W 63.33' \NSSP SEOt~e NSS 5 $Z•FJZ U\ SNO , 4, / / NV'M` wNCR T 0 B JR. 1 VNfSO S+INNEB BREBEN5YSR N JOYIN ow"~ J PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE MINIMUM STANDARDS FOR TIRE SURVEYS AS ESTABLISHED BY THE LIALS. AND APPROVED AND ADOPTED FOR SUCH USE BY THE NEV YORK STATE LAND / N TIRE ASSOCIATION. q ' F HEGy y~P ' GAFF }O REPLACE (2) INSIDE PILES co-///KING sT STpFFT i n ew. i REPLACE (4) INSIDE PILES mar N.Y.S. LIa, No. 50467 UNAUTHORIZED ALTERAMN OR ADDMON Nathan Taft Corwin III TO THIS SURVEY IS A VIOLATION OF SECTION 7208 OF THE NEW YORK STATE EDUCATION I.AW. COPES OF THIS SURVEY MAP NOT BEARING Land Surveyor THE IAND SURVEYOR'S INKED SEAL OR EMBOSSED SEAL SHALL NOT BE CONSIDERED TO BE A VALID TRUE COPY. CERTFICAMNS INDICATED HEREON SHALL RUN Successor To: Stanley J. ISaksen, Jr. L.S. ONLY TO THE PERSON FOR WHOM THE SURVEY Joseph A. Ingegn0 LS. IS PREPARED, AND ON HIS BEHALF TO THE TITLE COMPANY, Ga NMENTAL AGENCY AND Title Surveys - Subdivisions - Site Plans - Construction Layout LENDING INSIIRRION LISTED HEREON, AND TD THE ASSIGNEE OF THE LENDING INS'R- PHONE 631)727-2090 Fax (631)727-1727 TUNON. CERTIFICATIONS ARE NOT TRANSFERABLE. OFFICES LOCATED AT MAILING ADDRESS THE EXISTENCE OF RIGHT WAYS 7566 Main aln Road P.O. Box 16 AND/OR EAS EMENTS or OF RECORD. IF ANY. . NOT EASEMENTS SHOWN ARE NOT domesPort, New York 11947 Jamesport, New York 11947 NOT GUARANTEED. 32-00 tl cE..Y E D SURVEY OF PROPERTY N% xENgY ~ aDNN 62 \ s REFFEEB- 7 2014 F E B - 7 2014 SITUATE Jill° ORIENT Lrk TOWN OF SOUTHOLD S Board TwL,~_ ar "~y,L SUFFOLK COUNTY, NEW YORK S.C. TAX No. 1000-26-01-17.1 SCALE 1"=20' FEBRUARY 1, 2012 a. MAY 10, 2012 ADDED DOCK NOTE MAY 17, 2012 ADDED CZM LINE NOVEMBER 1, 2013 CORRECT SOUTH PROPERTY LINE LOCATION FEBRUARY 4, 2014 ADD ADDITIONAL NOTES 9A% S.a AgxQ AREA = 12,024 sq. ft. \ 90 ~7 7 \ (TO TIE LINE) 0.276 ac. GENERAL NOTES: DOCK REPAIR NOTES ARE FROM OWNER AND OTHER CONSULTANTS. sq. 59; .4 TYPICAL DETAIL OF DOCK REPAIRS, PLAN AND SECTIONAL VIEWS N Gym \ £ ~ ~~~'4~ ° ' • ~j, SCALE: 1" = 10' Fg \ ~ \ C r V I T, F, k Lb_I HL- IMEIEP AII'-IIJIFF" 11,111 F O\ \ \ a' G _I. E_ 'I. E'_Th:~ IMP IE.' FI ITT - 111 I_1 10' Dni lhU', FIr' Ih Ir - FILh FP COII I. ELIT- I iE 'I! i_I IIMHCISFPII IEEF t\ \ / \ • W~ iFl 'I 91 III -I F f\ / Gn 111=II sI - S--Pi ro 'LPP-Er III IT La r' DE TIVEFF -mil IP - r I CFF11r l AIII IT: I WILT- TF ToLI r, L.-- ' , 4F F _ "WIDTH ELF GPI _I EXISTING FIXED TIMBER DOCK TO BE PERMITTED PURSUANT TO \ m. - CHAPTER 275 FOR THE PURPOSE OF ESTABLISHING THE ABILITY - I I(I" 11 _11E FILE, I_I F1_1 1IL- TO UNDERTAKE "ORDINARY AND USUAL MAINTENANCE," I.E., ACTIONS \ ~X I \ n~ qy\ % . --1 II D(il _L4 _ F= ILII I NOT AFFECTING MORE THAN 75% OF THE STRUCTURE, Al "NORMAL GG MAINTENANCE" AS DEFINED BY CHAPTER 111, I.E., "PERIODIC \ I \ REPLACEMENT OR REPAIR OF SAME-KIND STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS OR \ I o ~~w \ PROTECTIVE COATINGS WHICH DO NOT CHANGE THE SIZE, DESIGN, OR \ ° Z e Z PROPOSED REPAIRS TO EXISTING FIXED TIMBER DOCK AS OF 6/11/13 INCLUD FUNCTION OF A FUNCTIONING STRUCTURE" AND WHICH "DOES NOT \ I \ ~ \ e • ye r 1) AS-BUILT REPAIRS FOLLOWING HURRICANE IRENE, INCLUDING INSTALLATION REQUIRE A COASTAL EROSION MANAGEMENT PERMIT" PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 117. OF NEW 2' x 10' UNTREATED DECKING AND REPLACEMENT OF STORM + (THE TOTAL COST OF REPAIRS MAY NOT EXCEED 50% OF THE ESTIMATED FULL DAMAGED INSIDE PILINGS, CAPS, AND STRINGERS (ACTUAL COST = $18,450) REPLACEMENT COST OF THE STRUCTURE AT THE TIME OF REPAIR, AS ANY \ Iu mw ~`i \J 2) PROPOSED REPAIRS DUE TO DAMAGE CAUSED DURING HURRICANE SANDY, SUCH REPAIR WOULD CONSTITUTE A "RESTORATION" AND REQUIRE A COASTAL \ I \mS~ wn °f.•e. INCLUDING REPLACEMENT OF ADDITIONAL 10" INSIDE PILINGS, 6" x 6" CAPS EROSION MANAGEMENT PERMIT PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 111). \ ~(n CP' \ I \ ° 'sa~c1 tJ. AND OUTSIDE STRINGERS, AND 4' x 6" INSIDE STRINGERS; AND INSTALLATION 5 I o lb u4 OF ADDITIONAL 2" x 10" UNTREATED DECKING (ESTIMATED COST = $8,700) ILI 4) TOTAL COST OF AS-BUILT AND PROPOSED STORM DAMAGE REPAIRS = $27,150 3) ESTIMATED FULL REPLACEMENT COST OF DOCK AS OF 4/6/13 = $202,700 5) TOTAL COST OF AS-BUILT AND PROPOSED REPAIRS AS PERCENTAGE OF i:: i. f~ • . i Y 70 S\DE P\~f5 I o HOWE It" ESTIMATED FULL REPLACEMENT COST OF DOCK = 13.4% / appE 1x11cAPS NNO ~ o s\M INS Dirk fANC. MON REP GC l2~ 8ER5 `Al OCK wNE O~ R0 S / 8252'0V\ W 63.33 Tfi. . INSTAS~ptENTS 5 ' \ TMS p\~E 0 La, / 'CN0 1A\/ / L~ , / \p UN ~0 WH JOHN N?EN+1 DDIV MUg7TH / /,NOD C JEAN p PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE MINIMUM STANDARDS FOR TITLE SURVEYS AS ESTABUSHED BY THE LIALS. D`9PP~I. ADOPTED J / b FOR S~~ US lH YO ATE LAND REPLACE (2) INSIDE PILES R 0e` BEET / / uTN G sT 1 / `REPLACE (4) INSIDE PILES llyy TWOS N.Y.S. Lic. No. 50467 UNAUTHORIZED ALTIs A A VI VIN MOmON Nathan Taft Corwin III TO THIS SURVEY OUTI TION DI SECTION 7409 OF THE NEW YORK STATE 1 OUGTON UW. C and Surveyor COPIES OF THIS SURVEY MEP NOT BEARING L THE SSE SURVEYORS INKED SEAL EMBOSSED SELL SHALL NOT BE CONSIDERED TO BE A VALID TRUE RUE COPY. CERTIFICATIONS INDICATED HEREON SHALL RUN Successor To: Stanley J. laaksen, Jr. L.S. ONLY TO THE PERSON FOR WHOM THE SURVEY Joseph A. Ingegno L.S. IS PREPARED, AND ON HIS BEHALF TO THE THIE COMPANY. GOVERNMEMAL AGENCY AND Title Surveys - Subdivisions - Site Plans - Const uction Layout (ENDING INS1TI11RON USIEO HEREON. AND TO THE ASSIGNEES OF THE LENDING INSTI- PHONE (631)727-2090 Fax (631)727-1727 TUTION. CERTIFICATIONS ME NOT 1RANSFERAHLE THE EXISTENCE OF RIGHT OF WAYS OFFICES LOCATED AT MAILING ADDRESS AND/OR EASEMENTS OF RECORD, IF 15BB Main Road P.O. Box 16 ANY, NOT SHOWN ARE NOT GUARANTEED. Jamesport, New York 11947 JOmesport, New York 11947 1 32-00t! Y SURVEY OF PROPERTY SITUATE 621 \ s . ORIENT TOWN OF SOUTHOLD 2pp ate' vs . SUFFOLK COUNTY, NEW YORK S.C. TAX No. 1000-26-01-17.1 SCALE 1"=20' FEBRUARY 1, 2012 e d ~ a MAY 10, 2012 ADDED DOCK NOTE MAY 17, 2012 ADDED CZM LINE ` 59 ,e• NOVEMBER 1, 2013 CORRECT SOUTH PROPERTY LINE LOCATION AREA = 12,024 sq. ft. (TO TIE LINE) 0.276 ac. fJ 3h Y R1n,. 4 GENERAL NOTES: DOCK REPAIR NOTES ARE FROM OWNER AND OTHER CONSULTANTS. PROPOSED REPAIRS TO EXISTING FIXED TIMBER DOCK AS OF 6/11/13 INCLUDE; 1) AS-BUILT REPAIRS FOLLOWING HURRICANE IRENE, INCLUDING INSTALLATION 0 ~rg.\ \ \ .•a• ^~~A1 OF NEW 2" x 10" UNTREATED DECKING AND REPLACEMENT OF STORM DAMAGED INSIDE PILINGS, CAPS, AND STRINGERS (ACTUAL COST = $18,450) 2) PROPOSED REPAIRS DUE TO DAMAGE CAUSED DURING HURRICANE SANDY, INCLUDING REPLACEMENT OF ADDITIONAL 10" INSIDE PILINGS, 6" x 6' CAPS AND OUTSIDE STRINGERS, AND 4" x 6" INSIDE STRINGERS; AND INSTALLATION EXISTING FIXED TIMBER DOCK TO BE PERMITTED PURSUANT TO \ \ OF ADDITIONAL 2" x 10" UNTREATED DECKING (ESTIMATED COST = $8,700) a CHAPTER 275 FOR THE PURPOSE OF ESTABLISHING THE ABILITY \ 4) TOTAL COST OF AS-BUILT AND PROPOSED STORM DAMAGE REPAIRS = $27,150 TO UNDERTAKE "ORDINARY AND USUAL MAINTENANCE," I.E., ACTIONS no 4\ A' 3) ESTIMATED FULL REPLACEMENT COST OF DOCK AS OF 4/6/13 = $202,700 NOT AFFECTING MORE THAN 75% OF THE STRUCTURE. AND/OR 'NORMAL U'` • 5) TOTAL COST OF AS-BUILT AND PROPOSED REPAIRS AS PERCENTAGE OF MAINTENANCE" AS DEFINED BY CHAPTER 111, I.E., "PERIODIC \ I \Q \ d . ESTIMATED FULL REPLACEMENT COST OF DOCK = 13.4% REPLACEMENT OR REPAIR OF SAME-KIND STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS OR \ I yo ' PROTECTIVE COATINGS WHICH DO NOT CHANGE THE SIZE, DESIGN, OR I y y \ e . FUNCTION OF A FUNCTIONING STRUCTURE" AND WHICH "DOES NOT \ ye REQUIRE A COASTAL EROSION MANAGEMENT PERMIT" PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 111. \ I \i° ~ "f' \ • (THE TOTAL COST OF REPAIRS MAY NOT EXCEED 50% OF THE ESTIMATED FULL REPLACEMENT COST OF THE STRUCTURE AT THE TIME OF REPAIR, AS ANY I~ mw ~w ? ,a SUCH REPAIR WOULD CONSTITUTE A "RESTORATION" AND REQUIRE A COASTAL \ I \wyr, snL f °L}+•~,' EROSION MANAGEMENT PERMIT PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 111). I \ y"° ILNE D EC ~V~ CPA ` T pO ki~ N Y I +y Q JAN 15 2014 d CF- J SDLh d I _ ` HERGE RG++' fq J . r tee try 3 CGNGF ~N e• , Y 63.33' 82'52'00 W '+A~/ / MHtF A 0 152 "0ww~` UN zo wRcS+ JO ENUNIOEN gFyDENEYSft PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE MINIMUM STANDDANDS FOR TIRE SURVEYS AS ESTABLISHED J BY THE LIALS. AND APPROVED AND ADOPTED FOR SUCH USE BY THE NEW YORK STATE LAND / b RE 55 tE OF NEty Q tAFrOO'~~F / vvT G STE STREW LL^ i ~ . 111'. o~2scsoas7 c`>r ~O N.Y.S. Lie. No. 50467 THIS SUFAFALTERATION ADDITION TO THIS Nathan Taft Corwin III SE SURVEY IS A VIO TI YO OF F SECTION 7209 OF THE NEW W YORK STATE Land Surveyor EDUCATION RAW. COPIES PIES OF F THIS SY YOR- MW NOT BEARING L THE LAND SURVEYOR'S INKED S&L OR EMBOSSED SEAL SHALL NOT BE E CONSIDERED TO BE A VALID TRUE COPY. CERTIFICATIONS INDICATED HEREON SHALL RUN Successor To: Slane J. eakeBn, Jr. L.S. ONLY TO THE PERSON FOR WHOM THE SURVEY JosepX A. Ingegno L.S. IS PREPARED, AND ON HIS BEHALF TO THE TIRE COMPANY. GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY AND Title Surveys - Subdivisions - Site Plans - Construction Layout LENDING INSTOUTION USTED HEREON. AND TO THE ASSIGNEES OF THE LENDING INST- PHONE (631)727-2090 Fax (631)727-1727 "ON, CFRGFICKYONS ME NOT TRANSFERABLE. THE EKISTENCE OF RIGHT OF WAYS OFFICES LOCATED AT MAILING ADDRESS AND/OR EASEMENTS OF RECORD, IF 1586 Main Road P.D. Box 16 ANY, NOT SHOWN ARE NOT GUARANTEED. Jamesport, New York 11947 Jamesport, New York 11947 32-009 search 1-~ 40 Village lane. OT tent, N'- Search Restauran, (,tit Dire(tkin., Httitnry 1 2440 Village Ln, Orient. NY 11957. USA 1 Village a Ruler a 2 Path ime Places Leasure the distance between two points on the ground ? My Places Map Length: 150.20 Feet ? ED Siahtseein9 Tour Ground Length: 150.25 Heading: 57.52 degrees I~1 ~ ? MQUSP Ilavigation ~ dear 450 Bay Lane CZ Ter) r'7~qosT-~ ' FED 1 3-7 + ar' rf Tru't Lavers Earth Ga ry Prima~rly pataba,F- • ? Q P{aC i... PhLtr:. 4 Aerials.Viewer Page 1 of 2 Na wr 'o,' Putch st ?niy5 Off. C.?1w Gf. _.:e. _na'_ ..r q t 4 L~r,a;e Q ~i ~ ~ ~ 4 2004 r 1SSG , i 1559 v. :M4 T:9P5 Utz 14 L T:957 ` h c\ k „r r A s7 `C-a F F B 1 9 ?_014: s. Board f Tr t http://www.historicaerials.com/viewers/ha-silverlight.php? 2/19/2014 NETR Online • Historic Aerials Page 1 of 2 typo ~i {y({)Rn onmental Dal Public Records Online Property Data Store Hrs;onc aa'.:_ Feb 19, 2014, 11:01 am -routsa[oY~U - r - _ _ . U. l Otro APR for $ Intro bata-e 3rn.. -,I , o 15 ~t5 o rnn fr.. t r o r _ F 1 NIACT ACCOUNT .t _qw It imam _ ...0..+..~... . Purchase N+ ! a 117989) a rr', FARMERS l a 40 a : .K • , Todd. PLAN FOR g. WHAT'S AHEAD. AND SEE HOW MUCH YOU COULD SAVE. y ' . r -116 o ~y O ' 1t /r ti va 1 aP ° off. o- FARMERS FARMERS In partnership with: NEW ADDITIONS DISCUSSIONS USDA 111. 1 r, Floods (1957) Buckingham. vifome (19591 Nike Mx.J- ~ "holon POINTS OF INTEREST.. rgra Dome, Atlanta, GA. D r' ~r rr r`-4 .,,,re of Cincinnati Reds PHxtkyliamol', . ;pops Mori" Speenway e u'o Park. San -),ago CA - F E B 1 9 2014 San Diego Zoo . rd'nommgton, Mwnesn[a r The a a .r r s athered from variety of government sources. Nationwide Environmental Title Research, LLC (NETR) makes no warantees expressed or imp racy or completeness of this data. This data is not to be construed as legal advice. http://historicaerials.com/aerials.php?op=home 2/19/2014 Board Of Southold Town Trustees SOUTHOLD, NEW YORK PERMIT NO.. H NA Q:.. t61.15 ISSUED TO fr 1Ttl~ArFIID FEB 1 9 2014 Pursuant to the provisions, of Chapter 615 of th _ the State of New York, 1893; and Chapter o State of New York 1952 and the Southold Town Ordinance an- titled '"REGULATING AND THEPLACING OF OBSTRUCTIONS IN : AND ON TOWN WATERS AND PUBLIC LANDS and the REMOVAL OF SAND, GRAVEL OR OTHER MATERIALS FROM LANDS UNDER TOWN WATERS;" and in accordance with the Resolution of The Board adopted at a meeting held on _ 2/28195.... F l 19. 9:5...,. and in consideration of the sum of $ 10000. paid by w" t .-GERALD A.. DO.RMAN..... . r r of .......Orient N. Y. and subject to the Terms and Conditions listed on the reverse side hereof, al of Southold Town Trustees authorizes and permits the following: Grandfather Permit:for an 8' X 100' & "L" shape 8' X 45' existing dock. Orient Harbor '-k all in accordance with the detailed specifications as presented in the originating application. ( IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The said Board of Trustees here- by causes its Corporate Seal to be affixed, and these presents to r' q: be subscribed by a majority of the said Board as of this date. o~FFn~co U /G17.. ~ Trsutrss P 1 Mary D. Dorman Attorney et Lau R-. 584B r 1 D t' r m + Suite 1008 January 23, 1995 'Ilnl New Yor)c, N. Y 10012 u u D Town of Southold FE8 1 9 2014] 212N0414292 Building Department Fax: 212.9414299 Town Hall 53095 Main Road ' P.O. Box 1179 Tr Southold, NY, ,11971 RE: Dr. Geraldand Lois Dorman 4_ Dear Madam or Sir: My uncle and aunt, Dr. Gerald and Lois Dorman of orient, are anticipating the sale of their residential property. Dr. Dorman purchased the property in 1958 and none of the buildings on the property have Certificates of Occupancy. Nor does the dock, which has been in place at least since the 1930's, have a permit. In that regard, I submit the enclosed application and copy of ajiiirvey dated 1958, in support of Certificates of Occupancy for: a) the main residential house; b) the garage; c)"the guest cottage; and d) the barn: also enclose a Consent to Inspect. In support of a grandfather permit for the dock, I enclose an 'application, a copy of the 1958 survey reflecting the existence of the 'dock, statements from neighbors and my own attorney's Affirmation. Theapplication fees of $100.00 for each application are also enclosed. I understand an inspection may be required. If so ple>1•se don't hesitate to call the applicants directly at (516) 321!A635. If you require further information, please let me know. Thank you for your courtesies. ve truly urs, MARY D3 MDD: I jt x G enclosures ~ l^ v, +p. ;.v% r'+b s a YV7 p, rg• X Al"tir ~r R f D j` In Re: AppliCation of FEB 9 [Q1Q 1( GERALD D. DORMAN for Grandfather Permit ar Tr MARY D: DORMAN, ESQ., being an attorney duly admitted to the E practice of law, affirm the following under penalties of perjury: 1. I an the niece of GERALD D. DORMAN and was born 12/30/49. 2. My earliest recollection of my uncle's dock was when I was 13 years old in 1952. I visited him for the weekend and caught an entire bushel basket of blowfish off the end of the dock. 3. In 1969 my father puchased a Boston Whaler for our family and we kept it at my uncle's dock until the boat was sold fifteen years later. 4. The dock has always been the same configuration. 5. I have kept my 17-foot boat there for the last four years. 6. The dock is in good repair and fully, unc Tonal. Dated: New York, New York January,Zj, 1995 MARY DORMAN 46 Via. •`~.y S y' a W 4 Albert J. Krups;W, President Gyc~5 rF0( Y Town Hall Jahn Holzapfet, Vice President 53095 Main Road ° P.O. Box 1179 William G: Albertson Martin H. Garrell ` D p ~r Southoid. New York 11971 La Peter Wenzel Telephone (516) 765.1$92 t l r Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD D i office Use On Y 2Q14 Coastal ET,osion Permit Applicatio ~L wetland Permit Application a, f Grandfather Permit Application 2 s Trustee Lands. Permit Application - Waiver Received Applicat n- J 14 TOWN OF Soy Clerical Review: 1e ~ [omploted..Apglcati n kincompl*te, SEGRA Classification: Type I Type II Unlisted Coorai'nation:(4atg sent) CAC Referral Sent: Date of Inspection: ~zj f tQ Receipt, of -CAC Rtport: ( ate) G=J Lead `Agency Determinations Technical Review:(date) JAN26 10 Public Hearing: (dat ~ t Decision: Approved Y ) (date) Application 'Fee: $ fo Cr. ` o 0 Name of Applicant GERALD D. DORMAN`& L'OIS A. DORMAN Address 25 NAVY' STREET. ORIENT.. NY .11957 Phone Number:( 516) 323-2635 Suffolk County Tax Map Number: 1000 SEC. 26,= ELK 1 - LOT 17 Property Location: WEST SIDE OF VILLAGE LANE AT INTERSECTION' OF NAV'7 T & VILLAGE LANE IN ORIENT (provide LILCO Pole`#, distance to cross streets, and location "Agent:. MARY D. DORMAN., ESQ. - (If applicable) Address: 584 BROADWAY - SUITE 1006, NEW YORK, NY 10012 Phone: (.212) 941-1202 Board of Trustees Application D GENERAL DATA Land Area (in scr4are;feet). APPROXIMATELY 4,896.00 FEB 1 I~ Area Zoning: L`I l Previous use of property: DOCK au3,FRONTAGE i Intended use of property:' DOCK and FRONTAGE Prior permits/approvals for site improvements: Agency Date NONE KNOWN X No prior permits/approvals for site improvements'. Has any permit/approval ever been revoked or suspended by a governmental agency? X No Yes If yes, provide explanation: Project Description (use attachments if necessary): DOCK HAS BEEN IN EXISTENCE SINCE 193.0s., DR. GERALD D. DORMAN PURCHASED PARCRT. WTTH-ANOTHER'.ACROSS'VILLAGE LANE IN 1958 WHICH HAS. BEEN - ATS RRSTDF.N GE E SINCE THAT TIME. WE ARE, NOW SEEKING A-GRANDFATHER - PERMIT FOR THE-IIOGK IN tLt?.TICIPATION OF-SELLING. THE PROPERTIES, Wnn TT.TQNAT. PROOF OF kRE-EXISTENCE OF TAT'R. TC A99 RNn Rn NR'RR Ac SCEEDULE A. 6t 7 7.. Board of Trustees Application • DD ,County of Suffolk s [f ~f State of New York FED 1 i4 •GtRALD-D. DORMAN - DEPOSES AND AFFIRMS THAT HE/SHE IS THE APPLICANT FOR THE ABOVE DESCRIBED PERMIT(S) AND THAT ALL STATEMENTS CONTAINED HEREIN ARE TRUE TO THE REST OF HTSAHER KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF; AND THAT ALL WORK WILL BE DONE IN'TH9 WMNMZ.SET FORTH IN 'THIS APPLICATION AND AS MAY BE APPROVED BY THE_SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF TRUSTEES. TBE APPLrICANT.AGREES:TO.HOLD THE TOWN OF` SOUTHOLD.AND THE Tow TRUSTEES. HARMLESS, AND FREE FROM ANY AND ALL DW04SAND CLAIMS ARISING UNDER OR BY VIRTUE OF SAID PERMIT(S), IF, GRANTED., IN C.QW ING T'HI$ APPLICATION,, I HEREBY AUTHORIZE THE TRUSTEES, TlIEIR ACrEN' ts).,ORREPRE$yEI'1`P:TIVE5~5), "TO ~NTER ONTO MY PRQPERTY Tb'INSPLCT T$E,'PRVMI IN CONJUNCTION WITH REVTEw OF THIS APPLICATION. Signature SWORN TO BEFORE ME THIS Z1 5f, DAY OF JANUARY ,1g 95 i Notary N~Iw'? ~YfYt b 3 Board of Trustees Application AUTHORTZATIQN (where 'th. e applicant is not the owner) I, GERALD D. DORMAN residing atavyLS+rPar (print.owner of property) (mailing address) do hereby authorize MARY D. (Agent) DORMAN, ESQ. to apply for permit(s) from the Southold Board of Town Trustees on my behalf. ~~bL N ~rl'7?n_Gkrv "(Owner's signature) D - P GERALD D. DORMAN. FED'] 9 B~rd Tr 4 - - i G~sLlLTT~S. A PROOF OF PRE-EXISTENCE OF DOCK ON PARCEL #1000, SEC. 26, BLK 1, LOT 17: 1. Copy of survey by 'Otto W. van Tuyl and Son, dated October 22, 1958. 2. Signed original statements from: a. Irma"Ombat b. Gertrude King Reeves C. Sarah Adams Wiggs n n 77 d. Roxanna R. Mellinger Iu~Ln(1),) e. William F. Gillooly D 3. Affirmations of Mary D. Dorman, Esq. FEB 1 g "oar 1 f it stees u^!e+~,yKr/„a• sna: s-iv~+.:.:~ M•:r~.a•.'~--"'~,.~r: .__.s,~s.. iSA J.F- . {'-•~t]..E -'x) _ ,;'sofa` . . sr All s4 ga jp;gds'.. tz.i SS Y ~u §Sxy.. ~ o,/ajrg P~ayoi3l h v S.a,p n n u IR rew N,a1jN/~ t ~ e W ~U p 1yy~ IX C V i .pie ~ ~ ~ Q F _ 15 W S ~ b $ ~ aas'~ c 1 q ~ ~ ~ Qa•lQW~~ d y.s a n b a V x. E- - s ~ b 9~ o 4 c 1 c h v 'Sh G/ '~e$W.cs~ ~or in~orma.~t~n Yt~"'Ya'~ Krtablozk -~or`man r~.ock . . j can Orievlf TUY xfi 'itl av~ S7"rcc ,,;a vl ~49 c. 1,96tos OF t4e jO( Tre T l9 71 D rv`-r Q~ NA?11¢ A i M Q T e a,d t r ro Ax}~ress a-s`a. ~o m ~+-c ~ rid T£~e~~ar1L Sid.- 3 ~3 _ a,s 7 ~ b~ How I6n9 I1-Vini Ih Ncnt JA& arl~cf ent~i~ ~L : 9Ui h 'e zt~ A W S~tov~ l sutin?ncr ~,s~ dew ( q-1 u E 6 b ! L Al ! f-, kA Al ) y T Ir C) l Y'~1CS~ ~2GO}~tCl~Oh 6 Me- dbtk P{~ i 93b t l P~ r t~ A nt b a 4s til S I tt5 4 iv J,(~ L~'YI-e is n~9 ~'~'~c. cS y=-~"- L.~--r~~ .S''`CI-~rl?3~~z N ~ ~-i/P- ~JbY~v~ E~u/La'- ~a L~ ~-o f3 L~lusM(£(K~E LLB eZVLCs ~or tn~erma toh Yt~,~,rd+n~ h~ Kxt Lkic-k larman Jetk av~, OYLeKfi B&I xt N vq S'rrcel- 2kl y1141t Lanlt. 1) +ctas of Ue dark ire • . R ?t a) Af ce 4-4-e-~ Bar of irus Ab1d>^ess ~q5 ~7 ol~Q` R~ ~}»W ~bn9 ~6Y(y~q fh 0f"itn g~ 10WCC n att.- A WS~f"nY Su?nt»e1' Y~Src~en~ C~ r~tes~ -r-mo)1kct,0% or -)fie J6tk av j 196a 9~g ~ ~e~y~.cs I ~ar `2ri~oTlna /~tOn re Y +K ,~h KrlaWotk -Iarman LLtk ah QY~ent` Bay at Nava. 5t-rcct ,vJ VlIn-e !-ROtos of Ue dock ~ 197l 1 r d~ ~ f ~ l1~2L1~11:3 Bar' f trustees- CO f 1 ./iple bo How l tong 11-Yin' th o,,,.t FZ7~ ` ~ ° ~rItcr zLte "Pl ~n C.C. `LUG r h '1Rc Ack d erl 1' s,J oYl Savnme-r Y`eS14eh17 L') l..AA )iesl rec-01ct-o oh o f /die, dotk >4 ads ~ss~~i /y ~s=-%~ rs~v ~ cSl ynz"turc. "RIC JpLes Pr four Wlyarma l-tov, rtQa'ra+nq ~ kti?c~lozk ^~orman ~oc1c aK"aUOrtovtt- -541 Xt Navy 5f'rC; tt Y,/11494 LA»it~)+otos of tie dock ire X971 '~11 Fe, f~dYess 3ox.3 Tclcf~,anc '.3~-- ~h9a~ dl,4 J- Mnw ~on~ ~lY?ri' Ih aNYCN - 04 Zti_. A YY 5 Ito r ~ S um to et' Y`¢S i den eTe.., ~~e~z: C, 1.+aY'112s~ ~cKO)~cr../i aM o~ /pie ~otk rCdrG~ffi~ cJ/fnluYC gat C 4 ?94 f5, ' F©r 2nyerma&ion YeiSge~ v~ J :Kyta U6j k _10 rfnakj Cotk an GGOr?thfi 73411 ;9t NWVj SrrCcl &J Yt fait 1=4yt ~+o~'os of ffe dct/C ~re - 19 71 f 4 D E91 ~1 v. aJ r, f f l4vi B id fU t T~1~fl~bnc ~~-.~3-3t6O2~ L~~ Naw'on9 ~tarr,t' '17 yerS ~s A YYsitor Suf nmGr Y- idea- ,fix- ,,o ~ia-+ c , --r:,(d"AS sdvay YeW4 0.D /0-0,( 4 vt.? 4ms C~ Exr- pest Zr-rot,01cc ti oh .o f -Me, Jbtk 72:>A" ap t3.~9'7 ia- l9 sy -IN700 7bboy IG,I~95 1) a A. - W/ L., L o W S T IAb90 Qo ~g.6 S .SGaflb/C~ ~ L • N e •d. /2.'9!9 ~ O Wi' atfd' Q, SAFE 3 Op rei~J. 1 OLD t11 : az°~s 4o•r 1.0,0 '05/ao-S l 1,11 MAR OF PROPERTY ~ su~zveY,~~ F'bR p GERALQ DALE DoRM_ A y.. . .S~o%: ~o'•~.~ . , ' DR /ENT' v monurnan `s: TOWN OJT SOUTHolo SUFFOLK CouNTYA Y. X41. c. m i d i n' m 1 ~I l~ Aerials.Viewer Page 1 of 2 A - ? 2440 ViNdQe ijnt. Ore^E, ~'i Seerct ms i Purchase ICI } • • . III Aena 0 0 Ok 'A Ago& 1980 I z; 196r+ 195 Topos T1974 • z 4 1 A Yew ~yF I x A~ F F B 1 G ,j I Y,~r\ ~M M 3~' , http://www.historicaerials.com/viewers/ha-silverlight.php`? 2/19/2014 John M. Bredemeyer III, President o~0~fF0(~e4hp Town Hall Annex Michael J. Domino, Vice-President 54375 Route 25 James F. King = P.O. Box 1179 Charles J. Sanders c Southold, NY 11971 O~ Telephone (631) 765-1892 Fax (631) 765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD February 26, 2014 Mr. Eric R. Bredemeyer PO Box 522710 'Marathon Shores, FL' 33052 Dear Mr. Bredemeyer. The enclosed Errata Sheet Notice of Error submitted by you during. the Board of Trustees hearing of February 19, 2014 was not accepted and admitted as part of the record of this application. Consequently, these documents are being returned to you. If you have any questions or comments, please contact the Board of Trustees regarding this matter. Sincerely, Michael J. Domino Vice President, Board of Trustees 0 Nunemaker, Amanda From: Cantrell, Elizabeth Sent: Thursday, February 06, 2014 8:35 AM To: Nunemaker, Amanda Subject: FW: 2nd Request Fwd: FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 Attachments: FOIL TOS UPDATE 2014.pdf; FOIL FORM UPDATE TOS 2014.pdf -----Original Message----- EFEB n A From: Cooper, Linda Sent: Thursday, February 06, 20148:19 AM 2014 To: Cantrell, Elizabeth; Finnegan, Martin; Hulse, Lori Cc: Krauza, Lynne Subject: FW: 2nd Request Fwd: FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957; Here are the attachments to the Bredemeyer FOIL request I sent to you yesterday. Linda J. Cooper Deputy Town Clerk Town of Southold 631-765-1800 To reach the highest peak you must first believe you can. -----Original Message----- From: Eric Bredemeyer [mailto:mysquire@embargmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, February 05, 2014 8:41 PM To: Cooper, Linda Subject: Re: 2nd Request Fwd: FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 Linda: You are correct that the attachments are basically contained in my cover email received by Ms. Neville and forwarded to you. Just in case you need them I am sending the attachments here for you as it appears that Ms. Neville's Blackberry did not. Again let me know if any questions arise. And, if you would let me know that you did get the attachments, too. Thanks. R/ Eric Eric Bredemeyer On 2/5/2014 2:51 PM, Cooper, Linda wrote: > Mr. Bredemeyer, 1 > I did receive your request that was Oarded to me by the Town Clerk howeverd not contain any attachments. The email itself seemed to contain all the info you were requesting so I have forwar ed your request to the Trustees' Office and the Town Attorney's Office. > Linda J. Cooper > Deputy Town Clerk > Town of Southold > 631-765-1800 > To reach the highest peak you must first believe you can. > -----Original Message----- > From: Eric Bredemeyer [mailto:mysquire@embargmail.comj > Sent: Wednesday, February 05, 2014 8:22 AM > To: Neville, Elizabeth; Cooper, Linda > Subject: Re: 2nd Request Fwd: FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY > 11957 > On 2/4/2014 8:35 PM, Neville, Elizabeth wrote: I am sorry I am out of the office. Therefore, I am forwarding your request to my Deputy, Linda Cooper for processing. Betty Neville Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry From: Eric Bredemeyer <mysquire@embarqmail.com> Date: Tue, 4 Feb 2014 18:50:39 -0500 >>To: <Elizabeth.Neville@town.southold.ny. us>; Neville, Elizabeth<E.Neville @town.southold.ny.us> Subject: 2nd Request Fwd: FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 Dear Ms. Neville: I am sending my email FOIL request again also with its enclosures. I understand you have had weather events in the Town, but wanted to be sure you got my request. In my prior dealings with your office you were always fast and courteous in acknowledging by return email receipt of my request. I am not sure if you got it, but want to be sure. Thanks. I hope you fared well with the snow. R/ Eric Bredemeyer (phone 305-609-7488) Original Message Subject: FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 >>Date: Sun, 02 Feb 201420:10:56-0500 >>From: Eric Bredemeyer <mysquire@embargmail.com><maiIto: mysquire@embargmail.com> To: Elizabeth. Neville@town.southold.ny.us<mailto:Elizabeth.Neville@town.southold.ny.us> Ms. Elizabeth A. Neville 2 Town of Southold Freedom of Info6ion Officer • >>REQUEST OF FEBRUARY 2, 2014 RE: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST--Application for Public Access to Records on the PROPERTY AT 2440 Village Lane (f/k/a Bay Ave.), Orient, NY 11957 in Suffolk County the matter of proposed dock permit and its related applications/materials District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1 and its predecessor Lot designations 16 and 17; property is owned by The Henrys Dear Information Officer Neville: 1.Attached please find my completed Form requesting copies of the subject property records. Please consider this request as my request for an update of any records/materials on the subject property received, generated or on file with/by the Town of Southold Board of Trustees, Attorney Hulse and Legal Department since December 2, 2013 and continuing to present (NOTE: not before Dec. 2, 2013). Please call or email if any questions. Thanks. This request is an update and also I have limited the offices within the TOS government. 2. My parents now both in their 90's have relegated much of their affairs to their two sons, John M. Bredemeyer III, and Eric R. Bredemeyer, the undersigned applicant of this request. I am requesting copies of the following again only as to the Southold Board of Trustees, Attorney Hulse and Legal Department-- a. Since 12/2/13 only: any update application materials, diagrams, surveys and correspondence, emails, memos of phone calls from persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY for a proposed dock permit and it related applications/materials. b. Since 12/2/13 only: Copies of correspondence, memos of any calls, emails, memos of any meetings, discussions by TOS Attorney, any TOS Official(s), any TOS Staffer to/from/with the "applicant" persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. The names and titles of the officials & communicant(s), and the dates of the contacts are requested if the underlying documentation of the communication is not being provided as a result of this request. c. Since 12/2/13: Copies of any and all official determinations by Town of Southold Board of Trustees, Attorney Hulse and Legal Department as to who is the Agent of the Applicant for the subject property and its proposed dock permit and related application(s)/materials. d. Since 12/2/13: Copies of any pleadings with any court or court official and/or to any attorney and/or official correspondence (as addressee and/or copy to) by or on behalf of the TOS and/or any TOS Attorney re-opening and/or seeking new/resumed judicial participation in matters concerning the unpermitted (dock) structure or (alleged/founded) violations in the bay in front of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. 3. On behalf of my parents and The Bredemeyer Family Trust and as the Requester of these records, I am willing to pay for the copies. However, if for any reason the costs of research and copying were to exceed $150.00 please contact me in advance so that I might be able to consider some way of limiting such costs, if possible. Also, if for any reason a record cannot be provided me please identify the record with such specificity that an appropriate appeal can be made. 4. 1 r respectfully request that any diagram or survey submitted since 12/2/13 that may be provided me be scanned/copied in as easy and "fast" manner in the "fast" copy being provided to me. IN ADDITION AFTER SENDING (BY Email preferred or disk) I should also request in addition a full size copy of such diagram(s) and survey(s) be made and I will make arrangements to retrieve the fuller size copy in person. I shall want the "fast" copy emailed, if possible as an attachment as you have done previously. PLEASE DO NOT WAIT TO SEND THE "FAST" COPIES FOR THE FULL SIZE COPIES OF THE DIAGRAMS/SURVEYS TO BE MADE. Call me if other arrangement for sending need be considered. I agree to pay for the full sized copies of the diagrams and surveys (post-12/2/2013), but do let me know if the aforementioned $150.00 should not be adequate before copying. I am sending this letter as an email with attachment of the scanned TOS FOIL Form and scanned signed copy of the request as a cover letter. I require the records copied/scanned and emailed to me if possible as soon as possible. Your assistance in this matter is very much appreciated. Thank you and all concerned for you help. 3 Respectfully, • • ERIC R. BREDEMEYER Eric R. Bredemeyer, Trustee of the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust, P.O. Box 522710, Marathon Shores, FL 33052 (tel: 305-609-7488) Encl: (1) Signed TOS FOIL FORM (2) Signed Copy of the letter > Betty: you are the best! Thanks. > Linda: Let me know if you have any questions. > R/ > Eric Bredemeyer 4 ERIC RAWSON BREDENEYER P. O. BOX 522710 MARATHON SNORES, FL 33051 305-609-7488 Ms. Elizabeth A. Neville Town of Southold Freedom of information officer February 2, 2014 53095 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 REQUEST OF FEBRUARY 3, 2014 RE: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST-Application for Public Access to Records on the PROPERTY AT 2440 Village Lane (Wa Bay Ave.), Orient, NY 11957 in Suffolk County the matter of rrop9sed dock permit and its related applications/materials District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1 and its predecessor Lot designations 16 and 17; property is owned by The Henrys Dear Information Officer Neville: I.Attached please find my completed Form requesting copies of the subject property records. Please consider this request as my request for an u ate of any records/materials on the subject property received, generated or on file with/by the Town of Southold Board of Trustees, Attorney Hulse and Legal Department since December 2, 2013 and continuing to present and not before Dec. 2, 201 Please call or email if any questions. Thanks. This request is an update and also I have limited the offices within the TOS government. 2. My parents now both in their 90's have relegated much of their affairs to their two sons, John M. Bredemeyer 111, and Eric R. Bredemeyer, the undersigned applicant of this request. I am requesting copies of the following again only as to the Southold Board of Trustees, Attorney Hulse and Legal Department a. Since 12/2/13 only: any update application materials, diagrams, spreadsheets/calculations, surveys and correspondence, emails, memos of phone calls from persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY for a proposed dock permit and it related applications/material s. b. Since 12/2/13 only: Copies of correspondence, memos of any calls, emails, memos of any meetings, discussions by any TOS Attorney, TOS Board of Trustee individual(s) member(s) and the Board of of Trustees and its Staffers to/from the "applicant" persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. The names and titles of the officials & communicant(s), and the dates of the contacts are requested if the underlying documentation of the communication is not being provided as a result of this request. i c. Since 12/2/13: Copies of any and all official determinations by Town of Southold Board of Trustees, Attorney Hulse and Legal Department as to who is the Agent of the Applicant for the subject property and its proposed dock permit and related application(s)/materials. d. Since 12/2/13: Copies of any pleadings with any court or court official and/or to any attorney and/or official correspondence (as addressee and/or copy to) by or on behalf of the TOS and/or any TOS Attorney re-opening and/or seeking new/resumed judicial participation in matters concerning the unpermitted (dock) structure or (alleged/founded) violations in the bay in front of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. 3. On behalf of my parents and The Bredemeyer Family Trust and as the Requester of these records, I am willing to pay for the copies. However, if for any reason the costs of research and copying were to exceed $150.00 please contact me in advance so that I might be able to consider some way of limiting such costs, if possible. Also, if for any reason a record cannot be provided me, please identify the record with such specificity that an appropriate appeal can be made. 4. I respectfully request that any diagram or survey submitted since 12/2/13 that may be provided me be scanned/copied in as easy and "fast" manner in the "fast" copy being provided to me. AND also 5. IN ADDITION AFTER SENDING (BY Email preferred or disk) of any records, I should also request a full size copy of such diagram(s) and survey(s) be made and I will make arrangements to retrieve the fuller size copy in person. I shall want the "fast" copy emailed, if possible as an attachment as you have done previously. Call me if other arrangement for sending need be considered. I agree to pay for the full size copies of any post 12/2/13 diagrams and surveys, too. The aforementioned $150.00 should be enough but let me know before copying if more is needed. I am sending this letter as an email with attachment of the scanned TOS FOIL Form and scanned signed copy of this letter. I require the records copied/scanned and emailed to me if possible. » ~~ewu do tin!- wa:~r fo seJ t~t- ~sp~ CT F.~ -r~,e P,, 2:t cofy fio be- #-^4COT 01.1SoWoeP; Your assistance in this matter is very much appreciated. Thank you and all concerned for you help J /-O It Respectfully, , Eric R. Bredemeyer, Trustee of the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust, P.O. Box 522710, Marathon Shores, FL 33052 (tel: 305-609-7488) Encl: (1) Signed TOS FOIL FORM (2) Signed Copy of the letter I o4y~c~^ qaa~ Pi~,Pa~ ^ry 4, p M ~2 P°P ~Ojh q C,yrOF ~ e ~C qyr O(~^,r • Q Oq/O cqs bd cOryFYCH~c~ ti • QCp 9p `gpF9 061, j ad c Bi O'1 o G ELIZ4BETHA. NEVILLE TOWNHALL, S309S M.47NROAD TOWN CLERK P. 0. BOX 1179 REGISTRAR OF I7TAL STATISTICS SOUTHOLD NY 11971 MARRIAGE OFFICER FAN: 631-765„6145 RECORDS MANAGEMENT OFFICER TELEPHONE. 631-765-1800 FREEDOM OF INFORMA TION OFFICER southoldtown.northforlknet OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC ACCESS TO RECORDS INSTRUCTIONS: Please complete section I of this form and give to Town Clerk's Office (agency Freedom of Information officer). One copy will be returned to you in response to your request or as an interim response. SECTION I. F/eµ f~ Sew `ch~ ItAAvv- ado+c r( orjaey11 ZO14 fdrd~ilsol~A?~cjF TO: T°uh-, Tr,)sT-z e 5 Mi 0/ne J 4NC A a~ ~ OlAevs - N L55 j)lv . (Dcparment or Officer, if known, that hifs the information you arte requesting). r- RECORD YOU WISH TO INSPECT: (Describe the record sought. If possible, supply date, file title, tax map number, and any other pertinent information). Piet se See AAJ4LCLJ-, ~,lScr t,! 4±e,- me L, o da-/e-O Cel, Z 2 ui`l GS ; ~kl1v s4-cx4ec< I Pre.. QeAp @C~ ,re4ues&- o+ Teis4ves Cl"1<'~¢r.c[~rtSS~/: )R)e : ~{(~r~~rr~Fya-F- Z'i~fo 1~~~a.5e%+Ne~ ~r~en~, ~y/19Srlca~ce~~ ae. (~Y yQ ~Pi LiO e, eA u f a JV~J A~ eD_~r JikG s~ St3 Signature of Applicant: Fe--~, _d~. B,e~ior.,e„4r 4'eM:1) Printed Name: 67gtL R, 312 L~EMEYc42 - Tee f}PC a q 3 H i N Address: -Ib,(edeY %!'~j e r :P-ot l o vie <4 bzt e Or•e„1 i V Mailing Address (if different from above): P-ya R OX -6-a Z7] 0 x ^ / a. r4'~~.o., '3 3 o S Z Telephone Number: ' 3 / 4& Date:G 02 Z O~ [ ] APPROVED [ ] DENIED* [ ] APPROVED WITH DELAY* Elizabeth A. Neville Date Freedom of Information Officer Hand carry to department? Accepting Clerk's Initials _ Yes No Applicant's initials *If delayed or denied, see reverse side for explanation. Cantrell, Elizabeth From: Cooper, Linda Sent: Wednesday, February 05, 2014 2:48 PM To: Cantrell, Elizabeth; Hulse, Lori; Finnegan, Martin Cc: Krauza, Lynne Subject: FW: 2nd Request Fwd: FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 FOIL request from Eric Bredemeyer forwarded to me by Town Clerk. I did not receive any attachments when it was forwarded to me and will be contacting Mr. Bredemeyer to let him know, however the info he is requesting is stated below. Linda J. Cooper On 2/4/2014 8:35 PM, Neville, Elizabeth wrote: > I am sorry I am out of the office. Therefore, I am forwarding your request to my Deputy, Linda Cooper for processing. > Betty Neville > Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry > From: Eric Bredemeyer <mysquire@embarqmail.com> D E Q F q:~ r > Date: Tue, 4 Feb 2014 18:50:39 -0500 > To: <Elizabeth.Neville@town.southold.ny.us>; Neville, •Elizabeth<E.Neville@town.southold.ny.us• LF E'8 - 5 2014 > Subject: 2nd Request Fwd: FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY • 11957 - (oc" > irfidv.'y:- > Dear Ms. Neville: > I am sending my email FOIL request again also with its enclosures. I understand you have had weather events in the Town, but wanted to be sure you got my request. In my prior dealings with your office you were always fast and courteous in acknowledging by return email receipt of my request. I am not sure if you got it, but want to be sure. Thanks. I hope you fared well with the snow. > R/ > Eric Bredemeyer >(phone 305-609-7488) > Original Message > Subject: FOIL UPDATE 2440 Village Lane Orient, NY 11957 > Date: Sun, 02 Feb 2014 20:10:56 -0500 > From: Eric Bredemeyer <mysquire@embargmail.com><mailto:mysquire@embarqmail.com> > To: Elizabeth. Neville @town.southold.ny. us<mailto:Elizabeth. Nevil le@town.southo Id.ny.us> > Ms. Elizabeth A. Neville > Town of Southold Freedom of Information Officer i > REQUEST OF FEBRUARY 2, 2014 0: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQO--Application for Public Access to Records on the > PROPERTY AT 2440 Village Lane (f/k/a Bay Ave.), Orient, NY > 11957 in Suffolk County the matter of proposed dock permit and its related applications/materials District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1 and its predecessor Lot designations 16 and 17; property is owned by The Henrys Dear Information Officer Neville: > 1.Attached please find my completed Form requesting copies of the subject property records. Please consider this request as my request for an update of any records/materials on the subject property received, generated or on file with/by the Town of Southold Board of Trustees, Attorney Hulse and Legal Department since December 2, 2013 and continuing to present (NOTE: not before Dec. 2, 2013). Please call or email if any questions. Thanks. This request is an update and also I have limited the offices within the TOS government. > 2. My parents now both in their 90's have relegated much > of their affairs to their two sons, John M. Bredemeyer III, and Eric R. Bredemeyer, the undersigned applicant of this request. I am requesting copies of the following again only as to the Southold Board of Trustees, Attorney Hulse and Legal Department-- > a. Since 12/2/13 only: any update application materials, diagrams, surveys and correspondence, emails, memos of phone calls from persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY for a proposed dock permit and it related applications/materials. > b. Since 12/2/13 only: Copies of correspondence, memos of any calls, emails, memos of any meetings, discussions by TOS Attorney, any TOS Official(s), any TOS Staffer to/from/with the "applicant" persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. The names and titles of the officials & communicant(s), and the dates of the contacts are requested if the underlying documentation of the communication is not being provided as a result of this request. > c. Since 12/2/13: Copies of any and all official determinations by Town of Southold Board of Trustees, Attorney Hulse and Legal Department as to who is the Agent of the Applicant for the subject property and its proposed dock permit and related application(s)/materials. > d. Since 12/2/13: Copies of any pleadings with any court or court official and/or to any attorney and/or official correspondence (as addressee and/or copy to) by or on behalf of the TOS and/or any TOS Attorney re-opening and/or seeking new/resumed judicial participation in matters concerning the unpermitted (dock) structure or (alleged/founded) violations in the bay in front of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. > 3. On behalf of my parents and The Bredemeyer Family Trust and as the Requester of these records, I am willing to pay for the copies. However, if for any reason the costs of research and copying were to exceed $150.00 please contact me in advance so that I might be able to consider some way of limiting such costs, if possible. Also, if for any reason a record cannot be provided me please identify the record with such specificity that an appropriate appeal can be made. > 4. 1 r respectfully request that any diagram or survey submitted since 12/2/13 that may be provided me be scanned/copied in as easy and "fast" manner in the "fast" copy being provided to me. > IN ADDITION AFTER SENDING (BY Email preferred or disk) I should also request in addition a full size copy of such diagram(s) and survey(s) be made and I will make arrangements to retrieve the fuller size copy in person. I shall want the "fast" copy emailed, if possible as an attachment as you have done previously. PLEASE DO NOT WAIT TO SEND THE "FAST" COPIES FOR THE FULL SIZE COPIES OF THE DIAGRAMS/SURVEYS TO BE MADE. Call me if other arrangement for sending need be considered. I agree to pay for the full sized copies of the diagrams and surveys (post-12/2/2013), but do let me know if the aforementioned $150.00 should not be adequate before copying. > I am sending this letter as an email with attachment of the scanned TOS FOIL Form and scanned signed copy of the request as a cover letter. I require the records copied/scanned and emailed to me if possible as soon as possible. > Your assistance in this matter is very much appreciated. Thank you and all concerned for you help. > Respectfully, > ERIC R. BREDEMEYER 2 > Eric R. Bredemeyer, Trustee of the J & 1 Bredemeyer Family Trust, P.O. Box 522710, Marathon Shores, FL 33052 (tel: 305-609-7488) > Encl: (1) Signed TOS FOIL FORM (2) Signed Copy of the > letter Betty: you are the best! Thanks. Linda: Let me know if you have any questions. R/ Eric Bredemeyer 3 0 0 John Bredemeyer, President guFFU(4. Town Hall Annex Michael J. Domino, Vice-President ep 54375 Route 25 James F. King s P.O. Box 1179 Charles J. Sanders Southold, NY 11971 y~Of +F aa°~ Telephone (631) 765-1892 Fax (631) 765-6641 Southold Town Board of Trustees Field Inspection/Work Session Report Date/Time: En-Consultants on behalf of JOHN & SARAH HENRY requests a Wetland Permit for the existing fixed "J" shaped pier that consists of an 8'x152' shore-perpendicular section, and 10'x36' and 10'x17' shore-parallel sections; as-built repairs consisting of the installation new 2"x10" untreated decking and the replacement of inside pilings, caps and stringers; and proposed repairs consisting of the installation of additional 2"x10" untreated decking and replacement of additional 10" inside pilings, 6"x6" caps and outside stringers, and 4"x6" inside stringers. Located: 2440 Village Lane, Orient. SCTM# 26-1-17.1 Type of area to be impacted: -Saltwater Wetland -Freshwater Wetland -Sound Bay Distance of proposed work to edge of wetland Part of Town Code proposed work falls under: _Chapt.275 _Chapt. 111 -other Type of Application: Wetland -Coastal Erosion Amendment -Administrative -Emergency Pre-Submission -Violation Info needed: Modifications: Conditions: Present Were: J. Bredemeyer M. Domino J. King C. Sanders Bay Constable Other Form filled out in the field by Mailed/Faxed to: Date: ate ~ Board Of Southold Town Trustees SOUTHOLD, NEW YORK` PERMIT NO.. 9 9_~ Q... DATE: ._ZL28/.95......... ISSUED TO ........GERALD D. D.4; AN - I Is Pursuant to the provisions, of Chapter 615 of the Laws of the State of New York, 1893; and Chapter 404 of the Laws of the State of New York 1952; and the Southold Town Ordinance en- titled "REGULATING AND THEPLACING OF OBSTRUCTIONS IN rAND ON TOWN WATERS AND PUBLIC, LANDS and the REMOVAL OF SAND, GRAVEL OR OTHER MATERIALS FROM LANDS UNDER TOWN WATERS; and in accordance with the Resolution of The Board adopted at a meeting held on ...21.28195..... , I Y I ^ 19.... :5...,.and in consideration of the sum of $..109.40.. paid by r GERALD_D...DO.FMAN_ N: Y. and subject to the t Terms and Conditions listed on the reverse side hereof, of Southold Town Trustees authorizes and permits the following: § Grandfather Permit :for an 8' X 100' & "L" shape 8' X 45' existing dock. Orient Harbor I - I ~ all in accordance with the detailed specifications as presented in r the originating application. i IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The said Board of Trustees here- by causes its Corporate Seal to be affixed, and these presents to ; a be subscribed by a majority of the said Board as of this date. t• 1 ro Trustees V OM uY wY41xwY s:~ _1V" ~ ~ vow n44 1 d Cl I ~ v Irrc ~,r ~ _ ~A c vT MrwN 2 1 A' t! ! LLOW .STREETW \ a wn N.B6°2 B' E. 1 $O \ Ip lelB - 14490 - 11 e.fz , w o ,3 y 1',~. aex~an b AI W le„II.n,W Mi. ~~^~M IUI WI wMww / 0 ~N I. ` e.., • W IIUIWN q wM10Vl ~ y .•LLw i 9 p,,Y p Y SGO /s/d O t A N, v/ E. /26.98 Z a ti ' tet ,d ,xa/ y3.00 h:.A1 C r Q 1l µ ~ ~ C p A9~ Pr.F IGL r ,1.`\N ~ m ft~ 5.86 ~ - w ~ M W : 82 ° 99 40°W /9A09 I9 X20°W >f•>f Y R`i-ANAVY ST R EET w@ e z r`° oeu9 /oa.. ~ 1 l ill ~rrr;, ~ r MAP OF PRdPERTY - - .1 st/F7v6YEO FOR Guaranteed to the T/t/c Guaianfrc and GERALD DALE UORMAN TrustComf+an~ ondtheNorfhFarkBank ~ ~.r - and TrusfComPon}/asaarvcyedLbt.22~195a see/e: 4o'm/". OR/ENT 0t1& W. van Tuy/4sen t TOWN. OF SourHOLD AiffP-71-16nit-7~ a6inonumen - - SUFFOLK COffNTY,N. Y. Lfoenscd LandSur~yor'+ ~i'.-aa nPorY! N. Y. I Ii • i JOHN AND SARAH HENRY, 2440 VILLAGE LANE, ORIENT M %r - - ~ 27. . a t fs 4i r r rx"iA r Ark 5 $ =-c 5 \t- i~ K rte.,. ~ br Y 4 nx,1° R Figure I. Aerial view of existing dock Photo by Microsoft Corporation. U r tl L! JAN 2 4 2014 Board f iru~'C ~ J I Jill _ - , Ott, 7- Figure 2. Looking west from beach toward Orient Harbor over existing dock. Nunemaker, Amanda • From: Neville, Elizabeth f Sent Monday, December 02, 2013 4:03 PM To: Toth, Vicki; Lanza, Heather; Donald J. Wilcenski; James H. Rich, III; Martin H. Sidor; Pierce e Rafferty; William J. Cremers; Flatley, Martin; Blasko, Regina; Cantrell, Elizabeth; Standish, ° Lauren; Verity, Mike; Bunch, Connie; Weisman, Leslie; Nunemaker, Amanda; Bob Ghosio; Bredemeyer, John; David Bergen; Domino, Michael; King, Jim; Andaloro, Jennifer; Christopher M. Talbot - Forward; Doherty, Jill; Finnegan, Martin; Jim Dinizio; Krauza, Lynne; Standish, Lauren; Louisa Evans; Neville, Elizabeth; Beltz, Phillip; Russell, Scott; Tomaszewski, Michelle; William Ruland Subject: FW: Town of Southold Application for Access to Updated and Additional Records 2440 Village Lane, Orient Attachments: TOS FOIL 12-2-13.pdf; Signed Ltr FOIL TOS 12-2-13.pdf This FOIL request is being sent to every department referenced on the foil form. Please respond to my office within five (5) business days. Thank you. Elizabeth A. Neville, MMC Cnpie5 CJ re veS'4cO Sout'hold'Pown Clerk __II PO Box 1179 rj/7RrM0. CJn E 6/_,_. E , Southold. NY 11971 Tel. 631 765-1800. Ext. 228 ?Z7~ ~C . o? pZp /3 F6 L Pax 631 765-6145 pp DEC - 3 2013 Cell 631 466-6064 2C c-P- Cpl O,/~ -J,)eC. 3, X 13 From: Eric Bredemeyer [mailto:mysquire@embargmail.com] Sent: Monday, December 02, 2013 7:07 AM To: Neville, Elizabeth Cc: Eric Bredemeyer Subject: Town of Southold Application for Access to Updated and Additional Records 2440 Village Lane, Orient REQUEST OF DECEMBER 2, 2013 RE: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST-Application for Public Access to Records on the PROPERTY AT 2440 Village Lane (f/k/a Bay Ave.), Orient, NY 11957 in Suffolk County the matter of proposed dock permit and its related applications/materials District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1 and its predecessor Lot designations 16 and 17 Dear Information Officer Neville: 1.Attached please find my completed Form requesting copies of the subject property records. Please consider this request as my request for an update of any records/materials on the subject property received, generated or on file with/by the Town of Southold(hereinafter TOS) since September 5, 2013 and continuing to present. In addition to the update request, I am requesting copies of records (Item 5 d) seen by me during my F.O.I.L. inspection on September 5, 1 2013, of TOS Board of Trustees' reco*le but which at that time I had not requ* copies, but do so now and related materials if they exist (Item 5 g). Paragraph 5 a. through h. below breakout a request(s). Please call or email if any questions. Thanks. 2. On or about September 11, 2013, 1 sent a letter to Robert Hermann, EN -Consultants, with a copy to The Henrys (owners/occupants of the subject property) with copies to TOS Officials, including you (in capacity as Town Clerk), Trustee President King and TOS Asst Attorney Hulse, which were all received by the addressees within or day or two of my posting it. 3. On or about October 28, 2013, 1 sent another letter to the same persons with the exception that Trustee President King was an addressee not merely a "copy to" on my 10/28/13 letter. 4. 1 have received no calls, no correspondence and no communication from the Applicant, anyone on their behalf of the Applicant; and no one from the TOS or anyone on its behalf as a result of either of my letters. I sought a response and the letters speak for themselves. 5. My parents now both in their 90's have relegated much of their affairs to their two sons, John M. Bredemeyer III, and Eric R. Bredemeyer, the undersigned applicant of this request. I am requesting copies of the following: a. Since 9/5/13 only: any update application materials, diagrams, surveys and correspondence, memos of phone calls from persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY for a proposed dock permit and it related applications/materials. b. Since 9/5/13 only: Copies of correspondence, memos of any calls, memos of any meetings, discussions by TOS Attorney, any TOS Official(s), any TOS Staffer to/from the "applicant" persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. The names and titles of the officials & communicant(s), and the dates of the contacts are requested if the underlying documentation of the communication is not being provided as a result of this request. c. Since 9/5/13: Copies of any and all official determinations by Town of Southold as to who is the Agent of the Applicant for the subject property and its proposed dock permit and related application(s)/materials. d. Provide copies of 3 checks that were in the TOS Bd of Trustee file when viewed by me on 9/5/13. (These 3 checks were stale* checks from May 2012). [*The FDIC considers checks older than 6 months as stale.] If for any reason copies of these old checks need to be redacted or otherwise altered stamping the copies as not negotiable or similar marking, please consider this request as allowing for such a markup in order that I may be provided copies but so TOS does not disclose excluded/protected information. If for any reason copies of even redacted checks cannot be provided me, then please provide me such information so that I may properly identify such non-provision of requested records such as a listing of the check number, payer, payee, signatory of the check, amount of money the check is for, any notations for what purpose the check had been intended, the issuing bank and account number. e. Since 9/5/13: Copies of any checks reissued to TOS or in its possession and/or control for the 3 stale checks from May 2012, or correspondence related to the staleness of the checks or suggestions of re-issuance now or in the future by TOS, the Applicant/its Agents and/or any financial institution. f. Since 9/5/13: Copies of any new checks issued by or on behalf of the applicant to TOS. g. Since May 2012: Copies of any and all ledgers, receipt ledgers or books maintained by TOS showing that it received and holds at least 3 checks in its TOS Board of Trustees' file on the subject property, and any other ledgers or books reflecting payments made, checks received, returned or cashed by TOS from or on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY, exclusive of routine tax payments to the TOS since May 2012. Please consider my request as allowing redacting of other entries/items copied not pertinent to my request and protective of legally exempted personal financial information. 2 h. Since May 2012: Copies of any Owings with any court or court official andoo any attorney and/or official correspondence (as addressee and/or copy to) by or on behalf of the TOS and/or any TOS Attorney re-opening and/or seeking new/resumed judicial participation in matters concerning the unpermitted (dock) structure or (alleged/founded) violations in the bay in front of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. 6. On behalf of my parents and The Bredemeyer Family Trust and as the Requester of these records, I am willing to pay for the copies. However, if for any reason the costs of research and copying were to exceed $98.00 please contact me in advance so that I might be able to consider some way of limiting such costs, if possible. Also, if for any reason a record cannot be provided me please identify the record with such specificity that an appropriate appeal can be made. Also, please specify the specific appeal authority and suggested/requirements needed for any appeal. If any privilege and/or exemption is asserted in a record/document precluding it from being provided by the Town of Southold to me, please specify (1)who by name and title, if possible, is asserting the privilege/exemption, (2) the nature of the privilege/exemption with specificity as to the specific item withheld (3)what action if any was last taken by anyone on behalf of the Town of Southold that might require the privilege/exemption to be continued and maintained, (4) what was the date of that action in (3), and (5) what acts or passage of time or occurrence would remove the privilege/exemption without the need for an appeal to obtain the record/document concerned should the privilege lapse or reason for the privilege no longer be required. I am sending this letter as an email with attachment of the scanned TOS FOIL Form and scanned signed copy of this letter. I require the records copied/scanned and sent to me here in Florida. Your assistance in this matter is very much appreciated. Having had no response to my aforementioned letters, I am turning to this FOIL. Thank you and all concerned for you help and patience. Respectfully, Eric R.. Bredemeyer Eric R. Bredemeyer, Trustee of the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust, P.O. Box 522710, Marathon Shores, FL 33052 (tel: 305-609-7488) Encl: (1) Signed TOS FOIL FORM (2) Signed Copy of the letter 3 EL7ZABETHA. IVE17ILLE TOWN HALL, 53095 MAINROAD TOWN CLERK P.O. BOX 1179 REGISTRAR OF VITAL STATIS77CS SOUTHOLD NY 11971 MARRIAGE OFFICER FAX. 631-7656145 RECORDS MANAGEMENT OFFICER TELEPHONE. 631-765-1800 FREEDOM OFINFORMA TION OFFICER soathoMfown.northfork.net ,f R E Q_ iDD OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK DEC - 3 2013 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC ACCESS TO RE O DS _ INSTRUCTIONS: Please complete section I of this form and give to TovIn Clerk's (cY Freedom of Information Officer). One copy will be returned to you in response to your request or as an interim response. please WAr"ed letter lateA Dec. 7., 2-at' 3, Mgls of R~v4. SECTION I. To:Tr~1tces L• Ca~stRbit ChC $1 ~ f S, rvy~ I c, (De artment or Officer, known, that as the mformatio ou are requesting). RECORD YOU WISH TO INSPECT: (Describe the record sought. If possible, supply date, file title. tax map number, and any other pertinent information))..~ J ICG.Se Se.e. AAb 1,.eJ E JuS4 (Crrcr w0<6 mews AAVRA lec7, Zo t 3 As ; c~~ FerG he ve ~M a e~ac~e(r~ssed Re = T Pvoeertj Ct 2440 5, ~~e `Qr:eh~ 1 IIQSr7 Co~Ce~n: ~q q of . VAO- e 0C Cot e,~ KI W 1,4tt-- 2 (\c Trustee- d Signature of Applicant. s~ 1 1 CO- don.es Rr &.:17 Intc{ Printed Name: LCR)G QZ DQC9tM see- lek,er o~ ?~~Z~t3 Address' der,,.eleY ho ~ - A+- fG '1--d rM Mailing Address (if different from ab/ove):gI ~1• jL,DX Sod l 1'taY<~~o.t d50tes ~L33o52. Telephone Number: 30 0 Date: hec- 2 2.0 1 [ ] APPROVED [ ] DENIED* [ J APPROVED WITH DELAY* Elizabeth A. Neville Date Freedom of Information Officer Hand carry to department? Accepting Clerk's Initials _ Yes_ No Applicant's initials- ' *If delayed or denied, see reverse side for explanation. SECTION H: (For use by Freedom of Information Officer only). Your request has been DEMED for the reason(s) check below: [ J Confidential Disclosure [ ] Part of Investigatory Files [ ] Unwarranted Invasion of Privacy [ J Record of which this agency is legal custodian, but cannot be found [ ] Exempted by Statute other than the Freedom of Information Act [ J Other (specify): Your request is ACKNOWLEDGED. There will be a delay in supplying the requested record until: Reason for delay: SECTION M. RIGHT TO APPEAL YOU RAVE A RIGHT TO APPEAL A DENIAL OF THIS APPLICATION IN WRITING WITHIN 30 DAYS OF THE DENIAL. CONTACT THE SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD (see below). THE TOWN BOARD MUST RESPOND TO YOU IN WRITING WITHIN TEN BUSINESS DAYS OF RECEIPT OF YOUR APPEAL. Southold Town Board Southold Town Hall 53095 Main Road, P O Box 1179 Southold NY 11971 Telephone: 631-765-1800 ERIC RAWSON BREDENEVER P. 0. BOX 522710 MARATHON SNORES, FL 33052 305-6099-7488 Ms. Elizabeth A. Neville Town of Southold Freedom of Information Officer December 2, 2013 53095 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 RE: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST--Application for Public Access to Records on the PROPERTY AT 2440 Village Lane (f/k/a Bay Ave.), Orient, NY 11957 in Suffolk County the matter of proposed dock permit and its related applications/materials District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1 and its predecessor Lot designations 16 and 17 Dear Information Officer Neville: Attached please find my completed Form and detailed Memo-letter of 2 pages with Enclosures which I have emailed to you. Respectfully, ERIC R. BREDEMEYER H ..`LDEC - 32013 3aai`o;a own' • • REQUEST OF DECEMBER 2. 2013 RE: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST-Application for Public Access to Records on the PROPERTY AT 2440 Village Lane (f/k/a Bay Ave.), Orient, NY 11957 in Suffolk County the matter of proposed dock permit and its related applications/materials District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1 and its predecessor Lot designations 16 and 17 Dear Information Officer Neville: LAttached please find my completed Form requesting copies of the subject property records. Please consider this request as my request for an update of any records/materials on the subject property received, generated or on file withiby the Town of Southold(hereinafter TOS) since September 5, 2013 and continuing to present. In addition to the update request, I am requesting copies of records (Ilem 5 a) seen by me during my F.W.L. inspection on September 5, 2013, of TOS Board of Trustees' records/file but which at that time I had not requested copies, but do so now and related materials if they exist (Item 5g). Paragraph 5 a. through h. below breakout the request(s). Please call or email if any questions. Thanks. 2. On or about September It, 2013, 1 sent a letter to Robert Hermann, EN -Consultants, with a copy to The Henrys (owners/occupants of the subject property) with copies to TOS Officials, including you (in capacity as Town Clerk), Trustee President King and TOS Asst Attorney Hulse, which were all received by the addressees within or day or two of my posting it. 3. On or about October 28, 2013, 1 sent another letter to the same persons with the exception that Trustee President King was an addressee not merely a "copy to" on my 10/28/13 letter. 4. 1 have received no calls, no correspondence and no communication from the Applicant, anyone on their behalf of the Applicant, and no one from the TOS or anyone on its behalf as a result of either of my letters. I sought a response and the letters speak for themselves. 5. My parents now both in their 90's have relegated much of their affairs to their two sons, John M. Bredemeyer III, and Eric R. Bredemeyer, the undersigned applicant of this request. I am requesting copies of the following: a. Since 9/5/13 only: any update application materials, diagrams, surveys and correspondence, memos of phone calls from persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY for a proposed dock permit and it related applications/materials. b. Since 9/5/13 only: Copies of correspondence, memos of any calls, memos of any meetings, discussions by TOS Attorney, any TOS Official(s), any TOS Staffer to/from the "applicant" persons or entities on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. The names and titles of the officials & communicant(s), and the dates of the contacts are requested if the underlying documentation of the communication is not being provided as a result of this request. c. Since 9/5/13: Copies of any and all official determinations by Town of Southold as to who is the Agent of the Applicant for the subject property and its proposed dock permit and related application(s)/materials. d. Provide copies of 3 checks that were in the TOS Bd of Trustee file when viewed by me on 9/5/13. (These 3 checks were stale* checks from May 2012). [*The FDIC considers checks older than 6 months as stale.] If for any reason copies of these old checks need to be redacted or otherwise altered stamping the copies as not negotiable or similar marking, please consider this request as allowing for such a markup in order that I may be provided copies but so TOS does not disclose excluded/protected information. If for any reason copies of even redacted checks cannot be provided me, then please provide me such information so that I may properly identify such non-provision of requested records such as a listing of the check number, payer, payee, • signatory of the check, amount of money the check is for, any notations for what purpose the check had been intended, the issuing bank and account number. e. Since 9/5/ 13: Copies of any checks reissued to TOS or in its possession and/or control for the 3 stale checks from May 2012, or correspondence related to the staleness of the checks or suggestions of re-issuance now or in the future by TOS, the Applicant/its Agents and/or any financial institution. f Since 9/5/13: Copies of any new checks issued by or on behalf of the applicant to TOS. g. Since May 2012: Copies of any and all ledgers, receipt ledgers or books maintained by TOS showing that it received and holds at least 3 checks in its TOS Board of Trustees' file on the subject property, and any other ledgers or books reflecting payments made, checks received, returned or cashed by TOS from or on behalf of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY, exclusive of routine tax payments to the TOS since May 2012. Please consider my request as allowing redacting of other entries/items copied not pertinent to my request and protective of legally exempted personal financial information. h. Since May 2012: Copies of any pleadings with any court or court official and/or to any attorney and/or official correspondence (as addressee and/or copy to) by or on behalf of the TOS and/or any TOS Attorney re-opening and/or seeking new/resumed judicial participation in matters concerning the unpermitted (dock) structure or (alleged/founded) violations in the bay in front of the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY. 6. On behalf of my parents and The Bredemeyer Family Trust and as the Requester of these records, I am willing to pay for the copies. However, if for any reason the costs of research and copying were to exceed $98.00 please contact me in advance so that I might be able to consider some way of limiting such costs, if possible. Also, if for any reason a record cannot be provided me please identify the record with such specificity that an appropriate appeal can be made. Also, please specify the specific appeal authority and suggested/requirements needed for any appeal. If any privilege and/or exemption is asserted in a record/document precluding it from being provided by the Town of Southold to me, please specify (I)who by name and title, if possible, is asserting the privilege/exemption, (2) the nature of the privilege/exemption with specificity as to the specific item withheld (3)what action if any was last taken by anyone on behalf of the Town of Southold that might require the privilege/exemption to be continued and maintained, (4) what was the date of that action in (3), and (5) what acts or passage of time or occurrence would remove the privilege/exemption without the need for an appeal to obtain the record/document concerned should the privilege lapse or reason for the privilege no longer be required. I am sending this letter as an email with attachment of the scanned TOS FOIL Form and scanned signed copy of this letter. I require the records copied/scanned and sent to me here in Florida. Your assistance in this matter is very much appreciated. Having had no response to my aforementioned letters, I am turning to this FOIL. Thank you and all concerned for you help and patience. Respectfully, Eric R. Bredemeyer, Tru ee of the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust, P.O. Box 522710, Marathon Shores, FL 33052 (tel: 305-609-7488) Encl: (1) Signed TOS FOIL FORM (2) Signed Copy of the letter D a DEC - 3 2013 T • •o 7 D NOV - 1 2013 ERIC RAWSON BREDEMEYER A O, BOX 5227-10 $4ut1A a crr0" I Board of Tru; MARATHON SHORES, FL 33052 Tel; 305-609-7488 October 28, 2013 Certified Mail NO-L 8D OUO/5 5 13y 7b Robert E. Herrmann, CM Specialist EN-Consultants 1319 North Sea Road Southampton, NY 11968 AND President James King Certified Mail No:A 0 Oq UO OO(71 S n 3'f to ) Town of Southold Board of Trustees 54375 Main Rd. P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 RE: Application for Town Wetlands Permit with TOS Trustees for John and Sarah Henry, 2440 Village Lane, Orient NY, filed May 17, 2012, by Robert E. Herrmann, Agent-Signatory for EN-Consultants, Dear Mr. Herrmann and President King: I wrote you, Mr. Hermann, with copies to several others of my correspondence dated September 11, 2013, concerning the subject incomplete application including a copy to (but not limited to) President King. My letter was addressed to Mr. Hermann based upon my review of the TOS Trustee file during my F.O.I.L. review in earlier September 2013. Mr. Hermann appeared then to be the person to whom I might be able to address my concerns on behalf of my parents/The Bredemeyer Family Trust. Please refer to my letter as if fully state herein. Since my letter I have received no communication from Mr. Hermann of any kind. I have also had no communication of any kind from The Henrys or anyone else on their behalf. I had hoped to hear from someone by October 15, 2013, given what I thought would be more than adequate time as I expressed in my letter. I do not know if the subject application has been withdrawn, modified or whether it has lapsed. Am I to expend additional time in this when there has been no courtesy of even a polite reply? I do realize that during this past month the closure of the Federal government (i.e. the Army Corps of Engineers) may have made it difficult for person(s) to properly research matters of concern in my letter of September 11, 2013. 1 also do not know if Mr. Hermann remains the point of contact for the subject incomplete TOS application or related matters. If, either or both of you (Mr. Hermann or President King) know with whom I may discuss/address and communicate about my concerns about the subject application, please advise. Due to the temporary closure of the Army Corps I have extended the October 15, 2013, date for the initiation of formal contact by the Applicant and its authorized representative with me until the first business day after the two-day Thanksgiving break. If the TOS Trustees have a Point of Contact (POC) for the subject application that might be someone other than Mr. Hermann, please advise. A response in the negative by the Trustees (e.g. that no new POC is known) would be appreciated. Has anyone at the Town had any contact with anyone on behalf of the applicant recently? I would like to communicate with them. Given the situation I hope that officials with the Town by this letter will assist not necessarily in having my concerns addressed directly but will promote needed contact with the purported applicant. I desire to hear from somebody on behalf of the applicant or to at least know the Town of Southold remains actively involved with a viable POC, if I am not to be ignored or the application silently abandoned. I look forward to a responsive communication as indicated soon. Thank you. Very truly yours, ERIC R. BREDEMEYER t Copy to: (Cert Mail)TOS Clerk; Copy to: Co-Trustee John Bredemeyer III of Bredemeyer Family Trust John & Sarah Henry; and Attorney Lori Hulse g, 4 ~~d~~.-•~~e r I :h3i1?~1~J~.J 1L1:.'L~ rl i MCA relfk,~ S~a resi U.S. POSTAGE U S 2 FORT 33ERS,FL rosre ~sne~ i~a OCAMOUNT13 7009 1680 0001 5511 3461 $6.11 000 11971 00023793-99 Nov - To „JV. a-~ n p1 S o V° d y 119 7) RETURN NIMPT i1113i1i,tli}~°i1131iji~iiiii(,1,',ii~il'liiilf~liif111i?il~~STED cL) PN J0dZ E I V D TO S IYJS+ e eS ERIC RAWSON BREDEMEYER SEP 1 6 2013 P. O. BOX 522710 MAR.4 THON SHORES, FL 33052 Souftw TO" Tel: 305-609-7488 September 11, 2013 Certified Mail No: Robert E. Herrmann, CM Specialist EN-Consultants 1319 North Sea Road Southampton, NY 11968 RE: Incomplete Application for Town Wetlands Permit with TOS Trustees for John and Sarah Henry, 2440 Village Lane, Orient NY, filed May 17, 2011, by Robert E. Herrmann, Agent-Signatory for EN-Consultants, Dear Mr. Herrmann: In response to my Freedom of Information Request with the Town of Southold (TOS), I had the opportunity to review the subject incomplete application and related materials that remain in the files of the TOS without any updates or recent activity at all for many many months. Let me briefly explain (1) my role, (2) my request whether you are the appropriate and empowered agent of the Applicant to work with me (us) to correct the matters of concern and (3) my concerns. 1. You probably recognize my last name, I serve as Co-Trustee of the 1 & 1 Bredemeyer Family Trust with my older brother John. It is my understanding that you know my brother in his capacity with the TOS Trustees. The Family Trust handles and controls the affairs of my very elderly parents' home which adjoins immediately to the south the applicant's parcel at 2440 Village Lane. My brother is limited in certain ways by his office so I am writing you. I, too, grew up on Village Lane with my family and am very familiar with the lands and waters concerned. I have seen the abandoned structure, the subject of the incomplete application, for two full summers now without change. Having recently retired with over 30 years with the Navy's JAG Corps, I am a licensed and practicing Florida attorney. In addition to my 1.D., my M.S. is from the Harrimann College. Land use finance and real property planning were my pursuit. I certainly enjoyed my studies with Dr. Koppelman. My background should demonstrate that I bring understanding and knowledge of the coastal, marine and landward zones, governmental- administrative/ quasi-judicial determinations in local, state and federal matters. 2. Please advise me if you are the agent for the Applicant, The Henrys, to fully address and hopefully remedy my concerns on behalf of my parents/their home. I would like to work with you and the Applicant if you as their Agent are fully able to speak for them concerning the subject incomplete application and any related or similar applications/re-applications/ new applications concerning the unpermitted seaward structure at 2440 Village Lane (be they with the State of NY, the Army Corps, LW RP Coord., Coastal Zone and/or TOS Trustees). 11 P g . 3. 1 do believe that the incomplete application and its supporting materials were they to be part of the perfected application and were they to become the basis relied upon by the Trustees that the application would be fated most probably for failure. Not knowing your prospective role yet, I share with you now a copy of a survey performed by Roderick Van Tuyl of November 15, 1978, as later used by the Suffolk County Dept. of Health Services with the Health Services approval stamped September 8, 1988. A careful review and comparing of this attached survey to the survey of Nathaniel Corwin of May 12, 2012, on file with your subject application, shows the Corwin survey to be wrong. All the relevant deeds/filings and other surveys I have seen match the VanTuyl not the Corwin. I can only conclude that the proposed unpermitted "dock" structure seaward of the property at 2440 Village Lane seriously crosses the extension of the property boundary between the Applicant's parcel and that of my parents home, the Bredemeyer Family Trust. Please note carefully: The erroneous Corwin survey angle is South 67 degrees, 02 minutes East and 00 seconds West whereas the correct VanTuyl survey shows the same starting point angle to be South 82 degrees, 52 minutes East and 00 seconds West. The difference is 15.5 degrees which when projected to the farthest seaward end of the dock yields at least a 20 foot encroachment across the boundary projection. This serious omission/error is not mentioned or discussed in the incomplete subject application. I have other concerns, but I look forward to working with you and the Applicant on this and all my concerns. Please consider this letter and its copies as notice of my concern and of my strong suggestion that the incomplete application/materials/Corwin survey in the TOS file that I saw on September 5, 2013, not be the bases of an application. I may be able to help, but I cannot change or foster matters as they currently stand. I look forward to our negotiation/contact. I should think were you to let me know in writing by October 15, 2013, whether you are empowered to act/and make binding representations on behalf of the Applicant would be acceptable. Giving you until then will allow you ample opportunity to contact your client at his residence in New York City. In the absence of such contact from you by then, or sooner in order to protect the Family Trust, I will wait. Since the application is incomplete and not perfected on its face and as I am unaware of any changes that would change the general appropriateness of an October 15, 2013 horizon, I do look forward to a good faith exchange with you and your Applicant. Respectfully, C_ Eric R. Bredemeyer Enclosures: Van Tuyl Survey of 9/8/1978 Copy w/survey : (cert mail)TOS Clerk; and Co-Trustee John Bredemeyer 111 of Bredemeyer Family Trust Copy to: John & Sarah Henry; Chairman James King, TOS Trustees; and Attorney Lori Hulse 2 1 3' a t James F. King, President ~rg so~ryo Town Hall Annex Bob Ghosio, Jr., Vice-President 54375 Main Road O P.O. Box 1179 Dave Bergen # Southold, New York 11971-0959 John Bredemeyer • ~O Telephone (631) 765-1892 Michael J. Domino Fax (631) 765-6641 :Nh COW, BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD TO: Linda J. Cooper, Deputy Town Clerk Town Clerk's Office FROM: Elizabeth Cantrell, Clerk Typist Board of Trustees Office DATE: July 19, 2013 RE: Foil Request from Eric Bredemeyer In reference to the FOIL request made by Eric Bredemeyer; at this time there is currently one file available for Mr. Bredemeyer to view in our office at his convenience in September, or at any time during regular business hours. Thank you. o~~gUFFO(,~c ELIZABETH A. NEVILLE, MMC Town Hall, 53095 Main Road TOWN CLERK P.O. Box 1179 COD Z Southold, New York 11971 REGISTRAR OF VITAL STATISTICS `i* .g Fax (631) 765-6145 MARRIAGE OFFICER y~ ~t Telephone (631) 765-1800 RECORDS MANAGEMENT OFFICER www.southoldtownny.gov FREEDOM OF INFORMATION OFFICER OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD D LS Q LS 2 pa 2 y, e ~ 9! G ' JUL 1 7 2013 TO: Town Trustees Police Department (Bay Constable) Swftld Board of Trustees CAC Planning Board Building Department Zoning Board of Appeals. FROM: Linda J. Cooper, Deputy Town Clerk DATE: July 17, 2013 RE: Foil Request from Eric Bredemeyer Transmitted herewith is a FOIL request of Eric Bredemeyer. Please respond to this office within five (5) business days. I will need to know IF you have any documentation and if Mr. Bredemeyer can come in to review files in early September. Thank you. ELIZABETHA. NEVILLE TOWNHALL, 53095MAINROAD TOWN CLERK P .O. BOX 1179 REGISTRAR OF VITAL STATISTICS SOUTHOLD NY 11971 MARRIAGE OFFICER FAX: 631-765-.6145 RECORDS MANAGEMENT OFFICER TELEPHONE: 631-765-1800 FREEDOM OF INFORMATION OFFICER southotdtownnorthfork.net 5eEATT,,~-CHED LEi T~Z7, 0 (1„SPeC+/ V; e U-/ rec o rW5 OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK 0.,00,A Sad} . S z o 13) TOWN OF SOUTHOLD APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC ACCESS TO RECORDS INSTRUCTIONS: Please complete section I of this form and give to Town Clerk's Office (agency Freedom of Information Officer). One copy will be returned to you in response to your request, or as an interim response. SECTION I. 7 TO•T w7T?sJeeS 134y 6ns'fw b~e CA (f, Pk,,,:hj Powrf) P4; ~il tit L~~a a4 2%oh (Department or Officer, if known, that has the information you are'requesting). RECORD YOU WISH TO INSPECT: (Describe the record sought. If possible, supply date, file title, tax map umber, and any other pertinent information).3EC14 T-TACH C --D L L T7,~ RC= ~gGhrty ai a erofl5e4 doeK 0-y by 2S'4v ? llaSeLar2 O :e t N It\9s7. Co,pi~S +.Q recaraS of ary tin v're~t fly -F~le~. a_~,~J-rn ¢;uny~~~r~;ay ~'d'/ 'f'''s Q"~ r re care c~ o W;H-"ArAW, a I:ca 'ate w"e e_ P'P (s re}.c,'ve~ b.' 70.,Jn v Su.41-1.0 fcl -J(70 r *J E V-Y m G 4-o 6e- arc v fi2c~~CU v S, r~ bvi 7wn~roSfees~C/IG~j~/any: 3 1c4~r u Cl q~- tor 2-1-7S &j Q- 1a 1Q C o "vale cloc/~~e4iwa(~K/klgf'~ ~1 2~iof0 U~II4 eL~r~ D,:e SSj-Af'%~'C'v..n+ /'~,yMaPD,mot-) avo/ptse2(oLC~xl~Guf/'7•~ py precJece Sai, Lar1s ~74...~s aS o.,,,hl~er Ma}e~:cts~~r 6e s ~r~eyS~ e_(1 a pi:t.-~ u.. x..11 (tea.+:c ~i7Cnc~l~Orn ~ Q-.c~ S'.+p~or'F'~5+ ue,~ 1. ro-to t ra A ey.~er'1' re ~J r'1'S ~J Signature of Appli6ant:~~~~ a- 13 At~ P ntedName :LR R? R2 DE/~f`/cry'os Co-tr, is C, ~ Br~deme~e Ia ~r ~rz Address: -VeEDeMEyE2 ~a.r:l i Hv c 0.1 V; Ila~ceL~~ey Or`~h 1 tJ y , t oX 5 t of ]~(ar~~~o ~(o ~S FL 33os2 Mailing Address (if different from above): P6 r TelephongNumber : -30-S-G c)7- r7q 2? Date: a?/y /4l Zoo p ' clESrre_ ~'ax f^5Pe,4Aie-Q Ye C.dr 5 an ;Per-son feL5,,-61e -face ca y~i.q HeecYS. [ ] APPROVED IREh190IED* J [ ] APPROVED WITH DELAY* C'Q.7 J U ~ 1 7 ~2~-3 Elizabe A. Neville Date Freedom of Information Officer Hand carry to department? Accepting Clerk's Initials Yes No ~pp'S i#hti~rJ- *If delayed or denied, see reverse side for explanation. ERIC RAWSON BREDEMEYER RECEIVED P. 0. BOX 522710 JUL 1 6 2013 MARATHON SHORES, FL 33052 305-609 7488 Southold Town Clerk Ms. Elizabeth A. Neville Town of Southold Freedom of Information Officer July 10, 2013 53095 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 RE: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST--Application for Public Access to Records on the PROPERTY AT 2440 Village Lane (f/k/a Bay Ave.), Orient, NY 11957 in Suffolk County the matter of proposed dock permit and its related applications/materials District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1 and its predecessor Lot designations 16 and 17 Dear Information Officer Neville: Attached please find my completed Form requesting inspection and access at Town Offices of the subject property records. I plan on being in Southold and my viewing/inspecting the records will minimize duplication costs. My parents now both in their 90's have relegated much of their affairs to their two sons, John M. Bredemeyer III, and Eric R. Bredemeyer, the undersigned applicant of this request. Although the subject property is the subject of alleged and/or founded violations of Town of Southold Codes (for unpermitted and unauthorized construction (e.g. see attached photo), it is my understanding that incomplete and unperfected application(s) for a proposed dock/wharf/catwalk have languished since the violation with little and no substantial filing activity by the applicant/subject property owners (The Henrys)/their agents or action by the cognizant town officials. I desire to view what records concerning a proposed dock/wharf exist so I can either better understand the reasons, if any, for this delay and the complacency in getting the subject property into compliance, or consider additional processes on behalf of my family. By the way, the photograph attached was taken over a year before Storm Sandy which means it is nearly 2 years now with nothing done. If action had been timely taken, this dock matter would have been completed long before Sandy and certainly before yet another year passed with my parents' concerns going unanswered. If you have any questions, please call me at 305-609-7488. 1 hope to view the materials around September 5. 2013. 1 appreciate all that you do. Asa former FOIA Officer myself for a regional governmental department, I know how diligent one must be in these matters. Thanking you in advance for your courtesy. Respectfully, ERIC R. BREDEMEYER Encl: (1) Completed Form "Application for Public Access to Records" (2) Photo of unpermitted & unauthorized dock structure-blockade fence d s Attachment to: FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST--Application for Public Access to Records on the PROPERTY AT 2440 Village Lane (f/k/a Bay Ave.), Orient, NY 11957 in Suffolk County the matter of proposed dock permit and its related applications/materials District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1 and its predecessor Lot designations 16 and 17 vv~ le OgUFFO( f James F. King. President ~ Cpl P.O. Box 1179 Bob Ghosio, Jr., Vice-President Southold, NY 11971 Dave Bergen ti Telephone (631 765-1892 John Bredemeyei Fax(631)765-6641 Michael J. Domino y~o! ~ ,~aor Southold Town Board of Trustees Field Inspection/Worksession Report lo~i 2 /J 2 5 Date/Time: En-Consultants on behalf of JOHN & SARAH HENRY requests a pre-submission inspection to discuss regulated vs. unregulated activities in accordance with Chapter 111 - CEHA, as-built fees and the requirement of an LWRP review for the purpose for applying for permits to make ordinary repairs and maintenance to the existing docking facility. Located: 2440 Village Lane, Orient. SCTM#26-1-17.1 Type of area to be impacted: /Saltwater Wetland -Freshwater Wetland -Sound ~ Bay Distance of proposed work to edge of wetland Park of Town Code proposed work falls under: _Chapt.275 ?Chapt. 111 -other Type of Application: _1~1 -Wetland -Coastal Erosion -Amendment _Administrative_Emerge ncy Pre-Submission Violation Info needed: Modifications: Conditions: Present Were: !'J. Kind _B. Ghosio `D. Bergen, J. Bredemeyer J Michael Domino ? D. Dzenkowski other Form filled out in the field by -'o J, Mailed/Faxed to: Date: • • REQUEST #1 ELIZABETH A. NEVILLE TOWN HALL, 53095 MAIN ROAD TOWN CLERK P.O. BOX 1179 REGISTRAR OF VITAL STATISTICS SOUTHOLD NY 11971 MARRIAGE OFFICER FAX. 631-765.6145 RECORDS MANAGEMENT OFFICER TELEPHONE: 631-765-1800 FREEDOM OF INFORMATION OFFICER southoldtown.northfork.net i~ OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC ACCESS TO RECORDS INSTRUCTIONS: Please complete section I of this form and give to Town Clerk's Office (agency Freedom of Information Officer). One copy will be returned to you in response to your request, or as an interim response. SECTIONL ~~e45e a'I rp /k14*4/dl,4e4 Nov. Iettoil~4or *AeP.rt..eK7fr~3o¢'(;c~cZt TO:Kjo cAj T-ras+ve$ bM ~9)In$IA~~ Ctl~ ~~n: ~'GnNUn P04 d SvePrv]r (Department or officerlif , known, tha as the i form n you are questing . RECORD YOU WISH TO INSPECT: (Describe the record sought It possi'blc, supply rises, IN6 title, tax map number,` and any other pertinent information). PICAS- r b" ICASe See lP-&Y [Jaen W" I® Zell 6S Mr J rezr,l e ' P-.QSrI„ 4~- 7 4Lt o V-la ties / ©r. e?N~ J IQ ( rl c o t cern~_O r'Ja e rOck/ AW01 R/ Wr Signature of Applicant: F==Sr- J Printed Namc: 6-9-1c- Address: ~l~'1F1L--SeC ~e er iF H~to ~tl r~y -~cg~ec icy R rnCUer 170--Jx ka"We A~ V:"Oa e LatNQ ~iekltlo / Mailing Address (if different from above): P 0. 3t))t S x'71 t7_ arti l~,o SltoreS ~L3?tzsZ Telephone Number: 3 0 - GO ~ L f p8 Date: ?"JO V • lo o i l I - t [ ] APPROVED [ ) DENIED* [ ] APPROVED WITH DELAY* Liza h A. Neville Date RECEIVED Freedom of Information Officer Hand cant' to department? Accepting Clerk's Initials _ Yes No Applicant's initials *If delayed or denied, see reverse side for explanation N ] 4 pUp Southold Town Cleft Eric Rawson Bredemeyer Freedom of Information P.O. BOX 522710 Act Request Marathon Shores, FL 33052 November 10, 2011 Please consider this Memo-Letter as R Inserted in its entirety in the attached Application for Pablie Records Form signed/dated November 10, 2011, sent to the Town Clerk (Certified Mail No: 7009 /650000/ SS// 3510 Dear Sirs: RE: PROPERTY AT 2440 Village Lane, Orient, Suffolk County, NY 11957 in the matter of a private dock/catwalk/wharf Please consider this as my Freedom of Information Act Request for public records (or such other named statute, act, authority or regulation requiring the provision of public records) retained by the Town of Southold, its officials, departments and staff. For each numbered Item below I have provided the Town's departments where the records are more likely to be located merely to assist you, but not to limit your search/provision of information. Please also be advised some of these requested items may be electronically available/or able to be scanned/e-mailed or copied to a CD/DVD. Such means will keep any costs for photocopying, postage and handling to a minimum. 1 am willing to provide you a blank CD/DVD to facilitate same, too, if that assists you in complying with this Request. I am willing to pay the duly authorized costs for providing this requested information, if I am not eligible for it on a no cost or reduced cost basis. However, if the charge for these records will exceed thirty-five dollars ($35.00),l expressly request in advance of me agreeing to pay above $35.00, a written communication to me detailing the charges and the pages/information to be provided with such specificity for me to understand the cost and the item to be provided (e.g. a large drawing that is not electronically available but could only be reproduced by special photographic process might be prohibitively expensive for the information contained thereon); and so I might better focus my Request to the nature of the -information. Equally, some agencies and offices utilize official copying services. If this is the situation with the Town of Southold's records, please advise me of this situation so that I may have proper dialog with them to reduce the costs and optimize the provision. Thanking you in advance for this courtesy. Please note that I am also sending you/others at Southold Town another and different Freedom of Information reauest concerning the same subiect property, but for a different matter. Preliminary Observation/Comments: My parents now both in their late 80's have relegated much of their affairs to their two sons, John M. Bredemeyer III, and Eric R. Bredemeyer, the undersigned applicant on this request. Both of my parents have lived continuously on Village Lane, Orient, NY, as immediate and contiguous neighbors to the subject property for nearly 50 years. My brother and I both grew up on Village Lane, as you may know. Due to my brother's position with the Southold Town Trustees and his and their requirements, he recused himself in certain matters as they may relate to my "parent's home" as it adjoins the subject property. (Please see, as if attached here, the Notice of recusal on file with the President of the Southold Town Trustees.] Accordingly, that is why I am the one making this request. It may take just a little more energy for me to be the applicant here than were my brother to be the applicant, but I am sure that someday, when and if we are as fortunate to be elderly, that we can hope that our sons and daughters are there to help each of us, and that those officials so tasked with helping the public are not only there to be sure to protect the public and the appearances of officials before the public, but that the officials are also there to assist the needs of our most fragile citizens. For surely, this request is on behalf of my family. continued on next Z pages 1~Page Eric Rawson Bredemeyer Freedom of Information P.O. BOX 522710 Act Request Marathon Shores, FL 33052 November 10, 2011 GENERAL CONDITIONS (FOR ALL INFORMATION REQUESTED) a. In your provision of requested information, all items below requested, are to include and not be limited to any information whether it is handwritten, typewritten, on any message pad, on any sheet of paper, on the inside or outside of flaps of any file folder related to the information, on any . electronic or magnetic storage media, in any e-mails, on any CD and DVD, in any electronic folder and file, of any drawings or schematics, of any surveys, receipts for submissions, phone messages jotted down, of any photographs, graphs, official forms, applications, denials, receipts for payments/waiver of payments documented, outlines, powerpoints, log/diary entries, calendars, notices, archived minutes of meetings referenced or relied upon in the matter for which information is requested, computerized materials; and any other item of information type or manner of recordation/memorialization not herein described that could be considered to be in furtherance of full disclosure as required by law and practice. In the absence of any additional more descriptive qualifier, these public records are those of Southold Town, its Departments, Officials and staffs. If for any reason an item that I have requested Is not to be made available, the applicant expressly requests that the specific item withheld be adequately described so as to identify the item properly by the Town of Southold and that the official so withholding the item also clearly describes why each such item, if more than one, is being withheld and the means/requirements, if any, to appeal such withholding. If there are any time limits placed upon the applicant in an appeal, or a request for clarification by the Town, the undersigned respectfully requests an additional 15 days on to any automatic time limit due to the distances involved since the recusal situation of John M. Bredemeyer III is for the benefit of Town of Southold; and means that there is no orient Area trustee available to the undersigned to fully husband the matters more expeditiously. Furthermore, any withheld information should be preserved, and not altered to the greatest degree possible/feasible, and not discarded/destroyed/ relinquished to others during the pendency of any appeal and ongoing investigation without advance and meaningful/actionable notice to the undersigned applicant. b. If there is no information to be provided me because there Is none (i.e. none available and none being withheld), a response in the negative, by the authority at your office(s) to make such a determination, as to there being no information is respectfully requested as to each and every such item for which there is negative response. c. If there Is to be any delay in providing any requested information, a timeline for the provision is respectfully requested by the authority at your office permitted to make such a delay, if anyone/any. INFORMATION REQUESTED 1. Copies of any currently valid Permit(s) granted by the Southold Town Trustees under Chapter 275 (Wetlands) and Chapter 111 (Coastal Erosion Hazard Areas) for a private dock/ catwalk/ wharf at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY, SUM (Suffolk County Tax Map, District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1; or predecessor lot designations, including but not limited to, District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lots 16 and 17, as lot number(s) may have changed overtime). Be sure to also provide all supporting types of information as per the General Conditions provided above by me for this Item 1 request. a. Likely Departments: Electronic: "Municity", Trustees and Bay Constable. 2. Copies of any currently valid other Southold Town prior authorization(s), grant(s) of approval, and any change orders directed to or for such authorizations concerning a private dock/catwalk/wharf at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY, SCTM (Suffolk County Tax Map, District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1; or predecessor lot designations, including but not 2~Page Eric Rawson Bredemeyer Freedom of Information P.O. BOX 522710 Act Request Marathon Shores, FL 33052 November 10, 2011 limited to, District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lots 16 and 17, as lot number(s) may have changed over time). Be sure to also provide all supporting types of information as per the General Conditions provided above by me for this Item 2 request. a. Likely Departments: Electronic: "Municity", Trustees and Bay Constable,. 3. Copies of any violation(s), citation(s), and stop work order(s) for the property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY, SUM (Suffolk County Tax Map, District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1; or predecessor lot designations, including but not limited to, District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lots 16 and 17, as lot number(s) may have changed over time) issued during the last 15 months immediately prior to the date of this Request in relation to a dock/catwalk/wharf/wharf barricade-fencing, and any and all permitted and/or unpermitted work. Be sure to also provide ail supporting types of information as per the General Conditions provided above by me for this Item 3 request. a. Likely Departments: Electronic: "Municity", Trustees and Bay Constable. 4. Copies of any currently filed applications for Permit(s) to be granted by the Southold Town Trustees under Chapter 275 (Wetlands) and Chapter 111(Coastal Erosion Hazard Area) for a private dock/catwalk/wharf at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, NY, SUM (Suffolk County Tax Map, District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lot 17.1; or predecessor lot designations, including but not limited to, District 1000, Page 26, Block 1, Lots 16 and 17, as lot number(s) may have changed over time), including but not limited to, any and all of the application's supporting materials, surveys, test reports, diagrams, photos, insurance documentation (of the contractor, builder, owner, land and workers), maps, engineering/architectural reports. Be sure to also provide all supporting types of information as per the General Conditions provided by me for this Item 4 request. a. Likely Departments: Electronic: "Municity", Trustees, Bay Constable and CAC. 5. Copies of any applications and supporting materials as in Items 3 and 4 immediately above, however, where the applications and/or related matter(s) have been tabled, withdrawn and/or otherwise suspended where the Town, its officials, staff and/or agents has/have not returned the materials to the applicant or the applicant's agent. If there has been such a return and there are any records no longer in the Town's possession, but known to have been in the Town's/Official's possession, then a copy of any and all receipts or correspondence for the records so returned is requested including the information identifying the recipient and the sending official. Be sure to also provide all supporting types of information as per the General Conditions for this Item 5 request. a. Likely Departments: Electronic: "Municity", Trustees, Bay Constable, Building, Zoning, Planning, Town Board and Town Supervisor. Thanking you in advance for your assistance and cooperation. If sending anything by e-mail, please call me at 305.609.7488 so that I may provide you the appropriate electronic address and be sure as to the compatibility(s) and sizes of the communication. Or, send to me at the below address. Very truly yours, =>11 ERIC R. BREDEMEYER, as trustee, and on behalf of the J. & J. Bredemeyer Family Trust C/O Eric R. Bredemeyer P.O. Box 522710, Marathon Shores, FL 33052 31 Page Town of Southold A '2267 Suffolk County, NY The People of the Slate of New York vs. LAST NA (DEFENDANT) FIflST ME MIDDLE INITIAL R/ STis/ SFi? ADDRESS F NO S'hy' .PlT~J / STATE UCENSE OR REGISTRATION NUMBER 4 a OPERATOR STATE TYPE OF LICENSE GATE EXPIRES SEX MPH DAM OF BIRTH OYES ONO OWNS VEHICLE THE OPERATOR OR REGISTERED ONNER OF VEHICLE DESCRIBED BELOW PLATE NO. OATS EXPIRES STATE PLATE TYPE ? N.T. ? NJ. ? N.Y. O N.J. ? ? PASS ? COMM ? VEHICLE MAKE ? DODGE ? BUICK ? CHEV ? LAO ? PONDAC ? FORD ? OJ]$ PLYM ? TOYOTA ? YOLKS ? BOOT ? 2D ? ADR ? BUS ? MCY ? S.W. TYPE RUCK ? TRAIIB. ? VAN ? VIN NUMB THE PERSON DESCRIBED ABOVE IS CHARGED AS FOLLOWS PLACE OF OCCURRENCE/ T PCT 140 DATE OF DFF£NS A TIME PM 4CItt,TW`~4~WLIA~GE~.OR IµNLET SUFFpD(CIX.wTV Nv IN VIOLATION OF SECTION SUB.. OF THE ? VEHICLE AND TRAFFIC LAW OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK BETHER (SPECIFY) ? O.S. ? COM ? BUS ? HAZ / G ' i~ DEF YEH AT ? SPEEDING OTHER OFFENSE MP11NA MPH ZONE MISDEMEANOR ? FACTUAL PART (NOT FOR TVB) THE ABOVE NAMED DEFEND NT DID ON THE STATED DATE. TIME AND PLACE ~ !fit ->`i~ i4 a P~ Tle FOrt2olrq-9 Nape~on/jP o~ulxMwhESS)s^Jro~1iMO~,na4on6NlieR, pl¢¢purc. Nirp W.Naclrea swam eG/vyF n(ela Y~Q CY F~ L/~p~~ deal 1,1z; 17 PARKING SCHEDULED En CONTACTCOURT? THE PERSON DESCRIBED ABOVE 15 SUMMONED TO APPEAR AT SOUTHOLD TOWN JUSTICE COURT, 5008, ROUTE 25, SOUTHOW, NY 11971 p.j OAiE OFA P[OPANCEINCi FgiTAI I AT AMQyI CD FALSE STATEMENTS HEREIN ARE PUNISHABLE AS A CUSS A MISOEMEANCP PURSUANT TOn ECRUN 210 L5 OF TILE P.LN Y.S. COMPLAINANT DATE - 'BADGE~r1y~ COURT COPY John & Sarah Henry 2440 Village Lane, Orient SCTM# 26-1-17.1 6/1312012 Ill MW > J - Jrr - nib.. ..r~r Y - _ ~ - _ - ..3.4°.3'^• - -+anTM r i ,s... 'l.. ~ 41 A v . a' ELL . P MST. • ,.:X^ : `"i'~ ~ r' • • JOHN AND SARAH HENRY, 2440 VILLAGE LANE, ORIENT T- ai-A .s ,Y} r Navy 6+ ' * ~ ~,a A s ~X. rte} 1' Figure I. Aerial view of existing dock. Photo by Microsoft Corporation. J 1 d Jill Figure 2. Looking west from beach toward Orient Harbor over existing dock. 1319 North Sea Road Southampton, New York 11968 sulta 3-6136 A-CONSULTANTS 631-283.6360 ENFax: n631- www.encosultants.com ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING May 17, 2012 Town of Southold Board of Trustees 54375 Main Road post office Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Attn.: Lauren Standish Re: John & Sarah Henry 2440 Village Lane, Orient SCTM #1000-26-1-17.1 Dear Ms. Standish: Please include the enclosed photographs to the above referenced application package. Thank you for your attention to this matter. Sin a ely, C K in S ephen Enc. pgUffQ(~ Jill M. Doherty, President O~ CD P.O. Box 1179 Bob Ghosio, Jr., Vice-President a Gyp Southold, NY 11971 James F. King ti Telephone (631 765-1892 Dave Bergen ,y T Fax(631)765-6641 John Bredemeyer p Southold Town Board of Trustees Field Inspection/Worksession Report Date/Time: 10-1(- 1/ Inspect the property of JOHN HENRY for a possible wetland code violation - extensive renovation and repair of existing "un-permitted" docking facility. Located: 2440 Village Lane, Orient. SCTM#26-1-17.1 Type .of area to be impacted: altwater Wetland -Freshwater Wetland -Sound /Bay Distance of proposed work to edge of wetland art~~ under: PI Town Codeg~pproposed work falls 2apt.275 VChapt. 11111 -other Type of Application: riWetland -Coastal Erosion -Amendment -Administrative-Emergency Pre-Submission Violation Info needed: n~~~~s 7 Modifications: Conditions: Present Were: F! J. Doherty l/B. Ghosio I/ j. King D. Bergen, J. Bredemeyer D. Dzenkowski other Form filled out in the field by Mailed/Faxed to: Date: + s r s J Ir ~ 'I ~ 7 f t+ f r, ~ ~p ~ Fs ~ ~ .r`: t r m P% Y C L C' I- \ I 1 f ;,3at Id ji 1 ; 1 ~~r dx~ r No R t i ? ~i "C~>' rat ,r 0 I ~.eax.~ '1~~i~ ` , •'111 ~ _,A~rv:. _ I`I ; ~ 4 F ° '`fit :;ill: 5 • ,'>e ~ ' , ~„r S . •rL. J'.,; 4r 1 Y in _ Jr_wm e ~S r w "how ,Ey . ~M~ t S r 't nu- i q s x ~ ~ - F ~ :ate r ; + ~ (f ti ~ k~j r a RM s ` L+s ' t r Y F ohn Henry -2440 Village Lane, Orient :iSCTM# 26-1-17.1 10/12/2011 -Mir noun r t , j _ PI Ne r # 4 _ =N... 41 6 XMMWANIAL v - 2 ,•'K rA 14 - S• • _ To: Southold Trustee President, Jill Doherty From: Trustee, John Bredemeyer, Trustee specializing in the Orient/East Marion area Subject: Request for Board review of activities at 2440 Village Lane, Orient & including Trustee Bredemeyer recusa Date: October 10, 2011 While this Trustee has received several requests from area residents inquiring how to proceed in the aftermath of tropical storm, Irene, activities within the coastal and wetlands zone at the subject property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, including but not limited to possible repair and new construction on a residential dock there, have taken place since, Irene, with no known contact with the Trustee Office or the area Trustee, myself. Within the last year, the Town Bay Constable and Code Enforcement Officer intervened on the subject parcel in a separate matter, status undetermined. Consequently, on October 4, 2011,1 requested that the Trustee Office place the subject property on the docket for Trustee monthly inspections for October. Since the subject property adjoins 2660 Village lane, the property of the J & J Family Trust (where my nearly 90 year old parents have owned property and/or resided in excess of 46 years) for which I am a Co-Trustee of that Trust (as disclosed in my Town ethics filing), I must recuse myself from all Board of Trustee discussion, review and determination(s) that might follow from this request, reserving a right of impeachment. To not delay the Trustees field inspection in my absence, I have contacted my co-Trustee in the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust, my brother, Eric Bredemeyer, and he has authorized me to communicate to the Board a right of access over the property of the J & J Family Trust property at 2660 Village Lane, Orient to enable the Trustees to perform their duties in the pending survey and review on or about October 12, 2011. Because of the age and infirmity of the Bredemeyer parents and owing to the uniqueness of this situation, Co- Trustee, Eric Bredemeyer requests that an additional official copy of any copy(s)and or notice(s) that would ordinarily be distributed in such a matter, be sent to him at the following address, for which he is willing to reimburse the Town regular postage costs. If this request is not possible, he respectfully requests that he be so notified in writing of the declination. Eric R. Bredemeyer P.O. Box 522710 Marathon Shores, Florida 33052 As this communication contains issues that may be both legal and ethical, Trustee President, Doherty may want to provide copies of this memo to the appropriate Town officials. I am sending an advance copy of this memo via email to those Trustees who get email service. Thank you all for your understanding and assistance in this matter, - - Trustee, - John Bredemeyer fill CC: Eric Bredemeyer, co-Trustee, P.O. Box 522710, Marathon Shores, Florida 33052 Trustee, James King (b/c no email service) - ti .1 / E W. G h w~+n~w n }j ~ v:tee J ~ii/rM I ` 3 rT It 4 j eah1011 Q V , f U OwAwn a' Sr^:wn 7204 d/M Unr Ywk Btr!le 2 O ~ Educa4a4 Left 1 000"Cims"mwretP bowhil the lard Baal a DBmGre4dtnteeoOF ~ . w1=01ea sted=to s': he. onN m tle Peraentor mrV M n N Dresard. err4 err hN heheM m M~ < twr caroerq.4orwnmentelaeena~nntl wJ:157~I0'W. TSQp Nndm4 imgm4mrJthe Nhe a"u' to :hR auagnxa d nairq 1, W; M. Guarantees M rm tranefembta w auaitimal irrtltud" a "ber'tua.a (o • C. L% Ur rYr ,7 n owns t ' _MAp OF' ~'ROritR7'Y N suRV~YE'o g 70 W/V OF rCDUTN060 I i av,7r,w7 teed 10 I 7/.Va' lrr~s:rrifr.C.C c: 0. ~Ild, D U U Hb r ra n:~lf l.Q..± &falrr , 641Ca~YJrtH. Su old COVnt u 3 .Stlr'VPa'rltdr .Sa ZT lBS. NOV - 31%9 ~aaUE43C YAtit J tK., f? C. ~ooo-ze-t_r . aNritxd~7/2~Id L rerranr.~Lpe%S~?I~ywd 'A• versmn,4 } n 1 1. all Inquiry, ' J l mquiFyj File Edit View Toolbar Window Help ik- 26 -T -179F4 5 7 x w1t - f to R p w f H4:fky John ~i 2011 ~t~ i ~t ~ r 41f vW 7 Iz,~,rlr ~ ~~i zt 2440 CIS L! a v rn r E a i7 x ti h i w'f.~~ § ra t('su., ~f 5L *'z'~ ,st >i s „ x , t~ 'r- ~ ! -x x atr.m z 3 t i r d d r s_~ >vR vC~- 'R a a ~+>~3S' re 9`~:R`4v°t S fin,, t tv„~{z" i I IE.z{{° r tSV, doe i z a gi t+ r't a - f (7 A83088t1UmKIEr ' ree ST4 411 NEnt , y ' n + . D D@6~C[g7HOdt : hx a a ! 'S ~ iv, ha.. n s a xt N ~'QwR8t8 'i i. S a aIFP ' "Lt di P{~, Tr rt ~I {i s , s ai~`3'#, ?a~~'+$dv,34atii+>? c~-•.I= ~~+iESaa n ~E k i;i { ( 3§ 9hs 6 c9: t L S i i L.1 { s1e . Y tl i'"'a`( y,µ y~ NAP ! s' 1 'sit, __C.~~I ]yy~c v¢41Yb111C/f-. ~rF S VIM N4i}j~i f 5~~~,~„~ 't'a"rb' R r iH I tT! Tff t I' Ko Lj Jft6t Flow r} R 1 ii i I Y ~ d, : yR~9 t!t~9d~x~~~r~°RTt ^lfj4'+s~3+ V,6$ tint,{.. Gx~~t if a r ~(~{t, ~,b - i i ~ , I ' 3 14 ~ l 9m~wlvit~i st^'mrj* ~ ki + ~ ( 1.:3~ i. Ilk! ~k~~i~Ec 23~d c v ' jai r4 , 4FR4liW P ~.'Y71 9 i451t56 i ' _ i I' ! M Tie'1 w taIS.~,:sty as ,.rh~^ -A P a x ; i 1 ` ! xa& a ( o-s >a ry r.r 4rv xr PA6~.' I I PP I.a ~r c di- Next lk r + r = I I I i 5 Uzi 4 ( o enl'e({' xl~ - ' , ~''*i } tdi^4q i I 'ii•$ l R rs p. r tfl , IS, R s, , ' r ae ~i' i&i i 7 :1 'N K~', J11 i i tltt! 1Ea "Nsi 'N { s 7 { xt 1lx roi'i'~{,y a z , . ii"a`rIV`xt" rY' s` YF r t kv at 'S i v+ i ita4t I A P. r r s { e 6 a t t f~sti drr,as. e{. , 1 s t f ss: rv~'t~ r~k~3 s( ,r t ~~~ISi sf"~ rR t~ ~ , R` vf< P ~'rk•.,w s r' i~ i ! tam i k a C'* 5R zn-m -1, , I i r~' 7d'R -t (~a''y f1 a ~rt'SV 'yi.,ib5 r21ts3 Om v r r c+ 7 x. r a ,=n, Ff fsy, ; a'! v "2 d'i" w I i Sr s ~rE s+ ( ( 51( ,r ! " i s 1 trn+sri 4, 'Y i t 2t4 Y S 14 ( ~ µ s + q Y' Y f P (i ~I 3 ~ ~ t 1'~}~~ aC t ItI i4lk t [ it it ( 7 iI i : : ! 5c f 5 l j i A ~t~ ii ~f s R~ F ~ J im 9 S r e 4, RX L iz ; t i r t ~ - x s 3 v, I a 'E-h W w a a v t x is t:e _ q i eFa I tY , 4 Ito- s{yt s t! ~i I {r ~ ~ t d V' Rt"t .-r !I a` ~ #J. 9 ~ 4v 6~~ J :I ~ & HS~u i , L ! a n a R";r k'N+,* a 8 r**~ 6.,,"i v tiu ! xz r'v'v' ay , : r asv. ( a {n3 ,0010 y~s7 a ~daQ iz~t t +'G2} S {tf„ !J I CS L 'hivt~L-R { V4 . < ° :lr{ ! i a Ama1^h try~,:Ieir'v tI . ss.:aa'v i asks } ° 3x -,a Ir a M", M _,r : rcda ~s@n~ar:.,...atS, Ready start Inbox - Microsoft Out... RP-1 Verson 4 - [OkIm To: Southold Trustee President, Jill Doherty From: Trustee, John Bredemeyer, Trustee specializing in the Orient/East Marion area Subject: Request for Board review of activities at 2440 Village Lane, Orient & including Trustee Bredemeyer recusa Date: October 10, 2011 While this Trustee has received several requests from area residents inquiring how to proceed in the aftermath of tropical storm, Irene, activities within the coastal and wetlands zone at the subject property at 2440 Village Lane, Orient, including but not limited to possible repair and new construction on a residential dock there, have taken place since, Irene, with no known contact with the Trustee Office or the area Trustee, myself. Within the last year, the Town Bay Constable and Code Enforcement Officer intervened on the subject parcel in a separate matter, status undetermined. Consequently, on October 4, 2011, I requested that the Trustee Office place the subject property on the docket for Trustee monthly inspections for October. Since the subject property adjoins 2660 Village lane, the property of the J & J Family Trust (where my nearly 90 year old parents have owned property and/or resided in excess of 46 years) for which I am a Co-Trustee of that Trust (as disclosed in my Town ethics filing), I must recuse myself from all Board of Trustee discussion, review and determination(s) that might follow from this request, reserving a right of impeachment. To not delay the Trustees field inspection in my absence, I have contacted my co-Trustee in the J & J Bredemeyer Family Trust, my brother, Eric Bredemeyer, and he has authorized me to communicate to the Board a right of access over the property of the J & J Family Trust property at 2660 Village Lane, Orient to enable the Trustees to perform their duties in the pending survey and review on or about October 12, 2011. Because of the age and infirmity of the Bredemeyer parents and owing to the uniqueness of this situation, Co- Trustee, Eric Bredemeyer requests that an additional official copy of any copy(s)and or notice(s) that would ordinarily be distributed in such a matter, be sent to him at the following address, for which he is willing to reimburse the Town regular postage costs. If this request is not possible; he.respectfully requests that he be so notified in writing of the declination. Eric R. Bredemeyer , G 1 5 Lo P.O. Box 522710 Marathon Shores, Florida 33052 As this communication contains issues that may be both legal and ethical, Trustee President, Doherty may want to provide copies of this memo to the appropriate Town officials. I am sending an advance copy of this memo via email to those Trustees who get email service. Thank you all for your understanding and assistance in this matter, T~tee-,- 0~7 hn Bre e~3 m y r~/' V+ O CC: Eric Bredemeyer, co-Trustee, P.O. Box 522710, Marathon Shores, Florida 33052 Trustee, James King (b/c no email service) pF SOplyo OFFICE LOCATION: MAILING ADDRESS: Town Hall Annex P.O. Box 1179 54375 State Route 25 Southold, NY 11971 (cor. Main Rd. & Youngs Ave.) n Q ell Southold, NY 11971 Telephone: 631 765-1938 Cow Fax: 631 765-3136 LOCAL WATERFRONT REVITALIZATION PROGRAM TOWN OF SOUTHOLD MEMORANDUM D en ' To: John Bredemeyer, President FEB 1 8 2014 Town of Southold Board of Trustees _ J,iuJ:wJ CRiI - From: Mark Terry, Principal Planner Trusten LWRP Coordinator Date: February 14, 2014 Re: Local Waterfront Revitalization Program Coastal Consistency Review for JOHN & SARAH HENRY SCTM# 1000-26-1-17.1 A Grandfathered Permit (4410) was issued in 1995 for a 100' long dock and 45' "L" shape dock. The existing dock does not conform to the permit. En-Consultants on behalf of JOHN & SARAH HENRY requests a Wetland Permit for the existing fixed "J" shaped pier that consists of an 8'x152' shore-perpendicular section, and 10'x36' and 10'x17' shore- parallel sections; as-built repairs consisting of the installation new 2"x10" untreated decking and the replacement of inside pilings, caps and stringers; and proposed repairs consisting of the installation of additional 2"x10" untreated decking and replacement of additional 10" inside pilings, Tx6" caps and outside stringers, and 4"xT inside stringers. Located: 2440 Village Lane, Orient. SCTM# 26-1-17.1 The application states in the narrative submitted with the CAF dated 1/16/14 that the proposed action is "normal maintenance" and therefore Exempt from LWRP CCR. The dock is not in conformance with the Board of Trustees Grandfather Permit and therefore the action cannot be exempted from review. The permit was issued for a dock length of 100', the current dock length is 152'. The "L" section of the dock was permitted at 45', the current length is 53'. The proposed action has been reviewed to Chapter 268, Waterfront Consistency Review of the Town of Southold Town Code and the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP) Policy Standards. Based upon the information provided on the LWRP Consistency Assessment Form submitted to this department, as well as the records available to me, it is my determination that the proposed actions are INCONSISTENT with the below listed LWRP policy and therefore are INCONSISTENT with the LWRP: 6.3 Protect and restore tidal and freshwater wetlands. A. Comply with statutory and regulatory requirements of the Southold Town Board of Trustees laws and regulations for all Andros Patent and other lands under their jurisdiction • 1. Comply with Trustee regulations and recommendations as set forth in Trustee permit conditions. Town records indicate that the structure was constructed (in its existing configuration) without the benefit of review of the Board of Trustees. x' Il Board Of Southold Town Trustees L~ SOUTHOLD, NEW YORK PERMIT NO, 4 4 I. Q.. DATE: 2128195 ISSUED TO. .,....GERALD_D' :DQ&NAN. . ; ,~utlEar~~atiun Pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 615 of fhe Laws of the State of New York, 1893: and Chapter 404 of the Laws of this State of New York 1982; and the Southold Town Ordinance saw _ Ydlad "REGULATING AND THE PLACING OF OBSTRUCTIONS IN. AND ON TOWN WATERS AND PUBLIC LANDS and fb REMOVAL OF SAND, GRAVEL OR OTHER MATERLALS FROM LANDS UNDER TOWN WATERS;" and in accordance with flat Resolution of The Board adopted at a meeting hold on . 212at 95- 19 .95..,. and In consideration of the sum of 1,00.00 paid by ..GERALD. D....DORMAN.._ r s of _ -Orient. N. Y. and subject to the Terms and Conditions Ssted on the reverse side hereof, of Southold Town Trustees authorizes and permih the following: Grandfather Permit for an 8' X 100' a "La shape 81 X 451 existing dock. Orient Harbor all in accordance with the detailed spacifioations as presented in the orig " ing appYwaron. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The said Board of Trustees here- by causes its Corporate Seal to be affixed, and theca prawat$ to be subscribed by a majority of the said Board as of ibis dab. rrrwrer Figure 1. Grandfather Permit X w , m nti• 4 ~ q"".: Ali ? A 0 4 _ u c '`i` r.:n vv n rn. c6r :1 MAP Or FXfO R 0n 1 F.ua.+• NMe Tipr GwivrKM ( aunvaven rwrcaywy..is/x. MvlARrk Bwl. ' p GERALD DALE DORMAN nr wd Fw1C pnyrsa ~Lw.r;yep a.»a: +o t,' OR/ENTRKnr ynY/*'•T°^ •n.nwwnvnf TOWN Or 54VT»OLO ' $VFfO[n CpMTYN.Y. L.ve:xeALi?.Rrwyw+. A Figure 2. Parcel showing permitted dock. T The dock is located in the Coastal Erosion Hazard Area (CEHA), however, aerial photos indicate that the dock was constructed prior to enactment of the regulations and is not required to meet square footage requirements. A CEHA permit is not on record. ra _ Figure 3. Dock shown on a 1962 Aerial. Note that the dock is located 8' from the southern property boundary. Pursuant to Chapter 268, the Board of Trustees shall consider this recommendation in preparing its written determination regarding the consistency of the proposed actions. Cc: Lori Hulse, Assistant Town Attorney ~o~SUFFD(,P~Q Peter Young, Chairman Town Hall, 53095 Main Rd. Lauren Standish, Secretary G P.O. Box 1179 ? 'F Southold, NY 11971 Telephone (631) 765-1892 Fax(631)765-6641 Conservation Advisory Council Town of Southold At the meeting of the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council held Wed., February 12, 2014 the following recommendation was made: Moved by Doug Hardy, seconded by Jack McGreevy, it was RESOLVED to SUPPORT the application of JOHN & SARAH HENRY to perform ordinary and usual maintenance activities on an existing "J" shaped pier, which pre-dated 1955 and consists of an 8'X 152' shore-perpendicular section and 10'X 36' and 10'X 17' shore- parallel sections, including as-built repairs following Hurricane Irene, including installation of a new 2"X 10" untreated decking and replacement of storm damaged inside pilings, caps and stringers; and proposed repairs of additional storm damage caused by Hurricane Sandy, including installation of additional 2"X 10" untreated decking and replacement of additional 10" inside pilings, 6"X 6" caps and outside stringers, and 4"X 6" inside stringers. Located: 2440 Village Lane, Orient. SCTM#26-1-17.1 Inspected by: Jack McGreevy, Peter Young, Peter Meeker, Doug Hardy The CAC Supports the application, however, provisions should be made for lateral access. Vote of Council: Ayes: All Motion Carried ~F/v EN-CONSULTANTS February 5, 2014 Elizabeth Cantrell Office of the Board of Trustees ee A Town of Southold G ' D P.O. Box 1179 R D Southold,NY 11971 LFE8 - 7 2014 Re: John Henry, 2440 Villaee Lane, Orient f; - u' pard co Dear Ms. Cantrell: As requested in your email on January 29, 2014, please find enclosed four (4) copies of a survey/site plan prepared by Nathan Taft Corwin III Land Surveyor, last dated February 4, 2014, which has been revised to include notations to indicate with more specificity the approximate area on the existing dock requiring the storm damage repairs described on the survey and also a more detailed plan view and sectional view to graphically depict the various structural components of the dock that are the subject of the proposed repairs. Respectfully yours, Robert E. Herrmann Coastal Management Specialist cc: Steve Angel, Esq. - - 1319 North Sea Road ;Southampton. New York 11968 p 631283.6360 If 631253.6136 . unr -i I i,iIt .com onv ronment.rl cnns,dr n<7 EssEKS, HEFTER & ANGEL, LLP COUNSELORS AT LAW 106 EAST MAIN STREET STEPHEN R. ANGEL P. 0. Box 279 WILLIAM W. ESSEKS CARMELA M. DI TALIA RIVERHEAD, N.Y. 11901-0279 RETIRED ANTHONY C. PASCA EAST HAMPTON OFFICE THEODORE D. SKLAR PHONE: (631) 369-1700 PYANPOINTMENT) FAX: (631) 369-2065 34 PANTIGO ROAD NANCY SILVERMAN EAST HAMPTON, NY 11937 LISA J. Ross WWW.EHALAW.COM PATRICIA M. CARROLL JASON S. SELMONT KEVIN A. McGowIN D MARCIA Z. HEFTER SENIOR COUNSEL D WILLIAM POWER MALONEY JAN 1 5 2014 OF COUNSEL January 14, 2014 r T V, Board of Trustees, Town of Southold 54375 Main Road P. O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Re: Application for Town Wetlands Permit with Town of Southold Trustees for John and Sarah Henry 2440 Village Lane, Orient, New York filed May 17, 2012 by Robert E. Herrmann, Agent-Signatory for En-Consultants Gentlemen: We are the attorneys for John and Sarah Henry. The Henrys are also represented by Robert E. Herrmann of En-Consultants. I enclose the following in support of an application for a wetlands permit filed by En- Consultants for the Henrys in May 2012: 1. check of En-Consultants to the Town of Southold in the sum of $500.00; 2. letter from Robert E. Herrmann of En-Consultants dated December 30, 2013 to James King, then Chairman of the Board of Trustees, together with attachments; 3. five prints of a survey by Nathan T. Corwin last dated November 1, 2013. Please place this application on the agenda for the February 19, 2014 meeting. Please be advised that En-Consultants will be handling the notification of the adjacent and opposite neighbors and posting of the property. Also, I respectfully request that Mr. Bredemeyer recuse himself from considering this application. The basis for this request is as follows: (00500377) ESSEKS, HEFTER & ANGEL, LLP COUNSELORS AT LAW 1. I understand that Mr. Bredemeyer his brother Eric R. Bredemeyer, are Trustees of the J&J Bredemeyer Family Trust which owns the property immediately to the south of the Henrys parcel; and 2. acting on behalf of the J&J Bredemeyer Family Trust, Eric R. Bredemeyer has taken a position against our clients in connection with the dock which is the subject of this application. In conclusion, please confirm that the matter is on the February I Vh agenda and also confirm that Mr. Bredemeyer will recuse himself from this application. Resp tfully yours, SRA:mw ephen . Angel Enc. cc: John and Sarah Henry - Via e-mail Robert E. Herrmann at En-Consultants - Via e-mail )00500377) ,FA/ EN-CONSULTANTS December 30, 2013 James Kin Chairman Board of Trustees Town of Southold P.O. Box 1179 JAN 1 5 2014 Southold, NY 11971 Re: John and Sarah Henry, 2440 VillaEe Lane, Orient SouG oi0 cnn L__ Tru Dear Mr. King: As you are aware, in May 2012, I submitted an application for a Wetlands Permit pursuant to Chapter 275 of the Southold Town Code to permit a legally preexisting dock that has existed on the subject property since at least the 1950s, as evidenced by historic aerial photographs readily available online. That application was submitted as a result of a violation issued to Mr. Henry for dock repairs that were made to the "unpermitted" structure after it suffered storm damage during Tropical Storm Irene in August 2011. After submitting the application, however, I was advised by your office that because the dock is located in a Coastal Erosion Hazard Area, we would also need to submit an application for a Coastal Erosion Management Permit and that our application for a Wetlands Permit would not be processed until such application was filed. As you are also aware, I have previously spoken with you, the Trustees, and Lori Hulse regarding my position that due to the nature of the repairs, Chapter 111 does not require issuance of a Coastal Erosion Management Permit, regardless of whether a Wetlands Permit was required or obtained. Specifically, Chapter 111 defines as a "regulated activity" the "construction, modification, or restoration or placement of a structure...," where a "restoration" is defined as the "reconstruction without modification of a structure, the cost of which equals or exceeds 50% of the estimated full replacement cost of the structure at the time of restoration." "Normal maintenance" of a structure, on the other hand, is defined by Chapter 111 as the "periodic replacement or repair of same-kind structural elements or protective coatings which do not change the size, design, or function of a functioning structure." And "normal maintenance of a structure does not require a coastal erosion management permit" pursuant to Chapter 111. Therefore, to determine whether a Coastal Erosion Management Permit is required, the Trustees must first determine whether the repair work should be characterized as a restoration (requiring a Coastal Erosion Management Permit) or normal maintenance (not requiring a Coastal Erosion Management Permit). And to make that determination pursuant to the above described definitions, the cost of the completed work and the estimated full replacement cost of the structure must be considered. However, because additional repairs to the dock were necessitated by storm damage caused by Hurricane Sandy in October 2012, the estimated costs of those needed repairs should be considered as well. To that end, I have enclosed copies of invoices from both Christensen Construction and Crowley Marine Contracting for the repairs that were completed after Tropical Storm Irene, i.e., the installation of new 2" x 10" decking and new inside pilings, caps, and stringers, the cost of which totaled $18,450. Also enclosed is an estimate from Crowley Marine Contracting for the $8,700 worth of repairs to pilings and structural timbers that were necessitated by Hurricane Sandy, bringing the total cost of the completed and needed dock repairs to $27,150. 1 have also enclosed an estimate from Crowley Marine Contracting for the full replacement cost of the dock, which totals $202,700. Thus, to be defined as a "restoration," the dock repairs would need to total at least - 1319 North Sea Road I Southampton. New York 11968 I p 631.283.6360 f 631283.6136 + one u a i9arit, com environrnr~ntal c0nsultincl • 0 $101,350 or 50% of $202,700, roughly $74,000 more than the actual cost of the repairs required by the recent storm damage. It is therefore our position that the Trustees should find that the repairs should be characterized as "normal maintenance" not requiring a Coastal Erosion Management Permit. Moreover, if it is determined that the repairs are to be characterized as "normal maintenance" not requiring a Coastal Erosion Management Permit, then the work would also be properly classified as a "minor action" pursuant to Chapter 268 of the Town Code, meaning that the repairs must also be determined to be exempt from waterfront consistency review. Specifically, minor actions defined by Section 268 include the "replacement, rehabilitation, or reconstruction of a structure or facility, in kind, on the same site (in place)... except for structures in areas designated by the Coastal Erosion Hazard Area (CEHA) law where structures may not be replaced, rehabilitated, or reconstructed without a permit." That is, so long as the work can be done without the need for a Coastal Erosion Management Permit, then the work is defined as an exempt minor action. Therefore, I am submitting herewith a site plan prepared by Nathan Taft Corwin III Land Surveyor, last dated November I, 2013, which has been revised to include notations specifying the above stated repairs and their corresponding costs along with the estimated full replacement cost of the dock. And in conjunction with this revised plan, I am respectfully requesting that the Board process our wetlands application at your next available meeting without further delay. To that end, I am enclosing a current check for $500 and ask that all previously submitted checks be returned to us, as they are now more than a year out of date. Please note that the survey has also been revised to correct an error in the angle of the southerly property line as it was previously depicted on the survey originally submitted with our application, a matter that was brought to my attention by a letter from Eric Bredemeyer, dated September 11, 2013, which was copied to you. After reviewing additional deeds and the 1978 survey of the adjacent southerly property provided by Mr. Bredemeyer, Mr. Corwin concluded that the angle of the southerly property line did indeed require correction. However, while Mr. Bredemeyer raises this concern in connection with his assertion that the corrected angle of the property line results in an encroachment by Mr. Henry's dock across the seaward projection of their mutual property line, as you are aware, the seaward projection of a property line is drawn at a right angle to the shoreline and not as a continuous seaward projection of the property line for purposes of allocating "riparian rights." Therefore, I trust you will agree that no such encroachment across the shared boundary line exists. Should the Board determine that it does not agree with our positions concerning the need for Coastal Erosion and waterfront consistency review or find that additional information is required before such a determination can be made, please let me know at your earliest convenience, as Mr. Henry would very much like to move his application forward at this point so that his repairs can be legalized and completed. Respeptfully yours, i Robes Herrmann Coastal Management Specialist cc: John Henry Stephen Angel, Esq 2 • 0 Crowley Marine Contractinrp. Bulkheading Dockbuilding Beach Stairs PO Box 618 Work 631-83it74o Greenport N.Y 1194.4 TeVFax 631-323-1772 Since 1997 icmwley@ optonline.net September 23, 2011 fI „ ~;"y {Fa ;i Pip John Henry IIuL1Jt1?{II) Village Lane Orient NY 11957 JAN 1 5 2014 SOLtlit)!G IGh(7 T Dear Johhn, I have attached the invoice for the reenforcement of the your dock. Install New inside piles caps and stringers $15,000.00 Payment... $7,500.00 Please sign and return NYS Capital Improvement form. Total amount Due. . . $7,500.00 Regards, Ian Crowley Crowley Marine Contracting Cell Phone 631-831-{74o Telephone/Fax 631-323-1772 email icrowley@optonline.net Christensen Construction Box 14 v vv 119--r lr, ~ o,~ la 631-323-2616 JAN 1 5 2014 _3 11 Jots. em-N $UUWO,O ,U*i '_4-10 Village L_=c T Orient,N.Y. 11 Dock 1.Plank 3 ; -.m tir 2X10'S. Et en tenth board to be fire v6 ith shock cords and fastened 4d nails to act as relea~ boards to relieve pressure on the dock during a storm. Labor 53450.00 i prime and coats) ex : - eum room where new -een insta h U f $ 0.00 Labor 3. Scrape,s L : -•::7< x% p on SZ ~ ndow. Not this win&,A m 7 have to e rep or SExx.00 4. Build ne,- _ ,A and 4 picket secticr•_ an nn , are. f Labor ar,' . _-als [5 sections a $300.0") ea: $ O-W T $6150.0 Pie`c -1 _ check payable to Robe Christensen Than' ~ Crowley Marine Contracting cnrp. Bulkheading Dockbuilding Beach Stairs PO Box 618 Work 631-831-1740 GreenportN.Y 11944 TeVFax 631-323-1772 Since 1997 icrowley@optonline.net SSA ~,P June 11, 2013 D Illl till John Henry JAN 15 2014 Village Lane Orient N.Y 11957 5056'v..rv . r f Tru Dear John, Please accept the following proposal for the repair ofyour dock on Orient Harbor. The dock will consist of the following: 10" butt inside piles (2 per bent) 6 "x6" CCA caps and outside stringers 4"x6" CCA inside stringers 2 "x10 Fir decking fastened with 30d HDG nails Total amount to replace piling and repair timbers as needed. . . $83,700.00 The project as proposed will require permits from NYSDEC, ACOE, and Town of Southold Trustees. We can acquire these permits on your behalf or work with a consultant of your choice. Terms: $1, 000 upon signing 50% upon commencement balance due upon completion If this proposal and its terms meets your approval please sign and date on the line provided. Agreed: John Henry June 11, 2013 Thank you for the opportunity to provide this quote. We look forward to serving all your waterfront needs. Regards, Ian Crowley Crowley Marine Contracting Cell Phone 631-831-1740 Telephone/Fax 631-323-1772 email icrowley@optonline.net Crowley Marine Contracting corp. Bulkheading Dockbuilding Beach Stairs PO Box 618 Work 631-83r174o Greenport N.Y n944 Tel/Fax 631-323-1772 Since 1997 icrowleyC optonline.net April 6, 2013 F John Henry D D Village Lane JAN 1 5 2014 Orient NY 11957 $GU[~IG~J Triistees Board V Dear John, Please accept the following proposal for the reconstruction ofyour dock on Orient Harbor. The dock will consist of the following: 10" butt fender piles and inside piles (4 per bent) 6 °x6" CCA caps and outside stringers 4 "x6" CCA inside stringers 514 "x6" Ipe decking fastened with stainless steel screws Fiberglass sheet pile splashboard under "ell" portion (2) 4 pile tie off dolphins on north side (2) 4 pile tie off dolphins on west side The existing dock will be removed and a new one constructed in its place. Total amount to remove and replace dock... $202,700.00 The project as proposed will require permits from NYSDEC, ACOE, and Town of Southold Trustees. We can acquire these permits on your behalf or work with a consultant of your choice. Terms: $5, 000 upon signing 50% upon commencement 25% upon dock framing balance due upon completion Cell Phone 63r83r174o Telephone/Fax 631-323-1772 email icrowley@optonline.net Crowley Marine Contracting corp. Bulkheading Dockbuilding Beach Stairs PO Boa 618 Work 631-83t-174o Greenport N.Y 1i944 Tel/Fax 631323-1772 Since 1997 ierowley@optonline.net If this proposal and its terms meets your approval please sign and date on the line provided. Agreed: John Henry April 6, 2013 Thank you for the opportunity to provide this quote. We look forward to serving all your waterfront needs. JAN 1 5 Regards, ]201]4 2f of T/ -fl Ialm Ian an Crowley Crowley Marine Contracting Cell Phone 631-831-174o Telephone/Fax 631-323-1/72 email icrowley@optonline.net ~~~gUfF4t4.c James F. King, President Town Hail, 53095 Main Rd. Bob Ghosio, Jr., Vice-President P.O. Box 1179 Dave Bergen y ' Southold,NY 11971 John Bredemeyer Wv Telephone (631) 765-1892 Michael J. Domino 1 Fax (631) 765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Office Use Only Coastal Erosion Permit Application Wetland Permit Application _Administrative Permit -Amendment/Transfer/Extension [Received Application: I a N I n a Received Fee: 5- a)17 VV ~Completed Application 11,21111 1111 -Incomplete J~ N _SEQRA Classification: 2 4 2014 i Type 1_Type 11-Unlisted j Coordination: (date sent) Jd. _ J -V,y.LWRP Consistency Asses ment Form I 1 1',CAC Referral Sent: 1 1 1 V Date of Inspection-2"/ -Receipt of CAC Report: -Lead Agency Determination: -Technical Review: Public Hearing Held: 19 l y Resolution: Name of ApplicantJohn & Sarah Henry 51 Riverside Drive, Apt. 16B Address New York, NY 10024 Phone Number: 12 799-4816 Suffolk County Tax Map Number: 1000 - 26-1-17.1 Property Location: 2440 Village Lane, Orient (provide LILCO Pole distance to cross streets, and location) AGENT: En-Consultants (If applicable) Address: 1319 North Sea Road, Southampton, NY 11968 Phone: 631-283-6360 C*rl ~ 6 .Board of Trustees Applic*n GENERAL DATA Land Area (in square feet): 12,680 Area Zoning: R-40 Previous use of property: Residential, single family dwelling with dock intended use of property: No change Covenants and Restrictions: Yes X No If "Yes", please provide copy. Does this project require a variance from the Zoning Board of Appeals Yes X No If "Yes", please provide copy of decision. Will this project require any demolition as per Town Code or as determined by Building Dept. Yes X No Does the structure(s) on property have a valid Certificate of Occupancy Yes No Prior permits/approvals for site improvements: Agency Date Southold Trustees #5433 10/26/01 Southold Trustees #5533 4/29/02 No prior permits/approvals for site improvements. Has any permit/approval ever been revoked or suspended by a governmental agency? X No Yes If yes, provide explanation: Project Description (use attachments if necessary): Perform ordinary and usual maintenance activities on an existing fixed, "J" shaped pier, which pre-dates 1955 and consists of an 8'x 152' shore-perpendicular section and 10' x Wand 10'x 17' shore-parallel sections, including: 1) as-built repairs following Hurricane Irene, including installation of new 2" x 10" untreated decking and replacement of storm damaged inside pilings, caps, and stringers; and 2) proposed repairs of additional storm damage caused by Hurricane Sandy, including installation of additional 2" x 10" untreated decking and replacement of additional 10" inside pilings, 6" x 6" caps and outside stringers, and 4" x 6" inside stringers, all as depicted on the survey prepared by Nathan Taft Corwin III Land Surveyor, last dated November 1, 2013. Wrd of Trustees Applicatiole WETLAND/TRUSTEE LANDS APPLICATION DATA Purpose of the proposed operations: To maintain existing fixed pier, as described in the project description and depicted on the survey prepared by Nathan Taft Corwin Land Surveyor III, last dated November 1, 2013. Area of wetlands on lot: 0 square feet Percent coverage of lot: Closest distance between nearest existing structure and upland edge of wetlands: N/A feet Closest distance between nearest proposed structure and upland edge of wetlands: N/A feet Does the project involve excavation or filling? X No Yes If yes, how much material will be excavated? N/A cubic yards How much material will be filled? N/A cubic yards Depth of which material will be removed or deposited: N/A feet Proposed slope throughout the area of operations: N/A Manner in which material will be removed or deposited: N/A Statement of the effect, if any, on the wetlands and tidal waters of the town that may result by reason of such proposed operations (use attachments if appropriate): The existing fixed dock has been present on the subject property in its current location and configuration continuously since prior to 1955 and the Trustees' jurisdiction over Orient Harbor. The current application seeks permission both for as-built repairs to storm damage caused by Hurricane Irene and for proposed repairs to storm damage caused by Hurricane Sandy. These ordinary and usual maintenance activities will serve to main the continued use of the existing dock but will not change the size, design, or function of the dock nor cause any adverse or other significant impacts on the adjacent unvegetated wetlands or tidal waters of Orient Harbor. However, the replacement of preexisting treated decking with untreated decking will reduce the amount of treated lumber in the waterway, which is presumed to have a beneficial impact on the adjacent wetlands. 617.20 Appendix B Short Environmental Assessment Form Instructions for Comoletin¢ Part I - Project Information. The applicant or project sponsor is responsible for the completion of Part 1. Responses become part of the application for approval or funding, are subject to public review, and may be subject to further verification. Complete Part I based on information currently available. If additional research or investigation would be needed to fully respond to any item, please answer as thoroughly as possible based on current information. Complete all items in Part 1. You may also provide any additional information which you believe will be needed by or useful to the lead agency; attach additional pages as necessary to supplement any item. Part I - Project and Sponsor Information Name of Action or Project: Henry Dock Project Location (describe, and attach a location mapp 2440 Village Lane, Orient, Town of Southold, Suttblk County, New York; property located on west side of Village Lane, +/-248' north of King Street, maps provided. Brief Description of Proposed Action: Perform ordinary and usual maintenance activities on an existing fixed, "J" shaped pier, which pre-dates 1955 and consists of an 8'x 152' shore-perpendicular section and 10' x 36' and 10' x 17' shore-parallel sections, including: 1) as-built repairs following Hurricane Irene, including installation of new 2" x 10" untreated decking and replacement of storm damaged inside pilings, caps, and stringers; and 2) proposed repairs of additional storm damage caused by Hurricane Sandy, including installation of additional 2" x 10" untreated decking and replacement of additional 10" inside pilings, 6" x 6" caps and outside stringers, and 4" x 6" inside stringers, all as depicted on the survey prepared by Nathan Taft Corwin III Land Surveyor, last dated November 1, 2013. Name of Applicant or Sponsor: Telephone: 212-799-4816 John & Sarah Henry E-Mail: Address: 54 Riverside Drive, Apt. 16B City/PO: State: Zip Code: New York NY 10024 1. Does the proposed action only involve the legislative adoption of a plan, local law, ordinance, NO YES administrative rule, or regulation? If Yes, attach a narrative description of the intent of the proposed action and the environmental resources that may be affected in the municipality and proceed to Part 2. If no, continue to question 2. X 2. Does the proposed action require a permit, approval or funding from any other governmental Agency? NO YES If Yes, list agency(s) name and permit or approval: X 3.a. Total acreage of the site of the proposed action? 0.29 acres b. Total acreage to be physically disturbed? N/A acres c. Total acreage (project site and any contiguous properties) owned or controlled by the applicant or project sponsor? 0.29 acres 4. Check all land uses that occur on, adjoining and near the proposed action. ? Urban ? Rural (non-agriculture) ? Industrial ? Commercial ® Residential (suburban) ? Forest ? Agriculture ® Aquatic ? Other (specify): ? Parkland Page 1 of 4 5. Is the proposed action, NO YES N/A a. A permitted use under the zoning regulations? X b. Consistent with the adopted comprehensive plan? X 6. Is the proposed action consistent with the predominant character of the existing built or natural NO YES landscape? X 7. Is the site of the proposed action located in, or does it adjoin, a state listed Critical Environmental Area? NO YES If Yes, identify: X 8. a. Will the proposed action result in a substantial increase in traffic above present levels? NO YES X b. Are public transportation service(s) available at or near the site of the proposed action? X c. Are any pedestrian accommodations or bicycle routes available on or near site of the proposed action? X 9. Does the proposed action meet or exceed the state energy code requirements? NO YES If the proposed action will exceed requirements, describe design features and technologies: N/A 10. Will the proposed action connect to an existing public/private water supply? NO YES If No, describe method for providing potable water: N/A 11. Will the proposed action connect to existing wastewater utilities? NO YES If No, describe method for providing wastewater treatment: N/A 12. a. Does the site contain a structure that is listed on either the State or National Register of Historic NO YES Places? b. Is the proposed action located in an archeological sensitive area? X X 13. a. Does any portion of the site of the proposed action, or lands adjoining the proposed action, contain NO YES wetlands or other waterbodies regulated by a federal, state or local agency? X b. Would the proposed action physically alter, or encroach into, any existing wetland or waterbody? If Yes, identify the wetland or waterbody and extent of alterations in square feet or acres: Orient Harbor - X Maintenance of existing pier with no change to existing water body or wetland. - FF 14. Identify the typical habitat types that occur on, or are likely to be found on the project site. Check all that apply. ® Shoreline ? Forest ? Agricultural/grasslands ? Early mid-successional ® Wetland ? Urban ® Suburban 15. Does the site of the proposed action contain any species of animal, or associated habitats, listed NO YES by the State or Federal government as threatened or endangered? X 16. Is the project site located in the 100 year flood plain? NO YES X 17. Will the proposed action create storm water discharge, either from point or non-point sources? NO YES If Yes, a. Will storm water discharges flow to adjacent properties? ? NO ? YES X b. Will storm water discharges be directed to established conveyance systems (runoff and storm drains)? If Yes, briefly describe: ? NO ? YES Page 2 of 4 0 18. Does the proposed action include construction or other activities that result in the impoundment of NO YES water or other liquids (e.g. retention pond, waste lagoon, dam)? If Yes, explain purpose and size: X 19. Has the site of the proposed action or an adjoining property been the location of an active or closed NO YES solid waste management facility? If Yes, describe: X 20. Has the site of the proposed action or an adjoining property been the subject of remediation (ongoing or NO YES completed) for hazardous waste? If Yes, describe: X I AFFIRM THAT THE IN6ORMATION PROVIDED ABOVE IS TRUE AND ACCURATE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE Applicant/sponsor name: rt E. Herrmann, Coastal Mgmt. Specialist Date: January 16, 2014 Signature: Part 2 - Impact Assessment. The Lead Agency is responsible for the completion of Part 2. Answer all of the following questions in Part 2 using the information contained in Part I and other materials submitted by the project sponsor or otherwise available to the reviewer. When answering the questions the reviewer should be guided by the concept "Have my responses been reasonable considering the scale and context of the proposed action?" No, or Moderate small to large impact impact may may occur occur 1. Will the proposed action create a material conflict with an adopted land use plan or zoning regulations? 2. Will the proposed action result in a change in the use or intensity of use of land? 3. Will the proposed action impair the character or quality of the existing community? 4. Will the proposed action have an impact on the environmental characteristics that caused the establishment of a Critical Environmental Area (CEA)? 5. Will the proposed action result in an adverse change in the existing level of traffic or affect existing infrastructure for mass transit, biking or walkway? 6. Will the proposed action cause an increase in the use of energy and it fails to incorporate reasonably available energy conservation or renewable energy opportunities? 7. Will the proposed action impact existing: a. public / private water supplies? b. public / private wastewater treatment utilities? 8. Will the proposed action impair the character or quality of important historic, archaeological, architectural or aesthetic resources? 9. Will the proposed action result in an adverse change to natural resources (e.g., wetlands, waterbodies, groundwater, air quality, flora and fauna)? Page 3 of 4 No, or Moderate small to large impact impact may may occur 10. Will the proposed action result in an increase in the potential for erosion, flooding or drainage problems? 11. Will the proposed action create a hazard to environmental resources or human health? Part 3 - Determination of significance. The Lead Agency is responsible for the completion of Part 3. For every question in Part 2 that was answered "moderate to large impact may occur", or if there is a need to explain why a particular element of the proposed action may or will not result in a significant adverse environmental impact, please complete Part I Part 3 should, in sufficient detail, identify the impact, including any measures or design elements that have been included by the project sponsor to avoid or reduce impacts. Part 3 should also explain how the lead agency determined that the impact may or will not be significant. Each potential impact should be assessed considering its setting, probability of occurring, duration, irreversibility, geographic scope and magnitude. Also consider the potential for short-term, long-term and cumulative impacts. ? Check this box if you have determined, based on the information and analysis above, and any supporting documentation, that the proposed action may result in one or more potentially large or significant adverse impacts and an environmental impact statement is required. ? Check this box if you have determined, based on the information and analysis above, and any supporting documentation, that the proposed action will not result in any significant adverse environmental impacts. Name of Lead Agency Date Print or Type Name of Responsible Officer in Lead Agency Title of Responsible Officer Signature of Responsible Officer in Lead Agency Signature of Preparer (if different from Responsible Officer) Page 4 of 4 NOTICE TO ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNER BOARD OF TRUSTEES, TOWN OF SOUTHOLD In the matter of applicant: John & Sarah Henry SCTM# 1000-26-1-17.1 YOU ARE HEREBY GIVEN NOTICE: 1. That it is the intention of the undersigned to request a Permit from the Board of Trustees to: Perform ordinary and usual maintenance activities on an existing fixed, "J" shaped pier, which pre-dates 1955 and consists of an 8'x 152' shore-perpendicular section and 10' x 36' and 10' x 17' shore-parallel sections, including: 1) as-built repairs following Hurricane Irene, including installation of new 2" x 10" untreated decking and replacement of storm damaged inside pilings, caps, and stringers; and 2) proposed repairs of additional storm damage caused by Hurricane Sandy, including installation of additional 2" x 10" untreated decking and replacement of additional 10" inside pilings, 6" x 6" caps and outside stringers, and 4" x 6" inside stringers, all as depicted on the survey prepared by Nathan Taft Corwin III Land Surveyor, last dated November 1, 2013. 2. That the property which is the subject of Environmental Review is located adjacent to your property and is described as follows: 2440 Village Lane, Orient 3. That the project which is subject to Environmental Review under Chapters 96,111 and/or 275 of the Town Code is open to public comment on: DATE: Wednesday, February 19, 2014 @ 5:30 p.m. You may contact the Trustees Office at 765-1892 or in writing. The above-referenced proposal is under review of the Board of Trustees of the Town of Southold and does not reference any other agency that might have to review same proposal. John & Sarah Henry PROPERTY OWNERS NAME: 51 Riverside Drive, Apt. 16B MAILING ADDRESS: New York, NY 10024 PHONE#: 212-799-4816 AGENT: En-Consultants MAILING ADDRESS: 1319 North Sea Road, Southampton, NY 11968 PHONE 631-283-6360 Enc: Copy of sketch or plan showing proposal for your convenience. *ROOF OF MAILING OF NOTICE* ATTACH CERTIFIED MAIL RECEIPTS Name: Address: John M. Bredemeyer, III and Eric R. Bredemeyer 2660 Village Lane as Trustees of the John M. Bredemeyer and P.O. Box 416 Jeanne R. Bredemeyer Family Trust Orient, NY 11957 John B. Henry Revocable Trust 54 Riverside Drive, #I 6B New York, NY 10024 Frederic C. Scofield 11305 Spaulding Street Grantor Revocable Inetervivos Trust Omaha, NE 68164 Sandra & Arthur Bertsch 2395 Village Lane P.O. Box 59 Orient, NY 11957 Kevin & Patricia Brogan 63 Risa Court Riverhead, NY 11901 STATE OF NEW YORK COLTN Y OF SLTFFOL K Robert E. Herrmann doing business at En-Consultants 1319 North Sea Road Southampton, NY 11968 being duly scum, deposes and says that on the 31st day of January 20 14 , deponent mailed a true copy of the Notice set forth in the Board of Trustees Application, directed to each of the above named persons at the addresses set opposite their respective names; that the addresses set opposite the names of said persons are the address of said persons as shown on the current assessment roll of the Town of Southold; that said Notices were mailed at the United States Post Office at Southampton that said Notices were Mailed to each of said persons by (certified)(regledeted) mail. Robert E. Hermann Coastal Management Specialist Sworn to before me this 31st KIM H. STEPHEN S day of January 12014 NOTARY PUBLIC STATE OF NEW YORK COMMISSION NO. 5015931 DUAL IFIED IN SUFFOLK COUNTY Notar blic EXPIRES AUGUST 2, 2041 CERTIFIED U.S. Postal Servicer. U.S. Postal Service,,., MAILT,, RECEIPT CERTIFIED MAIL,,, RECEIPT rn (Domestic Mail Only; No Insurance Coverage Provided) rr. (Domestic Mail Only; No Insurance Coverage Provided) L'd31~~W}"JYI' ° m o m p L F I v6 r r„ CC) Postage It L 9 m Postage $ ` y7 ~ uT A nJ certified Fee Q Certified Fee ? Posimarkz O 0 Reh Receipt Fee PoatlnaM G (Endorsem ment Required) Here C3 (Endorsement Retum ement Receipt Required) Fee , Here a \ O Restricted Delivery Fee Res"Clod Del'v Fee p (Endorsement Required) ~ (Endorsement Required) ,°n John M. Bredemeyer, III and Eric R. ildemeyer To el Postage & Fees ru Q ru as Trustees of the John M. Bre4e 'irllnd a M Jeanne R. Bredemeyer Family T'Irust r° John B. Henry Revoc I a o ,;APf 54 Riverside Drive, #1 0 2660 Village Lane r` ai°OBOZN' New York, NY 10024 f` P.O. Box 416 Siy saie,z Orient, NY 11957 Postal Postal CERTIFIED MAILT. RECEIPT CERTIFIED . RECEIPT EC3 (Domestic Mail Only; No insurance Coverage Provided) 171 :3 1-3 (Domestic Mail Only; No insurance Coverage Provided) l . M ° ° m USE M Postage $ riL ~ Postage $ SO(/ ~ U 1 certified Fee i q Certified Fee y y' 0 Retum Receipt Fee ` stmark O O Retum Receipt Fee N Postmark .4 O (Endorsement Required) I, ere O (Endorsement Required) ro Here O Q Restricted Delivery Fee t~ Restriced Delvery Fee Z r (Endorsement Requlretl) \ p (Endorsement Required) > 'c LIT Total For•Ul Tots' da 5 r-4 Frederic C. Scofield Sandra & Arthur Bertsch Sent To a 2395 Village Lane Grantor Revocable Instant a 11305 Spaulding Street r o a P.O. Box 59 " M1 OrPOBOX : ciry"sieie, Omaha, NE 68164 bry., Orient, NY 11957 rm, U.S. Postal Service~., CERTIFIED MAILT,, RECEIPT ru (Domestic Mail Only; No Insurance Coverage Provided) M I I U '9 E T IfT Postage $ y9 Certified Fee - ~A Retum Recelyt Fee -o PoSOnark0 C (Endorsement Required) Here z, Restricted Delivery Fee M (Endomemera Required) V 171 L l Total Poste-_ ° -9m, a ro Kevin & Patricia Br9ga~ C3 63 Risa Court r, orPOeOx". Riverhead, NY 11901 Crry, Blete,Z :r • John Bredemeyer, President ~,SUFF014, Town Hall Annex Michael J. Domino, Vice-President hao oos 54375 Route 25 James F. King P.O. Box 1179 Charles J. Sanders Southold, NY 11971 Telephone (631) 765-1892 Fax(631)765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD BOARD OF TRUSTEES: TOWN OF SOUTHOLD In the Matter of the Application of JOHN & SARAH HENRY COUNTY OF SUFFOLK) STATE OF NEW YORK) AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING TO BE COMPLETED AFTER POSTING REMAINS IN PLACE FOR EIGHT DAYS I Robert E. Herrmann , residing at /dba En-Consultants 1319 North Sea Road, Southampton, NY 11968 being duly sworn, depose and say: That on the7th day of February 2014 , I personally posted the property known as 2440 Village Lane. Orient. SCTM #1000-26-1-17.1 by placing the Board of Trustees official poster where it can easily be seen, and that I have checked to be sure the poster has remained in place for eight days prior to the date of the public hearing. Date of hearing noted thereon to be held Wednesday, February 19, 2014. Dated: (signature) obert E. Herrmann Sworn to before me this 19thdayof Feb2014 No'tar~_Public KIM H, STEPHENS NOTARY HIBLIC STATE PF NE.. PORK COMMISSION NO. 5015931 DUALIFIED IN SUFFOLK COUNTY EXPIRES A06UST 2. 201-7 NOTICE OF HEARING NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a public hearing will be held by the SOUTHOLD BOARD OF TRUSTEES at the Town Hall, 53095 Main Road, Southold, New York, concerning this property. Sarah {~en~ OWNERS OF RECORD:J-11, SUBJECT OF PUBLIC HEARING: For the existing fixed "J" shaped pier that consists of an W052' shore section, wd 10'x3 aid tfl" i w" secom; a~ nMmft consisting of the installation new 2"x10" untreated decking and the replacement of inside pilings, caps and strkqers; and repairs consisting of the installation of additional TOO" untreated decking and replacement of additional 10" inside pilings, 65x6' caps and outside stringers, and 4"x6" inside stringers. TIME & DATE OF PUBLIC HEARING: • kkdnesday, Febr6toxy /9 aoly- a.- or abw:~S"30" If you have an interest in this project, you are invited to view the Town file(s) which are available for inspection prior to the day of the hearing during normal business days between the hours of a.m and 4 p.m. BOARD OF TRUSTEES * TOWN OF SOUTHOLD * (631) 765-1892 • 0 Board of Trustees Application AUTHORIZATION (where the applicant is not the owner) ,5 y P, F1 Yl -C residing at ~~az? fib, ti r 1CC'2 (print owner of property) (mailing address) do hereby authorize -5 (Agent) to apply for permit(s) from the Southold Board of Town Trustees on my behalf. ~ (Owner's signature) Board of Trustees Application County of Suffolk State of New York -50Ht•A + SPQ C~ BEING DULY SWORN DEPOSES AND AFFIRMS THAT HE/SHE IS THE APPLICANT FOR THE ABOVE DESCRIBED PERMIT(S) AND THAT ALL STATEMENTS CONTAINED HEREIN ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF HIS/HER KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF, AND THAT ALL WORK WILL BE DONE IN THE MANNER SET FORTH IN THIS APPLICATION AND AS MAY BE APPROVED BY THE SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF TRUSTEES. THE APPLICANT AGREES TO HOLD THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD AND THE TOWN TRUSTEES HARMLESS AND FREE FROM ANY AND ALL DAMAGES AND CLAIMS ARISING UNDER OR BY VIRTUE OF SAID PERMIT(S), IF GRANTED. IN COMPLETING THIS APPLICATION, I HEREBY AUTHORIZE THE TRUSTEES, THEIR AGENT(S) OR REPRESENTATIVES(S), TO ENTER ONTO MY PROPERTY TO INSPECT THE PREMISES IN CONJUNCTION WITH REVIEW OF THIS APPLICATION. \121 A tgnnaa 6 11 SWORN TO BEFORE ME THIS I DAY OF , • I __~20jj- Y SCNROEL04*, EMY71:1310: e91b - state aO.019C92I9blic ed iNew YorExpires I S l~- EtN4,o,t&r,y FREY SCHROEDER ualia • Steh of New York 0. 01SC6219008 ed inNew York County sion Expires a/ • 3!• IS APPLICANT/AGENT/REPRESENTATIVE TRANSACTIONAL DISCLOSURE FORM The Town of Southold s Code of Ethics mohibils conflicts of interest on the part of town officers and employees. The RwMgg of this form is to provide information which can alert the town of possible conflicts of teg MA allow it to take whatever action rs nemsary to avoid am YOUR NAME: AU-t L' `.TURN 9, I'EU,,,t, (Last name, first name, middle mmal, unless you are applying in the name of someone else or other entity, such as a company. If so, indicate the other person's or company's name.) NAME OF APPLICATION: (Check all that apply.) Tax grievance Building Variance Trustee v Change of Zone _ Coastal Erosion Approval of plat Mooring Exemption from plat or official map Planning Other (If -Other-, name the activity.) Do you personally (or through your company, spouse, sibling, parent, or child) have a relationship with any officer or employee of the Town of Southold? "Relationshir includes by blood, marriage, or business interest. "Business interest" means a business, including a partnership, in which the town officer or employee has even a partial ownership of (or employment by) a corporation in which the town officer or employee owns more than 5% of the shares. YES NO . If you answered "YES", complete the balance of this form and date and sign where indicated. Name of person employed by the Town of Southold Title or position of that person Describe the relationship between yourself (the applicantlagent/representative) and the town officer or employee. Either check the appropriate line A) through D) and/or describe in the space provided. The town officer or employee or his or her spouse, sibling, paren4 or child is (check all that apply): A) the owner of grater than 5% of the shares of the corporate stock of the applicant (when the applicant is a corporation); B) the legal or beneficial owner of my interest in a non- orporate entity (when the applicant is not a corporation); C) an officer, director, partner, or employee of the applicant; or D) the actual applicant. DESCRIPTION OF RELATIONSHIP Submitted this n1 day of fil 204 Z Signature _77_ 7-r_, Print Name JatjA" 11 9 %H- r- Form - TS 1 Town of Southold • LWRP CONSISTENCY ASSESSMENT FORM A. INSTRUCTIONS I. All applicants for perm its' including Town of Southold agencies, shall com plete this CCA F for proposed actions that are subject to the Town of Southold W aterfront Consistency Review Law. This assessm ent is intended to supplement other information used by a Town of Soulhold agency in in a k in g a d e t e r m i n a 1i o n o f c o n s i s le n c y, *Except minor exempt actions including Building Permits and other ministerial permits not located within the Coastal Erosion Hazard Area. 2. Before answering the questions in Section C, the preparer of this form should review the exempt minor action list, policies and explanations of each policy contained in the Town of Southold Local Waterfront Revitalization Program. A proposed action will be evaluated as to its significant beneficial and adverse effects upon the coastal area (which includes all of Southold Town). If any question in Section C on this form is answered "yes" or "no", then the proposed action will affect the achievement of the LWRP policy standards and conditions contained in the consistency review law. Thus, each answer must be explained in detail, listing both supportine and non- supportine facts. If an action cannot be certified as consistent with the LWRP policy standards and conditions, it shall not be undertaken. A copy of the LWRP is available in the following places: online at the Town of Southold's website (southoldtown.northfork.net), the Board of Trustees Office, the PI 7J mend; D libraries and the Town Clerk's office. B. DESCRIPTION OF SITE AND PROPOSED ACTION SCTM# 26 i 17.a 2 4 2014 PROJECT NAME John & Sarah Hen "`r'0i0 The Application has been submitted to (check appropriate response): Town Board ? Planning Board El Building Dept. E] Board of Trustees Category of Town of Southold agency action (check appropriate response): (a) Action undertaken directly by Town agency (e.g. capital construction, planning activity, agency regulation, land transaction) (b) Financial assistance (e.g. grant, loan, subsidy) ? (c) Permit, approval, license, certification: Nature and extent of action: See attached JOHN & SARAH HENRY 2440 VILLAGE LANE ORIENT, NY SCTM #1000-26-1-17.1 Nature and extent of action: Perform ordinary and usual maintenance activities on an existing fixed, "J" shaped pier, which pre-dates 1955 and consists of an 8' x 152' shore-perpendicular section and 10' x 36' and 10' x 17' shore-parallel sections, including: 1) as-built repairs following Hurricane Irene, including installation of new 2" x 10" untreated decking and replacement of storm damaged inside pilings, caps, and stringers; and 2) proposed repairs of additional storm damage caused by Hurricane Sandy, including installation of additional 2" x 10" untreated decking and replacement of additional 10" inside pilings, 6" x 6" caps and outside stringers, and 4" x 6" inside stringers, all as depicted on the survey prepared by Nathan Taft Corwin III Land Surveyor, last dated November 1, 2013. All policies are indicated as "Not Applicable" because it is our understanding pursuant to Section 268-5 ("Review if Actions") of the Town Code and the corresponding definitions of "action" and "minor action" set forth in Chapter 268-3 ("Definitions"), the project meets the definition of a minor action and is thus exempt from waterfront consistency review. Specifically, because the repairs constitute "normal maintenance" and not a "restoration" pursuant to Chapter 1 I 1 of the Town Code (see notes on enclosed survey), they are not subject to the requirements of a Coastal Erosion Management Permit and thus meet the following definition of a "minor action" pursuant to Chapter 268: "13. Replacement, rehabilitation or reconstruction of a structure or facility, in kind, on the same site (in place)...except for structures in areas designated by the Coastal Erosion Hazard Area (CEHA) law where structures may not be replaced, rehabilitated, or reconstructed without a permit..." That is, so long as the repair work does not require a Coastal Erosion Management Permit, then the work meets this definition of a minor action and is exempt from review pursuant to Chapter 268. Location of action: John & Sarah Henry Site acreage: 12,680 s.f. Present land use: Residential, single family dwelling Present zoning classification: R-40 2. If an application for the proposed action has been filed with the Town of Southold agency, the following information shall be provided: (a) Name of applicant: John & Sarah Henry (b) Mailing address: 54 Riverside Drive, Apt. 16B New York, NY 10024 (c) Telephone number: Area Code 212-799-4816 (d) Application number, if any: Will the action be directly undertaken, require funding, or approval by a state or federal agency? Yes ® No ? If yes, which state or federal agency?NYS DEC, USA COE & NYS DOS C. Evaluate the project to the following policies by analyzing how the project will further support or not support the policies. Provide all proposed Best Management Practices that will further each policy. Incomplete answers will require that the form be returned for completion. DEVELOPED COAST POLICY Policy 1. Foster a pattern of development in the Town of Southold that enhances community character, preserves open space, makes efficient use of infrastructure, makes beneficial use of a coastal location, and minimizes adverse effects of development. See LWRP Section III - Policies; Page 2 for evaluation criteria. ?Yes ? No ® Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 2. Protect and preserve historic and archaeological resources of the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III - Policies Pages 3 through 6 for evaluation criteria ? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 3. Enhance visual quality and protect scenic resources throughout the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III - Policies Pages 6 through 7 for evaluation criteria ? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary NATURAL COAST POLICIES Policy 4. Minimize loss of life, structures, and natural resources from flooding and erosion. See LWRP Section III - Policies Pages 8 through 16 for evaluation criteria ? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 5. Protect and improve water quality and supply in the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III - Policies Pages 16 through 21 for evaluation criteria ? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 6. Protect and restore the quality and function of the Town of Southold ecosystems including Significant Coastal Fish and Wildlife Habitats and wetlands. See LWRP Section III - Policies; Pages 22 through 32 for evaluation criteria. ? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 7. Protect and improve air quality in the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III - Policies Pages 32 through 34 for evaluation criteria. ? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 8. Minimize environmental degradation in Town of Southold from solid waste and hazardous substances and wastes. See LWRP Section III - Policies; Pages 34 through 38 for evaluation criteria. ? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable PUBLIC COAST POLICIES Policy 9. Provide for public access to, and recreational use of, coastal waters, public lands, and public resources of the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III - Policies; Pages 38 through 46 for evaluation criteria. ? Yes ? No® Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary WORKING COAST POLICIES Policy 10. Protect Southold's w~-dependent uses and promote sitin f new water-dependent uses in suitable locations. See LWRP Section III - Policies; Pages 47 through 5 for evaluation criteria. ? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 11. Promote sustainable use of living marine resources in Long Island Sound, the Peconic Estuary and Town waters. See LWRP Section III - Policies; Pages 57 through 62 for evaluation criteria. ? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 12. Protect agricultural lands in the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III - Policies; Pages 62 through 65 for evaluation criteria. ? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 13. Promote appropriate use and development of energy and mineral resources. See LWRP Section III - Policies; Pages 65 through 68 for evaluation criteria. ? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable PREPARED BY _ TITLE Coastal Mgmt. Specialist DATE 1/16/14 Robert E. emnann Amended on 811105 ~F IV EN-CONSULTANTS January 24, 2014 Town of Southold (lll E C ( r°r? DD ~ Board of Trustees is 54375 Main Road AN 2 4 2014 1 Post Office Box 1 179 Southold, New York 11971 -jl Re: John & Sarah Henry 2440 Village Lane, Orient SCTM #1000-26-1-17.1 Dear Board of Trustees: In regard to the above referenced property, enclosed are the following for the Board of Trustees review: 1. Three (3) Wetland Permit Applications including: a) Short Environmental Assessment Form; b) Authorization & Disclosure Forms; c) Land survey prepared by Nathan Taft Corwin III, Land Surveyor, last dated November 1, 2013. 2. One (1) set of site photographs. 3. Application fee of $500.00 (previously submitted). 4. Three (3) LWRP Consistency Assessment Forms including: a) Survey. I trust this information shall allow you to process our permit request. Should any additional information be r wired, please do not hesitate to contact our office. Sin erely, Robe E. Herrmann Coastal Management Specialist /khs Enc. 1319 North Sea Road Southampton. New York 11968 ' p 631283.63601 [63 1 283 6 13 6 r~oiuuitii L;.cnn • 0 John Bredemeyer, President SUFF04t cO Town Hall Annex Michael J. Domino, Vice-President 54375 Route 25 James F. King P.O. Box 1179 Charles J. Sanders 'y Southold, NY 11971 '~0f is Telephone (631) 765-1892 Fax (631) 765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD January 16, 2014 Robert E. Herrmann En-Consultants 1319 North Sea Road Southampton, NY 11968 RE: JOHN & SARAH HENRY 2440 VILLAGE LANE, ORIENT SCTM# 26-1-17.1 Dear Mr. Herrmann: As per your request, enclosed are check numbers 5316, 5317 and 5327 issued by En- Consultants for the above mentioned property's application received on May 17, 2012 which has expired. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact the office. Sincerely, Eli eth Cantrell, Clerk Typist Board of Trustees lop • 5316 EN-CONSULTANTS 1319 NORTH SEA ROAD-PH. (631) 283-6360 SOUTHAMPTON, NY 11968 5 2_ 50-666.214 DATE P AY TO THE ORDER OF 10~~~ n~ ~XJ- /~c7~ A ~ $ THAN ~cQ 00. _:~DOLLARS 6) BBIDGEHAMMON .so wx~TOn xwo NATIONAL wuTx~xrrox, nr i ~eee BANK wwx.bmpmb.mm FOR er n'0 53i6B' 1:0214066671: 0202022i8211' 5317' EN-CONSULTANTS 1319 NORTH SEA ROAD-PH. (631) 283-6360 SOUTHAMPTON, NY 11968 50-666-214 DATE P AY TO THE ORDER OF _7vw~ 0L ~OL CX I~ ~ ~ ' f1 DOLLARS e. a~'"°:.~. BRIDGEHAMPTON .eo xwxrrox xo~o NATIONAL woTw.x~x, xT i I... BANK w~w.bntlaxemm FOR M 11.00 31711- 1:02i406667i: 0 20 20 2 2 18 211' 5327 EN-CONSULTANTS 1319 NORTH SEA ROAD-PH. (631) 283-6360 miwonrw SOUTHAMPTON, NY 11968 50-666.214 DATE May 22, 2012 PAY TO THE Town of Southold 2 .aD) ORDER OF 1 Two Hundred Fifty Dollars & No Cents*******************************r'_....._.-.._ DOLLARS IJ o ,ip" BBIDGERAMPTON ,so x~nrron nowo NATIONAL sourxwxrrox, xr i I... BANK w bn gmb.w ..s FOR John Henry 11.00532711• i:020,06667I: 0 20 20 2 2 18 211• 1319 North Sea Road Southampton, New York 11968 631-283-6360 A~EWCONSULTANTS Fax: 631-283-6136 www.enconsultants.com ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING May 21, 2012 Mark Terry, LWRP Coordinator Planning Board Town of Southold MAY 2 3 2012 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Re: John and Sarah Henry. 2440 Village Lane, Orient - Dear Mr. Terry: Attached please find a copy of an application that has been filed with the Board of Trustees for a Town Wetlands Permit to permit a legally preexisting dock that has existed in its current location and configuration since the 1950s, as evidenced by online dated aerial photographs readily available to the public. As a result of a violation issued to the owners last fall, the application is being made at this time to legalize several repairs that were made after Tropical Storm Irene, including the replacement of individual storm damaged inside pilings and girders and damaged and/or aging deck boards. Although I understand that a small swinging gate was also added across the width of the catwalk to prevent trespass on the structure (see attached site photos), the completed work can clearly be categorized as "maintenance or repair involving no substantial changes in an existing structure or facili " i.e., a "minor action" not subject to waterfront consistency review pursuant to §268-3. Only if the repairs to the dock constituted "replacement, rehabilitation, or reconstruction" requiring a Coastal Erosion Management Permit would waterfront consistency review be required. Therefore, I have not filed an LWRP Consistency Assessment Form with the Trustees. Should you determine the project is not exempt from waterfront consistency review, however, please let me know and I will file the form with the Trustees and with your office immediately. Re ctfully yours, Robert E. Herrmann Coastal Management Specialist cc: Lauren Standish, Board of Trustees EN-CONSULTANTS • 5316 1319 NORTH SEA ROAD-PH. (631) 283-6360 SOUTHAMPTON, NY 11968 S Z 50-666-214 DATE PAY TO THE ORDER OF 1 O~-\)?1 C~ `-~lJ-~/L(~\ r C)o OX OLLARS LI ~BRIDGEHAMPCON I'I~NATIONAL seuTMNµrowN, nr~i~iew 11 BANK FOR (jd8V) F-K.IOV~ nw 5317 SEA ROAD-PH. (631) 283-6360 F SULTANTS _ PTON, NY 11968 50-666-214 DATE Lf THE 0 ~,$DOLLARS DGBHAMPTONTOONAL K bdd, 1 V \ ( ZCti 5327 EN-CONSULTANTS 1319 NORTH SEA ROAD-PH. (631) 283-6360 ®+.no+r.. SOUTHAMPTON, NY 11968 50.666.214 DATE May 22. 2012 'D PAY OTER OF 'Town of Southold I $ ~ -750':T Two Hundred Fifty Dollars & No Cents******************************tt~ TO THE DOLLARS BRIDGEHAMPTON 'NATIONAL .au*NIU.~N.~ ~N BANK FOR John Henry =r 1319 North Sea Road Southampton, New York 11968 M 631-283-6360 Fax: 631-283-6136 EN-CONSULTANTS www.e nconsultants.com ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING ---:May 10, 2012 Lauren Standish Board of Trustees r Town of Southold 1 MAY 11 2012 P.O Box 1179 t" Southold, NY 11971 Re: John an, h Henry. 2440 Vilb= Lme. Orient Dear Mrs. Standish: Please find attached an application to pormit prtiing look fix the purpose of making ordinary and' routine repairs and maintenance. This application is being made at ft'* I because aft,'lIoparrtl Storm Irene, the HeM;s' contractor oommenced some simple w, lnG e replacement of individual storm _damegpl*pilings arrsi iris arW~ sptll~Iag boards. It is my u~erstandirrg that a vio~atiaatt vlas issued " tl~e work ~ecleuee a. dtIc " eked in its current location and configiumlon+ou the propeRyIs Z 1955, It is not a . structure pursuant to Chapter 275. Please note that because the proposed antiv tyw involves oWl"-wasuce or repair involv"' ntl substantial changes in an existing stttiaoun or laoitity," the ` Wok s by §2d8-3 ms a action" net requiring waterfibut epasistarcy +v pursuant to Therefore, we. submitting an LW 6 Consistency AsseftWO form with this appltantxr ' E 7L, Robert E. Henn Coastal Management Specialist Enclosures 1319 North Sea Road Southampton, New York 11968 631-283-6360 EN-CONSULTANTS www.enoonsunoonsu-lt ants.cms., 36 bm ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING Ma 21, 2012 James King, Chairman r - ' f 1 I Board of Trustees Town of Southold it •MAY 2 3 2012 M.', lox 1179 Southold, NY 11971 mmR a a . 1 ~ t~ ,36Ln and Sarah Henrv. 2440 Vihage Lnne. Orient I?ear k. King: As( - *1 submitted an application for a Town Wetlands P it a legally exi0od in its current location and configuration srnee - ~'as evi i madily available online. As°a rasuft df a vlola0qn, t)tn*0Natioa ' bwag t ' ,several repairs that were made after Tropical $io ul "'0 nnnl flue ° =-j -in" }filings and "girders and damaged and/or aging A - 10 w parameters of the catwalk to p`reventrespass on , see wt8t„cart appltcation). ~ # )n to my application, I received an email ft m I attremt an apphhon for a C6astai ta0316dVlanaem T url '~thvetlands petmtt v =bacausetherepaita • edtave enCl09gd herewith art onal check for $23U.balosed arC x ~ . ~ survey identifying the Coastal Ernaion Hazard Aroe.l3ottndary. ~ Tom understandi however, the comPfeted re , Pairs and ' Ulire reFaus of , ~ ` ot"`maintenance of stn'<ctures when and o " by §l 11-6 as not requiring a C.4?estal,Erosion Management ~tnfr, as i ~s the "pericldicreplacmment trr• of samtrkand wlri h do nest change the size, design or function of a functioning stnttohtt $d w9riLIS fieost Ere emplacement, rdrabilitefion or reconstruction of a stttoture;'". which wduM rI Erosion errt Permit for a permanent dock having a top surface area greater diart 240 " Therefore, it is our position that a Coastal Erosion Management Permit is not required for the fto*':ffun were conducted alter Tropical Storm Irene on the functional dock *,mount. However, should tlha`itoard have information about the work I am not aware of and/or would interpret the nature of the work differently, please let me know and I will act accordingly. Yours, Robert E. Herrmann Coastal Management Specialist cc: John Taggart, Esq. ~c~gufF~~~o 0 Jill M. Doherty, President Town Hall, 53095 Main Rd. James F. King, Vice-President P.O. Box 1179 Dave Bergen '1t Southold,NY 11971 Bob Ghosio, Jr. Telephone (631) 765-1892 John Brederneyer 1 * Fax(631)765-6641 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Office Use Only VI,Coastal Erosion Permit Application Wetland Permit Application _Administrative Permit -Amendment/Transfer/Extension Received Application: 17 I y -Received Fee: _Completed Ap lication ? Incomplete _SEQRA Classification: Type I Type H Unlisted -Coordination: (date sent) _LWRP Consistency Assessment Form -CAC Referral Sent: -Date of Inspection: -Receipt of CAC Report: -Lead Agency Determination: -Technical Review: -Public Hearing Held: Resolution: Name of ApplicantJOHN & SARAH HENRY Address 54 RIVERSIDE DRIVE, APT. 16B, NEW YORK, NY 10024 Phone Number: 212 799-4816 Cz`I ~ 0, Suffolk County Tax Map Number: 1000 - 26-1-17.1 OS- Uhiq ~I Property Location: 2440 VILLAGE LANE, ORIENT l C J I l (provide LILCO Pole distance to cross streets, and location) LUj K-l AGENT: EN-CONSULTANTS (If applicable) Address: 1319 NORTH SEA ROAD, SOUTHAMPTON, NY 11968 Phone: 631-283-6360 ~oard of Trustees Applica GENERAL DATA Land Area (in square feet): 12,680 Area Zoning: R-40 Previous use of property: RESIDENTIAL, SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING WITH DOCK Intended use of property: NO CHANGE Covenants and Restrictions: Yes X No If "Yes", please provide copy. Does this project require a variance from the Zoning Board of Appeals Yes X No If "Yes", please provide copy of decision. Prior permits/approvals for site improvements: Agency Date X No prior permits/approvals for site improvements. Has any permit/approval ever been revoked or suspended by a governmental agency? X No Yes If yes, provide explanation: Project Description (use attachments if necessary): For the purpose of making ordinary and routine repairs and maintenance, such as replacement of damaged treated deck boards with untreated decking and replacement of individual support timbers and pilings when necessary, legalize a preexisting "J"-shaped fixed dock present since prior to 1955, consisting of an 8' x 152' shore-perpendicular section and a 10' wide "J" section with an overall length of approximately 53 feet, all as depicted on the survey prepared by Nathan Taft Corwin III, L.S., last dated May 10, 2012. Ooarcl of Trustees Applicat WETLAND/TRUSTEE LANDS APPLICATION DATA Purpose of the proposed operations: To legalize a preexisting dock. Area of wetlands on lot: 0 square feet Percent coverage of lot: 0 Closest distance between nearest existing structure and upland edge of wetlands: N/A feet Closest distance between nearest proposed structure and upland edge of wetlands: N/A feet Does the project involve excavation or filling? X No Yes If yes, how much material will be excavated? N/A cubic yards How much material will be filled? N/A cubic yards Depth of which material will be removed or deposited: N/A feet Proposed slope throughout the area of operations: N/A Manner in which material will be removed or deposited: N/A Statement of the effect, if any, on the wetlands and tidal waters of the town that may result by reason of such proposed operations (use attachments if appropriate): The existing fixed dock has been present on the subject property in its current location and configuration continuously since prior to 1954 and the Trustees jurisdiction over Orient Harbor. The current application proposes to legalize the structure for the purpose of maintaining it and making ordinary and routine repairs, which will have no impact on the adjacent tidal wetlands or waters of the Town. • 617.20 SEAR PROJECT ID NUMBER APPENDIX C STATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY VIEW SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM for UNLISTED ACTIONS Only PART 1- PROJECT INFORMATION (To be completed by A plicant or Project Sponsor) 1. APPLICANT / SPONSOR 2. PROJECT NAME JOHN & SARAH HENRY BY EN-CONSULTANTS 3. PROJECT LOCATION: Municipality ORIENT County SUFFOLK 4. PRECISE LOCATION: Street Address and Road Intersections. Prominent landmarks etc - or provide map 2449 VILLAGE LANE, ORIENT, TOWN OF SOUTHOLD, SCTM #1000-26-1-17.1 5. IS PROPOSED ACTION: ® New ? Expansion ? Modification / alteration 6. DESCRIBE PROJECT BRIEFLY: For the purpose of making ordinary and routine repairs and maintenance, such as replacement of damaged treated deck boards with untreated decking and replacement of individual support timbers and pilings when necessary, legalize a preexisting "J"-shaped fixed dock present since prior to 1955, consisting of an 8'x 152' shore-perpendicular section and a 10' wide "ill section with an overall length of approximately 53 feet, all as depicted on the survey prepared by Nathan Taft Corwin III, L.S., last dated May 10, 2012. 7. AMOUNT OF LAND AFFECTED: Initially 12,680 s.f acres Ultimately 12,680 s.f acres 8. WILL PROPOSED ACTION COMPLY WITH EXISTING ZONING OR OTHER RESTRICTIONS? ®Yes FINo If no, describe briefly: 9. WHAT IS PRESENT LAND USE IN VICINITY OF PROJECT? (Choose as many as apply.) ® Residential 0Industrial ? Commercial Agriculture ? Park / Forest / Open Space Other (describe) 10. DOES ACTION INVOLVE A PERMIT APPROVAL, OR FUNDING, NOW OR ULTIMATELY FROM ANY OTHER GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY (Federal, State or Local) ?Yes ® No If yes, list agency name and permit / approval: 11. DOES ANY ASPECT OF THE ACTION HAVE A CURRENTLY VALID PERMIT OR APPROVAL? ?Yes ®No If yes, list agency name and permit / approval: IfJS A LT OF PROPOSED ACTION WILL EXISTING PERMIT/ APPROVAL REQUIRE MODIFICATION? Yes ILI No I CERTIFY TH THE INFORMATION PROVIDED ABOVE IS TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE Applicant/Sponsor Name OBERT E. HERRMANN, COASTAL MANAGEMENT SPECIALIST Date: MAY 14, 2012 Signature If the action is a Coastal Area, and you are a state agency, complete the Coastal Assessment Form before proceeding with this assessment PART II - IMPACT ASSESSMENT To be Cbm feted b Lead Agency) A. DOES ACTION EXCEED ANY TYPE I THRESHOLD IN 6 NYCRR, PART 617.4? If yes, coordinate the review process and use the FULL EAR E]Yes a No B. WILL ACTION RECEIVE COORDINATED RENEW AS PROVIDED FOR UNLISTED ACTIONS IN 6 NYCRR, PART 617.6? If No, a negative rh mTe~y be srpersoded by another Involved agency. mLLI No C. COULD ACTION RESULT IN ANY ADVERSE EFFECTS ASSOCIATED WITH THE FOLLOWING: (Answers may be handwritten, if legible) C1. Existing ar quality, surface or groundwater qualty or quantity, noise levels, existing traffic patem, solid waste production or disposal, potential for erosion, drainage or flooding problems? Explain briefly: C2. Aesthetic, agricultural, archaeological, hisiodc, or other natural or cultural resources; of community or neighborhood character? Explain briefly: C3. Vegetation or fauna, fish, shellfish or wildlife specks, significant habitats, or t restened or endangered species? Explain linear. C4. A co mmunity's existing plans or goals as offidafly adopted, or a change in use or Intensity of use of land or ocher natural resources? Explain briery: - F C5. Growth, subsequent development or related activities likely to be induced by the proposed adios? Explain briery: 06. Long term, short term, cumurafive, or other effects not identified in Ci-C57 Explain briefly: - C7. Other impacts including flanges in use of either quantity or type of energy? lain briefly: 0. WALL THE PROJECT HAVE AN IMPACT ON THE ENVIRONMENTAL CHARACTERISTICS THAT CAUSED THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A CRITICAL ENVIRONMENTAL AREA CEA 7 If s explain - brier ; Yes a No E IS THERE, ORRII7S THERE LIKELY TO BE CONTROVERSY RELATED TO POTENTIAL ADVERSE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS? I(yes n: Q Yes No PART NI - DETERMINATION OF SIGNIFICANCE (To be completed by Agency)' OMMUCTN7NS. Foreachadverse effedIdentifiedabove, detemlinewheharNissubatantia4 large, Imporantorotherwiseslgnifciant Each effect should be assessed In connection with its (a) selling (i.e. Urban or rump: (b) probability, of occgMng; (c) durebon; (d) Inevr#sibNity; (a) geographic scope: and (p magnitude. If necessary, add alacrnents or rehlrence su(iporting materials. Ensure that explanations oonWa mdtidenddetatito show lhatalrelevant adverse lmpactshave beenidenifredandadequately addressed. Nquestionddloartlwaschecked M IhedetekmMafion ofsigliffiwrlwmustevaluafe On potential inpadoflheproposed aWon on the enviriontrieflialcharecedsticsoflheCFA. CheckWisboxtyouhave WeUhtitiedonearmors POINW flyWWorWarilcartadversekWcswN MAYoodr. Thenproceeddiraglytblhe EAF and/or prepare a positive dedarallon. Chalk ids box If you have detennined, based on the Infion lalon and analysis above and atty supporting documetaslca that the proposed acs WILL NOT result in any significant adverse environmental Impacts. AND provide, on alldwnents as necessary. the reasons supporting deteminafion. Board of Trustees Lev `L Name of Lead Agency Oate 019P^Lf F K,1104-- President Prim or Type name or Hesponsnlle Of&or in Lead Agency Title of Responsible Officer rL~O Si nature of Responsible Officer in Lead Ppency Signature of Preparer (It different from responsible o(ficerJ Board of Trustees Application County of Suffolk State of New York -SoHt-' + SPR (c BEING DULY SWORN DEPOSES AND AFFIRMS THAT HE/SHE IS THE APPLICANT FOR THE ABOVE DESCRIBED PERMIT(S) AND THAT ALL STATEMENTS CONTAINED HEREIN ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF HIS/HER KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF, AND THAT ALL WORK WILL BE DONE IN THE MANNER SET FORTH IN THIS APPLICATION AND AS MAY BE APPROVED BY THE SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF TRUSTEES. THE APPLICANT AGREES TO HOLD THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD AND THE TOWN TRUSTEES HARMLESS AND FREE FROM ANY AND ALL DAMAGES AND CLAIMS ARISING UNDER OR BY VIRTUE OF SAID PERMIT(S), IF GRANTED. IN COMPLETING THIS APPLICATION, I HEREBY AUTHORIZE THE TRUSTEES, THEIR AGENT(S) OR REPRESENTATIVES(S), TO ENTER ONTO MY PROPERTY TO INSPECT THE PREMISES IN CONJUNCTION WITH REVIEW OF THIS APPLICATION. J r~c t 4 1/) tggn re p ~J I SWORN TO BEFORE ME THIS S DAY OF • f 20ij 4Ff SCHROEDER Notary Public lic - State tats of of New York No. 0I SC6249008 blic Qualified in Nov York County My Commission Expires AFFREYSCHROEDER Notary Public - State of New York y Qualified in New York Count Comm y Mission Expires • ]f%s_ Board of Trustees Application AUTHORIZATION (where the applicant is not the owner) p '5Y ~i J~rsi6~ Jlri U~~ /4p f 44" 1, -10~n 8• Nen'N residing at A) 1002y (print owner of property) (mailing address) 1 do hereby authorize FN-- 6ASu Ali JS (Agent) to apply for permit(s) from the Southold Board of Town Trustees on my behalf. (Owners signature) APPLICANT/AGENT/REPRESENTATIVE TRANSACTIONAL DISCLOSURE FORM The Tow. of Southold's Code of Ethics prohibits conflicts of interest on the pert of town officers and employees. The purpose of this form is to provide information which can alert the town of possible conflicts of interest and allow it to take whatever action is n s srvece t avoid same r n q'NIff / YOUR NAME: HEN RY JW fFiU(, 6 S1S L (Lest name, first name, middle initial, unless y 6u are applying in the name of someone else or other entity, such as a company. If so, indicate the other person's or company's name.) NAME OF APPLICATION: (Check all that apply.) Tax grievance Building Variance Trustee Change of Zone Coastal Erosion Approval of plat Mooring Exemption from plat or official map Planning Other (If "Other", name the activity.) Do you personally (or through your company, spouse, sibling, parent, or child) have a relationship with any officer or employee of the Town of Southold? "Relationship" includes by blood, marriage, or business interest. `Business interesr means a business, including a partnership, in which the town officer or employee has even a partial ownership of (or employment by) a corporation in which the town officer or employee owns more then 5% of the shares. YES NO v If you answered "YES", complete the balance of this form and date and sign where indicated. Name of person employed by the Town of Southold Title or position of that person Describe the relationship between yourself (the applicantlagent/representative) and the town officer or employee. Either check the appropriate line A) through D) and/or describe in the space provided. The town officer or employee or his or her spouse, sibling, parent, or child is (check all that apply): _A) the owner of greater than 5% of the shares of the corporate stock of the applicant (when the applicant is a corporation); _B) the legal or beneficial owner of any interest in a non-corporate entity (when the applicant is not a corporation); C) an officer, director, partner, or employee of the applicant; or D) the actual applicant. DESCRIPTION OF RELATIONSHIP Submitted this ay~of ~l r 2042- Signature - Print Name I0 kfiU / F U Form TS 1 • 1319 North Sea Road Southampton, New York 11968 631-283-6360 EN-CONSULTANTS Fax: www.encon631-283-6136 .com sultants.com ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING May 21, 2012 Mark Terry, LWRP Coordinator Planning Board Town of Southold P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Re: John and Sarah Henry, 2440 Village Lane, Orient Dear Mr. Terry: Attached please find a copy of an application that has been filed with the Board of Trustees for a Town Wetlands Permit to permit a legally preexisting dock that has existed in its current location and configuration since the 1950s, as evidenced by online dated aerial photographs readily available to the public. As a result of a violation issued to the owners last fall, the application is being made at this time to legalize several repairs that were made after Tropical Storm Irene, including the replacement of individual storm damaged inside pilings and girders and damaged and/or aging deck boards. Although I understand that a small swinging gate was also added across the width of the catwalk to prevent trespass on the structure (see attached site photos), the completed work can clearly be categorized as "maintenance or repair involving no substantial changes in an existing structure or facili i.e., a "minor action" not subject to waterfront consistency review pursuant to §268-3. Only if the repairs to the dock constituted "replacement, rehabilitation, or reconstruction" requiring a Coastal Erosion Management Permit would waterfront consistency review be required. Therefore, I have not filed an LWRP Consistency Assessment Form with the Trustees. Should you detennine the project is not exempt from waterfront consistency review, however, please let me know and I will file the form with the Trustees and with your office immediately. Respectfully yours, Robert E. Herrmann Coastal Management Specialist cc: Lauren Standish, Board of Trustees • • 1319 North Sea Road Southampton, New York 11968 631-283-6360 EN=CONSULTANTS Fax: www.encon631-283-6136 nts.com suftants.com ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING May 21, 2012 James King, Chairman Board of Trustees Town of Southold MAY 2 3 2G112 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Re: John and Sarah Henry, 2440 Villaee Lane, Orient Dear Mr. King: Last week I submitted an application for a Town Wetlands Permit to permit a legally preexisting dock that has existed in its current location and configuration since the 1950s, as evidenced by historic aerial photographs readily available online. As a result of a violation, the application is being made at this time to legalize several repairs that were made after Tropical Storm Irene, including the replacement and/or repair of several inside pilings and girders and damaged and/or aging deck boards. A small gate was also added inside the parameters of the catwalk to prevent trespass on the structure (see site photos submitted with our application). In response to my application, I received an email from Lauren Standish requesting additional application fees and an application for a Coastal Erosion Management Permit. As I understand that an additional $250 is due on the wetlands permit application because the repairs were conducted without the benefit of a permit, I have enclosed herewith an additional check for $250. Also enclosed are three (3) copies of an updated survey identifying the Coastal Erosion Hazard Area Boundary. To my understanding, however, the completed repairs and similar future repairs clearly fall within the category of "maintenance of structures when normal and customary," i.e., an "unregulated activity" defined by §111-6 as not requiring a Coastal Erosion Management Permit, as "normal maintenance" is defined as the "periodic replacement or repair of same-kind structural elements or protective coatings which do not change the size, design or function of a functioning structure." Such work is differentiated from the "replacement, rehabilitation or reconstruction of a structure," which would require a Coastal Erosion Management Permit for a permanent dock having a top surface area greater than 200 square feet. Therefore, it is our position that a Coastal Erosion Management Permit is not required for the repairs that were conducted after Tropical Storm Irene on the functional dock structure. However, should the Board have information about the work I am not aware of and/or would interpret the nature of the work differently, please let me know and I will act accordingly. R pectfully yours, ' Robert E. Hermann Coastal Management Specialist cc: John Taggart, Esq. • • 1319 North Sea Road Southampton, New York 11968 A-4~ 631-283.6360 Fax: 631-283-6136 EWCONSU LTANTS www.e nconsufants.com ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING May 10, 2012 Lauren Standish Board of Trustees Town of Southold MAY 1 1 2012 P.O Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Re: John and Sarah Henry, 2440 Village Lane. Orient Dear Mrs. Standish: Please find attached an application to permit a preexisting dock for the purpose of making ordinary and routine repairs and maintenance. This application is being made at this time because after Tropical Storm Irene, the Henrys' contractor commenced some simple structural repairs, including the replacement of individual storm damaged inside pilings and girders and damaged and/or aging deck boards. It is my understanding that a violation was issued for the work because although the dock has existed in its current location and configuration on the property since prior to 1955, it is not a permitted structure pursuant to Chapter 275. Please note that because the proposed activity involves only "maintenance or repair involving no substantial changes in an existing structure or facility," the work is defined by §268-3 as a "minor action" not requiring waterfront consistency review pursuant to Chapter 268. Therefore, we are not submitting an LWRP Consistency Assessment Form with this application. Res tfully yours z l,. Robert E. Herrmann Coastal Management Specialist Enclosures