HomeMy WebLinkAboutJamestown City Sd
At-home evaluation comments Page 1 of 3
LGRMIF Grant At-Home Evaluation Form - Comments
• Project Number 0580 -13 -4069
Institution Jamestown City Sd
Category Document Conversion and Access
Average Panel Score 77
Reviewer Susan DeBary
Recommendation M
Recommended Amount $51,335
Total Initial Score 80
1. Statement of the Problem Comments
2. Intended Results Comments
3. Plan of Work Comments
4. Local Government Support Comments
•
5. Budget Narrative and Forms Comments
$5613 for day forward scanning is deducted from the total.
6. Overall Impression Comments
Reviewer Thomas Lynch
Recommendation N
Recommended Amount $0
Total Initial Score 60
1. Statement of the Problem Comments
la&b I don't see an LG-IM filled out for the document scanning. lc Basically funding for local
governments at all levels has been decreased.
2. Intended Results Comments
Why the need for 2 scanners at Erie BOCES. They state one for backfile and one for day forward. Why
• not just buy one, do the backfile then use it for the go forward? I'd like to see some estimated quantities
of student records at Jamestown City School District. I don't see any LG-IM form filled out. Also I
wonder when school districts like this are going to pick uo the ball themselves and run with it. It seems
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/IgReports.do?i=revcomment&gid=4049 :+/9/2012
At-home evaluation comments Page 2 of 3
like LGRMIF has basically funded all their records management program.
• 3. Plan of Work Comments
3c. How many hours a week does Pam Brown the school districts records management coordinator
currently work? They just state part time .5FTE? What is the official relationship since they are asking
for 600 his pay for the grant? A bit odd since she works part time for the school district we don't see
any employee benefits charged to the grant. Basically she'll be working on the grant 33.3 weeks (600
hrs/I8hrs per wk). I don't see any LG-IM form filled out.
4. Local Government Support Comments
I'd like to see a line item in their budgets supporting records management.
5. Budget Narrative and Forms Comments
It's funny I was leaning toward funding this project at some level until I saw they never filled out any
LG-IM forms.
6. Overall Impression Comments
Reviewer Elizabeth Neville
• Recommendation F
Recommended Amount $56,948
Total Initial Score 84
1. Statement of the Problem Comments
2. Intended Results Comments
3. Plan of Work Comments
3.b. They did no address the requirements of the relevant general project category and document
conversion and access category very well. Although, a lot of the information may be listed elsewhere in
the grant application, it should have been reiterated here again. 3.c. They did a good job of naming
individuls with titles, but did nt list any education training. Again, it may be listed elsewhere, but it
should have been reiterated here.
4. Local Government Support Comments
4.a. They could have listed a lot more in this area, i.e. their servers and other hardware, software (not
grant funded) IT Specialists, etc. They did talk about some these things in other parts of application.
• But, again they should have reiteraed it here, too.
5. Budget Narrative and Forms Comments
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/IgReports.do?i=reveomment&gid=4049 5/9/2012
/ At-home evaluation comments Page 3 of 3
Support Staff Salary - Good justification Purchased services - Supplies & Materials -
• 6. Overall Impression Comments
In my opinion, this is a very worthy grant application that should be fully awarded. The fact they have
already successfully shared their EDMS with three (3) other school district gives them a good track
record and recommendation for awarding this application to add two (2) more to the mix.
Reviewer Geof Huth
Recommendation F
Recommended Amount $56,948
Total Initial Score 86
1. Statement of the Problem Comments
2. Intended Results Comments
a. What is the need for different day-forward and backfile conversion scanners for the BOCES?
3. Plan of Work Comments
• b. This subsection does not include a discussion of the shared services requiremetns or the general
requirements for technology grants, though some of this is addressed elsewhere.
4. Local Government Support Comments
5. Budget Narrative and Forms Comments
6. Overall Impression Comments
•
https://eservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/1gReports.do?i=revcomment&gid=4049 5/9/2012
At-Home Rating Summary Page 1 of 5
New LGRMIF Grant At-Home Evaluation Form - Ratings
• starting in Fiscal Year 2011-2012
Project Number 0580 -13 -4069
Institution Jamestown City Sd
Category Document Conversion and Access
Rating Guidelines
Scores Defined Interpretation
5 = Outstanding Applicant addresses the criterion with distinction
4 = Good Applicant has provided a cogent and convincing response to the
criterion
3 = Adequate Applicant has addressed the criterion only competently
2 = Fair Applicant may have addressed the criterion but is far from convincing,
or the project is inherently weak in this regard
1 = Poor Applicant has offered a few words in response to the criterion, but the
words show little to no understanding of the issues
0 = Unresponsive Applicant does not address the criterion directly or indirectly
• Reviewer Susan DeBary
Recommendation M
Recommended Amount $51,335
1. Statement of the Problem (20 Points)
a. Describes the specific records management problem the project will address,
provides qualitative descriptions and quantitative data about the problem and explains 4
why the project is a high priority [10 points] (System will multiply score of 0-5 x 2)
b. Identifies specific records that will be involved, and any previous grant-funded 4
projects related to these records and this project. [5 points]
c. Explains why funding from this grant program is essential to accomplishing the
project (For example, explains why funding is needed if funding was previously 4
awarded for a similar project.) [5 points]
2. Intended Results (15 Points)
a. Identifies each intended result and describes the anticipated benefits [5 points] 4
b. Describes in detail how the project will contribute to the development of a records 4
management program [5 points]
c. Describes in detail how the project will improve local government services to the 4
• public [5 points]
3. Plan of Work (30 points)
https://eservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/IgReports.do?i=revrating&gid=4049 5/9/2012
At-Home Rating Summary Page 2 of 5
a. Provides a detailed outline of the proposed work activities and a timetable showing
• when each phase of the project will be completed, demonstrates the soundness of the
method proposed and demonstrates the project's goals are attainable by 30 June 2013 4
(15 points) (Assign a score of 0-5, as the system will calculate the total value in the
Total Score )
b. Addresses each of the requirements of the relevant project category [10 points] 4
(Assign a score of 0-5, as the system will calculate the total value in the Total Score )
c. Explains who will be responsible for performing each project activity, including
project management. Indicates the qualifications of key project staff (including 4
consultants and vendors) in terms of education, training, and experience (5 points)
4. Local Government Support (10 points)
a. Demonstrates contributions to this project [5 points] 4
b. Describes how this project and records management in general will be maintained 4
over the long tern [5 points]
5. Budget Narrative and Forms (25 points)
a. Explains how the proposed expenditures will be used to support the project activities.
[25 points] (Assign a score of 0-5, as the system will calculate the total value in the 4
Total Score )
• Total At-Home Score 80
Reviewer Thomas Lynch
Recommendation N
Recommended Amount $0
1. Statement of the Problem (20 Points)
a. Describes the specific records management problem the project will address,
provides qualitative descriptions and quantitative data about the problem and explains 3
why the project is a high priority [10 points] (System will multiply score of 0-5 x 2)
b. Identifies specific records that will be involved, and any previous grant-funded 3
projects related to these records and this project. [5 points]
c. Explains why funding from this grant program is essential to accomplishing the
project (For example, explains why funding is needed if funding was previously 3
awarded for a similar project.) [5 points]
2. Intended Results (15 Points)
a. Identifies each intended result and describes the anticipated benefits [5 points] 3
b. Describes in detail how the project will contribute to the development of a records 3
management program [5 points]
• c. Describes in detail how the project will improve local government services to the 3
public [5 points]
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/IgReports.do?i=revrating&gid=4049 5/9/2012
At-Home Rating Summary Page 3 of 5
3. Plan of Work (30 points)
• a. Provides a detailed outline of the proposed work activities and a timetable showing
when each phase of the project will be completed, demonstrates the soundness of the
method proposed and demonstrates the project's goals are attainable by 30 June 2013 3
(15 points) (Assign a score of 0-5, as the system will calculate the total value in the
Total Score )
b. Addresses each of the requirements of the relevant project category [10 points] 3
(Assign a score of 0-5, as the system will calculate the total value in the Total Score )
c. Explains who will be responsible for performing each project activity, including
project management. Indicates the qualifications of key project staff (including 3
consultants and vendors) in terms of education, training, and experience (5 points)
4. Local Government Support (10 points)
a. Demonstrates contributions to this project [5 points] 3
b. Describes how this project and records management in general will be maintained 3
over the long term [5 points]
5. Budget Narrative and Forms (25 points)
a. Explains how the proposed expenditures will be used to support the project activities.
[25 points] (Assign a score of 0-5, as the system will calculate the total value in the 3
• Total Score )
Total At-Home Score 60
Reviewer Elizabeth
Neville
Recommendation F
Recommended Amount $56,948
1. Statement of the Problem (20 Points)
a. Describes the specific records management problem the project will address,
provides qualitative descriptions and quantitative data about the problem and explains 5
why the project is a high priority [10 points] (System will multiply score of 0-5 x 2)
b. Identifies specific records that will be involved, and any previous grant-funded 4
projects related to these records and this project. [5 points]
c. Explains why funding from this grant program is essential to accomplishing the
project (For example, explains why funding is needed if funding was previously 4
awarded for a similar project.) [5 points]
2. Intended Results (15 Points)
a. Identifies each intended result and describes the anticipated benefits [5 points] 4
• b. Describes in detail how the project will contribute to the development of a records 4
management program [5 points]
https://eservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/IgReports.do?i=revrating&gid=4049 5/9/2012
At-Home Rating Summary Page 4 of 5
c. Describes in detail how the project will improve local government services to the 4
• public [5 points]
3. Plan of Work (30 points)
a. Provides a detailed outline of the proposed work activities and a timetable showing
when each phase of the project will be completed, demonstrates the soundness of the
method proposed and demonstrates the project's goals are attainable by 30 June 2013 4
(15 points) (Assign a score of 0-5, as the system will calculate the total value in the
Total Score )
b. Addresses each of the requirements of the relevant project category [10 points] 3
(Assign a score of 0-5, as the system will calculate the total value in the Total Score )
c. Explains who will be responsible for performing each project activity, including
project management. Indicates the qualifications of key project staff (including 3
consultants and vendors) in terms of education, training, and experience (5 points)
4. Local Government Support (10 points)
a. Demonstrates contributions to this project [5 points] 4
b. Describes how this project and records management in general will be maintained 4
over the long term [5 points]
• 5. Budget Narrative and Forms (25 points)
a. Explains how the proposed expenditures will be used to support the project activities.
[25 points] (Assign a score of 0-5, as the system will calculate the total value in the 5
Total Score )
Total At-Home Score 84
Reviewer Geof Huth
Recommendation F
Recommended Amount $56,948
1. Statement of the Problem (20 Points)
a. Describes the specific records management problem the project will address,
provides qualitative descriptions and quantitative data about the problem and explains 5
why the project is a high priority [10 points] (System will multiply score of 0-5 x 2)
b. Identifies specific records that will be involved, and any previous grant-funded 5
projects related to these records and this project. [5 points]
c. Explains why funding from this grant program is essential to accomplishing the
project (For example, explains why funding is needed if funding was previously 4
awarded for a similar project.) [5 points]
• 2. Intended Results (15 Points)
a. Identifies each intended result and describes the anticipated benefits [5 points] 4
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/1gReports.do?i=revrating&gid=4049 5/9/2012
At-Home Rating Summary Page 5 of 5
b. Describes in detail how the project will contribute to the development of a records 4
• management program [5 points]
c. Describes in detail how the project will improve local government services to the 4
public [5 points]
3. Plan of Work (30 points)
a. Provides a detailed outline of the proposed work activities and a timetable showing
when each phase of the project will be completed, demonstrates the soundness of the
method proposed and demonstrates the project's goals are attainable by 30 June 2013 4
(15 points) (Assign a score of 0-5, as the system will calculate the total value in the
Total Score )
b. Addresses each of the requirements of the relevant project category [10 points] 3
(Assign a score of 0-5, as the system will calculate the total value in the Total Score )
c. Explains who will be responsible for performing each project activity, including
project management. Indicates the qualifications of key project staff (including 4
consultants and vendors) in terms of education, training, and experience (5 points)
4. Local Government Support (10 points)
a. Demonstrates contributions to this project [5 points] 4
b. Describes how this project and records management in general will be maintained 4
• over the long term [5 points]
5. Budget Narrative and Forms (25 points)
a. Explains how the proposed expenditures will be used to support the project activities.
[25 points] (Assign a score of 0-5, as the system will calculate the total value in the 5
Total Score )
Total At-Home Score 86
•
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/IgReports.do?i=revrating&gid=4049 5/9/2012
LGRMIF Reviewer Grant Summary Page I of 1
`RW~
Archives Partnershi Trust I Office of Cultural Education I Online Catalog-1 Search I Home
NEW YO R K STATE ARCHIVES
GOESONRECORD
Home Reviewer Home Participation Contact Information At-Home Evaluation Panel Deliberation
Grant Application Information
Project Number Institution Category
0580 -13 -4069 Jamestown City Sd Document Conversion and Access
Fill out an Evaluation Form for this Grant Proposal
Reviews are due by 04/13/2012
When the Evaluation Form for this grant proposal is complete, you may submit it. Once the Evaluation Form
has been submitted, you will NOT be able to update any scores or comments for this grant proposal.
Submit the Evaluation Form
The following links contain information about this grant proposal. The Application Sheet, Project Narrative
(includes Budget Narrative), Project Budget, FS-20, and LG-VQ/LG-IM (when applicable) are in separate
• files. The files are accessible in HTML or PDF format (the files will open in a new window).
Application Sheet - HTML Application Sheet - PDF
Project Narrative - HTML Project Narrative - PDF
Proiect Budget - HTML Project Budget - PDF
LG-VO Form - HTML LG-VO Form - PDF
LG-IM Form - HTML LG-IM Form - PDF
Proposed Budget Summary (FS-20) - HTML Proposed Budget Summary (FS-20) - PDF
Eligible/Ineligible Expenditures & Required Forms - HTML
The following documents were attached to the grant proposal. To download a document, click on the View
link. You must have the appropriate software to open the document type.
Action Document Name Description DoTypeent Size
View amesotwnmagingMicrofilmingForm.pdf School amestown High application/pdf bytes
View Intent Letters.pdf Intent d Services application/pdf byttes
View Shared Services.pdf Shared Services application pdf 109930
bytes
View PVimagingMicrofilmingForm.pdf Pine Valley application pdf 80924
bytes
• Cultural Education Center, Albany, New York 12230. Phone: (518) 474-6926
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/1gReviewer.do?item=grant&id=4049&assign=8059 3/28/2012
LGRMIF Application Sheet Page 1 of 3
Local Government Records Management Improvement Fund (LGRMIF)
• Application Sheet
Project Number 0580 -13 -4069
Institution Jamestown City Sd -
Mailing Address: 197 Martin Rd
Address:
City, State, Zip: Jamestown NY 14701 5397
Chief Administrative Officer: Daniel E Kathman
Title: F Superintendent
Phone: (716)483-4420
Email: dkathman@jamestown.wnyric.org
State Judicial District: 8 State Assembly Districts: 149 150
State Senate Districts: 57 State Congressional Districts: 27
Federal ID: 166001842 School District: Jamestown City Sd
Institution Type: City
NOTE:The institutional information listed above is pulled from the SEDREF database.
SEDREF, the single authoritative source of identifying information about institutions which
the NYS Education Department determines compliance with applicable policy, law and/or
• regulation.
If your institutional information is incorrect, it can only be updated once your Payee
Information Form is received by the Grants Administration Unit and approved by Grants
Finance. Grant Unit staff do not have authority to update SEDREF information.
The applicant cannot edit the SEDREF information above on their own.
Participating Institutions
Ged-Erie 2-Chaut-Catt Boces-Ahse RMO Appointed? Yes
p Year? 2011
Schedule Adopted? Yes
Year? 1989
Pine Valley Csd (South Dayton) rYeao Appointed? Yes
r? 2011
Schedule Adopted? Yes
Year? 1989
NYC Department of
Records and Information false
Services (DORIS) Grant?
oDORIS Agency
• ff(ifapplifcable)
Eligibility Requirements
https://eservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=cover 3/28/2012
LGRMIF Application Sheet. _ Page 2 of 3
IRMO Appointed? IIYes
Year RMO Appointed 2002 •
Appropriate Retention Yes
Schedule Adopted?
Year Schedule was 1989
Adopted
Project Director
Ji4
ame Karen Briner Peterson
Title Director of Human Resources & RMO
Phone 11716-483-4498
Email =Ikpeterson@jamestown.wnyric.org
Records Management Officer (RMO
ame Karen Briner Peterson
Title Director of Human Resources
Phone 11716-483-4498
Email kpeterson@jamestown.wnyric.org
Local Government Information •
County Chautauqua
Region REGION 8
Type School District
De artment/Unit
Population Served 115,400
Annual O eratin Bud et $77,000,000.00
I Number of Employees Full-time:882
Part-time:358
Amount Requested $56,948
Application
Application Type Shared Services
Project Category Document Conversion and Access
Project Type First Time Inventory: false
Electronic Records Inventory: false
Email Management: false
Summary description of proposed project activities: Describe the project, including scope,
objectives, and description of records. The summary should be brief, but should provide a •
clear statement of how you intend to use a LGRMIF grant.
This shared services grant will service Erie 2 BOCES and Pine Valley Central School
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServiet?i=cover 3/28/2012
_ LGRMIF Application Sheet Page 3 of 3
District in sharing the Jamestown City School District's Laserfiche Electronic Document
• Management System (EDMS). This grant application requests funds for Laserfiche licenses,
training, software installation, scanners, and a part-time support staff salary for Jamestown,
Erie 2 BOCES, and Pine Valley. Jamestown City School District needs to bring its high
school guidance department's inactive, permanent student files onto the district's current
EDMS. Erie 2 BOCES needs to bring its active personnel files onto our EDMS and Pine
Valley requires assistance with purging 28 years of student records and preparing these
records for scanning and importing into the EDMS. All three district have a need to improve
office efficiency, reduce costs, and create a disaster recovery system. We believe that in
combining these two school districts with three other school districts that are currently on
the EDMS due to a previous cooperative grant, we can achieve excellence in records
management while sharing costs and creative solutions. Erie 2 BOCES has also agreed to
allow the EDMS containing records from all five districts to be backed up onto its servers
located in Angola. This provides all partners with the assurance of knowing that their
important records are being backed up on three separate systems every evening.
•
https://eservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServiet?i=cover 3/28/2012
LGRMIF Narratives Page 1 of 13
Local Government Records Management Improvement Fund (LGRMIF)
• Project Narratives
Project Number 0580 -13 -4069
Institution Jamestown City Sd -
Ia. Describe records management problem
The Jamestown City School District (JCSD) is an urban school district that serves 5,400 students
in eleven school buildings (six elementary schools, three middle schools, one technology
academy, and one high school) with a district-wide free/reduced lunch qualification rate in excess
of 45%. JCSD is designated as "high need, low resource" by the New York State Department of
Education, indicating that its population has a higher than average need for education and support
services and a critical inability to support this need with the local property tax base. Over 80% of
JCSD's annual budget is provided by state aid, making the financial stability of the district
dependent on a highly political state budgeting process.
JCSD is currently facing a $1.3 million deficit for the 2012-2013 school year. Over the past three
years JCSD has laid off 95 employees, including teachers, teacher aides; and clerical, custodial,
transportation, and food service staff.
JCSD is located in Chautauqua County. The unemployment rate in Chautauqua County as of
December 2011 was 7.9%. There are seventeen school districts, including JCSD, located in
Chautauqua County. Many of these districts are highly dependent on state aid and have suffered
similar or worse financial fates than JCSD. Reduced state aid and a lack of tax revenues to fund
public education in the county have led school districts in this area to find ways to remain
financially solvent while still providing a sound education for their students. For the past six years
JCSD has partnered with neighboring school districts to provide cooperative services in the area
of special education, student transportation, and staff development. This has proven to be a
successful and cost saving partnership.
An additional cooperative relationship was established in 2010 when JCSD applied for a
cooperative grant through the Local Government Records Improvement Fund to enable the JCSD
to share its Electronic Document Management System (EDMS) with three school districts in
Chautauqua County.
The capability of a collaborative effort stems from a 2004-2005 LGRMIF grant which provided
funds to allow JCSD to scan and store more than 1,100 active and 750 inactive personnel files,
equating to 85 cubic feet of records. The installation of the EDMS allowed for simultaneous
access by multiple users, reduced need for storage space, provided greater document security, and
disaster recovery capabilities. The initial EDMS scope of use has expanded to include permanent
superintendents' records, school building architectural drawings, maintenance department
operation manuals, information on the district's seven current and four previous unions going
back to the 1940's, litigation files, board minutes, athletic department historical records, and
archival records of historic value digitized and shared with the local historical society.
The 2010-2011 cooperative grant application resulted in grant funding which allowed JCSD to
purchase EDMS licenses, scanners, and training for Fredonia Central School District, Panama
Central School District, and Southwestern Central School District. Additionally the grant allowed
for JCSD to open the EDMS, originally established to house and manage electronic records of the
district's human resources and payroll departments, to its pupil personnel services department.
• Additional grant funds were awarded for JCSD to purchase three servers to allow for dual, nightly
backups at two separate server locations in the district.
JCSD originally determined that sharing their EDMS was important after inviting area school
districts to send their key records users to a records management training sponsored by JCSD in
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServiet?i=narr 3/28/2012
_LGRMIF Narratives - -=7-- Page 2 of 13
2009. During the training the District's records management director and records management
coordinator heard that tight budgets made records management and the legal requirements •
imposed on governments to be unfunded mandates. It was at this time that JCSD determined that
opening up their EDMS, which was funded in part with LGRMIF dollars, would be a way to help
area districts alleviate some of their records management issues as it was not economically
feasible for the LGRMIF to provide grant funds so that every deserving government has its own
EDMS, especially when looking at smaller school districts.
The 2010-2011 grant allowed JCSD to incorporate the district's Pupil Personnel Department onto
the EDMS. This has allowed for active records to be stored on the EDMS providing multiple users
with simultaneous access, disaster recovery ability, and decreased employee time hunting down
missing records or entire files. It has also allowed for our CSE chair people to access student
files, including IEP's, behavior intervention plans, and functional behavior assessments while
running CSE meetings without having to bring these highly confidential paper records with them
to the various schools they visit in a day.
Although the 2010-2011 grant application was deemed to be a cooperative grant between JCSD
and the three aforementioned school districts, JCSD and the three school districts still maintain an
active relationship. In fact the district's RMO and RMC will be meeting with records
management staff at Fredonia Central School District the second week in April to discuss next
steps for getting another record series onto the system. JCSD's Record Management Coordinator
makes monthly stops at Panama Central and Southwestern Central school districts to assess how
the system is working and to answer any questions or make suggestions to staff using the EDMS.
The on-going relationship with these three districts is reflective of a more permanent shared
services model than that of a more temporary cooperative grant model.
During the fall of 2011 the JCSD hosted a School Records Focus Group created by retired Region
8 RAO Jim Tammaro. At this meeting JCSD showed attendees its EDMS system. Several school
districts in attendance showed great interest in the district's Laserfiche system. One such district
in attendance was Erie 2 - Chautauqua - Cattaraugus Board of Cooperative Educational Services
(Erie 2 BOCES). Since this meeting JCSD has been in frequent communication with Eric 2
BOCES regarding a potential partnership with JCSD. The relationship established with Erie 2
BOCES not only will provide them with access to JCSD's EDMS, but it also has a reciprocal
effect for all districts who use the shared EDMS in that Erie 2 BOCES has agreed to allow JCSD
to use their server system to provide a third backup for their system to improve disaster recovery
abilities in the event of a large-scale disaster. As Erie 2 BOCES has a dual server backup system
located in Fredonia and Angola New York, this provides the much needed geographical separation
between their servers and those of JCSD's.
A second school district originally approached General Code, the JCSD's Laserfiche vendor
located in Rochester, to inquire as to the possibility of obtaining an EDMS. General Code
informed the Pine Valley Central School District that due to its size, the more cost effective
solution for Pine Valley was to obtain access to JCSD's EDMS. As the Pine Valley RMO and the
JCSD RMO worked together at Erie 2 BOCES for many years, there was already a long-standing
professional relationship and Pine Valley asked if they could be incorporated into the JCSD
records management grant application. After meeting with the Pine Valley RMO, Marlene
Przybycien, and Superintendent Peter Morgante, JCSD agreed to take them on as a partner in this
grant application.
a.
Thus, for the 2012-2013 grant year, JCSD is entering into a shared services relationship with Erie
2 BOCES and Pine Valley Central School District while maintaining our permanent relationships
with Fredonia Central School District, Panama Central School District, and Southwestern Central is
School District. The needs of both new partners are vastly different, but can be handled through
JCSD's EDMS. Information regarding each governments' records management issues follows:
Erie 2 - Chautauqua - Cattaraugus Board of Cooperative Educational Services
https://eservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=narr 3/28/2012
LGRMIF Narratives Page 3 of 13 .
Erie 2 BOCES has employees stationed at four campuses and multiple satellite classrooms
• throughout Erie, Chautauqua, and Cattaraugus counties. This BOCES serves a geographic region
of 1,791 square miles and employs approximately 750 full-time employees with an additional 400
employees hired annually on an as-needed basis. They provide programs ranging from career and
technical education, to alternative education, to special education services for 2,500 students.
Erie 2 BOCES has a need similar to the original need of JCSD in 2004. They have multiple users
who need access to personnel and payroll records at the same time. However, Erie 2 BOCES
multiple users issue is compounded by the fact that multiple users maybe in different buildings, in
different towns, and in different counties. Like JCSD they require a records disaster recovery
system, and increased need for storage of active records as well as inactive records.
Although Erie 2 BOCES is not funded through local tax revenues like a typical school district, like
many governments throughout New York, they have also been negatively impacted fiscally from
the downturn in the economy and the previous four state budgets. Declining RWADA (rate
weighted average daily attendance) in Southern Erie and Chautauqua counties at the rate of 8 -
10% have reduced the amount of funding being generated for BOCES educational programs.
Additionally as component school districts' budgets are reduced due to state aid reductions, they
are opting not to participate in some BOCES Coser programs as they have done previously. This
has required Erie 2 BOCES to work with component districts in an attempt to reduce their budget
as well as those of their component districts while still trying to operate a sound educational
system.
The focus of this grant application for Erie 2 BOCES is related to the overwhelming number of
personnel and payroll records of active and inactive employees. The Carrier Educational Center
located in Angola, houses central administrative offices, business and financial services, and
human resources. The Carrier Center houses the personnel and payroll records for all current and
• past employees. This central repository has a secure, active records area and a secure, archival
records room. The active personnel records are kept in locked, legal lateral file cabinets housed in
the personnel department. Inactive personnel files are stored in a locked storage room. There are
243 cubic feet of active and inactive personnel files.
Erie 2 BOCES abides by the New York State Department of Education Records Retention and
Disposition Schedule (ED-1). These personnel files contain all records related to an individual's
employment history with Erie 2 BOLES. They include employment applications, resumes,
appointment letters, probation reports, performance reviews, disciplinary actions, civil service
documents, employee information forms, memoranda, salary notices, general correspondence,
employee health insurance information, and retirement documents.
There are currently five employees in the human resources department who handle these records
on a daily basis. Additionally there are payroll employees in the business office that also must
have access to certain documents in employee personnel files. Personnel records stored on the
EDMS would also allow for the sharing of necessary personnel information with supervisors
located in multiple sites across western New York without have to make copies and send
documents either via fax or school mail.
Erie 2 BOCES receives the majority of its records in paper format, however, there are document
such as fingerprint clearances, teacher certifications, and civil service related documents that are
now generated solely through electronic means.
The current paper system of filing and finding reduces staff efficiency. Increased efficiencies in
personnel file creation and management via an electronic document management system would
enable employees to improve customer service, reduce redundancies, decrease file storage space
and provide a secure backup of files in the event of a disaster.
Pine Valley Central School District
Pine Valley Central School District is a rural school district located near South Dayton. Pine
Valley represents a geographically and economically isolated area. The school district serves
approximately 700 students in an elementary school building and a 7-12 grade junior/senior high
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=narr 3/28/2012
_LGRMIF Narratives Page 4 of 13
school. In addition to rural tax payers, this district's tax base encompasses mainly dairy farms,
two small factories that employ approximately 100 people, and a grocery store. Pine Valley has •
run out of storage for inactive records and currently has no disaster plan. Reductions in staff will
have to occur this year as state aid has not kept up with increasing costs of employee pension
systems, health insurance, and other contractual items. Pine Valley is losing the $200,000 it
received last year in the federal jobs program, which increases its current deficit which must be
made up with higher taxes, program reductions, and employee layoffs.
Currently Pine Valley stores 28 years of inactive student records in a 10'X20' store room. There
is standard metal shelving on two sides of the room going up 18 feet. There are 120 cubic feet of
records stored here with two boxes being stored per shelf. Additional boxes are stored on the
floor and stacked as high as they can safely be stacked while allowing for a two foot walk way.
Due to the location of the district there is great concern about potential for water damage or mouse
infestation, especially during spring and fall seasons.
Due to a lack of funding and lack of available staff, the inactive records have not been properly
handled or purged as required by the ED-I schedule. As inactive student records go back 28
years, there are many records that can and should be purged from the student's file prior to an
importation into an EDMS.
Jamestown High School Guidance Department
During the last JCSD Records Advisory Committee meeting, the Committee determined that it is
:mperative to bring the district's Jamestown High School Guidance Department onto the EDMS.
The Advisory Committee determined that there are several areas of concern for this department's
records management process. Limited appropriate records storage, lack of staffing to handle
records management functions, and ineffective use of JCSD's PowerSchool student data system
were noted as issues that must be handled as a top priority.
Over the past several years JCSD has had to cut clerical staff in order to reduce costs while •
maintaining appropriate student - teacher ratios. The clerical staff at the high school's Guidance
Department was reduced by one full time employee and a second employee was reduced to part-
time. Although staff have been reduced, the overall student population at Jamestown High School
remains the same at 1,500 students.
The high school's Guidance Department currently receives requests for student records in high
volume throughout the school year, with record requests peaking during the college application
submission period. Over the past several years the RMO, who is also the Records Access Officer
and responds to all Freedom of Information requests and records requests made by attorneys, has
seen a dramatic increase in the number of former students requesting their student records in
support of social security disability claims as well as other social service related needs. The high
school Guidance Department clerical staff has also seen a substantial increase in the number of
former students who graduated more than ten years ago, who are requesting their academic and
health records as they are enrolling in colleges and trade schools after losing jobs due to the poor
economy.
The Guidance Department houses current student records in locked lateral file cabinets in the
Guidance Office. They also maintain inactive student records for all students who have left the
district in locked file cabinets also located in the guidance office. These inactive files are kept in
the guidance department for six years. Once the six-year period is reached, the files are relocated
to another bank of filing cabinets located in the basement of the high school. Their relocation to
the basement after six years is imperative due to a lack of space in the Guidance Department.
These cabinets were likely purchased sometime in the 1950's and are difficult to open and close as
rust is beginning to corrode them. When requests for these records are made, one of the clerical
staff must leave the office to go down three flights of stairs to the basement to access these
records. The file must be brought back up to the Guidance Department for photocopying and then
returned to the basement. When the RMO receives a student record request from a law firm or by
court order, a call is placed to the Guidance Department clerical staff and they must either pull the
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=narr 3/28/2012
LGRMIF Narratives Page 5 of 13
records if still located in the department or go to the basement to retrieve the records. These
records must then be photocopied and sent through school mail to the RMO located in the
administration building several miles from the high school. Typically when the RMO receives a
legal request for student records, an inquiry is also placed with the district's Pupil Personnel
Services Department. As current Pupil Personnel Services student records have been brought onto
the EDMS through the district's last records management grant in 2010-2011 for the PPS
Department, obtaining an electronic copy of the records takes seconds and not three to five days as
in the case of the Guidance Department's retrieval time. As time permits the PPS clerical staff
with help from the RMC, continue to scan and store inactive PPS student records onto the EDMS.
In addition to lack of appropriate storage space and lack of staff, there is also currently an
inefficient use of the district's Powerschool electronic student data information system. Currently
at the end of every year certain screen shots and reports are printed out of Powerschool and filed
into individual student files. This is a time consuming process in addition to being an additional
cost to the district in the amount of copy paper that must be purchased to perform this process.
Incorporating the Jamestown High School Guidance Department records onto the EDMS will
provide instant document retrieval for current and inactive records providing greater customer
service to current and former students, will significantly reduce the amount of time clerical staff
must spend daily retrieving records, and will reduce copy paper costs and clerical time as
Powerschool screen shots and reports can be electronically printed into the Laserfiche EDMS
without having to go through the steps of printing out the document and then scanning it into the
system.
Once all active and inactive student records have been incorporated into the EDMS, the Records
Advisory Committee will make a determination whether or not inactive student records will be
destroyed. If destruction is not deemed appropriate by the committee then the inactive records
• will be moved to the district's Records Center in order to remove paper records from the
basement.
lb. Identify records involved
b.
As indicated in the previous section, although all three governments' records management needs
differ, the needs of all three governments can be met through JCSD's EDMS. The governments'
record series to be imported into the EDMS as well as any previous projects is indicated as
follows:
Erie 2 - Chautauqua - Cattaraugus Board of Cooperative Educational Services
Erie 2 BOCES staff will scan and import more than 1,200 current employee personnel files into
the EDMS during the 2012-2013 grant period. This scanning and importing of personnel files can
be done during the grant cycle as JCSD scanned and imported an almost identical number of
personnel and payroll records during their 2004-2005 grant cycle. In addition to scanning and
importing these documents into the EDMS, human resource staff will also visually inspect every
document scanned into the system for 100% accuracy.
Erie 2 BOCES has received LGRMIF grants in the past. A 1990-1991 grant for inventory and
planning (Log No. 0580-91-0282C) was in the amount of $10,000. This funding was used to
organize records encompassing a 50-year time span for two merged BOLES. More than 686
• cubic feet of records were inventoried, which allowed for the disposition of 338 cubic feet of
records. A computer database for easy retrieval of records and disposition dates was also created.
https://eservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServiet?i=narr 3/28/2012
______LGRMIF Narratives _ Page 6 of 13
Another LGRMIF grant was obtained in 1991-1992 (Log No. 0580-92-0289) in the amount of
$30,000. This funding was used to create a facility for central storage of records with a security
system and an improved fire safety system. A records management policy was established and an
increase of staff awareness was created regarding this policy. As a result, the records facility was
completed, the Board of Education adopted a records management policy, and inventoried records
were moved into the facility.
Pine Valley Central School District
With the assistance of JCSD's RMO and RMC, Pine Valley will purge 120 cubic feet of inactive
student records dating from 1983-2010. Pursuant to the ED-1 schedule all records contained in
each student file that have met their retention date will be purged, a destruction list created, and
those records will be disposed of by a shredding vendor. As these records are purged, the
remaining permanent documents remaining in the student file will be scanned and imported into
the JCSD EDMS. Importation of these records will occur with the most recent and most accessed
records being imported in the system first.
Over the past ten years there has been no grant funding requested or obtained through the
LGRMIF.
Jamestown City School District
With the assistance of JCSD's RMC, the records of the two most recent graduating classes will be
sent to the district's Records Center for processing and scanning into the EDMS. Once this batch
is scanned and images verified for 100% accuracy, a second two-year graduating class batch will
be requested and sent over to the Records Center for processing, scanning, and image verification.
Over the past ten years, Jamestown City School District has received several grants through the
LGRMIF. •
In 2000 the district received funding to inventory 1,000 cubic feet of records that were not
inventoried in a previous 1992 grant. In addition, documents were repacked in record cartons and
labeled. A database to facilitate finding documents was created and data was entered.
In 2001 the district received funding to microfilm thirty-five years of Board of Education
minutes. This grant also allowed the district to purchase a microfilm reader/printer.
In 2003 the district received grant funding to hire a consultant to prepare a needs assessment and
feasibility study regarding active records storage in the Administration Building, specifically
focusing on the active records of the Human Resources and Payroll Departments. The study
indicated that an electronic document management system was warranted.
In 2004 the district received funding for three servers, two scanners, and EDMS Laserfiche
licenses for all employees of the Human Resources and Payroll Departments. Additionally grant
funding provided for installation and training as well as assistance in establishing a file structure.
In 2005 the district received funding for preservation of permanent and historical records located
in the Superintendent's Office. Archival quality containers were purchased and the RMC re-
housed, arranged, and described the series and created contain lists and find aids for accessibility.
In 2006 the district received grant funding to preserve and access district architectural drawings
and schematics through digitization to the district's EDMS.
In 2007 the district received funding for an electronic forms component to the EDMS system. •
In 2010 the district received a cooperative grant which allowed for the purchase of three
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=narr 3/28/2012
...LGRMIF Narratives Page 7 of 13
additional servers, five scanners, and EDMS Laserfiche licenses for three partner school districts
• and JCSD's Pupil Personnel Service Department. Grant funding also provided for license
installation and training.
Ic. Explain why funding is essential
c.
Funding through the LGRMIF is imperative. Jamestown City School District is the 19th poorest
school district in New York, however, it does not receive state aid at the 19th highest level and in
fact, has been under funded b $5 million per year for the past three ears. Pine Valley Central
School Distnct as no ability to fund any type of records management solution at this time, nor
the ability to pay extra staff to assist in any type of records management solution. Erie 2 BOCES
has also fallen on tough financial times and there are no additional funds with which to finance a
project of this magnitude.
The LGRMIF has provided funding for JCSD's EDMS system at a total cost over the past seven
years of more than $150,000. None of the districts JCSD is partnering with can afford this type of
money and the LGRMIF cannot afford to award this amount of money to every government who
makes such a request. However, after the initial costs of purchasing scanners and licenses and
providing funding for installation and training through the LGRMIF, these districts can afford the
LSAP (license renewal and maintenance) costs each year which equates to approximately $185
per license.
Erie 2 BOCES submitted a grant application for an EDMS in the 2011-2012 grant cycle. Their
application was denied and after seeing our Laserfiche system, they are pleased that their grant
• application was denied. The cost of the EDMS they selected and the funding required to have a
third-party vendor scan and import their data equated to over $100,000. It is very apparent that
sharing the JCSD's EDMS makes fiscal and logistical sense.
IIa. Intended results/anticipated benefits
a.
The intended results of this shared services grant project are as different as the three governments
involved, although the solution is the same for each government.
The Erie 2 BOCES during the grant cycle will scan and import all active personnel files into the
EDMS. These records will be verified for 100% accuracy by Human Resources Department staff
who are familiar with these records. With the assistance of JCSD's RMO and RMC, we will
create our active personnel file structure. By using JCSD's Laserfiche system, there is no need for
creating indexes or barcoded targets. We will use JCSD Human Resources staff as a resource
when making decisions to establish our own file folder structure.
A Canon DR-6030 C Scanner and a Fujitsu fi-6240 scanner will be purchased. The Canon will be
used for backfile conversion while the Fujitsu will be used for some of the day forward scanning.
The conversion to an EDMS solution with increase office efficiency on a daily basis by providing
immediate access to information contained in active personnel files. Efficiency equates to better
customer service for our customers who are our employees. The implementation of this paperless
system will reduce operational costs in the long-term by reducing labor, supplies, storage needs,
and clerical needs for records management. In addition, these vital records will be secured,
preserved, and protected in the event of disaster.
Pin-_ e_V Pn ral School District with the assistance of JCSD's RMO and RMC will purge all
inactive student files. Purged records will be placed on a destruction list and disposal of these
documents will be done pursuant to New York State Archives guidelines.
Once purged, all remaining records of long to permanent retention will be scanned and stored in
https://eservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=narr 3/28/2012
LGRMIF Narratives _ Page 8 of 13.
the EDMS. JCSD staff will work with Pine Valley staff to develop an inactive student record file
structure that is appropriate for the district. The JCSD RMC will assist Pine Valley in scanning •
these permanent student records into the EDMS.
This process will allow for easier access to student records and improved turn around when
student records are requested, thus improving customer service. This grant project will reduce the
amount of storage space required and provide a disaster recovery strategy.
The Jamestown City School District with the assistance of its RMC will begin scanning the two
most recent graduation c asses m o t e EDMS. As the district is familiar with setting up file
structure in the Laserfiche system, such a process will take very little time with the main focus on
scanning documents and verifying accuracy of these documents at 100%.
The importing of inactive student records into the EDMS will provide greater customer service to
the district's former students. It will also reduce the amount of space needed for inactive records
and allow the district to discard old, rusted file cabinets. The implementation of this grant will
also provide for a disaster recovery option. With backups of stored data occurring every evening
and being stored on three separate sets of servers with 25 to 40 mile separations is a far more
favorable scenario to maintaining paper records in rusted file cabinets in the basement of a high
school built one hundred years ago.
The benefits to all three governments are improved customer service, reduced personnel time in
finding documents, a more secure environment for confidential documents, reduced need for
storage space, and a disaster recovery option.
IIb. Contribution to development of records management program
b. •
The contributions to dividual school districts' records management programs is
immeasurable. T4rOCSD EDMS is an expanding system. Once licenses and scanners are
purchased, training is done, and systems are established, this system can be used for all other
records series that require longer or permanent retention dates.
The contribution to these districts' records management program is furthered by the fact that as
districts want to i ' e in other modul form records a ement or
wor ow components the can do so. JCSD has been using the electronic forms module for
SCVcrai years. ey have i"pited the ED-1 schedule into the Laserfiche Records Management
Module and are currently assigning retention dates electronically. Participating districts will have
access to this technology as well, through these Laserfiche licenses and as their understanding of
the system increase and their sophistication improves, they will have the ability to further improve
their records management programs with the use of these additional modules. Additional benefits
to individual records management programs will also occur as users of this system meet locally to
share ideas and learn more about what the system can do.
Ile. Contribution of Service to the public
C.
All three governments provide services to the public and to customers. Our customers are
students, students' parents, our employees, and our taxpayers. The EDMS allows for easier and
faster access to student and personnel records. It prevents the mishaps of spilled coffee on an
original document. It prevents the loss or misplacing of important documents. It allows for
documents to be sent electronically when possible. As these governments use the EDMS to store •
and access more record series, more benefits to these governments' customers will be realized.
https://eservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=narr 3/28/2012
WPMIF Narratives Page 9 of 13
IIIa. Detailed outline/timetable for project
• Plan of Work
The three participants in this shared services grant application have used September 1, 2012, as a
reasonable target in beginning this project in light of the recent history of delayed grant
acceptance notice. However, the grant timetable can be moved to a July 1 or August 1 start date if
funding notices are sent out in July of 2012.
September 1 - September 15, 2012
Project Manager, RMC, and RMO's of participating governments meet to discuss the grant award
and availability to have the Laserfiche vendor, General Code come into the districts to install
Laserfiche software and the ScanConnect software. Discuss timetable with Pine Valley for RMC
to aid in purging files prior to the scanning process.
Contact General Code to inform them of the grant award and to determine availability of staff to
install licenses and perform training.
Contact Gail Fishcer, RAO Region 8 to discuss the grant award.
Place add in local newspapers to notify of bid requests for the scanners.
September 15 - 30, 2012
Review scanner bids and determine lowest bidder. Place order for scanners.
RMC and Pine Valley RMO begin purging inactive student record files.
Meet with superintendents and RMOs of Pine Valley and Erie 2 BOCES to discuss the contract
establishing rules of use of the JCSD EDMS
October 1- October 31, 2012
RMC and Pine Valley RMO purge inactive student records
Meet with Erie 2 BOCES to discuss personnel file structure
General Code on-site at Jamestown (High School Guidance Department), Pine Valley, and Erie 2
BOCES (Angola office) to install Laserfiche licenses.
General Code to hold two days of training on the use of the Laserfiche system at Erie 2 LoGuidice
Center as it is centrally located to all three districts.
Sign contracts with superintendents and submit to New York State Archives for review and
approval.
November 1 -November 30, 2012
RMC and Pine Valley RMO purge inactive student records
Scanners are installed and individual district technology departments assist with installation of
scanners while General Code staff remote into system to finalize ScanConnect License.
JCSD RMO and RMC work with Erie 2 BOCES staff on setting up file structure.
December 1 - December 31. 2012
RMC and Pine Valley RMO purge inactive student records
Erie 2 BOCES continues scanning personnel files
RMC works with Jamestown High School Guidance staff to develop file structure
January 1 - January 31, 2013
RMC and Pine Valley scan inactive student files
Erie 2 BOCES continues scanning personnel files
Meet with Region 8 RAO Gail Fischer to update on grant status
Jamestown High School Guidance staff scan inactive student files
February 1 - Feburarv 28, 2013
RMC and Pine Valley RMO scan inactive student files
Erie 2 BOCES continues scanning personnel files
Jamestown High School Guidance staff scan inactive student files
March 1 - March 31, 2013
RMC and Pine Valley RMO scan inactive student files
Erie 2 BOCES continues scanning personnel files
https://eservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=narr 3/28/2012
LGRMIF Narratives Page 10 of 13
Jamestown High School Guidance staff scan inactive student files
April 1 - April 30, 2013 •
RMC and Pine Valley RMO scan inactive student files
Erie 2 BOCES continues scanning personnel files
Jamestown High School guidance staff scan inactive student files
Meet with Region 8 RAO Gail Fisher and General Code staff for training and to answer questions
about system
May 1 -May 31, 2013
RMC and Pine Valley RMO scan inactive student files
Erie 2 BOCES continues scanning personnel files
Jamestown High School Guidance staff scan inactive student files
June 1 - June 15, 2013
RMC and Pine Valley RMO scan inactive student files
Erie 2 BOCES continues scanning personnel files
Jamestown High School Guidance staff scan inactive student files
June 15-June 30, 2013
Meet with Pine Valley and Erie 2 BOCES separately to discuss grant results
Meet with Jamestown High School Guidance Department staff to discuss grant results
Prepare final reports
IIIb. Requirements of relevant project category
b.
As part of the initial set of meetings with the governments, JCSD personnel will discuss and
establish the process needed to prepare records for scanning with the individual governments'
RMO's. Discussion will include removal of paper clips and staples, file structure, and naming
conventions for document types. Discussion will also occur about how scanner settings should be
adjusted as needed depending on whether the document is in black and white, color, or should be
scanned in gray scale. Discussion will also include how to change the document size variance on
the scanners once they arrive. Currently JCSD owns one of each of the scanners that are being
purchased for this grant and can instruct using this equipment.
Using the current JCSD Laserfiche EDMS we will train participating governments' employees,
who will be working with the system, on how to scan and review documents and what to do if
rescans need to be done.
Because this software allows considerable flexibility in establishing file structure, there is no need
for barcodes, targets, or indexing. JCSD will discuss naming conventions and describe best
practices.
Laserfiche software abides by the imaging guidelines of New York State Archives as referenced
in the Archives' Imaging Production Guidelines. Laserfiche software also meets Department of
Defense guidelines for security.
Illc. Responsible parties and qualifications
c.
Karen Briner Peterson is the Director of Human Resources, Records Management Officer and
Records Access Officer for Jamestown City School District will be the Project Manager and will
communicate directly with Ms. Brown, Ms. Young and Ms. Przybycien. •
Pam Brown, the Jamestown City School District's part-time Records Management Coordinator
will assist the Jamestown High School Guidance Department and the Pine Valley Central School
District staff. Ms. Brown will also be working hands on with staff from the Jamestown High
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=narr 3/28/2012
_____LGRMIF Narratives Page 11 of 13
School and Pine Valley to purge and scan documents. Although Pine Valley has 120 cubic feet of
• records, ninety percent of these documents have met their retention and once purged and
destructions lists created can be destroyed. This leaves a very small number, approximately 17
cubic feet of records to scan.
JCSD's previous grant in which they worked with Fredonia Central School District to purge
inactive student files and scan only those of lengthy or permanent retention resulted in a 90%
reduction in actual documents that needed to be scanned into the system.
Jean Young, RMO for Erie 2 BOCES will be the Project Director for her government and the
contact for JCSD's RMO and RMC. Ms. Young will have decision making ability for Erie 2
BOCES regarding the Laserfiche file structure.
Marlene Przybycien, Business Official and RMO for Pine Valley will be the Project Director for
her respective government. Ms. Young will work with clerical staff to assist in purging records
and readying documents for scanning. Ms. Young will have decision making ability for Pine
Valley regarding the Laserfiche file structure.
4. IVa. Contributions demonstrated
All three governments will be making great contributions to the completion of this project. After
numerous meetings with Erie 2 BOCES they determined that the best way for their staff to learn
and understand the Laserfiche system is for the Human Resources staff to do the backfile
conversion with advice from JCSD's RMO and RMC. Jamestown originally did all of their
backfile conversion and although required considerable time and dedication, it resulted in a much
better understanding of the system and how it could be used then if the district had hired an
outside vendor to scan and import the documents.
. Pine Valley Central School District will be using two clerical staff from the administrative office
to help purge inactive student records and ready them for scanning. With the supervision of
JCSD's RMC the two clerical staff will scan and verify images concurrently. Pine Valley will
also pay for the costs to have the purged records shredded by a shredding company pursuant to
New York State Archives guidelines.
Jamestown City School District will have their RMC work with the Jamestown High School
Guidance clerical staff to ready and scan inactive student files. The RMC will do this as a part of
her part-time position with Jamestown City School District.
The Jamestown City School District's RMO and RMC will hold meetings and make site visits to
the two districts and will be available to answer questions or assist. The Jamestown City School
District will pay for the advertising of bid specifications for the scanner bid. In the 2010
cooperative grant, JCSD was not able to find a vendor who carried both Canon and Fujitsu
scanners at an affordable rate and found that the minimal cost of $50 to publish a bid request
resulted in a vendor who could provide both with a reduced price and free shipping. JCSD
anticipates doing this again.
IVb. Program Maintenance
JCSD, while running this grant will also still maintain its relationship with the other three school
districts also sharing the EDMS. It is anticipated with five districts that a procedure manual and
policy will be created and that meetings can be held between all six governments at least three
times a year to discuss best practices for electronic document management.
. As Laserfiche is an expanding system, JCSD stands ready to assist these governments as they
continue forward to incorporate more record series onto the system as we are currently doing with
Fredonia, Southwestern, and Panama Central School Districts.
There are already plans for all five districts to attend the July 18, 2012 Disaster Preparedness
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=narr 3/28/2012
LGRMIF Narratives Page 12 of 13
presentation being made by Region 8 RAO Gail Fischer in order to work together as a group on
how to handle disasters that would impact our electronic and paper records. •
Professional Salaries
Support Staff Salaries
The Jamestown City School District currently employs a .5 FTE (part-time) Records Management
Coordinator. Ms. Pam Brown was instrumental in assisting the RMO in establishing the
Laserfiche EDMS file structure as well as instrumental in helping to create the protocols and
naming conventions for scanning and storing records into the EDMS. Ms. Brown has worked
with Fredonia, Southwestern, and Panama Central School Districts in establishing their structures
and protocols when they joined the district's EDMS in the 2010-2011 grant.
Pine Valley Central School District has 28 years of inactive student records that have not been
purged. There are currently 120 cubic feet of inactive student records located at Pine Valley. Ms.
Brown had helped Fredonia with a similar issue in purging the records, creating destruction lists,
and scanning the documents into the EDMS. Ms. Brown will be providing assistance equaling
400 hours of time to help Pine Valley purge files, create destruction lists and help scan and verify
images for accuracy. She will be working in conjunction with 2 clerks located in the Pine Valley
administrative offices. Ms. Brown will put in 18 hours per week for 22 weeks in order to purge
the files, prepare them for scanning, and scan and verify images. This 18 hours per week for 22
weeks is based on 1,000 sheets per hour in purging files. As the high speed scanner that will be
used for the scanning scans at 60 sheets per minute should allow for 2,400 images per hour to be •
scanned and named pursuant to an agreed upon naming convention. Additional time will be
required to verify images at 300 pages per hour. Ms. Brown will spend 200 hours of time doing
similar tasks for Jamestown City School District. She will be working in conjunction with 1 clerk
to scan and name inactive student records. However, these files have already been purged
pursuant to the ED-1 schedule and will not require as much assistance as Pine Valley Central
School District.
Equipment
Minor Remodeling
Purchased Services
Jamestown City School District has used General Code as the vendor for its Laserfiche system
since 2004. General Code staff will come out to install 25 licenses at three separate locations in
three separate counties. The installation will take 2 days. While they are installing Laserfiche
licenses and Scan Connect licenses they will also do two separate days of training with all three
staffs at the Erie 2 BOCES LoGuidice Center in Fredonia. We will reserve one day of training for
later on in the grant year so that more complex concepts can be explained after users have become
familair with the system.
•
Purchased Services - BOCES
https://eservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=narr 3/28/2012
LGRMIF Narratives Page 13 of 13
• Supplies and Materials
Jamestown City School District is requesting funding for 25 Laserfiche licenses. The Erie 2
BOCES requires 15 licenses due to number of staff employeed in the Human Resources and
Payroll Departments as well as licenses needed for the Human Resources Director and two
assistant superintendents. Pine Valley requires 3 Laserfiche licenses for staff using the system.
Jamestown requires 7 licenses for two clerical staff and five guidance counselors. The district
must also purchase 2 Scan connect licenses for Pine Valley and Erie 2 BOCES as each district
must have a license in order to connect scanners to the system.
The district is requesting funding for 2 Canon high speed color duplex scanners. One will be
provided to Erie 2 BOCES due to the huge backfile conversion of active personnel records. The
second high speed scanner will be used to help complete the backfile conversion for Pine Valley
and Jamestown High School Guidance Department. Once the scanner is no longer needed for the
backfile, the District will loan it to any of the participating districts who need to borrow it. The
district is also requesting funding for three Fujitsu flatbed scanners to be provided to Erie 2
BOCES, Pine Valley, and the Jamestown High School Gudiance Department to aid in scanning
documents of unusual sizees and depths.
Travel
• Employee Benefits
Final Project Narrative
•
https://eservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=narr 3/28/2012
LGRMIF Project Budget Page 1 of 3
Local Government Records Management Improvement Fund (LGRMIF)
• Project Budget
Project Number 0580 -13 -4069
Institution Jamestown City Sd -
Professional Staff Expenses
Support Staff Expenses
Name Position/Title Rate of Pay Hours Worked
Records
Pam Brown Management $15.00 600.0
Coordinator
Inst'l Contrib. AmtRequested AmtAwarded ExpSubmitted ExpApproved
$0 $9,000 $0 $0 $0
Support Staff Totals
Inst Contrib. AmtRequested AmtAwarded ExpSubmitted ExpApproved
0 $9,000 $0 $0 $0
Equipment Expenses
Minor Remodeling
Purchased Services Expenses
Service Type Service Provider/Name of BOCES Calculation of Cost
Software
Installation & General Code 5 X $1,500
'Graining
Inst'l Contrib. AmtRequested AmtAwarded ExpSubmitted ExpApproved
$0 $7,500 $0 $0 $0
Purchased Service Totals
Inst Contrib. AmtRequested AmtAwarded ExpSubmitted ExpApproved
0 $7,500 $0 $0 $0
i Purchased BOCES Services Expenses
https://eeervices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=budget&a--true 3/28/2012
LGRMIF Project Budget Page 2 of3
Supplies, Materials Expenses •
Quantity Description Unit Price Vendor
25 Laserfiche $1,139.00 General Code
Licenses
Inst'l Contrib. AmtRequested AmtAwarded ExpSubmitted ExpApproved
$0 $28,475 $0 $0 $0
Quantity Description Unit Price Vendor
2 Laserfiche Scan $205.00 General Code
Connect Licenses
Inst'l Contrib. AmtRequested AmtAwarded ExpSubmitted ExpApproved
$0 $410 $0 $0 $0
Quantity Description Unit Price Vendor
Cannon DR 6030-
2 C Color Duplex $2,975.00 Scanner Solutions
Scanner
Inst'l Contrib. AmtRequested AmtAwarded ExpSubmitted ExpApproved
$0 $5,950 $0 $0 $0
Quantity Description Unit Price Vendor
Fujitsu fi-6240
3 Color Duplex $1,871.00 Scanner Solutions
Scanners
Inst'l Contrib. AmtRequested AmtAwarded ExpSubmitted ExpApproved
$0 $5,613 $0 $0 $0
Supplies, Materials Totals
Inst Contrib. AmtRequested AmtAwarded ExpSubmitted ExpApproved
0 $40,448 $0 $0 $0
Travel Expenses
Employee Benefit Expenses
Name Benefits Percentage
Pam Brown 0
Inst'l Contrib. AmtRequested AmtAwarded ExpSubmitted ExpApproved
$0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Employee Benefits Totals
Inst Contrib. AmtRequested AmtAwarded ExpSubmitted ExpApproved
$0 $0 $0 $0 $0
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=budget&a=true 3/28/2012
LGRMIF Project Budget Page 3 of 3
Grand Total
• Inst Contrib. AmtRequested AmtAwarded ExpSubmitted ExpApproved
$0 $56,948 $0 $0 $0
i
https://eservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServiet?i=budget&a=true 3/28/2012
LGRMIF Vendor Quote Form Page 1 of 1
• Local Government Records Management Improvement Fund (LGRMIF)
Vendor Quote Form
Project Number 0580 -13 -4069
Institution Jamestown City Sd -
Vendor Quote Form
Preferred Sole Quoted Selected
Vendor Description of Item or Service Fcoziact# Vendor Source LGPR Price Quote
Vendor
District has used Laserfiche
through General Code since
2004. No other vendor in the
area. Vendor providing
Laserfiche licenses at a cost of
General $28,475 for Laserfiche Rio true true false $28,475 false
Code licenses and $410 for the two
required Scan Connect licenses.
General Code is also charging
$1,500 per day for 2 days of
installation and 3 days of
trainin .
0
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/PrintAppServlet?i=vq 3/28/2012
FS-20 Form Page 1 of 2
The University of the State of New York PROPOSED BUDGET SUMMARY FOR A
• THE STATE EDUCATION DEPARTMENT FEDERAL OR STATE PROJECT
(see instructions for mailing address) FS-20 (02/07)
Project Number: 0580 -13 -4069
Funding Source: Local Government Records Management Improvement
Fund
Report Prepared By: Karen Briner Peterson
Name of Applicant: Jamestown City Sd
Mailing Address: 197 Martin Rd
City, State: Jamestown NY 14701 5397
Telephone#: County: Chautauqua
E-Mail Address: kpeterson@jamestown.wnyric.org
Project Funding Dates: Start 7/1/12 End 6/30/13
INSTRUCTIONS
Submit the original FS-20 Budget Summary, and 3 copies, all with signatures in blue ink, along
with the completed application directly to the appropriate State Education Department office as
• indicated in the application instructions for the grant program for which you are applying. DO
NOT submit this form to the Grants Finance.
Please submit the FS-20 Budget Summary as a two page form (not back-to-back on a single sheet).
Enter whole dollar amounts only. The amounts must agree with the budget category totals from
each Budget Category and Narrative Form.
For changes in agency or payee address contact the State Education Department office indicated on
the application instructions for the grant program for which you are applying.
An approved copy of the FS-20 Budget Summary will be returned to the contact person noted
above. A window envelope will be used; please make sure that the contact information is accurate,
legible and confined to the address field.
For information on budgeting, including 2005-06 REVISED guidelines for equipment and
supplies, refer to the Fiscal Guidelines for Federal and State Aided Grants at
www.oms.nysed.gov/cafe/.
•
https:Heservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/FsFonnServlet?i=fs20 3/28/2012
FS-20 Form _ Page 2 of 2
BUDGET SUMMARY
Ank
CATEGORIES CODE PROJECT Agency Code 061700010000
COSTS Project # 0580 -13 -4069
Professional Salaries 15 $0.00 Contract #
Support Staff Salaries 16 $9,000.00 Agency Name Jamestown City Sd
Purchased Services 40 $7,500.00
Supplies and 45 $40,448.00
Materials For Department Use Only
Travel Expenses 46 $0.00 Approved 7/1/ 12 6/30/13
Employee Benefits 80 $0.00 Funding Dates:
BOCES Services 49 $0.00
Minor Remodeling 30 $0.00 From To
Equipment 20 $0.00 Program Approval: -
Grand Total $56,948.00
Date: - -
CHIEF ADMINISTRATOR'S CERTIFICATION Fiscal Year First Payment Line#
I hereby certify that the requested budget amounts are
necessary for the implementation of this project and that this
agency is in compliance with applicable Federal and State laws
and regulations.
Date Signature
Name and Title of Chief Administrative Officer
Daniel E Kathman, Superintendent Voucher# First Payment
Finance: Log: Approved: MIR:
•
https://eservices.nysed.gov/ldgrants/FsFormServiet?i=fs20 3/28/2012
Local Government Records Management Improvement Fund
.Imaging and Microfilming Project Information Form (IG-Ill
LOCAL GOVERNMENT NAME j
Jamestown High School !1
ACTIVITIES (CHECX ALL THAT APPLY) E
IMAGING. MICROFILMING
Q PAPER DOCUMENTS TO DIGITAL IMAGE ? PAPER DOCUMENTS TO MICROFILM
? MICROFILM IMAGES TO: DIGITAL IMAGE ? DIGITAL IMAGES. TO MICROFILM
? DIGITAL DOCUMENTS TO DIGITAL IMAGE
RECORDS DESCRIPTION
NAME. OF RECORDS SERIES RETENTION PERIOD (YEARS)
Student Accumulative Record Permanent
DATE RANGE OF RECORDS RECORDS SCHEDULE (NAME AND ITEM NUMBER)
1990-20_10 275 a
TOTAL NUMBER OF IMAGES Explain in the narrative any discrepancies between the number of
42,000 images and the number of pages.
Format of use copies: ?t iazo or vesicular microfilm ? Digital images Number of original rolls: 16mm 35mm
CHARACTERISTICS
ELECTRONIC DATA. ? Digital Images ? Other electronic. formats (such as word processing files)
DOCUMENT SIZE. 11 X 17
PAPER TYPE card stock
PAPER CONDITION. good
IMPRINT
PAPER COLOR buff
FASTENERS staples
OUENCY OF FASTENERS consistent
RETRIEVAL
NUMBER OF REFERENCES REFERENCES NEEDING CCPIES' 100%
RETRIEVAL URGENCY ? Immediate Q Within 1 day ? Within 1 week
q
t
- - - -
0µ. York SIatz Amh,,,
Perm LGIh7 fl;?E~tb3
Local Government Records Management Improvement Fund
~maging and Microfilming Project Information Form (LG-IM)
LOCAL: GOVERNMENT NAME
Pine Valley
-a...__°.
AC NITIES (CHECK ALL THAT APPIV}
IMAGING MICROFILMING
PAPER .DOCUMENTS TO DIGITAL IMAGE ? PAPER DOCUMENTS TO MICROFILM
? MICROFILM IMAGES TO 0401TAL IMAGE ? DIGITAL IMAGES TO MICROFILM
? DIGITAL DOCUMENTS TO DIGITAL IMAGE
RECORDS DESCRIPTION
NAME OF RECORDS SERIES RETENTION PERIOD {YEARS}
Student Accumulative Record Permanent
DACE RANGE OF RECORDS RECORDS SCHEDULE (NAME AND ITEM NUMBER)
1983-2010 275 a
TOTAL NUMBER OF IMAGES Explain in the narrative any discrepancies between the number of.
6,720 images and the number of pages
Format of use copies: ?Dlazo or vesicular microfilm ? Digital images Number of original rolls: 16mm 35mm
CHARACTERISTICS
ELECTRONIC DATA E] Digital images ? Other electronic formats (such as word processing flies)
DOCUMENT SIZE. 11 X 17
PAPER TYPE Card Stock
PAPER CONDITION. good
IMPRINT
PAPER COLOR: buff
FASTENERS: Staples 3
OUENCY OF FASTENERS: consistent 3
RETRIEVAL
NUMBER OF REFERENCES REFERENCES NEEDING COPIES- 100%
RETRIEVAL URGENCY ? immediate [D Within 1 day ? Within 1 week
ON,,, York S!:a: drcts*eI,rm LG-Iht 91200
02/29/2012 10:29 7169883243 PINE VALLEY PAGE 02/02
•
February 29, 2012
New York State Education Department
New York State Archives
Grants Administration Unit
Cultural Education Center
Room 9A81
Albany, New York 12230
Re: Records Management Partnership
To whom it may concern:
• Please let this correspondence serve as notice of the intent of Pine Valley Central School District
to enter into a partnership with the Jamestown City School District to participate in their
Electronic Document Management System.
We are in agreement with Jamestown City School District that as the lead agency on this grant
application, they will provide installation of EDMS software licenses, training to appropriate
staff, and support and best practices on creation of electronic record file structure, importing
records into the system, establishing security protocols, and development of policies and
procedures. In this regard the Pine Valley Central School District agrees to provide time for
necessary staff to attend trainings and meet with Jamestown records management staff to
customize the EDMS for our district's particular records management needs. Pine Valley will
also provide staff time to help import the pertinent records series indicated in the grant
application.
We look forward to a long term partnership with Jamestown City School District.
Sincerely,
Peter Morgante
• Superintendent
ERIE 2 - CHAUTAUQUA - CATTARAUGUS Camer Educational Center
Angola, Erie Road
Board of Cooperative Educational Services 8685
184 - T Newyork k 1 14006-9621
(716)549-4454 FAX(716)549-1758
Central Administrative Offices (800) 228-1184 -Toll Free in 716 area code
January 12, 2012
New York State Education Dept.
State Archives
9A81 Cultural Education Center
Albany, NY 12230
To Whom It May Concern:
The Erie 2 - Chautauqua-Cattaraugus BOLES supports the Local Government Records Management
Improvement Fund Grant application to include its partnership with the Jamestown City School District
as the Local Educational Agency. As the LEA, it is understood that Jamestown will provide initial
technical support for the software program, import records to the server housed in Jamestown and
provide training as necessary.
The benefits to the Erie 2 - Chautauqua-Cattaraugus BOCES will be to eliminate the need for the
transfer of paper copies within its large geographic region; electronically archive documents as they
occur; and create a system of document storage retrieval for departmental use on an as needed secure
basis.
The partnership with Jamestown will allow BOCES to effectively continue to archive records without
limitation due to the size of the server housed in Jamestown. Such a prospect may ultimately allow the
BOCES to service districts in a similar capacity, therefore leveraging the investment.
Given, that Jamestown has demonstrated success and expertise in the transmission and archiving of
electronic documents; has partnered with other districts within our region and has provided significant
evidence of quality software usage, the Erie 2 - Chautauqua - Cattaraugus BOCES wishes to enter into a
partnership with the Jamestown City School District by utilizing funds acquired through the Local
Government Records Management Improvement Fund Grant to meet the objectives identified here and
in the grant proper.
Sinf.yrely,
Robert Olczak, Ed.D.
Interim District Superintendent
Erie 2 Chautauqua - Cattaraugus BOLES
• Cc: Daniel Kathman
LGRMIF Grant Cooperative/Shared Services Agreement Form
• Sponsoring Institution: Jamestown City Sd
Project Number: 0580 -13 4069
I hereby give assurance to the New York State Education Department that the
undersigned supports the enclosed application and will cooperate to the extent described
in the attached application. All records management project outcomes that are a direct
result of the support provided by funds from the State are, or will be, made available for
on-site examination.
Participating Local l
Government Institution: t7~r/
Date: a3 Signed:
(n
Chief Administrative -
Officer Print Name:
t~0 /3~r: i :D CAL Cz,~/t
Instructions
The Cooperative/Shared Services Agreement Form must be printed and signed by each
participating institution of your project. Then scan the signed form(s) and upload the form(s) to
your application as an attachment. Please use "Co Agreement" or "SS Agreement" as the
description for your attachment.
'For applicants who do not have access to a scanner, please fax the document to (518) 486-
1647 or mail it to:
New York State Archives
Grants Administration Unit
9A81 Cultural Education Center,
Albany, NY 12230
•
LGRMIF Grant Cooperative/Shared Services Agreement Form •
Sponsoring Institution: Jamestown City Sd
Project Number: 0580 -13 -4069
I hereby give assurance to the New York State Education Department that the
undersigned supports the enclosed application and will cooperate to the extent described
in the attached application. All records management project outcomes that are a direct
result of the support provided by funds from the State are, or will be, made available for
on-site examination.
Participating Local
Government Institution:
Date: ~~d, 7 Z Si e
Chief Administrative •
Officer Print Name: I e -tfe, M 0(_ 4 ri te,
Instructions
The Cooperative/Shared Services Agreement Form must be printed and signed by each
participating institution of your project. Then scan the signed form(s) and upload the form(s) to
your application as an attachment. Please use "Co Agreement" or "SS Agreement" as the
description for your attachment.
'For applicants who do not have access to a scanner, please fax the document to (518) 486-
1647 or mail it to:
New York State Archives
Grants Administration Unit
9A81 Cultural Education Center,
Albany, NY 12230
•
t tL:: i~,•.nil_::o~n
• LGRMIF Grant Cooperative/Shared Services Agreement Form
Sponsoring Institution: Jamestown City Sd
Project Number: 0580 -13 -4069
I hereby give assurance to the New York State Education Department that the
undersigned supports the enclosed application and will cooperate to the extent described
in the attached application. All records management project outcomes that are a direct
result of the support provided by funds from the State are, or will be, made available for
on-site examination.
Participating Local
Government Institution:
Date: Signed: ` 1 _ _ - -
Chief Administrative
• Officer Print Name:
b/ayiE L c.. X tJ 71/M41V
Instructions
The Cooperative/Shared Services Agreement Form must be printed and signed by each
participating institution of your project. Then scan the signed fort(s) and upload the form(s) to
your application as an attachment. Please use "Co Agreement" or "SS Agreement" as the
description for your attachment.
*For applicants who do not have access to a scanner, please fax the document to (518) 486-
1647 or mail it to:
New York State Archives
Grants Administration Unit
9A81 Cultural Education Center,
Albany, NY 12230
pd4ml eval.,:ation copy. vl, it _ i>://pd4ml.com