HomeMy WebLinkAbout1000-14.-2-1.9 o~ soyr
OFFICE LOCATION: yQ MAILING ADDRESS:
Town Hall Annex l0 P.O. Box 1179
54375 State Route 25 J~[ * Southold, NY 11971
Ccor. Main Rd. & Youngs AveJ H ~
Southold, NY 11971 ~ ~ ~O Telephone: 631 765-1938
Fax: 631 765-3136
Q~y000NiV
LOCAL WATERFRONT REVITALIZATION PROGRAM
TOWN OF SOUTHOT.D
MEMORANDUM
To: Jim King, President
Town of Southold Board of Trustees
From: Mark Terry, Principal Planner
LWRP Coordinator
Date: August 19, 2013
Re: LWRP Coastal Consistency Review for OLIVER FRANKEL
SCTM# 1000-14-2-1.9
Suffolk Environmental Consulting on behalf of OLIVER FRANKEL requests a Wetland Permit
and a Coastal Erosion Permit to restore the bluff face via cut-and-fill with the inclusion of 400+
cubic yards of additional fill obtained from an approved upland source; install a 10' tall, 20'
wide, 190' long rock revetment along the toe of the bluff; and construct 4' wide beach access
stairs with associated top 4'x5' platform, 4'x4' upper platform, 4'x5' middle platform, and
4'x13.25' lowest/main platform. Located: 29821 Main Road, Orient. SCTM# 14-2-1.9
The proposed action has been reviewed to Chapter 268, Waterfront Consistency Review of the
Town of Southold Town Code and the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP) Policy
Standards. Based upon the information provided on the LWRP Consistency Assessment
Form submitted to this department, as well as the records available to me, it is my
recommendation that the proposed action is CONSISTENT with the LWRP.
Pursuant to Chapter 268, the Board of Trustees shall consider this recommendation in
preparing its written determination regarding the consistency of the proposed action.
Cc: Lori Hulse, Assistant Town Attorney
I
i. ~A,~
h
Town of Southold ~ `"r~ 1/`l~ A,~ ~ ~
,J
LWRP CONSISTF,NCY ASSESSMENT FORM ~ ~ ` .
A. 1NSTRUCI'IONS
I. All applicants for pennits* including Town of Southold agencies, shall complete this CCAF for
proposed actions that arc subject to the Town of Southold Waterfront Consistency Review Law. This
assessment is intended to supplement other information used by a Town of Southold agency in
making a determination of consistency. *E.ceept minor exempt action,c including Builrli~ig Permits
and othermini.cteriul permi~c not /nettled u~idiin du' Cuctsud Ero.cinn Ha;ard Aron.
2. Before answering the questions in Section C, the preparer of this form should review the exempt
minor action list, policies and explanations of each policy contained in the Town of Southold Local
Waterfront Revitalization Program. A proposed action will be evaluated as to its significant
beneficial and adverse cffec~s upon the coastal area (which includes all of Southold Town).
3. If any question in Section C on this form is answered "yes", then the proposed action may affect the
achievement of the LWRP policy standards and conditions contained in the consistency review law.
Thus, the action should he analyzed in more detail and, if necessary, modified prior to making a
determination that it is consistent to the maxinmm extent practicable with the LWRP policy
standards and conditions. If an action cannot be certified us consistent with the LWRP policy
standards and conditions, it shall not be undertaken. pp
A copy of the LWRP is available in the following places: onlin olptl~d~'rw ~'t
(southoldtown.northfork.net), the Board of Trustees Office, th ° h ing Department, a
libraries and the Town Clerk's office. ~i,~
_ ~ ;~r~
B. DF,SCRIPTION OF SITN: AND PROPOSEll ACTION
SCTM# 014 02 001.9 outholdlown
r,
The Application has been submitted to (check appropriate response):
Town Board ? Planning Dept. ? Building llept. ? Board of Trustees
I . Category of Town of Southold agency action (check appropriate response):
(a) Action undertaken directly by Town agency (c.g. capital
construction, planning activity, agency regulation, land transaction) ?
(h) Financial assistance (e.g. grant, loan, subsidy) ?
AU6 - 9 %0"~~5
(c) Permit, approval, license, certification:
Nature and extent of action:
Applicant proposes to improve upon the ahove referenced ~ropertv in order to better protect the
existine storm-damaeed bluff from future storm damage Accordinel~ the applicant fro ores to
restore the storm-damaeed bluff face via cut-and-fill (with the inclusion of 400 00 cubic ards +
of additional till obtained from an approved upland source) and install a 10' tall 20' wide 190'
lone Rock Revetment to protect the toe of the bluff from future storm damage and erosion
Furthermore, the applicant is proposine to build a set of Beach Access Stairs from the to op f the
bluff over the revetment and down to the beach. The total le th of the staircase will be 68' 10"
and will descend 32' ~~c. - /l~•v P ~5 c s e c ~
Attach additional sheets if necessary
Cantrell, Elizabeth
To: Matt Ivans
Subject: RE: SERVER - FRANKEL Application
From: Matt Ivans [mailto:mdivansCaloptonline.net]
Sent: Tuesday, July 30, 2013 12:28 PM
To: Cantrell, Elizabeth
Subject: SERVER -FRANKEL Application
These are the dimensions of the platform (actually all four of the platfiorrns) within the proposed stairway:
(1) Top Platform: 4.0' Wide x 5.0' Long (20 square feet);
(2j Upper Platform: 4.0' Wide x 4.0' Long {1v square feet);
(3) Middle Platform: 4. d' Wide x 5.0' Long (?_0 square feetf; and
(4) Lowest/Main Platform: 4.0' Wide x 13.25' Long (53 square feet.
Matt
Matt D. Ivans
Su(foik Envvanmenta! Consulting, lnc.
~532i 537-5169 i~.u}
?~31J 537-5291 ffl
mdiuan>(~opti7ni(ne.nat
matt `^:~suffvlkenvironniental.com I
~ t ~ i~;•
1
Policy 3. Enhance visual quality and protect scenic resources throughout the Town of Southold. See
LWRP Section III -Policies Pages 5 through 7 for evaluation criteria
® Yes ? No ? Not Applicable
Subiect proposal will comply with this Policv in that we are simply attempting to restore and
protect what has existed hereon. and which helped define the local scenic resources of
the surrounding shoreline.
Auuch additional sheets i(necessury
NATURAL COAST POLICIES
Policy 4. Minimize loss of life, structures, and natural resources from flooding and erosion. See LWRP
Section III -Policies Pages S through 16 for evaluation criteria
? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable
Subiect proposal is not applicable to this Policv
AUach additional sheets if necessar}'
Policy 5. Protect and improve water yuality and supply in the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III
- Policies Pages Ifi through 21 for evaluation criteria
? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable
Subiect proposal is not applicable to this Policv
A~tuch additional sheets if necessary
Policy 6. Protect and restore the quality and function of the Town of Southold ecosystems including
Signil;cant Coastal Fish and Wildlife Habitats and wetlands. See LWRP Section III -Policies; Pages 22
through 32 for evaluation criteria
? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable
Subiect proposal is not applicable to this Policv
Attach additional sheds if necessary
Policy 7. Protect and improve air quality in the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section III -Policies
Pages 32 through 34 for evaluation criteria
? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable
Subiect proposal is not applicable to this Policv
Attach additional sheets if necessary
1
Policy l3. Promote appropriate use and development of energy and mineral resources. See LWRP
Section III -Policies; Pages 65 through 68 for evaluation criteria.
? Yes ? No ® Not Applicable
Subject proposal is not applicable to this Policy.
nu~ch additional sheds if necessary
Creutecl un 5/25/05 11:20 AM
FRANKEL /SERVER Property
Situate: 29881 Main Road; Orient, New York
SCTM 1000 - 014 - 02 - 001.9
on~~r
East Marion
~a ;
c Greenport
Oer.nq
tS~ Harhor
Sheher
Island
Heights G~ r s H o
E
{ BunNUi
E
Erla~es
° Southold vo Shelter
Island
kelam Silver Bead
Peconic zs snore,
c.,.ra wn
s......, rv~ ~a4r9us
I C
~~4
C
44`~~
aaA° S
n~c
w pJ i
G!
5°on0~ p AP
t
O` ryr0
NJ`e~ t Ol 3
p a a
ya' i
SPa O ~
G'
Bo 6
Wp
s
5%/iR Main Rd Old Maio q~
n
zs
2
d zs
Ra
a~~ r
- -
I
N ~i
J
4~-
~ ~ 65 ~
~ vo
o a~
o~ v:
K h
r~ ~ 5~ ~ ss~.u
~_~Ho
i , ~'m ~
r ~
..,~~t y / / ~ yr,°.
\ ~ ~'Y ~ .l 55 yQUxv ~4`~6"
\N ~ ~ ~q t~~~ rcurio ~_MO So
~ L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~l ~
r •~e
u
t L" 1y s ~ ° I s ~ v` V `P ~3 ~ A
{
~ K e? / NN ~ X0.2
~ ~ m~~..... ~ ~ j y ~ ~q semi L ~ v~ ~.o
b V Y _ M' ~
,
~ g ~ y ~ ~ ~
~ - a
~ „a ~
'M ~d1
Hain ao iain ~ , S ~
Ao ~ t ~ ~ _ a a
~r~_.~aa ti
oP. ~ I
/v ,s oo ,ES.~o,
sau
_
.m,v
~I
~ - - - e I - T^ COUNTY OF SOFFOLK (C w~mmo
I I
_ ~ ~ }~3 .
f ~ ~ - - off..u.~. Realeal
Pmperty~~ ~ a~ .=.o m - o o.
~ - e , . ~
S1~;RVl•;R I roperty
Siuialr. YS18ll Maim Koad, (hicuL, ~Y
SCTM#1: 10(1(1 - 01 I. - 0`L - 00 L9
> .
a
n>
kf.~ r,~ r+.k,,{..L , ~ v ~ r ,t > ,~>xz-` m d.~ •1
~'°n,~E' .'N. rky!.Y ~ °x'.~µ. ,y ear l? )yr l..".`C
E w~ f.
it' t Vu' ri
j , Yhoto~,~-aph sho~n~ing the top of the proposed stairway on the subject property.
"1'hc tla~s <leuole the position cif the stairway on the lop of tl?e hlufl~..
Photograph taken from the top of the hlull~, lacing; north.
SI:R~'l'.R Property
sILL1aLC `l9H`l l Maio Road, oricul, I~'1'
sC'l'M#: 1(1(1(1 - OIL - 02 - OOL9
i I ~I
r~
i.
i
i
„....y; _
G., s yy~wt ..tom
t~~p ~
,x ,gip i r.
r ! x
~I c.
y.
Photograph showing the kx-alion ?>f the proposal Beach Access Stai?way.
~ L:~~i?Icnt in the photograph arc the (lags narking the top a?ul bottom of the stai?-way.
Photograph take?? from the bottom of~ tl?c bluff, facing south.
Sl'.RVI~:R Propert~~
Situxtc Y98`ll Maiu Road, C)ricnt, ~1'
SC"l'M#: 1000 - 01 L - U~ - 00 L9
I
i ':k
i
i
~ -
i e ;)y:
_ x
- ~w
r
~
~
~ ~ e`
~ l _
11
.
I
l
Yholo~raph showing; the location of the proposed Rock Re~•etmcnl.
"l'he hig~hlightal Ilag~s mark the position of the proposed beach access staittivay
akm~; the Rock Re~~elment.
I Yholograph taken from the botloni of the b1utl•, lacing east.
'~I' ~ Sl?RVl?R Property'
situate Y9ftYl Maio Koad, Oricut, ~l~
sC1'MN: 1000 - O1 L - 0`L - 11111.!)
I
~ .
1..,
.
.e
~ =
.,,M.` .y. y
° .`~}tea ,'"r'4 ; ~wti -
t.~. "r a ~ a.. w b
A, x-
(1 iy~' f yam' 4 'n
~4 •3`~-.::' a ~?t{ ~ y eCs~.:. ~ tira t,M _ ` .
I
Photograph show~iu~; the location of the pro~?osed Rock Re~~etn~ent.
i h:~~ident is the en?1 of the easterly neighbor's rock re~~eUnent, as highlightal in the
photograph
Photograpl? taken a<ljacenl to the ncighbori??g rock rep°etment at the botton? of the
blull~, lacing west.
•
_
6
1`` ~ _
GOG ON P'L L ~ 40 ~ ~ t
I z ~
4~ HH (yy
_ P O
1 n.r r e m m ~J
Z 7 1` ~ N ~ ~j
> ::a , rem
I = THI DRAWING IS BASED ON A SURVEY
~ I m
f l-- ` BY JOHN FREERS, DATED 5-30-2Q12 ~
L ~ - Yo FOR CAROL SERVER AND OLIVER FRANKEL N p7
O ~ t. ~ i34 ml 34 36 3~
z ~ m ~l m ~
I O I OZ y
z O II
36
rc
Cf~ N
~ ~ 3
~ ~ _
p ) ~ it ~ ~ ~o
I i
~ ? ~ 4 ~ ° ~ ~ PARTIAL SITE PLAN
Qj' J
e -
C ~ i _
- - - -
z ~ , ~ - _ - _
~ ~ ~ / t~EW BuIFE,Orl eU W
W
rr ~ Z
1
- N dOEo
_ eWN VIEW ~ W
O
_ fA:16N OF WLR.[ae. FOe2. AND TWH i0 BE WlR£ i7 . JT(~ COI.GR OF I
_ .4DL.CFNT eTAIRe TO FHE EMT I C!b d
-f-'~• ~ 1 BR7YOE PiiHIO.V Yty.1CItIG CF 33~ EE:1ffi! eTA:R NNLhGD. I
PARTIAL SECTION }$f ggLblO~AtlFIB1N M ThE iroert~icr~ °w'~ w~ r' i `
• • s WRV10H •KT WsTN1 wMY+ w,c AT ror OF e'mFe uNaTlw IOCATIDN artu I
LOGKAiCa MFL]LNIb`T, pd?E b TO'fATCH M LLCATIOry 8NJ DFDGN N OTARdLFiL, ~ I
` SECTION_C-C
~ , sv_ti,i~vRn F~ id~i` sUIE: r : s
r, ~ s' J - as
t , - a onawri ay: >F~H
~{•y °y - ~ E:"~ ~ July 16, 2013
- ~ SHEET NO: •
` J ~n J
PARTIAL SHGTION
~ . I Southold sown
se
a~
~EV4MNF.T NOrxS 1 e_±d'- orer our wr
.~.nlaw.x xv ra~wu xe.sa rw 1 ax U
r wl~alcmemwlux m+mr~ 1 Yk~ O
~rm.alN.wrx.vm>ov+urww rew si. mn ~ Z
womw~wmwaNr~erun..v.l msn 1 a»s~`~ W
navF,Hw 1 _
,w rMnmswi ~swa~ma ma reel+-_xa ~'~--T-0 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ " _ _ _ av ~ IIV+y~+'
Nse m.eaxwaNCmwwm,cwax,EZ. 1 _ _ _
rwoorv~xs waumnr.acow~ ~ ~ 5cs
N*x NV.e+numvansceaa - ! / .~h]]{{
1 , _ m
!wurnvnNMmncao®uwwt'"~"`oo`Oii 1 Lr6~
'w1plMC+:.~l®w.fffi9w~rtauoN~r~ 1 1 /I~
IMRSfYMIW SiNl NI.7AYt 1 1V~'
IY
Tti~
3(L~` J 1 I
1 ~ / J
1 i N
'm~.me~N'1 1 1 /
~ 1 1 /
s"'~''"~ SECTION A-A
1 - J SECTIONC~ ~ ~~vNfen ~i ~ u~ r-s
uvnw.+r 1~~7 _ ~ - SGLE: P. S yuvnaone A QQ~f
q ~3 't~~ry cetHe,wern 1 XXQX`~~
{ rwcr wro+a ~~~li¢
ti C ; 'c_vy lfiE ~'S itp+e Q 4 ~S 1 /"S 4I
nv_ V d ~ r r ~ i= e4W
? C J
` ~.H fSl'T.(5
mit'JV EORXK„E ~ ~ '
Q ~
o -
.
~
I
w
~w
Z
6 ~3 - }
Q N
_ _ ~ J
is^'~_ j ~a
i y ~ m=~
...a ~ = ,may ~ ~ j M
F. 1
W ~ °a~`°
---a' w
1 0
;f deo-
1
4 1 '
1 1
~ . • 1
T ~ ~ ~ 6M`1'I& E{"~ SECTION B-B
xim ~ l~ 1 ~v ~ ~ ~,n vuc 1'.S
P
56/3" W ~ ~~>~5 eT
4
d SGt I t ~ ~'E1H !Qj
~~M ~ > ` ~ I _ SECTION D-D b i , ~ r'` j a,r / auwn ar: ~N
t1 ~ T.ua.ryon ~ i'~~'iim~v~~ss' ((~~~p q 16,2073
-~~p ~ t _ use~rsm!+n ~ - f b ry _ ~ ~ ~~}a
N, ~ ~%.:5~` rt~ ~ I , ~a ~V ~ LS SCALE: NTS
a
~ ~ SHEET NO:
Q ~
~ti ~ - ulj_ ~ 9 ~C~~
za •
tart J,ic. _ _ 1
~j Southold Town L(/j/_,~/1{
r f Tr tee
_ ,
ND ~50UN0
ONG v~A ~ i
19~~1~
"E W E
NB'°~' 2O SURVEY OF PROPERTY
~o
ti'- II
c N
IE T
TE• OR
51TUA
---__:_-FR~E~~,,,~nwA,~v°E__~-.- TOWN: 50UTf10LD
S
- -
• SU~1=0LK COUNTY, NY
F _
~~M ~F otuiF--------: =
- SURVEYED 05-30-2013
; SUFFOLK COUNTY TAX # i
__-~_y~p~iuFF_-~" 7 m 1000 - I A- 2- I ,9
i ( ; aH aN ti
~ CERTIFIED T0~
° _
~ _ p ~ CAROLE SERVER
OLIVER FRANKEL
Z ~O
o ~ ~ ~ li
'e ~3. LIN
i c~ 0 4
~rn~ ~ ~ N 1
,P~ ~ = N1p,1G
~ ~ i
a
-
~
- o ~ ~ ~
---_">d-- ZZ _A-
- a
~ _ $ o~
O~ p
it Wo°°~ Q~cn
I op~d
~ vO
.mph, ~'~kw ~ ~ ~°ruoR~~~~~ ~ lP
cwHTM O ~
~ ~/h~ - ~ p
~ N m z I
{
- ___~--Zr ~ A
I~JI l ~ "TT
t-~ (rp~
~ ~ ~ _ 2Y ~ _ Z Z
? n ~
U
rn $ v
h ( 1 ~ ~ T
-m `o_ J 1 (1R r
J ~ ~ ~
o
y
~
~ ~ ~ cv ~
A
O ~ o ~ ~I
~J ~ O
D ~
N z
O ro ~gz
Si ~
$o
ozp W\~
y~ ~
o~T y
-qqo
TO.gf~ \ ~
~
o
N
3
- - s R SogD
Mq/N89
s w~~ I
4
~ M,LfS`- F. , A
~ 05' FNE
0
D ~ 79°3g3°W2 9 ~Q~~G.Ey~lO9
fJ~j D ~ -`"P~,
JUG 2 9 2013 ~ , iE <e~,~~, ti > ~
r Og
NAt'.IRE C9NSfRVPNCY .y
Southold lawn ~ pQ'
ar f Tr t ~ L~N~ ~~ti 5
Mp.TGN SF~~AND SVP
m~ Mvn~p a nm..e bml wads W Y
NOTES: ~ ~rw.~
w [~,ygiu••tbi
- _ i._ ,~,OOD FEN~I= J O h N C . E N LE RS LRN D SURVEYOR ~
- .ay.a w /w a emra..e m a ww w
•oaw'~
Area = 25 I ,533 Sq. Ft. •e••r•^ +v~ ~ mt.
Area = 5,78 Acres
6 EAST MAIN STREET N.Y.S. L1C. NO. 50202 ny~~
GRAPf11C SCALE I 100'
RIVERIIEAD, N.Y. 11901 369-8288 Fax 369-8287 mwwr«•w.n•m a. wrraw+~
.amnM war~a. w.
w pny aN InYq Mtld YMtl Msn, atl
longlslandlandsurveyor.com m ~~~d~.~"'~L.eaigtlht"°n.a•
• • •
E_ i... 'i
i ,
_ _ - _ _ ~ `y
_ _ ~ ~ ~ i I
-
- ~ ~ `
_ fl
_ _ _ - ~ ~ ° pit 1 ~ f ~
VIEW , , ~ ~ ~ P
~I PLAN ~UL 2 9 213 . ~ _ g
Scale: l.0" - =0.0'±_ ~
" f Sautholdlown ~ .r, E+~ ,
a~ tZ~ustees ~ k :y
r~
~ j.j ~ t.
i
f ~ i ~ I
~ ~ '
o ~ ,1
ALF _ _ ~ t ~
n
1 j
I~
`~I ~ Y
i{ ~ I ~ 1
It ~ t, j i
h
~ ~_aa Q ~ . ,I
nEla~ - - ~ /
a iI ~
it ~ W <n ~ _ ,
` ,
_ - .4 ` '1
It01"(OM oP BLUFF _ _ - ~ r ~ I ~"r
~ P120 SED OCK GF.Th ~ NT R 5FD CK ~ i~ W 1 ~ ~
; ~ 1
1 6
~1 • I y~
r 1
~ .y 1 ~ s.
~ ~ ~ ~ ,
I~ ~ ~ }
F"I
I ~ f, f ~ I
~ y
r,~
p ; c
j~ ~ C ~ - ~
~ ~ H
;f
~ _
;l
d
4
p
~ ~ i
i I r:~
~ ~
/ y
T~'PICAI, ELEVATION VIEW ~ ~ 1 ~ a a
sate: r.a - t.o~ ± Ca e American Beach Grass ~ % ~ i~ ' ~ ' ~ ~
(fLnnro~/tila brevilignl~zkz) ~A t Y „ ~ r g
i Ga ` ~
Planted at 1.0' o/c ~ ~ , ~ ~ ; t~G ~ ~ E
~ l t ,r~`', y' ~ ~ I
~ ~ ~ r ! ~ I
it ~ d I 1~ f f 4 ~
~ p ~,~r.
d
~yyt r ~ r PK ~ > t , E ~ r~ i
r, 4 ~ ~ I ~ ;
I
' N
V~ ~ ~ f ~'1 ff r%Y~ t~ ~ ~2 1
p ~ /j ti ~ e i ,r }L '
/ ! ~ 1 W ~ i
~ ~ r ~r ~
i i
r
13 I1- ( ~ j f ~
l
~ I r3% r, t,, ; ~ J U L 2 9 ?C13 I' W r
lfll'i' nth SoutholdTawn ~ ~ ~ iJ ~ I~
.111 ~ ie ~ Bar fTr see i; /S/ ~ _
i
f'., w
S'~ i W ' ~ c .i
• I
i ~rceir ir,'esl i Y t~ i. u r rt d rz r~ r ~ w ~ 'i
SQ' rt i 1 r I -si t cij ~Lle o tivtt~m the hit sh e~cuot areal ii c r~dtttr is t (r(e ~ ;ti ~ z
~ lront~! dunes F r rt tld l ~ v- i L y taro fl p _r r d r ? r lnl l ,~tl ~ ~ y,,,~
4~oC _
- ~ 1 a't it 1 } ( - L I ~ ~ r+i j= i ~ n~~,r ra r 7j fii I
PLANTING PLAN SPECIFICS E. r . T, ra_ t _ ,,r r, r , . ~_r . z~ _ ~r,- I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : ~
I ~ 7
Pollo~~ing the re estabhshnrentrre gdadiug F- _ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ of the on final Blidit, the iust llatirn~ of a Rock ~ t'
Kecetment and a Rlufl~ Stau~~a3~, applicant ~ ( L
proposr~ to re-~e5etate the tact of the Bluf} _ ~ z r _ I
± «ith ('a „ ~
utea,ui u~y -,000 square ter°[ E _,,t.;~,. ,i. ~ _ ' ~ ~
~~mericau Reee h Gr a~~ (,~~~n»v~hrl.r - _ _ ~ ~ ~ ~ i
,i
r
hdrrrlt,~rul,itry, pltinteel at Ln ui ~ ~ -
-r c ~ _ l~;
i - . ` w ~ I~
- - - - - _ _ _ ~ i
h~'1 s ~ ,
I.
_ _ _