HomeMy WebLinkAbout2009RECEIVED
TO:
FROM:
RE:
DATE:
Elizabeth Neville, Town Clerk
Board of Assessment Review
JUL 1
Sol,hold Town Cleri~
REPORT - BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW - TAX YEAR 2009-10
July 1, 2009
Attached herewith please find for public filing in your office, complete file covering the
public heating(s) of the Board of Assessment Review, together with changes ordered by
this Board to the assessment roll, Assessors' acknowledgement, etc.
The duties of the Board of Assessment Review for the grievance period covering the
2009/10 assessment roll are completed.
Chairman
Member
er
Form BAR-4
STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF SUFFOLK
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
The undersigned, being duly swom do severally depose and say that deponents
are members of the Board of Assessment Review; that deponents have read the
foregoing and know the contents thereof; and the matters set forth are tree to the best of
the deponent's knowledge.
Sworn before me this 33 day
of June, ~/~9/ . , ~- .
.*.'*-x ;';' _,~ NH ~u"blid!, 8tare of New York
Not~ PublicTM
Member
Member
Memb~
RPTSA - 200 - 4/72
BAR-2 - Page 3 of 3
TO:
FROM:
RE:
DATE:
Town Assessor
Board of Assessment Review
ORDER FOR CHANGE 1N TENTATIVE ASSESSMENT ROLL
June 23, 2009
The Board of Assessment Review for the Town of Southold, has duly met to hear
Complaints or grievances on the tentative town assessment roll for the tax year 2009/10
as prescribed by law.
The Board, having duly convened, has considered each and every complaint or grievance
on the assessments for the tax year indicated, as filed with this Board, as prescribed by
law.
A majority of the Board has determined that all the changes indicated on the attached
page(s) will be made on the assessment roll by the Assessor.
Total number of complaints submitted by Assessor 1298__
Total number of complaints received on Grievance Day __3__
Total number of signed stipulations __99
Total number of correction of errors 50
Total number of complaints reviewed by the Board 1450__
Total number of reductions in assessment 47
Total number of withdrawals 0
Total number of dismissals 1
Total number of grievances without a change 1403__
NOW, THEREFORE, the Board of Assessment Review hereby orders the Board of
Assessors to make all changes in assessments as determined by the Board of Assessment
Grievance 2009
Residential
NAME SCTM# Code Date Submitted Result
1 Sanfordl Linda 81-3-27.1 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
4 Sanford, Linda 81-3-27.1 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
2 McGahan Trust 110~ 1-4 210 5/19/09 Reduced to 8900
3 1991 Trust for I & A Safer 98-5-2 210 5/19/09 Denied
5 Samolewski, Robert & Rita 1001-2-2-35 210 5/14/09 Denied
6 Pringle, Ronnie & Theresa 1001-2-5-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
7 Mattson, Jpn & Norma Fraser 1001-2-6-5 210 5/14/09 Denied
8 Weiss, Stephen & Kathleen 1001-3-4-33 220 5/14/09 Denied
9 Field Frank A Realty Inc. 1001-4-1 - 13 210 5/7/09 Denied
10 Watt, Nancy 1001-4-1 - 17.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
11 Watt, Stephen & Nancy Williams 1001-4-1-17.2 210 5/19/09 Denied
12 Carsten, Jill 1001-4-1-23 210 5/14/09 Denied
13 Mysliborski, Paul & Gabby 1001-4-1-25 210 5/19/09 Denied
14 Carpenter, Diane 1001-4-3-5 210 5/14/09 Denied
15 Waloski Weinman, Caroline 1001-4-3-29 281 5/14/09 Denied
16 Crocker, Stacey & Johnson, Vincent 1001-4-5-3 210 5/19/09 Denied
17 Miranda, Jose & Yolanda 1001-4-6-10 220 5/14/09 Denied
18 Rosa, Jeffrey 1001-4-6-37 220 5/18/09 Denied
19 Ficurilli, Antone Jr. 1001-4-8-17 220 5/14/09 Denied
20 Leete, Susannah 1001-5-1-9 210 5/14/09 Denied
21 Walton, Frances 1001-5-2-8 210 5/19/09 Denied
22 Kirkpatrick, Steven & Judith 1001-5-2-9 210 5/16/09 Withdrawn (Stip)
23 Quist, Gary & Elsie 1001-6-4-12 220 5/14/09 Denied
24 Kempner, Christina 1001-6-7-2 220 5/19/09 Denied
25 Aloi, Joseph & Baney, Thomas 1001-7-2-10 210 5/19/09 Denied
26 Farley, Mary 1001-7-2-14 210 5/19/09 Denied
27 Rowsom, Peter 1001-7-3-10 210 5/14/09 Denied
28 Wolf, Andrew & Heather Gray 1001-7-3-11.2 210 5/19/09 Denied
29 Heller, Lawrence & Marie 1001-7-5-13 210 5/14/09 Denied
30 Board of Managers of Oyster Pt. Condos 1001-7.1-1-1 210 5/7/09 Denied
31 Daniel, Robert Jr. & Linda 7-2-1 210 5/14/09 Denied
32 Rafferty, Chris 9-9-29.8 210 5/18/09 Denied
33 Trenkmann A. Estate Inc. 13-1-11 210 5/14/09 Denied
34 Berman, Alvin & Buchbinder-Bermin El 13-2-8.16 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
35 Schaefer, Michael 13-2-8.24 210 5/18/09 Denied
36 Morgan, Mary & Thomas 13-3-2 210 5/14/09 Denied
37 O'Ha~an, James 14-2-30.1 210 5/14/09 [ Denied
38 Karas, Nicholas 14-2-30.3 210 5/13/09 Denied
39 Fisher, Dorothy 15-1-22 210 5/14/09 Denied
40 Dinuzzio, Brace 15-2-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
41 Mendoza, Amelia 15-2-15.8 250 W 5/19/09 Denied
42 Pizzimsso, Joseph 15-3-22 210 5/15/09 I Denied
43 Connolly, Diane 15-5-24.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
44 Yudelson, Bruce 15-6-2 210 5/19/09 Denied
45 Owen, Elizabeth 15-6-5 210 5/15/09 Denied
46 Seewald, John & Catherine 15-8-26.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
47 Cuozzo, Joseph A. 15-9-1.3 210 5/12/09 Denied
48 Arnold, William 15-9-1.10 210 5/14/09 Denied
49 Papagianakis, Steve & Helen 15-9-1.15 210 5/14/09 Denied
50 Milligan, Richard 15-9-1.20 210 5/14/09 Denied
51 Papa, Joseph & Madeline 15-9-1.29 210 5/19/09 Denied
52 Welles, James 17-3-8 210 5/14/09 Denied
53 Papantonio, Edmond & Beatrice 18-5-9.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
54 Taylor, Carol Lee 18-6-21.9 210 5/14/09 Denied
55 Pignato, Josephine & Regina, Maria 18-6-24.3 210 5/19/09 Denied
56 Thomas, Janice 19-1-14.2 2}0 5/14/09 : Denied
57 Kanev, Lloyd 21-1-30.2 250 W 5/14/09 Denied
58 Weile, Victoria 21-2-11 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
59 Teperman, Lewis 21-2-16 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
60 Bulls, Mafia & Gerosa, Margaret 21-3-5 210 5/14/09 Denied
61 Gontzes, William & Artemis 21-4-1 210 5/14/09 Denied
62 Nicolelis, Peter 21-4-6 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 7200
63 Magen, Theodore 21-5-1 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
64 Austin, William 21-5-6 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
65 Zoitas, Ioannis 21-5-14 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
66 I Puma, Anthony 22-2-15 210 5/18/09 Denied
67 Cotrone, Don 22-3-7 210 5/15/09 Denied
68 Lagamma, Edmund & Kalliope 22-4-5.3 210 5/19/09 Denied
69 Politis, Antonios & Anna 22-4-6 210 5/14/09 Denied
70 Myslibomki, Mark & Cindy 22-4-14 210 5/19/09 Denied
71 Harte, Ellen M. 22-4-19 210 5/18/09 Denied
72 Copertino, John & Inge 22-5-13 210 5/19/09 Denied
73 Voumvourakis, T. 22-5 -31 210 5/15/09 Denied
74 Squitieri, Andrew & Elaine 22-5-32 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 7400
75 Fried, Paul & Judith 23-1-4 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
76 Bolletino, Anthony & Rosemary 23-1 - 14.6 210 5/14/09 Denied
77 Ioannou, Athas & Angel 23-1-14.7 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
78 Webb, Edward & Irene 25-1-9.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
79 Sorenson, Robert 25-4-5 210 5/14/09 Denied
80 McNeilly, Ellen 26-1-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
81 McNeilly, Ellen 26-1-5 220 5/14/09 Denied
82 Medovoy, Nauru & Neumann, Susanna 26-1-10.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
83 Turner, Robert & Pacinda-Tumer Mar~ 26-1-29 210 5/14/09 Denied
84 Mensch, Morton & Ruth 26-2-14 210 5/19/09 Denied
85 Tommasini, John & Arlene Long 26-2-35 210 5/14/09 Denied
86 Eshoo, Nina 26-3-3 210 5/19/09 Denied
87 McGough, George & Eileen 27-2-2.7 250 5/14/09 Denied
88 Prizeman, John & Diana 27-3-2.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
89 Davis, Anne 27-3-3.6 210 5/14/09 Denied
90 Rieger, Hans & Francoise 27-4-6 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
91 Santora, Joseph & Joanne 30-2-9 210 5/19/09 Denied
92 Dooley, John & Maria 30-2-12 210 5/14/09 Denied
93 Pecora, Marion 30-2-16 210 5/14/09 Denied
94 Aragaki, Tsunehide & Lila 30-2-24 210 5/14/09 Denied
95 Cohen, Abraham 30-2-44 210 5/14/09 Denied
96 Kondak, Edward & Patricia 30-2-54 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
97 Raicovich, Remigio & Maria 30-2-89 210 5/14/09 Denied
98 Stathopoulos, Argie 30-2-104 210 5/19/09 Denied
99 Schmidt, Cyntlfia 30-2-118 210 5/19/09 Denied
2
100 Misthos, George & Helen 30-2-123 210 5/14/09 Denied
101 Sotiropoulos, Konstantinos 30-3-3 210 5/19/09 Denied
102 Planzos, Thomas 31-2-5 210 5/14/09 Denied
103 Vallas, Theodore & Helen 31-2-6.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
104 Philippou, Hany & Irene 31-2-7 210 5/14/09 Denied
105 Mayer, Ronald 31-2-26 210 5/14/09 Denied
106 Tsoungos, Athanasios 31-3-6 210 5/15/09 Denied
107 Tsoungos, Athanasios 31-3-6 210 5/18/09 Denied
108 Coffey, Timothy 31-3-11.13 210 5/14/09 : Denied
109 Drenis, Athanasios & Stella 31-4-7 210 5/14/09 I Denied
110 Chekimoglou, Lisa 31-4-33 210 5/18/09 Denied
111 Corrigan, Eugene 31-6-5.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
112 Dzenkowski, Daniel & Mary Ann 31-6-23 210 5/14/09 Denied
l 13 Meshover, Stephen & Susan 31-7-17 2 l0 5/14/09 Denied
114 Goldsmith, Russell Jr. & Linda 31-8-5 210 5/14/09 Denied
115 Brennen, William & Patricia 31-12-5.1 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
116 Jones, John & Evelyn 31-15-11 210 5/14/09 Denied
117 Palumbo, Frank 33-1-7 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
118 Wojtas, Andrew & Evertz, Gabriele 33-2-35 210 5/14/09 Denied
119 Schoenstein, Joseph 33-2-43 210 5/19/09 Denied
120 Borrelli, Joseph & Frances 33-3-7 210 5/14/09 Denied
121 Trabelsi, Imed & Faith 33-3-11 210 5/14/09 Denied
122 Lettieri, Bernice 33-3-19.16 210 5/14/09 Denied
123 Karagiorgis, Nicholas 33-3-35 210 5/19/09 Denied
124 Mancini, Jeffrey 33-3-40.2 210 5/19/09 Denied
125 Rhinow, Bill 33-4-19 210 5/14/09 Denied
126 Martorana, Vincent 33-4-32 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
127 Gerazounis, Stelios & Magdalene 33-4-41 210 5/19/09 Denied
128 Speleotes, Vassilios & Maureen 33-4-60 210 5/14/09 Denied
129 Dobler, Max & Mariel 33-5-15 210 5/14/09 Denied
130 Haasper, Carl & Jorga 33-6-6 210 5/19/09 Denied
131 Droskoski, Mark 34-3-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
132 Berson, David 34-3 -29 210 5/14/09 Denied
133 Blum, Walter 34-5-12 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
134 Abadiotakis, John 35-2-4 250 5/15/09 Denied
135 Lieblein, William Jr. & Donna 35-3-4.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
136 Koebele, Robert & Deborah 35-4-12 210 5/14/09 Denied
137 Jones, Alexandra 35-4-13 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
138 Key, Carl & Charlene 35-5-5.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
139 Ruroede, Bart & Christine 35-5-6 210 5/14/09 Denied
140 Ahearn, John & Kathleen 35-5-13 210 5/19/09 Denied
141 Stocker, Lucille 35-5-28 210 5/15/09 Denied
142 Claps, Vincent 35-5-33 210 5/15/09 Denied
143 Trabulsi, Barbara 35-6-3 210 5/14/09 Denied
144 Zervos, Nikitas 35-6-15 210 5/14/09 Denied
145 Cooper, Robert 35-6-29 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
146 Grandinetti, Ralph 35-6-32 210 5/15/09 Denied
147 Stotzky, Guenther 35-6-33 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
148 Schoenstein, Fred & Jenny 35-8-3.3 210 5/19/09 Denied
149 Kelly, John & Rosemary 36-2-9 210 5/14/09 Denied
150 Quintin, Lillian & Henry 36-2-11 210 5/14/09 Denied
151 Holuka, Arthur & Patti 37-1-9 210 5/14/09 Denied
3
152 Murphy, Edward & Eileen 37-2-12.4 210 5/14/09 Denied
153 Lyman, Keith & Eleanor 37-3-21.1 2 l0 5/14/09 Denied
154 Pihl, Ellen 37.4-7 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
155 Cope, James & Florence 37-5-22 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
156 Brenner, Steven 37-6-4 2 l0 5/18/09 Denied
157 Jacobs, Peter & Mary 38-2-10 210 5/14/09 Denied
158 Malley, John & Valerie 38-2-14 2 l0 5/14/09 Denied
159 Mysliborski, Marj orie ,38-3-10 210 5/14/09 Denied
160 Wong, Clara 38-3-23.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
161 Wells, Gerald & Betty 38.4- l 0 210 5/14/09 Denied
162 Campbell, John & Loretta 38-4-23 2 l0 5/14/09 Denied
163 Cromack, Charles & Genevieve 38-5-1 210 5/14/09 Denied
164 Mangels, Rosalie & O'Gmdy, Lynda 38-6-1 210 5/19/09 Denied
165 McMonigle, Daniel & Genevieve 38-6-3 210 5/14/09 Denied
166 Erey, Iskender & Bengolea, Angelica 38-6-7 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
167 Llukaci, Albert & Antigoni 38-7-10.7 210 5/19/09 Denied
168 Tsimikas, Isidoros 40-2-20 210 5/14/09 Denied
169 Tzanopoulos, Demetm & Varis Elani 40-2-21 210 5/14/09 Denied
170 Kozora, Judy & Charles 40-3 - 10.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
171 Mohr, Christopher 40-5 -20 210 5/19/09 Denied
172 Reeves, Timothy & Susan 41-2-10 210 5/19/09 Denied
173 Corwin, Everett 42-1-30 210 5/14/09 Denied
174 Klein, Walter & Lorraine 43-1-8 210 5/14/09 Denied
175 Holevas, George 43-4-3 220 5/18/09 Denied
176 Holevas, George & Georgia 43-4-3 220 5/14/09 Denied
177 Lillis, Rebecca 43-4-36 210 5/14/09 Denied
178 Peluso, Anthony & Wilemina 43-4-37 210 5/14/09 Denied
179 Jeselsohn, Paul & Dubois, Francis 43-4-45 210 5/19/09 Denied
180 Sullivan, Betty 43-5-2 ~ 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
181 Candan, Hirant 44-1-18 ~ 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
182 Bitsakis, Anastasia 44-2-1 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
183 Bashian, Harry & Haykuhi 44-2-15 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
184 Greenpo~t Group LLC 45-2-10.5 280 5/7/09 Denied
185 Silver Sands Motel Inc. 47-2-12 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
186 Silver Sands Motel Inc. 47-2-15 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
187 Wachtel, Christopher & Mariaane 48-1-21 210 5/19/09 Denied
188 Wachtel, Donald & Tonia 48-1-32 210 5/19/09 Denied
189 Wachtel, Donald 48-2-6 210 5/19/09 Denied
190 Mims, Francis 48-2-17 210 5/14/09 Denied
191 Davis, Paul Jr. 48-2-33.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
192 Field Frank Realty Inc. 48-3-20.1 210 5/7/09 Denied
193 Verity, Michael 48-3-42.6 210 5/14/09 Denied
194 Ciaputa, Daria 50-2-7 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
195 Rigas, Angela 50-4-2.4 210 5/14/09 Denied
196 Melchione, Richard & Concetta 50-6-1 210 5/14/09 Denied
197 Kettenbeil, Fred & Laura 50-6-5.10 210 5/14/09 Denied
198 Ingarra, Frank & Carmela 51-3-2.6 210 5/19/09 Denied
199 Wrack, Frank 51-3 -2.8 210 5/15/09 Denied
200 Clancy, Paul & Manreen 51-3-3.12 210 5/14/09 Denied
201 Mutsakis, Michael & Capassakis, Evely 51-4-16.1 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
202 Sawicki, Joseph & Connie 51-6-14.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
203 Koukounas, Kostantinos 51-6-15 210 5/19/09 Denied
4
204 Mancini, Amelia & Ver Pault, Ann M. 51-6-25 210 5/14/09 Denied
205 Rogers Gmn, Susan 52-1-6 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
206 Perinuzzi, Lnigi & Maria 52-3-17 210 5/14/09 Denied
207 Marinucci, Luigi & Afita 52-3-18 210 5/14/09 Denied
208 Nowak, Julius 52-5-22 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
210 Brasca, John 52-8-2 210 5/14/09 Denied
211 Severini, Maryellen 53-1 - 14 210 5/19/09 Denied
212 Holley, Robert & Barbara 53-3-13.1 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
213 Cerreta, Kenneth 53-4-6 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
214 Wachtel, Donald 53-4-36 210 5/19/09 Denied
215 Gadomski, Vincent Jr. & Janice 53-4-38 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 4950
216 Lastihenos, Diann 53 -4-44.5 210 5/14/09 Denied
217 Gayson, Karen 53 -4-44.6 210 5/15/09 Denied
218 Glazer, Jean & Leonard 53-4-44.7 210 5/14/09 Denied
219 Gadomski, Thomas & Kathy 53-4-44.14 210 5/14/09 Denied
220 Denicola, Dominick & Carol 53-4-44.19 210 5/14/09 Denied
221 Ryan, Stephen & Helen 53-4-44.22 210 5/14/09 Denied
222 O'Sullivan, Jeannette 53-4-44.26 210 5/19/09 Denied
223 Rice, Patricia 53-4-44.30 210 5/14/09 Denied
224 Clay, Barbara Ann 53-4-44.33 210 5/14/09 Denied
225 Wieck, Albert & Dorothy 53-5-5 210 5/14/09 Denied
226 Wieczorek, Robert & Rita Reis 53-5-8 210 5/14/09 Denied
227 Barkin, Irene 53-6-27.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
228 Miller, Walter 54-1-16 210 W . 5/14/09 Denied
229 Woodall, William 54-2-3 210 5/14/09 Denied
230 Robison, Mary Ann 54-2-13 210 5/14/09 Denied
231 Rosenberg, Roberta 54-3 - 14.4 210 5/15/09 Denied
232 Winters, Penelope 54-3-14.5 210 5/14/09 Denied
233 Kuhn, Walter R. 54-3-25 210 5/15/09 Denied
234 Amicev, Marko 54-3-26.4 210 5/15/09 Denied
235 Vazquez, Donald & Jean 54-5-1 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
236 Schroeder, Diane 54-6-4.3 210 5/12/09 Denied
237 Gensler, Michael & Maryann 54-6-17 210 5/19/09 Denied
238 Romeo, Richard & Ann 54-6-18 210 5/14/09 Denied
239 Hawkins, Catherine 54-7-1.4 210 5/19/09 Denied
240 Lo Presti, Frances 54-7-1.5 210 5/14/09 Denied
241 Orlando, Andrew & O'Shea, Barbara 54-7-13 210 5/14/09 Denied
242 Hennessey, Walter & Fontana Marianne 55-2-1.4 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 13000
243 Grigonis, Robert 55 -2-8.6 210 5/14/09 Denied
244 Hamilton, Alfred & Eleanor 55-2-25.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
245 Kruk, Scott 55-3-4.8 210 5/19/09 Denied
246 Campbell, William 55-4-18 210 5/14/09 Denied
247 Rnthinoski, Thomas & Lori 55-4-21 210 5/14/09 Denied
248 I Kraehlinl~, Paul & Anne 55-6-5 210 5/14/09 Denied
249 Quinones, Karen A. 55-6-7 210 5/14/09 Denied
250 Reilly, Cathy & Kevin 55-6-15.9 210 5/5/09 Denied
251 Hansen, Melvin & Janice 55 -6-15.28 210 5/14/09 Denied
252 VanMater, Robert & Anne-Marie 55-6-15.54 210 5/14/09 Denied
253 Chabot, David & Su~an 55-6-15.61 210 5/19/09 Reduced to 5000
254 Russell, Mahlon & Klm 55-7-5 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
255 Smith, Henry Jr. 56-1-2.31 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 5800
256 Weber, John & Jean 56-5-16 210 5/14/09 Denied
257 Cassel, Carol 56-5-40 210 W 5/14/09 I Denied
258 Hymans, Donald & Barbara 57-1-32 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
259 Reibling, Albert Jr. 57-2-32 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
260 Romano, Alfonso & Antonia 58-2-2 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
261 Manno, Guisseppe & Catherine 59-3-16.2 210 5/12/09 Denied
262 Apadula, Frank 59-3-17.4 210 5/14/09 Denied
263 Homung, Bryan 59-3-35 210 5/19/09 Denied
264 Passadakes, Alexandra 59-4-5.5 210 5/14/09 Denied
265 Braslow, Robert N. 59-4~5.13 210 5/18/09 Denied
266 Bemstein, Warren & Nina 59-5-3 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
267 Glasser, Dean & Gladys 59-5-14. l 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
268 Seifert, William & Rose 59-6-3 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
269 Donarummo, Christopher 59-8-4.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
270 Kruk, Scott & Shawn P. 59-9-30.5 2 l0 5/19/09 Denied
271 Cagliuso, Joseph & Rosemarie 61-3-8.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
272 Webster, Donald & Ann 61-4-17.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
273 Leonard, Barbara 63-1-9 210 5/14/09 Denied
274 Hansen, Brian & Kathleen 63-2-16.4 210 5/12/09 Reduced to 5300
275 Wickham, Gekee 63-2-19 220 5/14/09 Denied
276 Tomasic, Eugen 63~3-14 210 5/5/09 Denied
277 Scarola, Frank & Donna 63-3-18.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
278 Clay, Barbara Ann 63-5-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
279 Sutton, Alexander & Tracy 63-5-17 210 5/14/09 Denied
280 Charnews, Clement Jr. 63-6-8 210 5/14/09 Denied
281 Agria, John & Mary 63-6-9 220 5/14/09 Denied
282 Vene, Chris 63-7-3 210 5/13/09 Reduced to 6500
283 Klos, Robert & Barbara 63-7-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
284 Charles, Barry 63-7-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
285 Lekich, Mary & Hagerman, Rita 63-7-15 210 5/14/09 Denied
286 Rubin, Stanley 63-7-17.4 210 5/14/09 Denied
287 Notaro, Frank & Antionette 63-%30.1 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
288 Intemodal Inc. 64-1-16 210 5/19/09 Denied
289 Quist, Gary 64-1-32 210 5/15/09 Denied
290 Pantino, Albert ~ Barbara 64-2-23 210 5/19/09 Denied
291 Glaessgen, John Jr. & Judith D. 64-2-47 210 5/14/09 Denied
292 Penney, William & Robin 64-3-4 210 W 5/14/09 ~ Denied
293 Cunnean, Thomas 64-4-12.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
294 Culliney, Frances 64-4-13 210 5/14/09 Denied
295 Dinoto, John & Jeanmarie 64-4-14.3 210 5/15/09 Denied
296 Schneider, Myles 64-5-5 210 5/15/09 Denied
297 Bennett Family Trust 68-1-10 210W 5/18/09 Denied
298 Ha~erman, Michael & Rim 68-1 - 15.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
299 Farley, Mary 68-3-4 260 W 5/19/09 Denied
300 Salt Marsh Lane LLC 68-3-13 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
301 Bennett, Scott & Alice 68-4-3.5 210 5/14/09 Denied
302 Ruggiero, Richard & Gail 68-4-21 210 5/19/09 Denied
303 Laub, Robert & Sandra 68-4-22 210 5/14/09 Denied
304 Ward, Edwin & Nancy 69-5-7.2 210 5/19/09 Denied
305 Peters, Mary & John 69-5-7.4 210 5/18/09 Denied
306 Laube, Gary & Leaden, Christopher 69-5-10 210 5/19/09 Denied
307 Carlson, Claude 69-5-13.4 210 5/19/09 Denied
308 Zeneski, Paul & Linda 70-1-6.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
6
309 McDowell, Kathleen 70-2-1 220 5/18/09 Denied
310 Carpluk, Theodore Sr. & Eileen 70-2-19.10 210 5/14/09 Denied
311 Wassmer, Henry & Anne 70-3-19 210 5/14/09 Denied
312 Olsen, David & Jennifer 70-3 -22.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
313 Gomez, Paul & Ellen 70-3-22.6 210 5/14/09 Denied
314 Skopelitis, Athina 70-3 -22.7 210 5/15/09 Denied
315 Robinson, David & Michelle 70-3-22.13 210 5/14/09 Denied
316 Wexler, Donna 70-4-23 210 5/15/09 Denied
317 Granfort, Lucille & Salvator 70-4-29 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
318 Barry, William & Betty 70-4-35 210 5/14/09 Denied
319 Peters, Bernhard 70-4-39.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
320 Anderson, Lois 70-4-45.5 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
321 Slotkin, Jay P. & J. Davis 70-5-4 210 5/19/09 Denied
322 Laube, Gary & Margaret 70-5-5 210 5/19/09 Denied
323 Russ, Donald & Virginia 70-5-8 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
324 Kowalski, Robert 70-5-30.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
325 Benic, Petra 70-5-39 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
326 McKeon, Peter 70-8-34 210 5/15/09 Denied
327 Strauss, Marc & Kern, Colette 70-9-16 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 4900
328 MacGregor, Meichelle & Keane, Joseph 70-9-45 210 5/14/09 Denied
329 Foshion, Mark & Duff7, Eileen 70-9-59 210 5/14/09 Denied
330 Yagle, James & Janet 70-10-4 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 3850
331 Rempel, Gary & Maryann 70-10-20 210 5/14/09 Denied
332 Baydala, Ann & Troy 70-10-46 210 5/14/09 Denied
333 Gallagher, Kevin & Dorothy 70-10-62.1 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
334 Keegan, Gerard & Mary 70-10-63.2 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
335 Small, George 70-11-5 210 5/19/09 Denied
336 Gundersen, James & Emily 70-11-6 210 5/14/09 Denied
337 Ponzo, Robert & Mary Alice 70-11-10 210 5/14/09 Denied
338 Bel~ora, Frank Jr. & Iris 70-11-15 210 5/14/09 Denied
339 Small, George 70-12-8 210 5/19/09 Denied
340 DeCarlo, Donald & Mary Ann 70-13-20.9 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
341 Palmer, Christopher 70-13-20.12 210 5/14/09 Denied
342 Best, Roger & Maureen 70-13-20.19 210 5/19/09 Denied
343 Nadelstem, Paula & Eric 71 - 1 - 18 210 5/19/09 Denied
344 Bridgen, Mark & Margot 71 - 1-20 210 5/14/09 Denied
345 Stickle, Robert 71-2-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
346 Principe, Jeannette 71-2-15 210 5/14/09 Denied
347 Stankewicz, Cathy 74-1-8 210 5/14/09 Denied
348 Wickham, Gekee 74-1-13 210 5/14/09 Denied
349 Damianos, Herodotos 74-1-42:6 210 5/15/09 Denied
350 Bohner, Ellen 74-2-11.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
351 Kruk, Scott 75-1-1.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
352 D'Mello, Leopold & Celcia 75-2-18 210 5/19/09 Denied
353 Beylerian, Edward & Therese ~ 75-3-15 210 5/14/09 Denied
354 Smith, Adam & Nicole 75-4-3 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 4600
355 Brantuk, Joseph 75-6-7.2 210 5/18/09 Denied
356 Coffey, Timothy 75-6-7.6 210 5/14/09 Denied
357 Coffey, Timothy 75-6-7.6 210 5/19/09 Denied
358 Fristachi, Joseph 75-6-9.5 210 5/15/09 Denied
359 Cacovic, Alexander 75-6-10 210 5/14/09 Denied
360 Rerisi, Gail & Matassa, Vincent 76-1-15.3 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
7
361 Rerisi, Victor & Matassa, Vincent 76-1-15.6 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
362 Cimino, Peter & Loretta 77-1 ~ 15 210 5/19/09 Denied
363 Vail, George III& Mary 77-2-7 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
364 Arias, Albert & Susan 77-2-10 210 5/14/09 Denied
365 Vlahakis, Stylianos & Maria 77-2-23 210 5/14/09 Denied
366 Berkhan, Catherine 77-2-26 210 5/14/09 Denied
367 Cohn, Nancy & Kelser, Mmy Elizabeth 77-2-28.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
368 Maxwell, Brian & Janet 78-1-2 210 5/14/09 ! Denied
369 Klavas, Peter & Jill 78-1-17 210 5/14/09 Denied
370 Property Uncommonly Perfect 78-1-29 210 5/19/09 Denied
371 Brittman, Joseph & Elizabeth 78-2-11.3 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
372 Reilly, John 78-2~12.1 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
373 Kosel, Anna 78-2-21 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
374 Holobigian, Rita 78-2-22 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
375 Frankola, Ferucio & Rina 78-2-36 210W 5/19/09 Denied
376 Frankola, Rina 78-2-36 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
377 Cortale, Joseph 78-2-39 210W 5/14/09 Denied
378 Brown, Gary & Carol 78-3-9 220 5/14/09 Denied
379 Alesci, Pasquale & Judy 78-3-43.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
380 Curran, Joan & Curran, Nancy & Patrick 78-3-43.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
381 Albro, William 78 -3 46 210 5/14/09 Denied
382 Kollen, Joseph & Anita 78-3-50.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
383 Boyles, William Jr. & Susan 78-3-54 210 5/14/09 Denied
384 Wenchell, Walter & Lynne 78-3-65 210 5/14/09 Denied
385 D'Alessio, William & Michele 78-4-5 210 5/14/09 Denied
386 Bowen, Susan Quarty 78-4-23 210 5/19/09 Denied
387 ' McKieman, Denis & Matthew 78-4-36.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
388 Kunst, John & Mary Ann 78-6-16 210 5/14/09 Denied
389 Lacaille, Joan 78-7-17 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
390 Spaeth, Peter & Cyra 78-7-40 210 5/14/09 Denied
391 Herman Frank T. Jr. & Betty M. 78-8-16.1 210 5/19/09 Reduced to 6000
392 I Lederer, Robert 78-9-5.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
393 Sutton, Alexander 78-9-54 210 5/19/09 Denied
394 Merkel, Donna & Joseph 78-9-57 210 5/14/09 Denied
395 Klipstein, Robert & Christine 78-9-58 210 5/19/09 Denied
396 Pratt, William & Miriam 79-2-11 210 5/14/09 Denied
397 Monahan, George & Sally 79-3-1 210 5/19/09 Denied
398 Tuohy, Sheila 79-3-3 210 5/14/09 Denied
399 Perez, Judith & Krac, Sandra 79-3-4.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
400 Ebeling, John & Barbara 79-3-6 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 8700
401 Mullen, Timothy & Nancy 79-3-8 210 5/14/09 Denied
402 Moczulski, Andre 79-3-31 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 6650
403 O'Neill, Daniel 79-3-33 210 5/14/09 Denied
404 O'Connor, Stephen & Carol 79-3-36 210 5/19/09 Denied
405 Swanson, Theodore W. & Anne 79-3-37 210 5/14/09 Denied
406 Sabalja, Philip & Lorraine 79-4q6.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
407 Frey, Robert 79-4-8 210 5/14/09 Denied
408 Torkelsen, Tor & Joan 79-4-17.7 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 10000
409 Albertson, Robert & Nancie 79-4-20 210 5/14/09 Denied
4 l 0 Lappe, Stevan & Christopher 79-4-32 210 5/14/09 Denied
411 Lastoria, Michael & Miriam 79-4-33 210 5/19/09 Denied
412 Richter, William 79-4-47 210 5/15/09 Denied
8
413 Synan, George 79-4-48 210 5/! 4/09 Denied
414 Behnnann, Robert & Marilyn 79-6-3.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
4 l 5 Mohr, Chris 79-6-4.4 210 5/15/09 Denied
4 l 6 Hudson, James & Christina 79-6-4.5 210 5/18/09 Denied
417 Esposito, Felice & Angelina 79-7-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
418 Steiner, Jack & Laurie 79-7-17 210 5/14/09 Denied
419 Benini, Vincent & Kathy 79-7-25 210 5/19/09 Denied
420 Adamson, Lenore 79-7-29 210 5/14/09 Denied
421 Corwin, Walter & Patricia 79-7-30 210 5/14/09 Denied
422 Kentrotas, Steven & Calliope 79-7-36 210 5/14/09 Denied
423 Kentrotas, Steven 79-7-36 210 5/15/09 Denied
424 Brown, Stanley 79-7-43.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
425 Hoffman, Philip & Karen 79-7-51 210 5/14/09 Denied
426 Kollen, David & Lauren 79-7-53 210 5/14/09 Denied
427 Pellicano, Florence 79- 8-13.1 250 5/15/09 Denied
428 Chicco, Giacomo 79-8-15.2 210 5/15/09 i Denied
429 Miller, Men'itt & Claire 80-1-33 210 5/19/09 Denied
430 Miller, Merritt & Claire 80-1-37 210 5/19/09 Denied
431 Porterfield, Elizabeth 80-2-3 210 5/14/09 Denied
432 Vanl~i, Antonio & Grazia 83-1-7 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
433 Kalas, Jerry 83-1-10 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
434 Aliano, Nicholas 83-1-12 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
435 Monol~ioudis, Gus & Catina 83-1 - 14 210 5/16/09 Denied
436 Aliano, Nicholas 83-1 - 14 210 5/15/09 Denied
437 Aliano, Margaret 83-1-15 210 5/15/09 Denied
438 Pearsall, Kenneth 83-1 - 15 210 5/14/09 Denied
439 Racanelli, Giuseppe & Rosa 83-1-22 210 5/19/09 Denied
440 Casarona, Joseph & Marie 83-1-26 210 5/14/09 Denied
441 Reiter, Joseph & Barbara 83-1-31 210 5/14/09 Denied
442 Dambassis, Lnida 83-2-7.2 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
443 Sojah, Martin 83-2-10.13 210 W 5/18/09 Denied
444 Walters, Donna & Bemzn¥, Rachel 83-2-19.4 210 5/14/09 Denied
445 Manl~iamele, Thomas & Kathleen 83-2-19.7 210 5/19/09 Denied
446 Fasolino, Umberto & Robin 83-4-2 210 5/19/09 Denied
447 Long, Gary & Linda 83-4-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
448 Lozada, Donna 84-1-6.4 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 5000
449 Graeb, Thomas & Diane 84-1 - 10.3 210 5/19/09 Denied
450 Shalvey, Thomas & Agnes 84-2-2.3 281 5/19/09 Denied
451 Quizhpi, Wilson & Clementina 84-4-9 210 5/19/09 Denied
452 Park, William & Terri 84-4-11.3 210 5/19/09 Denied
453 Baglivi, John & Amy 85-2-4 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 5300
454 Oman, Henry & Christina 85-2-5 210 5/14/09 Denied
455 Jimenez, Jacilyn 85-2-12.2 210 5/19/09 Denied
456 Damianos, Alexander 85-2-13.1 210 5/15/09 Denied
457 McKenna, Noreen & Cahill, Kevin 85-2-22 210 5/19/09 Denied
458 Seifert, William & Kan'imm 86-1-4.5 210 5/14/09 Denied
459 Reitman, Joel & Anne 86-1-4.22 210 5/14/09 Denied
460 Molnar, John 86-1-4.24 210 5/14/09 Denied
461 Mehrman, John & Norma 86-1-10.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
462 Pagano, Joseph 86-1 - 11 210 5/14/09 Denied
463 Bauser, Bernardine 86-4-1.7 210 5/15/09 Denied
464 Rosen, Carla 86-4-1.10 210 5/15/09 Denied
9
465 Jacobs, Peter & Dolores 86-4-5 210 5/14/09 Denied
466 Zinger, Juliana & Robertson, Christia 86-4-6.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
467 Daskin, Richard 86-4-6.5 210 5/14/09 Denied
468 Wexler, Donna 86-5-9.1 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
469 II~lesias-Wexler, Donna M. & Igesias, G. 86-5-9.1 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
470 Freda, Carol & Ur,/Arthur G. 86-6-26.2 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
471 Safalow, Linda C. 87-1-23.4 210 5/18/09 Denied
472 Dilworth, Anita 87-1-23.6 210 5/15/09 Denied
473 Soury, Lonnie 87-1-23.8 210 5/14/09 ! Denied
474 Mathie, Joan 87-2-14 210 5/14/09 ' Denied
475 Sauer, Carol Ann 87-240.1 210 W 5/14/,09 Denied
476 Holzer, Pamela & Robert 87-3-10 210 5/14/09 Denied
477 Hawkins, Sara 87-3-54 210 5/14/09 Denied
478 Lohn, Patrick 87-3-55 210 5/14/09 Denied
479 Lindtveit, Herbert & Catherine 87-4-7 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
480 Sprinl~steel, Bernard & Pollak, Marcia 87-5-19.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
481 McNamara, Margaret 87-6-10 210 5/19/09 Denied
482 Ricciardi, Michael & Judy 88-3-12 210 5/14/09 Denied
483 Schneider, Walter & Susan 88-4-12 210 5/19/09 Denied
484 Parker, Melvin & Diane 88-4-34 210 5/14/09 Denied
485 Rand, Jason 88-5-19 210 5/14/09 Denied
486 Piechnik, Robert & Carol 88-6-13.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
487 Engert, Richard 88-6-13.4 210 5/15/09 Denied
488 Mann, Barry & Carol 88-6-13.10 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 9000
489 Kilfoil, Richard 88-6-13.22 210 5/15/09 Denied
490 Fedele, James & Juliann 88-6-13.32 210 5/14/09 Denied
491 McGill, Ellen 88-6-13.36 210 5/15/09 Denied
492 Foster, John 88-6-13.48 210 5/14/09 Denied
493 Hurley, Britt & Pat 88-6-13.49 210 5/14/09 Denied
494 Steinbugler, Anne 89-1-5.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
495 D'Ascoli, Grel~ory & Finnigan, Denise 89-2-5.2 210 5/19/09 Denied
496 Cieplinski, Frank Jr. & Barbara 89-3-11.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
497 Prokop, Thomas 90-1-16 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
498 Power, Austin Jr. 90-2-5 210 5/14/09 Denied
499 Scibelli, Gabriel 90-2-15 210 5/14/09 Denied
500 Reardon, John & Elizabeth 90-2-19 210 5/14/09 Denied
501 Azmoun, Ali 90-3-19 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
502 Russo, Kathryn 90-4-22 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
503 Rand, Jori 91-1-2 210 5/14/09 Denied
504 Frazzitta, Joseph 92-1-6 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
505 Kaplan, Robert & Barbara Ann 92-1-7 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
506 Scheffs, Jan & Ursula 94-2-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
507 Hanauer, Sanford 94-3-1.8 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
508 Roufanis, Vasilios 94-3-1.11 210 5/19/09 Denied
509 Schrieber, Robert I 95-1-4.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
510 Collins, David & Jennifer 95-1-6 210 5/19/09 Denied
511 Giannaris, George & Maria 95-4-18.14 210 5/14/09 Denied
512 Kruk, Frank & Elizabeth 95-4-18.19 210 5/19/09 Denied
513 Lademann, William 95-4-18.32 210 5/14/09 Denied
514 Bogardus, Henry III & Susan 95-4-18.37 210 i 5/14/09 Denied
515 Gatz, William A. 97-3-11.8 210 5/18/09 Denied
516 Connolly, John 97-3-11.9 210 5/19/09 Denied
10
517 loveno, Peter T. Sr. 97-3-18.7 210 5/14/09 Denied
518 Forte, William A. 97-6-12.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
519 Valentino, Pamela 97-7-19.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
520 Schmidt, John & Margaret 97-7-26.4 210 5/14/09 Denied
521 Stepnoski, Frank & Doris 97-8-2 210 5/14/09 Denied
522 Stepnowsk¥, Theodore & Darlene 97-8-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
523 Walker, Peter & Eileen 98-1-7.17 210 5/14/09 Denied
524 Horton, Richard L. & Wf 98-1-26 210 5/15/09 Denied
525 Mesloh, Lillian & John 98-2-16.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
526 McNab, Glenn & Yvonne 98-34.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
527 Woods, Susan 98-3-7.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
528 Greenberg, Michael & Harriet 98-4-16.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
529 Allen, Richard & Diane 98-5-17.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
530 Livanos, Madeline 99-1-23 210 5/14/09 Denied
531 Wrynn, Kevin & Ors 99-3-4.12 210 5/14/09 .Denied
532 Milowski, Shelly 99-3-4.15 210 5/14/09 Denied
533 Lawlor, Ruth 99-3-12 210 5/14/09 Denied
534 343 East 18 LLC 99-3-19 210 5/15/09 Denied
535 Kitz, Charles M. 99-3 -21.1 210 5/13/09 Denied
536 Miller, Luck 99-4-14 210 5/19/09 Denied
537 Sessa, Leonard 99-4-27.1 210 W 5/18/09 Denied
538 Levine, Melvin & Lilian 99-5-12.3 210 5/19/09 Denied
539 Baker, Jonathan & Christine 99 -5 - 13 210 5/14/09 Denied
540 Orfanidis, George & Calliope 99-5-18 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 4770
541 Termini, Andrew & Susan 99-5-21.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
542 Lampropoulos, Theodoros 100-1-2 210 5/14/09 Denied
543 Eilers, Randall & Margaret 100-1-9 210 5/14/09 Denied
544 McCarthy, Charles & Anne 100-1-16 210 5/14/09 Denied
545 Kalich, Richard & Motto Mary 100-1 - 19 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 5140
546 Mazzarese, Charles & Regina 100-1-22 210 5/14/09 Denied
547 Young, William & Patricia 100-1-36 210 5/14/09 Denied
548 Menard, Richard & Carolyn 100-1-41 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 7000
549 Wills, John 100~3-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
550 Georgianis, Demetrios & Catherine 100-3-15.8 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 5200
551 S tagias, Karen 100-3 - 15.9 210 5/15/09 Denied
552 Terranova, Giacomo 100-5-2 210 5/18/09 Denied
553 Gurriere, Ray & Deborah 1.00-5-3 210 5/14/09 Denied
554 Papathanasopoulos 101 - 1 - 16.4 210 5/14/09 Denied
555 Braverman, Steven & Linda 101-2-18.4 210 5/19/09 Denied
556 Beebe, Susan 102-1-4.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
557 Benediktsson, Ben & Diane 102-1-4.5 210 5/14/09 Denied
558 Le Boutillier, Pamela 102-1-4.6 210 5/12/09 Denied
559 Forte, Edward 102-1-4.10 210 5/15/09 Denied
560 Gackenheimer, Charles 102-1-27 210 5/14/09 Denied
561 Doroski, Alice 102-2-2.5 210 5/15/09 Denied
562 Wickham, Gekee 102-2-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
563 Fuchs, Joseph & Adrienne 102-2-6.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
564 Pufahl, Joseph & Sandra 102-2-6.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
565 Lizewski, Joseph J. 102-2 - 12.5 210 5/7/09 Denied
566 McNamara, James & Patricia 102-4-1 210 5/19/09 Denied
567 Best, Constance & James 102-4-4 210 5/19/09 Denied
568 Penney, Jacqueline 102-5-18 210 5/14/09 Denied
11
569 Albrecht, David & Amy 102-5-25 210 5/14/09 Denied
570 Salice, Charles & Rose 102-7-7 210 5/14/09 Denied
571 Blasko, Timothy & Regina 103-1 - 19.8 210 5/14/09 Denied
572 Robinson, Steven 103-1-20.8 210 5/16/09 Denied
573 Oliver, Lloyd 103-1-20.12 210 5/15/09 Denied
574 Reynolds, John & Lorraine 103 -4-12 210 5/14/09 Denied
575 Massalin, Carolina c/o Cregan, Rose 103-4-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
576 Brewer, Arthur & Kathryn 103-4-19 210 5/14/09 Denied
577 Montgomery, Donald & Lynn 103-4-21 210 5/14/09 Denied
578 Phillips, John F. 1034-35 210 5/18/09 Reduced to 4500
579 Hearn, John & Joan 103-4-45 210 5/14/09 Denied
580 Depinto, Joseph & Mary Ellen 103-5-2.4 210 5/19/09 Denied
581 McGahan, Doug 103-7-11 210 5/19/09 Denied
582 McGahan, Dave 103-7-12 210 5/19/09 Denied
583 Deloiselle, Kenneth & Nancy 103-9-12 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
584 Dunhuber, Lorraine 103-10-1 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
585 Trentacoste, Diane & Robert 103-10-17 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
586 Matejka, Jerry & Linda 103-10-27 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
587 Boczek, Henry A. & Edith A. 103-10-28.1 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
588 Petty, Spencer III 103-12-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
589 Schoenhaar, Roy J. & Phyllis 103-14-9 210 5/12/09 Denied
590 Libassi, Paul & Anne 104-1-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
591 Klein, Jordan 104-1-9.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
592 Scoggin, Lindsey & Shelley 104-2-8 210 5/14/09 Denied
593 Kay,on, Frances 104-2-21 210 5/18/09 Denied
594 Di Domenico, Jeff 104-3-5.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
595 Higgins, Laurie Ann 104-3-11 210 5/19/09 Denied
596 O'Donnell, Michael 104-4-6 210 5/14/09 Denied
597 Langenfass, Richard 104-4-14 210 5/15/09 Denied
598 Rein, Elizabeth 104-5 -9 210 5/15/09 Denied
599 Culver, Kathlean & Robert W. 104-5-18.1 210 5/18/09 Denied
600 Branker, Ronald & Claudia 104-5-31.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
601 Branker, Claudia 104-5-31.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
602 Brundage, Leda 104-5-35 210 5/14/09 Denied
603 Slavin, Raymond 104-6-12.3 210 5719/09 Denied
604 Breen, John 104-6-18 210 5/15/09 Denied
605 Smith, William 104-7-5 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
606 Sferrazza, Joseph & Marilyn 104-9-2 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
607 Gambardella, Michael & Linda 104-9-6 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
608 Irving, John & Mary Anne 104-9-8 220 W 5/14/09 Denied
609 Mikulas, Richard & Robyn 104-9-11 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
610 Zalner, Joseph & Judith 104-10-2.1 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
6t I Seiferth, Kenneth 104-10-11 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
612 · Asciutto, Basil 104-11-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
6 t 3 Gallagher, Robert 104-12-8.2 210 5/15/09 Denied
614 Santora, Eileen 104-12-10.4 210 5/15/09 Denied
615 Palmeri, Felix 104-13-7 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
616 Brady Jaques, Melinda 105-1-5 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
617 Psyllos, Peter & Elaine 106-1 - 1.11 210 5/19/09 Denied
618 Carlton, Joseph 106-1-24 210 5/14/09 Denied
619 Meskouris, Chris 106-1-32.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
620 Thomas, George & Irene 106-1-34 260 5/14/09 Denied
12
621 Meskouris, Chris 106-1-35.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
622 Meskouris, James 106-1-36.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
623 Meskouris, Chris 106-1-37.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
624 Rallis, Nicholas & Irene 106-1-40 210 5/14/09 Denied
625 Katos, Michael 106-1-48.1 210 5/15/09 Denied
626 Clearly, John 106-2-13 210 5/I 9/09 Denied
627 Georghiou, Chris & Mary 106-2-28 210 5/14/09 Denied
628 Fmngas, Emanuel 106-2-31 210 5/14/09 Denied
629 Elisseou, Evan 106-2-33 210 5/18/09 Denied
630 Constantine, Emanuel 106-3-11 210 5/14/09 Denied
631 Moshouris, Irene 106-3-19 210 5/19/09 Denied
632 Anastasiadis, George 106-5-6 210 5/14/09 Denied
633 Thirkield, lta & Christopher 106-5-8 210 5/14/09 Denied
634 Baktidy, Theofani & Mary 106-5-13 210 5/14/09 Denied
635 Coman, Geoffrey & Phyllis 106-5-20 210 5/14/09 Denied
636 Papadopoulos, Dimitri & Alexandm 106-5-29 210 5/19/09 ~ Denied
637 Woj tas, Jennifer 106-5-31 210 5/14/09 Denied
638 Franlgas, Harriet & Stavridis, Jack 106-5-35 210 5/19/09 Denied
639 Lockwood, Lois 106-6-27.2 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
640 Menglide, Alexandm & Mirella 106-6-30 210 5/14/09 Denied
641 Celic, Robert Jr. 106-6-32 210 5/7/09 Denied
642 Sweeney, Steven 106-6-33 210 5/19/09 Denied
643 Williams, Kathleen 106-6-35 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 6350
644 Halkias, Bill & Stamatia 106-7-3 210 5/14/09 Denied
645 Kratsios, Spyros & Lucretia 106-7-18 210 5/14/09 Denied
646 Pando, Thanas 106-7-45 210 5/14/09 Denied
647 Zinon, Patricia 106-8-2 210 5/13/09 Denied
648 Phillipou, Charles 106-8-29 210 5/14/09 Denied
649 Zicopoulos, Dimitrios & Fanny 106-843 210 5/14/09 Denied
650 Fragias, Vassilios & An~eliki 106-8-46 210 5/19/09 Denied
651 Grathwohl, Jeff & Audrey 106-9-2.4 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 9800
652 Schmidt, Michael & Susan 106-9-4.5 210 5/14/09 Denied
653 Ariosto, Irene 106-9-4.8 210 5/14/09 Denied
654 B artolotto, Joseph II & Pasquina 106-9-10.1 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 7800
655 Wechsler, Smart 106-9-13 210 5/14/09 Denied
656 , Divello, Anthony & Zilnicki-Divello 106-10-1.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
657 Pawlik, Stephen & Stephanie 106-11-11 210 5/14/09 Denied
658 Eidler, Alan D. & Sharon 106-12-3.1 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
659 Bergen, Brace & Leigh Ann 107-1-2.6 210 5/14/09 Denied
660 Galdri, Alberta & Walsh, Brendan 107-1-8.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
661 Lynch, William H. Jr. & Ann M. 107-1-24 210 5/19/09 Denied
662 Cruise, Margaret 107-2-2.6 210 5/14/09 Denied
663 Renzi, Kathleen 107-2-3.8 210 5/14/09 Denied
664 McLaughlin, Edward & Stella 107-3-4.1 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
665 Piacente, Christine & Keith 107-4-2.5 210 5/14/09 Denied
666 Cirincione, Lorin V. 107-4-2.6 210 5/12/09 Denied
667 Burr, Clay & Elizabeth 107-5-5 210 5/14/09 Denied
668 Brooks, Richard & Sharon 107-6-11 210 5/14/09 Denied
669 Rehberg, Linda 107-6-20 210 5/14/09 Denied
670 Smith, Ronald & Maria 107-7-2 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
671 Confusione, Michael 10%7-9 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
672 Mueller, Ingeborg 107-7-11 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
13
673 Pindar Vineyards LLC 107-7-12 210 5/15/09 Denied
674 Binder, Brandon 107-7-15 210 5/14/09 Denied
675 Moscato, Lisa 107-7-17 210 5/14/09 Denied
676 Piscatelli, Mike & Heather 107-7-18 210 5/14/09 Denied
677 Ezzard, Robert 107-7-21 210 5/14/09 Denied
678 Gabrielsen, Kristina 107-7-23 210 5/14/09 Denied
679 Koch, Margaret 107-7-24 I 210 5/19/09 Denied
680 Kaminsky, James & Cynthia 107-7-28 210 5/14/09 Denied
681 Vasilakos, Van & Cheryl 10%8-7 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 4500
682 Klein, James & Doris 107-8-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
683 Orlowski, Felix & Regina 107-8-23 210 5/19/09 Denied
684 Donohue, Frank & Doris 107-8-24 210 5/14/09 Denied
685 Ley, Charles & Mabel 107-8-26 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 4500
686 Trupia, Maria 107-8-34 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
687 Burus, Steven & Linda 107-8-38 210 5/14/09 Denied
688 Sweeney, Carmen 107-9-14 210 5/19/09 Denied
689 Wolf Pit LP 107-10-4.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
690 VanEtten, Raymond & Theresa 107-11-2 210 5/13/09 Withdrawn (Stip)
691 VanEtten, Raymond & Theresa 102'- 11-2 210 5/19/09 Withdrawn (Stip)
692 Perge, Steve & Juliana 108-3-5.16 210 5/19/09 Denied
693 Foster, Roger Jr. & Christine 108-4-7.25 210 5/14/09 Denied
694 Williams, Brian & Dorothy 108-4-7.35 210 5/14/09 Denied
695 Shipman, Joseph & Cathleen 108-4-7.5 210 5/14/09 Denied
696 Lombardi, Giuliano & Maura 109-2-12.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
697 L'Hommedieu, Gregory & Sophia 109-2-12.8 210 5/14/09 Denied
698 Nolan, Thomas 109-3 -2.7 210 5/14/09 Denied
699 Woodhull, Terry & Laura 109-3-2.17 210 5/14/09 Denied
700 Duell, John & Rachel 109-3-2.20 210 5/19/09 Denied
701 Prestia, Barbara & John 109-3-2.40 210 5/14/09 Denied
702 Lee, Manfred 109-5-3 210 5/15/09 Denied
703 Lauinger, Kara 109-5-13 210 5/14/09 Denied
704 Paulick, Karen 109-5-14.13 210 5/14/09 Denied
705 Bums, Joseph & Marie 109-5-14.36 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 7950
706 Scott, Jason 109-5-14.42 210 5/14/09 Denied
707 Rubin, Phyllis & James 109-5-14.45 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
708 Graeser, Sheree & Ronald 109-6-3 210 5/19/09 Denied
709 Egan, Susan & McGuire, Sally 110-2-1 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 6400
710 Zanoni, Richard 110-2 - 13 210 5/14/09 Denied
711 Raleigh, Margaret 110-2-16 210 5/14/09 Denied
712 Kluko, John 110-2-21 210 5/19/09 Denied
713 Buhler, Caroline 110-3-16 210 5/14/09 Denied
714 Kuehn, Christopher & Aida 110-5-2 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 6900
715 Weiss, Meredith 110-5-12 220 5/14/09 Denied
716 Moone¥, Edward & Mary Ann 110-5-13 210 5/19/09 Denied
717 Boutzalis, Theodore & Anna 110-5-20 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 5600
718 Louttit, Robert & Bridget 110-5-21.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
719 Contino, Gene 110-5-28 210 ! 5/14/09 Denied
720 Garofalo, John 110-5-30 210 5/14/09 Denied
721 Grathwohl, Laura 110-6-12 210 5/14/09 Reduced, to. 5300
722 Iavarone, Pat 110-7-3 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
723 Leary, Paul 110-7-21 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
724 Slade, Michael 110-7-26 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
14
725 Suesser, Alfred 110-8-32.8 250 5/14/09 Denied
726 Sucher, Alan & Montano-Sucher Teresa 111-1-6 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
727 Soto, John 111-24 210 5/14/09 Denied
728 Slattery, Maureen & John 111-2-6 210 5/14/09 Denied
729 Renard Thiel, David & Thiel, Eleanor 111-3-17 210 5/19/09 Denied
730 Schleipman, Peter & Patricia 1114-8 210 5/14/09 Denied
731 Stauffer, Doris Weston 111 4-20 210 5/14/09 Denied
732 Gluckman, Thomas & Roby 111-5-2 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
733 Chester, Robert & Wanda 111-6-8 I 210 5/14/09 Denied
734 Auerbach, Andrew & Diane 111-7-15 : 210 5/14/09 Denied
735 Killeen, Thomas J. 111-7-18 210 5/12/09 Denied
736 Neumann, William & Martha 111-11-3 210 5/14/09 Denied
737 Hoffman, James Louis & Ruth 111-11-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
738 Despagni, Thomas 111-11-23 210 5/15/09 Denied
739 Koch, Barbara 111 - 12-5.4 210 5/19/09 Denied
740 Mallin, Barry & Kriegel, Gail 111 - 12-7.2 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 15400
741 Lehnert, Robert & Joan 111 - 13-1 210 5/14/09 Denied
742 Lehnert, Robert & Joan 111-13-2 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
743 Brantuk, Joseph G. 111-14-5.4 210 5/18/09 Denied
744 Dunhuber, Lorraine 111-14-11 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
745 Molloy, James T. & Gloria 111-14-37 210 5/19/09 Denied
746 Lehnert, Robert & Joan 111-14-40 210 5/14/09 Denied
747 Pagoto, Anthony & Patricia 111-15-1.6 210 5/14/09 Denied
748 Racz, Michael & Dessimoz, Gail 112-1-4.1 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
749 Rizzo, Joseph 112-1-6.1 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
750 Del~raff, Garrett 112-1-11 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
751 Mavrikos, Alexandros & Ar[gyro 113-2-11 210 5/14/09 Denied
752 Mantzouranis, Emmanuel & Paraskevi 113-2-15 210 5/14/09 Denied
753 Pimino, Pmtonio & Gilda 113-3-2.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
754 Sherlock, Francis 113-3-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
755 Trojanowski,. Richard & Pamela 113-3-5 210 5/14/09 Denied
756 Pappas, Teddy & Emily 113-3-6 210 5/14/09 Denied
757 Entenmann, Jacqueline 113-3-7.2 210 5/15/09 Denied
758 Delafuente, Paul & lla 113-3-7.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
759 Briggmann, Richard & Lori 113-3-7.4 210 5/14/09 Denied
760 Mallins, William 113-44.1 210W 5/15/09 Denied
761 Priolo, Frank 113-6-19 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
762 Gatz, Walter & Marilyn 113-7-22 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 21700
763 Hoel~, Thomas X. & Ma~y L. 113-7-23 210 5/18/09 Denied
764 Entenmann, Jacqueline 113-8-1 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
765 Reith, Thomas 113 -8-7.7 210 5/14/09 Denied
766 Gallil~an, Thomas 113-9~7 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
767 Smith, Robert & Mary Ann 113-9-11 220 W 5/14/09 Denied
768 Barnett, Michael & Lynne 113-9-12 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
769 Pane, Salvatore 113-10-2 210 5/19/09 Denied
770 Wells, Laurie 113 - 10-8.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
771 Warner, Dennis 113-11-6 210 5/15/09 Denied
772 Wells, James Jr. 113-11-7 210 5/14/09 Denied
773 Lindner, Gary 113-13-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
774 Harkoff, Dennis & Diane 114-1-5.1 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
775 Calabrese, Elise 114-6-3 210 5/14/09 Denied
776 Tesser, Mark & Lynn 114-7-1 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
15
777 Freudenberg, Kurt 114-7-2.1 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
778 Blessinger, Lawrence trustee 114-7-10.2 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
779 Formica, Louis & Elizabeth 114-7-10.6 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
780 M & L Family Parmership LP 114-7-10.8 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
781 Blessinger, Lawrence W. 114-7-10.6 210 W 5/18/09 Denied
782 Schenone, William & Maria 114-7-11.3 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
783 Hart, Richard 114-7-12.1 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
784 Lessard, Monica & James 114-7-12.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
785 Tison, Pauline 114-9-13 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 5000
786 Roth, Alfred 114-10-13 210 5/14/09 Denied
787 Taylor, William 114-10-17 210 5/14/09 Denied
788 Bedoya, Fredy 114-11-23 220 5/14/09 Denied
789 Mercier, Thomas & Barbara 114-12-6 210 5/14/09 ' Denied
790 Harkoff, Dorian 114-12-14.5 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 6700
791 Rose, Gary 114-12-16.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
792 Schenone, William 115-1-3 210 5/14/09 Denied
793 Cianfrol~na, Ronald 115-4-6 210 5/14/09 Denied
794 Dellaquila, Frank 115-4-8.4 210 5/15/09 Denied
795 Obohoski, Stella & Flanagan, Patricia 115-4-23 210 5/14/09 Denied
796 York, Scan & Candace ' 115-4-25 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 8900
797 Sheehan, Michael & McAteer, Kathleen 115-4-28 210 5/14/09 Denied
798 Grosberg, Israel & Robins, Cathy 115-5-10 210 5/14/09 Denied
799 Johnson, John & Connie 115-6-2 210 5/19/09 Denied
800 Scheer, David & Michelle 115-6-28 210 5/14/09 Denied
801 Minol~ue, James & Diana 115-10-6 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
802 Powell, Jeanne & Roller Jr. 115-11-6 210 W~ 5/19/09 Denied
803 Markel, Ellen & Mizrach, Jane 115-11-8 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
804 Williams, James & Michelle 115-11-16 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
805 Mitchell, Michael & Janet 115-11-18.1 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
806 Jackson, Warren 115-12-4 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
807 Othen, Drobet, Carolyn 115-13-7 210 5/14/09 Denied
808 Kujawski, Daniel & Debra 115-13-15 210 5/14/09 Denied
809 Whalen, John & Audrey 115-13-20 210 5/14/09 Denied
810 Czujko, Zenon 115-14-17 210 5/14/09 Denied
811 Jerome, John & Janet 115-15-20 210 5/4/09 Denied
812 Demartini, Diane 115-15-21 210 5/14/09 Denied
813 Sciacchitano, David 115-15-24 210 5/14/09 Denied
814 Depinto, Joseph & Rose 115-16-3 210 5/14/09 Denied
815 Berry, Mark 115-16-9 210 5/14/09 Denied
816 Miltner, Richard & Marilyn 115-17-14 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
817 Radil~an, Raymond & Diane 115-17-17.3 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 11700
818 Bundrick, William & Linda 115 - 17-17.7 210 5/14/09 Denied
819 Hoeg, James E. & Karen A. 115-17-17.10 210 W 5/18/09 Denied
820 Francica, Joseph J. 115-17-17.16 210 5/18/09 Denied
821 Hruz, Peter & Joanne 115-17-17.19 210 5/19/09 Denied
822 Reichardt, Dennis & Jean 115-17-17.20 210 5/14/09 Denied
823 McCabe, Susan& Jacobs, Stephen 115-17-17.25 210 5/14/09 Denied
824 Hygom, Scott & Kathleen 115-17-17.28 210 5/14/09 Denied
825 Bol~ut, John & Frances 116-1-1.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
826 Tyree, Barbara 116-1-8.3 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
827 Truglia, Dunewood & lleen 116-2-7 210 5/14/09 Denied
828 Giordano, Ed 116-2-16.1 210 5/11/09 Denied
16
829 Shortino, Mario 116-2-18 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 5800
830 Breuer, Eileen 116-4-3.1 210 5/15/09 Denied
831 McGowan, Lois 116-6-19.2 210W 5/19/09 Denied
832 Hagerman, Ellen 116-7-3.2 210W 5/19/09 Denied
833 Hagerman, Ellen 116-7-3.2 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
834 Eckert, James 116-7-8 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
835 Piacente, Keith & Christine 117-2-17.5 210 5/14/09 Denied
836 Koehler, Frederick Jr. 117-3-6 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
837 Gonzalez, Ubaldo 117-5-41 210 5/14/09 Denied
838 Caridi, Anl~elina 117-6-19.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
839 Voskinarian, Mourad 117-6-20.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
840 Clarke, Suzanne 117-6-32.2 210 5/19/09 Denied
841 Sullivan, Richard & Matson, Anthony 117-9-20 210 5/14/09 Denied
842 Pia, Christopher 118-1-2 250 W 5/15/09 Denied
843 Ma)ne, Frederick 118-1-15.1 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
844 Perry, Jonathan 118-2-11.4 250 5/15/09 Denied
845 Sampieri, Joyce 118-2-12 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
846 Menaker, Mitchell & Norman 118-3-8.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
847 Zimmer, Christian & Carol 118-4-3 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
848 Aloia, John & Elvira 118-4-9 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
849 Buffa, Philip 118-5-2.1 210 W 5/15/09 Denied
850 Comoran, David 119-1-17 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
851 Dessimoz, Gail & Racz, Michael 120-3-6 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 13800
852 Salice, Kathleen R. 120-3 -8.8 210 5/18/09 Denied
853 Chamberlain, William & Kathleen 120-3-8.13 210 5/14/09 Denied
854 Ranieri, Mieola 120-3-8.24 210 5/15/09 Denied
855 Domenici, Alfred 120-3-8.26 210 5/14/09 Denied
856 K_rukowski, William 120-3-8.27 210 5/19/09 Denied
857 Krukowski, William 120-3-8.27 210 5/14/09 Denied
858 McDonoul~h, Grace 121 - 1-3.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
859 Stevens, Matthew & Martha 121-4-15 210 5/14/09 Denied
860 Dana, Lorin & William 121-5-1.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
861 Feeney, Kevin & Kelly 121-7-9 210 5/14/09 Denied
862 Gutherz, Sophia & Miller, Martin 122-1-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
863 Fuentes, Kim 122-2-12 220 5/14/09 Denied
864 Steadman, Gregory & Catherine 122-2-24.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
865 Mercurio, Marcus 122-3-31 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
866 O'Toole, Richard & Kathleen 122-4-10 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
867 Mello, Chad 122-4-18 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
868 Lamaida, Paul & Debra 122-4-31 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
869 Doubrava, Joseph & Dora Kate 122-5-1 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 7300
870 Condron, Ronald 122-5-5 210 5/15/09 Denied
871 Gremler, William & Mary Ann 122-5-6 210 5/14/09 Denied
872 Wilsberg, William 122-5-13.7 210 5/14/09 Denied
873 Pymm, William & Marilyn 122-9-7.25 210 5/14/09 Denied
874 Silverstri, James 122-10-1 210 5/14/09 Denied
875 Kramer, Steven 123-3-4.1 210 W 5/18/09 Denied
876 Friedman, Stephen 1234-4.1 210 W 5/14/09 Denied
877 Hallenbeck, Geoffrey 123-5-3 210 5/I 4/09 Denied
878 Milot, Philip 123-5-26 260 W 5/19/09 Denied
879 Radigan, Raymond & Aileen 123-6~5.7 210 5/19/09 Denied
880 Lauriguet, Robert & Renee 123-6-8.3 210 5/14/09 Denied
17
881 Wickham, Jay Parker 123-7-1 210 W 5/19/09 Denied
882 Mueller, Nancy 123-8-11.1 210W 5/19/09 Denied
883 Minnick, Kenneth 124-1-3.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
884 Hansen, Sherry 125-1-2.13 210 5/14/09 Denied
885 Altman, Eugene & Joann 125-1-2.17 210 5/14/09 Denied
886 Grauer, John Sr. & Mary 125-1-2.20 210 5/14/09 Denied
887 Lewin, Ashley 125-2-1.23 210 5/15/09 Denied
888 Commander, Janis Real Est. & David 125-2-1.25 210 5/14/09 Denied
889 Travis, Richard c/o DiCandia 125-3 - 1.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
890 Wilcenski, Mitchell & Theresa 125-3-7.5 210 5/14/09 Denied
891 Palmieri, Frank Jr. 12544 210 5/14/09 Denied
892 Maher, Theodore & Kathy 1254-6 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 4900
893 Hal~erman, Ellen 1254-24.18 210 5/19/09 Denied
894 Dowlinl~, Edward 126-3-16 220 5/15/09 Denied
895 Kowalski, Daniel & Susan 126-3 -20 210 5/14/09 Denied
896 Pope, Henry & Martha Anna 1264-16.4 210 5/14/09 Denied
897 D'Addario, James 1264-17.2 210 5/18/09 Denied
898 D'Addario, James 126-5-6 210 5/18/09 Denied
899 Busch, Steven & Cardinale, Louise 126-5-9 210 5/14/09 Denied
900 Norell, Robert 126-6-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
901 Main, Kathryn & Elizabeth 126-6-11 210 5/19/09 Denied
902 Hildesheira, David & Tammie 126-7-28.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
903 Fiorelli, Stephen 126-7-31 210 5/14/09 Denied
904 Harkoff, Dorian & Dennis 126-8-19 210 5/19/09 Denied
905 Harkoff, Dorian & Dennis 126-8-20 210 5/14/09 Denied
906 Mnnz, Edward & Sandra 126-8-22 260 5/19/09 Denied
907 Clarke, O'Connor & Dorothea 126-8-25 210 5/14/09 Denied
908 Noble, Joseph 126-9-3 210 5/14/09 Denied
909 Kermanshahchi, Phillip & Linda 126-10-1.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
910 Golanec, Carey & Paul 126-10-7.2 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 5900
911 Seidenberg, Deborah 126-10-19 210 5/19/09 Denied
912 Cioffalo, Salvatore 126-13-1 210 5/15/09 Denied
913 Orent, Stephen & Jeanine 126-134 210 5/14/09 Denied
914 Conner, Lawrence & Deborah 1274-19 210 5/14/09 Denied
915 Nardolillo, Louis 127-5-1 210 5/15/09 Denied
916 Commander, David & Elizabeth 127-5-3 210 5/19/09 Denied
917 Lockman, Robert & Barbara 127-5-6 210 5/14/09 Denied
918 Kellinl~, Barbara 127-5-8 210 5/14/09 Denied
919 Ireland, Michael 127-5-10 210 5/14/09 Denied
920 Rose, John 127-5-11 210 5/15/09 Denied
921 Neville, Michael & Virginia 127-6-7 210 5/14/09 Denied
922 Commander, David & Elizabeth 127-7-3 210 5/14/09 Denied
923 Gunder, Hul~h & Laura 127-7-4 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 8000
924 Gueli, Charles 127-7-5 210 5/12/09 Denied
925 Small, Susan 127-7-16 210 5/14/09 Denied
926 Fedun, Deirdre & Patrick 127-9-4 210 5/19/09 Denied
927 Novak, Thomas 127-9-7 210 5/15/09 Denied
928 Krause, Carl & Karen 127-9-16 210 5/14/09 Denied
929 Scaparro, Bemardo 127-9-19 210 5/14/09 Denied
930 Gregory, Scott & Christine 127-9-20 210 5/15/09 Denied
931 Milner, Mary 127-9-22 210 5/19/09 Denied
932 Seifert, John & Tara 127-9-24 210 5/14/09 Denied
18
933 Scaparro, Charles 127-9-29 210 5/14/09 Denied
934 Detrano, Christopher 128-1-19 210 5/14/09 Denied
935 Detrano, Salvatore & Margaret 128-2-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
936 Mato~cik, Gerard 128-3-12.4 210 5/14/09 Denied
937 Cassidy, James 128-3-13 2 l0 5/14/09 Denied
938 Bookmiller, Brent & Colleen 128-3-17 2 l0 5/19/09 Denied
939 Robinson, Sherwood & Barbara 128-3-22 210 5/14/09 Denied
940 Potdevin, Robert 1284-23 210 5/19/09 Denied
941 Crosson, Joan & O'Rourke, Kevin 128-4-25 210 5/14/09 Denied
942 Chisholm, Joseph & Joan 128-4-26 210 5/19/09 Denied
943 Braunstein, Ellen 128-5-7 210 5/14/09 Denied
944 Pridlgen, Hilary 128-6-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
945 Pridgen, Hilary 128-6-15 210 5/14/09 Denied
946 McCaskie, Ronald 128-6-16 210 5/14/09 Denied
947 Carey, James & Quigley, Dorothy 128-6-20 210 5/19/09 Denied
948 Westee, Alphons 128-6-23 210 5/19/09 Denied
949 Zilz, William 129-1-5.2 210 5/18/09 Denied
950 MeKee, Paul & Lucille 129-1-8 210 5/19/09 Denied
951 Levin Family Partnership 135-2-10.1 210 5/4/09 Denied
952 Goldblatt, Bruce & Deborah 135-3-1 210 5/15/09 Denied
953 Lombardo, Anthony & Rosemarie 135-3-25 210 5/14/09 Denied
954 Curran, Michael & Susanna 136-1-2 210 5/14/09 Denied
955 Johnson, Paula 136-1 - 19.3 210 5/14/09 Reduced to 5700
956 DiGrel~orio, Robert & MmV Kate 136-1-36 210 5/14/09 Denied
957 Gledich, Rita 136-1-46 210 5/18/09 Denied
958 Logmnde, Michael 136-2-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
959 Boutwell 83 Trust Attn: Robert Mac 136-2-8.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
960 Reilly, Brian 137-1-26 210 5/14/09 Denied
961 Sporing, Robert & Patricia 137-2-13 210 5/19/09 Denied
962 Leperides, Gm$ory & Theodora 137-2-20 210 5/14/09 Denied
963 ~ Wilm, Walter 137-3-5 210 5/15/09 Denied
964 I Kiernan, Patricia 137-3-10 210 5/14/09 Denied
965 Furst, Michael & Joan 137-4-5.2 210 5/14/09 Denied
966 Lelmert, Robert & Joan 137-4-23 210 5/14/09 Denied
967 Samios, Nicholas & Dianne 137-5-13 260 5/14/09 Denied
968 Schneider, Georl~e 138-1-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
969 Gralton, Gerard & Mary 138-2-11 210 5/14/09 Denied
970 Reiter, Carl Jr. & Yvonne 139-3-7 210 5/14/09 Denied
971 Taylor, Nancy 139-3-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
972 LI Sound Oyster LLC 140-1-23.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
973 Antonucci, Russell & Lauren 140-2-36.3 210 5/19/09 Denied
974 Brigham, Lauren 140-2 -45.1 210 5/14/09 Denied
975 Victoria, Dorothy & John 141 - 1-11 210 5/14/09 Denied
976 Buchholz, Thomas & Winiarz, Marie 141-1-13.1 210 5/19/09 Denied
977 Schwarz, Rosemary 141-2-4 210 5/14/09 Denied
978 Racanelli, Steven & Janine 142-1-4 210 5/19/09 Denied
979 Giardiello, Alfred 142-1-14 210 5/14/09 Denied
980 Ciletti, Alfred 143-1-6 260 5/15/09 Denied
981 Ciletti, Alfred 143-1-6 260 5/14/09 Denied
982 Sidor, Doreen 143-1-9 210 5/14/09 Denied
983 Richards, Alan & Louise 143-2-24 210 5/14/09 Denied
984 Zahra, Richard & Maria 143-3-29 210 5/14/09 Denied
19
985 Skuro, Rose 143-3-30 210 5/19/09 Denied
986 JP Morgan Chase Bank 143-3-33.2 210 5/7/09 Denied
987 Kropp, Anthony 143-5-8 210 5/15/09 Denied
988 O'Neill, Thomas & Catherine 144-1-22 210 5/14/09 Denied
989 Doone¥, Julie 144-1-23 210 5/14/09 Denied
990 Palmiotto, Ralph 144-2-38 210 5/14/09 Denied
991 McGlone, Edward & Mary Ann 144-3-7 : 210 5/14/09 Denied
992 Scarola, Frank 144-3-20 210 5/14/09 Denied
993 Cubells, Stephen 144-4-5 220 5/15/09 Denied
994 Re~ynolds, Faye 144-5-16 210 5/14/09 Denied
995 Rodger, Edwin Jr. 144-5-21 210 5/19/09 Denied
996 Penney, Deborah 144-5-26 210 5/19/09 Denied
997 Wittmeier, John A. 145-1 - 1 210 5/18/09 Denied
998 Thoet, Carolyn 145-2-3 210 5/14/09 Denied
999 Cassidy, James & Mallinson 145-3-15 210 5/14/09 Denied
1000 Schlesinger, Alan 1454-7 210 5/19/09 Denied
1001 Chisholm, Joan 1454-16 210 5/19/09 Denied
20
Grievance Commercial 2009
Property
Name SCTM# Code Date Result
1002 170 Moore's Lane Realty Corp 45-7-3 440 5/7/09 Denied
1003 372 Jericho Corp. 84-1-26.3 449 5/18/09 Denied
1004 633 North Management LLC 59-9-30.4 484 5/18/09 Denied
1005 808 Realty CorP. 102-5-26 432 5/15/09 Denied
1006 1400 Young's Ave. Corp 60-2-10.4 463 5/4/09 Denied
1007 38-44 Front Street LLC 1001-4-10-31 454 5/18/09 Denied
1008 53795 Southold Props. LLC 61-1-16 481 5/18/09 Denied
1009 61475 Family Realty LLC 45.1-2-3 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1010 74825 Main Rd. LLC 45-4-8.3 461 5/7/09 Denied
1011 7-Eleven Inc. 46-1-2.2 450 5/7/09 Denied
1012 7-Eleven Inc. 62-3-37 484 5/7/09 Denied
10t3 Aiello, Liz 45.1-1-6 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1014 Aliano, Nicholas 83-1-11 591 5/15/09 Denied
1015 Anac, Ared 45.1-1-30 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1016 Andreozzi, George 38.2-1-33 411 C 5/18/09 Denied
1017 Angelina Properties LLC 114-12-2 484 5/7/09 Denied
1018 Angelson, Perry & Melinia 1001-4-7-20 411 C 5/7/09 Denied
1019 Angelson, Perry & Melinia 1001-5-4-26 481 5/7/09 Denied
1020 Aykaz, Diran 45.1-1-34 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1021 Badger Enterprises Inc. 121-3-7.4 120 5/15/09 Denied
1022 Baxter, William Jr. & Patricia 108-4-11.2 484 5/7/09 Denied
1023 Benalli LLC 59-3-29 485 5/18/09 Denied
1024 Bertault, Vincent 45.1-1-20 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1025 Bertorello, Robert 45.1-1-16 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1026 Bonvino, Joseph 56-4-6 421 5/18/09 Denied
1027 Breezy Sound Corp. 45-1-2.1 411 C 5/7/09 Denied
1028 Brokaw, Bennett 45.1-2-26 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1029 Busch, Steven & Louise 114-11-15 485 5/7/09 Denied
1030 Caligiure, Sam & Barbara 45.1-1-14 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1031 Caligiure, Sam & Barbara 45.1-2-10 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1032 Capital One N.A. 1001-4-10-10.1461 5/4/09 Denied
1033 Capital One N.A. 61-2-12.2 460 5/4/09 Denied
1034 Capital One N.A. 102-6-13.1 463 5/4/09 Denied
1035 Capital One N.A. 141-3-30 311 5/4/09 Denied
1036 Capital One N.A. 141-4-2 311 5/4/09 Denied
1037 Capital One NA. 141-4-3 330 5/4/09 Denied
103~ Capital One N.A. 141-4-6.1 463 5/4/09 Denied
1039 Caravanos, Jack 45.1-1-11 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1040 Carnation Properties Inc. 109-1-10.1 120 5/18/09 Denied
1041 Celic, Robert A 143-3-1 485 5/7/09 Denied
1042 Ciaccio, Joseph 45.1-1-2 !411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1043 Cleaves Point LLC 61-2-1 484 5/18/09 Denied
1044 Colletti, Lou 45.1-1-31 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1045 Corazzini, Richard 45.1-1-18 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1046 Costas, Minnie 53-1-3 415 5/19/09 Denied
1047 Coster, Wiliam F. 97-6-15 471 5/18/09 Denied
1048 Cove at Southold Brd. of Mngrs 87.1-1-1 411 5/18/09 Denied
1049 Cozy Coq:) 60-2-4 483 5/7/09 Denied
1050 Cozy Corp 70-2-11 485 5/7/09 Denied
1051 CSC Acquisition NY Inc. 52-5-59.5 449 5/5/09 Denied
1052 Cutcho Corp. 60-2-3.1 438 5/4/09 Denied
1053 CVS Albany LLC 143-2-30.2 453 5/7/09 Denied
1054 Damianos, Alexander 85-2-11.1 311 5/15/09 Denied
1055 Damianos, Alexander 85-2-13.2 311 5/15/09 Denied
1056 Damianos, Herodotos 59-3-28.5 130 5/15/09 Denied
1057 Damianos, Herodotos 74-1-38 105 5/15/09 Denied
1058 Damianos, Hemdotos 74-1-42.7 120 5/15/09 Denied
1059 Damianos, Herodotos 74-4-3.2 152 5/15/09 Denied
1060 Damianos, Herodotos 84-4-10.1 129 5115109 Denied
1061 Damianos, Herodotos 85-1-9 152 5/15/09 Denied
1062 Damianos, Herodotos 85-1-10 152 5/15/09 Denied
1063 Damianos, Herodotos 85-2-9.2 152 5/15/09 Denied
1064 Damianos, Herodotos 86-1-15 152 5115109 Denied
1065 Dank, Leonard & Beryl 97-1-1 120 5/7/09 Denied
1066 Dasilva, Lynn 45.1-2-7 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1067 Davey, Thomas 38.1-1-12 411 C 5118109 Denied
1068 Derjangocyan, Minas 45.1-2-23 411 C 5119109 Denied
1069 Di Borghese Castello LLC 101-2-18.3 485 5/7/09 Denied
10'70 Di Borghese Castello LLC 102-1-3.4 152 5/7/09 Denied
10'71 Di Candia, Frank 69-4-2.2 484 5119109 Denied
1072 Dixon, Thomas 45.1-2-13 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1073 Dolomite, Vincenzo & Ileana 1001-4-7-24 422 5/7/09 Denied
1074 Driftwood Cove Owners Co Inc. 46-1-31.1 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1075 Dmskoski, John & Susan 83-3-8 449 5/7/09 Denied
1076 Dursunian, Kevin 45.1-1-13 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1077 Dursunian, Marc 45.1-2-34 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1078 Dursunian, Pearl 45.1-1-28 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1079 East Wind Shores Condo Assn. 51.1-1-1 to 10 411 C 5/18/09 Denied
1080 Edson, Lewis 102-2-16 120 5/7/09 Denied
1081 End of the Road LLC 122-3-17.1 484 5/18/09 Denied
1082 Fabb, Risa 99-4-22 417 5/7/09 Denied
1083 FHV LLC 61-1-13.1 452 5118109 Denied
1084 FHV LLC 125-1-19.7 484 5118109 Denied
1085 First Settlers Ltd. 70-2-3 471 5/18/09 Denied
1086 Foodbasket Properties Inc.61.4-25.1 454 5/7/09 Denied
1087 Gama-Dun Park Corp. 142-1-27 432 5115109 Denied
1088 Gargiula, Christine 45.1-1-29 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1089 Genovese Drug Stores 142-1-26 452 5/15/09 Denied
1090 Georgiades, Elias 31-2-17.1 417 5/7/09 Denied
1091 Getty Petroleum Marketing Inc. 1001.4-8-35 486 5/15/09 Denied
1092 Giannatassio, Janet 45.1-1-27 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1093 Grattan, Joseph S. 140-3-30 471 5/18/09 Denied
1094 Greenport Galleria LLC 1001-5-4-31.1 481 5/18/09 Denied
1095 Greenport Realty Corp 35-1-21 421 5/7/09 Denied
1096 Greenport Realty Corp 35-1-22 418 5/7/09 Denied
1097 Greenport Yacht & Shipbuilding 1001-5-3-10 448 5/7/09 Denied
1098 Greenporter Motel & Spa 1001-4-8-29 312 5/7/09 Denied
1099 Greenpoder Motel & Spa 1001-4-8-30 415 5/7/09 Denied
1100 Greenporter Motel & Spa 1001-4-8-31 ; 415 5/7/09 Denied
1101 Gremler, William & Mary Ann 122-7-6.4 484 5/7/09 Denied
1102 Gritzka, Walter 45.1-2-17 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1103 Hamilton, Jack & Donna 114-11-11.1 481 5/7/09 Denied
1104 Handy Pantry Stores Inc. 114-12-3.1 480 5/15/09 Denied
1105 Hartwig, Andrea 45.1-1-9 !411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1106 Haviters, Aret 45.1-1-24 !411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1107 Hawkeye Energy Greenport 1001-1-1-1.1 853 5/15/09 Denied
1108 Henry, Joseph R. 1001-4-6-36 483 5/7/09 Denied
1109 Homer Inc. 1001..4-10-32 481 5/7/09 Denied
1110 Israel, Richard & Lisa 1001-4-9-24.3 1 484 5/19/09 Denied
I 111 Jarvis, Vincent 45.1-2-25 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1112 Jemco Realty Associates LLC 35-1-24 311 5/18/09 Denied
1113 Jerome, Thomas & Jeanette 75-2-9 120 5/19/09 Denied
1114 Jhamb, Devendra 45.1-1-26 i 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1115 JP Morgan Chase 1001..4-10-5 461 5/7/09 Denied
1116 Junge, Arthur 96-1-19.1 440 5/18/09 Denied
1117 Kaplan's Market LLC 1001-4-1-10.2 484 5/7/09 Denied
1118 Kekjs Headquarters LLC 102-5-19 483 5/7/09 Denied
1119 King Kullen Grocery Co. Inc. 97-5-12 452 5/15/09 Denied
1120 KMGF Property LLC 45.1-1-1 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1121 Kos LLC 96-1-1.4 442 5/18/09 Denied
1122 Kruk, Frank & Elizabeth 69-4-1.3 484 5/19/09 Denied
1123 Krupski, Eugene & Maryann 100-2-3.2 120 5/7/09 Denied
1124 Kuhlmann Management Corp. 1001-4-10-29 425 5/18/09 Denied
1125 L & R Vineyards Associates101-1-4.1 120 5/7/09 Denied
1126 L & R Vineyards Associates101-1-5.2 152 5/7/09 Denied
1127 Lajibrda LLC 75-1-14 431 5/7/09 Denied
1128 Lajibrda LLC 75-1-14 431 5/7/09 Denied
1129 Lajibrda LLC 75-1-14 431 5/18/09 Denied
1130 Lamonsoff, Eric 45.1-I-10 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
I 131 Leon Petroleum, LLC 74-4-7.1 486 5/15/09 Denied
l 132 Leon Petroleum, LLC 115-3-9 486 ' 5/15/09 Denied
1133 Leong, Jack 45.1-2-33 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1 ] 34 Lerian, Aret 45.1-2-1 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1135 Levin Family Limited Prtnshp 44-2-22' 415 5/4/09 Denied
1136 Levin Family Limited Prtnshp 44-2-23 415 5/4/09 Denied
1137 Levin Family Limited Prtnshp 44-4-5.1 240 5/4/09 Denied
1138 Levin Family Limited Prtnshp 45-1-4 311 5/4/09 Denied
1139 Levin Family Limited Prtnshp 135-1-15.1 311 5/4/09 Denied
1140 Levin Family Limited Prtnshp 135-3-19 417 5/4/09 Denied
1141 Levin Family Limited Prtnshp 135-3-20 417 5/4/09 Denied
1142 Levin Family Limited Prtnshp 135-3-21 312 5/4/09 Denied
] 143 Lizewski, Joseph J. 102-2-12.6 480 5/7/09 Denied
4
1144 Lizewski, Joseph J. 102-2-12.7 I 311 5f7/09 Denied
1145 Luby, Cindy 45.1-2-12 ! 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1146 Luby, Cindy 45.1-2-19 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1147 Lucas, H. 59-3-32.1 431 5/18/09 Denied
1148 Lucas, Howard C Sr. 59-3-32.1 431 5/7/09 Denied
1149 Lukas, Joseph K. 97-1-6.1 484 5/18/09 Denied
1150 Maiorana, Aldo 1001-5..4-17 481 5/15/09 Denied
1151 Marian Columbus Club Inc. 102-2-5 534 5/7/09 Denied
1152 Maritime Funding Group Ltd1001-5-3-7 449 5/7/09 Denied
1153 Marlake Islip Co LLC 73-3-1.1 120 5~4~09 Denied
1154 Marlake Islip Co LLC 84-2-4.1 120 5~4~09 Denied
1155 Mathie Realty LLC 1001-2-5-33.4 471 5/7/09 Denied
1156 Mattituck Laundry Inc. 114-12-3.1 480 5/18/09 Denied
115'7 Mattituck Products Co. LLC122-7-3.1 426 5/7/09 Denied
1158 May, Nancy 45.1-2-8 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1159 Merlot LLC 75-2-2.1 311 5/15/09 Denied
1160 Merlot LLC 75-2-2.2 311 5/15/09 Denied
1161 Meskouris, Chds 106-1-27 311 5/19/09 Denied
1162 Misak Management LLC 1001-4-4-39 411 C 5/7/09 Denied
1163 Monica & Mike LLC 114-3-1 570 5/7/09 Denied
1164 Montgomery, Michael 8, Mada 140-3-31 483 5/7/09 Denied
1165 Moore, Patricia 45.1-2-29 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1166 Murphy, Rachel Levin 44-2-20 421 5~4~09 Denied
1167 N 8, L Properties LP 112-1-9.1 129 5/7/09 Denied
1168 N & L Properties LP 120-2-4 311 5/7/09 Denied
1169 Neuburger, Weroer 44.1-1-7 411 C 5115109 Denied
11 ?0 North Fork Prof. Realty Assoc. 63-1-19 465 5~4~09 Denied
1171 Noyes, Anna M. 45.1-1-12 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1172 O'Leary, Patrick 45.1-2-27 411 C 5119109 Denied
1173 Osprey Dominion Co. 75-1-20.1 152 5/7/09 Denied
1174 Ostroski, Gary & Madella 1001-4-10-17 422 5/7/09 Denied
1175 Ovsianik, Allen 97-2-15 432 5/7/09 Denied
1176 Pagano Holding Corp. 1001-6-2-21.1 481 5/7/09 Denied
1177 Parry, Robert A. 44.1-1-10 411 C 5/18/09 Denied
1178 Peconic Landing at Southold Inc 35-1-25 642 5/7/09 Denied
1179 Penny; George L. Inc. 53-2-27.2 444 5118109 Denied
1180 Penny,. George L. Inc. 141-3-38.1 444 5/18/09 Denied
1181 Penney Wm. 55-5-2.2 435 5/7/09 Denied
1182 Pindar Associates 85-2-14 120 5/15~09 Denied
1183 Pindar Associates 113-7-19.24 120 5/15/09 Denied
1184 Pindar Associates 113-7-19.25 120 5/15/09 Denied
1185 Pindar Associates 113-7-19.26 129 5/15~09 Denied
1186 Pindar Vineyards LLC 85-2-15 120 5/15/09 Denied
1187 Pindar Vineyards LLC 108-4-1.1 120 5/15/09 Denied
1188 Pipes Cove Condo Brd of Mngrs 1001-7-1-16.2 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1189 Pipes Cove Condo Brd of Mngrs 1001-7-1-16.3 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1190 Pipes Cove Condo Brd of Mngrs 1001-7-1-16.4 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1191 Pipes Cove Condo Brd of Mngrs 1001-7-1-16.5 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1192 Pipes Cove Condo Brd of Mngrs 49-1-25.2 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1193 Pipes Cove Condo Brd of Mngrs 49-1-25.3 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1194 Pipes Cove Condo Brd of Mngrs 49-1-25.4 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1195 Pipes Cove Condo Brd of Mngrs 49-1-25.5 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1196 Pipes Cove Condo Brd of Mngrs 49-1-25.6 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1197 Pirrera, Anthony 55-2-20 485 5/15/09 Denied
1198 Pirrera, Anthony 55-2-21 330 5/15/09 Denied
1199 Pirrera LP 110-4-12.2 311 5/15/09 Denied
1200 Pollari Cliffside LLC 45.1-2-4 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1201 Quad Enterprises LLC 55-5-17 105 5/18/09 Denied
1202 R & M Gamett Holdings LLC 45.1-1-25 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1203 Rah5, Anac 45.1-1-4 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1204 Research Charters Inc. 1001-5-3-8 448 5/7/09 Denied
1205 RHX Corp. 96-2-7 120 5/15/09 Denied
1206 Riverhead Building Supply Corp 46-1-2.3 444 5/14/09 Denied
1207 Romanelli Realty 60-1-6 441 5/15/09 Denied
1208 Roth, George 45.1-1-23 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1209 Rung, Christopher 45.1-2-24 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1210 S & J Kims Company LLC 62-3-7 425 5/18/09 Denied
1211 S T Preston & Son Inc. 1001-5-3-f2.1 481 5/7/09 Denied
1212 Saberito, Joseph 45.1-2-32 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1213 Saglamer, Tanya 45.1-1-33 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1214 Saragas, Michael 55-2-7 130 5/7/09 Denied
1215 Scarola, Frank & Donna 121-3-6 449 5/7/09 Denied
1216 Schenone, William & Marie 140-3-3.1 484 5/7/09 Denied
1217 Schoenstein, Fred & Joe 45-2-8 440 5/19/09 Denied
1218 Schoenstein, Joseph & Fred53-2-15.3 710 5/19~09 Denied
1219 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-1 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1220 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-2 : 411 C 5115109 Denied
1221 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-3 : 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1222 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-4 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1223 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-5 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1224 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-6 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1225 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-7 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1226 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-8 ~ 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1227 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-9 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1228 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-10 ! 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1229 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-11 i 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1230 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-12 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1231 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-13 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1232 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-14 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1233 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-15 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1234 Sea Breeze Village Condo 44.1-1-16 411 C 5/15/09 Denied
1235 Semerciyan, Seran 45.1-2-16 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1236 Serota Cutchogue LLC 97-5-12 452 5/7/09 Denied
1237 Serpone, Concertina 45.1-2-20 411 D 5119109 Denied
1238 SH Central Park Family LP 122-6-30.1 431 5/18/09 Denied
1239 Silver Sands Motel Inc, 45-6-1 311 5/15/09 Denied
1240 Silver Sands Motel Inc. 45-6-2 464 5/15/09 Denied
1241 Silver Sands Motel Inc, 45-6-8 323 W 5/15/09 Denied
1242 Silver Sands Motel Inc. 47-2-1 i 311 5/15/09 Denied
1243 Silver Sands Motel Inc. 47-2-8 311 5/15/09 Denied
1244 Silver Sands Motel Inc. 47-2-9 415 5/15/09 Denied
1245 Silver Sands Motel Inc. 47-2-11 415 5/15/09 Denied
1246 Silver Sands Motel Inc. 47-2-13 415 5/15/09 Denied
1247 Silver Sands Motel Inc. 47-2-14 417 5/15/09 Denied
1248 Singletree Woodworking LLC97-1-14 484 5/18/09 Denicd
1249 Sirinian, Sarven 45.1-1-5 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1250 Smith, William J. 75-3-3 130 5/7/09 Denied
1251 Southold Pointe LLC 56-7-2 421 W 5/18/09 Denied
1252 Stepanian, Rupert 45.1-2-31 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1253 Stedington Commons (~ Gpt LIc 1001-6-2-23.5 452 5/4/09 Denied
1254 Stocken Development LLC 63-3-8 482 5/15/09 Denied
1255 Stmng's Marine Inc. 122-9-6.2 570 5/15/09 Denied
1256 Suffolk Bancorp & SCNB 97-5-12 452 5/6/09 Denied
1257 Suffolk Bancorp & SCNB 143-3-4.2 462 5/6/09 Denied
1258 Sweeney, James 45.1-2-5 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1259 Tedaldi at Tidemark Inc. 45.1-1-3 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1260 Tedaldi at Tidemark Inc. 45.1-1-7 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1261 Tedaldi at Tidemark Inc. 45.1-1-15 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1262 Tedaldi at Tidemark Inc. 45.1-1-17 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1263 Tedaldi at Tidemark Inc. 45.1-1-19 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1264 Tedaldi at Tidemark Inc. 45.1-1-22 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1265 Tedaldi at Tidemark Inc. 45.1-1-32 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1266 Tedaldi at Tidemark Inc. 45.1-2-2 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1267 Tedaldi at Tidemark Inc. 45.1-2-11 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1268 Tedaldi at Tidemark Inc. 45.1-2-14 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1269 Tedaldi at Tidemark Inc. 45,1-2-15 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
12?0 Tedaldi at Tidemark Inc. 45.1-2-21 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1271 Tedaldi at Tidemark Inc. 45.1-1-22 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1272 Tedaldi at Tidemark Inc. 45.1-2-30 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
]273 Terranova, Giacomo 121-2-1 485 5/18/09 Denied
1274 Theo Associates LLC 1001-4-7-21 481 5/7/09 Denied
]275 Tocaro Realty LLC 45.1-2-18 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1276 Tonyes Realty Corp. 61-4-23 432 5/7/09 Denied
1277 Townsend, J. & Johnson S. 1001-2-2-41.1 465 5/7/09 Denied
1278 Townsend Manor Inn Inc. 1001-2-3-9 415 5/7/09 Denied
1279 Townsend Manor Inn Inc. 1001-2-3-10 414 5/7/09 Denied
1280 Tyree, Tamara J. & Ors 116-1-8.1 311 5/15/09 Denied
1281 U Store It LP 63-1-10 484 5/7/09 Denied
1282 United States Postal Service 25-1-18 481 5/15/09 Denied
1283 United States Postal Service 102-5-2 484 5/15/09 Denied
1284 United States Postal Service 140-3-42.3 485 5/15/09 Denied
1285 Valcic, David 45.1-1-8 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1286 Viscardi, Rachael 45.1-2-28 411 C 5/19/09 Denied
1287 Vitale, John 1001-5-4-33.1 481 5/15/09 Denied
1288 Walbaum's Inc. 142-1-26 452 5/7/09 Denied
1289 Watson, May 1001-2-5-29 411 C 5/7/09 Denied
1290 Weiss, Russell 100-2-5.4 473 5/15/09 Denied
1291 Weiss, Russell 100-2-5.5 129 5/15/09 Denied
1292 Westview Holdings LLC 59-3-32.1 431 5/7/09 Denied
1293 Wheeler, Richard H. 55-2-22 ! 432 5/7/09 Denied
1294 Williams, Victor 45.1-1-21 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1295 Wisnieski, Michael 45.1-2-6 411 C 5119109 Denied
1296 WMS Realty Inc. 97-5-4.7 452 5118109 Denied
1297 Wolff, Kathleen McDowell 1001-5-4-29 481 5118109 Denied
1298 Woodhaven Manor Realty 95-1-7.2 120 5115109 Denied
1299 Woodhaven Manor Realty 95-1-8.3 120 5/15/09 Denied
1300 Woods, Elizabeth McCarthy 45.1-1-29 411 D 5/19/09 Denied
1301 Zahra, Charles & Jean 141-4-5 425 5/7/09 Denied
Stipulations 2009-10
1 Kirkpatrick, Steven 1001-5.-2-9 6000 to 5200
2 Millman, Angela 1001-5.-3-18 10800 to 10000
3 Nickola, Daniel 1000-15.-9-1.13 9800 to 8200
4 Hernandez, Jose 1000-18.-5-10 6800 to 5800
5 Catalano, Stephen 1000-22.-5-3 7500 to 7150
6 Soti.ryadis, Angeliki 1000-30.-2-34 5200 to 4900
7 Rogers, Sharon 1000-31.-7-21 4900 to 4500
8 Robins, Madeline 1000-33.-2-46 6350 to 5600
9 Pumhagen, N¢lia 1000-33.-5-1 6200 to 5500
10 Heins, Janet 1000-34.-3-2 4400 to 3900
11 Radacinski, Margaret 1000-35.-1-8 5650 to 5400
12 Bettler, Anton 1000-35.-6-36 8400 to 7500
13 Travis, Maggi 1000-48.-3-18.1 6500to 5150
14 Verity, Michael 1000-48.-342.6 8800 to 6800
15 Connors, James 1000-50.-3-22.3 11000 to 8500
16 DeNicola, Frank 1000-51.-3-3.4 10700to 8500
17 DeNiCola~ Peter 1000-51.-3-3.7 11200 to 8800
18 DeNicola, Peter 1000-51.-3-3.8 8000 to 6400
19 Weigold, Marilyn . 1000-51.-3-3.9 8500 to 7400
20 Rempe, Stacia 1000-53,-6-40 6300 to 5300
21 Ryzuk, Thomas 1000-54.-5-14 16200to 12000
22 Cochran, Carlisle 1000-54.-9-18.2 6400 to 4900
23 Siejk!a, Stanley 1000-59.-7-19 4400 to 4000
' 24 Kaelin, Adam 1000-59.-11-3 4500 to 4100
25 Laoudis of Southold 1000-61.-4-22 11200 to 8200
26 Abruzzo, Anthony 1000-63.- 1 - 13.2 8200 to 7300
27 Cardinale, Marisa 1000-67.-1-3 - · 6700 to 5300
28 Helf, John M Jr 1000-70.-7-13 7600 to 5500
29 Chilton, Edward 1000-70.-8-37 4900 to 4000
30 Hachmann, William 1000-70.-8-49 5800 to 4900
31 Adler, Terri 1000-70.-9-23 6000 to 5700
32 Laoudis T & A QPRT 1000-70.-13-20.4 58.600 to 56600
33 Mattebella Vineyards 1000-75.-2-15.1 4700 to 4200
34 Heins, Janet 1000-75.-3-1 8700 to 8200
35 Heins, Janet 1000-75.-3-2 9500 to 8900
36 Maher, Thomas 1000-77.-3-19 5600to 5300
37 DePaulis, Bruno 1000-79.-3-34 10200 to 9000
38 Orlando, Vincent 1000-79.-5-16.3 11000 to 9000
39 Wexler, Allan 1000-79.-8-18.2 6100 to 4100
40 Wexler, Allan 1000-79.-8-18.3 5100 to 4400
41 Pearsall, Ken 1000-83.-1-15 8800 to 6800
42 Garbarino, Thomas 1000-84.-1-6.7 6100 to 5500
43 Russell, Eric 1000-86.-1-4.10 8200 to 7300
44 Byrne, Catherine 1000-87.-2-18 4900 to 4500
45 Zanaboni, Patrizia 1000-87.-3-23 9300 to 7800
46 LaBarbera, Thomas 1000-88.-4-11 6500 to 5300
47 Simek, Richard 1000-88.-6-13.30 9300 to 8000
48 Clancy, Thomas 1000-95.-4-18.34 7300 to 6200
49 Rogers, Robert 1000-97.,7-12 7100 to 6800
50 Krill, William 1000-97.-8-9.1 6500 to 5500
51 Olsen, Janice 1000-100.-1-10 7300to 6300
52 Bianculli, Diane 1000-100.-1-37 6350to 6000
53 Sannino, Anthony 1000-101.-1-14.4 14900to 12600
54 Jung, Richard 1000-102.-1-4.7 9000 to 8100
55 KEKJS Headquasters 1000-102.-5-19 5500 to 4500
56 Homan, James 1000-103.-1-3 31000 to 23000
57 Conlin, Stephen 1000-103.-1-20.11 9500 to 8200
58 Cantelmo, Craig 1000-104.-12-7 6100to 5700
59 Van Etten, Raymond 1000-107.-11-2 5000 to 4500
60 McLean, Derek 1000-108.-4-7.41 8200 to 7000
61 Alec, Anna 1000-109.-1-6 5100 to 4600
i 62 Shields, Harold 1000-109.-5-14.30 13000 to 11800
63 Hassildine, Scott 1000-110.-5-4 7300 to 6300
64 Rust Fam. Ptnr 1000-111.-14-36.6 24600 to 20900
65 Gebbia, James 1000-113.-7-19.15 9100 to 8500
66 Navarra, Robert I000-113.-7-19.28 8400 to 7900
67 Testa, Stephen 1000-114.-9-9 13000 to 10500
68 Aver-Nemschick, 1000-114-.12-15 9200 to 7500
Susanne
69 ' Fenn Trust 1000-115.-6-14 7300 to 5500
70 Bladykas, William 1000-115.-6-18 6800 to 5700
71 Jerome, Greg 1000-115.-16-6 4800 to 4300
72 Gilbert, James 1000-115.-16-28 7100 to 5600
73 Wiederlight, F Marc 1000-11T-4-22 11100 to 9200
74 Flurry, Steve 1000-117.-6-23 7700 to 6400
75 Caliendo, John 1000-120.-3-8.5 7450to 6000
76 Horton, Nancy 1000-121.-3-7.3 13100 to 11500
77 Luzuta R C Revoc Trust 1000-121.-7-6 6450 to 5400
78 Ferris, Kathleen 1000-121.-7-8 9500 to 8400
79 Ragone, Patricia 1000-121.-7-10 7950to 6800
80 Olsen, David 1000-125.-4-24.12 15000 to 11800
81 Krogman, Raymond 1000-126.-3-2 5200 to 4700
82 Borak, Elyse 1000-126.-9-14.1 5400to 4800
83 Collins, Kathleen 1000-126.-10-21 11800 to 10500
84 Motherway, Nicholas 1000-126-13-2 14400 to 11500
85 McKenzie, Erica 1000-127.-7-3 8800 to 6800
86 Reisenberg, Lloyd 1000-127.-9-11 8600 to 8200
87 Hudock, Thomas 1000-128.-3-15 7600 to 6600
88 Peters, William 1000-139.-4-7 5300 to 4500
89 Smilovich, Raymond 1000-140.-1-4 5700 to 4600
90 Whalen, Cornelius 1000-140.-2-27 4200 to 3800
91 Lancia, Rick 1000-141.-1-20 7100to 6000
92 MacLellan, Robert 1000-143.-3-22 6900 to 6000
93 Fusaro, Joseph 1000-144.-2-29 7000 to 6000
94 Gaynor, Mark 1000-144.-3-10 6800 to 5800
95 Singleton, Mary 1000-144.-3-12 6100 to 5400
96 Mortimer, Donald 1000-144.-3-13 6700 to 6200
97 McAssey, Pauline 1000-144.-3-14 6000 to 5600
98 KVN, LLC 1000-144.-3-36 14500 12500
99 Leighton, Robert 1000-144.-4-10 15600 to 14600
Correctibn of Errors 2009/10
1 Doroski, Benjamin 100L-2.-5-30 Omitted Basic STAR
2 Israel, Issac 1001-4.-5-8 3400 to 3300
3 Millman, Angela P ~ 1001-5.-3-18 . Add Basic STAR
4 Tufaro, Janet 1001-6.-7-25.1 6000 to 5600
5 Grilli, Dorothy 1001-7.-3 -4 Delete Pro-rata
6 Bull, Priscilla T 1000-19.-1-19 Add Enhanced STAR
7 SGDP LLC 1000-19.-2-10.1 Add Farm Bldg Exempt
8 Fogarty, Kelly 1000-26.-2-2 Delete STAR
9 Latham, Scott 1000-54.-3-26.5 10800 to 9000
10 Sawicki, Joseph 1000-54.-3-26.10 12200 to 10000
11 Hulse, Walter 1000-54.-5-25 6500 to 5000
12 Bertschi, Stephen 1000-55.-2-8.10 11900 to 9000
13 Russell, Mahlon 1000-55.-7-5 Omitted BaSic STAR
14 Suffolk County 1000-56.-5-9 To R/S 8
15 Suffolk County 1000-56.-6-1.2 To R/S 8
16 Melly, Francis 1000z63.2-1-43 Add Enh STAR & Vets
17 Internodal Inc 1000-64.-1-16 10900 to 9000
18 Wesnofske, Eugene 1000-68.-4-8.6 Duplicate Parcel - Delete
19 Pickerell, Christopher 1000-70.-1-9 5800 to 4900
20 Lutkowski, William J 1000-77.-2-25 2900 to 800
21 Trupia, Maria 1000-78.- 1-10.20 Add Sr & Enh STAR
22 Prop Uncommonly 1000-78.-1-29 9400 to 8000
Perfect
23 Hurtado, John L Sr 1000-79.-2-7.3 8900 to 1700
24 Bergen, Joseph 1000-80.-1-29 10500 to 8200
25 Krupski, Jane 1000-84.-2-3.2 7100 to 6900
26 Looney, Matthew 1000-84.-5-2 Add Sr. Citizen Exempt
27 Pontino, John 1000-86.-5-12.2 7800 to 6600
28 Ryan, Michael 1000-88.-6-13.20 10800 to 9000
29 Cosmadelis, James 1000-88.-6-13.35 12600 to 9400
30 Schill, James 1000-90.-3-3 Basic to Enhanced
31 Collins, David 1000-95.-1-6 7200 to 6800
32 Rogers, Robert 1000-97.-7-12 6000 to 7100
33 Varano, Sal 1000-98.-4-26.1 6800 to 6300
34 Saddle Brook Rental 1000-102.-7-10 Delete STAR
35 Manarel, John 1000-103.-1-30 Delete Sr- Grant Basic
36 Mignone, Frederick 1000-107.-1-19 9000 to 8700
37 Trapanotto, Gary 1000-107.-4-8.1 6300 to 8700
38 True, Michael 1000-109.-6-13 9900 to 8700
39 Wanson, Gerald 1000-111 .-4-12 Add Basic STAR
40 Cavanagh, Maureen 1000- I 11.-7-14.1 Delete STAR
41 Hill, Linda 1000-111 .-11-13 21 ~400 to 20800
42 Ficner, Francis 1000-114.-6-9 Add Sr. Citizen
43 Rochefort, Ninette 1000-115.-6-11 Delete Vet, Add Pro-rata
44 Wilson, Susan 1000-115.-15-4 5200 to 4300
45 Harbes Farm Rhd East 1000-120.-1-1.3 Add Farm Bldg Exempt
46 Martinez, David 1000-121.-1-1.10 Add B, asic STAR
47 Bopp, Constance 1000-139.-1-6 Delete STAR
48 Smilovich, Raymond 1000-140.-1-4 Add Basic STAR
49 Carolan, Anne 1000-143.-2-18 Add Pro-rata
50 Robertson, John 1000-144.-2-37 6900 to 4000
Grievance Day
Tuesday, May 19, 2009
Chairman Gerard Schultheis called the meeting to order for the Grievance Day heatings
for 2009 for the Town of Southold at 9:00 a.m.
Gerard Schultheis: Good morning it's May 19, I would like to call this meeting of the
Town of Southold Grievance Board. Our first thing we need to do is swear in the
Assessors.
Daniel McConlogue: Would you please stand and raise your right hand. You do
solemnly swear that the testimony you are about to give in each proceeding and any
adjourned proceedings will be the truth the whole truth and nothing but the troth.
Kevin Webster: I do.
Robert Scott: I do.
Darline Duffy: I do.
Daniel McConlogue: Be seated please and state your name and home address for the
record.
Darline Duffy: Darline Duffy, 3165 Bay Shore Road, Greenport, NY.
Kevin Webster: Kevin Webster, 665 Gillette Drive, East Marion, NY.
Robert Scott: Robert Scott, 26700 Main Road, Orient, NY.
Daniel McConlogue: And for the record, these are the three Assessors.
Hearing #1
Daniel McConlogue: Would you please stand and raise your fight hand.
Linda Sanford: Uh huh.
Daniel McConlogue: You do solemnly swear that the testimony you are about to give in
this proceeding is the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth.
Linda Sanford: I do.
Daniel McConlogue: Be seated please and state your name and home address. The
assessors have been previously sworn.
Linda Sanford: Ok, my name is Linda Sanford and I live in Southold here, 780 Private
Road 17 in Southold.
Daniel McConlogue: What is the section, block, and lot?
Linda Sanford: The section block is...
Daniel McConlogue: Now you live in this house?
Linda Sanford: I do.
Darline Duffy: 81-3-27.1
Darline Duffy: Hold on to your hats.
Jonathan Wiggins: What is the assessed value?
Gerard Schultheis: 61,500 dollars.
Jonathan Wiggins: 61 thousand?
Linda Sanford: Yes.
Darline Duffy: Brand new construction
Linda Sanford: Yes.
Cara Wells: Owens, did Owens build that?
Linda Sanford: No, Bertani.
Daniel McConlogue: Does anyone have the indicated market value from that
assessment?
Darline Duffy: I do. At the .97 it's 6.34 million, at the 1.06 is 5.8 million.
Cara Wells: Darline, is this correct at 2.2 acres?
Darline Duffy: 2.15 yes.
Cara Wells: 2.15
Darline Duffy: Yes.
Jonathan Wiggins: Okay, and you have 250 feet on the beach?
Linda Sanford: Yes.
Daniel McConlogue: Do you have a copy of the appraisal?
Linda Sanford: No, the appraisal that was done was for the insurance, you know my
Chub insurance, and that was looking at the cost to replace and so I thought the
assessments were based on market value. I don't have it with me but I did have it
appraised about a year ago for the insurance purposes.
Gerald Schultheis: And at that point in time it was appraised at 6.8 million?
Linda Sanford: Yeah a year ago, yup. And you know its contents and everything else in
the home as well.
Cara Wells: So that included the contents?
Linda Sanford: Yes.
Cara Wells: Chub usually breaks out the house and the land or does the contents?
Linda Sanford: Yes, it usually does. I don't have that breakdown.
Gerard Schultheis: What proof are you offering in as to the value of the house?
Linda Sanford: I really want to thank you very much first of all for your time here. I just
wanted to have a conversation with you quite honestly. I was surprised by you know the
tax increase. I didn't expect it to be nothing honestly, and Darline and Bob have both
b6en very helpful to help me understand it, but I really just wanted to have a conversation
and understand a little bit on you know how the assessments are done. I thought they
were based on more market value and the market has declined. I just'got a recent figure
that I had seen that it was down about 4.8% in the last year for 2008.
Daniel McConlogue: Is that Southold?
Linda Sanford: That was, yes, Southold.
Daniel McConlogue: Do you have that?
Linda Sanford: I got that from John Nickles who I spoke to who said that was the recent
data he had.
Daniel McConlogue: And what was that?
Linda Sanford: 4.8%
Cara Wells: I believe that is in the newspaper.
Linda Sanford: Yes I think it was, you're right.
Daniel McConlogue: And that's minus right?
Linda Sanford: Yes, that's fight, that's right.
Cara Wells: Yes but this is based upon July 1, 08 not 09, not the last 9 months.
Linda Sanford: That's true, but there is coming up again I think the next time would be
coming up another tax bill.
Daniel McConlogue: The concern is this tax year.., the valuation date is July 1, 2008
Jonathan Wiggins: '08 is the date that is for the current tax roll.
Linda Sanford: Yeah, and you know I have looked at other places like for example I
know East Winds in Nassau Point has been on the market for awhile from 7.9 million
they've dropped it 6.9 and they finally took it off the market because they were unable to
sell it. I've looked at other homes and got some of the data in terms of the taxes that they
are paying and mine is clearly the most expensive for comparable acreage and waterfront
property. I don't know the home itself but I know my home is recently built.
Cara Wells: When was it done?
Linda Sanford: October 2nd, but you know I love it out here, I grew up out here, and I'm
coming home when I retire and my intentions are to move out here, and I don't have any
intention of selling the house at all. I want to pass it down generation after generation
and just to make sure my kids are able to pay for the taxes and stay here and not have to
move themselves. I just wanted to kind of give you my perspective and my observations
and ask that you just consider.
Gerard Schultheis: We really need to see some proof whether it is comparable sales or an
appraisal.
Linda Sanford: Well the only, you know...nothing has sold in that price range recently, I
mean the one that I have which would be the most comparable in terms of acreage,
waterfront, and even the size of the house is...
Jonathan Wiggins: I know.
Gerard Schultheis: Was it sold?
Linda Sanford: No. They can't sell it because the price they were asking has...there was
no market for it.
Daniel McConlogue: Just for your argument, is they're comparable homes to yours that
is assessed lower than yours.
Daniel McConlogue: (inaudible)
Linda Sanford: Yes. Now again when the assessment was done, I don't know the home
per se, I'm looking at acreage, I'm looking at waterfront and you know...
Daniel McConlogue: Can you give us a sheet or something, do you have anything on
that?
Linda Sanford: I wrote down, and this all, I can give you a copy of this. But I went...
Phyllis Atkinson: Can you bring it up here?
Daniel McConlogue: Give it to the chairman.
Linda Sanford: I went through and just looked at the acreage and waterfront property,
and again the homes I don't know about the homes really and then the tax parcels.
Daniel McConlogue: So you think these are comparable to yours?
Linda Sanford: (inaudible)
Daniel McConlogue: Generally speaking.
Linda Sanford: Yes.
Gerard Schultheis: So what we have here is just the name of the owners, the acreage, the
waterfront, feet on the water and the taxes.
Linda Sanford: Yes.
Jonathan Wiggins: You don't have anything as far as tax, size of house?
Linda Sanford: Right. Exactly.
Daniel McConlogue: Section, block, and lot I guess we could get it or you could get it.
Linda Sanford: I have it all. I tried to do a cheat sheet. I have it all.
Daniel McConlogue: You want to photocopy that and submit that what you have?
Linda Sanford: Oh sure.
Jonathan Wiggins: I would like to ask the assessor something...Darline?
Robert Scott: Wait, wait, one second please. Let's have one conversation here.
Jonathan Wiggins: The assessed value of the land has been 7,900 dollars since 1977,
thirty years later it's still 7,900 dollars as the land value, it is probably the same. Why
did it go up to 11,800 from '07 to '087 Did you reevaluate all of the waterfront
properties along that area?
Darline Duffy: Uh, yeah that's tree.
Jonathan Wiggins: Every one of them went up?
Darline Duffy: Several of them went up. I couldn't promise you that every one of them
went up. But I'll look that up for you.
Jonathan Wiggins: Ok, it just seems a little arbitrary; I'm just trying to figure out why.
Darline Duffy: For one thing...can I ask Mrs. Sanford a question?
Jonathan Wiggins: Sure.
Darline Duffy: Did you redo the bulkhead?
Linda Sanford: No I did not. That was already done by...
Darline Duff'y: Because it is a double bulkhead. You know, nobody has been down there
probably since 30 years. I have a picture of it, and it is a very substantial bulkhead and...
Jonathan Wiggins: It's a thirty-year-old bulkhead.
Darline Duffy: I have to check.
Linda Sanford: I didn't replace it so I'm not sure when it was replaced.
Cara Wells: Didn't the Millers replace that?
Linda Sanford: It was not Miller, Rosenberg was there before. The owners were
Rosenberg that I got it from.
Darline Duffy: Hang on I'll show you the bulkhead. It's very substantial. My feeling
was that this house...I don't have the bulkhead picture, but it's in the computer.
Jonathan Wiggins: Right right, but if somebody redoes the bulkhead we feel it adds
value to the land, wouldn't you reassess them at that point? But, they would need a
building permit to get bulk heading.
Robert Scott: Absolutely, we don't receive every bulk-heading permit. The Trustees
don't give us their permits. The only people who give us their permits are the Building
Department. Usually when we see a notice of change in the main structure of the
building then we have to take a look at any of the other improvements that we've done in
the past without notification to the Assessors Office. This is one of the things we take a
look at this particular point.
Jonathan Wiggins: So what you are say/ng is that the bulkhead was built and then they...
Robert Scott: There was no notification and then we went to take a look at it we had to
make an adjustment to that particular improvement that we didn't have previously on the
card.
Jonathan Wiggins: Did you... I mean 11 of '04 you've got demolition of dwelling and
reconstruction, 6 of 6 you've got construction of a garage, it seems like you should have
been aware of this situation long before '08.
Robert Scott: First of all this was a long process for her to do what she doing and one
thing that the Assessors do is that we don't try to kill anybody at any one particular
stretch. When we finish the assessment we have to look at every aspect on it and that
particular time she changed the assessment for everything at that particular point so she
wasn't tpfing to penalize Linda beforehand but at the end she had to put everything into
it.
Jonathan Wiggins: Yes
Cara Wells: It was a major...
Robert Scott: It was a major project.
Cara Wells: Major, major and it took a long...
Robert Scott: Beautiful job but a major project.
Cara Wells: Four years?
Linda Sanford: Four years, it took a long time. (inaudible)
Cara Wells: I'm sorry it took so long. I knew it was multi year, a multi-year project.
Linda Sanford: Yes it took a long time.
Phyllis Atkinson: Do you have...have you contacted any of the marine contractors to get
how much per foot it would cost to build the bulkhead?
Cara Wells: Costello probably has it.
Robert Scott: You can find that information out but I think you will find that at several
hundred dollars per front foot. That's the same with every...
Phyllis Atkinson: It was 300 a foot that was last year, so double is probably more than
that.
Robert Scott: With the cost of wood and everything else I can't tell you anymore because
I don't keep up with that.
Cara Wells: I know with that vinyl clad bulkhead on the Anderson property is quarter of
a million dollars. That's why 2 years to get the DEC permit so I do know that.
Jonathan Wiggins: Want to get some other property data property cards to see the
(inaudible) of some similar properties?
Darline Duffy: I have a parcel here on Jackson Street in New Suffolk that sold in
November of '07, it's an acre, it's 150 feet on the bay and they paid 2.75 million for it.
Historically, our waterfronts have been under assessed and at eleven eight...what number
am I using? We are looking at a million one for this two-acre parcel.
Robert Scott: With two hundred fifty feet of bulkhead and waterfront so the value
attributed to the land alone is very reasonable to be honest with you.
Jonathan Wiggins: Yeah, we are...I am just curious as to the spike in the land value and
I imagine that you gave us the two properties next door that are probably reflect similar
assessments. So maybe you can pull out 15.2 and 15.3.
Phyllis Atkinson: The house in New Suffolk that you just cited...
Robert Scott: That's just a lot.
Phyllis Atkinson: That's just vacant land? They demolished...
Robert Scott: It's a vacant lot and then the lot next to it was sold for 3 ½ million in the
previous year and that they tore the building down.
Phyllis Atkinson: Okay
Robert Scott: And that had 108 feet of waterfront and it was on a half acre so basically
they paid 3 ½ million dollars for one improved lot which they tore down for a lot to
reconstruct and then they bought the lot next door for 2.75 million dollars and it's just a
vacant lot.
Jonathan Wiggins: It's just vacant land? She paid 1.65 for her lot.
Linda Sanford: Right right.
Robert Scott: The basic thing here is that the amount that we got there is less than even
what the appraised insurance value indicates so...and I'm not sure, when they do an
appraised insurance value do they count the land?
Jonathan Wiggins: I don't know; I'm not an insurance appraiser so...
Phyllis Atkinson: Land doesn't burn.
Cara Wells: No because the land...fight.
Jonathan Wiggins: The land doesn't burn.
Robert Scott: But what I'm saying is that they've got 6.8, what they've got in
improvements in the inside are...
Linda Sanford: There are valuable things inside.
Robert Scott: So I think one of them compensates for the other as far as the land is
concerned so that...
Jonathan Wiggins: May I ask you a question?
Linda Sanford: Please
Jonathan Wiggins: What do you think the house and property is worth?
Linda Sanford: You know...I'm assuming it goes by market value. That's what
I...that's what it costs to replace. That is what I'm trying to explain to you.
Jonathan Wiggins: Yeah what do you think it is worth?
Linda Sanford: You know, it's probably worth, I don't know...a million less than the
6.8, you know7
Jonathan Wiggins: So you think it's worth 5.8?
Linda Sanford: I mean ifI took 5 % offof...I have to do my math, 5% offo£my
6.8...you have the calculator.
Robert Scott: She is saying 6.46 million.
Linda San£ord: That's what we have testified to come down, the market is down.
Robert Scott: We are saying that even at the lowest residential assessment ratio that the
state has at .0097; we are saying 6.3.
Linda Sanford: My 6.3 would include the property inside so you would have to...
Robert Scott: I know but we would ha'be to...
Jonathan Wiggins: That's for your insurance; we're not going to value your tea set.
Linda Sanford: I know but I would take that off the 6.8.
Robert Scott: You know at this particular point we don't want to argue.
Linda Sanford: I know we don't want to; we are friends.
Robert Scott: We have to...we are assessors, that's what we do and one of the most valid
ways of approaching the value of a property is the cost and since it was just
completed...what was the cost? And the cost is different from the appraised value.
Jonathan Wiggins: Sure
Linda Sanford: Yes. But I guess ifI couldn't sell it for that much, which I have no
intention of selling it.
Jonathan Wiggins: We're just looking for inequities here and there.
Robert Scott: To be honest with you the assessors and Linda both want to have an
assessment that's fine, if she does nothing else to the property we're not coming back.
Jonathan Wiggins: It's a lovely house, it's a good spot, and you're happy with it, that's
what's most important.
Linda Sanford: I agree; I love it.
Jonathan Wiggins: Wetre going to look at everything we can. Do you feel the
property...where did you get the 6.8 or that's the insurance?
Linda Sanford: That was a Chub appraisal and I will give you a copy of that.
Jonathan Wiggins: No I have no doubt. All I really wanted was the figures that we see
here before us.
Phyllis Atkinson: Does that include the bulkhead on the Chub appraisal?
Jonathan Wiggins: No I don't think so.
Linda Sanford: I have a copy. I don't think it does. I should double check; if it could
bum maybe they did include it right? It could bum down I guess.
Jonathan Wiggins: Or wash out.
Linda Sanford: I should double check.
Phyllis Atkinson: It's in the water, I mean how much can you...?
Linda Sanford: I'don't know whether they included it or not; I'll have to check
Phyllis Atkinson: Okay
Linda Sanford: You know it is...and Chub does tend to appraise, I mean, I've also
negotiated with them my insurance bill because that was also very high.
Phyllis Atkinson: Oh
Linda Sanford: And again he was out here, this was a year ago, he also had a hard time
because there was no comparables to take a look at.
Jonathan Wiggins: Yeah yeah.
Phyllis Atkinson: Did you have to supply him with the cost of construction? And that's
how he appraised?
Linda Sanford: No, no he measured, looked at the materials I used; I have installed a
slate roof so we put a factor on to that.
Phyllis Atkinson: Okay so he didn't really go to your specs and...
Linda Sanford: Not the (inaudible)
Jonathan Wiggins: Did you use real slate?
Linda Sanford: Yes
Jonathan Wiggins: That's nice
Linda Sanford: It has to last forever for my family and grandchildren and the great
grandkids.
Phyllis Atkinson: Did you want a copy?
Darline Duffy: Could I just take a look?
Jonathan Wiggins: (whispering to Gerard Schultheis) We have one here, this is 2.6 that's
this one and then you have here...
Phyllis Atkinson: Mrs. Sanford are any of these properties located along the bay?.
Linda Sanford: Yes
Phyllis Atkinson: They are.
Linda Sanford: Yes yes.
Jonathan Wiggins whispers to Gerard Schultheis about property cards they are looking at
(inaudible)
Robert Scott: Jonathan that one fight there you've got is one that hasn't been, it was done
over and we haven't taken a look at it yet, the valuation.
Jonathan Wiggins: I see the land has been the same since '76 and was reevaluated in
1990 and the building was demolished in 1980 but still the land has not gone up at all.
What happened to 15.2 I'm curious with that one because it is the same square, same
water frontage.
Darline Duffy: I don't know. Fifteen point two, because the numbers don't nm
consecutively it gets crazy.
Cara Wells: Mrs. Sanford is the 4.8 average for 2008...
Linda Sanford: Yes
Cara Wells: You know the major impact of that was after the evaluation date. It is really
the third and fourth quarter.
Linda Sanford: Foarth qumter, right right.
Cara Wells: And again you have to remember this is July 1 '08 date
Linda Sanford: Right, I don't know how frequently you assess. It's not every year so
I'm kind of paying at the peak and the market is down and no one is predicting that it will
go back up to where it was so that was my biggest concern because I happened to get it at
the peak.
Daniel McConlogue: They do assess every year.
Cara Wells: But not with physical inspections.
Linda Sanford: Right
Daniel McConlogue: They don't reassess.
Linda Sanford: Right right.
Robert Scott: If you would like for the ones that have the original cards up there I'll
make copies for you.
Cara Wells: Could you also make a copy of Mrs. Sanford's list?
Robert Scott: Sure
Daniel McConlogue: Do have you that...?
Linda Sanford: I do have it, it's a big...I mean it's...
Daniel McConlogue: I'm talking about the section, block and lot and the properties that
you claim are different assessments than you and that are comparable.
Linda Sanford: Let me show you what I have. It provides you with a short summary but
I do have all of them.
Daniel McConlogue: Are you going to submit that?
Linda Sanford: It's my copy but I can.
Daniel McConlogue: Okay give us a copy.
Linda Sanford: Would you like this?
Cara Wells: That's your proof?.
Phyllis Atkinson: The Assessors Office can copy it for you.
Jonathan Wiggins: Those are your pictures correct?
Phyllis Atkinson: Are these your pictures Mrs. Sanford?
Linda Sanford: No those are Darline's.
Phyllis Atkinson: They are Darline's. Okay, did everybody see the photos?
Jonathan Wiggins: Yeah
Daniel McConlogue: No bring them down this way.
Cara Wells: We would like to see them down here.
Robert Scott: I gave her a copy of the...okay.
Phyllis Atkinson: I'll take the copy.
Jonathan Wiggins: Everybody's got the same bulk heading pretty much.
Linda Sanford: I just pulled it off. There's nothing on homes here; I know that.
Robert Scott: That's what I'm saying.
Linda Sanford: If there isn't, I agree.
Robert Scott: I just want to tell them that this has got an indication but it's not completed
because it doesn't show the improvements on here; I just want to specify.
Darliel McConlogue: That's the ones with different assessed values?
Robert Scott: Yup, it's the ones with different taxes. There is a difference between
assessed value, this isn't equal assessed value; it's taxes, so this could be after
exemptions so I want to emphasize that.
Linda Sanford: Yes, that's true too and I for my own simple way to look at it...
Robert Scott: I'm not trying to...I'm just trying to be accurate is what I'm trying to say.
Jonathan Wiggins: Does this jetty indicate the edge of your property?
Linda Sanford: Uh actually...actually no (inaudible)
Jonathan Wiggins: Ok so that's all of your property.
Linda Sanford: I did put a lot into it because it was my dream home. I worked so hard
all these years and I thought well this I could leave to my family so...
Phyllis Atkinson: It looks gorgeous from the photos; it's absolutely gorgeous.
Linda Sanford: I grew up. on a farm out here, a potato farm believe it or not.
Darline Duffy: She went to the Laurel school, the little red school.
Phyllis Atkinson: Oh
Linda Sanford: My mom did, I went to Cutchogue actually, Sacred Heart, then I went to
Mercy High School in Riverhead. It is great out here and when I retire I'm coming back
home again.
Jonathan Wiggins: You couldn't be in a better spot.
Linda Sanford: ! know.
Darline Duffy: Someone is making a copy of that. You know, my staffis short...one
them is out and one of them is up there, a little short in the office.
Linda Sanford: It's hard because it is bound so...
Darline Duffy: I don't know how they are doing it.
Linda Sanford: I should have made a copy, I didn't think of it.
Gerard Schultheis: Do we have everything we need?
Jonathan Wiggins: Pretty much, I'm just a little curious about the price of land values
here Darline. I see 15.2 has the land assessed at eighteen one in '64 and then in '65 it
went down to sixteen and then in '70 it was sixteen four and in '73 it was eleven seven
and then '76 it was eight thousand two hundred.
Darlinc Duffy: You know what, I was in high school then I don't know what...
Jonathan Wiggins: Me too, I'm just seeing the price the value of the assessed value for
the land...
Cara Wells: The property was divided Jonathan.
Phyllis Atkinson: The property was divided.
Cara Wells: It was divided. It was originally 19 acres.
Jonathan Wiggins: This one here did increase a little bit that's an indication...
Robert Scott: Jon, can I make a statement about one parcel, 15.3
Jonathan Wiggins: 16.37
Robert Scott: Fifteen point three, the assessor that did that change is sitting fight here
and that was the first year I was in office, the first four months I was in office and that's
the last time I was able to go to the property and I didn't know at that particular point that
when we looked at one you had to review all the others, I've learned that since so if there
is any error on that particular lot don't blame anyone but me. Darline wasn't even in
office yet at that particular point.
Jonathan Wiggins: But here again she has a similar bigger piece of property a little less
water frontage and the land value is sixty one hundred.
Robert Scott: It goes by the front footage not the amount of the land.
Darline Dully: Yeah, sometime it's...forty, forty-five
Jonathan Wiggins: What is it?
Linda Sanford: Forty-five
Jonathan Wiggins: Is this the one right next door?
Gerard Schultheis: Forty-five dollars per foot.
Jonathan Wiggins: Yeah, we are talking about the frontage and this is 45 and one's 38.
Here's another one, 15.2 is also thirty-eight dollars per foot.
Robert Scott: That's the one I just told you about.
Jonathan Wiggins: The subject property, all right this one here is the 45,000 dollars
right?
Darline Duffy: (inaudible)
Jonathan Wiggins: Why would you change it? Between 38 and 48 dollars per foot I...
Darline Dully: I don't feel strongly about this.
Jonathan Wiggins: IfI look at something and I see something that looks like it needs a
question I'll ask it.
Darline Duffy: Good.
Jonathan Wiggins: All right we're going to review this.
Daniel McConlogue: I just want to make sure I understand. It's hard for me too~
Linda Sanford: It is...I don't know, these people do a wonderful job I'm not sure how
they do it.
Daniel McConlogue: It's based on an indicated market value, which is pulled from the
assessment.
Darline Duffy: Yes
Daniel McConlogue: And the indicated market value is either 5.8 million or 6.3 million
and as I understand it you're saying it may be worth 6.4 and had it sold sustained your
assessment.
Linda Sanford: The only data point I have is my Chub appraisal which was 6.8 and
again...
Daniel McConlogue: Yeah, but 6.8 then their assessment would be sustained because it
is based on the lower market value.
Linda Sanford: But but...
Daniel McConlogue: Go ahead Florence...
Robert Scott: That's half the name again.
Daniel McConlogue: I'm sorry.
Phyllis Atkinson: The Chub insurance includes the contents of the house.
Linda Sanford: Yes and it's based on what to be replaced not market value.
Daniel McConlogue: Okay so what do you say the market value is.9
Linda Sanford: I think it is probably something less than a million offofthe 6.8 so
maybe 5.8, I don't know.
Daniel McConlogue: Okay, even that won't get you a reduction. They're at 5.8.
Jonathan Wiggins: Well no, it depends on what ratio you use.
Linda Sanford: The factors and things that are being looked at.
Daniel McConlogue: We have to get that.
Jonathan Wiggins: Well we are going to discuss that.
Daniel McConlogue: That's the only shot you got.
Jonathan Wiggins: We are going to discuss that. Thank you very much.
Linda Sanford: I thank you very much for your time. Thank you all for doing what you
do here. It is a real men's job, real men's work and it was my pleasure to work with
Darline and Bob. This is my town and I love it and I love working with all of you guys.
Robert Scott: Thank you.
Darline Duffy: Thank you.
Gerard Schultheis: Okay it's 1:00 and we will adjourn until this evening. We will meet
again at 7:00.
Gerard Schultheis: It is Tuesday, May 19th 7 p.m. We are oPening the meeting.
Hearing #2
Daniel McConlogue: We will have to swear you in Mr. McGahan before we start the
testimony.
Wallace McGahan: I'm sorry.
Daniel McConlogue: Just stand there and raise your right hand. You do solemnly swear
that the testimony you give in this proceeding is the truth the whole truth and nothing but
the truth.
Wallace McGahan: Yes sir I promise.
Daniel McConlogue: Be seated, state your name and address for the record. We have a
machine here.
Wallace McGahan: Okay I'm Wallace A. McGahan. I reside at 1400 West Creek
Avenue, Cutchogue and I am the surviving spouse of my wife Mary whose trust is the
owner of the house. She died a few months ago this December and I'm making up my
mind whether I'm going to continue to live in the house as I have the fight to do but I'm
here because I'm confused of what I view as conflicting information. I'm going to
simply present the two pieces of information to you that confuse me and let you fellows
decide as your job what should happen in this case. The conflicting pieces of information
is that a professional appraiser that I had to call in because I required an appraisal to be
done because of the state tax return I have to file, and they demand an appraisal, so I got
an appraisal. Also, I wanted to know what the house is worth on the market essentially
because ifI elect not to live there it becomes the property of those people specified in the
trust, which are my children, and they will inherit and turn around and sell it and so I
guess that's their decision but I think that they will likely be thrown a loop and what will
they sell it for? That's the issue. What will they sell it for now versus what will they sell
for ifI would like to live there in a few months so that's all that is going through my
mind. On the other hand, what is the house worth on the market? The professional
appraiser says it is worth 800,000 dollars. He is a professional in the business and he's in
real estate and I guess he knows what he is talking about so I accept his number. On the
other hand, I come in and I talk to Bob and I talked with Kevin and they say that the full
market value of the house 876,000 dollars. The presumption that I have is that is what
the house would be able to sell for and on the other hand the appraiser says, as he took it
over, he wouldn't get more than 800,000 for it if he sells it now. IfI give it to him in 6
months he might not even offer me 800, he tells me he can sell it for 800,000 dollars. I
don't know what the house is worth and also I don't know the proper tax is on the house
and so I decided to let you fellows thirst out yourself. I gave you all the facts there that I
have that I know about and my confusion regarded those facts and so that's why I
presented this document to you and allow you to comment on this.
Jonathan Wiggins: Okay looks like a fairly new house.
Wallace McGahan: Yeah, the house was built in 1990 and finished in '91.
Jonathan Wiggins: And your appraisal says 805,000?
Wallhce McGahan: The appraisal is what the appraiser ended up with in his statement of
appraised value of 800,000 dollars. He went through the process that they use whatever
it is looking at comparables and different things and I supposebeing a realtor he also
looked at where he thinks the market is. I don't know what he looked at but he came up
with a number and wrote it right in and said this is what I think it's worth so I accept
what he said.
Jonathan Wiggins: Okay
Gerard Schltheis: Just for the record I am recluding myselfi
Jonathan Wiggins: Okay do you know this gentleman?
Gerard Schltheis: That's my father-in-law.
Jonathan Wiggins: Okay, let me start by saying I'm sorry for your loss. It is difficult.
Wallace McGahan: Thank you. Well we fought a good fight for 15 years and kept her
alive but Alzheimer's finally won. We spent a lot of money on medical expense and
that's why I need to look ahead because ifI have to pay 10,000 a year in taxes then I'm
going to be leaving here in two years because it's all going to be gone and I won't owe
any money anymore. I'll get a pension maybe.
Jonathan Wiggins: Now according to the state equalization rate we have your house
coming up at 948,000.
Wallace McGahan: 948?
Jonathan Wiggins: That's the state ratio.
Wallace McGahan: That's not the number you told me.
Kevin Webster: The level of assessment that we are actually using is 1.06
Jonathan Wiggins: They are using their own figures.
Daniel McConlogue: They take the assessed value and they divide it by the ratio and the
assessor is using one and the state has another and the question is which one do we use.
The one that Jonathan uses throws out the value of 948,000. Is that correct Jonathan?
Jonathan Wiggins: Yes
Daniel McConlogue: Thank you.
Wallace McGahan: I or my children will have to say what can they sell the house for and
presume that's the value and if that's the value then the tax should be based on the value
not on some formula so I don't what the formula means. There is a discrepancy and it
bothers me and that's why I am here.
Jonathan Wiggins: You spoke to Kevin?
Daniel McConlogue: Want to see what Kevin has to say?
Jonathan Wiggins: Yes, let's see what Mr. McCallister, I know a Kevin McCallister, I
keep messing that name up, Mr. Webster. Let's see what he has to say.
Kevin Webster: I have reviewed the appraisal with Mr. McGahan and the value that we
have on there now is the 876. My observations are that if you look at the appraisal and
the adjusted value that...Erica Stype did this, Andy's daughter, who I know very well and
I know Andy as well. The values that she came up with on the bottom the adjusted sale
price before she did the adjustments are 975,600, 935,500, and 805,500 so my initial
observation for Mr. McGahan is that sale number one comes in at 100,000 dollars higher
than what the state has the house at. Sale number two comes in at 60,000 dollars higher
than what the state has it at and sale number three does come in lower, but two of the
three sales that they chose come in higher than the assessment and the equalized value
that's on there from this assessment that was assessed in 1995. That's one thing I wanted
to mention. The second thing is that the sale prices are great sale dates; the sales have
really good sale dates for our evaluation of July 1st of 2008. The first one is October
2008, the second one is October of 2008 given within three months, and the third one is
right on the evaluation date July 18th of 2008 so you can't get better sales for an
evaluation date of July of 2008.
Jonathan Wiggins: (inaudible) 805,000?
Kevin Webster: That one sold July 18th of 2008 so when you look at the...
Daniel McConlogue: I'm sorry, what?
Kevin Webster: July 18th of 2008.
Daniel McConlogue: What was the price?
Kevin Webster: It sold for 750,000 dollars on July 18th. That one was right on the
evaluation date. But, if we accept that as a good sale for evaluation date of July 1st 2008,
which I think everybody would say that's pretty close, he took off, if you look at the
appraisal on the first line the date of sale, he took off 75,000 dollars under that line so
there's no reason why you would take off 75,000 dollars when you're trying to adjust that
sale with an evaluation of July 1St 2008, and number two as well, he took off 46,500 and
number one he took off 54,400, strictly for time, nothing to do with age, square footage,
basement, acreage, just when you talk about the time. So, if you look at number one and
you add back the time adjustment it comes out to a million thirty thousand, number two
comes out to 982,000, and number three comes out to 880,500, so all three of them then
are above what the equalized value we have for this house as of July 1st 2008. That's
why I feel that the assessment that has been on there for 14 years is still a fair tree
number because all three of them come out above what the equalized value is because
you would not be making time adjustments to July 1st when those sales are within three
months of the evaluation date and one is within 18 days. The reason I think he did that is
even though he says he's doing this or she's doing this as October, I'm sorry December
th
18 of 2008 is the date of the appraisal, so obviously the real estate market changed from
July 1 of 2008 to December 18 2008 so Erica is appraising this house as of December
th st
18 not July 1 so you would strike those time adjustments. They would not apply on
those negative time adjustments so the adjusted values again would be 1,030,000, 982,
and 880 strictly on time, nothing to do with the amenities, strictly on time. That is my
comment on the appraisal.
Wallace McGahan: Okay my comment on the whole thing is that I hear is the assessor
criticizing the appraiser of how he arises at the numbers. Now maybe we ought to have
the appraiser here to criticize how the assessor arises at the number. On the tax sheet it
says that the fair market value for the house is derived by using assessment numbers.
They (inaudible)me 76,000 dollm's. Somebody who is in the business of selling houfies
says that the fair market value, based upon his experience and knowledge and training, is
800,000 so that is why I am confused that the assessor whose business is assessing is
criticizing the appraiser whose business is appraising and that's why I don't understand
what is going on.
Jonathan Wiggins: I think that's our job here is to kind of...we go through all of this and
approve what the facts are.
Wallace McGahan: Oh ok, that's what I thought.
Daniel McConlogue: With all do respect, the assessors are appraisers too and they're
qualified.
Jonathan Wiggins: Yeah, we are going to look at it and I can see your point and I...
Wallace McGahan: Give me a letter from an assessor that says that this appraisal is
wrong and let them sign it like the appraiser did, you know in the appraisal he signed his
name and his reputation and his license is on the line, and now we have somebody who
has nothing on the line criticizing his appraisal. That's why I am confused. We have two
factions here, each with their own expertise saying that each other's wrong, well no the
other expert is not here. But I let them...
Kevin Webster: May I...I am not criticizing Erica's work here. I'm just pointing at that
the appraisal was done for a specific evaluation date of 5 months after our evaluation date
that we have to use for the state; so what was done for the December 18th 2008 evaluation
date and when the State says look it as of July 1st 2008.
Daniel McConlogne: And after that she took time adjustment?
Kevin Webster: Right she took off fifty four thousand, forty-six, and seventy five
thousand for the time adjustment because...
Jonathan Wiggins: So what your saying is her figures would be more accurate than the
State's because it is more up to date.
Kevin Webster: If you add back the time adjustments...you have to add back the time
adjustments and it would show then that the, her, indicated values ora million thirty-five,
and nine eighty-two and eight eighty are the State's value is less than that. The State's
value is 876 so all three sales are higher.
Daniel McConlogue: Your saying that State's value is 876? That's your value using the
lower assessment.
Kevin Webster: Correct.
Daniel McConlogue: The RAR is nine forty-eight.
Kevin Webster: Yes the RAR is nine forty-eight and two of the three sales are higher than
that as well, a million thirty and nine eighty-two.
Daniel McConlogne: Because of the weight of time?
Kevin Webster: Right because you would not be making time adjustments on that.
Daniel McConlogue: Seems like that's the issue.
Jonathan Wiggins: Well the houses aren't exactly the same I think we would have to
look at the appraisal and kind of go over it.
Daniel McConlogue: Oh yeah
Jonathan Wiggins: But it is an interesting case and we'll be happy to review it and
we'll...
Wallace McGahan: Just educate me a little bit hem...on my tax form there's a number
called 100% of full value what does that actually mean? I mean I interpret it to be what
the house is worth and could be sold for but maybe that's the incorrect interpretation.
Kevin Webster: It is the value your home is being...I'm sorry.
Wallace McGahan: And as of what date is that?
Kevin Webster: Yeah it is the value that your home is being taxed as if it's worth and
that's the value that you can come in and contest, that full market value. If you're
contesting that...
Wallace McGahan: Yeah, I am contesting that because another professional says ifI told
him look you gave me an appraisal on what you sell the house take your job and bring me
home 800,000 dollars because oh well you the fact you should bringing me home
876,000, he says no I gave you 800,000 as a number and I can't even give that now
because things are going to hell since I did that and so we would be lucky to get 750, if
we can get that. That's the kind of thing I am expecting will happen when we're trying to
sell the house so 876 is not what the house is worth today then even though it says so
right?
Kevin Webster: Well that's the difference between...
Wallace McGahan: Your meaning a willing buyer and a seller would agree on
Kevin Webster: As of a specific date that's what your being taxed is if that home is
worth.
Wallace McGahan: And what is that date?
Kevin Webster: July 1st of 2008
Wallace McGahan: I see.
Kevin Webster: It's not real time; it's not today; it's not tomorrow...
Daniel McConlogue: It's the evaluation date by law.
Wallace McGahan: I see. What you are saying is that today the house is .not worth 876
on the market.
Kevin Webster: I'm not saying that. I'm not a sales agent; I'm not listing your house;
I'm not going to sell it. All I am saying is that you're being taxed as if your home is
worth 876 as of July 1st of 2008. What you could list it for now you might talk to some
qualified people who handle that and they migh[ be able to help you out with that. I don't
tell people what I can sell their homes for.
Wallace McGahan: All right.
Daniel McConlogue: By law they have to value it as July 1 of that year; the assessor has
to value the property; that's their job.
Jonathan Wiggins: What date is the appraisal?
Daniel McConlogue: December 18th
Wallace McGahan: The date of the appraisal is February '09 1 think. No he has
December 18th.
Kevin Webster: The date of the appraisal is December 18th of 2008.
Jonathan Wiggins: Okay so even that's out of date but those have changed a bit since
then so...
Wallace McGahan: So they're saying is the house was worth 800,000 as of...
Kevin Webster: December 18th of 2008 was the appraisal
Wallace McGahan: That's the date of death, yeah. That's proper for the tax purposes but
I guess it's in terms of being able to sell it, not necessarily the property, maybe the
market...
Kevin Webster: And my opinion on this is that that's a low value of your home as of that
date because if you look at...
Wallace McGahan: Yeah but I don't think you are qualified to do that nor are you legally
in a position that the appraiser is to do it; that's why I am confused. You're telling me it
isn't worth that, the official appraiser who signs the document says it's worth this so what
am I suppose to believe?
Kevin Webster: Well I am giving you my opinion and my opinion is based on the fact
that if you look at what Erica came up with her adjusted values, which I said to you
before, one of them is at 975, one's at 935, and one's at 805 so she picked, which is
against really is against policy, she picked the value below the adjusted sale prices of all
three comparables.
Wallace McGahan: This is what I mean by sitting here and criticizing an appraiser who
makes an official number; that's what you are doing and that's why I am confused
because you are not in the appraising business and I am standing here listening to you
make an official defense of the document you've given me because you haven't given me
any and but yet you're saying that the document that I was given by somebody whose
reputation and name and license is on the line gave me different numbers but he arrived
at it incorrectly so he shouldn't given me that number. Who am I going to believe?
Cara Wells: But Mr. McGahan everybody in the Assessors Office are qualified
appraisers. They are credentials. They have the same credentials that Erica has.
Wallace McGahan: Yup I hope so, yup.
Daniel McConlogue: He's given testimony in his opinion and he was previously
SWOrn...
Wallace McGahan: I understand who pays the person who made the appraisal from a
different party.
Cara Wells: Sir, even if you used...
Wallace McGahan: and their underlying objective is different. They want to sell a
house; Kevin wants to support the revenues of the town and they're different underlying
objectives.
Cara Wells: Okay Sir ifI could just make a couple of comments. There is a very nice
house on Bay Avenue in East Marion that was on sale for 629 and then five something
and it closed earlier this week for 450,000. Now .if you used the statistics that we heard
floating around today, which was published in the Suffolk Times, the values were down
4.8% so that reduces yours from 876 to 833,952, which supports Mr. Webster's argument
that he thinks the appraisal at 800 or 805, or whatever it is, is too low. Now yes it is
down, the market will tell you what the fair price is but the market right now is pretty
much non-existent.
Wallace McGahan: Yeah
Cara Wells: If you were to go out today and try to find comps, three water view homes
that have sold and now the financial institutions are only taking comps in the last three
months. It would be hard for us to find anything comparable to your property because
there are no sales.
Wallace McGahan: How can you get a comparable with no sale? Yeah
Cara Wells: So if you use the statistics from Suffolk research about the fall in property
values your house would now be worth 834,000 dollars. Your appraisal says it's only
worth 800 and then she told you she wasn't sure if she could sell it at that price.
Unfortunately it is the middle range where you are, where the value of these homes are
the ones that are the least likely to be moving in today's market. The top of the market is
moving and the bottom of the market is moving.
Wallace McGahan: Yup.
Daniel McConlogue: Where is this house on Bay Avenue? What's the...
Wallace McGahan: My house is on West Creek Avenue.
Cara Wells: His house is on West Creek Avenue in Cutchogue.
Daniel McConlogue: Oh all right.
Wallace McGahan: It's about halfway down West Creek Avenue between the
(inaudible) go past the road and West Harbor Marina at the end West Road
Jonathan Wiggins: Mr. Webster what's the square footage of the subject house?
Wallace McGahan: Seventeen hundred and ten or something like that.
Kevin Webster: We have seventeen eighty the same as the appraisal. They have 1780
and we have 1780.
Wallace McGahan: All right.
Daniel McConlogue: Mr. Webster are you going to submit any sales to support...
Daniel McConlogue: You're just goingto...
Jonathan Wiggins: He has three sales on the...oh no no.
Kevin Webster: No I am not. No I am comfortable with the sales on the'appraisal the
only issue I have is...well even without taking away the time adjustments two of the
three are above and if you take away the time adjustment which I think is 100%
warranted it comes out to the value I stated.
Daniel McConlogue: That's the issue.
Kevin Webster: I can prepare a grid using these sales and it will come out to the same
exact value like I said a million thirty-five, nine eighty-two, and eight eighty would be
the same...probably about the same value. I have no problems with what she did with
the adjustments on the amenities the only issue was the time adjustment because we are
dealing with a different evaluation date.
Wallace McGahan: Well I begin to see where my confusion is now because it appears
that the Town taxes...they have some kind of formula that has nothing to do with
necessarily with what the house could sell for on the market place, it's a formula, and that
arises at a number which on the tax bill is called 100% of full value and that the appraiser
then comes up with his own methods which may or may not be liked by the assessor, but
none the less he has his methods, and he comes up with a number which he fully expects
I may mm around and say okay sell it for this number for me then. Maybe these are
numbers despite what they would sell for and the appraiser would probably...the
appraiser would have an opinion of what it would sell for really I guess. Do you?
Kevin Webster: The appraiser, well your appraisal or appraiser has an opinion on...
Wallace McGahan: (inaudible)
Kevin Webster: Oh what it would sell for? Oh we can't...
Wallace McGahan: I misunderstood that the number that you call a 100% of full value is
probably what it is worth of the marketplace.
Kevin Webster: As of that specific date.
Daniel McConlogue: That's what the assessor's position is.
Wallace McGahan: That's back in '08.
Kevin Webster: July of '08
Wallace McGahan: July of '08 yes.
Daniel McConlogue: That's his position.
Wallace McGahan: Well it's certainly worth less than that as of today. I think
everybody is suffering from the market.
Kevin Webster: Yes.
Cara Wells: That's what I said on the statistics from Suffolk research. The drop here is
4.8%, if you take that from 876 you get 833,952 which I rounded to 834 so even that is
higher than the appraisal of 800,000. Crystal balls are not in their toolboxes; they don't
read the market the buyers read the market and make the market.
Daniel McConlogue: Your taxes are based; the assessment is based on the market value
as of July 1. The assessors are saying that the market value is 876,000 on July 1 of '08
and they come up with that by making comparisons of other sales, comparable sales, the
appraisal that you submitted is used...that's how you determine what the market value is,
they compare other sales to your house and come up with a number and the assessor is
using your sale because they are valid sales, but they are not adjusted pi-operly for time
and that's (inaudible) intention of market value but it's both the same thing. They are
looking at, they are comparing the sale and the only question is the adjustment for time,
as I understand it.
Kevin Webster: Yes
Wallace McGahan: Well as I see it, what we are doing I know what I am going paying in
2009 because it's on the tax bill and that determines a value supposedly of the house back
in '08. Now I was considering what will I pay next year in 20107
Daniel McConlogue: We will worry about that then.
Wallace McGahan: The whole fuss I am making right now is for what I am going to pay
in 2010, isn't that correct?
Kevin Webster: Yes
Wallace McGahan: Okay so in 2010 you're telling me that I should pay taxes on
substantially higher values than actually exists because it's the value of what we are
talking about in 2008, so this year I'm paying taxes on higher values than it is today.
Next year I'll pay higher taxes on what even exists today and probably if the market
continues to do what it's doing higher than what it is than so you're at least coming up
with a year's taxes based upon a much lower evaluation at the time you are taxing me so
that doesn't strike me as a taxpayer; it's wonderful for the town actually but I'm arguing
for what I would pay next year and I think next year the market's going to be like it is this
year let's face that's the problem, it it's all over the country. Nobody thinks it is going to
happen here until it does everyone thinks their region is safe but I read the papers
everyday and I read the national figures and markets everywhere are going down.
Daniel McConlogue: We understand what you're saying but Kevin correct me ifI am
wrong those dates determine the 2008 valuation and you're paying that in 2010 but those
dates are all set by law.
Kevin Webster: Correct, your 2010 tax bill is determined by your market value as of July
2008. You are 100% correct.
Daniel McConlogue: By law
Kevin Webster: I'm not a legislature; I did not make that law. You are 100% correct in
that's the law and that's the law I have to follow.
Wallace McGahan: It didn't make me any happier that the legislature decided that's
what's going to happen. The money is coming out of my pocket and that amount of
money what determines who I got to leave this town in a few years so that's what I am
fighting for.
Kevin Webster: I would say this...it determines everybody's, all 18,000 plus parcels, in
the town's taxes in 2010 are determined by July '08. It's not...
Wallace McGahan: I'm not being discriminated against I know that.
Kevin Webster: No you're not. It's not just you; it's everybody.
Wallace McGahan: We're all being screwed equally.
Daniel McConlogue: Anything else Jonathan?
Jonathan Wiggins: No I think this is interesting and we'll look into it further. I
appreciate that your appraiser has offered an additional 30 pages of documentation.
Wallace McGahan: And I have that here if you need to see that. I will give you the full
document. There's 30 some more odd pages here if you need it.
Daniel McConlogue: He doesn't contest; the only thing he contests is...he accepts the
sale as an indication of market value. He just contests the one adjustment and all the
sales at the time.
Jonathan Wiggins: We will take it all. we are satisfied with this. I am a little curious
though of how she came up with a figure when these others are coming out at 975 and
935 and that's the question. Where did she get 800? That's my question; that's why I
think we should see the other appraisal.
Wallace McGahan: I have nothing more to add.
Daniel McConlogue: You can give the appraiser the form and see if she has an answer for
the assessor for that adjustment of time.
Kevin Webster: If I may, I know why she did it because she was appraising it as of
December 18th not July 1st. As of December 18th that's why she came up with the
negative 54,000 and so forth.
Jonathan Wiggins: That's her job isn't it?
Kevin Webster: What's that?
Jonathan Wiggins: That's her job to give the current market value to reflect what is
going on at that current time.
Kevin Webster: Right she did not do an appraisal as of July 1st
Daniel McConlogue: Is it possible that her adjustments for time are offand you are
saying maybe we should not take off as much because we find her adjustments for time
aren't correct.
Kevin Webster: My position is that you should strike the time adjustments off all
together that's is why I added them back.
Daniel McConlogue: Yeah but maybe the number we strike isn't that high.., well I don't
know.
If ou have a J th
Kevin Webster: y uly 18 of 2008 closed sale date my position is I don't
think you should make any time adjustment that's eighteen days from the evaluation date
and even October 6th and October 9th those are well within the parameter, those are right
on the evaluation date.
Daniel McConlogue: And December 18th isn't?
Kevin Webster: No it's not but even with those tim~ adjustments two of the three sales
are well above 876 but it's 976 one is 935 and the raw sale prices are a million eighty
eight and 930,000.
Jonathan Wiggins: Okay we thank you very much Mr. Webster and Mr. McGahan.
Kevin Webster: Thank you.
Wallace McGahan: I appreciate your time very much. You reduced my confusion.
Thank you.
Hearing #3
Daniel McConlogue: Let's take whatever testimony we can tonight and then if you have
to submit further papers you can make an application to the chairman.
Albert Safer: Ok sure thank you very much.
Daniel McConlogue: Right now just stand up and raise your right hand I'll swear you in.
The assessor has already been sworn in. You do solemnly swear that the testimony you
are about to give in this proceeding will be the truth the whole truth and nothing but the
truth.
Albert Safer: I do.
Daniel McConlogue: Be seated please and state your name and home address.
Albert Safer: Yes, Albert Safer I am the representative of this property owned by my
kids...Albert Safer.
Daniel McConlogue: Did we get your address?
Albert Safer: It's 1295 Robinson Lane
Daniel McConlogue: That's the subject property?.
Albert Safer: Yes it is.
Daniel McConlogue: What's that again?
Albert Safer: 1295 Robinson Lane, Peconic, New York
Phyllis Atkinson: This was vacant land when you purchased it?
Albert Safer: No there was a house there.
Phyllis Atkinson: Oh I see demo dwelling.
Albert Safer: Yeah we demoed it.
Robert Scott: Sorry I didn't make enough copies for you. I was trying to do it quickly;
there's two or three other pages that go with this, the proof. I just want to let you know.
Phyllis Atkinson: We can share.
Jonathan Wiggins: Okay you have the property evaluated as if it's worth three million
nine hundred thousand roughly?
Albert Safer: This is partial.
Robert Scott: That's a partial assessment.
Jonathan Wiggins: All right and you feel it's worth two million seven hundred thousand.
Daniel McConlogue: What is the proof that you are going to offer?
Albert Safer: Excuse me.
Daniel McConlogue: The proof that ~ou are going to be offered...
Albert Safer: I have...there are several of them. One of them is that the land value is
increased a lot and I'm told that it was improperly assessed because ! know that land
value doesn't usually get reassessed and they said that...
Jonathan Wiggins: Where is that page?
Albert Safer: The second thing is the property market values have come down between
15 and 20% in the last year or so and that's a known fact in the industry and certainly I
can bring original documentations to support that from the local broker. Certainly I do
have it checked to clearly look at my neighbor who has a similar house as mine and that'
his property is smaller than mine by 30 feet I believe; I don't make a mistake.
Robert Scott: About 23 feet.
Albert Safer: Okay so a very similar house and it has a bigger lot than mine.
Jonathan Wiggins: Is it on the water also?
Albert Safer: It is on the water next to...like mine. I don't what his values or what his
values are but I certainly believe they are lower than mine.
Jonathan Wiggins: We don't know for sure, we have to check it.
Albert Safer: No no it's like mine, the assessment is like mine.
Jonathan Wiggins: We can ask Darline right now~ Is that the 1.3-acre property next to
you?
Albert Safer: The property right beyond...
Robert Scott: 98-5-14.3 that he's talking about
Jonathan Wiggins: Okay so that one is 174. All right we're curious...
Albert Safer: And this lot I know is 3 ¼...I don't frontage, I know it's 3 acres or
something.
Darline Duffy: It is 3 acres.
Albert Safer: Excuse me.
Darline Duffy: It is 3 acres.
Albert Safer: It's 3 acres.
Jonathan Wiggins: Yeah
Cara Wells: The subject property is...what's the acreage?
Jonathan Wiggins: 1.8 acres and the 200 feet on the water and this other one is 174.
Darline Duffy: Correct
Jonathan Wiggins: Is the property next door to you that has 200 feet on the water also?
Albert Safer: Probably I don't know...under what name could that be...on the other side.
Robert Scott: We can find out but we don't know.
Albert Safer: The Madison's or...?
Jonathan Wiggins: We can look it up.
Phyllis Atkinson: The partial assessment that the tax has is that 50%?
Robert Scott: Twenty-five percent for the completion of the main house.
Phyllis Atkinson: Your assessment is what you consider 25% of the...
Robert Scott: No there's 25% of that could be added later on when the house is
completed. When we made the inspection of the house it wasn't quite complete so we
took 25% offthe total assessment of the main house there's more than one structure here.
Jonathan Wiggins: Right.
Robert Scott: There's a cottage; there's a garage building and there's the main house.
The main house wasn't finished when we were there so we took 25% offthe completion.
That's why we put the partial and we are going to look at it again next year.
Phyllis Atkinson: Oh so once we get the true, what you anticipate assessing it; I would
add 25%.
Robert Scott: You would add about another 9,000 dollars approximately.
Jonathan Wiggins: You would add 25% to the cost of the improvements.
Phyllis Atkinson: Okay
Jonathan Wiggins:. So that would take that up to 35...
Robert Scott: It's on the property card.
Cara Wells: It's right them.
Daniel McConlogue: Do you have some proof that ...some comparable sales or what are
you going use to proof...
Albert Safer: I will certainly provide that if I'm given an extension. I will provide
additional information. I know I didn't pay this amount. This comes out to like 2.8 or
something, the value of the house.
Robert Scott: It's forty one three is the...
Albert Safer: No no the improvements.
Robert Scott: We can't segment that. The assessment is 41,300 dollars we're going to
take 3.9 million dollars. I think you can see they purchased the property for...
Phyllis Atkinson: Four million four eighty
Robert Scott: I don't have the cards anymore; I don't know where they are.
Cara Wells: Here here
Phyllis Atkinson: Over four million
Robert Scott: Four million eighty thousand and then he put substantial improvements.
He demoed the main building and then completely did it over again.
Albert Safer: The four million that we paid for that address consisted of two separate lots
of half an acre each with beach rights.
Jonathan Wiggins: So you combined two lots?
Albert Safer: We didn't combine them. They are two separate. Somehow or another
when they did the deed they put a very low value on the lot and the rest of the value on
the main house. The property consisted of three lots. There's two sets of lots which is
visible with beach rights.
Phyllis Atkinson: One of the lots is waterfront and the other...
Albert Safer: The other beach rights only, yes.
Phyllis Atkinson: And obviously your house is on the waterfront.
Albert Safer: Right exactly.
Phyllis Atkinson: Okay, this the only card?
Robert Scott: No there's another card. I'm sorry Phyllis we were rushing to get as much
information to you as we could. We don't have a complete card here for you. We were
told we had to get in quickly.
Phyllis Atkinson: Okay
Jonathan Wiggins: Just to clarify this we're looking at the tax map number of 98-5-2,
which is 1.8 acres
Albert Safer: Right
Jonathan Wiggins: The 1.8-acre parcel in fact that he paid for a million dollars for.
Robert Scott: He paid four point, he put four million eighty thousand dollars~on that
particular parcel. He put 10,000 and 10,000 on 98-5-3 and 98-5-4 so if you want to say
he spent 4.1 million dollars on all three parcels I'm not going to dispute that.
Jonathan Wiggins: Okay so he owns two lots...
Robert Scott: which I could see here for he first time
Jonathan Wiggins: I'm sorry I understand and so those three lots were for a million
dollars.
Robert Scott: The same lots, 4.1 million
Jonathan Wiggins: 4.1 million okay
Robert Scott: And then.if you can see there's a demo, there's a permit to demo the
existing structure in the complete renovation. He rebuilt the entire structure all over
again and that's what you see here on cards two and three.
Cara Wells: Do you know what your building cost?
Albert Safer: I don't...I don't have them with me but I (inaudible)
Cara Wells: That would be helpful information to evaluate your clients.
Phyllis Atkinson: Would you be available when you retum with the additional
information to be present in case we have other questions.
Albert Safer: Absolutely yeah definitely. I live here.
Phyllis Atkinson: You're not just going to mail everything in right?
Albert Safer: No I live here. I spend most of my time here.
Phyllis Atkinson: Because I'm sure if we see additional information we'll have more
questions.
Robert Scott: Mr. Chairman there's a similar house to this earlier and one of the thing I
wouldn't have thought of it until she brought it in today is that she mentioned the
insurance aspect. You might ask him to bring that in as well.
Gerard Schultheis: Do you have the value of the house in insurance?
Albert Safer: I certainly do but I don't know what it is though.
Phyllis Atkinson: Can we get a copy of the endorsement page on your policy?
Jonathan Wiggins: The more information you could provide the better, like the building
costs are very important and anything else you have on the other properties.
Daniel McConlogue: Do you a formal appraisal that you are going to submit?
Albert Safer: 'I wasn't planning to but ifI have to I will I mean is it problem to get an
appraisal at this point I don't know.
Robert Scott: He doesn't...you don't have an appraisal.
Albert Safer: I don't have an appraisal.
Robert Scott: He doesn't have an appraisal so if you're asking him to get one at this
point I don't think it's fair to be honest with you.
Cara Wells and Jonathan Wiggins: No no
Cara Wells: The purchase price plus the building cost should be sufficient.
Robert Scott: I just want to be fair.
Phyllis Atkinson: It looks to me like you have asphalt shingles on the roof?.
Albert Safer: uh..
Robert Scott: What kind of shingles?
Albert Safer: Cedar shingles
Phyllis Atkinson: Cedar, okay.
Jonathan Wiggins: Do you want to give him a date to come back...next Wednesday the
Wednesday after?
Gerard Schultheis: We will be getting together again next Tuesday and next Thursday.
Albert Safer: Tuesday works better for me.
Gerard Schultheis: Pardon me
Albert Safer: Tuesday will work better for me.
Phyllis Atkinson: 9 to 1
Jonathan Wiggins: Thank you very much.
Albert Safer: Thank you.
Albert Safer: What is the date for Tuesday? Sorry
Phyllis Atkinson: May 26, we will be here from 9 to 1. We will not be in this room
though. We will be in the...
Jonathan Wiggins: We are going to check.
Robert Scott: If you want to come to our office we'll take you down there.
Albert Safer: Thank you I appreciate it.
Robert Scott: Okay
Jonathan Wiggins: Thank you very much for coming down.
Albert Safer: Thank you very much. I really apologize for being late.
Jonathan Wiggins: Okay
Cara Wells: We have all moved we all know what it's about.
Phyllis Atkinson: Oh yeah
Jonathan Wiggins: Have a nice evening.
Albert Safer: Nice meeting you again.
Gerard Schultheis: Okay it's 9:15 pm the end and we are closing the grievance
proceedings.
Submitted by: Amanda M. Nunemaker
6/3/09
Review on the assessment roll of the Town of Southold, for the tax year 2009/10, in
conformance with this order.