HomeMy WebLinkAbout04/24/2008 Town of Southold
Architectural Review Committee
Minutes
April 24, 2008
4:00pm
Town Hall Meeting Hall
MEMBERS PRESENT: Ural Talgat, Acting Chairman; Herbert Ernest; Joseph Lee; Ronald
McGreevy; Nicholas Planamento; Elizabeth Thompson; Heather Lanza, Planning Director;
Elizabeth Cantrell, Secretary
The minutes for the March 20, 2008 meeting were approved.
REVISITED APPLICATIONS:
HUDSON CITY SAVINGS BANK SCTM #1000-122-3-1.2, 2, 5.1 & 17
Mr. & Mrs. Daniel Mooney, P.C., owners of the project presented the application.
PROJECT APPROVED: The Committee fully endorses the use of solar panels on the roof
of the two-story office building. The Committee is approving the application with the
addition of the follmving recommendations:
· Try to match the roofing color to the color of the solar panels on the two-story
office building.
· On the office building facing north, remove the second-story ornamental roof and
replace proposed window with arch style similar to the windoxv on the single-story
building.
· Widen the ornamental roof on the front elevation of the office building to more
closely match the single-story building.
Add more of a mix of species of evergreen trees and shrubs on the south side and
southeast corner in the rear of the property than is currently shown on the plans.
· Eliminate lighting in the parking area that is further than 40' from the rear of the
building.
· Landbank maximum parking at the rear lot.
· Use more decorative lighting fixtures than some that are currently shown on the
plans, for example the Sternberg style as submitted and/or use of Dark Sky designs
all xvith metal halide lighting.
· Use a variety of cones of light and height of fixtures suited to the specific locations.
· The Committee does not endorse the use of the Ruud lighting fixtures as submitted.
· The two long, narrow parking islands should be combined into one wider island to
be located at the area closest to the building in the southern end of the parking lot.
· Shade trees are recommended for this wider planting area in the parking island.
MOTION MADE: Ural Talgat; SECOND: Herbert Hernest. All in favor
PRE-SUBMISSIONS:
CHASE BANK SOUTHOLD SCTM #1000-61-4-1
Kenneth R. Gar, An, AIA of JRS Architect, P.C. presented the application.
PROJECT NOT APPROVED: The Committee does not approve of the style of
architecture for this project. The architecture for both of these buildings should follow the
"character" of the North Fork. The Committee would like to see a building that reflects the
architectural heritage of the North Fork. The two projects submitted could be a bank
building anywhere in the United States.
MOTION MADE: Ural Talgat; SECOND: Elizabeth Thompson. All in favor.
CHASE BANK MATTITUCK SCTM #1000-143-3-33.2
Kenneth R. Garvin, AIA of JRS Architect, P.C. presented the application.
PROJECT NOT APPROVED: The Committee does not approve of the style of
architecture for this project. The architecture for both of these buildings should follow the
"character" of the North Fork. The Committee would like to see a building that reflects the
architectural heritage of the North Fork. The two projects submitted could be a bank
building anywhere in the United States.
MOTION MADE: Ural Talgat; SECOND: Elizabeth Thompson. All in favor.
A motion was made to close the meeting at 5:30pm. All in favor.
Elizabeth Cantrell
Secretary