Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutTR-04/29/1993TRUSTEES SUPERVISOR John M. Bredemeyer, III. President SCOTT L. HARRIS Albert J. Krupski, Jr.. Vice President Henry P. Smith Town Hall John B. Tuthill 53095 Main Road William G. Albenson P.O. Box 1179 Southold. New York 11971 Telephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD MINUTES APRIL 29, 1993 PRESENT WERE: John M. Bredemeyer III, President Albert J. Krupski, Vice-President Henry P. Smith, Trustee William G. Albertson, Trustee Jill Doherty, Clerk WORKSESSION: Among the 10 items on the worksession the following were discussed and resolved. 1. SEQRA FEES: A $15 charge to Trustees in addition to the estimated fee from Bruce Anderson, to cover r~iewwo~rk that needs to be done. 2. Henry P. Smith, Trustee was elected the Southold Town Board of Trustees liaison for the National Estuary Program. CALL MEETING TO ORDER PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE NEXT TRUSTEE BOARD MEETING: Thursday, June 24, 1993 at 7 pm WORKSESSION: 6:00 pm NEXT FIELD INSPECTION: Thursday, May 20, 1993 at 8 am TRUSTEE KRUPSKI moved to approve, TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER seconded. ALL AYES. APPROVE MINUTES: Special meetihg of April 5, 1993 and regular meeting of March 25, 1993: TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER approved, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES. I. MONTHLY REPORT: Trustees monthly report for March 1993: A check for $ was forwarded to the Supervisor's Office for the General Fund. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER movedto forgo the monthly report due to scheduling problems and will have ledger ready for next month. Board of Trustees 2 April 29, 1993 II. PUBLIC NOTICES: Public notices are posted on the Town Clerk's Bulletin Board for review. III. AMENDMENTS/WAIVERS/CHANGES: 1. James Volney Righter Architects on behalf of CAMPBELL requests a waiver to make additions to existing guest cottage as per revised plans dated March 25, 1993. Located East Harbor, Fishers Island. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYERmoved to approve for the waiver, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 2. THEODORE ZANG requests a waiver to raise house and fill not higher than the bulkhead. Located Private Road off. Main Bayview Road, Southold. TRUSTEE B~RDEMEYERmoved to stay with the Resolution of 3/25/93 return waiver fees, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES 3. THOMAS ZUKAS request a waiver to clear property 50' from landward. Also Board to discuss existing dock. Located Smith Drive, Southold. TRUSTEE SMITH moved in the form of a resolution to suspend dock permit and give 90 days to clear up navigation problem, and no boats can be kept at dock, TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER seconded. ALL AYES 4. ROBERT & ANNA FINORArequests a waiver to dismantle garage which is approx. 69' from bulkhead and to do renovations on existing house which is greater than 75' from bulkhead. Located 795 E. Legion Ave. Mattituck. TRUSTEE SMITH moved to give a waiver, TRUSTEE ALBERTSON seconded. ALL AYES 5. Karen Oxholm on behalf of NORMAN TAYLOR requests a waiver to add a garage and porch to existing dwelling as noted on plan. Located Cleaves Point Road, East Marion. TRUSTEE ALBERTSON moved to approve for the waiver, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES 6. MICHAEL ZUKAS requests a waiver to construct a 4' high wire mesh fence from the wetland monument 75' inland as shown on map. Located Bayberry Road, Southold. TRUSTEE ALBERTSON moved to approve the waiver, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES. 7. Eh-COnsultants on behalf of IRA GORDON requests an extension on Permit #3925 for a single family dwelling and dock to'expire on June 7, 1994. Located Willis Creek Drive, Mattituck. TRUSTEE SMITH movedto approve for the extension, TRUSTEE ALBERTSON seconded. ALL AYES 8. HARBOR LIGHTS CANAL ASSOCIATION requests an amendment to extend Permit 43932 for maintenance dredging of canal to expire with Army Corp permit on October 7, 2001~ Board of Trustees 3 April 29, 1993 TRUSTEE SMITH moved to approve the amendment, TRUSTEE ALBERTSON seconded. ALL AYES IV. PUBLIC HEARINGS: THIS IS A PUBLIC HEARING IN THE MATTER OF THE FOLLOWING APPLICATIONS FOR PERMITS UNDER T~EWETLANDS ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD. I HAVE AN AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION FROM THE SUFFOLK TIMES AND AN AFFIDA%~T OF PUBLICATION FROM THE LONG ISLAND TRAVELER-WATCH. PERTINENT CORRESPONDENC~MAY BE READ PRIOR TO ASKING FOR COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC. PL~A~ ~R~ YOUR COMFzENTS ORGANIZED AND BRIEF: FIVE (5) MINUTES OR LESS~ IF POSSIBLE 7:29 p.m. - In the matter of LESLIE TEMME to construct a one family dwelling approx. 45' X 36', a septic system, a well and a Catwalk. Located Goose Creek Lane, Southold. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Is there anyone here who wishes to speak on behalf of this application? Is there anyone here who wishes to speak against this application? Any comments from the Board of TrUstees? I know we had performed a field inspection and indicated we wanted a minimum of of a 40' buffer in the preliminary drawing and it was submitted today and the work order has been cut with the licensed land surveyor and shall be submitted as soon as they can. TRUSTEE SMITE: I make a motion we close this p~blic hearing. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: Actually the description that Jay read is just hand pruning. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: Second. ALL AYES TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: There being no further comment, I'll take a vote of the Board. TRUSTEE SMITH: I move we approve this application, with the added co~ents of the hand pruning. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: Second. ALL AYES 7:30 p.m. - In the matter of Peconic Associates on behalf of VARUJANARSLANY~/~ to construct approx. 95' of bluff protection type bulkhead to connect to existing bulkhead to the east. Approx. 150 c.y. of clean fill will be trucked in. Construct 18' X 68' wide wooden deck, and replace 3' wide stairs to beach. Located 54455 County Road 48, Southold. TRUSTEE BREDE~EYER: Is there anyone here who wishes to speak on behalf of this application? MERLON WIGGIN: I think you all know the background on this project, and originally this was much bigger and we reduced it to scope and the main thing that's changed is the retaining wall bulkhead at the toe of the slope. And right now the slope is slippery and part of the slope is slid down and another storm has created additional loss. This will be connected to the bulkhead to immediate east and his neighbor to the west will be another section of bulkhead. I have statements from both the neighborsto the east and west and have no objection to work Board of Trustees 4 April 29, 1993 being done. I'd also like to request in the interest of protection, that we approve this and we can get the work done. TRUS~E BRE~EMEYER: I~s there anyone else who wishes to speak on behalf of this application? The CAC considered the appliCation and t~hled it and deemed the application was incomplete historyand property permits were needed. The Trustees have been involved with this application for some time and Ica// tell you we have reviewed the aspects directly relating to us and had after discussions briefly with the Town Attorney was suggested that we move ahead on pur applications since this is not in a critical environmental area and didn't require full coordination. There's a chicken and egg problem here and there's some Building Dept. problems that are there and for us to link it in the process was disCouraged and Mr. Arslanyan still has to appear before the Zoning Board of Appeals for discussion of certain other items which is really out of our jurisdiction. This is actually a scaled down approach to what was a prior problem which included prior approval granted on a building permit for a sw~f~ng pool almost at bluff's edge. Certain other items whether lawful or not so that there's been an attempt by the owner and by his agent to scale back the process substantially to provide protection to the bluff as well as come up with some reasonable use in front of the house. I know that there was a prior histor~ and concerns. Any additional comments from the Board of Trustees? TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: I'd like to make sure that the slope is maintained. The slope from the bulkhead landward. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Any additional comments? There being none I'll take a motion to close this hearing. TRUSTEE SMIT~: So moved TRUSTEE ALBERTSON: Second. ALL AYES TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Vote of the Board in this matter? TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: I make a motion we approve the application. TRUSTEE AT.RERTSON: Second. ALL AYES 7:32 p.m. - In the matter of John Geideman on behalf of JOSEPH FLOTTERON to remove Old existing 20' X 4' dock~ ramp and float. Construct in same location a 30~ X 4' dock, a 3' X 10' ramp and a 6' X 30' float. Located 595 Clearwater Lane, Cutchogue. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Is there anyone here who wishes to speak on behalf of this application? Anyone here who wishes to speak against this application? Trustees? There being no additional coz~ents I'll take motion to close the hearing in this matter. TRUSTEE SMITH: So moved. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: Second. ALL AYES TRUSTEE KRUPSKi: I'll make a motion we approve the application. TRUSTEE SMIT~: Second. ALL AYES 7:37 pom. - In the matter of John Geideman on behalf of PIERRE GAZARIAN to construct bulkhead to line up with the neighbors bulkhead. Located Willow Terrace Lane, Orient Harbor. Board of Trustees 5 April 29, 1993 TRUSTEE BREDE~EYER: Is there anyone who wishes to speak on behalf of this application? Anyone who wishes to speak against this application? CAC do you recall an inspection on this? BRUCE LOUCKA: I was just going to ask you if you have anything from us. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Well you've got our Negative Declaration, and you were carboned on the Environmental Assessment. The applicant is trying to line up with the eXisting bulkhead. There was severe evulsion of the front of their property and is a continuation of the existing bulkhead line. It's pretty standard. As I said previously, we have now amended the application foim to show notification date for the CAC for referral so that we should get them back to you in time for assessments. Any other comments from the Board members? There being none I'll take a motion to close the hearing. TRUSTEE ALBERTSON: So moved. TRUSTEE SMITH: Second. ALL AYES TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Vote in this matter? TRUSTEE SMITH: I make a motion we approve. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Second. ALL AYES 7:42 p.m. - In the matter of J.M.O. Consulting on behalf of JAMES N. BAILIE to rePair and extend a stone wall by trucking in and relocating boulders at a point approx. 70' landward of MHW line, .and to create a garden landward of the wall. Located Private Road off Oriental Avenue, Fishers Island. TRUSTEE BREDE~EYER: IS there anyone here who wises to speak on behalf of this application? GLENN JUST: The only other agency which has any jurisdiction in this matter is the DEC and I've submitted a copy of their tidal wetlands approval to the board for their files. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Did the DEC approve what we had before us? GLENN JUST: Exactly. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: We had a lot of trouble ground truthing it. The December llth storm had really, talk about rearranging a beach, Bruce Loucka and I were there and it took awhile to get our bearings° I think that it was the stone fields had gotten reworked somewhat. I think the field report I issued on that as.a result of our inspection, indicated that it was acceptable as was provided~ there was no filling beyond the garden. There being any c~m~ents further, pro or con? None, I'll take motion to close the hearing in this matter. TRUSTEE SMITH: So moved. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: Second. ALL AYES TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Motion to approve in this matter? TRUSTEE SMITH: I~ll make a motion we approve the application; TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: Second. ALLAYES TRUSTEE B~R~EMEYER: I'd just like to add, no fill outside of garden. 7:45 p.m. In the matter of Land Use on behalf of JOHN A. BURNS requests an application to construct a 4' X 50' fixed dock elevated a minimum of 4' over grade, and a 3' X 15' ramp and a 6' X 20' float. Located 755 Lighthouse Lane, Southold. Board of Trustees 6 April 29, 1993 TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Is there anyone here who wishes to speak on behalf of this appliCation? The CAC included provisions that natural vegetation buffers maintain at least 20' since there is evidence of heavy water and high fertilization. Buffer should be required. Any additional comments? Being none I'll take a to close the hearing. I have a co, La,lent. These docks that we've been to build, 4' above grade, I think that's very and a lot of these structures I think are ugly to look at up there like that, and I think in a lot of cases no reason for it. I think the reason was for marine growth, andspartina to grow underneath it, and in a lot of places this is being done without the spartina even under it ~nd i think we should look at something that allows more light further spacing of dock planking or small size dock in this area so these things can be built so that they wouldbe more aesthetic looking. TRUSTEE BRE~EMEYER: I agree, I don't think they'll get permit ~d~r Army Corps. or DEC permit without the elevation. Do he,he Environmental~ Consultants out in the audience want to help us on that. ROY HAJE: You would have to convince both of those agencies to help you out, but I agree with you completely because if there's any number of examples of docks which are lower than that, where it over spartina where its growing very lushly. I think that concept is one of many serious ones. TRUSTEE SMITH: It adds a safety factor and an expense. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: I can remember almost ten years ago we were writing permits with 3' elevations. Is it possible that they wouldn't go back to 3' or is this gonna cast every applicant into going back to Azmy Corp and DEC. ROY HAJE: Unless a Board such as yours and other boards were to petition both DEC and Corps asking for revision, so if you approve at 3' the applicant would be stopped. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER:~ I think this requires more direct approach toother regulatory ap=ncies. TRUSTEEKRUPSKI: I think it would be more environmentally sound to go width the 3' catwalk. TRUSTEE ~SMITH: Two foot down is plenty. Four foot Ifeel is excessive. Ok let's approve the application. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: At this time I'll take a motion to close the hearing, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: So moved. TRUSTEE SMITH: Second. ALL AYES TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Motion in this matter? TRUSTEE SMITH: I make a motion we approve with the co~mlents of the CAC. TRUSTEE ALBERTSON: Second. ALL AYES 7:50 p.m. - In the matter of J.M.O. Consulting on behalf of THOMAS W. BUCF=NER to construct 2 one-story additions and deck onto pre-existing single family dwelling and relocate existing septic tank. Located Private Road, Fishers Island. Board of Trustees 7 April 29, 1993 TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Is there anyone here who wishes to speak on behalf of this application? GLENN JUST: We do not have a DEC Permit as yet. I spoke to Steve Sanford of the Bureau of Environmental Protection the latter part of last week and he has given his basically his "blessing" which is what we're waiting for in writing. TRUSTEE BR~DEMEYER: Bruce Loucka and myself conducted i~spections on Ma~ch 15, and transmitted an inspection report at that time, and I believe that when the Trustee Office receives the application fee and I think we were holding for the application fee and indicated the requirements for a possible zoning variance and that process indicated the application sh0Uldbe filed here. GLENN JUST: It has gone to the ZBA once we received a Negative Dec. from the Trustees. TRUSTEE BREDE~EYER: Have we corrected the tax map notation on this? And authorizing signatures, I guess we have completed proper needs and we have SEQRA already. I think we have a complete file here. We can move on. I say is there any additionalcommant? We'll close the hearing in this matter. TRUSTEE SMITH: So moved. TRUSTEE ALRERTSON: Second. ALL AYES TRUSTEE BREDEEEYER: Since I inspected it I'll put forward a motion to approve this application and grant permit upon submission of required application fee. TRUSTEE ALBERTSON: Second. ALL AYES 7:53 p.m. -.In the matter of Ward Associates on behalf of KATIE N~CHOAAUS ~onstruct a wooden bulkhead at toe of existing bluff. North side of Soundview Avenue, Southold. TRUSTEE Is there anyone here who wishes to speak on behalf~of this application? TOM ,SAMUELS: I'm just answering any questions you might have. TRUSTEE' BRED~EEyER: Any questions? Being none, I had CAC comments on this and they were negative. CAC had indicated t the disapproval was in order since there were no wal ~a. I know the Trustees on inspection were concerned The applicant had shown a history of trying vegetated means to stabilize and on case by case basis we discussed 'it and discUSsed the continuing the application to the hearing portion on it. We still have not made suale possible changes to the CEHA and I know we're still open to possibly discussing a uniform policy if one can be ..... BRUCE LOUCKA: What other than the bluff what is the problem? TRUSTEE BREDKMEYER: That's the sole problem. The house is a permanent .... BRUCE LOUCKA: The house is OK, if he could loose 20 more foot the house is already. TRUSTEE BREDE~EYER: I guess its a relative degree of importance of individuals or on the Board and what an individual who owns the property may bring to the process. BRUCE LOUCKA: And there's no other one in the area. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: That's correct. Board of Trustees 8 April 29, 1993 BRUCE LOUCKA: That's where we find the problem, because when we walked the beach the other day where there was bulkhe~ding and then a vacant or a piece next to it that wasn't bulkheaded that had twice as much damage as no bulkhead. TRUSTEE SMITH: When you say that the bulkheads are doing they're job if the bulkhead area has damage and the bulkhead are doesn' t. BRUCE LOUCKA: They're doing their job', but what's going to happen is, we had to walk through water around bulkheadm because the beach isn't there anymore. TRUSTEE B~RDEMEYER: Do you have a preferred position yet, I know the CAC had a presentation. I: guess it was Jay Tanski as for as a rock revetment at toe of bluff is universal, no feeling, just simply no hardened structures. BRUCE LOUCKA: One place where there's a rock that's, at high tide the rock's in the water. What~ we're looking at is nothing unless, as a last resort. If you c~n't move the house, and the house was in danger and you can't ave the house then stabilize the bluff that way, but other than that right we can't see .... sTRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: ~Cause this p~rticular sight, you can't ee, there's a normal angle of repOse, would be at the back of the house, it's natural very steep !and just to have angel of repose or recline of bluff if you ~ere to s~ek to amend it to stabilize itself, there's no propemty so it's just a matter of time before there 11 be an application before us which is a lot closer. TOM SAMUELS: The arqument is a good argument, as to how far you can retreat, the problem is what i~ gonna be the nature of the st°~m and h0~w much Loss is there gQnna be. The Nicholaus proper~y is a verY difficult area because clay is why the slope is .steep. But I challenge the idea that the bulkheads that have been built ~urther to the east have necessarily contributed to eros~n ~f adjacent property. In t~he absence of studies done on the SoUnd WhiCh I understand Sea G~ant has a proposal before the State for funding such a study, I Would certainly encourage the sta~e to spend the money, rather t~an make these constant retreat arguments. The average homeowner looks at the property ~roding away is d~ep!y concerned. IAnd again, how far do you ove? On the ocean beach during the December storm several houses lost 82' of horizontal and had to go to court to get court orders in order to protect thei~ houses, 'cause the houses could not be moved further back than they had. So you have that rea~ classical problem, and it is a . problem. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Is there anyone else who wishes to comment with respect to this application? Board members? TRUSTEE SMITH: Well just that I feel, people are loosing bluff or property, and I have a great respect for property if they want to protect it and they should be allowed to do so. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: At this time I' 11 take a motion to close the hearing in this matter. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: So moved. TRUSTEE ALBERTSON: Second~ ALL AYES TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Motion to approve this application? TRUSTEE SMITH: I '11 make a motion we approve this application. Board of Trustees 9 April 29, 1993 TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: I'll second this subject to any additional requirement for armoring particularly at the returns or in the front that the DEC might impose in their application process. It would be a question of the need here and I would automatically allow for that to occur as an amendment to our application. TRUSTEE SMITH: Jay, I would like to state that I would like to see this structure tight up against the bluff as possible without endangering the bluff. ALL AYES 7:23 p.m. - In the matter of En-Consultants on behalf of MICHAEL GAMBARDELLA to construct a timber dock consisting of a 4' X 110' fixed elevated walk, (including ramp at inner end); a 4' X 12' hinged ramp; (2) 8' X 16' floats secured by (2) 2 pile dolphins. Located 1450 Broadwaters Road, Cutchogue. TRUSTEE BRRDE~EYER: Is there anyone here who wishes to speak on behalf of this application? ROY HAJE: Only if you have any questions. TRUSTEE BREDE~EYER: I don't think the CAC had any comments on this. I'll take a motion to close the hearing. TRUSTEE SMITH: So moved. TRUSTEE ALBERTSON: Second. ALL AYES TRUSTEE BREDEM--EYER: Vote in this matter? TRUSTEE SMITR: I make a motion we approve this application. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: Second. ALL AYES 8:12 - In the matter of Peconic Associates on behalf of NARROW RIVER F~RINA to amend Town Wetlands and Trustees~ Permit 93809 to include authorization for placement of 15 private aids to navigation on Trustee land, Hallocks Bay (Long Beach Bay) nt, NY. TE~ BP~DE~EYER: Is there anyone here who wishes to speak on behalf Of this application? MERry'ON WIGGIN: Peconic Associates on behalf of the applicant~ Very quickly, just to bring a quick background. This previously marked ch~el started in the late 1800's and took ten years to put in place. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: I think this is good that this has finally come to a Public Hearing and that it's recognized that the Trustees' do have jurisdiction in this matter. I think that was our original concern. The fact that it was sort of blrpassed, or wether it was overlooked by which party doesn't matter. The fact that it's in front of us at a Public Hearing is important. TRUSTEE SMITH: What type of markers does the Coast Guard require? MR. WIGGIN: The CoaSt Guard wants all markers with the standard Coast Guard approved triangle shape numbers on both sides. The size dictated by how they're located and type of paint and color and everything else. TRUSTEE SMIT~: In other words, they dictate the placement? MR. WIGGIN: We made a recommendation where they modified the placement and they came up and inspected the whole thing. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: As a point of clarification, I believe for all parties concerned it was never an intention to not have the Board of Trustees 10 April 29, 1993 markers to be put on for full public discussion. What had happened is numerous scoping meetings and numerous meetings in the field discussing the impacts which largely surrounded the dredging at the time and the markers actually did show on a page two of what was part of the original package s~b~itted to this office. But did not show inadvertently didn't show in the verbal description so consequently was never published in the. Public Hearing Notice the first time the application was considered. The discussions that we had between the applicant a~d the Board had led the Board, and possibly incorrectly, to consider that the page 2 portion of the application was not gonna be acted on. Consequently we never transmitted an imcomplete n~tice indicating we need verbal description for the Public Hearing. It never showed on the Public gearing, and q~ite honestly we were surprised when the navigation aides went in. We realized that not only had there been a misunderstanding but there had not been a transmission of language into the P~blic Hearing process. So now we've inserted that and that's why we're here. And as far as this office basically has no alternative but to proceed with requesting to have an application put application forward which is very specific and we have to discuss as a Board of Trustees placement of any str~cture on our property because there are issues as to ownership of land as well as liabilities to the Town. The Coast Guard in a sense protects the Board through the permit that they would grant which indicates the size and type and refective nature. On the other hand we have a basic responsibility as owners of real property under water to grant the permission that they go in. So they're not usually exclusive but they do relate to each other. Is there anyone else who wishes to speak on behalf of this application? Is there anyone here who wishes to speak against this application? MR. RICHARD LAT~AM: We 1Qoked at it and though it a hazard to navigation. MR. WIGGIN: They simply said there should be all markers with the standard approved shapes on them. MR. LAT~L~_~: Well you ask the Coast Guard before you ask the Trustees. The DEC as a matter of fact approved five poles before you guys did anything 6 more of a foot i~ without they're approval. That's the sort of thing we're working on now. You can see thisthing what's gonna happen now. The channel is silted in and filled in, it zig zags as a matter of fact. Hallocks by the way spe~t a lot of money and they could have just gone down southChannel ~hich they sho~ldhave, the natural channel, they spent a lot of money on maintenance and doing this job and I don't think they would do it again. I think the one off the rock pile and get in the Bay and its natural channel along Long Beach is really the way for it to go. ~&t's the way the marina people did up to a couple of years ago and it worked out fine. Take the floating markers up in October or whenever they're finished then put them back in the spring. I don't think you need these permanent things. Finally the next step with finally making out with these people is "Well we'll have to maintenance dredge this whole channel, that's coming, you can Board of Trustees 11 April 29, 1993 see that. that will be here. I would ask you, the one guy who is not here, the Orient Trustees is not ~hle to be here tonight... TRUSTEE BREDE~EYEP.: I was gonna speak to that next. I spoke to him at length and I had told him that I would honor the conversation we had and I would bring that to the floor. MR. LATHAM: Before you vote I would like you to call him up on the phone. It may be unusual, but he is .... TRUSTEE B~RDEMEYER: No, I already discussed it, and I indicated to him that I pledged I would discuss his concerns and I plan after we took comments pro and con by the members of the Public what John had told me. MR. LATHAM: That would knock out his vote then. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Well I couldn't carry a proxy for him.~ I'm just gonna indicate to the Board what he ask me to relate which I indicated as a Trustee. I had an obligation to do because he felt strongly about it, not that he had called me and I was gonna be his position. I don't personally agree with that position but I offer to being it to the Board for the purpose of discussion. And I will do that after the rest of the Public Speaks. MR. LATHAM: Before you vote, call him on the phone. We don't have a conference phone but we'll join with whatever he says. Could you do that? TRUSTEE BP~EDEF~fER: I do not believe it would be entirely appropriate. I have given myword that I would bring forward John's issues. MR. LAT~LAM: He doesn't have a vote though. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: He doesn't have a vote. You have to be here to vote. MR. LATHAM: I would ask you to consider very carefully, this is a very important thing, once these pilings, as a matter of fact there are 11 there now and the applications for 15, I don't know, these things seem to grow. They're all over the Bay zig zaggi~g. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: We had the map taped together in one entirety if anyone.wants to look here. MR. LATF~%M: Well I would ask you to consider some other...leave ~couple of them there and remove the others. STE~ BREDE~A~R: Ok. Is there anyone else here who wishes to speak in favor or against these aides to navigation in Hallocks Bay? STEVE LATSON: We oppose to this from the beginning, because we have a permit and as we understood it at least that's what the Trustees seemed to have done. I think the big danger is that you will get a dredged channel in there which would be a very very big mistake. I can tell you right now that when we had the blizzard Hallocks probably got saved because it isn't a dredged channel and because there is shoaling in those channels and not all water can go out of that creek. A lot of flats got hurt bad as far as scallops population in that storm and I believe Hallocks ...... (shuffling of map paper inhibited transcription of Mr. Latson's speech) .... Where you're marking this channel as Richie mentioned some day someone comes along Board of Trustees 12 April 29, 1993 and says, "hey this channel!s filled in" and its already filled in. We don't want this dredge out business hazard to navigation. At the same time it w~uld be making a real hazard in this instance. The scallops for instance. We opposed to having a lot of craft in there and we're already part of the Bay a~d we don't want to compound the situation. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: Can I get your opinion on the proposed dredging? In the channel. MR. LATSON: First of all this isnlt the accepted normal channel in Hallocks Bay anyway. There's always been a shoal right in here (showing the area on map) on a typical low tide you only have 2 1/2 feet. TRUSTEE BRED~: Just as appoint of information this has bgen accepted by the CoastGuard ~d shows on the navigation charts and historically shown a marked channel. We were not the ones to make it nor include it on the navigation charts. We approved spot dredging in two loca~ions~ that are totally filled. MR.. LATSON: That's been that way for years, that didn't fill in. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: As a point of interest we are telling you this was a direct result of the storm. We have direct evidence as the problem. (At'this time too many people spoke at the same time in arg~ent). TRUSTEE BREDE~EYER: Any further comment with respect to this matter? I'll take a motion to cloSe the.hearing in this matter. ~USTEE SMIT~: So moved. ~RUSTEE KRUPSKI: Second. ALL AYES TRU~ BREDEMEYER: Your pleasure with respect to to the RusaVigationaI aids? TEE SMITH: You were going to speak on behalf of John Tuthill. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Yes. I would move we reopen this hearing for the sake of entering the record the comments of Trustee John Tuthii1. STEE KRUPSKI: Second. ALL AYES STEE BREDE~EYER: I talked with~Capt. Tuthill and he feels that the So~th channel should be ~.e referred channel and that we abandon this channel. He felt that if necessary we should go to floating markers as had been indicated by Mr. Latham. He felt there was adequate water and ~e felt there were similar depths in the South Channel and I Sndicatedto him I WOuld bring those co~m,~nts to the BOard at the time of the discussion. TRUSTEE SMtT~: Just that he wants to go to the SoutholdChannei. TRUSTEE B~RDE~EYER: Basically he felt we should go t° the Southold Channel and abandon this channel entirely. TRUSTEE S~IT~: This is the channel that Mr. Latson uses. The Southold Channel. TRUSTEE BREDE~EYER: He basically felt ~hey should not exist in this location, and we should use t~e Southold Channel. TRUSTEE BRED~: Being no further con~ent, I'll take a motion to close the hearing? TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: So moved. TRUSTEE ALBERTSON: Second. ALL AYES Board of Trustees 13 April 29, 1993 TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Your pleasure in this application? TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: I'll make a motion to deny the application and to request the removal of the 15 navigation aids. TRUSTEE BREDE~: Is there a second? TRUSTEE SMITH: Seeing as you have amotion and you can't get a second Jay, the motion .... TRUSTEE BREDE~EYER: You can't get a second. I think a motion has been lost not hearing a second the Board could move another motion I quess if t~at's proper and possibly... ~ There was some consideration for checking and confirming that the Coast Guard rigs would possibly allow for floating aids to navigation. T~USTEE SMITH: I think we should postpone it for one month to give Mr. Tuthill a chance to be here and express himself where he is from Orient. We could look into the possibility of the Coast Guard changing their mind on a different type of navigational aid. TRUSTEE ALBERTSON: I'll second that. TRUSTEE BREDEMEyER: Motion made and seconded to table the matter and to allow for communication with the Coast Guard saying that there is public concern. TRUSTEE BRMDEMEYER: Vote of the Board? ALL AYES 8:16 p.m. - In the matter of SUFFOLK COUNTY WA~ER AUTHORITY to install water mains in the Laurel area to provide domestic water and fire ProtectiOn for public use. Located along Birch and Bay Avenues, Mattituck TRUSTEE BR~DE~EYER: Is there anyone here who wishes to speak on behalf of this application? Is there anyone here who wishes to speak against this application~ Did the CAC get the full applications on the water authority ? BRUCE LOUCKA: No. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: We had some concerns. TRUSTEE BREDE~EYER: All the concerns were met. What I'm concerned is that the CAC did not get this file. There being no further comment, I'll take a MOTION. TRUSTEE SMITH: I'll make a motion we close and we won't vote on it until we get comments from CAC. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: I'll second that. Motion was made to await vote until comments from CAC. ALL AYES VARIANCE APPLICATIONS FOR PERMITS UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF THE COASTAL EROSION HAZARD AREAS ORDINANCE. 7:26 p.m. In the matter of en-Consultants on behalf of SUS~/~ TASKER to construct a one family dwelling, deck, retaining walls, sanitary system, bluestone (or similar pervious driveway) underground utilities and approx. 200 c.y. of clean sand and fill for the following schedule of variances under the Coastal Erosion Hazard Area Ordinance. STRUCTURAL HAZARD AREA: Code description of section proposed prohibited without variance. Board of Trustees 14 April 29, 1993 37-13D Non-movable structures (house with sl~h and curbing)propOsed within 25' of bank/bluff. 37-13D Non-movable structures (house with slab and curbing) proposed within structural hazard area. 37-13C Permansnt foundation (sl~h) attached to permanent structure. 37-13E No plans for landward relocation of movable structures have been provided. Located County Road 48, Southotd. Is there anyone here who wishesto speak on behalf of this application? This application will have to get a separate hearing under the Town's Wetland's Ordinance because it was inadvertently not advertised for both hearings at this time, so that next month it Will appear as a TOwn W~tland's Hearing specifically under Town Wetland Ordinance. This is the Coastal Erosion Variance Application at this time. ROY HAJE: Before I comment I'll just hand up to you some plans, revised plans, slightly. The ones that were forwarded to you with m~ cover letter of April 14, 1993 may have neglected to add the de~k on the north side of side. I want to be sure that you have that. TRUSTEE BRW~E~EYER: With respect to the updated, showing the revetment we request. It shows the deck. ~R. HAJE: The project plan which you have before you now is a result of the comments which the Board of Trustees made at the lastm~eting. We'have dropped the retainin~ wall in favor of a revetment Which goes no further northward thanthe corners of the adjiacent retaining~walls. The house location is pretty well fixed in that there s ia small lot. The house cannot be further south. There is a limited area in which to system. Again, fixing it as we have shown. ~eare~ · of the sanitary system which is the septic tank is a solid structure Which does not leak but does allow s~lid to settle out and then distributes the liq-~id fraction be contaihedl in p~Ols located southward. We havelocated them as far south away from the water as possible. We have indicated that the house would be constructed on pilings if it the determination ofthe Board if necessary. Please note the location of the adjacent structures. There are houses on both sides of this lot. Those structures would be atleast as close or perhaps closer to the water line than the proposed structure would be. Mrs. Tasker visited the property shortly after the December storm and reported there was not flooding o~ this parcel. Therefore we have complied as much as possible with your request. We would seek your favorable review. TRUSTEE BREDE~EY~R: For the purposes of the discussion here, is there anyone here who wishes to speak on behalf of this application? Anyone here who wishes to speak against this application? There were co~,ents contrary to this application from the CAC under the wetland ordinance. We did note that Board of Trustees 15 April 29, 1993 the request for the house on pilings was now offered so that being offered that particular requirement for a variance under that section would not be necessary if we are to accept that offered amendment. Is there any additional comment from the Board in reference to this application? TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: You get an application like this and I appreciate Jay, the work you put into this 'cause it's considerable, but it still comes down to ~hout the way I feel whole ordinance itself, I just don't see the point of most of it. You can proceed. TRUSTEE BRED~EYER: At this time, I'll take a motion to close the hearing in the matter the Coastal Erosion Variance permit. TRUSTEE KR~PSKI: I'll make a motion to close the hearing. TRUSTEE SMITE: Second. ALL AYES TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: I'll take motion to reserve a decision in this matter until after we hold a ~u~lic hearing under the Town's Wetlands Ordinance. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: Do you want to vote on this separately? TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: I would think that we could grant a separate approval or denial if that was your pleasure. I just thought we would keep it more consistent. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: You don't have a great turnout to discuss it. TRUSTEE BREDES~A~/ER: That's true, ~he advocacy against this not a strong as I thought it might have been. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: It's hard to expect a lot of strong opposition to this. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: We closed on it, and al!~ would say is that why not gO ahead On it and hold 'a hearing o~ it next month. The only thing is we'll find ourselves next month in a position we just found ourselves with respect to emergency dredging. We're gonna have to.fill the audience with people seemingly don't attend Trustee meetings, don't have an agenda, or don't participate and then they have a pet problem. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: I don't ' ' ~ think you re gonna have a problem like this. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER: Since I did the nuts and boltsI write-up in this I would mOVe we could approve [the appl~cati0nsUbject to the amended r~turn of En-Consul~ts dated 4/23/93 which shoWs a house on pilings and deck, associated sanitary s~Stem, and public water service, subject to auproval of variances because of the fact that the minimal relief necessary to effectuate the ordinance. And let me explain, by putting the house on pilings the applicant achieves the minimal requirement that the structure will in fact be movable or there could be some alterations, including removing it from the site quickly in the event of a major storm event. The fact is that they elliminate permanent slab or material by this construction and the fact that there's simply no further landward relocation possible in indifference to that where we asked for a stronger more durable rock revetment. The applicant provided that so they have met the test as its in the CEHA that they meet the requirements of a variance by providing that the relief necessary so that we can grant a permit. And that was a motion. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: Second. ALL AYES Board of Trustees 16 April 29, 1993 7:30 p.m. - In the matter of ANN POSEY FERGUSON to construct a single family dwelling, associated sanitary system, gravel driveway, decks, public water for a variance under Town Code Section 37-13D, insufficient setback or removable structures (deck) within the Building Hazard Area. TRUSTEE BREDE~EYER: Anyone here who wishes to speak on behalf of this application? GLEN JUST: On behalf of the application, Glen Just. I think the entire board is familiar with the project. We have here received a letter of non-jurisdiction from DEC or Health Department approvals and ZBA approval. TRUSTEE BRED~EYER: This application had the Wetland Hearing. Bruce Loucka and I had inspected it and done extensive measuring on it. We had very good cooperation from the applicant and they have submitted the planting plan for in front of the house. Any additional co~m~ent? MotiOn to close the hearing? TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: So moved. TRUSTEE ALBERTSON: Second ALL AYES TRUSTEE BREDE~EYER: Motion with respect to the Wetland and Coastal Erosion Hazard Area Permits? TRUSTEE KRUPSKI: I make a motion we approve. TRUSTEE ALBERTSON: Second ALL AYES V. ASSESSMENTS/ENVIRONMENTAL DECLARATIOn: 1. J.M.O. Consulting on behalf of JOHN BRIM requests a permit to place rock slope extending easterly which will vary in height from 6-7 feet in the area recently damaged by the stozms to a height of 2-3 feet at the easterly end near the property line. Located Private Road, Fishers Island. TRUSTEE BREDEN~M~ERmoved to approve a Negative Declaration, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded, ALL AYES 2. J.M.O. Consulting on behalf of DOROTHY HOADLEY requests a storm permit to repair 107' of stone revetment, construct 25' of stone wall in line with existing wall, remove wood ramp, regrade and replace rampwith 3.5' wide wooden stairs in accordance with plan approved by DEC. Located Pennins~la Road, Fishers Island. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER made a motion to issue a Negative Declaration with a fee of $150, TRUSTEE SMITH Seconded. ALL AYES 3. JOHN DOROSKI, JR. requests permit to construct a one-family dwelling with sanitary system and driveway as per survey dated April 22, 1993. Located Madison Street, Greenport. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI moved for a Negative Declaration, TRUSTEE ALBERTSON seconded. ALL AYES 4. J.M.O. Consulting on behalf of ARTHUR TOAN request permit to reconstruct an existing stairway which consists of a 3.25' X 3.25' landing, a 3' X 12' stairs, a 6' X 5/5' landing and a 3' X 11.5' stairs. New stairway shall be reconstructed in same Board of Trustees 17 April 29, 1993 dimensions except existing 6' X 5.5' landing shall be enlarged to 6' X 8' Applicant also proposes to construct a 4' X 24' catwalk (ele. 4' over grade), a 3' X 12' ramp, a 5' X 16' float and to install two 2 pile dolphins. Located Ruch Lane, Southold. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYERmoved for a Negative Declaration, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES 5. GEORGE BRAUN requests a permit to rebuild storm damaged lawn retaining wall (approx. 3' high) and move this wall to be in line with contiguous walls (approx. 6' out). Located 2005 Bayshore Road, Southold. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYERmoved to table this application for May 20 inspection, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES 6. RICHARD MAU~NER requests a permit to rebuild storm damaged lawn retaining wall (approx. 3' high) and move this wall to match existing wall of adjacent neighbors. Located 2055 Bayshore Road, Southoldo TRUSTEE BREDEMEYERmoved to table this application until May 20 inspection, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES 7. J.M.O. Consulting on behalf of WILLIAM EDGET requests permit to construct a 4' X 40' ele. catwalk, a 3' X 12' ramp, a 5' X 16' float. Located 200 Deephole Drive, Mattituck. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYERmoved to give a Negative Declaration, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 8. Henry Raynor on behalf of STRONGS MARINA requests permit to construct new bulkhead, dredge in front of new bulkhead, back fill behind new bulkhead and grade parking away from bulkhead as per revised plans dated April 22, 1993. Located Camp Mineola Road, Mattituck, James Creek. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER moved to table for further inspection of spoil area, TRUSTEE ALBERTSON seconded. ALL AYES 9. J.M.O. Consulting on behalf of Dr. T.J. MC DONOGH requests permit to construct approx. 85' of timber bulkheading and returns and to backfill structure with approx. 15 c.y. of clean sand to be trucked in from an upland source. Structure is for erosion control and. storm damage protection. Located 765 Cedar Point Drive West, Southold. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI motioned to table, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES 10. J.M.O. Consulting on behalf of FRANCES MC LAUGHLIN to construct 100' of timber bulkhead with a 20' return at its eastern end. Structure shall then be backfilled with approx. 350 c.y. of clean sand which shall be trucked in from an upland source. Applicant also proposes to reconstruct stairs and landings which along with bluff had been severely damaged during this past storm. Located 505 Sound View AVe. Mattituck. TRUSTEE ALBERTSON moved to approve for a Negative Declaration, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 18 April 29, 1993 Board of Trustees 11. Costello Marine on behalf of ANTHONY VITALE requests ten year maintenance dredge permit to dredge 6' MLW approx. 100 c.y. of sandy material at entrance to Fair Haven Inlet to provide boating access to property o~ners. Approx. 50-75 c.y. will be dredged each year. Located Inlet Way, Southold. TRUSTEE ALBERTSON MOVED TO GIVE A Negative Declaration, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 12. En-Consultants on behalf of ROBERT HAMILTON requests a permit to construct a timber dock consisting of a 4' X 20' fixed elevated walk (4' above marsh grass) a 4' x 12' hinged ramp, a 6' X 20' float secured by (2) pilings. Located 1180 Smith Drive South, Southold. TRUSTEE SMIT~moved to give a Negative Declaration, TRUSTEE ALBERTSON second. ALL AYES 13. LAURENCE & DIANE NIEBLING requests a permit to construct a 3 1/2' high bulkhead at the toe of the bank to prevent erosion during periods of storm tides. Land disturbed during construction will be reclaimed with the planting of native vegetation. Located 10020 Nassau Point Road, Cutchogue. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI moved to table, T~USTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES 14. ARTHUR TORELL, JR. requests permit to construct a one-family dwelling with-pervious driveway as per revised plans dated April 9, 1993. Located 365 Westwood Lane, Greenport. TRUSTEE SMIT~ moved to give a Negative Declaration, TRUSTEE ALBERTSON seconded. ALL AYES 15. J.M.O. Consulting on behalf of DR. ANT~O~f PETRILLI requests a permit to construct a single, family dwelling, sanitary system, deck, regrade and crushed stone driveway as per survey dated as revised Sept. 18, 1992. Located East End Road, Fishers Island. TRUSTEE BREDE~EYERmoved to table pending DEC and ZBA approval, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 17. ~lichael Bontje on behalf of SANDRA ZATARIAN requests ~torm permit to reconstruct deck and home within the existing foot print of same. Add wave attenuating gabian revetment within the foot print of the existing deck. Located Bay Ave. East Marion. TRUSTEE BREDEME~ERmoved to table this application, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES VI. RESOLUTIONS: 1. BRICK COVE - added on as a result of the worksession to approve the Brick Cove Outline as developed by Bruce Anderson granting a 14 day extension for inclusion of such additional comments as can be agreed ta by any other party. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYERmoved to approve, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES. Board of Trustees 19 April 29, 1993 2. Board to set public hearings for the May 26, 1993 regular meeting for those applications that have received Negative Declarations and those applications that are Type II actions. TRUSTEE SMITH moved to approve, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 3. Board to request County to purchase Robins Island to protect our watersheds and aquifers. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER moved to approve, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 4. Board to request monies for work to be done to secure declaratory judgement into the ownership of Hallocks Bay. TRUSTEE BRRDEMEYER moved to approve, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES. 5. EDWARD NORDSTROM to replace 38' of bulkhead within 18" with a 4' return on east side and a 16' return on west side. Located Wood Lane, Peconic. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI moved to approve subject to inkind/inplace with no encroachment, TRUSTEE SMITH' Seconded. ALL AYES 6. J.M.O. Consulting on behalf of RICHARD PRIETO requests a Grandfather permit to reconstruct inkind/inplace approx. 113' of timber bulkheading which has been damaged by recent storms, structure shall then be backfilledwith approx. 15 c.y. of clean sand which shall be trucked in from an upland site. TRUSTEE SMITH moved to approve, TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER seconded. ALL AYES 7. J.M~.O. Consulting on behalf of DR. ROBERT THOMAS requests a Grandfather permit to replace inkind/inplace 3' X 18.25' fixed dock elevated 4', a 3' X 10.5' ramp, reinstall a 6' x 16.5' float and to reconstruct 68' of retaining wall all of which were damaged during the storm of 12/11/92. Existing retaining wall was constructed with 6" X 6" ties varying in height from 3 to 4' Wall was placed on grade, no excavation had taken place. Locate Stillwater Ave. CUtchogue. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYERmoved to approve, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI abstained, REMAINING TRUSTEES AYES. 8. JOSEPH HOEY AND DAVID DALY requests a Grandfather permit to replace bulkhead inkind/inplace as noted on survey. Located 470 Town Harbor Terrace, Southold. TRUSTEE BRgDEMEYER moved to approve, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES 9. WILLIAM KAPULER requests a Grandfather permit to replace bulkhead inkind/inplace as noted on survey. Located 470 Town Harbor Terrace, Southold. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYERmoved to table 'this application, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES Board of Trustees 20 April 29, 1993 10. En-Consultants on behalf of DOUGLAS BARNARD requests a Grandfather permit to replace (within 18") 100 1.f. of existing timber retaining wall and backfill with 25 c.y. of clean fill to be trucked in from upland source. Remove and replace existing platform and steps which extend over wall. Located Paradise Point Road, Southold. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER moved to approve, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 11. Latham Sand & Gravel on behalf of GERARD BELLESHEIM requests a Grandfather permit to bring 400 c.y. of clean fill from upland source to stabilize bluff. Also to replace stairs and align 40 2-3 ton stone on filter cloth along base of bluff. Located 122 Soundview Road, Orient. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYERmoved to approve, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 12. Latham Sand & Gravel on behalf of MARTIN & SHIRLEY ZACHAR~US requests storm damage permit to construct additional 70' of retaining wall to tie into existing 30' retaining wall on east end due to severe erosion of bluff. Wall to be 3' in elevation above existing rocks. Approx. 200 c.y. of backfill from upland source to be placed and planted with rosa rugosa. Located 1Q55 Soundview Road, Orient. TRUSTEE TRUSTEE SMITH moved to give a Negative Declaration subject to $150 fee, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 13. Eh-consultants on behalf of HENRY LATHAM requests a Grandfather pez¥~,it to replace bulkhead within 18". Located 845 Rogers Road, Southold. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI moved to approve for Grandfather pezmit, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES 14. Eh-COnsultants on behalf of WILBUR BALDWIN requests a Grandfather permit to replace (within 18") 117 1.f. of existing brick ~nd block wall with new timber wall. A 10' return on n/s will also be replaced and extended 20' Approx. 17 c.y. of clean fill wilt be trucked in from_ upland source. Wall will connect to Shuler wall to south. Located 1725 Nassau Point Road, Cutchoque. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI moved to approve Grandfather permit, TRUSTEE ALBERTSON seconded. ALL AYES 15. En-consultants on behalf of KENNETH SHULER requests a Grandfather permit to replace (within 18") 114 1.f. of existing brick and block wall With new timber wall. A 4' return on s/s will connect with existing wood wall. Approx. 15 c.y. of clean fill will be trucked in from upland source. Wall will connect to Baldwin wall to be constructed to north. Project is an emergency. Located 1835 Nassau Point Road, Cutchogue. TRUSTEE TRUSTRR KRUPSKI moved to approve and to include platform and steps as per letter dated March 31, TRUSTEE ALBERTSON seconded. ALL AYES Boar~ Of Trustees 21 April 29, 1993 16. ROBERT ROT~MAN requests a Grandfather pezLL~it to replace dock inkind/inplace as per survey. Located Oaklawn AvenLe, Southold. TRUSTEE SMITH moved to approve for a Grandfather, TRUSTEE BREDE~EYER seconded. ALL AYES 17. J.M.O. Consulting on behalf of CHARLOTTE DROEG~R requests a Grandfather permit to remove remains of dilapidated dock and to r~construct a 47 x 110' fixed dock (elev. 3/5' over grade) a 3' x 12' ramp, a 5' X 16' float and to install two 2 pile dolphins. Located 670 Strohson Road, Cutchogue. TRUSTEE SMITH moved to approve, TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER seconded. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI abstained. 18. En-consultants on behalf of SARAH GICALE to replace 140 1.f. of existing timber bulkhead and 15' return on west side in same location and configuration. Approx. 65 c.y. of clean backfill will be trucked in from upland site. A 4' wide stairway from bulkhead to beach will be replaced. Located East Roa~, Cutchogue. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI moved to approve, TRUSTEE ALBERtSON seconded. ALL AYES 19. J.M.O. Consultants on behalf of ARTHUR URY requests a Grandfather permit to reconstruct inkind/inplace a 4' X 47' catwalk (ele. min. of 4' over grade) and to re-install existing 4' X 12' ramp and a 6' X 20' float which were destroyed during the storm of 12/11/92. Located 3750 Stillwater Ave. Cutchogue. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI moved to approve, TRUSTEE ALBERTSON seconded. ALL AYES 20. JOSEPH CHERNUS~KA requests Grandfather permit to reconstruct bulkhead, deck, and sunroof. Located Rabbit Lane, East Marion.£TRUSTEE BREDEMEYERmoved to approve, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 21. John Geideman on behalf of RUT~ BRAMSON requests a Grandfather permit to replace bulkhead inkind/inplace. Located 'Main Road, East Marion. TRUSTEE BREDE~fER moved to approve, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 22. FREDERICK COULTER requests Grandfather p~rmit to replace bulkhead inkind/inplace. Located 7020 Peconic Bay Blvd. TRUSTEE SMITH moved to approve, TRUSTEE E~V~E~EYER seconded. ALL AYES 23. FLORENCE WICKS requests storm damage permit to place approx. 20 yards of topsoil on the eroded portion of property and re-vegetate bluff. Located Route 48, Peconic. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYERmoved to approve, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES Board of Trustees 22 April 29, 1993 VII. MOORINGS: 1. JEFFREY CITERA requests mooring in Town creek for a 25' outboard with a 250 lb mushroom, with a for and aft anchor. TRUSTEE SMITH moved to approve, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 2. MARGUERITE GARVEN requests mooring in Jockey Creek for an t8' sailboat with a 200 lb. for and aft mushroom. Taking the place of George Mc Fadden's location. TRUSTEE SMITH moved to approve, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 3. KENNETH VAN METER requests mooring in Corey Creek for a 25' inboard with a 200 lb. mushroom. TRUSTEE SMITH moved to approve, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 4. LAWRENCE CULLEN requests onshore/offshore stake in Goose Creek at own property for a 19' outboard. TRUSTEE SMITH moved to approve, TRUSTEE KRUPSKI seconded. ALL AYES 5. RICHARD GREES~IELD requests mooring in Mud Creek for a 12' sailboat with a 75 lb. mushroom. TRUSTEE KRUPSKI moved to approve, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES 6. MARK KWASNIK requests mooring in Mud Creek for a 27' sailboat. TRUSTEE SMITH moved to approve subject to a 100 or 200 lb. for and aft mushroom, TRUSTEE BREDE~EYER seconded. ALL AYES 7. VIRGINIA GODDARD requests mooring in Narrow River for a 16' sailboat with a 75 lb. mushroom. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER moved to table, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES 8. NORA CONANT requests mooring in Narrow River for a 15' sailboat. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER moved to table, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES 9. KAREN SAUVIGNE requests mooring in Narrow River for a 16' sailboat with a 100 lb~ mushroom. TRUSTEE BREDEMEYER moved to table, TRUSTEE SMITH seconded. ALL AYES. Meeting adjourned at 9:35 p.m. Respectfully Submitted By: Board of Trustees 23 April 29, 1993 Clerk, Southold Trustees RECEIVED AND FILED BY THE SOUTHOLD TOWN CLEBK