HomeMy WebLinkAboutZBA-11/11/1971Southold Town Board of Appeals
APPEAL BOARD
MEA4BER
Robert ,,,v,/. Gillispie, Jr., Chairman
Robert Bersen
Charles Gri~onis, Jr,
Serse Doyen, ,Jr.
Fred Hulse, ,Jr.
N~er 2, ~71
Also p~eseng: ~. Hewa~A Terry, B~[1Ai~ Imspeogo~.
-I~/BLX0 ~~: Appeal Ne.' 1~7~-' 7130' P.~; (E.a.T.), upom
a~pli~a~iem ~f ~m"~a~ssa, ts~ View ~, G~ee~o~, ~ew
Y~k, ~ a v~i~e in aoe~a~e,'~h ~e Zon~
309, f~..~missiom ~e Xooa~e aoeesse~ ~fl~g
b~e~ no~h ~Y AAam Pe~, east by Ve~a ~. ~sson,
~y C~ek, west ~Y Bea~e ~B~2~e. ~ee pai~ $~,0~.
t~ applicon. .
~ ~: Is the~e a~o~ p~e~n~ who ~s~s
ha~ ~ ~m~I~.~an ~ttto~ en t~ ~k o~ t~ h~se, a
~e~. ~ ~ a~e to ~ o~ii~oe ~ pu~ ~he
S~athol~ Town Boa~d of Appeals
-2-
Nov. 11,. 1971
ba~k o£ the house, it would be in the meadow.
T~ Ot~K~,N: The ~t~ ~o~ a~ p~ch ~o Sh~ aa ~
~. ~E: They ax, e all cemmec~ed.
(The Boa.vd .and ~. ~ai~h discussed the dimensions of the
as well as
oomXd ~l~ ~ ~ou.~e i~ ~ ~ee~ l~tea~ of 3 fee~ to ~ line.
Af$o~. i~s~a~ion a~ i~e~ilon the B~ fl~s
applie~ ~e~eS~s ~r~sstom te locate aecesso~ ~i~
~ f~ y~d ~ si~e y~d a~ea on ~oPe~ loca~e~ sou~heas~
side of ts~ View ~. ~ Bo~ f~ds ~hat a~plic~t needs
a g~a~.fo~ s~o~ef aut~o~ile ~ ~ mowe~s, etc., ~
the ~ is~lr~og~lY s~ an~ Backs ~ cna e~ek ~
g~a~s in ~ f~ 2~d ~ea in this vicinity. The Bo~d Is
ha~s~p c~ea~e~ Is unite a~ woul~ ~ sh~ed ~ all
use ~ist~lct; an~ ~ w~lance a~s observe ~he spi~l~ ef the
~i~e and ~ net c~e the c~er of the district.
~ motio~ ~ ~. Hulse, secon~e~ ~Y ~* G~t~oni~, it ~s
~~ ~m ~a~assa,~ ~ V~ew ~ne, G~eenport', Mew
be ~~ ~misSion ~o locate accesso~ ~utt~i~ [g~age) in
f~ont.yar~ an~ sf~ y~ ~ea on p~er~ located em somt~ast
sifie of ~land View ~ne, subject to ~ following
T~t g~age ~ located no clese~ t~ ~ feet to the easterly
Vo~e of t~ Bo~: A~s:- ~ss~s: Gi~ispie, ~lse, G~igonis,
D~en. . . .
-3-
· I~LIC ~ARI~-.- Appeal No. 1~?~ - 7:4~ P.~, [E.S,~.), ~on
5o~thold, New Yo~k,
the Zon~r~ ~nce, ~t2cle III, .~ec~on 300, ~b~ctien 5 (a)
dwells. ~cation of ~oper~y= west side of Bei'sse~ AYe~e,
~theld, New Yo~E,
Boisseau Avers, south ~y Oath~Ime
~lvl~. ~e paid
The Chat~an Ol~ned the hea~ing By reading the applicatism
fe~ a special exeeptiem, legal notice of hea~ing, affidavit
attesting to its publics%ion l~ the official r~wspape~s, ahd
notise to the applisa~t.
T~E ~HA,~: ~s there anyone present who wishes to speak
~. T,A~RENOE J. LY~O, JR.: I think ~y application sa~ i~
up.
T~ ~: ~ om~ th~ I Weald say a~ou~ ~his is
t~t I be~eve $~ ~s lot, whe~ ~om wish te oo~ the
h~se~te a two f~l~ ~welli~, sheul& ~ inc~ease& tm ~,0~
sq. ft. tn e~er ~ mee~ t~ requirements of the p~esent
e~i~amce, T~ ~ew ~r~lnance, ~lch w~ De passe~ ~,
~eqaires 80,~ sq.
(The Board and Er. Llso discussed Bou~da~les amd ~imensions).
" TBE O~AIR~AN: You ha& a legal sized lot at the time it was
c~eate&. Y$~ c$~!~ go d~ to ~,~00 sq. ft. Increasing this
lot tc:2~,.000 sq. ft. w~l& brl~t~ et~r l~-&~ te 17,~0
sq. f~. ~ y~ application is ap~eve~ yo~ ~ Be set to sell
it off. H~ new is ~t house
' O' If the front' lot were so3~ se~e
~. LiS . !~ '~s b~ar~ new.
~y and I,,~re'livi~ In ~ house at t~ ~e~, I ~uld mot want
T~ ~~: ~n u~er ~ new
are 15-~ee~ ~.25 feet. ~ ~ ~ goi~
t~ ~e~ ~t mo fence is a~we~,
T~ ~AIRNAN: Does anyone else wish to speak for this
applieat~on? -
T~ere was no ~es~emse,
~ C~~: Is t~e ~yone p~esen~ who ~s~s ~o s~k
agains~ ~hiS. a~lioati~?
Bo~sse~ ATone, ~tho~, ~ev ~o~k,
~oses AIvi~ t~ p~es, ~o~lsi~ ,.99~' ~e, ~n~ ~wo
plots o~ ~p~to~ ~,~ sq,~ ft, each.
~onve~t ~e dwe~ on .eas~eF~,po~tten of. lot ~o a two fa~12
· ~XXi~, b ~a~pllc~) ~ ~ce~ eo~cte~ anew two
~ ~ :~s ~n ~emen~ vi~h t~ apyX~e~t,~.s r~ason~ to
eonYer~ b~ld~ on ~b eaate~ ~o~i~
family d~Xlt~g ~ division ~s ~e se-
d~lll~ is Xo~ated on a plot of not
Justice will be BetTed an~ the legally established
aso of neighberhoo~ p~epe~r an~ adjoining use
not ~e 1M~aanemtl2 e, aubs.tantiall~ l~u~ed a~ the spirit of
the ~l~nce uill be
en mot~en ~ Hr. G~lgemis, seconded .by
Now York,~ G~ ~mXsston ~OT ~nve~ oXXS~ d~ll~
Bo~sse~ A~o, S~Xd, New ~, s~2eu~ ~o ~ following
a~ ba8~ 2~,~00 sq. f~, This l~ase will ~Volve a
of ~ eas~17 bou~-of t~ re~ lot
~ fee~.
~em.
~ l~l~c Hea~ngs'aohoduXed.Fe~ .8;00.
t9 tn View ~ xe~e~
New ~E, New ~s~Bi~, T~aveXe~.~Feet,
~t~Xd, New Yo~k.
'DecisiOn ef the ~outhold. Town B~aFd of Appeals on~ Appeal No.
0~
~J~66; .Pablic t~earin~' ~1~ ~p~e~er- 3 ~ 1971,
C~p. ~B/a VictOria ~el and O~2t~es, Ba~iew R~ad,
New Yo~k, ~e~ a special exception in' accedence ~w~th t~ Zeni~
~din~ce, ~tlele ~'A, ~cti~n 350, ~sect~on
~e expand exis~g ~ina. L~a~ion of prope~: s~th
Ba~iew Road, ~th~, New Yc~,- B~ed n~r~h ~ Ba~e~ R~d,
eah~ ~ Ja~s Bitses, s~th B2 C~ey C~eek, ~st
(~to~e~. 21, 1~7~= ~. Ricked CapOn ~ ~. ~ Je~en of ~he
B~view Deve~p~nt Co~; ~B/a V~eto~la ~0~el~ a~d Co~tages, Ba2view
R~ad, ~thol~, New YorE, ~d a f~her disc~ssiem with ~ B~
~e~ t~ ~l~ly s~d ~i~s regaling
p~lem of existl~ ~i~.)
After investigation an~ inspestion, a~d p~blle hea~i~g, the
Boa~d detema~ined ~he following fa~ts pertinent to th~s 6ceSsion=
The applicant operates a motel at the above location with
two bedroom facilities im eno building, ~esigned to held
The applicant seeks l~aisston te expa~ the aoceiedatians
mot ~o~e t~-six ~so~ ea~, to'be pe~nt~ attac~ ~o
shore ~se~ e~ctrie pewee, sewage, a~ water f~il~t2es ~ a/e
t~ T~ B~ ef T~astees, as legated In Corey C~eek ~ the
the~-Bahamas, l~lorl~a and. ~u~ope, we have little-data" em the
problems encoumtered except that it ~oes mot appea~ feasible te
o~ leave thei~ moorings in t~se ~te~s'beea~se ef obvious
p~lems as~ctated wish narCOtic, s~e~ ef lives a~ p~ope~.
~e~ks in ~seboa~s. S~ ~ave~a~le experie~e is ~epo~ed In
t~ B~S.
the t~ f~ee ~t~e el' se~-pe~en~ h~se~oat facilities fe~
a ~i~m of ~ people, zo~ de~t~y in ~ e~ zo~, ~ ~
~ c~eated feF To~ ~ ~cal ~vices, sucB as f~e ~ peli~e.
pFtvate~ ~e~ pleas~e c~t of the s~ size, ~ ~ss, to ase
aceomaedate a total of 12 such houseboats.
The B~rd finds fu~$he~ that the policy of th~ To~n of
Southel~ has been to encou~aSe app~op~iate leimare use of ~ewn
lands and waters subject ~o reasonable control~ designed to
insure compattbili~y with su~ro~nding use a~eas.
On motion by ~. Glllispie, seconded by ~. Grigonis, it was
R~O~ Ba2view Development 0o~p. ~/b/a Victoria ~el~a~
Ce~ages,~Ba~few R~, S~thol~, New'York, be ~ ~mission
~o ~p~d ex~s~l~~ ~' legated seu~h .si~e of Ba~iew Road,
~hel~, New Yo~k, subject ~o the foll~i~ conditions:
of net ~o~e~han ten (1~) h~se~ts me l~ge~ ~ 13 f~. x 36
~af~ net e~ 30 ~n~s, fe~ use as a "reso~t l~gi~ faeilt~
sleepi~ ne~ me~e~ ~n s~ ps,sons e~h, to ~e o~ed e~ leased
t~ Bt~,lew flo~p., ~o Be moo~e~ to a proposed 1~ fcc2
deok~' ~o ~e si~a~ed in t~ wa~e~s in ~ey ~eek as des~rt~
and fu~he~ de~Sc~2Bed im s~vey s~ch at~ac~d to this
~66. Applim~ ~all no~ ~he Balldi~ l~c~o~ ef ~ ~e~
~d des~nation of ~e~ea~s mo~, i~ aceo~mce ~h t~is ~-
mission, p~o~ $o ~as~; as ~ as any o~ge which ~7-
f~om tl~ to ~e ~ t~ o~o~e~, ~be~ o~ disposition, o~
~eplaoe~n~ of h~seb.oats ac ~egiste~e~ ander this pe~mission.
~soboats so ~egia~e~e~ wit~ the Bulldi~ I~peoto~ o~ed o~
~a~ ~ ~ Ba~iew 0o~., ei2he~ wttB o~.vit~ou$ p~e~, ased
fo~ t~ above p~poses, sha~ be oonside~e~ ~r~nent~
~ ~ solely fo~ ~ use of ~egiste~ed guests wht~ moo~d
t~ deck a~ ~y not be moved with ~ests aboa~a. T~ fo~egoi~
pe~tasion is oo~itional ~en ~
A.~' 1. Approval by the BoaA~I of TruStees of moo~ing facilities.
(Approval was ~eceived on Novembe~ 8, 1971.)
2. Approval by ~folk Oount7 Boa~d of ~ealth of shcr~e
3. Approval by a~ ethe~ cence~ ge~en~~ a~ncy
B. C~eation of suitable pa~kimg facilities as ~equ2~ed in
the Zoning ~d~nance and p~oviding for at least 20 spaces.
C, ~eusebeats may be leased by t~e~ applicamtl solely te
t~a~sient and/o~ seasonal ~Aests and may not be subleased .by such
guests. Occupancy ~d use of eac~ houseboat shall be limited to
not ~e than six guests, all of whom must ~e ~eglstcrc~.
Do lo :Pea-mission £o~, oecu:pano~' is g~smt~d £~ ~d l~tte~
cale~a~ yea~ An w~ich this ~ermission is valid.
2. Pe~ssion to solX ms~ine l~bricants, gasoline, a~d
ma~tne fuels is denied.
3; £t~A~e of 9,000 s~Aa~e feet of ~land a~ea
o£ t~e'app houseboat moo~ed un~e~ item ~1 s~ll~ msed
i~ o~at~ ~ensityfo~ .zo~l~~ses.
~. ~tssion is ~anted fo~ the moo~ of ~o ~d~io~l
~i~te~ o~e~ ~ansient or ot~ pleases o~t, ~o ~ge~ ~hp~
~ f~. x 35 ft. x 30 ~. ~. This pe~-~ssion apples sealy to
~sien~ erst ~ is not to be in~e~p~e~ed as an exp~sien
~e~ of ~se~oats ~tte~ ~ item~l. T~ans~en~, as ~e
use~, is to~ imte~p~ete~ as X~t~t~.stay.ef~y such
p~lvate~o~e~ pleasu~eoraft to ~o wee~ ~otal e~psed
in a~ one ~nd~ ~.
~. ThLs pe~ssionby s~olaX exception
a~led of two ye~s'to Nove~e~ 11, 1973. On
~ate the Boa~ of Ap~als sha~eview t~ application a~ ho~
a rehe~i~.te dete~i~ ~t~ o~ not t~s ~rmission
be coati,ed, ~ified, o~ te~teA.
6. T~ Boar~-ofAppeals specifioa~ ~se~s
~e te~nate, e~e, or~m~y t~ te~' ~ conditions of this
action in t~ event ~ a t~at ~e the public ~alth, s~e~, or
~e of the To~ of
Vote o~ the BOard:
A~es:-~essrs: Gillispie, Origonis, ~lse,
~L~ t~ t~ m~tes' of t~ S~tho~d To~ Bo~ of
AP~als ~ted ~te~er ~1, 1971,
to m~or o~rectien.
On motion by I~. t~ulse, seconde~l by I~. ~rlgo~ts, ~t was
RESOLVED- ~;~t the- next regula~ meeting of the Seuthold Town
Bosmd of Apl~ats will be held at '7:30 P.I(., Thursday, December 9,
1971, at the Town 0ffioe, F~in Ro~d, ~ou~hold, New York.
Vote of the B°smd: Ayes:- Messrs: Gillisple, Grtgonis, ~,_:lse,
Doyen.
Om motion by H~. Doyen, seconded bye. Gilltspie, it was
RE~OLVED that ~he Sou~hOl~ ToWn Boar~ of Appeals set 7=39
P.~. (E.S.T.), T~?sday, De~embe~ 9, 197i, at the Town Office,
Hain Road,~ou$hold, New Yo~k, as the time an~ place of hea~Ing
upon application of Servioe~'~ignE~em~ors, 120East 131Street,
New Yo~k, New yOrk a/c Vol~nski Ol~smoBile, Travele~treet,
Southold, New Yo~k, for a special exception in acc~da~ce with
the Zoning ~dinance, A~i~le IV, Section~0§, Su~se~ion (~)
£0~ pexvaission to erect an on-p~emises 6
faced p~oJec~ing wall sign. Location of
Bros., soath st~e of T~avele~.f~t~eet,-Southold, New Yo~k, beun~ed
north byTTavsler ~t~eet, east by Ycungs Avem~e, south byLeciht-
Te~p, west ByH. W. I~nce.
Vote of the Besmd: Ayes:- Messrs: Gllltsple, Grigonis, Hulse,
Doyen.
On mo21onBy H~. Grigonls, seconded byHv. Doyen, it was
that ~he ~e~he~l ToWn Beard set
P.~- , Thursday, DeCembo~ ~
~ ~d,.~t~, Ne~ Y~k, as t~ t~ and ~lace e~.~~
upo~ application ef ~lce ~ ~ect0~s, ~0 ~st 131 ~t~eet,
New Ye~k, New~O~k, a/e V~linsk2 Ol~smebile. T~ave~r
~euthe~, New. Y~k, fe~ a speelal~exceptien in a~co~dancewith
the Zon~ ~t~ce, ~cti°n:~ (a), for pe~ssien, te e~ect
am o~emtses ~ si~with ex~ssive heist,' eve~ 6~6w,
and exCes~ heist able g~eand level, eVe~ 15.~6". ~ation
of ~-e~= ~~ke B~OS., south si~e of Trave~ Street,
Soa~o~, New Yo~k, b~d no~thby~Trave~~ Street, east
Y~s Avers, sou~by ~eiht-Te=~, west b~ H. W.
Vote of the Bo~: A~s:- ~s~s: Gilltspie' ~igonis, Hulse,
D~en.
$nmo~ionByl~o Nmlse, seconded by I~° ~igonis, i~ was
~.~. (B.~.T.),~T~a~, ~em~ 9, 1971,
up°n appl~ea~ou ~ ~d C. a~ Alice
Do~oo~ ~, ~ho~, Ne~ Yo~k~ ~ a v~an~e in aooo~oe
~ se~ off lo~ wi~h less ~n ~e~f~ed ~ea ~ ~ftcien~
sl~eya~d ~ea. ~ca~lon ~ p~ope~y: sou~as~ co~e~
~ood ~, $~hold, New Yo~k, Bomn~e~ north byDo~o~ ~,
eas~ byD~ood ~, s~h~ J. ~. ~ks,
Mo~is, west by P. ~ey.
Vote ef the Board: Ayes:- Messes: Glllispie, G~igonis, Eulse,
Doyen.
Om mo~lo~ by F~. Gi!lispie, seconded by N~. Nmlse, it was
RE~LVE$ tha~ ~he .$~hel~ Te~ Bo~ ~f ApPea~
~in Road, .S~ho~, New Yo~k, as ~h~ ~i~~ a~ p~e of ~i~
upon applloa~lon'of ~ Hall~k ~novan,
~u~y, Oo~c~icut, fo~ approval ~ access
of-way in ~coo~ance wi~h the"S~a2o of New Yo~E:
Rca~ * 17, ~itUck, New York, Bou~ed nO, th By p~iva~e ~i~-of-
~y, ~. R~ ~ 17, e~ By ~e~ge ~scelle, s~h ~ G~eat
~cenic Bay, ~ by T.
Vote of the Board:
Doyen.
Ayes:-I~essrs: Gi!lispie, G~lgonis, Nulse,
On motion by N~. Doyen, seconded by 1~. G~'igonis, it was
RESOLVED that ~ '~h0I~: T~ Bo~ of 'A~poa~
P.M. ~.$.T.), Tht?sday, ~em~ 9, 1971, a~ ~ To~
~tm Rea~, S~he~, New Yo~k,~'as ~ ~i~' a~ he~i~
upon application ef A~t~ ~ B~b~a Slean,' P. O. B~
~fe~, New Y~k, f~a v~fa~e tm ac~dance with ~ 'Z~i~
pe~ssien to ~eins~a~ mse ef ~e (2) family dwellt~ as a ~on-
co~o~i~ use; ~ca~l~n ef ~roperty: ~st ~id~ ~f Y~'s
Arena, ~len~, New York, b~e~ ner~ ~y ~iVa~e ~lg~-ef-way,
~s~ By y~s Ave~e, semth by E. ~. Eib, west by
~o~e ef ~he B~d: A~s:-N~ss~s~ Glllispie, Grigonis, ~lse,
D~en.
~i~, R~d, ~U~held, EeW'Xo~k, ~ ~he ~1~ and pla~e Of.hea~f~
upon appl~0a~i~m of Robe~-A. & ~s P.'~nsel' 20 :Brenno~
P~ee, ~es~, ~ew Jersey, fo~ a v~t~e in~
~he z~nl~ 0~dt~nce, ~t~le III, ~e~ion 3~6, for
~ ee~e$ ~w one fami~ ~welli~ wI~h lns~ficien~
ya~d*'se~baek, ~lon ~f~p~epe~: ~e~a~ Poln~ Drive
Eo. $8 on ~p ef ~ed~ ~ach ~k, ~hold, New
V~e ~f ~ Bo~d: ~s~-~ss~s: Gi~ispie,
D~en.
The meeting was a~jeu~ned a2 9~;0 P.M.
Re spec2£ully submitted,