The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutTR-5384 . . Albert J. Krupski, President James King, Vice-President Henry Smith Artie Foster Ken Poliwoda Town Hall 53095 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971-0959 Telephone (631) 765-1892 Fax (631) 765-1366 BOARD OF TuWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD August 2, 2001 Mr. Richard Daley R.A. PO Box 565 Aquebogue. NY 11931 RE: Bud George Holman 350 Park Avenue, Mattituck, NY SCTM#123-07-08 Dear Mr. Daley: The following action was taken by the Board of Town Trustees during a Regular Meeting, held on July 25,2001, regarding the above matter. WHEREAS, Richard Daley, R.A- on behalf of BUD GEORGE HOLMAN applied to the Southold Town Trustees for a permit under the provisions ofthe Wetland Ordinance of the Town of South old, application dated July 3,2001 WHEREAS, said application was referred to the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council for their findings and recommendations, and WHEREAS, a Public Hearing was held by the Town Trustees with respect to said application on July 25,2001 at which time all interested persons were given an opportunity to be heard, and, WHEREAS, the Board members have personally viewed and are familiar with the premises in question and the surrounding area, and, WHEREAS, the Board has considered all the testimony and documentation submitted concerning this application, and, WHEREAS, the structure complies with the standard set forth in Chapter 97-18 of the Southold Town Code. WHEREAS, the Board has determined that the project as proposed will not affect the health, Safety and general welfare of the people of the town, . 2 . NOW THEREFORE BE IT. RESOLVED, that the Board of Trustee approved the application of BUD GEORGE HOLMAN for a WetIand Permit for addition of a partial second story over existing first story, addition of a second story deck and exterior stair to that deck - roof over the center section of the second floor deck. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this determination should not be considered a determination made for any other Department or Agency, which may also have an application pending for the same or similar project. Permit to construct project will expire two years from the date it is signed. Fees must be paid, if applicable, and permit issued within six months of the date ofthis notification. Fees must be paid, if applicable, and permit issued within six months of the date ofthis notification. Two inspections are required and the Trustees are to be notified when project is started and on completion of said project. FEES: NONE Very truly yours, ~ 9- /6-.~~ fh- Albert J. Krupski, Jr. President, Board of Trustees AJK/cjc cc: DEe Building Dept. . . TERMS and CONOmONS The Petmittec BUD GEORGE HOLMAN \'U. C i ~ ~ ~I residiag at 350 Park Avenue. Mattitnrk N V N. Y.. as put" 01 the coosiderauoa for me lsSu.l'Ce 01 die Per1ult does UI1derstaod and prescribe to the fol- lowing: " 1. That the said Board of Trustees and me Town 01 Soutbold are released from IIJ'f and aU dama&a. Of: claims f<< dama&a. of sulrs arising directly Of: lndUecdy as a rauk of IIJ'f opet. atioo pedom>ed poinuaDt to this permit, aod me said p.o.... IICoee wi11, at his Of: her own ~ defend IIJ'f and aU such suilS"lnitiated by chltd pania, and the said ~e ..- fu111iablUq with teSpect tbaeto. to the ~"exdusioa of the ]lQud" of Trustees 01 the Town 01 ~ 2. That this Permit is TAIid for a period of . 24 IDOL wbIch is coasicIeaed to be the estimated time"required to coiDpIete the -work iaYOhed, batihoald cU-\,,;".nroes ..-nat, request for an exuoslon _y be made to the Board at .. later date. ~ That chis Permit should be rCtaiaed iadeCJOicely. or as loag as the said Petmlttee wishes to _1....ln the sttuCtUte or project iavolved, to proYide eridence to anyone coocemed chat IDlh- orizatioo was otiginally obtaiaecI. .(. That me wodtlmolved will be subject to the iasrecUoa and appronl of the Board Of: its apts, and aoo-compliance with" che provisioDS 01 the orlsi-fl"8 applicatloo. may be cause foe ft\'OCllUOO of chis Per1ult by moluuon of the said Board. ~ ~ j ~ 1 ~ 1 9. That me Permittee will obtain all other permits and coasenlS &bat may be required oup- plemental to chis permit which _y be subject to reYOke apoa fallure to obtaia -. ~ ~ j / ( . . Telephone (631) 765-1892 Town Hall. 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southald. New- York 11971 SOUTHOLD TOWN CONSERVATION ADVISORY COUNCIL At the meeting of the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council held Tuesday, July 17! 2001, the following recommendation was made: Moved by Bret Hedges, se~onded by Bill McDermotUt was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees APPROVAL of the Wetland Permit Application of BUD GEORGE HOLMAN 123-7-8 for the addition of a partial second story over existing first story, addition of a second story deck and exterior stair to that deck. 350 Park Ave., Mattituck ., Vote of Council: Ayes: All Motion Carried " . t DOXALD A. DEI'HS ARC HIT E C T S Aquebogue Square Route 25/ P.O. Box 565 Aquebogue. New York 11931 (516) 722-3511 FAX, 516-722-3859 h i :! f~ Donald A Denis. A.I.A. July 2, 2001 JUL - 3 200! Town of Southold Board of Trustees 53095 Route 25 PO Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971-0959 i L' RE: BUD GEORGE HOLMAN RESIDENCE 350 PARKA VENUE MATT/TUCK, NEW YORK SCTM# 1000-123-07-08 Dear Sir or Madam: Attached herewith please find an application in triplicate for a variance to build a deck and stair extending into the 100' bay front setback line. 1. Cover Sheet, General Data Sheet, Wetland/Trustee Lands Application Data 2. Short Environmental Assessment Form 3. Waiver Request 4. NYS DEC Letter of Non-Jurisdiction 5. Notice to Adjacent Property Owners and Sketch 6. Proof of Mailing of Notice 7. Disclosure Form 8. Notarization Form 9. Site Plan 10. Survey 11. Check in the amount of $50 to cover fee. Please confirm with this office, as soon as possible, if we are on the calendar for this month. Thank you. Sinc~r : yours, j /l.i ~/C (), _ fM"J( (~U~ b RlC ARD DALEY, R.A. RD:dmh Encs. ~,--.. -------- DO.';,\I;]) ,\. DENIS C I" I T r <' r s Aql.le:):."Ii_;ue Sq.,arp RUllte :2f-)./ PO Rc;x 7)65 AT_P-\:o)~~l_e. NFW Yr~l~ llY31 :S~C; 7)>-3~] 1 FAX 516 7223W/1 Dc",.::1:1 A r:k'llis, A I.A July 10,2001 Town of Southold Board of Trustees 53095 Route 25 PO Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971-0959 FAX - 765-1366 ,'" f' !\ Ii 1 n RE: BUD GEORGE HOLMAN RESIDENCE 350 PARK A VENUE MATTITUCK, NEW YORK SCTM# 1000-123-07-08 Dear Sir or Madam: Please note the minor changes in our application, in that our client would like a roof over the center section of the second floor deck as indicated on the attached drawing. We have modifled the notice and drawing to be mailed to the adjacent property owners to indicate this change. Please let us know if there is any problem before we proceed with the mail notification. Also, we believe that the description of the subject on the Notice of Hearing is ofa different project. Could you please review it and correct if necessary. SinJr.Y :j~S'f D R4~;;V;:~y, RA ~ RD:dmh Encs. l:O'd 6SBE-22L (l:E9) VIV .s~ueo PlEUOO Vl:V:60 l:O-Ol:-ln~ - GREAT PECONIC BAY 12"1."11' I 5 82."11'2"\" W IlOiIAI/III elF' ... -<TIT _ f , ~ U~!.~..;,..Run t<<IH "'~.ro...... -::;..i'-- = - .... ~ r. .... N .. fo.. ') lONE VE I ~ ZONE)( "'m AS..t_ -, \ '. ~ \ b I \ , I \ ,I ~ , '" I I 1 I , I I \ ..w \ \ !TA r - , I I F~ I /58 S " 0 I 1::::..3...... ! ~':lb ~! z5~ "" ~I uo- z.. ~ I I I, ._~\ I EO'd 6SBE-GGL 1 I I \ I I ~OItVf:'IIA'T I I I I I EXI3T'"'" DRIve. CU~~ING !l! \" ,ll 1:1 1>- I' \" \0 ,'.t 1>- I'll ,ill IlL 10 ,'" , I \ \ \ , I I I I , I I , I I \ \ I (lE9) I I ! . , I 100 n $ET8ACK ..i..- I"Jil:OM Hlc.H WATER DECClftAl1W: "0. I I I lw 1ST \ Hili ADOITION I I I I , I I I , I I I I wi ~l "I ~I "I \;;\ "', [ill ~\ wi ~I ...1 ~, "1 I , I I I \ I I I 1 1 I I 1 , I , \ 1 \ "s!-uaa Pl'euoO I I :,. VIV >- '" " OJ ~b "- .g,~ z'" r >- z >- " F:Y,. [:'(' ': - . '" JIJ\ I VG17:60 10-01-ln(' ~ ~ Albert J. Krupski, President James King, Vice-President Henry Smith Artie Foster Ken Poliwoda Town Han 53095 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971-0959 Telephone (631) 765-1892 Fax (631) 765-1366 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Office Use Only _Coastal Erosion Permit Application _Wetland Permit Application _ Major _Waiver/Amendmen Ch nges _Received Application: () I Received Fee:$ 57.J- Completed Application '7 (-,10 ) _Incomplete _ SEQRA Classification: Type I_Type Il_Unlisted_ _Coordination:(date se~~~ CAC Referral Sent: ~ l) I _Date ofInspection: 0 / _Receipt ofCAC Report: _Lead Agency Determination: _Technical Review: I _Public Hearing Held: '7/ ~ (/ f> I Resolution: ~inor ....,.. 11"f' .... .' r'- .... ,",-,'" JUL - j Mil i [l_ Name of Applicant Bud George Holman Address 350 Park Avenue. PO Box 978. Matti tuck. NY 11952 Phone Number:( ) 298-4825 Suffolk County Tax Map Number: 1000 - 123-07-08 Property Location: 350 Park Avenue. Matti tuck, NY 667 fp-p-r. wP-~r. of Mrlrrlt-onkrl RO;:ln Mrlt-t-it-lli""'k n,:::orwPj::ron NY rJlpl. poles (provide LILCO Pole #, distance to cross streets, and location)' # 5 & 6 Phone: AGENT: (If applicable) Address: . ,.r-- ~ Board of Trustees Application GENERAL DATA Land Area (in square feet): 77,758 sf R-40 Area Zoning: Previous use of property: Sinqle family residence Intended use of property: Single famJi:ly residence,] Prior permits/approvals for site improvements: Agency Date DEe I,gttgr of Non J"risdictiorl 05/11/01 _ No prior permits/approvals for site improvements. Has any permit/approval ever been revoked or suspended by a governmental agency? --x--No_ Yes If yes, provide explanation: Project Description (use attachments if necessary): Addiblilonfof a partial seeond story over existing first story, addition of a second story deck and exterior stair to that deck 9__ -, Board of Trustees Application WETLANDITRUSTEE LANDS APPLICATION DATA Purpose of the proposed operations: Add two addi tdJdmal bedrooms square feet Area of wetlands on lot: Percent coverage oflot: 4 "1 % Closest distance between nearest existing structure and upland edge of wetlands: 95 . 6 feet Closest distance between nearest proposed structure and upland edge of wetlands: 9 7 . 9 feet Does the project involve excavation or filling? No x Yes If yes, how much material will be excavated? 55 cubic yards cubic yards How much material will be filled? Depth of which material will be removed or deposited: 7 feet Proposed slope throughout the area of operations: 0 Manner in which material will be removed or deposited: Back hoe - excavation for new cellar area Statement of the effect, if any, on the wetlands and tidal waters of the town that may result by reason of such proposed operations (use attachments if appropriate): No effect . .., 1-(.16..!. (21Sn-Tp.xt 12 I PROJECT 1.0. NUMBER 617.21 Appendix C Slate Environmental Quality Review SHORTEN~RONMENTALASSESSMENTFORM For UNLISTED ACTIONS Only PART I-PROJECT INFORMATION (To be completed by Aopllcant or Project soonsor) SEa 1. APPUCANT ISPONSOA I 2. PAOJEC7 NAME H:"")lm;:tn "Rpc:;npnr'p Rlln C::pnrl)&::a Hnlm~n 3. PROJECT LOCATION: Municipality r..-F" C.:lunty Ilr 4. PAEC:SE LOCATION (Street address and road intersections. prominent landmarks, ;!IC., or proviae mapl 350 Park Avenue Mattituck, NY 11952 667' west of Maratooka Road 5. IS PROPOSED ACTION: o New ~ Expansion 6. DESCRIBE PROJECi BRIEFLY: o Moclificatlon/alteration Addition of partial second story over existing first story, addition of second story deck and access stair. 7. AMOUNT OF UNO AFFECTED: InitiallY ^ ^ .. acres Ultimatelv n 01 acres 3. WILL ,::f10PIJSEiJ ACTION COMPLY WITH exiSTING ZONING OR OTHER EXISTING LAND USE RESTr::lIC710NS? eYeS 6dNo It No, desc.ibe briefly Variance required for protection of deck approximately 3' within 100' setback from surface waters 9. VJHAT 1$ PRESENT LAND us;: IN '/IC1NITY OF PROJECT? ~eSidential n.!naustrial 0 C,,)mmerciaJ Describe: U Agricuiture U Park/ForesUOoen scace LJ Other 10. DOES ACTION INVOLVE A PERMIT APPROVAL OR FUNDING. NOW OR ULTIMATELY FROM ANY OTHER GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY (F2DERAl. 5T ATE OM LOCAL)? [lyes 0 No If yes. fist agency(s) and permiUacprovals Town Trustees, Building Department, possiblyyHealth Dept, DEC . 11. DOES ANY ASPECT 'OF THE ACTIO'" HAVE A CURRENTLY VAllO PERMIT OR APPROVAL? IiJ Yes' 0 No If '1p.s. list agency name and permit/approval DEC waiver of jurisdiction .:t- 12. AS A RESULT OF PROPOSED ACTION WILL EXISTING PERMIT/APPROVAL REGUIRE .\100IF1CAT1CN? DYes rn No I CEiiTIFY THAT THE INFORMATION PROVIDED ABOVE IS TRUE ,0 THE 3EST OF MY KNCWLSOGE AppJiC<lnt/SDonsor oam.~ B~ George H~an i)0 a )~~ Dd'.' 07/02/01 Signature: If the action is in the CO<Jstal Area, and you are a state agency, complete the Coastal Assessment Form betore proceeding with this a~~essment OVSR . -, PART ll-SNV1RONMENT)" .SScS3i....1E.NT ,--:-'J 'Je c::J~:::::letea JY .4.genc ..... aCES AC7;C:-l ::::(C2=.:: ;"NY : ,:~s L 7~RE3HOL:J IN -5 ;\I,:,cr:;;:::., ::J:...F,i' 517.::7 :y~s I-:.'la 3. 'NIL!.. ,.:..C-;-1CN ~E':~:VE. -:::::CRO/NA,;::J ,::l;E'IIEW:'S ?P.C'JIOEJ ""':M UNL1$72:J :...C7iCNS iN 3 ,'\l'fO::=:R. ~.~;:;, 5,7.57 may be suoersecec 'JY :!.nocr:er ;nvolvea a~ency. :t yes. .::ocrOlna!1J :ne reVIl~'N :roceS:3 a.na '.Jsa ~t\e =:JL:.. ~~'=. it ,'la. 3. negJ.t:ve ~ec:ar- 1-' Yes ~:-40 C. C':'ULO ACTiON ~ESUL, ,N ANY ADVERSE =::~=G'iS ASSCC:"=" TED ',v17H -~=. ,=.JLL.'':WING; rAnswers ;nay ~e :"1aMWrHten. d ;egrclel 01. =-"(isting ~ir Qua/it'!. surface or- qrounowafer cuality "r ~uantity. nOise ,e',els. ~xls.ing :,aific :atterns, 5olid.vasie :JrCCluc:]cn Jr ~'s:' potenTIal ror ~rosjon. ::::ralnage or ~Iooding orot:lems? E.:-:olaln ~riejly: C2. Aesthetic, agrlc:.rltural, lrCt1aeological. ilis,anc, or other "aClJraIOr cuitural :esourcgs: or commumty or ;"IeltjiiCCrnOOd. c~arac:er? :.xolaln C:}. Ife~efatlan or :auna. ;Jsn. snellflsn or 'Nllollfe species, sIgnificant :"laoilals. or :hre3tened or ~ncangereo scec:es? =.tclam ::Jrlally: C~, .-\ community's axis,jng jJlans or ,~oaJs as otflc:aHy adooted. or a cnange in usa or intensity ot usa of lana or other natural resourcss? E:cpJain C5. GrowU" subseouent:eveloomenl. or related ac:ivities likelY to be induceo'JY me oroo05eo acrion? SOJaln onefly, c:s, I_cng :erm, soor: ,erm.'::Jmuiative. or olner grfects not identified. in C-:.CS? :;r;olaln:lrlerjy" Str-er :moacrs ,jnc:;Jcing -:~am;es In 'Jse ot eltner quantity I)r :yce at energy}? ::..'toialn ~rieily. oJ. ~s ,HE:=lE.:R:S 7i-iE~E '_:KEL':' 70 3E. C8Ni"::10VE?SY ~EL-\.SO 70 ?OTENTIAL AOV:=.::l.SC: =:'N1RONME!'lT;'L :,'.1P~C7S? '-- Yes ~NO :f ':'e5. ~xclain CJrieily ?ART III-DETERMINATION OF SiGNIFICANC::; ITa ~e comoleted by Agency) INSTRUCilONS; For eaC:"l adverse etfect identified atove. determine whether it is substantial. large. imcortanr or otherNise signir! ::acn eifec~ snouJd be assessed in connection with its (a) setting (Le. urban or rural); (b) probability of OCC~9; (cl duratio irreversibility; (e) geogracnic 3ccpe: ana (f) magnitude. If necessary, add aHacnme"nrs or reference supporting malerials. :::1SU([ excran31ions contain suttic:ent delail to snow that all re!e'lant adverse impacts have been identified and adequately acdresset C;'eck rhis box if :/QU have idenrifiea ane or .-nore ;::otentiaJ/y large or significant adverse imaac:s whicil M,," oc:::.:f. Then ~rcceed direcrly to :he FULL ::AF ana/or prepare a positive" declaration. C;'ec:< :his ~ox if you have derermined, based on the information and analysis above and any SUDDortk doc'..JrnentaCicn. :l1a! :he procossa ac:ion l,VILL ~~OT result in~(1Y significant adverse environmental rmcac AND ,::lrovice en a.!tac:1ments as necessary, rhe reasons supconing this determination: '~""'t! '}I -..c...<1 ,A.;t'no::'1 ,-',.nc '031 'VUt' .....Hlf" .)1 ":~',con\,ale '''':lllo::~r :n :..<:...0 .",,:cncl "lIe 01 ><"',oon\lo'~ Vll'eer ;1\;nJlWe ,)/ .(~~con\'Ole .':;r:,(.:'( ,n ~C'.JQ ,....;cncv ),,<n..:u(C )l r"'!'~.Jrcr ill ,.,;,r;e,,,,nl 'fom 'l!,oon\'o'~ :J(r'c~n J...tc 2 . ---,- Bud George Holman 350 Park Avenue Mattituck, NY 11952 SCTM #1000-124-07-08 WAIVER OF PRIOR APPROVALS Weare requesting the waiver of the requirement for obtaining all other permits and approvals prior to submitting this application. .. .... ..... ., NOTICE TO ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNER BOARD OF TRUSTEES, TOWN OF SOUTHOLD In the matter of applicant: Bud George HOlman SCTM~lOOO- 123-07-08 YOU ARE HEREBY GIVEN NOTICE: 1. That it is the intention of the undersigned to request a Permit from the Board of Trustees to: Buildja second floor deck and exeerior stair extending approximately 3' over the 100 foot setback line for widths of 13' and 10' respectively Proposed structure~will not ex~end as far shoreward as existing structures. The'ce;'ter secti>on of the deck shQ(J;]:d1:be covered. 2. That the property which is the subject of Environmental Review.-is located adjacent to your property and is. described as follows: 350 Park Avenue or section 1000-123-07-08, Mattituck 3. That the project which is subject to Environmental Review under Chapters 32, 37, or 97 of the Town Code is open to public comment on: July 25,2001 You may contact the Trustees Office at 765-1892 or in writing. The above referenced proposal is under review of the Board of Trustees of the Town of Southoldand does not reference any other agency that might have to review same proposal. OWNERS NAME: Bud George Holman MAILING ADDRESS: '1 c;n P~r1<- ""QM"<i M<=Itti.tlJrky NY 11Ql:j? PHONE ~: h,1-7QR-4R7t; Ene.: Copy of sketch or plan showing proposal for your convenience. 20'd .s 6SBE-22L (tE9) ~I~ 's~uea Pleuoa ~t~:60 to-Ot-ln~ <t o Q. 0\ ltl OJ M I N N r.. " .... M ILl v c( .... c( , ~ .~ C III Cl '0 r- iU C o Cl c( N <t 0\ o .... o I o .... I c- J '") NOTICE OF HEARING r -<<<< \.. ---....... NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a public hearing will be held by the SOUTHOLD BOARD OF TRUSTEES at the Town Hall, 53095 Main Road, , Southold, New York, concerning this property. A.~ rh_ -~ ~ OWNER(S) OF RECORD: ~ ~ ~ECT Otf~US HG~~J~<l ~ wi ~"'~'<'>'? l.b'/~ ; ~ft4~~-::::i:~- . . TIME DATE OF PUBLIC HEARII\JG: Qd.., 'xr; '}thJ I gy... h fLh.a1.f 70 t..4d f '1'H . ~r- / If you have an interest in this project, you are invited to view the Town file(sl which are available for inspection prior to the day of the hearing during normal business days between the hours of 8 a.m and 4 p.m. BOARD OF TRUSTEES * TOWN OF SOUTHOLD * (631) 765-1892 . " New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Division of Environmental Permits Building 40 - SUNY, Stony Brook, New York 11790-2356 Telephone (631) 444-0365 Facsimile (631) 444-0360 ;:t " ~'-"" . -"--.. , .. ..., fl' o \.-) Erin M. Crotty Acting Commissioner LETTER OF NON-JURISDICTION May II, 2001 Mr. Bud George Holman 350 Park Avenue Mattituck, New York 11952 ~". t""--- - - C-L -, '" ./ 1-242iii1 Dona1ti A. ~ A.,t ~ ,oi- Re: 1-4738-02089/00005 SCTM# 1000-123-07-08 ~~, Dear Mr Holman: Based on the information you have submitted, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation has determined that: The portion of property which is located landward of the "top of the bluff' as shown on the survey by Joseph A. Ingegno dated November 6,2000 last revised April 9, 2001 is beyond the jurisdiction of Article 25 (Tidal Wetlands). Therefore, in accordance with the current Tidal Wetlands Land Use Regulations (6NYCRR Part 661) no permit is required under the Tidal Wetlands Act. Please be advised, however, that no construction, sedimentation, or disturbance of any kind may take place seaward of the tidal wetlands jurisdictional boundary, as indicated above, without a permit. It is your responsibility to ensure that all necessary precautions are taken to prevent any sedimentation or other alteration or disturbance to the ground surface or vegetation within Tidal Wetlands jurisdiction which may result from your project. Such precautions may include maintaining adequate work area between the tidal wetland jurisdictional boundary and your project (i.e. a 15' to 20' wide construction area) or erecting a temporary fence, barrier, or hay bale berm. Please be further advised that this letter does not relieve you of the responsibility of obtaining any necessary permits or approvals from other agencies. V" trul(\ours. ~V"Cl.A~ Roger Evans Perrl11t Administrator cc: Richard Daley BMHP/mep ., Board of Trustees Application " County of Suffolk State of New York f}3 Vy G:, //01/1 If t1/ BEING DULY SWORN DEPOSES AND AFFIRM;S TIIAT HE/SHE IS THE APPLICANT FOR THE ABOVE DESCRIBED PERMIT(S) AND TIIAT ALL STATEMENTS CONTAINED HEREIN ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF HlSIHER KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF, AND THAT ALL WORK WILL BE DONE IN THE MANNER SET FORTH IN THIS APPLICATION AND AS MAY BE APPROVED BY THE SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF TRUSTEES. THE APPLICANT AGREES TO HOLD THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD AND THE TOWN TRUSTEES HARMLESS AND FREE FROM ANY AND ALL DAMAGES AND CLAIMS ARISING UNDER OR BY VIRTUE OF SAID PERMIT(S), IF GRANTED. IN COMPLETING THIS APPLICATION, I HEREBY AUTHORIZE THE TRUSTEES, THEIR AGENT(S) OR REPRESENT ATIVES(S), TO ENTER ONTO MY PROPERTY TO INSPECT THE PREMISES IN CONJUNCTION WTIH 0DiJ'4Z:N Signature SWORN TO BEFORE ME THIS 1 1.......... DAY OF ;{ VL ", e. ,20~ ~~ .~v' ' . No Public ~ AMY F. WIPPERT NoIlIry Public, Stale of New York No. 01WI4884083 Qualified In Suffolk Count;. 3 Commission Expires April 13, "'" ., -, NOTICE TO ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNER BOARD OF TRUSTEES, TOWN OF SOUTHOLD In the matter of applicant: Bud George HOlman SCTMi1000- 123-07-08 YOU ARE HEREBY GIVEN NOTICE: 1. That it is the intention of the undersigned to request a Permit from the Board of Trustees to: Bui1sda second floor deck and eXBerior stair extending approximately 3' over the 100 foot setback line for widths of 13' and 10' respectively. Proposed structurae~ill not ex~end as far shoreward as existing structures. 2. That the property which is the subject of Environmental Review--is located adjacent to your property and is described as follows: 350 Park Avenue or section 1000-123-07-08, Mattituck 3. That the project which is subject to Environmental Review under Chapters 32, 37, or 97 of the Town Code is open to public comment on: July 25,2001 You may contact the Trustees Office at 765-1892 or in writing. The above referenced proposal is under review of the Board of Trustees of the Town of Southold-and does not reference any other agency that might have to review same proposal. OWNERS NAME: Bud George Holman . MAILING ADDRESS: 1 c;n P"rk ""Qtl"e Matti-tllrk, NY 11GC;? PHONE i: 611-?GR-4R?C; Ene.: Copy of sketch or plan showing proposal for your convenience. .s ~ -, ..... ., GREAT PECONIC BAY S 82D41'24" W IlDlAlN9CF ClU> .Em' _ ~ 124.41 S TE LINE ALCtlQ ,.w~~';m NARK :;.;tr--- =- = - .... - I~ \ I I 1 1 I NEW' OT... ".E.K...- --, I I I I I \ I I " iii .,' 1 100 FT SETBACK _ _.1.- FROM HIGH WATER I I ~w J FLR \ \ omoN \ 1 \ FF \ 1 ZZ 9 I I \ o~ \ \ I ~\L-, S Is'fCMEDAI~" I ......-' OVl~ ~\ I EXISTING I ~':)5d ~ I DRIVE t. I o I!' I CURBINC, I :<< ~ UQ. I I Z'" I \ !l! w\ ~I \ I:; """"""" "I IlS "'''- \1\ I~ ~I \ I ,,- wi w "'I I'" 10 fil l I~ ~I I'" wi Il'l ~l \ii .-1 IlL LI i 10 "I I" I ~ I I . I I i \ I I I \ 1 I I I I I 1 I \ I 1 I \ 1 I I %3 c I L I I I PAA f( I ~\ I \ I I \ I AVE~ I \ 1 I I I ,.. '.li ~ ",-0 ~..J z< ~ ~ U ,- I -~------- fill -, PROOF OF MAILING OF NOTICE ATTACH CERTIFIED MAIL RECEIPTS Name: Address: Katie J. Dexter 4] 0 Park Avenue Mattituck, NY 11952 Cynthia L. 0 'Leary 48 Taunton Rd Scarsdale, NY 10583 Melvyn Morris Mary Eisenstein 272 Park Avenue Mattituck, NY ] 1952 David and Ann Carien 155 Brompton Rd Garden City, NY ] 1530 William J. and Joan C. Conway 9 Michigan Rd Belrose Village, NY 1 ] 101 STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF SUFFOLK , residing at , being 'duly sworn, deposes and says that on the day of ,19, deponent mailed a true copy of the Notice set forth-rn-the Board of Trustees Application, directed to each of the above named persons at the addresses set opposite there respective nameSi that the addresses set opposite the names of said persons are the-address of said persons as shown on the current assessment- roll of the Town of Southoldi that said Notices were mailed at the United States Post Office at , that said Notices were mailed to each of said persons by (certified) (registered) mail. Sworn to before me this day of ,19 Notary Public .. .. 1\.l'l'Mt1AN'l' 'rnANSACTIONAL IlISCLOSUnR FUIlH The Town at Soubhold's Code of ~hhics ~tohibibs cuntlichs of interest on the part of town officers and employees. The purpose of this form is to provide information which can alert the town of possible conflicts of interest and allow it to take whatever action is necessary to avoid same. YOUR "AHR. Bud George Holman (L!lsl: name, firsl: name. middle i~it:lal:"unless you are applying in I:he name of someone else or other enl:il:y, such as a company. If so, indlc!ll:e I:he ol:her person's or company's n!lme.) ',:t;l" ~': <.{::~J:~,;t~'i\ \ "ATURE Or ArrLI~ATIO"! (Check !lll that apply.) -. ;~. .:'-; .,(l~.,l,. .... Tax grievance Vari!lnce X change of zone ^P'P\~al of pIal: , Exemption from plat or official map Ol:her (If "other," name the acl:lvity.) Do you pereonally (or ~hrough your Cb~pany, spuune, elbling, parent. or child) have a relationship vlth any officer or employee of the Tovn of Sou~holdl -nelnblonshlp- Includes by blood, marriage, or business interest. -Uusiness interest- means 0 busineas. including a partnership. in vhich the tovn officer or employee hoa even a partinl ovnerahip of (or employment by) a corporation in vhich the tovn offIcer or employee ovn!! more than 5% of the share!!. YES NoL If you anevered .YES,. complete the balance of ~hlb torm and dabe and sign vhere Indlcabed. Name of person employed by the Town of Soubhold Tible or posItion of that person Describe bhe relationship bebween yourself (bhe !lppllc!lnb) and the I:own offIcer er employee. Elbher check hhe approprlal:e line A) I:hrough D) and/or describe In I:he space provided. The ~own officer or employee o~ his or her BpOUS~1 sibling, parent, or child Is (check all ~hab apply). A) bhe owner of greaber I:han 5% of bhe sh!lres of the corporal:e sbock of the app1lc~nb (when the applicanb is a corpor!ll:lon), B) the legal or b~neficial owner of a~y in~eresb in a noncorporal:e'enl:lty (when bhe applicanb Is nab a corpoJ:8"ion) , C) an officer, dlrecl:or, parbner, or nmpluyue of I:he applle<lnl:, or D) I:he actual applicant. DESCI11PT!ml 0F Iltt.tlTl0NSlIlP ,"', f.' . J "_.." ,~~. ' _. ., L , . "'''~ "k.t.L~l '" to' ''':''1-- '" ...,. ,'.,. 'lll,'-t-HIo.w.'.Il...,..-. ,.", ....... ".. -~ . ..,'. '.:' ". ~:'~~lni:;~:':'''';~.: -;iJ.,.,.;j~:.~I~.:~.::::' . >::ld;;:~<';'~'~:{-li;l'?: . " .: ..' I' i' ,r.' ;..'~ .' ,'.;':,,"..,~'.! . '". 'ft:r:";j', (h :~:::::::. b'~f11~~~oOl'. . ~UU' .()!i.:;.'l4i~IC>.ry,:r~ prlttb h8m,=, '.' ,,-. ".....:.;;.:... .,:,..;'.."J--,.....~;.~~~~'..~.,....."..:~l\[;'i)~_ '." ".. ..' ""~I' ~'r~"~'l" 'i'" '~i.: ?~'I . {'(:~.~-/f<':~;h:'i;{~~~.,;. '~~.J~~'.L ., ~~P~~;~l~~J.~'.::'" ',>"-" ~'.'. . ,'" -'. ~':':J;: i~'~': '","":~~~~t (:::~.,'-;;..,?':/~b~_hUioAL ,.,. :(~,::i;~~. , . ..;:J,:q'~l . ELIZABETH A. NEVILLE TOWN CLERK REGISTRAR OF VITAL STATISTICS MARRIAGE OFFICER RECORDS MANAGEMENT OFFICER FREEDOM OF INFORMATION OFFICER. Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 FaX (631) 765-6145 '. Telephone (631) 765-1800 southoldtown.northfork.net OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC ACCESS TO RECORDS INSTRUCTIONS: Please complete Section I of this form and give to Town Clerk's Office (agency Freedom of InformatiRn Officer). One copy will be returned to you in response to your request, or as il'n in'terim response. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SECTION I. TO: DmC.e. nr-rt1l:m-r_5 (Department or Officer, if known, that has'the information you are requesting.) RECORD YOU WISH TO INSPECT: (Describe the record sought. If possible, supply date, file title, tax map number, and any other pertinent information.) ftttfre:: 41e ~\.V\;~ -b grot'" e\.r~ ~V\ ,r;; BtR& i-6lW'a<'l~~~ i~ lq99 (_~M< k) \l\~ ) Signature of Applicant: Pr~ted Name: V\ Address: -'\.\2., ~rl( Ave ~,~ I Mailing Address (if different from above): IS:) '-~LmApioh lli I ?6'(~C~Y, TeleptlOne 'Number: 5l/P 74-~. octroi Date: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ [ ] APPROVED [ ] APPROVED WITH DELAY" ~kd~~4~ Elizabeth A. Neville Freedom of Information Officer [ ] DENIED" RECEIVED OCT 2 8 2003 Date " If delayed or denied see reverse side for explanation. Southold Town Clerk .. "- LAW OFF1CES NEIL L. KANZER .. 1325 FRANKLIN AVENUE, SUITE 644 GARDEN CITY, NEW YORK 11530 NEIL L. KANZER JOHN R. SEYBERT DAVID R. FEEN STEVEN T. FARMER CRISTINA PRIETO RICHARD H. PETERSEN RICHARD M. MADIGAN LORRAINE M. KORTH AREA CODE 516 741-2121 FAX #: 516-741-3930 December 10, 2002 NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERV A nON Division of Environmental Permits Building 40 - SUNY Stony Brook, New York 11790-2356 NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERV A nON 625 Broadway Albany, New York 12233-1011 OFt: 3 0 2':02 NEW YORK STATE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE Department of Law The Capitol Albany, New York 12224-0341 RE: DEC PERMIT #1-4738-002089/00001 350 Park Avenue Mattituck. NOlw York Dear Sir or Madam: Please be advised that I am defense Counsel for Bud George Holman in the action entitled CORtERt v. HOLMAN currently pending in Supreme Court, Suffolk County. I am in receipt of a copy of the letter forwarded to you on November 13, 2002 by Michael L. Cirrito, Esquire. In his letter, Mr. Cirrito advises that the survey provided to him during the discovery process in the underlying litigation shows the subject groin is not on Mr. Holman's property, but on the property of his neighbor to the west. Mr. Cirrito further advises in his letter that due to the "inaccurate and false information" contained in the application for the DEC permit, he and his clients believe the permit to be "voidable." My client, Bud George Holman, purchased the property located at 350 Park Avenue, Mattituck, New York from Frank Abrams in 1968. At that time, the subject groin was already in place. Mr. Holman has advised the undersigned that at the time of his purchase of the property from Mr. Abrams in 1968, Mr. Holman was provided with a survey, prepared by Mr. Van Tuyl of G reen port, which survey demonstrated the westerly groin to be entirely within Mr. Holman's property lines. Said survey also demonstrated that Mr. Holman's property continued two (2) feet to the west of the subject groin. Following the purchase of the property in 1968, Mr. Holman had a house constructed on said property, raised his children in that house, and has borne the responsibility for the maintenance and repairs of the easterly, westerly and center groins, as well as the costs associated therewith, for the past thirty-four years. In addition, Mr. Holman has been taxed since 1968 for 1.9 acres which he understands to include the westerly groin and two (2) feet to the west thereof. Mr. Holman and his family quietly enjoyed the subject property for thirty-three years until the commencement ofthe litigation by the Corieris in 2001. The previous repairs to the subject groins were done approximately twenty (20) years ago by Pat Carig of Southold at the request of, and at the cost to, Mr. Holman. Mr. Carig passed away prior to the most recent repairs and, as such, Mr. Holman retained the services of Costello Marine Contracting Corporation. Costello obtained all ofthe necessary permits from the DEC and the Town of South old, and thereafter performed the work at Mr. Holman's property. Following the completion of Costello's work, and following the commencement of the underlying litigation by the Corieris, DEC Field Engineer Chris Arfsten was contacted by Environmental Consultant, Paul Napolitano, on behalf of Mr. Holman with regard to the work performed. Mr. Arfsten stated that the distance between the bulkhead and the easterly groin was within tolerances, and that the DEC has no way of enforcing the shortening of the westerly groin because it was not a remedial measure. Mr. Arfsten also stated that the longer length of the groins will only help to encourage regeneration ofthe beach area at PlaintiffCorieri's property, and that the DEC considered the matter closed as of January 2001. The survey to which Mr. Cirrito refers was only prepared in November, 2000 - more than one year after the repairs made by Costello Marine Contracting Corp. at my client's property. Until that time, and pursuant to the original survey presented to Mr. Holman upon his purchase of the property, Mr. Holman understood the westerly groin and two (2) feet west thereof to be entirely within his property lines. Based upon the original survey, Mr. Holman has, for thirty-four years, ensured that the subject groins were maintained and repaired to remain functional, and has borne the cost for said repairs. As such, any allegation of "inaccurate and faIse information" in the permit application cannot and should not be considered valid or in good faith. Should you require any further information or documentation from Mr. Holman, please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned attorney. Thank you for your attention to this matter. " cc: WHITE & CIRRITO Attorneys at Law 58 Hilton Avenue Hempstead, New York 11550 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Board of Trustees Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 NRW/rp Very truly yours, BY: . WEINER, Of Counsel 1. Agency 50,,/\-'0 I J '1'b 13'1' loj IS. Time ;;C} 0 7. Report Day ~(z...l: B.Date 16. Incident Type ~--;-;2tl:5 -~6 A. ~-v~?"c-~.7/<y-' Incident Addre~~ (Street No., Street Name, Bldg, No.. Apt. No.) f;;",t-/( flJ 15 , ( ~~2..... J Ou..J/V .I /C14 5 ,7;:,r 5 0 -,c; c // / ') r- ,-,'7'";?~ /J -r-:i"-<J...../ V"'" / / Rl510U~Cf 8'J'.:U'i',S G. R',SimNCF e\)S''\t~'" H. <::lp(rKr: J':.;.\)tSS .'\f <;:~)r ~;C! 31.E~nic o Hispanic 0 Unk. o NoMii5pank 33, Residern:;e Slat~ 0 Temp_ Res. - Foreign Nat. a ResIdent DTouri~t OStudent p'Other Commuter 0 Military 0 Home ess 0 Unk 37. Apparent Condition o Impaired Drug~ 0 Mental Dis 0 Unk. o Impaired Alco 0 Inj / 1\1 0 App Norm ). K. L M. N. 60. li(en~ Plate No ."td 66. Mak.e c.', //.;.r/C. [ j) /;1", 5]/L.W~?/ r;:...2<.J/'./S 41' c "a ND/Vc C}/" :z..{ r;J,.. ///- A /! C oc ,H-rc: /' o Scofflaw o Other 7810No ~~/ 79. Superviwr'!, Signature llndude Rank) 80. 10 No. 74. Inquiries (Check all th"t "pply) o DMV 0 WantIWafrant o Crim. History 0 Stolen Property 75. NYSPIN Mes!.<lge No 76. Complainant Signature Open 0 Clo!.ed (If Closed. che<k bo~ below) o Arrest 0 Pros Declined o Arrest .JUv 0 Offender Dead o Unfounded o Warrant Advised o E~trad, De<hn 0 Unk.nown 82. Status Date 83. NotifiedfTQT "age of Pages nr IC~7nz:: 17/q71 -F=AI SF= STA TFMFNTS ARF= PlJNISHARI F AS A CRIME. PURSUANT TO THE NEW YORK STATE PENAL LAW. New V ork. State Dep~rtment of' Environmental Conservilttori Dlvlaion of EnlllronmenUl p..,nlts. Regloll One lluildlng 40 . SUNY. Stony Broolc, NY 11790.2356 Phone: 16181 444-0386'.,j.: 16161444-0360 ~ ~ ~ John ~. CalU.ll C-_i~r March 4, 1999 f 1f" 3~1J f{Ll/~ art' ill m@ ~ 0 . Wl\-n. '..'.\......1.... ~".'-'-- '.Iil' ,. '1' it,", FEB ~ 4 tOOl ~' 1 , . TO' .\II~I' F,c: ":t'(I' I;.., - . ;''i\;'\'~ '-"~ 0\..) __ i l~~ Mr. Bud Holman PO Box 978 Mattituck, NY 119~2 RE: 1-4738-02089/00001 Dear .Permittee:! ~ . "'. In conformance with the requirements of the State U~ifor~ Procedures Act (Article 70, EeL) ~d its implementing'regulations (6NYCRR. Part 621) we are enclosing your permit. Please read all i condit.ions carefully. If you are unable to comPly with any.:, '.. . '. conditions. ple.jtse contact u.s at the above. address.. >./" ': Also enclose~ is a permit sign wh1ch 1s to be consp1cuously posted at the project site and protected from the weather. very. truly yours, !!::r: R~kfk- Environmental Analyst MMR:cg . enclosure IfII/ YOlUC STATE DIPAIlTMIIT Of INVIROMENTAL c;llIISERYATlOll pEe PERMIT NUMlIR pin IfFIerlVE DATE 1-473I.D2DI9tOODOI "e"ch' :5 I_ fACILITT/PROGRAM ~BEReS) , EXpIRATION DATEeS) , Uftdor die E..,ir_tal Merch 31, 2004 C...........ttan LIW I TYPE OF PERMIT _N...! a R.......l o Madlll.etl"" C ,.,.h to Corwtruet o Pernaf t to Openre I . Article 15, Tltlo 5: ProtectIon . 6llTCIlR 608, I/oter lIUIll ty a Artlel. 27, Tltl. 7; 6IIYtRR of Waters ! Clrllfle.elon 360: Solid 1I0st. M...._nf 0 Artlcl. 15, Tltl. 15: 'I/e'.r C Arttcl. 17, Tltl.. 7, e: SPDES C Article Z1, Title 9; 6NTtIR SupplV 371; N.I.ardous \ln1;8 Mar\ag......t a Article 19: Air pollution C Artie'. 15," Ti,le 15. WIlIer- Cont;ral 0 ArltcLe 341' C...teJ Er~lon : TranJipon Meneg_nr a Artl.l. 23, Title 27: Mtnod 0 Article 15, Title 15: LClI'I. Urd I-=l_tfon 0 ArUeL. 361 Floodpleln la'iIol'1d Well_ Mlnagement 0 Article 2': 'rHhwate,. wet: lands 0 Artf.l. 15, Titl. 21: I/ild, I ,0 ArtIcles r, 3, 17, I', 27, 37; $canic and RH:reactCNIl Rivers .' Artiele 25, Ttdal lIetL_ 6NYCRR 380. R~I.tt... Control PERMIT ISSUED TO , TELEPHONE.NUMRER ;':;;--fs'rr ' , . Iud ttahnen (516) 291-4125 ADDRESS Of PERMITTEE , U 'po lox 971 n i:i:R Ii ')iln!l Mln truck NY 11952 , , 'couueT PERSOM fOR PERMnT~ \/Diu< .. TELEPHONE NUM8ER C.ltell. Merine ContrlCtlng Corp. .,.",;-;;:::;- ::;:: ( " , 'r,161 477.1199 PO ~ox Z124 Or......... NY 11944i :NAME A~D ADDRESS OF PROJECT/FAC~LrTY l"f v! \..,~- ~ ~ : Nol..." Pr"""rtv , 350 Plrk Ave""e -, :LDCAlIOM Of PROJECT/fACilITY i ,SCTM _'000-123-7"8 , : "aU t tuck COUNTY tOWN IIlTERCOURSe Nfl" COORDINATES Sulfol k ~outh.ld Great Peconlc Sev < DESCRI:PT:ION OJ' AtnSbRIZZD AC'l'IVITY: , , , I:R.~on.truct two (2) low-profIL.jgroina, each 54' tons ..... 14" b.lIDW top of w\khucf. W.lt grotn to ~ shortened 10 ft. I ,and ...t groin to b. 8xtended 4, ft. Center groin to r...in unailturbod. Reconstruct west bulkhead return (14 ft.) In- kind/in-place. , , , By acc.pt~. of chla ~ft. the pe~ilt.. at,... eb.t ~. ~tt i. CDntfngent upon scrice c~lt.nc. with the ECe all 8ppllcable ..egulation., ~h. General CondfttOftl .,..effilld 's.. ~.. 2 & 3) Md an)' Special Conditions illCluded as part of thh permit. . PIRMIT ADMINI~TRAYOR. , ADOlf" George W. Hammarth HHR , Bldg. "0, IUNY, n_ Brook, MY 11790-2356 ~:,$IG~ DATE J/ i Mlrch 4 ,_ Page 1 of 4 , ; NEW VORl( STAlE DEPAR'NINT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONIiERVA'T1ON ,",OTlFICATION OF OTHER PERMlnE! OBLIGATIONS Item A: Permme. Accepts ,-egal Reaponaiblllty and Agrees to Indemnification The permittee elepressly !Igrees to indemnify and hold harmless the Department of Environmental Conservation . of the State of New Y 011<, its representatives. employees, agents, and assigns for all claims, suits. actiollll, damages, and costs of every name andidescription, arising out of or resulting from the permittee's undertaklng of ilcavitles or . operation and maintenance of the facility or facilities authorized by the permit in compliance or non-compllancawlth the terms and conditlo.ns of the ilElrmil . Item B: Permittee to Requtr~ lte Contractol'!l to Comply with Permit i . The permittee shall require its independent conlr8clor3, employees, agents and assigns comply wtth thl. permit, Including all special condilio~s, and such persons shell be subject to . the same sanctions for violallons of the Environmental Conservation ~aw as those prescribed for the permittee. Item C: Permltte, Reeponalble for Obtaining Other Required Permits The permittee Is responsl~le for obtaining any other permits, approvals. lands. easements and rights-of-way that may be required 10 carry out upe activities thal.are authorized by this permit. . . It.m D: No Right to Trespa~s or Interfere WIth Riparian Rights . This permit does not convey to the permilteeany right 10 Inlspass upon the lands- or interfllre with the riparian rights . of others in order 10 perform the permitted wor1< nor does It aulhoriz.the impairment of any rights, tille, or Interest In real . or personal property held or vested in a person nota party 10 the permit .' . . GENERAL CONDITIONS General Condition 1: Facility InspeCtion by the Department The permitted site or facility, including relevant records, is subject to inspection at reiilsonable hours and intervals by an authorized representati\!e of the Department of Environmental Conservation. (the Department) 10 determine whether the permittee is complying with thi5 permit and the ECl. Such representative may order the wol1< suspended pursuant to ECL71-Q301 andSAPA 401(3). .' The permittee shall proviqe a person to accompany the Departmenfs representative d~ring an Inspection tp the . . permit area when written or verbal notification Is provided by the Department at least 24 houre.prlor to such inspeCtion. A copy of this permit, indudlng all referenced maps. dtawings and special conditio.ns, must ,be available for . . Inspection by the Department at all times at the project site. Failure to produce a copy pf the permit upon .request by a Department representalive is ~ violation of this permit. ' G.neral Condition 2: Relationship of this Permit to Other Department Orders and.Determjn~tlon. Unless expressly provided for by the Department, i8.uanca of this permit does not modil)', $upers~e or rescind any order or determination p~eviously Issued by the Department or any of the terms; condit~!'s or reguiremenls contained in such order or dettilrmination. I' . Gelleral Condition 3: Appl,cation. for Permit R.n_a'. or Modlflcatlone The permittee must submit a separate written application to the Department for renewal, modification or tra:nsfer of this permit. Such applicatio~ must include any forms or supplemental information the Department requires. Any.. renewal. modllleatlon or transf~r granted by the Department must be in writing. . The permittee must submit a renewal application at Ilast a) 180 days beforei apiration of permits for State Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (SPOES), Hazardous Wast, Management Facilities (HWMF), major Air Pollution Control (APC) and Solid Waste Management Facilities (SWMF); and. . b) 30 days before e~lratlon of all other permit types. Submission of .appllcation$ for permit renewal or modlftcatlon are 10 be submitted to: ; NYSOEC Regional Pi;lrmlt Admlnll!trator. Region 1, SUNY Bldg #40, SlOny Brook. NY 11790-2356 General Condldo" 4: Pemjlt Modlncadona, Suspenalons and Revocadona by the Department The Department reservesithe right 10 modifY. au.pend or revoke this permit when: a) . the scope of the permitted activity Is exceeded or a violation of any condition of the permit or provisions of the ~CL and p.rtinent regulation. Ie fo"ncli b). the permit was obtained by mi.rwpIMenla\iQn or failure to diacloa" relevant facts; c) new malarial info~malion Is discovered; or d) environmental comdltions, relevant tachnology, or applicable law or regulation have materially changed since tPl,!, permit was Issued. . oec PERMIT NUMBeR 1-4738-02089/00001 PAGE...L OF ...L . : NEW YORK STATE DEI'''''1'a.<I!HTO' ENVIRONIoIEHTAlCONSERV"T10N PEAMIT.1W. ,...... 1~ ADDITIONAL GENERAL CONDITIONS FOR ARTICU!S 15 (mlE 5). 24, 25, 34 AND 6NYCRR PART &08 . . ( TIDAL WETLANDS) ',. 1. If future operallons by lIIe State of New York require !In alteration. In the position 01 the structure or work herein authorized. or iI, in the cipinion of the. Department 01 Environmental Conservetlonit shall cause unreasonable Obslnlclion to lhe tree nav!gallOll of said walBtB or flood IIowS or endanger the health, safety or weIfIIre of the people of the State. or cauSlIoSS or destruction 01 the nalUl'Il rellOurcee of th. Slate, the owner IllIly be ordel1!d by the Department toremow or *,ler lhe sllUdUral work, obstruCllons, or haZards caUSed thereby without expense to the State, and If, upon tile axp!ra1lOll or revocation of thie permi~ th. slructure, fill, eXClvallon, or other modification of the waten:oUnlll hereby alilhorized shall not be cornpI8l11d, the owners, shall. without expen.. to the State, and to such extent and in such lime and manner as the. Department of Environmental Conservation may require, remove . all or any portion of the uncompleted structure or 1IIl and restore to ita former condition the navigable and ftoad capacity 01 the walerc:ourajl. No claim shall be mede against the Slate of New York on accountQf any such. removal . or alteration. i 2. The Statli of New York ~ in no case be liable for any damage or injUJy to the structure or wOrk herein authorized which may be caused by or result from future Operlltiona undertaken by the State tot the conservation .or Improvement of navigalioni or for other purposes, and no claim or right to compensation shall a~ from any such damage. . 3. Granting of this petmit d~ not relieve the applicantoflhe responsibility of obtaining any other permission. consI'nt or approval from the U.S. /:l.tmy Corps of Engineers, U.S. Coast Guard, New York State Office of General Services or localgovemment whic~ may be required. . , . ~ . 4. All nece$$ilry precautions shall be taken to pl'llClude .contaminellon of allY weUand or waterway by suspended solids; . sedlm.nts, fuels. solvent~, lubricants. epoxy coatings. paints, concrete. leachate or any other environmentally deleterious malerials assciciated with the project. 5. Any malerial dredged In the prosecution of the work hetllln permitted sl,.1I be removed evenly, without leaving large refuse pll.... ridges across! th. bed 01 a waterway or floodplain or deep holes that may have a tendency to cause damage to navigable channels or to the banks of a waterway. S. mere shall be no unreasdnable interference with navigation by the work heraln authorized. , ; 7. If upon the expiration or revocation of this permllthe project hereby authorized has not been compl~ted.ihe . appllcilnt shall, without ex~nse to the State, and to .uch extent and in such time and manner as .lhe Department of Environmental Conservation may require, I8IIIOIIe all or any portion of the uncompleted slnJcture ar fill and re.tore the site to ils former condition. No claIm shall be made against the State of New York on account of any such removal or alteration. ' . 8. If granted under SNYCRR Part 608, the NYS Department 01 Environmental Cons.rvation hereby certifies that the subject project will not cont/"avene eflluent limitations or other limitations or standards under sections 301, 302, 303, 30e and 307 of the Clean Water Act 01 19n (PL 95-217) prolllded that all of the conditions listed herein are mel . . 9. At least 48 hou(ll prior to Clilmmencement. of the projec~ the permittee and contractor shall sign and return the top portion of the enclosed notification form c.rtifying that they are fully aware of and understand allterm& and conditions of this permit. Within 30 days of completion of proJec~ the bottom portion of the form must also be signed and tllturned, along with photographS of the completed work and, if required. a survey. 10. All aCllvltle. euthorlZed Ill/' this permit must be In striCt conrarmance with the approved plans submitted by the ; applicant or his agent.. p;art gf the p;armit ,ppllQltlon, . , Such approved plans wer. prepared by Cost8no Marin. Contnlctin.o C~m t')n O~tober 519gB and last revised Janua'" 18 1999 . OEC PERMIT-NUMBER 1-4738-02089/00001 I I PAGEJ,..OFL YORK 1oTl! D9 INT ENWIONM N1'AL CONseRVATION SpeCIAL CONDITIONS . .. 1. Ally debris or excess material from conslrucllon of tills pmjec:t shal be completely removed from the adjacent area (upland) and r.moVlld to Ian approved upland area tor disposal. No debris Is pennilted In tidal wellands and or protected buffer areas. i 2. The sllRge of COIIIIruc:lioil equipment and materials shaG be conllned to within the project work site and Of upland areas greater than 7S IIne"r feet ft'orillhelJdal weiland boundllY. . 3. Prior to any construction or removal of bulkheads n other shoreline 11IIbllizallon Ilr\Iclures ell beckfiU .hell be exl:avated landward of lhe]bulkhead and retained SO u not III anllr the wal8rway. tidal wetland or protected buffer aree. . 4. All ai'Bas of lIOiI disturbance resulting I'rom !hia project shall be Ilabillzed irnmedialaly following project completion or prior III permit expil'a~. whlchwer c:omea fv.l Tho approved methodologies are.u follows: . a. Stabilization of the enllre I1lsturbed lIIU With appropriala vegetation (grasses, etc.). :', Dee PSRMIT NUMBER 1-473~2089100001 PAGE..L OF ..L W!ft flU- WI( 1 C~ ~nJ", c.o~W~ ~P. ~6.~ 2..12.+ ~.r"""J"'o...l-,~:f. II~ ~I'" 4n'll~ " - 1~-~ C~'\ ftUNlt:.- .~y ;5 Q) - - - -- .:> . ~. . (~ ....-............... .;,. <......) VICI~1lY ~: .L ~~_.... -4 . ~-r ~c...1;A.'1' ( ~...~. .-r'.,. -c.') L...O<:ATlD!\.I Mee.: N'P\..4~ : Ht:....t> ..o~ !.rrlI- :. 9'o.llQlI.. "i'S ~~, >.1-(. I\~ serH#' , I<l>~" - lZ.~ '''-l! ~-r- ~ :~.... ; (!) m.. WI~ ~ .. l'1$l~ P-O ~...~.. V1~. N'(- 1100,3 :&'So ~~~.' I'Uqfrru~, N~.", 11~'5Z. ". 'I' I " ~ . . . .~: @""~-..a"~M.'~N @)_-(~ .. \'!)"'N.~"_ ,ar 'z."R._~. ~~~_. ~D ......_... . ~ l-UIIIf"~ I t<<. ."'0 ."l"~ I I"\,.. ~ t\AIIll'I1UC:.L I N"f. 11"1:52 , @""I...............~~T1 ~~Ava.. ~cM.,..'(.I~ ~;. ~l r>s......,:. . '. . t; ~. -YWCl .'J.#w ~LL-~'" ~_ . E-A(;H . 64' kClN& AN" so4/' ..loCIW "Tell" Clf' aul.l<Ii . IRI&COhI""IU.lGT '''''..T "UI."H.",c:>' "aT"'."', .N.MINeo, IN -1"!.Aca. ('4 ~"T) wD"'T"'e..': ,b..u.... ~"''''''''''''#II. .,.. ... ....-r. 'I:III~. .,.... vrtrZ&O I ALl. ,,"""_ _ ... ~'ftc:>. io.,aDac AJ'PROvBD All I'D 'n:a- AND CONDITlONI 0' l'ERMIT No.ll1~'~D~qIDODOI n'l1;~..... Dc.T~ ~,I.."e 94U.T" I t:*;$ JI'oNUAfll"f '''-. '...." .... ",to" r1:> .'i': eo~ ~N&- ~TI"lq 'f:D. '10)(", 2.1'2.... ~.-INft)t..I- I-l'l' . Sl" . ~17. I r-f1' ~. ilCf4+ .-..~:I'l',D1D~ ~.l>,_~ __ 11a;rf'"N_,Iorf. II"~Z. SlT'L : .3.'150 ___-..... ~c.oo..t<k'(.ll-' ~n-1": ....... - ~a..?. (1) ce..~t.~. ~. aD' - - - - D 10" 10' \ , ( 7"ft~) ~~1ST1t-14 1IAU.ttJ.+P4:>) ... 1'P1AoIN, , I ~, \ ~ " 'U' , IUOCDNSTFlUCT' ' , &JC16T. au.l<til!!AD ; lleTURHJ IN'I<'NO ; 'N-r-VII". (,"') ~: boHI-IW ",-y '~L~"" "'.. . ,;' . '~ , , ---" ,.....t<W EXIST: CaNT.Eo 6"'0''''/..J&..,..,..., TO fIlE.....""I'" ..-- "M~~ (l~;~~") 1-- Q\, AM.......(I-IZ-") " '. V ~ ClR.In- (VAR.I_ '^'IW'OoJp , ~"''''''lc:>NS) ... - ~ ~ "'P\4eO " e -- @ ~: : ~I" ~Ic., ~'( 1'.._'i."...c::r TWo L.#ol~...........N /~..... .IlACH 5..' l.QN4o . ...,.,,, 3..... ..L.DW' TDt- <:If' euL.1C'H5AP. w..'" G&otH '"I'D .. &HOIW,"""." 10 ....a,. AN. ....."l! C!J"""N 'Ib INI ........"""_ .. ...~, llteCON~TllttJC;T wesT 1IU~IoI""P(I""~) RATlJ"'N', IN-K1f'<IP, 'N-P'&.AC.. '~ ~....... -no .... ..wr. ,......_ ~......,ULD ~ ~t1__ ..,.. ..... ~IU _ ~ '.Y.DaC . A.PPtOVlID AS PO TIlIUG \~iD ;CONDlTIONS 'OF' ' "i'Ml~ NO. L:413'd- Oaoglj IUCDol ",..l3, -?,.I1'i Mttlfl.;_ l)G.~""':5'114!"l8 ~2...DpS - - ::1_ - JANUARY la, ,,,.,1 UM'1L 1: . ~,&y: ~~ HAoJI:Aut:,. c.DN"Tt!:Ae"t"I.....". CCflJP, ~O. 'JlO)(... ~2J'1- &;UoENPl>p:r", N:( 11't"'M" SIG. . 4f'1;l. IIGR .0' , ~I~l M'Pt.IC4>oN,\: 0.1" SUO~ 1"'.D._ ~~ ~~,'NY. II"~Z. :505l:> ~ ~e., ~-':""~.I"'~ 1600 - 12:; - i"'. " T' ~....e.V~:T10~ : ... D ~- - - - - ~: ("'''It''1II- 7'11 . (~:) . :J ... / . ~,~ ~ s..c: . (TYI"ICAI. Q" we!>T C5IfOIN) d &'1 r'~ , Ras.C>eIofC.. "'7.0- I I I AMHW "-Z,5' t-laTlI-: A.U. >+~ _ -.. ..-r,..","", ~""""lZ.-c>, ........ UAMII'_ -Ta ... ~ . . (?"L.e. ~T10N (,', ~WEf _,~O'" 4-' ) fU.N Vl'eMI ~ /exRflt.JCf 1IUL~~~\ '\ "t1:l...-N '. l ...~~/~' 5+ . t t,; i'TY:tOl" 'N. GIl~I~\ Q.- . -: . ~~. > :I r ~ ,. l' '. , TS1: Tc) ""..'D~C8 .. ." '. "ytclc APPllOVllD ,\5 PER TBRWI ....ND CONDITIOlSS" 01" \ 1'~R~aT No./.'f13S .oallg'l!ODOO'/ DATS .3 ,~ ~~., Mm.e... ..' .... bP"b81!!.D : ~ :I VIl,"C>t-I~ TWD ~~&.e- ~../:ll!frrlll& EAGH i .54' I.ON~ AloIO.4' IlreLDw 1'01" ot' aUL.KHEAP. ItECONftTItUCT WE6T &1.IL.l<HMO REiTLI~"", ''''-1\\'''17, IN-PLACe.. (14 FT.) , . ~"'OIl!oB.\Z.. oS: 1"'I'l~ ..."M_....... - S JAr-JUAR.Y Id .1""" --, ........ .' WHITE & CIRRITO Attorneys at Law 58 Hilton Avenue Hempstead, New York 11550 (516) 292-1818 Telecopier (516) 489-1940 William]. White Mary Ellen Cirrito Michael L. Cirrito Michael N. Durante Jeffrey S. Hochftlsen" Of Counsel James P. Nally' *ARmittedinNtwYork &Omm~t nAdmiuedinNfiPYm-k&Florida November 13, 2002 New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Division of Environmental Permits Building 40-SUNY Stony Brook, New York 11790-2356 NOV I 5 ?GQ{ New York State Department of Environmental Conservation 625 Broadway Albany, New York 12233-1011 L New York State Attorney Generals Office Department of Law The Capitol Albany, New York 12224-0341 Re: DEC Permit #1-4738-002089/00001 350 Park Avenue Mattituck, New York Gentlemen: I am sending you this correspondence on behalf of my clients David & Ann Corieri, the fee owners of 412 Park Avenue Mattituck, New York the property abutting the above referenced property to the East. On March 4, 1999 the D.E.C granted to Bud Holman, the owner of 350 Park Avenue, a permit to reconstruct two (2) low-profile groins. The permit required Mr. Holman to shorten the Westerly groin 10 feet. In addition, each groin was to be constructed 34" below the top of the bulkhead. The application upon which this permit was approved is enclosed for your review. As you will note, on the seventh page of this document, the site plan filed with the application indicates that both the easterly and westerly groin were located within the applicants' property. Since the permit was issued the applicant has rebuilt and extended the easterly groin as permitted but has failed to shorten and lower the westerly groin as required. As a result of this groin construction and the failure of the applicant to complete the permitted work as required the Corieri's, who purchased the property on January 19, 1999 have lost substantially all of their beach front. The Corieri's then instituted a civil action against the applicant now pending under index #28707-00 in Suffolk County, New York. During discovery in that action the Defendant produced a survey, a copy of which is enclosed. This survey indicates that the Westerly groin, which has not been modified since the application, is not on the applicant's property but rather is on the property of his neighbor to the West. Therefore, the applicant could never have had the ability to comply with the permit's conditions since Holman never had the legal right to modify the Westerly groin as required. This mis-statement in the permit application, whether intentional or unintentional, calls into question the entire grant of the permit and in our opinion makes the permit voidable. I am enclosing a copy of the report of Aram V. Terchunian, a Coastal Geologist who has determined that, "The impact of the Holman Groin is to block littoral sand transport from reaching the Corieri property and thus causing the beach to erode at an accelerated rate. This impact was easily predictable, and avoidable, if the specifications of the US Army Corps of Engineers-shore Protection Manual were followed. Shortening and lowering the updrift (west) groin would allow more sand to enter the groin compartment on the updrift (west) side, since the sand impounded there would be released to the downdrift (east)". My clients property and his riparian rights have been severely impacted by the grant of this permit based upon inaccurate and false information regarding property ownership. We request that his matter be thoroughly investigated by your office and that appropriate relief and action be taken with , 1 " all deliberate speed. Now that the winter storm season is upon us the erosion problem worsens by the day and is accelerated. Upon receipt of this correspondence please advise as to the action you will take regarding this serious matter. Very truly yours, WHITE & CIRRITO, LLP i2~~o ~ by: cc: Nancy Weiner, Esq. 734 Franklin Avenue Suite 664 Garden City, New York 11530 Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 , , REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL INTERVENTION ucs - 840 (REV 112000) Supreme COURT Suffolk COUNTY 28707/00 INDEX NO. PLAINTIFF(S); DA VlD eQRIERI and ANN eDRIERl I \~4' >./-r'" q~'~~ OEFENOANT(S), ,,;'; '\ '1- 0":"'<' t- BUD GEORGE HOLMA~~~~'\:J\J ., n1.~;J~ to.?::'.".....\ ,S~~;...\~ ~vr...; \l~OO l 1\ TE P RCHASED For Clerk Only IASentry date R.Jl PA.:tD OCT 2 9 200'2 EO',\I.<\F;O 1'- COUNT Judge Assigl1ed RJIDate Date issue joined: Sentember 29 2000 Bill of particulars served (YIN): [ ] Yes [ X] No _.__..__._n______..._________n_________________________---------------.---------------..----.-----------------------------.--------------------------- NATURE OF JUDICIAL INTERVENTION: (check ONE box only AND enter infonnation) [Xl Request for preliminary conlerence [ ] NoteofissueandJorcertificateof readiness [ J Notice of motion (return date: Relief sought [ ] Order to show cause (clerk enter retum date: Relief sought [ 1 Other ex parte application (specify: NATURE OF ACTION OR PROCEEDING MATRIMONIAL [ ] Contested [ ] Uncontested (Check ONE box only) -CM -UM COMMERCIAL [ ] Contract [ ] Corporate [ I Insurance (where insureris a party, except arbitration) [ I uec (including sales, negotiable instruments) [ I "Other Commercial -CONT -CORP -INS -UCC -DC REAL PROPERTY [ I TaxCeniorari [ I Foreclosure ! I Condemnation [ I LandlordlTenant [ I .Other Real Property -TAX -FOR -COND -LT -ORP GUARDS I OTHER MA TIERS [] . -OTH TORTS [ ] Notice of petition (return date: Relief sought [ ] Notice of medical ordentaJ malpractice action (specify: [ I State of net worth [ I Writ of habeas corpus [ ] Other (specify: Malpractice [ ] Medical/Podiatric [ I Dental [ I "Other Professional [xl MotorVehicle [ ] "Products Liability [ ] Environmental [ ] Asbestos [ I Breastlmplant [ ] "Other Negligence [ ] "Other Tort (including intentional) SPECIAL PROCEEDINGS (] Art. 75 (Arbitration) [I Art. 77 (Tmsts) [ I Art. 78 [ ] Election Law [ ] Guardianship (MHL Art. 81) [ ] "Other Mental Hygiene [ ] .Other Special Proceeding ',\ 2f(Q -MM -OM -QPM -MV - PL -EN -AS8 -BI -GTN -or -ART7S -ART77 -ART78 - ELEC -MlfYG -OSP . SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF SUFFOLK *****************************x DAVID CORIERI and ANN CORIERI, REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE Plaintiff (s), - against - Index #: 28707/00 BUD GEORGE HOLMAN, Defendant (s). * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * X The undersigned requests a Preliminary Conference. The nature of the action is Personal Injury - Automobile. The Names, Addresses and Telephone numbers of all attorneys appearing in this action are as follows: NEIL L. KANZER, ESQ. Attorney for Defendant(s) BUD GEORGE HOLMAN 1325 Franklin Avenue Suite 320 Garden City, New York 11530 (516) 741-2121 WHITE & CIRRITO, LLP Attomey(s) for Plaintiffs DAVID CORIERI AND ANN CORIERI 58 Hilton Avenue Hempstead, New York 11550 (516) 292-1818 II Dated: Garden City, New York October 28, 2002 To: WHITE & CIRRITO, LLP Attorney(s) for Plaintiffs DAVID CORIERI AND ANN CORIERI 58 Hilton Avenue Hempstead, New York 11550 C\Temp\Template.dot Yours etc., THE LAW OFFICES OF NEIL L. KANZER Attorneys for Defendant BUD GEORGE HOLMAN Office and P.O. Address 1325 Franklin Avenue Suite 320 Garden City, New York 11530 (516) 741-2121 File#: 0018479 STF SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF SUFFOLK * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * )( DAVID CORlERI and ANN CORIERl, AFFIRMATION OF GOOD FAITH Plaintiff (s), - against - Index #: 28707/00 BUD GEORGE HOLMAN, Defendant (s). * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * )( Steven T. Farmer, an attorney duly admitted to practice law in the State of New York, affirms under the penalties of peIjury pursuant to CPLR Rule 2106 as follows: 1. Your Affirmant is associated with THE LAW OFFICES OF NEIL L. KANZER, attorneys for the Defendant in the above-entitled action; and as such, is fully familiar with all the facts and circumstances contained herein. 2. The parties in this action have attempted on various dates to obtain discovery in this matter without the necessity of the Court's intervention. Demand(s) have been made requesting compliance without success. It is therefore necessary to seek Court intervention. Dated: Garden City, New York October 28, 2002 I~ /'-...~, '---.." STEVEN T. FARMER To: WHITE & CIRRITO, LLP Attorney(s) for Plaintiffs DAVID CORIERl AND ANN CORlERl 58 Hilton Avenue Hempstead, New York 11550 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF SUFFOLK * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * )( DAVID CORIERI and ANN CORIERI, Plaintiff (s), CERTlFICA nON - against - BUD GEORGE HOLMAN, Defendant (s). * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * )( CERTIFICATION PURSUANT TO ~130-1.1-a OF THE RULES OF THE CHIEF ADMINISTRATOR (22NYCRR) The undersigned certifies the following documents pursuant to 22NYCRRg 130-1.1-a: REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE Dated: Garden City, New York October 28, 2002 THE LAW OFFICES OF NEIL L. KANZER, ESQ. , BY: ,1 l.A --- STEVEN T. FARMER Attorney for Defendant BUD GEORGE HOLMAN Office & P. O. Address 1325 Franklin Avenue Suite 320 Garden City, New York 11530 (516) 741-2121 File #:0018479 STF Index No. 28707/00 Year SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF SUFFOLK DAVID CORIERI and ANN CORIERI, Plaintiff (s), - against - BUD GEORGE HOLMAN, Defendant (s). REQUEST FOR PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE ORDER THE LA W OFFICES OF NEIL L. KANZER Attorney for Defendant BUD GEORGE HOLMAN Office and Post Office Address 1325 FRANKLIN A VENUE, SUITE 320 GARDEN CITY, NEW YORK 11530 (516) 741-2121 To Attomey(s) for Service of a copy of the within is hereby admitted. Dated, ------------------------------------------------------ Please take notice o NOTICE OF ENTRY that the within is a (certified) true copy ofa duly entered in the office of the clerk of the within named court on o NOTICE OF SETTLEMENT that an order Settlement to the HON. of the within named court, at on 19 at Attomey( s) for 19 of which the within is a true copy will be presented for one of the judges M. Dated, Yours, etc. To THE LAW OFFICES OF NEIL L. KANZER Attorneysfor Defendant BUD GEORGE HOLMAN Attomey(s) for Office and Post Office Address 1325 FRANKLIN A VENUE, SUITE 320 GARDEN CITY, NEW YORK 11530 ~ , The Impact of the Holman Groin On the Corieri Property 350 Park Avenue Mattituck Town of Southold Suffolk County State of New York Coastal Geology & Coastal Process Analysis Prepared For White & Cirrito, LLP Prepared By Aram V. Terchunian, M.Sc. First Coastal Corporation Post Office Box 1212 Westhampton Beach. Long Island New York 11978-7212 5162882271 5162882271 FAX www.firstcoastal.net aram@firstcostal.net June 5, 2001 Impact oftbo Holmoa Groin. -. Soulbold, ~ Yoll< Prcparod ForWbile&CirriIo, lLP 6/S/OI. Pap 1 ofl9 ~ Table of Contents b PROJECT SCOPE. ENVIRONMENTAL & GEOLOGIC SETTING .........................................4 1.1. PROJECT LocATION & ScoPE ................................................................................. ......... ............4 1.1.1. Proiect Location.... .................................................. ................................................ ...........4 1.1.2. Proiect &ove. .................................................... ... ..... ........................ ................................5 1.2. ENVlRONMENfAL SETI1NG.............................................................................................. ............5 1.2.1. Site Description & Location ................................................................................... ............5 1.3 . COASTAL GEOLOGIC SETTING ......... ............. ........ .................... ...... .... ...... ... ..................... ...........5 1.3.1. Generalized Coastal GeolollV....................... ......................................................................5 1.3.2. Surficial Sediments and Soils................ .... ............. .......... .......................................... .........5 1.3.3. Generic Littoral Transvort. Beach. Bluff. and Dune Processes.......................................6 ~ GEOMORPHOLOGY. INLETS. CHANNELS. AND SHORELINE STRUCTURES.................8 2.1. AREA GEOMORPHOLOGY AND SHORELINE SHAPE .........................................................................8 2.1.1. Shoreline Comoartments.1nlets. & Channels......................................................................8 2.2. CoASTAL & LITfORALI'ROCESSES ..............................................................................................9 2.3. SHORELINE STRUCTURES...........................................................................................................1 0 2.3.1. Groins and Jetties .......................................................................................... ....... ...........1 0 2.4. THE HOLMAN GROIN............................................................................................. ......... ...........14 2.4.1. Reconstruction of the Holman Eastern Groin ...................................................................16 ~ CONCLUSIONS AND F1NDINGS ...............................................................................................19 3.1. COASTAL GEOLOGY & LrrrORALI'RocEss ................................................................................19 3.2. GEOMORPHOLOGY. INLETS. & SHORELINE STRUCTURES ............................................................19 3.3. THE IMPACT OF THE HOLMAN GROIN .........................................................................................19 3.4. PoTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS ..................................................................................... ...........19 Table of Figures FiflUre 1: Location Map of the Study Area...........................................................................................4 FiflUre 2: USDA Soils map of the Dro/ect site showinll the Riverhead and Beach soils..................6 FiflUre 3: Generic illustration ofLonllshore or Littoral TransDort. which moves the sand alonll the beach in resDonse to waves stri/dnll the shoreline at an obliQUe anllle. ..............................6 F/flUre 4: TVDical cross section of dune/bluff. beach and nearshore system identimnll sDecific ~................................................................................................................................................7 FiflUre 5: 1999 Aerial PhotOflraDh of Shoreline (Source: Suffolk Couniv Planninll DeDartment!. Note the well-defined navillation channels offShore of both James and DeeD Hole Creek. Also note the nearshore bar system and the builduD of sand on the west side of each inlet. All of these features confirm the littoral/lonllshore transDort direction to the east reDorted bv Eisel. 1977................................................................................... ...............................................8 FiflUre 6: Littoral Drift Map showinll the dominant direction of sand transport within the studv area. (Eisel. Mr.. 1977. Soecial Report 5. Marine Science Research Center. Reference 77- 11......................................................................................................................................................9 FIRST c;,;,ffaL Impa<1 oI'the Holman Groin - MoIlilud<. _old, Now Y 011<. Propared For While & Cirrilo.lLP6/~101. Page 2 01'19 Fif!Ure 7: Tvoicallavout and imoacts of a simde I!roin on a beach (Source. Shore Protection Manual. USArmv Coros ofEnl!ineers. 1984. Pal!e 5-36) ........................................................10 Fif!Ure 8: Tvoicallavout and confif!Uration of a multiole 1!70in field. (Source. US Coros. 1984)J0 Fif!Ure 9: Groin taoer desil!n recommended bv the US Armv Coros of Enl!ineers (Source US Armv Coros ofEnl!ineers. 1984. Shore Protection Manual. Pafle 5-45) .................................13 Fif!Ure 10: Close uo aerial ohotowaoh showinfl the 1!70ins and bulkheads in the studvarea. .....14 Fif!Ure 11: NYSDEC Permit # 1-4738-02089/00001 & Survev of Holman Prooertv......................15 Fif!Ure 12: Photoflraoh lookinfl west (uodrifi) from the Corieri orooertv showinl! the reconstructed eastern Holman flroin and the western Holman woin. Note the new PVC on the eastern Holman 1!70in and the lack of sand in front of the Corieri orooertv. ...................16 FiflUre 13: View of the Holman flroins. The ohotoflraoh was taken while standinl! adiacent to the Holman easterlv flroin and lookinl! uadrift towards the westerlv flroin...................................17 FiflUre 14: View to the east (downdrifi) from the west side of the western Holman l!7oin. Note the heiflht of the timber l!7Oin. .....................................................................................................17 FIRST (5iitiL bq>act 01'111. HoImm Groin - MIItilud<. Soulhold, Now Yark Prop_F...WhiIe& CUriID. ILP 6/'101. Pap 3 01'19 1. Project Scope, Environmental & Geologic Setting 1.1. Project Location & Scope 1.1.1. Project Location The study area is located in the Hamlet of Matti tuck in the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York. The study area is bounded to the south by the Peconic Bay (Figure 1), to the north by Dexter, and to the East by Sheehey and West by Holman. / .~ <S' \" 0.... ~.;l' {5 SOUTHOLD 6.21'01'-172030' 2410_D9~-!-~~~. CUr~HOGU: U.~f '. 41 DOQ' ~~...'> .RD~ 8M .,--~,.:;, ~25 . ''''.s- \"J ,,.. . 32" .. ........ . ~ ': . .. .. .. . ~Ib l ~ , .' .. . 1(;:; I 19h BM, .:\ $"t. ;._ 1.... 'I '~ . h." ,\.." ... t-" ~ I, 0 :t,C 25 " 1\""11 J I" CJ I.... .J~ ".''l., / .",( ~ ' -" I:" ~ 1"- .-, = r.-~. -.~..,../. ~---:Z I~ 'i/ I ~ '\ . Ma,;:'-atook'" . ; \.tv ,",; ,0 ....It - _241.' 'ri~ .. iPGnd J. A::<\o' ~tp~~~~---7I:i"-"\ "i8 V. \oJ 1... } /... "__..;.-= ,.J.~~~.,~ v ~ '~I--';;-~ --''". ", 3~ -I' ~ ~f2 ~(~ .\~ ",:' I ~ ~ .~,_:JtffJ':{.'~~~' ~ ", ~~-..' role. \:: \''\.i,~:' " II l. I' ,,$~I'.~ '-'..... '" -~..r;~', ~j,j " ,,~,-' I IJ ttQ II ,,', '23 . \.... '""~~...""",,~"':;.. I I ~11 ~ l 1 ' Ii ""0 ,It II \" - '... ~ ,....L. ..;.;. 'I PI(t.' " ~_I \, I''ll I'l ~~',: :~t,~ .,.. -~ :~.~~o I' ,. <:".." 1'1~"<~ ,,, I I, .~... I.. , t ~.. ,,~~ If' "- ~:" :_.~-~.',\_:,:: ~ ~I;: I,' .~:'~ ~ ' ~. ~:..... ;- ~ ~-t..~ DR /!'" ...' .~ J d\ \, : ":A;:p~:~:'::;;,;~:~:f~~'-;:~;:))'.~~:~~~Oka ~E;\"-"'''' ,-''>. {~~. :"" \;..... -,....il.. ,-,~-, '>~~'.'''''''-'P'''''t 4540 r,'<(" '", ~/," '\ ~; .. .; .. _ ."v' "rrji:.''---;-:-~l-?:-~/ .010 ~_ 1~:,~__,'_ .-': \..-:! \\ ' r-!~ ,; "':....\_\>.';.). '~..u __:~,.>i .~80000 '. 1.,Ii" ~ 0 ~;'C" , --<~"'S f.. I' '\I>~.. _..~-;:" FEET . t/ . :>>;; __~ \. %;.- ~, -.\ ~\ '~ .\: ~,,~~'~ ::,-":""-- 2 / _ -';-.r,,~,,'" .;J' - (:,' - :j'",','r"~;: ""...~." - ":" ','...... ~ ~ I'::l >:I~ -, ... ~~:......._:.,..,.--:,... 2e ~:~.~ ... 3 -:''f~'''-- '/ 4 'Project~jte6' " MA I III LICK QUADRANGLE NEW YORK-SUFFOLK CO. 7.5 MINUTE SERIES (TOPOGRAPHIC) > , ~ p 3 b 5 "39 . 10 Figure 1: Location Map of the Study Area ~aL lmpad; oflbe Holman Groin - Mallilu<:k. _lei, N... York ~ored For White & Cirrito. LLP 6mOl - Page 4 of 19 1.1.2. Project Scope The scope of the project is the Corleri property and the surrounding beachfront properties to the east and west. This report will evaluate the impact of the Holman groin on the Corleri property and the potential alternatives to alleviate any adverse environmental impact. 1.2. Environmental Setting 1.2.1. Site Description & Location 1.2.1.1.Shoreline Features The study area of this project includes beaches, bluffs, dunes, inlets, groins, and jetties along the Great Peconic Bay shoreline in the vicinity of the Corleri and Holman properties (See Figure 1). 1.3. Coastal Geologic Setting 1.3.1. Generalized Coastal Geology The study area is a recent beach deposit on the Great Peconic Bay shoreline of the North Fork of Long Island. The spine of the North Fork was fonned by glacial activity during the Pleistocene Glaciations, which left behind an assemblage of sediments to fonn the Roanoke Point Recessional moraine. As the glaciers gradually receded approximately 18,000 years ago, the meltwater and wind processes transported sand and sediments to the south forming an outwash plain that is today recognized as the Great Peconic Bay shoreline of the North Fork (Sirken, 1995 and Eise~ 1977). Gradually sea level rose and coastal processes reworked the sediment along the shoreline into the current configuration. 1.3.2. Surficial Sediments and Soils The surface soils of the study area are identified on the Soil Survey of Suffolk County (USDA Soil Conservation Service, 1975) (Figure2) as: Bc - Beaches: Sandy, gravely, or cobbly areas between water and mean sea level and dunes or escarpments. All of the beaches along Long Island Sound are very gravely and cobbly. Covers 1.2% of ground in Suffolk County. Rd A - Riverhead: Deep, well drained, moderately coarse textured soils that fonned in a mantle of sandy loam or fine sandy loam over thick layers of coarse sand and gravel. These soils occur throughout the county in rolling to steep areas on moraines and in level to gently sloping areas on outwash plains. ~aL Imp... of tile Holmm Groin - Msttitud<, _old, Now Yorl< i'rq>anod For WhiU & Cirrito.lLP61S101. Page l ofl9 Figure:!: lWDA Soils map of the project site showing the Riverhead and Beach .",ils 1 3.3 Generic Littoral Transport, Beach, Bluff, and Dune Processes The coastal processes oflittoral (longshore) transport, driven by the wind, waves, and tides have gradually reshaped the underlymg soils into a characteristic beach and 101" blufli'dune system common to the Peconic Bays. Littoral transport or drift is the alongshore movement of sand along the beach in response to wind, waves, and tic es. Ordinarily, waves will strike the beach on an angle and move sand in one dommant direction (Figure 3) The supply side is called the updrift and the receiving side is called the downdlift 7 l'qUil rn<l'<<!llOIl of 1"'*'""" l\dtDfbl dnf. r"'poM'''1 'ro run up tn:l (~rn ,.,., wave, ~ .~ 'f)wn.!'lriP Figure 3: Generic illustration of Longshore or Littoral Transport, which moves the sand along the beach in response to waves striking the shoreline at an oblique angle. I JR<";I '",<taL hnpwd. of the Holman {JTOin - Mattituck, Southolcl Ne\.\' York Prepared For White & Cirrito. LLP 6/5/O11 ~ Page 6 ofl9 A large amount of sand is also moved along the shoreline as submerged nearshore sand bars. These sand bars break wave energy and this helps protect and stabilize the beach. They also supply large volumes of sand to the beach. Inlan4 _...~ ~r..k<r 111M- Jj l tI>1t1l1Me for< e J", ....:jA....:-'...'" hrrn ~r of Ilerm Figure 4: Typical cross section of dundblujJ, beach and nearshore system identifying specific zones Sand on the beach is moved by wind into dunes and stabilized by seaside vegetation, including American Beach Grass, Dusty Miller, Seaside Goldenrod, Bayberry, Beach Plum, Rosa Rugosa, and other salt tolerant grasses. Dunes typically form of accretionary or stable shorelines. The dunes on the Peconic Bays are typically low profile, usually not more than 10 to 12 feet above sea level. The source of some of the sand on the Peconic beaches and dune are the eroding bluffs. Sand eroded from the bluff is entrained in littoral transport and moved laterally to maintain and nurture the beaches and dunes as described above (Figure 4). FIJL';;T {5a?TaL ~a<t oflbe Holman Groin. MoItilud<, _old, New Yad< ~ared PorWbile& Cirrito,lli'6/5/01. Pago7 ofl9 A large amount of sand is also moved along the shoreline as submerged nearshore sand bars These sand bars break wave energy and this helps protect and stabilize the beach. Thev also supplv large volumes of sand tc the beach. "r.' Il't.achrw ~;'or~ e>r~wl.cnt': ~. ',;,..__..____.:,1 :;,...f.,rcft. for~~hor.. ~ ill"..' :>~. l.~r, :/5-tfm Figure.: 1:Vpical cross section of dune/bluff. beach and nearshore system identifl'ing y,ecific zones Sand 0" the beach 1 s moved by wind into dunes and stabilized by seaside vegetation. including American Beach Grass, Dusty Miller, Seaside Goldenrod, Bayberry. Beach Plum, Rosa Rugosa, and other salt tolerant grasses. Dunes typically form of accretIOnary or stabie shorelines The dunes on the Peconic Bays are typically low profile. usuallv not more than I 0 to 12 feet above sea level. The source of some of the sand on the Peconic beaches and dune are the erodmg bluffs Sand eroded Irom the bluff is entrained in littoral transport and moved lateraliv to mamtain and nurture the beaches and dunes as described above (Figure 4) Impact of the Hobnan Groin - Mattituck" Southold. ]\;L'\\ i-ork Prepared For 'White & Cirrito. LLP 6/5/0 I - Page 7 of 19 2~ Geomorphology, Inlets, Channels, and Shoreline StructUlres 2.1 Area Geomorphology and Shoreline Shape 2 1 1 Shoreline Compartments, Inlets, & Channels Shorelines m the Peconic Bay are divided lUto sections (;alled compartments, wJthin which sand in usually transported in a similar direction, e~g~ from west to east. Natural features, such as mlets or headlands, or artificial features, such as jetties or groins, or a ; Jmb1l1ation typicallv demark these compartments~ Two wdl-developed inlets James Creek to the west and Deep Holes Creek to the ea:o,j define the study area compartment. Both of these inlets have been stabilized WJth bulkheads or jetties or both (see Figure 5) Figure 5;' ./999 Aerial Photograph of Shoreline (Source: Suffolk County Planning J)epartment). Note the well-defined navigation channels offshore of both lame.' and O""p Hole Creek Also note the nearshore bar system and the buildup of sand on the west side of each inlet. .4ll of these features confirm the littoral/longshore transport direction to thc ea..t reported 11.11' Ei..el, /977 Impact o1'11ll: Holman Groin - Mattituck, Southold, ~ev. Yark Pr'1>ar~ For White & Cirrito, LLP 6/5/0] - Pag.~ R of 1 ';l 2.2. Coastal & Littoral Processes On the subject site, the sand moves dominantly from west to east as demonstrated above, and as reported in the scientific literature for this area (Eisel, 1977 - Figure 6). Nonnal day-to-day processes and storm processes move the sand to the east in littoral transport as described earlier. As a consequence of this dominant littoral sand transport, sand builds up against the west side ofJames Creek and Deep Hole Creek. Simultaneously, sand is eroded from the west side of James Creek Project Site ,.. II! . . .... . . "It_ ~ l . "'. . . .. . . Ii ..",/'!.. .. li."'-"..~.. .- ,:.:,..~-" . .... .. .... ...' ."... ,- .> '. . , . " . .. .. ll' .. . . '" ,. J.,. .. ...... . . ,.... ,. . . ,- Direction of Longshore Transpo rt Indicated by Arrows Figure 6: Littoral Drift Map showing the dominant direction of sand transport within the study area. (Eisel, M. T., 1977, Special Report 5, Marine Science Research Center, Reference 77-1) I'IRS"I Ua~ Impad of the Holman Groin ~ Mat1ituck., Southold, New York Prepared For White & Cirrito, lLP 6/5101 - Page 9 of 19 2.3. Shoreline Structures 2.3.1. Groins and Jetties Groins and jetties are similar structures, which are used for very different purposes in coastal stabilization. Jetties are used at inlet entrances to block the flow of sand into channel and thus preserve navigation. Groins are used on the open beach to deposit sand for a recreational or protective beach. Either structure can be constructed of wood, metal, plastic, rock, or similar structures. Although the uses of groins and jetties are different, their impacts are similar, and thus the reason that they are often grouped together Groins may be used either singly (Figure 7) or in groups (Figure 8), depending on the desired condition and the site-specific configuration ofthe shoreline. BEACH Groi n- Adjusted ;/"':i;(')d;}iS;;~';!:'~" i. e /~~!~~:~n}~:_:~~)!}jif,;,=:~-.:t~;j:~~.~.:~.i:.~:_};.:..;:.:.'.....:.~..;...:.::..j.'.i..,.-~...'...'....:..:..~,.~,:,.::,,::,.,::,.:,:::~.,~:~,',.~~,,:: .. .. ,:.{:::.;~::~, n!(:-;~::':::,;:' . """.';'/"."""""="~ Origi.al/' Sbareli.e Grai. Adjusted Shorefi.. - Direction of Net Lo.gsho" Tro.sport Figure 7: Typical layout and impacts of a single groin on a beach (Source, Shore Protection Manual, US Army Corps of Engineers, 1984, Page 5-36) BEACH Original ~"i"" ./~"',,".,. ,i"',i',....... Is~..~~~:,:... .n.... .nn.'f........if.....~..n.... "::,:, ....)'.':::: ...n......::',ftP\ .......,.,.":.~';;'~'~>; n......:.~';;;;,:)' Grain Adjusted r Shoreline Direction of Net Longshore Transport Figure 8: Typical layout and configuration of a multiple groin field. (Source, US Corps, 1984) ~II~ (Jk1WaL Impact of the Holman Groin ~ Msttitud(, Southold, New Yark Prq>ared For White & Cirrito, LLP GIS/OJ ~ Page 10 01'19 In either case, the object of groin construction is to cause sand to deposit in one specific location (the updrift side) and to prevent sand from depositing in another location (the downdrift side). It is this specific function of groins, which has prompted the US Army Corps of Engineers (the primary federal agency responsible for coastal stabilization engineering the United States) to develop very specific design, construction, and reconstruction rules. For example, the Shore Protection Manual (which is the recognized design standard in coastal engineering) developed and written by the Corps outlines six rules for groin design: RULE 1: G,.oins Mn onLy be used to inte,.pupt Longsho,.e troanspo,.t. RULE 2: The beach adjustment nea" g,.oine wi U depend em tlw rrngni tude and di 1"8etion of the Longsho1"8 tl"GJ1Bpo,.t. RULE .3: ThE gPOin-indueed ""elDllU Lation of longsfw7'e d,.ift on the fo,.e- sho,.e IdU ".,aify the beaeh [J1'OfiLe, oilieh IdU then t,.y to ,.eestablish its naturoal shape. RULE 4: Wate,. pushed by ~ves into a gPoin oompa7'tment win SO<J18times 1"8tUT'l'l offsham in the fo1'l1l of Pip eu,.,.ents aLong tlw sides of gr>oins. RULE 5: The pe,.eentage of the longsho1"8 troan6po,.t Mhieh bypasses a gPoin Idn depend on g,.oin dimensions, fiLlet dimensions, ~te1" LeveL, and ~Ve eZirrnte. Rule 6: The longefwroe drift that is eo1Zeeted in the upd,.ift fiLLet is p,.evented fT'Om 7'8aChing the downd,.ift a,.ea:, whe1'8 the =nd baZanee it> upset . Source, Shore Protection Manual, US Army Corps of Engineers, 1984, Page 5-35 to 37 In particular, Rules 4 and 6 warn of erosional consequences from poor groin design, including diversion of sand offshore and erosion of the downdrift beach. The Corps also developed engineering standards for the length and spacing of groins: The spaeing between wains shouLd equaL two to th,.ee times the wain length f,.om the bB1'l1l e,.est to the seawa,.d end. Source. Shore Protection Manual, US Army Corps of Engineers, 1984. Page 5-450 J;,IK~, C.oa'ilaL Impact. of the Holman Groin - rviattituck. Southold,. Ne.v York Prepared For White & Cirrito. LLP 6/5/01 - Page 11 of19 In addition, the Corps has gone as far as to advise coastal engineers and other professionals of potential legal consequences from failure to follow the fundamental design principles, including prefilling the groin compartments with sand, proper spacing and length, and constructing the entire project in order: 11. .!,eJ;~_1 Aspects. The legal considerations discussed previously in Section V~3 of this chapter are also applicable to the construction of groins. Legal problems are varied and often complex, due to the diversity of legal precedent in different jurisdictions and the application of the factual setting to a particular body of law. Previous information on the functional design of groins emphasizes the fact that adverse downdrift shore erosion can be expected if the updrlft. side of the groin is not artificially filled to its impounding capacity at the t~e of groin construction. Liability for property damage insofar as the Federal Government is concerned will be determined with reference to the Federal Tort Claims Act. It is therefore incumbent on the owner of groin-type st.ructures to recognize the legal .tmplications of this coastal structure in order to plan, design, constructt and maintain the structure accordingly. It is thus prudent to seek legal counsel at the earliest stages of formulation. Source, Shore Protection Manual, US Army Corps of Engineers, 1984, Page 5-56 The Corps developed a detailed procedure for the order of groin construction, to ensure that an adequate supply of sand is supplied to the downdrift beach. Furthermore, the Corps recommends that all groin compartments be prefilled with beach compatible sand to facilitate the bypass of sand to downdrift beaches and minimize downdrift beach erosion. 8. Order of Gro~Co~tructi~. At sites where a groin system is under consideration, two possibilities arise: either the groin system is to be filled artificially or longshore transport is to be depended on to produce the fill. With artificial fill, the only interruption of lo-ngshore transport will be the period between the time the groin system is constructed and the time the artificial fill is made. For economical reasons, the fill is normally placed in one continuous operation, especially if it is being accomplished by hydraulic dredge. Accordingly, to reduce the time period between the groin construction and the deposition of the fill, all groins should preferably be constructed concurrently.. Deposi- tion of the fill should commence as Boon a8 the stage of groin construction permits. When depending on longshore transport, no groin will fill until all the preceding updrift groins have been filled. This natural filling ....'"ill reduce the supply to downdrift beaches. The time period required for the entire system to fill naturally and the material to resume its unrestricted movement downdrift may be 80 long that severe downdrift damage may result. Accordingly, to reduce this damage, only the groin or group of groins at the downdrift end should be constructed initially. The second groin,. or group, should not be started unt.il the first has filled and material passing around or over the groins has again stabilized the downdrift beach. Although this method may increase costs t it will not only aid 1n reducing damage, but will also provide a practical guide to the spacing of groins. Source, Shore Protection Manual, US Army Corps of Engineers, 1984, Page 5-56 1 Jw..;-j ,^ ",<taL Impact of the Hohnan Groin. Mattituck., Southold, New York Prepared For White & Cirrito, LLP6/5/0I -Page 12 of19 Finally, the Corps developed a detailed engineering procedure for reconstructing existing groin fields, which includes tapering of the downdrift groins to minimize disturbances to the downdrift shoreline and to reintegrate the flow of beach sands into the natural system (Figure 9) Normal Spacing j' /' isn snis'Ts2is31 Groins ", . -~ ~.' ':"~{\'6~:.i/' <:~~~( ;f~j ,;~' ! " Normal Length .~;;;;;: Original Shoreline y 60 Adjusted Shoreline Figure 9: Groin taper design recommended by the US Army Corps of Engineers (Source US Army Corps of Engineers, 1984, Shore Protection Manual, Page 5-45) In addition to this detailed design standards developed in the "Shore Protection Manual' , the Corps also prepared a more simplified "Coastal Engineering Technical Note: Groins - Their Applications and Limitations" (attached), for use in design and permit guidance. This Technical Note of eight pages reinforces the guidance in the "Shore Protection Manual" and stresses the fact that "the accumulation of material (accretion) on the updrift side is accompanied by a corresponding amount of erosion on the dawndrift side of the groin". (Page 1-2) This Technical Note also includes a section on "Functional Limitations", which underscores the problems with inadequate sand supply, the order of groin construction, and the recommended practice of prefiIIing groin compartments with beach compatible sand (see Pages 2 - 3). Repeatedly, the Technical Note specifies that groins will only work where there is an adequate supply of sand, entrapped sand can lead to downdrift erosion, the groins height and length must be chosen to maximize updrift filling and minimize downdrift erosion, groins must be stable against earth pressures and resist scour, and constructed to be prevent flanking (see page 6 & 7 - Design Considerations). [,IHS:l ;~.t'l2~ Impact of the Holman Groin - Mattituck., Southold, New Yark Prepared FOl"White & CiIrito, LLP 6/6/01 - Page 13 of19 2.'1 The Holman Groin \ ';er." "mIDs and hulkheads were constructed along the shoreline in the qUd 'Hea . mnpanrnem (Figure I ,oJ), for the purpose of beach stabilization Three suer !f<). ,.". were ,'1ls!<"Ce(1 .m the' Holman property and two on the Corieri property F'i~'uT!' /1/.' ( /O.\<' up aerial photograph showing the groins and bulkheads in the 'lUdl ,."rea, i r 19' 9 '\,1' Holman was granted permission by the NYS DEe I Figure III md ingtllen the eastern (downdrift) groin by four feet to 54 feet. and to ree ,honc" 'i", "perin "com bv ten feet to 5.1 feet "10 action was autborized or \ re{i\f1strucT )t1S1nLt and h(? ~P1{_f,dje ,:,rC'lr nH: ',y SD'Ff' Derml1 also nequired the seavvard end of the groins to be reco:-'{',tn_LC' ~:~d'~4 'nehes helm' the top oitbe existing bulkhead. The height of the pre-existinc gnl! \Vas ',()t ,dcntll'lcd \1ore[)'ver, the height of the groin at the intersection with the hulkh,'ad (the :andw;;rd end, " less than 34" and thus hgher than the seaward end. In othe, "n. (h the (o[l n('he ,,,,Oit' IS ~el [evel, but rather is angled upward towards the land Impat.1 orthc Holman Crom - f\.1attituck. SOlJtho[d. 'jC\\ '\ on, Prepared I-or Whik &. Clrrilo. l.I Y 6Jjf) 1 - l'a,,<c ] 4 oj ( ~""' ...,.. ~ l1fPIUa. ~TI"'q c..t:#.:r, 1':D.~. 2-1~ ~ 1-1'(, 1'~4-+ 51" ,....". II"!'" ----+~ '.....-... : ~. i '" ~ ~ i. "-.:,.../ ~ 1- ..~ \ i- .---- : tot,. aID ~ """",,""'__~n ~T\l&&., W'f". <1'~~ 3'I'D ~ a..l4-, Ha:rfrT\.ae,M...*" 'f'..:L SiSCIJ::1:f: ~-':lZ-30''''. I $ ...... Ii... ....- '" -' - II ..- ~. j" i ,. .~ ~ . .. ,"'..-----'. ,...f"',t"'" ;-H.... "'\0<=..... ......~. '. -rao~' \.!:2Il:::'''''''''''''- I \ I tu.-., '< _ (?V.) I( ',-- p.'fMJCT t .. .r'--.....- I I(.:~~~" _/-~ . ~ -' ..~ '==...,.=~-; "TWt..............t... Ak2~'~"') i .__.....!'O'\~-~ L" (..~....) f---.J~/" ~-"'" (\Ud!.'" wI WU,IIl! ~~'S) e - ~ - -~,...--. , ~ ~lC.~'( .......... --~~ :!!,:u~ T'WD ~.,.".....\.C,......... !~.. . -..r.GH ~04: ~ """. .&~ ......_....,..... 811~"". ""...-r GADI"" 1"0 ... . ,a...."."..a&J ro,...-.-r ...,.... ......... ~,., __ ~~ -1 r-aaT, fl:1lt:.cw~c:.T ~ .uuc.........po ~'4".) -"TU'lN, .N-IlU....PI I...-~.. ~ "I,'V? V'-I .............,-, ~ $t 'hU~ ...... ~ -- --.. .,..-..,... ..,.'0... . ~ ... .... ~ \.;-tD ;CQJ!fDl'I'JDNS -OF """'IT MO.I-,tf~- o.;toS~ /ODOOI I ~~-1~ ~(~ .of*~~ .:1 i..~.~ ~~ mL...- .,J....Nt.JA.RT lw/ r~"""I' ..-.. Figure!]- VYSDEC Permit # /-4738-02089/00001 & Survey of Holman Propem Impact ofth<;l Holman (jloill ~ Mattituck, Southold ~eu. 1'ort.. Pn'l'ared For White & :::irrrto. LLP 6/5,'(J] - Page] 5 of 19 "h, (J:stance hctween groins is 55 feet, which yields a groin length to spacm:c u( "- 'I ciw = '.1' ~ iJ one recommended by tile Corps, A groin lenf,,>1h of 18 to 2' ,eet ,',ould ~'k'> C:()i":Slstem. v,llh the Corps engineering standard. 4 Reconstruction of the Holman Eastern Groin \pparentlv \lr Holman reconstructed the eastern (downdrift) groin to the s"ccdi: ,[rlOnS ,t'tlw '\;VSDFC' perml!, but took no action on the updrift (western) groin (l'twn ' 'he (' <stcrh C!nm was apparently of the style and materials consistent with: IK a 'eJ Ai:,CI'\ umbel tongue and grove, similar to other still existing groms, fwo 'eat'll':": o( 'Ii(' :(':onstructed grom are different than the old groin and especially notew ,"'h, ::, the ncre:,;ed ~rn,,: length and the interlocking, impermeable pye sheathing rile jnnc.er ;em!!h 01 the reconstructed groin is a matter of record The perr]!! Sla:",: thm 'S I' 'ur tee! longer and the field examication by the NYSDEC between Juhll1l1 'e:plenbcf' 20(1': Clearly, a longer groin will intercept more sand and thus (""st' ::we ~'rOSIl n do\-'.. nd~'it1 Holmol'l Ea~;t ([)owl1drift) Groin Holman West ( LPdrift ) Groi " ~,.,_r" '...uflH'I:' "'~ ..iJ<.i ""'''" "I Ii COr"lerl GroIn l"igurr i.:' PhOTOgraph {ooking west (updrift) from the Corieri property showin~ the reconstructed ew.iern Holman groin and tile western Holman groin. lVote the n,'lI PI'( on the !'o.\'ten' Il'rJlman !frain and the lack of sa nt/ in front of the Corier; proper~v. Impact of the Holman (-rom ~ \lattitucl-. Southold. \je\\ " (lr!. Pn:p.ared j"Of \~'hitc & Crrrilo. J J.l' (,O(j,:() l - I'ag~' 1 (, "f !, -~~ Figun> /3: I/ielt' (~f'the Holman groins. The photograph was taken while standm1!. adJocent to rhe Holman easter,~v groin and Jooking updrift towards the wester~1' ;::r'-;Jn \.,' aellor< was apparently taken on the updrift or westerly groin, or on the IrtefTTl'<tlate !1',lln Figlfc ; &. i 4\ The westerly (updrift) groin rises to the full height 'i'l llLkhcad !!LIld extends seaward beyond the frame oflhe photographs. The g' d1 cn'l1partmem betwec,n the eastern and western Holman groins is full of sand -'-7'-- Figure /.,t. J-il,H' to the east (downdrift) from the west side (~f the we.,'lern I/o/mun r:rorn. .\'ote the hcn{lu ,'~l ,/1(, limber KTo;n. ]lllr~I(1 ofth.: Holman (/f"Olll - \1attiwcL SOUdlOld.,(,'\\ \orL Pr,'p;l.n.",J For \l,'hik' &. C,rrilo. L1-1' (;.6DI - l'''~'L I ~ ,))')' The reconstruction of the eastern groin, including the seaward extension and the use of irnpenneable, interlocking PVC, coupled with the lack of action on the western (updrift) Holman groin has had a devastating and highly erosive impact on the Corleri beach. Moreover, this impact was entirely predictable. In addition to extending the groin seaward and increasing its sand trapping capacity, reconstructing the groin with modern PVC materials (to replace old, probably deteriorated wooden materials) makes the groin more "sand tight". In other words, older structures tend to "leak" sand through the groin and thus a rebuilt groin, which does not allow this sand through will decrease the sand supply, will cause increased downdrift erosion. Imp'" oftbe Holman Groin - MaItilud<, Southold, Now Yark Prepared For Wbite & CiIriIo, LLP6/S/01 -Pago 18 ofl9 rIR."ll ~ 3. Conclusions and Findings 3.1. Coastal Geology & Uttoral Process The Holman and Corieri properties are located along the shoreline of Great Peconic Bay where the prevailing littoral transport of sand is from the west to the east. The shoreline consists of glacially derived soils that have been reworked by coastal processes and thus the beach consists of a veneer of sand coating the glacial sediments. 3.2. Geomorphology, Inlets, & Shoreline Structures The shoreline is defined by natural compartments, delineated on the east and west ends by inlets at Deep Hole Creek and James Creek, respectively. The shoreline been modified by the construction of jetties at James Creek and a series of groins and seawalls along the shoreline east of James Creek. The length and spacing of these groins as well as the construction are highly variable, although most of the older groins are constructed of timber. These groins are also in various stages of repair. The Holman property contains three groins and the downdrift (eastern) groin was reconstructed and lengthened in 1999. 3.3. The Impact of the Holman Groin The impact of the Holman Groin is to block littoral sand transport from reaching the Corieri property and thus causing the beach to erode at an accelerated rate. This impact was easily predictable, and avoidable, if the specifications of the US Army Corps of Engineers - Shore Protection Manual were followed. 3.4. Potential Remedial Actions Shortening and lowering the updrift (west) groin would allow more sand to enter the groin compartment on the updrift (west) side, since the sand impounded there would be released to the downdrift (east). Establishing a uniform groin length and spacing (consistent with the Corps of Engineers design standards) along the entire beachfront would be logical if the remaining groins to the east, in this case the Corieri groins ( and others) were of equal length and spacing. If the remaining downdrift groins were shorter, than the US Army Corps of Engineers formula for groin tapering and spacing would be most appropriate. Adding beach compatible sand to the Corieri property is also recommended, but only in combination with the other structural changes to the groins descnoed above. B:i~ bnpa<t oflb. Holman Groin - MattJlu<k. Southold, New Yotk Pn:pared For While & Cilrito, ILP6/5101-Page 19 of19 ARAM V. TERCHUNIAN, M. Sc. Curriculum Vitae Areas of Expertise * Geomorphology, coastal processes, coastal hazard and erosion analysis * Wetlands delineation, permitting and erosion control construction * Environmental science and resource management * Endangered species monitoring and management * Zoning analysis and interpretation Experience . 1990 to Present, First Coastal Corporetion - President Responsible for all aspects of the firms consulting and construction services for coastal property owners, municipalities, and associations. . 1988 to 1990 Coastal Stabilization, Inc. - Regional Manager of Development Market development and technical sales for the development of a proprietary beach stabilization product. Prepared and executed marketing stretegy, prepared and presented technical results at national and international conferences, and presented proposals and RFP responses to local, State, and Federel agencies. * 1984 to 1988, New York State, Department of State, Division of Coastal Resources - Coastal Hazards Supervisor - Responsible for review and recommendations for improvement of existing coastal hazard area management progrems in New York State, including coastal erosion hazard areas, flood protection, and disaster relief. Represented the Secretary of State in post coastal disaster survey, assessment, and evaluation teams. Reviewed erosion control and coastal area development actions within coastal hazards areas in New York's coastal zone. *1982 to 1983, University of Delaware and Ecuadorean Remote Sensing Agency Technical Advisor - Instructed Ecuadorean nationals in the use of remote sensing techniques for naturel resources mapping including mangroves, coastal erosion, sea surface temperatures, and Amazon land use changes. Prepared grent application for Space Shuttle Imaging Radar mission. Education . M. Sc. Marine Studies (Coastal Geology), University of Delaware, 1984 M. Sc. Thesis: Hen and Chickens Shoal, Delaware: Evolution of a Modem Tidal Shoal Impaa oflb. Holmoo Oroio . Mattitud<, Soothold. """ Y ad< Prepared For White & CiIrilo, UJ> 6/S/01 - Pago20 ofl9 ~~ * B. S. Environmental Science and Resource Management (Geology), Lehigh University, 1980 Publications *Daley, W., C. Jones, T.G. Mootoo, A.V. Terchunian, and G. Vegliante, 2000, A Blueprint for Coastal Management: The West Hampton Dunes Story, Shore and Beach, January 2000, V68, N1, pp 25-29. *Terchunian, AV. and JA Smith, 1998, An Economic Snapshot of Long Island's Barrier Island System, Shore and Beach, October 1998, V66, No.4, pp9-11. * Spencer, R., and AV.Terchunian, 1997, The Sand Thieves of Long Islanc/'s South Shore, Shore and Beach, July 1997, V65, No.3, pp 4-12. * Terchunian, A.V., and C.L MelUrt, 1995, Little Pikes Inlet, Westhampton, New York, Journal of Coastal Research, V 11, n 3, pp 697-703. * Psuty, N.P., PA Gares, M. Kearney, and A. Terchunian, 1992, Coastal Environments: A Field Symposium of the Mid-Atlantic Bight Coastal Zone. Guidebook, Center for Coastal and Environmental Studies, InsliMe of Marine and Coastal Sciences, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ, 79 pp. * Terchunian, A V., 1990, Performance of Beachface Dewatering: The STABEACH System at SailfISh Point (Stuart), Florida, in Proceedinas of the 1990 Conference on Beach Preservation Technoloav, St. Petersburg, FL. * Ball, Sally, F., P. R. Lanza, and A. V. Terchunian, 1989, Coastal Hazard Area Management in New York Stata, in Proceedinas of Coastal Zone '89, Charleston, South Carolina, pp. 4749 - 4760. * Terchunian, A. V., 1988, Can Seawalls and Beaches Coexist?, in Journal of Coastal Research, Special Issue 4, Autumn, 1988 Kraus, N. and O. H. Pilkey (eds.) * Terchunian, A. V., and C. H. Fletcher, III, 1984, Current and Shoreline Effects of Shore Perpendicular Structures, in Proceedinas of the 10th Annual Coastal Society Conference, Atlantic City, NJ * Terchunian, A. V., V. K1emas, A Alverez, B, Vasconez, and L. Guerrero, 1984, The Effect of Shrimp Pond Development on Mangroves, In Environmental Manaaement, v10 n3 . 4. Professional Affiliations Association of Freid Ornithologists Americen Littoral Society, Member Americen Ornithologists Union ~ ~a<t oftb. Holmm Groin - M8ltiludc, SoulhoId. Now York PnpuodForWbile&Cirrito, UP 61SIOI-Pall"21 of19 American Shore and Beach Preservation Association, Member Association of State Floodplain Managers, Member Coastal Education Research Foundation, Member Florida Oceanographic Society, Member Florida Shore and Beach Preservation Association, Member Group for the South Fork, Member Lehigh University Earth & Environmental Sciences Alumni Advisory Board, Member Long Island Coastal Alliance, Member Long Island Shore and Beach Preservation Association, Prasident Northeast Shore and Beach Preservation Association, Board of Directors Peconic Land Trust, Member Surfrider Foundation, Member The Coastal Society, Member Impad of1he HoImIIl Groin . Mattitud<, SouIbold, New Yad< Propared For While" Cirrilo, lLP 6r~rOI - Page 22 of 19 f'lRSl c;;.ffaL " New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Division of Environmental Permits, Region One Building 40 - SUNY, Stony Brook, NY 11790-2356 Phone: (516) 444-0365 Fax: (516) 444-0360 John P. CahiJ.l Commissioner March 4, 1999 Mr. Bud Holman PO Box 978 Mattituck, NY 11952 RE: 1-4738-02089/00001 Dear Permittee: In conformance with the requirements of the State Uniform Procedures Act (Article 70, ECL) and its implementing regulations (6NYCRR, Part 621) we are enclosing your permit. Please read all conditions carefully. If you are unable to comply with any conditions, please contact us at the above address. Also enclosed is a permit sign which is to be conspicuously posted at the project site and protected from the weather. Very truly yours, /!:::Jf; R~fk- Environmental Analyst MMR:cg enclosure NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION DEC PERMIT NUM8ER 1-4738-02089/00001 FACILITY/PROGRAM NUMBERCS) . PERMIT EFFECTIVE DATE March 3. 1999 EXPIRATION DATECS) Under the Environmental Conservation Law March 31, 2004 TYPE OF PERMIT . New o Renewa 1 o Modification o Permit to Construct o Permi t to Operate . Article 15, Title 5: Protection . 6NYCRR 608: Water Quality 0 Article 27, Title 7; 6NYCRR of Waters Certification 360: Solid Waste Management 0 Article 15, Title 15: Water 0 ArticLe 17, Titles 7, 8: SPOES 0 Article 27, Title 9; 6NYCRR Supply 373: Hazardous Waste Management 0 ArticLe 19: Air Pollution 0 Article 15, Title 15: Water ControL 0 Article 34: Coastal Erosion Transport Management 0 ArticLe 23, Title 27: Mined 0 Article 15, Title 15: Long Land RecLamation 0 Article 36: Floodplain Island Wells Management 0 ArticLe 24: Freshwater Wetlands 0 Article 15, Title 27: Wild, 0 Articles 1, 3, 17, 19, 27, 37; Scenic and Recreational Rivers . Article 25: Tidal Wetlands 6NYCRR 380: Radiation Control PERMIT ISSUED TO TELEPHONE NUMBER Bud Holman (516) 29B-4B25 ADORESS OF PERMITTEE PO Box 97B Mattituck NY 11952 CONTACT PERSON FOR PERMITTED WORK TELEPHONE NUMBER Costello Marine Contracting Corp. PO 80x 2124 Greencort NY 11944 (516) 477-1199 NAME AND ADDRESS OF PROJECT/FACILITY Holman Property 350 Park Avenue LOCATION OF PROJECT/FACILITY SCTM #1000-123-7-B Mattituck COUNTY TOWN WATERCOURSE NYTM CooROINATES Suffolk Southold Great Peconic Bay DESCRIPTION OF AUTHORIZED ACTIVITY: Reconstruct two (2) low-prOfile groins, each 541 long and 34" below top of bulkhead. West groin to be shortened 10 ft. and east groin to be extended 4 ft. Center groin to remain undisturbed. Reconstruct west bulkhead return (14 ft.) In. kind/in-place. By acceptance of this permit, the permittee agrees that the permit is contingent upon strict compliance with the ECl, all applicable regUlations, the General Conditions specified (see page 2 & 3) and any Special COnditions included as part of this penmit. PERMIT ADMINISTRATOR: George W. Hammarth MMR ADDRESS Bldg. #40, SUNY, Stony Brook, NY 11790-2356 AUTHORIZED SIGNA~E ./.<1 h/~ OATE March 4 1999 Page 1 of 4 Nt::V\f YUKK STAlE:: UI::;i""AKTMI::;N I UI- t:NVIKUNMt:N IAL t,;UN::it:KVAIIUN NOTIFICATION OF OTHER PERMITTEE OBLIGATIONS Item A: Permittee Accepts Legal Responsibility and Agrees to Indemnification The permittee expressly agrees to indemnify and hold harmless the Department of Environmental Conservation of the State of New York, its representatives, employees, agents, and assigns for all claims, suits, actions, damages, and costs of every name and description, arising out of or resulting from the permittee's undertaking of activities or operation and maintenance of the facility or facilities authorized by the permit in compliance or non-compliance with the terms and conditions of the permit. Item B: Permittee to Require its Contractors to Comply with Permit The permittee shall require its independent contractors, employees, agents and assigns comply with this permit, including all special conditions, and such persons shall be subject to the same sanctions for violations of the Environmental Conservation law as those prescribed for the permittee. Item C: Permittee Responsible for Obtaining Other Required Permits The permittee is responsible for obtaining any other permits, approvals, lands, easements and rights-of-way that may be required to carry out the activities that are authorized by this permit. Item D: No Right to Trespass or Interfere with Riparian Rights This permit does not convey to the permittee any right to trespass upon the lands or interfere with the riparian rights of others in order to perform the permitted work nor does it authorize the impairment of any rights, title, or interest in real or personal property held or vested in a person not a party to the permit. GENERAL CONDITIONS General Condition 1: Facility Inspection by the Department The permitted site or facility, including relevant records, is subject to inspection at reasonable hours and intervals by an authorized representative of the Department of Environmental Conservation (the Department) to determine whether the permittee is complying with this permit and the ECL. Such representative may order the worik suspended pursuant to ECl 71-0301 and SAPA 401(3). The permittee shall provide a person to accompany the Departmenfs representative during an inspection to the permit area when written or verbal notification is provided by the Department at least 24 hours prior to such inspection. A copy of this permit, including all referenced maps, drawings and special conditions, must be available for inspection by the Department at all times at the project site. Failure to produce a copy of the permit upon request by a Department representative is a violation of this permit. General Condition 2: Relationship of this Permit to Other Department Orders and Determinations Unless expressly provided for by the Department, issuance of this permit does not modify, supersede or rescind any order or determination previously issued by the Department or any of the terms, conditions or requirements contained in such order or determination. General Condition 3: Applications for Permit Renewals or Modifications The permittee must submit a separate written application to the Department for renewal, modification or transfer of this permit. Such application must include any forms or supplemental information the Department requires. Any renewal, modification or transfer granted by the Department must be in writing. The permittee must submit a renewal application at least: a) 180 days before expiration of permits for State Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (SPDESl, Hazardous Waste Management Facilities (HWMF), major Air Pollution Control (APC) and Solid Waste Management Facilities (SWMF); and b) 30 days before expiration of all other permit types. Submission of applications for permit renewal or modification are to be submitted to: NYSDEC Regional Permit Administrator, Region 1, SUNY Bldg #40, Stony Brook, NY 11790-2356 General Condition 4: Permit Modifications, Suspensions and Revocations by the Department The Department reserves the right to modify, suspend or revoke this permit when: a) the scope of the permitted activity is exceeded or a violation of any condition of the permit or provisions of the ECl and pertinent regulations is found; b) the permit was obtained by misrepresentation or failure to disclose relevant facts; c) new material information is discovered; or d) environmental conditions, relevant technology, or applicable law or regulation have materially changed since the permit was issued. . I I PAGE -L OF -L DEe PERMIT NUMBER I 1-4738-02089/00001 NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION PERMIT.1W, rev. 10198 ADDITIONAL GENERAL CONDITIONS FOR ARTICLES 15 (TITLE 5), 24, 25, 34 AND 6NYCRR PART 608 ( TIDAL WETLANDS) 1. If future operations by the State of New York require an alteration in the position of the structure or work herein authorized, or if, in the opinion of the Department of Environmental Conservation it shall cause unreasonable obstruction to the free navigation of said waters or flood flows or endanger the health, safety or welfare of the people of the State, or cause loss or destruction of the natural resources of the State, the owner may be ordered by the Department to remove or a~er the structural work, obstructions, or hazards caused thereby without expense to the State, and if, upon the expiration or revocation of this permit, the structure, fill, excavation, or other modification of the watercourse hereby authorized shall not be completed, the owners, shall, without expense to the State, and to such extent and in such time and manner as the Department of Environmental Conservation may require, remove all or any portion of the uncompleted structure or fill and restore to its former condition the navigable and fiood capacity of the watercourse. No claim shall be made against the State of New York on account of any such removal or alteration. 2. The State of New York shall in no case be liable for any damage or injury to the structure or work herein authorized which may be caused by or result from future operations undertaken by the State for the conservation or improvement of navigation, or for other purposes, and no claim or right to compensation shall accrue from any such damage. 3. Granting of this permit does not relieve the applicant of the responsibility of obtaining any other permission, consent or approval from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, U.S. Coast Guard, New York State Office of General Services or local government which may be required. 4. All necessary precautions shall be taken to preclude contamination of any wetland or waterway by suspended solids, sediments, fuels, solvents, lubricants, epoxy coatings, paints, concrete, leachate or any other environmentally deleterious materials associated with the project. 5. Any material dredged in the prosecution of the work herein permitted shall be removed evenly, without leaving large refuse piles, ridges across the bed of a waterway or floodplain or deep holes that may have a tendency to cause damage to navigable channels or to the banks of a waterway. 6. There shall be no unreasonable interference with navigation by the work herein authorized. 7. If upon the expiration or revocation of this permit, the project hereby authorized has not been completed, the applicant shall, without expense to the State, and to such extent and in such time and manner as the Department of Environmental Conservation may require, remove all or any portion of the uncompleted structure or fill and restore the site to its former condition. No claim shall be made against the State of New York on account of any such removal or alteration. 8. If granted under 6NYCRR Part 608, the NYS Department of Environmental Conservation hereby certifies that the subject project will not contravene effluent limitations or other limitations or standards under Sections 301, 302, 303, 306 and 307 of the Clean Water Act of 1977 (PL 95-217) provided that all of the conditions lisied herein are met. 9. At least 48 hours prior to commencement of the project, the permittee and contractor shall si9n and return the top portion of the enclosed notification form certifying that they are fully aware of and understand all terms and conditions of this permit. Within 30 days of completion of project, the bottom portion of the form must also be signed and returned, along with photographs of the completed work and, if required, a survey. 10. All activities authorized by this permit must be in strict conformance with the approved plans submitted by the applicant or his agent as part of the permit application. Such approved plans were prepared by Costello Marine Contractino Coro. on October 5 199B and last revised Januarv 16 1999 DEC PERMIT NUMBER 1-4738-020B9/00001 PAGE-L OF ~ NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION SPECIAL CONDITIONS 1. Any debris or excess material from construction of this project shall be completely removed from the adjacent area (upland) and removed to an approved upland area for disposal. No debris is permitted in tidal wetlands and or protected buffer areas. 2. The storage of construction equipment and materials shall be confined to within the project work site and or upland areas greater than 75 linear feet from the tidal wetland boundary. 3. Prior to any construction or removal of bulkheads and other shoreline stabilization structures all backfill shall be excavated landward of the bulkhead and retained so as notto enter the waterway, tidal wetland or protected buffer area. 4. All areas of soil disturbance resulting from this project shall be stabilized immediately following project completion or prior to permit expiration, whichever comes first. The approved methodologies are as follows: . a. Stabilization of the entire disturbed area with appropriate vegetation (grasses, etc.). DEC PERMIT NUMBER 1-4738-02089/00001 I I PAGE~OF~ T~~.",.. COsn:.u.o HMZ-IlJl:;.- Co~N<9 ~. "P. ~.~.x. 2-12.4- ~rotz:r, t-J:{ 11<:f44 ~Ito. 471-. 1149 HeW,).JfR>U<. ..~) ~-r.o.e>1<A. llb] :> Z. (~ S4~ <>o.l...-r<~) VIC,11\.111Y ~: -1000 ' $ f'l.llot> '\\ EJG'" ~ ~"-~c..-u.'( ( ~....<!t NDT'".,..."" ~ ') L-OCA.,....ID~ MP<~: \L If 'FL::wo.. ~~ ~1~16 '\ l5:d.. Y 3 AI'I"'U~ : t1r: lIo<ID HDLM/<>.l ~rO!- : P.O. eo<-- "I?8 ~rfUGt<.., "-1'1'. 11<>r.5".l- SClH 4/": 1~2)l> - 12-S '7-!; 3""O~~e". 1'UolflT\Jc:-l<-, Ni. 11.,-';2- ~,... ~ OWHeH: o 111L. WI~ eowl1A.V <'\ 1'1~lqboH P-t> "k.u..~3E'- Yl~ , NY. 1100.3 @ 1'11>\...~"t1Iofz>(t!JS~>-l @p,t.., ~t:>04Z'- e:>11P6.p.r,....~ Z-1l.. ~A.H- b..~. -.0... nv~ ~V'b. 4-10 ~ ~, , l-VIlfrrtJ.e.l<... H"f. Il"IS';%. ~ , ".....:!.ilt>ll ~rT\.Iq.) N'1'. 1I"'1:5Z )J0"f"~: APPROVED AS PER TEID<l!l "NO CONDITIONS OF L'ERJo,UT NO./-'I1.3i- D~D8q/oooo/ DATE ,3-;3 -99 mll/L , , t ,~~<<""TWo J.J:>.... f"IU:lF.lLt.- ~IN -.:rt<'l"nes ,"'ACH 54' L..OI',fG ANt:> 2>4-" e.e~OW TOPOf BUL..KH P. RECONSTRUCT 'weST BULKHeAD ReTUR.N, IN-KINP, IN-PLACe. (14 FEET) l>L..L. ~ .,...... Ile. +lo>T, t:>tPP6-t> qA.l-VAN~ , A1..L.. l.UH~ ~ \5e. ~Tl!t:>.. @ NI~L-'oS.~ ~Tl ~IZ- ~ AV.... . 11'-"lT"'T"u u:.. , /0.1.,.. I i<l'S'2- .. NYSDEC ~CS""..r-,: OCT~':5'J 1<'\"10 9\U..i" 1 or; S . JANUAR"( I<D, 19"1"1 ~.'f: C,Dsret.~ ~Nte- CD~"'nN~ 'PD. 'Box.. 2-124- ~~, I-J'i. 51(" .477. 1141 Q)f.r . 11"'# ; __ u.u u.>-rr: Mr. @;UO +tOt...>1J..N , 'P.6.&ol<....<=r-?-8 HAlT'T\J<-l'- , t-.r1'. 11'1~2. SIn:..: 3.'SO 'P~ b."V~. H",""rT'Lt CI<- I N'/'. 11'l'Q.. \1.cn1'1/' l<=>~ '1L:!. .7,6 ~e.I~ (/) 0;-' l,D" - - - - o 10' ~' -\ , ( -":t) e)l.ISTlN~ 13UL~) ~~N \ ~ i ~ 'I '" R.E.CONSTR.UCT CX16i: e.ULKHe:AP RETURN] 'N-KINO IN.PLAc:e (J4') ~~ ~W A:T '!oUL~1> . "- ---" ,......"""" EXIST." CENrell!. GROIN/JETTY To R.e.M'" I N L.w (1-12-") ,._AM AMLW(I-'2.-"'~) h.. l-rrr~ D2.J~ (VARIES W/W'N" COND'TIONS) Eae ......f'V>oo ~ ~ 8 .' e @ NYSDEC APPROVED AS PER TERMS ND CONDITIONS OF t'ERMIT No.I-113i-/J;J,b89/()Oo / DATE ..3-..:1 -"'1' 11?/11~ ... Qfi!-EA.i ft;.COl\Jr<:- ~'( ft>.C~~ : ~~c;;r TWO l.D-.J ~l.e.. ~_~ I :1'anu . "'ACH 54' Lo,",G AND' 34" S.EL.OW TOr- 01"'" WLK1-f6AP. weST GROIN TO 8E SHOR.TcNE.D I a FE.e.T" AN" e:A<$IT tSteOIN TO De EX.TEND'ISP 4- l"'eeT. R6CON5TRLlC.T WE:5T BULKHE.AP (I....FT.) RETURN, IN-KIND, IN-PLACe.. 6.>.L. ~.............. -rb l!E. +lOT, "P'f>f'e.t:> ~h.L>I""NIz.et> .......\.. WJ"'_ 1"'> 1ilE... ~ . L.J.IT'nI. ': OOT<l&E.fZ..:S ,19"'l8 ~,.. 2. OF'.s JANUARY IID,I"I"14 CPs-n:.u....o ~IJE;..- CONn:ACi"'I"lc,. c.D1Z-P. "P.O. $OX-.- :2-lz..-4- ~u:E-NPDtz:i, N.Y: 119+:1- 51(" . 41'"7. 1 ICf9 e.L-t:..V6.T'10N : ~ C> 2' 10' I ! ~I~: ~I<:.!>NT': t-lt. SUO-HOI.><AN r..o . %>0"" 4 i"tl l-I6'lTlTIJU<-., N'1'. II<1S z.. :30'$0 ~ A.:ve. H>-"....u"-lL , No{. 11452- ~-12.3-?" " ;:r' ~i11 *" : . ~1!oJ / ;:fe-TTY . 54 (TYPICAL oF' WE.!>T GROIN) 75';1 Tt> RESIDe.NC.E (O""''''j,1 \ (3') ~ Go' a'1 -+7.0'- I 1 I AMHW +2.5' ~ : Au.. t+~ -r... 1!oE- ..;.or. "'l1'f'IU> "rA'-V6.>l = J .u.... LU HlOIS-P- 12> -.. ~TEP . ( 1'1l...I!. ~~T10"-l t.', ~-nt1101<!i ~11'h'rIO'" 4' ) I~~q. "SUL~ \ '-: -It> ~N / / \'" ! (r 0N~ f1Le.s) / ~ ~f'ILIN<!jr-l / ~\ "" w.u.e. <'z.. ..~ ~E<><n+lN'" r:;; '"" , oS ~ ..f'L.A.N VI ~ : ) 3- :r ~ . ~!oJ / :n::rr'(' 54 (TYP. of W. GR~'N)rz t -i't -% 75'1:. T() Re61DENGI! -'- NYSDEC APPROVED AS PER TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF IERMIT NO. 1- 41~8 - b~{) rq JOOOD I DATE 3-3."1"/ mm~ I ~O&e.c> : > ~ ~~Go"'" TWO L<;:o.rJ"f'lLofiL.e- ~1~/=n~.TfI'e-S EAcf-\ ~ 54' LON'" A>-lO 34' E!>aLOW -rOP OF' BtlLKHE.AD. RECON~TRUC.T WEST BULKHEAD RE:rURN IN-KIND, IN- PLAC.E. (14- FT.) I D6""C>~ 5', 1"I"t~ ~., S bl=-:!: -JANUARY 1(" 1"1'1'1 95-20-1 (8/81)-90 New York State Department of Environmental Conservation o NOTICE .~ ~ ~ The Department of Environmental Conservation (DEe) has issued permit(s) pursuant to the Environmental Conservation Law for work being conducted at this site. For further information regarding the nature and extent of work approved and any Departmental conditions on it, contact the Regional Permit Administrator listed below. Please refer to the permit number shown when contacting the DEC. Regional Permit Administrator Permit Number / -'I13f -~;'(J!~tJtJ~/ Expiration Date 03"3 j-J..oo'l JOHN w. PAVACIC NOTE: This notice is NOT a permit . .-. ELIZABETH A. NEVII.:LE TOWN CLERK Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Fax (516) 765-1823 Telephone (516) 765-1800 REGISTRAR OF VITAL STATISTICS MARRIAGE OFFICER RECORDS MANAGEMENT OFFICER FREEDOM OF INFORMATION OFFICER OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLEff . . TOWN OF SOUTHOLD ..._. -"--~-~... rn t'" C",' " n s" 'u~rc &ii JUL 2 4 2000 L APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC ACCESS TO (,t. INSTRUCTIONS: Please complete Section I of this form and give to Town Clerk's Office (agency Freedom of Information Officer). One copy will be returned to you in response to your request, or as an interim response. ' ==============--===--=-----------------================ SECTION I. TO: / 'ow tV 7Iz.'uS7"EC S olttltc/ (Department or Officer, if known, that has the information you are requesting.), RECORD YOU WISH TO INSPECT: (Describe the record sought. If possible, supply date, file title, tax map number, and any other- pertinent information.) . 1~:3' 7- r ?p,t",,~ f .h;r ~u~J(1t.M:p Signature of Applicant: Printed Name: r-:::DAV I 0 Address: -4 \ 2- c. P 41L r( . (IPr; AVE- Mailing Address (if different from above): Telephone Number: dCfff <fo <{ I , . Date: '7/.2 \{ jo'O I ,. ------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------ [ [ ] ] APPROVED APPROVED WITH DELAY* CJlr~a ?:lew~ qeCEJVED [ ] DENIED* JUl 2 4 2000 Elizabeth A. Neville Freedom of Information Officer .....'hOld low" Clerk Date * If delayed or denied see reverse side for explanation. . . ~2/L~L2~~~,~~?3, 2L28735561 5HEEHAt-1 ' PAGE ~1 OilOI '~. WfD 1'.0' .41 'I','~' ell. som.1.lI CUlllll 8001 BUz.ua:rEl "" IQMIU !\'O- (lUIIIII: __CII'"",IlLI1'A"',",,Cft .,-_u"f' ......". 'I1'''O.._~cmCltn _....INJG~'rImI ,,",1!;Sa T..... H.I', 6BON "* :Rood p,o, _nft s.\lI&olII. If.. yon. lWO I hi 111lI1....laI ,..:..It... r'lOl_~ , OIo'l'tCE 01' TH1Ii TOWN CJ.iIlRX 'I'OWN 01' BotlTKOI.P "'....'CATION FOR l'UllI.IC Ace!!SI TD lleC:OIIPs tltiJIIUC;Tla"Il' I'I~A$' c.mpl~.. ,SICII"" I or 1~1, IDrm Ind gl.. \:a To..n CI..~'. lllIIce 'I"IV:}' Frellllam .r Inl.""oll.'" Offl..-), Ono IIOPV wilt b. 'OlllrMCl 10 '\"l'u In "up....n UI '(II"" .aqu,",. or II on Interlt. 'o~pon"", __...~iI _.....1:_..._ EIiI....-..x=~- ""K!- SICTlCIIl I. po lt1!COaD YOU WISll TD 'NSPlieT, lD.""llIo ,"' ,_rel sow,"" If p'AltII.. ."ppIV ell", m. titl., ,.. Np """"*,,, Ind.nT '.tho, p.rtlnonl Inro'....I.n.) AnY ,.~i~ ,~r.ft~'d ~o Bud Bo1man tor D~nstruct!an af ~roln at B:rDper~" f.,11m~t:.il ,.. D11i11!. 1 anti. &iIll!t,ioft. \ '-J. ,"'P4 '7. .LIs" , ~"''''''Appll<ant:1< ~a.}nj,,-;:;::._L.~ ,.Ift... .....t R' t It.h...lt. Ah....'hAII Acldrdll '10 park AV'tI!Ill1Jt! r.~ ...!,"'''tu''1r~ lI'u,,~' ~..".+.I.....\r vy l 'I1I~2 Manlng A4d~' (Ir "Ufl","' fr'Qh .bcNa'l '3 'BR~' ~'.h f:\~r..,..r_ II'fr It.. ,,,~~. T.....~ ..",.be";212.-I~J-!i.ll; a.M. 1J..hr~AP; 10 t .2.4.ftft . lII( E: ""ETV t: I.J ---.., ~ --...-...... --- . , J APPIllMlD I I APAIOVm ."11 IlIiI.AY. I 1 DE,.IED. fEB 1 0 2000 ~a~ .-*'11 ", I . I ~;"r """rhOld lown Clerk . DII. . l' ~.I.weCll e,. "c~i" '" '.""i. 11* ftlr ."p,-nallan. ill(r:B ~ ~ ,:fr' TO ... . . 0). .'/, j! . V.)lrA . . . JEAN W. COCHRAN SUPERVISOR Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Fax (516) 765-18:l3 Telephone (516) 765.1889 OFFICE OF THE SUPERVISOR TOWN OF SOUTHOLD August 9, 1999 Ann and David Corieri 412 Park Avenue Mattituck, NY 11952 .-~~\ ~] ~ ~j r ~f-~~t 0 mg ~ , -rqoq1 :\~-. (~, ' ., , IUvV'\1 " J,' .:.,:.. ' - ...j. I 1'" _ _______~___ Dear Mr. and Mrs. Corieri: Thank you for your recent letter regarding your property on Peconic Bay. I note that you sent a copy of your letter to the Board of Trustees; they are the responsible agency in this matter. They will investigate the situation and, hopefully, contact you with a satisfactory solution. Please feel free to contact my office at any time. Sincerely yours, ~c::~ Supervisor /rbw // cc: Board of Town Trustees .. . . 412 Park Avenue Mattituck, NY 11952 August 3, 1999 RECEIVED AUG 4 1999 Southold Town derle Town of Southold Supervisor and Councilpersons Board of Trustees 53095 Main Road Southold, NY 11971 Dear Directors: We recently bought a waterfront home here in the town of Southold on the Great Peconic Bay. Until this month there was a beach. Now there is none. In June our neighbor had a groin rebuilt immediately west of our beach. The groin was constructed very high on the bulkhead. It is my understanding that permits for this type of construction are issued to help property owners maintain their beaches, but built on a low profile as to not erode neighbors' beaches. Sand has built up on his side, at the expense of reducing our beach significantly. We estimate at least an 18" loss of sand depth on our side. Would you please have this groin checked to see if it conforms to what was permitted by the town board and/or the D.E.C.? Things are changing rapidly, so we would tremendously appreciate your prompt attention to this matter. Thank you. Sincerely, (0 CORIERI & ASSOCIATES, INC. 1527 FRANKLIN AVENUE MINEOlA. NY 11501 CERTIFIED r;LJtJwML_ Aoo ~, ~( ~-'_ 5 TOWN OF SOUTH .. i~~;'~}:-;. . ::-~ o "-<: -- P 422 440 418 J - .- , ~o> C 1 AUG .(;: .~ j /":1,,0. ..- -- -.'c:tnG 1 SLf:\lm 1. 1.:) 1Jl:,,.' ..--., David Corieri MAIL . . JAH20!m / COSTELLO MARINE CONTRACTING CORPORATION DOCK BUILDING' JETTIES' BULKHEADING . STEEL & WOOD PILING' FLOATS 423 FIFTH STREET. P.O. BOX 2124 . GREENPORT, NEW YORK 11944 . (516) 477-1199/477-1393/477-0682 . FAX (516) 477-0005 January 15,1999 Albert 1. Krupski, Jr., President Board of Trustees P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Re: Bud Holman SCTM #1000123-7-8 Dear Mr. Krupski: Thank you for taking the time to meet with me at the Holman property in Mattituck on the 12th of January to review the existing conditions at the site in regard to our application to reconstruct three existing functional groins. Please let this letter confirm Mr. Holman's acceptance of the Trustees recommen- dations at the conclusion of our meeting. We will also revise our drawings to reflect the more accurate conditions that exist along with the proposed changes. . The three groins are to be consistent in length and elevation . The elevation of each groin is to be 34" below the top of the existing bulkhead which attaches to the existing bulkhead just beneath the lower bottom stringer. . Remove 10' from the westerly 64'groin and lower the elevation to 34" . Extending the center groin by 6' to an overall length 54' and raising the height by 2". , The length of the easterly groin is to remain 50' long with 6" of additional height at the bulkhead connection . . ~l iJ ---.0 JM :'. 0 Img Albert J. Krupski, Jr., President Januaryl5, 1999 Page 2 of2 On the day of the Trustees inspection mean-low-water at that particular site was 2:32 p.m. Our inspection occurred slightly after 3:30 p.m. There was a AGOGEE condition the previous day (January 11th) and its gravitational influences on the tide. The winds were light easterly and the barometric pressure was 29.97 inches. Again, we acknowledge and accept the recommendations of the Trustees. Several photographs on the day of our meeting along with plans that have been revised accordingly are enclosed. We will forward copies of same to the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation. Again, thank you for taking the time to meet with me. If you have any questions, please feel free to call me. Respectfully, a ~';c~ Ene. cc: Margaret M. Rorke, NYSDEC -a. J..4 0(. N\" "l - ~ ,.;r-" oor...c "'" - ~o JAN 2 0 1999 I'V\ t.~ - ~: &2. PN\ PM","o ~..,,~ A'P" !~'4. PIII\ ,Q"I'"' Maa,..,N, '^I....... T'bW^I ~..,,~.t"$ ,-" -'9 ," -a. i-\.oL~A~ - ~""1\:~Q.1C.. ~o JAN 2 0 1999 J - I 7. --" -S, I-I-Q(.~If.Ai - "'14 "... ~ T\.4.C I<. ~o JAN L 0 1999 III ~ ~ !I;i " lli M..Lv..! - 2: 3 z. PIW\ 1> t4-0T' 0 ~..-. M.~ A p, .~ '3:"1 t; 'P"'l I-I ,-~, . ~ . o "1J. ~ I. "" .. N - I\t1 A \- . ""T Nctic,,,,"Oc. 17--1 'if'< iJ:, "A l ,. \,,;- Cite:. ~C.~"'I!A b I-/z.-,., .~\.\.. w 0 . ". ',H l.OI(. JAN 2 0 1999 . /V\ '" ". , T"'-'I. "" NIIW \\ C..toc" ~ "8", (. " Mo ""'" 0 I - , z. - ~~ . Albert J. Krupski, President James King, Vice.President Henry Smith Artie Foster Ken Poliwoda . Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Telephone (516) 765-18~2 Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD January 22, 1999 ~- ~l~~S s:c. Ro r a 1329 e a Ro d Southa on N . 1968 ~ /YI~ Re: BUDD HOLMAN SCTM #123-7-8 Dear Mr. Herrmann, The following action was taken by the Board of Town Trustees during a Regular Meeting, held on January 22, 1999, regarding the above matter: WHEREAS, BUD HOLMAN, applied to the Southold Town Trustees for a permit under the provisions of the Wetland Ordinance of the Town of Southold, application dated November 2, 1998 and, WHEREAS, said application was referred to the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council for their findings and recommendations, and WHEREAS, a Public Hearing was held by the Town Trustees with respect to said application on January 22, 1999, at which time all interested persons were given an opportunity to be heard, and, WHEREAS, the Board members have personally viewed and are familiar with the premises in question and the surrounding area, and, WHEREAS, the Board has considered all the testimony and documentation submitted concerning this application, and, WHEREAS, the structure complies with the standard set forth in Chapter 97-18 of the Southold Town Code, WHEREAS, the Board has determined that the project as proposed will not affect the health, safety and general welfare of the people of the town, - . . NOW THEREFORE BE IT, RESOLVED, that the Board of Trustees approves the application of BUD HOLMAN to reconstruct three low-profile jetties, one 65' and two 50' long, with condition that new drawings be submitted showing all jetties the same lenqth, not as requested in description. Located: 350 Park Ave., Mattituck. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this determination should not be considered a determination made for any other Department or Agency which may also have an application pending for the same or similar project. Permit to construct and complete pro;ect will expire two years from the date it is signed. Fees must be paid, if applicable, and permit issued within six months of the date of this notification. Two inspections are required and the Trustees are to be notified upon completion of said project. FEES: None Very truly yours, Cltt.&.1 {J" I&.V(4~~. Albert J. l;~t>ski, Jr. - , President, Board of Trustees AJK/djh cc. DEC Dept. of State ACE . l'f'~ ~ , GO~ ~..I1.Jt::.- c.o~~~ "P. ~.~)(.... 2-12.4" c$fPf'"f'--Nn>k.'-,!\l:f. Il~ 51lo. 41'? . 1149 ~o )AN 2 0 1999 '" Z. (~llLIl"P'tlI.It~..~~) V1CII\IITY ~: "\ClCO ' $ ~Dt>~ _ .... ~.,- ~c.. 1;A..'( ( ~""lJ !-lDT'''''o ~ ') L-D~IIDt-J ~: ..-..;.,":' (~M/e.. ,~.. ,.d ~I ~16 TS:A..y .3 Af'f'l..l~ : t1~. ~D HO~ :'I-r\!,. : 1".o.eac.. ~?8 ~nUc.lt-, t-J'I'. II~ ScrH $" Ibt>.o.. lZ.~ '7-8 &'$0 ~#/'f-. l"UoqflT\J~, N-{. ""'5'2- ~-r~ow_, @ l'11L. WI~ C.ONMIoV "\ MIl!A-l~ P-O ~""'3"'y",~> NT. 11003 @l'IlS\..~"t1/oP>(~1-l @p,a..1'~ @t1P5.IU;'Ie..~ z..?t. ~1l4'i<- 6..",,-. 1O;os" ~~ Cl.vt>. <110 ~ ~-ve.. . - t1MI1'~ I t<<. 11"lQ. N6f'\A!8 , Fl,...;!.o1it>6 Hl<ll'~ ) N'f'. II<t:5Z @NI~"~~TI ~ ~ "'".. . M~"'T'ITU~, N't' . 114'S'2- ~o.-.-, ~ ~S't'Al<< ~ LOW nu>F1u:.,.. ~IN / 'Q""'i<-1T'Ie& ,E-AGH . 54' t..<:>,..iG ANt:> 34" e.el.OW T<:>POF e.ULKH'J....r:>. ~: bol...L. Al..l- 1\I'''''''I'P&' -r.... !lIO- +l<>-r. 0IPP"1iC> ~.A.NI'UU> .. L.uH_ 1'2> &e. '"11r-U-1l<O - /} J J.X) ( r/t< dtdlr9, jI~ oc.,...~ = JANUARY _ fr..... rD . .'1 ' ~~L-' t1M4Nl!:.- ~"nN(::f <p:D.1!o><.... 2.12"'" ~ 1oJ'I'. 51<.. .477. 11"'1'" ~. 11<=t# ~u.HT": I"\r. SUP ~ 'PO.SOl<.... <=r-l'8 Hb:ffIT\.lc:.t<. , t-rf. 119">4. S I-re.. ; 3'50 'P~ A."r:-. J'1J>;rfrT'JC-l(.. ,N'1'. II~ ilCn1 '*' Ib"'" ' JZ.~ ' '? ,8 (/) ~. U)' ~''E'letI~E::. I 'I - - - - () 00' 1<)' i \ , (-,.:;:) e;)GISTtI-J" 13UCIU-teb.t>) 1"1:> ~ \ ~ i ~~ M!-lW b.:T' '!".ll.~. -- f'\rlvJ ,.. ..- W ('-12-"'''') AMI. AMI.W('-'Z-~)h.. 8) l-nf'~ 'DIU"'" (VAI'tIE? W/W,>JP CO/oJOITION5 ) " 5Be ~, ~ 8 @ 41z.EA-r f'!:.CO"-llc... ~'( ~~: ~.-nz,..c;r ~ l.D'toJ f"lI.CFtl.e... ~N l:n:m...... , "Ac.H 54' l.ONG ANP 34" &ELOW To,. opr etJLI<-HEAP. wes, GIlOIN TO BE SHOItTe.Ne.D '0 FEe.T, ceNTER tS~'N TO at! EX.TEt-.1DE.P (I. ,.i5ET AI'-JP EA~T GIlOIN "-0 Be e.)(."T'ENDet::t 4- Fa.eT; b.Lt.. ~~ -rz, 1!lE. <-Icr. ~;"Pf'tot> ~6..llJ6.NI%.l!!-t> ....." UJt1_ 12> toE. ~ .. ~~ OG--WCE.lZ-:S , ,.,..8 ~ 2., ~F- $ JANUA~Y liD,I'I"I"I ~ -e.y, o:>~ HAtr:Jt.Jt::.... ~N~AC..t"I"'~ ~. 'P.O.15OX-;;WZl't' ~u:.E.NPl>P=1, N~ 11'M4 $1(" . 417 . 11"'19 l>f'pt.'CboNT": '"*. 1SUI:> ~ 1"'.D.!'>O)<. .,n ~~, ~. II"lSZ. :s.SO ~ A:>I"e. . ~UGt<. . >-I;. 11.,'52- UlOO -12.S-jIl-9 {:.L"!:.V6,:tiON .... ~I"""': ~~: l~.~~ >~ 1 . ~I "-I / ::re;rrY. . . 54 (TYPICAL of' weST GROIN) (3") ~ r.: a'1 I I AMLW I I I AMHW - -AMHW . 2..5' ~: AU. ~ _ __~,pl9'l"l!P GfoU-'If6o.,IIZAU:>, A.l..l. W..,.-. ~ Mo ~ .. (1"11.& ~T10N I.', ~t-lEf ~~IOt.! +,) _'f'I,.Jl.N VI r=>.N ~ ) ,~ ! (r ~N~ ~les) / ~ ~PllIN"rJ / \ "'" ~e.. <'z... ..~~N4 ':; ~ , oS ~ . C;1u>t~ I ~" 54 ') (TYP. OF 'M GROIN /7 t"i"t ...~~:- I' 'j'"' -- - - o 20' 10' 7SI:lTO RESIDENGE 1~t.l411U\.~le..t-'\ ". -re ~N j ~ :I r ~ 75'~ TO RE'6IDENGI! \ f"l>.cpb6e.t:>: f'.e"<>N~"" ~ L.l:NJ~LA!- ~t-l/~~'l1'I~ EAGt1 .54 .LONe. ~o -34' e.eLOW -rop Of' ~V\.KH.gAD, ) :I r ~ De.""~ '6: I"""~ n..__..... ~ ^~.4 JANUARY 1(,,',~Jfq'l ~I "'~...'" \ GO~=:~~~W~ "'P. ~ .1WX- 2-12.4- ~Et'Nf"'O~, N~ Ilq44 ';i?1 &> . 4 t'r . ""19 r ~LJLq ,J'AN' Ii l'li ')0 , '. " .- " - \.-= L ..~"reA ~\ ~16 'E:A..y , 1. , ,@ ~Au @ \ \ ,@\ \V \ \ \ (~.~~. :> Z. (~ ~ dCO-lN1"(~) V1CII\IITY 1'1AP: ~. (/) f't..!\ot:> ~ .- ~ ~I~t-u..y ( ~"'~ I-IDT',.... ~ ') L-OCA..\IO~ ~: .3 Af'F\..I~ : t1~......0 ...o~ ~l~ : p.o.eoll- "'i'S ~rTUc..i<-, t-J'1'. 11"l':2- Sc:rH "": I"'Db - 1%-S'7'8 3'!S0 rto.t4:- ~I!.-. ~rrtlClt-, N'1'. II.,'S'Z. ~,... ~ OWNU-S: @ m.. WI~ eONl1A-v "l'lll!l-t~~ ~""'3Jl.VI~, NT. 11003 @ 1'le:t-~"'t1A.P>(~~", @p,t..'1' ~b1!4Z- @11P6.~Ie..1:lC.~ Z-?l. ,.~ 6"........ ~ ~UoN eWe>. 410 ~ ~e... . ~~, m. 11"ls::z. ~ , FI.-.;!.o1-tbll t1loll'~) N'1'. 11"1:52- @ NI~,,~ ~,., ~~b.v", M.."tT'I-ru~,Iol'l'. \~ ft.<>tP~s-~ : ~~<< ~ LD-w nu:>Flu:,.. 9t"O'N / -a-m,,:~s ,E-ACH '54' Lc,-iG ANt:> 34" BELOW -rOPOF 5lJLKH~D. tJO'T'".,.. : AL..L.. I"'V1"\I.P... "f"4> .... -+161' b~&P ~ANI~ 1 Al..L- L-UH_ '"T2> &e. \1I.U..'T1<o . .oG--r~ ~ I"<H~ ~,... I OF:$ . JANUA~Y I~. 1"'1"'1"1 . frIO'" V"'t' . .'f' , ~~L1!P" ~Nl!:- COt.t1'1lIaoCnW", 'f':t>.'80lC 2.124- ~ I-l'f. 51{., . 471. 11"11 ~. 11"'44- M>PuUoHT" , ~r. l5UD ~ 'P.b.&OlL. Cf:f8 HA:lT'T\I""," 1 I-K, 11'l"Z. s,~ : ~'50 1"~ 1>-'-Jr!-. HlQ'frruc.l<- I N'f'. 11'l"S1. ~'IF !<>DD .JZ.!,.",.a ~I~ I I ., I \ \ (7"::t) \ (f) ...' U)' - - - - D 10' '10' e)l.ISTlI-I" 1!lUC~) '1'2>~N \ ~ i ~~ ~W A:'T' '5UC~ . --" _A~vI , ,...... . ..-- .., (!-I~H''') AML.~ AML.W(I-'Z-~)h.. 8 \...nf'0J4&.. P1Urr (VARIE'So W/WINP CO/oJOIT~/oJS ) " I!Be ~'" ~ @ @ ~, f'eC6t-JIc...-e.A.'( ~SI!!oe> : 1E5Gl>Nsrtz,ue;;r "'1'lIUL I..b.... f"p.qOt~ ~1oJ 1:ncml1!$ . "'AGH 54' La"'G ANt' 34.'1 &eL.OW TO" 0JIi' evLI(1-4EAP. wesT (iIilOIN TO 8E St-iOR:TI:NE.P 10 FE.~TI ceNTER GIlPIN To &e e.x.Teto..lD&.c:::' ell ,.6ET ANP e,..I..~T 6~IN "'-0 ee. e;<.,..ENDe.t:t 4- FeeT; b.L... ~-.e.. "11> 1i!L *'T, ~'Pf'~ <!fbl.).l6<.NIU!.t:> AL.... '-'1...._ .". __ ~ . l.lt'IT"i!t. ": OG--n>CE!.lZ-:S ,'''l''Ifl SlIel:::r' 2- ~F- ~ JANUARY lID, l"l"l"l .. ~"&-<: c,o~ HAJt.l1.1l!:.- c.oN~AC..t"IN~ eIL:.. ~D.15OX-;;Uz.,+ 6lUENPDp::r, N~. II Cf.+:f <:;1(., . 417'. 11<q9 AA>\..I~T": "*. $UO ~ 1""..0._ "1'8 11Ao1TrT\lC..lC-- l N'I'. 11<\-; z. 3.'5'0 ~ b:>Ie. , l'\MfM'u<:.t<. . toJ'f, II.,-sz, L600 - I:z.~-i"-Q a" T' eL.,e..V6.\lot-J " -- - - ~1'T"1L-: o Z' \0' SC;rl11' : (~."~ 'it . ~I~ I j"~ . , , 54 (TY,..ICAL oF' We.ST 6ROIN) 75r~ TO RESIl;'E!NGE - -AMHW 1..s' (3') :.:J I I AMLW I I I AMHW ~: AU. ~ ~ ___ ~. PI1'n!P "",,-'I{A>.llZeD, .u....... L.UMIOP- 12> M- ~ . ('!"1l.1!. ~l1Ot-l t.') ~""" __~O~ +') _'f\Jl.N VI ~ ~ 1~t.ll:r1!llJ~i<J-\t'.p,\ \." -1b 1'-l!WWN j J ~~ ! {r (~Nq ftle.s) / ~ ~PILIN~Y / \. "'" ~e. <'L. ..~ ~Nq r:::: '<> , .s ~ "~IV/~' 54 (TYP. of' w, GItOfN)rz t ~i5.t " -\\."- .~ , <4~. , . ~ :I :r ~ 751-r. TO Rf:6IPENGe: \ ~Me.c> : l'Et"......I~'f" ~ ~~o..e- ~N/:r~T1'I~ EACH ,54 ,LON6 ~ $4' ~l.OW -rOP OF f>VL-KI-!;{AP. l> ] J: ~ SX~~~ it' I~,;\ ~,.. 5':>> $ DEC-1~-98 TUE 11:139 AM REG1 BMHP NYSDEC . 516 444 13297 . . New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Of'ic~ of Natural Resources Charles lIamllton . Regional Supervisor Bllildinll40 - SUNY, Stony Brook, NY 11700-1356 Telephone: {516} 444-0270 Facsilllik: (516) 444-11272 FAX TRANSMISSION COVER SIII:J:T TO: ---- -J ''''''' L~....~ #PAGES + COVER: ~ FROM: CL..._c.... I..l.........: q....., DATE: , ~ I (rl SO e. MESSAGE: ~(""'A-.J TC- "-t~..... h A....t.. A..'l ~...<<,)/-.......~ .p.;tJ .. 51\..0'...... tt..(> cJ ~ ("1-____ r"lI .,...-e A... " ~ c -n-l- . P.B1 ~ ..... ~ JohnP. eahU! CommissIoner I;t_E-,;- 15.-:?.8 TUE 11:1219 AM Ri1 BMHP NYSDEC 516 444 0297 . P.02 . Memo To: Margaret M. Rourke 1 From: Chris Arfsten Subject: Holman Prop. 1-4738-02089/01 Date: December 7,1998 . Chuck Hamilton and 1 field inspected this appliclItioll 01111123/98, and hAve the followine objections and modification requests. TIle existing groins are too long. Earlil:r the same day we met with John Costello of Costello Marine Contracting ami JlIwny King uf Suull101d Town for.... ..ppli=linn (Roman..m 1-4738- 02075101) that was almost identical to this one. The Town of Southold and The Marine Habitat Protection Unit lu1vc initiated an effort to reaoh uniform deci$ions on projects involviIU!: tidal wetl"",ci3 in th.. Town. Among the three pllrt;e.~ present for this meeting 1 inspection the following agreements were reached. . The vast majority of the groins along this section of Oreat Pcconic Bay are too long. The length of these groins should not e:xceed a length greater than the: ML W mark. Also the vast majority are too high and should be reduced in height. . The following objections and modifications are required: 1. The plan submillc<l is ina!Xw:ate, the groin on the western boundaJ)' oflhe property is in line with the existing return, not off set as shown. 2. The three groins, one at 65' and two at 50' will be reduced to 36' (west), 32'(middle:} and 18'(east} respectively which reflect the AML W mark as depicted on the plans submitted by Costello Marine Contr. 3. The elevation of the groin will not exceed a height that is less than 3' 3" from the top of the bulkhead. . ___D_:S:_~~~-=_';I!L.TUE__ 11 :10 AM Ri1 BMHP NYSDEC 516 444 02';17 . P.03 . 13) SPECIAl. CONDITIONS: } \ NOTES: ..~ ~ Wr:-~ ~1"lIL ~ ~ 1 ~1 /-A;;tO~J ~.~ ~ ~~-J~ ~~ y/~ ~~.(2H~~1/ .ke ~uuol /tJ 36./~f~~~ .lV4d~'f- . JL-K~~ <&- ,6~7 ~I 31 3 IJr ~ Vop 'l 'f-k ~d ~ .'," r ~ l l ) 1 c;.R-u/J ~ . ., .. Telephone (516) 765-1801 Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 SOUTHOLD TOWN CONSERVATION ADVISORY COUNCIL At the meeting of the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council held Tuesday, December 15, 1998 the following recommendation was made: No. 1610 Moved by Melvyn Morris, seconded by Kenneth Meskill, it was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees APPROVAL of the Wetland Permit Application of BUD HOlMAN 123-7-8 to reconstruct three (3) low profile jetties, 1 jetty 65' and two jetties 50' each. 350 Park Avenue, Mattituck Vote of Council: Ayes: All Motion Carried -- -"u.HT' : Mr. l!UO ~ 1"O.S.Ol<.... .,.,.8 i"\b.:rf'T\J..... I t-J"1'. 11'l....Z. .!-'60 "1'-""" A:ve.-. M~rT\JCI<- , N'I', "'l"Sl. ~,*,: Ib.... 'IZ-!o .7,& Wbl~~ boMI-\W A.T "M.l~~ . --.. - .- ., . ( . fper- V--t> .'l I .. CD~I,..O HMz.tNI!;..- <:!D~-rll..-taj ~ . 1":D.1!ol<.... 2-12~ ~~,...., 1-1'1'. 11"'l44- 51<.. . 471 . I jC'f"l SIae. : :ee..I~ 1 ~ -\ \ (7"::!) -) (18) (I~ -+ (A)1IlWV <-,"'v ,/ j...nr~ 0IUt"T' /' @) e #,{S' ~~: 4fZEAi f'!:..CDl\Jlc--e.A"( ~~c:;r ~ l.D... ~\..e,. ~N I :nom,," (') <<! 1.5"1: ""'0 (1) ~ ~o':l: . L.ln'Tlf.. -: b.1.\... ~~ 1b 1!E .war. ';"Pf'e.o ~M>lb.N1U'0 ~" L-'lr1_...... __ ~ . ~.. - R flU '. ,. Ui tV l.~ ~L_._. t<<)V - 2 1998 . (]) ~. J.O" - - - - o 10' 10' !:O)l.ISTft-l4 t5UL~) ,., ~N \ ~ i Ii8e ~, ~ 6J,) rl . ,,' ./,' rt, I. (~. .4- (/ ~. j-. OGo"0CE.fl-:S ,1"I"l8 SIIee;r' 2., ~F- $ )' ; . · ~"&-{, · ill c...os-tl!Li...b HAJUt.1t:.- CDN~""t'"IN4 CbfZ.P. 0 'P.O. ~:iWV't' 6r~PDP:\, NY. ll9Jt4 ~IG. . 417 . 11<=19 -,., rn @ ~ t<<lV - 2 /998 b.f'p\,.1~T; ~. suo +lO\.MAN 1"".D._ .,n ~rr\lC.I<-, N.... lI'lSz. 3.S-<> ~ A:>/e.. t1MfrT"ue.t<- . N'. 11.,S2- ~-n1 '" : IbO<> - 12.3 -? -<11 . ~I"-I / :re:rIY . (I)~a_e 1a'5"'~ , l~)~ :so'j: ( ~e&) TOWN OF SOUTH";'!' " .:::.... eL..e..Vl>.I\ON ..; -- - - ~1"""": o z' 10' (~...tt"""'7'~ 7~% TO _ ~o~ (3') Y t W13't ~)r . (AM~V'I)D. ' (AMl-.l ) ( .., JR>t12>,., ( AMtIW) ~, Au. t+~ "l2> -e..*,"".p~ GrA1-VN-I\Z.l!.P, o\.l....... UJMP6"-"12> M- ~iC . (l"n..e. ~TlO"-l e.', ~-ntt1J<!! -'1'1'<>'1'0'" 4-' ) .:f"\..Jl.N VI r;;w ~ 1~t.l<:r1!lU~~\ \'~~N j \" .. t " ~"-l ::rt;my (l)ft>of>DsU>7lt 'j: (Z)~<!.'SD':!: l ~es) h t ~i.t '\ \ i 7S':t -ro_ l"<>S't>eOJc.r; ~r:..) /, , ' ~f'OlIN<f!Y / / 'NoU-e. / ~Nqr ( 6o)11..W) V)J>.les) ) . . / />.M>t'fI\ . .l,:'S~E-~F f'1;Lbpl)/!,ItC> : ~~-r ~ ~~~ ~11>l/:reTfl\!!S (0\ @ ,-,,'ct ~t> (,.) ~ ~.:!: . oc.""D~ -6", 1"l"I~ ~T S.!lP:$ ToWN H6lMAtJ IV)ATIITVGt. COSTELLO MARINE CONTRACTING CORPORATION DOCK BUILDING . JETTIES. BULKHEADING . STEEL & WOOD PILING' FOUNDATIONS I -- ,.tloL'tA" WEsr 7 .~... (' ~ __I ,--,0 " r_...... .4.,1\ :,,". :~..~ . . . ~~ - ;=.=J ~ d :E :z :z: o ~ ." C/.) I o rv c= ill -l CD :J: = oL r0- o IAAl ~ ~ 1Wi! \= ,~~ ~;;. \~I ,'- I-T' , If O:l!C"'<,>",,.... UP, f:,..c !:!; ; Ii ,i ~I i! I 'IIPI " P g , ~ g i . ~ I /f!1l iii'i III I rliej IlIPI Ill! I, i it i i i 111I I I IIIII J iiiii'l IIIII IIIP IIHi i i i ~ ~ II I I I ;, I ~ ~ ~ ijI II IIIII !Hill! (rrrr :: riff! !!ll} -~!., ~ mi!~ i:I~; - . , , ! = . ~ ~ &' Q. ~~n '00 ~~~ i~~ ~ .00 !)( TI ,~ .~ v> ~8.~~ zn -n <~o ~~~ 'OJ n ~ ""'1:: ...."',. ~' , - \1 ~ ~ , I ! i ! ~ II 0; g ~ i' o r 8 . i '1 t ~ ""'- ~ ~ '"',., '"-s ~. ~-" -~, \ ! I i I I --' is ...J ~, ~ /' ~'f', ---L.L.L.', Ii ~i I .in !,~ I . . i ,.,"--- 'i'~~"---_+ "(Wl ~.~ NO. ~ ~ '">EE'">EC.NIl,l21 21! -OS-lie. Ii r}1 ~ , 5 . ..>> '4{ , .~-~~~;. - ~ '~ ..;.." ..- ~ ~........::::. "'.... '(.)-:Y . '\ ~ ~ - m ~ '" " \": ~ g ~ (_.-.~ ~. \ , ~ " 't.~ " --- ... t 1 ....,. --- "" '"' ~ -,\ ~ "'- . ""''' I'\\. '" \ ~ ~ ~ -t--o .....'\ '( 't ">- "- \\ \... ~. '1 L '- """ T\ ~- ., r-' ~ " 'l\ , "- '-' 'l. ..., '-" " ----------- '::hI C' >' ("oC'" oS: h / S/e1L.... I"',,,-y , ~ y,llfFOl.t 'n ~.t'~~ ~ ~" == ~~, Q . (.1 '" ""'if 'o!:; J:!'j ~. ,,"'~ ~ ~.;, ~OJ + i-9 . Ai bert J. Krupski. President John Holzapfel. Vice President Jim King Martin H. Garrell Peter Wenczel Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold. New York 1197\ Telephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD ORIGINAL Office Use Only Coastal Erosion Permit Application ~Wetland Permit Application ---Grandfather Permit Application ---waiver/Amendment/Changes ~Received Application: 111~)9f V'Received Fee:$ ISO.Db Completed Application 111~J9B Incomplete SEQRA Classification: Type I Type II Unlisted Coordination: (date sent) ---- "CAC Referral Sent: '~15 ~Date of Inspection: I Receipt of CAC Report: Lead Agency Determination: Technical Review: ~ Public Hearing Held: 1#-IIf>J9/t Resolution: - m ~ & ~ i' .;. TOWN :F ~~~:0: U I ~o 82-. Name of Applicant Bill) H t\Lf'-IAN Address -P.O.BD)<' q'1~ I MATrITUc..K, N~ 1195.;L Phone Number: (5/~) ~98- 48',1.5" Suffolk County Tax Map Number: 1000 - L.21-7-g Property Location: .:tSc:> pA"R"I::: A\IE./IlUE. I I\.\ATrlTllc..k (provide LILCO Pole #, distance to cross streets, and location) AGENT: COSTE":LL..6 M,6,1~-'NE. c..oNrRflc...,fNro COR~. (If applicable) Address: "p.O. :BO,K .:l.l.;l't J G,~ E E::N POl?T I t--L~r II'! <.J..lf P~~:~fJ~ 11l-6JJJ-r 1 1Itard of Trustees APPlicati~ GENERAL DATA Land Area (in square feet): Z6 000 to.,. , Area Zoning: S I NCL E FAl-tll Y RES I bENTtA L IIIATI!.I?F'Rl'>Ni Previous use of property: 'REst.D"'l-l-rt AL Intended use of property: NoD c.J.+JHJ&. E: Prior permits/approvals for site improvements: Agency Date . UN.\O.ID\LH{ No prior permits/approvals for site improvements. Has any permit/approval ever been revoked or suspended by a governmental agency? ./ No Yes If yes, provide explanation: ",fA . Project Description (use attachments if necessary): RE.C.ON-5TRll c..T THR.E.E- '-oW PRbFILE.. 3"E..TTIE"J I I I - ras -r d - SO ' 2 . '.....,~ ~"'''*~ . Board . . of Trustees Application WETLAND/TRUSTEE LANDS APPLICATION DATA Purpose of the proposed operations: MAl N-r,4.1 ~ EX!."" I Nc. L E.\J E L Foe. STRUC:to ~ E.S "'I- eX./.5T I N<;; BEAC'I-I Area of wetlands on lot: 5.TI>.SILI Ti 01=" BUU:..Ht:.AD AI/A_ I NIA I BEAcH A'REA 5E~WA~D oF" J30~1-/E/U) square feet Percent coverage of lot: % Closest distance between nearest existing structure and upland edge of wetlands: ^If,4 feet I Closest edge of distance between nearest proposed wetlands: ^/IA f~et I structure and upland Does the project involve excavation or filling? ,/ No Yes If yes, how much material will be excavated? II/)}l I cubic yards Depth of which material will be feet N/A " removed or cubic yards How much material will be filled? Proposed slope throughout the area of operations: deposited: II//A I N/A , Manner in which material will be removed or deposited: NIA I Statement of the effect, if any, on the wetlands and tidal waters of the town that may result by reason os such proposed operations (use attachments if appropriate): Nt') t-I~ATI\I E... E=:Ff E:.-rT) 3 E.TT \ E.S ARE /;,,/(/.<;1/ J-.Jc. II . -.~~-"tt." . . NOTICE TO ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNER BOARD OF TRUSTEES, TOWN OF SOUTHOLD In the matter of "F,1\l') 1-\ ()l MAN SCTMlIlOOO- 1.:13- 7- 'il: YOU ARE HEREBY GIVEN NOTICE: 1. That it is the intention of the undersigned to request a Permit from the Board of Trustees to: RECDI.lSTRIlCT -n+RE..E.. E 'kr."'.T/NC;; .,"Flr IE..'" 2. That the property which is the subject Environmental Review is located adjacent to your property and is described as follows: .'LC;O?A Rk. A \/ !":NI J ~ A.R'f.A NA1) ON p~():\j:'{',... PL../H15 3. That the property which is subject to Environmental Review under Chapters 32,37,or 97 of the Town Code is open to public comment. You may contact the Trustees Office at 765-1892 or in writing. The above referenced proposal is under review of the Board of Trustees of the Town of Southold and dose not reference any other adjacent that might have to review same proposal. OWNERS NAME: BUD H 0 L ~-A N. MAILING ADDRESS: 1~ ~~~~~~l () i"R'NE. c.ONrR~T/N6 ?{).,BO'f. d.l.::14, t;. ; N f19'fLf PHONE #: co\<'.P. Ene.: Copy of sketch or plan Showing proposal for your convenience. .., ,\\ ~r:~ -21~ ... :ro~sOU\h ,~ 5 , . . Albert J. Krupski, President James King, Vice-President Henry Smith Artie Foster Ken Poliwoda Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Telephone (516) 765-18lt2 Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TRUSTEES: BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD TOWN OF SOUTHOLD In the Matter of the Application of _____~~Jl__lio~ii--------_____ COUNTY OF SUFFOLK) STATE OF NEW YORK) AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING I,:J"OHN A. COSTELLO, residing at ~j['I'"l='NPO~T NEIAJ '1DRK being duly sworn, depose and say: That on the.3 R!l day ot>"'CE'H!lf,R 199 , I personally posted the property known aSIOOI'l-I::l.3-7-Rel ~~O :PA'll'l::)\IIFNllf:. MA1"'TI'TIJC'K NJ by placing the Board of Truste s official poster where it can' 1 easily be seen, and that I have checked to be sure the poster has remained in place for seven days prior to the date of the public hearing. (date of hearing noted thereon to be held~,lqq~ on oc- aboUt ') ~ 00 Q 1'(\ , Dated: 12./3 In'' Sworn to before me this 31!D day of [)€C.EI"lf5E~ 1998' U! kftAA) i ~ NOtary Public SUSAN E. LONG Notary Public. State of New York No.01L04968343 Qualified in Suffolk County _ QQ Commisalon Expires November 6. 1lU..1 ""~"'~,;"-~,-,-!",,,,,".. ~'.,:~~~ II f s'jert 'Jtom Memo ~- ~% N-o ~~ SUE LONG I~O [)~ \fVJr ' ~-k &dJVV\ ~ - ~ ~ , /" ~ @ ~ D ~t~"f, ELLO ylARINE CONTRACTING CORP ! P.O Box 2124 . Nnv - 9 1998 " Greenport. NY 11<)44 " '1.1 (516)4771199 ;1-..1! tIOWN OF sCiTJi1~, r ' -- -"- Z ?5'O 45'3 271 ~ Receipt for X::' Certified Mail ___ No Insurance Coverage Provided ~=a Do not use for International Mail (See Reverse) S tto ( nniS ().Lt~ 1.((,.( Postege Certified Fee Speciel Deliverv Fee Restricted Delivery Fee <') 0) ~ Return Receipt ShowiDg .r: toWhom&Date~ ~ Return Receipt'Sh ing ~ Date, and Ad4ress 's A .. TOTAL PostaQi!l_ 1- o &Fees ., o ClI l'l E o "- '{l Postmark or Diiq!:, :: Ilfr r $.3~ 1.71 . \ \".' ill. 7 r----------- ; - ~: -.[ =- { p ~~ ........ 01 ~l:t'~(S Sent 10 P 812 ~ Certifi .x:.. No Insur; ........ Do not u ~~ (See Re, Sent 10 Postage Postage Certified Fee Certified Fee Certified Fee Special De)iver~ Special Delivery Special Delivery Fee Restricted Deliv Restricted Delivl Restricted Delivery Fee '" en Return Receipt Return Receipt: en 0 Return Receipt Showin! to Whom & Del en to Whom &,DaIE g "" ~ Return R~ipt , to Whom & Dale Deliva e Return Receipt ~ <tl Date, and Addr' " Dale, & Add~s Return Receipt Showin. ::; c " Date, & Address of Deli ~ c 0 TOTAL Postage -, TOTAl. Postage ~ & Fees o & Fees -, TOTAL Postage 0 Postmark or D 0 0 & Fee, CIl CO Postmark or Oal 0 l'l '" CO Postmark or Date E '" E E 5 ~ ~ "- en en 0- 0- en 0- STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF SUFFOLK -~ 812 ~ CertifiE ~"No Insurar ___ Do not USE ~:r~T~~ (See Reve P ,Stale & ZIP Code Postage Certified Fee Special Delivery Fee Restricted De/ivery Fee o Return Receipt Showing en to Whom & Date DeliveTed ~ Q) Return Receipt Sh~ing 10 .5 Dale, & Address of beJivery :. TOTAL Postage Q &Fees o CO Postmark or Date '" E ~ en 0- E- 812 580 223 ~ ~ Certified Mail Receipt ~. No Insurance Coverage Provided __ Do not use for International Mail .':;;a'E~'-~:::SE (See Reverse) Sent to , '""'" Certified Fee Special Delivery Fee Restricted Delivery Fee o Return Receipt Showing en to Whom & Date Deli...~~' ~ Return Receipt Shqwlng ~OWhoWJ" Date, & Address otDeMv y " c ~ ., TOTAL Postaie ci & Fees ~ Postmark or bafe . '" E ~ en 0- I ~~ ~~ ~ residing at FRflNT SiRf:Ei c:~ p ':f ' being duly sworn, deposes and says that on the ~D11\ day of ~c\C"\.lSF-R.. ,1~, deponent mailed a true copy of the Notice set forth in the Board of Trustees Application, directed to each of the above named persons at the addresses set opposite there respective names; that the addresses set opposite the names of said persons are the address of said persons as shown on the current assessment roll of the Town of Southold; that said Notices were mailed at the United States Post Office at C:j<::E:I2.N.\>t)~1 , that said Notices were mailed to each of said persons by (certified) (registered) mail. Sworn to before me this ~qth day of ()(',ID.RE.R.. ,19 'l<ir . ..b<l&l! C. ~ - Notary Public Lr CI VvIL- SUSAN E.lONO Nol8ry Public. Slala 01 New Yark No.01L04968343 Qualified in Suffolk Coull1Y _ a a Comml.llan Expires November 8, 1LJ.1 6 oo~~~~wrq~ tIlV - 2 1998 '.11 I I _~.,J TOWN OF SOUIJ~'i . . County of Suffolk State of New York ) .30l1-N A \ ~DST E/.,}...C> BEING DULY SWORN DEPOSES AND AFFIRMS THAT HE ... IS THE APPLICANT FOR THE ABOVE DESCRIBED PERMIT(S) AND THAT ALL STATEMENTS CONTAINED HEREIN ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF HIS/.., KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF, AND THAT WORK WILL BE DONE IN THE MANNER SET FORTH IN THIS APPLICATION AND AS MAY BE APPROVED BY THE SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF TRUSTEES. THE APPLICANT AGREES TO HOLD THE TOWN, OF SOUTHOLD AND THE TOWN TRUSTEES HARMLESS AND FREE FROM ANY AND ALL DAMAGES AND CLAIMS ARISING UNDER OR BY VIRTUE OF SAID PERMIT(S), IF GRANTED. IN coMPLETING THIS APPLICATION, 1 HEREBY AUTHORIZE THE TRUSTEES, THEIR AGENT(S) OR REPRESENTATIVE(s), TO ENTER ONTO MY PROPERTY TO. INSPECT THE PREMISES IN CONJUNCTION WITH REVIEW OF THIS APPLICATION. ' a~ SIGNATURE "'l'l,)JO SWORN TO BEFORE ME THIS ~~. DAY OF Oc.. TClSE:R.. ,1933 j"MMJ [ ~ NOTARY PUBLIC SUSAN E. LONG Notllry Public. State of New VOlt No. 01L04958343 CoIr-~~"'=:~1: 1ill Suggested space for location Map THIS IS NOT A PERMIT 7 . . ==~ ~~ '~-:-~ COSTEllO MARINE CONTRACTING CORPORATION DOCK BUILDING' JETTIES. BULKHEADING' STEEL & WOOD PILING' FLOATS 423 FIFTH STREET, P.O. BOX 2124 . GREENPORT, NEW YORK 11944 . (516) 477-1199/477-1393/477-0682 FAX - (516)477-0005 AUTHORIZATION FORM Date: ;w~ 1, GI.)}' c~t~7k~::~~" /'J., ~.IJ I \ d I located at /h~~~ J.J.-.-.... ):'Z( v owner Jf) / 1'-- of 3) 0",,01./1. ((~ -k,,,.( ~ein~/Property Name do hereby give Costello Marine Contracting Corp, the authority to act as agent in my behalf in applying for all of the necessary permits in order for work to be done on my property described above. ~) 2_rll}.c 'J/L /JC,C{,, ro': ..L_-......._..... . . ..W41ziBlI-Te,( 12 PROJECT I.D. NUMBER 611-.21 Appendix C stete Environmental Quality Review SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM For UNLlSTI;O ACTIONS Oilly ART 1-r.I>ROJECT'INFORMATlON (To b. completed by Appllcanl or proJect sponsor) ;'" . I. APPUCANT./SPONSOR 2, PROJECT NAME Costello Marine contracting Corp. 3. PROJECT LOCATION: NATTI TUC- Mvnlclp'l1ly T Co"nly S u f folk .... PRECise LOCATION ,Streel addresS and foad I.nlersecllons. pronl1nenllandmarks. elc., or provide map) SEaR See Attached area map. 5. IS PROPOSED ACTION: o New 0 elC~anslon 8. DESCRIBE PROJECT BRIEFLY: o ModHlcatlonlallerallon S (l) ~5' -r (d..) 50' 1(EC6f-.\3,RVeT TI-\-~E-E :5 E. TTI12S , 7. AMOUNT OF LAN8 AFFECTED: 0 Initially acres Ultimately acre! 8. WILL PROPOSED ACTION COMPLY WITH eXISTING ZONING OR OTHER EX1SflNG LAND USE RESTRICTIONS? (ZJ Yes 0 No II No, describe brIefly 9. WHAT IS PRESENT LAND USE IN VICINITY OF PROJECT? ~ Residential 0 Industrial 0 CommercIal DescrIbe: o Agrlcullure o Palk/ForesllOpen space o OIhe' 10. DOES ACTION INVOLVE A PERMIT APPROVAL. OR FUNDING. NOW OR ULTIMATELY FROM ANY OTHER GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY IFEDERAL. STATE OR LoCAL)? ~ Yes 0 No If yes. list agencyls) and perrnl11approval5 WATERFRONT NYS DEC, ACOE T61.lJf..\ of- SOU L. 1'- DOES ANY ASPECT OF THE ACTION HAVE A CURRENTLY VAllO PERMIT OR APPROVAL? o Ye5 ~o If yes, IIs1 agency name and permlllappro'ial 12. AS A RESULT OF PROPOSED ACTION WILL EXISTING PERMIT/APPROVAL REOUIRE MODIFICATION? DYe. mHo I CERTIFY THAT THE INFORMATION pnOVIDED ABOVE IS TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE CONTRACTING O:le I~/ 1';'/9 ~ I I 510nalu1e: lithe 8cllon Is In the Coastal Area, and you are a state agency, complete the Coastal Assessment Form belore proceeding wlth,lhls assessment OVER 1 . f'lZE:r"..IEf" 1W ' ..' GOSfl:.U..D HM!..nJt::-- CO~<:, ~. "P. ~ . 1W)(.. 2-12.4- <'1rU'--Nf"D1i!;\'",!\l:{ "q4<\- ~lto . 471' . 11"19 J' .....;........ (~~. ~~11._ ~\' ~16 ~I " $ <IClOO . t> Z. (l"PDI-1 ~ <><:l'lNT"1' ~) VICII\1ITY ~} f'~Dt> \\\.- ~ ~-r ~t.-1;A.-( (~I....<!t ~-y2:>~) L-Q~\'ID~ Mb-f::>: Af"'\A~ ~ t1~......0 HOL~ ~l'fl!.. : 'P.O. eol'- ",\""8 t'\IoOl1'rTUGl<-, "-1"1'. 11"fS2- Sc:r-H~' 1"'t>6-'...~.1'-!\ .J,'SO ~~e-. ~rT\!<:AL-, Ni. 1I.,'Sz.. ~-r' ~ oY'l~: (!) MIL. WI~ C.OH~"" "11'11l!.1ol1~~ ~""'~IloYI~, NT. 11003 @1'I1>t.-~~t1M"1'~~l-I @l"A-'1'~bli!otl'- @11~.~I\!.-1*-"'""'"'" z,.?l. ~_ b.~. -to'l"S' ~UoN CL'it>. 410 ~ N:oIe, . _ ~rT1J.e.l'-. t-rf. 11"1'5':3- ~ J F..... 3041c:4 t\lRl'rt'UCA'-} 1'04'(, 11"1:52. @NI~~~~.n ....IZ- ~ />.v... . 1'1..-rrI"''' <.IL. , 101'< . 11"1'5'2- ~osr~ :. ~sne-uc.:>r' ~ U:>W f'1ZC4'-1LL- ~Ir-J j-.:ri!.:mes. , (I) ~ rr.;':i: boNe> (2.') e 5ll':i: . bol..L. ~....... l5I!!- +10.... t>lf'f"1IO ~VAHI~ 1 .u.... L.ut11!l1'l'- 1'b se ~~O .. . :01 'iI loJO'T'e- : ~ @ lli_. NOV - 2 1998 .De.-r~ ~,I..q~ ~-r' I '* S . .:--- . . Albert J. Krupski, President James King, Vice-President Henry Smith Artie Foster Ken Poliwoda Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, N ew York 11971 Telephone (516) 765-18!fl Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD BOARD OF TRUSTEES: TOWN OF SOUTHOLD ----------------------------------- ORIGINAL In the Matter of the Application of _____J2~12__}lo~1i------------- COUNTY OF SUFFOLK) STATE OF NEW YORK) AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING I,:rOHN A. C.OSTELLO, residing at c;l::.I'"I'"Nf'o~T NElAJ 'f DRK being duly sworn, depose and say: That on the.3 RJ> day ofl>l>C.EH!lf,R 199 , I personally posted the property known aSIOOI'l-I~3-7-Re' ~SO ~A~\:: AIIFNIlE:. MA-rTI-rIJC'K N~ by placing the Board of Truste s official poster where it can ' J easily be seen, and that I have checked to be sure the poster has remained in place for seven days prior to the date of the public hearing. (date of hearing noted thereon to be held~,lqqt on or aboUt ')~OO ()fC\' Dated: IZ./3}9'if Sworn to before me this 3 ~D day of D€C.EJ'-\f5.E~199S' u; ~)L~ NOtary Public SUSAN E. LONG Notary Public. State 01 New York No.Oll0495B343 Qualified in Suffolk County _ QQ Commission Expires November 6, tll.J..l NOTICE OF HEARING NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a public hearing will be held by the SOUTH OLD BOARD OF TRUSTEES at the Town Hall, 53095 Main Road, Southold, New York, concerning this property. . OWNER(S) OF RECORD: 'l>uo ~'~n SUBJECT OF PUBLIC HEARING: 'RtCO,,'at-rUL-t ~&oHt4J TIME & DATE OF PUBLIC HEARING:1)ec.tflaIQQt . en c:>r"' a.licu..'\' 1)4.co pm. If you have an interest in this project, you are invited to view the Town file(s) ~hich are available for inspection prior to the day of the hearing during normal business days between the hours ot 8 a.m and 4 p.m. - BOARD OF TRUSTEES * TOWN OF SOUTHOLD * (516) 765-1892