HomeMy WebLinkAboutSD-108 �,.
BUILDING-STRUCTURE INVENTORY FORM FOR OFFICE USE ONLY
3�
DIVISION FOR HISTORIC PRESERVATION UNIQUE SITE N0�6.3��•�t.'
QUAD SO 108
NEW YORK STATE PARKS AND RECREATION SERIES
ALBANY, NEW YORK (519) 474-0479 NEG. NO.
YOUR NAME: Town of S old / S PLIA DATE; January„ ,-1987
Southold, L.I. , N.Y. 11971
YOUR ADDRESS: Town Hall, Main Road-__TELEPHONE: (516) 765-1892
ORGANIZATION (if any): Southold Town Community Development Office
IDENTIFICATION
I. BUILDING NAME(S): 8t3n_4th*n JP.nni S 1d. Glover house_
2. COUNTY: Suffolk TOWN/CITY: Southold VILLAGE: Southold
3. STREET LOCATION: Main Bayview Rd. at Ba water Rd. south west corner
4. OWNERSHIP: a. public F1 h private
5. PRESENT OWNERPtanley Karanewski ADDRESS: same
6 USE: Original: Residence Present: Residence
7. ACCESSIBILITY TO PUBLIC. Exterior visible from public road: Yes KI No ❑
Interior accessible: Explain
DESCRIPTION
9. BUILDING a. clapboard KI b. stone ❑ c. brick ❑ d. board and batten ❑
MATERIAL: e. cobblestone ❑ f. shingles ❑ g. stucco ❑ other:
'). STRUCTURAL. a. wood frame with interlocking joints 23
SYSTEM: b. wood frame with light members ❑
(if known) c. masonry load bearing walls ❑
d. metal (explain)
e. other brick foundation
10. CONDITION: .1. excellent ❑ b. good 23 c. fair ❑ d. deteriorated ❑
11. INTEGRITY: a. original site ❑ b. mowed ❑ if so,when'!
c. list major alterations and dates (if known):
SD-RSM XV-24
12. PHOTO: from south 13. MAP: N.Y.S. DOT Southold Quad
South (front) and west elevation LV iOw H Ii.
Cem zt
F NIE�
9 .
25 g
14
:, ..Laughing
Water's'
1 [ south t6;bor
i Park •$rf:•z r'•
f
•tir; ,.. ;.� �.r.•;� _ -_:. � og Neck
Baii
-- H
SD 108
14. THREATS TO BUILDING: a. none known b. zoning ❑ c. roads ❑
d. developers ❑ e. deterioration ❑
f. other:
15. RELATED OUTBUILDINGS AND PROPERTY:
J. barn❑ b. carriage house ❑ C. garage ❑
d. privy ❑ e. shed ❑ f. greenhouse ❑
g. shop ❑ h. gardens ❑
i. landscape features:
j. other:
16. :SURROUNDINGS OF THE. BUILDING (check more than one if necessary):
a.open land X b. woodland KI
C. scattered buildings
d.densely built-up ❑ e. commercial ❑
f. industrial ❑ g. residential ❑
h.other:
17. INTI-RRELATIONSHIP OF BUILDING AND SURROUNDINGS:
(Indicate if building or structure is in an historic district)
Low density, quiet country road, with houses surrounded
by expanses of open Fields and farmland.
18. OTHER NOTABLE FEATURES OF BUILDING AND SITE (including interior features if known):
1�-story, 4-bay gable roof house facing south with
off-center entrance and center chimney.
SIGNIFICANCE
11►. DA-1 I- OF INITIAL CONSTRUCTION: _ 1761 --
ARCHITECT:
BUILDER:
_'[I. HISTORICAL AND ARCHITECTURAL IMPORTANCE:
Brick oven.
This small old house is barely visible behind its shrubs
and trees. It would be a great addition to the street-
scape if it could be seen.
21. SOURCES: Currie—Bell. Old Southold Town's Tercentenary.
1940. P. 142
Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission
22. THL N1C: Report. 9/10/1984
Form prepared by Rosemary Skye Moritt, research
assistant.
SD 108 C
'fT `
` •.LRS} � �1
SODOM SCHOOL DISTRICT'
in 1340
Y
i
Vti
4
Sado+ St�e �o „+sx eya.r .a1 P ,14'Pa
v+ o N
+` . . P r n H E c xt1;
1 4+ N 2 05
o
h a4 *5'r.lol4a ,1�, y j�ar�ar4o.
t
•'t o t °• yy4 SCDCOr1
d
• { �.,T.• H.11ecti u�ra SCHOM x15TRIC.T
A; i . s....... a (GIItGA It.a)
z t
• ! o
*% \ *' bs
Fro t v
� K
,N1rr1'i•.f and fr.rGlrlc prr,lKlrrl h' I! �,l.rue! Irr]trarlr. .1t.1P r111.1 it.l:�rin�
R
.• ,fr�, ;. hj .lirrx Rrii/;lltrr. 7-r,re'r1rF, 1'l.rrrui►r, C.rrrntiy+rner. 1941.
r
l)tittL .incs indicate a road not in alsc in I v
Y 1 1 J4 Gr�.
r �i a map from:
r�•tr'y1
WALT WHITMAN AT SOUTHOLD
by Catherine Molinoff
i r3 C .W.Dost College
f _ 4 of series of monographs
BUILDING-STRUCTURE INVENTORY FORM FOR OFFICE USE ONLY ;D 108
UNIQUE SITE NO.
DIVISION FOR HISTORIC PRESERVATION QUAD
NEW YORK STATE PARKS AND RECREATION SERIES
ALBANY, NEW YORK (SIR) 474.4474 NEG NO
BA(-PH 1NIt-WAA4
YOUR NAME: JOY' 3 G A DATE: Q I '
MAIN ROAP, 0Ric/17- H9577 a3 31aV-(a
YOUR ADDRESS:37Y WAM t)W WAY 5ouarltc`D TELEPHONE: ] t,s- -s'31# 7
ORGANIZATION (if any): S aw i n.-D /c,v.J 4N,0Af144KS r h'L'sE it 77011 C"4 M r SS/(L%.)
IDENTIFICATION
1. BUILDING NAME(S):. K 14RA tV tV.SKI Hd u�,C t bi'�7�. J td1G�l lr h j
2. COUNTY: 5UPP:QLk - TOWN/CITY: 500TI4414-2 VILLAGE: SCU'U404-12
3. STREET LOCATION: 94Y0CW n°D A7 f/y,6!R5C- 716*' .UJ7W SDo,tl 1.4401,300, KD, s00rdof-D
4- OWNERSHIP: a. public ❑ Ix private a
5. PRESENT OWNER: 9r,,}A:461Y KAAA1V~Ws Ki ADDRESS: 43,0 EW RD; 5 ;r40L0 097/
N. USE: Original: IVAI g Present: N CFl c=
7. ACCESSIBILITY TO PUBLIC: Exterior visible from public road: Yes ❑ No f,O-IiI&Ir OVY149S
Interior accessible: Explain PR,VAT- HOME
DESCRIPTION
R. BUILDING a. clapboard b. stone ❑ c. brick ❑ d. board and batten ❑
MATERIAL: e. cobblestone ❑ f. shingles ❑ g. stucco ❑ other:
1). STRUCTURAL a. wood frame with interlocking joints
SYSTEM: b. wood frame with light members ❑
(if known) c. masonry load bearing walls❑
d. metal (explain)
e. other
10. CONDITION: a. excellent ❑ b. good c. fair ❑ d. deteriorated ❑
11. INTEGRITY: a. original site I b. moved ❑ - if so,when?
c. list major alterations and dates (if known): C�ENTqA4 011'qiVG}' 5 r iL4e ,}No rifr
8A Z k-i L'-'6'4c-'e I'"I PL1)C.0 S14 m 01CV 197' z lW i 441VCo;� 6141-G 0'V '01V&:'_C140ivlNcY srAcK ) IZF801Lr t:,
LCIUC�)NAL F1RrP4);Cc-5 PtZeg3AQe' kVop
12. PHOTO: )3r cK w:fN� ,aDp uA dpi i ►1 13. MAP:
25
C� Four
{� 1��✓'. Lan,
Q pckey Cr
S
5 UTAOL
J � Fr-'
l sem' doss d p s.
tiro t=^
mc
tom~' C� t.�RI:.AT.>�HQG�r
Biu �.� :, :j � •
Gr. �'A Y�VJ E VJ
SD lab
14. THREATS TO BUILDING: a.none known X b.zoning❑ c. roads ❑
d. developers ❑ e. deterioration ❑
f. other:
1.5. RELATED OUTBUILDINGS AND PROPERTY:
a. barn X b. carriage house ❑ c. garage ❑
d.privy 0' e. shed ❑ f. greenhouse ❑
g. shop ❑ h. gardens ❑
L landscape features: 1416-11 NUC-PS RIRROVAQ Cf S+196"5
j. other:
16. SURROUNDINGS OF THE BUILDING (check more than one if necessary):
a.open land ❑ b. woodland ❑
c.scattered buildings
d..densely built-up ❑ e. commercial ❑
f. industrial ❑ g. residential C'
h.other:
17. INTERRELATIONSHIP OF BUILDING AND SURROUNDINGS:
(Indicate if building or structure is in an historic district)
18. OTHER NOTABLE FEATURES OF BUILDING AND SITE (including interior features if known).
NDT MUCH 1jLrE141+TraN C-XCcPr CiAIl0VC y
RlGi+titL 9. RWIgS 00 c?ITHGA Sieg OF GNrR'4") U - a UF- Ti11125 r3i't7i2CCA.I
Si,44L[ AC(Nvi3 CE1 _A(J, - r1ELDSn)IVws ,r=/LLGD WIFH AASi-02, t'-, roo yt/lAV A T67A ceN�r ccr+c.
!9rrrie iZgFr6;A5 5/V%AL1_, uiVi IIVIsNti-O 4rJciD
SIGNIFICANCE
19. DATE OF INITIAL CONSTRUCTION: C - 17 4,0
ARCHITECT:
BUILDER:
20. HISTORICAL AND ARCHITECTURAL IMPORTANCE:
(,�CcCNi IR+�IeU a-i:`G` O IS `rl4 AT t=/ASS OW+V6Q, J0IVA7-11A/t:_ ��nl,lliNC5�
W,ls H fit±I LUT calor}Ry Wr+A sa`IJii:'rt w+_jo W:+s OA P ru iZt;U l31 7Wc--
r2lTJ5H PAI-56A 5,91P 141 V kl HAfd Ok)
I. SOURCES:
:?. THE1%IE:
Southold Town Landmarks 'reservation Commission. 9/10/84
Ralph Williams 323-3646
SD 108
Clapboard house of STANLEY KARANEWSKI
corner of Bayview & Baywater Avenues, Southold
765-1521
Built in 1761 - (in original condition? )
Built by Jonathan Jennings, who was improsoned by British in
Revolutionary War & died on a prison ship in N.Y. harbor.
Ship had hauled sugar from (Barbados? )
Called a "halfway house"
Owned by Doc Billy Glover c , 1900
Is a Cape Cod w/ added wing. Two chimneys .
r
Ralph Williams asked lir. Karanewski to call me
RESEARCH:
Riverhead Records room:. No deed
14«roK+w,rMitzi t s file of Revolutionary War Southold soldiers - no record
Mather' s Refugees to Connecticut shows two S4uthbld brothers , Ezekiel & Jonat
Jennings serving in the rd Line" of Col. Josiah Smith' s Regiment
in Revolutionary Lar (P. 427-8, 509) Biog. , P . 572.
Wrote National Archives, Washington D.C. for forms to fill out to get
military information and pension records of Jonathan Jennings
Also check State Archives for Connecticut. (N.Y. was British in Rev- War)
Southold Town 'Landmarks Preservation Commission. 9/10/84
9�R
SD 108
Jonathan Jennings in Riverhead Recird Room:
DATE GRANTEE GRANTOR LIBER PAGE
1819 Jonathan Jennings Benjamin Smi.ty E 53
1846 " " John Webb 43 407
Jere Terry
1849 Steve Jennings 44 3o6
53 10
1350 " " Henry 56 101
103
1 Oft
Southold Town Landmarks Preservation Commission. 9/JO/84
W e":-
0
\
,+ h ►"! r �r s p.+,� • f i. °e^t t� ,may
O ci tiYf ;fit+ y
000
dri
r _ 1
M
:hisY.
i }
Vj
------------
CD
N
JONATHAN JENNINGS HOUSE Southold JONATHAN JENNINGS HOUSE
Baywater Ave . at Maim Bayview Rd . , Southold
Photos & evaluation by Ralph ?,Tilliams
0
Original 1760' s kitchen fireplace replaced
0 by this one, c . 1860' s ,
0
Note original lintel reset high in brick wall. 1 .
�. Bake oven and ashpit from original. 1760' s House faces south.
0 now bricked up, but visible on right side Parlor to left (west) of entrance
of mantle . Oven and ashpit more visible in original kitchen (c . 1760 ' s) to right
photo #5 • 2 bedrooms (chambers) in half-story upstairs
4
Ul
Co
� A-S
y
aIL
�1 ♦ ` �. �' �-�-ate_ �q, r V
PO
ca
rI { r•
7-99
Jj
r r a
fD 1 �i• :�t1� ' rr+; � :}fit'�R.
lit
&CD W
C 4 F.
W�y�
o. JONATHAN JENNINGS HOUSE, JONATHAN JENNINGS HOUSE, JONATHAN JE�dNINGS HOUSE,
Southold Southold Southold
2 6 5
N
Close-up of front door - Half-story second floor has Close-up of kitchen fireplace
simple framing, dentils 2 chambers (bedrooms) i
under plain cornice reached by steep stairs . On right of fireplace can be
seen bricked up ashpit
Inside the door T' a small This east chamber shows from 1760 ' s, and more dl=tl.,y
vestibule or porchll, carelessly dtessed rafters over it can be seen an,
opening into a room on either (woodworking deteriorated in f earlier oven, also now
19th Century from the bricked up .
side meticulous early Colonial tj
wood work. F,
a
oa
Ox
�+
ZA
Cn
•a++ y
c�
F1 JONATHAN JENNINGS HOUSE, southold
W
3
0
:75 JONATHAN JENNINGS HOUSE, Parlor fireplace (back-to-back with
o Southold kitchen fireplace .
H8 Original mantle & fireplace c . 17601s )
M replaced by this one c . 1860 ' s .
cD
01' The pitched roof leaves little space in
the half-story attic bedroom walls Old trammel in fireplace .
`a Batten door leads into entrance vestibule .
\ Photos & evaluation by Ralph Williams
0
co
4
d
�I
d
Co
50 !Og .
war
14p AM r
S ' :.� .M 1r '`. I �F7 •S}- �ti h_Ir► '�" 7�'��r y..�� ,f} _pnfr.' a _.'��`, ,
`U , ~ tsi[�3 �� ��?- �'�t gra• a ! `��'" ... -- µ
h ..s ..-. ..
o• - 'y}., µ�� �x tl£. ' 1' v-tS c Ff`.- .�_S� r �.j � r�'--
L-1 1-4 Mw
I,i �1�Yi`-�^ fir. �� Far �� � ./'�- r� �.•.� -.S.% q. .� '<•� :.5-r r.
1 �1
�_ Il J-
1TvS�rr+"+
-5; Prmhrrton.
Kakr.2; llfrrrJilh. t; t11F1 i' .i mart s:r 7 ,non,1,3: 1 tGGo; #.
b
T 7 5� ,• ins Salmon,circ°r So-
�'hafo! y
� �unathan,eliot fitoson l
S r72,4r;
�Se11h 13. Reeve. T
C)
l `n Reeve, 04 the 17 �i:61. Samuel
Reeve,
ne vru d.iic,
Cosountot.u'mi le
ot.o 1104J9179 ttt House, 1 [
llarbar 'S f%�c' i
V fff V��e � �, t• ��.i ry{tt7:��i',t.',�,r1..�'lt��t''t:1..f'11t1ll::3
r
cn
tt is tj
�c"yry
• 'S 11 ,M1,117TTr.�•';',1'.4I�•1�;:'r•j•*��
SD 1 :
•.�I' F-Y.ti k � fi1\.. � '�'
F� _�J• - ✓ 6 YBp
Southold
The west ilpstairs bedroom (parlor chamber)
shows uncut
logs usedas braces •
Southold Town Landmarks
Preservation • i
SD 108
1
I James, was active To Daniel H. Horton was handed down the celebrated
id carrying on some Barnabas Horton Cask of 1640, which according to "Hortons
and the little house in America" (genealogy) was brought over from England by
the cannon balls are Barnabas filled with household goods (or legendary gold and
,rhead. In 1793 Col. silver which gave it its name of 'Uncle Barney's Money Pot'!)
rt, sons of Captain The cask has recently been presented by Mr. Horton to South-
where it now stands old Historical Society.
uding the two fire-
g, a single chimney 50. PRE-REVOLUTIONARY HOUSE
total cost was 300 Moved 1846 from Hogg Necke
d the James Tuthill Joshua Wells Hutchinson
(Mrs. Arthur B. Mitchell, South Harbor Lane,
iele of the late Miss Opposite Emerson's Road, Southold)
:himneys, preparing Joshua Wells Hutchinson, son of Elijah Hutchinson and �I
of Montgomery, Arminda Overton, was born 1820 in the Hutchinson family
nown as the "Uncle homestead (no longer existent) on lands stretching over South
fined in family own-
Harbor, Corey Creek Hutchinson's Creek territory. That home
,as the last Horton which faced Corey Creek stood far down the lane. "Wells" as
he was known descended on the line of Thomas from the
Thomas Hutchinson, "late of Lynne" and early Southold.
HOUSE Wells married in 1844 Julia Maria Smith, daughter of
George Washington Smith and Emma Reeve, daughter of
Sheriff, or Squire, Josiah of Aquebogue and Riverhead. Julia's
outhold) mother, Emma Reeve Smith lived when widowed in the
"Billie Doctor" house well known at the corner of jasper's
'ew Road was built Lane JBalwater Ave. anda iew Rom ou o now
ide Keturah Terry,' owned by Richard Weber). -Billy Doctorilliam 1 , Glover-
'.eeves. The central son-in-law.
ad. Additions were In 1846, two years after his marriage, J. Wells Hutchinson
n the 20th century, had an old house in Great Hogg Necke, Bay View, moved to
litia but he was a land neighboring his father's house on South Harbor Lane.
e was son of Capt. The kitchen wing also was moved from Hogg Necke. Unfor-
d brother of Col. tunately there is no record of the Hogg Necke location but an
on James Horton antiquarian authority has established the oldest parts of the
:hildren: Jonathan house as Pre-Revolutionary in origin. This is one of the finely
preserved old homes which has had its charm of antiquity
id Susan_ His son retained by Joshua Wells Hutchinson's granddaughter, the 1
d, marrying Lydia present owner. The house has grown through different periods {
orn 1824, married, and the construction features are clearly distinctive of their i
d, second, in I862 respective ages.
whom were born
knd Daniel Halsey 51. JOHN HOWELL HOUSE 1827
if Daniel H. Hor- Of Earlier Origin
merations of Hor_ (The Howell Farm, South Harbor Lane, Southold)
John Howell (1801-1883), descendant of Edward and
45
Guide to Historic Markers. Southold Historical
society. 1960
� w
3
SD 108
� y
oil
'l • S �. I
+4. .
' � �y y'..�r�\.'Iii —,+ � 4 } �� - � -- -•- •���� -
Y I
4 go
Coast Survey. T-68. 183
e.
SD 148
142 OLD SOUTHOLD TOWN'S TERCENTENARY
1 original house, however, was built by Samuel Youngs in 1658
and has passed through the hands consecutively of Hempstead,
f Gardiner, Coleman, Appleby, Albertson, `Derry, Wickham and
w
Ilartranft families. It has long been claimed that the old
' Barnabas Horton kitchen, middle 1600s, eventually became
Richard S. Sturges' carpenter shop and now is the Girl Scout
headquarters on Oak Lawn Avenue. It had moved only across
the main road and around a corner to its present location. A
replica of the house itself which is no longer in existence stood
on the lawn of the town clerk's office during the celebration.
The site of the original house, R. G. Terry's property, was
marked by a Celebration sign, "Barnabas Horton, Baker."
In Bay View the Deacon James Horton house, 1711 (the `
lower wing), stands just beyond the old district school (Miss _ ,
Mary L. Dayton's house---Mrs. E. W. Scherr's residence) ; lei
the old lenninr.,s house-, z761, stands at the sharp bend of the
`Tray iew road (Henry Sayward) ; the first Joseph Hallock
house, built by him ir. the 1700s, on the Bay View road, is now
the remodeled Reydon Club House.
There are a number of interesting sources of information
about old houses, to which reference has already been made.
H. Howard Huntting and Jonathan G. Huntting kept valuable
scrapbooks throughout part of the last century, and these
books are now mines of information about old Southold Town.
In them are found the "Hobbles about the Village" by J. Hor-
tonCase, who tells the story of some of the old houses from
J. Wickham Case's sources for such history.
Would that the owners of all the old houses of Southold
Town might preserve them and hand them on to posterity, not
allow them to be destroyed wantonly nor decay to the ground I
They are precious for the very sustaining of a character which,
if lost, would mean defamation to much that the town holds
dear to itself. This chapter comes to a close, having made its
salute to that spirit dwelling within or about some of the oldest
houses of Southold Town, with a prayer for their well-being i
r and safety through all the days and years ahead.
Cz
Ann Hallock Currie—Bell. Old Southold Town' s
T
Tercentenary. 1940
I
F-