Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutTR-4354 DiSalvo, Diane From: DiSalvo, Diane Sent: Wednesday, December 02, 2020 10:30 AM To: Mike Griffin Subject: RE: Gardiners Bay Estates Trustee John Bredemeyer and Assistant Town Attorney Damon Hagan advise that you will need to apply for a Full Amendment to your Permit#4354. What currently exists does not match the original permit and plan—so you would need to apply for the actual existing plus 4 whatever it is you wish to now do. This would require the noticing of adjacent property owners as well as a public hearing. I can further advise you what you will need to provide in order to apply if you contact me by phone. I i R vLe D%SG11 V0 5oL,ttkoLO Towvi, T Lcstees 543Y5 TRou,te 25 southc)Ld, NY :L:L (&31) ���1892 Z6Z� a4mk �(/CL i WA -a-4 From: Mike Griffin [mailto:g, Sent: Thursday, October 22 To: DiSalvo, Diane j Subject: Re: Gardiners Bay; Diane, Thank you for your quick Attached is our schematic, he space between the fingers. In addition we would like to replace wood with composite to reduce maintenance costs and splinters for children. Finally, we would like to replace the flotation for slips and dock for 2, 3, and 4. Slip 1 and dock have the new rubber box flotation. The rest of the dock has the old foam insulation flotation. Thank you. Look forward to hearing from you. Mike Griffin Marine Committee Chair GBEHOA On Thu, Oct 22, 2020 at 3:30 PM DiSalvo, Diane <diane.disalvogtown.southold.nY.us>wrote: See attached i DiSalvo, Diane From: Mike Griffin <griffinmf@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, October 22, 2020 4:00 PM To:, DiSalvo, Diane Subject: Re: Gardiners Bay Estates Attachments: GBEHOA Dogwood Dock Revision 01.07.2020.pdf Diane, Thank you for your quick response and research. Attached is our schematic for our revision. We would like to equalize the space between the fingers. In addition we would like to replace wood with composite to reduce maintenance costs and splinters for children. Finally, we would like to replace the flotation for slips and dock for 2, 3, and 4. Slip 1 and dock have the new rubber box flotation. The rest of the dock has the old foam insulation flotation. Thank you. Look forward to hearing from you. Mike Griffin Marine Committee Chair GBEHOA On Thu, Oct 22, 2020 at 3:30 PM DiSalvo, Diane <diane.disalvogtown.southold.ny.us> wrote: See attached f j DiRv�.e D�SG2Lvo �(.6A see- SokthoLcl TowvL Trustees ` pNiQ Cr 54S75 T2.oute 25 �sT/1�8-5 p�. �/Yl U�ls G�2cFFiNl� �.o. -Fox aw TV 00 SDu kaI ' N`( 11J IF /¢- tr 1 Michael F. Griffin P.O. Box 571 i i ID6 ► � 7-1 IN- , 1� j. " 4 i . 1 W 90- t {' 3 is � G 1 ' , I Board Of Southold Town Trustees • SOUTHOLD, NEW YORK 1e 4354 DATE: July 11, 1994 k PERMIT NO. �� h� 4 ' ISSUED TO . .. Gardiner§. Bay Esta_tes s Aut4ortzafiuu '. 5 Pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 615 of the Laws of , the State of New York, 1893; and Chapter 404 of the Laws of the Z / State of New York 1952; and the Southold Town Ordinance en- b: " THE PLACING OF OBSTRUCTIONS titled REGULATING AND R� IN AND ON TOWN WATERS AND PUBLIC LANDS and the r� REMOVAL OF SAND, GRAVEL OR OTHER MATERIALS FROM jE LANDS UNDER TOWN WATERS;" and in accordance with the It Resolution of The Board adopted at a meeting held on June 30.. . �; • `t 94 150.00 19 , and in consideration of the sum of paid by of N. Y. and subject to the y o: Terms and Conditions listed on the reverse side hereof, -� of Southold Town Trustees authorizes and permits the following: �; y ! �b To install stairs, a 3' X 25' catwalk, a 31X12' ramp, one 4' X 48' main float, two 3' X 14' finger floats, one 6' X 16' finger float `. and pilings. Located end of Dogwood Lane, East Marion _ FY all in accordance with the detailed specifications as presented in Rro " the originating application, f ' � IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The said-Board of Trustees here- } by causes its Corporate Seal to be affixed, and these presents to \ ay be subscribed by a majority of the said Board as of this date. FO ' O j �lt y►� Trustees � � •1 �--. �� ::.1.:t ems. _ e..y ai :4 .�a" .Yi' 1 � � PROTECT PLAIN _____..._.--_----__-.�_..____--• -•------•`"_AJp11C '_>.L :.r0 n0:3@3 t0 add.--L.'s11pS t0 e_:1Lit1..]�; .. .. ._... ._ .. -. ..•. _......"-.111•-EA! T MAP-ION dock o,f recc7_!structi.i; existi ff, cat:vallc 31r.231 it�l 5 :tiles; elevated 4 ' 6-t Inartina,; 31-xl2' I;Ix4'' float •::it:_ C — 31.Z_L fi _er:, area '% 4 piles; auin-� ZZ O 'xl- I a k as ce.-­.ter fi:c;er �' " y x3 goy . SuFFojLK CCU:vYy . t :�, N TAk M�p '�i •~ � ��� _ { SUKF DL_K CouNr_Y a 3. � EX1S7t>✓G ) EXr5TlN(,7 io 1 j ti .21 .Project:' Dogwood , • ;s '..j La. r Catwalk ' z, a L IJ • c " 41 .c > t = yj & Dock f Spring pond,Le t East Marion Gardiners _ -- EstatesFome- i ry•, owners Ass, inc. Consultant: • \�,�,� , L.J. matzen ; V .. Dated: 3/4/92 SCALE �oi n ^' __ _� ___ _- .____ __._.___... _._.�_pOc'K� CONST' VCT�Ot�/. •`•.,'_'_.. _ ._. .... � EIr. I oFa RFvT4iQ_ 01Q9?_ CRQSSECT IO N NA! T AARiON v SIe� Zs ."sSlu �� ? J HAQfi"K coyNT2 � .CSC i r riliHl_*2.6 t id 1 1 c i IAJTERTIDA L pFATN of `-- 'A w a N iGH PFN�TRAT s riA%Zsy (15') i Pro 'ect: Dogwood La. r• rr Catwalk i & Dock i Spring Pond, Last Marion Appl. Gardiners Bay estates Hcme- palica.::t propocec to add 4 slips to exi ;tinS owners ssn. ,Inc. ' dock bI reconstructine existi_. cat,...-lk 3'x25 ' l Consultant : :lti: 6 piles; . j'A �'} ao` ra.r::I.; 4'x4� ' float � i�:i 2 - j'r:14' fin e„s arid L. J. ti.atzen • j SG'A? /" = /G�<.,T.. `� rile�;Tus ..g 6 'xlo ' dock as center rii>>ger. Dated: 3/4/92 RGVIsE:= /n/`3a19P_ D��K CONSTRUCTION 6HT2.oF - !h!6-ao 3 �r1�6Pr( Y 4f op� Jez� -Z RA )(2 O/ Tel c A&&-� ww-1A Z 9A crr, f0a��G�P�2rl�i�t�trref' g'�,�� I�ee�/ -F�� y�✓lc d Q�2y�iJ+cCr!'-ray. �1 Cr �3 � /`+�� Gvl l� lj2¢,zJ �� �i�e Td1'' ��f11/�(1Y'�t`�✓�J �itJL �yy�1�iYlQ#-f Z 3A 08�21r/yle 7t�r -Flay' �•�r�/+►S �J/ �12-j` A FOLI(C�G APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS y� Southold Town Hall Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman y ,= 53095 Main Road Serge Doyen, Jr. IS P.O. Box 1179 James Dinizio, Jr. y O� Southold, New York 11971 Robert A. Villa lt �a Fax (516) 765-1823 Richard C. Wilton Telephone (516) 765-1809 BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD MEMORANDUM JUL 2 TOWN OF SOUTH®,gyp TO: Board of Town Trustees FROM: Board of Appeals r DATE: July 11, 1994 SUBJECT: Town Trustees' Proposed Permit for Docking Gardiners Bay Estates Club, Inc. 1000-37-1-part of 23 at Spring Pond, Orient Harbor, E.M. This is sent as a follow-up for record purposes to confirm our understanding that any and "all permits issued by the Town Trustees are, of course, subject to compliance with all zoning regulations and that the applicants before the Town Trustees have been advised of this requirement by your office (as well as ours). Since neither the Building Department or the Board of Appeals has received an application by the owner-association of the subject premises to dock or moor no more than two (2) boats other than those owned and used by the owner-association (as interpreted in ZBA determination filed under Appl. No. 4156 rendered May 11, 1993), the docking and mooring is limited as provided at Article III, Section 100-31C(3) of the Zoning Code, or subsequent code changes as may be modified by Town Board legislation. A copy of this memorandum is being furnished to the applicants for their record and further update. cc: Mr. Lawrence Matzen Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Assn, Inc. P.O. Box 342 East Marion, NY 11939-0004 Town Building Department , .... . . . Albert J. Krupski, President John Holzapfel, Vice President William G. Albertson Martin H. Garrell Peter Wenczel Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Telephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD J11ly 11, 1994 1:.awrence Matzen Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association, Inc. P.O. Box 342 East Marion, NY 11939 Re: Gardiners Bay Estates - Docks SCTM ilOOO-37-l-p/o23 Dear Mr. Matzen: The following action was taken by the Board of Town Trustees during its regular meeting held on June 30, 1994 regarding the above matter: WHEREAS, Lawrence Matzen on behalf of GARDINERS BAY ESTATES ASSOCIATION, INC. applied to the Southold Town Trustees for a permit under the provisions of the Wetland Ordinance of the Town of Southold, application dated January 22, 1992 and, WHEREAS said application was referred to the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council for their findings and recommendations, and, WHEREAS, a public hearing was held by the Town Trustees with respect to said application on June 30, 1994 at which time all interested persons were given an opportunity to be heard, and, WHEREAS, the Board members have personally viewed and are familiar with the premises in question and the surrounding area, and, WHEREAS, the Board has considered all the testimony and documentation submitted concerning this application, and, WHEREAS, the Board has determined that the project as proposed will not affect the health, safety and general welfare of the people of the town, NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Board of Trustees approves the application of Lawrence Matzen on behalf of GARDINERS BAY ESTATES CLUB,INC. to install stairs, a 3', X 25 'catwalk, a 3' X 12' ramp, one 4' X 48' . . main float, two 3' X 14' finger floats, one 6' X 16' finger float and pilings. Located end of Dogwood Lane, East Marion. Permit will expire two years from the date it is signed. Two inspections are required and the Trustees are to be notified upon completion of said project. Very truly yours, &/.,..1 ~ /~. 9. Albert J. Krupski, Jr. President, Board of Trustee AJK:jd cc: CAC ZBA . . APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS South old Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Fax (516) 765-1823 Telephone (516) 765-1809 Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman Serge Doyen, Jr. James Dinizio, Jr. Robert A. Villa Richard C. Wilton BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD MEMORANDUM ffõJ {} & {} 0 r¡; {} rfñ] WlJ J.l, 2 @94 ~J TOWN OF SOUTHOLD TO: Board of Town Trustees Board of Appeals ~~#.L?....J July 11, 1994 FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: Town Trustees' Proposed Permit for Docking Gardiners Bay Estates Club, Inc. 1000-37-1-part of 23 at Spring Pond, Orient Harbor, E.M. This is sent as a follow-up for record purposes to confirm our understanding that any and all permits issued by the Town Trustees are, of course, subject to compliance with all zoning regulations and that the applicants before the Town Trustees have been advised of this requirement by your office (as well as ours). Since neither the Building Department or the Board of Appeals has received an application by the owner-association of the subject premises to dock or moor no more than two (2) boats other than those owned and used by the owner-association (as interpreted in ZBA determination filed under Appl. No. 4156 rendered May 11, 1993), the docking and mooring is limited as provided at Article III, Section 100-31C(3) of the Zoning Code, or subsequent code changes as may be modified by Town Board legislation. A copy of this memorandum is being furnished to the applicants for their record and further update. cc: Mr. Lawrence Matzen Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Assn, Inc. P.O. Box 342 East Marion, NY 11939-0004 Town Building Department SAMBACH ASSOCIAT. Architects 11 Halter Lane LEVITTOWN. NEW YORK 11756 /(2/-. ~hc(qLf ~ [][J(J([D LETTER Phone 731·5506 Date June 27 1994 To Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall PO Box 1179 Southold, New York, 11971 Subject Gardiners Bay Assos Application local address; please be advised that not withstanding my previous objections l to the application for a 6 boat float by Gardiners Bay Homeowners Association presently penàing before the Town Trustees, I hereby no longer oppose this application. Sincere y, A.LA. 460 East 11939 D Please reply D No reply necessary SIGNED fT,fir.1 'ao·~ ~.3,I¿¡blet'Qm ~~ 'n.: (;row., M¡¡S5.014~O . . GARDINERS BAY ESTATES HOME OWNER ASSOCIATION,INC. P.O. Box 4, East Marion, New York 11939-0004 Southold Board of Trustees Southold, New York œ §@.~::§ m June 4, 1994 ,,1º:.~~~·; !" f. S~~~~.;..T t~!; t ~ Dear Sirs: Please be advised that on June 4, 1994 Gardiners Bay estates Home Owner Association Inc Board of Directors passed the following resolution in regard to dockage on Dogwood Lane: 1. The Sambach's will give existing ramp/catwalk and float to Association, valued at $1600.00. In consideration of this donation the Sambach's will have the right of first refusal for the dockage of one boat and pay the annual floating dock and boat fees. 2. It is understood no right of the Association Property are given away. 3. If GBEHO Board agrees to this recommendation, the Sambach's will send a letter to the Southold Board of Trustees stating no objection to proposed application of GBEHO and will not take any legal action. 4. If application is approved, the Association will enter an agreement with the Sambach's that if the property is ever sold the new owner has the yearly right of first refusal to dock one boat on one side of the float. 5. If the Town Board of Trustees does not approve application for the six boat float all the provisions of the above paragraphs apply. Both Mr and Mrs Sambach have agreed to the above resolution. Very truly yours, 13~ Barbara Calcagnini, Secretary GBEHO . . ,.v~ _'¿~;11.(~~; . œ Œ © Œ 0 W Œ r/'~¡ '1' ~~~y 2 61994 ¡t) TOWN OF SOLJTHOLD PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS Warren A. Sambach Jr. R.A. Registered Architect 11 Halter Lane Levittown, New York 11756 (516)731-5506 Registered Architect: New York State Florida Arizona License License License # 16176 # 12681 # 21847 Presents Zoning Testimony at: Town of Hempstead Board of Zoning Appeals Town of North Hempstead Board of Zoning Appeals Town of Oyster Bay Board of Zoning Appeals Village of Malverne Board of Zoning Appeals Village of Rockville Centre Board of Zoning Appeals Village of Farmingdale Board of Zoning Appeals Town of Southold Board of Zoning Appeals Arbitrator for the American Arbitration Association, Garden City, New York Member: American Itlstitute of Architects, the Long Island Chapter, Mineola, New York Member: New York State Associaton of Architects, Inc.-Albany, NY 12210 Member: Federal Association of the American Institute of Architects, Washington, D.C. 20006 Member: National Council of Architectural Registration Boards, Washington, D.C. Member: The Long Island Historical Society, Garden City, NY New York Institute of Technology: "Cum Laude" Bachelor's in Architecture 1973 Perso~al Biographic Record listed in "Who's Who in the East" 24th Edi tion November 1993/94 , . . (516) 756-9384 Fax (516) 756·9607 ALAN H. VALENCIA ASSOCIATES REAL ESTATE APPRAISERS - CONSULTANTS 83 Beechwood Street, Fermingdale, New York 11735 Mr. Warren Sambach A.I.A. 460 Bayview Drive East Marion, NY 11939 May 5, 1994 1m Œ & Œ U r¡; Œ fñ} IJi] MM 1 6 -""'J~, . TOWN OF SC:, ",: I) EconomJ.c \';OIlS f:.::~~,- loss of pier and float RE: Dear Mr. Sambach: After our recent meeting to discuss the possible taking of your pier and float rights, considerable research was undertaken to determine the extent of your economic loss. This research indicates one of the most highly significant reasons for purchasing a waterfront home (be it bordered by a right of way or easement) is inclusion of docking rights. As with all water- front properties, which are valued at a premium, this was a highly motivating factor in your purchase. Indications obviate to the fact that you paid not only for the physical property, but additionally all soft costs relating to the construction of same (i.e. plans, permits, EPA studies, DEC and D.S.Corps. of Engineers applicatons, etc.). Of greater significance is the market appeal to purchase based upon those rights to use and sell. Value is related and closely interwoven with the rights of ownership of property. These rights are known as "The Bundle of Rights." Consistent with these rights is the principle of Anticipation (future benefits, both tangible and intangible) and the Principle of Contribution (any item or agent that adds to the value of the pro?erty, not what it costs.). Ongoing research and studies indicate you will sustain an economic loss in the $20,000-25,000 range. However, time restraints have precluded our completion and these estimates may prove to be on the conservative side. We will advise you as to additional progress as we complete the study. Very truly yours, ~~ Alan H. Valencia N.Y.S. Certified Residential Real Estate Appriaser . . Boa~d o~ T~udteed Town o~ Southo.1.d Town Ha.1..1., 53095 Main Rd. Southo.1.d, NY 11971 f{D)FJ1..r {} rfñ] ÜlJi c;'" 2 6 1994læ¡ "A,.! I ". . J (- c:.;c.::!;\ ':1- SOUTHOl' D ---=.¡ I~ay 21, 1994 Rt: Ça~dine~d Bay tdtated Homeowne~d Addociation Dock Pe~mit Application SUfi) #37-4-17 çent.1.emen: P.1.eade be advided that the app.1.ication ~o~ a dock pe~mit in Sp~in9 Pond by the Ça~dine~d Bay tdtated Homeowne~d Addoci- ation id i.1..1. conceived. J am a 14 yea~ p~ope~ty owne~ and a tu.1..1. time ~edident o~ Ça~dine~d Bay tdtated and have deve~a.1. ~eadond ~o~ my ob- jection to the app.1.ication. The~e id no need ~o~ additiona.1. dock dpace at thid time. Many at ou~ membe~d a~e widowd, widowe~d o~ othe~wide din9.1.e, do not own a boat, do not want a boat, a~e too o.1.d to boat o~ cannot atto~d a boat. How- eve~, addumin9 that in the tutu~e a need to~ mo~e dock dpace dhou.1.d a~ide, than the dockage a~ea on Fox Jd.1.and dhou.1.d be expanded. The p~ima~y intent when dock dpace wad o~i9ina.1..1.y condt~ucted on Fox Jd.1.and wad to take ca~e o~ p~edent needd and p~ovide an a~ea to~ eadY expandion. Thid expand ion location would be mo~e lea~¡ble, le~~ exp~n~¡ve, le~~ 06- t~udive, out ot ha~md way and .1.edd didtu~bin9 to the natu~a.1. envi~onment both in condt~uction and udage. My objection to the app.1.ication id tu~the~ enhanced by the May II, 1993 decidion ~ende~ed by the Southo.1.d Boa~d at Appea.1.d. Said Boa~d'd inte~p~etation at Section 100-31C 13-a) dtated that the~e id no badid .1.e9a.1..1.y ~o~ 9~antin9 the dock condt~uction pe~mit to the Ça~dine~d Bay tdtated Homeowne~d Addociation. Since~e..1.y , .æ£ß~ ~LG~ Cf¡icha~d Oi B.1.aÚ Judith Oi Bladi 360 Bayview D~. P.O. Box 736 tadt Ma~ion, NY 11939 . ill . rn © rn ß W rn I~ MAY 2 3 1994 æJ TOWN OF SOllT~J~\~D 2435 Cedar Lane East Marion, NY May 20, 1994 Board of Trustees Town of Southold 53095 Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Gentlemen: Re: SETM #37-4-17 Dogwood Lane - request for a floating dock This is to advise that our family is opposed to the building of any more dock space on Spring Pond. We have enough boats there now. More could damage the eco-system. Sincerely, 0(AJ~ william w. Parrott r· . .. ~ . . . Hay 13, 1994 Boarè of Town Trustees Town of Southold 53095 Main Road Southold, N.Y. 11971 OlOHlnos ~O NMO. (ñl ~I ~_~ Å9H_, ~ ~ ~ j' ,~ RE: Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Assoc. (GBEHOA) SCTM #37-4-17 Gentlemen: I wish to register my objection to Gardiners Bay Estates, (GBEHOA) application for a dock permit at the foot of Dogwood Lane, ROW south of Bayview Drive, East Marion. I am a year-round resident and a director of GBEHOA. I have consistently voted against this proposal every time it carne up at our board meetings. (See my letter to the Zoning Board of Appeals, attached.) Now that the Zoning Board of Appeals has rendered its interpretation of Section 100-31C(3-a) of the Zoning Code, there is no legal basis for granting a permit to GBEHOA. On June 4, 1993 the association~s attorney, Ongioni & Borrelli advised the President of our association that; "... .The ZBA decision confirms that with regard to the docking of boats, only those owned and used by the resident owner of the land where the dock is to be located, is permitted under the code... ...". They further advised that: "....a docking facility mustbe on land held in single and separate owner- ship and im roved bv a one-familY dwelling or other permitted pri!:lcipal use as provIded In the zonInq code."(underlining by- the attorney) Our association obviously is not and cannot be a "resident owner" of the land in question, nor is the land improved by a "one-family dwelling" Therefore Is~~rftê.try request that the permit be denied. Your refusal to grant a permit will not adversely affect our members' use of Spring Pond. We currently have excess moorings which are not being utilized and to my knowledge there is no waiting list. Very truly yours "~I C"" tv .¡..¡ . \ ~, J I\jJ~T~~ Ý l.). ~\/ Geo0Je W. Clark 30 Dogwood Lane East Marion, N.Y. 11939 J . . CoPy April 3, 1993 Town of Southold Zoning Board of Appeals Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman J Re: Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association Application for Interpretation of the Zoning Code of the Town of Southold . Dear Mr. Goehringer: I am writing to you to register my objection to Gardiners Bay Estates (GBEHOA) application for a dock at the foot of Dogwood Lane. I am a year round resident and a director of GBEHOA. When the dock proposal was submitted to our Board, I voted against it. There is no need for this dock since there is ample room for more boats at our present facilities. If a need does arise in the future, then it would be more feasible to locate the dock on Fox island, thereby eliminating any "adverse effect" objections such as those of Messrs. Sambach Jr. and Di Blasi. (Objections which I believe have validity) I do believe however, that we must obtain an interp- retation of the boat code for R40 zoning and hope that your Board 1~ able to do this in a timely manner. A form letter prepared by our Marine Committee directed to you, to be distributed and signed by those GBEHOA members in favor of the dock, is not entirely accurate. It states that the construction "...will not cause any harm to the health, safety, or welfare of the community or of any adjacent or nearby neighbors" I beg to differ. Instead of a quiet right of way between their homes,that produces little "traffic", placing a dock at the foot of the right of way between Sambach Jr. and DiBlasi's homes will produce added foot traffic, cars loading or unloading gear for boats, vehicle parking etc. and...most important...a diminution of their property values. It seems eminently unfair that these two members should suffer real economic loss so that a mere five members at most, can moor their boats literally in front of the aggrieved members"homes.It is particularly distressing when the altern- ative(constructing a dock on Fox iSland) is so simply attainable. The form letter would also have you believe that our community property values would drop if the committee's application is not granted.This is an exaggeration.We have always had adequate space for our member's boats and with Fox island as a "reserve" area, future needs are assured. . .. . . . . , (2 ) As a practical matter, it would be impossible to guarantee boat space for each of our 95 to 100 families.It just doesn't exist.But' with the usual demographics breakdown, we have our share of people too old to boat any longer, or who cannot afford to boat, or who simply don,t want a boat. As a Director of GBEHOA, I try to be mindful of the interests of everyone in the Association. The proposed dock, if approved, would adversely affect two of our mpmbers. If not approved, no one would suffer economic loss. Sincerely, ,~:f:~: ŒWv East Marion, N.Y. 11939 Gardiners Bay Estates . . Town Trustees Southald Town Hall 53095 Main Rd. P.O. Box 1179 Southald, NY 11791 f/õJ~ 'fi¡j r:;tt./L Œ: ' '- L~fJR 2 / /qo" ,rr¡",. __ ~, l ...,-0'1.'1 t., .~- ,... ___ - "-~.. ~ :', i. '\"- ç' -.; '. . April 15, 1994 In Gardiner's Bay Estates, in East Marion there are 2 pier and floats in Spring Pond that do not have permits. The one belongs to Dick DiBlasi and the other belongs to Warren Sambach. Dick DiBlasi's pier and float is in front of his house at 360 Bayview Dr. Wa=en Sambach' s pier and float is in front of his house at 460 Bayview Dr. These two people are in violation of the law and somethi~g should be done about this. It is up to the Trustees to protect our waterfronts and inland ponds and creeks. Thank you, A disgruntled taxpayer ,'. . \q' . j{rv' r;\'~\ \ APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS . Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman Serge Doyen, Jr. James Dinizio, Jr. Robert A. Villa Richard C. Wilton Telephone (516) 765-1809 . "FOl'¡'>''6 ,_c' ~"\.VU~ ... '1 /'I.~ ., ,~}, "a '~, ,~' ,..,' \ ~>'~. 0., ~ _,.;'~: ___ ...¡ ':¡' 0'::) ,- :-' \. '.; (.f.) ~ \:( =e: ~¡ \,~ '1'- ~-'" ': <::> "iiò" ~Ií ~ ,,(.., ".C.', ."'~ .çi ~''''(" -,,'I)""' 'c. " _~ ~ jY -::;~~~~' SCOTT L. HARRIS Supervisor BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD ~ fl & May 12, 1993 ~ r, Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Fax (516) 765·1823 Telephone (516) 765-1800 Carmella Borelli, Esq. Ongioni & Borelli 218 Front Street Greenport, NY 11944-0562 Re: Gardiners Bay Estates Home OWner Association, Inc. Appl. No. 4156 - Appeal for Interpretation Dear Ms. Borrelli: Please find enclosed a copy of the Board's Action in the above matter rendered at our May 11, 1993 Meeting with Findings and Determination. Very truly yours, Linda Kowalski Copies of Decision to: Building Department ~ Southold Town Trustees vr Mr. Lawrence Matzen Mr. Warren Sambach, Jr. , f r . . APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS ,,' ~;?~:('~~-.- {;:/ 'f't.~:·~;\ .J "'./- ~.£: < ':) .-- '-) ;.;.", ~ ~,~\ -, "'~ """"".:-:''1- ~'J ., " ~ ,y ~~~~~~~~~~~-~:~:> ;:- SCO'IT L. HARRIS Supervisor Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman Serge Doyen, Jr. James Dinizio, Jr. Robert A. Villa Richard C. Wilton Telephone (516) 765·1809 BOARD OF APPEALS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road PO. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Fax (516) 765·1823 Telephone (516) 765·1800 DELIBERATIONS/DECISION: Appl. No. 4156: li1 "':1 Ii / '1'1 ~ (/ Upon Application of GARDINERS BAY ESTATES CLUB, INC. (record owner as per Deed at Liber 7671 page 415) - by Lawrence Matzen, Chairman of the Marine Committee in behalf of the GARDINERS BAY ESTATES HOME OWNER ASSOCIATION, INC. This is an Appeal based upon the February 10, 1993 Notice of Disapproval issued by the Building Inspector requesting an Interpretation of Article III, Section 100-31C(3) of the Zoning Code which provides for "...docking or mooring facilities for no more than two (2) boats other than those owned and used by the owner of the premises for his personal use." Applicant is proposing to construct new dock areas with multiple boat facilities at the community beach of Gardiners Bay Estates. Location of Property: Part of Private Road known as Dogwood Lane situated along "Spring Pond," an estuary of Orient Harbor; also shown on the Map of Gardiners Bay Estates, Section 2, filed in the Suffolk County Clerk's Office as Map No. 275, East Marion, NY; County Tax Map ID Nos. 1000-37-l-part of 23 (private road), and part of 17 (underwater land). (Extensive testimony was received and the hearing then concluded, pending deliberations at a later time.) WHEREAS, Application *4156 is made under the Zoning Ordinance of the Town of Southold, Chapter 100, for an interpretation of Article III, Section 100-31C(3-a) pertaining to accessory uses in the residential zone districts; WHEREAS, said application makes specific reference to property owned by the Gardiners Bay Estates Club, Inc., now known as the Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association, Inc., which property is underwater land shown as "Spring Pond", .identified on the Suffolk County Tax Maps as District 1000, Section 37, Block 1, Lot 17, containing 6.8+- acres in total area. Waterfront accessibility is shown in this application to be at the end of Dogwood Lane, although other deadend streets are shown to exist (from the end of Beach Court and Old Orchard Lane, to the waterway of Spring Pond; WHEREAS, members of the Board viewed the property and are familiar with the current zoning designation of "Low~Density R-40 Residential" and the character of this property wþich is 'r Page 2 - Appl. No. !6 · Matter of Gardiners Bay Estates Association, Inc. Decision Rendered May II , 1993 underwater land shown on maps for a preexisting subdivision' known as Gardiners Bay Estates, sections I and II; WHEREAS, after due notice, public hearings were held by the Board of Appeals on February 23, 1993 and April 22, 1993, and all statements and materials submitted have been made a part of the permanent record; WHEREAS, at said hearings all those who desired to be heard were heard and their testimony recorded; and WHEREAS, the record and all testimony have been carefully considered, and the following pertinent facts noted: 1. LOT DESCRIPTION: The subject premises comprises an area of 6.8+- acres of underwater land referred to as "Spring Pond" at East Marion, Town of Southold, Suffolk County. 2. ACCESS TO UNDERWATER PARCEL: Accessibility to this underwater land is shown on the maps submitted under this application to be at the end of Dogwood Lane, although other deadend streets are shown to exist at the end of Beach Court and also at the end of Old Orchard Lane, to Spring Pond. 3. PREEXISTING SUBDIVISION: The property in question is shown on the Subdivision Maps of Sections I and II, Gardiners Bay Estates at East Marion, filed in the Suffolk County Clerk's Office on September 23, 1927. Sections I and II preexist the enactment of zoning (1957). Approximately 40 years later, Section Three was filed and approved on February 27, 1968 by the Southold Town Planning Board for the creation of interior lots i173 through i188. 4. WATERFRONT LOTS/INTERIOR LOTS: It is noted that 51 lots border directly on the waterway of Spring Pond; the remaining 50 lots in Sections I and II are interior lots. Lot No. 16 is shown on the filed map of Section II as "Beach for use of lot owners." Also, the Section III Subdivision Map shows 16 additional "interior lots" as approved in 1968. The total number of lots shown on the Maps of Sections I, II and III is '122 (combined waterfront and interior lots). 5. NEW YORK TOWN LAW - TIME FOR APPEAL FROM DECISION OF ENFORCEMENT OFFICER. Effective Ju~y 1, 1992, Town Law was amended (codified) by adding a new Section 267-a. One of the amendments included the filing within 60 days of an appeal based upon the decision, order, requirement, interpretation of the Building Inspector. The action of the Building Inspector upon which this interpretation is requested is dated February 10, 1993, and the appeal was filed with the Clerk on Febru~ry 11, 1993. ~ .. r :page 3 - Appl. No. t56 Matter of Gardiners Bay Decision Rendered May . Estates Association, Inc. II, 1993 6. BASIS OF APPEAL: The action taken by the Building Inspector, upon which this appeal for an interpretation is made is dated February 10, 1993, and reads as follows: "...PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that your application dated February 10, 1993 for permit to construct dock with multiple boat facilities at Dogwood Lane, East Marion ... is returned herewith and disapproved on the fOllowing grounds: Article III Section 10Q-31C3, Property Zoned A and owned by Subdivision Assoc. Action required by Zoning Board of Appeals to address proposed use not allowed in Agricultural Zone i.e. more than two boats not owned by property owner... ." 7. USE VARIANCE: It is noted that no record has been found that makes reference to other relief; and to date, an application for a use variance has not.filed. b.eel'\ 8. OTHER AGENCIES: It is noted that this project is also contingent upon compliance with other agency permits and/or finalizing reviews under other applicable statutes now pending, or previously issued including but not limited to the: a) N.Y.S. Department of Environmental Conservation; b) Department of the Army; c) Town Trustees of the Town of Southold; d) Planning Board of the Town of Southold, as may be appropriate. 9. OWNER-CORPORATION: The record owner as shown on the deed recorded at Liber 7671 page 415 was conveyed on July 7, 1974 by Gardiners Bay Co., Inc. to Gardiners Bay Estates Club, Inc., under the laws of the State of New York. A copy of an Amended Certificate of Incorporation changing the name of the corporation to Gardiner's Bay Estates Home OWner Associa- tion, Inc. (GBEHOA) has been submitted as part of the record. GBEHOA is a Not-For-Profit Corporation organized under Section 803. This Not-For-Profit Corporation is a membership organization which requires ownership of property in speciic areas of East Marion, presently at Gardiners Bay, before becoming eligible and accepted as a member of the corporation. , , .,' . :Page 4 - Appl. No. t56 . Matter of Gardiners Bay Estates Association, Inc. Decision Rendered May 1/ , 1993 TOWN CODE DEFINITIONS 10. PERSON OR ASSOCIATION DEFINED: Section 100-13 of the Zoning Code categorizes association under the definition of "person," as follows: ...PERSON: Any association, partnership, corporation, cooperative group, trust or other entity, as well as an individual.... 11. OWNER OF LAND DEFINED: Section 100-13 of the Zoning Code defines owner as a "...person having vested or contingent interest in the property in question" including a dUly authorized agent, attorney, purchaser, devisee, and fiduciary having vested or contingent interest in the property in question. Real property law provides for ownership as being held individually, jointly, in common, or in corporate or partnership form. This parcel is in corporate ownership form, not individually, not jointly, and not in common ownership. The corporation is the owner. The membership is not the owner. The membership is a union forming the shareholders of the corpora- tion. 12. RECORD OWNERSHIP TO PROPERTY IN QUESTION: The ownership to the underwater land which is the sUbject of this application is in the name of an association-corporation referred to as the "Gardiners Bay Estates Home Owner Association, Inc." A corporation is defined as a "person" under the Southold Town Code. The code clearly does not provide for separate individual stockholders or members of a corporation to be multiple owners of the land. Stockholders of a corporation are defined in Black's Law Dictionary as holders of shares of stock, sharing proportionately in its net profits or earnings or in the right to distribute assets on dissolution. Stockholders also share rights to participate in the general management of the company. Stockholders may be one or more persons or sub-corporations. A corporation may exist with an unlimited number of shareholders, with more than one corporation, or with no shareholders. Ownership of land is not defined as members of a corporation, nor is an owner defined as the number of members in a corporation. Ownership of land is clearly defined as a person, a corporation, a partnership, a trust, or an entity as a single unit. 13. INTENT OF ACCESSORY USE AT 100-31C: It is well-known to Board Members that the intent of Section 100-31C is and always has been to allow an extension of use to a particular piece of property, accessory and incidental to the residence on the lot, for the docking of his own boat, and provided~further that title to the boat is in the same name as the owner of the · . . '. Page 5 - Appl. No. t56 . Matter of Gardiners Bay Estates Association, Inc. Decision Rendered May 1/, 1993 property. In addition, accessory uses would be permitted to have up to two boats other than those of the owner of the residential parcel. The Zoning Code does not provide for an extension of use for interior lots (without direct frontage on a waterway) in residential subdivisions for mUltiple docking facilities. The Zoning Code also does not provide for cases where the owner of the boat is not the same as the owner of the land at the docking facility and waterfront property. Interpretations are limited to clarifying and interpreting the code, not legislating new definitions or new zoning laws. 14. TITLE OF BOAT OWNERSHIP. No information has been furnished by the applicant to show ownership of the boats intended for docking or mooring by the applicant-owner (GBEHOA). ACCORDINGLY, on motion by Chairman Goehringer, seconded by Member Wilton, it was RESOLVED, that Section 100-31C(3-a) of the Zoning Code is hereby clarified for the purposes of interpretation as follows: 1) For the purpose of Section 100-31C(3-a), an owner of a parcel of land shall be an individual, a partnership, corporation, cooperative, or other entity, or a combination of the above, as a single unit; 2) That for the docking, mooring or accommodation of noncommercial boats, only those boats owned and used by the resident-owner of the land immediately adjacent to the land which the docking or mooring is to be located, may be allowed as an accessory for hisown personal use, provided the waterfront lot is held in single and separate ownership and is IMPROVED WITH A PRINCIPAL ONE-FAMILY DWELLING OR OTHER PERMITTED PRINCIPAL USE AS PROVIDED in Section 100-31 and Section 100-30A.2 applicable to the R-40, R-80, R-200 and A/C Zones to which this docking must be accessory to. Additionally, up to two other boats may be docked or moored which are not in title to the same landowner; 3) All docks and moorings are subject to reviews by the Southold Town Trustees in accordance with the rules and regulations of the Southold Town Code. Vote of the Board: Ayes: Messrs. Goehringer, Dinizio and Wilton. (Absent were: Member Doyen of Fishers Island and Member Villa.) This resolution was dUly adopted. * * ,." *,,--7 , /~ , (/ ~t, GOEHRINGER, CHA lk /GERARD P. , , . . GARDINERS BAY ESTATES HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. East Marion, New York 11939 - 0004 October 30, 1992 HYS Department of E:1Virol:l~ental Conservation Buildinß 40 - sum stony Brook, ¡¡Y 11790-2356 Attention: 0arleen Gerbino, Program Aide ]E: UFA }1-4738-00462j00001-l Gardiners :Say Estateo !!omeowl'lers AslSoc. Property - DOGwood Lane Rißht-of-Way Dear Ps. Gerbino: III response to your letter dated August 7, 1992, attached please find 4 copieo each of revised project and croosection plans. These were l~lodif;ied to reflect your recoru~endatioll to install only one catwalk, constructed a minhlUI'i of 4' above grade over tidal wetlands, cOIl~ected to one main float with three finßers. The Daßes of adjacent landowners are: La.i Sa~bach, Judith. DiBlasi, and Dorothy Longworth. If you aeed any further information please contact me. I can be reached at 516-477-9675. s~~~ Lawrence J. Matzen, Chairman ¡'¡arine ComrAÌ t tee ytc: /cc: 4 copies of revised project and cro..ectioA plans Board of Truateea, To.. ot Southold U.S.A. Corp. ot Engineera I i i i I ! i il ! i ¡ \ ! I ¡ I , , I I I ¡ I i i ¡ ¡ I ! ¡ I ! i , , Iv! ~ ¡ ~¡::: ¡};.1 '" Ii.... ~ n, :: j 0) I' i ~¡ 0 !;' .. :~! 1 0' -it -I t;;)i ~¡ f D.______._.__...__ ¡ ~, ¡ rt ¿,.-- <fg' ).. :-r--.-..--.í--...-...'.-'..- j '", : ,!!, r---"--'" .. ---:¡, \""1.\-75'" ~~\--->: Iii D ~ O/!3LM', ~ I, 0'" I I I LA \ ^~ ¡ DOC~ :'" I ¡ .)::s: ¡ 1\) , ......, " I ~ ib Ib:d ;?>~'~~·~-I~~·'~\IIf: ,_ .---- 7 ____ \ .....-- ---- y,\ /", <J'- \ \( I, \ \ \ '-~ ....1:11- I '! i" ' I -~\:- ¡~¡, ¡ ~ -'J~~' -\.\----- ___,._>j~¡;; ¡ I' I~~ ¡ ,u¡ -",,, î ,., -~.l. lovE : ¡ , '. T.~."-!!:!.. I!D"'-'þ·...v I t _/ '::e~':'ðAL V~Nb-~-'~~:---';rf¡ '-J-'~ Ó-~---; ¿/ "'<-1. v. I,' II' . , ,,'1>,r<.S/i v, V ~ ~ V V V' I' V V V, ~ l/ \/ ~ 1 " I I, IÌ ,,- ~ v V ~ \Ì'" t' .!J ~~, :) ,...... ~ - ~," ..........".,. _. - ~ - . - . -... -- 0; _ .. cr---" __ .. 'OJ_O;;'~ """\£:"),,1 L.¢ - .. -~ ~ - .. ._ t _ . _ . ~_. . \V \k~r-e-I", f . Ï3, z-- IN I t>T"¡'¡ -- ,.-.. .'7 /8'1' /1''- ",,,-re,".. 1.... I ...., / I I I ¿ "Ic.--_ : '" ' i"'''·¡ i :I: ¡ "\1\' ;~,; , , , ' \" i _1 i 0 !~ i;¡> :~ f¡;¡ ,'" ;0 iò ,""- 'IP '0 I :~ ..,:..;...::;-~-:-:-. d t-::! su t" 0 <1". ::< CD "-i tJJ p.. ,:: f-' '~.. c-+ VJ su- SJJ '<1"::< '¡::-N<1" 'CD .. "-D::< N ~ -V """: "'",. Iv~.... ~:ç¡ \ ~ < "-.'..---.". '" (f' ~ c <) ~ 11 ~ ,.c-"6 O).r- ~ )- ^- ~11n I () ~ C ¿ -\ '< - - -~ ."- .... .-----..------ o IJJm;Þ " su ::< '<: d CD f-' >-:I M.. tJJtJJ <1"'" ;t>suSJJ tJJ <1" >-:I {¡)CÐP. ~ tJJ f-" ::< l-t ::r: CD ::<0>-:1 () GI tJJ . '" I l:zJ en su't:J tJJ>-:I <1" f-" ,-::< ".t)1¡ ~ 'tJ f-"O 01::1 ::<p. ~ t"'tJ su >-:I . 0 I >-:I ",'-J::: R" " ' <1" t:I 00 " su t:I' ;..- <1" 0 . \ ~~ ~ f-'O ' ;';-0 p. '---" .-- ,", ~_.~A-.._....~.^~.~·... ..-.,...-......-..-....-....... "----,,.., "-""'r- , I U !\~ 1 --j I ,- +1-1 ~i µ..~ ~'J ~. 0 ~(j ftl ¡-~ ('T 0 '"{- I-'.I-r. ::,-';>'- ..J · f-'.. ,.... CD (]'\oo c.., _1:- c....; P" ... -1-...1 :.: ;>-: -J.I-) (-1" ~ -f:- -liD c: C)([J (') Id 1--" - t;': .:) Ii · ,-.. ... I II · ¿.~ t-IJ L; 1,;.:1 I.J CD (Ï 0 0, Ú I--' ~ ~. - ~t1 m ~ ( ) Þ<. çT < 0 (¡) I--' p.\ rt 0-, ~~ c-r -J. IT - ¡...J.'l) ::::; 0 rt µ'Gl p. ;-~. ~ o .~- CD ~ n f\) - ~ p.. :>" f-'. I {Ii 01.¡'::-- p¡ rt (4' ;¡¡ \y' 1-" 01 _;¡, '; 1-1 0>-: Idt., 1-" ill !--...J!j td :~.; .¡:- I-j () [f¡ cT_(""t~n (i) t-I. çT ,I- I-j 1>-iJ;; ;,¡,¿ 0 1-1, ~\.J ~\) ~t·..·I--'CD r-" C') ~}",.. ~< ;, W \...N --I. t'} I-j ,..\...~, c,: CD (I~ >< - ("T ..., f-'X f-" "' I'd I\.> ~ ~~ -\J1C. '1. , '''0 ;,.. ; ). 2: 'Q :JJ o '-\ , !1'4 '0 ¡-\ ..",,~-~ _.~- ,.'. '"... . - LJ ~~~ :1 )Z... 1 ! :)"'¡11-o I ~~ ;6' , I ~ .x" 1::1 " ~~ t=-.. f ¡ i ~~--- ¡ ~. r' ...... , '- 1 \I q i' ,C) ¡ "' 1 j " ,I , ¡ '[ I I ¡ I j ........,.,- ,..'"-'''-''', ,....... J 0, ...ç:.- 1-1 :"": µ. :1.. !.t f-J. 0 ~a ~(j ;'-: r;- - 0 I~J f-J.,,_! ~... p.,' ~ I··J...· ~. (fJ 0\0' () C. -f-- ~.< :'\ -. -'rj '.' >-: ~. '""$ c+ r:: +.-- -J ,to {rr C,) CD () I-c; 1--" -C!; a I-j .' -. '" 0 èti H~ (; 'U f--JlI1cTO 0', 0 1- ., C1 - Sl' m ¡::: CD xc+<oC) 1-..1 ru ,to 0\ -::: ~ ~. c+ -~. ((! :.i 0 c-t ~LC"'-! n..:':" :;l~ o .¡.- CD p.. o [v - ~ ¡.2., ~ 1-" I ~\1 (f) ..r:- ~\1 ('1" ri- C") vJ ....." tl) - r~ ~~ f-I o~~dc-.j~J· CD f-J :".; ~cJ ::1-+:'1'1 () (¡¡ c+ - ('"1" ~l", ro 1-" rt cT rs I-~ : __: ~-~ 0 f-J. P ~1 I-I):~.... f-I CD 1-" C" :,- >< 1 ::: (I) \..-'>J 1-" l't:; ~1 -vI c:: 1<1>ln>:-"" " ~"I-" f . ~ ¡\J ru : 'Í \ :---:: -\JlC'¡ . p.. ; 1 I I j t , i 01 01 °1 ~. , j 01 01 2' ~; ~¡ -\ o~ 2j , ¡ c:j r.= " r-.h -J"a 11\ ... , :t. '-' '-\ \. - ~ .. ~·n 1:::( i t 18 1'\7 ['tn' ..r> », , J :,." J :.....'(1\ I ,::J; < . '~- , '" , '" ¡"i tJ <,}I> ...... :" 0 ''''(;:¡- ¡uo I , - , 0{) , \) o lJJ~~ '" po :3 '< ~ CD .. " l"J ClJCIJQ c+su ÞP>~ ClJc+Po CIJ CD 1-" ::.:s en::s . CD ~~~ :3 '" ot . u " $1J 0 c+t-':3 CD· CIJ Po '" ""-<I--' . c+ ~1 VJ:-:: ~ "-PJc+ +- c+.. ........'" ~'" 1\):3 t'J tI> t-' '-0 ~ '¡:¡ R" ¡u 6 c+ 1-" \::J ':j :3 0 CD :::(JI) o~o su :>;' c+ I"j '<1 () .. 1-" 0 su \::J 0:3 c+ 0 :3 Po '" Ü'J su '" 1--'0 :>;'0 Po L) . -. ... ...-', ..,.-,....",..... '" _..~. I ------1' I i ìiJ. ~ _____-l --1 I ..... -t;, . ,..-e·"..,,", --......,' .. .-,....... '-" . J ¡.. ~ '1., ~ , , I 1 ; ;+ Þ: It: N 1 1\1 0'\ , ,0 I.N ¡g I~ '-I '- "0 \ ¡Z I ...... O J -...",'--- --.."- ,. .., ._.,;.. .......... .-.._....._..........__...,~_._...-_'o.- '-." . . N~w York State Department of Environmental Conservation Building 40-SUNY, Stony Brook, New York 11790-2356 (516) 751-1389 FAX (516) 751-3839 ~ Thomas C. Jorlin9 Commissioner August 7, 1992 Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Assoc. P. O. Box 342 East Marion, NY 11939 Attn: Mr. Lawrence J. Matzen RE: UP A #1-4738-00462/00001-0 Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Assoc. Property - Dogwood Lane Right-of-Way Dear Mr. Matzen: On May inspection of Way. 21, 1992, the Department conducted an on-site the property located on the Dogwood Lane Right-Of- Pursuant to the field inspection, it was determined that the area is vegetated with both intertidal and high marsh and that the addition of a second catwalk would degrade the underlying tidal wetland due to increased shading. Additionally, given reasonable alternatives, the second catwalk is neither reasonable nor necessary. Therefore, please be advised that, as proposed, your project does not meet the standards of permit issuance as set forth in Tidal Wetlands Land Use Regulations, 6NYCRR, Part 661.9(b)(1)(i) and 661.9(b) (1) (iii). A copy of Part 661 is enclosed for your reference. The Department therefore recommends as an alternative that the applicant modify the project to install only one catwalk, constructed a minimum of 3\' above grade over tidal wetlands, connected to one main float with three fingers. This configuration would provide access to all the proposed floats while minimizing damage to the tidal wetland. . p . . Mr. Lawrence J. Matzen August 7, 1992 Page 2 Before review of your project can commence, the following must be submitted: - Four copies of a modified plan which shows one catwalk, one main float with three fingers and all marsh area accurately depicted (a copy of your plan i s enclosed with recommendations noted thereon); - Four copies of a revised cross-section, to scale, which shows modified structure and, most importantly, distance above grade (minimum 3~') over tidal wetlands. All marsh area must be accurately shown on cross-section; and - Names of adjacent landowners. Upon receipt of the application will resume. you have any questions. requested information, processing of your Please do not hesitate to contact me, if sincerely, ,n 1 ~ ~ . uarJJ-,./,v ~tu_ /L-ó"r Darleen Ge bino Program Aide DG/rw enc. cc: file ·;.r \ ": _.1 r " ' \ 1-: °1 lÜ: t-,i 0; [Y' " (I J I , i i i , ¡ ¡ , ..,.-... '. ' ... .'- rc©W>~ I -- _ -. j~ ~ 1'_ , - . - Ji3.J."..... ..1 I .. -- ~d" " H' ) ,-(1 /.1-- ;."2.."..---:-:':". ,. ~ H5~v~ . fl Î ...at.L '" 3.J."', .~ -I l--- ,{. ,.¡. I ! 7-""or:-" ~ I ,.,no1f"n···....· A . I O~I~:.;·····. /,1 d! ~ -L.3~. ).... \.'0;-·· ~ ... () .L ..... 9 ¡ , ." I ! I I I Ltf~----Ù- ,00( ........ ~~ ...<!,..,...,.~-'S< ~ ~ ~/Iy '8>( " ..¡,,, ~::. ~ \ ~l,.. ~~~ \ ¡:- ....., ~ ~ ': o ". U II. I ... ~ 4" J.,. ~'5.. J ~ ô' ~13..1,It'" J.... ,L81 - tJ ,~ " Q ,_ H.LOIM _'" \ ~ ~ f:- ~ ....,.- ,__" .'''_ ,____'__.__ r?, % Vl ,I "JAI"l' 1- ---.--... ..(), ,..<~~.3 I ^ f,. vo .. '"-. ,O~ --- ,.0_ . .. .9. 1....:"-4' f I ~ \ I : ¡ I , Il -' I L-. It ' ..' . ,. --- ' . , -t-F-" II LJ~-' i ~ I I ~c~l-o r-' :. :" I I' ,-"'" ~ ,-..- ../ I ....... ,. ~.,) \-;,1, {>; ; j^' ~1 " .. (I L ..) (I {I , , <:( \~f>_____~' "'rl'---'~- '. , ::i'. I " ;. ,I' ,,\ l' /,"' .../ IN ~... : 1 L_~1.-- .. , \ I , , ¡ i , ) I i \ , \ i ~ i .-' .. ~,--'- ~ fl· n-\-~ ~ 'i \- ....) r: .,... }:. \11 ':l. NW - , - ~ ~ ~~ '" ~< <J ")0 " () <1 ~ .f ~ .. i I ¡ I N ..----.- ,; ; ....-..-.. '. ' _.~_._. ..-.- --1 , , !e. --.. t IV . U) EJ 0 HOC ~ b:: '-1 -d <:: C ~ Q 0 :'d U) I' .. IV--- O. . IV U)" -... ~ H'µ ~tJ-:t 11, 11 c¡j c¡j U) Q.µ........ 1úJ·~~.µC<:.:'1,1r<'1 I C .., U) U) .', .,-j.µ ~"r<1 H 3..;j , ~. ~ p >,:g ~ 'J IV ,~' P--'-i \U ...,¡ ~ "-' ...f-) tJ) [<I c<: ÇIí ~ o,.c¡ c¡j , , ._ 0 t) P i I i ! i , I I , i 1 i .J ~I ¡II' ... I j~ I, I.... It!! ,-I I 'r . , '(~ I f: , , -_. .. .~..- ._--~ -.- . - -.-- . . HARVEY A. ARNOFF Town Attorney MATIHEW G, KIERNAN Assistant Town Attorney OFFICE OF THE TOWN ATTORNEY TOWN OF SOUTHOLD MEMORANDUM II, 53095 Main Road ,0. Box 1179 d, New York 11971 Fax (516) 765-1823 Telephone (516) 765·1800 TO: John M. Bredemeyer, III, President, Board of Trustees Gerard P. Goehringer, Chairman, zon,inCd _ of Appeal Harvey A. Arnoff, Town Attorl).eY ¿" FROM: DATE: January 26, 1993 RE: Gardiners Bay Estate Homeowners Association I would like to meet with both of you at a mutually convenient time this week, to discuss the problems with this project on an informal basis. , c,ì . \ 6.\ J...I . J\ ~6-A G()\ \ . . . GARDINERS BAY ESTATES HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION,INC. East Marion, New York 11939 - 0004 October 30, 1992 lJYS Departr'1ent of E:J.virOl:ll'er:tal Conservation Buildinß 40 - SU;;Y stony Brook, i!Y 11790-2356 Attention: ;:Jarlee:1 Gerbino, Prograr.-, Aide ,1)-;: UPA ,n-4738-00462/00001-1 Gardiners 5ay Estates !!or!l.eowners Assoc. Property - DOGwood Lane Rie;ht-of-Way Dear ns. Gerbino: III response to your letter dated August 7, 1992, attached please find 4 copies each of revised project and crossection plans. These were ~lOdif;Led to reflect your recoumendation to install only one catwalk, cO!1structed a minimuri. of 4' above grade over tidal wetlands, connected to one main float with three fingers. The maRes of adjacent landowners are: Lani Saabach, Judith_ DiBlasi, and Dorothy Longworth. If you need any further information please cODtact me. I can be reached at 516-477-9675. Sincerely, ~ Lawrence J. Matzen, Chairman !·[arine ComrÜttee jEnc: cc: It copies of revi.!led project aJld cra..aotio" plal\s Board of Tru.tee., Town at Sauthald U.S.A. Corp. of Engineer. 13~~'~;~~-I.;~ f. __/ ----'-- \ -,.- y ï\ .....", "'- )' \ (I ',- \'( ~ 1\ / v .../....,~ 'v \\ "'7'"1: \ i . " ,~r¡- "-'-..·-'~\-'--·J"c' ~\~, ¡~~ I ~ \.\ --------..--,>:1"" {' lð::! I . i~" 1 -r'D 1 ~ I ~.l. I I. "'En."", b : ¡ I~e ~':'b-A-~~:-~~:!'~tB:-_':k rl I¡ ~Nb ~ ~ 'I , '''-I. """r...S/i ¡)- ~ -0 . V F~' I" VI-V "VrlC/\/~: ~l¡ I'i 'V~'.. v v V '~-4 ì ·JI ~:. t~ .". ,.....~ - '- '- :"Ë~;:;"; :..:.,- h_ '~hq---r ~ _. _, __. -^. -............. 1"l"'", ;) I ¡ I Ïi>, " r:-------L1t----- ~, ¡ \. ~,-¥3' ) Ln-79' ~ì.~ ! j(---r--------- ..·~·--··'IT'..-~--·- .-.0-'.---..,--·....-.'..·· ·..·..·1-' ¡ DIßt.M I ' I ¡ g iìi I I i oOCI( I '^, j """i , . 1\) , ' .):~ I I 1: 1"1 · I U ~: _1 :1 t_,d ~¡ , -' o '" )I) ! , I I I I I , I I I t ¡ í ¡ i ì I ¡ ~ ! o! ~ ot ;, f)¡ ,... }:.¡ '" ni",: 0: ,,~ ~. I~I õ ;' ' ~! 1 0' ;\ -' 1;); .t¡ j , ,.._._____,., 'H' '" ""..... W,,,,"-/-I-- ....... Ì' /8'7' /I'r "'".,."" If' ~ c: <) ¡;! '" ? ~ 6 (\ .:t r- ~~^ tl1~ Co ¿ -, '< - ~ - '- - - -~ .," ~",,.. ----.,-----..~-----"._--~..... _.~ \I" ';'1; J) !:t" I '" "'"_..-0· . ~\~ 1 ,- +-·1 ~i p..;.r:.. ¡ ~:: ~. 0 td i tt.5 ï ('""f'" 0 "r r -J.t~·; ::.-~. I..J \ , ¡-.._. I"' I <1. n, C\ () ; Ù.' .I~- c::< ~\\ ~ ... _I' j ,.. >: ~J. I-j ~- ~ s:.:.. .~- ---J ([J (¡", C)Q¡ (') Id 1.J·-mObJ :~ _.:_ 0 O¡, ~ lJ: leI I-.J CD çT 0 0',0 ---J~ ::,; _ ~\1 m ~ CD >~ CT <: (") hi ~,~-~ ~~~çT \~ - f-" m :0 0 .'" (T µC,-¡ v ¡..~. ¡.:.' ~ i '-\ o .~- CD ~ :!n () f\, - X ,c ,,' ..... ;;.- -J' t I I I:~"~ m +.- ; -\ P1 (""'t" c1- : v) \J' -J. UJ -U.:;I- ~'"O () >: Icj r,:, -J. ; t' Cù ---.J~; 'd ~ >- :_'; .¡::- 'J () (J¡ çT - c-t ~n : 2:. eD 1...J· ,to ,t- .., H);~ :.i 0 .-J. ¡:\J ~ I~ t, .... f-J ill -J'H :....-:>< " ({)\.J., ---1. D: t-j '\"'v¡ œ CDW>< "IT ~ ~...J þ< ---1. "' f\)f\J:-, ~..,j" ..\J1G,! ,-'- l:3;j en ~'O rn 'i <+ f-'. ::> :C:()1¡ ~ 'i '1:J f-'·O 01:1 ;:>p. - rn'U ~'i . 0 I ""<1>'~ :<' () , IT Ö 00 () SD ö' þ,- <+ 0, \ ",()1¡ ~ SD .., 1-'0 Þi"0 p. ö 0 SD 1:"'0 IT' ;:I <1>c...rn p.. ¡:: .'" -J .=...("'1- VJSDSD .......<+;:1 '¡:-NIT .......<1>.. "-D::> f\J o W~;Þ '" SD ;:1« <1> I-' 'i tr1.. rn rn ("'I-!.í) :C--SDSD rn <+ 'i rn<1>p. oS rn f-" ;:I H:~CD ::.JO"i () S rn . <1> I , ];) ~ ¡;; '" c> ~' o -0 \> -~;;~-~~ ' . .,- .-¥----.. . . ~ _ .. A..... _,......._~... ....,..,.. '-'. ,...........', _. --" ,--"~,,, ... _........~_.___~_ W'. __.~ .. .-.,..,,,,,0_0- ".-.."...-." .~ ......."- --. r'---'--------e --- IIn 0 n ; ,..... 1 i I , ì , ~ " ,; .; ~ ..... ~'?, I J C', j I 1 .j::' .., ., µ"';I-- (1' f--'O'tj j ~CJ ::-- {- - () '-(1 I-J·të¡ ~;':'..'~ f-J...· fJ' C11 OIO'\) 'I Ó, .¡-c- t::~: ~, 'j -. _to ,. X t-J.I-j <+ ~ +'I--J.'D , " (\)(b 0'<; 1 I", -'" 0 ..., j &, -' 0 0 ...., l:-;j~! 0 I 1-'C11 <+0 I (T,O I--'t-s co 0 - St' C11 ,::: '" à x <+< 0 OJ , I-' PJ rr I () \ :r~ ,I-~' (""1" \) i _ ~..J. (1' :~ 0 0 I rl ~.I...CI! 2 I ~ jJ ;.~.' p' 1 0 .¡.- C11 p.. ((.) 0 Iv -~ ~ -¡ \ ;K fJ' ; t ~'¡¡ co+- ;;V ! "' (1-('1" C [;)\"'J -J. t'J () - I"~ ',' I-' -! 0 ~ 'd t¡ ~" '" ---J:'.J 'd \ ::-<.¡.- I, 0 (¡; 0 1 M' - ('"t. ~\' ~ " '" -I.<+ ("1" L.- ; ..., HJ :', ." 0 1-'. µJ :~1 ¡ ~:-.¡.... 1-'''' !-I'Cl] ;, x ! '" m \...I~ fJ· L'"; >, -vI (!J ¡ '" In :--; - M' .., -I:y' fJ' , . <1' [\Jrv:, i :."" -Vlr.:! ¡ P- ¡ I \ t.)~ I ~< j ~Vï u 0 o w~ t<j {J:¡ , '" :"1 " (lJ 0 ",po \I> 't:J <+t-';:; ;:; '< I-' (f '"I }\\õ '" . (f '" .. <+ fJ· P- ,::: '"I l'J ;:; ,~ ;-..... .. c..,1-' (f (f <;> .- oq .', ''''w . <+ <+\1> (lJ I) 0 I p, ~" (lJ '"I '"I 'd , - \..N:-:':: :3 (f <+P- fJ· 0 , -() .......(lJ <+ (f '" fJ· 0 ;:; ' \' +- c-t".. ;:; '" ;:> ;:; P- .......N . '" - '-0'" - S:.., f\J;:; 1-1 (f ~.J (11 0 t q ),~~ )" -t I ~ (7 f'I -0 ~~ ~b' .J:ì; ~, ~_... dt:- .. ",h -~... I1\JII... 0~X. - ~" ~"'d r t 18 rl1 t'1n' IbO )', ij'LI R"\,,'" U!~ o. o '" 0"0 ;K <T 0" P1cJ <+0 ",oq P1 '" 1-'0 ;KO P- "." .... ...-,.,'....,.-... .... ....~-.....'" ...,..,..." I ....---'" I I I I N 0'\ , t ___....-t --¡ ... -t;. , " Or¡ ..J. T ~ ~ 1.. ~ ! I : i+ p, it"¡ , 10... ~... , , "'-0"'.-'.._-.-. ~_..,,_. . N J ,0 t;J ¡g ¡~ 1-1 1- \0 z . v.~,,__ ~'~'~-h____".,~_~_~___ , . \ . . N<:w York State Department of Environmental Conservation Building 40-SUNY, Stony Brook, New York 11790-2356 (516) 751-1389 FAX (516) 751-3839 ~ Thomas C. Jorling Commissioner August 7, 1992 Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Assoc. P. O. Box 342 East Marion, NY 11939 Attn: Mr. Lawrence J. Matzen RE: UPA #1-4738-00462/00001-0 Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Assoc. Property - Dogwood Lane Right-Of-Way Dear Mr. Matzen: On May inspection of Way. 21, 1992, the Department conducted an on-site the property located on the Dogwood Lane Right-Of- Pursuant to the field inspection, it was determined that the area is vegetated with both intertidal and high marsh and that the addition of a second catwalk would degrade the underlying tidal wetland due to increased shading. Additionally, given reasonable alternatives, the second catwalk is neither reasonable nor necessary. Therefore, please be advised that, as proposed, your project does not meet the standards of permit issuance as set forth in Tidal Wetlands Land Use Regulations, 6NYCRR, Part 661.9(b)(1) (i) and 661.9(b)(1) (iii). A copy of Part 661 is enclosed for your reference. The Department therefore recommends as an alternative that the applicant modify the project to install only one catwalk, constructed a minimum of 3\' above grade over tidal wetlands, connected to one main float with three fingers. This configuration would provide access to all the proposed floats while minimizing damage to the tidal wetland. ... . . ~ . . Mr. Lawrence J. Matzen August 7, 1992 Page 2 Before review of your project can commence, the following must be submitted: - Four copies of a modified plan which shows one catwalk, one main float with three fingers and all marsh area accurately depicted (a copy of your plan i s enclosed with recommendations noted thereon); - Four copies of a revised cross-section, to scale, which shows modified structure and, most importantly, distance above grade (minimum 3\') over tidal wetlands. All marsh area must be accurately shown on cross-section; and - Names of adjacent landowners. Upon receipt of the application will resume. you have any questions. requested information, processing of your Please do not hesitate to contact me, if Sincerely, JJ r¿Ju·J.c-ß-t..-rlc·,_¿r' Darleen Gerbino Program Aide DG/rw enc. cc: file . . _""YTO ATn.."lOftor Regulatory Branch DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY NEW YORK DISTRICT. CORPS OF ENGINEERS JACOB K. JAVITS FEDERAL BUILDING NEW YORK. N.Y. 10278-00110 December 10, 1992 ,.- SUBJECT: Department of the Army Permit No. 19920111 Mr. Lawrence J. Matzen Chairman, Marine Committee Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association, Inc. P.O. Box 342 East Marion, New York 11939·0004 W 11 (¡;J ., 0 D r'L!5 r¡; {} I fñ] -J.., c~_~ ~ ]~I .~, ,,' !' J"II~ ~n L , . .. I n --_.oo, ..,' ,'_,,'."",: Dear Mr. Matzen: We have completed our review of Application Number 92-01l1-L2. Pursuant to Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899 (33 USC 403), you are hereby authorized by the Secretary of the Army: WORK: Replace an existing pier assembly with a 3 foot by 25 foot fixed pier supported by 6 piles, elevated a minimum of 4 feet above the grade of the marsh, a 3 foot by 12 foot hinged walk-ramp, a 4 foot by 48 foot main float with one 6 foot by 16 foot and two 3 foot by 14 foot finger floats. The floats will be secured to four pilings. WATERWAY: Spring Pond, Gardiners Bay LOCATION: East Marion, Town of Southhold, Suffolk County, New York Kindly display the enclosed notice of authorization sign at the project site. The activity authorized herein must be completed within three years of the date of this permit, and is subject to the enclosed conditions. You are required to submit to this office the dates of commencement and completion to the authorized activity. Enclosed please find two forms for your use in submitting the required dates. Notice is hereby given that the permittee should recognize that a possibility exists that the structure permitted herein may be subject to wave wash from passing vessels. The issuance of this permit does not relieve the permittee from taking all proper steps to insure the integrity of the structure permitted herein and the safety of boats moored thereto from damage by wave wash and the permittee shall not hold the United States liable for any . . such damage. The authorized activities must be performed in accordance with the enclosed plans. If any material changes in the location or plans of the subject work are found necessary, revised plans should be submitted to the District Engineer. The~e plans must receive the approval required by law before work begins. ~~;~,;;e,~~" L~rj(JJ~_ . or aJd in ehalf of'" , homas A York , Colonel, Corps of Engineers Enclosures District Engineer '. ) ,e'.\ . STArE OEP..\RT.\1Er\lT OF EN\"IRQ.....'\IE'T.-\l CO'>;SlRVel\; q;-~iJ-1J 111) ':101_ :5l mc PER....II r '"U·\1I1t R 1-4738-00462/00001-0 FACllIT\ PR:OGR.".\1 "IU.\1ßERhJ .. - - PERMIT Under the Environmental Conservation Law (ECL) TYPE OF PERMIT ICh~ck All Applicable Boxell ~ New 0 Renewal 0 Modification D Article 15, Tille 5: PrOtection of Water D Article 15. Tille 15: Water Supply D Article 15, Tille 15: Water Transport D Article 15. Tille 15: Long Island Wells D Article 15. Tille 27: Wild. Scenic and Recreational Rivers D 6NYCRR 608: Water Quality Certification o PermIt to Construct D Article 17. Tilles 7. 8: SPDES D Article 19: Air Pollution Control D Article 23. Tille 27: Mined Land Reclamation D Article 24: Freshwater Wellands Article 25: Tidal Wellands Article 27, Tille 7; 6NYCRR 360: Solid Waste Management ~ D ~FH(':"I\E DATE Nov. 17, 1992 EXPIR" nON OA IE o Po, Nov. : ..' m D Article 27 Hazardou a e D Article 34: Coastal Erosion Management D Article 36: Floodplain Management D Articles 1. 3. 17. 19.27,37; 6NYCRR 380: Radiation Control DOther: PERMIT ISSUED TO I TElEPHONE :'-lUMBER Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Assoc. , Inc. I I ADDRESS OF PERMITTEE P. O. Box 342, East Uarion., NY 11939 CONTACT PERSON FOR PERMITTED WORK I TElEPHONE NUMBER L. J. Natzen, P. O. Box 342, East Marion, NY 11939 I I NAME AND ADDRESS OF PROJECT/FACILITY LOCATION OF PROrECT/FACllITY End of Dogwood Lane right-of-way south of Bayview Drive, East Marion COUNTY I TOWNt:(1O"Xðt1t.kMJf I WATERCQURSE¡'..VETLAND NO. 1 NYTM COORD IN" TES Suffolk Southold Sorin" Pond E: N·" DESCRIPTION OF AUTHORIZED ACTIVITY Install stairs 3' x 25' catwalk 3' x 12 ' ramo. one 4' x 48' main floa t two 3 ' x 14 ' and one 6 ' x 16 ' finger floats, pilings. All work shall be in accordance with the attached NYSDEC aooroved olano By acceptance of this permit, the permittee agrees that the permit is contingent upon strict compliance with the ECL, all applicable regulations, the General Conditions specified (See Reverse Side) and any Special Conditions included as part of this permit. , JJe ut Re lona 1 ...ut..ory A';'i-:, .; PERMIT ADMINISTRATOR ADDRESS ~."on I. D ø- -..I ... u David DeRidder I!NJ7Ð...k, N.Y. 11'790.:015. AUTHORIZEDSIGNArUR, ,ØA~~- DATE 11/17/92 Page 1 of 5 . . . 95-20-6a (1O/90)-25c ADDITIONAL GENERAL CONDITIONS FOR ARTICLES 15 (Title SJ, 24. 25, 34. 36 and 6 NYCRR Part 608 ( . 9. That if future operations by the State of New York require an al· teration in the position of the structure or work herein authorized. or if, in the opinion of the Department of Environmental Conservation it shall cause unreasonable obstruction to the free navigation of said waters or flood flows or endanger the health, safety or welfare of the people of the State. or cause loss or destruction of the natural resources of the State. the owner may be ordered by the Department to remove or alter the structural work. obstructions. or hazards caused thereby without expense to the State. and if. upon the expiration or revocation of this permit, the strutture. fdl. excavation, or other modification of the watercourse hereby authorized shall not be com- pleted, the owners, shall, without expense to the State, and to such extent and in such time and manner as the Department of Environmental Conservation may require, remove all or any portion of the uncompleted structure or fill and restore to its former condition the navigable and flood capacity of the watercourse. No claim shall be made against the State of New York on account of any such removal or alteration. 10 That the State of New York shall in no case be liable for any damage or injury to the structure or work herein authorized which may be caused by or result from future operations undertaken by the State for the conservation or improvement of navigation. or for other purposes. and no claim or right to compensation shall accrue from any such damage. 11 Granting of this permit does not relieve the applicant of the responsi- bility of obtaining any other permission. consent or approval from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. U.S. Coast Guard, New York State Office of General Services or local government which may be required. 12 All necessary precautions shall be taken to preclude contamination of any wetland or waterway by suspended solids. sediments. fuels, solvents, lubricants, epoxy coatings, paints, concrete. leachate or any other environmentally deleterious materials associated with the project. 13 Any material dredged in the prosecution of the work herein permitted shall be removed evenly, without leaving large refuse piles, ridges across the bed of a waterway or floodplain or deep holes that may have a tendency to cause damage to navigable channels or to the banks of a waterway. 14 There shall be no unreasonable interference with navigation by the work herein authorized. 15 If upon the expiration or revocation of this permit, the project hereby authorized has not been completed, the applicant shall, without expense to the State. and to such extent and in such time and manner as the Department of Environmental Conservation may require, remove all or any portion of the uncompleted structure or fill and restore the site to its former condition. No claim shall be made against the State of New York on account of any such removal or alteration. 16. If granted under Article 36. this permit does not signify in any way that the project will be free from flooding. 17 If granted under 6 NYCRR Part 608, the NYS Department of Environ- mental Conservation hereby certifies that the subject project will not contravene effluent limitations or other limitations or standards under Sections 301, 302. 303, 306 and 307 of the Clean Water Act of 1977 (Pl 95-217) provided that all of the conditions listed herein are met. 18. All activities authorized by this permit must be in strict conformance with the approved plans submitted by the applicant or his agent as part of the permit application. db L J Matzen, dated Such approved plans were prepare y . . _ 3/4/Q'} r 1 ~~t" rpv; ~pn 111f./Q?KIJ.I ;:mr1 11/Q/Q? SPECIAL CONDITIONS 1. Entire length of catwalk shall be elevated a minimum of 3.5 feet above grade (distance is measured from ground to bottom of dock sheathing). 2. All remnants of the old dock not used during/in the new construction shall be completely removed. Any debris or project shall area (upland) for disposal. wetlands. 3. excess material from con~truction of this be completely removed from the adjacent and removed to an approved upland area No debris is permitted in tidal 4. A row of staked hay bales or approvable erosion control devices shall be placed 20 feet south of the edge of pavement and extend from the retaining wall on Lot 119 to the retaining wall on Lot 120 at commencement of regulated activities and remain in place until project is completed and all disturbed areas stabilized with vegetation. 5. The storage of construction equipment and materials shall be confined to the area landward of the required haybale line and buffer area. DEC PERMIT NUMBER I 4738 00462/00001-0 PROGRAM/FACILITY NUMBER I Page 3 of5 '. , NEW!K STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CDNSERtON . 95·20.6f (12/85)-25c SPECIAL CONDITIONS For Article 25 ( Tidal Wetlands 1 6. To protect the values of the tidal wetland, a permanent vegetated buffer zone shall be established. There shall be no disturbance to the natural vegetation or topography seaward of the mean high water line as shown on the 1/6/92 survey prepared by Roderick Van Tuyl. 7. Dredging is prohibited during any aspect of construction authorized by this permit. 8. There shall be no disturbance to vegetated tidal wetlands as a result of the permitted activity. 9. Floats and ramps may not rest on vegetated tidal wetlands. 10. All repairs to existing structures shall be confined to replacement of existing structural elements with use of old dock in new design and no change in dimensions or materials unless specifically authorized herein. 11. No permanent structures may be built on dock without first obtaining Department approval. 12. Docks may not be placed so that docked boats extend over adjacent property line, interfere with navigation, or interfere with other landowners riparian rights. Supplementary Special Conditions (A) thru (J) attached. DEC PERMIT NUMBER 1 4738 00462/00001 0 PROGRAM/FACILITY NUMBER I Pagé of~ . . TRUSTEES John M, Bredemeyer. Ill. President Albert J. Krupski. Jr.. Vice President Henry P. Smith John B, Tuthill William G, Albertson Telephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 SUPERVISOR SCOTT L. HARRIS Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Soulhold, New York 11971 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD S.E.Q.R.A. NEGATIVE DECLARATION NOTICE OF NO SIGNIFICANT EFFECT ON THE ENVIRONMENT APPLICATION NO. 1000-37-4-17 NAME: Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association DATE: May 12, 1992 RESOLVED that pursuant to Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law, State Environmental Quality Review and 6NYCRR Part 617, Section 617.10 and Chapter 44 of the Code of the Town of Southold, notice is hereby given that the Southold Town Trustees, as Lead Agency for the action described below, has determined that the project will not have a significant effect on the environment. Please take further notice that this declaration should not be considered a determination made for any other department or agency which may also have an application pending for the same or similar project. :, TYPE OF ACTION: Type I DESCRIPTION OF ACTION: to construct a 3' X 25' catwalk; with 6 piles; elevated 4' at spartina; 3' X 12' ramp; 4' X 24' float with 2 3' X 14' fingers and 3 piles and to move existing catwalk and dock 12' to east as per revised plan dated April 28, 1992. LOCATION: Tax map No. 1000-37-4-17 REASONS SUPPORTING THIS DETERMINATION: 1. An on site inspection has been conducted by the Board of Trustees. 2. An environmental assessment, submitted by the applicant and reviewed and completed by the Board of Trustees, has indicated that no significant adverse effects to the environment are likely to occur should the project be implemented as planned. cc: Applicant, DEC, U\L- · TRUSTEES John M. Bredemeyer, III, President Henry P. Smith, Vice President Albert J. Krupski, Jr. John L. Bednoski, Jr. John B. Tuthill Telephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 .. SUPERVISOR SCOTT L. HARRIS BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall 53095 Main Road P,O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 TO: \)c...~\<e'N:.. 0\, (,.e,hr-o LEAD AGENCY COORDINATION REQUEST DATE: L{~;).I-C¡Â Enclosed is a permit application and a completed part I of the Environmental Assessment Form. Southold Town Trustees are interested in your ageny's comments in acting as SEQRA Lead Agency for: NAME: (,..ÚJ;"<!.",,,,,,, Qx....y ~\4..~ I-tb"",,,-- ÒL-<:,.''''-'~ A~<..:='-io" LOCATION: ~~ LV",-" Lc~, CN:"".i""",ó "'''-'1 CS+., £c..::,f- V¥'ok~"",\ TAX MAP: 1°"'0-:'7-'-1-17 PERMIT * DESCRPTN: Sc.C.- F+t\6.£.!,,«4 PERMIT REQUIRED: f>LJ TOWN WETLAND ( SEQRA CLASSIFICATION: ~ Type I <)6 UNLISTED ) OTHER ( ) Type II () CEA Please contact John M. Bredemeyer, III, President, within 30 days and be advised that the Southold Town Trustees (WANT)/(DO NOT WANT) to assume lead agency. SENT TO: DOS ( ) DEC (,>L) DOH ( ) PB ( ) ZBA ( ) BLD ( ) Please complete, detach and return this form to expedite processing. _ Involved Agency: N"SÒtc.c.. t-.L -.L ¡,L () jJ'>SOQI,,--t./ðAi Project Nð.rQe: Gc¡...J"I1-e.¡¿~ !)qý SUices 'T"Yy1e ~Y1c:¡r"s__ O..J Location: r::Ð:J, 'ffWtID&. Lo..-...e., G-Cl¡¿'d..¡'ne¡¿s ;3/1,/ é;sf / CI'T':,-r rnarl SCTM: /DOD-U37-l./-/7 ,L] We at HYS DEe.. (Hav~ objection to Southold Town AGENCY Trustees assuming Lead Agency. Comments/Reasons: ;CPR 2 4 Ic::¡q? ð~7n. ~ Signature of Autñorized Relff''W~~n''~~t:i'''& i --;:,--'-,'1 Ilõì ~JtJJ. ,\P_!L 1 P 1,,1 I' r"I' -¡ ;¡ I . , ' i, , I 1992, , · DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY . NEW YORK DISTRICT CORPS OF ENGINEERS œ-.Œ © Œ U \VI Œ ~" ~ JACOB K. JA VITS FEDERAL BUILDING ,I n j, NEW YORK. N.Y. 10278-0090 ,; '¡ ;; APR ? 9 1992 R[PlY TO ATTENTION Of , rOIN!\! OF '::n~;".,..·::", ,.' ._'_.._..,"__~_':--_ ____:_J.~_~' April 22, 1992 Eastern Permits Section SUBJECT: Application No. 91-0111-L2, by Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association Inc. Mr. Lawrence J. Matzen Marine Chairman Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Assocition, Inc. East Marion, New York 11939-0004 Dear Mr. Matzen : At the joint permit processing meeting held on April 21, 1992,the Fish and wildlife Ser,ice of the U.S. Department of the Interior recommended that the proposed structure to be a minimum 4 feet above the ground and no piles to be driven into intertidal marsh. The National Marine Fisheries Service and the U.S. Environmental Protection agency concurred with the above recommendation. You are hereby given the opportunity to address the agencies' recommendations if they are not acceptable to you. If they are, please submit revised drawings. If you have any questions, please contact Ms. Sophie Ettinger of my staff at (212) 264-6730. Sincerely, &h1~. q ,¡:¡;,,.~ ,'oI! James W. Haggerty Chief, Eastern Permits section . . GARDINERS BAY ESTATES HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. East Marion, New York 11939 April 29, 1992 Department of the ArMY KY District Corps of Engineers Jacob 1'. ,Tavits Fe:lerEll "u,L] clinc,' ;:ew Yor)" ¡-Y 1027(;-90 ~ Attention: James]. Hagcerty Chief, Eastern ~erJ'lit.s :)8cU,on 2e: ~pplication I~o. 9]-0111-J,2, Gardiners îJay ~stateu }To11eOWnerG Asuoc. Deéir .3irs: Tj1i" letter is in rBslJoy",e to j'ollr letter of April 22, 1992. 70 CO,';I,ly \'lith the rce'.I.,"18,datiot;" of .'fildlife :3ervice of the n.:). DelÆlrtll,ent of the Interior, the ':a.tioÌlnJ_ ~·arine Fisherier.3 .13ervicG éd-lJ the U. ,';. Lnver()l1I.Hjúté\1 '_~'l'ntec t.l()Ù ~J.LG1iCj-, ,I-!e are L,eilùin¿ }Oll rE;vised. '-::rofj~ection éind Proj8ct llli-~jl;:. rrhey will ::j1LO\'j tl1e 1-',rOI1o;-;ü:i :::.Lruct'Jr,:: to ~E a UiLd.hUi¡l Lt-' (-!.bove tilt:! cround and no pileE ':li 1.1 ",e dri VP.\l ii; tr; t;,e in tertiJuJ. ;;;¡:,r¡;J¡. If therp. bre any further 'lue,;tji)(,S, Oea:ip. call ¡;e at 51(,-lt77-~~':;7~¡. Your" truly, T,éi,¡:~'rel1ce J. ~ 'atzoIl, (~h¿J.tr :..:,.:1 : 'arine r;OLt., li t tee ."rí-:I'~::_';, TLC. i-:nc. ¡ ~) ¡ ()ï -, -j ~¡ ~I Qj c!", °1 I N .,.,."..,., r 00 ...... Y' - 1 'r! , . ..,..~, -' -' ~. - l__ \t) N \ \ \ .:>(----- '.~ '..._.~.....,.--._...--_... . ~. -. I I ; '.~! ',o~ ' I, <', t' "0 0'>:: Orl so (\j bDSO o.¡..> P(\j ~..u.>:: u "' U <D 0 '0 ~P ~<ÙoIi p..,..:¡ .<; 1: ~ / J \( U(j') ;:;"hi D_' 8~ lJ· ___'JJ-t 'l , ~~,\W'CI , ~ - , ¡.,,, , "J:~' I ... \it I o. _ ~r-' .. ~. , :,. 1. ! ¡ ¡: I , :' I ,·:::'fT:=-i~:'-.I , { Ii ...:...::':":( r ~ J: , , <L~ 0- ~~ ~~ t, J I , __n~t.. , In - b -------- u _ __.__ . lu <Dq UJ~H ~:'J:j ft ft <D . "0 ¡:: ¡:: UJ ¡:: ¡:: 0 'M <D UJ o .~ "'d...µ U} p.. ~ ~ (\jet: (\j (\j.¡..> bO~:t!}{QtQ ¡:: :i) ~ 'M .¡..> .~ <D ~ UJ rl>,¡:: PI ca ro so tI} r·1 et:JY1 0 ¡::(\ wa- N'- ...¡..>..:t '¡">I\J'- ¡::::>.:r<> (\j .¡..> . rl >-;¡ .. ;::J "0 UJ . w ¡::,..:¡.¡..> o (\j u n ... , I)- : ~{1!; ....Q( ... ' " <,¡; ~(\{¡ nl-i ~Uji - 1.1.1. I fi,:t.! ",It). I ¡ r ! ¡ I ! , , h: o lr'\ -I) C\J .~ :.-:.µ ~ o...µ - rc; ..µ;(¡ t·r', ..µ t".:: - :\~ rr) 0.', C1j -T 0 .; r-! 'u- ..µ ~.~ C¡....¡ (\J u OJ W r-I ~...µ - ill ¡, 0:' ':)-,-1 .... -I...) :> f\.J.,-j ü '1 (I' ~,~ (~I 0 ~ rl ~. "..r C' 1.' ..j-r·{ì U ... I' t; ,:) ~ " fQ:. \1- ,CJ) rz: 10 !0 (y: 1;.' o D .... .....,..-~ o rf) ."}( ~i '.' -1--" ill ~:: ~ rl .1 .t~ (t.:' :1 "rl -'-I :'.' "::: '.1) r·:'~ ~-w :..:) - iJ) (t~ O\.OC\! ',.) U p~ r-I ':~ C, _-=-: X·..-I "c') ~..¡...> - (H ç: (:'~'rl r" 'r-! :-; _"¡"J ..µ ...._j- t') ~: .... ~\J rl "r--/ ¡lj _'-,~, ::-: X X o .-I.r-I- r.1.1 .r-! C'_í. } r:, ,...., ;:-: ~'i C) r.:'f -I-j. ~u I :> n~ Ci:í ~}~ ü ..,: u {] 1\] ;-: t t ! t ¡ , ¡ CI' ...... Q 11 -, '0 !II "- IÚ .... « :J _.. ~. _.~_.~-""--._----~..._------ ."h' .,,-.---, . 10- I ; , I , <: hO ,O~ -- _0_ _ _ .9_., '" ~ I of' Ir"~-)\ -... i I i I II , ' "": ~'. . ", ..I, Q.., H 0, 1..1' hi of æ: 0..1 I . , .- .- . ,.. ~/' A\ . / ,t (I ,. ,~ A ,.(\ ,.. I / l_ .-- .-- .-- , ~ [>. ,,~. ~ ~ \=I.,~ ~ ~J... ~ VI <!. oil!! -,- .. " "'"x L¿J <0 '>- ~" a ~ a ~ ,f. " IN I' I, '1 Io.M,¡I I I ~-- -.... --- , , ; , ; ~ , I ¡ I ! ~ .- - -- - ( r0l ) -rOo- "'.:t- ð - - - :, .'. , ). I ~ \ ___nuh -,-~~~---- t1I II- CII t>I ~ 'U 0..'<: Orl ~ l1:! bO,. o +>..-.: ql1:!{) 00 ~: .CD '" o . '" l1:! ~>-1 ~ 'Us:: 1:10 O'M ~, H oj bO'7' s::-. 'M+> H u¡ p,oj UJ r<l l~r l' . ! : I 1 , , i , òo - i , ¡ : I <-.h~ '~- i 1 ,]- --d-'- ~) I , I CD . u¡ S {) HOS:: Q) t:r: t-I s:: 'M u¡ J' 'UCDU¡ H +> u¡ l1:!oj~ c~ +> u¡ u¡ ~..µ-¡ ~ :>-,s:: oj ¡: ~rf.l 0 N\ \ , \-, N , '«J I " 1 C\J s::~ "CD'- +>N~ s::+>'- l1:!oj", ..f.J '"';' rl .'. ::J . 'U u¡ 'J CD s:: . +> 0>-1 oj u q <1 IJ '" > '" It: (lJ "'- " I ; t : ¡ L--~-:"dT-'!' , , I ' tJi_"'rr.;~ ! ,="(\\, I 'I __. __' _, I , _.. _. a -.. ___I ,-:::! / ". : I f^ ^ I, .(I 'I I ¡I¡ I}' f r I . I!I I ,t,,'( ", .1 '\ ~-'Pf ".------.-- I I I , I I J (\ : ¡- :fú ,\.tJ , T: 'Uì ;' ~:: '0 'h. ì + i !<.J } in> Iii,... ~" ¡ ~.n :(J ¡.....; :~/, 1 ~ ;0. ~ .f ) (~J """': 'I. ~ j~¡~ L.¡ IV ¡j :0 ;¿- i 0 .cj í :V¡ i I ' .J -. -.. _ }: 3J.1,¡.~.....,O"1'''' ..--_..._....3"" fi'--l1 1.\ {I'---'''- I "' t: H5uv"" I ~~ ~ ^ l{ ,,""CItL\';I.LIVI " I I ~ ~ j ~ ~-~~ --- ~~¡'Õ¡¡-;';ØQ- ·ô·~-;,··, . " ,~ -r-r '. ·f7..J.3~ :¡ii,-' _~_.. , I ¡ a,~ '.~ ~ I I ,I~---------------\ \-- ,OO( 1 .....". '- ' --.! N ':'-1 ~.1 ì,...-", -' ~.,. ,L51 of__ H.L-(l//"1·--':''' 1 --..." ._"- } "n ¡,I~ \ 'I}",:r: \ ~... ~ \ 0'" 0 ~g ~ \ ~ ~Jt;:. ..!I:. .~. ..1 '- " \ ~ 3 * g ----.. '.I:\b:.: "\311\/..'<1'8 , '- "<!to> .".~ "'J ~'Iy -1>" ~t".. '\. ..... ~ ~ 2. '" - ::, . {) 1>- u a. ~ :c 4' ....... ~ z ? \l ~ ~ ~t~ V1 >I ..-.'~-- j i ¡ . .-_::::_"':.7.:...::'"">-;- -':Jf¡.¡n .,-~'C.. -?~;)~{](' ~:'~~\~ _"J .~. :.._~: :æ:.t:::I . . .", ',~, - :-"~ !;¡, ii / ) ø -,.' . ~.." ....~t" rI "), ,>;,},.n:"" ;¡ ~l..' . HARVEY A, ARNOFF Town Attorney SCOIT L. HARRIS Supervisor -~ . -~-".- Town Hall. 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Fax (516) 765,1823 Telephone (516) 765-1800 MAITHEW G, KIERNAN Assistant Town Attorney OFFICE OF THE TOWN ATTORNEY TOWN OF SOUTHOLD CONFIDENTIAL MEMORANDUM ~·~---:;'->~-'-~'-:I~--7i~ '\>; ¡2· '.,1 ~ ; ,[U'-~_L":L.L.CL! nil I r---- , I' . Û APR ,- 9 1992 l~) TO: Zoning Board of Appeals ~' Board of Trustees Harvey A. Arnoff, Town Attorn~v TOWN OF SOUTHOLD '-'-'- FROM: DATE: April 28, 1992 RE: Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association I matter. have read the letter of Marie Ongioni reference the above-referenced My interpretation of the applicable code sections are as follows: There does not appear to be any impediment to an "owner" having as many docking spaces as he or she de¡;ires, provided same are for residential use and the boats are, in fact, owned by the property owner. In addition to that, however, they may have docking facilities for no more than two "non-owner" boats. It would appear that we have a rather anomalous situation in our Code since it would appear that if the homeowners association does not own any boats than the maximum number of slips they can have is two. I recognize that the foregoing interpretation may create a good deal of problems for not only existing but future dock applications. May I suggest that we all meet at a mutually convenient time and place (perhaps with Councilman Penny) so that we may discuss how we want to address this now and in the future. Since Marie Ongioni seems to be pressing the issue, kindly contact Mary upon' your receipt of this to schedule this meeting. cc: George Penny, IV, Councilman . LAW OFFICES OF . r''''"-~-:-- .....-- '.. I fõ! JL~Ž--.~_tWJ Œ ,~ Uù APR L, 4 1992 ~ MARIE ONGIONI 21 B FRONT STREET P.O. BOX 562 GREENPORT. NEW YORK 1 1944 TOWN OF SOUTHOlD MARIE ONGIONI CARMELA L. BORRELU TEL. (516) 477-2048 FAX (~IE;¡ 477-8919 April 21, 1992 Ms. Linda Kowalski Zoning Board of Appeals Town Hall Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Re: Gardiners Bav Estates Homeowners Assoc. Dear Linda, Please refer to our previous conversations and Marie's letter of April 14th with regard to the Association's application pending before the Board of Trustees to move and construct docking facilities at Gardiners Bay. The Board of Trustees has requested that you confirm by letter the decision in the Dellala matter wherein the ZBA found that the owner of property may have docking for no more than two boats in addition to those owned by the property owner (which in essence means any number of boats owned by the owner plus two other boats) . The Board of Trustees has agreed to process the Association's application but would like confirmation of the statement I s in Marie's letter regarding the aforementioned decision. Thank you for your assistance in this matter. Very truly yours, MARIE ONGIONI aJ By: Carmela L. Borrelli cc: John M. Bredemeyer III, Board of Trustees Larry Matzen, Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association . . TRUSTEES John M, Bredemeyer, III, President Henry P. Smith, Vice President Albert 1. Krupski, Jr. John L. Bednoski, Jr. John B. Tuthill --;:.~~. "reiJ!" --:"', '''';''V~''%'''' ,.....>i .',". "-~ ,'- ;-<-( :::::.~ S -, ~ _'". ~ ~¡ ;~'J ";;",' .::..:., !5;, ,'$'" l,.¡¡. ,~~\1 ,',"'" ';),.'.0' .:~ '?r ~. -> .iY ,- ," - .. ~ .~ .- - - - , ~-·::"'0,:-:;:::;,::,:.j_~~ SUPERVISOR SCOTT L. HARRIS Telephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516)765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall 53095 Main Road P,O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 LEAD AGENCY COORDINATION REQUEST -:s:"'-""<:S ~J1<:..d"y, (:\, 'h'{ CD, p. TO: \:)c...~\e.-..e.. ~,(,.e,Io:",o, .DEL.. DATE: Y':',J,I-ct;;!... Enclosed is a permit application and a completed part I of the Environmental Assessment Form. Southold Town Trustees are interested in your ageny's comments in acting as SEQRA Lead Agency for: NAME: &<.:u'¿'",....-" Ih'-Y fS\4,~ ¡..j.",,,,,,"- Ö'-".:..,=::' A~:x"<..,~"",, LOCATION: L::c~ LVe"" L..'~. L--.:,....-L.."'-,'> P'<L..{ C',j.,) £c.b+- V¥'A-I",'ì TAX MAP: 10Du-::'7_ L-j-17 PERMIT * DESCRPTN: See.. fH\£u:..,«4 PERMIT REQUIRED: M TO~ SEQRA CLASSIFICATION: ~) o WETLAND ( Type I UNLISTED ) OTHER ( ) Type II ( ) CEA Please contact John M. Bredemeyer, III, President, within 30 days and be advised that the Southold Town Trustees (WANT)/(DO NOT WANT) to assume lead agency. SENT TO: DOS ( ) DEC (~) DOH ( ) PB ( ) ZBA ( ) BLD ( ) #,<r"'/ CP<P,</ Please complete, detach and return this form to expedite processing. Involved Agency: Project Name: Location: SCTM: We at (Have/No) objection to Southold Town AGENCY Trustees assuming Lead Agency. Comments/Reasons: Signature of Authorized Representative '- . . DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY NEW YORK DISTRICT CORPS OF ENGINEERS JACOB K. JAVITS FEDERAL BUILDING NEW YORK. N.Y. 1027B-0090 ~' REPLY TO ^ HENTlON O~ April 6, 1992 Eastern Permits section SUBJECT: Comments Received in Response to Application No. 92-0111-L2, by Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association, Inc. Mr. Lawrence J. Matzen Marine Chairman Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association, Inc. East Marion, New York 11939-0004 Dear Mr. Matzen: Correspondence expressing concern regarding the subject application has been received by this office. Copy of the letter from Mr. Warren Sambach Jr. RA is enclosed. It is requested that you provide a response and/or rebuttal to the items raised in the attached correspondence. You may elect to voluntarily contact Mr. Sambach to resolve his concerns with the proposal. However, this is not mandatory. If you have any questions, please contact Ms. Sophie Ettinger of my staff at (212) 264-3912. Enclosure ~' incerely, (I,j /ji ~ J/'" 'r, ..' JJ:'o,* /, " , (jO I J Haggerty C Permits Section ·, . sAMBACH ASSOCIATES Architects 11 Halter Lane LEVITTOWN, NEW YORK 11756 n .re'~~"" 1\YlJ. (f!) lJOO([D LETTER Phone 731-5506 Oat. Ap r i I 1, 19 9 2 ToDepartment of the Army NY Distric~ Corps of Engineers Jacob K. Javitz N.Y. N.Y. 10278-0090 James W. Haggerty Chief, Eastern Permits Section Subi.ctApp. #92-0111-L2 by' Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Assoc. t" Dear Mr. Haggerty: with regard to the above application I would like to submit the follow- ing: a copy of the plans with some comments of mine, a copy of my letter to the Southold Board of Trustees and a copy of the Town Trustees, Town of Southold Wetland Ordinance Hearing Calendar. Please note that the application before the Town Trustees is the same application by Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association as your file number 92-0111-L2 The plans, as submitted to you, show both in plan and section, 9 piles for the proposed new catwalk ramp and floats. I question the "piles" shown or indicated on the catwalk and ramp-are these piles? I also question the piles shown in the middle of the intertidal marsh. These piles should be on either side or end of the intertidal march as I have marked on the plans you sent me. I also question the amount of piles? The plans you ".-' sent me show 9 piles and the Town Trustee notice says 3 piles. There are some serious discrepancies on these plans, from what is shown, what is written and what is required. Although the zoning, use of the property, and the D.E.C. requirements do not come directly under the Department of the Army NY District Corps. of Engineers there are some further "adjustments" and "requirements" that I feel are necessary at the Town, and D.E.C. level, and some minor dredging for the relocated catwalk, ramp and dock. SIGNED [OJ Please reply o No reply necessary ,--- rur"t 'IJO 2 ^~,"I"hle1rom(~I"c..G'Olon.M3511 01450 ,....'. ~ IÞ '...,.., l.\YJJ(jJ)[][)(J,([D LETTER SAM BACH ASSOCIATES Architects 11 Halter Lane LEVITTOWN, NEW YORK 11756 Phone 731·5506 Date April 1, 1992 10 Subject Page 2 of 2 I would also like to receive a copy of any correspondence of comments and/or approval that the Corps. sends to the Gardiners Bay Estate Home- owners Association Inc. Thanking you in advance for your time and consideration. t~sa~ P.s. Please address all correspondence to: Warren and Lani Sambach 11 Halter Lane Levittown, NY 11756 SIGNED L I Please reply o No reply necessary r'_"'" I~O ~ "'~".lble '.om {-',iFif!Jllnc.G,oton. Ma.,s 01450 , . '--···..--'·----.'·-.'·'..'..-t OA:¡~~~·I~V·Ë..-~~=~~~~:---;. ..---~~; Ii',' N '6i "'- WlO'f"J.I - , fT', : It 11\ ~ ' 187' AT wi'\T¡;,I~ 'I "-Ie 0 'f <>'¥"\1 "- J, 'I, ? " 3' ç~ . I' I ~ ~ 1 '\" c: -G!~ ! ~ ~ l ~o6 ~i'\~ ~ J¡,' --{ \~." ¡¡ ~, 'I~ ~".~ ~{ ~ '" ~ '3 ~ ~Ë ~ , ~ ~l ; l:t: i~ · ; ~ 1 ~itt ~ : : ':í' ~ J. ~ ~_ !j~,,~) '";'~__'" .... . . (,I' :r ~ .~''''~ -:f'· '...., .-..,. .- - - - ~ , .... '-'T---' ) i rw-> ~ I " , ~ ~: f {! ¡: -d.-~ _ )' VI 1/) :: Y..., '. ," , .~---(-, I. ro_ __ """'---'''V ~ __t.~_ ._~ f I .or -'" ,to '/' I I .... [l It v' ¡::~, t-'- 0., t r-' I _r, It,:~ .-----f ; : .. ..... I I '" I , n-t~¡ --~ð --- :¿o' .._-----:--'~.----,..- - .. .-.......-...----.-.- -,- I' ¡ I I ¡ ! I ¡ , ~ I i I r v¡. 0, )0-' ,-I I r' ·....1 I ~f I ~~ r I r.~¡ I L t I , I I ........ -. ---- ME:.""", J,.Ø~Ï\Ti,t _... _._ ......., '\. "1i!: 01-'\1 /.¡/<;s.- ~.... ~'Î' '........ 100' -\ '\ ·--·..?..i.eJ)1. \v Ii' "-,..~~.!?-'I.O.N~'V" 1'" f' l' ,I, IÑTEI\TlQI'IL.~ f 1'o'^"ISH y I) \:I J-- 'Þ 1 '" ~, r I I I I i I 1 I I i I I ! ¡ I , , r i ¡ ¡ ¡ f , , I , ! ¡ 1)) »¡ ... 0, ~"" ~~ 4: ... ~"-t'J~ ~ ¡ 1'1 J' I ",~ ,,: z.\\ ç; 11:., :~'~ I " 'V I "'Z . ;11"1 ¡ ~:.:t : ¥,,~ : i i i I i I , ¡ ¡ I , 1 -I:. ,""h 2Y' ~ --...-----.-..- - , ~ , IV L~ 1., , \l, . I-I~ 'l~ ~';..f01~-i!~--~'I~ (""t-. ~ :;j ~ d (fJ Ii . 0 mÿ(¡) m -I c+~.' ~...J. p.. ¡:: '1 l>J.. i:1 ~ .. .. -I 0] en ~0t1 Ro 0r+ ';" (. - c-t- GJ JU v1i,,'S\) :b J.J JU t-j'U Öo 0" '-....c-t Ij tn ct..., f-'. 0 . .r.-Nr - tnCDP. Ot;l oJUtJ ........... .s I)] IJ· i:1 p. þ¡" r+ 0 \f)t1 t1. o Oq I\J Hi:t1.. ~... 1.:!01- 0 o(31)] 0 ... P- I .__.--...----,.-,.....--::.-...........,..."......., ...-......._""'._...0-.......-......_.....,._. ........... .........__ou.........._..................-......~ I ~ , ~;,II ~!~~ ~ ~ !Jtl J. ~-~ ~l if'; §i':: it, I ! i ¡ I I I I I , , ! 10 )0 ¡ () /:. ! , (J' 0\ 21 1.1) I -11 :.<.1 ¡ ~ -I i .., \ l ~) 1 -,. "\ '::"1 :! i ! I ¡ , L" I ¡:t.:~ !O\i,; 1'~(111 -II! i \\~ I~ ' 1-'," !II! ~ ¡ J\I i I , . --'-~--,----,-, ~_.._...._. .......__.._.w_~ _._..___..._..__......... . '~ N " - In n » r- [" " , " .. q, ...... CI , 1 1 ! ì I.) 0 I" 0 dot-' ;j CD· tI1 p. '" .. c..1~ . & S\> vl:-~ tJ '-11>& .~(""I·.. ,-" '0 CD I\J::J o I " i I' = ;~~.li~', ¡"I;~r:;:.~ :&: r _5 I ' '-1'1 ~ C,.' . ~:~ '~,i ,I: Q= 11 "ù'Æ - , :!i J¡f1"d ~l 'rii, ! ~ it) -s1. lj .- \J 0, j I q -----),<;" I I I i I '" () , q ~r--i- ' ~ ¡;1 -0 c::l t=== ;: ~g I' L-l ï- I I' I'~I~ ~ ?' ~,w<.Ig¡ --- .- ~ 1 ¡ I~¡ !;t ~~ J~I:~ - ~ ~ I' ~ ~ ~, ; ; ~ T=lll' ~ '- '-I' 1 _to I' I :1 I J - - - - ~ '11 I~ :' 1 1 P 1\1' i, : fl. ª !~ i ~ I~ 8 I~!I ,¡ 1,6 ~ 6-!l:.. '~, ,0- j 'I ~.... t) I' ;~' -..,!::! i:::.. ... X it l= o .AI D (f: II> JT\ () '"i o I r~ I I i ,i~ i \1\ f"""\: .. 1f1~ \'" ï ~- , ' {:)- * -::J - '0 ~ " ,,","g~h I -/ ~ ~~~ I '" 0?; r.\. - ~ .. î'" 1=~ )=....,.. ...... 1 ( :¡¡8 1'\1 ¡III)' 0p », l' .¡ , , c::) I:=.-: ..' .. ' ! -- f ..... 't.;. , .....-_.._~-- ....._-..... ...- .....--..--- o ~I> toJ tJ1 ~.< gl-' ~ ~ <II . & 1-" Ii I.>J I:J CII CII G1 :3: oq >¡:~ ~ 'tI CII & p. .... 0 CII CD 1-'. () I:J :j CII I:J I:J p. . <II ~ ~ Þ>1 Ii 141:1 en U fI) n I t"u R"¡Uli o t:H1 . o <II n:o¡n þ¡' c+ 0" I1>t:;I &0 ., oq ~g Po ,$ \J r fr 1)' ~ r-~ k ro, h ._-_.----- ....--....... ........~.,....".....~.... ..~-. ........... ~............. .....~~...-~- . . 460 Bayvlew Drive East Marlon,NY 11939 Mailing Address -11 Halter Lane Levlttown, NY 11756 March 23, 1992 John M. Bredemeyer III President, Board of Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall naln Rd. Southhold, NY 11971 Subject:Gardlner's Bay Estate Homeowner's Assoc. Town Trustee Meeting "larch 26, 1992 Dear Mr. Bredemeyer: It has been brought to my attention that the Gardiner's Bay Estate Homeowner's Assocletlon of East Marlon ha~ filed an application along with plans for a catwalk and floating dock for four boat slipS and to relocate an existing catwalk and a two boat float In Spring Pond, East Marlon. N.Y. I am against this proposal. As a member of this Association. as the adjoining property owner, as the present owner of the "to be relocated" catwalk and as a Registered Architect In the State of New York, Florida and Arizona I respectfully submit this letter based on my review of the plans and application of the Association. The plans do not accurately describe the conditions that exist at the site. A survey wss prepared for the Asspclatlon by Roderick Van Tuyl, P.C. There are serious discrepancies between the Association's plot plan and the survey: specifically the MHW line, the MHL line and the spartlna grass location. In fact there s no Indication of any epartlna grass on the plot plan and there Is substantial spartlna grass In the area of the proposed and relocated catwalks as per the survey. According to the plans and Section depicting the propoeed construction, a hinged catwalk Is shown approximately In the middle of the spartlna grass. If built according to plan, this catwalk would not remain the constant 4'-0" above the spartlna grass as required by the Department of Environmental Conservation. The plans have a general note "minimum of 4'-0" above the spartlna " but with the hinged catwalk the approach to this hinge Is not 4'-0" above the spartlna nor Is the hinged section down to the floating docks, both are shown on an angle. There ehould be a "fixed" section of the cetwalk 4'-0" above the spartlna with a hinged approach ramp at one end and a hinged ramp down to the floating dock at the other end. The width of the spartlna from the MLW line to the edge of the landwood aide of the spartlna Is approximately 8'-0" to 10'-0" wide. 11 fixed 8'-0" to 10'-0" catwalk, 4'-0" above the spartlna has to be provided. From this fixed catwalk a sloped catwalk approach could be attached as well as a hinged catwalk down to the floating dock. CC©f1f '. . ...._-~._.- I do not feel the plans should be approved without showing what I have,descrlbed above. The proposed catwalk, In order to meet the code, must be built this way' It will now protrude further out Into the pond than as shown. Although this Is not the Town Trustees concern, the new length of the dock will Impact on the boats travelling In and out of the potld and on the boats moored In this area. The eKlstlng catwalk that Is to be relocated approKlmatley 12'-0" east has eKIsted In Its present location for approKlmately 25 years which 'was prior to the Gardiner Bay Estates Homeowners Association becoming the owner of the property, The catw~lk was built In 1967 by the former owner of my house. Gardlners Bay Estates became the owner's of the property In 1974. Since this non-conforming catwalk Is proposed to be relocated It too would have to conform to the present day requirements for a catwalk ove,- spartina grass (as previously outlined). Once again, the submitted plans do not reflect that fact nor address any dredging that might have to be done In order that any boats tied to this float would not "sit on the bottom" at low tide. If even minor dredging Is required, the proper permits should be filed for with the NYS DEC and the Corps of Engineers and show where the dredged materials (spoils) will be deposited, The proposed catwalk and float will be for Association Members' bosts and Association Members' use (a public area). A hsndrall must be Installed as per the New York State Building Code Sec. 713.1(f)(1) and (3) and (4) and the Life Safety Code of the Stete. This handrail should be 30"-36" high and" shall be designed to resist a lateral Impact at the top equivalent to a minimum linear load of 50 lb. per foot," Sec. B03.9(b). The railings or vertical members should have not more than 6" epaces between them. The plans as submitted do not reflect these code t~equ1rementB. The plot plan also falls to show the location of another catwalk and two boat float on the Association properLY In question. This catwalk Is correctly Identified and placed on the survey prepared for the Association by Van Tuyl. This catwalk and float also have been In existence since 1967. I further trust that this application complies with the Town Zoning Uequlrements for the Residential Zone (R-40) In which the property Ie located. Thank you for your time and consideration. RA t(Q)f1f i:," ','-; - - ~~~~~i~~i:~~~ I!~i',iIt~:·~¡~;;~;;;t~;;; f.~":~~!!~~:i:::' '" "': ' ,:. ,,11IAT.VBUCIIBARlNGSWlLLi ,·TownolSwd,oldrodOlo. ',bcloroM..eb27.1992. AII,oob " ,,;,' ,'; ,::DB flBLD 'BY THB .IQ)Ïl:!:' AUbiJlmo".be:Ii¡ned.ncI leal..s, '...........ooruå.e4WW......IlId· ~;I ~ \,1........ "' : TRtJSTBRS OF THB TOWN Of; m e.",~lopa.l,, llnly malk.r.d I'Bid on: . c~ and the Vd.... ..w. dOl. RqUtI" .", fï'"¡ ::', I . _SOurnOlDLAT THB SOUl1l0LD i D.tnp Trudu",ud lubmJued to 1.bt the. relttae of Pedenl (\h\d. or take ," ". [''',;:',,: ""'OWN HALL . MAli! ROAD' Ofnu.f1hoTow.CIork. Tb. bid ,...y.dmInlIU.II.."'¡""wltblnd>.;,;,ì .j .. ,.j.; .::SOUTHOLP, NSW YORK ON: p'¡u Ihall.o< Indodea.y "0, lod. 'proj... poI...o ",..delt I....m... In', : ,1 .~ ¡., '. .:) .~SDAY MARCO 16.. 1992 ON: eral, stale or IOf.lI. hom which ,he dle.preœdbta IBnlmoe..- . ," . . .". . :: ,I ¡!.. .:": ',TIIB fOLLOWINO APPLICA.' T.....ISWIb.ldll..orn.., .. 00...abouIM..cII30,I\I92,""'. ' : i ",,' " TION9 fOR, PBRMITS UNPBR i.. ,DATBD: 1.1.."'6, )992. : ......,nomed V,u'a. wID .........Ib. ' ".I" , 'IlIn PROVISIONS Of 1118 WBT. : . IUPITII T. TERRY V.s. o..p.,tmont clll"",lna..,d V.· ' l,il..:i·,: ;"LAND ,ORDlNANCB Of TIIB, SOIfl1!OLDTOWN CU!RK ban Do.tlopn.n. 10 odu.. Ped",.. " ',TOWN.: ,:' 7J2J·ITMI2 ' r,'nd. .nd..1iu.lor th.lloullna ,I , 7:15 P.M. _ ¡" lb. moue, or the LEGAl. NOTICE .nd C'.oauwmty Dovel""",.., AI< or d' ~ .,.pptiw\un.r l.m.. M.Mehon on: NIYfICE OPFlNDII'IG OF ·11'14 (l'L 93·J83) lI...encIod lor the ..' " .' , be:holl..', S...lbold Tow. to dn:da.' NO SICI'IU1CANT IMPACf ebov. pto t<O. \ \, .,10.000 cubic y..d. .101.... nnd' ON TilE ENVIRONMENT 1b. Villi" cl G.....pcxt It .."i· (I.': " " ' ,.I"" Golcitmhh·, Inl.. ond pi... \he: ANO - . 'yln, '0 IIVD Iboo ,b. Vlllea' .1 " ",:mlledoI "" Kenny'l &ad¡ ond TowlI' ADVANCE NOTICE TO 0.....1'011, New york.... W'tW.... R. . :, Propo"y: 3$S ~bur¡ '11 . .' ,:B..oIt. Southold. TIúI m.1tlbt w.. ' PUBLIC OF REQUEST fOR Poll, m, in hil .melel e.peellY .. ; " u" R..d 13). B... b " ,:'1011 durinalh. Oe.. JO '" (XL 3t, ¡ , RELEASE OFFUNOS M.y"" ....ltnll to."""" Ibe JIm. ¡, Courtly 'IQ Mop Pomel, ,;.19911'0..0., . ..' ANOCER11FICATlON dltdm.,\be Ped....OOWII 1f....."t,it.OI.J7.1 C.......I..clld ., '" 7:16 P.M.....InIb. m."..clth.', VlI\oa.oro..o...... d""II.....PIIOatl....nopondbU.):.:,¡.!,J7 n &30).', " ;1: "'.. ,.i. 'P'Plicarion of Mad. Tropia reqUett ¡ 236ThhdSlred. ·.lti~, In ~ 10 amtmlßeDW .....·~·X·~ ";;:f(Jj·1:40 .¡.rn;·i.....1 ~~,.:,!ì: '.' . ·~:parmh to COhllrue' lODe hmilY'1 g-..POIII,pNowYiRl""'hI19d""c I '. ,"I'~ILdeci'Ioa"m.kta. UI'I~oq:·' ·.~~~ANTHON AND-OBI. ,:+,dwo~,76'r"""ddolwetlondolJno, on o. ,...on, 0 or '11""0,' '," ond'u...II1......'I"""lbHltlolbo...',', ':'SOUROS.11If1 It.. 'F }t ,,' ,"U d<Jh>...... by lb. To..... Trulltel , ' 1..11 Direa...,(SI6) 477-2J91 ..'. ,,:,bt~ bI ¡!I....,The..... df... ollh.~,~..ï¡- ....odDa .4ot.1IIÜnIIIoo ~: );"11,'." ..'" "'. ,.1.' " )oed.. per ..~otd """"Y.doIedl... .' "'1 Conlfylo,.orrl...II .woo.., I\, Poll,l\ ~~",~ ""IftIrðvII ii\iIII~cH'H;;¡¡\íj"'í"\hIi1oor ð , "..ry JI, 1993, l.ouled .. Sl..~y m. M.oyor .. .' lb. Villi,. ol O.....pen, N.w York, ' .....110< "' ..ob_ il tt i'ii :,,;. .: .. ,.. TO AIJ..IlflF.RESTIID AGBNC\1iS, ..' m.y..~ .... BlooI< 0..... /uodJ. ond,. ,"iAnlclo ID. Soodoa 100., I ¡i ,',', '.,.. ,> ,¡~' ,7:17P.M. -Inth. _01 lit.; GROUPS,ANDPBRSONS, ,',IIIID will"".. '!'IofIo4ll1 .._..,., ,·~"'lIoI. XXiV....... 10< 'f! .,...'.... :'" j,.".."u..iloot ol,Oonllo... O.y, ø...... \ , n..b......."'od VUIo""'-' ,,' ·lIblUlI.. u.de. lite Ndlunil B.vi,:,_ U!øIJa. OrrIÎa_ Any ¡'fi>:'.: ", .".,IIOtDOf'".''' Alloelell... IOqu.n¡. ,I. "'10<11 lb. V.S.' Dcpe"m..' or.:: ',' """"",,101 ,Policy AI< or 1969.IWD¡;I~, "~'COII, uillorllbt¡lo.f.aJl1 [ :'ti'" ".;" 1.,:. permilro.......". J' X 16' oo'woII:', ",",II., oed U,..... D..olOl",enl" ,; """,wm ........'" obj...loe,!o I""f')~' oI,i:cIàøa;,..bJeêt,.,"'" , 1. !!1, ' " .. -1-'.: (eIov..... ....., .rwI.~ " X 16' '""""! ....... Ped.,oIlund,..,d..lIdo 1 or ,¡ ': prt>~ only if Þ It "" one olll1.dol~~'<, ,J1oi '....1\1, .lpIle '.. í . ;lfJ;t.;: :.... . ·;.,¡..4' X 24' no.I.with 2 _ 3° X 14" rm.: : the HootiD. .nd Communlly De· ; , '. .1øWJn, buu: (a) dUll dtø CIII1ifica&lOft·)i~,.tlii prvYlII, e.o. a. "flulr : ; ¡ ¡J ~ ;::." .' f· ~ len and :5 pD"~ abo rAOYlII uI'dÐ,! \'elapnen( Act or 1974. I' unllnded,. ~ ;' J "I' øot¡ In r'aI eUl:l&l.aI hy the œrd-(' .; _..-deI ThlI..t¡_lœ ¡ ;¡J ',,1 (~: ' ~,:~;""'0II: 11' UJI: III ~..k "" APOOi- I (PL, 9J.J8~) 10 be Uled 10' th. 101·'¡'ì}:!:,I)1o'.o1Iiœ.Or om... ol,~I; I' ~tbe,R-4Ó R..1tIoGtIaI %' ¡¡;~,'\i" ' ,\ .',..... rilJtl 01 w,y ond pood property. lo"'"a proJoetln 111 Py 1990 S",II1'·; ( 'e~'¡'¡ by, HUD; .,,(b)ïMlIt!,O Þ· ,[II'odd W. deoeribod poÌu 1'\',1' . :.'_ ~ ~~ s .' Pœd' M OD. ¡ Chiu Communhy. D~velopn\tnt.;:::··,··plioln.~r.Rnyhonmen..l R*vle.~~I~:.vi~d dnoup deed CIa I ~!,':;;',..' .~ ~fí' ; ". I\tem.~lero; BI~O~lProsnm. . ...ReooRlrDf.~'projKtlnd.1cataomlt'!,~r,\:~2I3016O.lOth.pnleQtl \1.q·.'I¡\ '~:'~ : JO'tcpb Friedman to coo_Un' fixed;. . &uidllWU' VI~lnl Slruclure.' .(on·of. ~'rired ~tdJIOlt ~in. oi:;,::~~}1on tI~Y'..l~2.S ('i .1, t '. ,i '.' opcD..walkway l' X 35'; ldDaed mnp' .~ Provil1OO SIr AddnJon.,1 Houlln. .lIep .ppUcable to die project. in the ;"'{ ::' of) Tucker L.lla" SOl ti ~:!t: ,:.; , . 3" X 11'1 .wo ßo.linalkd., t-tdJ So! J~n1u - 224 South Slt,..f'~ The VD- tb\'Ùauntnbl review proceu. Objcç. ::. Cqwtryfu M.p P,rcell , X '¡ n..ÛIII doeltJ 'CCURd by I.." I..., 1I1~~b .Ib. 0,,,,,,,,,., H....In, II"", mull be pn;pen:d ond ~hmlaed .. " 59·10.12, ThlI pua:t GO ; \" ~ r~~: .' \...piJe.¡ all per drlwU1&1 Ind dl.1.runl· . A1JlhonlYI WID aequlm the v.unt" in .ocordanc.e wldi Ib, required pro- :~;;. ~.; let area or 20.('00 141. fr..: t .,'" ' ' ,IOl-milted. Loeoled .. S90 RII,y, MIL. bU.hu,d II)U~re 01 224 ~ "olb S..... .. _to (24 CI'R "".. 51) ood moy ... , "':' '" too.O r.... : "1 ¡.'j ..'.ûlUCk.·. . ,. alld ,ubn~ti.U~. n:lllbUhate h b\lo dd....ned to HUD - u.so,Dtpln"'~Ìi ~,!:!;':~H(.1 A 4) 7:45 ,..... ^r ~ J',,:" . ·R ~¡_19 JP.M. - In lb. ","II.. or:' I..W: ""h"". 'J'':.!d''.::::)(onThe 2'beo~,'.OOIU' m . ~ ~ H~" :o!.Vomobon ~,,-"t-';H; ~IUJAMRlÇ I'~D' OOOoooDD^ .....'. OlJll:'tt ohn.onrequenpermltto!, ."UIõ nn...... CIa¡ ('G. ............I'~W.un;I'U_ œflDl_;'::~£:"'" ßI\ I J . conUnn:l · ." X 14° rlo.tinl dock·' (und. '11111 be provided by . locII ~ral Pluaf N~w York. N.. York : ~:. cmcendnl prtml&ef kn ~¡,.'. :~ ";Ih. 3' X 16° nmp. All mauer. 10;' I bank w~, Comrnunh)' Devd~enl.. . 10211. ObJeca.1oni: '0 ihe relute a(: ··S~ Main Roed, laurd (aee .;~~ ¡!.; be made 01 CCA tre..ed Illmbcr~; Fund. wid be. Uh~tJ fur lhc rt;habilha- .. f\utd. ØIt blllO. other Ihan Ihote It.IItd I~ :1' ~ \'. NY. Coun.y Tu MIF :¡ ~!... Located 4SCO 01. J,,¡. illo, M.o1I1.< II"" .Ilbe '.....0... ," , .bo.. 'will n'l b. c.nsld...d by, 'I' ~dOOO-122.06,30.1 (p.. , '. '\, 1\Jc\.. \ ! ., ThJ. adlvit)" ",W lùe place widûn. . ·.I"! HUb. No obJeclioa feceived .allOr.· :l";:~"'deI": ',' ti¿ ::¡.. 7,20 r.M. 'In "'. """". cl Dotty' .b. VIIl.~. 01 G...llpo", Suffolk: ':;: ArrilI4,;Im,wlllbo ~ by'h~~;:·";" (e) Appl. 1'10 ~ \'\'~' ..huowdd........1 ptllDil 10 000''''''', Coun'y.N.wY..~.. ,':II\JD.,.",·.. " ,..,,, ....;;,,*.......lolbeZon...OnIiJ , ~ :~';" ' . . 6', X 30' nOlIln, dock wid> pllol' II bu h.... d".nTW\m "'ot ,oob ' WilUaa R. PeIl,ID. M*y¡,j "',;",.., ¡Ony, Soetl... 10IJ.1t! I " ~l~"-! . I :.·';'aod .....X 10' .runp to u.ttDd.no rur< . t-eqUC.II IOf rdUIO 0(. ",,!dl ViUl Rot , ,VUlI.ae ci On:a1pOlt ~:;w. 8dJeduIe, ' lor pennJnic . ~.,',' ;1, ,,¡'II,ud,.. odj....'dockl. L<tcoÞ:d 29S;. , """,Ulult.. e~.. lI~nifi....lly 0/. .. 236'11tbd S-1.I~,~·~ pddcIpel -,... ~ ~' ::,.~¡.~,;" ',; &11"'&1"" A....M.oIti..ct. ' ", rectlnalb. 300U.y ol,lb. bnm... .n"~:, " pn:oopon.N..."Y....n941 1\"1';,11. pemeI,t1ùrd pda<:~ '.~:: j./_~ ~;. ". 7:21 P.M. _ In lhe maner of. rnnDImt", ,..uordU'lllly,lhc Vilh&e ..1324-1TMI2: -'.' , -, i:tr:" th, ..,.blbhmen1. of 21 I...'.':..... . ·.R~I1Scrln.;."q"enpcinililocm- oIGrunpo"ha.ðeddtdn~t0p'e. .' NUlll:£OFJŒARINGS ~ ~.~... an4~theatabUJlI'Þa i ~+,: ,'._ r"od open woII:wey 4' X 80', PO" ... F.avlrm"",nlo1lmp"01 ~1"" NOTlCB IS IIBRBBY OIVBN, ,'Ory ... ~oId'.III 10 ~ I, , , . hio¡od ....p 4' X 14'. Dootina dock' me.. und.. .be NoIlolIll E....oo, put- 10 SeoriocI, 7.61 of \be Towa.. ."..... ea.obIulua'"lor , .I,;~k; ;,'6' X 20', b....oU Iwo 2.piIt dolp/lllll m....1 Policy A.I..I 1969 (PL 91·' ... l.ew ....111. Cod. of lb. To.... 01 ;.1,:,1...., ol..ed ..bIcI.. , ,,'" . ' , "..,.....IIooIIn' dodt. Loc:oJed :1745 190). Th. .......,10' ,.<11 d,dd... ~ .: SouIhoId; Iha 10000wlo, ........ 1l1li f';1~ oI'.....h., I \'III..... I I ,. 'il ' ' , ': Pioo 'Jìoe Rood Coldq.... oot to P"I"" .um I..."",.nl ,.. .. ,be b.ld I", public hurin_, bel... .... " ~ : lublll'.1e ,b. pro", lJ '" '. c'. ALL PBRSONS INTBRESTBD .. ,loll...".. " . SOUTIlOLD TOWN B9ARD, Of l¡~,·oI.I/I"."."'I" " , .. . , IN SAID MAITBRS SHOUL!) AP. .' I. TI..,. will be: IN] IIgnln""II'I.... ' APPBALS OIlh. S..1hold To... ::'".0:-" ....... ",ld'DI;') .,01 ~ ¡'in:': ;: : PIlAR, AT TIm 11MB AND PLACB " ; I.... .d..... ...lronm..1I1 ' : H.II. 53095 MoIrt Rood, Soothold. ' I· ;>, pttmio.. 111_'" In ,.. ", ,;':"hIlOVnSPBCIF\UOANPWILL; , , ,Imp'..'''' . . ' . N.w.Y....,I\IJ7I.....WBDNUS\>AT;,':.....,....,hoIauoZonoOll1 I. LI:' _ .' \ ;". BB OlVHN AN orroRTUNlTYro!. 1. Any po\~nh'11mplc~. which :. ': MARC".~, 1992 COdIM.eacla, .tìC~~.<;..fill1QI. (If Occupa :'!.! ~~_,' .' . .DB UBARD.COMMBN15MAY Oa . I,bele rroJedl mlY '.\'8 un 111)". . tbø,timeliped6ec1btIoWI ~', I. . ~"'f r:thII&" pttmln. bas t ',: ,':SUBMITIl!D IN WRITING PRIOR ,ropetÙ.. 11..«1 In..,. .li,lbl. ' u) 7:Sf p..... AppI. No; 4090 "'-, 'l:'J:..........pled "lib" ~',',·\<;:,'ì.,'",;,'i...f ':, ','T011IBßQARJNO. ro<lb.N..ionolR'I""~oIHh-. MR. A~P,. MR$: II.. LLOYD, .~i-1 alldlna"-witho. Dated Mudll50 1992 torie PI.ç(!, \VUI be mtlia_lcd . KANHV. Van... 10 1M Zo.uøl 0.-- . ; .L!~ 111 dwtUiD, aM.. . ,i . t .... . ..' :..' . .,. ". JoU M. B~eyer" m. through d,,~ Villase". e~t:culed· dhllllll"~ ·Ardde xxm. Stdkta. 1(Q.. :" ~:j; .:... .(It) AppJ. No ,~i :'~.'~' .':' I" ~tidc:nl MeI'llQrI"d~m or A,fcemenl 239.... tOl'pemúnlOl1 to lXJII.tnltt lei.. .( i :,WÍWAM c. aooDJ ' :; ~;"t' , ,:! ',.. ' .. i:;, 'JIeonI cl T..... TII"'''' (J/JI/!9) ..d Ib, c"'fÚ'~ ... dlllod 10,..1111.. ...U1oa rðr In;' ',¡ !it'lor. S....... n.= ¡.: ',i,:,:~,.~:, >,', , " . I :~: .f .,; .;. . By: TJ.D. ~åIp"aCfk . ~ of1i"b "hnolNIn cl:e ccx>rtk III ratI~. çre~~.d.tJY~~I'. ~~~ i.....:.U ð; ~ ~ !£x, Secd.ort-I()O.10 B(J~ . .:f.;~.'73n.ITMt2 . .... . :'. . '. w\ . e ew lor. .rorlc'. w.bJWI..lOuw.ttuAlaII..ae.......;{.\flPtJøida.!(.)....e ~~);:f.: '. J . ""~:.-: '. üGALNO'IlCE . .j. Prenrvall"ø Olhel. .nd l00.'Mtlromth.17o''''.ltJuai.fr{IitIaamI.(b)antltlbll '~r;: '- ... _.. _.=. :~':'.\. :,_._ _~...:. _ n_..............".... _.".~' .';~.:.;~......... _.. ~.~!~~~.~.~~~ _~~. .(~~. .~~~~~.~!.'.'. ....... ~.l~~__H~~. .~.J_.. .~~~.!. ~~~~. ~. ::'.:: ,~~M!rr. ~.f~."ft!!1 r."""::" 'at !he end of !he m '..' Those' inle.esll:' , Lucas nl 765·9200 ~·NOW,P'a' '.:', Abortion rights ' are ,e~pecled \0 me " S, The Easl End ",Women (NOW) Its 'log early on April: , ,fare Is $40. Rest:rV1 , ¡, Make check! pe Hampton Days. N: . . GARDINERS BAY ESTATES HDMEDWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. East Marion, New York 11939 ~ {} (ilJ R o r {9 15 0 r¡; {}, Qn April 21, 1992 II A~ - /Iii CPR :~ I ~ !¡j~ Section V"," '-::-c~-:--l ~ ,."ì,,o,,,,/ --, _....:,,~,J;,,:, n -'-..,-. -. Department of The Army NY Corps of Engineers, Sastern Permits Jacob K. Javits Federal Building Tlew York, ¡¡Y 10278-0090 Subject: Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Assn. Reply to letter from James J. Haggerty Appl. ,:<92-0111-12 dated 4/6/92 Dear Sirs: As you requested, I am answering, below, questions raised by I~r. Sambach, Jr., in his letter to you dated April 1, 1992. (1) "Are these piles?" Yes, they are piles as noted on crossection. (2) "Piles in intertidal marsh~' Drawings as submitted by me, showing such piles, conform to approved standards by USACOE, !/YSDEC and Town of S¢uthold. (3) "amount of piles in Town notice~' Town showed abrieviated version of plans. (4) Questions on Project Plan: Plans call for moving Er. Sambach's existing "non-conforming" (32" high at spartina) catwalk and 2 piles 12' east, as is. Difference in depth is a 6" trough under his keel. If this is not acceptable we will propose an amendment to the plans to delete moving his catwalk. It would then be his responsibility to move it and conform to today's codes. (5) Crossection plans: In consideration of Mr. Sambach's water view over our right of way property, we tried to make the catwalk as least obtrusive as possible (therefore, the ¡¡lanted catwalk ri¡¡e to 4"). No agency has found this objectionable. I would like to inform you that the land area in que¡¡tion i. a right of way acce¡¡¡¡ to Spring Pond. The As¡¡ociation, comprising 100 member¡¡ (on 79 acres), owns this tax paying right of way and Spring Pond bottom. Mr. Sambach pays the Association a yearly right of way fee to have his dock on Association property. (Page 1 of 2) GARDINERS BJlÞESTATES HOMEOWNERS ASSOCI~ON, INC. To: Department of The Army April.21,1992 We realize Hr. Sambach's Main concerns are his change in view and the added traffic of 4 members using their boats. There are now 4 boat" docked on 2 floats, 2 moorings serviced from here and boat launching. There are also numerous other moorings and docked boats in his view. The Association has always pErser~ed over previous projects with ¡¡;imilar complaints. On October 19, 1991, the G.B.E.Il.A., Inc., Board of Directors, approved the construction of floating docks for 4 member boats on the Dogwood Lane Right of Way. The Southold Town Board of Trustees and the Building Inspector inspected the site on April 18, 1992, in answer to Pr. Sambach's letter to them which you enclosed. I believe I have answered all questions satisfactorily. In moving Sambach's catwalk, as is, r:r. Bredemeyer, President Town of Suuthold Board of Trustees, said "It wail alright to move it, as is, since it was in place for a long time, and minor in nature." He also said it was a matter up to G. R.!':.I! .A. Board of Directors, to decide whether to r.lOve it or not and the Town Soard would not stand between our Association and its members. I hope this letter clarifies the matter. If there are any other questions please get in touch with me. !~ telephone number is 516-477-9675. Yours truly, Lawrence J. ~atzen, Chairman :'arine Comnittee, G.B.E.H.A., Inc. cc: Southold Town Soard of Trustees (FaGe 2 0 f ;:» · . DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY NEW YORK DISTRICT CORPS OF ENGINEERS JACOB K. JAVITS FEDERAL BUILDING NEW YORK, N.Y. 10278-0090 REPLY TO ATTEtlTlOtlOF April 6, 1992 Eastern Permits section SUBJECT: Comments Received in Response to Application No. 92-0111-L2, by Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association, Inc. Mr. Lawrence J. Matzen Marine Chairman Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association, Inc. East Marion, New York 11939-0004 Dear Mr. Matzen: Correspondence expressing concern regarding the subject application has been received by this office. Copy of the letter from Mr. Warren Sambach Jr. RA is enclosed. It is requested that you provide a response and/or rebuttal to the items raised in the attached correspondence. You may elect to voluntarily contact Mr. Sambach to resolve his concerns with the proposal. However, this is not mandatory. If you have any questions, please contact Ms. Sophie Ettinger of my staff at (212) 264-3912. Enclosure ~;~:,:e,',Y'C" J}"ff~ J es W. Haggerty C ief, Eastern Permits section ~~.'" ... ,. . ~~ . . n .n4t"~~'''' 1\)'11 (f!) lJOO® LETTER ., sAMBACH ASSOCIATES Architects 11 Halter Lane LEVITTOWN, NEW YORK 11756 Phone 731-5506 Dale April 1, 1992 ToDepartment of the Army NY District' Corps of Engineers Jacob K. Javitz N.Y. N.Y. 10278-0090 James W. Haggerty Chief, Eastern Permits Section sublectApp. # 92-0111-L2 by'Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Assoc. -, í'" Dear Mr. Haggerty: With regard to the above application I would like to submit the follow- ing: a copy of the plans with some comments of mine, a copy of my letter to the Southold Board of Trustees and a copy of the Town Trustees, Town of Southold Wetland Ordinance Hearing Calendar. Please note that the application before the Town Trustees is the same application by Ga~diners Bay Estates Homeowners Association as your file number 92-0111-L2 The plans, as submitted to you, show both in plan and section, 9 piles for the proposed new catwalk ramp and floats. I question the "piles" shown or indicated on the catwalk and ramp-are these piles? I also question the piles shown in the middle of the intertidal marsh. These piles should be on either side or end of the intertidal march as I have marked on the plans you sent me. I also question the amount of piles? The plans you ~' sent me show 9 piles and the Town ~rustee notice says 3 piles. There are some serious discrepancies on these plans, from what is shown, what is written and what is required. Although the zoning, use of the property, and the D.E.C. requirements do not corne directly under the Department of the Army NY District Corps. of Engineers there are some further "adjustments" and "requirements" that I feel are necessary at the Town, and D.E.C. level, and some minor dredging for the relocated catwalk, ramp and dock. SIGNED [] Please reply o No reply necessary -------- ---- , ._---- rom' '01).2 ^va,I~IIIRhom fNCfj.E1nc. Grol()l1. Man 01450 . .~, , ,", , . r\ rIt"'" 1\YJ1 (f!) lJ[J[],(j]) LETTER sAMBACH ASSOCIATES Architects 11 Halter Lane LEVITTOWN, NEW YORK 11756 Phone 731·5506 Dale April 1, 1992 Subject To Page 2 of 2 I would also like to receive a copy of any correspondence of comments and/or approval that the Corps. sends to the Gardiners Bay Estate Home- owners Association Inc. Thanking you in advance for your time and consideration. ""U!~ Warren Samb h Jr. Architect AND adjoini g roperty owner husband of i Sambach, owner of record t~sa~ P.S. Please address all correspondence to: Warren and Lani Sambach 11 Halter Lane Levittown, NY 11756 SIGNED IJ Please reply o No reply necessary rop" ."r>? ""R~Rbl"from~~'nr;,Grolon.MB!I' 01.50 _ L--~~-'---_:~~:-==- I ; I ì I ì t ) r !t¡. 1"'>, )-' ,-I I rll I...., ~I f- II' .J nl \1 I L I I , I I .-..-..?.!.f~~(, \V ---.- FT/ANh " II' "·-·"'-'-.':':'_,<OUN!I!L~ f' f' f ,/,0 IN1'el\nD"'L r "1^I1S H -r 'J Ii' J-- 'Þ '-. -"---... ME"",v "'Ø~;,Ti:R" _ . _._ 1\ \1\ ~;;!C ...."11 ? )< ;r " ~ .- ")00.);, ..., 11 n , 0 ~ C ... ~ ..., .:J. ........... "- -"¡~ -11' """<;s.- ~..... <!/j' ............ 100' -\ \ 1 '" , þ, , r -+-, - "'t L w ... 'i ---~ 18~~~~~~H ~; tt I ~~ I ~, >1 ~J~,': ~ ~ i¡I~1 \h ~~J;. ~~.:, ~r~ 6 ~\¡¡ ~,Ç ~ ~. 'I~ ¡;~~ 3- Q)'! ~1~: 1: i~ ~ p 1'1 _ '; ~ ','. ¡- tt ~j¡I "''''}'1 ~ P J. --~l~ f.~~~) ~\4____ 'ì ~¿:::~.- '- - ~ ~ :~! .. ·····r-·~~~ .-- I~ , ... o ø I I ... 1'» h> I I 1'i :: -d.-~ - \1' Y -~~y~~.I-...L._.L-t--'¡.y- .__.~~ I t / -} I~ ,/-, v' 'I ...... (~v v ~... I ,__...... __ .._......, I I ~ '---- - 1 ~~.,: -..1.--.-.0- r-¡¡~i-: ," . r I I -r:: , 2Y' -> ' ... , t -----------..---- '" , ' f[~~4¡ - - ""6 - - - . <0' I r I 1 i I ! IV 1., ... \.!., i I I ..... .. i f , I , , ¡ , ¡ i f i ! ..¡~ ( .Jf i' -' í \Y ./ 11) -" »/ "". oí ;....t..~~ 4i ..C~tn ~I l à J!! --"" )1: Z' I : " L" "V ~Z , ' 1"1 ~: ~ ,tl :fb ,.. :. -~ -. . , I ~ , ¡ i , i ! I-I~il~~"~~-~'I~-W~--~Iqt !;f-·::1;::J~dcnt-j -0 (Þ L...¡O) cD I--' rt-1.Jo' ~~. 0.. '" '1 L'J·· ::1 ð- ro .. '-' OJ en 3:0t1 R<' ~ 0 VI iJ- ;¡r :Þ Pi~) e;.d t1 n" ..........c-t::1 rn c+1-f f-'·o 0 () . .r:-t-Je- - cn<Dp.. ot::l oJUö '-moo. 1nf-'0:;10. Þi'rt-o \0:;1 I:f. '" Oq I\J HtJjro ~>! 1:J01- 0 o 13 In 0 . I ) Po .__.~,........................."""'..,... . ....-...,-................--.. .............._~............._-.~...._............-............_..~- .' I . ~~Ü ~ ~ r- g~ .!l ~ i~~ 1-1 ~í~ -.,. !!J &" =)t I ~ ... I I I ¡ 1 I ,j I !¡ ¡ ¡ ! g I i !-:> 1 ; /', ! , ; \)' 0\ 21 (¡) I -11 :,Ü i ~1 -t i ~., \ l) ~ '-t "¡ ! j ! I ¡ I , I ¡~~; \ ,...<. ~' .. , In I· {,(1 --to i)\\~ I., , I...." !III -:¡;. ¡ M i I I , , . . - __-................._·..A....~~~. _, .._.... ...... ....~__.........__...... ...A'..........,........... .....___.__.........._........... ...... ......_........_.. ..._~....... ...., _... . ·_--~:··---7--:'~.,.. ,I !Z! N ~ " - o In o » r- I" "- " II q ..... Q "' \J 0, I.J (') ¡u 0 d-l--t ;j ctI· [ } p. '" .. LII-' . c+ su vl:-~ tj .......Plc+ .r:-c-I"·· ......." \.0 ctI f\J :-J I , "'" . , , ! ~' 1.1 ¡~! i , I: m ~ ,tS ....."~ I ' "~,,! ~ ~I ~ i: ~;. ' i' ,., ~ 'Iii O.;.~ !~ -- f 1\ ~¥~"d ! i~lj -s:J _ ~ .- q . -----",- I I I i I N o , ¡ I q ~ ~ ~r-'-'''l- ; š ¡;1 -D c:) ¡-=-::- ::- ~;n , ... :J::J t> .{ ~ \1\ 0\; .~ ,~-& ~ í~- I <:J_ * ":j .; .. ~ <is' .....h , '~ iìì:;¡~ I ....../ 1ft ,$.>: .'- "--''"1 \. - ~ ~ O'n \\__ ,_ i<. I=Ú-- ....---- _..- 1 ( :liS nJ ('t()' Or> », /' I ~f , .' c.::) 1:--" ,-' I, .1":- .._._ d. .__ .__ o ~I:'> p.J tI> ~,< gl..J ~ 'f '" . c+ t-'. '1 t<J I:> C/I C/I G1 :;<: Oq :.>¡:~ ~ 'U C/lC+µ' 1-"0 C/I '" t-" 0 ::s I:> C/I::S ::s µ. . '" ~ ~ Þ,Pi I-tM {¡) tJ en o I Ic"'u R"¡U'1 o öÖ . o '" o.o¡o þ\ çt" 0" SUt1 c+o ~ o~} ~g µ. .' .. o .N o ¡ß rr\ ~ o 1 IZ. I ., , , I' 1i>13J ~?' {1'. ,<'IG , ¡-' ;~, 'j -0 {D¡ i - -- - - Ž~! "II' r : , ~~~fi:'1 - Go II" ~' ~ ~ 1f.! .1; ~ ~~~~, ~ Z. 10' : to I; '.:.. I , ' -fI' ' I "] - - - - ~ f! r~ :, , 31~!: I~ ... IJ: I C:. ___ 8 I~ i!! 1,6 öq If I ~ :":9 <:7- j- ! i It) '.... t) I' IV' ,,., :~ ~I !:.. ... ~:¥ i= --f I ¡ - -t.;, , .·.·n ~ ...~__ ~ r t !-i' r' t ~), 'I", 1°, ¢, ~- .'.-_..""::"-:;-;-- .._~....... ,..,...,".,.,...,., ...-...~.....- .......,~..~.............. ....~....._~- . . 460 Bayvlew Drive East Marlon,NY 11939 Mailing Address -11 Halter Lane Levlttown, NY 11756 March 23, 1992 John M. Bredemeyer III President, Board of Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall Ilaln Rd. Southhold, NY 11971 Subject:Gardlner's Bay Estate Homeowner's Assoc. Town Trustee Meeting ¡'larch 26, 1992 Dear Mr. Bredemeyer: It has been brought to my attention that the Gardiner's Bay Estate Homeowner's Association of East Marlon ha~ filed an application along with plans for a catwalk and floating dock for four boat slips and to relocate an existing catwalk and a two boat float In Spring Pond, East Marlon, N.Y. I am against this proposal. As a member of this Association, as the adjoining property owner, as the present owner of the "to be relocated" catwalk and as a Registered Architect In the 'State of New York, Florida and Arizona I respectfully submit this letter based on my review of the plans end application of the Association. The plans do not accurately describe the conditions that exist at the site. A survey WaS prepared for the Asaoclatlon by Roderick Van Tuyl, P.C. There are serious discrepancies between the Association's plot plan and the survey: specifically the MHW line, the MHL line and the spartlne grass location. In fact there Is no Indication of any spartlna grass on the plot plan and there Is substantial spartlna grass In the area of the proposed and relocated catwalks as per the survey. Acco~dlng to the plans and Section depicting the proposed construction, a hinged catwalk Is ehown spproxlmately In the middle of the spartlna grass. If built according to plan, this catwalk would not remain the constant 4'-0" above the spartlna grass as required by the Department of Environmental Conservation. The plans have a general note "minimum of 4'-0" above the spartlna " but with the hinged catwalk the approach to this hinge Is not 4'-0" above the spartlna nor Ie the hinged section down to the floating docks, both are shown on an angle, There should be a "fixed" section of the catwalk 4'-0" above the spartlna with a hinged approach ramp at one end and a hinged ramp down to the floating dock et the other end. The width of the spartlna from the MLW line to the edge of the landwood side of the spartlna Is approximately 8'-0" to 10'-0" wide. II fixed 8'-0" to 10'-0" catwalk, 4'-0" above the spartlna has to be provided. From this fixed catwalk a sloped catwalk approach could be attached as well as a hinged catwalk down to the floating dock, (Ç:(Ö)\P'1 . , . I do not feel the plans should be approved without showing what I have,described above. The proposed catwalk. in order to meet the code. must be built this way: it will now protrude further out into the pond than as shown. Although this is not the Town Trustees concern, the new length of the dock will Impact on the boats travelling in and out of the pond and on the boats moored In this area. The existing catwalk that Is to be relocated approximatley 12'-0" east has existed In Its present location for approximately 25 yeers which ·was prior to the Gardiner Bay Estates Homeowners Association becoming the owner of the property. The catw~lk was built In 1967 by the former owner of my house. Gardlners Bay Estates became the owner's of the property In 1974. Since this non-conforming catwall< Is proposed to be relocated It too would have to conform to the present day requirements for a catwalk over spartina grass (as previously outlined). Once again. the submitted plans do not reflect that fact nor address any dredging that might have to be done In order that any boats tied to this float would not "sit on the bottom" at low tide. If even minor dredging is required. the proper permits should be filed for with the NYS DEC and the Corps of Engineers and show where the dredged materials (spoils) will be deposited. The proposed catwalk and float will be for Association Members' boats and Association Members' use (a public area). A handrail must be Installed as per the New York State Building Code Sec. 713.1(f)(1) and (3) and (4) and the Life Safety Code of the State. This hsndrail should be 30"-36" high and" shall be designed to resist a lateral impact at the top equivalent to a minimum linear load of 50 lb. per foot," Sec. B03,9(b). The railings or vertical members should have not more than 6" speces between them. The plans as submitted do not reflect these code t-equlrements. The plot plan also fails to show the location of another catwalk and tWD boat float on the Association property in question. This catwalk is correctly Identified and placed on the survey prepared for the Association by Van Tuyl. This catwalk and float also have been in existence since 1967. I further trust that this application complies with the Town Zoning Requirements for the Residential Zone (R-40) in which the property ie located. Thank you for your time and consideration. t(Q)f1'( ~"A~H =3Af'IBACH ~llb"'''';''~f'~ . . : I NOTlëû· IŠ·~~~:;··~t vaP . itk ¡~;¡i;~;h~ ~;~;;,"~ìd.: ~r:;:-_;;:'Ñ:~":: :.': : . ';', ,11IAT PUOUC IIBARlNOS WILLi ,'To...oISm~loldl<>dOlo., ..,', boloro Mor.h 27.1992. AI1.ooh ,; ;,ßO JlBLD 'OY TIIB J:2Jïli, ' AUbiJ,mu","",i¡ntd.ndlcaltd: . ............on<elvcdwiUbe.....Id· . .!. TRUSTOR!; OF THE TOWN 0(1¡ in b~~lopc' I'J¡iJnly rn.rkc:d uBkI on: . cred and the Vd1l., ~ not mquolt . " SOUTIlOlD AT THB SOUTIlOLD i D.mp ,n.",,", ..d .ubml.... I<> ~.. 'ho ..I.... 01 Pedoral lund. or tako" ,^ ;' ; TOWN HALL, MAI/I ROAD' Olliu o[ ~'o Town Clod<. Tho bid : any .clmirù.tI.~v. .cd"" .,ltIWI....: ,;ì ~'NOW "Pia. : ,.',: .,:SOUTIIOLD, NDW YORK ON; pritc ,hall n..lnclud. ..y 'n, lod- , 'proj'" pdor '0 the.d"......iIi...In:::J :,;' Abortion rlghls ' .;:..nnmSDAY MARMf ,.6 1092. ON: tnl. AIde: or Jor.l, rrom which the . the prKedl:na Imd.enct.· . ~ .. . ..: ;: '. TIIB ,fOLLOW[NO APPLICA-: To... o[ Smthold b "<111('1, 00 or about Morell 30 1992' II.. ' are ,e<pecle4 10 me , ',TlONS,POR. PBRMITS UNDOR I.. ,DATI!D: M'l<ñ6, 1992. :'".""".'1IIIIttd Vr!1'I' will·........; the ',;5, The East End ", '11m PROVISIONS OP 111B WBT.: ' JUDITII T. lrnRY u.s. iJqJaJtmenl of 1I....inland U.· ':Women (NOW) lIs ';,LAND ORDlNANCB OP TIIB· SOlfl1l0LD1UWNCLERK ban Dovet......., 10 rota.. Ptd.,oI, " : Ing early on April ~ " TOWN. .' 7323·ITMI2 I.,.d. oad.. '1111. I 01 the U.utln. :' fare is $40. Reservr , 7:" P.M. _ i. lb. matte, of the, -tEGAI. NOnCE .nd Commtoi'J' Dovelopo"l A.. of :,', : u_,. .,"pptJ"'lon.r l.m.. MoM.hoo on' NIYfICEOPFlNIIING OF ,1114 (1'1. 93,383) II.......... for Ib" ';"': ,: ......e checks pe behol/ 01, S.."hotd Town 10 dn:dIO' NOSIGNlnCANT IMPACf .""".pn> 1d. ' Hampton Bays. N,' , 10.000 c,bl. y..d. 01 el... ...d' ON TilE ENYIRONMENT Tho Vill'I' of O....pott 10 ceni, .' 1.lrom Golò...w.·,lnl.. IIId pi... tho' AND "'Iyln"o IIUD Ibu the VIIII,o 01', ",: m.tedal... Kcnny"IIead, IIId ThwlI ' ADVANCE NOTICE TO 0.....1'0": No!, YOI~ ood WIW~ R. ' :' I'1iJpcIlY: 3." Roocnboq "Otadt, Soulbold. 11ú. m....W .,oo' PUBI..IC UP REQUEST fUR, roll, m. 1ft hi, olhelol.....ctty .. ;'" voll Ro.d 13). B... " " ,::1011 dO'¡"llho Ocl. 30... OcL 31, ¡ , RELEASE OF FUNDS M.y.,. conoe... 10 ,CCIf'\.... ¡.ria.', ' I" Couoty Toa Mop P.....' . 1991......, . , AND CERTIF1CATlON dicdon 0'.... Pcd.... COIIIIi Ih.....;,~,rt:.OI.I7.1 r.......l.. ct"'; I " .,: 7,16 P.M. _ In the "",te.o( U.. \ Villal' 01 0......... ' U?" II ........' 10 tal.... ""P"l"lbII·}: ':'''1 ~ 19, A 30 . : " , ;' II ,'.' ~, I,;',,: " ,';: op¡>IIeabOtl of M.d. TNpi. ""Iuea, , 230 6 ThIrd SUutN v_~ 119" :Io..l. - I<> ..,.¡.........II1... ~',é,t" ':'(2) 1:40 p...; ApPI. I . .:. pormh 10 .0"".... . 00' Iomlly I _pon..w I~' ~ , :, ......, declol,,·m.kl.,ID' .w...:" ,~: ~ AI'I1'HONY AND UBI ; I;¡ I' . ~. :.dwellina 76" rrom tidal ...ed.nd.t line I ConÞcl. .rtr1on: Rlehard CaU1uso.' . ancI·lhall.h.., rtlpœlibUit1e, bave '. . '1' SOURO!. nil b .. .~ I ,S':: : '., , :' ,~;,u d<Iio..,td ,by tho To"" Tru".., ' 1..'0 DirtetOl;(516) 417·2391 ,,'. ;':, bt",!hI ¡!i!'l; Tho I..ot "'oct "'!be;".../, ...tllnl 0 det.múnaII.., , .)J.'!\W' ",.":,, ,." ,.I;,' " jood.. per ..~oed ......,,_,.... .' ",' CeI1lfylo.,OIIIt:en ,woo.., II. 1'ell.1I. ~~", ~ ...;Cft'riI"oI....,..~ðf·H~liIní',1hI01oori ,'I '.. ' ::"'1}' 31, 1992, l.oUI.d o. SI..py m. Mayor .. . th. VIm.o 01 O.oonport, Now York ' ........... uub_, \.I \1 í'H,' "',', '" TO AIL1NTERESlliD AOBNCIES, ",,' m.y ,....... Bluet 0,...,...... and ", ,","AttIeIe ID. SeotIoø 100.' 1'1":'''' ' ";, ~ "," 7:11 P.M. -In the ....... or th.. OROUPS.AND PHRSONS, ",nOD wIII"'v. '!'Io/Iod III ..opoo< ,,!..'tloI. XXIV, laoat... lOCI j .1:. ;;~~'(:' :.. '::;~!'~!oft of Oarclb)e.n Ba,.Ib~I, na.wmIl-fUlmed VUJae0J"'OPOM" . .' ·l1blUd". ander lI:.e Nalloni.1 BaYi":·;··lIZanle' OntlDlItCt.. Any I . "f/';. . .~. ~ UoœCf'Iwaerl! Alloeltllon "quanj. 10 requClI. !.bo U.S.:Departrnenl. of ,:: . . 1'1:JØIQM1_,PoUty Ac:t of .1!H$9, H1.lD.p.~,.,tadœl for a .....f.wy [ :"t.i~' ,j,,:, ' !.,: pormitl<>_nru... 3' X 16' caIWolI:¡' 1I"".lna ...d U,ko 0...101'....1110 i ,:":,,,..01 ....pI all ~bjo..IOD,!o I"'''')f ~.., ,000000000..bJeit ,,",_ j . .1, ," ' t¡. (cIov.... ...~ Ind.~ 3' X 16' ramp; i rot.... Pcde.ot lund. mrðct 1!~' 101.; ,,~ ""'11/ It u "" .... of thofol'~'ì; tlo.,p.rml", ..pt.le .n ..r· .·f¡+j.:4· X ~4' no.I.with 2 -]' X 14' rlD~;. : Ihe: .~o...(nl Ind Commun-Ily De· ; I .'. .10..... baa: (II) tIuI. dJllœnifi.ci&lOß·Ji-il ~ p"'nlt, elc. a. ",Ulu . , ¡ "' ,. '.~.!:.. .to·and 3.pålet; abo, mavll abl.iD~ Ii . ~clopnflfl~ An or 1974, al unen.ded. :. . ::. ".. not¡ in: rial eQClll,ed ..,. .... oefll-f' A l~ a,&a:IM ThI.ub ec:i 101 I .¡,: ')-f:' , , :;,ca'wolI:.12 caJt; on WOIk '" AuOOl- (PL 93,313) '0 be .,td I., lb. 101,'V:!:fyIol'øIIlco.," om... oI,irpp&alI' ~the R-4Ò R..IdaatIaIZ, "iV,,,,-, , ' ¡',:,.Iica riah' oh,y.... pool! property.' 10winHrojootln III Py 1990 s..on ~.;,f"""""'òd !>y,HUD; .,(h) ;¡';¡,th.,oP:~ :ï\t'odd,W. cr.oeribad ¡WceJ i H'·I . . \ ':'.-8 '. ' Pœd' MOD..· ~ Chlu Community, D.,velopmtnl.·....··,· pUoanl·j.Rnyhonmlnl..1 JtIYlewJ:I1J, ~'l'"vlred thruu.&' .lu.l_ ¡,'fee, , ' Diode 0 Proa R th IndI f'tl' 2130 ...- wilt¡:, , . ':, )i! ',..':'h fri.";;'.. .: :O:,:;:''J'if..:'':: ,lwviliw...u';';;~.';t S'''Clure, : " , 'I::'~ ~~~~l'" 'fi:;::;J~:~:'\1on ~~~~I;'~ i r·.. ~I~~; :: . '. ·.i '.'.: opon.wtlkwa, l' X 35'; hinted runp! Ind Provllion pr Add.l1on.1 Hnulln. . _rep .ppliclble 1.0 die proJ'ct.1n &he .,:'i ~·:oO Tucker Laae Sou ! ¡ .\:' ' , ',." 3' X 12'lIwo no.tlna _" cadi S· ! Un;" - 224 Suulh S,,<,<¡. Tho VU, ' .."'......nIII ..view pi...... Objoc.· , , ' C\1bIIIY 1b M.p P~rœJ ~ X WI noot1n¡ docka ,,,,,,,,,d by fw. 1'10, 11IIOUlh ~.. O''''''I'I'' llou'ÎnI ~on. mull be prcpercd IIId ",bm1oecl ,: I ' S9·10.12, Thh ....... "" :1" .~ L ;:. ,.~.:.~~~~~~;:;I:.n~;~~:' ~lr~~'::I::.u~Ra~~;~: ;:~a;~ "::U~~;¡~rllh;,)i.~~ ':':~r' ~ 1-::00:~OOO Iq. fL. i :'i\¡:i;~. ·tituck. and .ubna"û.Uy Rhabilhalð h bUo addrened 10 nUD - U.S..ÐepartW\¡¡ rii:»L,,·Ø A: 4) 7:45 p.JJ1. AM I ," " ,7:19 P.M: - In ,ho mill.. 0[:-' 'wo ho...;nl un,a (ono 2,bt~.00nt ,.....OCII...btJ..d U",," ~op<':!L WIWAM C. OOODAI , ". !: Robert 1ohntol1 reque'l permllta:; and Ale. J--bedrocm). The .cqulllth'G . ..meta. N~" York Ala omce~ 26 Fed~ ~ :.i ~ ~;1Qd RlClIARD GOOD^ J OOftltruet · I' X 24' floalÍnl dock:. fund. 'N.m be provided by .Ioca.. .: ~ral Plaut N~w .York, N.w York ;. ~~ œnœrninl prtmIaet be ";Ib & 3' X 16' runp. All matta. to; b.nk wh~le Com.n\tnh) Dcvd~tnt 10278. Objection. to it\. relnte or.,-. .~.J Main ROlli, Lnrd (JIþJ ¡. "(I' b. ...d. o[ CCA ","od 10mb..,: F...d, will be u"d I.. the roh.blth.- ..' IlIl1d, OIl huel otherlhan!hooo....... ,¡ :'1\ NY. CounlY T.. M.p ¡ ~j : ' .LOC.a1CCI 4SCO Oi: J:.:!t We. Mauj-¡ 1lonof \he t~ttlJre. . '.. \', .hove 'wl11 nol. be eottddafllut by..} ~t:~·1000..122.06.30.t fiR' , . ~~ I ~. tuc\.. l I 11tb acù.vlIY ",Wtlke pI.OII within. . 'i-:- ItUD. No obJeclioD teClelveð afMli' :i.';·: aaðer: it . "'i.. 7:20 P,M. 'In the 01....' of Betty' 'bo VilI'IO 01 C:....pon, Sullolk i . J' April 14¡: t~wIII be ~ by'h~ ~;',,", (.) API'I. N. 4!J91 :, ~r: i : "Þeuowlki ~1 ptnnil 10 COOlbUtt. COUIII)', New YOlk. .: , 'nUo. ~ \ " '.J I IDee 1.0 the Zoniq Ordin It,. . " 6', X 30' nootina dock wi... pUOI: 11 hu b.... d..onnintd Ibll ,ucb " Willi.. R. p"U,m.M¡y;,r ," . }(XIV. Sectiod 100-102 '," ~ :91:":; :.'.-101:1 4' X IO'.ramp 1.0 eJ.tt:Dd.no ru...., te.qutlllor rr.I\'!..o of fund. wUl not. ' Vll1q;etl.O~ ~I ',: SdJedule, tOf permmior ?: '~~:.k, ~'1, ..:·dll~:cd .fQ adjateo~lfock'.1.ocsIed 295!, QOfUlilute an actiOl1 .ianifÏcantl)' Ill. . 236Thbd Sind li~ ~.t.f!Ird prlddpa' ate œ 1hi ~ ,r, '" ' ; ':,:.EII' Leal"" Ave., MauI.udt. ','octinl tho quolity 01 Ibo"","", ",vi: ,: . ", (I....pon.N.... YOlk 11941I~.;j:;'11. ........,Third pdncÖp r . 7:21 P.M. _ In the miller of rnrunmt Nld, .ccordinø1y,lbe Vilhte ..7324-ITMI2: ....: , '! ~ 'r¥." th. u\abU_hmAl of III i i:~:':!I"~~: I "Robo"Scripp..oq"...pcimit,o om. " o[ G_" ¡", decid,d ""'0l"e· ' ' NuíICEOFHEARINGS, "", aod!o<t/raeotobllilao..., I ·~I' . .,a\nK:I. rp:.ed øpen w&lkway 4' X 80'. rare.... Ettvlrcnmcnl.t hnpaç151a1e~ NOTlCa IS IIRREBY OIVBN, 'or)' Ute lnctdeDllll.o I .. '.,. hiDaed IIDJp 4' X 14", OoIUna dock' menl. undcr the N.,lonal Environ- PUUUNlt w SedIod 2R1 of 1I-."nnra... '. H1H eaablbhmentfOl" II: :1.· '1~::.: '::~6' X 20'; III""" Iwo 2·rüe dolphio. menlA. Polit)' Atl flf 1969 (PL 91·' Law ud da. Code of the Tðwø of .!. .;: I.... of ...d v.hidel. , , ~',:' :' "to I..... ßooIlna dock. 1.oc:aIed :r74S 190). The ....... for ..'" dodo!.... " Soutlrold; dI. fol1o"''''1 ........ 'fri H:,~~ aIIeni6ti.., I vorI..cal. 11! ):.' . '. Pine Tree kOlkf, Cutchoaœ. DOl to prepare .uth 1I....ement. ~re al : be beld lor pubtiç bu.rin" belore: the ::¡ ':J .ubuhu.. th. propo! LJ ':¡,,~: ,,', ALL PBRSONS INTBRBSTBD.. r.uow", . ' '50urnOLD TOWN B9ARDOP "¡:I~,'''iool1'''' 0'" lor... " , , ,IN SAID MATIl!RS SKOU' n Al'- " ,1.11.... will be no oII"IOc..'100& ' APPBALS 01 Ihe 80.thold To....:: '.'" I.tho. ...01'0....1 0.... 11~;;·i . . :. ~PßAR.,^T TI1811MB AND MAca ." f I.eon .dvenll eovlroßn1enllll .: nau, not' Main Road, Suøtho1d, . !.'.;~ lPftmIau .. 100000alIn t I, ~ ':'"',¡,,;^ßOVB 8PBC\FlIiD AND WIL4/' . ,impo.... , , N.."y.... 1197I,IaI,WBpNl!S\,AY,,';.'..: anI,ø.m-Zone Dbtt I. II;'. : ;. DR ON1IN AN orroRl1JNt1Yro ~. Any polenl.i.al imp.cil which. :: MARCH..2:'. 1992 eom~et'ld.a. .t}(.a\.<;'8:1'IIIh:.le (If Occur'" ~ i " .~. ; .: ,DB }IKARD. OOMMBNlS MAY DQ .' Ihc.e rroJt:dl m.,. haa\'e un 1Irq'. . tbe.dmellpedliedbtlo'WI,":.., .. ,i... f :Î-~ _.the ptt:miH. baa Ix ~t ;,',~t.,.,",.~.:., .:.: ~:.; SUBMITfBD IN \VJlIT1N"O PRIOR propert.lCI Uated in or ell..ibl~ . (1.> 7:31 ,... AppJ. No. 4090.;....~ 'i: :t~ ,.a..oocupled "'1b hi ~ ¡, ",'1UTHBIIBAlUNO. ' for th. N.dooal RoaJ".,o[lIia.. MR. A/lP MRS. It., LLOYP '::d"tlldbtl' OIdtwioh"", ·r\·.· .'.; . . n.ted; March 6, 1992 lonc Plac:~, will be mill.aled . '. KANBV. Van... 10 1M ZÐa.laI Or.'. ." ~h~ ÏI1 dw~.11It. . '~'~' ,':. , I ' ," :.. 101m M. B.......eyer. m. Ihrouab the VilIsIO'. ...cuted dIo..co~ ,Article xxm. SedIoo 100. :" ',J. ,:,.. (b) Appr. No, ,ì I~·~·:··, Pteûdcnl MemQralidura or ^.reel11enl 2]!U l«pennIJllorIto aJII'1r\1~Id- .! I ~ wtwAM C. OOODA ;:\'~;,~~ '!",; ,:';:~;, 'BoanI of T"".T........, (J':I1/B9) ",d tho oorryin. ~ut dl~ori 10..1111.. d.,.UInI fðr In.: ~ ¡;'íIOl' Spedat &=' ¡," i,;,t',," ,',: ,:1:"7'" ',' 'Br:JIl\ThOlp,CI"k:, ,.II:"h~hm1·NIncl~o:""""II'''''':''' ·~'~~·ld,IIv~~le.ß~~lrol,,·I.~Of'Pl~~loo.IO 0(1'1 ,:!.'~'3n~ITMI2 . .. '. . ·.W . eWlOI& .,Ionc'.· Wø.I'iõIIIIOu..IIUIICQ..e"UI..·\.\¡;~..u.io,!(.)a.....a ~~;:~ : J . . .~ .':~ J.lGAL NOTICE '. Prenrvalldd OUin, .nd. 100 (eet (rom thf!i lop 0' alt. b.urrr·n; Iid.fIlI, (b) an.ftIbIh 'fb' .f. ~..... ... .'. ..... ..~...':".~ .... .~:.~ n._...... ...... no·_.. ...J ..;: .:.:......... .. .~.~~~~~_~~~~.?~..I~~..~~~!~.~!.'!... n...~~~~~.~~ .~~.'..~~!!~!.~~~~.~.::.. ~~.~~~~.~.f~.rf,"I.1 I', t.. , ..... 11·j;··. lit.;.! ..... U 'I l r·· :,~ r' . ..I..i ·f I" ,~ ¡ t· . . : \ ~;, ;.i ..I l\,;·Y.; II ,I 'I' :' " ' .\ q' '. ~ I ;¡ , ( ....~- ,...0;:....::, , 'al the end or the m , '," Those' inlcresl.. , Lucas nl 765-9200 · LAW OFFICES OF MARIE ONGIONI 21 B FRONT STREET P.O. BOX 562 GREENPORT. NEW YORK 11944 TC\~lN OF SOUTHOLp~ MARIE ONGIONI CARMELA L. BORRELLI TEL. (5115) 477·2049 FAX (516) 477-S919 Matthew Kiernan Assistant Town Attorney Town of Southold Southold, New York 11971 April 14, 1992 Dear Matt, Re: Gardiners Bav Estates Homeowners Assoc. Board of Trustees My associate spoke to Linda Kowalski at the ZBA today and she confirms that Section 100-31 C(3) (a) has been previously interpreted by the ZBA as we had anticipated in my letter to you of April 8, 1992. The ZBA found in the Delalla matter decided in 1981 that the owner of the property may have docking for no more than two boats other than (i.e. in addition to) those used by the owner of the premises for [his] personal use. In other words, the owner can dock as many boats as the owner wants to dock at the site. Based on the above, I ask that you advise the Board of Trustees that the application from Gardiners Bay Association for a four (4) boat docking facility not be held in abeyance pending an interpretation of this section. The Association's application is within the number of boats allowed under the code. Since we anticipate that other matters will need to be addressed by the Board of Trustees before this application can be granted, I ask that you advise them that the number of boats is not an issue so we can proceed and avoid unnecessary delay. Thank you for your cooperation in this matter. Very tr~ours, ?Ii" MARI ONGIoft? CLB/snun cc: Larry Matzen, Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association Linda Kowalski, Zoning Board of Appeals John M. Bredemeyer III, Board of Trustees · 10) Œ Œ Œ ß 'If} Œ .~,~ ~ MðQ r ; REPLY TO ATT(rJTW:m OF DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY NEW YORK DISTRICT CORPS OF ENGINEERS JACOB K. JA VITS FEDERAL BUILDING NEW YORK, N.Y. 10278-0090 MARCH 26, 1992 TOWN OF ~QUTH0' .~. Eastern Permits Section SUBJECT: Appl ication No.92-0111-L2 by Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association Inc. To Whom It May Concern: The New York District, Corps of Engineers has received a request for Department of the Army authorization for the following activity: ACTIV!TY: Construct a 3 foot by 20 foot fixed pi er, el evated a mi nimum of 4 feet above grade of the marsh, a 3 foot by /6 foot ramp, a 4 foot by 24 foot float with two 3 foot by 14 foot finger float secured to three piles; and move existing piers 12 feet eastward. IN: Spring Pond, Gardiners Bay AT: East Marion, Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York APPLICATION BY: Gardiners Bay Estates Association, Inc. P.O.Box 342 East Marion, New York 11939 AS this work is minor in nature, authorization may be by Letter of Permi ssi on. Thi s is in accordance with current Federa 1 Regulations governing work in navigable waters of the United States. To accomplish the coordination required, prior to the issuance of a Letter of Permission, your review of the enclosed drawing(s) is requested. Pursuant to Secti on (c) of the Coastal Zone ~'anagement Act of 1972 as amended [(16 U.S.C. 1456 (c)], the applicant has certified that the activity complies with and will be conducted in a manner that is consistent with the Coastal Zone Management Program of the State of New York To allow for the timely processing of the subject application, your comments are requested within 15 days of the date of this letter. Sincerely, ~.tÆA,)"'" /'fY ffi1J-~l:A mes W. Haggerty C ief, Eastern Permits Section , Enclosures I I I I I I I I (') It1 n » r- fl1 " " 11 q "- C) , I \J 0, I I ¡ I I I I j , , , ¡ I I I 0, j , 81 /'. 1 , 0¡ 01 21 /j)1 -Ij ;;Vj q¡ -' \ (J~ ~ , ..::.¡ ¡ , . I i J , 1 if ^ 71 )""'(1' I i:t < j Imn , '" ; ,11 hI) i ,,' ¡. , .¡v....... I" ' . '" .- :.\~ :'. I\J i ì i , .._-_..._~~"......_..__..,. -- ........'.......-..' "..,___·'.·__·_w....·._.·. --.--- N -.---.. ......--,.,.--- u ç., 0 tJjJ. o :E 1\1 ~t";:; ;:;,< I-' ~. ~ ~ [rJ" .. c.., I-' en ~~ . p:- ~S1> '1 ~¡;~ g¡ ~ß: +- <+.. ;:; en ;:; .........N . (f) 'ÜCD ~ ¡J;:>j 1\>;:; H!:tOJ ;:;CD '" " , i I I ì i , ~j ~ R"~~Ó ~ ~. t1 J: . " ::; 0 CD ...... O:l:¡ 0 ::;::oq~<+ ~ ~O" >j "d ~t1 ....... 0 ('"TO 0;:; '" oq ;:; Po ~ '" ~ 1-'0 :>;'0 Po - __ u_ ._ .. q -----'" I , i ~. q N o - ~ T--' ~ -i \--_ __"'--- ).f" ..0 qt __ _ ¡ ";0 , II>::! 1 .' ¡ x _, tJ _ _ . ,\- _..' " ,- --- .... . c.:::) /:=.- .- I J 1 r --J _of ; ... I~ ¡ " , , .. ~g '::'~i! '. '" -¡ , '" '-':!~\ ~"q 1 ( 3!8 rl7 1::0' .... >, , I , , , I i J. ..... OQ -- -_.-- ¡ , i I ~ ,,$ .. r ,~ !) ~ r'O F. I .+ Þ: it: ...~ ~.... ..-...........................--- .~-_........ "., "'-,' ,- "."'.""", "".....- .......~...',-- . 1 I 10 1;0 '0 ~ I~ !~ I 12 I f I, I ...., j -I "' ~~ ßAyf~(E. D._RI\I E-'--'-'-_"--===~ -.---'--,....---....'N·--'--_..·,·.._¡¡, .._._~._...------.- _ 1.'j - 01 >E- WIO"-I-I - j \l \II ( 187' AT w,o¡r¡; R, , I ~~~ ~- I ?~8 ç~ ! 2~¡ '~- Ij " .. n f 0 -<: r ~ ~ ~h ! ~~~ ~f! I ~~ ~~ rtI , 3. 7-,. ¡ v - . lÌ\ ;~~ j "':\> =t. ¡:10 ,,~ ) I \ { ¡ I ¡ ¡ i ¡ j ¡ ! ¡ !¡' r Ú)! 0, I :¡.; ¡-' I "'I 1......1 t ~r I l- I U I !,J I;}i ,¡ î ,I L i , I ., I i I ._~-~-_.~.~. "- "- "'1~ ~1' """<;so. ~ :>.¢ "i', '- t 100' -\ \--- r f If ¡NTE"nOl'tL. M"'~SH " I) 1,:1 µ.. 'Þ I ~ . . I tu , r +- - Oft L w , ·---·-Q~41 '--"'~ ~... ....····...·~~~JlO"NO>\~ý_ r '-. -----... ME.....I/... _.._.. ,.,,~ "OL.,.--W"-TE'R -.. -._ I I\> t, , \t /¡¡? ~ ¡;>-gWi'--17'~--~su ~ c+.~:::s~ 0)'1 -0 COC-¡OJ CO I-'<+~ '1' Po' ¡:: I-1tr1.. i:< CO .. ...... en OJ :~(Jt¡ R<' n :': <+ <+ '" su <+ VIS\> P> ~su P> 1-1 'tJ t:I .. '<+~ 01<+1-1 f-'·O 00 .¡:è'NM- OJ COp. Oi:< OSUt:l' ,-CO.. oJ m f-'. i:< p. :>; <+ 0 '.01:1 i:< ~ 0;0<! I\J H iJ:1 CO I» .:E i:< 01-1 1-'0 oSlm :>;0 . CO P. I Ì' . ·..~.=_T...,...-. i I I ¡ , , ( ,- ..- ) I d l - - ,- "'- '-- - - '~"" ,-- '._TU" I ~w ,"I I I " I I 71>1 1'1 :' -d.-~ \plY ,{I¡~¡' I 'I .r! '¥ r- v' IV ',0) Y . t I ./ ,/- Ii { 'f t,_.....,... v v ë::.. I ~ '-f:_J~ --. --..,----, r ¡ : ,On . t 1 -t:. , 2¥:_=-.__. ' , I I "I, l' l_~ ~¡ , . I ---6---0- ~o' '" o , ':'Vi -J'V~,,/ IJ' . -'" ". . ." " -0 ;1J; 0; 4¡ 1'1' , ~¡ , "i r-' », ¡z : I ' I , , ~ I I ~ I ~ , . _-......~_....·_>-I.....'--.-.~ ...-...-....... _............................_.............-.....,.,......,.........4...._ . . 460 Bayview Drive East Marion,NY 11939 Mailing Address -11 Halter Lane Levittown, NY lill~ rfT u \} ,Œ ,00 March 23, 1992 0 -"'c~_._______..-. , ".. I MAR ,~ 5 ,-. ¡ TOWN OF SOUTH OLD John M. Bredemeyer III President, Board of Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall Main Rd. Southhold, NY 11971 Subject:Gardiner's Bay Estate Homeowner~s Assoc. Town Trustee Meeting March 26, 1992 Dear Mr. Bredemeyer: It has been brought to my attention that the Gardiner's Bay Estate Homeowner's Association of East Marion has filed an application along with plans for a catwalk and floating dock for four boat slips and to relocate an existing catwalk and a two boat float in Spring Pond, East Marion, N.Y. I am against this proposal. As a member of this Association, as the adjoining property owner, as the present owner of the "to be relocated" catwalk and as a Registered Architect in the State of New York, Florida and Arizona I respectfully submit this letter based on my review of the plans and application of the Association. The plans do not accurately describe the conditions that exist at the ~site. A survey was prepared for the Association by Roderick Van Tuyl, P.C. There are serious discrepancies between the Association's plot plan and the survey: specifically the MHW line, the MHL line and the spartina grass location. In fact there is no indication of any spartina grass on the plot plan and there is substantial spartina grass in the area of the proposed and relocated catwalks as per the survey. v According to the plans and Section depicting the proposed construction, a hinged catwalk is shown approximately in the middle of the spartina grass. If built according to plan, this catwalk would not remain the constant 4'-0" above the spartina grass as required by the Department of Environmental Conservation. The plans have a general note "minimum of 4'-0" above the spartina " but with the hinged catwalk the approach to this hinge is not 4'-0" above the spartina nor is the hinged section down to the floating docks, both are shown on an angle. There should be a "fixed" section of the catwalk 4'-0" above the spartina with a hinged approach ramp at one end and a hinged ramp down to the floating dock at the other end. The width of the spartina from the MLW line to the edge of the landwood side of the spartina is approximately S'-O" to 10'-0" wide. A fixed S'-O" to 10'-0" catwalk, 4'-0" above the spartina has to be provided. From this fixed catwalk a sloped catwalk approach could be attached as well as a hinged catwalk down to the floating dock. . . . I do not feel the plans should be approved without showing what I have described above. The proposed catwalk, in order to meet the code, must be built this way: it will now protrude further out into the pond than as shown. Although this is not the Town Trustees concern, the new length of the dock will impact on the boats travelling in and out of the pond and on the boats moored in this area. The existing catwalk that is to be relocated approximatley 12'-0" east has existed in its present location for approximately 25 years which tas prior to the Gardiner Bay Estates Homeowners Association becoming the ,¡ owner of the property. The catwalk was built in 1967 by the former owner of my house. Gardiners Bay Estates became the owner's of the property in 1974. Since this non-conforming catwalk is proposed to be relocated it Þ too would have to conform to the present day requirements for a catwalk ~ over spartina grass (as previously outlined). Once again, the submitted plans do not reflect that fact nor address any dredging that might have to be done in order that any boats tied to this float would not "sit on the bottom" at low tide. If even minor dredging is required, the proper permits should be filed for with the NYS DEC and the Corps of Engineers and show where the dredged materials (spoils) will be deposited. (~ The proposed catwalk and float will be for Association Members' boats and Association Members' use (a public area). A handrail must be installed as per the New York State Building Code Sec. 713.1(f)(1) and (3) and (4) and the Life Safety Code of the State. This handrail should be 30"-36" high and" shall be designed to resist a lateral impact at the top equivalent to a minimum linear load of 50 lb. per foot," Sec. 803.9(b). The railings or vertical members should have not more than 6" spaces between them. The plans as submitted do not reflect these code requirements. 'J-. (5\ The plot plan also fails to show the location of another catwalk and two boat float on the Association property in question. This catwalk is correctly identified and placed on the survey prepared for the Association by Van Tuyl. This catwalk and float also have been in existence since 1967. I further trust that this application complies with the Town Zoning Requirements for the Residential Zone (R-40) in which the property is located. Thank you for your time and consideration. RA . . . . GARDINERS BAY ESTATES HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION. INC. East Marion, New York 11939 ::~.rch 9, 1992 0epa.rt:.~ent of tll8 .:lr~:·_:l ~~ District Corps of ~n5il~p~r3 J8,CC:-O I:. Javib3 :?ejer~.l ?uildin¿; ~·rew Yor~.?:) :--;:- l027C-Cí)90 Attention: Ja..~,es:. ::aU;~rty 7.e: )..PIJlica.tiO:l.~ 92-0111-="2, -,J~r :::1r~1.iEer;: "?a:' 2.:Gtates Honeo'Nners AGsocip.~ tio~-:, I:'1c. Jear 3irG: Tc coc,pl:; ','¡it;, your letter of Feoruary 4, 1992, enclosed please find revised cross-section showin~ Ð.n a:iditioY18.1 len:¡th of 4' to c~,tv:6,l:-<:. "lJur~ tru2- ~~ -..J ~ L6.\';rence .J. ::atzet1 :'5..ri~le ::~L:;lir·-:an Inc. .Jcc: ~oVln of ,':)out!~oll l.-=.C. · . DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY NEW YORK DISTRICT CORPS OF ENGINEERS JACOB K. JAVITS FEDERAL BUILDING NEW YORK. N.Y. 10278-0090 REPLY TO ...TTENTQN OF February 4, 1992 Eastern Permits Section SUBJECT: Application No. 92-0l11-L2, by Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association, Inc. Mr. Lawrence J. Matzen Marine Chairman Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association, Inc. East Marion, New York 11939-0004 Dear Mr. Matzen: The following is in regards to the subject ap~lication to construct a 3 foot wide by 16 foot long fixed p1er dock elevated a minimum of 4 feet above grade, install a 3 foot wide by 16 foot long ramp, a 4 foot by 24 foot float with two 3 foot b¥ 14 foot finger floats, and three piles, and to move an exist1ng pier 12 feet eastward in Spring Pond, Gardiners Bay, at East Marion, Suffolk County, New York. We have received your letter dated January 21, 1992 and the supporting documentation. Based on our previous experience with the Federal environmental agencies, we recommend that you extend the ramp as necessary to insure that a minimum depth of 2 feet at mean low water will be available to avoid foreseeable objection on this matter in the future, and to revise the submitted drawings accordingly. Once we have received such drawings, we will resume processing your application. If you have any questions, please contact Mr. Roberto Barbosa of my staff at (212) 264- 6730. Sincerely, ./ " -, "1/.' /.., / ~7<· ./ iJames W. Haggerty Chief, Eastern permits'Section . . GAR DINERS BAY ESTATES HDMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION,INC. East Marion, New York 11939 - 0004 œ rn ~ ~ : w"rn œ I-Iarch 9. 1992 TOWN OF SOUTHOlD Board of Trustees Town of Southold Southold. NY 11971 Re: Dogwood Lane r/o/w 90ck Project Dear Sirs: Enclosed please find (1) letter from Department of Army dated 2/4192. and (2) our response dated 3/9/92 with the requested revised drawings. Therefore. in order to comply with the above. we request an amendment to our project increasing the length of the catwalk from 16' to 20'. For your information. we are also enclosing recent correspondence, and response. with the D.E.C. Yours very truly cdz-~' Lawrence J. Hatz ~~arine Chairman Ene. . . GARDINERS BAY ESTATES HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION,INC. East Marion, New York 1193 ill rn ~ rn : U rœ ~arch 16, 1992 ..J TOWN OF SOUTHOLO! ¡,YS Del't. of Environmental Conservation ~ivision of qegulatory Affairs qegion 1 stony Srook SU,';Y Ca!·tpus, nlde; 40, '<001'1 219 stony Brook, ;'¡Y 11790-2.556 Attention: Darlene r. 3erbino T)ear Sirs: Applicant proposes to construct: a 3tx20' catwalk (elevated 4' over Grade at vegatation) and 6 CCA wood piles; j'x16' ra¡1pj 4'x24' float with 2 - "x14' fingers and' CCA ~lOod l'ilesj also to !'IOVe 12t east, existing ,'x12' catwalk anù 2 CCA wood piles and 2'8"x16' rar.1p and 6'4"x15' float with .5 sea~onal galvanized pipe piles; all work on Association right of way and pond property. Yours very truly, c~~~--¡J- Lawrence J. ;I;~~ ¡'íarine Chairman Ene: Revised Project and Crossection Plans Revised Short ~nviro~ental Assessment Form 0.-" 651J ~ ab 75 l.p7/1 . . I I I i I I J '<: Un 'Uw 0-' 8i: ) þ.... . , "I :nJ 'I'Ì -:J +' Q $' l. ~ -I ( ~ 71:-- i - 1>0 ,.. , I I i I i . .'1.. _ _ __ 1 -"'~ P ~ , '7 \ - ;;) , í ! - , i i .. J :) } .J.! , ... .I) i I ----11 J) I ¡:::I: :) ¡ Þ' Œ:~ ... ¡ ''I>' 0-- \lJ~ , -/1;- --- ; I l- v ¡ ';¡: , ____J" ; \ . , \ \ ~ , 0 \ b , \ ¡ N ¡ , \ , , ! ~ I """'----- b I I , I I , ! r N ._~ - ---.----- g;:¡ ~~~ ~~ 'I ;0: ctJ ~ Q) . ,.,- bI);O: "d ¡:: ¡:: rJJ ¡:: oo.¡..> ~ o .¡..> ¡:: 0 ·rl Q) rJJ .¡..> ctJ'- t t:J ctJ O.rl "d.¡..> rJJ ¡:: _"" I ~"u~ 0.. ~ ~:1-=r::1~ I~I c..> ;: C) bO::E: t!J UJ UJ r-II-:>.. !'--' Q) 0 ¡:: ¡ï¡~ =' "dl ..:!: . ~ CI ..,.., .., r-i~. CD co . Q) ! fiI")~ ¡:;<ù~s.~ iU'~5":¡-:;;¡::¡ o....:¡ <f.!'<i-=r:D:1ou A !uJ: -------~_____ .____0 V1, ¡ :>: I "'I ¡..: ~ ¡ ì i7 , - ¡C i~ ¡O I::> ~~ ir.- ¡CI) rz: 18 r ,~ ,<.) ~o ,0 , ¡ t ¡; ! f ¡ l'~ ¡ ¡ ( ( . , lò ~ ! 1'~ ---.... ~ 617.21 Appendix C State Environmental Quality Review SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM For UNLISTED ACTIONS Only PART I-PROJECT INFORMATION (To be completed by Applicant or Project sponsor) . I . 14·16·4 (2187)- Text 12 I PROJECT t.D, NUMeER SEQR 1. APPLICANT ¡SPONSOR IJardiners Bay Sstates I 2, PROJECT NAME '10(';'.'/Ood Lane right of VIi9Y HOllle()w"'o~c '1 C'c~~ Tn" fl ~~H n~ ' " 3. PROJECT LOCATION: Municipality :Sast Marion ,<:;0" thnld 'Pnwn County "" f"f"n'l, 4, PRECiSe LOCATION (Street address and road Intersections. prominent landmarks. etc., or provide map) End of Dogwood Lane, near Bayview Drive, Gardiners Bay ;èstates, East ~J:arion, NY 11939 5, IS PROPOSED ACTION: ŒNew o Expansion o Modification/alteration 6,DESCRIBEPROJECTBRIEFLV:App11cant proposes to construct: a Yx2ü' catwalk (elevat; þd 4' over grade at vegatation) and 6 CCA woodpilesj 3'x16' ral1pj 4'x24' float with 2 3' x14' fingers and 3 CCA woodpiles; also to move 12' east, ex fLGtintj 3'x12' catwalk and 2 CGA wood pileG i9,nd 2'8"x16' ral:lp and 6'4"x15' float )lith ~: seRGonsl It;lvallized pipe pileL' j all work on Association riGht of ViaT [J.nd Jonel pro )er - . 7, AMOUNT OF LAND AFFECTED: Initially .013 acres Ultimately .013 acres 6, WILL PROPOSED ACTION COMPLV WtTH EXtSTtNG ZONING OR OTHER EXISTING LAND USE RESTRICTtONS? ¡g Ves DNo If No. describe briefly 9. WHAT IS PRESENT LAND USE IN VtCtNITY OF PROJECT? o Residential D Industrial D Commercial D Agriculture D Park/Forest/Open space IX! Other Describe: ;\.fJsociation right of ,my and l'rivate recreational, boat docking and boat launchinG. 10, DOES ACTION INVOLVE A PERMtT APPROVAL. OR FUNDING. NOW OR ULTtMATELV FROM ANV OTHER GOVERNMENTAL AGENCV (FEDERAL. STATE OR LOCAL)? DtVes DNo If yes, list agency(s) and permll1approvals Town of Southold, US ,\r;"y Corps of Engineers 11, DOES ANV ASPECT OF THE ACTION HAVE A CURRENTLV VALID PERMIT OR APPROVAL? Dves QQNo If yes, list agency name and permltfapproval 12, AS A RESULT OF PROPOSED ACTION WILL EXISTING PERMIT/APPROVAL REOUIRE MODIFICATtON? DVes ŒlNo I CERTIFY THAT THE INFORMATION PROVIDED ABOVE IS TRUe TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE . AppHcantfsponsor name: Lawrence <1,. :'e..tzen Date: .3/16/92 ,C SIgnature: C i "~-L '\._~ V If the action Is In the Coastal Area, and you are a state agency, complete the Coastal Assessment Form before proceeding with this assessment OVER 1 PART II-ENVIRONMENTAL ASSL ,.>MENT (To be completed by Agency) A. DOES ACTION EXCEED ANY TYPE I THRESHOLD IN 6 NYCRR, PART 617.12? If yes, coordinate the review process and use the FULL EAF. OVes ONO B. WILL ACTION RECEIVE COORDINATED REVIEW AS PROVIDED FOR UNLISTED ACTIONS IN 6 NYCRR, PART 617.6? If No, a negalJve declaration may be superseded by another Involved agency. OVes ONo c. COULD ACTION RESULT IN ANY ADVERSE EFFECTS ASSOCIATED WITH THE FOLLOWING: (Answers may be handwrItten, if legible) C1. Exlsllng air quality, surface or groundwater quality or quantity. noise levels, existing traffic patterns, solid waste production or disposal, potential tor erosion, drainage or flooding problems? Explain briefly: C2. Aesthetic. agricultural, archaeological, historIc, or other natural or cultural resources; or community or neighborhood character? ExplaIn briefly; C3. Vegetation or fauna, fish, shellfish or wildlife specIes, signUlcanl habItats, or threatened or endangered speCies? Explain brIefly; C4. A community's existing plans or goals as officIally adopted, or a change In use or Intensity of use of land or olher natural resources? Explain briefly. C5. Growth, subsequent development, or related activities likely to be Induced by the proposed action? Explain briefly. C6. Long term, short term, cumulative, or other effects not Identified In C1·C5? ~xpl8ln briefly. C7. Olher Impacls (Including changes In use of either quantity or type of energy)? Explain briefly. D. IS THERE, OR IS THERE LlKELV TO eE, CONTROVERSV RELATED TO POTENTIAL ADVERSE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS? DYes 0 No If Yes, explain briefly PART III-DETERMINATION OF SIGNIFICANCE (To be completed by Agency) INSTRUCTIONS: For .ach adver.. .ff.ctld.ntlfl.d abov., d.t.rmlne wh.th., II I. .ub.tantlal, larg., important or oth.rwl.. .Ignlflcant. Each .ff.ct .hould be .......d in conn.ctlon with Ita (a) ..lIlng (I.., urban or rural); (b) probability of occurring; (c) duration; (d) Irreversibility; (e) geographic scope; and (I) magnitude. If necessary, add attachments or reference supporting materials. Ensure that .xplanatlon. contain .ufflcl.nt d.tallto .how that all ,.I.vant adverse Impact. have b..n id.nllfl.d and .d.quat.,y addre..ed, o Check this box If you have Identified one or more potentially large or significant adverse impacts which MAY occur. Then proceed directly to the FULL EAF and/or prepare a positive declaration. o Check this box If you have determined, based on the Information and analysis above and any supporting documentation, that the proposed action WILL NOT result in any significant adverse environmental impacts AND provide on attachments as necessary, the reasons supporting this determination: Name of lead Agency Prmt or Type Name of Responsible Officer in Lead Agency Title of Responsible Officer Signature of Responsible Officer in Lead Agency Signature of Preparer (If different from responsible officerl Date 2 . .. ., 14,1(',2 (2/R7)~7c @ rn 0 W rn 1m SEaR MAR 23 ::_ F RM ¡ , , .", ) /iF ~OUTH(ij.f'; . Purpose: lhr> full rA' I~ d('''Ignpcf to 11£'lp applicants and agencies df'termme. ~Qr~' FR~'tflef.~tñer-a project or action m.l\, bp <;ignificant 1 he question of whpther an action may be o;;ignificant is not alway" easy to answer. Frequent- ly, there are cl"pe( Is of a project th.,! are o;¡ubjertivp or unrllc,lsur£,iIblr. It is also understood that those who determine significance m"v h.,\"p litllp or no formal knowlpdge of the environment or may hf' technically expert in environmental analysis. In addition, many who havp knowledge in one partir.ular area may not be aware of the broader concerns affecting the question of Si~Jljfi("<lIK(, lhe full tAr i<; intf'nded to providE" i1 method wher('hy applicants and agencies can be assured that the determination pro(PSS has be£'n oruerly, r:ompreh£'llsivp. in nature, yet flexiblp to allow introduction of information to fit a project or action 617.21 Appendix A Full EAF Components: The full EM is comprised of three parts: Part 1: Provides objPctiv(' data and information about a given project and its site. By identifying basic project ditta, it assists it reviewf'r in the analysis that takes place in Parts 2 and 3. Pari 2; focuses on identifying the range of possible impacts that may occur from a project or action. It provides gllidan(f~ as to whe'ther an impact is likely to be considerp.d small to moderate or whether it is a potentially- large impact. The form also identifies whether an impact can be mitigated or reduced. Part 3: If any impact in Part 2 is identified as potentially-large, then Part 3 is used to evaluate whether or not the impact is actu.:dly important. DETERMINATION OF SIGNIFICANCE- Type 1 and Unlisted Actions Idenlify Ihe Po,lions 01 EAF completed for this p,oject: ¥ Part 1 ~ Part 2 oPart 3 Upon review of the information recorded on this EAF (Parts 1 and 2 and 3 if appropriate), and any other supporting information. and considering both the magitude and impo'tance of each impact. it is reasonably determined by the lead agency that: ~ A. The proiect will not result in any large and important impact(s) and. therefore, is one which will not have a ~ignificant impact on the environment, therefore a negative declaration witllte pft'pared. o B. Although the project could have a significant effect on the environment, there will not be a significant effect for this Unlisted Action because the mitigation mea,ures described in PART 3 have been ,equired. therefore a CONDITIONED negative decla,ation will be prepa,ed.· o C The project may result in one or more large and important impacts that may have a significant impact on the environment, therefore a positive declaration \\-iII be prepared. ... A Conditioned NE'gative Declaration is only valid for Unlisted Actions c;::,r~hC'f ~ Fs-.lqk~T /:1tp,.Q. a~ A 5fO( hL- . Name of Action .5;v#-v'/ ~ 71-~J Name of lead Agency :77J~1] ;It. 8/ech~e!úr J1T ;res Print or Type Na,mE' of Responsible Oi{¡cer In Lead Agency Title of Responsible Officer , ~ 7--:rJÞ.-. . .. gnature of RC5pon<;.iblc OfficN in If'ad Agf'T1CY Signature of Preparer (If dIfferent from responsible officer) q Ii, /f2- . Date 1 PART 1-PROJECT INFORMATION Prepared by Project Sponsor NOTlrr. Tille; dní"rTH'nt ,<; df'signf'd to a"..i"I ill df'termilling whf'ther thr ¡¡clion proposrd IIh1)' 11.1\'í' " q~n1fl(ant pfff'ct on the pnvironllH:,nt Plp.c'<;p complpte th(' ('olirf' form, PMts ^ through E. Answers to these qUf\<;tiom will he con<;idprpd ao¡¡ pint of lilt' application for .,pprnvill clnd I1l':¡V hf' <;uhject to further verification <loa public reVIl'W. Prn\'idl~ anv addItional inform,ltion you 1)('1;f'\,(, will hp Ilf'f'df'd to romplt'!£' PrUtc;¡ 2 and ~ It ie; f'xp('ctf'd lb.,! completion of fll£' full [,\r will be depPlloelll on information currently ,1\"aiIJhlf' .,nd \\dlnot Imolv(' I1PW studipc;, resf'cJrch or invf'stigallol1 If il1forrn,llion rf'qU1ring sUf"h additional work is unavailablp. so indicatE" and spf"cify earh inc;lanCf.' NAME OF ACTION DO(-r",.iC:Co..J") /..J ,.¡e R.../b-{-fr c'r- r.....".-y FJ..c·/tïJ¡"; E- /)cCJ.t.. LOCATION OF ACTION (InClude Slreel Addres9. Munlclpallly and County! ¡<'¡JC ÇyD((-W':Oi)II)I""--J""''''' "'''~VIF:W OK, &-~;¡'b J~">¡¡"ýlS¡"Tc:}, Ç4l5.H/,>i<¡{,,v 5' ¡OF(')«, N/ 11939 NAME OF APPUCAN rlSPONSOR ;:'~ a..~t·I(££ TELEPHONE H..· ~1<- 6-ARD/.NE"H 1>1'1 eo;7itrt35 H<Y1ECWI'¡""F2~ '"'SS(., ,,00,- )..J./N{l.f!IJu!_I-IPi7'%J:: t57(, -'/7'7-Cfb,,?Ç ADDRESS pO ï3Cx. '3-1-:1. 6. H). \<JÜ,..,J f-'-j //<]3'/ CITY/po e., I-1AíZ¡ 0 /.-1 I STATE I ZIP CODE )J" ¡¡'He¡ NAME OF OWNER (If dllhtfenl) I BUSINESS TELEPHONE 5A-H -l?_ I , ADDRESS CITYfPO I STATE 1 ZIP CODE DESCRIPTION OF ACTION :~'.... ?O' (J>-rw/r'-I<{raT$""r~ò "1" c>;"-R. (~ftA/)¿, ~í v'r~11t 1"D~ A-~I) G: (cA v- ,(liJ i·;)/¡...~'" LC,v ':jiRv(....j" . -) 3JJ\./"~ Rñ--Þ1P i "'Ý~¡( '2.4' FJ..D~T wtTlf .;z.- ~.)¡ 1~/J=/..u('>'C_"~s i'tJol. 3- { L ^ (.l..'~','D Pil-C' J ; J"t ..~í -;-c r1 (-'of ~ /t:t' e.A-& í) ex ,51~/;4I& 3'~ J:z.. j ,~rk.11)~1( AI'IJi> ;L - ¡X)). ~ (-r'b iJJ ...e!.. ~).iþ 9'S:'>L It:' R.fl'1.... ))-"",) /.,' y"'x. I~J Fl-cÞ,-T ......,íH 3 5èASO)J/rJ.. vj:tJ,tI.Jt¡JJ,-;¡..eà PIPe:':- pll_e 5. ~ Af>.... ¡,wtRJ<. C'N ~t;"Çr'll.J.JI¡J/(;~ r;;¿Jf.-,.IT L·F ~v"""Y J't,"þ PO"',) PRe, PC'¡¿T';I. Please Complete Each Question-Indicate N.A. if not applicable A. Site Description Phvsical setting 01 overall proiect. both developed and undeveloped areas, 1, Present land use: DUrban Dlndllstriill DCommercial DResidential (suburban) DRural (non,lar",) DForest DAgriculture C10ther .'),..s5(,)UA""J~,J ;J/~Hr G.F....'A"i ..¡ ~[.¿,II.I.IC ?o~_v~ ,-1- 1<~c.ilEA'rl o}J ';0.1'\7 þ(X-Jl,.OH,. r- J-}If¡U ~cH/.N'f- 2. Total acreage of rrojf'ct ;¡rra: Æ?~_ .¿t- acres. APrROXIMA TE ACREAGE PRESENTL Y AFTER COMPLETION Meadow or IIrushland [Non,agricultllral) Forested Agricultural (Includes orchards. cropland. pasture, etc.) Wetland [Freshwater or tidal as ['er Articles 24, 25 of ECL) Water Surface Arf'ð Unvegetated (Rock, earth or rilll Ro"d~, building.. <1nd other paved surfaces Other (Indicate type) .\ Whc1t i'i pr('dorninant ..oil typ£'('i) on project ..i[pl Sf} µ .i) a Soil drtllllage fJWpll drained It) i:) % of <;ite OModerately well drained % of site [lPoorly drainpd __ % of ..it£> b If any agricultural land i~ involved, how rni1IlY acres of soil are classified within soil group 1 through 4 of the NYS I and Clas"ifir-ation SY5tf'rn1 - acres (See 1 NYCRR 370) 4 Arf' thprp bedrock outcroppings on projf'rt <;itpl f.::JYf'5 gNo it \\'hat I" df'pth to hedrork1 (in feet) acres acres acre5 acres acres acres .. 01"> acres .01 "S acres acre" acres acres acres acrp~ acres acres acres 2 5. Approximate percentage of proposed project site with slopes: ❑0-100, _. /0 O % ❑10-1S% % 1115% or greater % 6. Is project suhstantially contiguous to, or contain a budding, site, or district, listed on the State or the National Registers of Historic Places? []Yes 5(No 7 Is project substantially contiguous to a site listed on the Register of National Natural Landmarks? Dyes 9No 8. What is the depth of the water table? V044 (in feet) 9. Is site located over a primary, principal, or sole source aquifer? Dyes ,4No 10 Do hunting, fishing or shelf fishing opportunities presently exist in the project area? ❑Yes J$No 11 Does project site contain any species of plant or aninal life that is identified as threatened or endangered? L I1'c5 JKNo According to Identify each species 12. Are there any unique or unusual land forms on the project site? (i.e., cliffs, dunes, other geological formations) C1Y'e5 KNo Describe 13. Is the project site presently used by the community or neighborhood as an open space or recreation area? 1Ves C)No If' yes, explain iWAT:DOCKiAJG d iCAuA1c #)A) — 14. Does the present site include scenic views known to be important to the community? KYes ❑No 15. Streams within or contiguous to project area: A)0A/g a. Name of Stream and name of River to which it is tributary 16 Lakes, ponds, wetland areas within or contiguous to project area: a. Name Fc>/j b b. Size (In acres) G• 8 17. Is the site served by existing public utilities? Dyes KNo a) If Yes, does sufficient capacity exist to allow connection? ❑Yes ❑No b) If Yes, will improvements be necessary to allow connection? Dyes ❑No 18 Is the site located in an agricultural district certified pursuant to Agriculture and Markets Law, Article 25-AA, Section 303 and 304? Dyes XNo 19. Is the site located in or SUbStantialN c rtigt us to Critical Env'ronmental Area designated pursuant to Article 8 of the ECL, and 6 NYCRR 617? es 20. Has the site ever been used fo� os I d !r4hazardous wastes? Dyes XNo ZZZ B. Project Description 1. Physical dimensions and scale of project (fill in dimensions as appropriate) o a. Total contiguous acreage owned or controlled by project sponsor o acres. �A.i✓ tLAKe b. Project acreage to be developed. .0/3 acres initially; . c' /'S acres ultimately. c. Project acreage to remain undeveloped N/A acres. d. Length of project, in miles: A/} (If appropriate) e. If the project is an expansion, indicate percent of expansion proposed %; f. Number of off-street parking spaces existing _ram; proposed g. Maximurn vehicular trips generated per hour /4 (upon completion of project)? h If residential: Number and type of housing units: One Family Two Family Multiple Family Condominium Initially X Ultimately X--- i. Dimensions (in feet) of largest proposed structure 41A height width; length. j Linear feet of frontage along a public thoroughfare project will occupy is? —t7lA— ft. 3 2 I low much natural material (i e , rock. earth, etc ) will be removed from the site? 4') tons/cubic yards 3. Will disttuhed areas be reclaimed? [:IYes CI No lmJ N/A a If ves, for what intended purpose is the site being reclaimed? b %Vill topsoil he stockpiled for reclamation? ❑Yes ❑No c Will upper subsoil be stockpiled for reclamation? ❑Yes [:]No 4 Ilow many acres of vegetation (trees, shrubs, ground covers) will be removed from site? ._� acres 5. Will any mature forest (over 100 years old) or other locally important vegetation be removed by this project? OYes ANo 6 If single phase project Anticipated period of construction months. (including demolition). 7. If multi phased a. Total number of phases anticipated (number). b. Anticipated date of commencement phase 1 month year, (including demolition). c. Approximate completion date of final phase month year. d. Is phase 1 functionally dependent on subsequent phases? ❑Yes ❑No 8. Will blasting occur during construction? ❑Yes VNo 9. Number of jobs generated: during construction e//k ; after project is complete ?-//t 10. Number of jobs eliminated by this project _. AJ�b _. 11. Will project require relocation of any projects or facilities? JIYes ❑No If yes, explain r10 Ve, err 17'1P -, CA1 WALK .L nnCK l Ehs - 12. Is surface liquid waste disposal involved? ❑yes Mcr a. If yes, indicate type of waste (sewage, industrial, etc.) and amount b. Name of water body into which effluent will be discharged 13. Is subsurface liquid waste disposal involved? Dyes f71LJo Type 14 Will surface area of an existing water body increase or decrease by proposal? ❑Yes KNo Explain 15. Is project or any portion of project located in a 100 year flood plain? ❑Yes WO 16 Will the project generate solid waste? ❑Yes PR40 a. If yes, what is the amount per month tons b. If yes, will an existing solid waste facility be used? Dyes ONd c If yes, give name ; location d. Will any wastes not go into a sewage disposal system or into a sanitary landfill? Dyes ❑No e If Yes, explain 17 Will the project involve the disposal of solid waste? ❑Yes KNcr a. If yes, what is the anticipated rate of disposal? tons/month. b If yes, what is the anticipated site life? years. 18 Will project use herbicides or pesticides? ❑Yes ,KNo 19 Will project routinely produce odors (more than one hour per day)? ❑Yes ANo 20 Will project produce operating noise exceeding the local ambient noise levels? Dyes Fj(No 21. Will project result in an increase in energy use? ❑Yes KNo If yes , indicate type(s) 22 If water supply is from wells, indicate pumping capacity LJIA gallons/minute. 23 Total anticipated water usage per day &YJ4 gallons/day. 24 Does project involve local, Stale or Federal funding? Dyes UNO If Yes, explain 4 . 25. Approvals Required: • • Submittal Type Date City. Town, Vdl.ii, P("'rd 1QYes f]No $2w/ZOr�pu9/{cLt� lU � City, Town. Village Planning 130ard I lYes ❑No —� —_ City, Town Zclninr! Board UYes ❑No _ City, Couri llc• 'Ih Department ❑Yes ❑No Other Local Agenres I lYes IJNo Other Regional •\geocivs LIYes LJNo - - —_ State Agencies AY'es L]No E r j , Federal Agencies WYes ❑No II SAC.or- C. Zoning and Planning Information 1 Does proposed action involve a planning or zoning decision? Dyes JgNo If Yes. indicate decision required: Uzoning amendment ❑zoning variance ❑special use permit [-]Subdivision ❑site plan Unewirevision of master plan ❑resource management plan ❑other 2 What is the zoning classification(s)of the site? R !/0 3 What is the maximum potential development of the site if developed as permitted by the present zoning? 4 What is the proposed zoning of the site? )t J1A 5. What is the maximum potential development of the site if developed as permitted by the proposed zoning? r A 6. Is the proposed action consistent with the recommended uses in adopted local land use plans? Ryes ❑No 7. What are the predominant land use(s) and zoning classifications within a '/4 mile radius of proposed action? fgj&) - i3d7N//JC a�.4CL1 4 E66770 USe pF,ZhK ,& B. Is the proposed action compatible with adjoining/surrounding land uses within a '/4 mile? byes ❑No 9. If the proposed action is the subdivision of (and, how many lots are proposed? a. What is the minimum lot size proposed? 10 Will proposed action require any authorization(s) for the formation of sewer or water districts? Dyes Wo 11 Will the proposed action creapte,,a1 demand for any community provided services (recreation, education, police, fire protection)? ❑yes NNO a If yes, is existing capacity sufficient to handle projected demand? Dyes LINO 12 Will the proposed action result in the generation of traffic significantly above present levels? Dyes 14No a If yes, is the existing road network adequate to handle the additional traffic? Dyes ❑No D. Informational Details Attach any additional information as may be needed to clarify your project If there are or may be any adverse impacts associated with your proposal, please discuss such impacts and the measures which you propose to mitigate or avoid them E. Verification I certify that the information provided above is true to the best of my knowledge. Applicant/Sponsor ame ..v e r,e J. 1 ae DateS-- Signature Title L/JR &MAA, - ,IAg. &e C4pedlt/Trc! 4' $-3 l-/A If the action is in the Coastal Area, d you are a state agency, complete the Coastal Assessment Form before proceeding with this assessment. 5 Part 2—PROJECT IMPACTS AND THEIR MAGNITUDE Respnnsibilily of Lead Agency General Information IRcad (-arcdully) • In r o,P l,ting the loon thr if virwer should be f!.mdrd I,y Ihr questionnr Have my responsrs :rod •Ir,termmation< been reasonable? Ihr revmwe r is not expected to br in expeiI environmental analyst • identify mg that ,nr nmpacl Will hr polenU,-lly Iaige I, olunut 2) does not mean that it is also ne,-es•.anly sir^ifi(anl. Any large mpar I Most be es aluated if, I' x i to determine significance Identifying an impact in waunri � simply asks (hat it be looked at further • T he Examples provided are to assist tll(. if s ow. i by showing types of impacts and wherever possible the threshold of magnitude that Would trigger a response in column 2. the examples are generally applicable throughout the State and for most situations But. for any specific project or site other examples and/or lower thresholds may be appropriate for a Potential Large Impart response. thus requiring evaluation in Part 3. • The impacts of each project. on each site. in each locality, will vary. Therefore, the examples are illustrative and have been offered as gurdnnce I hey do not constitute an exhaustive list of impacts and thresholds to answer each question • The number of examples per question does not indicate the importance of each question. • In identifying impacts, consider long term, short term and cumlative effects Instructions (Real] carefully) , a. Answer earh of the It) quf shins in PART 2 Answer Yes if there will be any impact. b Maybe answers should be considered as Yes answers c If answering Yes to a question then check the appropriate box (column 1 or 2) to indicate the potential size of the impart If impact threshold equals or exceeds any example provided, check column 2 If impact will occur but threshold is lower than example, check column 1 d If revievver has doubt about size of the impact then consider the impact as potentially large and proceed to PART 3 e. If a potentially large impact checked in column 2 can be mitigated by change(s) in the project to a small to moderate impact, also check the Yes box in column 3 A No response indicates that such a reduction is not possible This must be explained in Part 3. 1 2 3 Small to Potential Can Impact Be Moderate Large Mitigated By IMPACT ON LAND Impact Impact Project Change 1 Will the proposed action result in a physical change tot a project site? MO ❑YES Examples that would apply to column 2 • Any construction on slopes of 150'0 or greater, (15 foot rJ'�e r 100 ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No fool of length), or where the general slopes in the project WaWceed Fx�(jl 10%. fir • Cons lrnrc:t inn on land where the depth to the water table is less than ibt ❑ ❑Yes El No 3 feel • Construction of paved parking area for 1,000 or more vehirASIQ ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No • Construction on land where bedrock is exposed or generally � ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No 3 feet of existing ground surface /" " • Construction that will (Ontinue for more than 1 year or involve ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ONO than one phase or stage • Excavation for mining purposes that would remove more than 1,,0(�jQ ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No tons of nature) material (i e , rock or soil) per year • Construction or expansion of a sanitary lawndfill! v ❑ El ❑Yes El No • Construction in a designated floodway / /0 ❑ ❑ ❑Yes El No • Other imparts ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ONO 2 Will (here be an effect to any unique or unusual land forms found on the site? (i e . cliffs, dunes, geological formations, etc.] i!NO ❑YES • Site.( ific land forms. ❑ El ❑Yes ONO 1 2 3 IMPACT ON WATER Small to Potential Can Impact Be 3 Will proposed action affect any water body designated as protected? Moderate Large Mitigated By Impact Impact Project Change (Under Articles I5, 24, 25 of the Environmental Conservation Law, ECL) LINO DYES Examples that would apply to i olumn 2 • Developable area of cite contains a protected water body. ❑ ❑Yes ❑No • Dredging more than 100 cubic yards of material from channel ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No protected stream. • f xtension of utility distribution facilities through a protected wateA4 ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No • Construction in a designated freshwater or tidal wetland )v ❑ ❑Yes ❑No • Other impacts _ .[ ❑ El Dyes El No v 4 Will proposed action affect any non-protected existing or new body of water? °ENO DYES Examples that would apply to column 2 • A 10% increase or decrease in the surface area of any body ter ❑ ❑ Dyes ❑No or mole than a 10 acre increase or decrease. • Construction of a body of water that exceeds 10 acres of surfaA/Vea. ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No • Other impacts: ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No 5 will Proposed Action affect surface or groundwater quality or quantity? ❑NO DYES Examples that world apply to column 2 /W • Proposed Action will require a discharge permit. 114 ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No • Proposed Action requires use of a source of water that does not El ❑ ❑Yes ❑No have approval to serve proposed (project) action. /t/[/ • Proposed Action requires water supply from wells with great r an 45 El El ❑Yes El No gallons per minute pumping capacity. • Construction or operation causing any contamination of flAter ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No supply system. • Proposed Action will adversely affect groundwater. ���� ❑ El Dyes ❑No • Liquid effluent will be conveyed off the site to facilities�wtfiich presently ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No do not exist or have inadequate capacity. • Proposed A, lion would use water in excess of 20.0((A allons per ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No day, • Proposed Action will likely cause siltation or other rji$yf$/rge into an ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No existing body of water to the extent that there will be an obvious visual contrast to natural conditions. �) • Proposed Action will require the storage of petroleum QeA4mical ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No products greater than 1,100 gallons. • Proposed Action will allow residential uses in areas wrlpVtowater ❑ ❑ Dyes ❑No and/or sewer services. • Proposed Action locates commercial and/or industrial users w�h hr may ❑ ❑ Dyes ❑No require new or expansion of existing waste treatment arN1/tlr Storage facilities. • Other unpacts ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No 6. Will proposed action alter drainage flow or patte s, or surface water runoff? 9O DYES Examples that would apply to column 2 • Proposed Action would change flood water flows. /V4) ❑ ❑ I ❑Yes ❑No 7 1 2 3 Small to Potential Can Impact Be Moderate Large Mitigated By Impact Impact Project Change • Proposed Arbon may cause substantial erosion ~ V ❑ j_.� ❑des LINO -)) ❑ ❑y'es LINO Proposed Ac Uon is incompatible with existng drainage paf'lerHs. ❑ • Proposed Action will allow development in a designated flo Y. ❑ ❑ ❑)es ❑No • Other imparts ❑ ❑ ❑y'es ONO IMPACT ON AIR yy 7 Will proposed action affect air quality? +n10 ❑YES Examples that would apply to column 2 • Proposed Action will induce 11000 or more vehicle trips in any ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ONO hour. • Proposed Action will result in the incineration of more than 1�1)14`f ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ONO refuse per hour //.. • Emission rate of total contaminants will exceed 5 lbs. per ho VfW0a ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No heat source producing more than 10 million BILI's per hour. • Proposed action will allow an increase in the amount of land cghy/i(Jlted ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ONO to industrial use • Proposed action will allow an increase in the density of indu?vv ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ONO development within existing industrial areas • Other impacts. ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No IMPACT ON PLANTS AND ANIMALS R Will Proposed Action affect any threatened or endang red species? E_ O ❑YES Examples that would apply to column 2 • Reduction of one or more species listed on the New York '�PdkOeral ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ONO list, using the site, over or near site or found on the site • Removal of any portion of a critical or significant wildlifva itat. ❑ ❑ El Yes ONO • Application of pesticide or herbicide more than twice a year, o ier ❑ ❑ El Yes El No than for agricultural purposes. • ❑ El ❑Yes ❑No Other impacts 9 Will Proposed Action substantially affect non threatened or non-enclangered species? I_iNO ❑YES Examples that would apply to column 2 �1 �� • Proposed Action substantially interfere with ao/v dent or � ❑ ❑Yes []No migratory fist shellfish r wildlife species. • Proposed Action requires the removal of more L r �10 acres ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ONO of mature forest (over loll years of age) or other locally important vegetation IMPACT ON AGRICULTURAL LAND RESOURCES 10 Will tire Proposed Action affect agricultural land nurses? : NO []YES Examples that would apply to column 2 - • file proposed action %%out(] sever, cross or limit ac s t agricultural El El ❑y'es ❑No land (includes cropland, hayfields, pasture, vineyard, o chard, etc ) 8 1 2 3 Small to Potential Can Impact Be Moderate Large Mitigated By Impact Impact Project Change • Construction activity would excavate or compact the so' rofile of ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No agricultural land • The proposed action would irreversibly convert re th 10 acres ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No of agricultural land or, if located in an Agric t lal stric more than 2 5 acres of agricultural land • The proposed action would disrupt or prevent in all tiot a icultural ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No land management systems (e.g., subsurface dr in lit , outlet ditches, strip cropping); or create a need for such me sures (e.g. cause a farm field to drain poorly due to increased runoff) • Other impacts ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No IMPACT ON AESTHETIC RESOURCES 11 Will proposed action affect aesthetic resources? NO OYES (I( necessary, use the Visual EAF Addendum in Se n 617.21, Appendix B.) Examples that would apply to column 2 • Proposed land uses, or project components obv usly d' r nt from ❑ ❑ ❑Yes []No or in sharp contrast to current surrouI s patt ns, hether man-made or natural. • Proposed land uses, or project cv ibl to sets of ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No aesthetic resources which will eliminifi a I re ce their enjoyment of the aesthetic qualities ur • Project components that will result ination or significant ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No screening of scenic views known to t to the area. • Other impacts: ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No IMPACT ON HISTORIC AND ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESOURCES 12. Will Proposed Action impact any site or structure of hiA.rgnatedas toric, pre- historic or paleontological importanceDYES Examples that would apply to column 2 • Proposed Action occurring wholly or pars ntially ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No contiguous to any facility or site listed on tal egister of historic places • Any impact to an archaeological site or fwithin the ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No project site. • Proposed Action will occur in an areasitive for ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No archaeological sites on the NYS Site Inve • Other impacts. ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No IMPACT ON OPEN SPACE AND RECREATION 13 Will Proposed Action affect the quantity or quality of existing or future open spaces or recreational opportunities? y Examples that would apply to column 2 ONO STYES • The permanent foreclosure of a future recreational opportunity. ❑ ❑Yes ❑No • A major reduction of an open space, important to the community. ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No • Other impacts. wi /z ❑ ❑Yes ❑No 9 1 2 3 IMPACT ON TRANSPORTATION Small to Potential Can Impact Be 14. Will there be an effect to existing transportation systems? Moderate Large Mitigated By )p ❑yES Impact Impact Project Change Examples that would apply to column 2 • Alteration of present patterns of movement of peo c goods ❑ ❑ Dyes ❑Nn • Proposed Action will result m major traffic prohlei is ❑ ❑ ❑)es ❑No • Other impacts. _ ❑ ❑ [-]Yes ❑No IMPACT ON ENERGY 15 Will proposed action affect the community's sour of fuel or energy supply? O DYES Examples that would apply to column 2 • Proposed Action will cause a greater than 5% incre in e e of ❑ ❑ Dyes ❑No any form of energy in the municipality _ • Proposed Action will require the creation or ext Sion of an energy ❑ ❑ ❑Yes []No transmission or supply system Co serve more than 0 single or two family residences or to serve a major commercial or industrial use. • Other impacts: _ ❑ ❑ ❑Yes EINo NOISE AND ODOR IMPACTS 16 Will there be objectionable odors, noise, or vibra ion as a result of the Proposed Action? �F�NO DYES Examples that would apply to column 2 • Blasting within 1,500 feet of a hospital, school or Ve /s)esitive ❑ El ❑Yes ❑No facility • Odors will occur routinely (more than one hour per (lay) ❑ ❑ Dyes ❑No • Proposed Action will produce operating noise exceeding the local ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No ambient noise levels for noise outside of structures. • Proposed Action will remove natural barriers that would act as a ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No noise screen • Other impacts: ❑ ❑ Dyes El No IMPACT ON PUBLIC HEALTH 17 Will Proposed Action affect public health and safety? FAO DYES Examples that would apply to column 2 • Proposed Action may cause a risk of explosion or release of hazardous ❑ ❑ [-]Yes ❑No substances(i e oil, pesticides, chemicals, radiation, etc.) in thefevenl of accident or upset conditions, or there may be a chronic I w le e discharge or emission • Proposed Action may result in the burial of "hazardous s tes' an ❑ ❑ Dyes El No form (i e toxic, poisonous, highly reactive, radioac v irr to ' g. infectious, etc 1 • Storage facilities for one million or more gallons of liquified natural ❑ ❑ Dyes ❑No gas or other flarnmable liquids • Proposed action may result in the excavation or other disturbance ❑ ❑ Dyes ❑NO Hilhin 2.000 feet of a site used for the disposal of solid or hazardous waste • Other impacts ❑ ❑ El Yes El No 10 M 1 2 3 IMPACT ON GROWTH AND CHARACTER Small to Potential Can Impact Be OF COMMUNITY OR NEIGHBORHOOD Moderate Large Mitigated By 18 Will proposed action affect the character of the eris[jng community? Impact Impact Project Change NO ❑1'ES Examples that would apply to column 2 • The permanent population of the city, town or village,'fn cvhi h the ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No project is located is likely to grow by more than Sob. • The municipal budget for capital expenditures or oWsr s ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No will increase by more than S% per year as a result • Proposed action will conflict with officially adopte . ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No • Proposed action will cause a change in the density ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No • Proposed Action will replace or eliminate existing f cis ❑ ❑ [-]Yes ❑No or areas of historic importance to the community. • Development will create a demand for additional ommunity services ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No (e.g. schools, police and fire, etc.) • Proposed Action will set an important precedent for future projects. ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No • Proposed Action will create or eliminate employment. ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No • Other impacts: ❑ ❑ ❑Yes ❑No 19 Is there, or is there likely to be, public controversy related to potential adverse environmental impacts? �NO DYES If Any Action in Part 2 Is Identified as a Potential Large Impact or If You Cannot Determine the Magnitude of Impact, Proceed to Part 3 Part 3—EVALUATION OF THE IMPORTANCE OF IMPACTS Responsibility of Lead Agency Part 3 must be prepared if one or more impact(s) is considered to be potentially large, even if the impact(s) may be mitigated. Instructions Discuss the following for each impact identified in Column 2 of Part 2: 1 Briefly describe the impact. 2 Describe(if applicable)how the impact could be mitigated or reduced to a small to moderate impact by project change(s). 3 Based on the information available, decide if it is reasonable to conclude that this impact is important. To answer the question of importance, consider: • The probability of the impact occurring • The duration of the impact • Its irreversibility, including permanently lost resources of value • Whether the impact can or will be controlled • The regional consequence of the impact • Its potential divergence from local needs and goals • Whether known objections to the project relate to this impact. (Continue on attachments) A J' ,� /rN (L Sac /7Jr ✓✓ ` GARDINERS BAY ESTATES HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. East Marion, New York 11939 :_arch 9, 19c2 1:r5 -Dept. of Er_viromental Conservation Division of ReSulatory Affairs 4e;ion 1 Stony Brook SU7-,� Ca-pus, 31dC. 40, Poo- 219 Stony 3rook, _ Y 11790-233= Atte;:tion: ')arlene '=erbino E : A,plication Id. "`- 1-!;Tjc 00y 2-00001-0 -Dear Sirs : in reply to your request for additional infor:, ation the fcllo;:in- are enclosed: 3 conies revised project Ulan 3 conies revised cross-section 3 copies of authorization letter fro:- 3oard of ')irectors 2 stanped surveys ldjacent land oz;ners are : Judit:. -Di lasi and Lani 7. Sai::bach. .Suffolk Count;. Tax "ap 10C'j0-037-01-23. ie are askin for an ac.e_.d: ent to increase tt:e lenEth of the catmalk froi:, 15 ' to 20 ' to co:iply with the t3 " . (letter enclosed) . It is sno-oin on the revised cross-section. Yours very truly2 Laoirence J. tzen "ari ne Chair.^an r_c . cc 70z:n of Southold r�NNn7 - O r1 CYN P U VO 0 0 10 N U] -P N -:I- n n P: F4 c h+N+ W 0 Kl a o2' h0:_: U1 Co rl 7 N Fa C.' .. W $A � •'O �. as vP'iw m o r-) � Q i((4 ro Ji in T t o 13 CLI Al O-, %�, /1 � 'r ' -_ ' � ,W i 1 �L'S"•rino$O+ti4i.49;;�...boi` •y f tip} t vy y� i NW p 1 w x Y E �h Y = 4i v + J � � u a n 1 a a d, i 2�-r ,n F— Ncair —' �v -- _- i 40 Vol F, ELO coy O -P O N co +3 Cd i•?' �� S :' " co 0tiac 4 ti n a td! CU N 4+ 4+ \ I .Up7 n ." +, r4 w c, v ��1 W d ca . u� "1 �d1 W � �' 3 Oa �I W�# $ as v1 F] � P7 O U Cl 11)r} u _ .. . S —___ _ ..._.._.. _ NWI 00 f 7 ce i � Z Y � I L f/5p/5p/5p � r 1 x o Di 0 E - - - - � R � S! S o N O I � i 'o I N O o n W Q ^^rr V 4M El 0 (4) GARDINERS BAY ESTATES HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. East Marion, New York 11939 "arch 9, 1002 _73 e_ot. of "nvironr:ental Conservation 3—U:71' Caripus, Bldg. 402 oo;•i 219 Stony Brook, - i 11790-235; Attention: Darlene Jerbino pplicatioi, Id. 1-473r^_.-00Wf2-00G01-0 7e%3r Sirs: 'Ihe oard of 7irectorz, of irardinerE day states :?oi:-eo':,,ners Association, Inc . , lies ,riven 1.a,sre:,ce J. - 'atzen, ;oard .et:,ber and '-arine Chair::_an, authorization for peruission to a p1V� for -per :its to construct a 4 boat docf on the _�0�;'✓:ood !,ane ri,-gilt of Z:ay, into tonal. _ours very truly, ;;amen Sa,..baci, Sr. ,/ic-.resident Ft� i TRUSTEES ''F John M.Btedemeyer,III,President , SUPERVISOR Henry P.Smith,Vice President Go SCOTT L.HARRIS Albert J.Krupsld,Jr. 0,f, • John L.Bednosl i,Jr. a 53 Town Hall Main Road John B.Tuthill P.O.Box 1179 Telephone(516)765-1892 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES Southold,New York 11971 Fax(516)765-1823 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD March 12, 1992 Lawrence J. Matzen P.O. Box 342 Dogwood Lane East Marion, NY 11939 RE: Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association SCTM #1000-37-4-17 i Dear Mr. Matzen: This letter will confirm in more detail our conversation of March 10 and 12, 1992. The Southold Town Code Section 100-31 (3 ) (a) states that "There shall be docking or mooring facilities for no more than ( 2) boats other than those owned and used by the owner of the premises for his personal use" as an approved accessory use in the R-40 District. As there is no mention of community docking facilities, it is recommended that you seek an interpretation and determination from the Town Attorney and Zoning Board of Appeals as to the need or applicability of a variance for your proposal. The Board of Trustees cannot proceed with your application until these essential questions are answered. Also, I must apologize for not noting earlier that your file did not contain a completed Long Environmental Assessment form for this project, a blank form is enclosed for your use. V y truly yours, John M. Bredemeyer,III President, Board of Trustees JMB:jmt enc. cc: Town Attorney Zoning Board of Appeals r �S�FFOi1r�o� c (:_ Town Flail. 5'1,095 Main Road N ' ' tS P.O. [lox 1179 Telephone 0 ® _ (516) 765-1801 � 01 ��Q� Southold. New York 11971 SOUTHOLD TOWN CONSERVATION ADVISORY COUNCIL TO: Southold Town Board of Trustees / AWN OFSOUT FROM: Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council MOLD DATED: February 25 , 1992 RE: RECOMMENDATION OF WETLAND APPLICATIONS The following recommendation were made by the Southold Town Conser- vation Advisory Council at its meeting held February 13 , 1992 : On a motion by John Holzapfel, seconded by Bruce Loucka, it was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees disapproval of Wetland Application No. 37-4-17 of Gard ' ers Bay Estates Home- owners Association to construct a 3 ' x 16 catwalk e ovation ) , 3 ' x 16 ' ramp; 4 ' x 24 ' float with two ( 2 ) 3 ' x 14 ' fingers and three ( 3 ) piles ; also, move existing catwalk 12 ' east . All work on Association ' s ROW and pond property. The Council recommends disapproval because it has a policy of one dock, with a capacity of four ( 4 ) boats on a single piece of property. The Council does not wish to see marians developed by property associations. - Spring Pond, East Marion . Vote of Counci: Ayes: All Motion carried. On a motion by Stephen Angell, seconded by Cynthia Sturner, it was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval of Wetland Application No. 122-4-32 of Robert .znba„en to construct an 8 ' x 24 ' floating dock with a 3 ' x 16 ' ramp using CCA treated lumber. The Council approves provided the applicant contain runoff and maintain nataural vegetation on enbankments . 4500 Ole Jule Lane , Mattituck. Vote of Council: Ayes : All Motion carried. The Council tabled Wetland Application No. 113-6-8 of Joyce Deckenstein Lakin to add a second 6 ' x 20 ' float plus one 8" diameter pile to existing dock to reach deep water. The Council needs to determine who owns the mooring located off the dock extension and wish to inspect the site with all members present . 830 Jackson Landing, Mattituck. n TRUSTEES �n� John M.Bredemeyer,III,President Li 1 SUPERVISOR Henry . Smith,Vice President "' m SCOTT L. HARRIS my v, �"� Albert J.Krupski,Jr. John L. Bednoski,Jr. y Town Hall John B.Tuthill tig X,x 53095 Main Road P.O.Box 1179 Telephone(516)765-1892 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES Southold,New York 11971 Fax(516)765-1823 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD January 23, 1992 Mr. John Holzapfel, Chairman Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council Southold Town Hall Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Dear Mr. Holzapfel: Transmitted herewith is application No. 37-4-17 for a wetland application submitted by Lawrence Matzen on behalf of Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association. Please prepare a written report of findings and recommendations with respect to this application. Very truly yours, '�4 . -�r �f �' John M. Bredemey`er, III President, Board of Trustees JMB:jt GAROINERS BAY ESTATES HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. East Marion, New York 11939- 0004 JAN 2 2 "19? January 21, 1992 4"!AM OF SOUTH, LD Board of Trustees Town of Southold Southold, '+Y 11971 Dear Sirs: On October 19, 1991, the 7Board of Directors of Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association, Inc. , resolved to place a four slip floating dock in Spring Fond, on the Dogwood Road right of way. The land and the pond bottom is fully owned by the Association. It is the widest Association right of way on the shoreline of the pond ( 1E7 ' at MW) . ge are enclosing, herewith, our applications for the necessary permits. Our boat rules do not allow flushing of toilets or sleeping on boats overnight. The Marine Committee has made a determination that "boats with operatable, flush overboard, marine toilets will not be permitted to dock or moor in spring Fond". 4e look forward to receiving a favorable review of the attached permit applications. Yours truly, GARDI ERS BAY ESTATES HOP{EO NERS ASSOC. , IE1C. c Lawrence J. Matzen Marine Chairman Enc. j TRUSTEES ( � L. .1,. a SCOTT L. HARRIS Supervisor John M. Bredemeyer, III, President ', Henry P. Smith, Vice President . .,� ' aC Town Hall, 53095 Main Road Albert J. Kmpski, Jr. �� a +' . P.O. Box 1179 John L. Bednoski. Jr. ITV Id, New York 11971 John B. Tuthill BOARD OF TOWN TRU 6 L,r Vr (516) 765-1823 Telephone (516) 765-1892 TOWN OF SOUTHOL one (5Ib) 765-1800 JAN 2 2 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD( APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE TO THE TOWN TRUSTEES, TOWN OF SOUTHOLD, SUFFOLK COUNTY, NEW YORK, FOR THE ISSUANCE OF A PERMIT PURSUANT TO THE LAWS, ORDINANCES AND REGULATIONS GOVERNING THE COASTAL AND INTERIOR WETLANDS , FLOOD PLAINS AND DRAINAGE AREAS OF SOUTHOLD TOWN, AND THE ISSUANCE OF PERMITS PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 32 OF THE CODE OF THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD. APPLICATION NO. .577- Li- %� _DATE January 14, 1992 Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners APPLICANT' S NAME: Assn. , Inc . TEL. NO. 477-9675 MAILING ADDRESS: P.O- Rox -542, nogwood La. , ',ast 11arion 11Y 11939 AGENT- Lawrence J. : atzen TEL NO. 477-9675 AGENT ADDRESS: P.O. ,3ox 342 dogwood I.a. , blast 11arion, 1iY 11939 PERMIT REQUESTED TO: AP plicant proposes to construct a 3'xl6 ' catwalk (elevated 4' over grade ) * 31x16 ' ramp; 41x24' float with 2 - 3'xl ' fingers and 3 piles, also, move existin.- catwalk 12' east; all wor on ssocia. ion right of wav and Pond property. LOCATION OF PROPERTY FOR REQUESTED PERMIT: Spring Pond, East N.arion 1;Y TOWN: Southold TAX MAP NO: 1000- 037-4-17 CREEK. BAY OR HARBOR FRONTING PROPERTY: Orient Harbor SIZE ,v PROPOSED WORK: LENG-H . Catwalk 16 ' , Pamp 161 , Float 16 ' WIDTH: Catwalk 31 , Ramp 31 , Float 24' • OP. Page 2. YDS. TO BE EXCAVATED: none YDS. TO BE FILLED: none MANNER IN WHICH MATERIAL WILL BE REMOVED OR DEPOSITED: ;lA WIDTH OF CANAL, CREEK OR BAY FRONTING PROPERTY: From 90 ' to 300 ' DEPTH AT LOW TIDE: 3' AVER. RISE IN TIDE: 2.6 ' . DISTANCE TO NEAREST CHANNEL: 800' to Bulkhead Channel DISTANCE PROJECT EXTENDS BEYOND SIMILAR PROJECTS IN AREA: average same AREA ZONING: residential IS PROJECT FOR PRIVATE OR BUS. USE: Private INTENDED USE OF PROPERTY: Private, Association recreational boat dockin- DESCRIBE KNOWN PRIOR OPERATIONS CONDUCTED ON PREMISES: Private ,Association boat docking and launching. HAS ANY PRIOR LICENSE OR PERMIT BEEN ISSUED TO ERECT STRUCTURES, DREDGE, OR DEPOSIT FILL ON SAID PREMISES: s"es HAS ANY LICENSE OR PERMIT EVER BEEN REVOKED OR SUSPENDED BY A GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY: ifo DESCRIBE FULLY THE REHABILITATION OF PROPERTY: lone expected DESCRIBE PROPOSED CONDITION OF PROPERTY AFTER WORK IS COMPLETED. INCLUDE AN ADDITIONAL SURVEY OF PROPERTY SITE IF NECESSARY: �,pmp. exca; t added lb ' catwalk. ARE THERE ANY COVENANTS OR RESTRICTIONS IN YOUR DEED WHICH WOULD PROHIBIT THIS PROJECT: o WRITTEN CONSENT OF OWNER IF NOT THE SAME AS APPLICANT: LrA COUNTY OF SUFFOLK ) STATE OF NEW YORK ) Lawrence J. ';atzen BEING DULY SWORN DEPOSES AND SAYS THAT HE IS THE APPLICANT FOR THE ABOVE DESCRIBED PERMITS, AND THAT ALL STATEMENTS CONTAINED HEREIN ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF HIS KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF, AND THAT WORK WILL BE DONE IN THE MANNER SET FORTH IN THIS APPLICATION AND AS MAY BE APPROVED BY THE TOWN BOARD OF THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD. THE APPLICANT AGREES TO HOLD THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD AND THE TOWN TRUSTEES HARMLESS AND FREE FROM ANY AND ALL DAMAGES AND CLAIMS ARISING UNDER OR BY VIRTUE OF SAID PERMIT, IF GRANTED. IN COMPLETING THIS APPLICATION, I HEREBY AUTHORIZE THE TRUSTEES , THEIR AGENT OR REPRESENTATIVE, TO ENTER ONTO MY PROPERTY TO INSPECT THE PREMISES IN CONJUNCTION WITH REVIEW OF THIS APPLICATION. Signature of Ap i ant SWORN TO BEFORE ME THIS DAY OF , 19 C SHEPPEYAP^_^,'—, l=.:J Mary PUEer., `U York i NOTARY P I ot;:'ifisd b Acl;;County Commission9923 EXAMINED BY APPROVED DISAPPROVED CONDITIONS (If any) SIGNATURE OF CHAIRMAN COMPUTATION OF FEES Approved 2/27/85 PART II—ENVIRONh1ENTAL ASSESSMENT (To be completed b' A 1 qency) A. DOES ACTION EhCEED ANV I THRESHOLD IN 6 NYCRR, PART 617.121 If El Yes NO y Ordinate the review process end UCB the FULL Eb,-- y� B. WILL ACTION RECEIVE COORDINATED REVIEW AS PROVIDED FOR UNLISTED ACTIONS IN 6 NYCRR, PART 617.6? If No,a negative tleclaranon r may be superseded by another mvolveo agency. ❑Yes ❑No C. COULD ACTION RESULT IN ANY ADVERSE EFFECTS ASSOCIATED WITH THE FOLLOWING:(Answers may be nantlwrftten. it legible) C7. Existing air quality, surface or grountlwater quality or quantity, noise levels, existing Irallic patterns, solid waste Production or disposal, potential for erosion,drainage or flooding problems? Explain briefly: C2. Aesthetic,agricultural, archaeological, historic,or other natural or cultural resources;or community or neighborhood character? Explain briefly: C3. Vegetation or fauna, fish, shellfish or wildlife species, significant habitats,or threatened or endangered species? Explain briefly: Cd. A community's existing plans or goals as officially adopted,or a change in use or Intensity of use of land or other natural resources?Explain briefly. CS. Growth, subsequent development. or related activities likely to be Induced by the proposed action? Explain brietly. C6. Long term, short term, cumulative, or other effects not identified in C1-057 Explain briefly. C7. Other impacts(incWtlmg changes in use of either quantity or type of energy)? Explain briefly, D. IS THERE,OR IS THERE LIKELY TO RE, CONTROVERSY RELATED TO POTENTIAL ADVERSE ENVIRON&IENTAL IMPA p ❑Yes F,No If Yes,explain briefly GTS. PART III—DETERMINATION OF SIGNIFICANCE (To be completed by Agency)INSTRUCTIONS: For each adverse effect identified above,determine whether it is substantial,large,important or otherwise significal Each effect should be assessed in connection with its (a) setting (i.e. urban or rural); (b) probability of Occurring- irreversibility; (e) geographic scope; and (f) magnitude It necessary, add attachments or reference su pporting mater explanations contain sufficient detail to show that all relevant adverse im . and adequately acts have been identified ai ials Ensure it .(d) duration; (. p addressed. ❑ Check this box if you have identified one or more potentially large or significant adverse impacts Which MAY occur. Then proceed directly to the FULL EAF and/or prepare a positive declaration. Check u have determined' based On ❑ ocumentlation,t if thatothe proposed action WILL NOTtrt result in any signie information ficant tladverseoenvironmental an AND provide on attachments as necessary, y Supporting Y the reasons supporting this determination: impacts Ndme ni txdJ Agency Ynm w type Name ul Ncsponsiule UII¢er in Lees n gcncy l rile of KnponubiC Uf pert >igna[ure w Hesponame in Lead Agency -_,_ $igna Wre or Preparer III different Irom msponsime on¢eq DJIC _ •tea _ (2167)—Text 12 A4. PROJECT I.D.NUMBER 617.21 SEOR Appendix C 104 State Environmental Quality Review SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM For UNLISTED ACTIONS Only PART I—PROJECT INFORMATION (To be completed by Applicant or Project sponsor) 1. APPLICANT/SPONSORGardiners Say estates 2. PROJECT NAME Dogwood Lane right of way Homeowners Assoc.4,0. PROJECT LOCATION: Mpnlaloallty East 7arion, Southold Town. capnly Suffolk; 4. PRECISE LOCATION(Street address and road intersections,prominent landmarks,etc.,or rgvlae ma End of 'dogwood Lane, near 3ayview T)rive, ar�iners 3ay _:states, Last i:arion, .;Y 11939 S. IS PROPOSED ACTION: ®New ❑Expansion ❑Modification/alteration 6. DESCRIBE PROJECT BRIEFLY: proposes to construct a grade ) ; 3 x x catwalk e eva - ed 4' over g ) ; 3'xlo' ramp; 4'x24' float with 2 - 3' l4' fingers and 3 piles; also to move existing catwalk 12' east; all work on Association right of way and pond property. 7. AMOUNT OF LAND AFFECTED: Initially _Ol a C tZ`p S' _ acres Ultimately acres B. WILL PROPOSED ACTION COMPLY WITH EXISTING ZONING OR OTHER EXISTING LAND USE RESTRICTIONS? ®Yes ❑No If No,describe briefly 9. WHAT IS PRESENT LAND USE IN VICINITY OF PROJECT? ❑Residential ❑!nd.strial El Commercial ❑Agn6ulture ❑ParklForest/Open space ®Other Describe: Association right of way and private recreational boat docking and boat launching. 10. DOES ACTION INVOLVE A PERMIT APPROVAL,OR FUNDING. NOW OR ULTIMATELY FROM ANY OTHER GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY(FEDERAL, STATE OR LOCAL)? QYes ❑No If yes, list agency(s)and permit/approvals Town of Southold, US Array Corps of 3ngineers r. 11. DOES ANY ASPECT OF THE ACTIO14 HAVE A CURRENTLY VALID PERMIT OR APPROVAL? ❑Yes No If yes, list agency name and permit/approval 12. AS A RESULT r H OF PROPOSED ACTION WILL EXISTING PERMIT/APPROVAL REQUIRE MODIFICATION? ❑Yes I_I'' o I CE11TIFY THAT THE INFORMATION PROVIDED ABOVE IS TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE Appl,canllsponsw name: Lawrence J. i°atZen r3�F TnC. Dd1e: 1/141/14�_ \\ Signature: _ 1 .. If the action is in the Coastal Area, and you are a state agency, complete the Coastal Assessment Form before proceeding with this assessment OVER COUNTY OF SUFFOLK ) STATE OF NEW YORK ) Lawrence J. "atzen BEING DULY SWORN DEPOSES AND SAYS THAT HE IS THE APPLICANT FOR THE ABOVE DESCRIBED PERMITS, AND THAT ALL STATEMENTS CONTAINED HEREIN ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF HIS KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF, AND THAT WORK WILL BE DONE IN THE MANNER SET FORTH IN THIS APPLICATION AND AS MAY BE APPROVED BY THE TOWN BOARD OF THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD. THE APPLICANT AGREES TO HOLD THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD AND THE TOWN TRUSTEES HARMLESS AND FREE FROM ANY AND ALL DAMAGES AND CLAIMS ARISING UNDER OR BY VIRTUE OF SAID PERMIT, IF GRANTED. IN COMPLETING THIS APPLICATION, I HEREBY AUTHORIZE THE TRUSTEES , THEIR AGENT OR REPRESENTATIVE, TO ENTER ONTO MY PROPERTY TO INSPECT THE PREIISES IN CONJUNCTION WITH REVIEW OF THIS APPLICATION. Signature of Applic SWORN TO BEFORE ME THIS DAY OF J� 19 �c SHER warypw!o' FODGEgS / TARY LIC is f- S9 7°'Ci7 York EXAMINED BY APPROVED DISAPPROVED CONDITIONS (If any) SIGNATURE OF CHAIP14AN COMPUTATION OF FEES Approved 2/27/85 AL App ant proposes to Construct3 ' % EA T MARION 16 ' catwalk (elevated + ' over grade at vegation) ; 3 'xl6 ' ramp; 41x24' float IN� °-I�( with 2-3 'xl4 ' finGers and 3 piles; also ='{ z to move existing catwalk 12 ' ear,t ; all f � °�z3 J :_work on Assoc, right of way and pond �I property. r +' .Applicant : Gardiners Pay :;states Homeowners Assoc . , Inc. ` Ci r / Purpose : Assoc . private recreational �J / docking. i` Datum: i'.ean low water s,5a%TAK &%A 2 j �SlCALTIIg��0020'� Location: 72°20'23".H/41° 07 '091"1 � a P ~ 3 UO 3 � 3 Lu W J i ,V T Nvv�O � �- 000M G CL C0 } 00 o / Z. SCALE GARnir4 d6y En ATE:S E Cd REE--MAP. VFGARDJNrRS i AwRENCk.. 7. ._3h7F:.LI f CLAY-1`u?ATr-VI "G2" -Gtil"�. MA-RINE COryn1T'[EE -MAP NO. 279 / iy Y:'. CWFFT I F,--? pi � 31 ci aC. id v aLL � o• �T � • X x N i T\ � 3 " h- 0 n O N a 2 a x W <� }ta h Y 1 ti� O V d k i� t W O N NEET2oF !! f � �J GARDINERS BAY ESTATES HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. East Marion, New York 11939 P.O . Box 4 July 16 , 1994 tt TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Thomas Wickfam Supervisor Town of Southold P .O . Box 1179 53095 Main Road Southold NY 11971 Supervisor Wickam: I am the new President of Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association Inc . and I want to know if we are in compliance with all Rules , Regulations and Zoning of the Town of Southold . This is with reference to the installation of a new six boat floats , pier and catwalk. I would appreciate a call at my home, 477-2521 or at my office, 734-7492 to make an appointment to discuss the possible problem. Sincerely, A- p Liz C Warren A. Sambach Sr . P.E. low - BLDG. DEPT'. TOWN OF SOUTHOLD East Marion, NY 11939 September 26 , 1994 Gentlemen: It has come to my attention that Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Ass ,n does not have all the necessary permitsdfrom the Town to install the six boat pier and float already in place. I trust something will be done about this , either a violation be issued or the ne- cessary permits be issued. Yours truly, Longtime resident SEP 2 7 W TOWN OF SOUTHOLD- GAROINERS BAY ESTATES HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. April 18, 1993 East Marion, New York 11939 d E 0 d R D Mr . John M. Bredmeyer, III MI Aft 19 199(i President, Board of Trustees TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Southold Town Hall P . 0. Box 1179 Southold, New York, 11971 3?-5- 1 Re: Sambach and DiBlasi Applications Dear Mr . Bredmeyer : The Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Association, Inc. Board of Directors has reviewed your letter of January 22, 1993 addressed to Mr . Sambach. As noted in your letter, the property involved is owned by the Association and is subject to our dominion. The particular marine facilities involved in these applications are the responsibility of the Marine Committee, one of the Associations 's standing committees . Under their auspices the docking facility is leased on an annual basis and is renewable at the discretion of that Committee . As a result of the terms of the agreement, the applicants have no vested right to perpetual usage of the dock . They enjoy the privilege of usage at the pleasure of the Marine Committee who can terminate the agreement on any renewal date . At the April 17, 1993 meeting of the G.B.E.H.O.A. Board of Directors, at which a quorum was present and voting, the following motion was passed by a vote of 10 to 0 with 2 abstaining. "Resolved, that the applications to Southold Town by Sambach, and DiBlasi for grandfathering docking rights in perpetuity on Association property be denied . " Based on the above, the Association has decided to withhold its consent to the proposed grandfather applications . We respectfully request that` the applications be denied on the basis that the applicants dd not have authority to seek same without benefit of the Association 's authorization. If you have any further questions on this matter, please do not hesitate to contact me . Very truly yours, Gardiners Bay Estates Homeowners Assoc . Inc. Edward Birdie, President I PUBLIC NOTICE � t� ll US Army Corps fn replying refer to. of Engineers Public Notice Number:93-02180-L2 New York District Issue Date: Ju Jacob K. Javits Federal Building ly 30, 1993 New York, N.Y. 10278-0090 Expiration Date: August 30, 1993 ATTN: Regulatory Branch To Whom It May Concern: The New York District, Corps of Engineers has received an application for a Department of the Army permit pursuant to Section 404 of the Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. 1344) and Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899 (33 U.S.C. 403) . APPLICANT: New York State Office of Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation Belmont Lake State Park P.O. Box 247 Babylon, NY 11702-0247 ACTIVITY: Construct a gabion revetment WATERWAY: Gardiners Bay LOCATION: Orient, Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York A detailed description and plans of the applicant ' s activity are enclosed to assist in your review. The decision whether to issue a permit will be based on an evaluation of the probable impact, including cumulative impacts, of the proposed activity on the public interest. That decision Will reflect the national concern for both protection and utilization of important resources . The benefits which reasonably may be expected to accrue from the proposal must be balanced against its reasonably foreseeable detriments. All factors which may be relevant to the proposal will be considered including the cumulative effects thereof; among those are conservation, economics, aesthetics, general environmental concerns, wetlands, historic properties, fish and wildlife values, flood hazards, floodplain values, land use, navigation, shoreline erosion and accretion, recreation, water supply and conservation, water quality, energy needs, safety, food and fiber production, mineral needs, considerations of property ownership and in general, the needs and welfare of the people. The Corps of Engineers is soliciting comments from the public; Federal, state, and local agencies and officials; Indian Tribes; and other interested parties in order to consider and evaluate the CENAN-OP-RE PUBLIC NOTICE NO. 93-02180-L2 applicant will obtain a water quality certificate or waiver from the appropriate state agency in accordance with Section 401 of the Clean Water Act prior to a permit decision. Pursuant to Section 307 (c) of the Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972 as amended 116 U.S.C. 1456 (c) ] , for activities under consideration that are located within the coastal zone of a state which has a federally approved coastal zone management program, the applicant has certified in the permit application that the activity complies with, and will be conducted in a manner that is consistent with, the approved state coastal zone management program. By this public notice, we are requesting the state' s concurrence with, objections to, or waiver of the applicant ' s certification. No permit decision will be made until one of these actions occur. For activities within the coastal zone of New York State, the applicant ' s certification and accompanying information is available from the Consistency Coordinator, New York State Department of State, Division of Coastal Resources and Waterfront Revitalization, Coastal Zone Management Program, 162 Washington Avenue, Albany, New York 12231, Telephone (518) 474-3642 . Comments regarding the applicant ' s certification should be so addressed. In addition to any required water quality certificate, the applicant has obtained or requested the following governmental authorization for the activity under consideration: New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Permit Town of Southold Wetlands Permit It is requested that you communicate the foregoing information concerning the activity to any persons known by you to be interested and who did not receive a copy of this notice. If questions should arise concerning this matter, you may contact Sophie Ettinger, of my staff, at (212) 264-6731 . FOR THE DISTRICT ENGINEER: eph J. Seebode Regulatory Branch 3 5' n ; {I UI m c m Cc:.14 a 44 O C a, \ po Or C: •N W9 �+ O V,{ ooN O 44 U I U f� 1(p1 i ri A �• - / +F • f1 O � O W N ia'/ .(piy,�p �'� Ul T ou in a U .. le a !\ I;Y I •`�� o I � M 4 Yg U I .'•i �• �. I i „ a� t� CENAN-OP-RE PUBLIC NOTICE NO. 93-02180-L2 WORK DESCRIPTION The applicant, New York State Office of Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation, has requested Department of the Army authorization to construct a gabion revetment at Orient Beach State Park, in Gardiners Bay at Orient, Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York. The applicant proposes to stabilize approximately 1550 linear feet of storm eroded shoreline by installing gabion mattress revetment. The proposed work would require placing approximately 879 cubic yards of new gabions and fill, and replacing approximately 1, 334 cubic yards of gabions and fill material below Spring High Tide line, for an average of approximately 1.43 cubic yards of fill per linear foot. The stated purpose of the proposed work is to restore and improve shoreline protection at the Orient Park roadway. 4 CENAN-OP-RE PUBLIC NOTICE NO. 93-02180-L2 impacts of this proposed activity. Any comments received will be considered by the Corps of Engineers to determine whether to issue, modify, condition or deny a permit for this proposal. To make this decision, comments are used to assess impacts on endangered species, historic properties, water quality, general environmental effects, and the other public interest factors listed above. Comments are used in preparation of an Environmental Assessment and/or an Environmental Impact Statement pursuant to the National Environmental Policy Act. Comments are also used to determine the need for a public hearing and to determine the overall public interest of the proposed activity. ALL COMMENTS REGARDING THE PERMIT APPLICATION MUST U PREPARED IN WRITING AND MAILED M REACH THIS OFFICE BEFORE THE EXPIRATION DATE QF THIS NOTICE; otherwise, it will be presumed that there are no objections to the activity. Any person may request, in writing, before this public notice expires, that a public hearing be held to collect information necessary to consider this application. Requests for public hearings shall state, with particularity, the reasons why a public hearing should be held. It should be noted that information submitted by mail is considered just as carefully in the permit decision process and bears the same weight as that furnished at a public hearing. Our preliminary determination is that the activity for which authorization is sought herein is may affect piping plover (aharadrius melodus) habitat. Pursuant to Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act (16 U.S .C. 1531) , the District Engineer is consulting with the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service to determine the presence of and potential impacts to piping plovers in the project area or their critical habitat. Consultation with the National Marine Fisheries Service has determined that the proposed activity is not likely to affect various endangered or threatened species of sea turtles. Based upon a review of the properties listed or eligible for listing in the latest available version of the National Register of Historic Places, there appears to be no sites included in the Register within the permit area. Presently unknown archaeological, scientific, pre-historic or historical data may be lost by work accomplished under the required permit . Review of activities pursuant to Section 404 of the Clean Water Act will include application of the guidelines promulgated by the Administrator, U.S . Environmental Protection Agency, under authority of Section 404 (b) of the Clean Water Act and the 2 j M„60A2,?1)NUS d N •• O,LO,Ih ' r�l 0o x m k7 0 r I :.•� I Or] fr O 0 O O 4-, x 'C3 f •rl N C )� JI v Ll N V S~., O '� N CO � N �- f U O O•rl Fa -P CO z A a ci 0 Cs "I a5 dN"% cc Cj ho — �, c, w • r� m [n 5 . b O • t, O nT •4+ S art ti a [u N oar - Li I i tV a'�o I vIQ t ! I la^V7SI/❑ i ..^. N Cv r 1 ) cy— P2 `S U C._Jp _ { .y .� - N Y. 4 �. N -y. o .f� rl .� ^ ^ n i 0 }, 1 71 r, •.* }; 'ci .f '� ;� ! � � � � i Ld AN r Cq U > 0 a^ Lei ri (J'U fr + ' ; �M 4'O rviio8`RNYI.L3M ..-'1 CViI IQ D o r i o -N 4 •,A < tad P.- wj� i o o\o 0 r _ r]2 O •� -.f fie) I �11 J. o � r ll � o i 1I 1 tf b V I - 1 r N G� 1 c[ H. O 'C +Ci •`.. a+ O 'Ti ` i N•�f : ' �i• r �t -c c^ e y 1 f L �,V• t� 'cf D 1 py� i F'n+ Cro a i s Ip O f (7,0 1-1 c) , ° m -� a (^ ? x ¢+ � ocoi 13t0f3 r Ct r iT1 Z + o m e y f f IN, N' t i A+ Ca fi cf ct P cl W W C) q n COD Pb - $ y O - - _ CD -c+ P' ~ o f• N. A+ y f C9 FJ -\Il C: i Op r Y. P. R R+ V C] O 111CD Y t�J to 4,- c+ 7 lt8 I m 7J 1p, cct �G m F1 d l- "f L J o n 4 3 , : .. cy C N C+N N pq X .. f t,, :.1 CA C+ p. P. O I" LA-TT. yl 0��09�N 0 R I __.�_ ..I��.._..._..,....._._..._,_,.._......�. LoNG T2°20.Z3.,w