Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutBoos, Norman C a`}T.q•Y r4 a a< ,a{F a -.-�.. .w�.�+.•.r ------------ TELEPHONE (516) 765-1892 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 _ October 10, 1984 Mr. Allen T. Schwab, President Nassau Farms Association P.O. Box 85 Cutchogue, New York 11935 Dear Mr. Schwab: In response to your letter dated September 27, 1984 regarding the application of Norman C. Boos for additional dock facilities in Broadwaters Cove, Cutchogue, by letter received from the Southold Town Board of Appeals dated May 9, 1984, the Appeal No. 3203 application for Norman C. Boos was withdrawn without prejudice, by resolution adopted by the Board of Appeals. Therefore, Mr. Boos can not further expand this facility until all approvals are obtained from the Building Department, Board of Appeals, and any other department that would be' involved. Very truly yours, Henry P. Smith, President Board of Town Trustees Ilene Pfifferling Secretary to Board cc: Town Clerk✓ Building Dept. Board of Appeals Planning Board Trustees file t�L to log �x rtiat P. O. Box 85 CUTCHOGUE, NEW YORK 11935 September 27, 1984 Chairman, Board of Trustees Town of Southold Main Road Southold, NY 11971 Dear Sir: It has came to our attention that Mr. Norman Boos has voluntarily withdrawn his applicaticn relative to the exjpansicn of his present marina on Broadwaters Cbve. We, the residents of Nassau Farms, and particularly those in the immediate area of the marina, have opposed the expansion of the present facility. We were gratified to learn that Mr. Boos had withdrawn his application. since this is a matter of concern to our Association representing the residents of Nassau Farms, we respectfully request that we receive notice in the event that Mr. Boos should elect to reactivate his application at any time in the future. Very truly yours, Allen T. Schwab President ATS jw 4Southold MAIN ROAD - STATE : ROAD 25 SOUTHOLD, L.I., N.Y. 11971 RICp TELEPHONE (516) 765-1809 APPEALS BOARD MAY d Q�1984 MEMBERS f.�vn Clerk douthOld GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN CHARLES GRIGONIS, JR. SERGE DOYEN, JR. ROBERT J. DOUGLASS JOSEPH H. SAWICKI May 8 , 1984 Richard T. Haefeli , Esq . McNulty , DiPietro & Haefeli 130 Ostrander Avenue , Box 757 Riverhead , NY 11901 Re : Appeal No . 3203 - Norman C. Boos I Dear -Mr. Haefeli : Attached for your records is a copy of the resolution adopted at our Special Meeting held May 2 , 1984 , withdrawing the subject application without prejudice as requested . Yours very truly , GERARD P . GOEHRINGER CHAIRMAN By Linda Kowalski Enclosure cc : All State , County and Town Agencies 0uthold Town Board ® ®� °�►��''� MAIN ROAD - STATE ROAD 25 SOUTHOLD, L.c., N.Y. 11971 TELEPHONE (516) 765-1600 ACTION OF THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Appeal No. 3203 Application Dated December 20 , 1983 TO: Richard T. Haefeli , Esq . [Appellant (s) ] McNulty , DiPietro & Haefeli for NORMAN C . BOOS 130 Ostrander Avenue , Box 757 Riverhead , NY 11901 At a Meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals held on May 2 , 1984 the above appeal was considered, and the action indicated below was taken on your [ ] Request for Variance Due to Lack of Access to Property New York Town Law, Section 280-a [ ] Request for Special Exception under the Zoning Ordinance Article , Section [X ] Request for Variance to the Zoning Ordinance Article , Section [X ] Request for Variance from Zoning Board of Appeals . -�� letter dated June 1 , 1978 to request additional dockage facilities . I WHEREAS , on December 20 , 1983 , an application for a variance has been filed requesting additional dockage facilities at premises located i at the south side of Skunk Lane (Bay Avenue ) , Cutchogue , New York , now of Norman C . Boos ; WHEREAS , since the date of filing this application , an environmental', . , review process has been pending concerning this proposed project ; and 'Xl -�' WHEREAS , on April 25 , 1984 , this board has been requested to withdrawL] the subject application , without prejudice : NOW, THEREFORE , BE IT RESOLVED , that Appeal No . 3203 , application for NORMAN C. BOOS , be and hereby is WITHDRAWN WITHOUT PREJUDICE . Vote of the Board : Ayes : Messrs . Goehringer , Grigonis , Douglass and Sawicki . (Member Doyen of Fishers Island was absent . ) This resolu- tion was unanimously adopted . DATED : May 8 , 1984 . CHAIRMAN, SOUTHOLD TO ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Form ZB4 (rev. 12/81) I CC== s �iovthold Town Board of Appeal� MAIN! ROAD - STATE ROAD 25 SOUTHOLD, L.I., V.Y. 119711 RECEWE® TELEPHONE (516) 765-1809 APPEALS BOARD � MEMBERS FEB GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN Town Cleric seufh®ld j CHARLES GRIGONIS, JR. SERGE DOYEN, JR. ROBERT J. DOUGLASS NOTICE OF POSITIVE DECLARATION JOSEPH H. SAWICKI I Appeal No. 3203 . Application of: NORMAN C. BOOS Location of Property: South Side Bay Avenue, Cutchogue, NY. County Tax Map Parcel ID No. 1000-104-08-2.1, 2. 3, 2. 4 , 2. 5. j Project Proposed by this Application: To expand nonconforming marina from 35 boats to 53 boats. ENVIRONMENTAL DECLARATION: Pursuant to Section 617.10 (c) of the N.Y.S. Department of Environmental Conservation Act, Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law, and Section 44-4 of the Southold Town Code, and other applicable statutes, the Board of Appeals as lead agency and in accordance with a previous declaration by this board clas- sifying this project as an Unlisted Action and determining that same may have significant adverse effects upon the environment, hereby determines that a Draft Environmental Impact Statement j (DEIS) will be prepared in accordance with Section 617.8 and resolution unanimously adopted by this board on February 11, 1984 and January 10, 1984 [copies of which are attached and made a part of this declaration .and describing the possible significant environmental effects identified and stating the reasons support- ing this determination] , Lead Agency and Person to be Contacted for Further Information: j Southold Town Board of Appeals, Main Road, Southold, New York 11971, (516) 765-1809 [or 18021 , Attention: Linda Kowalski, Secretary and Clerk of the Board. The LEAF has been circulated and no objections have been received j within the 1.5-day commenting period from other departments/agencies; however, there is public controversy- concerning this proposed project.; This declaration should not be considered a determination made for any other department or agency which may have a different application since the same has not been integrated to be within the purview of the Board of Appeals -at this point in time. Dated: February 11, 1984. BY ORDER OF THE SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN i j ss 21 LO Southold Town Board of Appeals V, MAIN ROAD STATE ROAD 25 SOUTHOLD, L.I., N.Y. 11971 TELEPHONE (516) 765-1809 APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN NOTICE OF DECLARATION CHARLES GRIGONIS, JR. SERGE DOYEN, JR. PURSUANT TO ROBERT J. DOUGLASS JOSEPH H. SAWICKI N.Y.S. 'ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY REVIEW ACT Appeal No. 3201 Application of: NORMAN C. BOOS Location of Subject Property: 8000 Skunk Lane (Bay Avenue) , Cutchogue., County Tax Map Parcel District 1000 , Section 104 , Block 08 , Lot 2. 1, 2. 3, 2.4, Project Proposed: To expand marina dockage facilities for 18 boats. ENVIRONMENTAL DECLARATION: Pursuant to section 617. 7 of the N.Y. S. Department of Environ- mental Conservation Act, Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law, and Section 44-4 of the Southold Town Code, and in order to commence the processing of the SEQRA procedures, the Board of Appeals of the Town of Southold at this time declares itself lead agency in this proposed project and hereby classifies the same as an Unlisted Action which may have a significant adverse effect upon the environ- i ment for the following reason-s: 1. Information has not been submitted indicating the type of sewage systems available, if any, for those boats having sleeping, kitchen, or other facilities, which may cause pollution into the waterway; 2 . Information has not been available indicating the type of maneuvering for those boats to be navigating to and from each docking facility, which may disturb the wetlands area along the edge of this subject area. It is hereby requested that the applicant and/or his agent furnish our department with a completed Long Environmental Assessment Form. This declaration should not be considered a determination made ford any other department or agency which may also be involved, nor for any other project not covered by the subject Z.B.A. application. Dated: January 10, 1984 . BY ORDER OF THE SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN For additional information, please contact: Linda Kowalski, Secretary and Clerk for the Board of Appeals at 765-1809 (or 1802) . P� J 45 a� li Id ' wn Board of Appea ' 3outho 10 h MAIN ROAD - STATE ROAD 25 SOUTHOLD, L.I., N.Y. 11971! TELEPHONE (516) 765-1809 I APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN FEB15 SH CHARLES GRIGONIS,JR. SERGE DOYEN, JR. Town cteyk&Kdwd ROBERT J. DOUGLASS February 14, 1984 JOSEPH H. SAWICKI Mr. Norman C. Boos One Cedar Street Massapequa, NY 11758 Re: Appeal No. 3203 Variance for Expansion of Marina ;J- Dear Mr. Boos: Re i At a Special Meeting of the Board of Appeals held on February 11, 1984, it was the unanimous agreement of the members to request a Draft Environmental Impact Statement in accordance with Section 617.8 of 'the State Environmental Quality Review Act which shall contain at least the following: (1) a concise description of the proposed project, its purpose and need; (2) a concise description of the environmental setting of the adjacent areas, sufficient to understand the possible effects of the proposed project; i (3) a statement of the important environmental impacts of the proposed project, including short-term and long-term effects and typical associated environmental effects, i.e. : [a] alteration of the adjacent wetlands area, such as widening of the channel if needed at present or in the future; [b] changes and effects of the adjacent wetlands area due to wave action from navigation; [c] pollutants-sewage being discharged due to increased navigation; i Page 2 - February 14, 1984 To: Mr. Norman C. Boos Re: Appeal No. 3203 - SEQRA Variance for Expansion of Marina (4) an identification and brief discussion of environmental i effects which cannot be avoided, if the proposed project is implemented; I (5) a description and evaluation'-,-,of. reasonable alternatives, including no-action alternative; (6) an identification of any irreversible and irretrievable commitments of resource's' which would be associated with the proposed action should, it be implemented; (7) a description- of mitigation measure's, to minimize the environmental impacts on: [a] alteration, of the adjacent wetlands area, including erosion, due, to increased navigation and maneuvering of vessels; [b] sewage pollution; I 1 [c] other pollutants from navigation, etc . (8) a description of any growth-inducing aspects of the proposed project; (9) a list of any underlying studies, reports, expert testi- mony and other information obtained and considered in preparing ! this statement [together with copies of same for reference] . Upon receipt of the Environmental Impact Statement, we are 9 required to provide for a 30-day commenting period and then to proceed with Section 617.10 of the SEQRA provisions. For your reference we are enclosing photocopies pertaining to other material to be included in this statement. Yours very truly, j GERARD P. GOEHRINGER CHAIRMAN Enclosures By Linda F. Kowalski cc: Southold Town Board I I " a � C,09L TEL. 765-1802 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD OFFICE OF BUILDING INSPECTOR RECEIVED m P.O. BOX 728 v' TOWN HALL FEB 9 04 SOUTHOLD,N.Y. 11971 Town Cleric Southold February 9 , 1984 Mrs. Judith T. Terry Southold Town Clerk Southold, NY 11971 Dear Judith: After reviewing the application of Norman C. Boos for a wetland permit to construct additional float and catwalk accommodations for eighteen boats, I wish to submit the following data. 1. The Board of Appeals is now in the process of determining whether or not relief should be granted to Mr. Boos, on the restriction placed on the marina of a maximum 35 boat capacity, and no boats longer than twenty-four feet in length. 2 . The property in question, encompassing the marina and water under it, is all private property and the marina is pre- existing and a non-conforming condition. First I 'd like to address the non-conformity. The Town laws address the problem of what a non-conformity is and also what conditions will eliminate a non-conforming condition. Unfortunately there is nothing in writing that prohibits the expansion of a non-conforming condition (except by ruling of Zoning Board of Appeals per case) . I understand the practice or procedure was that a non-conformity should not be allowed to expand but never was too much of an effort made to enforce it, as evidenced by other non-conforming marinas. Reading the Wetland Ordinance and the history behind it, I find that to simplify its powers, I would say, "All lands Town owned that are under water or classified as Town owned wetlands are the responsibility of the Town Trustees and their jurisdiction. All water or wetland that encompasses private property are the sole responsibility and jurisdiction of the Town Board. " There have been a good many cross-overs and this practice should cease, as it leads to awkward and embarrassing conditions that are not necessary. This present case is one in point. Southold Town Clerk, 2/9/84 Page 2 Should the Board of Appeals decide to grant relief to the present restriction, then at that point, the Boos ' would have to go to the Planning Board for an amended site plan and adjust- ments for parking, etc. The Boos application would then have to be acted upon, for a wetland application, by the Town Board. Please be aware that the Trustees have already had a hearing on this matter, so to avoid too much embarrassment, possibly the Town Board could ask the Trustees for some input. I would also suggest that -some effort be made to refine and re-define the guidelines they would be able to operate under. Sorry for the delay in answering and I hope this has been of some help. Very truly yours, Victor Lessard Executive Administrator VL:ec xc: Town Trustees y ^ �j¢77 � Southold Town Board of Appeals MAIN ROAD - STATE ROAD 25 SOUTHOLD, L.I., N.Y. 11971 RECEIVEDTELEPHONE (516) 765-1809 APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS JAN 26 GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN CHARLES GRIGONIS, JR. 'sown Clark Southold SERGE DOYEN, JR. ROBERT J. DOUGLASS JOSEPH H. SAWICKI TO: Southold Town Clerk Southold Town Trustees DATE: January 25, 1984 SUBJECT: Appeal No. 3201 - Norman C. Boos Pending SEQRA Review Proposal to Expand Marina Transmitted herewith for your records is a copy of the Long Environmental Assessment Form recently received by our -office as lead agency in the above matter. - Comments may be received by our office on or before February 9, 1984 . A lack of response will be interpreted to mean that your department has no objection. -- Yours very truly, GERARD P. GOEHRINGER CH RMAN e:� Kski Enclosures Days: 433-0010 ' f N, ` Evenings: 541-4604 .I o erg6otrrariifa Est. 1950 ����",y' �� `' BAY AVENUE (Skunk Lane), CUTCHOGUE, L. I., N. Y. 11935 Secluded Dockage with Electricity Mailing Address- Jan. ddress:Jan. 13, 1984 Norman C. Boos 1 Cedar St., Massapequa, N. Y. 11758 Southold Town Board of Appeals Main Road - State Rd. 25 U, `i`iJ�cz:j Southold, NY 11971 lrlll� G � y9�F { ��.�: 1 Attn: Dir. Gerard P . Goehringer , Chairman Dear Mr. Goehringer: With reference to your letter dated Jan. 3, 1984, I respectfully submit the following: (a) The maximum number of boats docked at the marina with the present docking has been 37 boats plus my personal boat . I ' d like to mention that my boat is for sale (Listed with McMichaels Yacht Sales in Sag Harbor . Until my home is completed, target date early fall 1984 , I must continue to live on it during the week- ends . (b) I 've enclosed for your review our construction plan which indicates the length of walk to be 175 ' and width 2011-1/2" . ( c) Site plan enclosed indicates that we can provide up to 62 parking spaces , however as stated in my letter dated July 14 , 1982 ( the same is true of the 1983 season) even during the hottest days with the heaviest traffic there has never been more than 20 cars parked at any one time . 'After proposed expansion, parking for 62 cars will frankly NEVER. be necessary however the plan indicates that they are available . (d) As to width of channel, it is 50 ' wide at the narrowest portion. The total projection of the proposed catwalk and fingers into the channel is approx 2011 , our personal boat is 14110" in width with a 3' spring line meaning that the boat we use projects into the channel roughly 181 , resulting in a difference of only approx. 22' . (page 1 of 2 , continued) WE ARE NOT TO BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR INCLEMENT WEATHER, THEFT, FIRE,ACCIDENTS OR OTHER CONTINGENCIES BEYOND OUR CONTROL. t• Page 2 of 2 The boats in the marina basin have no problem with respect to access or egress and a difference in the width of the channel of 21' will not result in any less maneuverability. Sir, I would like to request that the topes of the public hearing of the Board of Trustees held on the 13th of December, 1983 , be reviewed by the Board of Appeals for inbut as to the function of the marina and the community need for additional dockage. Thanking you for your courtesy and cooperation with regard to this matter. Cordially, Norman C. Boos enc . =K�'�` • kroagwa6?i We Marina 2'0 —16' r i 316A �¢ ry yX� �OS/ on AltdOIJ r L ' �� rig.. ,� � .--✓;� Y �v `n/ormt, L ow k/,41^�R f J ti a, Norman C. Boos New Work proposed indicated in red • . �i i FO It •_T� J i i �- � ,I � � 1 c- � 1 • r- �_ � - �I 11 1 { }�T-I iii- FP, r '^ I PERMIT NO. y NEW YORK S( DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL COVRVATIO 10-83-1610 r •, ti 4�-1-'•-1 �. �.cili F PERMITLow UNDER THE ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATIO Wy 8 X ARTICLE 15, (Protection of Water) X ARTICLE 25, (Tidal Wet la s 't.dt±� ARTICLE 24, (Freshwater Wetlands) 8 ARTICLE 36, (Construction in Flood Hazar eas) :RMIT ISSUED TO Norman C. Boos DDRESS OF PERMITTEE One Cedar Street, Massapequa, NY 11758 )CATION OF PROJECT(Section of stream, tidal wetland,dam, building) Northwest corner of Broadwater Cove at the Broad— raters Cove Marina located on the south side of Bay Avenue, Cutchogue. ESCRIPTION OF PROJECT :onstruct approximately 175 linear feet of 3'6" wide floating catwalk with nine finger piers reasuring 3'6" X 16'6" long in accordance with the plans entitled "Broadwater Cove Marina" prepared by Norman C. Boos, received December 21, 1983. DMMUNITY NAME(City,Town, Village) TOWN :utchogue - Southold JUNTY FIA COMMUNI IY NO. DAM NO. PERMIT EXPIRATION DATE uffolk I I I March 31, 1985 GENERAL CONDITIONS 1. The permittee shall file in the office of the appropriate Regional 8. That the State of New York shall in no case be liable for any damage mit Administrator, a notice of intention to commence work at least 48 or injury to the structure or work herein authorized which may be caused by or irs in advance of the time of commencemFnt and shall also notify him result from future operations undertaken by the State for the conservation or mptly in writing of the completion of the work. improvement of navigation, or for other purposes, and no claim or right to 2. The permitted work shall be subject to inspection by an authorized compensation shall accrue from any such damage. resentative of the Department of Environmental Conservation who may 9. That if the display of lights and signals on any work hereby authorized er the work suspended if the public interest so requires. is not otherwise provided for by law, such lights and signals as may be pre- scribed by the United States Coast Guard shall be installed and maintained 3. As a condition of the issuance of this permit, the applicant has ac- by and at the expense of the owner. ited expressly, by the execution of the application, the full legal respon- ility for all damages, direct or indirect, of whatever nature, and by whom- 10. All work carried out under this permit shall be performed in accor- r suffered, arising out of the project described herein and has agreed to dance with established engineering practice and in a workmanlike manner. emnify and save harmless the State from suits, actions, damages and .ts of every name and description resulting from the said project. 11. If granted under Articles 24 or 25, the Department reserves the right to reconsider this approval at any time and after due notice and hearing to 4. Any material dredged in the prosecution of the work herein permitted continue, rescind or modify this permit in such a manner as may be found to 11 be removed evenly, without leaving large refuse piles, ridges across the be just and equitable. If upon the expiration or revocation of this permit, the of the waterway or flood plain or deep holes that may have a tendency to modification of the wetland hereby authorized has not been completed, the ise injury to navigable channels or to the banks of the waterway, applicant shall, without expense to the State, and to such extent and in such S. An material to be deposited or dumped under this permit, either in time and manner as the Department of Environmental Conservation may require, Y remove all or any portion of the uncompleted structure or fill and restore the waterway or on shore above high-water mark, shall be deposited or dumped site to its former condition. No claim shall be made against the State of New the locality shown on the drawing hereto attached, and, if so prescribed York on account of any such removal or alteration. reon, within or behind a good and'substantial bulkhead or bulkheads, such will prevent escape of the material into the waterway. 12. This permit shall not be construed as conveying to the applicant any right to trespass upon the lands or interfere with the riparian rights of others 6. There shall be no unreasonable interference with navigation by the to perform the permitted work or as authorizing the impairment of any rights, k herein authorized. title or interest in real or personal property held or vested in a person not a i. That if future operations by the State of New York require an alteration party to the permit. he position of the structure or work herein authorized, or if, in the opinion 13. The permittee is responsible for obtaining any other permits, ap- he Department of Environmental Conservation it shall cause unreasonable provals, lands, easements and rights-of-way which may be required for this truction to the free navigation of said waters or flood flows or endanger project. health, safety or welfare of the people of the State, or loss or destruction he natural resources of the State, the owner may be ordered by the Depart- 14. If granted under Article 36, this permit is granted solely on the basis t to remove or alter the structural work, obstructions, or hazards caused of the requirements of Article 36 of the Environmental Conservation Law and eby without expense to the State; and if, upon the expiration or revocation Part 500 of 6 NYCRR(Construction in Flood Plain Areas having Special Flood this permit, the structure, fill, excavation, or other modification of the Hazards — Building Permits) and in no way signifies that the project will be ercourse hereby authorized shall not be completed, the owners shall, free from flooding. lout expense to the State, and to such extent and in such time and manner 15. By acceptance of this permit the the Department of Environmental Conservation may require, remove all or p Pli permittee agrees that the permit pis contingent upon strict compliance with the special conditions on the portion of the uncompleted structure or fill and restore to its former reverse side. clition the navigable and flood capacity of the watercourse. No claim shall made against the State of New York on account of any such removal or ration. 20-4(9/75) (SEE REVERSE SIDE) �-u=y:.. .w.ry.-y T�- •�h-. '� »"iv:Si' _�.'-, ,..,... - •t sz-�..+-+::�k.`• F.w: ..>w+ •- -"'_�F .�___•::�- x""-- n` :!"�:3�w'.,.y;��-p,� ^•'� ,:L- n ;�`.a -SF ', �,5-'aty-�`c-=vc�:#.•'%yZ-`''�{�?, «.4 27.•�.",.�"=, '�Taswa.:� 'r f•,kge,,-► ' '`"„'E'}r* ttz,: Ys-r,° 5.,"�a.•,�C'� � - A r SCIAk'.CONDITIONS 16. There is to be no dredging, filling or bulkheading associated with this project. 17. There is -to be no disturbance to vegetation or topography along the existing shoreline. SEE ATTACHED CONDITIONS A - J, P • r 'ERMIT ISSUE DATE PERMIT ADMINISTRATOR _ i ADDRESS Bldg. 40, SUNY--Room 219 January 12, 1984 Daniel -J. Larkin Stony Brook, NY 11794 �.r^6`-�-.� .�•_ - - -.r...=�.:.,t�«s_^s.,,':>:':A.. - +a"-- ter'- - �K.• -_ -.:i;`>;:{- ' _' -a.:,._.•.::- t��c: `r{:. -:,,.ia. a''. r,"X~. :f a^ WON0ki_a'ins='y, ;S a`-c'.�Si; =•5.„-'s'? ' :i -•'Y' 'a is- -'_.-. v^ ,' Z"" �k-••4 i•t .' Y ; :=v 4) - The following conditions shall apply if- checked- as applicable by the Regional Permit Administrator: K. All dredging shall be conducted so as to leave a uniform bottom elevation free of mounds or holes. L. All spoil material shall be disposed of either in the Atlantic Ocean or at an apprgved U.S. Government Dumping Ground, as directed by the District Engineer, U.S. Department of the Army, Corps of Engineers. Any spoil material not intended for such water dis- posal shall be removed from the site and disposed of at an approved upland site. M.. All fill and-spoil material shall be suitably contained at the work site so as to prevent its eroding, leaching or otherwise entering into-adjacent wetlands and waterways. H. - All peripheral rip-rap berms, cofferdams, rock revetments, gabions, bulkheads, etc. shall be completed prior to placement of any fill material behind such structures. _O. •-.All repairs- to existing structures shall be confined to replacement of- existing structural elements with no change in-design, dimension, or materials, unless specifically authorized herein. X _P_._ The -following Water Quality Certification shall-apply--if* required _ by one or more agencies of the United States-- Government and if __--checked as applicable by the Regional Permit Administrators: In -accordance with Section 401(a) (1) of the Clean.Waters.Act-of 1977 (PL 95-217) the New York State Department of Environmental _ -Conservation hereby certifies that the subject project- proposal will not contravene effluent limitations or other limitations-or- standards - - - --under-Sections -301, 302, 303, 306 or 307 or the Act. DATE, January 12, 1984 Daniel J. Larkin, P.E. Regional-Permit-Administrator- Division of Regulatory Affairs 10-83-1610 NYS Department of-Envirarmental_ Conservation -Building 40, SMTY—Room- 21-9 Stony Brook, NY 11794 (516) 751-7900- - _1.i21 •C:'_��Yy»' iL,yi-Y�-kJ`a:: tom.._...._x..". '� ""'r 4 .. .._ ..__ - '�_�'T.^.�'u+o-S7"ii�a�eA-i�3.� 'w�z-+�-3`ia � �`T«t•SL.+.!'Y�a'"Y.��uN"�.i`.�-w''•:.crj•} _ _ _ _ _�_ _ _. _ _ � •:. TELEPHONE (516)765-1892 )BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 January 23, 1984 Mrs. Judith T. Terry Southold Town Clerk Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Dear Judy: Transmitted herewith is correspondence pertaining to the Wetland Application before the Town Board, on behalf of Mr. Norman C. Boos for the construction of approximately 175 lineal feet of floating walk with nine fingers, each approximately 16' long to accomodate additional dockage for eighteen (18) small boats located at Broadwaters Cove. Very truly yours, Board of Town Trustees Henry P. Smith President By Ilene Pfifferling ip Attachments ` xc: Trustees,/ FULA- Southold Town Board o ppeais MAIN ROAD - STATE ROAD 25 SOUTHOLD, L.I., N.Y. 11971 TELEPHONE (516) 765-1809 APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN CHARLES GRIGONIS,JR. SERGE DOYEN, JR. ROBERT J. DOUGLASS JOSEPH H. SAWICKI January 11, 1984 Mr. Norman C. Boos l One Cedar Street Massapequa, NY 11758 Re: Appeal No. 3201 Variance to Expand Marina Facilities Dear Mr. Boos: At a Special Meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals held last evening, January 10th, the board declared itself lead agency pursuant to the N.Y.S. Environmental Conservation Act, Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law, and Section 44-4 of the Town Code, and classified your proposed project as an unlisted action which may have a significant adverse effect- upon the environment for the reasons listed in the attached Declaration. Pursuant to the above, it is requested that a Long Environ- mental Assessment Form, which is attached, be completed by you and filed with our office as early as possible. Please don't hesitate to call our office if you have any- questions. nyquestions. Yours very truly, GERARD P. GOEHRINGER FyL� j2MAN t.0L(ci�'�Enclosures inda Kowa si; cc: Building Department Town Trustees Planning Board Supervisor F.J. Murphy, - � FBoard);:®f Appeals Southold ®gun 11971 � OLD, L.I., N.Y. - � , ; �• � SOUTH MAIN ROAD - STATE RDAD 25 �O TELEPHONE (516) 765 1809 141 APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS NOTICE OF DECLARATION GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN PURSUANT TO CHARLES GRIGONIS,JR. SERGE DOYEN, JR. UALITY REVIEW ACT ROBERT J.DOUGLASS N.7- S - ENVIRONMENTAL Q JOSEPH H.SAWICKI __ N C, _BOOS Appeal No. 3201 Application of: NOS' Cutchogue. v - 8000 Skunk Lane (Bay Avenue) , Location of Subject property: BlocSection 08 , Lot 2.1, 2. 3, County Tax Map Parcel District 1000 , Section 104 , 2.4 , 2 . 5 . : osed: To expand marina dockage facilities for Pro Project P 18 boats. ENVIRONMENTAL DECLARATION: of the N.Y.S. Department of Environ- Pursuant to Section 617 .7 and in order to ation Act, Article 8 of thenEcode�nmental Conservation is mental Conserv the Board of Appea Town Law, and Section 44-4 of fhthe°SEQRA- procedures, agency in commence the processing classifies the same as anUnlisted,--envi-7 the Town of Southold at thio time declares itself ea th of Prop ect and hereby this proposed p J significant adverse effect upon Action which may have a sig reasons: n1e� for the following the type of 1. Information has not been submitted indicating sleeping, systems available, if any, for those boats having sewagecause pollution into the kitchen, or other facilities, which may waterway; the type of navigating to and from each docking 2. Informationehboatsttoebe able indicating edge of this maneuvering for those facility, which may disturb the wetlands area along t subject area. agent furnish reauested that the applicant and his It is hereby _ Environmental Assessment Form* our department with a completed Long o be involved, nor for any ration should not be cons' iso a determination made or This decla enc which may a any other depart or agency subject Z .B.A. application. other project not covered by CHAIRMAN ar 10 , 1984 . BY ORDER OF TEOARDUpHOGOEHRINGERARD A Dated: January APPEALS - G lease contact: Linda Kowalski, Secretary Clerk for the Board of Appeals at 765-1809 (or 1802) . For add m additional inforation, P and C1 s - Days: 433-0010 Evenings: 541-4604 Est 1950 ���i�� �OV V..:r,�Z:, BAY AVENUE (Skunk Lane), CUTCHOGUE, L. L, N. Y. 11935 :` Secluded Dockage with Electricity Mailing Address: Jan. 16, 1984 Norman C. Boos 1 Cedar St, Massapequa, N. Y. 11758 Southold Zoning Board of Appeals Town Hall Main Rd. - S .R. 25 Southold , NY 11971 A ttn: Mr. Gerard P . Goehringer; Chairman Dear Mr. Goehringer: In accordance with your letter dated January 11 , 1984, enclosed please find completed Long Environment Assessment form. I 've heard rumor that a petition against this action with heavily ex- aggerated claims is being or has been sent you. Said petition assert- ing that we have ( 1) live on board people in the marina with resulting cooking and human pollution, (2) that boats are oversize and (3) that traffic creates a problem, I would like to document for the board that these claims are invalid: ( 1) Live on board: With the exception of A . Zimmer (my wife ' s brother) patrons of the marina live within a short distance of the marina. They walk and bike in addition to driving to the premises . They ,certainly do not live on board, nor is it honestly feasible for them to come aboard to cook, home is much more convenient . On occasion my brother-in-lair does stay overnight at the marina during which time he uses our personal - dockside facilities . It has been noted on both 1983 and 1984 contracts that live on board is not permitted (see enclosed) . As to my own boat, I do live on board during weekends and I utilize the toilet facilities in the storage building as purchased (also enclosed) . I have not made these facilities available to anyone other then my in-laws but if the board wishes me to do so I certainly will readily comply. I supply and maintain refuse cans for those in need. (2) Boats are oversize : Our boats ran e in size from a 13 ' boat to two boats that are 25 ' and one boa . 271 . The twenty-seven is owned by Mr. & 1:rs . R. Wacker, members in good standing in the community, who traded up from a 21 footer to the present size . They have been patrons of the marina prior to and during the entire time that we have been owners . In view of the fact that they are such good people , and they conform to the rules of the marina, we could not tell them they must leave because they are now oversize . ( 3) Parking: The enclosed photo (a) showing marina during our first Page 1 of 2 - Continued WE ARE NOT TO BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR INCLEMENT WEATHER, THEFT, FIRE, ACCIDENTS OR OTHER CONTINGENCIES BEYOND OUR CONTROL. '`�''xw�+kiW��1$�C ?'�n'C'u_�:�^L^`'.C��a'1��42`^-w'r-'.�{`r3..�Ta?'"e aa, .^�-•--eu:. j"-T�.T_'sc'„-._._."'."'r,` r, -"--,-__----_...--._.____..-..-__—_. __ .___'_. _ (2) year of ownership clearly indicates parking to be adjacent to the road. There was no way for any patron to leave the marina without having to back onto Skunk Lane , dangerous in view of people sometimes speeding around the bend in the road. Since ownership , parking has been taken off the road (photos b & c) by means of blocking cars from just pulling in and out. This was accomplished by placing the pilings and hawser lines as noted (photo b) and the telephone pole automobile stops as in photo a have been moved much closer to the white 4 x 4 posts creating a good size parking area (photo c) . Parking in the area of my home -has been landscaped, in a year or so no auto in that portion of the marina will be seen from either Skunk Lane or Nassau Point Causeway. These photos indicate the entire marina basin. The platform of photo d is 20' overall enabling you to compare size of boats down the line . Photo c shows boats on the road side as well as the east side . You can see from these photos that the boats are day boats , good for- a leisurely outing, fishing or water skiing. They are not what would be called live on board type boats. To tie up a few loose ends . There is simultaneously community need as well as financial requirement for the expansion. The cost of operation far exceeds the revenue . I stated at the Trustees hearing that I will not again ask to increase the facilities if this request is passed and that -is true . My home is almost ready to move into , I wish to do so . I as well as my neighbors wish to enjoy the quietude of the area and do not intend to make this into a large commercial enterprise . As you are aware, I am requesting an increase of eighteen additional boats , approximately 18' or less over the covenant set forth by the Board of Appeals several weeks prior to the sale of the marina (covenant dated 6/l/78 , deed delivered 8/23/78) . On May 17th 1978 , to establish these ,guidelines , the former owner (Angelo Petrucci) in a letter to the Board of Appeals stated lie could accomodate with ease 40 to 45 boats , but for his purposes chose 35 ( letter enclosed) . There is ample room for this proposed addition. Cordially, Dorman C. Boos enc. Addendum: At the Trustees meeting it was mentioned that at times people have exceeded the 5MTH rule which would result in erosion of the marsh and wetland area. On occasion this has happened in the channel and we let the few who have done so be aware that it is against the law and would make them subject to expulsion from the marina. NO ONE has ever sped in the area of any docked boats however, and this addition would have the effect of protecting rather then destroying this vital area. People do slow down in the area of boats . TOWN OF, S OUTHOLD I - • a, EtvJIR0-%7,/NTAL ASSESS_,1ENT — PART II}`'' _ Lam`p �`J y. PROJECT IY ORI-=-ATION t NOTICE: This docu.,ent is designed to assist in detersrtninq whether The action proposed may have a sienificant effect cn ttie env;;-nrrrc—,t- Please coaTlete the entire data Sheec• �swe to these questions Ntll be considered ds Part or &,e zypiicaticn for approval and ray be subject to further verification ana public review. Provide any adZiiticnsl infomaOon you beiieve w,11 be needed to canplete PARTS 2 and 3- 1t Is expeetea that ccr,rpletion of the EAFwiII be dependent en infomaeion currently available and wiII not involve new studies, research or investigation.- I` -i�.f�r-ation requiring sucn additional work is_unavaijable, so Indicate Ind specify each instance. OF .�� =� - - ,- - B n ,rais',tnrc�'Cl� 8000 Skunk Lane 'u_-chogue , NTY 1 9 6 .n�7C-_ _':1 :i,'. ;F :r Ct_T!••�i'' - ;)�rmr� Norman C:: Boos (74a) ' 3MME S ?FMNE: 2119-0010 1 Cedar' St. `-`y r• Hada e ua 2.1 NY 11758 2""77C" g= 000„__7 (7r=ei-ly describe type Of aroj or ac=ion) Construct 175 Lineal foot of R ,,. , small Moats . CCXPLE-i EACH QUE-iu'i - €ndic2te 3-A. if not aoolicoole) . (rhysic_1 gat::-; of overall project, both develacet• and :;ndzvelcoed areas) i, General ciarac:_r of -`e land: Generally unifor" slope X Generally 'txavEn and roiling Jr irT-';ular �. �t--52'1L '.and use: Jrzn , Industrial Ccr-ere-ai X . SuDU:nen , Rural• , rr,res t Aaricultureliarina ocal acr'ace --rojec= area: N.Aaere-s. No physical change to land or mater. Aocrxi.maca 'c"age: ?risantly After Ccm.olat:-)n Presently A;t=r rcmolec-;cn Ile=dcw or 3rusniand acres ac:•-=s Wat_r Sur-aca Ar--a 3c:=s ac"s an-oc I'nyonaraL�j ^CX, -- ear:- or fill; 'c''-s acre's _ acr?s , �. •;ori=..^.c = 'sn•.�at'r or rfc?: '_� ter -'r-:-, ;;tr-'c?s :iha: is 7�_ cr'nan: Sall :/pal's) an aro;=r: ;: ._. '-T A - a 7. 2. -r. :.._. J?Cr^C.0 :u:_..•DJ1ngS a1 :*'•,]c=- �' -=� v'' X 10 , 2. ;ha* is c_cu: .o :ed-=c'c? rT" ''- 3/'_!73 • '91 0-lot �; 10-15 15� or ' • - - reposed project site with slopes: ,, _ —ate -erc2nt_c_ o` p 6. ..c7r�tt. ?�..1. greater ,,, . s to, or ccntain a building or site listed on the national Register of liistorl�, s rizces? Yes 2 ,o _ y-l— is tie dz;t; to the Water tab le? T fe_t ^tio 3. ',h:!t •h rP ect area? Yes g. Zo h,:nting or fishir.; cPPortunities presently exist in e p - e animal life that is 'i ed as threatened or C-;eS roiect site ccntain any species of Plant Identify each species 10. p Ycs x ,Jo, according to �* sitz? cliffs, dunes, other geologii�i or unusual land fortis an ,.hc Project 11. Arc_ t':erea y LniG;�e5 x_Ko- (Up-scribe - for^atrc-s - — ; hborheod as an open space or recreat.ion- r�sently used by the car:-uni,.y or neig _ • -__ 12. Is :tie project si._ presently Yes _1L o. ite offer or include scenic views or vistas known to be 13. C_-es the present s important to .the couni - - X „� _YZ5 - - nwithin or contiguous to project area: None " 14. S_•r__.•ls within iver to which it is tributary of strean and na^e of r _ 1[. Lsr s, d5 wetland areas within or ccntiguoLs to p roject area: • b. Size (in acres) _ a, tie.:{ 13ro 1�'a q alile radius of the projec� e.g. • land use and zoning classific,tion within . l!2 story).Jr. dc'ni'an; and the SGa1e Of de'fe10p .enL (e•g- 1sinslesf==fly resit-n..ial, Q-2) story family residential 1 1^ y ll in dire:,cions as appropriate) 1. physical dicensiens and scale Of project (fi 01 acres. d by project sponsor a. Total ccntiqcus etre';= o'r+nel 1 b. Project aCTeaS> d=veleped- �� acres in acres 1lt;�..atelY- G. PT-ijac' acr�aSe to remain undeveloped - O •h of project, in wiles: NTS (�r app�priat_) proposed building square fool d. L_n;�. a expansion prop •pct is an expansion of existing, indicate percent or xp e- If pro''- N developed acreage �= zS= • proposed f. flu-_' er of off-stmt parking spaces existing _4 3-- (upon ccsrp letion of project) waxi,;,�-� vehic: izr trips generated per hour q, oe of housing units: h. Ir residential : ,w,b_r and ty• Ocndo.miniula 1 existing Two Family Multiple Family One'Far.ily Initial r------ tlltimzte Orientation lc,�=_nt i. IF: ;ielShhornooa-City-rtegior.al Esti rated Fr? Non-conforniirig ►narina C.c,r.ercial nei1hl)orllood Industrial NA feet. ��l height of tallest proposed structure �— J. Tot_ --------------------- . 2. How rut` natural '=anal (i.e. rock, earth, etc.) will be reToved from the site - None tons cubic yards. Hca r..any acres o` ve;a'zticn (trees, shrubs, ground covers) will be removed fro. site \One acres. 4. mill 2,1y mature -crest (over 100 years old) or C-, .er locally-fsportant vegetation be removed by this project? Yes X ;lo c. Are there any pians for re-veyetatio to repl�_ce that removed during construction? Yes NO N-N 5. If single phase project: Anticipated period of construction 1 ranths, (including demolition). 7. If multi-phased project: a. Total munber of phases anticipated No N A b. Anticipated date of comrencerent phase 1 month year (including demolition) c. Apprexirate completion date final phase conth _year. d. Is phase 1 financially dependent on subsequent phases? Yes No 8. !;ill blasting occur during constriction? Yes X No 9. Nu7ber of jobs generated: during construction None after project is cop-pleta yT�}1e 10. 1114,.-der of jobs eli,inated by this project Nona 11. .'ill project require relocation of any projects or facilities? Yes X No. If yes, explain: 12. a. Is sur-Face or subsurface liquid waste dis:csal involved? . Yes X No- b. If yes, indicate type o waste (sewage, industrial, etc.) —— c. If surface disposal name of streal into which effluent will be discharged —— 13. Will surface area of existing lakes, ponds, streets, bays or other surface wa•te mays be increased or decreased by proposal? Yes X No. . 14. Is project or any portion of project located in the 100 year flood plain? Yes No 15. a. Coes project in•rolve disposal of solid waste? Yes X No b. I` yes, will an existing solid waste disposal facility be used? Yes No - e. If yes, give name: location d. !-fill any wastes not go into a swage disposal system or into a sanitary landfill? Yes No lb, Will project use herbicides or pesticides? Yes X 'lo 17. Will project routinely produce odors (•mre t. z„ one hour per day)? Yes _X NO 18. Will project prduca operating noise exceeding the local zrbience noise levels? Yes X No 19. will pro;_ct result in an increase in energy; use? Yes t No- If yes, indicate type(s) 20. if vjat_r supply is fro- wells indicate pu-oi--, cacacity i�T11 gal s;minute. 21. Total anticipan d avatar usage ger =2v _ NTA -al-,/day. 22. ,.cr•in�: a. ghat is do^inart 'zcning classif-c__icn of slt'? 1,mai rinn� i X11—: irri cu turaI b. Currin[ s;ecific zoning classification of site Non—conformirip: imirina e. Is Pr,posed use ccnslstant wit.: present zoning? YeS _ d. If no, indicat-2 desired zoning i -3- - f r C5. A;provals: a. Is any Federal permit required? x Yes No b. Coes project involve State or Federal funding or financing? Yes x No c. Local and Regional approvals: Approval Required Submittal Approval (Yes, l'lo) (Type) (Date) (Date) City, Tc•,.+n, Village Boardy�� Anrj omal Ci ty, 7C.4-1, Villace Planning Soard Yes An rpya( l7 City, Tcwn, Zoning Board Yesyariatice 3 City, County Health Departmnant SCO 0th2r local agencies NL n_ _ 0; er re;icr.al agencies TT n D Federal Agencies Z eS .�,Y I li_�_I Ill nPPT S C_ i l.7_.-t T iG'L:L ?:.ILS - Attach any additional information as nay be, needed to clarify your project. If there are or may be any adver_e i-,.cts associated with the proposal, please discuss such impacts and the measures viii-ich Can be ; ken :o or avoid thin. PREPAREWS S?:.*inTIURE. z Z_ - - TiTL=. flim Pr CATE: 1 1 EI R4 T0,RN OF SOUHOLD EiTV1,uN-_M_E_ITAL ASSESSI•L,YiT — PARr_ —I- 10 PROJECT IMP.;CTS AND THEIR NLAGNITUDE_ Ganer:1 inforrz:io^ (Read Carefully) in c_---pi-:!ting t`.e form t`e reviewer should be guides Ny the question: Have my decisions and determinations teenre2scr.a;,1a? The reviewer is noc expected to to an expert environmental analyst. Identi,`ying t^at an affect will be potentially lar;e (C07LI .n 2) does not mean that it is also necessarily sicnific2nt. Any large effect fnust be evaluated In PIP. 3 to determine significance. Sy _identifying an efrect In coiu-n 2 si.-ply asks that it be looked at further. Ths Examples previd_d are :o assist the reviewer by s`e:ting types of effects and wherever possible the threshol of -.egnlzuce that would trig;er a response in coir^ 2. The exp-.ples are generally applicable throughout the State and for most situations. But, for any soeci =ic protect or site other axa.'nples and/or lower thresholds r--ay be .ore appropriate for a Potential Large Isaac= rating. - Each project, on each site, in each -locality, will vary. �ierefore, the examples have been offered as guidance They do not constitute an exhaustive list of impacts and thresholds to answer each question. - The ru-ter of examples per question Coes not indicate the importance of each question. - INST=L'CTIONS (Read Carefully) a. Answer each of the 1S questions in PART 2. Answer Yes if there will be any effect. b. Maybe answ ars should be considered as Yes answers. c. If answering Yes to a ouestion then check the _:orccriate box (column I -or 2) to indicate the potential size of the imcact. I` impact threshold equals or exceeds any exar..ole provided, check colurn 2. Ir irpaC: will occur but threshold is lower than examole, Check colo.-,n 1: d. If reviewer has doubt about the size of tale imaac= :1aq consider the irmact as potentially large and proceed to PA RT 3. e. If a potentially Targe i.^pact or effect can be res,.c;d by a change in the project to a less.t:ian large _ lracnitud_, place a Yes in column 3. A No response indicates that such a reduction is not possible. �. 2_ R VA LL TO POTENTIAL CAN IMPACT of MODEPATE URG6C REDUCED BY IMPACT DAPACT P-RcjzzT C.iA:"I,2c IMPnA CT GN UNA NO YES - WILL TF ERE 3E AN _EEEC`t AS A RESULT OF A PHYSICAL CrtANSE 70 00 PROJECT SITE? E,a-ales that .mould Apply to Colusn 2 _ Any construction on slopes of 15b or greater, (1: foot rise oer 100 foot of If-:ngrh,), or where the general slopes ir, the project area exceed 10:. _ Constr•cticn on Land where the dept, to the wata, table is less than 3 feet. Construction of caved oarking area for 1 ,007 or -ore vehicles. _ Cznstruction on lana ..^:ere bedrock is exposed or ^er_lly witnin 3 feet of existing ground sur.ace. _ Construction that will continue for ,-yore than. 1 ;•ear or involve no re than one prase or glace. Excavation, for miring purposes that Mould r=_r~v -cre than 1 ,000 tons of natural ;2t2rial (i.e. rock or sail) per /ear. Construction of any new sanitary landfill. P.A T E LAp.GE RECUCrTJ-2d-- s . ;,CT TJ.:'ACT poOJE: Ccnstructicn in a d^signaled floodaay. Otr:r i;7;2cts: 40 YES 2. �I' _ T'rE-= �'J r, F_CT TO :NY UNIQUE OR U�;i;SUAL UN9 FC?'i5 00 F:-ND' C�; T:.- SiT-? (i.e. cliffs, dunes, c=ologic-i 'or�a- ticns, Etc.) SOCclfic 12nd rOrns: _ I! c�rT ^!I WATER NO YES 3. WILL . =OJ7-C7 ;,FFEC7 ::Y WA ccR BODY DESICiAT:D AS .:........(D 0 • . F=OT=CTED? (Under Articles 15. 24, 25 of the Envir- cr...-zn al C-,nservaticn Law, E.C.L.) that ":cul d .';:ply to Col tuarn 2 _ Crs,;ir.n_ . ore t`an 100 cubic yards of material from c..^,nn.el 0f a protected strea.^t. Ccrst-.. _.cn in a d=si n ated freshwater or tidal wetland. Other imoacts: 4. WILL p=C,;E:T AFFEC—, .:jy iiC:l-PPO EC71E0 EXISTRIG, OR ;i_1 NO YES °CCY GF 1!.;T_R? ........................................... -- -oles tat Would A poly to Column 2 % _ A lra ir,crns2 or decr:asa ir the surface area of any body of water or .ire th:!n a 10 acre increase or decrease. _ Ccr.struc�:�n of a body of viater that exceeds 10 acres of surface arca. 0t1:2r lY0 YES 5. WILL r'ROJECT AFFECT SURFACE OR GROUrIOIPATER OUALITY? ' to:J 0 E--z:-:)les that !•Fould Apply to Cclu,-m 2 Project will require a .discharge permit. Project requires use of a source of water that does not have approval to serve proposed project. _ Prrject re;uires •gat2r suoply from wells with treater t`:--n 45 gallons per nlnute PL-Ming capacity. Ccnstm-c'-icn or ocerztion causing any contamination CT a public water supply system. PM:2e t .rill adversely affect grcurd,-acer. _ Licuid e`rluent will be conveyed oft bre site to iarilities v,nlch presently do no eXis% Or have ir,ade^,nate c_.acity. _ Proj?ct requiring a facility that Would use water :n excess of 20,000 gallons per day. Protect wi11,1ixely cause siltation or other discnar_a inrn an existir:7 body of vrater to the extent that t`ere ' ';,'-'LL TO POTENTIAL CAN V IP.IC 7 Sc mE?,ATE LARGE REDUCED 13Y 'IMPACT I IPACT PROJ ECT CHANGE Otr.er I-oacts. !1ILL PP^�=C" r�T=R ?� c p.^,TTr:?!IS OR SC==�C= !:,TEF ::0 YES 0 ;? ............................. (DO Exa-cle that `:ould ?only to Colw,� 2 P _ flood •..ater flows. eject Mould ir.._=?e _ Project is likely to cause substantial erosion. Project is inccr--atible 'with existing drainage patters. Other impacts: it'PACTON AIR ;;0 YES 7. WILL PF.OJECT AFF:-r-7 AIR QUALITY?..... � 0...................... Exa-oles that !Iculd hcply to Colu!-n 2 Prcject Hill ince ce 1 ,170 or more vehicle trips in any given hour the incineration of more than 1 ton projec' will result in of refuse per hour. Project emission rate of all contaminants will exceed 5 Per hour or a cat source producing more t.. 10 .. . nillicn BTU's per hour_ _ Other im=acts. 111AC7 PL-tITS VIO agr�t S `10 YES $. MILL P=OJE AFFECT ANY T.iR ATENE7 OF E''ICANCZFCr 5?=1IES[ 0 O Exa=les that .!culd Ap3ly to Wur,,n 2 1 4 A ::ew York -- { Reduction of one or ire species listed on the - or F2rerzl list, using the site, over or near sitz or _ found on the site_ Re�oval of any portion of a critical or,significznt wild- life habita'. Ao?licaticn of Pestici,'�2 or harbicide over ro:-e than trice a year ot`:^_r t:an `or agri"!-_u:'al Purocses. Ot`er Impacts: :'.!L ?^ T SU° T;•'IT,.:LL'f :,Fr"tCY .;C:I-T;:RE�i_:ice :F ;0 YES . .......................... .. ......... 0 Ex=�cle t-at ,joL:ld Apply to Colum, 2 er - o any -esi'ent _ Pro;=r_' :rculd st;hstantiall_i interf.e_r_ with or migratory fisn or wildlife species. Prnjec`_ recuires tie reraval of ,-ore than 10 2cre5 of - o ger i0O ears in ace) or otne- l�cslly - ure "or_st �: y im.pori:ant vegec'_t'On. 1 i . Z. 3: TO POTENTIAL CAN i"PACT:3' " '.uucraTE LARGE REDUCED BY - IMPACT IN'Pa.CT PROJECT Cu,9G:' I'-'PACT C:1 VISUAL RESGL'.:CE 10.. :LL 7'i� ?='2JECT ===CT VE=i:$, VISTAS ORTHE" VISUAL NO YES 0. T: _ :�E:C:;EO; =C0 OR COY"UNIITY? .............. ti th:t „culd :;,Ply to Colc; " : ALL TO POTc:;TI"L CAA", I.ca;CT•E= MOEP? TE U. GE PEDUCED 3Y - Its?ACT I':PACT PP,CJECT CXml,;E id. W11 LL ?.^.OJ"cl T a`-=.CT Tr_ CC::-:UNITIES SOURCES OF nJ=_ :a NO YES EN-ERSY Su?PLY? .......................................... Q 0 ' X Exarclas that Would Apply to CoILY-7n 2 _ ProJ2=t causing greater than 51 increase in any horn of energy used in nunicicality. - Pra?ect re;uirirg :he creation or ex:ension of an ere-:.Y • transnissior or s:ooly systam to serve more than 50 single or oro family res,d2r:cas. Other impacts: Tt•'?iCT 0'1 NOISE - 15. 'WILL Tr:---?_ BE 03JECT IMASLE OOGRS, :'NOISE, GLARE, 7:3:L TION NO YES or -aECTRIC.,L OiS:J EANC= AS A RESULT OF THIS PP.0:E=T? ... 00 cxaroles that 11cuid Apply to Column 2 Blasting within 1 .500 feet of a hospital , school cr ,'-,her sensitive facility. - Odors will occur routinely (:rare than one hour per '_ay). - Project will oroduce 002r=ting noise exceeding :he - ___ local ambient noise levels for noise outside of s: :c:lres. Project will rz.-r,va natural barriers that would ac= °s a T noise screen. Other impacts: TuP�C; C;! 4E:LT:-1 � Pp7ep0S NO YES 15. 4IL! PROJECT AFFECT PUSLIC PEZ70 ANO SAFT Y? ............ 0 - Exanoles that 'Would Apaiy to COl= 2 _ Projec: will cause a risk of explosion or release of hezarda us subscancas (i.e, oil, pesticides, chemicals, radiation, etc.) in the event of accident or upset conditions, or trere will be a cr.rcnic lc:+ level discharge or emission. Pro;ect that will result in the burial of "ha=ar'nus wastes° ` (i.e. toxic, -oisarcus, highly reactive, radicac=:ve, irritating, infer::eus, etc. , inclucinq wastes that are solid, sari-solid, liquid or contain gases.) Storace facilities ;or cne million or more gallons _f liquified nacural gas or otter licuids. Ot ner i pacts: s lu]rrT •. r=- ' 7-J ..`� i_ •• .i cnr:'.u,,liTY OR • ii. 'SILL PROJECT A=r�CT i'r.� C'-,�pACT=4 nF ME EMSTIi1G NO YES CJ:� LY? .. .... ..........................................GO EX' 71e t=at Vauld Apply to Colurn 2 T'he ccpula:ion of : e City, Tc'dn or Village in :)high the ;rod___ is lcca:ed likely to grcw by more than 5. of _ The .municiozl budgets `or capital exn_enditures or opera- tin-- servlc's will increase 5y more than 5A per year as a result Or this pro;'r:. Will involve any cer..anert Facility of a non-agricultural use in an igricuit::ral district or remove prime agricultural lands rrzzn cul tivation. p -ojcct ►:ill replace or elininate existing facilities, str,Lctures or zre3s of historic importance to the coy-Munity. _ Cevelcpc�_-nt- will inejca an influx of a particular age wi:h special n_ecs. rPmjec: will tet an .moor:—int precedent for future projects. _ rro;ect will relocate 15 or more empleyees in one or more .businesses. other ...pacts: NO YES 13. I5 T; ZRE r':3LiC CO:;T?_.cnSY CO:;CERNINIG T'r'.E PROJECT? .......� . Ex2'-^1--s that , •could !,pply to column 2 _ Eith'_r goverment or citizens Of adjacent cor-Lunities have expres5zd op;ositien or rejected the project or have . not :;ctrl epntacte�. CSjections to t`•e prp;ect from within the corriomty. Yes IF P%N'Y ACTIO?l I11 PORT 2 IS IDENTIFIED AS A POTENTIAL LARGE I;'?ACT OR Ir '(OU CANNOT DETEF44ME THE M,. G:IITULDE OF IIiPACI , PROCEED TO PART 3. PORTIONS OF EAF COMPLETED FOR T'IS PROJECT: I;:TER41NIATION -- PART I PART I1 PART 3 L'aon revie••,e of the information recorded on this EAF (Parts 1, 2 an_- 3) and consldcr;n^, 'cath the magnitude and irmortence of each irpac_, it is reasonably determined that PREPARE r. llcl ATI IE QECL.�Rr1TIC1{ A. The project will result in no .major irn:acts and, therefcre, is One which may not cause significant darrage to the envlr mment. 2. Al _.•cuch the _ro�egt could have a significant effect on the ten; rrr2nt '`=re .rill noc be a significant Wac_ in this :ss2 PREPARE A ilEiLzTi'!E DEC'4�.ATIO:, :eC= 752 the mit`;aticn c':su'res d25Cr:O?'1 in PART 3 have teen inglu:ed as per: 0' e Orcposed :-ciscz. 0 I e r ;e c_s PREPARE POSITIVE OECL.- AT 'i C. "re �r9j�C; ',�i, l result in one ,r ccre major ad• r`e oe £ =E '? i0:1 PROCEED �. t nam ca"not 5a reduc=e and May Cause Significant darlace to tn.e environ ent. 0 Date Stignature cf" ?f!spons::le—Official in L Agency Sicra_ure or ?reaarer (if different from responsio12 officer) Print or type name or responsible offs - :,` To;-IN OF SOUTHOLD ENVIRO`.i,1ENTAL ASSESSMENT , PART III EVALUATIO;`: OF THE IMPORTANCE QF' IMPACTS Part 2 °s pr'::ared if one cr -ore impact or efi2Ct is c:nsidered to be potentially large. Tho runt of •+rit:n, necessary to answer Part 3 rep `_e daternined by answering the Question: In briefly • cc-;l.:ti�i ir,s:r UC_:ons beic-a have I placed jr, '_nis record suf f Scient lnior-mation to indicate the re_SCna01Eness Jf -.y 112clsicnS? i S T:.-,T:C::S Cc-pl t�_ fCllc,tinq fcr e2c`1 j.-pact or effect id-enti f led in•Column 2 of Part 2: None 1. 9rj:!ny dz•scrite tie impact. 2. Cescri�_ (if arolicacle) how the impact might be nitigated or reduced to a less than farce impact by a pro- ject c-.an;e. lased on the info :icn available, decide if it is reasonable to conclude that this inpact is iC.3o rtant to t`e 1lnlcipality (city, town or village) in rinicn the project is located. To ans:lar t. e Question of importance, CCnsl?�r: - T`e probability of the icract or effect occ::rrjng - The �uratien of ~_.he impact, or effect - Its irreversibility, including perianently lost resources or values - xhet'er tie impact or effect can be ccntrjlle' - The regional consequence of the impact or effect - Its potential divergence from, local ne=ds and ;oats - Whether Cnc-an objections to the project apoly to this impact or effect. GETS--li:::,iIC:1 OF SiGUFICA'"C.^. An action is considered to be significant if: : One (or core) im-•tct is deter-fined to both ial-_•e and its (their) consequence, based on the review j above, is irocr'2nt. t PAF.T Iii STA E",1E.1177 a (Continue cn Attachnantc, as needed) .s - mailing .waress: Norman U . isoos ,.,nays s1:-,-i ,�l„ 541-40041 ( �r 5t. � D<< Zia 73.4-63`_'.3 .. - Dias_�peQua , NY 11758 BRO:1DIVATERS COVE MjNRINA • Coritract - Summer DoCILZ1 191.13 t ft c h i s t r;l t•i o rl _�- 1.ength of lio,It 1 Iloat,' Nnnic Aritltll cif Beam Nl) / owner N ame & address m w' Tel n 7'3 ` S Ct, S''i� � /� U 11� 3 � _ RENTAL FEL. IS FOR PERIOD OF APR. ' I , through Nov . 1 O\1.1" please circle which is applicable for your boat. 19 $q40 -O0 22 ' - .,?370 .00 Minimum to 16♦ - 310 .00 , • _ 350 .00 23' - 380 .00 17+ - 320 .00 20 , _ 360 .00 24' - 390 .00 18, - 330 .00 I hereby acknowledge that the aforementioned -lee is to be paid in the following manner: DEPOSIT: - Minimum of 25% to be received at Broadwaters Cove Marina by Feb . 15 , 19 83 . BALANCE: • - To be paid in full and received at Broadwaters Cove Marina by 4•/15/83 . PLEASE NOTE: Reservations cannot be held unless payment in full is received by 4/1/83 . I clearly understand that the said fee is for a rental charge only LE, for any (la-mage and that Broadivaters Covetna �heftaccidentis NIOT RorPany l{contingency beyond caused by weather , fire , our control . I also agree- to abide by the following rules and regulations: NO speed in excess of 5 M311 in marina or channel , no loitering, unattended children, swimming, crabbing or fishing in marina. \To live on board. Any infringement of the above rules may lead to ezllilsioti from the marina. PLEASE NOTE FUItTIIER: Dockage after \ovember 1 , . ►)J s{ ,cciril {lerrli s5i ori. only. '� - - --- -- — ----- — -- -- Jiollatlll' C t�3G r elct oivl eclhcl;lent. �-3 g{)oI1511)lE' ror incl etucnt u'ea tl[c"', . e are no {tlll�r contingencies {levor.d our control. ,icc•icicnl� or a - .��;.-. _ >•F>'sik#''�'%-• - - - - - '•✓✓��=a:'.siJ.-vim' .r ts,jy__ 'x'•_•__�•"'_ :. -. _ -t . R.PR-_`tip-'•`—•: �ti(m'•�.: -.T - _ -_ y''�af..l+:�'�'.`.u�-'.tvsY'.- -_.i4wi-'•,..ts `._�:.sv�, =i:.._...-. - �'-�iy F^..+yi•. ?Y a-."3ys (:T +s{. I,rf 'Stj;" }rip§'•� -Y=: .,1.Y{�.v%'•',•;:�ea.-.-.'-"- •- ,� nY • _— -_�_�'' t:_� .--t_,'-•�� 3:=':�,'�''- Days: 433.0010 r rt ;ta,t_4 Evenings: 541-4604 �"'.�.. '*,-� �,,_�',- •3-"��,'Fes; a 734-632-� Marina n 3 ist. 1950 BAY AVENUE (Skunk Lane), CUTCHO - �z;�-= ;�z-•-��,�,:.,:.;�;,.._.,_- GUE, L. L, N. Y. 11935 `' c Secluded Dockage with Electricity ' Mailing Address: Contract - Summer`.Dockage 1984 Norman c. Boos 1 Cedar st, Massapequa, N. Y. 11758 Length of Boat Registration # Width of Beam •�-M�•-S ' - - - Boat Name ' Owner Name & Address n e � Tel ��d• �� �avey^ ' � ,41� .o�q RES N'PL FEE I FO ERIOD OF APR. 1, through N6v. 1 , ONLY Please circle '-which is applicable for your boat. Minimum t 16' - $325.00 21 ' - $400.00 17 - 40.00 22' - 415.00 18' - 355.00 23' -- 430.00 - 19 ' 370 .00 24 ' - 445.00 20' - 385 .00 _ For your convenience gas & oil - are available. I hereby acknowledge that the aforementioned fee is to be paid in the following manner: DEPOSIT : - Minimum of 25% to be received at Broadwaters Cove Marina by Feb. 15 , 1984. BALANCE: - To be paid in full and received at Broadwaters Cove Marina by 4/15/84. PLEASE NOTE: Reservations cannot be held unless payment in full is received by 4/15/84 . I clearly understand that the said fee is for a rental charge only and that Broadlvaters Cove Marina is NOT RESPONSIBLE for any damage caused by weather, fire , theft, accident or any contigency beyond our control. I also agree to abide by the following rules and regulations : NO speed in excel of 5AIPIi in MARINA OR CHANNEL, no loitering, unattended- children, swimming, crabbing or fishing in marina. NO LIVE ON BOARD. Any infringement of the above rules may lead to expulsion from the marina. PLEASE NOTE FURTHER: Dockage after November 1 , BY SPECIAL PERMISSION ONLY. Or,G/ * S n Acknowledgement WE ARE NOT TO BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR INCLEMENT WEATHER, THEFT, FIRE, ACCIDENTS `—:-.�: �i -- �• ._ _ OR OTHER CONTINGENCIES BEYOND OUR CONTROL .� •}(r.�"•�yi.����gas`t'�ss _�� ,: i.�+a:a- �'=3 c•._`.�..�'�s:_,:.: - �=. .. _ _ - ti: ��:,' ;s _, .;•. _ `- :-. — t rt1�c., .Y.a'fiY« v -"�'"s•�a^3 + "�S '94' -:,T•a -`+��T[s�.�r{1-Ls".',.'�.�..ktF�4`fyi`ar'.a��r'. .a s. IIy31�� The Sale of this Property includes the following: Three hundred and seventy feet (370 ft.) on— Bay Avenue or Skunk Lane Cutchogue, New York 11935 1. The Marina or Boat-Basin provides slips for dockage of 35 boats, up to 24 ft. 2. Electricity and Fresh Water. 3. A ramp to launch,take-out,service, or paint bottom of boats,etc. 4. A tool and utility concrete-block storage building with toilet. 5. The sale of gas and oil, consisting of a 575 gal.tank and electric-pump. "~' Inspected and passed May 29, 2978 by Suffolk County No. P-00854-P00853. 6. Water front building—lot, (431500 sq. ft.) for construction of a house and septic-system,no construction within (30 ft.) of line mean high-water. _ Passed and Approved November 4, 1974 by New York State Dept. of Environmental Conservation, Stony Brook, New York. 7. Precast 900 gals. Septic tank, 5 shallow pools already installed, and inspected. Approval date November 3, 1974, Permit No. 450159, Health Service Reference No. 4-50-159. 8. Water Supply tested and approved Oct. 24, 1975, Lot-A-4S0-160 by H-2-M Corporation Water Analytical Service 500 Broad Hallow Water Road Melville, New York 11746 Real Estate Property Tax for 1977—$460.12 Liability Insurance for 3 year policy—$210.00 - - -e:«�.-` -�.. ^.:-:".�_•-•-,-.-.._.�.....-•�- .. TTS._-,ti •_-.-. .-;,< '. - - -�,^'-.. . +z�+��"�"`'.:�.."�'-�.'.?=:��n:�Y: `:�l%�•--- .;,:�`�::�R;;Y�_a+,-r.,:=F+,-..���'t7t•$-��i"•."'�--'fil-.fi�*�Y•r�:=`'"=•_. 7`'" bt? t t c �♦..�-6 a .r.re.,�.rc... ,L�, �1, s 4 F _ l•;"«e34It.,�+._� �a �*QcT`�'' � •cry t� y>. �'� �Z++T•rt �I{�#-��/ �.� k'�'y`�YvtiG•i4�<.'.^n'1-�.•w`t`4' 4 tel. S. F aF4y K ti< ,i EN ".y.�'�' �.." r .t �'i " 7'x .•4" ¢,. ..�¢-t �.F;.re i al } .f,+1 '•ste � i gw r r,, t ✓ J 's.,4 '�,+trYk#.'l5" yj''-"rk. ��'� �1�� `s�lj�"�.*�@� �►•{�"t���x T�t�M7 +�, t �-��r e�-I�f '��, gu�S+-na„,�,t x- �r•� �' v.'1q.. �"'+ „ �r�a.-... tyc �? •z t �. ,k,f gir���"�t�r.�,..3.��-ts� �F�k eL. �..s�•:o. � �'1 aYr � �{,�f 1Y,4 s Vit` FA, t MR ov r �sl•'��,`�3 �'� •l 'moi ' . J cox rr-.;.rk..,[��_ � � � <• 's. e{ .. t'` 'S' ?`k^rc r.1 y. :`;{,(•-,�yr.,,.c��,., .a..,;� .tif'��£Sw t.,:- "�'•��� � � '1 •fN Y`IK 7 W1 .a �4r BOuthold Torn Board c;- �ppe_.le M'n �--y 17. 1978 4_ ;.Sou�i�old.,L.I.,u.Y: 11• -L-- . :.._: -�w::_= _:___':_: , •' - - - - -- _ . _ ',-•r=--'�_- - _ �;;- - Attention:Robert �ai `-.��•�= '-•�-':~rte':-- '-r=a^"-.w".a-'-•.- i'�-�-.--.-."''"'w-.+-re'-...-..=Y.r���`�i ,..r"` T.,sw..+�i^ hri••`=y-7•F'- T~�•_ '-�=-+a•i�<'•. `�._.,r:�.:• _.`.`..'y'.`.�' ,�')+i - -+51-' _ �?._" .,`.`F _ - i_"��"1..::��"y..-w.�r"..a.-,.-.�.---„r"- - _� _ ...-.._.y .c�-��_�.�--�•.--+ws+.r=- �.J:�..:•:_�� _. F=G ir.— r_4�r-T' :Y-•�.+:`��,'�sr•"�.,.,a-•�.:y- "�T::a:.e.�'�=�'-�-- -. .,_'7'y",...--_-•.�.._ - I - _ In reference ~Lo- your litter- dated_'`t:ay-o:1;7 -�ieouti-Lrir�_ -icusine8s Iconduct pori the-�outu. �fde of_-cry properly on Say avenue--or:thunk-Lane"=Cutichogua-N,Y: " '� == ol y �aiouledge-I- �yive you -the-foll6wias, information.,` - _ I 'bought my property in 1947 from her.' ' Rti].gh- Sterling of Cutohogue _ --= '�-�•:-:_ _ _- .� _ -- - In 194b--I applied for and received a7 dredging- Permit:-Boom Southold Town Trusto®- .'1l -Goldsmith. with approval of Supervisor=-Norman- Xlipp:to'-Dredge= -W_ =my.property=for the-purpose oS a--BoaL'_fias ixia;=_-� _ ins ori Mss__ _ - _ +..-:..ter.- _ __ __ __ _.:___ ;�,��:G: ___ --___ —._•.____ _ _ "f_.��was� _ -_ _ y _- "!�� .:sY• _ -..`t - - r In the^fall :o f 1948' I:hired=,the_8_outn. Shore Dr9dginJ C o:` '-of'"Fa tah6�dei ,is Y _- - - _T'o Dredge the Boal }resin for- =-- - - -- "_ _- �- •. � - _ � T_ _�..'.'�.'"'•_ - - :-�..+>-r'ts!�T.•.:.-,'.._�-W.i.i�:{-....._......�-.w ' �-�+�-..._ `--rte"r..r-+.w+ws_:�•.wr• ter'-_- .•-a.�`_ Bdd, ...�.. ;�3n�21i11=�ticz�;�lug�•op®retior�"_u�t�_�Pres�==water �;��eleb trinity*. rises_pear I scdoa it�d=dffckage dor`aboiit _1�3.or. 1g Bost_e_ '��'YL����L�Y�••4'SM;FA_'.J"•a11•1.a....'.i:s3_3"^-..�� �✓id.'T?'-+ „ - _ �-Y_�,yl-___•_y.+-��'WY+w. .•ar_. _ .��r 1.4i�R-•w�1!._� _i�.^n-,- +�wrR_.sf L-._.r.�.. _ ._ti...`.y .=-_�By 195? Iy'bad r 8 DQsts.==a�oz+e o�=lasg;that year..==� attzz'tied-tai"sell< gae an- 54, '==�";Zor�_the='c onveneiit��}�o �: ,�...w.:._�...�..�.��..____•.:�. ___ - -. � 7sA.•Y�::a�.1. ::.:: .=.a•so..� __ �rs.:_r._. -J ... - - '"w..T....__..r.�V+v-^�_-i^.-r.•_- _ .�. ..- ^_ �:�h...:. -' ------ _,...•:= -r-.4---:.��..-r.;•V..�Y.i-::+� -_....-.-R�;�tr_ ' 11i'1957--.iVibers- o the =$dfning.-Gommit't®a.aMMUtin3• o� the= fold e�rin _ffiesbers t= =. _7Ctto,• Yari_fiyle,Karol d--Reeve; 8ad=rohn_'tdic as inspected an:::approved the � = ; �existano6 or-my' ,my presenL,zBoat: Zwizi:raid::®,gre•ed_that.this-'c oma unitir`_wast - _ _ � . ' : Y named_ori-th1.a=type.'of °sexvtco_' ,as-•:all=--ay:-customers,_then and no-vv are;neighbors; ands®sidenta of;ttessau 'Pt:� x6maaiv..ft ms'-who_need' the=•.Yaailitiea,:.that W-y 'tn16 r �•.-• �.-+�•- -.....-x . s:��: �in3- •u..irrs,.y,CW+'.k�r"+r^'....., -•i . �.S.pM="�,rw.. 'lc- y, ,..w........��`fis .��"..,.r�'� +-�--- ...-�-.•.�:-.�.. r;a• �,.—.,---•--••..-._�_..._�.:._:..-.qty--_ ''-" In' referghoe:.4o '1h1&,;isame_ property = T- -_woul'd--like_ to. point out"'and, have the'�l'�`= _Board;Fisc acre elf that-I 7 4ae=in=_theiTredgl6g "Zicavating -and --Bulkheading - -n,atisiixess'trom 195 {fo' 197 '='and oonducted--all phases_ o� this husfnec - =-including the Boat Basin= Buein®se- on the-same Parcel. of i�raperrLy. t- As of yto date I aauid acoiii o to Ywitn .ease Forty or Forty�rive Boats - -=-%Between-Ziateen 'dr Twenty"Four _ Ho over fcr my_ .purpose I choose to keop Thirty 'oxo to `i'hirLy wive Boats. Hoping. this' resume will melt with Pair approval, r-i proval,acid I mil: r.Pve a st : atement From yrnLr board. �. :.- 4 Thank You very =ucho . _ Yours +'rely 3roadwt:ter3 move Boat Basin ' Bay. :.venue UutiC'ho--ue ,ir. 1.la. �� 12 35 7-;.411 r",b64Ccde -,tZacaed fl.-A Une o: m,y Blllheudd'• A� �~3- _..--i _ _ _ _ - _ _•k __ ��r � _ _ --.ti..-��^�Sle Jx.. _ _ _ _•5'+;5•Y'1I^H�._��-• - „�Ja �`r�i�«.r.t�.�. Y - -- a:r5.._:...---..s``1a'^ �.^,-Ju-_..x�-0n+i�.'rtT'4_14.y�i.�'tv`Y..- -y�.r!yAa:w :V:=.M-..�L��i�.•-`�-3::,-i�--�.-tq_ -�TY��:.:-'-', -- -.�a'.f�i_�..,r..:_a.2:-•'_.��•_tiX=r•r...5•`_��'�..-:'... •^tet-= rzF T��'7: - - ___ _ 4 - Ts. - _� Z'. �Oathold Town board C ippe;.18 Kay 17,1978 `.3,OuLnold, -,"Attention,Robert W.aillieale,-Jr.'jnairman ...2•--#r;...,.,-ra.•=-..rte..-,��__ ._ _. y�.rL ,_,ww-..�.;_.....,•....... __., _..._,., .�. r• ...x,_. -....,.._.___••••--•�-+--:•- F.x-_. jam; _ ..� --"'.r.:r... -r'-'.'-'_'.".^-^'^_^.:. .:.•r•--,:�" -r_%'.�ri~i••;rt-•.---+.,, �'-yei'•'`3+u�..-,•;�y,�'�`_!"•,'- �• nzv'Z'�s+ _ ` i s _�arw.�ir•-.'_ "^'�',.T_.F=.;.�';z•-T.'7w`Fs-a...-.�"'*F•�-�"+-•rCcaw+....;.. ==�'_�-"�""^�`�.«-Y;^.._,^-'=�s4`_.*^i.,-iy�=.�..:`:." �.':._.'..-....:�-r`;T -� /d - J�'.'i.".-.. . . ,;.'__ ._ � -.cam-,.+.Y-_=.•-•%.e.--,•^-. - r.-----+�•-'---�,a.t�.- .-!, -'^ `.:2.Z}� -• ' -" _= In-rQference toyol:btter d c d il,sy- 6 197 abouts Lr18 -buelnesa' Icviaduot =-- jon the outu.`;pide of-LEY-- iroperty ou Bay,avenue'-bir--bhunk Lane CutcYiogso,N. - _ t:ie~beat-of my knowledge-`I Give you -the~followin3, information. _' - 'I botiGht my property_ in 19.47, from Mr.' Ralph_ Sterling. of. Cutohogue. In 1940 I~'applied for and received-d dridging_p'®rmii: from Southold-Town -_- . Trustoe U .Goldsmith. with approval of 5upervisor-:Norman- Uipp-_to'--DredLe= ~ _ prof 9-for the_ purpose or a -Boat'.bas in_ or�-W�ViUa L:. of 1948-TIred-- the-South.Shore Drodgln ,Co: of ?ataho�;-ue,I Y,- ==-- -_To Dredge the BoatBasin for.- �'-'',,,,•r.:..u'«:.-.::-."•i,...-.-.v�-ti•,s'...�...�.v.`.�s+,.1+.-c�•-rr-=-+i',..�_-a�`�.+•�+.--- - _ --••"Y,:Tr rte. .�-�_ -the Baat2Baain.xes`in Sull 50- r'l1nE::. t#,ors''��th�•=�resYi�=water r�n3_.�.._ "�sleo t_ricityr. Yiet - e year�'.I--acdomaited_=d6ckage dor.about =1�3 .or�l bo3te- - �`.-s�-ra,r• v �•tn..;,u,_.._...:.:..w... - - s "`�i��:.+�,s,�,.'�w','�i�eir's:"•"•`.cam+.."-'",-r.-""'+"_'..,�•5��= _.r.-:: ..,,...�.i r-ni"r.4w:.:,.►"a,h"wYs:., �.:'=.='�_ Bj.=195k:71--had 28 bCnts4xmoz�e=o s2esg;3�hat yesr 1L. 'started aell.gs - nd oi2 -;Zor_=the-coneenencso}�o��•t� austomera�=. - -_—��,M_��.:._= _ .�__y�;.—�.�-�--�:�w:=•�. -�...f.=�•��'- •iS��✓�a'4' .pU�v'�iiw�: =.IwSw'i•?["-_r-"'-�- f-•+-kms•-•__..•.._..•.-..-..-• ____ __ _ -. -.n - -•a-J--�-...-+•'�......�� Y•-'•; � •-.�}<: ':Iia -1957..mpmbera of. thy =$fining:Co�tt'L®e.00n81st3nof the-' followinE :mesbers, "Ctto,- Vari' Tyle,iiarold=Re e; e=i =Joha w�:c aa:.iaspect'ai un::. approve -.the - _�- existaxios of my-. presenti Boat:= eisf aad`aigreed'=that=this-:co munity:_wasr in- - 'need..oto--t�h4a type-of. aerie©: ;as =all---my�-cdato_iers then and now-., are, neighbors;. . - ; and residents of•-11assaw FL:` and..XeI wsaii•.�'arma;wha.need the .faailitles:•..that -� .. ---- - -,-�•-:••�.-- 7-11 i.ri=provide=-A.�..:�:-•..=<:�;�:�:��•� .-�..•.� �------�:.��,:���..�•: �` In reYereroe:rto •this=Btieae-property Z=�Kould_=like', to point auL"and h�ivg the aHdre-ok that 1 xae'In Lh® Dred�Sing..s.aa ratlag -and -.Bultheading - -` - - -- -- - - - - - -from' 195 197 and_conducted' all phases -o� this_ bustneast{ - -:the _ _ - - including:the Boat* Basin' Bueinsea - on the'--same Parcel. of kreperty. 3 �'As of Jto date I could-acoo=odat©•-witn ea:se •forty :or rorty Five Boats - -'Fietxeen Sixteen `Cr Twenty Four Feet; However fcr 'my purpose I choosey to keop Thirty 'lxo to thirty give Boats. Hopin:,: this reizutae will meet with yo-xr approval,and Y Fit:_.rP�Aiv's a ::tatesment from youz' Board. r Thank You very much :;. YcurF, truly - Bro.:_iwi:ter3 Cove Bort Bain Bay' :.venuo Outcho °:e L. 1.i,Y. iij35 Ocie .,ttac ed fl-.A cnc o_ my 31111neadd. _t PERMIT NO. NEW YC _ ATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVA 10_83_1610 PERMIT31za,� , UNDER THE ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION LAW "2,3( X ARTICLE 15, (Protection of Water) X ARTICLE 25, (Tidal Wetlands) ARTICLE 24, (Freshwater Wetlands) 8 ARTICLE 36, (Construction in Flood Hazard Areas) ERMIT ISSUED TO Norman C. Boos DDRESS OF PERMITTEE One Cedar Street, Massapequa, NY 11758 OCATION OF PROJECT(Section of stream,tidal wetland,dam, building) ort west corner o roc water Cove at the Broad- caters Cove Marina located on the south side of Bay Avenue, Cutchogue. ESCRIPTION OF PROJECT 2onstruct approximately 175 linear feet of 3'6" wide floating catwalk with nine finger piers reasuring 3'6" X 16'6" long in accordance with the plans entitled "Broadwater Cove Marina" )repared by Norman C. Boos, received December 21, 1983. OMMUNITY NAME(City,Town, Village) TOWN :utchogue - - Southold OUNTY FIA COMMUNITY NO. DAM NO. PERMIT EXPIRATION DATE ;uffolk March 31, 1985 GENERAL CONDITIONS - 1. The permittee shall file in the office of the appropriate Regional B. That the State of New York shall in no case be liable for any damage mit Administrator, a notice of intention to commence work at least 48 or injury to the structure or work herein authorized which may be caused by or irs in advance of the time of commencement and shall also notify him result from future operations undertaken by the State for the conservation or �mptly in writing of the completion of the work. improvement of navigation, or for other purposes, and no claim or right to 2. The permitted work shall be subject to inspection by an authorized compensation shall accrue from any such damage. t! iresentative of the Department of Environmental Conservation who may 9. That if the display of lights and signals on any work tereby authorized er the work suspended if the public interest so requires. is not otherwise provided for by law, such lights and signVs as may be pre- scribed by the United States Coast Guard shall be instal ed and maintained 3. As a condition of the issuance of this permit, the applicant has ac- by and at the expense of the owner. 3ted expressly, by the execution of the application, the full legal respon- ility for all damages, direct or indirect, of whatever nature, and by whom- 10. All work carried out under this permit shall 0�performed in actor, �r suffered, arising out of the project described herein and has agreed to dance with established engineering practice and in a workmanlike manner. emnify and save harmless the State from suits, actions, damages and As of every name and description resulting from the said project. 11. If granted under Articles 24 or 25, the Depairtment reserves the righl to reconsider this approval at any time and after-'due notice and hearing to 4. Any material dredged in the prosecution of the work herein permitted continue, rescind or modify this permit in such if manner as may be found to ill be removed evenly, without leaving large refuse piles, ridges across the be just and equitable. If upon the expiration ourevocation.of this permit, the I of the waterway or flood plain or deep holes that may have a tendency to modification of the wetland hereby authorizr;8 has not been completed, the ise injury to navigable channels or to the banks of the waterway. applicant shall, without expense to the Staff; and to such extent and in such S. An material to be deposited or dumped'under this time and manner as the Department of Environmental Conservation may require, Any p p permit, either in remove all or any portion of the uncompleted structure or fill and restore the waterway or on shore above high-water mark,shall be deposited or dumped site to its former condition. No claim shall be made against the State of New the locality shown on the drawing hereto attached, and, if so prescribed York on account of any such removal of alteration. reon, within or behind a good and substantial bulkhead or bulkheads, such will prevent escape of the material into the waterway. 12. This permit shall not be construed as conveying.to the applicant any right to trespass upon the lands or interfere with the riparian rights of others '6. There shall be no unreasonable interference with navigation by the to perform the permitted work or as authorizing the impairment of any rights, k herein authorized, title or interest in real or personal property held or vested in a person not a 7. That if future operations by the State of New York require an alteration party to the permit. the position of the structure or work herein authorized, or if, in the opinion 13. The permittee is responsible for obtaining any other permits, ep- the Department of Environmental Conservation it shall cause unreasonable provals, lands, easements and rights-of-way which may be required for this truction to the free navigation of said waters or flood flows-pr endanger__,_,prnject. health, safety or welfare of the people of the State, or loss or destruction he natural resources of the State,the owner may be ordered by the Depart- 14. If granted under Article 36, this permit is granted solely on the basis it to remove or alter the structural work, obstructions, or hazards caused of the requirements of Article 36 of the Environmental Conservation Law and -eby without expense to the State; and if, upon the expiration or revocation Part 500 of 6 NYCRR(Construction in Flood Plain Areas having Special Flood this permit, the structure, fill, excavation, or other modification of the Hazards — Building Permits) and in no way signifies that the project will be ercourse hereby authorized shall not be completed, the owners shall, free from flooding, `lout expense to the State, and to such extent and in such time and manner the Department of Environmental Conservation may require, remove all or 15. By acceptance of this permit the permittee agrees that the permit portion of the uncompleted structure or fill and restore to its former is contingent upon strict compliance with the special conditions on the dition the navigable and flood capacity of the watercourse. No claim shall reverse side. made against the State of New York on account of any such removal or ration. 204(9/75) • •• (SEE REVERSE SIDE) ' +�,b� •.�'T-rik��LKO.�c��.Pi.�:`` "J• ••Y^..-�.' .�. -_ _ r"1�.�r.J;'.2:'- �i.`..3.`.']."n`- .... �J - _�+5xia:52�E��%S-�: ysn�6''4��,� .ay,= �;r�i�y.y s"v_-.'y= .�'1>_ J,-,)F'.-}+�-�+.�,i;'..•....: V,K.-,-�t� y�'���j.,i,_�'.}� ;r ._ 'e$^-��C�c+§.4`a'�'�YxY3°. :3`.i� �^'Ti1I"d_.r.+Ta.-•1'.i..":='a`�'�"`'•�'`?`:__=i.Jz,�_�_�_�i��t�,r'�'S�i�!�r'.�:�=/Fi�+"h�S4fR�b+vw`t' '� S CIA—ZONDITIONS , 16. There is to be no dredging, filling or bulkheading associated with this project. 17. There is to be no disturbance to vegetation or topography along the existing shoreline. SEE ATTACHED CONDITIONS A - J, P s PERMIT ISSUE DATE PERMIT ADMINISTRATOR _ f ADDRESS Bldg. 40, SUNY--Room 219 January 12, 1984 Daniel J. Larkin `; . Stony Brook, NY 11794 �i "�- -rte•«--:�.: _ _.�s�.-. - -_--- -="__�_<-- _',__ � _ ,--- _ - - - -" ' - - - :'-„�;,'`` ..ti.-".r5.> •;<,��,: :ice,^3`�-. -^5.=-::.: _•,:�.�...;:�;.: s5.�.�?:3q:>i' -`-�;��.'_�--t-•e^ Tt�" / The following conditions shall apply if" checked ,as applicable by the -Regional Permit Administrator: K. All dredging shall be conducted so as to leave a uniform bottom elevation free of mounds or holes. L. All spoil material shall be disposed of either in the Atlantic Ocean or at an approved U.S. Government Dumping Ground, as directed by the District Engineer, U.S. Department of the Army, Corps of Engineers. Any spoil material not intended for such water dis- posal shall be removed from the site and disposed of at an approved upland site. M.. All fill and"spoil material -shall be suitably contained at the work site so as to prevent its eroding, leaching or otherwise entering into-adjacent wetlands and waterways. N. All peripheral rip-rap berms, cofferdams, rock revetments, gabions, bulkheads, etc. shall be completed prior to placement of any fill material behind such structures. _O. - All, repairs- to existing structures shall be confined to replacement of- existing structural elements with no change in-design,. -dimension., or materials, unless specifically authorized herein. % F..•_ The -following Water Quality Certification shall-apply--If•-required _ by one or more agencies of the United States Government and if . __--checked as applicable by the Regional Permit Administrators: In -accordance with Section 401(a)(1) of the Clean.Waters.Act--of- ' • "'1977 (PL 95-217) the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation hereby certifies that the subject project- proposal will not contravene effluent limitations or other limitations-or-standards; --..under-Sections -301, 302, 303, 306 or 307 or the Act. DATE, January 12, 1984 Daniel J. Larkin, P.E. Regional_-PermitAdministrator- Division of Regulatory Affairs NYS Department- of.Environmental- -------- 10-83-1610 Conservation —`Building 40, -SUINY—Room- 21-9- Stony 1-9Stony Brook, NY 11794 (516) 751-7900" ` - e' z C- 55 BAST Mvn AvmINIUM -�:�o `�a�stss. 0.1;•0. 9'rnn3g� n���t� � . January 14, 1984 b Southold Town Board of Appeals Town Hall Southold, New York 11971 Dear Members of the Board: As residents of Cutchogue and customers for the past -•-two years of the Broadwaters Cove Marina we would like to add our whole-hearted support to Mr . Boos ' application for the expansion of his facilities . We suspect that the major issues , pro and con, have been voiced by this point but hope that some of our ' personal experiences and observations may help shed a positive light on the question. 1 . Availability of slip space at the marina, the only such facility for several miles in either direction, was the determining factor in our decision to recommission our power boat after five years in storage as we were beyond the stage where we wanted to be concerned about an unattended boat moored in the Bay. Boat expenditures , as is well documented, are considerable and in our case have resulted in nearly $3, 000 in revenues to local canvas makers , mechanics , boat movers , marine supply stores , i gas docks , and insurance agents it two years . In short, pleasure boating is good business for the i Southold Town economy. �[ 2 . We have frequently remarked that even on prime weekends the marina is surprisingly full of unused b boats and noticeably void of signs of humanity. s 3 . We do not own an automobile and seem to be only one of many boaters dropped off at the marina with the land chauffeur then driving off for points unknown. This pattern is most common with Mr . Boos ' teenaged client-navigators which age group seems to j be the majority in Cutchosue ' s boating population. r; a - •TJ -2- Parking is , in our opinion, a non-issue . We recall only once last summer when the area along the road seemed to be filled to capacity although it appeared that one could have then easily found space in the parking area closer to Mr . Boos ' house . 4 . The marina is a neighborhood facility and its pattern of usage differs from some of the larger commercial facilities in the area . It appears that most boat owners have residences locally which serve as the focal points for weekend social gatherings and entertaining rather than the dockside entertaining which is more common with the owners of large craft at some of the marinas which accomodate those sorts of boats , again suggesting that conventional parking capacity standards do not apply. 5 . We have never seen evidence that anyone is living 4 aboard -a boat, except for Norman himself. Most of the boats are simply too small . It is unusual, in fact, for anyone to linger any longer than is necessary to handle the details of getting underway or closing up the boat . All of us need to be concerned with the over- development of the North Fork and we favor the careful review of proposals such as this . It is important that in this issue the nature of the marina' s use patterns be carefully examined. It is not a conventional heavy use facility. Norman has developed a facility which is aesthetically pleasing, properly maintained, well managed, and an asset to the community. In our opinion the addition of 18 more slips will not degrade the area by resulting in a congested facility. We strongly recommend your approval of the proposed expansion . Our fellow boaters need dock space . ' Sincerely,� A' thleen Burnside Kilbride David W. Kilbride w January 16,1984 3 ' To Whom It May Concern: I am a resident of Nassau Point, have been for eight years, and also a tenant of Broadwaters Cove for the past two years. In the years that I have been passing the marina on my way to and from home, I have observed and commented about how Mr. Boos has been constantly improving the appearance of the grounds and the structure of the marina. As a tenant I can honestly state that the grounds are maintained meticulously and his parking facilities are excellent. It is for the above reasons that I decided to dock my boat at Mr. Boos' marina and with God's help, hope to continue to enjoy his facilities. Sincerely, win& J Harold Winters r �� BASIL A. SANTINI January 13, 1984 Southhold Town Board of Appeals Main Road Southhold, NY 11971 Gentlemen: We have a residence on Sterling Road, Cutchogue, located just around the corner (about a 4--5 minute walk) from the Broadwaters Cove Marina on Skunk -Lane, (Bay Avenue) , Cutchogue. It has come to our attention that the Owners and operators of the Marina, Mr. and Mrs. Norman Boos, want to make better use of their Marina .property by adding some slips to the existing location. It is surprising to learn that their attempts to improve the area and provide expanded and better service and docking facilities are meeting with resistance from some of the other local residents. We have enjoyed our home in Cutchogue for nearly two years and have had the pleasure of docking our small boat in the Broadwaters Cove Marina for the past two summers and it is our intention to continue. It was not too difficult to learn that the original marina was in disrepair and not in keeping with the fine area. Since Mr. and Mrs. Boos have taken over the marina a' few years-back, many, many improvements have been made and maintained. The general housekeeping is impeccable, and the arrangements they have made for parking has ensured that everyone who needsto park their - car at the marina can be done off the main street, Skunk Lane. (Previously, cars would have to be loaded/unloaded and parked directly on the road.) Anyway, our experience during the past two summers has been nothing but excellent. Even on the busiest of days, we have always been able to easily find a parking space (if we didn't walk - as many of the marina users do') . There has always been adequate facilities for refuse and all the people (of all ages) have always been considerate and helped police the area to keep up the standards that -Mr. and Mrs. Boos have established. Interestingly enough, Mr. and Mrs. Boos have thought so much of the area and their marina that they have been building (themselves) a fine residence' on the immediately adjacent lot to the marina and I understand that it will be finished and they will be able to move in within the next couple of months. I am certain that the Board will take all facts into consideration when making a final decision but also trust that due consideration is given to Mr. and Mrs. Boos' request and the increase in revenue that they may be able to realize, however slight - for whatever increased number of slips eventually allowed. Full time supervision right on the premises is an advantage that, in most cases, is immeasureable. tYi.83o:."'%i:ir�..�_ %a`�, R,_ ' Southhold Town Board of Appeals Page 2 January 13, 1984 In short, we feel that, being residents of the area, having Broadwaters Cove Marina in our neighborhood, with its fine standards and facilities, is a definite asset, and that the moderate expansion plans will also prove to be an invaluable asset. My wife, Beverly, and I would be happy to discuss this further and please feel free to call me at work if you so desire (516 - 944-3500) . Very truly yours, - Basil A. Santini BCC: Mr. and Mrs. Norman Boos c/o Broadwaters Cove r ti, H RECEIVED JAN23w January 18 , 1984 �'®�r�n Clerk S®a,th®8d Southold Town Board Southold, New York Dear Sirs, I would like to take this opportunity to help clarify a number of items pertaining to the Broadwater Cove Marina, Bay Avenue, Cutchogue. Ofters, after an enjoyable evening with the owners of the marina, Evelyn, my sister and Norman, my brother-in-law; my wife and I will retire to our own boat in the marina. We do this rather than set sail late at night, tired or in poor weather, or drive to our home in Bayport. In doing this, we will use all of the marina' s facilities including the bathroom as we would if we were visiting their home, but not only for this reason. Our boat is equipped with a Coast Guard approved Marine Sanitation Device, which is sealed to the outside water. Even with approved holding tanks, whenever we visit another marina or restaurant, we always make an extra effort to use the shore facilities rather than those on our own boat. Both my wife and I are extremely careful and always wish to avoid any kind of pollution, especially water pollution. It is not right to help destroy the things you enjoy the most. Being family members, not only grants us extra considerations at the marina, but also gives us the opportunity to discuss the marina and it' s future throughout the year. I feel that I can honestly say that the purpose of Broadwater Cove Marina is to provide a service to the community while doing so in a safe and beautiful manner. Not only have I helped to remove garbage from the marina, but I have helped to plant thousands of seedling to be used for beaut- ification and environmental reasons. I am most proud of helping to remove a very dangerous condition that existed at the start of Norman' s ownership. At that time, only a few cars could park on Bay Avenue along the front of the marina. When leaving, a driver had to back out into sometimes speeding traffic. In two years this was all changed. Now, there is not only parking for many more cars, but a turn around or drive strip has been made. Now a driver can drive out frontwards safely onto Bay Avenue. 0 2 - Anyone who drives past the marina today and remembers the unkept, dangerous, waterfilled hole in the ground called a marina that existed five years ago, can easily see what five years of planning and hard work can do. Norman has transformed the area into a safe, parklike marina. I believe that the Township and its people are fortunate to have in its midst a marina owner who is not only a hard worker, but also interested in community pride. Sincerely, Al 10 Baywood Lane Bayport, NY X42 o TownPP ,'Jvl MAIN ROAD v STATE ROAD 25 SOUTHOLD, L.I.o N.Y. 119°71 TELEPHONE (516) 765-1809 APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN CHARLES GRIGONIS, JR. SERGE DOYEN, JR. ROBERT J. DOUGLASS JOSEPH H. SAWICKI January 11, 1984 Mr. Norman C. Boos One Cedar Street Massapequa, NY 11758 Re: Appeal No. 3201 Variance to Expand Marina Facilities Dear Mr. Boos: At a Special Meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals held last evening, January 10th, the board declared itself lead agency pursuant to the N.Y.S. Environmental Conservation Act, Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law, and Section 44-4 of the Town Code, and classified your proposed project as an unlisted action which may have a significant adverse effect upon the environment for the reasons listed in the attached Declaration. Pursuant to the above, it is requested that a Long Environ- mental Assessment Form, which is attached, be completed by you and filed with our office as early as possible. Please don 't hesitate to call our office if you have any questions. Yours very truly, GERARD P. GOEHRINGER CHAIRMAN Enclosures By Linda Kowalski cc: Building Department Town Trustees Planning Board 4 Supervisor F.J. Murphy D , r' JM . . ld Town Board of Appeals MAIN ROAD - STATE ROAD 25 SOUTHOLD, L.I., N.Y, 11971 TELEPHONE (516) 765-1809 APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN NOTICE OF DECLARATION CHARLES GRIGONIS, JR. SERGE DOYEN, JR. PURSUANT TO ROBERTSS JOSEPH H.. SAWICKI N.Y.S. ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY REVIEW -ACT AWIC6(I Appeal No. 3201 Application of: NORMAN C. BOOS Location of Subject Property: 8000 Skunk Lane (Bay Avenue) , Cutchogue. County Tax Map Parcel District 1000 , Section 1,04 , Block 08 , Lot 2. 1, 2, 3, 2 .4 , 2 . 5 . Project Proposed: To expand marina dockage facilities for 18 boats. ENVIRONMENTAL DECLARATION: Pursuant to Section 617. 7 of the N.Y.S. Department of Environ- mental Conservation Act, Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law, and Section 44-4 of the Southold Town Code, and in order to commence the processing of the SEQP.A procedures, the Board of Appeals of the Town of Southold at ,this time declares itself lead agency in this proposed project and hereby classifies the same as an Unlisted Action which may have a significant adverse effect upon the environ- ment for the following reasons: 1. Information has not been submitted indicating the type of sewage systems available, if any, for those boats having sleeping, kitchen, or other facilities, which may cause pollution into the waterway; 2 . Information has not been available indicating the type of maneuvering for those boats to be navigating to and from each docking facility, which may disturb the wetlands area along the edge of this subject area. It is hereby requested that the applicant and/or his agent furnish our department with a completed Long Environmental Assessment Form. This declaration should not be considered a -determination made for any other department or agency which may also be involved, nor for any other project not covered by the subject Z.B.A. application. Dated: January 10, 1984. BY ORDER OF THE SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF APPEALS - GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN For additional information, please contact: Linda Kowalski, Secretary and Clerk for the Board of Appeals at 765-1809 (or 1802) . Southold Town Board ®f Appeals MAIN ROAD - STATE ROAD 25 SOUTHOLD, L.I., N.Y. 11971 AA TELEPHONE (516) 765-1809 APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN CHARLES GRIGONIS, JR. SERGE DOYEN, JR. ROBERT J. DOUGLASS JOSEPH H. SAWICKI January 3, 1984 Mr. and Mrs. Norman C. Boos One Cedar Street Massapequa, NY 11758 Re: Appeal No. 3201 Variance for Nine Additional Docks Dear Mr. - and Mrs. Boos: At our Regular Meeting held December 28 , 1983, the board members reviewed your recent application and the board requested the following information: (a) What is the maximum number of boats docked at the same time on •the present docking? (b) What is the length of the proposed docks from the edge of the existing bulkhead? (c) Please provide, a plan showing the proposed additional parking spaces (in addition to the 43 parking spaces required by the prior decision in Appeal No. 2914) . (d) Please indicate on the plan the width of the channel ' s thoroughfare and its location for navigation. Thank you for your cooperation. Yours very truly, GERARD P. GOEHRINGER lk CHAIRMAN P?J Qo` MA RA �IiAS 1 Twenty-three East Elm Avenue,Wollaston Park,Quincy,Massachusetts • Zip Code 02170 • Telephone 773-6350 • Area Code 617 t Career Planning and Placement Center J h,N 03 934 Dec. 22, 1983 Southold Town Board 7w:;a O�erk Southold Southold, L.I. Ref; Nroman Boos Petition This note is to affirm that I have no objection to the proposal of Mr. Boos, whose property abutts mine. inc rely Do al P ey / 4 Broa t Drive. Cutch , s } s J { 4 t 4 S S l f 4 , ti s (55(,ut hold Town Boa:-(_ f Appo ,l s -9- Novem,__z 25, 1983 Special Meeting 0 CORRESPONDENCE: Appeal No. 2914 - IgC)IZM'lN C. BOOS. Correspondence was received NToventk,�=.r 3, 1983 from they oi:ice-off Lhe Tawn Clerk requesting an opinion f_roirt this hoard as to ahc!ther. Mr. Boos should be p�,rmittecl to construct additional flOilting catwalk to accommodate 1.8 addition small brats without additional applications to the Z .B .A. 71he board members confirmed and acquiesced with the Chairman ' s _reply tc the `rown Clerk dated NovemI)er 7, 1983, indicating that an expansion of th'Ls noncc)nformi.ng InarLna to accommodate more than ;5 boats would .require additional Z .B.1,. approvals, however, such Proposals should be referred to the Building Department for their cer+_l_f icati.on and referral accordingly. 5L fP— 1)(®— I ,'�, , Tuesday night, that matter is very much I rustuDes, at issue J)CPr•15'_ lot 93 Q��r ®, Air Boos is asking to increase the capacity of his marina from 37 to 55 slips. 'en da fI^ said the expansion is necessary to Dig keep-his operation financially viable,and There will be a regular meeting to meet increased demand Although TR t>'S TF ES of the Board of Town Trustees at opponents of the expansion were so plentiful that Trustee president Stouten- 7 p.m., Tuesday December 13, hurl h was forced to ask other spectators 1953, at the Town Hall, Main to wail in the hail,the opposition was not R S V Road, Southold, universal None other than North Fork The following items will be ironint�Ccdyici resident Ruth reviewed: (t i�<< orm:ai y a foe of expansion Michael Carlucci- To construct t f c1 is, lave qualified support to the a bulkhead and dock in C'onkling plan sO Point Creek, Greenport. "1 agree it should go to the ZBA first," Michael Carlucci-Referral from she said, "but we desperately need more the Town Board of Wetland Ap- marina srace It'ti abetter way to control plication #170 to construct a boats and tllel, pollution " bulkhead and,dock in Conkling Mrs Oliva's opinion was shared by Point Creek, Greenport, pothers at the meeting, includu,g Trustee Norman C.Boos-To construct a John t3ednoski Jr.,who said "I don't see /floating catwalk with fingers' in how it would do any ham. I think we are Broadwaters Cove Marina, Cut- foilunale that Mr Boos is willing to do, �chogue. this This (expansion) is needed to bring; Norman C. Boos-,Referral from dollars into the marina to pay the bills. I of Wetland feel Mr, Loos certainly is entitled to this. the Town Board Application #172 to construct a "Sometimes the popular decision isn't always the best decision,",Mr Bednoski floating catwalk with fingers'in concluded Broadwaters Cove Marina, Cut- Trustee Frank Kujawski, although �chogue. stopping short of endorsing the project, , said he is unaware of any significant{ a environmental problems with it. f"oes:Charge More Money Opponents of the expansion suggested, among other things, that Mr. Boos raise docking tees instead of increasing the number of slips. They cited pollution- from boats currently using the marina, RECEIVED and expressed concern about future- expansion. utureexpansion. JAN 91984 Once the Boos application was tabled, �,-o nnnnnn+itc of tk,> 'i r•.nhnr v --- TI, .. f t Town Clerk Southold ES o. vvS ;�P�R-5��) D R E b Cq t DIN L ��T® -- - ®f DKA 640 Fog, 1,03- - r Oat FOK 67 CCI 4pill � IR RIVEWA - f� rLAJ �� � ✓ 4 pBSOdO.Scj 00 F v► , �s !=`0 �- 1`� M�N� ��� t/�= U ' ,, ,��- S�A IC • 1 rte , a P cjcL,v ga;-r/y. (0 3.s We, the undersigned, James Reale, Michelena Reale, Angelo Petrucci, Georgette Petrucci live on Bay Avenue (Skunk Lane) , Cutchogue directly across the road from Broadwater Cove Marina owned by Norman C. Boos. Norman C. Boos has applied to the Trustees to construct a floating catwalk with nine fingers for eighteen more boats in the Broadwater Cove Marina channel. This will obstruct free navigation and be very hazardous to the marina's navigation. Let us not lose sight of the fact that this marina is in a residential area and is a nonconforming zoned piece of property (not zoned for business) . We feel at this time that the marina is operating at its full capacity of thirty five boats as the Southold Town Board of Appeals letter dated June 1, 1978 states and Mr. Boos was well aware of what he bought. The additional fingers or slips increasing the amount of boats stored in this marina would congest and would add additional traffic on an already busy, narrow road and the only road leading in and out of Nassau Point, creating noise and rubbish on the road. There is no parking area for eighteen more boats except on the road not to mention the depreciation of the real estate properties in our area. When launching boats it creates a traffic back up and is a hazzard because boats being launched need the complete width of flay Avenue (Skunk Lane) . The increase in boats stored in this dead end marina with people sleeping on board overnight certainly has to create problems on water pollution and the environment. We hope the Planning Board, Board of Appeals, Building Department and Trustees will take these above facts under consideration when making their decisions. We would appreciate your notifying us whenever this matter comes before the Southold Town Board of Appeals so that we can express our opinion on r this matter .at those meetings. �) �k !%-Lf —£:t:.�.<" ( ��{'t-� !C l7�w•z, c t� 'i.��G tc r-c-' ��� �/7—}� •,` �)Cz. l G<r."=, -<< (�f'.l:'• !� � �'�� (�`��G• L!`�j < ����/• �/ ��S CLf J��r t -(/'�y'(,,•t�j�,:(! !/J'I / 1.^._ i 1/ 1'1'i )`--'f.'�: /�/y✓ / 'r!'1 / �/ f i - ��J Z ----- �CL(, l�l�i�i�„cC.e(�'��G� v�C�2�) �G�C�LGv (.C� �• ��r-�J` ,0.Y / �l Iq CC: Southold Town Supervisor Francis J. Murphy Southold Town Attorney Robert W. Tasker Southold Town Clerk Judith T. Terry' Building Dept. Executive Administrator Victor Lessard Building Inspector George Fisher Building Inspector Curtis Horton Building Inspector Edward Hindermann Southold Town Planning Board Chairman Henry Raynor & Members Southold Town. Appeals Board Chairman Gerard Goehringer & Members Southold Town Trustees Chairman & Members President Nassau Point Association President Nassau Farn Association President Broadwater Cove Associ-ation Y s.� A/ t te t&..,0 e e e o e h Th s eo 4in4 kv 0 4 1® e tl C7E° +e 89 Tk m r, =� Southold Town Board of Appeads TELEPHONE 7E59;JFLtc 1802 • APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS June 1 , 1.978 ROBERT W.GILLISPIE,JR.,CHAIRMAN ROBERT BERGEN CHARLES GRIGONIS,JR. SERGE DOYEN,JR. Norman C. Boos AM5tx ;§r1(sditx Bought Mr. Angelo Petrucci Marina August 23, 1978 Mr. Angelo G . Petrucci Bay Avenue Cutchogue , New York 11935 Dear Mr. Petrucci : As you know, your business on the south side of Bay Avenue, Cutchogue, New York, is classified as a non-conforming marina or boat basin. According to our present zoning ordinance, a non-conformin use is any use,ywhether of a building or tract of land, or bth, ei,ng-on the effective date of the zoning ordinance, which does not conform to the use regulations of the district in which it is located. The definition of a marina is any premises containing one (1) or more piers, wharves, docks, moorings , bulkheads , buildings , slips , basins or lands under water, designed, used or intended to be used primarily for the docking or mooring of boats , for or without compensation. Using your letter of May 17 , 1978 , and the above definitions as a guide, it seems to us that_your non-confo Eierming marina includes_the_ following: Tseasonal operation of a marina or boat basin with docks or slips for not more than thirty-five (35) non-commercial boats not more than 24 feet in length. Specia services or owners such as fresh water, electr1rc r, oil and gasoline are also permitted. We think that this service barge is an integral part of your marina operation and may be stored on your property when not in use . You are not permitted to store boats, build boats or conduct the retail sale of boats on your premises . Hopefully, this clearly defines all permitted uses for your property. If there are any other questions , please bring them to our attention.. ou very -rtly, ROBERT W. GILLIS , c R. CHAIRMAN RWG:bcc cc : Mr. Charles Grigonis Mr. Edward F. Hinderman Southold' MAIN ROAD - STATE ROAD 25 SOUTHOLD, L.I„ N.Y. 11971 TELEPHONE (516) 765.1809 ACTION OF THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Appeal No. 2914 ` Application Dated July 27 , 1982 for a Rehearing TO: [Appellant (s) ] Stephen F. Griffing, Jr, , Esq . (For Norman C. Boos) 120 Court Street, P.O. Box 982 Riverhead, NY 11901 At a Meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals held on September 16 , 1982 the above appeal was considered , and the action indicated below was -taken on your [ ] Request for Variance Due to Lack of Access to Property New York Town Law, Section 280-a [ ] Request for Special Exception under the Zoning Ordinance Article , Section EXA Request for Variance to the Zoning Ordinance Article III , Section 100-31 Article V, Section 100-51 [ ] Request for The Public Rehearing in this matter was held on August 17 , 1982. Rehearing in the Matter of the Application for NORMAN C. BOOS , One Cedar Street, Massapequa, NY 11758 , by Stephen F. Griffing, Jr. , Esq. , for a Variance to the Zoning Ordinance , Article III, Section 100-31 and Article V, Section 100-51 for permission to reduce land area for existing marina by dividing premises into two parcels , one as a marina and one' for residential use , each having insufficient upland area. Location of Property : South side of Bay Avenue (a/k/a 8000 Skunk Lane) , Cutchogue, NY; bounded north by Bay Avenue; west by Brickley; south by Gross; east by Hochbaum; more particularly identified as Suffolk County Tax Map Dis- trict 1000 , Section 104 , Block 8 , Lot 2 . 1. This board by a unanimous vote agreed to review its original decision in this Appeal. This matter was reheard at a regular meeting of this board held on August 17 , 1982 . At such rehearing, appellant presented new and further evidence, all of which is set forth in the minutes 'of said rehearing. Based upon such new evidence , this board finds that strict compli- ance with the zoning code would result in practical difficulties and, accordingly, grants the variance SUBJECT, HOWEVER, TO .THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS , to wit: 1 . That the permission granted herein is only for the7shall uction of one private one-family dwelling on the premises (compris ,871 square feet of which 47 , 364 square feet are under water) , ispeci- fically understood that the marina located on the premises ever be considered a separate parcel of property, and the entire or shall remain in one ownership. [In effect, this property shall not be permitted to be subdivided with the existing uses. ] l 2. That a parking plan with a minimum of forty-three (43) parking spaces for the marina use shall be submitted to and approved by the Planning Board. 3. That the new dwelling proposed to be constructed by the appellant shall be located on the premises as indicated on the map entitled, "Broadwaters Cove Marina , " initialed by the Chairman on August 17 , 1982 ; and that the construction of said dwelling shall com- ply in all respects with all laws and rules and regulations applicable thereto. (CONTINUED ON PAGE TWO) DATED: September 17 , 1982 , CHAIRMAN, SOUTHOLD TOWN ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Form ZB4 (rev. 12/81) Page 2 - Appeal No. 2914 Rehearing: Norman C. Boos Decision Rendered September 16 , 1982 Location of Property: South side of Bay Avenue, Cutchogue, NY; more particularly identified as Suffolk County Tax Map No. 1000-104- 8-2 . 1, Vote of the Board: Ayes : Messrs. Goehringer, Grigonis, Douglass and Sawicki. Absent was : Member Doyen (Fishers Island) . This resolution was unanimously adopted. � * k RECEIVED AND FILED BY PP����� TF1E SOUVOLD TOWN CLF K / � � DATE 47/1719.2 ii Chaim an d6ard of Appeals 'Town Clerk, Town of So told REC—,E® DEC 28 1983 Towyn Clerk Southold We, the undersigned, James Reale, Michelena Reale, Angelo Petrucci, i Georgette Petrucci live on Bay Avenue (Skunk Lane) , Cutchogue directly across the road from Broadwater Cove Marina owned by Norman C. Boos. Noizman C. Boos has applied to the Trustees to construct a floating catwalk with nine fingers for eighteen more Moats in the Broadwater Cove Marina channel. This will obstruct free navigation and be very hazardous to the marina's navigation. Let us not lose sight of the fact that this marina is in a residential area and is a nonconforming zoned piece of property (not zoned for business) . We feel at this time that the marina is operating at its full capacity of thirty five boats as the Southold Town Board of Appeals letter dated June 1, 1978 states and Ms. Boos was well aware of what he bought. The additional fingers or slips increasing the amount of boats stored in this marina would congest and would add additional traffic on an already busy, narrow road and the only road leading in and out of Nassau Point, creating noise and rubbish on the road. There is no parking area for eighteen more boats except on the road not to mention the depreciation of the real estate properties in our area. When launching boats it creates a traffic back up and is a hazzard because boats being launched need the complete width of Bay Avenue (Skunk Lane) . The increase in boats stored. in this dead end marina with people sleeping on board overnight certainly has to create problems on water pollution and the environment. We hope the Planning Board, Board of Appeals, Building Department and Trustees will take these above facts Linder consideration when making their decisions. We would appreciate your notifying us whenever this matter comes before the Southold Town Board of Appeals so that we can express our opinion on this matter at those meetings. �1�f`���:.:� /Gr..,E'er ��4��., lei'-�:.%�.�- �•.`��.�.--% �-.,..� ����?1�.�-� :..�' 7�y �/o,�- 75 /J�r.%�'(.4'i(,l�i'e,y�.' � �"�� `{/ //C./Q, ly��(r'� :� ����.Cl' �,.'- a�:i<° �G�LG':L�� '-t /�• / ��,.t�t_-�j% �, t �%,l�r�L:._l,c;-`. L/ 3�1.� (/��'�i'�)tel+-':r%/���/�U'GGz^.��� I%JIi.S.t,�)i��C�%/✓(/';,y.tl '�� '•' � � r� ,- _ 'p� _U` I✓u �C��� I.C'�2.c-�..r�C.z�' J�)1 G ��l'',�,-,t.,,'- (_=��efL�Lf-4J��L��c-r�-- �CL�J�jy��''`�! �1-�' f 1,;; %_Y; - r t loay- a-64�4 a__ -----c - y J r4 CC. Southold Town Supervisor Francis J. Murphy Southold Town Attorney Robert W. Tasker Southold Town Clerk Judith T. Terry Building Dept. Executive Administrator Victor Lessard Building Inspector George Fisher Building Inspector Curtis Horton Building Inspector Edward Hindermann Southold Town Planning Board Chairman Henry Raynor & Members Southold Town Appeals Board Chairman Gerard Goehringer & MeaThe-rs Southold Town Trustees Chairman & Members President Nassau Point Association President Nassau Farnns Association President Broadwater Cove Association 1 .ti Southld Town Boarof Appeals d t ®UTHOLDQ L. 1 Ne Y. 11971 TELEPHONE 765 1802 APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS June 1 , 1978 ROBERT 1N.GILLISPIE,JR.,CHAIRMAN ROBERT BERGEN CHARLES GRIGONIS,JR. ,FRGE DOYEN,JR. Norman C. BOOS AxqA5tx=' RA )" Bought Mr. Angelo Petrucci Marina August 23, 1978 Mr. Angelo G . Petrucci Bay Avenue Cutchogue , New York 11935 Dear Mr. Petrucci : As you know, your business on the south side of Bay Avenue, Cutchogue, New York, is classified as _La. non-conforming_marina or boat basin. According to our present_ zoning ordinance , a non-conform'ln _use is any use, whether of a building or tract of land, or both, e�c�sting on the effective date of the zoning ordinance, which does not conform to the use regulations of the district in which it is located. The definition of a marina is any premises containing one (1) or more piers, wharves, docks, moorings , bulkheads , buildings , slips , basins or lands under water, designed, used or intended to be used primarily for the docking or mooring of boats , for or without compensation. Using your letter of May 17 , 1978 , and the above definitions as a guide, it seems to us that our non-conforming g .mar_ina includes the following -— -- - T�ie seasonal operation of a rnarin or boat basin with docks or slips for riot more than thirty-five (35) non-commercial boats not more than 24 feet in length. Specla- servi.cess or owners such as fresh water, electirm, , oil and gasoline are also permitted. We think that this service barge is an integral part of your marina operation and may be stored on your property when not in use . You are not permitted to store boats , build boats or conduct the retail sale of boats on your premises . Hopefully, this clearly defines all permitted uses for your property. If there are any other questions , please bring them to our attention. ou very r ly, ROBERT W. GILLIS , R. CHAI P14AN RWG:bcc cc : Mr. Charles Grigonis Mr. Edward F . Hinderman ®c�vFFUL -�� M_ 3 outhold Town Board of Appeals MAIN ROAD - STATE: ROAD 25 SOUTHOLD, L.I.. N.Y. 11971 TELEPHONE (516) 765-1809 ACTION OF THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Appeal No. 2914 Application Dated July 27, 1982 for a Rehearing TO: [Appellant (s) ] Stephen F. Griffing, Jr. , Esq. (For Norman C. Boos) 120 Court Street, P.O. Box 982 Riverhead, NY 11901 At a Meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals' held on September 16 , 1982 the above appeal was considered, and the action indicated below was eaten on your [ ] Request for Variance Due to Lack of Access to Property New York Town Law, Section 280-a [ ] Request for Special Exception under the Zoning Ordinance Article , Section [XX] Request for Variance to the Zoning Ordinance Article III , Section 100-31 Article V, Section 100-51 [ ] Request for The Public Rehearing in this matter was held on August 17, 1982. Rehearing in the Matter of the Application for NORMAN C. BOOS , One Cedar Street, Massapequa, NY 11758 , by Stephen F. Griffing, Jr. , Esq. , for a Variance to the Zoning Ordinance , Article III, Section 100-31 and Article V, Section 100-51 for permission to reduce land area for existing marina by dividing premises into two parcels , one as a marina and one' for residential use, each having insufficient upland area. Location of Property: South side of Bay Avenue (a/k/a 8000 Skunk Lane) , Cutchogue, NY; bounded north by Bay Avenue; west by Brickley; south by Gross; east by Hochbaum; more particularly identified as Suffolk County Tax Map Dis- trict 1000 , Section 104 , Block 8 , Lot 2 . 1. This board by a unanimous vote agreed to review its original decision in this Appeal. This matter was reheard at a regular meeting of this board held on August 17, 1982 . At such rehearing, appellant presented new and further evidence, all of which is set forth in the minutes 'of said rehearing. Based upon such new evidence, this board finds that strict compli- ance with the zoning code would result in practical difficulties and, accordingly, grants the variance SUBJECT, HOWEVER, TO .THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS, to wit: 1. That the permission granted herein is only for the construction of one private one-family dwelling on the premises (comprising 117 ,871 square feet of which 47, 364 square feet are under water) , it being speci- fically understood that the marina located on the premises shall never be considered a separate parcel of property, and the entire premises shall remain in one ownership. [In effect, this property shall not be permitted to be subdivided with the existing uses. ] 2. That a parking plan with a minimum of forty-three (43) parking ' spaces for the marina _ use shall be submitted to ich_napproved-by tFie Planning Board. 3. That the new dwelling proposed to be constructed by the appellant shall be located on the premises as indicated on the map entitled, "Broadwaters Cove Marina, " initialed by the Chairman on August 17 , 1982; and that the construction of said dwelling shall com- ply in all respects with all laws and rules and regulations applicable thereto. (CONTINUED ON PAGE TWO) DATED: September 17 , 1982. CHAIRMAN, SOUTHOLD TOWN ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS Form ZB4 (rev. 12/81) Page- 2 - Appeal No. 2914 Rehearing: Norman C. Boos Decision Rendered September 16 , 1982 Location of Property: South side of Bay Avenue, Cutchogue, NY; more particularly identified as Suffolk County Tax Map No. 1000-104- 8-2 . 1. Vote of the Board: Ayes: Messrs. Goehringer, Grigonis, Douglass and Sawicki. Absent was : Member Doyen (Fishers Island) . This resolution was unanimously adopted. praCEIVED AND FIT BY VE APPS ,yf,E SOUT1,0LD TOV114 CF-PZ DATEq))7/9,2 Chairrdan B6ard of Appeals Town Clerk, Town of So cold . o��FFo�co V3 • TELEPHONE (516) 765-1892 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD RECEIVED Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 DEC 14 10 Southold, New York 11971 Town Clerk Southold December 14, 1983 Mrs. Judith T. Terry Town Clerk Town Hall Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Dear Mrs. Terry: Transmitted herewith is the action taken by the Board of Town Trustees at a regular meeting held on December 13, 1983: RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board to TABLE the application of Mr. Norman C. Boos until the Building Department and the Board of Appeals transmits their comments on said application. Very truly yours, Board of Town Trustees Paul Stoutenburgh I President ip SOUTHOLD TOWN CONSERVATION ADVISORY COUNCIL RECEIVED Southold, N. Y. November 23 , 1983 Town C+erk Southold Mrs. Judith Terry Town Clerk Main Road Southold, NY 11971 Dear Mrs. Terry: The following action was taken by the Conservation Advisory Council at a regular meeting held Tuesday, November 22, 1983 . RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board approval " of the wetland application #170 submitted by Michael Carlucci to construct a bulkhead and floating dock. Conkling Point Creek, Greenport. RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board aproval of the wetland application #171 submitted by William B. Smith on behalf of Augustus Fink, Jr. to construct three (3) catwalks and floating docks. Cedar Beach Creek, Southold. RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board approval of the wetland application #172 submitted by a2Kaa-a—B9oss to construct a floating catwalk with 9 fingers to accomodate 18 additional small boats. Approval to be given with the stipulation that the Trustees inspect and approve. When the above has been completed, the channel will be only half the width forcing boat traffice up close to the opposite side of the channel where there is a lot of spartina grass. This traffic will cause undo damage. Broadwaters Cove. Cutchogue. RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board approval of the wetland application #173 submitted by Grace A. Finora to construct a floating dock. James Creek, Mattituck. Respectfully submitted, FRANK CICHANOWICZ, CHAIRMAN By Jane Moffatt, Secretary Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 4 JUDITH T.TERRY _ `rt 3 ">�' TELEPHONE -.a.. TOWN CLERK (516)765-1801 REGISTRAR OF VITAL STATISTICS OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD November 7, 1983 Mr. Victor G. Lessard Executive Administrator Southold Town Hall Southold, New York 11971 Dear Victor: Attached, hereto is the application of Norman C. Boos for a Wetland Permit, as well as his prior application and permit and action of the Board of Appeals concerning his non-conforming property. The Town Board questions whether Mr. Boos' proposal to construct additional floating catwalk to accomodate 18 additional small boats is an expansion of an existing non-conforming use I have asked this same question of the Board of Appeals and there is attached hereto an Interdepartment Memorandum dated this date, which suggests this be referred to you for clarification. May I have your opinion in this matter before moving forward. Very truly yours, Judith T. Terry Southold Town Clerk Attachments Southold Town Board of Appeals MAIN ROAD - STATE ROAD 25 SOUTHOLD, L.I., N.Y. 11971 TELEPHONE (516) 765-1809 APPEALS BOARD MEMBERS GERARD P. GOEHRINGER, CHAIRMAN CHARLES GRIGONIS, JR. SERGE DOYEN, JR. ROBERT J. DOUGLASS JOSEPH H. SAWICKI INTERDEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM TO: Judith T. Terry, Town Clerk FROM: Jerry Goehringer, Chairman, Z .B.A. DATE: November 7, 1983 SUBJECT: Premises Now of Norman C. Boos (formerly of A. Petrucci) Location: South Side Bay Avenue, Cutchogue County Tax Map Parcel Nos. 1000-104-008-2 .1 and 2.3 This memorandum is in reply to your November 3 , 1983 request con- cerning the premises of Norman C. Boos and located at the south side of Bay Avenue, Cutchogue. We have reviewed the documents submitted with your request and have researched the history of this property, finding as follows: (A) The marina has been in existence as a nonconforming use since the adoption of zoning in 1957 and is located in an "A-Residential and Agricultural Zone. " (B) Pursuant to a ZBA letter of clarification to Angelo Petrucci, who was the former owner of the premises, dated June 1, 1978 : (1) . Operation of this marina was restricted to not more than 35 noncommercial boats, not more than 24 feet in length; (2) No storage of boats and no sales of boats would be allowed. (C) In Appeal No. 2914, a conditional variance was granted allowing Memorandum -November 7, 1983 Judith T. Terry, Town Clerk Re: Norman C. Boos Property the construction of a one-family private dwelling, provided: (1) the entire premises remain as one parcel [117,871 sq. ft. of 'which 47,364 sq. ft. are under water] ; (2) there be a minimum of 43 parking spaces for the marina use to be submitted to and approved by the Planning Board; (3) construction of the new one-family dwelling as per the filed site plan and in compliance with all other applicable laws and regulations. (D) Wetlands Permit #45 allowed certain dredging and bulkheading west of the existing marina; (E) The recently-filed Wetlands Permit Application #172 ' requests the placement of additional catwalk (s) with fingers to accommodate 18 additional boats. it is our opinion that expansion of this nonconforming marina to accommodate more than 35 noncommercial boats would require addi- tional approvals. Due to the fact that this is a "nonconforming" marina in a resi- dential area, any proposed changes to this property should be referred to the Building Department for their certification. 9 Z47, -gu' Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. BOX 728 Southold, New York 11971 JUDITH T TERRY TOWN CLERK ` -� TELEPHONE (516)765-1801 REGISTRAR OP VITAL STATISTICS OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD November 3, 1983 Mr. Gerald Goehringer, Chairman Southold Town Board of Appeals Southold, New York 11971 Dear Jerry: Attached hereto is the application of Norman C. Boos for a Wetland Permit. The Town Board questions whether Mr. Boos' proposal to construct additional floating catwalk to accomodate 18 additional small boats is an expansion of an existing non-conforming use and should, therefore, be addressed by the Board of Appeals May 1 have your opinion in this matter, and if in the affirmative, the necessary forms I may transmit to Mr. Boos for an application before your Board. For your further information, 1 am also attaching herewith a former Wetland application and permit issued by the Town Board in 1980. Very truly yours, Judith T. Terry Southold Town Clerk Attachments nY sv-, ri,�`�rrtz§6yvrY�.r f Town Hall, 53095 Main Road �`'" i` P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 JUDITH T TERRY � A> ~' TELEPHONE TowN CLERK (516)765-1801 REGISTRAR Or VITAL STM ISTICS OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD October 31, 1983 Southold Town Board Southold Town Hall Southold, New York 11971 Gentlemen: Transmitted herewith is application no. 172 for a wetland permit submitted by Norman C. Boos. Copies of this application have been forwarded to the Board of Southold Town Trustees and Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council on this date for their report of findings and recommendations. Very truly yours, Judith T. Terry Southold Town Clerk Attachment S�f b � Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. BOX 728 Southold, New York 11971 JUDITH T TERRY TELEPHONE TOWN CLERI: (516)765-1801 REGISTRAR 01:VITAL STAT ISTICS OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD October 31, 1983 Mr . Frank Cichanowicz, III , Chairman Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council Southold Town Hall Southold, New York 11971 Dear Mr . Cichanowicz: Transmitted herewith is application no�-72 for a wetland permit submitted by Norman C. Boos. Please prepare a written report of findings and recommendations with respect to this application. Very truly yours, Judith T. Terry Southold Town Clerk Attachment _ f 9 � : Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 t, Southold, New York 11971 JUDITH T.TERRY TELEPHONE TOWN CLERK (516)765-1801 REGISTRAR of VITAL STATISTICS OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD October 31, 1983 Mr . Paul Stoutenburgh, President Board of Southold Town Trustees Southold Town Hall `. Southold, New York 11971 Dear Mr. Stoutenburgh: Transmitted herewith is application no. 172 for a wetland permit submitted by Norman C. Boos. Please prepare a written report of findings and recommendations with respect to this application. .- . Very truly yours, Judith T. Terry Southold Town Clerk Attachment _ �- y Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Esc 01 . Southold, New York 11971 JUDITH T TERRY ~> ¢' "Y TELEPHONE TOWN CLERK (516)765-1801 REGISTRAR 01 VITAL STAI ISTICS OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD October 31, 1983 To Whom It May Concern: Attached hereto is Environmental Assessment Form completed by Norman C. Boos in connection with his wetlaland application no. 172 for a wetland permit . Permission is requested to construct floating catwalk with fingers at Broadwaters Cove off west side of Bay Avenue, Cutchogue, New York. �Judith T. Terry Southold Town Clerk Posted on Town Clerk' s Bulletin Board on 10/31/83 r TOWN OF SOUTHOLD SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM INSTRUCTIONS : a in order to answer the -questions in this ' short' EAF it is assume I concerning t that the preparer will use currently available he project and the likely impacts of the action . It is not expected that additional studies, research or other investigations will be undertaken. (b) If any question has been answered Yes the project may be significant and a completed Environmental Assessment Form is necessary. (c) If all questions have been answered No it is likely that this project is not significant . _ (d) Environmental Assessment I . Will project resu t in a large physical change to the project site or physically alter more than 10 acres of land? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes_KNo 2. Will there be a major change to any unique or unusual land form found on the site? . . . . . . : . . . YesXNo 3 . Will project alter or have a large effect on -- existing body of water? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yes - 4. Will project have a potentially large impact • on grounNo dwater quality? . . . . . . Yes o 5 . Will project significantly effect drainage . . �'N flow on adjacent sites? . . . . . . . . .. . .I. . . . . . . ... . . . . Yes No 6 . Will project affect any threatened or endangered plant or animal species? . . . . . . . . . . . Yes VNo 7. Will project result in a major adverse effect on air quality? . • . . . . . Yes No 8 . Will project have amajoreffectonvisual character of the community or scenic views or vistas known to be important to the community? YesNo 9 . Will project adversely impact any site or A_ structure of historic, prehistoric or paleontological importance or any site designated as a critical environmental area by a local agency? . : YesNo 10. Will project have a �'major �effect .on .existing or future recreational opportunities? . . . . . . . . . Yes VNO 11 . Will project result in major traffic problems or cause a major effect to existing transportation systems? ."': . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -- Yes No 12. Will project ',regularl.y cause objectionable odors, noise, glare, vibration, •or electrical disturbance as a result of the project ' s operation? . • .-. . . Yes\/No 13 . Will project hav,e anyimpacton•public�health . • or safety? . . . Yes\/No 14. Will project affecttheexist-ing �community �by � j directly causing a growth in -permanent population of more than 5 -percent over a one year period or- have a major negative effect on the character of the eo_ mmunity or j neighborhood? . ., . . . Yes No 15 . Is there public controversyconcerning �the . � �— project? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . YesNo ; PREPARER ' S SIGNATURE 42ZZAZ _ REPP.ESENT ING_ .5'eL _ DAT-E " Town Of Southold Town Clerk's Office Southold, N. Y. RECENVED %T 2 ` 19x33 APPLICATION FOR WETLA1 MS PERMIT Application No. ...1..7cL........... Date of Application ..... ..Qe.t.,....24.�,.,1,98.3.......... Identity of Applicant .................................................. Address of Applicant ........1„Cedar NY 11758 .... .... ...................................... INST°UCTIONS FOR PERMIT A. This application is to be completely filled in by typewriter or ink and submitted to the Town Clerk in quadruplicate, accompanied by written• permission from the owner of the property if-not=::- the some as the applicant. - B. Pilot Plan must be drawn to scale on the reverse side of this application showing the locaticn of property, the names and locations of owners of adjoining properties, and a detailed description of proposed project. (Note: Copies of the Pilot Plan may be made by a copy machine and attached to the Permit Application.) C. No operation shall be initiated by the applicant until all permits that are required are issued D. A detailed statement of the rehabilitation and prc,posed condition of the premises after the work is completed must be given, including a survey if required. E. It permit is being sought for a more sizeable excavation 'than the construction of a private single dock or jetty, then this application must be accompanied by a survey and topographical map certified by a registered land survey or Professional Engineer. The horizontal control of survey shall be based upon an approval local coordinate system. The vertical control for elevation and sound- ings shall be based upon United States Coast and Geodetic Survey and/or United States Geological Survey datum. F. A statement must accompany the application describing any known prior operations conducted on the premises in question and whether any prior licenses or permits have been issued to erect structures or to dredge or deposit fill on said premises and whether any such permits or licenses were ever revoked or suspended b Pe y a governmental agency. G. A filing fee of $25.00 shall accompany the applicotion. This filing fee includes one inspection there is a $5.00 fee for each additional inspection. i H. The Town Board upon requestq- ti� applicant for a permit, may waive in whole or in port, the provisicns of Article II, Section 24--0, subdivisions (b and kC-Y where it finds that nature of the 9 proposed operations are such that the requirements of such provisions are not necessary for a proper consideration of a permit application. I Upon eoproval of this application the Town Clerk will issue a permit to the applicant. Such ermit shall be avoilcble for inspection at any time, upon request, Examined .................................................. 19....... Appro-ved ............................................................ .. Disapproved ........................................................... Cnn,4itio^.e, if any ...... .................. .. ........... .... . .... ..... . ................._ ........... + .................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................. ExaminingBody ..................................................................................................................................... Signatureof Chairman ......................................................................................................................... APPLICATION IS HEREBY MAD` to the Town Board of the Town of Southold, Suffolk Ccunt/, New York, for the issuance of a permit pursuant to the Laws, Ordinances and Regulations covem- ing the Coastal and Interior Wetlands, Flood Plains and Drainage Areas of the Town of'Saurhold: Permit requested to ...conUtruct... p,groj-...175 lineal feet3 '6" wide floating . .................................z............................................ catwalk with 9 fingers approx. 316" x 1616" long to accomodate .................. ... .................................................................................... 18 additionalsmall boats . Location of property for which permit wanted....Broadwaters. Cove n.Iarina�........................ 8000 Skunk Lane , Cutchogue, NY 11935 .................................................................................................................................................................. Home address of permit applicant if different from aforesaid location ...1...Leda-r..S.t................... .................Massapequa,...NY,Mas§Apje�qM,...NYA.1.75.8................................................................................................. Creek, Boy or Harbor fronting property ......Bxoadwat-er...Cove....................................................... .................................................................................................................................................................. Size of proposed work: Length .....1.7.5...1.,.1.....QUIwa.1,k...-Aild...9..a.C.!.6.!!.. ].ng�X: ... .total...approx:..325...1 ..f.. Width .....3.16...11 . ..................................................................................................................................•. Height Above High Waterfl oate..ag. .do.eks...................................................................................... DepthBelow Low Water ..........-......................................................................................... ................... Yardsto be Excavated ......MQU0............................................................................................................ Yardsto be Filled ..............noUe............................................................................................................ Width of canal, creek or bay fronting property.....§Q' ..................................................................... Depthat Low Tide ................4.......... .................................................................................................. Averc7eRise in Tide ............................................................................................................................. �r Is this for private or business use% ...........bUS.], e. s........................................................................... Area 'ening .......Nwi-.corifAx:(Ding..pA:e-,exis.ting...marina................................................... Mcnner in which material will be removed or deposited ........4IDAQ.................. .......... ...................................................................................................................................................... Intended use of property ..........additional dockage . ......................................................................................................... .... ............................................................................................................................................................. Written consent of owner of preoerty, if not the same as the cpplicont ........................................ .................................................................................................................................................................. .................................................................................................................................................................. COUNTY OF SUFFOLK ) STATE OF NEW YORK ) SS: Ndr ....Gooc. . ...................... ........................................ being duly sworn de::cses and says that he is the copi liccnt for the above descried eermit, and that all statements contained herein cre true to the best of his knowledge and belief; that the work will be done in the manner set for'h in this ac-chcarncn end as may be ccprcved by the Tc,,vn Bocrd of the Town of The c2pliccnr agrees to hold the Town of Southcid and the Town Ecord harmless cnd free from any and ail damages and claims arising under or by virtue of sold permit, if grgnted. .a ..lO . ........ Sig t re cr Apol�ccr;t Sworn to before me this .. 4.4................... dcv of ...QAJ:h —!......................... 19. 'a�..... ............. A 1111-4 h' i' .y rublic Notary-Public, Slate of New York No. 30-4753140 . Qualified in 'Nassau County Commission expires March 30, 198S rB' Norman C . Boos Application for Wetlands Permit F) Marina is a Pre-existing marina. Prior licenses and permits as follows: Army Corps of Engineers #11112 Dated 8203/79 To construct 440 L.F. Bulkhead D .E. C. #TIV15276-0109"A" SP IVQ Dated 1/12/79 To construct 440 L.F. Bulkhead D.E.C. #TIT-15276-0109"A" PW IVQ Construct 30 ' x 10 ' ramp DEC 10 81-0184 Dated 1081 Construct 1 family house . Town of Southold dated 10/26/82 #11982 Construct 1 family house r ' i -�6' t6 7% 1-4 yXY 0A P1JC III LA I - ` J BROADIVUATERS COVE MARINA Norman C. Boos - : "-,;_ � • __- _" -- �,16A I ale - tri 74 tz OZ ^, -.r.-�" �>-�"?`'�' -'-:En_«tet.`•'-a,.-'F- - - '"v'Rrt - S�_.. ... - - _ rP - - - - ,-F`, � - - I• tf ,y= 4 . - • . _.. .. � .. ,soy. + ._ s � - _ _ � vlr. H�usE �g,G7 2.5, ie' FLAB _ pal UT _ `. p i �� pos.� ar1-ou 1aOA ,asodoi ,. sHAOD SEUVAIQVOUR :_ 1 . _- -- — 69.63 = 'flogNY Avt� f e u 1-- ittic �r 77 ` 0 d�,p t �' i ��' D v e of j c qjr. YoJ - F IN, 1\•t' r I W '' 4.1 Er c� 1 Op nr OH_ v 00 411_ !' • _ i •t1Y _ .�All I NORMAN C~ 800S AT ~%~$T CUTCHO~UE TOV/N OF $OUTHOLD SUFFOLK COUNTY, N. Y · ~PR/L 2~,/985 AVENUE Ar. 85e 46' 00"£. MAR/N~ N/O/F' /2.79'