Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutTR-4368 - ~ TRUSTEES John M. Bredemeyer. III. President Albert 1. Krupski. Jr.. Vice President Henry P. Smith John B. Ththill William G. Albertson Thlephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Office Use Only: ~ Coastal Erosion Permit Application Coastal Erosion Variance Application Wetland Permit Application Waiver from Chapter 97(Application/permi Trustee Lands Permit Application Grandfather Permit Application Completed Apps. Date:J-Ji-7~ Inspection date: 4-;'U' 'i'f 'fL.,.! CAC comments-Date: Sent~lJçuRec'~?i Variance Required: (Y/N~ Neighbors notified-Date: /' SEQRA Type .(JO \;;..!41. CÐo\d. I v"Coord.: Date. sent '. '-f-"vr-If<{ ,.,.:¿.j :¡;~' . ct. vSEQ~ DeterJ~\J.n./date:h,lY-f'f sIt! 9-111'--' v-1?ubhc Hear~ng/date: 'r-J.,S-:- 7 Y ¡'U Findings: Approved (Y/N) Special Conditions: (Y/N) (see file) Permit(s) issued-date: 'bee. Application Number;SCTM#lOOO- 94-1-14 . SUPERVISOR SCOTT L. HARRIS Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 DATE REC,: œ rn:R~::Œ ill Tn'···· ..-, It.... ,to '-- . ~ 0 :"-.; J'"\ MAR 3 0 1994 Date: 3/25/94 Applicant: Proper-T Permit Services for Ronald Stritzler Address: P.O. Box 617 Cutchogue, NY 11935 Phone (516) 734-5800 Interest: (owner, consultant, lessee, etc.) Consultant/agent Owner of Property: Ronald Stritzler Address 51 Stirrup Lanr Roslyn Heights, NY 11577 Phone ( Subject Property Location: 3055 Sound view Avenue, Mattituck (See attached maps.) (Provide LILCO Pole #, Distance to cross Streets if not on location map) THIS IS NOT A PERMIT Page 1 · ,* See .p~ect description. Yds. to be excavated: * 1ds. to be filled: * Manner in which material will be removed or deposited: Width of canal, creek or bay fronting property: N/A Depth at low tide: N/A Aver. rise in tide: N/A Distance to nearest channel: N/A Distance project extends beyond similar projects in area: N/A Area zoning: R-80 Land area in acres: 0.82 horizontal projection Is project for private or business use: Private Intended use of property:, Private residence Describe known prior operations conducted on premises: Construction of one-family private residencé. Has any prior license or permit been issued to erect structures, dredge, or deposit fill on said premises: Not to knowledge. Has any license or permit ever been revoked or suspended by a Governmental Agency: Not to knowledge. Project Description The project description must also include plans for reclamation of land disturbed during construction of the principle and accessory structures and underground structures (i.e., pipeline and septic system; make additional attachments if necessary). See attached sheet. THIS IS NOT A PERMIT Page 2 . . Proper-T Permit Services POST OFFICE BOX 617, CUTCHOOUE, NEW YORK 11935 (516) 734 -5800 March 25, 1994 PROJECT DESCRIPTION; Application of Ronald Stritzler Construct retaining wall 410' long, typically 6' above grade, with returns at each end, Length of returns estimated from survey to be 12' at west end and 22' at east end; actual lengths to be determined during construction by intersection of top of retaining wall with face of bluff. Smooth face of bluff, in accordance with recommendations of Suffolk County Soil and Water Conservation District, to permit revegetation and minimize further erosion fron run-off; use material resulting from smoothing as backfill behind retaining wall. a subsidiary 01 THE PECON/C EASTERN CORPORATION . . "·16··12167)-Te"12 I PROJECT I.D. NUMBER 811.21 Appendix C Sllle Envlronmenlel QUlllly Rlvlew SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM For UNLIsTED ACTIONS Only PART I-PROJECT INFORMATION (To be completed by Appllclnt or ProJect ~ponsor) SEaR 1. APPLICANT /sPONSOR I 2. PROJECT NAME James E. Fitzqerald, Jr. Stritzler retaining wall 3. PROJECT LOCATION: Munlelpallly Southold County Suffolk 4. PRECISE lOCATION (Street Iddress Bnd rOld Intersecllons. promlnenllandmarkl, etc., or provide map) 3055 Sound View Avenue, Mattituck, NY 11952 See attached map!;;. 5. IS PROPOSED ACTION: rn New o Expansion o ModUleallon/.neratlo" 6. DESCRIBE PROJECT BRIEFLY: See attached sheet. 7. AMOUNT OF LAND AFFECTED: N/A *horizontal projection Inlllally 0 . 82 acres *ae,ea Ulllmately acrla 8. WILL PROPOSED ACTION COMPLV WITH EXISTING ZONING OR OTHER EXISTING LAND USE RESTRICTIONS? i:2'Ivaa oNo " No, describe briefly g. WHAT IS PRESENT LAND USE IN VICINITY OF PROJECT? 121 Re.ld.n"al o InduOl,lel o Commercial o Ag,leullur. o Park/Forest/Open IIplce oOlha' Describe: Medium-sized private residences 10. DOES ACTION INVOLVE A PERMIT APPROVAL, OR FUNDING, NOW OR ULTlMATELV FROM ANY OTHER OOVERNMENTAL AOENCV (FEDERAL, STATE OR LOCAL)? ÈjV.. oNo II yes, IIsl loency(s) and permit/approval, No approvals to date. Permits: NYSDEC, Southold Board of .Town Trustees 11. DOES ANY ASPECT OF THE ACTION HAVE A CURRENTLY VALID PERMIT OR APPROVAL? o v.. tJNo If yes, list Igency "Imll and permltllpprOYl1 12. AS A RESULT OF PROPOSED ACTION WILL EXISTlNO PERMIT/APPROVAL REQUIRE MODIFICATION? oVe. (J No I CERTIFY THAT THE INFORMATION PRoVID~D ABOV~ 1& TRUE TO THE BEST OF MV KNOWLEDOE ~a~e~ E. Fitz~~rald~~~roper-T Permi~ Services Mar 25, 1994 . pp can Sponsor name: ~ / I //.... . ....-;---... Dale: C ~ /! / ,;.~ 'v' /' L Slgnalu,e: ( u,,//Jr ¿..J 'i1,c?,"¿¡ ti'Í1J! . J ,/;I / tf'í v _v , Ihe acllon 'S In Ihe Coaslal Area, and you are a state agency, complete the Coastal Asse8Bment Form before proceeding wlIh this aU.ssmenl OVER 1 . . fõ)Œ®Œß\'IlŒ~ lJü APR 2 8 1994 æJ rF\\t'iN OF SOUTH OLD 51 Stirrup Lane Roslyn Heights, New York 11577 October 25, 1993 President Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall, 53095 Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Dear Sir: Please be advised that I hereby designate and authorize James E. Fitzgerald, Jr. of Proper-T Permit Services to act in my behalf as my agent in the submission and processing of a permit application for the construction of a retaining wall on my property located at 3055 Sound View Avenue and designated by Suffolk County Tax Map No. 1000-94-1-14, and to furnish, upon request, supplemental information in support of the application. Yours truly, ~~ ~yV17 Ronald Stritzler, MD . . THE AREA OF THE PROPOSED PROJECT IS CIRCLED /JurA: P01'ld. E'f V1:C1:N1:TY HAl? , , , , , . .~ SUFFOLk COURT' (HAGSTROM) NORTH RACE VICINITY HAP Application No. reqðtding the-propêrty o¡-- RONALD STRI'TZLER Suffolk County Tax Hap No. 1000-94-1-14 Represented by Proper-T Ser~~~ea P.O. Box 617, Cutchogue, NY 11935 James E. Fitzgerald, Jr. 516-734-5800 Sheet of Hatch IB, 1994 . TAX MAP SUFFOLk COURTY, ft.Y. District 1000, Section 94 THE SITE OF THE PROPOSED PROJECT IS CROSS-HATCHED ." o· , ." ..0 " tU. "_00, "" .n Of' .~'Of' -~'·o~. 'oo "",,!,... "n 0«000_ ·a.-~ol ·..."k z z . " lit R' .. '. " \ ',,- \, " \ \ z \ \ \ ".\ \ \ \ \ //~ "- .~,:.:." .."...."..\ ,. TAX MAP --~~-- ---- ApplicaHon No. regArding the-prõperty 01'- RONALD S-ray-rZLER Suffolk County Tax Hap No. 1000-94-1-14 Represented by Pr~pe~-T Services P.O. Box 617, cutchogue, NY 11935 James E. Fitzgerald. Jr. 516-7~4-5800 Sheet of Harch 18, 1994 ID'd. )<.. Il,'''PILES óIQ.C. 31-10"- 14' T't'1'i;- alEATtlJtitr . :5EAWA~ -=:t~---- bY, b WAl,E.R. ! I ~ . INIDjA}',jU) ~ ~¡t.b +OLLDW~R. b'f.l:, 'A 4' :iJUrrBWCK'5 AT JOINT5 IMPORTANT NOTE: THIS DRAWING REPRESENTS A TYPICAL CROSS SECTION OF TH~SED CON- STRUCTION. SITE CONDITIONS MAY REQUIRE MINOR VARIATIONS, 3/,!-' ììE PDQ fjE.tV GrA\)E:.. VF1kTER. l!Wn1 I I L_ EX\5TINS- GiI?A'bE l , ~ , 1 ~ B'd1ilk~ C'I..OI'/ti'; 6'a(!, B'd. fufT/1'/ tX>lYó JEAlJ~~'i ALL Wt-fBËR.. IQ î\E.. c.c.A -PRE.::t5~. WEATtb. NL AAeJ)WARE. KJ 1JE. ~f.v^NIZ.E:j), SCA.lE 1z' ~ l' SBCTXON VIBW Application No. regarding the property of RONA~D aTR~TZ~ER Suffolk County Tax Hap No, 1000-94-1-14 Represented by Prpper-T Services P.O. Box 617, Cutchogue, NY 11935 Jamsa B. fitzgerald, Jr. 516-734-5800 Sheet of Harch 18, 1994 . . STATEMENT TO THE SOUTHOLD BOARD OF TQ!oi!:LTRUSTEES County of --rJ{¡f.i}~-) State of New York ) I, Ronald Stritzler, belng duly sworn, depose and affirm that I am the owner of the property located at 3055 Sound View Avenue, Mattltuck, New York and identified by Suffolk County Tax Map No. 1000-94-1-14, and that all work will be done in the manner set forth in the present application and as may be approved by the Southold Board of Town Trustees. I agree to hold the Town of Southold and the Town Trustees harmless and free from any and all damages and claims arising under or by virtue of said permit(s), if granted. I hereby authorize the Town Trustees, or their agent(s) or representative(s) to enter upon my property to inspect the premises in conjunction with the review of the present application. 1 II. lYX~¿¡I. .1h.vv-yY7. Signature Sworn to . 1-1 V¡' /1'\ I 11n ., I, L/'} .s e thls ...~J.. day of ./.l.,.,J..;l.,iV,UY-/J....., 19. , .... .... . ,~~¿c:,,¡ft<-- Notary Public I K~TH','." '1' '_¡', :~> ~OTAR': ,'~J~t_:: ",.. , ",' Yq :-¡o" _. /' Qualm.__" ;,~ "". ',Ct::/" ~ommlssic.l :x.; ir~s lull ...1, ì9-L1 " . . TRUSTEES John M. Bredemeyer, III, President Albert J. Krupski, Jr., Vice President Henry P. Smith John B. 1\¡!hill William G, Albertson Thlephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 surERVISOR SCOTT L HARRIS Thwn Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 SoUlhold, New York 11971 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD 30 year Maintenance Agreement Erosion Protection structures Chapter 37 Southold Town Code Southold Tr4stees as Administrator I (we) Ronald Stritzler type or print name(s) the owners of record of property at! o 5 Sound View Avenue Mattituck (type or print street address SCTM 11000- in applying for a Coastal Erosion permit for a~Erosion Protection structure do hereby agree to a 30 year maintenance program for a structure commonly known as a retaining wall of approximately 435 feet as shown on the attached feet of length licensed survey of the as-built structure. It is my/our understanding that we are to maintain this structure with materials designed to endure 30 years and or equivalent to the original approved structure and that for any maintenance which involves more than 5% in length of this structUre we are to give prior written notice to the administrator, waiting for their approval in all but true emergency situation's which would seriously endanger life 1 property and important coastal natural resource features such as bluffs or wetlands. We further understand that failure to maintain the structure could result in a requirement to post a bond and or have the repairs ordered as a lien against the property UpQn a finding by the 'rrustees that said lack of maintenance would risk life 1 property or important natural resources features including protected 1 rare or threatened animals and plants. ~4.-'(7).¡ V' [~~'11::{~ SWORN TO BEFORE ME THIS :!..o,d.- DAY OF ÙC/r-~ 119-1...) ~11.,,) f'l7 I1-t £.d.L- NOT Y PUBLIC NOrAIIY ROSE M. PURCEu. .' PUøL/ ;. s.... of New...... .... 1~~4t-4'6'32t - Comm"",,o ,,_In a....,¡¡~. - ,.."". June 30, t Please submit three copies of a licensed lan survey made within one year of the original construction. This maintenance agreement shall only be valid upon the final approval of the administrator. Subsequent owners may apply to the Southold Town Trustees to re-authorize this maintenance agreement. · Proper-T Permit Services :. POST OFFICE BOX 617, CUTCHOGUE, NEW YORK 11935-0617 .\priI19. 1995 (516)734-5800 ,~~::: ]@ L~"WN OF:O'JW01D: ~Ir. .\lbert J. Krupski. Jr., President Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall. 53095 '\lain Road Southold. New York 11971 Re: Pennit No. 4368; Ronald S@zler Dear ]I. Ir. Krupski: Because of the significant cost of the installation of the requiæd saIld fill seaward toe prokc- tion in the approved project Dr. Stritzler has asked that 1 obtain fì'om \'ou infOlmation sup- porting the rationale for your rcquirement that the seaward face of the rctaining wall bt: completely ¡;overed with sand. We would be pat1icularly interested in knowing about projects, if any. of this sort that have be¡:n approved by your agency in the past and successfully completed. so that I\e may lisit them and talk to the property mlllerS and or contractors about their experiences. [fthere have been studies published b~' the t\ew York State Department of Emironmental Conservation. 'Iew York State [)epat1ment of State Di\,ision of ('oastal Resources and Water- fÌ'ont Revitaliz.1tion. LT.S. .-\rm~' CotVS of Engineers, Department of c\griculture SoiJ ConseIV;I- lion Sef\ice. \hm York Sea GranL or any other agency, academic or rcsearch organization. or commercial operation suppot1ing this design feature, and upon which you based your rcquiæ- mcnL please prmide the rcferenct:s. \\'e also thought that it might be of\'alue. if su!ticient data are not rc:adiJy a\'aiJable to conta¡:t the other organizations llhich might have an mt.::rt:st or expel1iSi: in this arca fot their opimons on the currently-r.:quired approach to toe protection. and. as a mancr of ¡¡,ct the value of any tOt: prokction in tlus specific location. ~h' notes [¡'()m the Truskt: meeting of July :!X. 199~. indicate that alleast one of the 'I'mstees telt that it I\as unreasonable 10 require that the oWIIcr he responsihle for rcplenishing the sand a subsidiary 01 THE PECONIC EASTERN CORPORATION . . ProJJér-T Permit Services ~ POST OFFICE BOX 617, CUTCHOGUE, NEW YORK 11935·0617 (516)734-5800 Jauua" " "" lli~ JM r 0' P , I lTO~\:\~ r.(: WI! ! ; , ' Mr. Roger Evans, Deputy Regional Permit Administrator New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Division of Regulatory Affairs SUNY Campus, Building 40, Room 219 Stony Brook, New York 11790-2356 Re: No. 1-47 38-00940.LQ000I-0; RonaLd -P.t!_itz le,):: Dear Mr. Evans: This is in response to your letter of 12/8/94 concerning this project. A revised Section View (dated 1/2/95) is enclosed which shows: 1. The height of the bulkhead referred to NGVD. 2. The sand cover of the bulkhead in compliance with the requirement set forth in your letter. 3. Statements concerning planting of the fills and bluff and renovation of the bluff. Also enclosed is a Project Plan (dated 1/2/95), based upon a portion of the survey previously submitted, which repeats the responses listed above. If you need anything else, please call. . Fitzgerald, Jr. cc: Southold Trustees Dr. Stritzler Dr. Samuels, Rambo a subsidiary of THE PECONlC EASTERN CORPORATION + J1' !'féND-..., RANT IDITM èEAOi-1 ~ á'RA.$S Oi'j 18" QB{rEI?S \ I \ ~., -,---' -.. "- fñ1Œ®rO'/: I~i!----·" ' . !fli; JAN' 0 ':->''- ¡ ,J",; . L IO'gi~b''jJILES \ NEW 6Ml)E- Aï>f'Q.O'iC- 1 ON Zit- ~f.\o~N ¡. ERE, 3)(/0)<,/4' T't6; ~«E'Ä1t\I«ér "',1,'//1 ;" S>,15T1N& GRAbe.. -+-s'rtXVD t ÎÔ ~E. AT TfE NAIU"Al.ANGJ..E. 01" i2ffi:Œ. of l11E.. F'LL M¡\~¡,6-,1... . . , '-0 <! :$EAV¥\RD PLN--IT NEw 6£A'DE WITH "BEACH ß-RA'S'S ON 16" C'E.NTERS NE.W f:,:l.b WALE~ / / ;;;~ I:, 'HJ~.w()JE R.. I II/I, '", II II '/'" ,/ I .,,, ";,,,0- [(j<fJ:' , ~,'# _t-" tN'E (Ç 'tLo FF lC-tE. '>ý' í?E1WvTE1) AS H=£.. ;1-\E. W±r£$TIO/5 11'/ :irlL.. iJ:;NŒf2... VATION ŒEulŒE k&e.T CF 1&/{ob3,- 'B4EE. A/(&tS" 1C",~E. H~u I~I~C~ 6FA_v ON 18" æm=kS. 6'1.£ ~TT~l.D01C'5' AT ;:]DINTI Þ6 NEE'DED f f-- 1 ~ 1 TIJ 8'~'ff()S ~ ..l All... WHEEl:. To IE Cf:A -YIf;;SLJI2E:-- TRt=ATë.l). Ad... J.\A{¿])W,Aji1¡E íb 'BE. a-k.VN-\!ZE."J) ~CA¡.J::., ý¡." = l' SECTION VIEW ----- __________ ____n_______"_ --. --------- Application No.~-473B-00940l00001-0 regarding the property ~f' - RONALD STRITZLER Suffolk County Tax Hap No. 1000-94-1-14 R~p["esenteò by Proper-T Ser~ices P.o. Box 617, Cutchogue, NV 11935 James E. Fitzgeralrl, Jr. 516-734-5800 Sh~et of January 2, 1995 ........" '....... '\ \ \ \\ , \ ' I \ \ I ~ ~ '~" ,~ '1\ \, 27/.88' r: ~O I \ I " I ~ ~ ~ ~ I / ~,/ I \ I, \ u I II//, \ I I I I I I I / / s \ -- ~ / I Y . 0 r-- p: : '\ I : ~/ // ---- I I I 's / :.\ I I I \ I o:::o:::wo:::' I I I "'t ~ I \ I ( / j I ) I ' I ~~co~1 I, I Ill¡', \ \ \ \ " I' .,,' /, ? I I oz I I I I I' f " o ;," / ~8d' I ,UJZI-WI I I I 1'1 '~O>- \ I Z -' ,<!:O U I I Ifñì w 0 \ ~ \ \ I ~~ x< - - /'./ / ê§~~ %/ !:i J~ ì...... I \ II, oZ I /' ,..--_/ <!:o:::<!:! J I -q I- {( / >w Z \ I \ II I J OUJwo I I I :<::: '-, ON / zzo:::' I. I ~ a \ I \ \ <!:rl \ " / WO<!:UJ I <.. ...... I W + \ "'....- o:::uCOUJ -7 ' I ) ", I I '\;2z \ r / / W-I .~ --;' / I )' ~~ \ II 1\ -I<!: / / /' CO~t<\CD I I' \ =>I I I O~~I / / I i. ~ \ 1\ \ I COI- \ I / / / I- au / 0 "..!I I ~\ \ u.o::: \ \ I I I / / ZN<!: /"1 "I - ,OW / u.~.......w / , ..... \'\ I \ I \ I / u. Ncol ~ \)-.0 \ \ I CLCD I I I I / =>UJrl I r' \ " " ,\' O~ I \ \' -IZ Z ,~ , , ~\ I-I \ \ \ I / I / I C02~~ ~J ~\ \ I I \ I / f I u.1- 0 ......... \ \' \ \ \ \ I I I , II I OUJI-W , \ \ \ I WO:::I- \ II \ 1\ \ I \ ¡f,', ~~~~ \ l \ \ \ \ \ I \ \ \ I r I 'I <!:=>W-1 '" l\\ \ \ I I ,\ \ \ 'I I ~ U.UJO:::CL I () \ \ I II \ \ \ I J I ~ ~O' I \ \ \ \ I I \ I \ '''''11 a ú' \ \ I I I \ 'I-: \ \ I"''''' ... <:I \ \ , I \ I I I \ ~I\\\\ \~~:A~Ó\li I( \' \ I \ \ I I \ ~ \9 ~ ~ \ I I I I I "- I \ \ \,\I_J I \\"-\ I I W:Z: ~ \1 I I>~ I \ ......,\ \ I . ::Jo I \ \ :'" \ II 10~ \ \ I I' I I I-~ \ \ \ ' ' \ \ II Ô~ \ I \ II \ II I -I I \ \ I \ II II ~~ \ \ \ I \ I I U.o _ \ I I 1\ \ '" I \ \ I WI-UJ I I I ,I \ I \ CO-1E5 \ \ I \ \ \"- \ I \ \ ~~~ \ \ , ~ \ ~ I I I ou.~ \ I \ I \ \ .~ \ ; \ I ï:5Q~ I I 11 I ~ I I \ ;2ï:5~ I I I I \ \ ~ I I I I ~;2z I \ \ \ I ,CO-10 I " I \ ~ c: I O~(f) I \ .~ I Z UJ \ I I I\. ... I \ ~~~ \ \ I I {, \ () I I ~CL CD \ \ \ I I I It; I I <!:~¡:s I I I II I I "- ,/ I ~u.ï:5 \ I I I I I ( ð <!:OCO \ \ '\. I I I I I I I I ("I \ I I \ , I I I d ¡ \ \ \I 1 \ I ,I . \ \ \ \ I ¡, I..J, I 1\ ; I I \ ,I "" . \ I I \ I I I I I \ \ 1 I ,,\ I , \ I \ N. 2'·36'00· W. I \"'()\Í) I \ I ,r \ ~ '-"'1:-1 I' \ I ~ 1\ ~ ,I¡¡ \ \:)"'1"- " ",'iqi'f~ ~ 'I)", '" () \!) () 'Ñ , <:' , I \ \ \:) \ \ '" 5: 24·24'00· E. I.. \ \' . J I \ , \I) \ \ . . \ \ \ ìo ~\ \ \ \ \ £ ~ \ 'j' '- ~ \:) \ '. ~ \ \ \ ~~ W U -1~ <!: W <!: 00 Q u.. OJ _h....-I W 0::: -IOOWZ -10:::1-1-0 ~ <!: <!: u.::;:: -IEUJ <!: -I UJ WWI--I-.--J<:( P: UJu.-1O::: ~CD oo:::u.u. I-WO I > u.u OOWO<!: «UO W w I--IWOJ IOUJUJ ,,¿I- Oz -.J OCL........... =>l-o:::W p: Z<!:O:::O W::;:: W LL 1--1 0:::( LLI-- OUWOZ ~ UJ <!: I-u. W-1 zu.. --.JQ... O=>OCD O:::UJ<!:ZW u. W<!:CO II . ZI-,,¿ -10UJ 1--1 (L-.J C::(I--O::: W::>~ w <!: 0 co ::> -1 I- W I---.JZ 0:: C> LL <1: 1--1 w <!:I-OZu.u ~ -~___ .., ·.·,..··c" ........... - r_ -1_ ¡¡ /'> ..... t'!'." .. r-' .......... '., ___ lí) :::c I :-........ Q) ~- . : -.@ :::J .I,;:;J; 0......... a , ! ;'.~-,¡ ~ ~ . f-j ..y ~ ...... --- ...... ...... ~ ...... u ì:. o .::t \I - rl \ W -1 <!: U UJ -1! .. i¿-:§ ...... z 0( ..¡ ø. v ~ , ~ , ~~ :....rs1'f ¡O~g ItN=: I~~ . Ig-H~ I~" 0- . \I)~~ ~~t )>: . co-· f-< .~.~ 0 >- ~'E~6 .~ ~< g ~~Zu .'Z O~ C:óO f< U rz¡ ~ o c: ø. , 0 o¡ ?' 9. 43.' r<"t' ...... ...... ,,~ " , ...... ...... ~ :::> æ """'--, - ~!i ......~ " ~ ~ ~ o ~ o '" ~ U ~..:. N 0~~ t U... ~ ~ 'P'i¡;;;~ ~ >. .., È k ~ 'O(lg. ~b1'5~ C u . ", ~E-4U~ ~ I r-- ~ ~ ~~ ~ ø>:~ Q¡~t:: ... o .. 0 k~w ~ p. ~ e u . . .., . " ~ · . New York State Department of Environmental Conservation BUII;!!10 4O-SUNY, Stony Brook, New York 11790-2356 Telephone (516) 444-0365 Facsimile (516) 444-0373 December 8, 1994 Langdon Marsh .,·...__Cmnmiss¡""., 7 r~ fI \11 ;. ; ,I, Mr. James E. Fitzgerald PO Box 617 Cutchogue NY 11935 ~ '.; \11" . '; . { iUL; JAN I 0 I L_____.. , TO\¡VN úf ;)1/,;, L ___'._'" __ . RECEIVED , DEC l~' 1':194 J.E. FITZGERALD Re: Request for additional information Ronald Stritzler Application # 1-4738-00940/00001-0 Dear Mr. Fitzgerald: This letter shall serve to confirm our telephone conversation of 12/7/94 concerning the above application. based upon the information most recently submitted, Department staff have no objection to the bulkhead proposal. There are, however, some unclear aspects of the proposal and some additional information we require. They are as follows: 1. Height of bulkhead in reference to NGVD. It is not clear from the plan and cross section what the finished height of the bulkhead will be. The maximum height we can approve is +12' NGVD. This should be consistent from the cross section to the site view. 2. Sand cover of the bulkhead. The entire bulkhead should be covered with sand and planted with beach grass on 18" centers. This aspect must be shown on plan view and cross section. 3. Regrading and revegetation of the slope should also be shown on the cross view and plan view. o printed on recycled paper . . , Mr. Fitzgerald Page 2 Please submit three copies of revised plans. Upon receipt of these plans we can promptly issue your permit. If you have any questions I can be reached at the above address. Ve~y, truly yours, I ')/~. (l,\.8ðcv", Ro~ Evans Depµ Regional Permit Administrator '-- RXE:cg cc: R. stritzler . . Albert J. Krupski. President John Holzapfel, Vice President William G. Albertson Martin H. Garrell Peter Wenczel Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold. New York 11971 Telephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD September 5, 1995 James Fitzgerald Proper-T Permit Services P.O. Box 617 Cutchogue, NY 11935 RE: Your Letter of August 31, 1995 Dear Mr. Fitzgerald: As you may know, the Board of Trustees was founded on the Andros Pantent, which then Governor Andros imposed upon Southold Town on Halloween, 1676. Since our beginning, we have not remanded frozen in place, but have changed our policies, codes and ordinances to respond to changing human activities and the environment. The process of re-evaluating how the Board conducts itself within our jurisdiction make us more responsive to our "modern" problems such as access to the water, shellfish limits and erosion control. In regard to your letter from Dr. Stritzler, I am afraid that Dr. Stritzler has taken his application our of context with the workings of the Trustee Boards, present and past, and tries to hold you responsible for our actions. It is my belief that Dr. Stritzler's application received the proper review from the Board necessary to protect the environment and his property. (This involved many phone calls to the contractor and many site inspections). On an application of the magnitude of this we wanted to insure both and took all steps necessary to do so. Dr. Stritzler should be grateful that his application wasn't "rubber stamped". Without a proper review a poorly planned erosion control structure could result in tremendous property loss on his part. . . It is really impossible to hold Mr. Fitzgerald responsible for the actions of our Board. ~:1' 9(~'{9' Albert J. Krupski, Jr. President, Board of Trustees AJK: jmd . . Proper-T Permit Services POST OFFICE BOX 617, CUTCHOGUE, NEW YORK 11935-0617 (516) 734 -5800 August 31, 1995 Mr. Albert J. Krupski, Jr.. President Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall, 53095 Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Dear Mr. Krupski: Please note the attached copy of a note dated June 9, 1995 that I received ITom my fonner cli- ent, Dr. Ronald Stritzler, in which he states that my "failure to proceed in a timely manner" was responsible for problems which wOlûd not have occurred "had the pennits issue [sic] by the previous trustees. " I would appreciate it if you would comment on that notion. If you could provide me with your written comments in time for the Small Claims Court hear- ing on Friday, September 8, 1995, it would be helpful. Thanks for your help. /~ 1ruIy'''~,-/" ) / . / I /t l;"--~,-- ~:-r---- ~I ,: ......~ /~ . ¡ ./ '. ,.---...::....-, ' / //-' /'/.' / / ,c i;¡ 1["" \(, ';f,~ i... '( {( r L' ,/" James E. Fït~er,¥, Jr. t' I a subsidiary 01 THE PECONIC EASTERN CORPORATION . . , , ,.' ----- ---~ [Ro;lni. 8tril%l.r ß 1 STIRRUP LANE ROSLYN HEIGIITS, NEW YORK 1l57'7 b-9-'1í" ·/itCtl/¡t, ~Qh~ Q, Vt1 I o/f"~ D. cJ J.t Fir. TTS- CGtli. I Yl ~i ð-UA-~ ~~ \':'\'\\ ~ I-k ~~ -\.~ à _C2...V'-~~ (j Q-th1 ~ J~ ~~~ /ì~ .~ èJ-~ ~.. "S) V-.Q. -\-0 0- ~ .~ ~ ~ \V1 ~ ~ 'YY\.~ J. ~ ~ If\\-u \t.a~ 1 0- Y) 12M,¡- 't'~ i \' /VvJ) ~ ~ ð-J.Q. ~ '1- ~~ . . " , . ~~~, ~~~~ ~ N-d ~ð~ '~.,,~,~~~ ~~~\-L..~ ~'~~~ ~~. ,_\~ ~~ ~~ O-~~~b~V. ----R ~ . ~ w.I w.I Þ- ~ ~ ~ , QI ... -a Q Þ- . ~ t! ~ . ~ "::=Þ z o - .... u :) DIi: .... en Z o u \!) Z - DIi: :) Q Q III >- oC -I D- en - Q III III .... en :) ~ III U - .... o Z en - ::r: .... Q -I o :E: .... :) o en IL - o I;:: - Z - ~ .N o >: ~ .... Z '7 _ _ L!') III Q c.c U ..."" - 0 .. It :E:....i o ...W :)~ en 0 IH '" ... en :) DIi: ... Z ~ o ... , . . . . Albert J. Krupski. President John Holzapfel, Vice President William G. Albertson Martin H. Garrell Peter Wenczel Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Telephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD October 25, 1994 Proper-T Services Mr. Jim Fitzgerald P.O. Box 617 Cutchogue NY 11935 Re: RONALD STRITZLER SCTM 1194-1-14 Dear Mr. Fitzgerald. The following action was taken by the Board of Town Trustees during its regular meeting held on August 25, 1994 regarding the above matter: /' WHEREAS, Proper-T Services, on behalf of RONALD STRITZLER applied to the Southold Town Trustees for a permit under the provisions of the Wetland Ordinance of the Town of Southold, application dated March 29, 1994, WHEREAS, said application was referred to the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council for their findings and recommendations, and WHEREAS, a Public Hearing was held by the Town Trustees with respect to said application on August 25, 1994 at which time all interested persons were given an opportunity to be heard, and, WHEREAS, the Board members have personally viewed and are familiar with the premises in question and the surrounding area, and, WHEREAS, the Board has considered all the testimony and documentation submitted concerning this application, and, WHEREAS, the Board has determined that the project as proposed will not affect the health, safety and general welfare of the people of the town, NOW THEREFORE BE IT, , . . RESOLVED, that the Board of Trustees approves the application of RONALD STRITZLER to construct a 410' long retaining wall typically 6' above grade, with returns at each end and placed in the cliff buried completely with sand and re-vegetated. The top of the bluff will be mounded and graded to prevent any runoff from the edge of the property down the bluff and that the re-vegetated plan of the Suffolk County Soil and Water Conservation Department will be followed. Permit to construct project will expire two years from the date it is signed. Fees must be paid, if applicable, and permit issued within six months of the date of this notification. Two inspections are required and the Trustees are to be notified upon completion of said project. FEES: ¡.)ott/¡J' Very truly yours, {2¿~t..·1 9 /~. 9, Albert J. Krupski, Jr. President, Board of Trustees AJK/djh cc. CAC ? . Proper-T Permit Services . POST OFFICE BOX 617. CUTCHOGUE, NEW YORK 11935-0617 (516) 734 -5800 October 3, 1994 {õJŒ@ŒQWŒfij) Uù OCT 4 1994 I~J TOWN OF SOUTHOLD President Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall, 53095 Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Re: Ronald Stritzler; SCTM #1000-94-1-14 Dear Sir: At the Trustees' Meeting on 8/25/94, the Board approved the permit for this project contingent upon the submission of a revised survey showing the location of the bulkhead at the toe of the bluff, and a revised drawing of the construction showing the suggested fill on both the seaward and landward sides of the bulkhead. Here is a copy of a letter to Roger Evans of the DEC, together with attachments which fulfill the requirements of the Board. If you find them suitable, please arrange to issue a notice of approval of the permit. If you need anything else, please call. a subsidiary of THE PECONIC EASTERN CORPORATION . . ÍÏÌJs{~ -- Proper... T Permit Services POST OFFICE BOX 617, CUTCHOGUE, NEW YORK 11935,0617 15/6) 734 -5800 September 29, 1994 Mr. Roger Evans, Deputy Regional Permit Administrator New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Division of Regulatory Affairs SUNY Campus, Building 40, Room 219 Stony Brook, New York 11790-2356 Re: No. 1-4738-00940/00001-0: Ronald Stritzler Dear Mr. Evans: This is in response to your letter of 9/1/94 concerning this project. A revised survey (dated 9/26/94) is enclosed which shows the location of the proposed bulkhead at the toe of the bluff. A revised Section View (dated 9/12/94) is enclosed which shows the proposed construction method. Methods of construction will be those ordinarily used and generally recognized as suitable for the installation of bulkheads on the Sound shore of Long Island. Access will be obtained to the beach at Bailie Beach Road. The need for stabilization of the toe of the bluff is recogniz- ed in publications of the Suffolk County Soil and Water Con- servation District, the U.S. Department of Agriculture Soil Conservation Service, and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, as a first step in controlling the effects of erosion of the face of the bluff. That such control is needed is amply demonstrat- ed by the continuing loss, at a significant rate, of usable property at the top of the bluff. A copy of the report entitled "Inventory and Evaluation of Land, Water, and Related Resources" for the project site, dated 12/20/93, is enclosed. It states the need for toe stabil- ization. Included also is a copy of USDA Technical Note: Plant Materials No. 11. It discusses in some detail the methodology of bluff stabilization, including providing "protection at the toe of the slope with a low, well-constructed bulkhead." a subsidiary of THE PECONIC EASTERN CORPORATION . . Mr. Roger Evans -2- September 29, 1994 The question of the relative value of a rock revetment is addressed in detail in the letter from Thomas E. Samuels, of James H. Rambo, Inc., also enclosed. In addition, information from the Corps of Engineers suggests that rock revetments are generally more successful in protecting against "normal" wave action, and less so in protecting against the waves which would reach a revetment under storm conditions such as those necessitating the proposed project. Dr. Stritzler agrees that the minimization of rain run-off along the top of the bluff is a significant factor in protecting the bluff, and necessary regrading and collection of run-off from impervious surfaces will be undertaken as part of the overall project. Dr. Samuels' letter also contains other information and comments which should be of value in your continuing review of the project. With regard to your request for site-specific cross-sections of the bluff: the preparation of exact cross sections by a surveyor by means of a ground survey would involve considerable further expense, and I would hope that an examination of the contour lines on the submitted survey would provide sufficient data for your purposes. The same comments, to an extent, apply to your request for the depiction of vegetation on the plan. Extensive photographic coverage is available, some of which was included with the original submission. Additional photographs can certainly be provided of any specific area in which you are interested. (YÕU~s It. ru~.e~. [ 0~Y.) ,t¿.L ,(ì-:/ n I{ , ¿if·, E 'it~tßd' J<, cc: Southold Trustees Dr, Stritzler Dr, Samuels, Rambo ".'-';f'lll,r,... lit 15 , " . , , '1" ' "'I"; I ~ r, . FILE COpy ." "'1\111 f..tF';tl! fir ^falll:ll!. I 'HIE "II , "1I<;f !lV/\" 1011 II;FIIVIf:r:: INVENr.rOHY & EVALUATION CW' LAN D. W A'1'li]H. AN I) Hli:I.A'I'ml> HliJROUHCmS MIL ItON^LII RTHITï.LEIt I1EOIIES I E 1 IIY ~1^",INU ^IJllltEHH, ~I HTlltHIII' I.^NE. ^SSIS I r=r, IIY 1'",,1 ^. T"Ny""lnlIA I ""^ I () ;tllf.f. fHHINII VIEW ^ VENUE M^'I"I' ' 'IICI<. NEW YOItI< 119f.2 H(,HI.YN IIEIUIITH. NEW YOHI( I)pI'PIIIIH~I' 211, I'^ I ' II ~'17 I!I\I:\ IT) INIJIVIIJII^I. ( I (;nOI II' (' 111111 or nOVFI1NMEN I SIII,^ liON: The hluff f"e" I" ""v"I'"lv ""m\,,<I n'H' COI,tlII""" 10 netlvelv el'ml" <lue to thlnl Retloll. The high th\eR nll<\ "to;'111 thleR '·"II..h th" hl"ff toe n",\ "I'" ero<llllg Rwny the tOf'. ^R thl" ..OlltlIlU"" th" hl"ff fn.." will RloUlth off tt'ylllg to I11nllltnlll n IIntlll'nl nng-lfI of I'P.JH}~{,. MORt of tlH' hhlrr fn('p iR h"t'C" ntH1 hn~ n vr.t'tlpnl Fllopf' ill Romc nt'p.n~, 1'h(" hluff lnp vnl'i,,~ In plpvnllon nlld IR f'ut IUH'\(, Jr'I'pJ!lIhn·ly. Thp h"rH'h tH'('''RR Rtnh'R folloWR 1111 old 1111II1I'nl I' lvil,,, whl,'" IR Vl't'Y lu'nvlly vPJ~plnt"d IIOtV. MORt of Ihp hluff tqp "d~p IR VPI',V hpnvlly v"i~"tnll'd 111~ ) willi 110 IU'I'PAR fl'o!!! 'lip ynl'd. "'hp ('flgp I~ VP1"I('1I1 1o oVPI'hrUlftll1f!, wllh 1"lOt~ f'x'H,~,.d fl'oltl IIIHII'I'II,."Ih III" woody vPftfl'nllfJlI IIllfl "'f'f' ftl'u\Ylh nlllllJ( Ihn f1t1f{f1, "flWII '"'1'11 "I'UIII..I Ihrl hutllUl I... nllt I hIlW"Vllf'. 1"" IlIwlt 10 thp wPRI Rlnpc'R dowlI lowlII'd:q Ih" hlllff flll'f', 'I'''h~ '''''''' IH lIC'f1f'HRlhlf' 1'1'0111 "huvp, Thp HI' ¡~ vPI'tif'nl nil nloll'! hp"f' 111,,1 tn IIH' \Vf'At, (hi tI", f'1I~' thf' "IIIIT r,,('f' hfl(~On"~R h"IIvlly v"I\'''tllt"d ''''''O''A II,,, 111'1"'" Io" ' """ ""'AI of 110" Io,w",' hlllf IA II"llv"ly ",·oflllll\'. Whf't'" Ih" InwII """" m""IA 110" v"t'II"III III', <I"ht'l" hll~ h",," ",,'owII 01110 lloe hlllff, Am'h nR, hl'ntwh I'lIttlllg" II'H' l"IIf lilt",·. N",,,· 110" ,\P,'I\ ",,¡It ¡o th" "IIAI AI.\" th"t'" IA n pln~tle I'll''' exlllllg fr'flll1 ,,,,,'et'I("ooll" Ollto the hlllff fne". I'II"t ""OAIOII wnR "vhl,,"t ~~~~*~~~~~~m h"low II,,, pip'" ^IAo two plpf'A "xll Ollto tI", III IV II n""n thnt "lope" .10wlI to th!'! hlllff fn"". '1'10" ,·.!Of top of Ih" hOIlA" IR nnl wilh 110 out"r dowII Rpollt". HIIGGEHTE[) HOI,lITlON(H), Thf' fI",,1 Rt!'!1' to n<ldl'e"s Is lo!'! ~tnhlll7.nlloll. COlltRet MI'. ,.fRY Tnllsld nt New York Hen n,'nllt Exlellslon HCI'vl..e, pholle: 032 -R730 for reeom- mendntlons on toe stnhillzntlon. ^ rt",· h'RtolllnK pl'opel' Rtnhlll7.ntlon. clent' off dehrls from the bluff fnee. f ebrls will only ndd "xeess weight ond smother exlallng vegetRtlon on the bluff fR"e, Th" only ncee""lhl" nren f"om nhove IR whel'e thf' !nwn me"tR the ""m\illl( hlllff top. ThlR """n mny hf' "lit hnl'l\ to n IInll1l'nl nllglf' of '·"I'0Re. Th" ,'!'!st or (h" 1',1~p iR lint fU'('PA:qihlp ,hiP 10 'hp VPI'Y 111'nvy V('f~"11I11vp g.'ow,tl. II \Yo,lId lint he n<lvl"nhle to elen,' th" v..g<,\"tloII "ltll'" thl" mny ollly ""'''·''·'·IIt.. Ih.. ,,'·oAloII. I r lit nil possible, trees Rt the vCl'y e<lK" "hollh\ he cut <lown to th" g,'olll,,\ ",,,I root "y"t"ms lert IIndl"lllrberl. I{IIoel\ down the ~I'OIR 011 thf' hlllff foce whleh nre now nœrIy vertlcnl. to le"R"n the slope for plnntlng. Theil follow the f'n"lo"ed bl'oehll"e "'", I'lnnt thc hnr" n""nA to 'CIIp'" ^me,· .,nll lIen..hgl'nRR. Th" pIpe thnt exllR onto th" h\t,ff fne" ",,,I th" two tI",t exll onto the InwII n"cn mllY h" .h'nh'''gf' pIP!'!R fOl' th" roof nren. If ao. f'liminRte the one from the blllff eomplf'tely. n dl'Y well should 10" In~tnIle<l. The snme mny hp donf' fo)" thp othr.I' twn, howrvrl". 1IRlng n cllfruRcr poni<1 ~Inw down thr. roof I1Inoff. ^ ~l11nIl h",'m "nil I,,' "Oll~t,·"..",., III0llg II", hl"ff 1,01' ,,<11(" Wlll'I'" tlo" RIII·fll('.' "lInoff now now" OV..I· th" hlllff fn"" to "top thlA t'''noff 111"\ lllIow th" wnl",' time 10 pCI'eolnte into the gl"oUlu1, Tit" hpI'111 ~hollh' hf' plfllltf'(1 io n IH~I''''nIH'"t g'l'OlllUI (~nvpr 01' turf I(l'n"". ^ny ",,'milR ""'I"h'"'' nl''' lhf' In'l<l\lwn""~ """IH J ~lhllll y. C\llItnd Nr>w Y\I,'I\ HIIII" n"pnl'tml"nt of Envll'onm"ntnl Con""l'vntk», nn" tI,f' T\lwn nllthol"ily fol' 1'1'01'''1' permits. (~IH~R . Ie ( I'Pr!. ""J""'"'"''' '""'''Q'1Ir '41 I"I~ " 111 ,'" . . 3 , 4. VegetatE" the slop... This wil further protE"oct it from any waves overtopping thE" bulkhead and reachIng thE" back of the vegetated level area. Use Cape Ameriocan beachgrass for this also, t'~anspl~nted in th~ p.ar-Iy spring. Place onE! 35 mrn film canIster of Oqmocot:~ slow í~l~asl? fêt-t,1 iZêt" into each planting hole and then plant three stems 01- cul",~ pel h(.le, Elach hole should b,", 12-18 i n,= he 5 é4 P ;t r" t . 5. Adapted shrubs and vines can be added when the slope·is wel I stabi I ¡zed WI th 9'"855. Species includE' Bayberr-y, Rugosa '-05e, and S'!ach plum. 6. Keep al I trees pruned to shrub height on the slope. Ma i ntenance of the bu I khead and vE"gE"tated s lope wi II be requ ired on a continuous basis. Rem~ve debris from planted areas, keep al water diver-ted fOI-ln t~lE' ~Iope, do not ov~r irr-igate the lawrl ~bov~, ~voi,j AKrês~ivø fl~ot tt~ffic and t·ep~ir allY Ijal11~gelj Of 0,- ..,1.1 1119 at"iÔ'a'!';-. . . . fõ)mœlD un &21199t TOWN 0 100 JAMES H. RAMBO, INC. BISHOPS LANE SOUTHAMPTON, N, y, 11968 PHONE: (516) 283-1254 WUNNEWETA ROAD CUTCHOGUE, N, Y. 11935 PHONE: (516) 734-5858 September 26, 1994 James E. Fitzgerald Proper-T-Services P.O. Box 617 cutchogue, N.Y. 11935 Re: Ronald stritzler Dear Mr. Fitzgerald, This letter is in response to the letter dated September 1, 1994 by Roger Evans, the Deputy Regional Permit Administrator, regarding the above referenced application. I suggest you forward this letter to him. I understand that you have submitted a revised plan to Mr. Evans depicting the bulkhead at the toe of the bluff, removing the bulkhead from the surf zone during all but very severe storm surge. The Southold Town Trustees, specifically Mr. John Holzapel, stipulated that the bulkhead be completely covered with sand on completion and that this sand be replaced on an annual basis. This "trial" procedure, if it fails, would result in the placement of stone toe armor and a landward splash pad (quarry stone) and this may well be a condition of the D.E.C. permit. Mr. Starr of the Coastal Hazards Section Region I has consulted with Mr. Holzapel and has approved this approach as indicated by Mr. Holzapel. As per the N.Y.S.D.E.C. Tidal Wetlands regulations, this structure is listed as "generally compatible" and should not generate a positive declaration. As to the proposal to revegetate undamaged portions of the bluff, it would be recognized that partial bulkhead construction at the toe of the bluff would exacerbate the long term stabilization sought by the applicant. Revegetation stabilization of sound bluffs have been notably unsuccessful in the absence of toe protection. The N.Y.S.D.E.C. may be correct, believing a rock revetment would protect the bluff, however, the following facts must be stated. .. . . 1. The cost of such a structure is ±2 times the cost of an armored timber bulkhead. 2. The footprint of a revetment would be 18' seaward of the toe of the bluff in order to attain the 9' MSL top elevation with a N.Y.S.D.E.C. 1 on 2 slope requirement. 3. Access for either structure is from Bailey's Beach Road, 3/4 mile west of the project. Construction of a revetment would require in excess of 35 trailer loads of quarry stone and at least 250 payloader trips from Bailey's Beach Roqd. 4. This would be a major construction project. 5. Rock revetments do require splash pads as wave runup is increased as the waves run up a 1 on 2 rock revetment. In fact, splash pads must be increased with revetment construction. 6. Rock gabion construction on the Long Island Sound has been spectacularly unsuccessful in these extremely high wave energy environments. To conclude, I would suggest that the bluff, upon completion of toe protection, be planted with Cape American Beach Grass, 18" on center. I can assure the applicant that natural revegetation will occur once the toe is protected and the bluff will in all but the most severe event, have no further damage and should any overtopping occur the damage will be minimal and easily repaired. We have constructed ten bulkheads in this area as result of the recent N.E. storms. since 1967, all the bulkheads in this area have succeeded and there has been no beach loss in excess of that caused by the Mattituck Inlet groins. Sincerely, 4~· Thomas E. Samuels Southold Town Trustees; Attn: John Holzapel Ronald Stritzler Roger Evans, N.Y.S.D.E.C. Louis Corso . . . Nev York state Department of Environmental Conservation Building 40 - S.U.N.Y, stony Brook, Nev York 11790-2356 Telephone (516) 444-0365 Facsimile (516) 444-0373 ~ ..... ~ September 1, 1994 Langdon Karsh co..tssioner James E. Fitzgerald Proper -T- Services P.O. Box 617 Cutchogue, NY 11935 , RECEIVED S[p 0 <> 19 . JlO' u, 94 .&;;. FI1'ZG ERA.LD RE: Ronald stritzler #1-4738-00940/00001-0 Dear Mr. Fitzgerald: Department staff have reviewed the information submitted in support of the above application and conducted a field inspection, of the above site. The following are our comments and findings. We are concerned about the potential impacts the proposed project would have to stable sections of bluff and the beach itself. The wall proposed is a significant distance seaward of the toe of the bluff, 20' in some places. This seaward location places the wall in the surf zone during storm surge, promoting wave reflection and beach scour during those events. The structure does not have toe protection or a landward splash pad. This lack of splash pad would allow the bulkhead to retain large amounts of overwash causing it to ultimately fail. The lack of toe protection exacerbates beach scour and the likelihood of blowout during overtopping. You have not indicated methods access for machinery and materials. resubmission. of construction or areas of Please include this in your The need for a shore line stabilization structure along the entire property has not been demonstrated. Some areas of the bluff are stable and heavily vegetated. Most importantly, no upland structures are threatened in any way. Your project description indicates that Suffolk County has made site specific recommendations. This report was not included in your application, please forward a copy. staff see potential problems with your project as proposed, . . that may equal or exceed the perce1ved benefits. We ask that you consider a revised project description including revegetation of . ! . .' . . Mr. Fitzgerald Page 2 the slope and providing toe of bluff armor only where absolutely necessary. Rock armor protection for the toe of the bluff would be preferable in several ways. Rock armor is inherently "softer", it does not reflect wave energy back to scour the beach. This armor coùld also be placed further landward as it requires no tie rods or dead men. Additionally, rock revetment reduces the need for a splash pad area landward of the structure. To continue processing of your application we will need the following: 1. Copy of the report from Suffolk County Soil and Water Conservation District. 2. A substantial discussion of alternatives to a vertical faced wall, including the one offered. 3. Methodology of work, transportation of materials and machinery. 4. Several site specific cross sections of the bluff with existing and proposed conditions. 5. Depiction on plan of vegetation on bluff. 6. Removal of stormwater discharge on bluff face, which is exacerbating bluff erosion. Upon receipt of the above we can resume processing. If you have any questions I can be reached at the above address. y truly yours, ~ J-l r Evans ty Regional Permit Administrator RXE:cg cc: Ronald stritzler Town of Southold . New York state Department of Bui1dinq 40 - S.U.N.Y, stony Te1ephone (516) 444-0365 Facsimile (516) 444-0373 . eo Env1ronmental Conservat1on Brook, New York 11790-2356 e ~ September 1, 1994 Lanqdon Karsh co.-issioner James E. Fitzgerald Proper -T- Services P.O. Box 617 Cutchogue, NY 11935 r{õJ~jtlLlJU~1~) i IflJ I S£P -!1 1994 "I . RE: Ronald stritzler #1-4738-00940/00001-0 Dear Mr. Fitzgerald: Department staff have reviewed the information submitted in support of the above application and conducted a field inspection. of the above site. The following are our comments and findings. We are concerned about the potential impacts the proposed project would have to stable sections of bluff and the beach itself. The wall proposed is a significant distance seaward of the toe of the bluff, 20' in some places. This seaward location places the wall in the surf zone during storm surge, promoting wave reflection and beach scour during those events. The structure does not have toe protection or a landward splash pad. This lack of splash pad would allow the bulkhead to retain large amounts of overwash causing it to ultimately fail. The lack of toe protection exacerbates beach scour and the likelihood of blowout during overtopping. You have not indicated methods access for machinery and materials. resubmission. of construction or areas of Please include this in your The need for a shore line stabilization structure along the entire property has not been demonstrated. Some areas of the bluff are stable and heavily vegetated. Most importantly, no upland structures are threatened in any way. Your project description indicates that Suffolk County has made site specific recommendations. This report was not included in your application, please forward a copy. Staff see potential problems with your project as proposed, that may equal or exceed the perceived benefits. We ask that you consider a revised project description including revegetation of . . Mr. Fitzgerald Page 2 the slope and providing toe of bluff armor only where absolutely necessary. Rock armor protection for the toe of the bluff would be preferable in several ways. Rock armor is inherently "softer", it does not reflect wave energy back to scour the beach. This armor could also be placed further landward as it requires no tie rods or dead men. Additionally, rock revetment reduces the need for a splash pad area landward of the structure. To continue processing of your application we will need the following: 1. Copy of the report from Suffolk County Soil and Water Conservation District. 2. A substantial discussion of alternatives to a vertical faced wall, including the one offered. 3. Methodology of work, transportation of materials and machinery. 4. Several site specific cross sections of the bluff with existing and proposed conditions. 5. Depiction on plan of vegetation on bluff. 6. Removal of stormwater discharge on bluff face, which is exacerbating bluff erosion. Upon receipt of the above we can resume processing. If you have any questions I can be reached at the above address. v~y truly yours, ~.l §¿'¿'v(.0 Rof.J r Evans Dep ty Regional Permit Administrator RXE:cg cc: Ronald stritzler Town of Southold . . . Albert J. Krupski, President John Holzapfel, Vice President William G. Albertson Martin H. Garrell Peter Wenczel Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold. New York 11971 Telephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD S.E.Q.R.A. NEGATIVE DECLARATION NOTICE OF NO SIGNIFICANT EFFECT ON THE ENVIRONMENT APPLICATION NO. lOOO-94-l-l4 NAME: Ronald Stritzler DATE: July 28, 1994 Chapt. 97 - Wetlands Chapt. 37 - Coastal Erosion RESOLVED that pursuant to Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law, State Environmental Quality Review and 6NYCRR Part 617, Section 617.10 and Chapter 44 of the Code of the Town of Southold, notice is hereby given that the Southold Town Trustees, as Lead Agency for the action described below, has determined that the project will not have a significant effect on the environment. Please take further notice that this declaration should not be considered a determination made for any other department or agency which may also have an application pending for the same or similar project. TYPE OF ACTION: Type: Unlisted DESCRIPTION OF ACTION: Applicant requests permit to construct a 4l0' long retaining wall typically 6' above grade, with returns at each end and completely covered with sand. Length of returns estimated from survey to be 12' at west end and 22' at east end, actual lengths to be determined during construction by intersection of top of retaining wall with face of bluff. Smooth face of bluff, in accordance with recommendations of Suffolk County Soil & Water Conservation Department, to permit vegetation and minimize further erosion from run-off, use material resulting from smoothing as backfill behind retaining wall. LOCATION: SCTM ~lOOO-94-1-l4 REASONS SUPPORTING THIS DETERMINATION: 1. An on site inspection has been conducted by the Board of Trustees. 2. An environmental assessment, submitted by the applicant and reviewed and completed by the Board of Trustees, has indicated that . . . . no significant adverse effects to the environment are likely to occur should the following mitigation measures be implemented. cc: CAC . . Proper-T Permit Services POST OFFICE BOX 617, CUTCHOOUE, NEW YORK 11935 July 11, 19 (516)734-5800 Q70HlnOs .:10 NM01I ~' t766/ l I lnr r [Ifl Ð IÆ 0 Ð @ Ð @Jj Mr. Albert Krupski, Jr., President Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall, 53095 Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Re: Application for Ronald Stritzler~ SCTM #1000-94-1-14 Dear Mr. Krupski: I just found out that Allan Connell is a member of the CAC. It is my understanding that Mr. Connell is very knowledgeable on the subject of bluff erosion on the Sound, and as a matter of fact is employed by the USDA and/or the Suffolk County Soil and Water Conservation Service to provide expertise in this area. Since you stated that the Board felt it did not have a back- ground in the concepts involved in the Stritzler application, I ask that you obtain detailed comments from Mr. Connell which would assist in your evaluation of this application. a subsidiary 01 THE PECONlC EASTERN CORPORATION . . Prol{~"- T Permit Services POST OFFICE BOX 617, CUTCHOGUE. NEW YORK 11935 Ma ~-5800 00 Mr. Albert Krupski, Jr., President Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall, 53095 Main Road Southold, New York 11971 'Œ o M~ - 4 1994 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Re: Application for Ronald Stritzler, SCTM #1000-94-1-14 Dear Mr. Krupski: As I have mentioned to Jill on several occasions, the project under construction a short distance west of the Stritzler property (apparently SCTM #1000-94-1-12.2) looks much more extensive than the Stritzler project, and yet I have not been aware of the public notices which would presumably required by a coordinated review. If, however, it was the subject of a coordinated review it would seem that much of the data, comments, a so forth collected as a result of that review would be applicable to the Stritzler project since you indicated that it was a broader range of expertise you hoped to bring to bear on the current project by means of requiring the coordinated review. I ask again that you consider an uncoordlnated review for this Unlisted project on the basis of the "no permit required" response from the Corps of Engineers and my assurance that application has been made to the DEC (Notice of Receipt of Application is attached). To the best of my knowledge no other agencies have regulatory authority in this situation. I would be more than happy to assist in obtaining comments from any other agencies which might offer suggestions or comments (Sea Grant?) for your consideration, with the hope that a formal coordinated review could be avoided simply to eliminate that fruitless delays which are built into such a procedure. I would appreciate the opportunity to discuss this further with you before the next Board meeting if you think that would be of any value. trul , ~ /£/ ,?:i;~" You s Enclosure: DEC Notice of Receipt, J¥nes I L/ 3/29/94 a subsidiary 01 THE PECONlC EASTERN CORPORATION · II !i ·Il Ii! I! .!I ¡ ¡! ~, 11 i!l! 1i !!!! I "'~f""'''_. .. (lokll2) f LW YORK STATE DEPI\RrMENrOF ENVIRONMENml CUNSERVI\ßON [) VISKJN OF REGULATORY I\FFAIRS REüll)N 1 STONY BROOK SlINY CAMPUS. BUJ(ì "0. ROOM 219 STONf SHOOK NEW YORK 11190-2356 JAMES FITZGERALD PROPERTY PERMIT SERVICE BOX 617 CUTCHOGUE NY 11935 11"1'3'5-0617 1",11",111,1""11"1,1,11""11"",111,,,1,,,111,,,11,1,,1 (Iukl , I) - !';IFlph! ht·re) ------ NOTICE OF RECEIPT OF APPLICATION The Division of Regulatory Allairs has received Ihe apphcation referenced below. The male rial submitted is being reviewed by staff. and you will be advised in wriling regarding the Department's findings. In all future communications, please reler to the Appllcalion 10 number. A¡JphcallOIl 10: 1-4738-00940:00001-0 Date Received: 03/29/94 Apphcant: RONALD STRITZLER Faclhty: STRITZLER PROPERTY Desr.riplloll: CONSTRUCT RETAINING WALL AND RETURNS DEC Contact: ROGER EVANS RECEIVED APR 1 3 1~94 J.E. FITZGERALD · '7 'iÎ)~'::i; ~o()9. ,iL~ ~UfFOl~ l&'\)JI~~'" (<V ,;:f ~ '" :::. ~t, 'Q . ''I I en :æ: ,()' 'ð.-, ~ "j ~ - ~ if ~~J-ß~~V BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD lyC Albert J. Krupski. President John Holzapfel. Vice President William G. Albertson Martin H. Garrell Peter Wenczel Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold. New York 11971 Telephone (516) 765,1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 I'I.~· - 3 ' LEAD AGENCY COORDINATION REQUEST TO: TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN DATE: Enclosed is a permit application and a completed part I of the Environmental Assessment Form. Southold Town Trustees are interested in your ageny's comments in acting as SEQRA Lead Agency for: NAME: RONALD STRITZLER LOCATION: 3055 SOUNDVlEW AVE.. MATTITUCK NY 11952 TAX MAP: 1000-94-1-14 PERMIT 11 Pending DESCRPTN: See attached PERMIT REQUIRED: (X) T~ WETLAND ( ) OTHER SEQRA CLASSIFICATION: ) Type I ( ) Type II ( UNLISTED () CEA Please contact Albert J. ;;:rupski. Jr.. Trustee , within 30 days and be advised that the Southold Town Trustees (WANT)/(DO NOT WANT) to assume lead agency. SENT TO: DOS (X) DEC 0<) DOH ( ) PB ( ) ZBA ( ) BLD () ACE (X) CAC (X) ~lease complete, detach and return this form to expedite processing. Involved Agency: Project Name: Location: WSCeTMat: N YS 0 c (" r'"'\ J- ~ (Have~ objection to Southold Town AGENCY Trustees assuming Lead Agency. Comments/Reasons: Clpr' Cú\.J' Iv be Hun EI9/ S-J, Authorized Representative r Albert J. KrupSki, President John HOlzapfel, Vice President William G. Albertson Martin H. GarrelI Peter Wenczel . . BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOVTHOLD Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 SoUthold. New;York 11971 Telephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 TO: TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN LEAD AGENCY COORDINATION REQUEST 'l,.s, Cmopl,t" d,t'Ch 'nd r'turn this form to '"POdit, -oceSSing. 'olved Agency: . ect Name: ion: PI,... COnt'ct Alb,,, J. '<rup"k1. h., TrU"'" . .i thin 3D d.ys 'nd h, .dVisOd th.t th, SOUthOld Tawn Trust". (WANT)/(Do NOT WANT) to assume lead agency. SENT TO, Dos!>ó DEC o() DoH ( ) "" () EBA ( ) BLD () ACE (x) CAC (X) SouthOld TOWn Trust". 'r, int,r'St'd in >our .g,ny's comm'nts in acting as SEQRA Lead Agency for: NAME: RONALD STRITZLER LOCATION, '0" SOUND V,", AVE.. MATTITUCK NY 11952 TAK MAp, '000-94-1-1, PElOnT. P'niling DESCRPTN: See attached PE""IT REQUIRED, (X) Toww ""TLAim ( ) 0",,", SEQRA CLAsSIFICATION, (j) Typ, I ( ) Type II ( ) UNLISTED () CEA Enclos'd is · P'rmit 'PPlic.tion 'nd . campl,tOd P'rt I of th, Environmental Assessment Form. DATE: '7 -~ if - '1 Y AGENCY ~sSuming Lead Agency. '!sons: (Have/No) Objection to SOuthOld Town Signature of Authorized Representative i:t ...-- ORf-ÞVr.. .. NlC EASTERN C THE PECO /-'" . . DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY NEW YORK DISTRICT CORPS OF ENGINEERS JACOB K. JAVITS FEDERAL BUILDING NEW YORK. N.Y. 10278-0090 n[PlY In ATTFN11011 or April 15, 1994 , , I Eastern Permits section SUBJECT: Application Number 94-03330-L2 by Ronald stritzler Ronald Stritzler c/o James E. Fitzgerald, Jr. Proper-T Permit services P.o, Box 617 Cutchogue, New York 11935 Dear Mr. stritzler: On April 15, 1994, the New York District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, received a copy of your Joint Application for permit requesting authorization to construct approximately 410 linear feet of retaining wall with 12 foot and 22 foot returns above the spring high tide line of Long Island Sound, at Mattituck, Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York. Our review indicates that since the proposed work does not appear to include dredging or construction activities in or over any navigable waters of the United States, the placement of any dredged or fill material in any waters of the united States (including coastal or inland wetlands) or the accomplishment of any work affecting the course, location, condition or capacity of such areas, a Department of the Army permit, in accordance with 33 CFR 320-330, will not be required provided the proposed work is executed in accordance with the referenced material. Care should be taken so that any fill or construction materials, including debris, do not enter the waterway to become a drift or pollution hazard. You are to contact appropriate state and local government officials to ensure that the subject work is performed in compliance with their requirements. If any questions should arise concerning this matter, please contact Denise Butts, of my staff, at (212) 264-3913. " Sincerely, Enclosures ) . J i/\/~1,' ,', ,'J¡-/ )/-(L,oA·Y,/\ mes W. Haggerty ä (. ief, Eastern Permits section RECEIVED API? 2 9 '. 1994 J.E. FITliG ERALD . Minutes April 26, 199~ . _ J No. 1128 Moved by Robert Keith, seconded by Jack Hagerty, it was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees APPROVAL WITH STIPULATIONS of the Wetland Application of THOMAS AND ROBY GLUCKMAN 111-5-2 to construct a swimming pool with appurtenant deck and pool house. The CAC recommends approval with the stipulation that the area below the pool be bermed off and plant beach grass on the berm and bluff; all runoff is to be contained on site; move pool to 75' away from existing bulkhead (swing pool area 90 degrees and adjust). 1350 West Cove Road, Cutchogue . Vote of Council: Ayes: All Motion carried. No. 1129 Moved by Stephen Angell, seconded by Allan Connell, it was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees APPROVAL WITH STIPULATIONS of the Wetland Application of FRANCIS S. PERRONE 111-1-21 to replace pilings, floating dock and walkway damaged in December 1992 storm. 6' x 20' dock, ~' x 16' ramp. The CAC recommends approval with the stipulation that spartina patens by planted on the bare area of the beach above the Mean High Tide mark; make catwalk 3' wide with railings and elevate catwalk to 3 1/2' above grade and extend the elevated catwalk to within 5' of road to ramp to allow vegetation of the beach area. Haywaters Road, Cutchogue Vote of Council: Ayes: All Motion carried. No. 1130 Moved by Allan Connell, seconded by Jack RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold WITH STIPULATION of the Wetland 86-2-11 to construct a dock as shown proposed dock. The CAC recommends approval with the stipulation that upland of the Mean High Tide Mark, the elevate the ramp to ~, above grade. 3635 Wells Road, Peconic Vote of Council: Ayes: Bruce Loucka, Stephen Angell, Jack Hagerty, Patricia Isaksen, Robert Keith and Allan Connell Nays: Betty Wells Hagerty, it was Town Board of Trustees APPROVAL Application of DONALD MAGGIO on submitted survey and plan of Motion carried. No. 1131 Moved by Robert Keith, seconded by Stephen Angell, it was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees DISAPPROVAL of the Wetland Application of RONALD STRITZLER 9~-1-1~ to construct a retaining wall ~10' long, typically 6' above grade, with returns at each end. Length of returns estimated from survey to be 12' at west end and 22' at east end; actual lengths to be determined during construction by intersection of top of retaining wall with face of bluff. Smooth face of Page 3 . . . . Minutes April 26, 1994 bluff, in accordance with recommendations of Suffolk County Soil and Water Conservation District, to permit revegetation and minimize further erosion from run-off; use material resulting from smoothing as backfill behind retaining wall. The CAC recommends disapproval because it is not needed. suggests the applicant stop the runoff from the lawn and provide a natural vegetation or a berm to prevent the runoff. The Council also the applicant stop throwing lumber and other materials off the cliff. 3055 Sound View Avenue, Mattituck Vote of Council: Ayes: All Motion carried The CAC buffer of suggests No. 1132 Moved by Stephen Angell, seconded by Robert Keith, it was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees APPROVAL WITH STIPULATIONS of the Wetland Application of RICHARD K. FRERKINC 115-12-9 to erect catwalk and floating dock per submitted plans next to area previously used as a boat mooring (stakes still exist. Catwalk 50' x 4'; ramp 4' x 12'; 6' x 12' float in liT" configuration. The CAC recommends approval with the stipulation that the catwalk be 3' wide and elevated 4' above the high tide mark; also the Council is concerned by the length of the project. The length of the project should be determined by need and must not extend beyond what is shown on the application. 680 Deep Hole Drive, Mattituck Vote of Council: Ayes: Bruce Loucka, Stephen Angell, Robert Keith, Betty Wells, Jack Hagerty, and Allan Connell Abstain: Patricia Isaksen No. 1133 Moved by Bruce Loucka, seconded by Jack Hagerty, it was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees APPROVAL of the Wetland Application of CEDAR BEACH MARINE SCIENCE CENTER 93-2-2.4 to conduct scientific research relating to the growth of cordgrass in fixed height intertidal shelves. In order to conduct the research applicant proposes to construct four intertidal wooden shelves to hold sand. Marine Learning Center, Cedar Beach, Southold Vote of Council: Ayes: All Motion carried. No. 1134 ROBERT PATTERSON 6-1-10 to construct guest rooms, terrace, walk, deck platforms and to install additional drywell in existing sanitary system. All construction activity to take place a minimum of 55' from freshwater wetlands. A continuous line of staked hay bales shall be installed prior to and maintained during all phases of construction activities and an area of "no disturbance" shall be maintained. Crescent Avenue, Fishers Island NO RECOMMENDATION, THE CAC DID NOT MAKE AN INSPECTION Page 4 . . Albert 1. Krupski, President John Holzapfel. Vice President William G. Albertson Martin H. Garrell Peter Wenczel Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold. New York 11971 Telephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD March 30, 1994 Chairman Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council Southold Town Hall Main Road Southold, NY 11971 Dear Chairman, Transmitted herewith are the following applications for a wetland permit: RONALD STRITZLER SCTM 194-1-14 Please prepare a written report of findings and recommendations with respect to these applications. Very truly yours, t2Lt,·1 ~ /&.~ (d~' 9. Albert J. Krupski, Jr. President, Board of Trustees AJK/djh . . Proper-T Permit Services POST OFFICE BOX 617, CUTCHOGUE. NEW YORK 11935 (516)734-5800 March 25, 1994 fñ)ffi©ffiUWffi~ IUù t-\f\,R 2. 9 1994æJ iO\~~C\~ ",;: SQ'JTHOLD ( Vii' 'Î: '../ 1-:,.---- President Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall, 53095 Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Re: Application for Permit on Behalf of Ronald Stritzler Dear Sir: Attached are the documents which have been prepared in support of the application for a permit to construct a timber retain- ing wall on the property of Ronald Stritzler in the Town of Southold, Suffolk County. Proper-T Permit Services represents Dr. Stritzler in this matter, and a letter of authorization is part of the submission. It is important for administrative and record-keeping purposes that all correspondence and the permit, when issued, be sent to Proper-T Services at the above address. If there are any questions, or if additional information is needed, please call me. Enclosures: Application Form Application Fees ($150 + $50) Letter of Authorization Notarized Statement of Applicant 30-Year Maintenance Agreement Short Environmental Assessment Form Project Description Vicinity Map Tax Map Project Section Project Plan View Site and Survey of Property Photos a sUbsidiary of THE PECONfC EASTERN CORPORATION