The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutTR-5894 Board Of Southold . Town Trustees SOUTHOLD, NEW YORK PERMIT NO. 51 9'1. .. JOSEPH PENDERGAST ISSUED TO .........00......... .....................00..00..... Autqnrilutinu DATE: .P.'pril 21, 2004 .................. Pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 615 of the Laws of the State of New York, 1893; and Chapter 404 of the Laws of the State of New York 1952; and the Southold Town Ordinance en- titled ."REGULATING AND THE PLACING OF OBSTRUCTIONS IN AND ON TOWN WATERS AND PUBLIC LANDS and the REMOVAL OF SAND, GRAVEL OR OTHER MATERIALS FROM LANDS UNDER TOWN WATERS;". and in accordance with the Resolution of The Board adopted at a meeting held on ..Ap!::U..~L 200~.., and in consideration of the sum of $?OO..oo. .. paid by !"''''':p..I:>..I'en<;l':.r:8.<l"t........ ...00..""" of ...m..l:'i"'I1"':.'" I,,;land ...... .... N. Y. and subject to the Terms and Conditions listed on the reverse side hereof, of Southold Town T rudees authorizes and permits the following: WeUand Pennit to construct a pier assemtHy consisting of an "S" shaped. pite-supported timber pier consisting d 35'. 25' and 10' sections. a 40' by 3.5' ramp, and a 24' by 8' float secured by four (4) guide pilings and Install five (5) mooring pilings, and with the condition the construction dœsn't begin until August and must be completed by January 31- of the following year, and as depicted on the plan prepared by Docko, Inc. last dated March 3, 2003. . aM In accordance with the detailed specifications as presented in the originating apptocation. IN WITNESS WHEREOF. The said Board of Trustees here- by causes its CorJ>orat~ S~al to be a~xed, and these ~sents to be subscn"bed by a maJority of the said Board as of this dat.e. 4;lA,;-~l'¿ ~.~)? /I. Trusiees TERMS IInd CONDITIONS ne Pumittec Joseph Pendergast .......:NN Oriental Ave.. Fishers Island -:...:..... at N. Y.. as put of. cbe <ODSidetatioo fo< the us..'~ of the Permit does ÞøCleøÞÐd and p«scribe to the foI- 1owÏ/IB: 1. TIw the said JIoud of Trustees and the Town oE ~Jð.oId - released from IJ1'f and aU damases. oc daIms for damages, of suIIs atØiøg. ctirccdy or iÐdItccdy as a ~ of IJ1'f oper- ation pedom>ed I",_nt to chis peøaIt. and the aid t>-nI-wI1I, at Ids or bet own ~. defend ...,. and aU IUd> llÚes 'InJtI,ted "" cbild futia, and the said 11 . 1/1- ...."..., fu1Ilåh11ity with respect cheœto. CO the ooøpll'fe ~""..w. of the IIøard of Tnsœa of the Town oE ~ 2. That cbIs PC1IDIt Is ftIid foe . pedod of 24. IIOS. .mld1 is CIO'asld-"'d to be the cs<i-..,ed time requùed to complete the -œ inwl1'ed, IJIIt iboaId mo-nre< ...--. request for on e><œøsåon _y be made to the Board at a bier date. ~. That this Pennit should be retaioed iadefUlÍtely, or as loag as the said permittee wishes CO _.I....ln the suuaure or project involved, to provide evidence to ~ ~ that ouch- cdzatioa was originally obtaiaed. 4. That the wodc imolved ,.¡u be subject to the i~ and appronl of me Board or Its agents, and ----'P"....... with the provisioøs oE the odgiaadøg application, may be coase for revocaâon of this Permit by œsoluâoa of the said Bœrd. S. That theœ will be no uøreasoa.tole interfeteOœ with aavigatioo as a ~ oE the wodc bcreia abtOOdzed. 6. That theœ sba1l be on interfeteOœ with the right of the public to pass aod repus aloog the bead. betweco Iùgb and low water awks. 7. That if future openâoas oE the Town of SootJ.oId reqaIre the I'eIDOftI UJIiIoc alœødoøs in the location of the wad< bcreia .,.... _I r ~, or If. in the opInIoc> oE me Board oE Trasœes, the . wad; sba11 cause _hl~ obsttuCtlOD to ftee øavigadoo, the aid p..-I- will be ~"'t..ttcd, upoo. clue onàœ, to rcsuo.e or alter chis wodc oc project bereia swed "'~ ~l~ "I to the Town . of. Soutbold. . 8. That the aid Board ,.¡u be notifkd "" the l'etmiuee ot the .. .~. Cf the wodc IIIIIh- orized. 9. That thep;._õ.- ,.¡u .obtaia aU other peønia and (V''{nlc·dJat may be requited sup; p1cmrt'tol to this permit ~ _y be subject to revoke upoo fellate to obtaia some. .' , 07/28/2004 13:31 8505727559 DOCKO INC PAGE 01 . . Dockol Inc. P.O. Box 421, Mystic. CT 06355 (860) 572·8939 Fax: (880) 572-7589, e-mail: dockoOsnet.net rBJ IE ~ IE ~ WJ lE JR'i U11 JUL,8 2004 :~ July 28, 2004 Mr. Alkrt Krupski, President Southold Board of Trustees PO. Bdlx 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Soutflold Town Board of Trustees Re: Joseph Pendergast Permit 5894 Dear Mr. Krupski: 'rhis letter is to inform you that Mr. Joseph Pendergast will begin dock construction at his property on Fishers Island on or about August 2, 2004 in accordance with the above referenced permit. The Permit sign will be posted during the work as required. The contractor for Mr. Pender8ast is D. ], Whelan Corporation, P. O. Box 2079, Sag Harbor, NY 11963. Yours truly, DOCKO, ,iNC. . 1-(1d 1l71~ Keith B. Neilson, P.E, !I- KBN:jG1 cc: Mt. Joseph Pendergast File: 04-04-1297 PENDERGAST . . Albert J. Krupski, President James King, Vice-President Artie Foster Ken Poliwoda Peggy A. Dickerson Town Hall 53095 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971-0959 Telephone (631) 765-1892 Fax (631) 765-1366 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD April 21, 2004 Keith B. Neilson, P.E. Docko, Inc. P.O. Box 421 Mystic, CT 06355 RE: JOSEPH PENDERGAST ORIENTAL AVE., FISHERS ISLAND SCTM#10-10-10 Dear Mr. Neilson: The Board of Town Trustees took the following action during its regular meeting held on Wednesday, April 21, 2004 regarding the above matter: WHEREAS, Docko, Inc. on behalf of JOSEPH PENDERGAST applied to the Southold Town Trustees for a permit under the provisions of Chapter 97 of the South old Town Code, the Wetland Ordinance of the Town of Southold, application dated October 18, 2002, and, WHEREAS, said application was referred to the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council for their findings and recommendations, and, WHEREAS, a Public Hearing was held by the Town Trustees with respect to said application on April 21, 2004, at which time all interested persons were given an opportunity to be heard, and, WHEREAS, the Board members have personally viewed and are familiar with the premises in question and the surrounding area, and, WHEREAS, the Board has considered all the testimony and documentation submitted concerning this application, and, 2 . . WHEREAS, the structure complies with the standards set forth in Chapter 97 of the Southold Town Code, WHEREAS, the Board has determined that the project as proposed will not affect the health, safety and general welfare of the people of the town, NOW THEREFORE BE IT, RESOLVED, that the Board of Trustees approve the application of JOSEPH PENDERGAST to construct a pier assembly consisting of an "S" shaped, pile-supported timber pier consisting of 35',25' and 10' sections, a 40' by 3.5' ramp, and a 24' by 8' float secured by four (4) guide pilings and install five (5) mooring pilings, and with the condition the construction doesn't begin until August and must be completed by January 31 st of the following year, and as depicted on the plan prepared by Docko, Inc. last dated March 3, 2003. Permit to construct and complete project will expire two years from the date the permit is signed. Fees must be paid, if applicable, and permit issued within six months of the date of this notification. Inspections are required at a fee of $50.00 per inspection. (See attached schedule.) Fees: None Very truly yours, ~..f? ~.t}. Albert J. Krupski, Jr. President, Board of Trustees AJKllms . . ~ April 6, 2004 ~~~R~::~~ Board of Trustees, Southold Town P. O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Southold Town Board of Trustees Dear Ladies and Gentlemen, Thank you for the opportunity to again review the application ofMr. Joseph Pendergast to construct a dock adjacent to our property on West Harbor, Fishers Island, NY. We have no objection to the proposed dock, but because we swim in the Cove, fish in the Cove and base our livelihood in the Cove, we would like to repeat our concerns. Our aquaculture business has been our sole source of income for the last 20 years. We operate both a shellfish hatchery and extensive nursery systems. Our hatchery cultivates microscopic larvae, the most sensitive stage of the life history, and operates from January through July. The hatchery draws approximately 1000 gallons of the Cove water per day during operations. This water is filtered with a I micron bag filter. On our dock we have land based upwellers which are flow through nursery systems utilizing about 100 gallons of Cove water per minute, and in the water attached to our dock are 4 large FLUPSY nursery systems that flow approximately 3000 gallons per minute. Our livelihood, therefore, is intimately dependent upon the maintenance of excellent water quality in the Cove. The Cove is very small and activities at any of the docks or on any of the properties (lawn and tree treatments for example) in the Cove affect the water quality of the entire Cove. Our concerns reflect this issue of water quality. I. The construction of the dock will cause a significant amount of turbidity in the small cove which could be a significant problem for our hatchery operations. We have larvae in the hatchery from the beginning of February until the end of July. Impacts to our hatchery associated with dock construction would be significantly reduced if construction occurred outside this time frame. 2. Floating sawdust from CCA treated lumber that ends up along the tide line in the Cove could cause a long term chronic problem. Shellfish larvae are extremely sensitive to copper. When we built our dock, we cut and trimmed lumber at a cutting station and removed all sawdust from this site. Mr. Neilson, ofDocko, Inc. states that there are . . . alternative environmentally sound materials, which would be best of all. 3. Cleaners and solvents used in routine maintenance of pleasure boats are extremely toxic to young shellfish and the food they eat (phytoplankton). In fact, they are harmful to all marine life. 4. The bottom sediments of most of this small cove are fine silts that are mayonnaise-like in consistency. The Cove is shallow and it is necessary for us to tilt our outboard to get from our dock to the channel at low tide, as it will be for Mr. Pendergast. Propellers can stir up the bottom and create turbidity throughout the entire cove. This impact can be minimized by tilting engines and using minimum power in the Cove. Without dredging, this Cove is unsuitable for a large inboard vessel. Carefully maintaining high standards of water quality in the Cove benefits everyone who shares it. I do not believe my concerns result in restrictive suggestions associated with this project. IfI can be of any help please don't hesitate to contact me. S;:~~~J Steve Malinowski, PhD Fishers Island Oyster Farm P. O. Box 402 Fishers Island, New York 06390 631-788-7899 cc: Joseph Pendergast Keith Neilson NYSDEC . . ~ PIRATE'S COVE MARINE P.O. BOX 365 FISHERS ISLAND, NEW YORK 06390 Albert Krupski Chairman, Southold Board of Trustees Southoldr NY 2 April 2004 Dear Chairman Krupski: In regards to the application of Joseph Pendergast for a dock and float in the inner cove of West Harbor on Fishers Island, I wish to urge your favorable consideration. Mr. Pendergast is a client of this boat yard and as such we are well aware of his boating enthusiasm despite the nature of his handicap. In the design process for his dock, careful consideration has been taken to accommodate his immediate neighbors' concerns and activities. The sensitive design process also accommodated the requirements which allow easy access for Mr. Pendergasrs physical handicap. The design also considers the limited nature of the small cove in which it is located. In short, Mr. Pendergast has had a dock project designed with sensitivity for all aspects of the marine environment. I would urge you and the Board of Trustees to favorably consider this application. Sincerely, X~~i- telephone: (631) 788-7528 . fax: (631) 788-7873 . email: pcminc@fishersisland.net . . P.O. Box 357 Fishers Island, NY 06390 April 12, 2004 Mr. Albert Krupski Southold Town Board of Trustees Southold, New York Dear Mr. Krupski: I am writing this letter in regards to the dock that Mr. Joe Pendergast is submitting for permitting. Joe's house is directly across from my dock in the cove. I fully support his building a dock, as it would be no hindrance to navigation in the cove. Mr. Pendergast is handicapped and in a wheel chair. A dock at his home would offer him the opportunity to enjoy boating and fishing. Therefore r urge the Southold Board of Trustees to approve his application for a dock permit. Sincerely, CY~~ Paul F. Tombari cc: Docko, rnc. . I . April 13,2004 Att.Mr.AIbert Krupski Southold Board of Trustee Dear Sir: As a close neighbor we have no objection to the proposed construction of the Joseph Pendergast dock to be built in our cove. SincereIy,John Ski Family #~. . . JOSHUA Y. HORTON Supervisor GREGORY F. YAKABOSKI TOWN ATTORNEY greg.yakaboski@town.southold.ny.us Town Hall, 53095 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971-0959 PATRICIA A. FINNEGAN ASSISTANT TOWN ATTORNEY patricia.finnegan@town.southold.ny.us Telephone (631) 765-1939 Facsimile (631) 765-1823 OFFICE OF THE TOWN ATTORNEY TOWN OF SOUTHOLD June 23, 2003 Keith B. Neilsen, P.E. Docko, Inc. P.O. Box 421 Mystic, CT 06355 Re: Joseph Penderaast Property Dear Mr. Neilsen: Please allow this letter to confirm our recent telephone conversation wherein you indicated that you would be withdrawing your client's application for waiver from the Trustee moratorium. As we discussed, you applied to the Town Board for the waiver. According to the terms of the moratorium, the Town Board will consider a waiver only if a residential or commercial structure is in danger of collapse or structural failure. As this is not the case with your client's dock proposal, you have agreed to withdraw the application. I am enclosing a copy of the moratorium law for your reference. You indicated that you may still wish to apply to the Trustees for an exemption, but I urge you to review the enclosed language. From the information you have presented to date, it does not appear that you have met the requirements for the granting of an exemption. Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or comments. \t~:õ;~~~ Patricia A~an, Es~. ® Assistant Town Attorney PAFlmd attachment cc: Town Board, Board of Trustees, Town Clerk, Town Planner - wlo attachment I"n~'"'' 10:46 86057275. DOCKO INC PAGE 01 . DOCKO,INC. P.O. BOX 421,14 HOLMES STREET MYSTIC, CT 06355 TEL t# ('6IJ) 572-1'3' FAX' (861J) 572-7569 E-MAIL tIocIW@",n-IIÐ Pkøse cøll tile øbove IIlIlIIMr if"u of tile pilgG of'''ò føx tin IIOt reuWd. Fax Transmission The information contained in this commrmication is CONFIDENTIAL. may constitute inside information, and is intended only for the use of the addressee. Unauthorized use, disc1oSll1'e or copying is STRlCny PROHIBITED and may be unlawful. If you have received this commrmication in e"or, PLEASE NOTIFY US IMMEDIATELY AT (861J) 572-1'3' AND DESTROY THIS TRANSMISSION. DATE: April 22. 2003 TO: Ms Charlotte Cunningham, Town of Sou/ hold Trustees FAX # (631) 765-1823 FROM' Keith B. Neilson, P.E. SUBJECT.- Joseph Pendergast PAGES: 5 MESSAGE: Ms Cunningham: We were informed this morning by the US Army Corps of Engineers that the permit for Mr. Joseph penœrgast will be issued shortly with the attached dock configuration. Please be sure that these attached drawings are the ones that are part of your submission. Is this project on this month's agenda? Please let me know. Thonks, Keith PLEASE CALL UPON RECEIPT OF THIS FAX TO CONFIRM ITS ARRlV AI.. THANK YOU. .. -. rõ)~C~DVJ~rm lnl APR 2 3 2003 IW Soulhold TaWIl Board of Trustees r . ;.. 5. "TJoE55 AI"I'I.JCA."T1ON ~WNGS ~ A COM~TlON OF ~ FOR IOE!RMt'r »U'lPOSES, Tl-tev Næ NOT ~ C~ DOCUt-1EN1'"S. 6..AOJOINING ~~ \/,1ST: EAST: J. W:S-reR P.AS<SONS Sl'EVe" MAUNO'MõIQ ~:2 ::;foI'IJ'1IN ~ ASl-teRS~. NY OO;90 eBõ!NARDSVII..U!. N.I ~ 04/22/2003 10:45 a3/141?003 11:59 85057275~ 8605727. . . . L...Oc:;::,.A. T10N ~ IIEFÐ'ENœ CHORf: !¡!~ I -.:: SGA<.E. 'lOCO N YAIiD!- 111::1 1000 I!:!Ic::::::I 11:::11::1 I' NOTES: 1. ~A"T"CN ='ATUM 5 _ ~ WA¡-r=R ;¡ l1CE DATA IS TAIŒN AëQM=NOAA l1CE 'A6!.S ~<'IICJ: :\\IEST~ ~. PRDJéCT"~ CONS~ so.u: OF ~Wlœ FÐCED \WOOD RI-S """D 'n""SEot PIER INSTJOU........ 8 X jA.. "-OAT 'Wffi1 ~TED HINGED ~)ONC ~NT" PlUNGSÞl.SC AVE ì1E~ "'UN~ ALL WA~~ OF n-tE APP,.o.RENT' HIGH WA¡-!::R.UNE "". PRDJECT~ "THS IS A I'RJ\IAT'E DOC>; FOI< ~~ BOA"T1NG. DOCKO INC DOCKO INC PAGE 02 PAGE: 82- . TOVV'N OF SOUïì-lOl-c:;, FlSHEf<!S 15~D --- =-- =-- \~ iJ It ... (: r'~ '. V \- 'ii =-- --. r~"·· ,~:, :~ \.'. ~ .' ). \. . .:",-,~._>: ':1 -,..;:) ==- ,... L ".." ,-'" .--.. . A·: p' :c"'¡ 'VV'ë:s-r _.-.. -<. '., ,: ':\ ~Ol<· _..,:"<:<>,. ~......"'\ ~' )" "". -', :.J.. :.- i . .". . ro',/'. .:ti- ·L~'-"·· _-- .... '~..L> . -- ". '. . . ~. ~. /. r' -' . '.'). P/~"TC.$ cove. .......~'. " . /'-·7""' ,'..:.1._., '.;. -- " . '~..,.. 0....- PflO.JECT: .....L-- '. / '., --.,/,:;', New F'IXED-""NO , .' .:.....);...,1). F'tOA7'7NGDOCK ~ >,;/. '.) 1<· '-;ì ,,/~~, =- .... "/-,-.. 7 ;"'-'L .... ".," =---..,~.. '....... :MI- -,- "~, '. .";, . /:..~... ~\ / , ''1.,.- i' '"\~/I ;'. . ,'''''-" , ." '/-' ;::õIOII- I. 'I' =- [,." -/ \. ¡. . - '::ãc- . " ..: . - '-.., ..-~ , \(). ~./ .~'-. . 'r!'" '" . . ." ..~ '. :¡:.¡..~ '-'. . .;. :.' "- . I .y ·_:~J,t~?> ,-'-- /.. . . . ,-=<i"t>To!i" --_ , .' " ~,.~~ '. ~~ . \ ' '....... .L"J:::... I \ ~. " .( ii'::'~.~~:..:':'~~ '. " \. _'/N/F'_.r ""'''''pem . .~"" ~- I .\.......,. , <' ~---- ~)'>~ .. ,'\ .- I \ \' OFPAJ<SONS ' ,( ': ';---- " ," \!p I ., ., . :- ....( i '." .. .;.....- ._..J ,-- <-- ..-.. -- ._~, , - . ....'" -- . p.~r: ... '; 0':; : ::J.~"': .: .., .. '. . PENOSiGAST .' NIF~JT:> __ . . .. OF MAWNO'W'SK: . O'v'ER......LLPf.-...A,.N 03-G031"CD& WA~AY; ""ON DATE: ~: ~5(;,Itt&.! r.¿QO I I AQC 300 z¡c¡"OO 0 AOO NEVV F'1XED PlE!1ê AND FL-OA7'7NG POCK F'I$I.á ~ I$VIND, TawN OF $CIUTHOL.C> ~COUNTY, NIW"\"CIIII; ~T~ ~I~a. :200:2 DSEI"H ÆNOERG...sT PI2O..ecr; 11-14-0:2 ACO!! i.DCA-n:¡N. APR 2 3 2003 Southold Town Board 01 Trustaes -~"-~.1'oC.~1O.z.......... r_.Ã._"'''''' ,AGENT: 5>1IõE1" , OF ... DOCKO. INC. l:oIIfte.~Æ ~,cr 0Q!!ð seo 512 eø!IIíI _ IJSO 512 7!!S êl""\AL:L' ~_,~ DWG ~1»7.'" 04/22/2003 10:46 86057275tþ DDCKD INC . ~ ~ ~- NO<nH 4 ;1(....0 I IX.....o I I I I I I I I I I I I I I PI.c<..o...TE5 COVE "-"7 x..... ~ -~ -~ -- / - -~ -~ ~- , I I \ \ -. . >(4'" x.¿c ~~- \ , , " I I I / -5.' ;rt ~ ...._-'- NOTE: Wêi'LoNos SUIlVEY by I<ICHARD ~ (US. x;oe CI1ITB!JA) ,..,--~- - ...Q ......... , --- -~ -- , , , , , , , , / I .....X I I I I / / .' / / ~ ~- ~ / / .' ~~- --- , , ---- -_...~"- --.....- x·:'.o 4.0 X 4 ---- eorrot1 SEPlMENT'S : LDOSE SU , / --,-"---- - -- --~~-- _).0 -- / / -"---- .' / / , -, ·3.AlX " -~X-----_/ .,..,11. PLE / , --........... ~-~ -- X-L6 X·IS .:J-;l.'.... --- ".--"- .1.3., .." .- X~g - :;;;\...... , '-""6 ~ -"".- / / / ,.- PAGE 03 EXI5TN:; F\..Oo<O."ING DOCX -~ ~ ~ .- --=--- ..~ / / / ,..:2EX15'TNG / / ,.022X, / , ~ , / / / ~/.?T/NG- C:Q~rnON5 ~se,.o.u:1·.X'· .'" PROJecT' l..OCA11ON: NEI),I FIXED PIEr< />NO FLoA 77NG OOCK 10 " ;x) APR 2 3 2003 WATERWAY: DATEõ: AI'P\,.JC;ANT: ~ ~ ISLMIO, NEW VORl:: WASHNGTON COUNTY. CONNECTlC\iT PIAA"IS COVE oc;TOBER ð. 2002 JOSEPH PENDERGAST Southold Town Board of Trustees AGeNT: SHEET 2 OF'" DOCKO, INC. K.i1116._,Æ . ...."...." CT" 06SSS ð60 577. 8939 FAX ð60 5T.2 7S69 S'1AIL: ~ - ..rtJWt ~~~,",= lOIð1X:1C7.:11I-A9""'" £'....~ ~ D\WG ~297.02 04/22/2003 10:45 . 03/25/2BB3 11: 34 85057275. 86B57275'ð' DOCKO INC OOQ<O INC . PAGE 05 PAGE: B2 NEVv' 716.oFF PILE! TOP a. r7", (TYP) -. ...,- NfiVv' FLOAT wrrH V---Q:2..NT1NUOUS ~TAT/ON -Þl...WOD--- f',JC:;Jr;!.-rH /iiii!1-E!!!'V"""" TlC:;Jf',J _-.a 1'.'0' '" ~ " '0 NfiVv' 8' X 24. . FLOAT \M"1"H CONTINUOI..JS FI.OATAíION New FI-OAT QESTr<Airvr Ne:v.t /iAMP UFT PlU: íOP a. 17 .. (TYP) CIi055 SR....a: Ne:v.t ~. X 40 ' Ne:v.t FIX6D PIS< [lêAMP eNO a. 5.. MAX SL.OÆ l' f'1A)( 5I-OÆ 1 ; NfNV ~L.. EL.. 4FT ABOVE DIiECK SSGlNNING E/...7~ - New 71E.oFF PILE! TOP EL.. 17", (TYP) - Þ+-NV 3.""":&' - -- -.. -Þl...WO,O--- --- ~~~.::::~..,..!\;~~":-..:;~,~~. ~;'''':'''''''''. f~t~?...~'~...':~;!j,,:~~"'...... '"' .....~_. .~.:' ·'tÆ.....~- . :;_.,,--:.;::.~,,:-~":f.~~~."'~~I'" ":':;7.< ~_ ._'.~.".........""'V!"""'_ . Ne:v.t 5UPPO~ PI¡,JE (TYP) NEW SP/..IT ..çL."AMP arid ~SS e~E ('TVP) ,^""ss-r Eal-s'v',...,..,-nOf',J ~~1·.2O· "" '0 " 20 CIIIO.J!CT' NfiVv' FIXED PfSl.AND FLOA71NG DCX;K IŒV1SED ,Þ~2 ;OCOE COER I!LAV Þ<'T1ON RI!MSED >13-Q3 ;OCOE "'1III~Tx:¡N IUMseD >~ ÞCŒ- Þl:X). DIr1eN51ONS 1-DGA"T1QN, reI_1>5 1SI..MC',...ewYCAK w...eHil'GTON c::a\.NTV. c:;oNNeC11CUT W"TTiifN-/Þ<Y' I"W'TE!S COIlE DA'Æ CJCT08I!R 8 = C) ~, J05I2F'" ~ )OGI!NT: $HI!ET 4 OF 4 DOCI<:::.C). INC. o::.tIt1l5,_PIi ~ cr0es5 860 572 ðØ?J9 F"'" 5SO 572 75*1 EI'-\ItL:. ~ . -~Øf" DWQJ ~'»'1 """" _, o.:.dœ.lM ;!J25I:IQœ 9.!50""'" """"'" --..,... 04/22/2003 10:45 e3/14/2eB3 11:59 8505727559 86857275. DOCKO INC DOCKO INC . PAGE 04 PAGE 83 . . ~...- .......... " ~-- / --.::> ~ -- :--- ---'" r- ~= :1 ~- ~=~ -,---- ---:) =--===-~ ~~ -=.l r-===- -=.=1 :----=---~ -------= =====~-3 =~ ~-~ :- ==---', -=- _-=.=:4 I..E (7'YP) -- -- I _____ =;==~ , ,/ ..~3 -2-'-- ::xs:~::-i '.."'LL"..·· .",.. ,,' -, :;-=,~\5 . ." ... ~,~~"'3 . --------- , , .3~ :::::- -;::- ø . ~ *... -- , . . / _NEW-*(X.40 - - -J:ilAMP ,I " ~ NEW 5LJP'PO~ STONE w. PILE (TYP) .." , ---~-- - ------ ----:.:..;.-:~ NOTE,'CRP'~ ~_.c;e 'PONT IS n-e I!'r"'~T AT THE WATERWARD E!N:' "'" £(¡S1"N9 WÞU.~ ..... " PI~Te.s C:OV5 ~ ¿;¡;Jf1' ~--..:.- :::.~...:::;;:::~ ~ .. I)Q5'TN¡; \ fU:IA,'Ttd ooa f I~ I ~.- ~- ...-,... -..;.......-:::...-:::.:.-. I I I I NEIW 175-OFF !O';fOt"", ~ENT5 , LOOSE 54- T N(!iW FL-OAT t:eES772AJNT Plt..E. ("T"'r'P) / _ ,NEW 8 '.x 24- ' FLOAT =:aQS"T'J\G /," ¡;~= ~~5~ r~~,,-1-, _ r ~ /¿'" 6 '., NEW RAMP UFï-, '. '. ~ .~' -3 -/ .... Cf<Ð55 17MSé~ "¡'- ~_-,=-_ OILE \!\ ~ NEW 4" \MD¡E ~ Pla<1 - --.- -'. Ef:!,? ~!S .~ -~.:.:::;=--_. -- - - . -- ---- NEW HAND~/;; .' ,- - - ,.' - - -.. do' ABO\/EE DECK _1 AI<SA OF 5CA~- .. ~ ~OOO"T"Me!!RS -. '- .... _..._. _" ::~.:=:<=-- k~~~ ·-~w..T^T~ '-4-:- Jïi7¡;:~___~\J,; ;¡y~a·~ "'f, . sø............ OF .Þ- Ilil/'lil':';' ,,1/:.» '/1 -¿;..~ .. ~ - .1.11.1..,--: '1'11" ',' ,:)0:: "x 1:< WOOD 11 eel'! ' .","-'i-" 't". ~ .. ____~ ~- __ .......... ~r 'I .~ ~.-- ~~~, -~ -- - -- - "' - -' .~..::....-.' ~..- - -". " ..,..-~.._~=----- - - - - ~- - y ¥ ;;..."" -- ¡ _ _.1 ..----......--.---...".~-.--- . ;,i'~...: .:. - - -_ ,---'-' y .--.,., '*'" ..-/../'. .:~-- .. .>.._...__.~~~. .<......-.- - --~.~:;,:;.:-:=:~:-:-~.... ~~/~ -- / ..~__._._.-- .....< /' . WAU.. "_ _ _ '" -- "-. ,~._"'_-:-.ç;:..,.. ,-.' , SEGINNIN . .- - - - - - - .- - ..- :-~ _..~~-;;:~. ,¡¡... ~~-:.~ 7:: ·-""="I..._n. _ _ ..-../.-;:::-......-::: ... .~ ._..J"': ~'-'-r= ..-,--.--. _____ .,;¡o,#_'._.- ."_.. ~, I ~ ~',- __.. " / _____ '"""''"'no:.......... ...___...~"". , _;", I OF ÆNDERGAST - X) .., 0 ÆOJEw'Ï: NéVV FIXED PlS2.,..4ND P'L.OA í/NG r::xx;1< -.-...-.-. / -._- -:< P'-"""""-J '-""IE'^' -.::~ ".X>' I XJ -.'W-It . / r' (. ::'0- Southold Town Board of Trustees L.OCA'I1O"< APR 2~T AGENT, sr-eET 3 OF ... DOCK-O. Ir--.J.C. ...., e. "'*"" ~ ~ cr 06æ5 f!JI!I:) 5T.2 .Me!' !"AX ð£,Q 572 iSEi9 Ef""\¡IrIIL..' --liIlBf'nwt OWG 02~~zr¡ ~,.....,...'CX)CJC;g,NC..~~~''IO-4''''''-¡ F......d. þiM'f~ 09.-0603 MON 12:53 FAX 516 765 6145 SOUTHOLD CLERK ~...:¡.""* Accounting IilJ 001 . . ELIZABETH A. NEVILLE TOWN CLERK REGlSTRAR OF VITAL STATISTICS MARRIAGE OFFICER RECORDS MANAGEMENT OFFICER FREEDOM OF INFORMATION OFFICER Town Hall, 53096 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Fax (631) 765-6146 Telephone (631) 765-1800 southoldtown. northfork.net OFFICE OF THE TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Re: President Albert Krupski, Jr., Boar~ Trustees TownClerkElizabethA.Neville ~ Fishers Island Harbor Committee response to Joseph Pendergast dock permit To: From: Date: 6/9/03 I am sending you the response received today from the Leslie Goss of tbe Fishers Island Harbor Committee on the above. 09'06 '03 MON 12:54 FAX 516 765 6145 . SOUTHOLD CLERK ""*""*-+ AccOunting I4i 002 . . Fishers Island Harbor Committee POBox 176 Fishers Island, New York 06390 June 5, 2003 Elizabeth c. Neville Southold Town Clerk 53095 Main Road POBox 1179 Southold. NY 11971 f, - ,_~'/ED J~,: 2JJ3 South old Town CIeri Dear Ms, Neville. - I am writing iii respOnse rô your recjuesl for reView'änd Input of the FlsIi-ers IstãnOBaioor Committee reg-.uding the Joseph Pendergast dock permit application and the Town Trustee dock mOraIorium. This is the first time the Town has asked for our review and comment on a dock pennit application. We have supplied unsolicited comments in the past on various dock permit applications from Fishers Island. Although we appreciate Ihe opportunity to comment on Fishers Island shoreline and harbor activities and issues. we are somewhat unelear as to why you seek our input regarding the Pendergasl dock. According!O the documents you sent for our review, the NY DEC and NY DOS have issued approvals for this fixed pier and float. It may be that, according 10 the documents, the Trustees were unable to conducI a Bile inspection before the moratorium went into effect? The Committee met on May 23" and discussed this permit application. Our Comrninee reviewed this application using the same criteria we use for approving and siting mooring locations. We considered impacts on navigation, the environment, and the adjacent properties. The orily concern raised during our discussion was !bal of water depth and the size of !be vessel using the dock. Weare unclear about the size of thc vessel or vessels that will be docked at this site. This particular area is shallow. In the past we have not issued mooring pennits for larger vessels in shallow areas despiTe their proximity to launch sites or particular requesls of the mooring pennil holders due to our concern of chw-ning up the bonom. Thank you for seeking our comments regarding the Pendergast dock permiL application. Perhaps the Town will solicit comments from th r Committee pennit applications at Fishers Island as well. - - ~-- - M~~r~~~, ð ' Þ&.cs~Goss Chair J .. . Cocko, Inc. P.O. Box 421, Mystic. CT 06355 (860) 572-8939 Fax: (860) 572-7569, e-mail: docko@snet.net January 7, 2003 Ms Charlotte Cunningham Town of South old Board of Trustees P. O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971-0959 I:'¡- 9 ,}nW "-' ' '__ ,7t-' Re: SEQR, Part 1 Applications Joseph Pendergast, Richard Bingham, Lucius Fowler Dear Ms Cunningham: In accordance with our conversation last month regarding the three above-referenced applications, we are pleased to transmit herewith the SEQR, Part I application documents which you requested. I trust you will find these documents complete and acceptable. If you have any additional questions or concerns please give me a call. Very truly yours, DOC~O, \N~. ( ~ t;ß~,,- Keith B. Neilson, P.E. KBN:jm Enclosures CC: File: 02-06-1314 FOWLER 96-09-705 BINGHAM 02-04-1297 PENDERGAST . . ..... SEQRA RESOLUTION RE: JOSEPH PENDERGAST SCTM#10-10-10 Resolved by the Board of Trustees of the Town of Southold that the application of JOSEPH PENDERGAST more fully described in the public hearing section #20 of the Trustee agenda dated Wednesday, December 18, 2002 is, pursuant to the SEQRA rules and regulations, an Unlisted Action; and be it Further resolved that the applicant is required to submit Part 1 of the Long Environmental Assessment Form (LEAF); and be it Further resolved that upon receipt of the LEAF the Clerk of the Trustees is hereby directed to commence a coordinated review pursuant to SEQRA. . , . Telephone (631) 765-1892 Town Hall. 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 Southold. New York 11971 SOUTHOLD TOWN CONSERVATION ADVISORY COUNCIL At the meeting of the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council held Monday, November 18, 2002, the following recommendation was made: JOSEPH PENDERGAST to construct 28(+/-) LF of 4- wide pile and timber pier, instail an 8'X 24' float with associated 40' hinged ramp and restraint pilings, five tie-off pilings all waterward of the apparent high-water line. Located: Oriental Ave., Fishers Island. SCTM#10-10-10 The CAC did not make an inspection, therefore no recommendation was made. -I \0 'f /~/ . . JOSEPH PENDERGAST NEW FIXED PIER & FLOAT INNER BAY OFF PIRATES COVE AND WEST HARBER FISHERS ISLAND, NEW YORK OCTOBER 14,2002 Prepared by Docko, Inc. NARRATIVE STATEMENT GENERAL The Pendergast's have bought property which fronts on the Inner Bay located off Pirate's Cove in West Harbor on the north shore of Fishers Island. It is their desire to have a fixed pier and float at which they can dock their motor boat. The site is situated between the property of Mr. J. Lester Parsons and Mr. Steven Malinowski on the south shore of Inner Bay. Mr. Malinowski operates a shellfish aquaculture facility which is dependent on clean water for the health of the shellfish. Mr. Parsons owns a small docking system for recreational boating immediately west of the Pendergast property. Clockwise around the Inner Bay, other properties are owned by John Ski, Ronald Zanghetti and Paul Tombari. On the north side of the entrance to the Inner Bay is property of BD Remodeling. BASIS OF DESIGN Mr. Pendergast is handicapped and utilizes a motorized wheelchair for mobility. The dock system for the Pendergast usage was originally to consist of a fixeq pier, sloping down gently from a 7-foot elevation at its beginning, to a S-foot pier elevation at the end, followed by a hinged ramp to a float. After considerable discussion with Mr. Malinowski, the pier was aligned so as to parallel the Malinowski dock and provide access to the deepest water possible (at lease 4 feet deep in accordance with NYS DEC policies) within reasonable length of shore from Mr. Pendergast's shoreline. In an effort to avoid as much bottom scour with its resulting turbidity, the end of the float was kept at a point where the deepest water was accessed. Water of a depth of S feet was measured in this area during bottom probing, The float position was on the line between the outennost extent ofMr. Malinowski's dock and Mr. Parson's dock. Mr. Malinowski called as a result of the draft dock concept plans and requested that the float system be re-aligned slightly to the west so that the bottom turbidity issues would be minimized. This modification was made and drawings were issued to Mr. Malinowski and Mr. Parsons. Mr. Malinowski raised four other concerns: dealing with construction timing, containment of saw dust, avoidance of solvents and minimum power maneuvering, all of which will be accommodated by Mr. Pendergast. . . Mr. Parson's response to the drawing indicated a significant objection to the amount of encroachment of the pier and float; that it would adversely affect access to his dock and use of the "Inner Bay" as a hurricane haven. Accordingly, the float and associated tie-off piles have been moved shoreward 15 feet and the northwesterly tie-off piles on the south slip have been removed. Additional field work has been doneto assure that this configuration will not interfere with the range line Mr. Parson's has established for access to his slip to avoid navigational conflicts. Mr. Pendergast is also not adverse to people securing their boats to his piles during hurricanes. In addition, in order to maXimIze compliance with ADA standards for handicapped access, the pier has been shortened 20 feet and a longer hinged ramp of 40 feet is to be installed. Because of the weight of the ramp, we have made the float a 24-foot length and landed the ramp near the middle of the float. The tie-off piles have not changed their location as a result of the longer float. This configuration however, will allow Mr. Pendergast ride down the ramp and access the northerly edge of the float from which he can immediately board over the cockpit gunwale into his boat. This boat will be tied bow in (to the south) to allow for this access method and in order to keep the propeller in the deepest water possible to remain sensitive to Mr. Malinowski's concerns about turbidity and water quality. The pier will span the tidal wetlands fringe at the shore with a beginning deck elevation of 7 feet to allow adequate sunlight exposure during the morning and afternoon to the grounds beneath the deck. Wetlands along the fringe of the Inner Bay were marked by a certified soil scientist using US Army Corps of Engineers standards to provide the most accurate data for compliance with standards. The end of the pier remains at elevation 5 and the ramping section slopes at 1 foot vertically to 12 feet horizontally, in accordance with ADA standards. Mr. Pendergast has agreed that the hinged ramp will exceed this 12:1 slope when the tide is at the low end of its cycle but feels that this is acceptable for his use and approves of the design. Accordingly, known concerns over this project have been accommodated and a safe docking facility can be built at this site for recreational boating in accordance with existing laws, regulations, design criteria and standards for approval without impeding navigation or public access to public trust lands and waters. The revised application drawings have been issued to Mr, Malinowski and Mr. Parsons so that they have an opportunity to comment on this modified approach. 2 I , I , I " ¡ ~ I :--1' , I , I , .,,-¡-,. ~, t . ., .'~ "---r , I , I , I r-:-~ I I ,j I " I 't ... ¡ 'x'" ~~ ":'<-~ ,/ ".,..... "+ s -& , , ~ \'- \ S t '" " , ' ./ ~ ./~ / .// ~ ~ " " . )f, . '0, -'-, " 1,-~8\ é· ,,'-- . ~ . NEW FIXED PIER & FLOATING DOCK INNER HARBOR I PIRATES COVE FISHERS ISLAND, TOWN OF SOUTHOLD SUFFOLK COUNTY, NY JOSEPH PENDERGAST OCTOBER 8,2002 LOCATION MAP " PROJECT: WATERWAY: LOCATION: i Bl - - - ~-- APPLICANT: DATE: , I , ..,.:.it' Sea flower Reef - light- ¡-J ¡.. r.. J --I j s , "CO_ , o~,,- '''; \.Ot\J-~ '" t\f._\J~O\.\Z'" ___-S ' .-/ -- --- /~ ~ / " / / /.- ,,-" /- - '~ / ./ ~ ~ '.,~.. , . 'i" '- North +Ig, ~1\.;.)26,1 DUmpling " '-.. \1 b" ~ 'f¡ '" <¡'. .-?" . , ( \ FO., H..mm",,'ck , ' \ lùt'\J o .,. :_:¡..~ ,S ;"----r i' I tl ,;;--5 uth , \,' \¡ umpling i II : II ~ " 60'" 1'4 ~s ~ " I, " '. "ì II II', " ." " " " " r '. -', -If- , J F,; :;~~~_L I' II Havv¡,.L N.. <- " , .' S 0 V,' " *--- , . Í i / ;,--.w--- 1.-0-.-- " , 1,:'--- ::-- -¿------~--=-- //,+ "\~' l~';;-'-"/~~~__~'~'/- I ~;?,. ,/ .__'1""b' hF.;"d.. I !:¡"B~¿:28 :"'-ç", [',--1,-'-- .' ",/10- ~, Ide~n..;'S: ~__ __ _ Pain..!; SOUN ~-- : " LJ_ _ 30 BLOC¡{ ISLAND" " " , . . NEW TIE-OFF PILE ----------TOP EL IT" (TYP) 'II !I NEW SUPPOR PILE (TYP) I II 1 4' CLEAR NEW FIXED PIER END EL 5 :" "',. NEW FLOAT WITH . = ~NII'Y.C~OU9>__.. _ -LWO.o--- ,= _,':-'''> ï -' ï.._- '\. --- - - -- ----------- ~ - --- --.........- ---~------ \_~;: ~~~~l,¡~y ·rI _..",-,. ~'BOTi :'~I :-1:::--1-'1:'111:- :-SP-NI: ~., =1.1 PRC::>PC::>SED Ef'.JD 'v'/EVV GRAP\-tICSGÞi...E '"=20" I XJ 10 o I XJ NEW TIE-OFF PILE TOP EL 17± (TYP) \ \ , NEW FLOAT RESTr<AlNT PILE TOP EL 17 :" (TYP) NEW .3~ X 24' !<AMP : MAX SLOPE 1:.3 . ".".,' ....- .' ::"<i":<:·\·{~.::i:;? NEW RAMP LIFT ROSS Bf<.ACE NEW FIXED PIER END EL 5 :" MAX. SLOPE 1 : 1 NEWf<..ßJL EL 4FT MOVE DEC/( BEGINNING EL 7:" 7" -,AH\V3.4':a:- - -,ALwo.o--- - -------- '. .,....... NEW 8' X 24' FLOAT WITH CONTINUOUS FLOATATiON NEW SUPPORT PILE (TYP) NEW SPLIT-CLAMP and CROSS BRACE (TYP) PRC::>PC::>SED PRC::>F/LE GRAPHIC SCALE 1· = 2.'J . I 20 10 o I 20 PROJECT, NEW FIXED PIER /'ND FLOATING DOC/( LQCA1l0N, FISHERS ISLAND. NEW YORK WASHINGTON COUNTY. CONNEC1lCUT PIRATES COVE OCTOBER 8 2002 JOSEA-t PENDERGAST WATERW'AY, DATE, APPl.ICANT AGENT, SHEET 4 OF 4 DOCKO. INC. KeITh B. Neilson, PE My,"c, CT 06355 860 572 8939 FAX 860572 7569 EMAJL: docko@snet.net DWG 02-04--1297 '--e,m Nell..Qn. cmc<"::>.I"':: 10''0.':200.:21149'"'''''' Pendergo..t--48d1."9 · ì ,. Jay Parsons 52 Chapin Road Bernardsville, NJ 07924-1102 Voice: (908) 766-5845 Fax: (908) 766-0711 E-Mail: jparsons3(.@cs.com ilil)\, A lllC" October 30, 2002 Keith B. Neilson, P. E. Docko, Inc. P. O. Box 421 Mystic. CT 06355 Re: Pendergast Dock Dear Mr. Neilson, Thank you for your letter of October IS, 2002 and revised plans. While you clearly intend to maximize Mr. Pendergast's dock, your changes are helpful and I have less objection than I did. This is not to say I approve a dock of this size, but assuming this is your final proposal I will not actively oppose it. I leave it to the Trustees and Army Engineers to decide the appropriateness of this structure. I must say I am concerned by the statements about Mr. Pendergast's disability. Building the proposed dock to suit his access needs is fine, but the landward end of this project is at the foot of a very steep hill. The house is at about the 40-foot elevation and no more than 100 feet inland. There is no way a motorized wheelchair can climb the hill. Carving the hill into a series of ramps of l2-to-l or less grade would be difficult if even possible and would certainly be unsightly. Constructing a tramway of some sort might be possible, but the result would also be unsightly and disruptive to the environment. I question whether the application should be considered unless the Trustees are also told what the plans are for providing a means for Mr. Pendergast to travel between the house and the dock. As it is, the application is silent about a matter that may involve considerable construction and that is essential to provide the intended use of the dock. Sympathetic as I am to everyone's desire to keep his boat at home and to Mr. Pendergast's special needs, it would be far easier, cheaper and less disruptive to the cove ~t~v~:~~ent for him to continue to keep his boat at a man f~ere he can dri\~'e his car to e~ou, J ,,~g Cc: Southold Town Trustees) Av-;",..¡ (")~ .~ .SEPH PENDERGAS" . . PHOTOGRAPHS ~ - ~"r:~ . ,:" " .r; . -- ."" , (.~.-I· . ",' , / . ~ .. ABOVE: THIS IS THE ACTUAL PROPOSED PIER LOCATION ALONG THE SHORELINE. THE VEGETATION IS AT ITS NARROWEST WIDTH COINCIDENTLY WITH THE NEAR CENTER OF THE PROPERTY AND REASONABLE OFFSET FROM MALINOWSKI IN THE BACKGROUND. .:~.5~. ...- - ~__.~~':'IIi . "\~ ~. ~~~ , ..-*';'~.":.'- ,.. - . ~~ - '1" (~--~ ~?:. .. ~I, ;::r . ".-. . .... .."'- 'i;:e~~~jff:~~,,~, .!I ~.-.:.-,~-:"~~ ." -,. --- ____··P./.-~..".,..~.. ",. __or-'-..' ._."..".r." ", .:,.:;.:...... _1±~~-"- "..,... v'.....;:-. ,~,. '~=':~ .'. .~...._-...~.~:- .:_}.~4~:~ _~~:- ,..¡;:.."... ::1;;~ .. '- .r:-[#'-·· .~-. .~- ABOVE: THIS PHOTO SHOWS THE PENDERGAST PROPERTY AND HOME FROM THE WATER LOOKING TO THE SOUTH. PARSONS' HOME AND DOCK SYSTEM IS AT THE RIGHT OF THIS PHOTO AND THE NEW PIER SITE IS JUST LEFT OF CENTER. ... ... JOSEPH PENDERGAST PHOTOGRAPHS I i '.,,--, r:'~l·L; ;:>:::':1 ~ -.,,;, ';':"'~'" '. ,,¡:'t:"-J' . 1'--"'. r, -...: '. -,:,' \ ~-,-r--::' L '.,.. .;y{ .:rW~·.? , :..:;-! 1IIl1,..- ÿ." ...- .....·,..c·" I'" .;; :':-·-r~-¿~- ~ ~---~.::.:.~:~. _0 _ _~. . I \. ---__~,..,. . . .,f¡........ .. .,t· r t ~ . r , . :v.~ ~~': ~q, .~... '. "..,~ . ·1.f.J¡ ;'~ , . ...' . ~I " ~~. ' ~ ~"""'.' ~ :...-... p'" -~-·.;c_r··<:"" 'r. . ""~ ABOVE: THIS PHOTO IS LOOKING EASTERLY ALONG THE SHORE SHOWING MALINOWSKI'S PIER AND DOCK SYSTEM IN THE BACKGROUND. THE PROPOSED PIER IS TO GO OVER THE ROCK OUTCROP IN THE CENTER ABOVE: THIS PHOTO SIMPLY SHOWS THE SHORELINE FRINGE MARSH, SPARTlNA ALTERNA FLORA AND SOME TIMBER DEBRIS. ... ... T Cocko, Inc. P.O. Box 421, Mystic, CT 06355 (860) 572-8939 Fax: (860) 572-7569, e-mail: docko@snet.net October 15, 2002 Mr. J. Lester Parsons 52 Chapin Road Bernardsville, NJ 07924 Re: Pendergast Dock Revised Drawings Dear Mr. Parsons: We have reviewed your letter regarding the proposed pier for Mr. Joseph Pendergast in the Inner Bay off Pirate's Cove and have made several modifications to the pier as previously discussed and transmitted to you by fax. We have moved the pier and float system 15 feet closer to shore to make sure that your navigation line is not impeded and we have talked with Mr. Pendergast about boats tying up to his piles during use of the Inner Bay as a hurricane haven, Mr Pendergast is glad to be of assistance in those types of circumstances. These revised drawings have been submitted to the Town as part of the official application for Mr. Pendergast. I trust that you will find these revisions acceptable and that they adequately deal with your concerns over boating in the Inner Bay. Yours truly, DOCKO, INC. /t;¿I9Jµ~ Keith B. Neilson, P.E. KBN:jm Enclosures CC: Mr. Joseph Pendergast Town of South old, NYS DEC, US ACOE File: 02-04-1297 PENDERGAST , ... ... TOVVN OF SOUTHOLD FISHERS ISLAND ..~ -~ ''''''olj I . '. f i j -r !.- ----. ---- .,/ i r-- \ NOI<1Hl \ . \. ,= I ..J:::- A -- < ' '''^'-'' ~ i. ' 5 ----- .---- ---- VVES T HARBOR ~ .~, ---- 1. ELEVATlON DATUM IS MEAN LOW WATER }--- . . /.' I COVE·"'-·_..;' " '.-.1. PROJECT: ·--··'L... NEW FIXED AND LOCATION r---1AF' REFERENCE CKART-13214 I = = = 1::::1 = I GRAH-1iC SCALE 1QD:J 0 1000 IN Y,AR[JS ._~ .~ NOTES, --- 2, TlDE DAT"- IS TAKEN FROM 2002 NOAA TlDE TABLES REFERENCE, WEST H"'1<BOR 3. PROJECT DESCRiPTlON CONSTRUCT 2é;'LF OF 4-FT IMDE FIXED WOOD PILE AND TlMBER PIER INSTALL AN 8' X 24' FWATIM111 ASSOCIATED HINGED RAMP AND RESTRAiNT PILINGS ALSO FIVE TIE-DFF PILINGS ALL WATERWA¡<D OF 111E AFPARENT HIGH WATER LiNE, , , -- z --- ~ / " \ \ 4, PROJECT PURPOSE, 111IS IS A Pl<JV"-TE DOCK FOR RECREATlON"'- BOATING, ---, I --- 5, 111ESE ADPcIC"-TlON DI<AIMNGS REPl<ESENT A COMPILATION OF SURVEYS FOR PERMrf PURPOSES, THEY ARE NOT CONSTRUCTION CONTRACT DOCUMENTS. 6, ADJOINING PROPERlY OWNERS, WEST, EAST J, LESTER PARSONS STEVEN MAUNOWSKJ 52 CHAPIN ROAD FISHERS ISALND, NY 06390 8ERNARDSY1LLE, NJ 07924 SITE PROPERTY OF PENDERGAST C==''v'ER-ALL N/F PROPERTY OF MA.LINOWSK PLA--.N GRAA-i1C SGAu: T = 400 I 400 300 xx::> 100 0 I 400 PROJECT, NEW FIXED PIER AND FLOATING DOCK WCATlON FISHERS ISlA\ID, TOWN OF SOUTHOLD SUFFOLK COUNTY. NEW YORK WEST HARBOR =r08ER 8. 2002 JOSEPrl PENDERGAST WATERWAY DATE, ADPcICANT, AGENT, SHEET 1 OF 4 DOCKO, INC_ Keith B. Neilson. PE Mystic, CT 06355 860 572 8939 FAX 860 572 7569 EMAJL: docko@snet.net II DWG 02-D4-1297.o1 f...e1rn Ñe<I5On D="-Q.I~,c 1010-'2oo2923,..:>.¡-1 P~"derg':>5T-l"""9 ),:..0:< ,,~~~ _=-==~~ _11)./ :::::~~~/"""'EXlSTING =--.:-~- x -09 // FLXED OO::~ 1 _ _ = '5í-~~t1~~/-"''';~'-'~ì 2 ~ \ <-0.3 I \ \&." __ -19 __13 II \!l _ ,- HW ---=- - ~ - - - / QA. \ ~ ~~ ~"'.w c c , ' - -'.2"IEXJSTING ._ ~ Á'i.<~'· ~~;" -::. ,." .___' ~"!J / ..,::.r, "."~.,"' _ _ -- O~;t-o~, .~~- /~tl-f:~~~;~ == WOODTlM8EI< _ :.~)._1\- ~ ;"r_,_o.'rI.. .i~__ =- . ~ ---~- 04 - _ ~ - ~ _ - -Q~ _1.1,__ ~"O:.! 09 ;:"".r"<.>-..- ., _- _--- :)5 ,-0.... '\,-0.& ./ 2\)_----- - - :..tt.:< ~ --------====--- ----= W"' -- -<~, ~,~W~ ... ,,' .'C._~~_- AL\V ~#- AAEAOFSCATTERED :.'"?:C" ..........32'ir--·~REM"JNS [!¡, . ~FlXEDD<:JÇ~ I ~... tn. "",-_WOODllMBERS __"-""""O"'~)('"",~ \"\J "", /./~5.·ì ~_--------=-..;:~ I' .. ~ '0;;-_____- "7~_ \è";;__·"..;2;>'./·· / V.A ~. __~.""'" ,II _ % . . . 03 '0. .,- ",0', ' _. .-;: _J/' / . 'i~1f PROP,!'!:<!.)f: EXJSllNG 1__ .c:-= ~_....._,~.~_~~12X12WOOOTIMBER '~r t/·r¡...-~"· -.;." ¡_~"' ~&¥.~oF~K~~ FIXED DOCK '" c '3' 1 . /' / - ~~, .' ~DS ~ MALINOWS~. Jr." ~~.;. . /'. ..;/('V UMrT ';~r<'.~'(-"b~"",,:"":&i:t'~...;,....,~;!,;x- - ~----." ;/·.~I./ r'--;IN"F~55- ~ - - -5EENOTE- ~þ~'r";.;wÄRÊNi--'" ~ '~~~~~';_~~":1HW":';"~';·..',~ ,'" '~,;<.5. ~'> .. __ _.~'-~:-_.:/~, 51 6EXI5TlNG ~PROPERTY I..JNE' . ." I . .. '-'-'O~' 6' . - ~ ~";-X-~'::~-'::'-----~·3.ð /'~ / 'SPARTlNA CONCRETE W..AJ..L -,=,,;,:'~,:;;;'i} ~ ""'T",-"-'=;~5~, " j;<5!'Î;~:¡~'''---x.'' c6~60!-f6%s· .."Tl!1~E.R'~"",~.,"\,§;~ ~"" PROPERlY '5 GRAPH.:; 5CAŒ ,. ~ 20 ~'St!("<,"''1~'î~;;ç::.~~~;~'&:;:;~:;'¡1;.j BRUSH l' _8- I 1NïFPROPÉi<Tti~ - ,~ OF PENDERGASr 20 "OF PARSONS,,:,:,,_AA"Al<ENT 6 C·. {{:-;;¿"'*3i~"'':,~~';~:O:,'::'ji' PROPERTYUNE "';'0 PROJECT, NEW FIXED PIER AND FLOATING DOCK ... ... - ~.~ , -- NORTh 4 ~. P/R-ATES COVE ~ ,1_45 , \'~, -40 ·'_-'-7 . 40 , I I , ~ -~"-- s I I , I I I I I ·5 . -40 ",·4Q .>...: \ -5.1' \ I '. '- ~~ NOTE' ~DS SUI<\'EY by RICHARD SNARSK.J (US, AGOE CI<JTERLA) . , --'-0 ' I -44'" I I I ~'-'-'"~"-" . -..Q -.. -4.ð:", --- . BOTIOM SEDIMENTS c LOOSE SILT -3Q - - ,~"- ·3 .36 v ·28 , ' ., ·';;--'0 RLE .--. ., ·_16 ._1.5 -;;.' ·.21. . ·03 , ·1.:3 " -16 -1.:3 . -03'-' LOCATIONc ~ --------,-"- ---======-----===- ~ EXJSTING FLOATING DOCK =--~-----=--- ~===-=.~~ --~--=-- ==--~---=~ ~"-' -'''-" ~~ ----- --- -- ~~=- --=---====--=--== -- --- --- -- ~- - --' --------------=---- ----- -- -3 -~.....--~ --------- ----. ----------===--=:=-=- ';),'.2'''/ ·2 . EXJSTING RAMP ., ',"';,10 ---------- --=-:=74·___73 ----- 10 I 20 o WATERWAY DATE, APPLICANT FISHERS 15lAND, NEW YOI<K WASHINGTON COUNTY. CONNECTICLfT PlAATES COVE OCTOBER 8. 2002 JOSEPH PENDERGAST AGENT: 5HEET 2 OF 4 DOCKO, INC. Kei1i1 B. Neilson. PE Mys"c, CT 06355 860 572 8939 FAX 860 S72 7569 EMAJL: docko@snet.ner Ke,Tt! Nell!50I"I, Docko,lro:; lQ.'8i200211..¡.9 AM PendergQI!ir--;?cM'9 DWG 02-04-1297.02 ... ... æ E " ·...0 S PIRATES COVE NOTE ' CRP CONSTRUCTION REFERENCE POINT IS TI-iE EYE80L T AT TI-iE WATERwAI<DENDOF "'~7 EXJSTING WALL REM"JN5. -'-,----- ~-- -- .------------- --=====~=- ----- -- - - - -~~--=~ =======---=---=---= - -------- --- =-------------=-- NOIVH --4 ':f:' I -«< r¡; .~ \ rtfj-p.1fP r-19 '';] " ~- ~~, ë~ 7J '±" ' ~EW TIE-OFF -.--_-:-.=- '- ,PILE (7YP) -- ~~~~' N£WFLOAT;O~2n,~~__:c ~ _ "";-"" PU' (rYP) '0 '. .l.±.'.,- '": ,'k~ -:CC ,-cfJ1C - - -4 NEW 8 'X 24 ' FLOAT, , -2::V / ~p ---=--.=:;It ·c·..· -Wp;~~NN~S . /'0· NEW!}~pX40 ~_~._ ~'o -~~._C~,~ ~ /. NEW RA-MP LIFT· ,..-" , '·0' -"""'=o,Wo~=~~- / -36 v, __ ~ II -3 CROSS TIMBER \j\.û , ·11 A. '::::=~.'='-.../·EXJSTING c:-..::~= _,-I -;;:~ 0 RLE ~ ^ -09 / AXED DOCK ~=--==- I NEW.. .4. E·NWlDDEEL.F,5¡XED PIER~ NEW SUPPORT ~T~~~G (O,~.::,~,- 1 ::=c. =1·'.' ~ PILE (tyP) ,~ H'';7 ·¡I -2·" - ,·'5 NEW HANDRAI~ " ~-.'9 -_ = ._', ".>'.:...OI~~~G /:'. .'-, ~ - -- 01, _0..1. _ 02 m ._ --,I _'-" -. -03 -09," 4 'ABOVE DeCK "7' WOOD ~~:, -01 ~~!',_~~ :¡ ·1 0' ~~D~~~D p. _ 2, ± ",;~:-~¡;O~, i~~~C~¿=~~ ¡ - - - 05 ~~.;i.."",-",.u -0' ,-o~ - - : --- ,~ " " J~== EXJ5TING ===: !,~!II~IT!I!11'rff¡II'I~} ,rl~~ ;',_ ,AL~=::;;-~/ ^ O' ,. 4 '~D~ 'f 1 I I ," II ¡ 05-____-- / WFl1""'~~·""g" ~L I Ilil,' J ¿ . Co..:: , j., \N/F PROPER~ - u -. 1"· X P WOOD TIMBER ;,..... WETlANDS' ~,... .... .' "",.~.':' EXJ5T1NG'- d,:;.ò·~~:-,,- -209.¿ .¿ ~~ -/ 'Í .\~~~:¿OF<r'H,,\.:·~>4-;" RXEO DOCK '0 J' ',- .(- - - - - ,- _.- - -"';; Y '- Æ UMIT"MAUNOWS':'~: - ,...¿- '~ ' Æ, . 5 ' t~. ~-<;'«"-"~,:'.:;r.;'.~.r.~;;¡;.'""J.<I~ \""".;---~:;. ;' -~~~,. ,'e .. 1'",,/;,,;',./·' EXJ5TIZG '~;;":~~~NE ,."".",.MHW,,"!,'1"! . -.. .:--',,-- _ _..~'_' ,..e,,-.¿..4., 7'" ,,".,'"""&_,7" /, / 6.1 CONCRETE WALL ~,"' ~:.;:J¡ _ _ _ _ ~"'-:;;-"'--"'" '38 /,' EGINNING 7 ", ":. ·~··~~I'· ='~~I;¡I·~I::..'iE"JS ~9>' /-,x_""EL.7± ..' '~ ' f"~71 71 ~-\__ STING i.vooDL, '., _.-..~,y~ ~-=<_.' . SITE ,.--_"-., TlMBERW,A.LL -.': h~ \'.'F6__ - nn........PERTY ~~\~~it~l BRUSH 5·' r 1- OF Æ~DERGAST - '~8- - do ~OF PARSONS:F;1_ADPAAENT 6, .' i"t~.~{;F;>2:~"€-\;~:t.:~~r?~~:~~~~~ PROPERlY UNE ____ - ~";B ¡; Pf<OJECf: ~ -;.¡fiP ",:::-'':': , \-<_4.0 I I I \ EXJ5TING \ R.OATING DOC~ M"UNOW5Ki ------=-----=.:... -- - =====-=-- --=.-=--- -- - -..'::; - PL.-Ao..N '-/1 E'VV GRA.PHIC SCALE. 1· = 20' 10 o I 20 NEW FIXED PIER AND FLOATING DOCK LOCATION FISHERS ISLAND, NEW YORK WASHINGTON COUNTY, CONNECTIClJT RRATE5 COVE =rOBER 8, 2002 J05EPH PENDERGAST WATERWAY DATE. APPLICANT. ,AGENT. 5HEEr 3 OF 4 DOCKO, INC, Kel1ti B. Neilson. PE Mystic, CT 06355 860 572 8939 FAX 8605727569 EMAtL: docko@snet.ner DWG 02:.04--1297 ~¡,t, Neilson. DX'-o.Inc;; 10.·'9'2002318 PI'1 PendergosT-3E.dv<.g .,/ i r-- \ """'"'l-- \ E \. ·."0. I ..J::.: - .A _0 < .~" ~ i ' l~--\ . -<..Le. ... ... TOVVN OF SOUTHOLD FISHERS ISL...-AND .~....) I . , r i ' .J I t.. ... s VVEST HARBOR ~ LOCATION r-----LAP REFERENCE Cft.,..,. , 13214 I ~ )::::I )::::I 1=1 1=1 I GRAPHrCSCALE 1000 0 1000 IN Y ARD5 - ----- ----- ...~~ ----- "-_." NOTES: ..",,- PROJECT. '~". ' . ......../-... 1. EL-EVAllON DATUM IS MEÞN lOW WATER 1---- If) 2, llDE DATA IS TAKEN FROM 2002 NOAA llDE TABlES REFERENCE: WEST HARBOR, 3, PROJECT DESCRJP110N: CONSTRUCT 2&LF OF 4-FT \.\I1DE RXED WOOD RlE AND 11MBER RER, INSTALL AN 8 X 24 FWAT \.\11TH ASSOCCATED HINGED RAMP AND RESTR.AJNT PILINGS ÞL50 FIVE llE-oFF RUNGS ALL WATER\VARD OF THE APPARENT HIGH WATER LINE, --- \ \ \ , \ .'.-\D, \ " ~( ,_. " ~ \\..-/N; PROPERlY A) , \ '. OF PARSONS " 4, PROJECT PURPOSE: THIS IS A PRIVATE DOCK FOR RECREAllONAL. BOATING, 5, THESE APPt..ICAllON DRAWINGS REPl<ESENT A COMRLATION OF SUR'vEYS FOR PERMrr PURPOSES. THEY ARE NOT CONSTRUCTlON CONTRACT DOCUMENTS. ORJENT.AI.- AvENUE SITE PROPERlY OF PENDERGPGT ~'V"E~LL 6, ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNEF<S: \VEST EAST: J. lESTER PARSONS STEVEN MALINOWSKI 52 CHAPIN ROAD FISHERS ISAL.ND, NY 06390 BERNARDS\~LLE. NJ 07924 I AOO 300 200 100 0 GRAP-i1C SCAI..E r = 400 ---- ----- -- / ! ',,- " ~-----~,/ !\ , \ I \ I --~. \ - ~-- , I N/F PROPERlY OF MALINOWSK PLAN I 400 PROJECT: NEW FIXED PIEr< AND FLOATING DOCK -,~. ~ ......., LOCAllON, ,,.'>-:\ . ~ ".\ . WATERWAY: DATE APPLlCN--IT, FISHERS ISLAND, TOWN OF SOllTHOLD SUFFOLK COUNTY, NEW YORK WEST HARBOR OCTOBER 8. 2002 JOSEPH PENDERGAST ,.' " " AGENT: SHEET 1 OF 4 DOCKO. INC_ KeI1'h B. Neilson. PE Mystic. CT 06355 860 572 8939 FAX 860572 7569 Er1ÞJL-: docko@5I1et,net I , " ~..'~ : .,(~¡~~: ,:; :~.~ ::'~','.~ ~;/ ~'_:.":"::'--'_/ ~ >-.ecth Ned5Ol'. Dc.d.o '<1C \0. 10 200.2 923 -"J'4 Pe""e~ga,,~-1 m'9 DWG 02-04-129701 ~ . October 4, 2002 Town of Southold Board of Trustees PO Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 or' - 0 Dear Sir, I have reviewed the application of Mr. Joseph Pendergast, to construct a dock adjacent to our property in West Harbor, Fishers Island, NY. As I have discussed with Mr. Pendergast, we have no objection to the proposed dock. However, since we operate a shellfish aquaculture business trom our dock and the boat Mr. Pendergast plans to berth at this dock is considerably larger than any of the other boats berthed in the Cove, I do have several concerns. Our aquacuhure business has been our sole source of income for the last 20 years, We operate both a shellfish hatchery and extensive nursery systems. Our hatchery cultivates microscopic larvae, the most sensitive stage of the life history, and operates trom January through July. The hatchery draws approximately 1000 gallons of the Cove water per day during operations. This water is filtered with a I micron bag filter. On our dock we have land based upwellers which are flow through nursery systems utilizing about 100 gallons of Cove water per minute, and in the water attached to our dock are 4 large FLUPSY nursery systems that flow approximately 3000 gallons per minute. Our livelihood, therefore, is intimately dependent upon the maintenance of excellent water quality in the Cove and my concerns all reflect this issue of water quality. Our Cove is very small and activities at any of the docks or on any of the properties in the Cove could potentially affect the water quality of the entire Cove. My primary water quality concerns associated with this project are: 1. The construction of the dock will cause a significant amount of turbidity in the small cove which could be a significant problem for our hatchery operations. We have larvae in the hatchery trom the beginning of February until the end of July. Potential impacts to our hatchery associated with dock construction could be significantly reduced if construction occurred outside this time trame. 2. Floating sawdust fÌ'Om CCA treated lumber that ends up along the tide line in the Cove could cause a long tenn, chronic problem. Shellfish larvae are extremely sensitive to copper. When we built our dock we cut and trimmed lumber at a cutting station and removed all sawdust trom the site. I understand fÌ'Om Mr. Neilson of Docko, Inc. that there may be alternative, environmentally sound, materials. If these other more environmentally sound alternatives are more . . expensive, we would be willing to discuss the possibility of making a contribution to help deftay the increased costs of materials. 3. Cleaners and solvents normally used in the routine maintenance of large pleasure boats can be extremely toxic to young shellfish and the food they eat (phytoplankton). This boat will be approximately 40 feet &om the nursery systems attached to our dock. Minimizing the use of these materials while the boat is at the dock would minimize the impact of this new dock on the water quality of the Cove. 4. The bottom sediments of most of this small cove are fine sihs that are mayonnaise-like in consistently. The propeller of such a large boat will undoubtedly create turbidity throughout the entire cove. I believe this impact could be minimized if care is taken to use minimum power in the Cove. We live on a beautiful little cove and I sincerely believe that maintaining high standards of water quality is not just important to our business, but in everyone's best interest. I do not believe that any of my concerns resuh in any overly restrictive suggestions associated with this project. If you have any questions or comments please do not hesitate to notitÿ me. Sïç¡rel~~t-, ~m'í~wski, PhD. Fishers Island Oyster Farm, Inc. Box 402 Fishers Island, NY 06390 Cc: Mr. Joseph Pendergast Docko, Inc. NYSDEC · - "' October 2, 2002 i, \ r , ZOOl L - Board of Trustees P.O. Box 728 Southold, NY 11971 Re; Joseph Pendergast, SCTM#1 000-01 0-1 0-10 Ladies and Gentlemen: As to the above named permit, my brother and I are owners of tax map #47388910,-10-2 on the Gloaming, Our property is directly across the cove from Mr. Pendergasts property. the cove is already overdeveloped. Each property owner should have access to the water from his property but not so to overwhelm the entire cove. The Pendergast project would affect all property owners in the cove, the area is just to small for so large a dock with tie off piles. This is a small sheltered cove, not a Marina. Furthermore, I was under the impression that all involve neighbors should have been notified about this project, we were not. Although we are not direct neighbors, construction of this magnitude would definitely affect my property in an adverse way. Would you please put me on the mailing list on further developments. Yours Truly, ~< Zc-~~ Ronald Zanghetti . . J. Lester Parsons, III 52 Chapin Road Bernardsville, NJ 07924-1102 Voice: (908) 766-5845 Fax: (908) 766-0711 E-Mail: jparsons3@cs.com Board of Trustees P. O. Box 728 Southold, NY 11971 3 LI ',. Re: Joseph Pendergast, SCTM#lOOO-OlO-lO-lO Ladies and Gentlemen: Although I hate to be a bad neighbor, I must object to the request of the Pendergasts for a permit for a 95-foot dock and tie-off piles next to my property on an (apparently unnamed) cove off West Harbor, Fishers Island, NY. I own the property immediately west of the Pendergasts, with a dock, as shown on Pendergast-3.dwg submitted by Docko, Inc. in support of the application. I should note that note 6 of Pendergast-l.dwg incorrectly places me to the east of Pendergast and Malinowski to the west. The drawings themselves place us correctly. I concede the Malinowski dock is about as long as the proposed Pendergast dock. I was not party to the Malinowski permit process and doubt I would have consented to the Malinowski dock being as long as it is, but the Malinowski dock is much less intrusive than the proposed Pendergast dock. It is in shallower water near the mouth of the cove, angles so as almost to parallel the shore east of it, and in spite of its length is no obstacle to navigation by others, since there are rocks northeast of it that require all traffic to and from the cove to pass well north of its northern end. Malinowski uses his dock in business and apparently needs its full surface area to rinse and dry the oysters he raises for market. No reason appears why tht> Pendergasts cannot use a much shorter dock, about the length of ours, extending only to the depth of three feet below mean low water as does the Malinowski dock and all other docks in the cove. If the Pendergasts have a larger boat, they should keep it at the marina. Entrance to and exit from the cove by boat requires close attention to mostly- submerged rocks northeast of Malinowski's dock and near the end of the road named "The Gloaming" as depicted on Pendergast-l.dwg. As an aid to myself and others, some years ago, and long before this application, I posted on my dock a day range, consisting of a yellow triangle on a piling and a yellow stick on a piling 10 feet behind it. By keeping the stick in line with the triangle, one can navigate in and out with safety. The trustees are welcome to examine the site, and I am no artist, but I believe the safe course marked by the range runs approximately (references are to Pendergast-l.dwg) from the center of the letter "0" in "PROJECT" to the center of the 'T' in "NIF PROPERTY OF . . . PARSONS" and passes extremely close to the proposed Pendergast dock. It looks like it may well pass south of some of the proposed tie-off piles. Consequently, a dock of this size with tie-off piles will prevent use of the range and be a hazard to anyone navigating to or from the cove. Far worse if a boat is tied to the dock and part of it protrudes north to or beyond the piles. Plus, I see no reason why I should have to detour around the proposed dock. It is twice as long as it needs to be to serve the types of boats everyone else in the cove (six existing docks, not counting those at the entrance) keeps and uses. Finally, although I am told casual anchorage in the cove is prohibited under the Harbor Management Plan, this cove provides excellent protection in hurricanes. When a storm threatens, small boats often tie to or near our docks, and larger boats anchor and raft in the middle ofthe cove. Since the Pendergasts propose to take over the deepest water and much of the center of the cove for their private use, this will no longer be possible, There will no longer be swing room for boats drawing 4 feet as there is now. I have no problem at all with the Pendergasts having a dock. I used to keep a 28' Bertram at my dock and have no doubt they could do likewise with a 55' dock with tie- off piles in line with the outboard end of that dock. The proposed 95' dock, plus IO extra feet of extension into the center of the cove for tie-off piles, is far more than needed, compatible with the other docks pointing into the cove center or reasonable. I understand that a longer dock would permit keeping a larger boat without grounding or churning up the bottom-so would it for us all. The answer to that is to keep a smaller boat. I respectfully request that this application be denied. I further request notice of any hearings on this application so that I may arrange to be present. Copies to: Docko, Inc. (applicant) Army Corps of Engineers . . Docko. Inc. P.O. Box 421, Mystic, CT 06355 (860) 572-8939 Fax: (860) 572-7569, e-mail: docko@snet.net October 15,2002 NYS DEC Environmental Pennits Building 40, SUNY Stony Brook, NY 11790-2356 Re: Joseph Pendergast New Fixed Pier & Floating Dock To Whom It May Concern: On behalf of Mr. Joseph Pendergast we request a Tidal Wetlands Pennit including Water Quality Certifications, as necessary, for a new fixed pier and floating dock on Fishers Island, New York. We enclose the following in support of this pennit application: .:. Four prints each of plans titled: Project: Waterway: Location: ''New Fixed Pier & Floating Dock Inner Bay Fishers Island, Town of South old Suffolk County, New York Joseph Pendergast October 8, 2002 Applicant: Date: .:. Four copies of the NYS DEC Joint Application, including the Short Environmental Assessment Fonn, Tax Assessor's Map, Photographs and Location Map. I trust that you will find this application package complete and acceptable; please let me know if the need for further infonnation arises. Very truly yours, 7~~~ Keith B. Neilson, P.E. KBN:jm Enclosures CC: Joseph Pendergast US ACOE Town of South old: Krupski File: 02-04-1297 PENDERGAST · .. ~ 95-19-3 (BJOO)pfp JOINT APPLICATION New York State FOR PERMIT United States Army Corps of Engineers Appllçable 10 él\eI1Cles ólnd perm,t categories hsted 1(1 Item 1. PI.... read aU insU!JcUons on back. Attadladdlllonarlnformallonssneeded. Please plinllegiblyortype. 1. Check pennlls applied for. 2. Name of Appllçanl (UM full name) I Telephone Number (daytime) NYS Dept. of Environmental Con..rvatlon JOSEPH PENDERGAST (631) 788-7560 o Stream Disturbance (Bed and BankS) Mailing Address 0 ORIENTAL AVENUE Navigable Walen; (Excavation and Fill) 0 Docks, Moonngs ()( Platforms PoslOffice I Stale I ZIp Code (Con6lruct or Place) FISHERS ISLAND NY 06390 0 Dams and Impoundment Structures 3. Taxpayer ID (If applicant is not an individual) (Conslruct. Reconstruct or Repair) 0 Freshwater Wellands o Tidal WeUands 4. Applicant I, alan: (check as many as apply) o Coasta! ErosIOn Control o Owner 0 Operator o Lessee o Municipality I Governmental Agency o WII(j, ScenIc and RecreaUonal Rivers ,. If .pp''''''' . ,at Ih. OW,.,, Id."ify ow,., h.,.· o'h....I,.. yo, m.y p',,,,d. A..'IConIBct P.<so' "fonn.tio" fa 401 Water QualIty Certification Owner or Agent/Conlact Person 0 O.vner [2] Agent/Contact Person Telephone Number (daytime) o Potable Water Supply MR KEITH B. NEILSON. P.E.. DOCKO, INC. (860) 572-8939 0 Long Isrand Wells Mailing Addrtl.s 0 P. O. BOX 421 AquatIC Vegetation Con!rol Posl Office 0 I State I ZID Code Aquatic Insect Control MYSTIC CT 06355 0 Fish Control 6. Project I Facility Locallon (mark location on map, see Instruction 1a.) NYS OffIce of General Service. Counlv. TownfCilvNdlaae: Tax Mao Sectianl Block ILot. Number: (State Owned lands Under Water) SUFFOLK SOUTHOLD, F.I. 010 10 10 0 Lease, Llœnse, Easement or Loçalion /lncludjn~ Street or Road) I TeleDhone Number fdavtlme\ other Real Property Interest ORIENTAL AVENUE (631) 788-7560 Uhllty Easement (pipelines, conduits. cables, elc) Poal Office sloIlel ~p Code 17. Name of StrMm or WaterDodv (on or near projeçt site) 0 Docks. Moonngs or Platfonns FISHERS ISLAND NY 06390 INNER HARBOR / PIRATES COVE (Cons!ruçt or Place) 8. Name of USGS Quad Map: LocaUon Coordlnale.: Adirondack Park Agency NEW LONDON, CT-RI-NY 0 Freshwater Wetlands Permit NYTM·E NYTM-N 4 o Wild, SceniC and Recreatronal RIVers 9. Project DescrlpUon and Purpose: (Category of Activity e.g. new COl1slluclionlínstallation, mainlenance or replacement; Type of Structure or Activity e.g. bulkhead, dredging. fitling, dam, dock, taking of water; Type of Matenals and Quantities; Structure and Work Area DImensions; Need or Purpose Served) Lake George Park Commission 0 Docks (Col'IStruct or Place) THIS IS A PRIVATE DOCK FOR RECREATIONAL BOATING. o Moorrngs (EstSDlish) CONSTRUCT 28 (+/-) LF OF 4-FOOT WIDE FIXED WOOD PILE AND TIMBER PIER, INSTALL AN 8' X 24' FLOAT WITH ASSOCIATED 40-FOOT HINGED RAMP us Army Corps of EngIneers AND RESTRAINT PILINGS AND FIVE TIE-OFF PILINGS ALL WATERWARD OF o Section 404 (Waters of the Umlect States) THE APPARENT HIGH WATER LINE. o Section 10 (Rivers and Hartlors Act) o Nabonwlde PeOlllt (sJ Identify Number{s) For Agency LJse Onty. DEC APPLICATION NUMBER US ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS I'.":.""'po,,· OJ'" r" Witt P",¡.ct oee,py] I:"~ P",po..d .tart F3. EoUm.tad ~omp'ot'.n o 0 0 .ta" La'd?0 0 D..., Date: POVIIII, PI.IbJlc Commercial Yes No 12/1/02 2/1103 1... Has Work Begun on ProJect? (If yes, attach 0 0/'" LI., P,.v'." P.nnlt f AppflcaU.n Numb....nd D...., (If Any) 8Aplanabon of why wor1l. was started without permit.) Y.. No 18. Wllllhls Project Require Addiüonal 0 0 If Yes, US ACOE, TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Federat, Slate, or Local Permlla? Y.. No Please List 17. If applicant Is nOlthe owner, both musl sign the appllcallon I hereby affiOll Ihat information provided on this fOOll and all attachmet1ts submitted herewith is true 10 the best of my knowledge and belief. False litatements made herein are pumshable as a Class A misdemeanor pursuant 10 Section 210.45 of the Penal law. Further, the applicant accepts full responsibility for alt damage, direct 01' Indirect, of whatever nature. and by whomever suffered, arising OIJt of the project described herein and agrees to indemnify and save harmless the Slate from suits, actions, damages and costs of every name and descnplio resulting from aid p r eel In addition. Federal law, 18 U S.C., Section 1001 provides for a fine of noI mortlltlan $10,000 or Impnsonmem for not more Ihan 5 j~~r both whe an a p reant ~V:I: and WIllingly falsifteS. conceals, or covers up e melenal fact; or knowingly makes or uses a false, ñcbcious or fraudulent statement o 1-'1, r'A)" T,tl. DateiQ.-ID-~ Signature of Appllea ~ . tot 1..1 ------~~ Dat'; h, r--, . f\.1 Signalu,. of Owner 1\ I. ~ L" lr. Title II I RESET I ( V r PROJECT 10 NUMBER /- 617.20 APPENDIX C STATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALl1Y REVIEW SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM for UNLISTED ACTIONS Only ( To be completed by A plicant or Project Sponsor) - SEQR PART 1 - PROJECT INFORMATION 1, APPLICANT I SPONSOR JOSEPH PENDERGAST 2, PROJECT NAME NEW FIXED PIER AND FLOATING DOCK 3.PROJECT LOCATION: FISHERS ISLAND, TOWN OF SOUTHOlD Municipality SUFFOLK County 4. PRECISE lOCATION: Street Addess and Road Intersections. Prominent landmarks ete _ or provide mao SITE IS LOCATED IN THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF PIRATE'S COVE AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF WEST (INNER) HARBOR. 5. IS PROPOSED ACTION: ø New 0 Expansion D Modificalion f alteration 6, DESCRIBE PROJECT BRIEFLY: CONSTRUCT 28 (+/-) IF OF 4-FOOT WIDE FIXED WOOD PilE AND TIMBER PIER, INSTAll AN 8' X 24' FLOAT WITH ASSOCIATED 40-FOOT HINGED RAMP AND RESTRAINT PILINGS AND FIVE TIE-OFF PILINGS All WATERWARD OF THE APPARENT HIGH WATER LINE. 7, AMOUNT OF LAND AFFECTED: Initially 100 +/. acres Ultimalely acres 8, WILL PROPOSED ACTION COMPLY WITH EXISTING ZONING OR OTHER RESTRICTIONS? ø Yes 0 No If no, describe briefly: 9. WHAT IS PRESENT LAND USE IN VICINITY OF PROJECT? (Choose as many as apply.) ~ Residential 0 Industrial 0 Commercial DAgricurture 0 Park I Forest I Open Space 0 Other (describe) THIS PROPERTY AND ADJACENT PARCELS ARE ZONED AND UTILIZED AS RESIDENTIAl. 10. DOES ACTION INVOLVE A PERMIT APPROVAL, OR FUNDING, NOW OR ULTIMATELY FROM ANY OTHER GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY (Federal, State or Local) 0Ves 0 No If yes, list agency name and permit I approval: TOWN OF SOUTH OLD TIDAlWETLANDS, USACOE PERMIT UDNER SECT. 10 OF RIVER AND HARBORS ACT 11, DOES ANY ASPECT OF THE ACTION HAVE A CURRENTLY VALID PERMIT OR APPROVAL? DYes 0NO If yes, list agency name and permit I approval: 12, PROPOSED ACTION WILL EXISTING PERMIT I APPROVAL REQUIRE MODIFICATION? INFORMATION PROVIDED ABOVE IS TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE Applicant ERGAST Date: Si nature D' O~ Ifthe action is a C omplete the Coastal Asses tal Area. and you are a state agency, ent Form before proceeding with this assessment .' - j . . PART II· IMPACT ASSESSMENT 0 be com leted b Lead A enc A. DOES ACTION EXCEED ANY TYPE I THRESHOLD IN 6 NYCRR, PART 617.47 If yes, coordinate the review process and use the FUll EAF. DYes 0 No B, WILL ACTION RECEIVE COORDINATED REVIEW AS PROVIDED FOR UNLISTED ACTIONS IN 6 NYCRR, PART 617,6? If No, a nagativa declaration may be superseded by another involved agency. o Yas 0 No C. COULD ACTION RESULT IN ANY ADVERSE EFFECTS ASSOCIATED WITH THE FOLLOWING: (Answ"", may be handw_n, ~ leglbla) C1. existing air quality. surface or groundwater quality or quantity, noise levels, existing traffic pattern. solid waste production or disposal. itanllal for arosion, dralnaga or flooding problams? Explain briafly: I C2. Aesthetic. agricultural, archaeological, historic. or other natural or cultural resources; or community or neighborhood character? ExpJain briefly: C3. Vegetation or fauna. fish, shellfish or wildlife species, significant habitats. or threatened or endangered species? Explain briefly: C4. A communIty's existing plans or goals as officially adopted. or a change in use or intenslly of use of land or other natural resources? Explain briefly: C5. Growth. subsequent development, or related activities likely to be induced by the proposed action? Explain briefty: C6, "ng tarm. short larm, cumulativa, or other affects not identified in C1-C5? C7. Other impacts (indudin cha as in use of either uanü or of ane Explain briefly: Ex lain brie D. WILL THE PROJECT HAVE AN IMPACT ON THE ENVIRONMENTAL CHARACTERISTICS THAT CAUSED THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A CRITICAL ENVIRONMENTAL AREA (CEA)? (If ves, expiain brieftv: DYes 0 No I , Ö"::.',oÖ ::r"~'roŒ,c~'~"~~ro~'"'''~'''--~'"'~'m .-.....1 PART III. DETERMINATION OF SIGNIFICANCE (To be completed by Agancy) INSTRUCTIONS: For each adversa affect idenllffed ebove, determine whethar n is substantial, large, important or otherwise significant. Each effact should ba assassed In connaction with Its (a) setting (I.a. urban or rural); (b) probability of occumng; (c) duration; (d) irreversibility; (e) geographic scope; and (I) magnitude. If necessary, add attachments or reference supporting materials. Ensure that explenatlons contain sufficient detail to show thet all relevant adv0fS8 Impacts heve been Idantlfjad and edequately eddressed. If quaslton d of pert II was checked yes, the datermlnetlon of significance muet avaluate tha potential impactofthe proposed action on the environmental characteristics of the CEA. Check this box If you have Identified one or more potenüalty large or significant adverse impacts which MAYoccur. Then proceed direcUy to the FUL EAF and/or prepare a positive dedaratlon. Check this box If you have determined, based on the infonnation and analysis above and any supportfng documentation, that the ptOp05ed actk>r WILL NOT result In any significant adverse environmental impacts AND provide, on attachments as necessary, the reasons supporting thi determination. Name of Lead Agency Date Pnnt or Type Name of Responsible Officer In Lead Agency Tffie of Responsible Officer Signature of Responsible omcer In Lead Agency Stgnature of Preparer (If dtfferent from responsible Offlcer) . , . . . . ,. Docko. Inc. P.O. Box 421, Mystic, CT 06355 (860) 572-8939 Fax: (860) 572-7569, e-mail: docko@snet.net October 15, 2002 J, r Mr. Albert Krupski, President Southold Board of Trustees P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Re: Joseph Pendergast New Fixed Pier & Floating Dock Dear Mr. Krupski: On behalf of Mr. Joseph Pendergast, we enclose herewith the following in support of his permit application for a new fixed pier and floating dock on Fishers Island. .:. Two prints each of plans titled: Project: "New Fixed Pier & Floating Dock'" Waterway: Inner Bay Location: Fishers Island, Town of Southold Suffolk County, New York Joseph Pendergast October 8, 2002 Applicant: Date: ... Two copies of the Southold Board of Trustees permit application. U.S. ACOE and DEC applications, Tax Assessor's Map, site photographs and location map, check in the amount of $200.00 payable to the Town of South old. -, Please note that this application and drawings differ from those originally prepared for this project and mailed to adjacent property owners on September 17. 2002. After discussions with Mr. Pendergast's neighbors, J. Lester Parsons and Steven Malinowski, we shortened the pier and dock encroachment, changed to a larger, more suitable hinged ramp and changed the tie-off pile configuration so as not to hinder other operations in this cove and yet provide maximum handicapped access and usability for Mr. Pendergast. In order to avoid adverse impacts to Mr. Malinowski's aquaculture operation, we respectfully request your most expedient review of this application so that construction of the permitted facility can be completed prior to February I, 2003. I trust that you will find this application package complete and acceptable; please let me know if the need for further information arises. Very truly yours, lz;{:iJL Keith B. Neilson, P.E. KBN:jm Enclosures CC: Joseph Pendergast Anny Corps of Engineers NYS DEC: Environmental Permits File: 02-04-1297 PENDERGAST . . Docko, Inc. P.O. Box 421, Mystic, CT 06355 (860) 572-8939 Fax: (860) 572-7569, e-mail: docko@snet.net October 15,2002 NYS DOS Department of Coastal Resources 41 State Street, 8th Floor Albany, NY 12231 Re: Joseph Pendergast, Fishers Island New Fixed Pier & Floating Dock To Whom It May Concern: On behalf of our client, we submit the attached Federal Consistency Assessment Form for a new tixed pier and floating dock on Fishers Island, New York. We enclose herewith the following in support of this permit application: .:. Two prints each of plans titled: Project: Waterway: Location: "New Fixed Pier & Floating Dock" Inner Bay Fishers Island, Town of South old Suffolk County, New York Joseph Pendergast October 8, 2002 Applicant: Date: .:. Two copies of Corps of Engineers, NYS DEC and Town of Southold Application forms, Location Map, Tax Assessor's Map and NYS DOS Coastal Management Federal Consistency Assessment Forms. I trust that you will find this application package complete and acceptable: please let me know if the need for further information arises. Very truly yours, D~~ (eith B. Neilson, P.E. KBN:jm Enclosures CC: Joseph Pendergast NYS DEC: Regulatory Affairs Town of Southold: Krupski File: 02-04-1297 PENDERGAST . \.:UAts I AL MANA\:j~M~N I ....KU\:it(AM . Federal Consistency Assessment Form An applicant, seeking a permit, license, waiver, certification or similar type of approval from a federal agency which is subject to the New York State Coastal Management Program (CMP, shall complete this assessment form for any proposed activity that will occur within and/or directly affect the State's Coastal Area. This form is intended to assist an applicant in certifying that the proposed activity is consistent with New York State's CMP as required by U.S. Department of Commerce regulations (15 CFR 930.57(. It should be compOleted at the time when the federal application is prepared. The Department of State will use the completed form and accompanying information in its review of the applicant's certification of consistency. A. A.PPLlCANT 1. Name JOSEPH PENDERGAST 2. Address: ORIENTAL AVENUE FISHERS ISLAND NY 06390 3, Telephone: Area Code (631) 788-7560 B. PROPOSED ACTIVITY 1. Brief description of activity: CONSTRUCT 28 (+1-) LF OF 4-FOOT WIDE FIXED WOOD PILE AND TIMBER PIER, INSTALL AN 8' X 24' FLOAT WITH ASSOCIATED 40-FOOT HINGED RAMP AND RESTRAINT PILINGS AND FIVE TIE-OFF PILINGS ALL WATERWARD OF THE APPARENT HIGH WATER LINE. 2, Purpose of activity: THIS IS A PRIVATE DOCK FOR RECREATIONAL BOATING, 3. location of activity: SUFFOLK COUNTY County SOUTHOLD City, Town or Village SOUTHEAST CORNER OF WEST HARBOR Street or Site Description 4, Type of federal permit I license required: US ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS 5. Federal application number, if known: NOT YET KNOWN 6. If a state permit I license was issued or is required for the proposed activity, identify the state agency and provide the application or permit number, if known: C. COASTAL ASSESSMENT Check either "YES· or "NO· for each of the following questions, The numbers following each question refer to the policies described in the CMP document (see footnote on page 2) which may be affected by the proposed activity. YES NO 1. Will the proposed activity result in any of the following: 8. large physical change to a site within the coastal area which will require the preparation of an environmental impact statement? (11, 22, 25, 32, 37. 38, 41, 43)... . ... . . . . .. .. . b. Physical alteration of more than two acres of land along the shoreline, land under water or coastal weters? (2, 11, 12, 20, 28, 35, 44), , . . , . , ' . . , , , . . . . c. Revitalization I redevelopment of a deteriorated or underutilized waterfront site? (1). d. Reduction of existing or potential public access to or along coastal waters? (19,20) . . . . 8. Adverse effect upon the commercial or recreational use of coastal fish resources? (9.10). f. Siting of a facility essential to the exploration, development and production of energy resources in coastal waters or on the Outer Continental Shelf? (29). . . . . . . .. .. g. Siting of a facility essential to the generation or transmission of energy? (27). h. Mining, excavation, or dredging activities, or the placement of dredged or fill material in coastal waters? (15, 35). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Discharge of taxies, hazardous substances or other pollutants into coastal waters?(8.15,35) j. Draining of stormwater runoff or sewer overflows into coastal waters? (33) . k. Transport, storage, treatment, or disposal of solid wastes or hazardous materials? (36, 39). I. Adverse effect upon land or water uses within the State's small harbors? (4). . . . 2. Will the proposed activity affect or be ~ in, on, or adjacent to any of the following: .lL .lL .lL .lL .lL .lL .lL X X .lL .lL .lL a. State designated freshwater or tidal wetland? (44) . . . . . . . . . . b. Federally designated flood and I or state designated erosion hazard area? (11, 12, 17). c. State designated significant fish and I or wildlife habitat? (7). d. State designated significant scenic resource or area? (26) . e. State designated important agricultural lands? (26) . 1. Beach, dune or barrier island? (12). 9 Major ports of Albany, Buffalo, Ogdensburg. Oswego or New York? (3). . h, State, country, or local park? (19, 20) . , , . ' i Historic resource listed on the National or State Register of Historic Places? (23). X X ........ .lL .lL .lL .lL .lL .lL .lL 3. Win the proposed activity a any of the following: . . a, b c, d, e, Walerfront site? (2, 21, 22), ' , , . . , . , Provision of new public services or infrastructure in undeveloped or sparsely populated sections of the coastal area? (5) . . . . . . . . . . . Construction or reconstruction of a flood or erosion control structure? (13, 14, 16). State water quality permit or certification? (30, 38, 40) . State air quality permit or certification? (41, 43) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Will the proposed activity occur within and I or affect an area covered by a State approved Local waterfront revitalization program? (see policies in local program document) . L L -L L L L D, ADDITIONAL STEPS 1. If all of the questions in Section C are answered "Non, then the applicant or agency shall complete Section E and Sub the documentation required by Section F. 2. If any of the questions in Section are answered "YESN, then the applicant or agent Is advised to consult the CMP, or where appropriate, the local waterfront revitalization program document. The proposed activity must be analyzed in more detail with respect to the applicab~ state or local coastal policies. In the space provided below or on a separate page (s), the applicant or agent shall: (a) identify, by their policy numbers, which coastal policies are affected by the activity. (b) briefly assess the effects of the activity upon the policy; and (c) state how the activity is consistent with each policy. Following the completion of this written assessment. the applicant or agency shall complete Section E and submit the documentation required by Section F. E CERTIFICATION The applicant or agent must certify that the proposed activity is consistent with the State's CMP or the approved local waterfront revitalization program, as appropriate. If this certification cannot be made, the proposed activity shall not be undertaken_ If this certification can be made, complete this Section. NThe proposed activity complies with New York State's approved Coastal Management Program, or with the applicable approved local waterfront revitalization program, and will be conducted in a manner consistent with such program.· Applicant I Agent's Name: DOCKO INC. KEITH B, NEISLON. P E. Address: P,O, BOX 421 MYSTIC CT 06355 Telephone: Araa Code (860) Jí:~ ~ ,~(), Applicant I Agent's Signature: _ _ -:. fdJ'J ~ I Date: nt oIL, 14¡ 2.=1. F, SUBMISSION REQUIREMENTS 1. The applicant or agent shall submit the following documents to the New York State Department of State, Division of Coastal Resources and Waterfront Revitalization, 162 Washington Avenue, Albany, NY 12231. a. Original signed form. b. Copy of the completed federal agency application. c. Other available information which would support the certification of consistency. 2. The applicant or agent shall also submit a copy of this completed form along with his I her application to the federal agency. 3. If there are any questions regarding the submission of this form, contact the Department of State at (518) 474-6000. REGARD 2a & b, THE PROPOSED FIXED DOCK, RAMP AND FLOAT WILL BE LOCATED ON THE WATERFRONT AND IS LOCATED WITHIN THE FEDERAL FLOOD ZONE ON THE STATE JURISDICTION FOR TIDAL WETLANDS (LESS THAN 6' DEPTH). THE SITE IS SUBJECT TO COASTAL FLOODING BECAUSE OF ITS LOCATION ON WEST HARBOR IN FISHERS ISLAND SOUND, NYS WATER QUALITY CERTIFICATION IS REQUIRED FOR THIS PROJECT BY THE CLEAN WATER ACT. THIS CONSTRUCTION REPRESENTS NO SIGNIFICANT CHANGE OR SIGNIFICANT EVIRONMENTAL IMPACT AND WILL NOT CAUSE ANY DETERIORATION TO SENSITIVE ENVIRONMENTAL FEATURES, WATER FLOW AND CIRCULATION; IT IS CONSISTENT WITH PROGRMS FOR PROTECTION OF WATERS, TIDAL WETLANDS, AND PROTECTION OF THE COASTAL ZONE REGARDING ITEM 2c, ALL BEACHES ON FISHERS ISLAND ARE CLASSIFIED AS NESTING HABITAT FOR SHORE BIRDS, THIS PROJECT WILL BE SCHEDULED FOR CONSTRUCTION AFTER THE BREEDING SEASON WHICH SHOULD MITIGATE ANY POTENTIAL SHORT TERM IMPACT. THE STRUCTURE ITSELF SHOULD NOT AFFECT THE QUALITY OF THE HABITAT. *These state and local documents are available for inspection at the offices of many federal agencies, Department of Environmental Conservation and Department of State regional offices, and the appropriate regional and county planning agencies. Local program documents are also available for inspection at the offices of the appropriate local government. -2 - FCAF RavlRød 12/6193 . . . Docko. Inc. P.O. Box 421, Mystic, CT 06355 (860) 572-8939 Fax: (860) 572-7569, e-mail: docko@snet.net October 15, 2002 Mr. Michael Vissichelli U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Jacob Javits Federal Center, Room 1937 New York, New York 10278-0090 Re: Joseph Pendergast New Fixed Pier & Floating Dock Dear Mr. Vissichel1i: On behalf of Mr. Joseph Pendergast we request a Department of the Anny Pennit for a new fixed pier and floating dock on Fishers Island, New York, We enclose herewith the following in support of this pennit application: .:. Two prints each of plans titled: Applicant: Date: "New Fixed Pier & Floating Dock" Inner Bay Fishers Island, Town of Southold Suffolk County, New York Joseph Pendergast October 8, 2002 Project: Waterway: Location: .:. Two copies of Corps of Engineers and NYS DEC Application Fonns, Location Map, Tax Assessor's Map, photographs and NYS DOS Federal Consistency Assessment Fonn. I trust that you will find this application package complete and acceptable; please let me know if the need for further infonnation arises. KBN:jm Enclosures CC: Joseph Pendergast NYS DEC: Environmental Penn its Town of Southold: Krupski File: 02-04-1297 PENDERGAST APPLICATION FOR D ARTMENT OF THE ARMY PERII-IlT 10MB APPROVAL NO, 0710-003 . (33 Cf"R 325) Public repúJting burden for IhlS eülllXtion of infonmuion is estimalcd 10 avcrage 5 hours ptr response, including the: time for n~viewing inslruclions, searching existing da1a soun:cs, gathering and mltintaining !.be data needed, and completing and reviewing the collection ofinfonnatioD.. Smd COl11ß1CDts regarding this burden estimate of any other aspect afthis collection ofinfoßßA1ion, including suggestions for reducing this burden. to Departmau oCDcfc:nse, Washington Headquarters Service Directorate of oflnfonn81ion Operauons and Reports. 1215 Jefferson Davis Highway, Suite: 1204, Arlington, VA 22202-4302; and to the Office of Managcmenl and Budget, Paperwork. Reduction Projc:cl (0710..0003), Washington, DC 20~03. Please 00 NOT RETURN your Conn to either of those addresses. Completed applications must be submitted 10 Ihe District Engin~er havingjurisdiclion over the location of the proposed activity. PRJV ACY ACT STATEMENT Authority: 33 use 401, Scçlion 10; 1413, 5cçtion 404. Principal Purpose: These laws require permits authorizing activities in, navigable waters of the United Stares the discharge of dredged or fill material inEO watcr5 of the United Slates, and the transportation of dredged material for the purpose of dwnping it inlo ocean waters. Routine Uses: Informutlon provided on this form will be used in evtùuating this application for a permit. Disclosure: Disclosure ofrequestcd information Is is volumary. Ifintunnalion is not provk:!ed, however, th~ permit applictttion cannot be processed nor can a pennie be issued. One sei oforiginiU dra\\'ings or good reproducible copies which show the location and character of me proposed activity must be attached to this applicatio.n (su sample drawings and lI1s.tructions) and be submined to the District Engineer having jurisdiction of the proposed activity. An applicacion that is not completed in full will be returned. (ITEMS) THRU' TO BE FILLED BY THE CORPS) I. APPLICATION NO, 2, FIELD OFFICE CODE 3, DATE RECEIVED 4.DATE APP. COMPLETED ITH/S BELOW 10 BE FILLED BY APPUCANT 5 APPLICANTS NAME 8 AUTHORl2ED AGENTS NAME & filE JOSEPH PENDERGAST KEITH B. NEILSON, P.E. DOCKO, INC. 6, APPLICANT'S ADDRESS 9, AGENTS ADDRESS ORJENT AL A VENUE P. O. BOX 421 FISHERS ISLAND, NEW YORK 06390 MYSTIC, CT 06355 7 APPLICANT'S PHONE NO'S W/AREA CODE 10, AGENT'S PHONE NO'S WIAREA CODE a Residence (63 I) 788-7560 a. Residence b Business b. Business (860) 572-8939 II. STATEMENT OF AUTHORlZA TION I hereby authorize. DCX'KO, INC. to act in my behalf as my agent in the processing of¡his application and to furnish, upon request, suppl~ncnw infoml~=in~:rp.:JfiN\?J ~ - 7, ~ - 0.2.., j' APPLICANTS SIGNATURE ~ DATE JOSEPH PENDERGAST NAME, LOCATION AND DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT OR ACTIVITY 12. PROJECT NAME OR TITLE (See instructions) NEW FIXED PIER AND FLOATING DOCK 13 NAME OF W ATERBODY, IF KNOW (if applicable) 14. PROJECT STREET ADDRESS (if applicable) WEST HARBOR ORJENTALAVENUE FISHERS ISLAND, NY 06390 15, LOCATION OF PROJECT SUFFOLK NY COUNTY STATE 16. OTHER LOCATION DESCRIPTIONS,IF KNOWN, (See instructions) LATITUDE: 41° I5'3"N, LONGITUDE: 72° 00' 27" W 17, DIRECTIONS TO TIlE SITE TAKE FERRY OR AIRPLANE TO FISHERS ISLAND, VIA CAR PROCEED EASTERLY ON WHISTLER A VENUE WHICH BECOMES EQUESTRJAN A VENUE AND THEN FONE STREET WHICH ENDS AT ORIENTAL A VENUE. TURN RIGHT AND PROCEED APPROXIMA TEL Y 1/2 MILE TO THE SITE, ENG FORM 4345, Fèb. EDITION OF SEP 911S OBSOLETE. (PropoRenl:CECW~OR ," " I . . . . 18. Nature of Acti\'ity (Description of project, include all features) CONSTRUCT 28 (+1-) LF OF 4-FOOT WIDE FIXED WOOD PILE AND TIMBER PIER, INSTALL AN 8' X 24' FLOAT WITH ASSOCIATED 40-FOOT HINGED RAMP AND RESTRAINT PILINGS, FIVE TIE-OFF prLINGS ALL WATER WARD OF THE APPARENT HIGH WATER LINE. 19. Project Purpose {Describe (he reason or purpose of the project, see instructions) THIS IS A PRIVATE DOCK FOR RECREATIONAL BOATING. USE BLOCKS 20-22 IF DREDGED AND/OR FILL MATERIAL IS TO BE DISCHARGED 20. Reason (5) fOf Dls¡.;harge N/A 21. Type (5) of Material Being Discharged and the Amount of Each Type in Cubic Yards N/A 22. Surface Area In Acres ofWellands or Other Waters filled (see instructions) N/A 23. Is Any Portion úf ¡he Work Already Complete? Yes NoX IF YES, DESCRIBE THE COMPLETED WORK 24. Addresses of Adjoining Property Owners, Lessees, Etc., Whose Property Adjoins the Waterbody (if more than can be entered here, please attach a supplememallisl). EAST: J. LESTER PARSONS, 52 CHAPIN ROAD, BERNARDSVILLE, NJ 07924 WEST: STEVEN MALINOWSKI, FISHERS ISLAND, NY 06390 25 List orOlher Certifications or Appro\'als/Denials Received from other Federal, State or Local Agencies for Work Described in This Application AGENCY NYS DEC NYS DOS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD TYPE APPROVAL· IDENT. NUMBER DATE APPLIED PENDING PENDING PENDING DATE APPROVED DATE DENIED ·Would include but IS no stri KEITH B NEILSON, P.E" DOCKO, INe. The application must be signed by the person \\ desires to undertake the proposed activity (applicant) or it may be signed by a duly authorized agent if the statement in block II has been filled out and signed. 18 U.S C. Section 1001 provides that: Whoever, in any manner within the jurisdiction of any department or agency of the United States k.nowingly and willfully falsifies, conceab, or covers up any trick., scheme, or discuises a material fact or makes any false, fictitious or fraudulent statements or representations or makes or uses any fabe wflling or document knowing same to contain any false, fictitious or fraudulent statements or entry, shall be fined not more than SIO,OOO or imprisoned not more than live years or both. 'U ,S.GPO, 1994-520-478/820 18 " ~ 'ª ~ C' ;..? '-I' ~ o ¡¡~.al ---------.... "\ ~ ~ 0. '" '" ., "- 'õ '" ~ ~ _ e (~~ ""~ 1;'" - ,. \ (~ ( i~ ~~ o. \ ~\ "'~ ·2 " / EXISTING /~2:2X// J<..AMp / / ·1 , ,)(-10 / / / / , / / / --=-:. / X-O.2 -PoLW ====- / / ......,\"Ò:J 0:1::::::==- /~~/. - / / -u >ý ~~ / EXISTING _~ / / X -09 / FIXED DOCK =====- / / / ,-' ,EXISTING ~ 0.2 - / STONE W,ALl¡ = \ 1/ :'<-0.3 I -19 X-I.3 A< . _ _ _ '10<- - - _ _ .... '- \ /OA/ . ~ - - - - - - - ~....................... - -X-:w\EX1S11NG / -'-."- ---::.:~~ _ -,/ GROIN / / ;;1.4 "~'-:O3- ,,-1..3 X_16 /-----;;~. X-O~1 <;12 /é '" .o9'>;,'~ __....... -...:.-- ~ ~..._-" WOOD TIMBER . ·1 '-<:>7 '_11"'>.,'-- - _ _ _ _ - ~~~r-- 09;;A -Q,!; . "" -0-' X-06 /' \) _ _ - - -- _~~ ~, ,.' ,_ ~~ -<~ -~O~W~, o .ALW~;¡¡ AAEA OF sco,TTERED -~'"~ ,.,/'2 X (\ REl-'\'JNS,·'./ /In ",- 04 ~U ,/ /;;¡~ O~ ~OODTIMBERS__-"- ^ It '1~/ ¿" -./ ",,0:> -____- ...., .;.r~-, :z .F, EXJSTlNG , 0. "2 h,~':_ '7 ~ ~ W~~MBER ,'9 - / );;'~ ' .,/ FIXED DOCK 'o~."""J ._-,'/-.'---~~ t:;;::¡.,,;~)' _ ~- ,--~DS .J->:2.:::., , '\ W _./'.J"/'/ ',o/'"""x"-- 5 . :z _ _ '\ '. 1,3 !I. -;-" .rP:." 5\ ð -SEE NOTE- ,~...~:('rMHW'"'_or"'_~" -....-" d~ ';:;. -,.:::-. .r~,;"r' '" ~.'r-!t~~\~1,:...::;.'f.'<~~-~1 !:n .....-Ú: __.--=.::.-:.-:.....:-- r':J.~~..-.I:/ ,.-- 67 EXISTING ",'{ ~"'..:" ,';: -._ ~ ~ . _ : ~ - 'Î9'X"·:,::,=::3'~,s /.;;' / / /' ......SP.ARl1NA CONCRETE W,AU.. " ..., ~~-1',,,,,- ~ ..:..... . ..._. /'. /' ALTEF2N!FLDRA _ _ - 7 -::::..\(:~:~.:.:'~·;~II\ .. =':~;:-T~_ .;~i2N~_.;~,9_:<;:-:/~-.__ _. 5<~)/ /. ~=-- - --..-.- -,'0'''''_' .-.".:~if. .- ",_-_:."",,' /// ,,/ /.~'S/T~ ~I1!.:'~§'3~W"i~.}~,Zf:n. ~..,- ",' / / ,';; PROPER1Y ,. d .. ''c,'(..~. :'i.~~~j.~'1:ç';;:;." BRUSH .- ./ / _ð- - I 'NIF·- ";;;;:'r.·P'·E·~~:} 5 -" "/j OF PENDERGAST - :io I ~~~, ~. .. 'OF PARSONS""· APPARENT 6- A."". '''''_"w.",..·.,~;R-PROPEI<1Y UNE , _ .""; PROJECT, NEW FIXED PIER AND FLOATING DOCK .';~..:>..,~ ~"\:".;I_'-~.~,.:I:>,..~>.~,,,::. 7 - . - r--- / / ·.(.~O --.----.- , , ~------..... .............-----....... ~ E P/RA.TES COVE '<~, )<-4.5 , IX -4.0 I I I \ \ I \ I I I I I I I ~ -"---.............. I \ I \ \ \ , , '- s ·5 " -~o \ \ I I I ',-"'0 -51 X .~ -.........--- -.................... NOTE, WETLANDS SuRvEY by RJCHARD SNARSKI (US. PeOE CRJTERI"-) .- ~- --- -'------,- ·'0 , , , ~ I -'4X I I I / / / / -..................... , , 46X " ....Q , , ----.-...... ., BOTTOM SEDIMENTS, LOOSE SILT / / / .- / / --- - -,,- -- ·.0 ~------........ -~6 X ., -:2d >.: -27 a PILE -......"-'-. ------ .{ -16 --~ X-'.5 '. -- :...~ -21. " - - - ~- EXISTlNG FlDATlNG DOCK - -- - -3 / - / _'A 7~_ EX/ST/NCS Cc?NDIT/c?NS G~IC 5C.ALE l' = 20' 10 o I ;¡o WATERWAY DATE APR..ICANT, FISHERS ISI-AND. NEW YORK WASHINGTON COUNTY. CONNEcnCIJ1" ~MTES COVE =OBER 8,2002 JOSEI'H PENDERGAST LQCATlON, ,AGENT. SHEET 2 OF 4 DOCKO, INC_ Keith B. Neilson. PE Mysiic. CT 063S5 860 572 8939 FAX 860 572 7569 EMAJL: docko@snet.net ¡(eLm Nc!leon. Doc!.D.I~ 10'5/2OO211...9,.>.M Pcndcr9a~T~2c.M9 DWG 02-04-1297.02 N~3.^O LOAT RESTI<AJNT PILE (TYP) / NEW8 'X24 'FLOAT - --~"'- ......... NOTE, . CRP . CQNSTl<UC110N REÆRENCE POINT 15 THE EYEBOL.. T AT TI-tE WATERWARD END OF EXlS-nNG Vv..ALL REMAINS. -~ --4 ~,-,-~-~ I \ \ \ \ EXJSTING \ FLOATING DOC'" \ MAJJNQWSKJ \ \ I - PIRATES ~~. ý'~ J, D / I"Z- / h 31 'Va GlOH1nOS ~O Nfv\Ol S3:!iSfm1 ~O ml'V' ' ,. \ I \ I EXISTING - RAMP _"_ __,"_ -4 /?~!~CK ~~~f~--!., 1"0:: C", .' ..' 36 '± NEW RAMP LlFT-- '-' - - ~ CROSS TIMBEI<S u> ~=J /. 'u NEW 4 ' WIDE FIXED PIER 1 . - - - - - - END EL. 5 ' z . ~ ('\. - . ·1 . -- - ·2 ~'-'"'--- - -- --- NEW HANDI<AJL: ". , 4 'ABOVE DECK .1 . ARE'-" OF SCATIERED· _ 1 .-':t .. '¡WOOD TIMBERS - - - -:. ~ ::,- ~ ~ ." :::":::~- ALWf......t&·~~< SPAR1lNA~-~E~T~~/ Y~-~:>-1 II TTT,Ti/ {",' '"u ~, ...._~~~':::O!:"'- S.·~~< 1:. '--'iI: EXls~~ljl!J =: ~ ~ ~:'N~~D_TIMBER~ ¿~~i' .K... FOO:B=K 'iI: v -_..=~~: -. '!1 '~/" ~ -~----- J_ -- '~~. -;,..-f-".. J ---------- - - - '---..." 1""""-- ~... .,;.-" (/., ,/ " - 'n ~-e-...---- \,', 11.;;:;--" -,-:. - " - ~~~ , - ___~~.:::: -=- _ _ _ _ _..,:::....-::;..___::-::..{.' __ ¡0'EXlSTlNG. _ .. ~ ; ". "'~~,=-'~'-=-:_~~./", ÇONC'SéTÉWALL ¡¡~ '.._... - - - - -. - =-- ,:'.:;:.::.c...-- BEGINNIN .' \l.-;~ .: ~ -·~~N;;·PA~~~ L - ~ ' ~~--,._J~L. 7 ± ~~FS '" .~'~ ~ _ J~- ~-,_ STING W=Dh " ~.~~~.:-.:::-;,-c> - /j" SITE'. '-"'--.'.'_ TIMßERW.ALL.. "-: .~sg \~___. ,// PROPEI7rV ~ªs:~~~~.ror..'$~J~W;~"·1 BRUSH .- ../' ,-- I""- I I _ _ I ,Ñì~"'PRõ~Ê~ 5 - - _ _ - / ) O~ PENDERGASr' 20 OF PARSON~~f~APPAAENT 6· - / ,.f. :ie"'~ ',"-""£ti"g~ PROPERTY LINE _ ~ - - _ _ :::-?"- PROJECT, NEW FIXED PIER AND FLOATING DOCK - 25'± P~N '-../'/EVV GJ<ADHIC 5GAJ....E 1· = 20 ' '0 o I 20 REVlSED 11-22-02 DISTANCE TO ,ABUTTERS REVlSED 03-3-03 ACOE ~ER CONFIGURATION WCATION FISHERS ISlAND. NEW YORK WASHINGTON COUNTY. CONNECTICUT PIRATES COVE OCTOBER 8, 2002 JOSEPH PENDERGAST WATERWAY DATE, APPLICANT ,"6ENT, SHEET 3 OF 4 DOCKO. INC. Keith B. Neilson, PE Mys"c, CT 06355 860 572 8939 FAX 860 572 7569 EMAJL: docko@snet.net D\VG 02-04-1297 Kelm Nell!!IGII"I DOC~O, INC. ;3114/200;310.15 At1 Pel"lder-¡;oo$r-3H..;t.Ng ¡ I :1 I' NEW TiE-OFF PILE TOP EL 77< (TYP) II "" ' ~" I T 4'% I 4'CLE"'" NEW FIXED PIER END EL 55 ;" j I I·: NEW SUPPORT PILE (TYP) ,....- ·"·"·""·":·'1'r·"'·'·'· .'·"":·:..,-_·:l'·,·:,:,·,.-··:-"":·~""'¡_·:··, . ~ ." . .-, ." -," ~-' ." . , ,., ... . ., ,.'" .,..->"'. , 'I' ~.. '.' ,~{?}:~~n~~: \:;~i~~ :~~~~~~~>S;~ ~Q,3.:;t~~0~'??~f\\~? ~t~~~~, NEW FLOAT WITH . cc l/7;DNTlN/JOUC, AJ..W 0.0- __ fl·, .. , ,.:! : ~¡#~%ì{~~~1 ""I '-'-'". .. II ..' .....-.. ~::s,·~ ';,':";:". NC:::>R.TH ELE'v""~TIC:::>N GR.A.DHIC 5CAL.E 1" = 10' I 10 5 o I 10 NE\V TIE-OFF PILE TOP EL 77< (TYP) NEW FLOAT RESTRAiNT NEW RAMP LIFT PILE TOP EL 77;" (TYP) r- CROSS BRACE __"ð.JU/I""lI""l_____. ------ NEW r<AlL EL 4FT ABOVE DECK BEGINNING EL 7;" f'<-Mi 15' -·,A}-M.t3.4:1:- - - NEW.3:6- X 4-0 ' rRAMP MAX SLOPE 7: NEW FIXED PIER END EL 5", MAX. SLOPE 1 : 72 10' , if " NEW8X24'FLOAT / WITH CONTINUOUS ~ FLOATATION .. " 'I , :' . 1::-':': '-1:::1\"::- Ic':-I.I I 'If\}EW SPLIT -CLßMP and CROSS BRACE (TYP) NEW SUPPORT PILE (TYpj VVEST ELE'v""~TIC:::>N GRAPHIC SCAœ l' '" ':;¡O . I 20 10 o I 20 PROJEcr: NEW FIXED PIER AND FLOATiNG DOCK RE'v1SED 12-26-02 AGOE RER ELEVATION R~SED 3-13-03 AGOE RER CONFIGURATION REVISED 3-25-03 ACOE ADD, DIMENSIONS LOCAllON FISHERS ISLAND, NEW YORK WASHINGTON COUNTY. CONNECTlCIJf PIRATES COVE ocrOBER 8 2002 JOSEPH PENDERGAST WA1"ER\\!AY D.ATE APPLICANT: AGENT: SHEET 4 OF 4 DOCKO. INC. KeIth ß. Neilson. PE Mysftc, cr 06355 860 572 8939 FN< 860572 7569 EMAJL...: docko@snet.ner DWG 02-04-1297 Keith Neilson. Docko,lnc 3/25/2003 9:50 ÞM Pendergast-4F.dwg . . CockoJ Inc. P.O. Box 421, Mystic, CT 06355 (860) 572-8939 Fax: (860) 572-7569, e-mail: docko@snet.net July 28, 2004 Mr. Albert Krupski, President Southold Board of Trustees P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Re: Joseph Pendergast Permit 5894 Dear Mr. Krupski: This letter is to inform you that Mr. Joseph Pendergast will begin dock construction at his property on Fishers Island on or about August 2, 2004 in accordance with the above referenced permit. The Permit sign will be posted during the work as required. The contractor for Mr, Pendergast is D. J Whelan Corporation, P. O. Box 2079, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, Yours truly, DOCKO, INe. . ~¡¡;¡: E I U ~., JUl 3 0 iro4 ,--' ' Soulllold_ I Board of Trustees J 1J~~-d If 7l1~A..... Keith B. Neilson, PE KBN:jm CC: Mr. Joseph Pendergast File: 02-04-1297 PENDERGAST - . . DockoJ Inc. P.O. Box 421, Mystic, CT 06355 (860) 572-8939 Fax: (860) 572~7569, e-mail: docko@snet.net Ms Lauren Standish Southold Board of Trustees P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 ~ ~A: ~,n ,,' ~ 4 Soothold Towo Board of Trustees Re: Joseph Pendergast Dear Ms Standish: Following up on your conversation with Keith Neilson yesterday, we are transmitting herewith page 6 of the Southold Board of Trustees application, "Proof of Mailing of Notice" for Mr. Joseph Pendergast, indicating that we have sent the most recent pennit drawings to the adjoining property owners via Certified Mail. We have also enclosed a set of the most recent permit drawings as well, indicating various changes that have been made to the project. I trust that this will provide you with the required materials needed for the scheduled hearing later this month. If there is anything further you need or you have any questions, please give our office a call. Yours truly, ( DOCKO, INe. !;b7UU7l1~~~ Joan McLaughlin for Keith B. Neilson, P.E. KBN:jm Enclosures CC: Mr. Joseph Pendergast File 02-04-1297 PENDERGAST . PROOF OF MAILING OF ~~~~rH r~R~IFIED MAIL . NOTICE RECEIPTS U.S. Postal Service CERTIFIED MAIL REr~D: (Domestic Alail Only: No InsurafJ.~ Coverage Provided) Addreó U.S. Postal Service CERTIFIED MAIL REr.FIPJ (Domestic Mail Only; No Ins-t ranee C . . - . . overage Provided) Return Receipt Fee .....D (Endorsement ReQuired) D D Restricted Delivery Fee D (Endorsement Required) CJ Total Postage & Fees :T ~ H~ 5, tell e " f'í\ tZ ! ( ~ av.Ls.k_L......n_______. .-'! S¡;;,.i."ÄPï.,¡õ:,-2----···h·...nn------n--L---- . I d' ~ ;~~':::~J---LS-----~ m__ ;;'·.\~G ¿:ë¡o·----------m 111 111 :T 111 :T :T U" :T IMIT ID: 0355 111 111 :T PostmarK 111 ".~ ..D Clerk: KP6D59 D 0 04/02/04 0 CertffledFee IONARDSVIll£. N.J. 01924 Postage Certified Fee Postage $ . tIIt{ ID: 0355 , . \ ' U / .'(.~ i Postmark 1""':"/ Here Jt"Ø"<: KP6D59 J: / Retum ReceIpt Fee (EndOl'SementRequlred) ~DellveryFee CEndorsernentAeQUil9d) ToIaJ """-. '- $ D :T D""" ent 0 .-'! ----------J:..'_ ~ -tL1~ n Jr<'QO C 8 :~'BA.::¡::~ 'C-:-iZh-:-> . ..~....--.---...__._.__.__...__._ o ë··------···----....-------..----..hE!:PL":!____f?4 . I'- . Ity.S_'~"'4 i$l!'rl\Ord V(¡(~ iiJj"·,)...:¡qj.ii.... . .11.. .. ".. , -. - . 04/02/04 :11 . . COUNTY OF NEW LONDON .... - - Docko, Inc. , residing at 14 Holmes Street Mystic, CT, being duly sworn, deposes and says that on the 2nd" day of APRIL 2004, deponent mailed a true copy of the Notice set forth in the Board of Trustees Application, directed to each of the above named persons at the addresses set opposite there respective names; that the addresses set opposite the names of said persons are the address of said persons as shown on the current assessment roll of the Town of Southold; that said Notices were mailed at the United States Post Office at Mystic, CT that said Notices were mailed to each of said persons by (certified) (registered) mail. ¿jJ&):av.- , Sworn to before me this ~(\d Day of APRI L , 20 ðt.f - CJuz,::t'ôc??1c.f ~,~ ~sion Expires: April 30, 2006 6 It . Albert J. Krupski, President James King, Vice-President Artie Foster Ken Poliwoda Peggy A. Dickerson Town Hall 53095 Route 25 P.O. Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971-0959 Telephone (631) 765-1892 Fax (631) 765-1366 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTH OLD BOARD OF TRUSTEES: TOWN OF SOUTHOLD ~ECEIU ~ APR 1 5 2004 ' 1...00/ Southold Town Board of Trustees --------------------------------------------------------------- In the Matter of the Application of ---~C)~C24)-~__~~~~~-------------------- COUNTY OF SUFFOLK) ST ATE OF NEW YORK) AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING I, p~ Dto.-n . , residing at q M IÂ[, CLn R OlÂct 01 ð- L\.fYY\.i L T Dlð37/ being duly sworn, depose and say: That on the ~day of /tfrì / . 2001/, I personally posted the property known as ,Joj{.Ph ~f'or..aa.[r by placing the Board of TrtÍstees official poster where it can easily be seen, and that I have checked to be sure the poster has remained in place for eight days prior to the date of the public hearing. Date of hearing noted thereon to be held t uo&, llD r\ I ~ IJ ~~ð4. - 01"\ 6HiBliit- ~ fW) Dated: /~ð~ (signature) Sworn to-,before me this dj' of 200 i .J!ir)/iLI'/J- ~' "I ' Notary Public / / ~ \~fRO~IICA HAMilTON I ",y PUBLIC [ ',' .. 0:= NEW YORK 1:0 01 HAG067785 QUALIFIED IN SUFFOLK COUNTY _ TERM EXPIRES... /;? /1 7/0') - e;, . Albert J. Krupski, President James King, Vice President Henry Smith Artie Foster Ken Poliwoda BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Office Use Only .. Town Hall 53095 Main Road P.O, Box 1179 Southold, New York 11971 Telephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516)765-1823 UGI I ~ ,; Coastal Erosion Permit Application ~Wetland Permit Application _Gwrandfa/ArntherdPermt~/' tChAPPlication L_. ai ver en men anges / í¡ Received Application: /0 / 11I·ý" Recei ved Fee: :J.H /" [ , Completed Application ¡O/¡<;f/ () ·v __ Jncomplete I ¡r ~SEQRA Classification: ~pe I Type II Unlisted ~ ~ordination: (datefi3et~)' ,O~ CAC Referral Sent: 0 L~ ____ Date of Inspection: If? '"~ ____ Receipt of CAC Report: I Lead Agency Determination: Technical Review: Public Hearing Held: /r/ÙI/"-v Resolution: f I Name of Applicant Joseph Pendergast Address Oriental Avenue, Fishers Island, NY 06390 Phone Number: (631) 788-75qO Suffolk County Tax Map Number: 1000 010 - 10- 10 Property Location: Oriental Avenue, Fishers Island, 1/4 mile east of "The Gloamin " (provide LILCO Pole #, distance to cross streets, and AGENT: Docko, Inc., Keith B. Neilson, P.E. (I f appl icable) Address:P. O. Box 421, Mystic, CT 06355 Phone: Fax: (860) 572-8939 (860) 572-7659 ·. . .. Board of Trustees Application GENERAL DATA Land Area (in square feet) Area Zoning: Residential Previous use of property: Intended use of property: The site is approximately ~ acre. Residential Residential Prior permits / approvals for site improvements: NONE KNOWN Agency Date L__ X No prior permits / approvals for site improvements. Has any permit / approval ever been revoked or suspended by a governmental agency? X No Yes If yes, provide explanation: Project Description (use attachments if necessary) : Construct 28(+/-)LFof 4-foot wide pile and timber pier, install an 8' x 24' float with associated 40-foot hinged ramp and restraint pilinqs, five tie-off pilinqs all waterward of the apparent high water line. 2 ·. . .. Board of Trustees Application WETLAND I TRUSTEE LANDS APPLICATION DATA Purpose of the proposed operations: The purpose of this project is to provide access for recreational boating. Area of wetlands on lot: Percent coverage of lot: 1,500 (+/-) 10 (+/-) square feet % Closest distance between nearest existing structure and upland edge of wetlands: 80 (+/-) feet Closest distance between nearest proposed structure and upland edge of wetlands: 0 feet Does the project involve excavation or filling: X ~ ~s If yes, how much material will be excavated? N/A cubic yards How much material will be filled? N/A cubic yards Depth of which material will be removed or deposited: N/A feet Proposed slope throughout the area of operations: N/A Manner in which material will be removed or deposited: N/A Statement of the effect, if any, on the wetlands and tidal waters of the town that may result by reason of such proposed operations (use attachments if appropriate): There may be some effect on wetlands and shallow tidal waters as a result of this proj ect due to shading and short term minor impacts during piling installation. 3 .. . .. Board of Trustees Application COASTAL EROSION APPLICATION DATA N / A Purposes of proposed activity: Are wetlands present within 75 feet of the proposed activity? No Yes Does the project involve excavation or filling? No Yes If Yes, now much material will be excavated? How much material will be filled? (cubic yards) (cubic yards) Manner in which material will be removed or deposited: Describe the nature and extent of the environmental reasonably anticipated resulting from implementation project as proposed. (Use attachments if necessary) impacts of the I 1 ~ i'" - . ; ~ 4 ·. . .. NOTICE TO ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNER BOARD OF TRUSTEES, TOWN OF SOUTHOLD In the matter of applicant: Joseph Pendergast SCTM#lOOO- 010 -10 -10 YOU ARE HEREBY GIVEN NOTICE: 1. That it is the intention of the undersigned to request a Permit from the Board of Trustees to: Construct 28 (+/-) LF of 4-foot wide fixed wood pile and timber pier, install an 8' x 24' float with associated 40-foot hinged ramp and restraint pilings, five tie-off pilings all waterward of the apparent high water line. 2. That the property which is the subject of Environmental Review is located adjacent to your property and is described as follows: The site is located in the southeast corner of Pirate's Cove at the southeast corner of West Harbor. 3. That the property under Chapters 32, public comment. You 1892 or in writing. which is subj ect to Environmental Review 37, or 97 of the Town Code is open to may contact the Trustees Office at 765- The above referenced proposal is under review of the Board of Trustees of the Town of Southold and does not reference any other agency that might have to review same proposal. OWNERS NAME: Joseph Pendergast MAILING ADDRESS: Oriental Avenue Fishers Island, NY 06390 PHONE #: (631) 788-7560 1\1_'1 \', Ene. : Copy of sketch or plan showing proposal for your convenience. 5 - .. . .. ,. Cocko, Inc. P.O. Box 421, Mystic, CT 06355 (860) 572-8939 Fax: (860) 572-7569, e-mail: docko@snet.net October IS, 2002 Mr. Steven Malinowski Fishers Island, New York 06390 Re: Pendergast Dock Revised Drawings Dear Mr. Malinowski: Several weeks ago we had a chance to talk with you about the proposed pier and float for Mr. Pendergast, your neighbor to the west in the Inner Bay off Pirate's Cove. We have re- aligned the dock structure and after two brief discussions with J. Lester Parsons, we have made further revisions. We have shortened the pier by approximately IS feet, put on a longer ramp to ease access by Mr. Pendergast who utilizes a wheelchair, and yet maintained access to the water as deep as possible in accordance with DEC standards (4 foot minimum to avoid future dredging potential). We have also deleted some of the tie-off piles at the northwesterly end of the dock configuration to assure that Mr. Parsons' range line for navigation to his dock would not be obstructed. I trust that you will find these modifications acceptable. We realize that your initial concerns on the project, remain; that you'd like to have construction completed to January 31, 2003, you'd like to use materials that do not have CCA treated wood, if possible, or at least contained and collect any CCA sawdust and debris so that copper leaching into the Inner Bay waters is minimized or completely eliminated, that you would encourage Mr. Pendergast to use low-power settings for berthing maneuvering and no solvents would be used on the boat. Mr. Pendergast is agreeable to all of these and we are urging the pennitting agencies to review these documents for approval as quickly as possible to allow construction in January. We wish to thank you for your input into this project and would encourage you to review these drawings and correspond further with the Town if you feel so inclined. Yours truly, ~S9K5J/ÎlNCf<- ", {øk:f1:A.Jij..flo~ Keith B. Neilson, P.E. KBN:jm Enclosures CC: Mr. Joseph Pendergast NYS DEC, Town of South old, US ACOE File: 02-04-1297 PENDERGAST .' . . Board of Trustees Application County of Suffolk State of New York Joseph Pendergast BEING DULY SWORN DEPOSES AND AFFIRMS THAT HE / SHE IS THE APPLICANT FOR THE ABOVE DESCRIBED PERMIT (S) AND THAT ALL STATEMENTS CONTAINED HEREIN ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF HIS/HER KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF, AND THAT ALL WORK WILL BE DONE IN THE MANNER SET FORTH IN THIS APPLICATION AND AS MAY BE APPROVED BY THE SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF TRUSTEES. THE APPLICANT AGREES TO HOLD THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD AND TOWN TRUSTEES HARMLESS AND FREE FROM ANY AND ALL DAMAGES AND CLAIMS ARISING UNDER OR BY VIRTUE OF SAID PERMIT(S), IF GRANTED. IN COMPLETING THIS APPLICATION, I HEREBY AUTHORIZE THE TRUSTEES, THEIR AGENT(S) OR REPRESENTATIVE(S), TO ENTER ONTO MY PROPERTY TO INSPECT THE PREMISES IN CONJUNCTION WITH REVIEW OF THIS APPLICATION. SWORN TO BEFORE ME THIS ~9~ , 2 OC,:~ r " téL Notary Public ~ ( 01£\ TC Ol~ F t.___UM [J (\ C.\.U(\ í\.{ 0\= g~ lLé:, GAIL L. WYLLIE /j: OfFfcIÑ.NÖì"ÃRŸ NOTARy p~':j2 L WYLLliEAL M\'~MMI5SIO;:~~£ ~:.~c:..~lD" MM1SSION rv.: N,.....,....., ""r, OV, 20 7 . . Board of Trustees Application AUTHORIZATION (where the applicant is not the owner) I, Joseph Pendergast residing at (print owner of property) Oriental Avenue (mailing address) Fishers Island, NY do hereby authorize Docko, Inc. (Agent) P.O. Box 421, Mystic, CT 06355 to apply for permit(s) from the Southold Board of Town Trustees on my behalf. ---------- 8