HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlock, John L & Anna K- Denied TOWN BOARD
MiNUT ES
PRESENT:
SUPERVISOR ALBERT MARTOCCHIA
JUSTICE MARTIN SDTER
COU~CILM3~ HOWARD VALENTINE
COUNCILMAN LOUIS DEMAREST
TOWN CLERK ALBERT W. RIOH~OI/D
ToWN ATTORNEY ROBERT W. TASKER
Plock - Change of zone
The Supervisor called the hearing to order Councilman
"2. By changing from "C" Industrial District to "A"· Residential
· and Agricultural District, the following described property:
"All that certain tract of land situated at Bayview, Southold,
in the Town of Southold, County of Suffolk, and State of New York,
and more particularly bounded and described as follows:
"Beginning at a point on the ordinary high water mark of
line between land of Plock and land of
by
the
boundary
Reydon
Shores; from said point of beginning running easterly along said
high water mark, ·800 feet, more or less; thence through, said lend
of ~ock, two courses: (1) southerly 1200 feet, more or less; thence
(2) westerly 800 feet, more or less, to said "Reydon Shores";
· thence northerly along said "Reydon Shores", 1200 feet, more or
less to the point of begining.
Being and intended to be the sa~e parcel shown as a "C"
zone on the zoning _map of the Town of Southold, as adopted
April 9, 1957."
Counoilman Valentine read the recommendation of the Southold
TownPlanning Board as it concerns this hearing.
~ SUPERVISOR MARTOCCHIA: Is there anyone present who wishes
to speak in favor of this change of zone?
(There was no response.)
SUPERVISOR MARTOCCHIA: Is there anyone present who wishes to
speak against this change of zone?
R. G. TERRY, ESQ.: I am an attorney with an office at Southold.
I appear on behalf of Jqhn Plock and Anna Plock, o~mers of the
property that is proposed to be changed. I wish to make it clear
that Mr. Plock is opposed to this change of zone. This is the only
classification which would permit him to use the property for the
purpose which he had originally purchased it. He uses it for
shellfish research, shell£ish culture and promote ~yster researoh.
I woi~ld call your attention to the facb that this classification
has been in existence since the enactment of the Zoning Ordinance
in 19%7. We all agree that Mr. Plock has not abused the property.
He has done nothing detrimental tothe neighborhood. The change
of classification at this time is Unwarrantied. Mr. Plock has
been dedicated to this property and certified he is not going to
do anything that will depreciate the value of the property. The
zoning classification was adopted in 1957, 12 years ago. Mr. Plock
has continued to use this property. This classification should be
left as it is. Before, Mr. Plock speaks, I would like to give
you for~aal objection petition against change, again call~'~he
attention that you will be required to have an affi~'mative vote
of five members of the Board to effect this. I would like to have
Mr. Plock talk on the use of this property, and after Mr. Plock,
Prof. Smith.
~LR. JOH~ PLOCE: I am the owner of this property. We obtained
this property in 1947, and contir~d use since that date~. We have
spent a minimum of $20,000. Minimum of $20,000. In many years
it is more than this amount. We have allowed the Federal
GoveEmnent to have use of this area for three years, from 1957-
1960 and they came up with new discoveries. It is ou~ hope to
reproduce oysters in this culture sand,
We have been unable to do this, but progress in research
in other areas show that oyster can be reproduced in laboratories.
We w~ut to continue the growth o£ theses, oysters to marketable size~
90-99% of these oysters can not be ~E~ grown to marketable size.
We are hoping to reduce this rate to ~0% and hopefully less than
that. We hope to reproduce the se oysters and grow them to
marketable size. I don't know why this property was ~ught up
for change. We hope to continue this operation . We at the
present time live right on this property I have lived in this
community for a good many years. We certainly never tried to do
anything that .would be detrimental to the cormnunity~ and I don't
intend to do it at this time.
PROF. SMITH: John Plock has the only two ponds of this type
in the United States. There are some inJapan and some in France.
~e have ponds where we attempting to grow oysters to marketable
size. Mou know that the oyster business in this area is in
terrible shape. These two ponds are outstanding in this area.
The use of these ponds has helped the shellfish business on the
northeast. We want to bring oysters back into this area. We
propose to rebuild the industry. We can't reproduce oysters
here, ~ud we Tound out the reason why~ but oysters will grow% in
treated ponds. We want to bring the oyster business back to Long
Island and use the ponds for further experiment. The only other
type of pond like this in the United States is in O~sfor~,Md. ,
come to look at these ponds. These ponds will give insight in
the direction of the shellfish culture in the' northeastern
United States.
SUPERVISOR MARTO~CHIA: Is there anyone else p~esent who wewkE
.wishes to spgak against this propesed change o£ zone?
(There was no response.)
SUPERVISOR MARTOOCHIA: Is the~e anyone p~esent who wishes
to be heard one way or the other?
(Thez~ was no ~espons~)
SUPERVISOR MARTOCCHIA: Hearing none, I will close the hea~ing
at this time Fo~ the further deliberation oS the .Board.
ii
In the Matter of the Proceeding of
the Town Board of the Town of :
Southold to Change the Building
Zone Ordinance of the Town of :
Southold, Suffolk County, New York.
THE HONORABLE MEMBERS OF THE TOWN BOARD OF THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD:
W~, the undersigned owners of the entire area proposed to
be changed from "C" Industrial District to '~" Residential and
Agricultural District do hereby object and protest the proposed
change as set forth in the Notice of Hearing to be held on
July 15, 1969, conc~erning our premises at Bay View, Southold,
Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York°
STATE OF NEW YORK )
) SS:
COUNTY OF SUFFOLK )
On the /~day of July, 1969, before me personally came JOHN
L. PLOCK and Ai~NA K. PLOCK, his wife, to me known to be the
individuals described in and who executed the foregoing instru-
ment, and they acknowledged to me t~t they e<ecuted the same.
SE~SS~A~ ¢. TEa~',-, ~.~ Public.
Southold, Town Plann Board
SmUTHr-ILD, L. I., N. Y. 119'71
:?~LANNING ,BOARD MEMBERS
John ~Wickhalrn, ICh~irrnan
Henry' Moisa
Alfred Grebe
William Unke[bach
FrAnk Coyle
June 24~ 1969
Southold Town Board
16 South Strest
Greenport~'N~w York
Gentlemen;
Upon the motion of the Town Board to re-zone property
of John Plock N/S Bayview - east of Reydon Shores, Southold,
N.Y. from "C" District to "A" District the Planning Board
recommends waiting until a'"Light Industry C-l" zone is
created as reco~nended and putting this parcel in the more
restricted "~-l" district rather than making it a "non-
conforming" use in the "A" district.
Respectfully submitted,
John Wickham~ Chairman
Southold Town Planning Board
1969
Front & ~4ai~ Street
Green~rt, L.I., Ne~ Y~k 11~
Planing C~is~ion (6 CO~s}. A~
Also pl~e sen~ a co~ of ~he ~ey o~ John Plo~'s
"C~' zone pro~rty east of ~ey~n
Yours truly,
Howard Terr,~ /
B uil~hng Ins~tor
~K
C~OLI'i'HnLD, L, I.. N, Y. 119'71
April 23, 1969
l~. John Wickham
Chairman Planning Board
Cutchogue, L.I.,N.Yo 11935
Dear F Lt. Wickham;
Enclosed herewith is a
copy of a resolution passed by the
Southold Town Board at a meeting held
on April 22, 1969.
You are instructed to pre-
pare an official report thereon pursuant
to the provisions of Article IX of the
Building Zone Ordinance of the To%rn of
Southold.
Very truly yours,
Albert W. Richmond
AWR/mr Town Clerk
Green~rt, L. !., ~e~ ~ t~944
Be~e~on ~iv~l~ an~:~g fr~ "B" Dis==t to "A" District,
~ohn Wick. ham, Chairman
Southol~ T~wn Planning
VAN TUYL & SON
February 28~ 1968 I
DESCRIPTION: Proposed Ghange of Zone
"G to A", Bayview, Southold
(pa~t of l~nd of Jeho_ Plock)
Begi~uir~ at a point on the ordinary b~ghwater mark of
Shelter Island Sound, where said high water mark is intersected
by the bo'~ndary line between lsm_d of Plockand !and of "Reydon
Shores"; from s~id point of beginning r~ning easterly along
said high water mark, 800 feet, more or less; thence through
said land of Plock, two courses:
(1) Southerly ~200 feet~ more or less: thence
(2) Westerly 800 feet, more or less, to szid "Reydon Shores";
thence northerly along~id'~eydon Shores", 1200 feet,more or less,
to the point of beginning=
Being and intended to be the same parcel shown as a
"~" Zone on the Zonir~ Map of the To~n of Southold, as adopted
April 9, 1957~
V~Y TUTL & SON
To: Howard .Terry '
VAN TUYL & SON
February ~.~, 1968
DESCRIPTIOn: Proposed qhange of Zone~
South Side Main Road
East of "Beixedon% Southold
Beginning at a point on the southsr!y line of the ~in Ro~d,
230°97 feet easterly along said southerly line from a private
road kno~m as ")~shamomaque Avenue"~ said point of beginning
being the northeasterly corner of lot 2, block 2, as shown on
"Map of Beixedon Estates"~ filed in the Suffolk qouuty qle~:~s
Office ss M~p #~72; fro~ said point of beg~.~o, ing r~uing along
said southerly ±ine of the Main Road~ No 57 ~2~ 00" Eo ~
~00o0 fee~ to l~nd of Lang$ thence along said land of Lang~
So ~4° ~ 40~ E, - 1600 fee%more or less~ to ordinary high
water mark of To-,m__Harbor; thence southwesterly ~long said
high water mark~ 950 feet more or less~ to the shore of the
~inner basin~ as shown on said "~p of Beixeden Est~tes~; thence
northwesterly and then northeasterly and then again northwesterly
~d then northerly along s~id shore about 1600 feet to the ~aster!y
oorner of lot 8~ block 2~ as shown on ~aid map~ thence along said
lot 8 and along lots 7, 6~ And ~ No 7 ~6~ 40~' E. - 260 feet~more
or less; thence alcug said lot 5 ~nd along lots 4 , 3 and said
lot 2~ N. 25~ 2? 40~" Wo - 366o2i feet to ~'~
~n~ point of ~eg~uzng~
Being and intended to be the same parcel sho~-n as a ~:B:~
Zone on the zoning map of the Tovm of $outhold as adopted
April 9~ ~957~
VAi~ TO_-YL & S01,Y
To: Howard Terry ~ ..
?.,~.., ~ r.: ~.,~. ~ ':~i;' i,"l=** -
..... -; ..... ,~-...~-;-- I~ing
~ ,s.'.~.,,~ ~,~ %.i,i~.~., i".~'.~ .,. .~'."~
~ .. ~.'., ~'~. ,,,. ~::' .~, ¥. ~'.,. ,~.t..,.~": i~ez' and ~uhUshe~
--.,-t '-..' ,'Lh." :. :~ '~'' ~" ' ':'~ - ~;~t
: ~., :.,: .~:,, ,........~PaPez
'~" ""'" ' "*' ' ' ~' '"-' ' the ~,~-''e
~ e, (~..,%.~.~ .:,'~t.:..s'
' :,~1~. ;,'~.-~,~'~ *~:~,", ..~, :i-, '.~ w'..,,~ ~ tho ~ Snff~l~ ~ee~ Iimes
_.~.~..~,,~ ... ~.~.~ ~.~ ...., ~ ~_r ..... ~ ...... ~ ..........
"~'~. "~:";' ?: ....... ""~ ' ~" ~a ~a ~ .~ ......
-3- ~*'%:'" ~ ~[~¢ .~r~c~ .... .. · ' .......... ' . ' ...
'. '-~ 'o~' ~r6- ~o ,.~. .,. :. %,v ,.' .:, :~. "' '"~" '9 G~
8oaffnolO,. g'~ffolk Ct.~.'r :'. ';"[~.. S~ ;,'t. ~.. ~'~rl. ~,* : q~'.. ',~.,':., ...,.; ..'~'~ ~ '. ' .
-~o~ to ~end the ~., .- ~:~, j~ "~;,~ ~t.~r'r~t ;,~ ~ :.:;'.. ,
~Iaps)
'ri~tu~l Dist~ct;' the. fol[o','.'.r~ ,,I ,~,,,I .... f, I, .1C~J~
~ ~-'io~c~ OI%;.~_A~I~S o~-~ COUN~ OF SUFFOLK ~ ss:
~ zola o~ ~ STATE'OF N~ YORK
~ ~ne O~nc~Oz':t~l C. Whitney B~th, Jr., being duly sworn, says
~T. that he is the ~itor, of THE LONG IS~ND
~ea~ J.
York,
p~hnc
~ ,' ~ b~ held b~ the ~tho~
~ ~o~ m,,~he ~ o~ the I T~VELER - ~ITUCK WATCH~N, a public news-
~?~r~, New Yor~ m ~ paper printed at Southold, in Suffolk Count; and that
~,'l~ a~ ~:~ o'clock ~ the e~'e- } ~he notice of which the annexed is a printed copy, has been
~f a~ ~y ou.~e Io~o~m, publish~ in said Long island Travemer-Mottituck Watch-
't. ~ ~ofl~ '~: ~-'~' man once each week for ..... ~..~,.,....
~"~successively, commencing on the ................. ~.~.~ff ........
. ,
~ ,~'m~. . m~}~t~'~',~em~¢~.. . ~ ~.. ~ ~ . ... day of ...... . ......... , 1~..
Sworn to before me this ......... ~..., ...... day of
gBELE pAYNE
~uther~'~;o~ ~:~i~ P~.I ~6~ Public State or
~. ~i ~,~[~ alo~ ~i~,~d[. No. 52-3041000
f'~ ~. ~r'~a~'if' ~'~)OI Corniness,on Ex0ires March 3C. [971
~hea~er~f ~an~ th~n
%~ the eatery, com~' OL~ lo~ ~
:~,eillg arut in~ended ~o be the j
9.
~ fa~o~g de~bed proof:
c ~ at Ba~ew. '~at.~ld
S~o~, and. S~te of
,~.(I:, Souih~rJ~ ~ f~t m~e or[,
aon lh~ zo~ map of
n rf P✓ �_�' - f. — '
0
I
1
r 6 '•---- -'^---- or i i r<j Hick Wq.C:.r Hfv✓k
44
b s I
7�1��,W'lt �'k✓/ ''� � -"Y�td !.kq�s ��Cl��'/ ���!l���y '�' d 'Q
u: w .UN
4 �
� 1
4 k j
' - � �� � � � - � � /1/.6335''N/.- 39.50 , ���VI•� ; -
s �
'i - � � � � ` � I .v ���O�"r'! N. .9 'io ' v✓- _ 3.3/. 70 9 �d
� h
j
a j / .a F i/ vON�/ G . `e AAIAIA
fir" 1 fJ / � %� Towrv' o�-Sr�•%T��t.:; N.1!
I, ? �
56.3 S^•� p . 7-Y�sf✓i rGry✓�/�r�'
l rl +
r 1
y Trcrcu�c� Mt+rc L, Z 7 1-96-3 Frcrr� a sur✓�
ClarZ-' 410rif,,
ss.ss ' 0
, : >,e = zs' Gr�c�aor�f New - .