Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMaidstone Development, Inc. EDWARD J. BA~LKE 5 Revile Road Bayville, N.Y. 11709 November 29, 1979 Southold Town Board Town Hall Main Road Southold, N.Y. 11971 Re: Maidstone Development, Inc. Petition for change of zone Gentlemen: I am the owner of 5.2 acres of real property located on the North side of Middle Road, Greenpert, New York which is under contract of sale to Maidstone Development, Inc. I consent to the application of Maidstone Development, Inc. for a change of Zone~ A Residential and Agricultural to M-1 Multiple Residence District. I authorize Maidstone Development, Inc. to proceed with its application for the change of zone. Sincerely yours, Edward J. Bahlke EJB :ab TOWN OF SOUTHOLD SHORT ENVIRON~LENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM ~o the orojec~. ~ita o~ .°h~sicallv. al:e-_ =hah ~0 acr~s of land? .......... Yes X 2. W~i ~here be a ~jor chan~e ~o ant '~i~u~ or -.-~ ..... ~ ....~ ..... --~ ,,~ . . / .... ~. ~.~.',z~c, /. ~.~ ~ -' /~," SCHEDULE A ALL that certain plot, piece or parcel of land, situate, lyinq and being near Greenport, in the Town of Southold, County of Suffolk and State of New York, bounded and described as follows: BEGINNING at a monument on the northerly line of the North Road at the southwesterly corner of land, now or formerly of Parlamis, formerly of Marston, being the southeasterly corner of the premises herein described; from said point of beginning running along said northerly line of the North Road South 53 degrees 24 minutes 30 seconds West a distance of 255.26 feet; running thence along land now or formerly of Crystal on a line parallel to and 250 feet westerly from the westerly line of said land of Parlamis North 24 degrees 56 minutes 30 seconds West a distance of 852.29 feet to ordinary high water mark of Long Island Sound; running thence along said high water mark of Long Island Sound North 32 degrees 09 minutes 30 seconds East a distance of 297.75 feet to said land of Parlamis; thence along said land of Parlamis South 24 degrees 56 minutes 30 seconds East a distance of 962.47 feet to the point or place of beginning, said premises containing 5.207 acres according to survey of Otto W. Van Tuyl & Son, dated October 31, 1961. P~serving to the party of the first part, her heirs, legal representatives and assigns the right to the use of the pond on the premises and to drain the pond completely, or to leave the pond in its present condition, providing nevertheless, that if the westerly line of the premises herein conveyed cuts through any part of the pond, the party of the second part, his heirs, legal representatives and assigns, may at his discretion, fill in such part of the pond as may lie within his property line. RECEIVED ! i9 '9 CASF I'-.TO: ~:~.'~ ............. STATE OF NE~Ar YORK PETITION TOWN OF SOUTHOLD IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION OF FOR A CHANGE, MODIFICATION OR AMENDMEiYT OF THE BUILDING ZONE ORDIN- ANCE OF THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD, SUFFOLK COUNTY, NEW YORK. TO THE TOWN BOARD OF THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD: a domestic corporation with principal offices 1. I, .~t.I.~.~.~.O.~...~~.. ~.~., ......... ~1%~ at .~.?.~..~.~.~c..~.~...~.: ...P.~.r.~. ~efferson Station, New York 11776 (insert name of petitioner) contract vendee Suffolk County, New York, the undersigned, am the ~ of certain real property situated at Greenport, Town of Southold and more particularly bounded and described as See Schedule A attached hereto. 2. I do hereby petition the Town Board of the Town of Southold to change, modify and amend the Building Zone Ordinance of the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York, including ~he Building Zone Maps heretofore made a par[ thereof, as follows: To change the zoning classification of the above premises from: "A" Agricultural and Residential to: "M-i" General Multiple Residence District. 3. Such request is made for the following reasons: The property, because of its size and location, is well suited to multiple residence use. It is located in an area containing several parcels zoned M-1 Multiple Residence, and B Light Business. Therefore, the rezoning would conform to the general character of the neighborhood. The property is situated on Long Island Sound on a major East-West road near the Village of Greenport, and is secluded from neighboring properties by its dense vegetation. Applicant plans to erect eight 3-unit condominiums. MATDSTONE DEVELOPMENT, INC. (L. STATE OF NEW YORK, ) ) SS:- COUNTY OF SUFFOLK, ) Joseph C. Martirano ............................................... BEING DULY SWORN, deposes and says that the President of he i~the petitioner in the within action; that lie has read the foregoing Petition and knows the contents thereof; that the same is true to his (her) own knowledge, except as to the matters therein stated to be alleged on information and belief, and that as to those matters he believes it to be true. MAIDSTONE DEVELOPMENT, INC. (L. S.) ......... : ........... Sworn to before me ~ Abigail~. Wickham Notary Public. Notary Public, State of New Yo~ No. 52-4642871 Qualified in Suffolk Count~ Ielffi IF.,X~r~ls March. 30. 19 ~1 , WHEREAS, a petition was heretofore filed with the Town Board of the Town of $outhold by ...... ~.~?.~.o..~...?.~.v.~.~l.~.~.? ...~.~.(~.. ............... requesting a change, modification and amendment of the Building Zone Ordinance including the Building Zone Maps made a part thereof by chang- "A" Residential and "~,~-1" General lng from ....J~g~V.i.q,~J;.g~7.?:~ ........... District to Mul.t.i.l~le...P, esi.de.n~.e District the property described in said petition, and WHEREAS said petition was duly referred to the Planning Board for its investigation, recommendation and report, and its report having been filed with the Town Board, and thereafter, a public hearing in relation to said petition having been duly held by the Town Board on the ..~J~h ........... day of ............... I~l~ .......................... , 19~9...., and due deliberation having been had thereon NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the relief demanded in said petition be, and it hereby is DENIED. DATED: June 10, 1980 JUDITH T. TERRY TOWN CLERK TOWN OF SOUTHOLD PUBLIC HEARING May 6, 1980 CHANGE OF ZONE APl .CATION #244-~fAIDSTONE DEV OPMENT CORP. A public hearing was held by the Southold Town Board at the Southold Town Hall, Main Road, Southold, New York at 8:15 o'clock P.M., Tuesday, on Mai' 6, 1980 in the matter of the application of Maidstone Development, Inc.for change of zone from "A" Residential and Agricultural to "M-i" General Multiple Residence District on property located at North Road, Greenport, New York. Present were: Supervisor William R. Pell III Councilman ttenry iV. Drum Councilman John J. Nickles Councilman Lawrence Murdock, Jr. Councilman George R. Sullivan Town Clerk Judith T. Terry Town Attorney Robert W. Tasker SUPERVISOR PELL opened the hearing at 8:15 P.M. COUNCILMAN MURDOCK read the legal notice of hearing as follows: PURSUANT to Section 265 of the Town Law and requirements of Chapter 100 of the Code of the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York, public hearings will be held by the Town Board of the Town of Southold at the Southold Town Hall, Main Road, Southold, New York on the 6th day of May, 1980, on the following proposal to amend the Building Zone Ordinance (including the Building Zone lIaps) of the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York. 8:15 o'clock P.M. By changing from "A" Residential and Agricultural District to "M-I" General Multiple Residence District the property of Maids,one Development, Inc., situated near Greenport, in the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York, bounded and described as follows: BEGINNING at a monument on the northerly line of the North Road at the southwesterly corner of land, now or formerly of Parlamis, formerly of Marston, being the southeasterly corner of the premises herein described; from said point of beginning running along said northerly line of the North Road South 53 degrees 24 minutes 30 seconds West a distance of 255.56 feet: running thence along land now or formerly of Crystal on a line parallel to and 250 feet westerly from the westerly line of said land of Parlamis North 24 degrees 56 minutes 30 seconds West a distance of 852.20 feet to ordinary high water mark of Long Island Sound; running thence along said high water mark of Long Island Sound North 32 degrees 09 minutes 30 seconds East a distance of 297.75 feet to said land of Parlamis; thence along said land of Parlam]s South 24 degrees 56 minutes 30 seconds East a distance of 962.47 feet to the point or place of beginning, said premises containing 5.207 acres according to survey of Otto W_ Van Tuyl a Son. dated October 31, 1961. I also have a letter from the Southold Town Planning Board, dated March 3, 1980 which reads as follows: The following action was taken bi' the Southold Town Planning Board at a regular meeting held February 25, 1980_ RESOLVED to recon~end to the Southold Town Board denial of the application (2) PUBLIC REARING May 6, 1980 CHANGE OF ZONE AP~ ~CATION #244-MAIDSTONE DEX OPMENT CORP. of Maidstone Development, Inc. for a change of zone from "A" Resi- dential and Agricultural to "M-i" General Multiple Residence for property located at Greenport for the following reasons: 1. The Board considers this would be spot zoning. 2. It would set a precedent inthe area for further downzoning of property. /s/ Henry E. Raynor, Jr., Chairman, Southold Town Planning Board. I also have a letter fromthe Suffolk County Department of Planning dated April 3, 1980 which reads as follows: "Pursuant to the requirements of Sections 1323 to 1332 of the Suffolk County Charter, the Suffolk County Planning Commission on April 2, 1980 reviewed the above captioned application and after due study and deliberation Resolved to disapprove it because of the following: 1. It is in- consistent with the Town of Southold Development Plan which desi- gnates this area for agricultural-single family residence develop- ment; 2. It is inconsistent with the pattern of zoning in the surrounding area and therefore must be considered as "spot zoning"; 3. It would tend to establish a precedent for further downzonings in the locale along Middle Road (C.R. 27); and 4. There appears to be ample land available for multi-residence purposes in the surrounding area_ /s/ Gerald G. Newman, Chief Planner, Suffolk County Department of Planning. SUPERVISOR PELL: The question is now, does anyone wish to speak in favor of the applicant? ABIGAIL A_ WICKRAM, ESQ.: Yes, Abigail Wickham for the applicant. I have prepared a color coded map that I would like to put up, with your permission, for the Boards' review. And I also, if I may have your permission, I have prepared a duplicate of that map, if I could tape it up here so the audience can see what it is that we are ~alking about. Now, I'd like to start by describing the project to you. This is the location of the property shown here in green along the North Road in Mattituck. I have shown other multiple residence zones in the Town of Southold in blue, business areas in red, the gray are the roads. These yellow areas are merely to show the municipally owned property that the Village of Greenport owns property outside the village limits and the County of Suffolk ...... COUNCILIIAN DRUM: You're talking about Greenport? The green you said was in Mattituck. MS. WICKHAM: I'm sorry, Greenport, yes~ The purpose of the application is to rezone the property from "A" Residential to "M-i" General Residence, Multiple Residence. The primary object of the change of zone would be to erect condominiums. They indicated in the application, my client wishes to erect twenty-four (24) units on the property_ This is less than the maximum permitted in a multiple residence area. The maximum being approximately twenty-nine (29), there being 5.24 acres of property. We did originally intend to erect eight (B) three (3) unit buildings. My client is considering a change in that lay-out in order to further maximize open space and perhaps cluster the buildings. Now, as to the location of property, it's about 2_5 miles from downtown Greenport. It is also in the immediate vicinity of a number of business zones and a number of o~her multiple residence zones. We feel that in light of these considerations, it does in fact comply with the considerations expressed by the Town of Southold in adopting their comprehensive plan, In relation to garden apartments in a tax based development which this would qualify as, the PUBLIC HEARING (3) May 6, 1980 CHANGE OF ZONE APt CATION # 244-MAIDSTONE DE ~OPMENT, INC. plan is recommending consideration of a medium density residential residence uses on various sites, which would be strictly controlled by zoning regulations. The areas which were pointed out in the comprehensive plan as being suitable for multiple residences were those in the immediate vicinity of retail shopping, service and general commercial areas and I think that you can see from here that there are a number of areas, the Village of Greenport does not show on this map, but the other business areas do show. It is also located on a major east-west route - Middle Road (C.R.27) The plan does not say it has to be in the immediate vicinity of an actual municipality such as Greenport or Southold. I think it refers more to being in general commercial areas which I believe we are_ I would like to mention some of the other multiple residence areas. This is not a unique usuage for this area. We have a number of condominiums stretching further this way along the North Road, the Soundview, Levin properties, also some commerical uses also some multiple residences recently rezoned coming up here all the way to the Sunset Motel. Over here we have the San Simeon project which I understand is going to be underway in the somewhat near future. While that is vacant land that is available for multiple residence that is limited according to the testimony given to the Town Board on the application to senior citizens defined as being 62 years of age or older, so it is not generally available for multiple residence withoul 1,mitation as to the age of residents. In addition, there is a parcel here of approximately 17 acres owned by people by the name of Smith. That was rezoned in the late 50's and the intention at that time was to put up a motel. I should point out that this small strip of blue, while it is not shown on the current zoning map as multiple residence, it was rezoned and shows in the town records as being multiple residence, not necessarily for purposes of multiple residences but for access to the water. I think, for this property here. The general jist of that application, and I think the more suitable use of that property is for a motel type use. Down here, there is another area of multiple residence which is owned by the KOA Eastern Kampgrounds and that has been developed for campground usuage. The area here which we are proposing is i~ the immediate vicinity of these other areas, it would be used for, as I indicated multiple residences residential uses - condominiums, not motel hotel establishments. Now, the reason for that is there have been a number of discussions with one of the neighbors, Mr. Crystal. through his attorney. Mr. Crystal. as I understand it, did not object to the rezoning, but only to the possibility that the rezoning might result in a commerical establish- ment and we have agreed and have offered covenants to put on the property which would preclude its' use as a motel hotel commercial development because we do intend to proceed with the condominiums usage. I think the willingness of my client to agree to covenants does indicate that he does intend to go ahead and develop the property right now. not just let it remain idle for future speculations. If he intended to do that he would not be putting such a restriction on it because it would harm his resale future values. The other factor I would like to address is one of need for the un,ts. There are a couple of units being erected now down here on the Sound that have been very well received in terms of market desirability_ My client and I have both received a number of inquiries from people who have heard about our application and were interested in this type of residential unit. They would be fairly expensive luxury units geared toward a well established group of people. It would be a (4) PUBLIC HEARING May 6, 1980 CHANGE OF ZONE APPLICATION #244-MAIDSTONE DEVELOPMENT, INC. fairly exclusive community and every effort would be made to make ii an attractive asset to the Town of Southold. Needless to say, the tax benefit to the Town of Southold from this type of develop- ment would far exceed its development as currently zoned for single family residences. The other point tha% I think is important to consider is the comparability with the surrounding properties. It would be a residential use similar to the other residential uses down here. I have indicated on the map by small brown boxes the existing single family residences on %he strip between this proposed rezoning and the o~her multiple usage along the Sound. As you can see, all but two properties down here along the road have single family homes on them. I think tha~ in light of this and also in light ~hat they are small parcels ~he likelihood of those properties being subject to downzoning or rezoning is very small. I don't ~hink that the tendancy that the Planning Board saw is a likely possibility because of their existing ,u~age and ~heir small size. As I said before, we are planning a nice resi- dential community and I think it would blend in well with ~he surrounding properties, the topography of the property is such as that i~ would not be extremely visible from the road. The property is much deeper than i~ is wide so that the units would be in large part back fromthe road. We have also agreed to screen the properties, mainly on the instance of Mr. Crystal who lives next to this property on the west, to screen along the boundaries with natural vegetation in order ~o further minimize the impact on ~he surrounding areas. I don't have ~oo much more to say. I would prefer ~o see if you have any questions or comments tha~ I might discuss with you. SUPERVISOR PELL: Does anyone else wish to be heard in favor of the applicant? MR. SAM MARKEL: I think it might Greenport a little shot in the arm business wise. I think tha~ anything that would give our area a little business boost would be pleasantly welcomed. We don't have industry out here. Primarily, if we could get some more business for the local shop keepers, it would be very good. SUPERVISOR PELL: Anybody else wish to be heard in favor of the applicant? (There was no response.) SUPERVISOR PELL: Does anyone wish to be heard in opposition to the application? WILLIAM PRICE, JR., ESQ: I represent the adjoining property owner, Mr_ Bur~ Crystal. As Miss Wickham said, my client is not opposed to the concept of condominiums. And as Miss Wickham said, we were presented with proposed covenants and restrictions that would limit the property to development in a residential manner. Unfortunately, I was presented with them this evening and cannot get in touch with my client at this time, and therefore must proceed. Let us take a look a~ what we have here. We ~alk about what the actual area looks like. We have Chapel Lane where you have the nursing home. Even though it is zoned "M-I" it is one of your special exceptions that is allowed in the "A" residential area. (5) PUBLIC HEARING May 6, 1980 CHANGE OF ZONE APPLICATION ~244-MAIDSTONE DEVELOPMENT, INC. We have the Soundview complex up where this "M-i" is. And then we have a stretch o£ property which is "A" residential and has been used as "A" residential and now there would be the probability or the possibility excuse me, if this application were granted that this residential area could be used in the future by some new, not necessarily this developer, but some other developer for motel and hotel purposes. This is a relatively exclusive area, as we all know, for having £ront footage on Long Island Sound. In talking about the other so called business areas around here. This area over here off of Moores Lane, that's the Greenport Moores Woods which has the sewer plant and water recharge area. We have the KOA which is zoned business, this also here is part of the Greenport Moores Woods area. Now, as I said, my client is not opposed to ~he concept of condominiums, however, this particular application requesting a change of zone to the "M-i" zoning which would allow motels in the future with the covenants, my client or his successor, should he sell the property, would be required to enforce these covenants_ Whereas if it were not a change to "M-i" but rather to light multiple zone. Then in that e£fect, the Town o£ Southold would be able to do some of the enforcement and not result in the long and slow tedious process of trying to enforce covenants. Now, I have pictures of what this particular area looks like. This was taken two Sundays ago by an employee of, Mr. David Bruckheimer. This past Sunday I went and took a look and this does make a fair representation of Mr. Crystal's property, the property adjoining to the west, and part o£ the property where the application is made for. One of my clients major concerns is also that the possibility of additional erosion to the sound bank. His house, as you can see from that photograph, is on the edge of the bank itself and any further erosion of the bank would cause an immediate hardship and possibly danger to his property. This picture here is a picture taken from the sound beach, also by an employee, Mr. Bruckheimer. Now, it has been checked out that this picture is a fair representation o£ a view from the sound looking ~oward the applicant's property. Now, that does not look as though there has been much erosion in that area. However, we have a picture showing steps on the property to the west of Mr. Crystal's property showing the di£ferent heights o£ bulkheading deterences they have attempted to use to prevent erosion in that area. It has been represented to me that those pilings, those concrete pilings off o£ the stairways have become much more exposed since ~he installation of that particular stairway. As a final representation as to the type of the erosion tha~ has been going in that area, we have a closeup picture o£ those particular pilings that were holding the steps showing in that other picture there. In summary, as I have stated, my client is not opposed to the concept of condominiums but the possibility that commerical use could be instigated in that area adjoining his property. He purchased in the lines that he was in ~he "A" residential zone and for that reason is concerned as to this change application as well as the evidence of erosion in there where construction of a project of this magnitude may further speed up the erosion of the sound bank in that area. Thank you. SUPERVISOR PELL: Thank you very much, ~r_ Price. Does anyone else wish to speak against the application? (6) PUBLIC HEARING May 6, 1980 CHANGE OF ZONE APPLICATION #244-MAIDSTONE DEVELOPMENT, INC. FRANK BEAR, Southold: I am speaking on behalf of the North Fork Environmental Council and the North Fork Audubon Society compiling a membership of approximately 800. I would like ~o endorse the concerns expressed by both the County Commission and the Southold Town Planning Board. The reasons that they gave are basic and it is true, of course, that the Southold Town Development Plan urges that the development along in this area be residential and that there be a minimum of commercial and other types of develop- ment_ The £act that there are other things that have been done contrary to this, certainly doesn't justi£y making the same errors again, or doing something just like that again because every time you add another commercial or "M-I" type of area, you also increase ~he number of people who will be dependent upon the water supply and who will be using other facilities. This is a piece of property slightly less than 5¼ acres and if developed according to the present zoning, it would not take more than 5 homes. Now, they are talking about 24. Now, this means that almost five times the number of residences will be placed on this, if the plan that has now been presented, is finally executed. I would like to point that this area is a part of what is referred to in the water study by Malcolm Pirnie Engineers which was done for the Town of Southold in 1967 called area "C". The area "C" is approximately 4% of the water supply in the entire Town of Southold. This reports point out that areas "A" & "B" that extend from the western boundary to almost the area where this is located have approximately 90% of the water supply in the Town of Southold. Whereas, areas "C" & "B" which extend to ~he eas~ and ~he Little Hog Neck and Great Hog Neck all they have is a total of 10%. Now, to further use up the wa~er supply in this area, it seems to us to be a unwise use of the land or in accordance with the type of wise planning that was done when the town plan was worked out and finally adopted by the Town Planning Board. As the previous speaker said, also, ~his would intend to be the kind o£ spot zoning which might lead to a similar type of zoning or rezoning in the future to the type of buildings which could be motels and trailer camps and could make a big difference in the kind of area that now exists. I think ~o spot zone in this way and to change the character of the area even further would be detrimental to the entire town. As far as being in the vicinity o£ commercial, the commercial type of business that exists in that area is not the type of commercial business that is considered the type near which multiple housing should be built. They are talking about commercial districts, such as down town areas such as in Greenport, Southold or in other areas. This is not that type of area, it would be a long way from central business districts. On behalf of these two organizations, I would like to urge ~hat this Town Board accept the recommendations bo~h of the Southold Town Planning Board and of the Suffolk County Planning Commission and deny their request. Thank you. SUPERVISOR PELL: Thank you. Does anyone else wish to be heard against the applicant? DR_WALTER SMITH: You should look at the experience as you go further west. Mr. Winston built a whole mess of things in Mt_ Sinai Harbor, now we have Mt. Sinai bluffs down in Mt. Sinai. I think you should also look at the evidence compiled of three (7) PUBLIC HEARINGS May 6, 1980 CHANGE OF ZONE APPLICATION #244-MAIDSTONE DEVELOPMENT,INC. years of hearings down on the marine council on bluff zoning. This is very important. It is a proven example to be 100 feet back from the edge of the bluff, the rate of erosion on the north fork is very large. You must remember that the ocean is coming up. Since 1940, it is up 8 inches, the rise seems to be accelerating_ So, we are going to have more and more erosion no matter what we do. So, ~o protect the village and the people owning the property they should be built back. So, that in about 70 years they may wash away, but in the normal run of things in our lifetime, the 100 feet back will be fine. We have to take all this modern evidence into hand before you make a decision. And I think you should look at the publications that we have from the County on bluff zoning. It could answer a lot of your questions. Thank you. SUPERVISOR PELL: Does anybody else wish to speak? MR. HENRY LYTLE, Peconic: My name is Henry Lytle. I am speaking on behalf of the Civic Association of Southold-Peconic. For the past 25 years we were the original supporters of and sponsors of zoning in the Town of Southold_ We think the original Planning Board did a great job in laying these maps out and there is still left a lot of room for multiple dwellings still available. We are opposed ~o further spot zoning or break down of zoning as it now stands. Enough said. SUPERVISOR PELL: Thank you. Mrs. Galdys Csajko. GLADYS CSAJKO, N.F. Taxpayers Assoc.: Two things: First the taxpayers have been on record since 1969 against spot zoning. nd we have watched since 1969 when everybody discussed the Master Plan. This was going to be it. No changes. For eleven years the Board of Appeals has given nearly everybody that has come before them practically, a change. There is spot zoning being done all over Town. We are violently opposed to spot zoning. This is spot zoning. Number two: When are you going to enforce the Master Plan. Now, this is a new board, this isn't the same old bunch. You're new fellows. Now, is the time. When are you going to stop making changes, when we look like Coney Island down here? Another thing I want to point out. The people that buy this property know what this property is zoned when they buy it. They know what they are buying. Why do they come in and then tell you it is a hardship? Let them buy "M-I" property to put the condominiums, if that's want they want to do. SUPERVISOR PELL: Thank you very much. Does anyone else wish to speak against the application? (There was no response.) SUPERVISOR PELL: Does anyone else wish to be heard on this? ERNEST RADFORD: I would like to be heard on it. My name is Ernest Radford_ As £ar as the talk just now about the erosion on the bank. I have known that property for thirty years. In fact, I sold most of that property and there has never been any erosion on that bank because it is in an alcove, it just doesn't (8) PUBLIC HEARING May 6, 1980 CHANGE OF ZONE APPLICATION #244-MAIDSTONE DEVELOPMENT, INC. erode there. The only erosion that has occured along that bank is what people may have done to create erosion. For instance, next to the gentleman, Mt. Crystal, ~here is a property which I sold to a party by the name of Pringle. Then Pringle bulldozed down ~he bank because he wanted to cut down the height so that he could make access to the beach a little easier. But he has put back vegetation on it and such which has helped ~o reestablish the thing, so ~here is no erosion, even there he has actually chopped down the bank. In reference to the various comments about zoning in ~he area, it seems to me tha~ there has been an awful lot o£ talk about criticism because somebody wan~s ~o change something that was previously zoned in a certain way. But there has to be certain changes. In other words, I don't ~hink that the zoning board, at the time the zoning ordinance was created, was so clever tha~ ~hey could know exactly what was necessary in every area in the Town of Southold. And there is bound to be certain areas which ~hey would be more adaptable for a different type of zoning. That's all I have to say. SUPERVISOR PELL: Thank you very much. Does anybody else wish to be heard on ~his application? ABIGAIL A. WICKHAM, ESQ.: Supervisor Pell, May I make a few comments in response to these. I just want to be very brief. I like to add to something that the gentlemen speakfing jus~ said. As far as the erosion on the bluff goes, I don't that the erection of condominiums or any other type of building 100 feet back £rom the bluff, which is the setback requirement, would accelerate erosion. I think erosion on ~he sound bluff is a fac~ of life. This particular sound bluff, I do not ~hink is subject to extensive erosion. It is well planted and it has been ~here for some time. I certainly do not ~hink tha~ it would be in my clients interest or anyone elses in that property to do something that would jeopardize the bluff. As far as ~he water goes, there is public water here from the Village of Greenport which my client has spoken to the Village of Greenport about ~hat it would be a possible source of water supply and of course, any sewage use would comply with the County Board of Health requirements. As to the reference made to spo~ zoning, as a matter of law, I do not believe this is spot zoning_ It is in an area where there are o~her uses of this type. It is a residential use and I've tried to stress EhaZ tonight that we are looking for, we did not apply for "M" Light because o£ restrictions ~n that particular district in terms of the number of years it can be put together and other density requirements. There are business areas, a restaruant, and a number of other uses near here. And I think that the fact that we are two or three miles from the center of Greenport, if is no% such an extreme distance. Out here on the North Fork things are by nature qui~e far apart and when you say immediate vicinity you don't always mean one block down the street. I also would like to urge you to consider the benefits to the Town of Southold in terms of tax advantages, attractive usuage, and a different ~ype of residential use which is gaining in extreme popularity. Thank you. SUPERVISOR PELL: Thank you. Does anyone else wish to be heard on Zhis application? (9) PUBLIC HEARING May 6, 1980 CHANGE OF ZONE APPLICATION #244-MAIDSTONE DEVELOPMENT, INC. COUNCILMAN LAWRENCE MURDOCK, JR.: Could I just read in another letter in the file? SUPERVISOR PELL: Yes. COUNCILMAN MURDOCK: This is a letter which was received in the Town Clerk's Office on May 6th which is today from the Suffolk County Department of Health Services and I think it should be read into the record for purposes of information. It Js addressed to Judith T. Terry, Town Clerk "RE: Maidstone Development, Inc. Zoning Change from "A" Agricultural and Residential to: "M-i" General Multiple Residence District, Dear Judith: I have reviewed the above referenced zoning change in respect to the water supply and sewage disposal facilt±es. 1. It appears that public water is available to the property. However, special considerations will have to be given to the sewage disposal system due to the poor soil conditions in the area. 2. The feasibility of connect- ing to the Greenport Sewer District should be investigated. Very truly yours, Royal R. Reynolds, P.E., Public Health Engineer, General Engineering Services. SUPERVISOR PELL: Does anybody else have anything else to add? Any questions from the Board? ERNEST PAPPAS, Vice-President of the Cedar Beach Park Assoc.: I don't want to exacerbate this discussion any longer, but as a taxpayer and vice-president of the Cedar Beach Park Association, I just feel that this might be a dangerous precedent. SUPERVISOR PELL: Does anybody else wish to be heard on this application? COUNCILMAN JOHN J. NICKLES:Miss Wickham, I just got a little confused with Mr. Price's comments with regard to the covenants. Would those covenants from your client be to the Town or to Mr. Crystal? MS. WICKHAM: They would be imposed on the property. They would be with Mr. Crystal. I had not offered to ~mpose them with the Town. I don't want to engage in contrast zoning. If the Town wanted them to run to them, I think we would consider that. COUNCILIIAN NICKLES: It wasn't a request, it was just a question. MS. WICKRAM: No, it is just something that was worked out with Mr. Crystal. or ra~her is in the process of. SUPERVISOR PELL: Does anyone else on the Board have any questions? (There was no response.) SUPERVISOR PELL: If not, I will declare this hearing closed and move onto the next one. Respectfully submitted, Hearing adjourned at 9:05 P.M. ~-~~ B COUNTY OF SUFFOLK RECEIVED  F,~AY 6 1980 Town Clerk ~.outl~Jd DEPARTMENT OF HEALTHSERVlCES DAVID HARRI$,M.D ,M.P.H. COMMISSIONER May 2, 19g0 Judith T. Terry Town Clerk Town of Southold Southold, New York 11971 ~ ~eidstone Development, Inc. Zoning change from "A" Agricultural and Residential to: "M-l" General Multiple Residence District Dear Judith: I have reviewed the above referenced zoning change in respect to the water supply and sewage disposal facilities. 1. It appears that public water is available to the property. However, special considerations will have to be given to the sewage disposal system due to the poor soil conditions in the area. 2. The feasibility of connecting to the Greenport Sewer District should be investigated. Very truly yours, Royal R. Reynolds, P.E. Public Health Engineer General Engineering Services RRR:amf OFFICE OF TOWN,CtI~RK T~WN OF. SOUTHOLD JUDITH T. 'i £RRY 'SUFFOLK COUNTy TELEPHONE · Southold, L. I., N. Y. 11971 April 29, 1980 Roy R. Reynolds Dept. of Health Services County of Suffolk County Center Riverhead, New York 11901 Dear Roy: The Town of Southold aniticlpates there may be some problem with water on the two (2) enclosed change of zone applications: Maidstone Development Corp. and Wayne Associates, May we have your comments on both of these applications? Very truly yours, dTT/bn Town Clerk cc:file Enc./ LEGAL NOTICE NOTICE OF HEARING ON PROPOSAL TO AMEND ZONING ORDINANCE ~C)(.JNTY (34: SUFFOLK ss: STATE OF NEW YORK Pursuant to Se~ion 265 of the Town Law and require- ments of Chapter 100 of the 'Code of the Town of Southold, Patricia Wood, being duly sworn, says that she is the Suffolk Count)'. New York, public hearings will be held by Editor, of THE LONG ISLAND TPo6,VELER-WATCH/VLAN, the Town Board of the Town of Southold at the Southold Town o public newspaper printed at .C. outhold, in Suffolk County/ Hall, Main Road. Southold. 2nd that the notice of which the annexed is a printed copy, New York on the 6th da'/ of May, 1980, on the following r'os been published in s~id Long Island Traveler-Watch- proposals to amend the Build- man once each week for / weekS ing Zone Ordinance lincinding '7 the Building Zone Maps) of successively, commencing on the ..... /_ ................................. the Town of Southold, Suffolk County. New York. Jay of ~)Zt~ 19..~.-.. 8:'15 o'clock P.M. By chang- - . ' ........................ ' ingAgriculturalfrom" A" Residential and 8:30 o'clock P.ld. By chang.~tc~ ---- ._.'7':~...~ ~''~._...~7~...._....,...~'~-.. General Multiple Residence Agric~tural Otsttiet to "M-I" District the property of Maid- General Multiple Reslaence stone Development, Inc.. situ- District the property of Wayne ated near Greenport. in the Associates situated at South. Town of So uthold, Suffolk old, iff the Town of Soutbold, County, New York, bounded County of Suffolk, State of Sworn to before rrm this .............../..O.... and described as follows: New York, bounded end des- , BEGINNING at a monument eribed as follows: ~ 19.....,~?~.._. on the northerly line of the BEGIlql~NG at the comer =~f'"'""" .................. North Road at thc southwest- formed by the intersection of erly corner of land, now or the southerly side of Orchard formerly of Parietals. [o, merly L~ne (private) with the easter. , ,_t Marston. being thc south- ly side of Cedar Bench Road; ' m' ''''' ~~)~--~t~'J~ ~~ ''''''' --~'--- -- running thence along the .......... ]-.-~-~,. ...... easterly corner of the premtses southerly side of Orchard lame Notary Public '~' herein described; from said south 66 degrees 52 minutes point of beginning running 20 seconds east 4S1_63 feet to along said northerly line of the a point; running thence 60 North Road South 53 degrees degrees 37 minutes 40 seconds CLEMENT J, ~1 minutes 30 seconds West a east 63.02 feet to a point; NOTARY ~l~l~NseY0~ distance of 255.56 feet; run- running thence along the ate ning thence along land now or of a curve boating to the right ~ 1~ ~ formerly of Crystal on a line having a radius of 156.20 feet a parallel to and 250 feet waster- distance of 121.09 feet; run- ly fi~m the westerly line of ning thence south S8 degrees said land of Parietals North 24 46 minutes ,50 seconds east degrees 56 minutes 30 seconds 181.42 feet to a monument; Cedar Point Drive'end akm8 ~West a distance of 852.29 feet running thence south 62 deg- the easterly side of Cedar to ordinary high water mark of rees 07 minutes 30 seconds Beach Road north 23 deg~es Long Island Sound; running east 205 feet to the ordinary 07 minutes 40 seennds east thence along said high water high water mark of Cedar 322.11 feet to.the corner first mark of Long Island Sound ~Beach Harbor; thence souther- dbove mentioned at the point North 32 degrees 09 minutes ly and southeasterly along the or place of BEGINNIIqG. 30 seconds East a distance of ordinary high water mark of Any person desirin~ to be 297.75 feet to said la, nd of Cedar Beach Harbor 426 feet heard on the above proposed Parietals; thence along said more or less to the northerly amendments should appear at land of Parlamis South 24 line of lot No, 30 on Map of the time and place above so degrees 56 minutes 30 seconds Cedar Beach Park afor~nen, specified. East a distance of 962.47 feet tioned; rumlln~ thence earth DATED: April 8, 1980 t~ the point or place of 62 degrees 07 minutes 20 BY ORDER OF THE beginning, said premises con- seconds west 220 feet to a SOUTHOLD TOWIq BOARD taining 5.207 acres according point; thence north 22 degrees JUDITHT. TERRY to survey of Otto W. Van Tuyl 07 minutes 40 seconds east Town C~erk dc1961Son, dated October 31, 28.25 feet; running thence IT, 4/17/80(186) north 66 degrees 52 minutes 20 seconds west 754.52 feet to the easterly side of Cedar Point Drive; runninB thanee alone the °"~*'"qV side of westerly corner of land, now 60 degrees 37 minutes 40 sec- or formerly of Parlamis, for- onds east 63.02 feet to a point; merly of Marsten, being the running th~nea along the arc southeasterly corner of the ola curve bearing to the right premises herein described; having a radius of 166.20 Ieeta from said point of beginning dis~nce of 121.09 feet; run- running along said northerly ning thence south 58 degrees lineoflheNorthRoadSouth53 46 minutes 50 seconds east degrees 24 minutes 30 seconds 181.42 feet to a monument; West a distance of 255.56 feet; running thence south 62 de- running thence along land now grees O7 minutes 30 seconds or formerly of Crystal on a east 205 feet to the ordinary line parallel to and 266 feet high water mark of Cedar westerly from the westerly Beach Harbor; thence south- line of said land of Parlamis erly and southeasterly along North 24 degrees 56 minutes 30 the ordinary high water mark seconds West a distance of of Cedar Beach Harbor 426 852 29 feet to ordinary high feet more or less to the north- water mark of Long Island erly line of lot No. 39 on Map of Sound; running thence along Cedar Beach Park aforemea- said high water mark of Long tioned; running thence north LEGAL NOTICE Island Sound North 32 degrees 62 degrees 07 minutes 20 sec- NOTICE OF IIF, ARING ON o9 minutes 30 seconds East a onds west 220 feet to a point: PROPfX.qAJ~?OAMIgND distance of 297.75 feet to said thence north 22 degrees O7 ZONING ORDINANCE land of Parlamis; thence minutes 40 seconds east 2~.25 Pursuant to 8eclinn 265 of along said land of Parlamis feet; running thence north 66 the T~,'n Law and requi~ South 24 degrees 56 minutes 30 degrees 52 minutes 20 seconds men' ' C'l~ptee 166 of the seconds East a distance of west 754.52 feet to the easterly Code-_ th~ Town of Southold, 962.47 feet to the point or place side of Cedar Point Drive; Suffolk County, New York, ., of beginning, said premises running thence along the east- public I~ will b~ held by containing 5.207 acres accord- erly side of Cedar Point Drive the T°wn B~i~l of the Town of lng to survey of Otto W. Van and along the easterly side of Southold at the 8oulhold Town Tuyl & Son, dated October 31, Cedar Beach Road north 23 HaH, Main ~ Southofd, 1961. degrees O7 minutes 40 seconds New York o~ [he 6th day ~ 8:30 o'clock P.M. By chang- east 322.11 feet to the corner May, 1~0, on the ~:" lng from "A" Residential and first above mentioned at the prop~ to ~ ~e ~ Agricultural District to "M-I" point or place of BEGINNING. l~ZameOrdi~mmce(fl~tdi~' General Multiple Residence Any person desiring to be theBuilding~Malm):~Om. District the property of Wayne heard on the above proposed Associates situntedat South- amendments should appear at C~unty, New York. -- .: old, in the Town of Southold, the time and place above so 8:l$o,cJa~p.M. By~,TM County of Suffolk, State of specified. II~ f~mn "A" R~ ncaa' New York, bounded and de- DATED: April 9, 19~0 Agricult~'ai Dtntrf~of to ."M-I" scribed as follows: BY ORDER OF C, el~'al M~dliple B,~ BEGINNING at the corner THE SOUTHOLD District the ~ og Maid- formed by the intersection of TOWN BOARD shm~ Development, Inc., sltu- the southerly side ol Orchard JUDITH T. TERRY ·,ted near ~, in the Lane (private) with the east- TOWN CLERK Town of Soulllm]d, ,~offnlk erly side of Cedar Beach 1TA17-3421 Com' New York, hounded Read; running thence along and ~ ~ril~la~ fiffio~: the southerly side of Orchard ~ BE61NNING at a monu- Lane south 66 degrees 52 meat on the northerly ~ of minutes 20 seconds east 451.63 the North Rtmd at the south- feet to a point; running thence - COUNT~ OF SUFFOLK, I STA~'E OF NEW YORK, ~ ss: ....... Jq~r~ .Gu~.v.~o~n .............. being duly Sworn. sa~s that . .~h~.. is Printer and Publisher of the SUFFOLK WEEKLY TIMES, a newspaper published at Greenpart, in said county~ and ~hat the notice, of which the annexed is ~ printed copy, has been published in the satd Suffolk Weekb/ Times once in each week, for ...... .o.n..e ................. weeks successively ~ommencing on the 17th day of .~.Alo~c. il ............ 19.80 ~ ........ ....... Sworn to before me th~s ../.7, .~.#.._ ~ day of .. ~-.~ ........ 19..~.g{.. ~ .......... ........ HELEN K DE VOE NOTARY PUBLIC Sla[e o! New York No 4707~7& Sullork Coun[,~ leFm E,ID~res March 30. 19~_.,/ STATE OF NEW YORK: SS: COUNTY O]i' SUFFOLK: JUDITI{ T. TERRY, To%~n Clerk of the To~;zn of Southold, New York, being duly s%.;orn, says that she is over the age of twenty-one years; that on the 9th day of April 8O ]9 she affixed a notice of which the annexed printed notice is a true copy, in a proper and subs.tantial manner, in a most public place in the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York, to wit:- Town Clerk Bulletin Board, Town Clerk Office Main Road, Southold, N.Y. 119'71 Notice of Public Hearing upon application of Haidstone Development, Inc. for a change of zone - 8:15 P.H.-H~}~ 6, 1980. ~" Judith T. Terry, Tg~n Clerk Sworn to before me this 9th day of Anvil 19 80 tary Public ELIZABEfH ANN ND/ILL~ NOTARY PURLIC. Sta~e al New Yoi'k No. 52-B[25850. SuClolk LEGAL .'~ . ~ ~, NOTICE OF HEARING ON PROPOSAL TO A~%E~TD 7ONINC- OPPTNz~NCE Pursuant to Section 265 of the Town Law and requirements of Chal>ter 100 of the Code of the 'Town of ,~outhold, °ue£elk County, New York, ~ublic hearings w~l! be held by the To,-n Eosrcl of the Town of Pouthold at the Southold Town Hall, Yain ~ottd, Youthold, New York on the 6th day of YaF, ~980, on the follou'inff .roposals ~o amend the Building. Zone Ordinance (includin~ t__~-e nu~ldin~ Zone Haps) of the Town of Ooutbold, Suffolk County, Y'tew York_ 8:15 o'clock P.I'~_ By chamt-inz from "~" qe:s~dontial and Agricu]tum~l District to "}'-l" qeneral Yul~tple We,~denee near Greenport, in the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, York, bouuded a~cl descrJb=d ns follows: BZGTFYF'rq at a menus-apt on the nm'the¥ly ~ine of the North Road at zhe southwesterly corner of land, nov' o': ~ormerly of Parlamis, formerly of "'arstoa. beinq the SOtltb~a:zter]v corner of the m'emises he~-pi~ c~scribed; fro.: y~afr~ }'oinh of l]eginninp running along said northerly line OF tile Xro"tl1 Road South 53 degrees 24 minutes 30. scconcls West $ r'~ [:~..tanc, e' of .,a5.5o feet; runnin% thence alone: land now or fo:-"-e~'ly Crystal or. a line t~araltel to and 250 feet t .... ~este. ,. fuom the westerly line of said ]ar, d of r~arlamis North 24 dec,roe:; 56 rain. Ecs~o0 seconds West a distance of~a~,~:~. 29 feet to ordinary. hi~'h water mark of Lon~ Island ~ound: rtmnin~ ~hence a]on~ said high water mark of Lonq Island Sound North ~2 de,trees 0q minutes 30 seconds East a distance of 297.75 feet to ~m~d land of P~rlamis; thence aloha said !and of Parlamis ?outh 24 dearees 5a minu~es 30 seconds East a distance of 982.4~ to the ?oint or place of beginning, said premises o *~ o,_ta~ nin~ 5.207 acre~ according ~o ~urvey of Otto ?~. Van ~u,-I e eon, datedl October 31, 1961. Page _9 _ Lei [ Notice 8:30 o'clock P_~'_ By changin~ from "A" Residential and Agricultural District to ".~J-l" General ~[ult~iple Residence District the property of Wayne Associates situated at ~outhold, in ~he Town of Southold, County of Suffolk, State of X[ew York, bounded and described as follows: BEGINX~IN~ at ~he corner formed by the inters~ection of the southerly side of Orchard Lane (private) with the easterly side of Cedar Beach Road; running thence along ~he southerTy side of Orchard Lane south 66 de~rees 52 minules 20 seconds east 451.6~ feet to a point; running thence 60 de~rees 37 minutes 40 seconds east 63.02 feet to a point: running thence alon~ the arc of curve bearing to ~he righ~ having a radius of 156.20 ~eet a distance of 121.0g feet; running thence sou~h 58 dezrees 46 minutes 50 seconds east 181.42 feet to a monument: runnin~ ~hence south 62 degrees 07 m~nutes B0 seconds east 205 feet the ordinary high water mark of Cedar Beach Harbor: thence southerly and southeasterly alone ~he ordinary high water mark of Cedar Beach Warbor 426 feet more or less to the ~or~herly line of lot No. 39 on ~ap of Cedar Beach Park aforementioned: running~ ~hence north 62 de~rees 07 minutes 20 seconds west 220 feet to a point; thence north 22 de~rees 07 ~]rm~tes 40 seconds east 28.25 feet; running thence north 66 degrees 52 minutes 20 seconds west 754.52 feet to the east~]y side of Cedar Poin~ Drive; runnin~ thence along the easter]~.- side of Cedar Point Drive and along the easterly side of Pedar l~each Road north 23 degrees 07 minutes 40 seconds east S22.]1 feet to the corner first above mentioned at the f~eint or nlace of BEGINNING. Any person desiring to be heard on the above Dro[~osed amendments should a~apear at the time and place above so s~ecif led. DATED: ADvil 8, 1980 Bv mPDFP OF T~F SOUTHOLD TO~t'~~ BOA~.D ,JUDITt7 T. TERPY T O I'[~N CLERK Pa~e 3 - Le~ · Notice ~ lo~] .~"-*' ~OE'"'~.,w~ ~'~rq AFFIDAVITS PLEASE PUBLISH ONCE, A°RIL 1., OF PI~LICATIO![ TO JUDITH T. ~'~v=., . , TO"IN ~T~-PW._ . , ~"'~',",I .... O~ SOUTFOL~ MAIN ROAD, SOUTHOLr~. ~i' YORK_ Copies to lhe following on ~-prJl 9, 1939 The Suffolk Times The Lena Island ?rave]e~--':atchman, Inc. Town Clerk ~ulletin Board Town Poard Uemb, e~s Abigail A. Wickham, a/c Ys~datone Development, !nc. John E. Ci}l~.es, a/c ~rsyne Associates COUNTY OF SUFFOLK RECEIVED Q APR 4 1980 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING To~m ~i~rk ~01~01~ LEE E. KOPPELMAN DIRECTOR OF PLANNING April 3, 1980 Ms. Judith T. Terry, Town Clerk Town of Southold Main Road Sou~old, New York 11971 Re: Application of "Maidstone Development, Inc.:' (Case No. 244) for a change of zone from "A" Agricultural and Residential to "M-l" General Multiple-Residence, Town of Southold (SD-80-2). Dear Ms. Terry: Pursuant to the requirements of Sections 1323 to 1332 of the Suffolk County Charter, the Suffolk County Planning Commission on April 2, 1980 reviewed the above captioned application and after due study and deliberation Resolved to disapprove it because of the following: 1. It is inconsistent with the Town of Southold Development Plan which designates this area for agricultural-single family residence develop- ment; 2. It is inconsistent with the pattern of zoning in the surrounding area and therefore must be considered as "spot zoning"; 3. It would tend to establish a precedent for further downzonings in the locale along Middle Road (C.R. 27); and 4. There appears to be ample land available for multi-residence purposes in the surrounding area. Very truly yours, Lee E. Koppelman Director of Planning Gerald G. Newman GGN:jk Chief Planner OFFICE OFr' T~' m, rN ,., C'LER K T.O¥~N O~ SOUTFIOED JUDITH T. TERRY SUFFOLK :COUNTY TELEPHONE TOWel CLERK '.t- "4 4 (516) 765-1801 Southold, L. 1., N. Y. I 1971 March 6, 1980 Suffolk County Planning Commission H. Led Dennison Executive office Building Veterans Highway Hauppauge, New York 11787 Gentlemen: Pursuant to Sections 1323 to 1332 of the S'~ffolk County Charter the Town Board of the Town of SouLhold hereby refers the following proposed zoning action to you. Amendment of Zoning Map Location of affected land: On the shore of Long Island Sound on the north side of County Route 27, near the Village of Greenport, Greenport, New York. Suffolk County Tax Map No.: District 1000, Section 040, Block 1, Parcel 20. WiLhin 500 feet of property of the Village of Greenport, within 500 feet of County Route 27, within 500 feet of Long Island Sound. Enclosed is recommendation of the Southold Town Planning Board, and correspondence from the N.Y.S. Department of Environmental Conservation. Very truly yours, Judith T. Terry Town Clerk Enclosures P ~R D $outhold, N_Y. 11971 HENRY E RAY[':OR, Jr., Chairman TELEPHONE FREDERICK E. GORDON 765- 19~ JAMES WALL BENNETT ORLOWSKI. Jr, GEORGE RITCHIE LATHAM, Jr. ~C~ ~ ~ 1980 Supervisor William R. Pell III Town Hall Southold, New York 11971 Dear Supervisor Pell: The following action was taken by the Southold To;rn Planning Board at a regular meeting held February 25, :[980. RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board denial', of the application o£ Maidstone Development, ][no..for a change o£ zone from A Residential to'M-1 General Eultiple for property located a~ Greenport for the following reasons: t. The Board considers this womld be spot zoning. 2. It would set a preoeden~ J_n the area for further down- zoning of property. Yours truly, HENRY E. RAYNOR,. JR., CHAIRM~J~ sOUTHOLD TO~ PLANNING BOARD By Muu~iel Tolman, Secretary Copy to Deputy Supervisor'Johnso~ Councilmen Dr[nm, NicRles~ Murdock, Sullivan IRVING L. PRICE, JR. February 6, 1980 Town Board Town of Southold Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Re: Maidstone application Gentlemen: Please be advised that this office represents Mr. Bert Crystal who is an adjoining land owner to property for which an adjoining land owner to property for which an application has been made for a change in zone. I would appreciate it if you would notify this office of any meetings or hearings pertaining to the application of Maidstone for a change in zone from A-Residential-Agriculture District to M-1 General Multiple Residence District. This request is not to be considered a statement of approval or support for the application nor is it to be construed as an objection to the application at this time. The request for notification is made because of Mr. Crystal's immediate and present concern for the protection of his property. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact this office. Very truly yours, IRVING L. PRICE, JR. [:.'... _~.. T ~. ~j T.3. <-~ Lit',. ~~.___ William H. Price, Jr. cc: Planning Board, Town of Southold ~ TOWN OF SOUTHOLD TOWN OF JUD[TH Y. TERRY SUFFOLK (~OUNTY ~ELEPItONE ]OWN CLERK ~516) 765-1801 [~JeG[STRAR OF VIYAL SYAT[ST[CS Sottthold, L. l., N. Y. l [971 NEGATIVE DECLARATION NOTICE OF NO SIGNIFICANT EFFECT ON THE ENVIRONMENT Dated: February 5, 1980 Pursuant to Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law State Environmental Quality Review and 6NYCRR Part 617, Section 617.10 and Chapter 44 of the Code of the Town of Southold, notice is hereby given that the Southold Town Board, as load agency for the action described below, has determined that the project will not have a significant effect on the environment. DESCRIPTION OF ACTION Application of Maidstone Development, Inc. for a change of zone from "A" Residential and Agricultural District to "M-i" General Multiple Residence District on certain property at North Road, Greenport, New York. The project has been determined not to have a significant effect on the environment for the following reason: An environmental assessment has been submitted which indicated that no significant adverse effects to the environment are likely to occur should the project be implemented as planned. The New York State DeparEment of Environmental Conserva- tion indicates that no permit is required under Article 25 (Tidal Wetlands) of the Environmental Conservation Law. Further information can be obtained by contacting Mrs. Judith T. Terry, Town Clerk, Town of Southold, Main Road, Town Hall, Southold, New York 11971. Copies to: Wickham, Wickham & Bressler, P.C., a/c Maidstone Development Inc. Commissioner Robert F. Flacke, DEC, Albany Roy L. Haje, DEC, Stony Brook Building Depaztment, Town of Southold Town Clerk Bulletin Board RECEIVED WICKHAM, WICKHAM NEW ¥0~ 119S~ January 31, 1980 Office of Town Clerk Town Hall Main Road Southold, N.Y. 11971 Attention: Judith T. Terry Re: Maidstone Development, Inc. Dear Judy: Enclosed is a copy of a letter received from the Department of Environmental Conservation indicating that no permit is required in connection with this application. Sincerely yours, ~ga~ ~. W~ckham ~W: ab Enclosure ( (. RECEIVED Bldg. -50, ~ - P~ 219 S~ B~k, ~,~ York ~794 (516) 751-7900 ~sio~ January 22, 1980 Joseph C. M~rtirano For: Maidstone Developmemt Inc. 45 Woodland Road Miller Place, New York 11764 t~: TW 15273-0109 Construction of 24 condominium units between Long Island Sound and Middle Road on a 5.2~ acre lot roughly 200' to the west o£ Village of Greenport, Southold Dear Mr.Martirano, As a result of your inqn~iry concerning the abov~ r~feren~, parcel, this De~ ~nt has oonduc~d an_ on-site in~pection. ~,~ have fo,md the parcel or (project) ~o be above 10' in elevation. Therefore, pursuant to Par+- 651, Official Compilation of Codes, _Rules and P~p~lm~iop~ of the Sta~ of Iq~ York~ Section 66104(b) ~ r~ permit under ,~-~mle '25 (Tidal [~tlands) of the En~m~ntal Conserv~tic~ L~ is requix~- Very truly !~urs, P~gional Permit Adminis~b~r Rc<r_~a ~, B.~fairs Stony Br~k, Nc~s York ~794 (516) 751-7900 Counis s ioner January 22, 1980 Joseph C. Martirano For: Maidstone Development Inc. 45 Woodland Road Miller Place, New York 11764 TW 15273-0109 Construction of 24 condominium units between Long Island Ssund and Hiddle Road on a 5.2~= acre lot roughly 200' to the w~st of Vii~la~ ~f Greenpor t, Southold Hr. Har~irano, ~ a res,~t of ~ ~d~, ~nc~g ~a ~ ~fercm~i oar~]., -this ~t. h~ ~nduc~ ~_ on-site ~on._ ~.h ~na~._-~ found ~x~-' ~ p~rcel or (p~je~) ~ ~ above 10' in elevation. therefore, '/pursuant to Pa~t 651~ Official Cc~,.-~ilation of Codes, r~.nles anJ P~_tions of ~%~'~ S~te of I-i~ York~ S~tion 661~4(b) ~ ro N~t' ~c..~z- ' .... .~]~le 25 (Tidal ~'.le~) of 'd%e ~'~n~]_ ~nse~a'~on I~.~, is r~r~ RECEIVED ~PR ~ ~ ~1980 -. __.,,, I 1 1}/ .......... January 14, [980 Mr. William Pel], Supervisor Town of Southold Main Road Southold, Long island, N.Y. Dear Mr. Pell: I received the attached notification upon my return from vacation. After speaking with my attorney Frederick J. Tedeschi, he suggested that I write you directly with regard to this matter. We own a home at 290 North Road adjoining the property referred to in the attached notification. We are of course, quite concerned with this new development since we have invested a substantial amount of money in our home.and wish to protect it in its original state. We specifically refer to the fact that the entire area has natural forestry enabling us and our neighbors to have privacy from the main road. We would strongly oppose any change that would disturb this environment. We also have a major concern regarding the bank which we ourselves did not distrub so as to insure no further erosion. I realize that the matter will be discussed fully with the conservation department but never-the-less I consider it a concern since my home is substantially closer to the cliff than we would expect the new developer would be permitted to build near. Please recognize that we are not looking to obstruct any reasonable development on this adjoining property as long as we are not adversely affected and that we maintain a natural barrier. File ~ TOW~ OF ~ I understand that this matter will be granted a public hearing which I would like to attend. If there is any further information, please do not. hesitate to call me at my New York Office. Thanking you in advance for your cooperation, I remain Sincerely yours,~,~ Bert Crystal'----- BClm : ...... ;."'¥' o'l TOWN.?;Q._A?.D~_TOWN OF SOU FHOLD In tile Matter of the Petition of : : NOTICE change of zone : to tile Towo l;oard of 1he Town of Southold. : TO: Bert & Marilyn Crystal 114 East 72nd Street New York, N.Y. 10022 YOU ARE ItEREBY GIVEN NOTICE: '1_ Ti]at it is the intention of the undersigned to petition the Town Board of the Town of Southold to request a change of zone. 2. That the property which is the subject of the Petition is located adjacent to your property and is des- cribed as follows: North Side of North Road (County Road 27), Greenport, Town os Southold-~New York, bounded on the South by North Road, on the East by-P~q~ocy, on the Nortl_] by Long Island Sound, and on the West by Crystal an¥-Pringle containing approximately 5.2 acres. 3. ~hat the property which is the subject of SLIch Petition is located ill the following zoning district: A - Aqricultural and Residential 4. Ti]at by such Petition, the Lmdersigned will request dmt the above-described property be placed in the following zone district classification: . M-1 - General Multiple Residence. 5. That within five days from the date hereof, a writzeo Pe£itioo requesting the relief specified above be filed in the Soutt~old Town Clerk's Office at Main Road, Southold, New York and you may then mid there examine the same during reDdar office hours. 6. -Fl',ac before the relief sought may be granted, a public hearing inust be held on the n3atter by the Town Bo..'d; that a notice of such hearing must be published at least ten days prior to tl~e date of such hearing in fi~e Suff'olk Times and in the Long island Traveler-Matdtuck Watchman, .ewspaper5 published in the Town of Soutlmld and designated for the publican;on of such notices; tha~ you or y~ur representative have the right to ap- pear and be heard at such hearing. Dated:. Decer~er 18, 1979 NAIDSTONE DG%~LOPi,~NT, INC. n-- · ~f~ail'A. ~ickh~m Attorney WICKH~], WYCK[{~ & B~SSLER, P.C. Post Office Address: 4953 Nesconset Nighway Port Jefferson Station, New York 11776 TOWN OF sOUTHOLD NEL~ YO~Ri[ ST~.TE DEPAP. TI~i,~T OF ENVIRONI~Z. ITD£ COI~SERVATION razOR. 40, SUllY - Room 21~ S~ony Brook, New York 11794 (516) 751-7900 D~emnbar 31, 1979 ~,9~3 Ne~oun~t ~e~ of b~ ~ ord~e, T~ of Dear ~. On the basis of the info.orion premented in the above-referenced Pe~i~l~ i~ appears that a petit will be required from the New York State Department of Environmental Conservatiom Law, Article 25, for the work proposed therein. I have enclosed an application form (directio~ on back), a ~ionnaire and an Environmen~al Assessment Form for preparation of ~ pe- tition for pe~i~. regy D~IEL J. Local Tidal ~etlandm Permit Administrator ce~ T~ of 9on. Id T~ ~uEk' a ~u~ld, a~ York 11971 File O~F~c~ o~,' TO~¥N OE SoIYrltOLD ~ . /.--~,, JUDITH ~1. TERRY ~S UFFOLK~(~OU~qT, y TELEPHONE Southold, L 1., N. Y. 11971 December 19, 1979 Mr. Roy Haje Environmental Analysis Unit Building 40, SUNY - Room 219 Stony Brook, New York 11794 Dear Mr. Haje: Enclosed find completed short Environmental Assessment Form, application, and copy of map of proposed change of zone by Maidstone Development, Inc. This project is unlisted; other agencies may be involved but the optional coordinated procedures for designating lead agency and determining significance will not be followed. The Southold Town Board wishes lead agency status. (SEQRA) May we have your views on this matter. Written comments on this project will be received at this office until January 7, 1980. We shall interpret lack of response to mean there is no objection by your agency. Very truly yours, Judith T. Terry Town Clerk Enclosures cc: Southold Town Building Department OFFICE O F:~ IO?,¥N~ ~ LER K TDWN OF, SOUTHOLD JUDITH T. TERRY SUFFOLK.COUNT~' TELEPHONE Southold, L. I., N.Y. 11971 December 19, 1979 Southold Town Planning Board Southold, New York 11971 Gentlemon: Transmitted herewith is petition of Maidstone Development, Inc. requesting a change of zone from "A" Residential and Agricultural District to "M-i" General Multiple Residence District. You are hereby instructed to prepare an official report defining the conditions described in said petition and determine the area so affected with your recommendations. Very truly yours, Judith T. Terry Town Clerk Enclosures (5) OFFICE OF/i. OWN~L:EERK TO~ ~Ea~ '~-~-~ :' ,~ ,' ,~' (~16) 76~-1801 REGISrRA~ OF VITAL StATiSTiCS ~'~ .._/~.~' Southold, L. I., N. Y. 1197[ Dece~e~ 13~ ~979 To Whom I~ May Concern: A~ached hereto is Environmental Assessmen~ Form completed by Maids,one Development, Inc. in connection with their pe~i~ion no. 244 for a change of zone from "A" Residential and Agricultural District to "M-i" General Multiple Residence Distric~ on certain prope=~y 8~ No=~h Road, G=eenpo=~, New Yo=k. ~Judith T. Terry~ Town Clerk Posted on Town Clerk Bulletin Board - 12/13/79 RECEIVED .......... l J~3 ! ~½ J979 WICH:HAM, WICKHAM & BRESSLER, ~'.c. December 18, 1979 office of To~n Clerk Town Hall Main Road Southold, N.Y. 11971 Attention: Judith T. Terry Re: Maidstone Development, Inc. Petition for change of zone Dear Judy: Enclosed is notice in connection with the above application, together with proof of mailing. I am quite embarrassed that in the process of getting this application filed, I forgot one of the most important elements. Thank you for your cooperation. Since~r?~y ypurs, ~: ab O~FI'C~ OF7 TO,WN OF. SOUTHOLD JUDITH t. IE~Y '~UFFOLK~ ~OU~Y ~LEP~ONE To~ ~RK ~d"_-'.~' '~l I' ~1~r (516) 765-180l ~GIS~R OF VITAL S~ATISTICS ~'~J'~ Southold, L 1., N.Y. 11971 December 13, 1979 Ms. Abigail A. Wickham Wickham, Wickham & Bressler, P.C. blain Road, P. O. Box 1424 Mattituck, New York 11952 Dear Ms. Wickham: I am in receipt of the application of Maidstone Development, Inc. for a change of zone. In accordance with the Code of the Town of Southold each adjoining property owner must be notified of the petition. I am enclosing the necessary forms and request that one copy be filed with me as soon as possible so I may proceed with processing the application. Very truly yours, Judith T. Terry Town Clerk Enclosures WICKHAM, WICMHAM & BRESSLEI~, ~.c. [~L~ 1 ~ NEW YORK 11~5~ ~l~ ~ ~ December 12, 1979 Town Clerk Town of Southold Town Hall Main Road Southold, New York 11971 Re: Maidstone Development, Inc. Petition for chan~e of zone Dear Madam: In connection with the above, my client's application for a change of zone, I enclose the following: 1. Six (6) copies of the proposed application, together with letter of consent from the owner of the property. 2. Six (6) copies of survey. 3. Short Environmental Assessment Form. 4. Six (6) copies of portion of Southold Town Zoning Map showing zoning classification of surrounding property and subject premises. 5. Check enclosed in the amount of $100.00, for filing petition. Please forward the papers to the Town Board to schedule a hearing date. Sincerely yours, Abigai~ A. Wickha~ AAW: ab Enclosures TOWN BOARD, TOWN OFSOUTHOLD In the Matter of the Petition of : NOTICE Change of Zone to the Town Board ofthe Town of Southold_ : TO: Mr. Richard Petrocy North Road Southold, N.Y. 11971 Bert & Marilyn Crystal 114 East 72nd Street New York, N.Y. 10022 Mr. & Mrs. Bruce Pringle North Road Greenport, N.Y. 11944 YOU ARE HEREBY GIVEN NOTICE: 1. That it is the intention of the undersigned to petition the Town Board of the Town of Southold to request a change of zone. 2 That the property which is the subject of the Petition is located adiacent to your property and is des- cribed as foUows: North Side of North Road (County Road 27), Greenport, Town of Southold, New York, bounded on the South by North Road, on the East by Petrocy, on the North by Long Island Sound, and on the West by Crystal and Pringle containing approximately 5.2 acres. 3. That the property which is the subject of such Petition is located in the following zoning district: A - Aqricultural and Residential 4. That by such Petition, the undersigned will request that the above-described property be placed in the following zone district classification: M-1 - General MultLple Res±dence. $. That within f~ve days from the date hereof, a written Petition requesting the relief specified above will be filed in the Southold Town Clerk's Office at Main Road, Southold, New York and you may then and there examine the same during regular office hours. 6. That before the relief sought may be granted, a public hearing must be held on the matter by the Town Board; that a notice of such hearing must be published at least ten days prior to the date of such hearing in the Suffolk Times and in the Long Island Traveler-Mattituck Watchman, newspapers published in the Town of Southold and designated for the publication of such notices; that you or your representative have the right to ap- pear and be heard at such hearing_ Dated: December 18, 1979 MAIDSTONE DEVELOPMENT, INC. bv p t'e' er ~bigail A. Wickham, Att y ed~l°nerfwIC~{AM, WICFJ{AM & BRESSLER, P.C. Post Office Address: 4953 Nesconset Highway Port Jefferson Station, New York 11776 PROOF OF MAILING OF NOTICE ADDRESS NAME No. zi31443 No. No. 43! RECEIPT FOR CERTIFIED MAIL RECEIPT FOR CERTIFIED MAIL RECEIPT FOR CERTIFIED MAIL NO INSURANCE COVERAGE PROVIDED- NO INSURANCE COVERAGE PROVID[O-- IlO INOURANCE COVERAGE PROVeD-- GOT FOR INTERNA'nONAL MAIL NOT FOR IffTERNA110NAL MAIL NOT FOR INTERNATIONAL MAIL (See Reverse) (See Reverse) (See Reverse) ~[,F . -- STREET AN6.NO ' - .~ ~'' ~ STREET AND NO ~/X~?~ ~ ' P O STATE AND Z'@ CODE p O~TA i'E AND ZiP C O.[~ E ~ P STATE AND ZIP CODE POSTAGE $ , / ~ FOSTAG~ $ i/~~'~ POSTAGE 1~ LU SPECIAL DELIVERY ¢ ~. SPECIAL DELIVERy ¢ t~ SPECIAL DELIVERy ~ POSTMARKORD&~:-~- ~ g POSTM*RK OR DATE ~ 'O"TMAnKORDATE STATE OF NEW YORK : COUNTY OF SUFFOLK: ss.: Alice Burgon , residing at Meeting House Creek Road Aquebogue, New York , being duly sworn, deposes and says that on the 18th day of December , 19 79 ., deponent mailed a true copy of the Notice set forth on the reverse side hereof, directed to each of the above-named persons at the addresses set opposite their respective names; that the addresses set opposite the names of said persons are the addresses of said persons as shown on the cur- rent assessment roll of the Town of SouthoJd; that said Notices were mailed at the United States Post Office at Mattituck, New York ; that said Notices were mailed to each of said persons by (certified) ~ mail_ Alice Bur~ Sworn to me this 18th day of December , 19 79 Notary Public BOROTHY HENDERSON -e * ,Ile, y' �/N326,49217 5 22 9 Expst,rlol 55A 5.SA J 3zszssae /' 1 E2146,923 rx '•� r 'ItJ2s,eso 3J O 1 SUFFOLK COUNTY 4 r U+ E2!46,54600 6.IAIc1 21.7A Cc I \ r �e 1 VILLAGE "L� mW 11\\0' 1o.aA(tl \\00 SEE SEC NO 130 OF x VV? \;\ 3\:�Q i m GREENPDRT N 425!0566` / 0 1 7 ° SUFFOLK 7,4A(t) j COUNTY ; x 325,x11 po ao.. •, '•J °. E 2!46.411.99r � ryyi \A _IIL P a , II Q 23 24 1 i4 z4 15.3A(c) 1. \ ��9 9A(c) ✓yea \� / ;O 1 x J23,o5]24 "K♦'d � fQ, a E2,44G,»651 ° °' 4 y' B •.g° N 324,Bn as ,, • Ez.44gs1e se ' 21 a LIA(c) yG,4jrn '! Tv N�M1�O 2.6A([1•• •:�� "°3.2 x 324,710 ae .TAI.) E2,446,291 60 6 1.9A1c1 ♦ 52A(c) '� b"v r •v •° I6 is - 1.3A(cl as 4 } O 14 x ' 2 5 1 72Alcl 23.5A(cl .6A1c1 4 2.3Mc1 t 4P .6 x IA(C N 323,569]e ,r, �♦ E 3,443,257 B6 H°3]00 E l i3]! pa ]23,9460 r1 A N 423,591 B0 4 � L2A([ L i.IAI[) E x G45,24 361- �E 2,44],49 7.54 6 ' • S 12A1[) +` n 32],4-615 [ NA w NO2-51' 0"E i IAIcO °° - 'w�Et H4,]5911 - IL 11.9!mo E y i n TOWN OF SOUTHOLD �S I •[ ,IAltl • 5 4, _ / iol6 x 323,32o 0c E 2,446,Sfi9 50 1 f° 3.IAIc1 ° °4 VPa' ,r5x3,3]701 x - - 'am e3 g . t Nz!sLAG ,zoto6 VILE OF GREENPDRT rv323_!O-L If- \O ___ _�_ i • 32 O n _ N 323,x0205 .31 J\ FOO PARCEL N. + 11E241apaJ 25 1 YLE55 OX4WN OTHEPW aEW 41L �Pn OGEx TIEfi 4 O� "b1 323,14244124 A! � °' - 14E Wllxin Tuv c� n - - •' a �TIJ'.fif605 1.44],631.'6 (O EE sEC 24004 )I �7 P E 2!M!3e 22� B5 33 57 N 277.30 3x1641.92 2 447.31] 90 1+ 91 5937 X 337 19 S }� -J 4jO' -01-001 0 �Rj ••� 9. 513 W 43 E VVe.00 .22206 e5 2447 440.72 1 r 2479 02'30 M 2317V w `O Ql ' -_ 10. Spy VV 47 W 629.66 321,947.20 2 446.5BB.7V p FOR PARCEL 240. SEE SEC N0.040- 322,10612 -03-001 x14439757 O i FD. 31 L.D ^)• `'° A ,��'r 7 4. , E'er a,. to 2p.T]971 �3e F g Q' r f 13 ���EEE SH,e65 T3 \ 'N 3x2,672 � 31 �/ I " ' E 2,115,293 19 \ 1 X ,Q y. O \II 1\ A 0 \ \ Ips `lr E 2,444,33597 - \ I A WA` 4 5.1,L AW 3 9 7 00 01(l LTAIw ' 2 7.1 A(a1 ? ___177_ .� .gyp ✓� -r N 321,601 63NS3J f J y I!�4(C iy1 g 4SJOe E x.445,199.60 ei'], °0wW f T M /' 6 ep - pr"' X' �•f'i?'v ,r ° - L - g4 is 'sua,' fir• ✓,7 v r "' '�" � s° � � µl Aw: � � .r �` � rl 1 ✓, 4 !" b Nf 1i4.rr� r M.\' Q 9 a I {y5`#sTBd 1` ' W r'"�t 'pv^ �..�..•.r`"F „1q, C''•z� r.ry .r"'` 'r�✓,.r" t p v'1'S2",`4 »^ 1� _ �� ma^ rG 1� j "y �.3( +Y^' J �H✓"X b m Y1xfsr i ✓.»+ >wf /n _ rut \ /�� r 'P'h'il' .r 'rtiva f r . }"> f / p •Q \\ a t 'r •,4 � 154- o '� \�R/� i M m`JNf"J.� ^"''`�y°JE'�" 9 r"_ � eK F ��g74f IL S CT- .44 �JA Y' - A I 5 i+S!Yr. Ali , r'� • , .'1` 3Y' As R, V�°`A a"F';4 YrP- A(`v«�%°�.;;�;,, ,�d�r '`r n r �u>�� ren, �,�I�i b'I T/' r ,f�}'*d'f°'�r�,`t�' ,+ ..�,�'✓' ' 1 Prt r . � r I �� lrxs�� � •/' 13 J �Y'ar' F 1 '� ✓r��X � .a. } d:a V yaj T r �p •� X • •y� 3�� r 1 t y P"i4z » a ffi QpprmL, loca jon tP vke+ e .ii' f 1� b r�r✓ T r "'� ��7 ,a" ' .J� zd 31' , z � Ot ¢IFIuil13 Sln e. J'� yI uv l4 �5e f _. ^ 1 r ,may �+/I ! - ^' ♦p O SGmll4� Ves2cleNCes w iY, wl' �1' ! f� d t� a{6 dr •'' ' 3/ 4< /.. -' 10 1 +d /'N �B �„irr �j 1 FOR PARCEL NO 6.I Alcl m ISj ';, `'e,,, > ! , r�N i^ ✓ + i ,fi.�{y� d. 4 i, : 4B i. ( / f g' py ! Y /�� Y ; 7 1 h•'fi SEE SEC 40.044 Afr"r6 f 1 .3 t%oa-ooz ; ! •r'"v``' ww,b7 �a4 ' [ r 1r`r ,,r ^ tY alf `' 4y / �„ feu '�9' ✓t Oq ✓ � f rra:f Y� N ryr� ' �• u • � a",,,1� � '�J �' rPin T 5 LILCO B M fjry o Tb 3 3 K 15.4 A I e) Q 8.5 A ) r ; rfII�my4 / Y 4 M 1 �Coy-/ { k 1 / � I I js it E m I pea I es Q. I I ''I W I - 1 - O G. 5-53 I M I PDl-E (, .ZoN6 h A I .,B.,ZONrs , ti A A ,�u H I I A —& 'v .,. -. - , vlounoNo � _ f�/�Ayw� µf.., Cyt y.. SEcnov>$pA W Y F oil ! na r �'� "7'b�(M,'i-/ � mRP4A/AF iN15 jpxVFY MAP NOi LfAA1N0 6 4 Np tV}'EYUh$INI p lER OR may. EM1I,1055Ep SM5 HgIE,NJi OECON50f9f0 AOp4[I IIPCOPY { � �IyI GVAPA Etr "1}"+ 'coMrngrr Y'w nw:A f9'Da ' � ' Y � S �4 C � tANbIIUG INSiHtnlOFl ll6inlA tAU'"�'� ' s � 'S �: s A�e�iAR�� � Pa rXf ASfIGFEps w rrcr V.'�9J Al,p - t 0 ADD_eu�MNrEes fq�i4 M'Apg^ u irnNRR rvsnruEvc>ols;gA�I ", fl, ' KMA !FS" t ;���' �cr�f � i• a k�,k +. � � ' ., - ,-1 - t..��`an�d' G.dr/d�,+. .: l - �L"csn, ;y