HomeMy WebLinkAboutMolin,Thomas & Oscar Amend #27 WHEREAS, a petition was heretofore filed with the Town Board of the
Town of Southold by ....... ..~...~...~....O..~..~...~...O..~...~..~. ........................
requesting a change, modification and amendment of the Building Zone
Ordinance including the Building Zone .Maps made a part thereof by chang-
ing from .......... , ...... .~...~..~..~D..~...~.... ~....~....~...~.~~ ...................
"1,1" 14U~?ZPI~ R~SZDEI~C~
District to ......................................................................................................
District the property described in said petition, and
WHEREAS said petition was duly referred to the P'ianning Board for its
investigation, recommendation and report, and its report having been filed
with the Town Board, and thereafter, a public hearing in relation to said
petition having been duly held by the Town Board on the ...... ,~ ........... day
of ................. ...1~...¥. ....................... 195..~.., and due deliberation having been
had thereon
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the relief demanded in said
petition be, and it hereby is ~Z'~:lf,~.
SOUthOLD TOWN CLERK'S OFFICE
RALPH P. BOOTH~ CLERK
REGISTRAR OF VITAL STATISTICS
SOUTHOLD, N. Y.
STATE OF HK~ YORK:
SS:
COUBTr OF SUFFOLK:
mm, deposes emi says that he mides at
Sout~ld, in the Touu of Southold, Cmmt7 of
Suf~lk, and Sr. af~ o£ Hew York; ttmt be b the
Touu Clerk of the Touu of Sou~hold; that on tim
__~_ .... day of .~ ................... ~a¥__~_. ..... . 1959, ho poated
a copy o f~ the BOTX~ OF ~ OF ZOIll~
NO, ..~ ~_? . , & copy. of which 'ia anoe~ed bet~.to
the a t~nl:a~rd eainCatned by hf~n puxlnumC
Ot~£1ce at Soutbold, ~ ~o~; that. auch poaC~
by )tn vas done pursuant to the erov~~ o£
the Teen Lee and purauant to the ~eolution
o£ the Smathold Toun ~oard.
,(L.S.)
~tea' ": lm~bllc .h~~- held,
'~t~ua~trto the r~~~
law, ~e Bull~ ~ne ~~-~e~
(~u~ ~ B~ld~g Zone~
,:~p) ~ ~ T~n of ~u~old,,.
Suffo~ ~'ty, N~
~end~ at a reg~r meet~ of~
~ ~uth~ld ~wn ~ard held on~
May 5, 1~9., ~
By c~~ng ~m '"A" ~den'~
~ and ~~tur~ D~lct to'
"M" ~ul~ ~Mence ~tr~t ~e
fo~ow~ d~~d pr~y:
~ ~at ~r~ t~ct or ~r-
~1 of l~d ~lt~ ~. G~een-~
~rt, ~. ~e Town of ~u~old,'
~~y of ~fol, k, ~d
~ew York, ~d more ~~rly~
~d~ ~d d~r~d ~ fol-'
19ws:
B~n~ at a ~t on ~e
no~er~ ~ne ~ N~h ~d at
now o~ f~rly of ~~on;,
r~ al~ ~d l~d.n~ or
go~erly of ~on No~
~t ~re or l~ ~ ~e wa~rs
~ ~n8 ~d ~d; ~ce
~~ a~ ~e ~ore of ~ng
~d ~d ~ f~t .~ or
1~ ~ ~d ~w or forum of
D. H. Horn; ~~ ~ng ~nd
· l~t ~n~on~ ~th ~ f~t
~ or le~'~ ~e 'n'~~l~ l~e
~~rly l~e of No~ ~d
W~t 320 f~t more or
~lnt ~ p~ of'_~~~.
~n~ ~ut
. . more or 1~.
~ BY~~~
STATE OF NEW YORK, 1
~ ss'
.c~.. .... ...~..'-~-~ .... ~~ ............ being duly ~worn,
says that .....~/~~ ....... is Printer and Publisher of the ~T~-'~"OLK
TIMES, a newspaper published at Greenpo~, in said county;
and that the notice, of which the annexed is a prated copy,
has been published ~ the s~d Suffo~ Times once in each
week, for ............................................................ ~~ .......................... week~
the ......... .............
SUCCeSSIVely
d.y of .............. ............ [ ........ ......
Sworn to before me this ......
.'~ .............. 1~.~.., j
day
of
CORNELIA C. KEOGH
NOTARY PU~3LIC, St.~te of New Yo~k
N~. 2.. 9 890
Qualified in Suffolk CountY
Term Expires March 30, 1961,
CORNELIA C. KEOGH
I407ARY PUBLIC, State of NeW York
No. 62.2093890
Qualified in Suffolk County
Term Expires March 30, 1961-
.thene~ along
oil ~ ~ Sound
".': m~e or l~'to 1,and
of D,' H..H~-
.~ :R~d; 'Lth~]~lC~ ~' the
.noKim~v, nne-of. NOrth'. Road
· !~t ~Q.i~ more ~r 1~ ~_ ~e
~. '~u~ 3.1~ ~res
~y ~. d~~ ~ ~heard
.~~.
· ..~~: .~. ~4, ~ ' ~ .
· . ~ ~~::~ ~.'.'~., '.-~
. .
STATE OF NEW YORK,
~ ss'
COUNTY OF SUFFOLK, j
*'~'~.-.....;. '-
..... .... :~:~..::.,~.:.~..:.,C,~.~£,:, .... ~',~:~..:::.!:.~.~:,.:~..~.:~ ................. being duly
Sworn,
says that .....~.(J:: ......... is Printer and Publisher of the SLrFFOLK
TIMES, a newspaper published at Greenport, in said county;
and that the notice, of which the annexed is a printed copy,
has been published in the said Suffolk Times once in each
week, for ......................................................... .~.:.;r.!~:.,.).~::. ............................ weel~
..............
successively commencing on the ', ._L,_~ ',-~M ...............................
Sworn to before me this
............ _. ...............
Ii
NOTICE OF ADOPT ION OF
.BUILDING ZO~ O~..~INANCE
NC~' ICM t$ H~iIEBY .GI~N that after a public hearing 'held
pursuant ~ the requlrem~,nts of law~ the Building Zone Ordinance
,.
(including the Building Zone Maps) of the To~n of ~ou~hold., Suffolk
County, New York was duly amended at a regular, meeting of the
~ou~hold Town Board held on May 5, 19%9, as follows:
'By changing' from "A" Res~ential
to -M" ~tltiple Residence
;.
! propertr~
Dated]
District the
and Agricult~al District
following described
Ail that ee'rtatn tract or parcel of
lan~ ~ituate near Greenpo~t, in the Town
of Southold, C~unty of Suffolk, and 8tare
of New ~ork, and more -par'ticularly bounded
ami described as follows:
Begi~tng at a point on the northerly
line of' North Road at the southeasterly
co.er of lard now or for~rly of Shmmont
from s~aid point of Beginning runn~ along
said lan~ now or formerly of Shannon North
570 .feet mere or les~ to the water~ of .Lon~
Islan~ 8o~~ t, henoe e~~rly ~long the ~ore
of l.o.n~ Island Sound 200 feet more .or less to
land now or formerly of D. H. ~orton$ thence
~on~la~ 1.a~t ~ntio~d South t.69 f~t raore
t4a*n~ ~long th~ no~'th~rl¥ !in~ of ~o~t,h Ro~
W~~ 3~0 f~t ~or~ or 1~~ t,,o ~ lx~int or
pla,e of beginning. Containing about 3.105
l~y 5, 1959
.BY' ORDER OF THE $OUTND~ TOWN BOARD
-RALPH P. BOOTH
TOWN CLE~
BOARD OF TRUSTEES
Tn'"'"~? OF
.~,'~'-,~ ~. S OUTHOLD
Green~,ort, . .
May
Pres ent :
NOP~'!AN E. KLIPP, Supervisor
CLARK, Justice of the Peace
RALPH TUTHILL, Justice of the Peace
LOUIS D!~MAREST, Justice of the Peace
LESTER ALBERTSON, Councilman
RALPH P. BOOTH, Towm Clerk
ROBERT TASKER, Town Attorney
APPLICATION OF THOMAS MOLIN
:- __.--:r_. ~ ... ,_. ;-. ;. ~ ......... _ ..... -';- - ..... :: -' ' '~ ' ~' - -- - - ...... --
~ ~ -~'~~,¥, OF THOMAS MOLIN
~rPLIC~z~ ·
SUPERVISOR KLIPP:We have the recessed hearing on
~he~,etition o¢~... Thoma~ Moii~ for a change of zone ~.rom
"A" ~ae-~ id en t ~
~ ~al _nc~ Ag,_mcu!turai to ~ultiple Residence
We a~e ~econvening the hearing
Is there any person' present
who wi:shes to be heard in favor of .~ranting the application?
R. G. TERRY, m.o~~ ,., (Attorney for the applicant)-.
Gentlemen, I appear here on behalf of Mr. Molin, a~d I
would like to make a few statements for the record
~avor of t.he application
I think 'that you are all
f~miliar with the location of the property, the general
nature of it, and the fact that it is in the vicinity
of a~ open air movie, the Long Island Lighting Company
substation, as well as the labor c~mp of the Eastern
suffolk Cooperative, and I believe the labor camp owned
by Mr. King. In addition, it is in the vicinity of
· extensive land owned by the Village of Greenport and
property that previously has been changed to a
motel
zone, I believe, belonging to Harry Smith, a rather
large tract across the street, and to the west of us
I think there are three parcels of property that have
been previously changed to "M" zone, that of Jack Levin,
and. Mr. and Mrs. Be~dickson, amd I think a Mr. Bittner.
I think that you will concede that the use of the property
3
and the location o,~ the ~-~roperty is such, and the use o~
the surrounding area today, it really ~makes it feasible
for use as a multiple residence or motel area, especially
view of the Association across the street, a~d the
fact that the p'roperties in the vicinity have been changed
to a multiple residence zone. I will say nothing fur~aer
at this time unless there is someone who wishes to speak
in opposition, and then then I would like to have the
opportunity to be heard further.
SUPERVISOR KLIPP:
Is there any sort of building in
the near future here?
MR. MOLIN: Yes, i have some plans. Within six months.
SUPERVISOR KLIPP:
The reason I ~m asking that, we
are continually changing residential property into
multiple residence, and I haven't seen anybody start any
mote is yet.
MR. MOLIN: I know that.
SUPERVISOR KLI~PP: Is there any other person who
,
wishes to be heard?
MR. BENDICKSON:
I ~m here with my wife. We have
property within 200 ft. to the east and within 600 ft.
to the west. We are in favor of this change to an "M"
zone.
SUPERVISOR
KLIPP: Is there anyone
eise who w~shes
~ the application~
to speak in favor o~ .
(There was no response.)
SUPERVISOR KLIPP:
if not, is there any person who
wishes to speak i~ opposition to the application?
(There was no response.)
SUPERVISOR KLIPP:
Hearing none, we will close the
hearing at this time for the further deliberation of the
Board.
PUBLIC HEARING
TOWN BO ARD
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
Greenport, N. Y.
April 21, 1959.
Pres ent :
NORMAN E. KLIPP, Supervisor
HENRY A. CLARK, Justice of the Peace
RALPH TUTHILL, Justice of the Peace
LEWIS DEMAREST, Justice of the Peace
LESTER ALBERTSON, Councilman
RALPH B. BOOTH, Town Clerk
ROBERT TASKER, Town Attorney
APPLICATION OF THOMAS M. MOLIN
.... ,l! 1~_~_~ ~ ,~_ - .................. _ ..................
SUPERVISOR KLIPP: I
will open the public hearing
at this time, and read the legal notice:
Pursuant to Section ~65 of the Town Law and ~rticle
IX of the Building Zone Ordinance of the Town of Southold~
Suffolk County, New York, a public hearing will be held by
the Southold Town Board at the office of the Supervisor~
16 South Street, Greenport, New York, in said Town on
April 21, 1959, at 2:00 p.m. of said day, on the follow-
lng proposal to amend the Building Zone Ordinance (includ-
ing the Building Zone Maps) of the Town of Southold~,
Suffolk County, New York:
By changing from "A" Residential and Agricultural
District to "M" Multiple Residence District the following
described property:
All that certain tract or parcel of land situate near
Greenport, in the Town of Southold~ CoUnty of Suffolk, and
State of New York, and more particularly bounded and
described as follows:
Beginning at a point on the northerly line of North
Road at the southeasterly corner of land now or formerly
of Shannon; from said point of beginning running along
s~d land now or formerly of Shannon North 570 feet
more or less to the waters of Long Island Sound; thence
3
easterly along the shore of Long Island Sound ~00 feet
more or less to land now or formerly of D. H. Horton; thence
along the land last mentioned South 469 feet more or less
to the northerly line
of North Road; thence along the
northerly line of North Road west 3~0 feet more or less to the
point or place of beginning.
Containing about 3. 105 ac res
more or less.
Any person desiring to be heard on the proposed
amendment should appear at the time and place above
specified.
Dated: March ~4, 1959.
By Order of the Southoid Town Board
Ralph P. Booth, Town Clerk.
SUPERVISOR KLIPP:
This matter was referred to
the Southold Town Planning Board for their recommendation,
and at this time, I will read the recommendation of the
Southold Town Planning Board:
This is to certify that the following action was
taken by the Southold Town Planning Board at its meet-
ing on March 17, 1959.
In the matter of the petition of Thomas M. Molin
and Oscar Molin for a change of zone from "A" Residential
and Agricultural to "M" Multiple Residence district
certain real property situated near Greenport and more
particularly bounded and described as follows: North
by Long Island Sound, East by D. H. Horton, South by
North
Road, and West by Shannon, it is hereby
RESOLVED, that the Planning Board recommend to the
Town Board that the change from "A" Agricultural and
Residential to "M" Multiple Residence district be made
on the property included in the legal description by
Otto W. Van Tuyl, Surveyed on December 14, 1945.
The Board fee is that in view of the fact this
property is almost across the street from two labor camps,
and there are other "M" districts in the immediate vicinity,
this is probably the best use of this land. We are of
the understanding that the petitioners, plan to build four
double duplexes on this property in approximately one year.
Very truly yours,
(signed) John Wickham, Chairman
SouthoId Town Planning Board
SUPERVISOR KLIPP:
Is there any person present at
this time who wishes to be heard in favor of the change
requested in the petition?
MR. THOMAS MOLIN:
This is a preliminary sketch of
what we decided on.-
SUPERVISOR KLIPP:
At this time, Mr. Molin, do you
5
want to say something in favor of the petition?
MR. MOLIN: I don't think I have anything to say.
Mr. Terry was supposed to be here, but under the cir-
cumstances he wound up in New York so he can't get here
to the hearing, so I at least bring that down and submit
that, and if we can't c.ome to any conclusions on it
we will continue it to the next meeting.
SUPERVISOR KLI P P:
Well, Mr. Krupski called me
this morning and he told me what you are asking, that the
hearing be postponed.
MR. MOLIN:
Yes, and if there are any in opposition.
SUPERVISOR KLIPP:
Wel~, it makes it rather difficult
after we have advertised.
MR. MOLIN: I realize, tha~. I do realize that and
I think Mr. Krupski discussed it with you and Mr. Terry.
SUPERVISOR KLI PP:
Yes. We want to give everybody
as much of an opportunity as we can to be heard, and
if there are none who are opposed to it, I would suggest
maybe they file some sort of a statement or brief. I
don't know what else I can do at this time. And we will
reserve our decision until such time as we receive that.
Is there any other person who wishes to be heard in
favor of the change?
(There was no response. )
6
SUPERVISOR KLIPP:
Is there any person who wishes
to be heard in opposition?
STANLEY CORWIN, ESQ.,
( Gre enpo rt,
N.Y.): My
name is Stanley Corwin. I represent Isabel Shannon
who is the property in,mediately to the west of the
property sought to be rezoned and by this application
the Board is presently considering.
I have a fee ling
about the several applications which have come before
this Board have been creeping easterly from Jack Levin's
much larger motel a little bit to the west, and in Just
about the same distance from that motel west of it is
Mr. Lederle's house and I own. a piece of property
a little bit west of him, and I am very much concerned
not only on behalf of Mrs. Shannon, but individually
and as an owner of a piece of property along the Sound
there, that the same thing may be happening in that
direction as it happened tO the eastward, and that is,
all of a sudden I am going to find on each side of my
property lands which are zoned for
Multiple
Residence
while I am still sitting on a piece of Residential property.
.&nd I cannot, gentlemen, for the life of me, conceive
how anyone conscientiously Can consider that the creation
of a situation as exists along the Sound there from Mr.
7
Lederle's property east, Multiple Residence, Residential,
Multiple Residence, almost lot by lot to the east, can
by any stretch of the imagination be called comprehensive
planning and zoning.
I think it is the very antithesis
of that, and I think it should be stopped now. You
people are already aware, I am sure, that the type of
rezoning that has already been 'undertaken by this Board
has led to some litigation where its constitutionality
is very seriously questioned, and i suspect if this
9resent application were to be granted, we would be
involved in mo re of that.
And as an alternative to
this lot by lot and every other lot way of doing it,
let us tackle this business of rezoning this Town for
Multiple Residence on a comprehensive basis if you feel
you must, and ~that is the place to do it. Let us not
kid around and make it all multiple residence from
Southold Town Beach as far east as Orient, but certainly
not every other lot, that is not the way to do it.
I think you must realize with this creeping business
somebody else will want to put up a motel. Sure, we
need motels as the Planning Board told us; all of us
are aware of that. That is not the way to put them up,
by zoning every other ~t. And this is worsening an already
bad condition and I hope the Board will very seriously
consider this application and reject it.
Thank you.
SUPERVISOR KLIPP:
Is there any other person
present who wishes to be heard in opposition to the
application?
(There was no response. )
On motion of Mr. Albertson, seconded by Mr. Demarest,
and unanimously carried, the hearing will be continued on
May 5th at 2 o'clock p.m. for the purpose of having the
applicant's attorney appear.
NOTICE OF HEARING
TO ~ND ZONING
ON PRO POS AL
ORD I NANCE
Pursuant to Section ~6~ of the Town Law and Article IX
~ of the Building Zone Ordinance of the Town of
County, New York, a public hearing will be
!,Toma Bo~d at the office of the Sul~rvisor,
$outhold, Suffolk
:i Greenport,
held by-the Southold
16 South Street,
New York, in said town on April 21, 1959, at 2~O0 P.M.
~ of said day, on the following proposal to amend the Building Zone
Ordinance (including the Building Zone Maps) of the Town of
!.Suffolk County, New York:
By changing from "A" Residential and Agricultural Dis
~,ito "M" Multiple Residence District the .following described ~ope
Ail that certain tract or parcel of land
situate near Greenport, in the Town of Southold,
County of Suffolk, and State of New York, and
more particularly bounded and described as
follows,
Beginning at a point on the northerly line
of North Road at the southeasterly corner of
l~nd now or formerly of Shannon l fl'om ~aid point
of beginning ~u%nlng along ~aid land now or
formerly of Shannon North %70 feet more or less
to the waters of .Long Island Sound~ thence east-
erly along the shore of Long Island Sound 200
feet more or less to land now or forn~rly of
D. H. Horton$ thence along land last .mentioned
South ~69 feet more or less to the northerly
line of North Road~ thence along the northerly
line of North Road West 320 feet more or less
to the poi. n~ or place of beginning. Containing
about 3.10% acres more or less.
Any person desiring to be heard on the proposed amendment
should ap.pear at the time and place above specified.
Dated: March 2~, 1959
BY ORDEE OF THE
TOWN BOARD
$OUTHoLD
RALPH P. BOOTH
TOWN CLERK
$outhold Town Planning Board
SOLITHOLD, L. I., N. Y.
PLANNING BOARD
MEMBERS
Johr, '~(/~ckh~rn, Ch~irme.
Harold R. Reeve
Alfred Grebe
Archib,~[d Youn~
Report To:
March 20, 1~9
Southold Town Board
Southold, New Zork
Gentlemen:
This is to certify that the following action was
taken by the 3outhold Tov~ Planning Board at its meet-
ing on March 17~ 19~9.
'In the matter of the petition of Thomas ~. ~.!olin
aad Oscar ~[olin for a change of ~ne from "A" Residential
and Agricult~.~al to "I,F' ~ltiple Residence district certain
real property situated near Greenport and more particularly
bounded and described as follows: ~orth by Long Island Sound~
East by D. H. Horton~ ~outh by North Road~ and West by
9hannon~ it is hereby
~SOL~D, that the Planning Board recommend to the Town
Ooard that the change from "A" Agricultural and Residential
to "M" Multiple Residence district be made on the property
included in the legal description by Otto W. Van Tuyl~ Survey-
ed on December 1}+~ 194~.
%'he Board feels that in view of the fact this property
is almost across the street from two labor camps~ and there
are other "M" districts in the immediate vicinity~ this is
probably the best use of this land. We are of the under-
standing that the oetitioners olan to build foyer double
duplexes on this property in approximately one Meat.
Very truly ?ours~
/John Wickham~ Chamr ~an
Southold Town Planning
Board
SOUTHOLD TOWN CLERK'S OFFICE
March 11, 1959
Mr. John Wickham
Chairman Planning Board
Cutchogue, L.I.,N.Y.
Dear Mr. Wickham;
The original petition
of THOMAS M. MOLIN and OSCAR MOLIN, of
Greenport, New York, relative to
change of zone from "A" Residential and
Agricultural District to "M'~ Multiple
Residence Zone, is in the files in the
office of the Planning Board at Southold,
New York.
You are instructed to
prepare an official report defining the
conditions described in the petition and
determine the area so effected with the
recommendation of your Board.
RPB/mr
~ry truly yours,
Ralpl~ P. Booth
Town Clerk
CASE NO:
STA.TE OF NEW YORK PETITION
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION OF
FOR A CHANGE, MODIFICATION OR AMENDMENT OF THE BUILDING ZONE ORDINANCE OF
THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD, SUFFOLK COUNTY, NEW YORK.
TO THE TOWN BOARD OF THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD:
~O~.~S ~. ~IOLIN, Oreenport,
· '~. "OSO.,~LR"' 5 ............................ ' ............................................................
Suffolk Count,,, New York, the undersigned, am the owner~lf~l¢ feo'~property- -----~certain situated d~
..¢~!'.~..~t].~.~!?~.t]..~;l .................................... and more particularly bounded and described as follows:
North by Long Island °ound;
East oy D, H. Horton;
~)uth by North Road~
est Oy Sherman.
See attached map
2. I do hereby petition the Town Board of the Town of Southold to change, modify and amend
the Building Zone Ordinance of the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York, including the
Building Zone Maps heretofore made a part thereof, os follows:
TO ehsnge Prom
"A'~ ~esldential end ~grlcultural zone to
~" i~ultlplo Residence Zone.
3. Such request is mode for the following reasons:
This propertywes originally purchased with the intentlon of erectlng
a gotel. In view of the character of the neighborhood, in order to
render tae property productive [rom an income standpoint, petitioner
proposes to erect auplex units. Premises are In immediate vicinity
of ~. Zone property and diagonally acros~ the road from the f~stern
Suffolk ~ooperacive Labor Camp and che ~regory & Doyle Labor C2mp.
(Thomas t,~ol~n )
STATE OF NEW YORK, )
) SS:-
COUNTY OF SUFFOLK, )
...... .T..H...0..~...S....~.!.0.~j~ .................................................. BEING DULY SWORN, deposes and says that he is
the petitioner in the within action; that he has read the foregoing Petition and knows the con-
tents thereof; that the same is true to his (her) own knowledge, except as to the matters therein
stated to be alleged on information and belief, and that as to those matters he believes it ta
be true.
~worn fo before ma
0
~0
~.~IJRVEy FOR
~'~OI4fN O? ,..~.OU TH O L D
· .~U~-,=-OLK Co., hl. Y.
,$o~/¢ Ioo'= I"