Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutLeung - 265 Orchard St Marina de Conciliis our Uni4U����9 e tie, Allan Wexler `�y�� /N0't9 PO Box 1179 Jeri Woodhouse a iund r e Southold,NY 11971 O SDUW9 o Telephone: (631)765-1809 Kim E. Fuentes,Coordinator = Four4ea } �' o N'0 +` ��0 �� kimf@southoldtownny.gov c o� 10 G RFSFRVATO' Town of Southold Historic Preservation Commission Certificate of Appropriateness March 28, 2024 RESOLUTION #03.28.2024.2 RE: 265 Orchard Street, Orient,NY. SCTM# 1000-25-2-11.1 Owner: Darien Leung RESOLUTION: WHEREAS, 265 Orchard Street, Orient,NY, is on the Town of Southold Registry of Historic Landmarks; and WHEREAS, as set forth in Section 170-6 of the Town Law (Landmarks Preservation Code) of the Town of Southold, all proposals for material change/alteration must be reviewed and granted a Certificate of Appropriateness by the Southold Town Historic Preservation Commission prior to the issuance of a Building Permit; and WHEREAS, the applicant submitted a proposal on February 20, 2024, for approval to install a new fence and gate surrounding an in-ground swimming pool; and WHEREAS, the applicant's representative, Stacy Paetzel, RLA, appeared before the Commission on March 28, 2024 to describe the proposed improvements; and WHEREAS, the proposal is described as six (6) feet in height NYS Pool Code Compliant Wire Mesh Fence, and proposed Natural Wood fence and gate to match existing fence and gate, as depicted in Architectural Plans, titled "Proposed Pool Fencing Plan", dated February 14, 2024, prepared by Stacy Marshall Paetzel, RLA; and WHEREAS, the Commission has determined that pursuant to Chapter 170-4(E)(2) of the Southold Town Code, the Commission has the authority to determine that some proposals do not rise to the level of requiring a public hearing, as the proposal is de minimis in nature; and WHEREAS, the Commission has determined that the subject application is de minimis in nature and, therefore, does not require a Public Hearing, and Certificate of Appropriateness #03.28.2024.2 HPC, Leung—Fence, SCTM No. 1000-25-2-11.1 Page 2 WHEREAS, the applicant shall submit to the Commissioners photographs of the finished improvements upon-completion; and WHEREAS,the Commissioners may conduct a site inspection of subject premises once improvements are completed; and NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED,that the Southold Town Historic Preservation Commission determines that the proposal described as six (6) feet in height NYS Pool Code Compliant Wire Mesh Fence, and proposed Natural Wood fence and gate to match existing fence and gate, as depicted in Architectural Plans,titled "Proposed Pool Fencing Plan", dated February 14, 2024, prepared by Stacy Marshall Paetzel, RLA; meets the criteria for approval under Section 170-8 (A) of the Southold Town Code; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED,that the Commission approves the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness, subject to approvals by all involved agencies; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED,that any deviation from the approved plans referenced above may require further review from the Commission. Motion made by: Commissioner de Conciliis Motion seconded by: Commissioner Wexler VOTES: AYES: Commissioners Wexler, Woodhouse and de Conciliis. (3-0) RESULT: Passed Please note that any deviation from the approved plans as referenced may require further review from the commission. Signed: , Kim E. Fuentes Coordinator for the Historic Preservation Commission Date: April 2, 2024 LEUNG RESIDENCE 265 Orchard Street Orient, New York EXISTING PROPOSED 6'HT. OUTDOOR NATURAL WOOD SHOWER TO BE FENCE TO MATCH REMOVED EXISTING -SEE IMAGE 2 EXISTING EXISTING EXISTING UHT. BARN PROPOSED NATURAL WOOD ON-GRADE COTTAGE FENCE TO REMAIN STONE PATIO I SEE IMAGE 2 marshall paetzel ° ° LANDSCAPF AkDCWTECTURE PO Box 478 -- - 72'-9"__ 5175 Middle Road — Mattituck, NY 11952 ° phone: (631) 209 -2410 fax: (631) 315-5000 email: studio@mplastudio.com PROPOSED EXISTING NATURAL I PRIVET HEDGE PROPOSED WOOD GATE TO SURVEYOR: EXISTING GENERATOR 18'X 45' POOL REMAIN, HARDWARE John M. Abruzzo, PLS TO BE MODIFIED TO MEET NYS POOL P.O. Box 61 1 CODE COMPLIANCE Islip Terrace, NY 11752 -SEE IMAGE 1 Office: (516) 381-1056 PROPOSED POOL EQUIPMENT LOCATION PROPOSED 10'-0" ON-GRADE �] PROPOSED 6'HT.PRIVET STONE HEDGE FOR SCREENING PATIO EXISTING SOLID WOOD SCREEN PANEL TO REMAIN EXISTING AC UNIT(TYP.) / EXISTING NATURAL WOOD PROPOSED 6'HT.NYS POOL I / PICKET FENCE+GATE TO CODE COMPLIANT WIRE ,,---EXISTING REMAIN MESH FENCE I PROPOSED NATURAL WOOD -SEE IMAGE 3 GATE TO MATCH EXISTING NYS EXISTING WALL POOL CODE COMPLIANT GATE, -SEE IMAGE 1 OF EXISTING GATE FOR REFERENCE EXISTING PRIVET HEDGE TO REMAIN ,TYP. a I � I = EXISTING EXISTING RESIDENCE I EXISTING COTTAGE SCREENED-IN ° PORCH v I v SITE DATA: EXISTING v SCTM#: 1000-25-2-1 1.1 - NATURAL WOOD Zoning District: R40 I !PICKET FENCE+ I Lot Area: 37,653 SF (or 0.864 acres) GATE TO REMAIN NOTES: I l. Base map information based on survey prepared by John M. Abruzzo, PLS, dated April 26, 2023. EXISTING GRAVEL EXISTING GRAVEL 2. This drawing is for the purpose of DRIVEWAY TO DRIVEWAY TO obtaining permits only. NOT FOR REMAIN REMAIN CONSTRUCTION. EXISTING IRON LEGEND 3. Unauthorized alteration of this plan is a GATE TO REMAIN violation of NYS Education Law. �- -- PROPERTY LINE REVISIONS ----- _ ------ -._- —` DATE DESCRIPTION EXISTING NATURAL WOOD FENCE EDGE OF PA VEMENT EXISTING NATURAL WOOD PICKET ORCHARD FENCE RC H qR p PROPOSED C HT.NYS POOL CODE S REE . COMPLIANT WIRE MESH FENCE T PROPOSED 6' HT NATURAL WOOD FENCE S @ a r�nsc,� Historic Preservation Commission EXISTING PRIVET HEDGE TO ! j`. BE MATCHED Resolution #: / '`�' r Dated: . . ` "ffio� 00 , FR; PROPOSED PRIVET HEDGE TO PROPOSED 6'HT.BLACK WIRE FSQ� G � C)' MATCH EXISTING-HEDGE TO MESH FENCE WITH TOP RAIL jp�Ns PVP� Or xo ;• - r3Y r,' r : HIDE 6'HT. BLACK WIRE MESH BEHIND PROPOSED PRIVET GQRfG FENCE WITH TOP RAIL BEHIND HEDGE. MSpP� b• 5 h• h wa M �> X. TITLE: a. u gg gg • k 1. r puLt'\ �P It M 1 y=as PROPO ED POOL , r 1 : o. , k< WqF FENCING PLAN .r :.: >• . .. t:Y ,.,. ..,R o"' i P,7`i. ::ca_ '�4. 'r y dr'(r >?:. �g�. �r r < yi .i. :. r ". ;. ��".." .+fd' :h � r,.1 � ....,fl r k... .}•. .#•'`'�'k._,k,. b,l, ,az. � r i `G i`1 �,_:..: ,...- ;. ,..; ,:... ... .} °� -• '�il''E., ,}.:.o,^ t ..; t .MtlJti:: � .. � „ •.....,,`. r" .:: . ,:' n •� -, .,. "c-,iya:y.�,q�.f,r- .,.r,•a. "., r .d .: ZFa ( {r S': r -:' '�. z,j}f��.S. ��.,, t.:, .� t �._' r y 4 i 7 A yL A. l' I 1 F. I r i r :W9' .. ,'. r.,n: .,`{�Y�� s ,a... d" �,: :':i�.' Yk .�I.' Y • '.. .;f> • rt. r d 1 s r SCALE 1/16" = 1'-0" ° C)' XISTING NATURAL WOOD GATE TO REMAIN/MATCH 2 6' HT. NATURAL WOOD FENCE TO MATCH EXISTING 3 6' HT. BLACK WIRE MESH FENCE WITH TOP RAIL DRAWN BY: Image Image Image C.EAST F P CHECKED BY: S.PAETZEL DATE:2024.02.14 REVISED: SHEET 1 OF 1 ur U.ni Mariella Ostroski,Chairperson � gUe'S�, r'abuthold Town Hall Annex Anne Surchin,Vice Chair. Tun 54375 Main Road Fabiola Santana Tunof f m P.O. Box 1179 SOUT •Allan Wexler Southold, NY 11971 u"`�'�0� Jerilyn Woodhouse r co rIAI Tele: 631-765-1809 Marina de Conciliis °9, I www.southoldtownny.gov Kim Fuentes,Coordinator °Ay °° kimf@southoldtownny.gov FSERVATION TOWN OF SOUTHOLD HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION APPLICATION SUBJECT PROPERTY ADDRESS. 265 Orchard Street, Orient, NY 119 D ECEONED FEB 2 0 2024 TOWN OF SC�UTHOLD SUBJECT PROPERTY TAX MAP NO.: 1000-25 _2 _11.1 �lx'�R�C PRESERVATION COMMISSION OWNERS NAME: Darien Leung 1 IAMING ADDRESS: 50 Bridge Park Drive, Apt 9B, Brooklyn, NY 11201 PHONE: 917-328-4353 E-MAIL: dleung@torys.com DATE ACQUIRED PROPERTY: December 2013 OWNER'S REPRESENTATIVE: Stacy Paetzel, RLA MAILING ADDRESS: PO Box 478, Mattituck, NY 11952 PHONE: 631-209-2410 E-MAIL:stagy@mplastudio.com STATUS: LOCAL LANDMARK X IN LANDMARK DISTRICT Orient Historic District NATIONAL HISTORIC REGISTER X PROPERTY ZONING DISTRICT R 40 EXISTING USE single family PROPOSED USE single family residence residence PROPOSED WORK: REPAIR ADDITION RENOVATION NEW WINDOWS --NEW DOORS J REPLACE SIDING REPLACE ROOFING NEW FENCE X NEW SIGN APPROVALS REQUIRED: ZBA NA TOWN TRUSTEES NA PLANNING BOARD NA I understand and agree that no work on this request shall commence until written approval has been given by the Building Department if a Building Permit is required. If no permit is required,written approval must be received from the Historic Preservation Commission. OWNER/REPRESENTATIVE'S SIGNATURE. Print Name: Stacy Paetzel, RLA Historic Preservation Commission-Page 2—Building Design and Materials TOWN OF SOUTHOLD HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMNUSSION CHECKLIST Instructions for"Certificate of Appropriateness"Application required for Building Permit on Registered Landmarks Items to be included: 1.Application 2.HPC Standard Q&A 3.Notice of Disapproval: Issued by the Building Department, dated within 60 days 4. Agent Authorization Letter: for owner's consent when using a representative 5. Photographs of building, surrounding area and adjacent buildings, labeled 6. Property Survey and Site Plan: showing existing structures and proposed addition. 7. Complete set of construction documents,as submitted to the Building Department, including window and door schedules,materials,dimensions, locations on the fagade(top of sill and dimensions on elevations and on building sections, as well). This document must be prepared by licensed design professional, dated, stamped, signed: Three(3)print sets and(1)digital set of proposed improvements at 1/4" scale,to include: BUILDING PLANS AND ELEVATIONS: ✓ Provide elevations of all sides affected,with building heights noted. ✓ Indicate location of all finish materials on plans and elevations. ✓ All pages of architectural/engineered plans shall be numbered, signed by a licensed design professional and indicate the date prepared and/or last revised date prepared. CHECKLIST: Please Provide Building Design and Materials below. Samples, supporting materials may be requested: Roof: Existing Form and Material: N/A Proposed Form and Material: N/A Siding Existing Form and Material. N/A Proposed Form and Material: N/A HPC—Application, Building Design and Materials 11_15_2023 (Revision#3) 2 1 P a g e Historic Preservation Commission-Page 3—Building Design and Materials Doors• Existing Form and Material: NIA Proposed Form and Material: N/A Garage Doors/Basement Door: Existing Form and Material: N/A Proposed Form and Material: N/A Windows• Existing Form and Material: N/A Proposed: N/A Manufacturer: N/A Exterior finish: N/A Style: NIA Types of Sash: NIA Lites: N/A Muntins: N/A Trim & Ornamentation: Existing : N/A Proposed: N/A Chimneys• Existing Form and Material: N/A Proposed Form and Material: N/A Porches-Decks: Existing Form and Material: N/A Proposed Form and Material: N/A HPC—Application, Building Design and Materials 11_15_2023 (Revision#3) 3 P a g e Historic Preservation Commisoiv1, -Page 4—Building Design and Materials Fences Existing Form and Material: See attached for description and images of existing and proposed fencing. Proposed Form and Material: Canopies/Awnings: Existing Form and Material: N/A Proposed Form and Material: N/A Gutters/Downspouts: Existing Form and Material: N/A Proposed Form and Material: N/A Solar Panels—Please provide Engineered Plans Proposed Form and Material: N/A Foundation: Existing Form and Material. N/A Proposed Form and Material: N/A • FAILURE TO SUBMIT DRAWINGS AND REQUESTED MATERIAL WILL RESULT IN DELAY IN THE APPROVAL PROCESS. • IT IS STRONGLY SUGGESTED THAT THE APPLICANT REVIEW THE HPC HANDBOOK at http://www.southoldtownny.gov/DocumentCenterNiew/320/LPC-Handbook-Final-Draft?bidId= • ALL APPLICATIONS MUST HAVE A REPRESENTATIVE AT THE CONFERENCE AND PUBLIC HEARING TO BE REVIEWED. • A PRE-SUBMISSION CONFERENCE WILL BE SCHEDULED PRIOR TO A FORMAL PUBLIC HEARING. PUBLIC HEARINGS REQUIRE POSTING AND MAILINGS BY THE APPLICANT AS DESCRIBED IN CHAPTER 55 OF THE SOUTHOLD TOWN CODE. • SECTIONS OF LOCAL LAWS AUTHORIZING REVIEW BY THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION OF PROPOSED WORK ON DESIGNATED TOWN LANDMARK PROPERTIES CAN BE FOUND IN CHAPTER 170 OF THE SOUTHOLD TOWN CODE HPC—Application, Building Design and Materials 11_15_2023 (Revision#3) 4 J'P a g e Historic Preservation Commission-Page 5—Building Design and Materials AUTHORIZATION FOR REPRESENTATIVE residing at. (print property owner's name hereby authorize -r s h (Agent) -c�,d.oi-r� to apply on my behalf to the historic Preservation Commission. Own Sign e. - Date: Print Owner's Name i t HPC—Application,Building Design and Materials s 11 15_2023 (Revision#3) S P a ge F DurUnigUe J�pO MAZ urewa7e G . . Town of Southold Historic Preservation Commission Standard Q&A for Historic District and Landmarked Properties Welcome to the Historic Preservation Commission. Our goal is to help you achieve your objectives with preservation of the exterior remaining true to its original design, assuring that the continuum and continuity essential to a historic district or property is maintained. There is a process to achieving the best outcome. • All applicants are encouraged to have a Pre-Submission Conference whereby the application and renderings are reviewed, questions are asked, and,recommendations made that will guide the applicant to a successful outcome. • If things are very straight forward and clear, a recommendation to go to a Public Hearing will be scheduled. • If it is necessary to better understand the project, a Site Visit may be suggested. This is a special accommodation, whereby one Commissioner or more will visit your property and have eyes on the ground able to assess your plans within the context of its location. • The Commissioners will report back to the'Commission, share their newfound knowledge and recommend either another Pre-Submission Conference or a Public Hearing. The Administrative Assistant to the HPC will contact the Applicant and make scheduling appointments. • If there is a Public Hearing, where the Commissioners believe a Site Visit is necessary", the Public Hearing will remain open until it may be resumed at a subsequent date. • Decisions are made because of research and negotiation that lead to a motion to grant a Certificate of Appropriateness. If the motion is not made, further work needs to be done to accomplish a mutual goal. • In the case of the granting of a certificate of appropriateness, the Historic Preservation Commission shall be empowered to impose reasonable conditions upon the applicant to ensure that the activity is conducted in a manner which is consistent with the spirit and intent of Chapter 170 of the Town Code. Incomplete or partial applications are not recommended. They lead to incorrect thinking and a lack of continuity. ' l 2021-08-24 The HPC is required to have an architect on the Commission. This is the greatest benefit to an applicant. Their knowledge, perspective and experience often lead to the best outcomes that the applicant can have. Please consider this mandate as your best investment. In anticipation of your meeting with the HPC, listed below are standard questions you may wish to be prepared to address: 1. When was your house first built? Prior to 1858 2. Do you know your building is within the Historic District? yes 3. Are you familiar with Chapter 170 of the Southold Town Code (Landmark Preservation) which applies to this application? yes 4. How is the design for your protect sympathetic to the surrounding neighborhood? The proposed materials and style of fencing are in kind with the pre-existing conditions on-site and in-keeping with the character of the neighborhood. 5. How do your plans and elevations show adherence to the historic district mandates in Chapter 170? NA 6. Have you supplied images of neighboring residences? yes ' 7. How does this renovation illustrate compatibility in terms of scale and massing with neighboring structures? The proposed fencing, gates, and hedges are to match existing on site. 8. What is the square footage of the original building? NA 9. What is the square footage of the renovated building? NA(no change proposed) 10.What is the height of the original building? NA 11.What is the height of the proposed alteration, addition or new building? NA(no change proposed) 12.What are the materials you are using for windows/doors, foundation walls, trim and siding? Natural wood fence to match existing on site, proposed wire mesh behind Privet hedge 13.Do these materials match, "in kind", those of the original structure? The proposed wood fence+gate will match existing fencing +gates on site. The proposed wire mesh for the required pool enclosure, will be placed behind the privet hedge so that it is not visible. i 1 2021-08-24 FORM NO. 3 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD BUILDING DEPARTMENT SOUTHOLD,N.Y. NOTICE OF DISAPPROVAL DATE: February 23, 2024 EP TO: Leung, Darien u 50 Bridge Park Dr Apt 9B F'[.N 2 D 2 2024Brooklyn,NY 11201 HISTORIC P WN OF RESERV U SOtlTHpLD COMMISSION Please take notice that your applications dated January 8, 2024 and February 20, 2024: For permits to: construct repairs and alterations to an existing accessory barn to include converting part of the barn into a permitted cabana and to construct an inground swimming pool fence barrier to an existing single-family dwelling at: Location of property: 265 Orchard Street, Orient,NY County Tax Map No. 1000 - Section 25 Block 2 Lot 11.1 Is returned herewith and disapproved on the following grounds: The proposed construction, on a nonconforming 37,653 sf. lot in the Residential R-40 District is not permitted pursuant to Section 170 of the Southold Town Code and is subject to Historic Preservation Commission ap rp oval. d - au-�A Authorize0bignature Note to Applicant: Any change or deviation to the above referenced application may require further review by the Southold Town Building Department. CC: file, Historic Preservation Commission 265 Orchard Street Orient, New York marshall paetzel LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE Existing Site Conditions- Front of Property O �j -,rill II �I • • • ' ni Oil y4`'r �:;�y,s �. fir.. �` ►,`4tt �; 1—; r,< ?'. 265 Orchard Street Orient, New York marshal) paetzel LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE Existing Site Conditions- East Side of Main House t. _ a � k C •�' >y I WIN yk.•If� i!��;' yL N,Y PB. 4 "✓I^l s 'a`�t: 'yam„ �M^� 4 _Y: 265 Orchard Street Orient, New York marshal) paetzel LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE Existing Site Conditions- Back side of Property IF 06 F. r r. c_ • OrchardStreet Orient, New York marshall paetzel LA NDSC APE ARCH I TEC TURE Existing Site Conditions- Eastern side of Property yr J Sr R •'f�y�} �a,�+�a!!'.-'�.15' "�' 'Y�,` � A'PF t�p►"�r�.�" � t��i/ l?I �x` ' }� '� h �9t��,i' `yF�' i ( � "ram •{• 1 �. �. - m. • s ,� .�,� �•' , _ � '� ��.���►�q���,y�,�,- ,ro ,tea, . R 4 .i 265 Orchard Street Orient, New York marshal) paetzel LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE Existing Fencing + Gate Conditions to Remain Q 1 � III 7;�Nuxfi; , Inl ton 11111 II #IM I�M���UM zVt � I L � J Y r1ii III 11 Existing Wood picket fence + gate at side . ... ;, yard • OrchardStreet Orient, NewYork marshall paetzel 1-4 LANDSCAPE ,A RCHITECTUPE Existing Fencing + Gate Conditions to Remain ITMITT Existing Solid wood enclosure to remain t e! J V`r y Jar rl i•��i t t- yet r.. y� -�,,;,�'r��'S�Sz °^ •::yes .� '�, ��,�,r'� i .°''. E ;� �,., •�,�,i� � �' +�. �� �� ..,,,� •�+^yVw -�� K.� ,� r ��• � ��� .S'4� � ` �`I�� r Nr r L�� 'CyS '}5y., y. �7r.1��C_-.�' �'�'`� �y •��+�/_"y� r>,�\�rJ• � ''� 'i L 4' ��,i 1 `ttit.' Lf •b Y � � ��`+' .. e� a,� k. ��` Y �<<., a'fi � ".�. t ~ �: Ti .01 tr t ire �r y K `•3.0. � �a�+r•�' t-'�'�'i '�b 7°� ,,�,,�'i"�`k�'+- t aJ'.� kk 5? .� ' �` t ��� f"ice,�+.�,:�1�41 t, �.A� ,yam - {•. `� i 4�i:i'. >ti of ��s-�4`� t r'�.!' � � • � - y,,��t, `- '•� � � ,AS7/'� � I � j -aka �� 1 ,•tom, r y.�h'Y k ter' �. J I.,y�+�• � +�I *r ,\�. y r `4(`*t��. ti ter { ►� f s,. s- • i • • • ••• • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• • • R .�' I,fi r�ngrl sr, Y•.! Y. yffs`��rl= � licit!.' ",{� ♦ /.�',� - =. '=' r i�4,��,—:: �. sial�,/ 1 ,r,': •: . " r, ,t K eke!' � 1 '� y, Al - -.. f(� Y ..4'yr. g' r�" y� tifi�j,,• i. �1.. •s/ � � .4� "j"-' �;f s � •. jp! '�'►� �..`t ✓'---,/1•i �'�.. i• iY�'�a.��#t� j b''•!1�Y; r,�` ° •4 � �..r � ', If ��n/���g_► ,te,!�"v i,f w ��r Y/S �� rre'f1" �we . .. r, �:`.. 14, 14 out i.• h h�. A -F 't- 265 Orchard Street Orient, New York '9-- V55;� marshall poetzel LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE Existing Fencing + Gate Conditions to be Matched G Existing 6' ht. natural wood fence to be matched � 1 i :4�I Proposed 6' ht. natural wood fence to match existing on site • OrchardStreet Orient, New • rk marshall paetzel L A N D S(-A PE A PC H I TEC TU RE Fencing + Gate Conditions at Neighboring Properties Privet Hedge asootartei� 0 : Ina ekkni.Wew vak •faogk Sneer View -- s Auq 2012 'i� },v �. -.ate+......-�- —� rM ��I �,r•_ x. ... - �t,r,. ':`'.�;•:4+r`. .e. Goog awoRwaa� p p ,;' onra eww ra* k ' Googk .ae..w rnton •em.omw • OrchardStreet Orient, New York '9-- v5!kA 1 p(jetzel L AN n S CAPE A P�*H!TF17 T 11 P F Fencing + Gate Conditions at Neighboring Properties ••• Fencing/Gate 530lTehartl$t Q ��� • MIT— Club lw - ..r' • '4t, �., t •� '�r gee^i.. Q' -- a - - a _ r it n.dew YaM -� j]C_. �'4'q'c .+'*� r,• ,i� h, :'.: � J'".:.,1- l� .2`:.=�.r:,b2 i•ice. .' . y �' 265 Orchard Street Orient, New York 9%.-- v55Y marshal) paetzel LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE Fencing + Gate Conditions at Neighboring Properties Wood Fencing/Gate .. 1 l Y+yV '1 j,. 1 ec,e � C Fuentes, Kim From: Fuentes, Kim Sent: Tuesday, February 27, 2024 9:01 AM To: 'Simon Eisinger' Cc: 'Stacy Paetzel'; Dwyer, Tracey; Nunemaker, Amanda; McGivney,Julie Subject: HPC Darien Leung, 265 Orchard Street ' Attachments: leung_20240227081756.pdf, HPC STANDARD Q&A2021 cover letter W_Q&A.pdf; HPC Draft Standard requirements with Appl 11-15-23 PDF.pdf Simon, Attached, please find the Notice of Disapproval that includes all proposed improvements on the above subject property. At this time, our March 28, 2024 agenda includes Ms. Paetzel's application, to erect a fence and gate, surrounding the swimming pool, (attached) for review by the Commission. Please submit an application that will incorporation all work being proposed (including the fence) with drawings and required information. Two separate applications to the HPC from two different design professionals for proposed work on a single property is not ideal. I've also attached our HPC application that should be completed and submitted well before our meeting date of March 28, 2024, so I can adjust the agenda accordingly. Our next meeting dates are April 25 and June 27. Contact me with any questions. Kim E. Fuentes Board Assistant Zoning Board of Appeals Coordinator, Historic Preservation Commission 631-765-1809 kimfasoutholdtownny.gov Location: 54375 Main Road Mail:P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 1 From:Simon,.Eisinger<simon@led-nyc:com> Sent: Monday, February 26, 2024 5:10 PM To: Fuentes, Kim <kim.fuentes@town.southold.ny.us> Subject:265 Orchard Street Hello Kim, Stacy Paetzel mentioned that she was in touch with you regarding the application for a new in-ground swimming pool and fence at 265 Orchard Street, in Orient(Darien Leung, Owner). I recently submitted a permit application for the restoration and renovation of the accessory barn structure on the same property.After speaking with Amanda,we were hoping to present our LPC application for review simultaneously with that for the pool. While we have not yet received our Notice of Disapproval,we would like to get on the schedule. Is this possible?And in the mean time, are we able to schedule a Pre-Application Meeting? Finally, it appears that the sample Application for Certificate of Appropriateness is missing from the LPC Handbook.Are you able to provide us with a copy? Many thanks, Simon Simon Eisinger,AIA, LEED AP simon LED-NYC.com LYNCH EISINGER DESIGN Architects 319 Grand Street,2"d Floor New York, NY 10002 T 212.219.6377 M 917.450.6153 www.LED-NYC.com ATTENTION:This email came from an external source. Do not open attachments or click on links from unknown senders or unexpected emails. 2 1 Fuentes, Kim From: Fuentes, Kim Sent: Friday, February 23, 2024 3:34 PM To: 'Stacy Paetzel' Subject: Darien Leung - 265 Orchard Street - HPC Application for pool fence Hi Stacy, I received a copy of the Notice of Disapproval from the Building Dept. Examiner today, and have placed your HPC application on the Thursday, March 28, 2024 Work Session Agenda at 3:00 PM. Kim E. Fuentes Board Assistant Zoning Board of Appeals Coordinator, Historic Preservation Commission 631-765-1809 kim&_southoldtownn-y gov Location: 54375 Main Road Mail:P.0. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 From:Stacy Paetzel<Stacy@mplastudio.com> Sent:Tuesday, February 20, 2024 5:38 PM To: Fuentes, Kim <kim.fuentes@town.southold.ny.us>; Dwyer,Tracey<tracey.dwyer@town.southold.ny.us> Subject: 265 Orchard Street- HPC Application for pool fence Dear Kim and Tracey, I dropped off the HPC application today at the Building Department—as well as the building permit application for the barn renovation (prepared by Simon Eisenger,the architect). Both applications should be on Tracey's desk. I have not received an official`Notice of Disapproval'of the pool building permit yet,which we need to submit with the HPC application—not sure if you mailed that,Tracey? I'm happy to swing back by tomorrow to go over anything. If the HPC has space on their agenda this Thursday to review the pool fence and gates,that would be amazing! I think that application should be fairly straightforward. Thanks to both of you for your guidance on this! Best, Stacy Stacy Marshall Paetzel, RLA 1 S77'13'50"E 119.00' _" S78'59'00"E 49.6n M 4' CHAIN LINK FENCE �� 0 22.2 BLOCK WALL AT GRADE Mso 21.7 MON. o V Y X _�( x - 0.5'E 21.0 . `.21.7 12° 12" --24• 21.7 M GRAVEL 21.80 6 1 40.9' rn t2" 22.0 34.4' / N FRAME BARN N �j 1 STORY FRAME o FF 22.2 OUTDOOR � N COTTAGE SHOWER FF 23.2 ` O 40.9' s3 RIDGE 37.2 20.7 34.4' ...��:��.... 00 22.0 WOOD 21.8 � DECK I 21.5 ilB W HEAD . W � / � I U W O 10.1' o y GENERATOR 20.6 = o �F 3 0_ io / / 21.5 AC � ......AC' ..........41.8' 18.7/ 4' WOOD-FENCE" 42" 20.0 20.7 19.8' 21.1 I' 3 1 2 ^ I / 20.0 N `� o WOOD DECK 21.6 .3'... � 1.3'ABOVE GRADE 21.4 CD STORY 34.4' 21. 1 21.7' 21.4 - 1.0' 21.1 1 STORY FRAME 1 Z 2 STORY WI p _I 6 2, COTTAGE o 19.5 "' .•........ ENTRANCE ui / 48 Q' FRAME RES. .3'ABo C �I 21.2 FF 22.5 1 zo GRADE RIDGE 35.2 1 1265 J 19.9, i 28.3' 1Q.2'...I FF 22.9 -15.1'- J 4'WOOD FENCE g. 1103 ' 20.7; �CH RIDGE 44.7 IT i21.3 ENCLOSEDWoo'00 II c ' WOOD PORCH I 0 -00 20.8 ROOFED 21.0 w N WOOD PORCH I: � • o 17.2 18.6 � I N �D WELL 20.9 N tl I J 2 ow o �: I ./ 9.3 I N ' 21.4 - ON. 202.94' 36" 17.2 17.8 1 PRMT HEDGE 120.8 'S"A T 21. APRON ASpt APRONT 19.4 20.0 15.4 CONCRE(E rr,,36" I � N66057-59>hw �,i 135�01 �g.0 20.4 O 85.93 I EDGE OF PAVEMENT 18.4 30"W E T 15.8 R C yq R Nay 56 S T R ,E I 17.6 T I t V NOTES: - Elevations refer to NAVD1988, GPS established. - Lot Area: 37653 sf, 0.864 ac. - Town of Southold Zone: R40 Low Density Residential CERTIFIED TO: SURVEY OF PROPERTY Situate at ORIENT TOWN OF SOUTHOLD SUFFOLK COUNTY, NEW YORK SCALE 1"=20' APRIL 26, 202J .TM. DIST 1000 SEC. 25 BLK.2 LOT 11. 1 UNAUTHORIZED ALTERATION OR ADDITION TO A SURVEY MAP Job No. 23-077 Nq BEARING A LICENSED LAND SURVEYOR'S SEAL IS A VIOLATION OF Revisions: �M•�1Q� O OHN M.ABRUZZO PLS. SECTION 7209, SUBDIVISION 2, OF THE NEW YORK STATE ®� S VEYOR-NEW YORK AND CONNECTICUT REGISTERED EDUCATION LAW. ©2023 %%�� P.O. BOX 61 IS P TERRACE, NEW YORK 11752 g. PH: 516-381-1056 EASEMENTS AND/OR SUBSURFACE STRUCTURES RECORDED OR UNRECORDED ARE NOT GUARANI®UNLESS o jmaabruzzo®optonline.net PHYSICALLY EVIDENT ON THE PREMISES AT THE TIME OF THE SURVEY. GUARANTEES INDICATED HEREON SHALL ONLY RUN TO THE PERSON(S)FOR WHOM THE SURVEY IS PREPARED, �6 AND ON HIS BEHALF TO THE TITLE COMPANY,GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY AND LENDING INSnMIONS LISTED. S083A GUARANTEES ARE NOT TRANSFERABLE TO ADDMONAL INSTITUTIONS OR SUBSEQUENT OWNERS. THE OFFSET DIMENSIONS SHOWN HEREIN)FROM STRUCTURES TO THE PROPERTY LINES ARE FOR A SPECIFlC N qNDJOHN M. ABRUZZO l S, NY 50834 PURPOSE AND ARE NOT INTENDED TO GUIDE THE ERECTION OF FENCES,RETAINING WALLS,POOLS,PATIOS, PLANTING AREAS,BUILDING ADDITIONS OR ANT'OTHER CONSTRIICDON, CT 70282