The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutTR-4602TRUSTEES SUPERVISOR John M. Bredemeyer, III. President SCOTT L. HARRIS Albert J. K_mpski. Jr., Vice President Henry P, Smith Town Hall John B. Tuthill 53095 Main Road William G. Albertson P.O. Box 1179 Southold. New York 11971 Telephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Office Use Only: -_.,,~ ~-. DATE REC.: Coastal Erosion Permit Application !I ~ if ~ '/ ~ --Coastal Erosion Variance Application ~'~,~:5~'- - · · -- etland Permit Application 7 ,~ ~ ~ ~ , Waiver from Chapter 97 tAppllcat~on/perm~: ~ ~ 3 ~ Trustee Lands Permit Application ~Grandfather Permit ~Ap.p_li/catj. o.n ~C~mpleted Apps..DaSe. ~L~%~/r ~ ~Ipspection date. ~//7/~~ ~ /, ,Variance Required: (Y/N) Neighbors notified-Date: SEQRA Type Coord.: Date sent SEQRA Determin./date{ / / ~-~ub lic Hearing/date: -- Findings: Approved (Y/N) Special Conditions: (Y/N) (see file) Application Fee: Permit(s) issued-date: ~. ¢¢~ ~/j-~. Application Number;SCTM%1000- //7~ /V~/~ Date: Applicant: 4~4~ ~ / Phone Interest: { w~, consultant,lessee,etc.) Owner of Property: Address Phone ) (Provide LILCO Pole ~, Distance to cross Streets if not on location map) THIS IS NOT A PERMIT Page 1 Yds. to be excavated: ~n~-~ Yds. to be filled: ~-~ Manner in which material will be removed or deposited: ~ canal, creek or bay fronting property: ~~ ~ Width of Depth at low tide: Aver. rise in tide: ~ ~ Distance to nearest channel: ~ Distance project extends beyond similar projects in area: ~ Area zoning: ~ Land area in acres: /~ Is project for private or business use: ~~ Intended use of property: ~-~ ~c~/~ Describe known prior operations conducted on premises: ~ Has any prior license or permit been issued to erect structures, dredge, or deposit fill on said premises: ~ Has any license or permit ever been revoked or suspended by~ a Governmental Agency: ~ Project Description The project description must also include plans for reclamation of land disturbed during construction of the principle and accessory structures and underground structures (i.e., pipeline and septic system; make additional attachments if necessary). THIS IS NOT A PERMIT ~Pagc 2 ' i , ~ A/~W BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES - ~ TOWN OF SOUTHOLD SHORT ENViRONtVIENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM Project Information (To be completed by Applicant or Project sponsor) 4. Is proposed action: ~ / / ~ ~ / 6. Precise location (road intersections, prominent landmarks, etc. or provide,map) ~~ 7. Amount of land affected: ~Yes [] No If No, describe briefly 9, What is present [and use in vicinity of project? ~ Residentia, [] industrial [] Commercial [] AgdcuIture [] Park[and/open space [] Other Describe: Does action involve a permit/approval, or funding, now or ultimately, from an'/other governmental agency (Federal, state or local)? [] Yes ~ No if yes, list agency(s] and permit/approvals Does any aspect of the action have a currently valid permit or approval? [] Yes ~] No If yes. list agency name and permit/approval type 12. As result of proposed action will existing p6rmit/approva[ require modification? B rd of Trustees Application- State of New York DEPOSES AND AFFIRMS THAT HE/SME IS T~ APPLICANT FOR 'r~ ABOVE DESCR/BED PERMIT(S) AND THAT ALL STATEMENTS CONTAINED .W~EIN ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF HIs/HF~R KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF, AND TqIAT ALL WORK WILL BE DONE IN THE MANNER SET FORTH IN THIS APPLICATION AND AS MAY BE APPROVED BY 'i'm SOUTHOLD TOWN BOARD OF THUST":w.S. THE APPLICANT AGltEES TO HOLD THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD AND '~'~u~ TOWN TRUSTEES HARMLESS AND FREE FROM ANY AND Ar.L DAMAGES AND CLAIMS ARISING UNDER OR BY VTRTUE OF SAID PEP/~IT(S'), IF GRANTED. iN COMPLETING THIS APPLICATION, I F_EREBY AU'£nORIZE THE TRUSTEES, THEIR AGENT (S) OR REPRESENTATIVES ( S), TO E/~TER ONTO MY PROPERTY TO INSPECT THE PREMISES IN CONJUNCTION WITH REVIEW OF T~IS / SWORN TO BEFORE ME THIS ry Public JOYCE M. WILKINS Notary Public, State of New York No. 4952246, Suffolk Coun~ Term Expires June 12, 1~.~ Town Hail Albert J. Krupski, President 53095 Main Road James FAng, Vice-President P.O. Box 1179 Henry Smith Southold, New York 11971 Artie Foster ~ Ken Poliwoda Telephone (516) 765-18~/2 Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD October 22, 1998 Tom Samuels Samuels & Steelman Architects 25235 Main Road Cutchogue NY 11935 RE: JAMES MANNING SCTM 9117-10-10 Dear Mr. Steelman, The Southold Town Board of Trustees reviewed the survey dated and received in our office on October 21, 1998 and determined that your proposal to construct a second floor addition to an existing accessory structure landward of the principal building, to be out of the Trustee Wetland jurisdiction. However, any activity within 75' of the Wetland line requires a permit from this office. This determination is not a determination from any other agency. If you have any further questions, please do not hesitate to call. Sincerely, Albert J. Krupski, Jr. President, Board of Trustees AJK/djh cc. Bldg. Dept. s ^ M u [ [ s & IO OF$OUTHO[[ S T E E L M A N October 19, 1998 Board of Town Trustees Town of Southoid Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold New York 11971 RE: Manning Residence Tax Map # 1000-117-10-10 Dear Trustees: Enclosed please find one copy of the survey, and a check for $40 for the property referenced above. The proposed construction, a second floor addition to an existing accessory structure landward of the principal building on the property, and is greater than 75 feet from the edge of wetlands. We are therefore requesting a letter of non- jurisdiction from the Board of Trustees. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call us. Sincerely, SAMUELS & STEELMAN ARCHITECTS Tom Samuels cc: Jim Manning ARCHITECTS 25235 MAIN ROAD CUTCHOGUE, NEW YORK 11935 (516) 734-6405 FAX (516) 734-6407 Pag~ 2 Dept. Tho purpose of these proposed groins that being Iow pro,qb (one ~ abo~ tl~ ex.lng beach profile) is to allow cxc~ss material to be carried alor~ tho sh~reline, but to mainlain the existing beach level. Unfortunatel7 because of the derision of tho Southold To~m Trustees tha t~eteh distance bet~-ea groins has been doubled and their eff~otiveness to nm~tain beach level has been reduced. It is noted that there has been severe emslon the last two seasons, where in spots there has b~n a Pleas~ note tba~ I ara the contractor engag~ to b~d tha Manning groins, Also I would like to note that m, l?ather built the 20 groins to the e~s~fiat have beet~ suceessf-el, Th~ work was done in the late I hope this letter will suffi¢~ as to the informal/on ueeded by )mr orgarfizatioa_ NEW SUFFOLK DOCK BLrtLDINO Laxvxenea M. Tuthill, LMT/tlr NEW SUFFOLK DOCK BUILDING SCHOOL HOUSE CREEK NEW SUFFOLK, L.I., N.Y. 11956 July 22, 1996 Mr, William geld~usea Environmental Anal)st Co~sisteney Review Section Div/sion o£ Coastal Resoumes and Waterfront R~itallzatioa Department of Stat~ Albany, N.Y. 122314)001 Dear Mr. Feldlxtsen: Re: F-96-235 With reference to your le~r of Ma5' 7, 1996 referring to tho proposed groins tm the property of John and Yames Manning ia New SuffoLk, pleo,~e note that the Southold Towa Trustees require the omlssicra o£t~ of tho groins. · Before discussing the Polieie~ #13 and #14, t would ask th~ >vu please read the enclosed arti¢te I ~mte for the magazine Shore and Beach ~,n the luly 1995 i,~,uo on ~e Effeels of Lc, cai Winds. There is a tremendous la& of knowledge, experience, and educatioa in design and comtm~on of groins, principally by go~rnmemal agencies, who prohibit the oonmction of groins. Since 1970, ~ have not be~z able to build ext~rimental groins, With over 20 major variables effecting the design of groins, rye must nmke further stu~es as mentioned ia my article. This generation ggm~-am<tat officials bas been by the environmantal educators that groins are nO good, The7 have published oreO' data on groins that have not been effected and have never made any sludies on groins that have been eff-ecti~ arat working. This particular oxen x~$ filled ~-ith over $' of sand in tho period betwmn 1950 and 1960. To the ~'¢st are about 20 groins built of 1" material that are ia excellent c,e~dition ~ ~;ill holding smd. project~ are never publicized. Starting from the Manning properties and working easm-arfl, the beaches are effected by a different condition: ( 1 ) They are ia ~e area effected by a the throat o£~am~r bct~een the Robin ldand amid bar and New Suffolk called the North Ram (2) The Shinnecock Canal only le~s water into Peconie Bay, thereby increasing the flow of~vamr o~. ofthe bay. This causes erosion to the east, DEPARTMENT Of STATE - - - ALbaNY. NY 12231-0001 July 15, 1996 J.H. Geideman, P.L.S. P.O. Box 416 East Marion, NY 11939 Re: F-96-235 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers/New York District Permit Application #96-03090-L2 John & James Manffmg, Great Peconic Bay Town of Sothold, Suffolk County DEC #1-7438-01321/00001 Second Request for Additional Information Dear Mr. Geideman: On May 7, 1996, we notified you of our need for additional information regarding the above-mentioned project. Since we have not received a response to our request, we carmor commence our review of your federal consistency certifieation. Please provide the information requested in that notification (copy enclosed) to the Department of State within thi~y days from the date of this letter. If we do not receive the requested ir/formation, we may close the file on your project. Please be advised that the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers cannot issue a permit for this project unless the Department of State concurs with your consistency certification. A copy of this letter has been sent to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. Please call W'flliam Feldhnsen at (518) 474-6000 if you have any questions on this matter. Diana L. Boos Consistency Coordinator Division of Coastal Resources Enclosure and Waterfront Revitalization cc: COE/New York District - Jmes W. Itaggerty NYS DEC/Region 1 - John Cianci Town of Southold - Albert Kmpski STATE OF NEW YOrK DEPARTMENT OF STATE ALBANY, NY 12231"0OO1 ALEXANDER F. TR~ADWEL1 S~C.~A~ O~ S~A~ ~ ~--UgUS~ 8, 1996 J.H. Geideman, PLS P.O. Box 416 Eat Marion, NY 11939 Re: F-96-235 U.S. Army'Corps of Engineers/New York District Permit Application #96-03090-L2 John & James Manning, Great Peconic Bay Town of Southold, Suffolk County DEC #1-7438-01321/00001 Acknowledgement of Federal Consistency Assessment Form and Additional Requested Information Dear Mr. Geideman: The Department of State received your Federal Consistency Assessment Form and supporting information, has received the additional requested information on July 24, 1996, and lias determined that the submitted documentation is adequate to commence our review of your proposed project. We will contact you if additional information may be necessaEy for consistency review purposes. You and the Corps of. Engineers will be notified of our decision when we have completed our review of this project for its consistency w/th the New York State Coastal Management Program. The Corps of Engineers cannot issue a permit for this project unless the Department of State concurs with your consistency certification. Please call William Fetdhusen ar (518) 474-6000 if you have any questions. Sincerely, ~ ~, W'/lliam F. Barton /~ Chief, Consistency Review and Analysis Bureau D/vision of Coastal Resources and Waterfront Revitalization WFB:dlb cc: COE/New York District - Denise Butts NYS DEC/Region 1 - John Cianci Town of Southold - Albert Krupski STATE Of NEW YOrK DEPARTMENT OF STATE ALBANY. May 7, 1996 Mr. J. P.O. Box 416 East Marion, NY 11939 Re: F-96-235 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers/New York District Permit Application-96-03090-L2 John & James Manrfing-Replace Storm-damaged Groins-Great Peconic Bay Town of Southold, SuffoLk County DEC #1~7438-01321/00001 Request for Ad~tinnal Information Dear Mr. Geideman: Pursuant to 15 CFR 930.58, the following data and information is necessary to enable t~e Depmhnent of State to adequately assess the coastal zone effects of this proposed project. Please provide photographs which document existing site conditions and upon wh/ch the location of the groins is outlined. Please compare the length of the proposed groh~s to those along the adjacent shore. New groins exceeding the length of existing groins are lilly to starve downdrLft areas of sand. In accordance with New York State Coastal Management Program Policy #14 (policies enclosed), please discuss and analyze the effects, if any, of the proposed groin replacements upon the ~/ttoral transport of sediment to adjacent shorelands. For example, the submitted drawing indicates that the updrift cells of the groins aright need to be filled. You should provide information indicating what effect tiffs filling might have on the adjacent shorel/ne and how much material would be required to fill_ these cells. Also please describe the extent of the erosion that has occurred in the last two years during which the groins were not functional. Pursuant to 15 CFR 930.60(a), the review of your consistency cen/ficafion will begh~ afte~ we receive and determine that the necessary dam and information is adequ~ ~o assess coastal zone effects. Any additional information which you believe will facilitate our consistency re~Aew of ttfis project would be appreciated. SHORE & BEACH OBsERvATION$ II The Effect of Local Storm Winds on Receding Wavewash and Sand Transport Lawrence M. Tuthill, PE, CE. E XISTEx,rG RESEARCH and published smddes on beach lion, Bur on shore, in ff~ wave wash area, because of retraction, erosion seem nOt ~o have taXOn into account the effects of wind ~d waves may not I~ in line, thus affecting the process of local storm vdnd direchoa and speed at the dine of sand transport and erosion. These ob.servadons of the refuting wave wash. involved in local e. oasiolx are important i~ the &sign and place. A review of ~ceat mi¢les in the literature seem8 to show meat of low prof/l* groins, for exa_mple~ as well ~ of thaor*~i- Rat t~is variable has r~ot ~ closely considered (in the bibli, coO importance in understanding erosion pmce$ses. Further ogtaphy see "Works Consulted" as well as Hofikawa 1 ~88a, eh. studies should bo made, 4 on tne. asures in the %wash' zone). Close observations of forces acting on tile swash zone in the ¢omext of diurnal cycles REFERENCES AND BIBLIOGRAPHY of land- and seabreezas~ and of wave direction within a groin field* have been made and extensively analyzed. Dorirk~ a major (Works storm, flowevef, becanse of the severe conditions, it is almost imt)ossible to r~ake vi,~,ual obse~'atiohs of tt,~ actual erosion i. Hola~, g.A, ",Edgewams and the Configac~tion of th? Shoreline". IN Kom~r process. This in mm has led to tt~ reliance oa compUter mod- elsL These models seem not to have included local storm winds ~. mdkawa, mye~hi, s& as an important variable. Wh/le previous s~dies: emphasize the ~lear,~hore Dyna~eie$ and Coastal Proce~sgs: ?heoo', roi* of edge waves aa a eans~ of ericSon, ! believe ~his may no!: 3. tatum, Beagles L. aa~l Ps. cia bi. fully account for what at. ally happens. ~State~ of Re~e-atch on tl~. Near Sho~', $~ore ned Beach 62,3: July. In the great swrcn of March I962 leases of 30 meters of beach along the northeastern Un~£ed States ~eaboard were not encore- 4, Seen, C,, $. Murray. S, I-I~, $. ~ubayda and E, men, I was at at Orient Point, Long Island, NY. Wind8 v-ere in Oeo~,hysical Unio~h 54 9}, 1973 820-833. the orde~ o~ 65 kilometem per ho~ and were parallel to the ~, $~ndar, V,, >'l, Noethe~ ned K. Plolz beach. T~e beach was eroding m fast that lumber being need in "7v~. Dff~t~ens £n a Groin Fi~IC', Jo~tnkat of Cvastai the constdlct/oll of a butkhead had to be mover[ TWICE shore- 1994, Ward, In the years since ti-ds combination of lo,al stoan winds q~'ori~ Co~alt~i) and wind direction r~lative to beachftont was ot>ser,'ed on e, ral other occasfoll$ in which erosion took place, Ftsh~r, J. S. en~ R. The essence of the process seems to be. as follows: "Beach Processes an~ Coastal ~.ly~od>~r~cs", ~r~'hwark Pap~rs 1. Energy in an arriving wave transports s~d upland tmtil wave emrgy is exhansted; the ramming wavawash carries seaward. Koran, P, CRC firandbook ot~ ¢oa.~ta! Processes arm Erosion. l~¢ca Raton, 2. An onehor~ wind. however, re~ards the speed of the ir:g wavewasl/. This is one factor w~¢h diminishes mud trane- cgC !ams, 1983. por~ seaward, tl~reby contributing re the steepness of the beach ~a~*, N, C. a~d O. H. Pilk~y, ads. profile. Others factorS inclade beach porosity and increased 'Wac Ef'~t of S~walls oa the B,ach". Sp¢¢ia~ Issue e-4, .~ourtuzl of mean water ievel. Coastal R~ssa~c& CRC Fauneafion, 3, When local storm winds are parallel m a I~ach a different M~s, R. W, ~d Ir. E. Ko~m, ~. scenario recalls. Because of wave refraction, the waves turn tnterpretafioaoflW~ndflowCl:a~cteri~ti¢$framF, otla~_Landforma. and approach the beach at approximately a 45-degree angle, Specie/P~t~ #i92. Th~ Geological Society of America~ 4. ~'hep. storm wirid~ ax~ parallel to the beach the for~ of I982. the Vdnd aceelerams t!~ r~turnlng wavewas& This added anat. Shel:ard, ER a~d D. L. gy increases retaining wavewash water velocity and i~ sand ~Nearshor* Processes". ~ Fisher ~d Doles. a0s., i977 carry ng capacity, thereby creasing erosion.~Thhs in my experi- ence the relatioastxio of local storm Mnda ~o the beach and the ACKNOV~qLEDGEMENT returning wavewash are rna.~r fa~a's in the eros/on proeess~ ~Grateful acknowledgement is made for a review of these mate. Most studies seem to be be.sad mt data collected a~ a 'teau~l rials by Francis Conner, Ph,D, Human .Ecology and Remote Sensing Laboratory, Department of Anthropology, Hunter of off-shore ston'n& .At times the direction of local storm Willda College, may drastically affect waves gec~ra~ed by off-shor~ ston'a& STATE Of NEW YORK DEPARTMENT Of STATE ALBANY. NY 12231-0001 September 30, 1996 John H. Geideman, PLS · P.O. Box 416 East Mar/on. NY t1939-0416 Re: F-96-235 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers/New York District Permit Application #96-03090-L2 John & James Manning, Great Peconic Bay Town of Southold, Suffolk County DEC #1-7438-01321/00001 Dear Mr. Geideman: The Department of State has completed its evaluation of your Federal Consistency Assessment Form and certification that the above proposed permit activity complies with New York State's approved Coastal Management Program, and will be conducted in a manner consistent with tiffs program. Pursuant to 15 CFR Section 930.63, and based upon the project information submitted, the Department of State concurs with your consistency certification. This concurrence is without prejudice to, and does not obviate the need to obtain all other applicable licenses, permSts, and approvals required under existing State statutes. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers is being notified of this decision by copy of this letter. Sincerely, ~ ~ C~orge R. Stafford 7 Director Division of Coastal Resources and Waterfront Revitalization GRS:WF:dlb cc: COE/New York District - Den/se Butts DEC/Region 1 - Regional Permit Administrator Tow~ of Southold - Albert Krupski t~'~ pdnted on recycled paper Board Of $outhold Town Trustees SOUTHO.LD, NEW YORK PERMIT NO. ~/~)~. DATE: ....~Y 23, .~.~96 ISSUED TO .......... ~.~.~....~'~g Pursuan(. fo +he provisions of Chap(.er 615 of fhe Laws of +he S~ra+e of New York, 1893; and C~lap']'er 404 of fha Laws of fha Sfa']'e of New York 1952; and fhe Soufhold Town Ordlnance en- (.i(.led "REC=ULATING AND THE PLACING OF OBSTRUCTIONS IN AND ON TOWN WATERS AND PUBLIC LANDS and fha REMOVAL OF: SAND, GRAVEL OR OTHER MATERIALS FROM LANDS UNDER TOWN WATERS;" and in accordance wi'ih 'J'he Resolu('ion of The Board adopfed afa meefing held on ...~.~-~..2~ ....... 19...c~6., and in consideration of fhe sum of $...~5~.~.~.0. paid by ................... ................................................................... of N.Y. and subjec'l' fo fhe Terms and Conditions lisfed on fhe reverse side hereof, of Soufhold Town Trus(.ees au+horizes and permffs ('he following: to rep~ace~ 2 existing 110' groins as per drawing dated 5/14/96. all in accordance wifh fhe derailed specificafions as present'ed ~n fhe origina~ring application. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The said Board of Trus{'ees h~re- by causes ifs Corpora(.e Seal (.o be affixed, and +hese presenfs ('o be subscribed by a majorlfy of ('he said Board as of ('his da('.e. Board Of $outhold Town Trustees , SOUTHOLD, NEW YORK PERMIT NO ~-~ I~ DATE: ...~a~ ~3, ..%~96 ISSUED TO Pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 615 of the Laws of tl~e S~'ate of New York, 1893; and Chapter 404 of the Laws of the State of New York 19B2; and the Southold Town Ordinance en- titled "REGULATING AND THE PLACING OF OBSTRUCTIONS IN AND ON TOWN WATERS AND PUBLIC LANDS and the REMOVAL OF SAND, GRAVEL OR OTHER MATERIALS FROM LANDS UNDER TOWN WATERS;" and in accordance with the Resolution of The Board adopted at a meeting heJd on .Ma~ 22 ....... 19...g& and in consideration of the sum of $ 15.0.,.00 paid by [Iohn Manning of N.Y. and subject to the Terms and Conditions listed on the reverse side hereof, of Southold Town Trustees au~'horizes and permits the followlncj: To replace 1 existing ll0~ groin as per drawing dated 5/14/9t all in accordance with the detailed specifications as presented in the originating application. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The said Board of Trustees h~re- by causes its Corporate Seal to be affixed, and these presents to be subscribed by a maiorit¥ of +he sald Board as of ~)'his dat, e. ST^re OX NEW YORK ! ~ DEPARTmENt OF STATE t~%~l\~ OF SOUTHOLD ALBANY, NY I223i-0OO~ ALEXANDER ~, ~READWELL SECRE?ARY OF STATE Au~st 8, 1996 Albert J. Krupski, Jr. Trustee, Town of Southold 53095 Main Street P.O. Box 1179 Southold, NY 11971 Re: F-96-235 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers/New York District Permit Application #96-03090-L2 John & James Manning, Great Peconic Bay- Dear Mr. Krupski: Enclosed is a copy of the information submitted to the Department of State for review of the above-referenced project with respect to its consistency with the Coastal Management Program for your information and preliminary review. Please contact William Feldhnsen, the DOS reviewer assigned to this project, at (518) 474-6000 to discuss your concerns, and any additional information which may be necessary to assist you in reviewing this project. Any comments you may have will assist the Department in reaching a decision as to the consistency of the proposed action with the approved NYS Coastal Management Program. Please note, however, that if we do not hear from you within 45 flays of the date of this letter, we will presume that you have no objections to the proposed project. Sincerely, , William F. Barton Chief, Consistency Review and Analysis Bureau Division of Coastal Resources and Waterfront Revitalization Enclosures c,' \~ WFB:dlb ~t'~ pdnted on recycled paper iQ DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY JACOB K. JAVITS FEDERAL BUILDING C~h,,~T/~. NEW YORK~ N~Y~ 10278-0090 199 RECEIVED Eastern Permits Section ' SUBJECT: Application N~m~er 96-03090-L2 by James & John Manning John H. Geideman, PLS ................. P.O. Box 416 East Marion, New York 11939-0416 Dear Mr. Geideman: We have reviewed the additional information you submitted on April 3, 1996, which includes a second application under the name of John Manning. We have determined that since t~'~ pr6~ects would be appropriate to treat both as one permit action. The proposed work appears permissible under Department of the Army Nationwide Permit No. 3 based upon your representation that storm damage has occurred within the past two years. However, since you indicate some of the damage occurred greater than one year ago; project-specific Coastal Zone Management (CZM) concurrences will be necessary from the New York State Department of State (NYSDOS). This is beCause they have imposed a regional condition on Nationwide Permit No. 3 which limits repairs from storm damage to that which has occurred within one year of the date of'~such event. It is therefore recommended that you submit a completed Federal Consistency Assessment Form to NYSDOS. Once NYSDOS concurs that the proposals are consistent with the CZM Program of the State of New York, we expect to be able to confirm nationwide permit applicability. By copy of this letter, we are informing NYSDOS of our intentions in this matter. If you have any questions, please contact Ms. Denise Butts of my staff at (212) 264-3913. ~incerely, ', /Ja~es W. Haggerty ~ ' ef, Eastern Permits Section CF: NYSDOS Board Of $outhold Town Trustees SOUTHO.LD, NEW YORK PERMIT NO.. /"//~J'~. DATE: .....M.~y 2~ .!.996 ISSUED TO ...... Pursuan~ fo +he provisions of Chap{er 615 o{ {he Laws of +he Sfafe of New York, 1893; and ~apfer 404 of fha Laws of {he Sfafe o~ New York 1952; and +he Sou{hold Town Ordinance en- rifled "RE~U~TIN~ AND THE P~CIN~ OF OBSTRUCTIONS IN AND ON TOWN WATERS AND PUBLIC LANDS and RE~OVAL OF SAND, ~RAVEL OR OTHER MATERIALS FROM LANDS UNDER TOWN WATERS;" and in accordance wlfh {he Resolufion of The Board adopfed afa mae+lng held on J9 ~.~., and ~n consideraflon of fha sum o~ $ ~5~.0 pa~d by .................. O~ N.Y. and subie~ fo fha Terms and Condi+~ons lisfed on +he reverse side hereof, of Sou{hold Town Trusfees aufhorizes and permffs +he following: to ~e~c~, 2 exist~g 1lO' groins as per drawing dated 5/14/96. all in accordance wi{h ('he de{ailed speciflcaHons as presen+ed in {he originM'ing appllca{ion. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The said Board of Trusfees here- by causes ifs Corpora{e Seal fo be affixed, and {hese preseM's be subscribed by a ma[orify of {he sald Board as of {his Albe~t J. Krupsld, President Town Hall 53095 Main Road John Holzapfel, Vice President ~l P.O. Box 1179 :Jim King ~ Martin H. Gan'ell Southold, New York 11971 Peter Wenczel Telephone (516) 765-1892 Fax (516) 765-1823 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD May 23, 1996 John Geideman P.O. Box 416 East Marion, NY 11939 Re: James Manning SCTM 9117-10-10 Dear Mr. Geideman: The following action was taken by the Board of Town Trustees during its regular meeting held on May 22, 1996 regarding the above matter: WHEREAS, John Geideman on behalf of JAMES MANNING applied to the Southold Town Trustees for a permit under the provisions of the Wetland Ordinance of the Town of Southold, application dated March 25, 1996, and, WHEREAS, said application was referred to the Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council for their findings and recommendations, and WHEREAS, a Public Hearing was held by the Town Trustees with respect to said application on May 22, i996, at which time all interested persons were given an opportunity to be heard, and, WHEREAS, the Board me~ers have personally viewed and are familiar with the premises in question and the surrounding area, and, WHEREAS, the Board has considared all the testimony and documentation submitted concerning this application, and, WHEREAS, the structure complies with the standard set forth in Chapter 37-18 of the Southold Town Code, WHEREAS, the Board has determined that the project as'proposed will not affect the health, safety and general welfare of the people of the town, NOW TFIEREEOREBE IT, RESOLVED, that the Board of Trustees grant a Wetland Permit to replace 2 existing 110' groins as per drawing 5/14/96, and, BE IT FURT~EKRESOLVED that this determination should not be considered a determination made for any other Department or -Agency which may alse have an application pending for the same or similar project. Permit to construct project will expire two years from the date it is signed. Fees must be paid, if applics]~le, and permit issued within six months of the date of this notification. Two inspections are required and the Trustees are to be notified upon completion of said pro~ect. FEES: None. Very truly yours, Albert J. Krupski, Jr. President, Board of Trustees AJK/jmd cc: CAC P~coM/c Zec¢/'o~ /'t~o' J.H. GEIDEMAN ~ ~: .t >J- NEW YORK /~93 9- ¢/& ": , .~,~.::-:~.~ ............................................................................................ o& ~ ~a ~¢,'~¢ ~/,,, N.Y. S~te MC. L~d-Surveyor, ~ ~ 6 ~ I Y .~z w DEPARTMENT OF STATE ALBANY, NY ~223~-0001 May 7, 1996 Mx. J. H. Geideman, .PIS P.O. Box 416 East Marion, NY 11939 Re: F-96~235 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers/New York District Permit Applicafion-96-0309fL2 John & James Manning-Replace St~tn~amag~l Groins-Great Peconic Bay Town of Southold, Suffolk Count~ DEC #1-7438-01321/00001 Request for Additional Iuform~on Dear Mr. Geideman: Pursuant to 15 CFR 930.58,the following data and information is n~u~y to enable the Department of State to adequately assess the coastal zone effects of proposelI project Please provide photographs which doenment existing site condit5 amd upon whicl~ the location of the groins is outlined. Please compare the length of tl~/P°serl groin~ to those along the adjacent shore. New groins' exceeding the length of;a~- -coastal ~ gromsM.are/ikely to statue downddft areas of sand. In accordance with New Yort~h_ .~ anagement e ertects, if any, of the Program Policy//14 (policies enclosed), please discuss and ~ to adjacent shorelands. proposed groin replacements upon the littoral transport of s~ of the groins might need For example, the submitted drawing indicates that the upddfect this £fl[~ m/ght have to be filled. You should provide information indicating ~/red to fi//these ce//s. Also on the adjacent shoreline and how much material would ~ last two years during which please describe the extent of the erosion that has occurre the groins were not functional. :Y certification wi//begin after Pursuant to 15 CFR 930.60(a), the review of your cformation is adequate m assess we receive and determine that the necessary data coastal zone effects. Any additional information which you believe ~ ~tate our co~sismncy review of this project would be apprec/ated. A~ril 22, 1996 The CAC recommends disapproval because there is no need shown. Soundview Avenue, Southold Vote of Council: Ayes: All Motion carried. No. 1341 Moved by Robert Keith, seconded by Betty Wells, it was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees APPROVAL WITH PROVISIONS of the Wetland Application of JOHN LaFORCE 113-9-16 to construct a timber dock consisting of a 3' x 95' fixed elevated (~' above grade of marsh) walk; 32" x 20' hinged ramp; 6' x 20' float secured by (2) 2 pile dolphins. The Council recommends approval provided the dock does not exceed the neighbor's dock to the west nor interfere with navigation. 855 Home Pike Road, Mattituck Vote of Council: Ayes: All Motion carried. No. 13~2 Moved by Robert Keith, seconded by Bruce Loucka, it was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees APPROVAL WITH AN EXPLANATION of the Wetland Application of JOHN and JAMES MANNING 117-10-11 & 10 to replace four existing groins on beach damaged by storms, removing same and construction four new ones each 110' long from foot of upland bank. The Council normally does not recommend approval of groins however, it recommends approval for this project because it is an improvement over the current situation: 1. The high profile groins are being replaced by ~ow profile groins. 2. Reducing the number of groins from five (5) to four (~). 12~5 Jackson Street, New Suffolk Vote of Council: Ayes: All Motion carried. No. 13~3 Moved by Robert Keith, seconded by Allan Conne[I, it was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Board of Trustees APPROVAL WITH STIPULATIONS of the Wetland Application of HAROLD HEPENSTEIL 123-3-14 to construct an 88' x Lp raised catwalk; a D., x 1LP ramp; and a 6' x 20' floating dock. The Council recommends approval provided the project is shortened so the length does not exceed the the neighbor's dock to the north. 1055 Bungalow Lane, Mattituck Vote of Council: Ayes: All Page 2