HomeMy WebLinkAboutCAC-03/20/1987 cn7 Town Hall, 53095 Main Road
Q P.O. Box 1179
TELEPHONE �i�ol ®� Southold, New York 11971
(516)765-1801 r
SOUTHOLD TOWN
CONSERVATION ADVISORY COUNCIL
Regular Meeting
Friday, March 20, 1987.
The regular meeting of the Southold Town Conservation Advisory
Council was held Friday, March 20 , 1987 at 7 : 00 P.M. at the
Southold Town Hall, Main Road, Southold, New York.
Present were: Martin Garrell, Chairman
John Holzapfel, Member
John Tuthill, Member
Ralph Condit , Member -
Betty Wells , Member
Jeanne Marriner, Member
Heather Cusack, Member
Linda Cooper, Secretary
Also Present : Paul Stoutenburgh, Southold Town Councilman
The next regular meeting of the Southold Town Conservation
Advisory Council was scheduled for Thursday, April 23 , 1987
at 8: 00 P.M. at the Southold Town Hall. Group inspections
were scheduled for Thursday, April 23 , .1987 . Members will
meet at 3 : 00 P.M. at the Southold Town Hall.
DISTRIBUTION OF NEW APPLICATIONS
No. 509 - John Tuthill Inspection tDaniel and Irene McKasty)
Construct a private dock 70 ' long, 40 ' wide. 13220 Maine
Road, East Marion.
No. 510 - Group Inspection
James E. Fitzgerald, -Jr. , Pres. , Broadwaters Cove
Association, Inc. - Replace existing bulkheading,
return, and replace three existing pilings, bulkheading
March 10 , 1987 - Page 2
catwalk; add approximately 20 ' of open catwalk;
maintenance dredge docking area; add three floating
docks with four fingers . South side of east end
of Mason Drive, Cutchogue.
No. 511 - Ralph Condit Inspection - Alan Cardinale
Installation of new floats as per amended sketch
plan submitted to Council. Foot of Bridge Lane at
Nassau Point on Wunneweta Pond, Cutchogue.
No. 512 - Group Inspection - Michael M. and James B. Sueiro
Maintenance dredge 40 c.y. and install two 20 ' x
5 ' floating piers . Wiggins Lane, corner of Dawn
Drive , East Marion.
No. 513 - Group Inspection - Harold Reese
Clear property of brush, briars , and undergrowth
to be able to walk on property and provide access
to surveyors. Fronting Long Island Sound and Dam
Pond, East Marion.
No. 514 - Martin Garrell Inspection - Old Mill Inn
Repair existing bulkhead, install pilings for I-Beam,
install 4 pilings for deck and build deck. End of
West Mill Road, Mattituck.
No. 515 - Group Inspection - Christian B. Salminen
Addition of 16 ' x 20 ' deck, ground level and step
to East Marion Lake shoreline. 240 Lakeview Terrace,
East Marion.
No. 516 - Heather Cusack Inspection - Joseph Lestingi
Construct a stairway down facae of bluff fro access
from yard to beach. A 10 ' x 10 ' equipment storage
room will be attached at lower end of stairway.
1150 Sound Drive, Greenport .
REPORTS
Long Island Sound Study - Martin Garrell
The study has be very active and has turned up some very inter-
esting sidelights . The area in the western section lacking
oxygen is much deeper and larger than orginally expected.
An additional surprise was the discovery that the oysters are
carrying an extremely large amount of zinc. As a result of
the study, the Federal government may put guidelines on the
amouont of heavy metals in shellfish.
Group for the South Fork - Jeanne Marriner
The group formed to save Peconic Bay has been upset with the
lack of monetary support by Local, State or Federal Governments .
Thus far all funding has been going to Long Island Sound studies
and without support the Peconic Bay could die .
C_ 1
Marc ?0 , 1987 - Page 3
Riverhead CAC Meeting - Jeanne Marriner
Mrs . Marriner attended a regular meeting of the Riverhead CAC
and reported that the Council in Riverhead has a set of maps
with overlays . By utilizing the maps and overlays that Council
can determine the topography of an area to aid in the decision-
making process . The Riverhead Council faces the same problems
as Southold regarding the huge suge in building and the desire
to build on parcels which at one time were considered totally
unsuitable for building purposes.
Chairman Martin Garrell stated that he sould like to consult
with the Riverhead CAC regarding funding by the State CAC .
Southold Town Master Plan - Jeanne Marriner
Jeanne reported that the Souothold Town Board has been facing
pressure from the local marinas regarding the CAC ' s recommend-
ations for altering the Master Plan to include a Marine Recre-
ation designation. Martin Garrell advised Mrs Marriner to
continue to attend all Master Plan meetings .
At that time Councilman Paul Stoutenburgh explained his presence
at the meet.ip_g. He had been_:rfteet ftq with the town planner
Dave Emilita, Coucilman Penny and the marina owners to devise
a workable solution for the Marina Business/Marine Recreation
designation in the Master Plan. Through a series of compromises
they came up with a Marine I and II to separate marinas on
creeks from marinas established on large bodies of water, like
the bay. Councilman explained in detail the limited uses and
restrictions which would be placed upon marinas in creeks to
protect the creek waters and surrounding ares without hurting
the marinas financially.
APPLICATIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
On a motion made by Martin Garrell, seconded by Ralph Condit ,
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
of Wetland Application No. 489 submitted by Geddes Parsons
to construct a single family residence 55 ' from tidal marsh.
Approval is with the stipulations as per the letter from John
Thatcher, Fishers Island Conservancy.
West Harbor, Fishers Island.
Marc- 20 , 1987 - Page 4
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
On a motion made by John Tuthill, seconded by John Holzapfel,
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
of Wetland Application No.490 submitted by Peconic Associates
on behalf of Sal Prato to construct a 30 ' x .40 ' building and
a 30 ' x 50 ' fenced in storage area.
Kerwin Blvd. , Southold.
Vote of Council: Ayes: All
Motion carried.
On a motion made by John Holzapfel, seconded by John Tuthill
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
of Wetland Appllication No. 491 submitted by Nick Tsouris to
armour 125 ' of eroded Sound fron bluff with 3-4 ton rock .-.@,-
3 ton/lineal foot . Install core stone and filter cloth base
1 ' below MLW and 5 ' seaward of 3ton toe stone. Install 24 '
returns at each end of property. The Council recommends approval
but suggests the applicant work with the Southold Town Kenny' s
Beach Erosion Committee.
First house east of Kenny' s Beach, Southold.
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
On a motion made by Ralph Condit , seconded by Martin Garrell,
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
with conditions the Wetland Application No. 492 submitted by
Ralph Levy to place 3/4 gravel aat the area next to the creek
at a depth of 2" - 3" in an area 6 ' x 75 ' . The Council suggests
the permit be withheld until possible violations have been
rectified. (Upon inspection of the property it was discovered
that a 4" diameter hose was being used to drain water from
the driveway into the creek; also there is a deck being con-
structed but no permit is displayed. In addition there are
questions as to whether the dock on premised has been issued
a permit . )
885 Arshamomaque Avenue, Southold.
Vote of Council: Ayes: All
Motion carried.
On a motion made by Martin Garrell, seconded by Ralph Condit ,
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
of Wetland Application No. 493 submitted by En-Consultants ,
Inc. on behalf of Bernhard Peper to rebuild existing damaaged
dock of dimensions 4 ' x 32 ' ; fixed elevated ( 3 .5 ' above grade
or marsh) walkway; 4 ' x 12 ' hinged ramp; 6 ' x 20 ' floaat secured
by two 8" diameter pilings .
955 Lupton Point Road, Mattituck.
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
Marr, 20 , 1987 - Page 5
On a motion made by Martin Garrell, seconded by Ralph Condit ,
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
of Wetland Application No. 494 submitted by En-Consultants,
Inc, on behalf of Joan LaCaille to construct a timber dock
consisting,,-:df .:a A '- 12 ' fixed elevated ( 3 .5 ' above grade of
marsh) walk; 4 ' x 10 ' hinged ramp; two 4 ' x 20 ' floats with
a 6 ' x 20 ' outer "T" . Floats will be secured by 8" diameter
pilings .
1255 Waterview Drive, Southold.
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
On a motion made by Ralph Condit , seconded by John Tuthill,
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
of Wetland Appllication No. 495 submitted by Gull Pond Dawn
Corp. to construct a single family dwelling-, deck, sanitary
and/or well.
East side of Dawn Drive
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
On a motion made by Ralph Condit , Seconded by Heather Cusack
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
with stipulation Wetland Application No. 496 submitted by Deep
Hole Creek Association tomaintenance dredge a channel 180±
x 75± to 6 ' below MLW. Approximately 2000± c.y, of spoil will
be removed by dragline crane and deposited on beach above MHW.
The Council approves if the spoil is placed on east side of
beaach.
Deep Hole Creek, Mattituck.
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
On a motion made by Martin Garrell, seconded by Ralph Condit ,
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
of Wetland Application No. 497 submitted by the Land Use Co.
on behalf of Nicholas Micciche to construct a 3 ' x 30 ' catwalk
leading to a 3 ' x 16 ' ramp leading to a 5 ' x 40 ' float dock.
260 Oak Street , Cutchogue,
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
On a motion made by Martin Garrell, seconded by Ralph Condit ,
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
of Wetland Application No. 498 submitted by Dana Fox to con-
struct a dock, floating platform and walk.
305 Private Road, ( 2500 ROW) opposite Deer Road, Mattituck.
Vote of Council: Ayes: All
Motion carried.
Marc' 20 , 1987 - Page 6
On a motion made by John Tuthill, seconded by Martin Garrell,
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
with stipulations Wetland application No. 499 submitted by
Henry Stasiukiewicz to build a new home and add 150 yd. of
fill tolivel depression on property. The Council approves
with the stipulation that the applicant leave a 35 ' natural
vegetaation buffer between house nad creek.
Cases Lane Ext . , Cutchogue,
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
On a motion made by John Holzapfel, seconded by Ralph Condit ,
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the southold Town Trustees approval
with qualifications of Wetland Application No 500 submitted
by Anthony and Carolyn R. Leggio to register terracing and
landscaping. The Council approves but suggests the Trustees
withhold the permit pending any possible penalties for completing
work without any attempt at obtaining the proper permits .
2300 Glenn Road, Southold.
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
On a motion made by John Tuthill, seconded by Ralph Condit ,
it was
RESOEV.ED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
of Wetland Application No. 501 submitted by Charles Bowman
to creatae two 3acre lots and construct a single family dwelling
and sanitary system on eaach. Approximately 2500 c.y. of fill
will be installed at the site to raise the grade for flood
plain and SCDHS requirements . applicant also proposes to install
two fixed docks leading to ramps and floatsper submitted plans .
Main Bayview Road, Southold.
Vote of Council: Ayes : John Tuthill, John Holzapfel
Nays: Jeanne Marriner, Ralph Condit , Martin
Garrell, Heather Cusack, Betty Wells
MOTION LOST
On a motion made by Ralph Condit , seconded by John Holzapfel,
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town trustees disapproval
of Wetlands Application No. 501 submitted by Charles Bowman
to ( see above ) . The Council cannot approve the application
as submitted but would suggest the application be amended to
allow one house onthe northerly parcel. The Council totally
disapproves of the house on the southerly parcel.
Main Bayview Road, Southold
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
✓ Maarc,- ?0 , 1987 - Page 7
On a motion made by Heather Cusack, seconded by Ralph Condit ,
it ws
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Tpown Trustees approval
with stipulation of Wetland Application No. 502 submitted
by the Land Use Company on behalf Anthony Gambino to construct
a 30 ' x 50 ' single family dwelling plus attached decks a minimum
of 60 ' landward of high marsh. Install a samotaru system a
minimum of 100 ' landward of high marsh, and install a well.
The Council recommends approval with the stipulation that the
applicantleave a 35 ' natrual vegetation buffer between the
house and marsh.
Lupton Point Road, Mattituck,
Vote of Council: Ayes: All
Motion carried.
On a motion made by Martin Garrel, seconded by Ralph Condit ,
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
of Wetland Application No. 503 submitted by En-Consultants ,
Inc. on behalf of Cleaves Point Village Condo Association to
construct 607± l.f, of low profile timber retaining wall plus
15 ' return on west side and 30 ' return on east side. Back
fill with 400± c.y, of clean sand and loam to be trucked in
form commercial upland source. Wall will be above spring high
water.
Shipyard Lane, Greenport .
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
of Wetland Application No. 504 submitted by Port of Egypt
Enterprises , Inc.to place two floating timber dock: 1 . 5 '
x100 ' with eight 3 ' x 20 ' finger docks ; 2 . 5 ' x 60 ' with five
3 ' x 20 ' finger docks .
-Main Road, Southold--"-
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
of Wetland -AppYlication No. 505 submitted by En-Consultants ,
Inc. on behalf of Louis Sulich to construct a timber dock consisting
of a 4 ' x 100 ' fixed elevated ( 4 ' avoce grade of marsh) walk;4 '
x 12 ' hinged ramp; 6 ' x 20 ' float secured by two 10" diameter
pilings .
Broadwaters Road, Cutchogue.
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
of Wetland Application No. 506 submitted by En-Consultants,
Inc. on behalf of Philip Salice to construct a timber dock
consiting of a 4 ' x 40 ' (with additional 4 ' x 4 ' offset at
outer end) fixed elevated walk extending form existing bulkhead;
4 ' x 16 ' hinged ramp; 6 ' x 50 ' floaat oriented N-S and two
6 ' x 30 ' floats oriented E-W to vorm "V" . Dock over area behind
existing bulkhead ( 30 ' x 99 .5" ) and construct a 12 ' x 15 ' gazebo.
Bayview Avenue,Mattituck
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
Marra`-'20 , 1987 - Page 8
On a motion made by Ralph Condit , seconded by Heather Cusack,
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
with stipulations Wetland Application No. 507 submitted by
The Land Use Company on behalf of Jerry Bady to install three
mooring npiles as per supplied plans and to maintenance dredge
a 20 ' x 45 ' area to 6 ' at MLW with approximately 88 c.y. of
resultant spoil to be disposed of at a suitabel upland disposal
site. The Council recommends approval with the stipulation
that there be no dredgeing. Also the CAC suggests the Trustees
withold the permit until appropriate action has been taken
regarding the work already completed without first obtaining
the proper permits .
1775 Calves Neck Road, Southold.
Vote of Council: Ayes: All
Motion carried.
On a motion made by Martin Garrell, seconded by Ralph Condit ,
it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees approval
of Wetland Application No. 508 submitted by The Land Use Company
on behalf of William Horstmann to resheath approximately 164 '
of timber bulkhead. Also to extend the return located at the
east end of the bulkhead an additional 4 ' landward.
Little Peconic Bay Blvd. , Southold.
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
DISTRIBUTION OF NEW APPLICATIONS
No. 509 - Daniel and IreneMcKasty - John Tuthill inspection.
No. 510 - JamesN.E.,, Fit.zgerald, Jr. , Pres . , Broadwaters Cove
..,. ,. ,. wAssbat' ori,,",Ic. - Group inspection.
No. R'd - Alan Cardinale. - Ralph Condit inspection.
No. 512 - Michael M. and James B. Sueiro - Group inspection.
No. 513 - Harold. Reese ---Group inspection.
No. 514 - Old Mill Inn - Martin Garrell inspection.
No. 515 - Christian B. Salminen - Group inspection.
No. 516 - Joseph Lestingi - Heather Cusack inspection.
There being no further business to come before the Council,
on a motion made by John Tuthill, seconded by Martin Garrell,
it was resolved to adjourn at 9 :45 P.M.
Respectfully submitted,
Linda J. Cooper, Secretary