HomeMy WebLinkAboutCAC-06/13/1989 oc��FFO(��0
s
tC=l� Town Hall, 53095 Main Road
P.Q. Box 1179
TELEPHONESouthold, New York 11971
.(516)765-1801
SOUTHOLD TOWN
CONSERVATION ADVISORY COUNCIL
TUESDAY, JUNE 13, 1989
A meeting of the Southold Town conservation Advisory council was
held Tuesday, June 13, 1989 at the Southold Town Hall, Main Road,
Southold, New York.
Present were: John Holzapfel, Chairman
. Daniel Kujawski, Member ,
MargaretcFeeney, Member
Stephen Angell, Member
Bruce Loucka, Member
John Tuthill, Member
Betty Wells, Member
Linda Cooper, Secretary
The meeting was called to order at 5:05 P.M. by Chairman John Holzapfel.
RECOMMENDATION OF WETLAND APPLICATIONS
No. 728
On a motion by John Holzapfel, seconded by Daniel Kujawski, it
was
REOSLVED to recommend to the -Southold .Town Trustees APPROVAL WITH
STIPULATIONS of Wetland Application No. 5-14-89-118-2-11.2 submitted
by the Lagoon Association to maintenance dredge bulkhead to the
lagoon to continue free. tidal flowand safe passage- for small boats .
Spoil to be placed north of inlet to 'provide beach nourishment .
The CAC approves the dredging however., itquestions the necessity
or reasonableness of the excavation which could create problems
with the downdrift .
Lagoon at Nassau Point , Cutchogue.
Vote of Council: Ayes: All
Motion carried.
N6. 729
On a motion by Bruce Loucka, seconded by John Tuthill, it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees APPROVAL .of
Wetland- Apglicat!on No 5-9-89-90_4=14submitted by Joseph Spitaliere
to--'construct- a 4 ' - x 30.1 catwalk- (elevated 4 ' over IM) ; a 3 ' x 8 '
ramp; and 6 ' x 20 ' float .
Orchard Lane, Southold.
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
Page 2
No. 730
On a motion by Bruce Loucka, seconded by John Tuthill, it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees APPROVAL of
Wetland Application No. 5-10-89-90-4-19 submitted by Joseph Spitaliere
to construct a 4 ' x 60 ' catwalk (elevated 4 ' over existing marsh) ;
3 ' x 8 ' ramp; and 6 ' x 20 ' float .
Orchard Lane, Southold.
Vote of Council: Ayes: All
Motion carried.
No. 731
On a motion by Daniel Kujawski, seconded by Bruce Loucka, it was
RESOLVVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees DISAPPROVAL
of Wetland Application No. 5-13-89-57-1-33 submitted by Barbara
Burke to 120 ' retaining wall above SHW and attached corners of
adjacent retaing walls; approximately 200 c.y. of clean fill to
be trucked in for backfill. The CAC recommends disapproval because
no need is shown; there is no evidence of erosion; and there is
thriving vegetation.
1150 Blue Marlin Drive, Southold.
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
No. 732
On a motion by Stephen Angell, seconded by Daniel Kujawski, it
was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees DISAPPROVAL
of Wetland Application No. 5-11-89-35-8-5 .3 submitted by Peter
Fakiris to maintenance dredge a 90 ' x 100 ' docking area to 8 ' at
MLW; resultant spoil (approximately 675 c.y. ) to be disposed of
on applicant ' s upland property. The CAC recommends disapproval
because the dredging would have a defilious effect on the clams
and bottom organisms and no need is shown . The project would be
creating a "pothole" effect on the bottom.
ROW off Shipyard Lane, East Marion.
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
No. 733
On a motion by Stephen Angell, seconded by Margaret Feeney, it
was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees APPROVAL WITH
CONDITIONS of Wetland Application No. 5-2-89-56-6-7 submitted by
Armando Cappa to install floating docks for six ( 6 ) boats to be
used for restaurant patron docking ( seasonal only) . The CAC recommends
approval with the condition the applicant adjust the plans to reflect
that the project will stay in line with others and not be out in
the dredged channel. The CAC would also like to suggest the applicant
not put in grass to the edge of the bulkhead, the council suggests
the applicant plant natyural vegetation. This would be a perfect
opportunity to show the public what should be done in a bulkheaded
area.
Old Main Road, Southold.
r
Page 3
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
No. 734
On a motion by Stephen Angell, seconded by John Tuthill, it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees APPROVAL of
Wetland Application No. 5-12-89-139-10-25 submitted by Ali Agarabi
to install a new catwalk, ramp and dock.
365 West View Drive, Mattituck.
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
No. 735
On a motion by Margaret Feeney, seconded by Stephen Angell, it
was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees APPROVAL of
Wetland Application No. 5-8-89-123-8-24 . 1 submitted by Frederick
A. Ross to construct a 100 ' x 4 ' fixed dock. The CAC recommends
.APPROVAL WITH THE STIPULATIONS that the dock go out no further
than the neighboring docks and not the proposed 100 ' ; also the
catwalk should be elevated 4 ' above the grade of the marsh.
Bungalow Lane , Mattituck,
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
No. 736
On a motion by Margaret Feeney, seconded by Bruce Loucka, it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees APPROVAL of
Wetland Application No. 5-71-2-11. 1 submitted by James Campbell
to construct and place at a bulkheaded mooring lot a 6 ' x 20 ' float
and 3 ' x 10 ' ramp for use by small pleasure boat .
350 Harbor Lights Drive, Southold.
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
No. 737
On a motion by Daniel Kujawski, seconded by Bruce Loucka, it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees APPROVAL of
Wetland Application No. 5-6-89-70-13-20 . 1 submitted by Douglas
Rose to build and float an attached dock to existing piles and
residential bulkhead. (4 ' x 10 landing; 3' x 12 ' ramp; 6 ' x 20 '
float ) .
Kimberly Lane, Southold.
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
No. 738
On a motion by John Tuthill, seconded by Daniel Kujawski, it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees APPROVAL of
Wetland Application No. 6-1-89-35-5-33 submitted by Rhoda Weston
to add a 4 ' x 5 ' platform; a 3 ' x 10 ' ramps; and 6 ' x 20 ' float
.e
Page 4
to an existing bulkhead.
450 Snug Harbor Road, Greenport .
Vote of Council: Ayes : All
Motion carried.
No. 439
The Council did not have an opportunity to inspect Wetland Appllication
No. 6-2-89-7-5-4 . 1 submitted by Mrs . George de Menil to renovate
an existing garage/apartment by constructing 800 s .f, wood frame
addition on sono tube piers . No excavation to be done except for
piers .
Fishers Island, New York.
No. 740
The Council did not have an opportunity to inspect Wetland Application
No. 6-3-89-3-7-5 submitted by Mrs . W. G. Rafferty to renovate existing
garage/apartment and construct 400 s .f, addition. No excavation
except piers and new septic system.
Middle Farms Pond, Fishers Island.
TABLED AT MAY MEETING
No. 718
Wetland Application No. 4-9-89-78-4-15 of John O'Hagan to construct
a private single dock, catwalk and mooring. The CAC will still
continue to TABLE the applications until it receives clarification
regarding the ownership of land.
Foot of Corey Creek Lane, Southold.
No. 719
On a motion by Margaret Feeney, seconded by Stephen Angell it was
RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold 'Town Trustees DISAPPROVAL
of Wetland Application No. 4-13-89-56-6-11 of William Geraghty
to fill and grade approximately 9000c.y. fo clean fill to complete
filling of parcels to LIRR embandment . The CAC has determined
the area contains marsh and applicant proposes to fill the marsh
area.
Main Road, Southold
Vote of Council: Ayes : Margaret Feeney, Stephen Angell, John
Holzapfel, Daniel Kujawski, Burce Loucka,
Betty Wells
Nays: John Tuthill - Feels the disapproval is
"a wasate of time, won't
do anybody any good to
disapprove" .
Motion carried.
Page 5
Since the meeting started late and due to the number of applications
which had to be discussed it was decided that the CAC would hold
a special meeting to cover items on the agenda which the Council
did not have an opportunity to discuss.
NEST MEETING DATE
The next meeting of the CAC was scheduled for June 20, 1989 at
4 : 30 P.M. at the Southold Town Hall.
The meeting was adjourned at 6 :35 P.M.
Respectfully submitted,
4'-w"'
F &5-�
Linda J. Cooper
CAC Secretary