Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1000-109.-5-14.45 OFFICE LOCATION: �*0f SD(/Ty0 MAILING ADDRESS: Town Hall Annex P.O. Box 1179 54375 State Route 25 Southold, NY 11971 (cor. Main Rd. &Youngs Ave.) Southold, NY 11971 G Telephone: 631 765-1938 LOCAL WATERFRONT REVITALIZATION PROGRAM TOWN OF SOUTHOLD MEMORANDUM To: Glenn Goldsmith, President Town of Southold Board of Trustees From: Mark Terry, Assistant Town Planning Director LWRP Coordinator Date: April 16, 2021 Re: Local Waterfront Coastal Consistency Review for JAMES & PHYLLIS RUBIN SCTM# 1000-109-5-14.45 Jeffrey Patanjo'on behalf of JAMES& PHYLLIS RUBIN requests"a' Vl/etland Permit to construct a proposed 215 linear foot long natural stone boulder border along the landward side of existing wetlands to prevent salt water intrusion during storm tides; during construction a silt fence will be installed between the proposed stone and the existing wetlands and remain until area is stabilized; 40 cubic yards of clean sand fill will be placed landward of the proposed stone and the disruption area will be planted with non-fertilizer depended grass seed; and for the removal of existing catwalk and replacement in same location a proposed 4' wide x 32' long fixed catwalk; all decking to be thru-flow and all work to be performed from an upland location. Located: 745 Cases Lane Extension, Cutchogue. SCTM# 1000-109-5-14.45 . The proposed action has been reviewed to Chapter 268, Waterfront Consistency Review of the Town of Southold Town Code and the Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP) Policy _ Standards. Based upon the information provided on the LWRP Consistency Assessment Form submitted to this department, as well as the records available to me, it is my recommendation that the action for the removal of existing catwalk and replacement in same location a proposed 4' wide x 32' long fixed catwalk is INCONSISTENT with the policy standards and therefore is INCONSISTENT with the LWRP. 1. A permit for the existing dock was not located in Laserfiche files. Chapter 275. Wetlands and Shoreline requires that No new docks will be permitted over vegetated wetlands or such that it causes habitat fragmentation of vegetated wetlands in the following areas: Downs Creek, Hallocks Bay, Hashamomuck Creek and Pond, Long Creek(branch of Mattituck Creek, East of Grand Avenue bridge), Pipe's Cove Creek and West Creek. A dock is defined as Any permanent or seasonal structure, except a building, located or proposed to be located on lands abutting or comprised of freshwater or tidal wetlands or connected to a bulkhead or the upland and extending over the water's surface, designed to secure vessels and provide access from the shore to a body of water. For the purpose of this chapter, this term shall also include the associated structures necessary to cross wetlands and adjacent natural areas. The term "dock" includes the terms "wharves," "piers," "fixed docks," "docks,"or "floats." Pursuant to Chapter 268, the Board of Trustees shall consider this recommendation in preparing its written determination regarding the consistency of the proposed action. Cc: Damon Hagan, Assistant Town Attorney 4 ED Town of Souhold �� L' P C�DI�tS�S�`�Clt ASSESSlO�I�T APR 0 5 2021 �Soutnaid Town A. INSTl��T2�i'IONS Planning Board 1. All applic M for penoiits* including Town of Southold agencies, shall. complete this CCAF for proposed actions that are subject to the Town of Southold WatmbMt Consisftey review Law. This assessment is minded to supplemcnt other intforma$ion used by a Town of Southold ageney in meldng a of consistency_ except minor-exempt actions including Building Permits and other ministatal permitsnvtlocated wWW the Coastal BvdonHaWdArea. 2. Before answering the questions in Section C, the preparer of this form should review the exempt uainor action last,policies and explanations of each policy contained in the Town of Southold Local Waterfront ReNitalization pjogmm. A.la-''oaction will be evaluated. as to its sib tial e u ecoa , , . 'rh. all o oldT 3. this form is answered "yes"or"no",then the proposed aodon will WRP policy standards and conditions contained in the oonvstenoy r m ® n dei tb a d mous --be certified as consistent with the LWRP policy standards and taken. le in the following places:online at the'flown of Southold's �_�,,,��, , rl .nef),the Board of Tivst s Office, the Planning Department, all local libraries and the Town Clerk's office. Bo DIES ON OF SUZ AND PROPM ED AMON SC's 1 og_ _______- / •�l� PROJE CT NAM -7 y s' s eS C4E x T — �. 't-e-4 The Application hu been subffi*ed to(dmk appropriate response)° Tovm Boara ❑ pkmdng Board❑ BuRding DepIL ❑ BOWd of`fli es 1. Category of Town of Soudiold agency action(check appropriate response): (a) Action undedaken directly by Town agency 04 capital ❑ construcdon,pig actively,agency regulation,land transaction) ❑ (b) Financial assistance(e.g.grant,loan,subsidy) (e) hermit,approval,license,c d ca#ion: NW=and extent of action. / F Location of action: q S e,� Site acreage: / • 2�J Framitlanduse.- PfftMtZDnWg classMOVAon: &S I If an application for the proposed anion has been filed with Ow Town of Southold agency, the Mowing mon shall be provided: (a) Mame of applicant: ��►M e S * P 1►I //ts n (b) lvlailing address: 7 4 5- Ca Sts ton e. ¢x T. (c) Telephone numbm Area Code� ) G 31 • $y• ��-7q (d) Applicafion number,if ax►:_ Will the acdonnbe directly underWmn,regWm fiw4ing,or approval by a state or federal agency? El acATo U If yes,which state or federat agency?n1`1 SD 4s.D pD p S C. Evaluate the project to the following policies by analy3bg how the project wM farther support or tot support the policies. Provide all proposed Best iidawgement Practices that vM ffan her each poMq. Incomplete answers will require that the form be returned for completioz. IDRVEL FM g AST Policy 1. Poster a paftm of d welopmwt in the Yawn of Southold dust mases communhy dmneftir, preserves opera space,makes efclent me of inftstmcharer makw beaefieW use of a coasW flotation,2ad Mintnbes adverse effects of developiamt. See LWRP Section M—Fe es;Page 2 for evalvatten Witerh. [�rYes ❑ No [3 Not AppNeable P��t�e-E rv►•te�t'S f'���a��� �+�,�- �S Co�+Srstt.,,t a.�e-� _P®1 �c�.�� A90h addtt=d sheds if aeceesMy Policy 2. Protect and presem historic and haeo iWl ruourm of the Town of SouthoR& Sae L� -{ Seedon M—�-Pondes Wages S tbrouO 6 for evaluation edter� U 'Yes 1:1 ro �l Not Applicable Iv Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 3. E®haace vbusl quaff and proted sunk resources tbroughoat the Twa of Soaathel& See L' Rp,Swdon M—Polieies Pages 6 through 9 for"untion critearla �Yw ❑ Na ❑ Not Applicable Qravee,+ Provc S oi, +�tS A. AoRea.lir2 Attach edditiond sheen if*C89=7 NATURAL COAST PCLICM Policy 4. Mnimke los of life, st metres, and anaftral mourm from fioofflmg and erosion. See L VIIk Sectfou M—Policies Pages 8 through 16 for evaluation criterla Yes ❑ No ❑ Not Applicable PrV tye--Fs e. 4 Attach addif3onal sheets if necossary P01S$q 5. profact and improve water qwffity and supply in the Town of$quthold.See LWRP Section M —Policies Dago 16 through Zl for evalaadon w1brk ❑ Yes ❑ No E riot App&mble Attach additional sheets ifnecessary Polley 6. Pa'otect and restore the clualW arad � o �fta Town of Southold NOSYstenm 1md"dh'9 See� Sectio M�Policies;Pages�& Siggifi�t Coastal Fish and Wildlife Eaibitsts through 32 for evaluation Oteris. ❑ ❑ E�K Yes No Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy 7. Protect and improve air quality in the Town of Southold. See LWRP Section H1 — Policies Pages V through 34 for evaluation criteria. E] Yes No[Z Not Applicable Attach additional sheets if necessary Policy S. Minimize environmental degradation in Town of Southold from solid waste and hazardous substances and wastes. See LWRP Section M—Policies; Pages 34 through 38 for evaivatiou criteria. El Yes Q No u Not Applicable MLIC COAST POLICIES Policy 9. Provide for public access tos and recreational use of, coastal waters, public lands, and public resources of the Town of Southold. See yLWRP Section in—Policies; Pages 38 through 46 for evaluation criteria. Ef Yer-1 No D Not Applicable f d 1t P�- rI vl fQ�S va �4: /t frefSS � l�f?OI t'C/Zs � T��lL�A'O�oN 6tC t'fyl �� Attach additional sheets if necessary WOPJQNG COAST POUCM Follcy 10. Protect Southold's water-dependent uses and promote slag of new water-dependent arcs in nitable iocotions. See LVW Semon M—Policies;Pmes 47 through 56 for evaluation eriterls. Q Yes [I iqo 2 riot Applcabie :C ate Attach additional Sheets if necessary Poliq 11. l nmate sustainable vu of RvIng marine resources in Lozg Fsland Sound, the Pecenic E tuaq and Town waters.See LWRP Seetion M—Policies;Wages 57 througb 62 for evaluaflon crjterI& (� 9 ❑rtes F1tJ lei. .o$Applicable Mach additional sheets If aecamy policy n. Pruett agricultural hinds in the Town of Southold. See LVMP Section ffi—Policies;Pages 62 t}mugh 65 for evaluation eriteria. El ya M No E"Not Applicable ✓�0 e�t G Attach additional amW Naeaessary PoMcy 13. Pu° mote appropriate use and development of emery and mbeM MOWN& See LWRP Sermon M—77 pone 63 througin 60 for elation eriftrim. D yez M i�To 110t Appliiabb P A D �� • ra`�-�rL 'SL]g �, DATL+ 1 -af 5URVEY OF PROPERTY SIT,UAT�:� CUTTCHO}&U� {� TOWN: SOl1 1 T"7L/L1� vD R p OR EOR d — SU�OLK GOUNTY, NY GET MERLr E 1 q7A plNLENNC oF, 1 SURVEYED JAN. 26, 2010 NOOD FEB 1 6j2021 5117E DATA AUG. 12, 2010 i SUFFOLK COUNTY TAX # `—S6 thold°Town; S 1000 - IOq - 5 - 14.45 I Board of Trustees, CER7ZFMD TO: Oq� P1[7L LUS RUBI i / 1\ x��__CHArN L`=�lCp 3-93.00, z r��1 ; ♦__\ \t ♦ f +�. 1 = f ---------------------------.._-_ / 1 r ' �, �' '' I Ir LAWN '♦ ------WOODED -' ,'�'rf I,/'— �l j , D(1 `•..�/�,s' 14.7' / ` �' _ ` +. / , "+J 25TH I / , ,� ♦'� +`+ ��It I / Il, If ♦,�' yLANNJW /// 40 Ur '� 'ALD1TfG/ 1 t 4 1 +�- ♦` � �� Pte" rr -�� � + 1 +.1 1 .` y �- ,�/ I� � +r1 / ONDId 53 ♦ r _` ^; , /, .ate / �♦ 'may � 737'30,Z 50 37'3 Q� SM DATA: cssct�riwr ADS& LarCOVIMCI : PROPERTY: 75.120 S.F. BUILDABLE LAND MINUS WETLANDS/POND 50,370 S.F. 1003 NOTESz EXISTING HOUSE 2,907 S.F. 4.81% y EXISTING DECK 447 S.F. 0.70 k Okv OR R TOTAL EXISTING LOT COVERAGE 3,354 S.F. S.SS% EN J SRM 1M� kl off; •Yuutreuea a�motm.m wales,!a a an„ey r`NOiy1�-D DRAINAGE 5Y5TEM GALGULATION5: -%.t—1` tioosm iii o PIPE FOUND PROPOSED HOUSE 6 SCREEN POACH 446 S.F. 0.74SY �•+`EgZ $ trcr.Y-kstataea.a�rm.• PAOPOSEa DECK 66 S.F. 0.14% ADDITION ROOF AREA, 447� sq. ft. qvy co we ira ,ne cr lo,we awva�J'TAKE FOUND TOTAL PROPOSED LOT COVERAGE 532 S.F. 0.88% 447 5q Ft. X O 7 = 76 cu. Ft. OF iVZW 76 Cu. t./42.2 = l.6 vertical ft. Of V dla. Ieachln pool required "=a peO eoa emu ro cennue.ea to ua vm!° copes' ELEVATION REFERENCE NGVD '2q DATUM TOTAL PROPOSED AND EXISTING LOT COVERAGE 3.885 S.F. 6.43% Q'„ Ef� Q PROVIDE(l) 8' dla• X 2' DEEP 5TORM DRAIN POOL �r='Beat ma ret owa+e aan ekp iy tree tkb ' em..o-,nea-1=. a a aae aeaeo tno ex- ?Y.Ng Coco of Rdctice fm Lord 5v Padopted ry o�irtl 6�i. Ymk male ADeeebt3,of .eloeaL Gr eycra,eaa carellkolk�etnU res my FLOOD ZONE A5 ANNOTATED FROM FEMA a.a.v,HO eelee t0 tb 1Rb«a•ej�vminiat- FLOOD ZONE MAP NO. 36103GOI63H Area = 15,120 S. F. Qr ,r �1 ela+e as tet,reaNmoWe to aadntena,emtnvucm Area - 1.1245 AGreS ® i i"^i;" ' ' P 6 K ��•,� :i �1 'I ' !j I' 1 I• l� {'t:t i j-,.F,r"'_ GRAPHIC SCALE I"= 40' PeTLAND i=LAGS TIED TO B/4GGHARI5, BUSH BY SURVEYOR LA Sv 6 EAST MAUI STREET - - N.Y.S.1✓IC.N0. 50202 JAN. 26, 2010 AS LIMIT OF HIGH MARSH AIAIEPIMA;D,N.Y. 11901 369-8288 Fax 369-8287 ' REF.—C:\Documents and Setdn9s\0wnei\My DocumentsUMy Dropbox\10\10-106 ml h improJements.pro ;ti t ( z}Yii ..t�: 2 + Photo 1 (11/20) y I Photo 2 (11/20) Sk PL Photo 3 (11/20) ll Ri ^T'_r - !` Y k Photo 4 (11/20 _ n � m b q. e f• f .; W :.'. SEE SM NO.102 - 12D n wwma ♦ to Nal x 1L WTCII---�_-_ ---_--7Z-_-- UN FOR PCL NOL - 12-7 1� ♦ 0 ♦ ]2 _ - SERE SEG NO. - n 72 24.4 191 Y 102-04-006.1 ta'�A p •' ` '�'i e zt w 1 i0c� 1 w flwwloFaamnu J w I• 15.6 16 • www 0 00 11 OEFaOwBlr6lfXIV w \! 123. A i a '.6 ' 1.a 7.5 O y0 w 55A w ' 7l2 � 122 11.6 1>•• 2Wa pA NI�r' ,...a '`o\ w w -6 2' w ♦6 Y 10 93 20 121 .V'' 6,1 H>5 ©i 1 ♦ f0A I o 1, ° e I ua m 1111 w3 o. 12Na PEOOErClND7EU6L 64C - 4 7 ♦11 n �•� 6622A • t.]Ahl Ewe zr2 I tau to I m a w. . - 11�OIAIb69901p0 .. � 4 � 6 64" tAVal ♦ � . bN6R61I16WA •' ,' 4 0 I n HA H30 w ♦t2 p9' II s , A m N . I i a 14MA ♦u 6 27.1 i w 145 w � 10 Jri _ -4. w' H31 wI E 24 1�yyc1 18' G71 ..I,a cEOAPS u tTNa �TM wp: xw 2 20 as -.- .',p1 �• 4o eaaA - l -c, - Hao A t r _ C) u7 N39 16.5 t.W21 �,. • - 1 a: 21 r .. 01,801111,OID 61M . Z3 A > HTS A Kl aBb19 (}Ofwbdw06 21 n .e zb 27 1418 ■. �-\- tN�ow164r tttxq t,�9 14.9 210 ta... 241 _ _ 1427 .` 2b 1.20, 1.0 A H10 1. MI000 WY am 14.45 -■1 ♦ p2{2 ' I14M d IC. 1.7AIa220 103 14.11 CIA !A m1 A r 'I / •/ I c M n l ttE 2 w ae a 1425 1'.. ! j 2 6.7 35.4A(G) 3e F A.i 1M w 7 (Q A H.12 l0A[c� s 2U I I I gT i d ten - / MO. w 224 m H24 j s I I D.5Nq �f10MMOF Olnn't A 14.114032 14 w 14.Q oAB.w6.r/ ♦ , A :a -A(0 2b ♦A 210 w a as 1.1Nc) d i II Z E s.7Nq z� 231 ' IE 11.7N`) N GEEN WAY S 71 OnIewOE A ,.,A ee w .'i _ ].1 - 2m w 14.19 14.19 ac. �9cN1P y A 12A 40 I 264 \ •. � 0 210 S p4_' �,w 1416 i NaEw . (• I I � _ H3] IIJ C 2,,, A w CLAW I ♦ 3. 69 - 1.]Alq vccconcvrn , _ I ,\. �..•\.1 _ ' S ,aunt as e 9 �[• m ♦ _ n a9.O NOTE: J/(a AH OVERIM CONDfipN E%I5159Ef1N®) I '� 2 n / PAliCEl5109O&9.419.BANO 15 FDR PCE.NO. + roa xLNo. - YLnt n 1.tA ♦I 1SEE 1641 NO. 11601-001] SEE SEG NG 1+e®40+. x w t.1Nq tltVO,-0WS 1 - . * ----- �-- ---_ .LINE IMTCH �--- � U11E .. am SSG x0.,16 SEE SEC,.116 -- -- �•• -- -- °p""" er NOTICE COUNTY OF SUFFOLK © x lid717WLO SECTION NO E " '.-�. ..-.-'-.- � •_.,� :. .:, �� �� Real Property Tax Service Agency v §'�S _ - a � _ _ �.^ir R-w1.�•. limo- Y'- ... ti ,. .. .,-, _ 32' PRINTER 215 LF OF NATURAL STONE BOULDERS PLACED NOTE THE MAXIMUM QUANTITY OF STONE TO BE PLACED n IN INTERLOCKING PATTERN APPROXIMATELY 1'TO 2' HIXxR U PROPOSED 4'WIDE x 32' LONG FIXED CATWALK W/FILTER FABRIC BACKING TO PREVENT SALT WATER FROM IS 2.5 TONS PER LINEAL FOOT W/THRU—FLOW DECIONG ON ENTIRE STRUCTURE ENTERING PROPERTY DURING STORM TIDES PROPOSED ROCK WAIL,SEE OfA7L THIS SNEET PROPOSED SILT FENCE EMBEDDED 6' PROP06ED GWIDE PROPOSED 6'X6'CCA POSTS PROPOSED 40 CY CLEAN SAND FEL W/4'TOPSOL PRIOR TO START OF CONSTRUCTION AND AND NON—FERTILIZER DEPENDENT GRASS SER MIXTURE. UNTIL FINAL STABILIZATION 6 OOAPLETED DOM GRADE PROPOSED GRADT FEB 16 2021 � UMTS OF TIDAL wERAEIDs AS DELINEATED BY :: JOHN C. EMERS L.S.ON JANUARY 28. 2010 //\/j// \ 1' _ 2' t ::\ ::\ : :: :� \..\.:... . Southold Town Board of Trustees APPROXIMATE N H.w. EL z St AFPF40NU TE M.H.W. EL 2.5* �MLW APPRDbMATE M Lw El oot PROPOSED SILT FABRIC UND1tF �.//\ /\ \ / //\j\\ \ \///// \`/\\> \\ \ \ \ij\j \` \/ / / \� \\ / /\� PROPOsm SIL7 FABRIC LNJDER /i\//\ \ \` \ /\�/\/\\\� / E1 K Il MH OF Roar `/ j/� CATWALK TYPICAL SECTION ROCK WALL TYPICAL SECTION N.T.S. N.T.S. Wo OD SAY Sall Air farm It/ - N/0/F BRIDGET CAREY & ATA DINLENC _ ®Cedars Gulf Club -� , .745 Case;Lane _�� CIO EXI5TNIG EDGE OF CLEARING LINE i EXISTING FLOOD ZONE SEPARATION UNE Nunh Fork Cuontr {� v . t•Y PROPOSED LIMITS OF GROUND DISRUPTION PROPOSED 40 CY CLEAN SAND FILL W/4'TOPSOIL / W ANDNON—FERTRZEEND R DEPENDENT GRASS SEED MIXTURE. L , PROPOSED 215 LF OF NATURAL STONE BOULDERS PLACED w +. / LOCATION MAP ` M IRERLoaaw PATTERN APPROXIMATELY 1'TO 2'HEIGHT / / W/FILTER FABRIC BAgUNG TO PREVENT SALT WATER FROM / .. / ENTERING PROPERTY DURING STORM TIDES i' •�• 3 W/ $ N.T.S. #745 i•�' �'�.`ZoArPROPOSED W / i% ft0l)1 � a` ` P STARTOF�CONSTR°CONSMBEDDEDTRUCTION,wo°w�AllED PROPERTY OWNER: 2 STORY t / / UNTIL FINAL STABL17ATION IS COMPLETED / FRAME RESIDENCE �. . . ,� O� ` / i/ I ..� ,:, / JAMES RUBIN ��` PHYLLIS RUBIN PROPOSED 4'WIDE X 32'LONG FIXED CATWALK 745 CASES LANE EXT. (KL WORK Two BEEPPERFORMED FRON OM UPLAND) CUTCHOGUE, NY 11935 / i :': '✓ O/ REMOVE EXISTING 5'X B'WOOD DOCK i :i" U PREPARED BY: i EXIS!ING Pow :. . . i / JEFFREY PATANJO i P.O. BOX 582 BOHEMIA, NY 11716 LIMITS OF TIDAL.WETLANDS AS DEUNEATED BY 631-484-9332 a JOHN C. EHIFRS L.S. ON IANU1W 26.2010 JJPATANJO®GMAIL.COM • . / j Proposed Permit Plans SCALE: A - _ L 1"=40' NOTES: -� / PROPOSED PLAN, DETAIL AND DATE: 1. LOT AREA: 75,120 S.F. / 1.7245 ACRES N/0/F ,� ' / LOCATION MAP 2-10-21 Ab 2. PORTIONS OF PLAN FROM SURVEY PREPARED BY: KEN J. KNOERSCHILD ire :i ! / 745 CASES LANE EXTENSION JOHN C. FREERS, L.S. CUTCHOGUE, TOWN OF SOUTHOLD 6 EAST MAIN STREET, RIVERHEAD NY 11901 �'�(� / °j SUFFOLK COUNTY, NY SHEET: SURVEY LATEST DATED AUGUST 12, 2010 I J - TAX MAP N0. 1000-109-05-14.45 1 of 1