HomeMy WebLinkAbout1000-51.-6-40 OFFICE LOCATION: oE SO(/Ty0 MAILING ADDRESS:
Town Hall Annex h0 lQ P.O. Box 1179
54375 State Route 25 Southold, NY 11971
(cor. Main Rd. &Youngs Ave.)
G Q Telephone: 631765-1938
Southold, NY 11971
oI�'rDU ,N
LOCAL WATERFRONT REVITALIZATION PROGRAM
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
MEMORANDUM
To: Michael Domino, President
Town of Southold Board of Trustees
From: Mark Terry, AICP
LWRP Coordinator
Date: June 14, 2019
Re: LWRP Coastal Consistency Review for ANDREW & LINDA TOGA
SCTM# 1000-51-6-40
Suffolk Environmental on behalf of ANDREW & LINDA TOGA request an Administrative Permit to
remove seven (7) oak trees at various locations across the subject property. Located: 2425 Mill
Creek Drive, Southold. SCTM#: 1000-51-6-40
A similar action proposed on the parcel was reviewed on February 16, 2018 and recommended as
inconsistent with the LWRP. The proposed action has been reviewed to Chapter 268, Waterfront
Consistency Review of the Town of Southold Town Code and the Local Waterfront Revitalization
Program (LWRP) Policy Standards. Based on the new submittal and my assessment, the proposed
action.is recommended as INCONSISTENT with Policy 6 of the LWRP.
1. Some trees depicted in the photographs to be removed are very close to wetlands
(standing water) and the need should be better justified.
Pursuant to Chapter 268, the Board of Trustees shall consider this recommendation in preparing its
written determination regarding the consistency of the proposed action.
Cc: Damon Hagan, Assistant Town Attorney
Town of Southold RECEIVED
LINrRP CONSISTENCYASSESSNW1 NT FORAM JUN 0 7 2019
1 Town
I own
A. INSTRUCTIONS RECEIVE
Board
I
1. All applicants for perrnlits* including Town of Satabold agencies, shall complete dais CCAF for
proposed actions that are subject to the Town of Sumhold Waterfront Consistency Review Law, This
assessment is intended to supplement other information used by a Ta"m of Southold agency in
inaking a determination of consistency. *F-rcept ininor P-reynpf actions hirluding B118ding Permits
and other PrInisterfal pernaffs not located o-Ithin the Coaval Erosion HazardAren.
2, Before answen:ngm the questions hi Section C, the preparer of E5. form should review the exempt
minor action list,policies and explanations of each policy contained in the ToiNii of Southold Local
Waterfront Revitalization Program- A proposed actign will htMaLimted as to Jts sigirific-mit
beneficivI and aftcrsa eff
qqt-,q um- i lLie�qzqtal arm(Whichhiclu all of Southold,ro,-vo).
3. It any question in Section C on this forra is aDsivered 'yes" or"no", then the proposed action will
affect the achievement of the LWRP policy standards and conditions contained in the consistency
review law. Thus, each answer must be CX12101ned in detail. listin-a both -supporting and non-
suppor "O0 s
ng f�tts. If an action can'n' t be ocrtiried"a' consistent with the LWRP policy standards mid
conditions,It nni be taideitaken.
A copy of the LWRP is available in die following places: online at the Town of Soudiold`$
wabsite (souAhdldtovkn.nor*Hbrk.ne% the Board of TrdsLecs Office,the Planning Department, all
local libraries and the Town Clerk's office,
B. DESCRIPTION OF SITE A"PROPOSED ACTION
SCTM9 ,
PROJE CT N, .IE TOGA Property
The Application has been submitted to(check appropriate response).-
Town Board El Planning Board El Buflding Dept. n Board of Trustee;;
1. Category of Town of Southold agency action(check appropriate response):
(a) Action uTidertak-en directly by Town agreney(e.g.capital F -1
constructiGn,planning activity,agency regula'don,land trai=ctio n)
(b) Financial assistance(e,g. gr=t,loan,subsidy)
(C) Permit,approval,licenst'. certification;
Nat=and extent of action;
Applicant seeking regulatory approval to remove a total of seven trees from the property to
make sufficient room for construction activity.
Location of action:_2425 Mill Creek Drive * Southold,New York * 11971
Site acreage: 0.5±acres
Present land W-:_SingleEamiLy_Resideadal_
Present zoning classification: R-40
2- If an application for the proposed action has been bled ,.p=ith die Town of Southold agency, the folto"Ong
information shall be provided:
(a) Name of applicant. Andrew&Linda Toga
(b) Mailing address:— 16 St. George Glenn Dr. * Setauket,New York * 11733
(c) Telephone ntuiibor; Area Code( ) (516)--983 -6853 -
d Application numtxr,if any.
--A)1A
I—
Wil I the action be directly undertaken,reqidre fundirig,or approval by a state or federal ag,-acy?
Yes 0- No If yes,whicb state or fideral agency?
C Evaluate the project to the following policies by analy7ing bow the project gill further support or
not SUJJI)ort the rJ4)ljCie$L, Provide all proposed Best Management Practices that will further each policy,
Incomplete answers will require that the form be returned for completion.
DGWELOPED COAST POLICY
Policy 1. Poster a pattern of development in the Town of Southold that enhances community Character,
preserves open space.,makes efficient use of infrastructure,makes beneficial use of a coastal location,and
minimizes adverse effects of develop m cm t. See LWRV Section III—Policies; Page 2 for evaluatiou
criteria.
[J-Yes [:] No RINot Applicable
This is a necessary facet for the approved constructed activity by the Southold Town Board of Trustees Permit#9393.
Policy 2. Protect and presme bisto-de and archaeological resources of the Toiiv of Southold, See
I,' ._P Section III—Policies Pages 3 through 6 for evaluation criteria
11 Yes 0 No FX1 Not Applicable
This is a necessary facet for the approved constructed activity by the Southold Town Board of Trustees Permit#
9393.
Attach additional sheets iftneeessary
Police 3. Enhance k-isual quality and protect scenic resources throughout the Town of Southold. knee
LNVRP Section ITT—Policies Pages 6 through 7 for evaluation criteria
I Yes N. � Not Applicable
This is a necessary facet for the approved constructed activity by the Southold Town Board of Trustees Permit
#9393
Attach ndditiotnaI 5hects irnecmary
NATURAL COAST POLICIES
Policy 4. Minimize loss of life, structures, and natural resources from flooding and crosion. See 1.WRP
Section III--Policies pages S through 16 for evaluation criteria
0 Yes. 1:1 No 0 Not Applicable
This is a necessary facet for the approved constructed activity by the Southold Town Board of Trustees Permit
#_93-9-3g addition, siltation fencing will b_e—jnsta)led as_pe�tlae apptwoyed e2r struction,conseuet�tl,X,
-.-minimizing construction_site-run=off_-- - - - -- - -
Attacb addiflonal sheets ifnecessary
Police 5. Protect and improve water quality and supply in the Town ofSouthold.See LJVRP Section III
Policies Mages 16 throu.gli 21 for evaluation criteria
rVI
1,-,3 Yes EI No LJ Not Applieahle
This is a_necessary facet for the approved constructed activity by the Southold Town Board of Trustees Permit
##9393.In addition siltation fencing will be installed as,per-the approved construction,consequently,
nuzing-r-0 StDJCtlon.Site_run+Off
Attach additionj)l sbi:tts if necessa y
Policy 6. Protect and restore the quality anti finetion of the Town of Southold ecosysteins including
Significant Cmtal Fish andWildlife Habitats and wetlands. See L)A-rRP Section III—Policies; Pages 22
tbrough 32 for evaluation criteria.
F] F
Yes Nio Not,Applimble
This is a necessary facet for the approved constructed activity by the Southold Town Board of Trustees Permit
#9393.
Aaat*h ifnecessaq
Policy 7. Protect and improve sair,rluality in the Town of Southold. See LWR-P Section In — Policies
Pages 32 through 34 for evaluation criteria.
n Yes No Q Not Applicable
This Policy is not applicable to this project
Attach additional shcct-,if'nccc.-Ty
Policy 8. Minimize environmimtal degradation in Town of Southold from solid waste .and hazardous
substances and wastes. See LIQ'Section III—Polleiesl Pages 34 through 38 for evaluation criteria.
n YeS EI No Not AppReable
This Policy is not a licable to this proiect
PUBLIC COAST POLICIES
Policy 9. Provide for public access to, and rccreationat use of, coastal waters, public lands, and public
resources of the Town of Southold, See LWRP Section III—.Policies; Pages 38 through 46 for evaluation
criteria.
Q YcJ-1 No Not Applicable
This Policy is not applicable to this project
Attach-ddidwal shra is if ntcessaq
WORKING COAST POLICIES
Policy 10. Protect Southold's eater-depandebt u-m and promote siting Gf neer water-dependent uses in
suitable locations, 'See LNVRT-y Section 1I1---=Policies; Wages 47 through 56 for evaluation trite'-a.
❑ Yes ❑ No E] NO Applicable
This Policy,is not applicable to this project
Attach additlowl sheets ifnecessar�y
Pulley M Pronaote sustainable use of 1-hin amarine re-so�rreas in Long Island Sound, the Pecenie
Estuary and Town eaters. See LVVRP Section III—Policies; Pages 57 through 62- for evaluation criteria.
❑ Yes ❑ No E Not Applicable
This Policv is not applicable to this project
Mach additional slicets irneccssary
Policy 12. Protect agricultural lands is the Town of Southold. See LNVRP Section III — Policies; Pages
f? through 65 fnr evaluation criteria,
❑Yes ❑ No❑ 1'+iot Applicable
This Policy is not applicable to this project
Aaach adc as-nrt1 sheets I€ncccssary
Policy 13, Promote Appropriate use and development of energy and rtrirrcnii resources, See LNVRP-
Seetion III—Policies; Pages 65 through 68 for evaluation criteria,
❑ Yes ❑ No L Not Applieftble
Th s�c_y is-moLapplicable to his project
PI PAIEII BY-R.,,-1 • A uo,n TITLE&e h L s 2017
r
rOGA Property
Situate: 2425 Mill Creek Drive • Southold,New York • 11971
S CTM#: 1000-051-06-040
(Photograph Taken 05-09-2019)
a
jk
77,
P.
x°
The photograph above depicts the seaward most tree to be
removed from the property. This picture was taken facing
south.
TOGA Property
Situate: 2425 Mill Creek Drive • Southold, New York • 11971
SCTM#: 1000-051-06-040
(photograph Taken 05-09-2019)
Ak
y
w
1
r
N,*^
o e
1 ?
The photo above (taken facing south) depicts the trees to be
removed from the property.
TOGA Prope rt
Situate: 2425 Mill Creek Drive • Southold, New York • 11971
SCTM#: 1000-051-06-040
(Photogra h Taken 05-09-2019)
J IMP
112 li
a
1
t
V
yg l
T
r
f.
„ my•.. " may, . „ `. _ u ,p_ _
4 ,
:+ .a'�#F M1 % I+.CY".�rcP�+Y. 0. a� �� �' ..uY..*r^.✓Y.a ,.ih.✓Y�� � yaa: � ..
_ _ r
The photograph above (taken facing north) depicts the trees
on the road side of the property adjacent to the westerly
shoreline to be removed from the property. (Please note the
trees were not flagged due to the presence of Poison Ivy
(Toxicodendron radicans)).
TOGA Property
Situate: 2425 Mill Creek Drive • Southold, New York • 11971
SCTM#: 1000-051-06-040
(Photo gra h Taken 05-09-2019)
-
. •_ rte._-},
d " �
a r
4
> I[y-
°_ V _
x
F
The photograph above (taken facing northeast) depicts the
trees to be removed from the property. (Please note that the
trees were not flagged due to the presence of poison ivy
(Toxicodendron radicans)).
PR JE IES.CIZIP'I'IOI�To #.
SlrTE PLAT l r
1.6 —30.0
Applitci�t proposes to rexla®ve seven (7) a#tie
Proposed ( - ,
If
'Decicti®us Trees (green) lo,eated with'r _subject:
! ! Propane Tank —PROPOSED _ ;
TRENCH nlitl, :,property clue-- to7 ,their pr®xini p: 1®cation t®. the
- -
.r-
Nod �� DW ro osed activities ,a roved via. To %vri ®_f "Southold'
p = Pp.
TREES to be 1 ` � E. ° , ` hoard ®f:TiF 9tees llTo. 9393;`;'dated Februa 13,:2019:
C \ \ ! ry, . o
\ �,REMOVED
PROPO
�'CA[N[NG HALL
•1 - - �1 1 • .l`- U
.51
}, ` �'� .r ; v r ` •a" '—PROPOSED "1 rc ,� w
I`.a
RETAINING WALL o �
BUG- 3 \ l W U N
t a NO �PROP�S ) I
MAY 1 ) 1 ►� z
4, —EXISTING
I � 3 2019 �Y � � , mnRo-acrio� 51,`r'CPARY SYSTEM /�� �
f ) \�• \ �vAN4QQ i/A. 20 BE ADA.4'DONSI) x ^ M
�r"q � ti�f ,' � �"+r' ''�`3� �� b •PRQS$1d`4YE..
z
X/
q j JJ
llip".1POSE AIR FaISIVB AT' 4 ; O n /•PROPUSED a � z
'���a,,_ o ,�
r FHOFOSED,' ® O u M
2t E61 al I iy GAGE nR1v,U1 y• ` cn U o kn
t \ c S� P$OPDSED'f,f p l�
c R yX ! t1 • �' �� %�sSHOWER/. = W)
1
ROPOSED
cq
lif
m�o. I/�/J J !JLYVS�l1?T"✓` �' iaI-rD�CELLARt/?PY'R9'OIPOQNS�PnEOn!DRCH!i'
,If',
AND SOWN CPRO /COVERED_
�F)
"FRAME DVE
! ! C ( 1 \
SDi LpRopOSED raxlslTNG =I
2nd STORY B.iLCQ� CHDINBY E
I / _—•-12 N a
ZY
11' EXLSTtNG 'EXfSPING -r _
$�- WOOD STEPS COMPOSITE
Na:4STEPS AND_
O -O
n ca
ARSHAMOMAQUE POND
E
FLOATING n C
a�
MCrAL RAMP WOOD DOCK
u
DOCK DOCK
TEST HOLE BY:McDONALD GEOSCIENCE
APPROXIMATE LOCATION U� 0p0 '
of WELL LEAD titpo_op5',�Y DATE: APRIL 10, 2017
p5,pp�06•YOStIdYR
+pOp U�0� Cts CNR +v EL 10.0
��-_ �1GB� �p�• O SM BROWN SILTY SAND.
M AY 1 J 20 19 1, NOTE: SANITARY SYSTEM � ~ c.��� - EL. 3.0
G1` I NOT LOCATABLE. / �, �\ SW
BROWN FINE TO
ev` Ap00 ��y _ COARSE SAND.
I - _� —v�_pgp0a9oRLg5 Nr� EL. 0.6
Jul• ;05SA0 04 FOR�OtAG t 04 , SW WATER IN PALE BROWN
�p00_p HOA,. 1� ti' o
�i0'dIl .R•r a -•- �� pY @. �,�.(y FINE TO COARSE SAND.
it ti QI.V� EL-7.0
WATER ENCOUNTERED
8.56 9.4ft. BELOW SURFACE
om
tL�j I i i `soft
IIII ° yy �p01 � ox
y GUY PROPOSED
WIRE YOA 15 0 TRENCH DRAIN
- N°:1 I\�305"� 50 L DW WIDT o LOT COVERAGE CALCULATIONS:
-- LOT AREA: ±18,945.81 Sq.Ft. = 0.43 ACRES
PROPOSED FRAME DWELLING =2,030.12 Sq.Ft.
I 1000 GALLON °� A WOOD DECK = 336.00 Sq.Ft.
PROPANE TA uf1 COVERED PORCH+STEP= 171.33 Sq.Ft.
P.LINE I STEPS+LANDINGS 83.00 Sq.Ft.
IR AININCEWALL ;%/ DWELLING WOOD STEPS = 59.45 Sq.Ft.
AS REQUIRED 0�/ / CELLAR ENTRANCE = 55.00 Sq.Ft.
W I (T.W. 11.5) I r o ° / WELL HATER =
°. 1000-051.00-06.00-039.000 SHOWER 21.00 Sq.Ft.
A co I \ I I �i LAND NOW ORFORMERLY .TOTAL AREAS =2,755.90 Sq.Ft.
PROPOSED
I GAS LINE 1610 tii TH PROP SED k MARIIYN FUHRMANN •LOT COVERAGE = 14.54%
\ IALONG WALL MIN. G �E ti° RETAINING WALL
F�0 I w AS REQUIRED
�J 2ft ►O (T.W. 11.5)
0.0
I No:2 1PROPOSED IN G G "'i EXISTING_---_
HYDRO-ACTION SANITARY SYSTEM
f AN400 I/A. � . #118fk TO HE ABANDONED
15Oft
/ N mf90fL-12
c; y 135 1123fL
///INI �� C PROPOSED 4fL �j APPROXIMATE LOCATION
DI UTION BOX. r OF WELL HEAD
q I P4 o ' _ PROPOSED HYDRO-ACTION CONTROL PANEL AND
Coec
ti� AIR PUMP ON 36"x36%6" WITH w 10/10 WIRE.
zz,5e ±27:4 5.8
/PROPOSED AIR VENT AT v N FRAME
I BUILDING 18" ABOVE GRADE ),PROPOSEDx ED
i m WITH CHARCOAL FILTER. ° ENLARGED, PROPOSED 4.9
R,GARAM$ ti�lb DRIVEWAY n SUNROOM
c Ee I j'(Ex.GF 13.7) 6.7 \�
No:�ti, ' I tDW �b /pROPOSE�iiiiilliiiili " APPROXIMATE LOCATION
c ��? SHOWER/ i 1 i i i l i OF SANITARY SYSTEM
7.17/ /�`/?'!7 �a.BD,1 i 23.4 �ti t92fL
I CEPLLAR EN RYS r /ED 2nd STORROPOS Y lii iii , STONED WALKWAY
L' �� / / I•t3f 0.0x5,5 1-- / �m 1111111
ITS
/ADDITIONi// i ill
SHOWER =14�
i
,0
�P _ DE �RIP�
P .0SC TION:��TE��. NF:
7 ,
_ + . , .< '
: C i ATM l cai tr ro;" ores to s 'remove=;Tseven (7),: °mature; ,.
P-P i p =p _
III Proposed f �D;eciduous Trees =`(green)._ located ,within . subject o
I Propane Tank PBOPOSED
1 I I` TRENCE{BRAIN :prop .rty. -due,;, -to:.--their` - r k
y e p oximate- location to, the
N°°' 1 ` \ D t proposed r,activities -app"roved, vias Town;,'"of Southold:'r
TREES to be :S:oaidhof Tru_sties N,0.43 3; .date_d Februa 13, 20.19: , 7,
REMOVED �.r,-
_- -- f �� ..4•- x...n.+,r+.sr+ f [vwc,.. .,. aF V .. .°.-_ _. ?r - 'J 1
1�\\_. - � } � I \ \ u S 2n _ ut _ xV. rv+•a.v ,a , y.Ywarxr«c•ro+.-..e....r++r. _ -w,f+.. +.ro-,c•w-..._..2xar.�.r•vrr.<,.."..w.rxworw.n+i" `Q
y� PRO 0
AS UIRED
OCD
N
���,\� aG r-E-i ' .✓, ., ROED
RETAINING WALL
U �" N
{PROPD� \TA I �i b 6YISTING�'r t/� Zi ani 1 j
HYDRD-ACPIOI14 cn
� � a �/' �' r. ': SANITARY SYSTEM t I"r Z
rAN4D0 I- 1 i TO DE ADANDONSD x Z
r to r `JNN ` PR POSED UL
Q Jp' D UTION BOX
//?ROP'
OS! AIR VENT�LINB AT ~ W "
+ a RUHhING`fie" ARo GRADs PROPOSED 5 a z o
/ NITH.cwAm ENLARGEDX O Cn s
�r r f. ` PROPOSED O o O o
CD In
+ `�ROPOSCsD !GARAGE//i ' DRIVEWAY N
�`� NHo 9�jr� �' � I C� C�4 �P1�OP08B�'�: ' •' , O O � p l�
C2 I ` d N !�SHHOWER
� M
'/PRUPOSED a: co
`SAM,+ r,= %:21Jid STORY. ;
�y /ii"ADDMONf. I
WS
TNlG
rEL1R-$NTP. �E- ii�°•-C!/O,�PRR.OEP,D USPBODR�C�H/'
AND SHOWPRO lfl �-EXISPING1N10
3v
'
>
16.4.+ —
r44
{
. °
1 btlr- PROPOEED FASTING a
II I I l O 2nd STORY a Op CWIEY q
Inl lLn
—12 N
ii —10 V
c EXISTING 'EXLPOSIT _
WOOD STEPS -COMPOSITE i _ r�
�� 3TRP5 AND- !_; - — — =_= _ �2----- L c!) +
LANDINGS No: �I o
No:5
=s II
ARSHAMOMAQUE POND r
�_�
E
s
;,*
FLOATING d
WOOD DOCK
DUCK
DOCK �X .w}�tit'tNi ed c. o
TOGA Property
Situate: 2425 Mill Creek Drive West ■ Town of Southold. ■ New fork
SCTM #: 1000 — 051 — 06 m 040
`j
SITE
r l fJ
y 16t R TALL CPFFK DP.
' 57ti RICIOXNi,RD } f+ti'1 h"),,NSLL t:RFEP'DR.
4firLFAIRP, 1N-,,MLLCHFEF..1-•R �f'''=� .� .. - t' •
y,-l
U
"HN.hly:FiF.4.FIU Ry k', _ J IStiLGti 3i £EI
4:fJ01"B LL CIiLE&f�li'�., >`
�3l.tILLCRLCK GR
21115 Lr+Fis]CRCEK DF
,21:x7 A@L CF£EKLf:" t �" -
s 14,111,1 LLCFEE, IR ?a�SL%+I t+ FEFKDi ;
f
mu LIi
23'i.IALL CREEK VR
214,1.11LL:^RCEt(DF; `�-' 3 , i+ •13n,.PA
ti i` , ACL!:REEKGF Y_,.r • - •-�' t 21^s,Lu41,CFFI:K'GR
'
SITE y�� _ - `; ,•'J'` �r v ^+.NS lC+h'hs CFiLEK DE '
13+VMG CREEKPR
�•__-:__._--• o - .. - _ t9n_+LA1GCREEKDR,
1144L{1PL_CREEK t3R
IIA L-.-,tk,CFLEF LSI!
i