HomeMy WebLinkAbout241 ~TOWN OF SOUTHOLD, ~IEW YORK~
APPEAL FROM DECISION OF BUILDING INSPECTOR APPEAL NC>. ~l~t~
DATE Nevember 24.~ 1959
TO THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS, TOWN OF SOUTHOLD, N. Y.
I; (We) FLoyd Houston A/C Goldsmith & Tonffhill Youngs Ave
Name of Appelbnt Street and Number
Southold N.Y, HEREBY APPEAL TO
Municipality State
THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS FROM THE DECISION OF THE BUILDING INSPECTOR ON
APPLICATION~ FOR PERMIT NO..,.-E-...9.,0.Z ....................... DATED ..~.o,.v,.e..m.,b.,e..r....2.~...1..9..5.~ .................
WHEREBY THE-BUILDING INSPECTOR DENIED TO
Floz. d._., AgA .s.~9.zA, ~ ./..q...CT.o..I..d.s. mith..&....T..n. ~.h..i. ,1...i. .......... Name of Applicant for permit
of _Vo~ugs Ave~ Southold, N.Y.
Street and Numbey Municipality State
~1 PERMIT TO USEand build overhead storage tanks
( ) PERMIT FOR OCCUPANCY
( )
1. LOC~TION OF THE PROPERTY.~/S.JZQungs..A'~e,.~.-L.~Z.IL-A ........ ':.C.E..dist ..........................
Street Use District on Zoning Map
.....x~..~ ............................................... ~ ......... , Southold, N.?.
Map No. Lot No.
2. PROVISION (S) OF THE ZONING ORDINANCE APPEALED (Indicate the Article Section, Sub-
section and Paragraph of the Zoninfl Ordinance by number. Do not quote the Ordinance.)
Article V Section 503
3. TYPE OF APPEAL Appeal is made herewith for
(~[]Di A VARIANCE to the Zoning Ordinance or Zoning Map
( ) A VARIANCE due to lack of access (State of New York Town Law Chap. 62 Cons. Laws
Art. 16 Sec. 280A Subsection 3
4. PREVIOUS APPEAL A previous appeal ~ (has not) been made with respect to this decision
of the Building Inspector or with respect to this property.
Such appeal was ( ) request for a special permit
( ) request for a variance
and was made in Appeal No ................................. Dated ......................................................................
REASON FOR APPEAL
( ) A Variance to Section 280A Subsection
(i~,~X A Variance to the Zoning Ordinance
( )
is requested for the reason that : It is desired to erect two 15,000 gal overhead storage
tanks on steel cradles~ located so that the northerly ends of tanks would line up
withthe present front of the loading rack. This would l&ave less than 3Oft to the Rail
(Continue on other side) ._Road right of way as required.
Form ZB1
I -
IJEGAL NOTICE
Notice of HearIng
Pursuant to Section 267 of the I
Town Law and the provIsions of
the Amended Building Zone Ordin-
ance of the Town of Southold Suf-
folk. County, New York, public
hearmgs will be held by the Zon-
Ing Board of Appeals of the Town
of Southold, at the Town Clerk's
Office, Main Road, Sauthold, New
Y.ork, .on Decembc,r 9, 19'59, on the
followmg appeals;
.7; 30 P. M. (E. S. T) upon ap-
pl1catlOu of Gennaro Maneri, Pike
and Maple Avenue, Mattituck New
Y?rk, for a variance in accordance
wIth the Zoning Ordinance Article
III, Section 300, Subsectio':' 7, for
per,IDlssl,on to locate priv,ate gar-
age with reduced setba'ck. Location
of property; south side Pike street
and west side Maple Avenue Mat-'
tituc~, New Yorl{, bounded' nartill
by Pike Street, east by Maple A ve- i
nue, south by H. R. Reeve, and
west by E. Pike.
7;40 P. M. (E. S. T.J, upon ap-
pl1<:atlOn of LeRoy Tuthill, Main
Road, Mattltuck, New York, for a I
special exception In acc<>rdance
with the Zoning Ordinance, Article
IV,Sectlon 408, ,and article VIII,
Section 703A, Ior permission to
erect three (3) portllJble ground
. signs on Wernlses {)f ES80 Service
station, corner of Main Road and
Wickham Avenue, Mattltuck, New
York.
8;00 P. M. (E.8.T.l, upon appli-
plication of Floyd Houston, ale
Goldsmith and Tuthill, Youngs Av-
enue, Southold, New York, for a
variance in a,c,c.ordance with the
Zoning Ordinance, A,rticle V, Sec-
tion 503, for permission to reduce I
side yard setback on stde of prop-
erty bounded by railroad right-of-[
way. Location of property; west 1
side Youngs Avenue, Southold, New I
York, bounded north by L. 1. pro-l
duce and Fertilize~ Co., east by I
Youngs Avenue, south by Railroad, 'I
and west by L. I. Produce and Fer-
tilizer Co. I
8;20 P. M. (E. S. T.J, upon ap_1
.Plication Df Nelson Axien, Box 352, I
Pecanie, New York, for a variance
in accordance with the Zoning Or-,
dinanee, Article III, Sedion 303,1
and Article X, Section lOOOA, for
permission to reduce frontage and I
sell as a single lot. Variance L'i i
also requested due to lack of 8;C-1,
cess in accordance with state of:
New York Town Law Section 280A.1
Loeation of property; north side:
Private Road, off Mill Road, Pe-I
conic, New York, bounded north by
Long Island Sound, east by other'
I lands of the applicant, east by
right-of-way, and west by G. Hip-
i well.
I 8;40 P. M. (E. S. T.), upon ap-
ipkation of Midgley and Horton,
! ale Fritz Kohn, Cutchoguc, New
York, for a variance in accord-
ance with the Zoning Ordinance,
Article III, Section 304, as referred
to in Article IV, Section 400, Sub-
section 1, for permission to reduce
front yard setback for a residential'
, dwelling in a business district, Var-I
rance is also requested due to lack!
of access in accordance with state i
of New York Town Law, Section:
2SnA. Location of property; Private II
Road, east side Old Harbor Lane"
New Suffolk, New York, bounded:
north by H. E. Mas.on, cast by pri-1
vate Road, south by H. H. Tuthill,
anI west by Canal.
9;00 P. M. (E. S. T,;, upon
pUcation of Almet Latson, Private
Road. .east side Youngs Avenue,1
Southald, New York, for a variance!
due to lack of 3lc,cess in accordaJJJl.e I
with state of New York Town I
Secton 280A. .. Property located --.
private road, east side Youngs Av
enue, Southold, New York, bound-
ed north by A. Dolfinger and P
Sawyer, east by K. Salmon and A.
Latson, and others, south by Town
Creek, and west by C. Nissen, A.
Downs, and others.
Any person desiring to be heard
on the above applications shaull
appear at the time and place above
specified.
DATED; November 25, 1959.
By Order of the Southold Town
Board of Appeals. ltD4
-----~--
STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF SUFFOLK,
week, for _
successively
day of
~
commencing on
Sworn to before me this.
day of
1
f 58;
J
.. u......__u_m~~u. .....u..................______ weeks
'"
the ..........:2:'.:.c:....." > .
19,~:(...
,----
, \ '
...___...__~_,U.:-~.:.h_
...h:.:...~J,...........l
f
c:.L+...J . /) . I
..........~...~.....:...b~it.
cor:';U.I.\ c. KEOGH
;J;)lM:Y ;>lJE3L1:~, State of New York
;'J.,.;. ;2-,~09?B')O
Q~_~J!:ficd ill Suffolk County
1""_.0 .: ~~i~-~s ,'J1Jrch 3D. lCj51
REASON FOR APPEAL Continued
I. STRICT APPLICATION OF THE ORDINANCE would produce UNDUE HARDSHIP because :
There are at present four tanks totaling ~0 thousand gallons of fuel and gasoline
buried in the SoutheaSt corner of the premises all of which are within the distance
requested for the new installation~-~.-E, to the south of the front Qf.-,the present
loading dock. The prope>ty is zoned "C" industrial,having been used for storage yard
for many years. The adjoining property to the West ~ L.I.Produce & Ferterlizer Co has
a large grading station & Ferterlizer factory which is located 'immediately adjacent
to the R.R.r~gn,. of way aproximately the same dz~ance as we request.
2. The hardship created is UNIQUE and is not shared by all properties alike in the immediate
vicinity of this p'~opbr-ty an'd[ in this use district because t' We are the only fuel dealer in thio
area, ~nd our requirements are vastly different than other businesse~ in the area.
3. The Variance would observe thb spirit ~of'the Orainanc~ an~ WOULD NOT CHANGE THE
CHARACTER OF THE DISTRICT because ~ This is an e×~sting storage yara of ~¥ ~ears
duration~ ~ving been used for building supplies., coal yard, fuel dispensing facilities
otc, it is in the heart of the commercial and heavy business district of the village,
and has its own rail siding and highway access. The proposed use will not change the
charicter of the ne. ighborhood, .or harm any prooerty values in the area. We maintain
fire fighti~g-:£ac~iities 6f~o~r eWn~on~th~-pre~ise~, and have hydrant service for
other fire protection. The gasoiLne tank vents are of flash proof co_.s~ructzon,~ ~ all
construction is of aDn?ov~dma~g~als~ the new tanks are for the storage of fue2 oil
and will meet alt safety requirements.
STATE OF NEW YORK )
) ss
Sworn to this .................... ~....~... ................. day Qf ..................
·
I~otar~ ?ub[[c. State of New York
~ FORI~I NO. $ ''
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
BUILDING DEPARTMENT
TOWN CLERK'S OFFICE
SOUTHOLD, N. Y.
....Y ~..A:,,~ .................................................
...... ......................................
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that your application dated .................
for permit to construct .'~.~,...~..~.~,.i~...o..~T~t t~t~Z~mises located at -.:..~.?~o~..A~...~,
· .~.--N .z/~ -. · .~.-.'.~.. -.~ ................................... i'.-.. Street ~h~I~l~
Map ......;;~ ......................... Block ........ ~ ................ ~ ............ Lot ........ ~ ........................... ~is
~L~lB~~disapproved on the, fol!owi ng grounds ...... :-..
~e~f~..~. !~. ~..~.~y...,..-... ~ .~:~.. ~., ..............................................................................
FOII~ ~0. 1
TOWN OF $OUTHOLD
BUILDING DEPARTMENT
- Tow. C R 'S OFF,CE
..... SOUTHOLD, N..Y.. ..................
Examined '/~/f~ ~' ~1~ , 19..~.~: ..... ' _,~..~
Approved ......... i. M.Z/ ..........
Disapproved
'-'"'"'":'~'" ........................ . ....... :'"'"::'."':: ....... ::'".';'7;::"
(Bui ding Ins~ctar) ~ '
INSTRUCTIONS ..............
a. This a~]'i~a~n must.be comple~ fiiled in by '~pewrffer or in.ink~o~,submi~ed~,id~pl,icate to the Building
Inspector.
b. Plot plan showing location of lot and of buildings on premises, ~relationship to adjoining premises or public streets
or areas, and giv~g~ detailed d~cri~ion of b~t.ot p~e~y mu~ be-drawn o~-the diagram ~hich is~t Of'this ~ocation.
c. 'The'work c0vere~'by this ap~licatlon may not'be commenced before ~ssuance of
d. Upon approval of this ~pplication, the Building Inspector witl issue a Building Permit to the applicant. Such
permit shall be kept on the premises available for ins~.ction throughout the prggress of the work.
e. No building shall be occupied or used in whole or in part for any purpose whatever until a Certificate'of Occupancy
shall h~e been granted by the Building Inspector.
APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE to the Building Department for the issuance of a Building Permit pursuant to the
Building Zone Ordinance of the Town of Southold, Suffolk Count, New York, and other applicable Laws, Ordinances or
Regulations, for the construction of buildings, additions or alterations, or for removal or demolition, as herein described.
The applicant agrees to comply with all applicable laws, ordinances' and regulations.
..... .....
(Siflnotur~~por~tion)~
~oaress or applicant)
State whether ~pplicant is owner, lessee, agent, architect, engineer, general contractor, electricidn, plumber or builder~
1. Location .of land on which propose~ wor~ will be done. Map No: ............................. T.'.~;.,.'- L~t'~: .............. .......
Street and Number ..... ~~~~...~.~.:..~.::.:~_._.~~ ~) .~.,..~..._.._.
2. State existing use and o~cy of premised intended use and ~cupancy of pr~osed co--on:
b. Intended use and ~cupancy ........................... :~....~ ........................................................... ....
3. Nature of work (check which'-~plicable): New Building .................... ~,~ition .................. .~~ ......
Repair .................... Removal .................... Demolit'ion...i...'..: ........... Other Work (Describe) ~.~.'.-~
4. Est,mated Cost .~..~...~..'~....~.........-~.. ............................ Fee .... ~ .....................................................................................
(to be paid on filing this application)
5. If dwelling, number of dwelling units .......................... NumbeF of'dwelling units on each floor ........... ~ ......................
If garage, number of cars .............................................................................................................................................
6. If business, commercial or mixed occupancy, specify nature and extent~f each type of use..~ ...... ~ .....................
7. Dimensions of existing structures, if any: Front ........................... Rear ............................ Depth ................................
Height ............................ Number of Stories ................................ : ............................................................................
Dimensions of same structure with alterations or additions: Frodt ...... ' .............. J ........... Rear
Depth ................................ Height ................................ Number of Stories ................................
8. Dimensions of entire new construction: Front ............................Rear ............................ Depth .....~..~....'. ...........
Height ...... ~.~.~... Number of-Stories ...... ~ ...... /.~ ~'
9. Size of lot: Front ~..~.~.~. ........ Rear ..~.~ .......... Depth ~..~.~.] .........
~ s
10. Dote of Purchase ...~....L..~. .......................... Name-of-F~rmer OWner ........................................................
1 ]. Zone or use district in which premises are situated ...... '..~ .......... ~ ................................................................
con~trbcfion'Viold}e any zoning law, ordinance or regulation?
q 2. Does pF~sed ' '" ~ ........................................................
13. Name of Owner of pre~s ........................................ p, aa s ..................................... ~ .... Phone ....................
Name of Architect ........................ ~.~ ....................... -..Address .......................................... Phone NO .....................
Name of Contractor ........................................... Address .......................................... Phone NO .....................
PLOT DIAGRAM
Locate clearly and distinctly all bui dings, whether existing or proposed, a~d indicate all set-back dimensions from
property lines. Give street and block numbers or description according to deed, and show street%nqmeF and indicate
whether interior or corner lot.
STATE OF NE~.YO~ ~ ) S S
COUNTY OF .~~] ..... ) ' ~'~ ,
~ ~::~?:~':'..~~~, ~~-., '~e~ du..~wo~ d*o~s o.~ .v~ ,h~, he ~ the o~p, ~
a~ve named. He is the ............... ~....;~~~...~.-...~.; .............................................
.. - ~:- _ (Contractor, agent]corp0rate officer, etc.) . ..
of said owfie~' or owners,':ond s du y author zed .to perform or ho,e-~rformed the said work and to make and tim
this a~Ol[eatiBh;%thfi~ ~ll:stotem~"-c6nta~ifie~d'ih this opp cot on 'a~e-.tru, to the best of his knowledge and belief;
and that the wo~k will be performed, in-~the manner set forth~in'-the apPlicotion filed therewith.
. ~ot*~ Public, State of ~ew York
................ ~.5 ~, of ...... .,..,..~...,..~...=, ........ ,~,~.~.,~,*, ,. ~~
,.r------- 11
L1?flAL NO'! ICE
_otice of Bearing
P\tI:"8118nt to S..t10n 267 of the 'tovn 1&w and the II' ov151oo.
of the '-n'lded BuUcl1Q1 ~one OJ'd1J:lan.. of the Tovn of Southold,
Sut1'olk COlIIlVl .." YOrk, pv.bl1. MU'1IlI1 Will be hel4 bT the
Zon1I.lC Board or Appeals of the Tovn of Southol4, at the Tovn
Clerk's otfice, Main Road, Southol4, )fev York, on D....ber 9,
19~9, on the tollov1nc appeals-
7.30 P.M. CE.S.T.)~ upon application 01 Gennaro Manerl,
Pike and Mapl. Aftftlle, llattituek, lfcty York, tor a vU'~~ 1n
accordanc6I nth the Zon1nc Ordinance, ArUcle III, S6Iction 300,
Sulle.ot1on 7, for pe1'll11..1on to looate prlnte ,arace with
reduoed s.t_ok. Location of property. 80uth side Pike street
and west aldaMaple Aftll'lle, Mattituok, Jfew York, bourlded north
by P1ke Street, .ast bT Maple Avenue, south by H. R. Reeve,
and west by E. PikA.
7.1to P.M. (m.S.T.), upon application of LeRoy Tuth1ll,
Mal8 Road, Mattituek1 )fey YOrk) to:r . special .x..pt1on in
aceordanoe with the zontnc OrIS.nee, Al'Uel. IV, S.cttion 408,
and Artiol. VIII, Seotion 703A, to:r pea1aa1on to enot three
(J) portable I1'OUD4 s!lns on preJlli.-.s of ESSO Servioe Station,
corner of Ma1n Road and Wickham Avenue, Hattltu.clt, New York.
8.00 P.M. (E.S.T')hupon application of no;rd Houston,
ale Goldsm1th and Tuthi ,Younes Avenue, Southold, )few York,
tor a variance in acoorianM with the Zoning o:rdinanoe,
Article V, eeotion 5'03, to:r pe1'll1sdon to reduce side yard
setbaok on 814. ot property bo1.m4ed by 1'a1lr0a4 r1&ht-ot-way.
Looation of propertya .at sld. Younes A.venue! Southold, New
:Cork, 'bounded north by L. I. Produce and Ferti izer Co.,
.ast by Younas Avenue, south by Rallrou, and ......t by L. I.
ii Produce and Fert111u1' Co.
'I
SaC!O P.M. (F.S.T.),upon appl1eat1on of Nelson Ax1en,
Box 352, Peeon1c! ~v York, tor a varianCfl 111 accordance
with the Zon1nc OMlnano., Artio1e III, Seotion 303t and
Article X, "etion 1000A., tor pel'llliulon to nduee rrontage
and ..11 as a sing1. lot. Varlanc. 18 also nq_sted due to
lack of acee.. in accordance v1 th State or Rew York town
Law Section :a80A. Location ot property. no:rth aid. Private
Road, oU MUl Road, Peconlc, Kew York, bounded north by
Long Islam Sound, east by other lands ~ the appl1cant,
south by right-ot-way, and west bT G. HirwU.
0.40 P.M. (E.S.T.), upon application of ~gley and
Horton, e/e .r:rltz Kobn, Cutcbosue, Hew York, tor a V8J'iance
in Accor<l.anM 'WIth the Zen1.nc Ord1nan"1 Artiele III, S ecUon
)01+, as nt.rred to in Article IV, S.ct on 400, Sub..ctlon 1,
tor pel'lll1ssion to reduce hont 7ard setback tor a resident1al
dwlling in a bUSiness district. Var1anoe 18 also requested
due to lack of aeoa.. in aocordanoe ....1th State ot New York
.Tcr.m Law, Section 280&. Location ot property. Private
1.1.o:a east side Old Harbor Lane, I.w Suttolk, lew York,
be ed north by H. E. Mason, east by Private :!load, south
by H. H. Tuth1l1, and wst by Canal.
rm-
n
Page 2 - Legal Notice
9.00 P.M. (E.S.T.), upon application ot AJ.met Latson,
Private Boad, eaat dele lounga Avenue, Southold, Ifev York,
tor a varianoe (11.- to lack ot aooe.s 1D accordance with
state of Kev York Town Law, Se.tion 28OA. Property loeated
on priVate road, east aid. YO\1IIIS A'hDue, Southold, New :Cork,
bo&mded north by A. DoltiDI.l' and P. 8a..."..r1. east 'b;y K.
SlI.lIIon an4 A. Latson, and otbera, south b.Y Town Creek, and
"at 'b;y C. Ibaen, A. DO'WIUI, aDd othera.
An7 penon dea1ruw to be heard on the above applicat10ns
should appear at the time and pla.. above .pee1tled.
DATlml IfoftllIber 25', 19,9, By Order of the Southold Town Board
of Appeals.
If .. . . ..
PLEASE PilBtlBH OlfCEJ DECEMaER It, 19J9, ,UfD FORWARD AFFIDAVIT
0' PUBLlCA'l'IOJf I:N.MED:rA. TELl TO TFII BOARD (J' APPEALS, 010 'l'OWN
vumx: OPFICE, MAIN ROAD, SOU'1'}iOLD, HIW YORK.
I
I
I
I
i
I'
....*
Copies IIdled to the tollovinr on JfoV'ellber 27, 195'91
~::V~~il
no)'('l HOUlton, ale Goldslll1th and Tuthill
Nelson Ax1en
H1dgl.y and Horton, ale P'l'1ta J.Cohn
AlIIet Latson
lA~~
~ T
-.r'<<~'~.-
c;:-......." ..,,,.... -;C;j:..:'~-'
'''~~ ..
~&
~~~":~_"'t'_~." .'
it ,)""t ,..... 1,.. .1 .... "
~ '.
Telephones:
Peconic b424 Southold 3767
Established 1842
S~, 1t- t. - ?/ew. S~, 1t- t.
21 December 1959.
Board of Appeals,
Town of Southold,
Southold, N.Y.
Gentlemen:
Will you kindly dismiss from your docket, our appeal from
a ruling of the Zoning Board in connection with the erection of
overhead fuel oil storage tanks.
Due to the rejection of the original application, we have
made other plans.
Very truly yours,
~~,
sm'ith & Tuthill
Floyd D. Houston.
'-../
-
-
\
\.
[
...
I
I
~
r
-
'"
\
-
L
I
,
I
J
'"
~;i
\
I
-"',
L
I
"
.
,
\
[
or
--
v
',\L
-
\
..
\
\
\
I
y
t
^
,
!
r"
"-~"""-"".~,..
"--"
FORM NO. 2
TOWN OF SOUTHOLD
BUILDING DEPARTMENT
TOWN CLERK'S OFFICE
SOUTHOLD, N. Y.
BUILDING PERMIT
(THIS PERMIT MUST BE KEPT ON THE PREMISES UNTIL FULL
COMPLETION OF THE WORK AUTHORIZED)
N<.? 907 Z
Permission is hereby granted to' Date ...............V.................................. 19........
Floyd Housto,t\ .JJr;.... .Y:9.J.,i. riWUh.. ~~.. !:~!;h~;q..... .~.............
Y.mmgil...{Wfl.. ...............................s...............
......SOuthOJ,07... I.Y ....................~...................
J. \'.J,..1t.&t!';..J!')f!!;~A\'?!:l...................................
;~i\..N/s~~i\':J..J:!
........................................ .'?~~d.~.....~::.~.?>'~.............~......................................................
;C~;;;;,;;;;,,;;,,;,;;,~I\~'~~~~,;';;;;:,;:;;";:
to .. .Er.llQt. ."ml .w,,;i,n:!;,,;i,n.. :!;w.:iJ:l.. .Q:V!i'X.l:t.
Bui Iding Inspector
-----------------~-----~~._---~_._~----.,.-
__~,-'<__~_.-=,_."_.,"_,____ ______;',_.-__.~,_ _.-___,,~"~,__~,~_~____,_________c.__.__"____,..._ ______
Nt! 907 Z
-- _ DA TE_ __ _ __ _ ____
".., ~., rfl . '-0
· played during construction- -
i ng Dept. to get a certificate
---_"_-__-,--____--,-.-"'"'..-,,---,---==__=~_o_=___,,..--~__ ..
m______ _ "'-"__..____.. _ ..
OF SOUTIIOtD ---